Professional Documents
Culture Documents
THESIS
by
SITI HAMIDA
AI 150349
Artinya: “Hanya kepada Allah aku mengadukan kesusahan dan kesedihanku. Dan
aku mengetahui dari Allah apa yang tidak kamu ketahui.” (Qs. Yusuf:
86)2
Abdullah Yusuf Ali, (1934) “The Meaning of Glorious Qur’an Text Translation and
1
Commentary”, p. 245
2
Abdullah Yusuf Ali, p. 245
DEDICATION
In the name of Allah SWT most gracious merciful and the prophet Muhammad
SAW, the inspiration of Muslim’s life.
My beloved father (Kholis), thank you for your sacrifice, love, support, care and
pray. Without your pray, I cannot finish my study.
My beloved mother (Darmiana), thank you for your patient to educate me so far,
for your sacrifice, your love, support, pray and all of that you are given to me.
For my sisters, Reni Asnita and Liana Astri. My brother, Irawanto. And for my
niece, Naifa Zahrani. Thanks for all the affections, attentions, happiness, and
laugh which colored my day.
My beloved friends, Siti Aisyah, Sri devi Arisandi, Rini Rahayu, Ana Sholawati,
Rika Agustina, Dian Ratna Ningsih, Andi Astri Wardhana, Miftahul Jannah,
Ulmala sari, Afrasin Maisah Rahman, Randi Mirza, and Zamril. Thank you for
your inspirations, all of you are good people, I am so happy to living around wise
people as you all.
My dearest classmate, BSI A and B, for your kindness, love, support, and
everything.
The last for all people who have helped me in writing this thesis, I would like to
say thank you so much. I love you all as always.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
Alhamdulillahirabbil ‘aalamiin.
All praises be to Allah SWT, the most beneficent and the most merciful
that shows me the right path; Islam and let me flow easily in accomplishing the
thesis entitled “ELIZABETH BARRETT BROWNING’S LIFE AS
REFLECTED BY HER SELECTED POEMS”, which is submitted to fulfill
the requirements for bachelor degree (S1) in English Literature, Adab and
Humanities, Islamic State University, Sultan Thaha Saifuddin Jambi. Sholawat
and salam be upon prophet Muhammad SAW who has brought us from the
darkness to the lightness.
Then, I would like to thank those who have assisted me in writing this
thesis. My sincere gratitude goes to:
1. The Rector of Islamic State University, Sulthan Thaha Saifuddin Jambi, Dr. H.
Hadri Hasan, MA. The Vise of Rector, Dr. H. Suaidi, MA, Ph.D., Dr. H.
Hidayat, M.Pd., and Dr. H. Fadilla, M.Pd., who allowed me to study in the
university.
2. The Dean of Adab and Humanities Faculty, Prof. Dr. Maisah, M.Pd.I. The
Vise of dean, Dr. Alfian, M.Ed., Dr. H.M. Fadhil, M.Ag., and Dr. Raudhoh,
M.Pd.I.
3. The Head of English Literature Department, Ulfatmi Azlan, S.S., M.A and the
secretary Dian Muhlisa, MA who have given the great supervised.
4. My great supervisors, Firdiansyah, MA and H.Mislan, M.Pd who have
continuously guided me throughout the process of accomplishing this thesis.
5. All of my lectures who have given me knowledge and experiences during
meeting in the class till now.
6. All of officials in Adab and Humanities Faculty who have managed my
administrations and requirements as long as my study till graduation.
ABSTRACT
CHAPTER I : INTRODUCTION
1.1 Background of the Problem………………………………………...….1
1.2 Formulation of the Problem…………………………………………...5
1.3 Limitation of the Problem……………………………………………..5
1.4 Purpose of the Research……………………………………………….5
1.5 Significance of the Research…………………………………………..6
CHAPTER II : THEORITICAL FRAMEWORK
2.1 Biographical Approach………………………………………………. 7
2.2 Expressive Theory………………………………………………...… 10
2.3 Semiotic Study……………………………………………………… 11
2.4 Poem ……….…………………………………………………...…... 13
2.5 Meaning……………………………………………………...……… 15
2.6 Review of Related Research………………………………………... 17
CHAPTER III : RESEARCH METHOD
3.1 Design of the Research…………………………………………...…. 20
3.2 Source of Data Collection…………………………………………... 21
3.3 Technique of Data Collection………………………………………..22
3.4 Technique of Data Analysis………………………………………… 23
CHAPTER IV : FINDING AND ANALYSIS
4.1 The meaning in Elizabeth Barrett Browning selected poems……….26
a. How do I love thee………………………………………………...26
b. A thought for a lonely death-bed……………………………….....27
c. Exaggeration………………………………………………………27
d. Irreparableness…………………………………………………….28
e. A curse for a nation……………………………………………..…28
f. The cry of the children……………………………………………..29
4.2 Elizabeth Browning selected Poem Reflect Her Real Life…………..30
A. Reflection of Happiness.………..…………….…………………..30
How Do I Love Thee…………………………………………….. 30
B. Reflection of Sadness.………………………………….…………33
a. A Thought for A Lonely Death-Bed………………………....... 33
b. Exaggeration………………………………………….……….. 34
c. Irreparableness………………………………………………….35
C. Reflection of Sympathy………………………………………...... 36
a. A Curse for A Nation……………………………………...…... 36
b. The Cry of The Children……………………………...…...…... 38
CHAPTER V : CONCLUSIONS AND SUGGESTIONS
5.1 Conclusions...……………………………………………………….. 40
5.2 Suggestions ..……………………………………………………….. 41
REFERENCES
APPENDIXES
CHAPTER I
INTRODUCTION
3
Suwardi Endraswara. (2011). Metedologi Penelitian Sastra. (Yogyakarta: FBS Universitas
Negeri Yogyakarta, CAPS). p.65.
4
Ibid, p.45.
5
http://www.scribd.com/doc/31552799/Pengertian-Sastra-Menurut-Para-Ahli (retired on
friday at November 16, 2018 at 04. 13 pm).
Literary work is one of human creativities. It is divided into three
parts, which are called genres i.e. poetry, prose and drama. They have
certain characteristic and terms. Since this thesis deals with poetry, it is
worthwhile to define what poetry is. In the encyclopedia Americana,
etymologically the word “poetry” was divided from Greek word “poiein”
which mean to make or to construct.6 Poet result is from creativity processes
operating under the impulse of feeling and embodying the combination of
product of the poet’s perceptions thought and feeling.
Poem is the tool to express the human feeling and sense that used
selected language as a media to explore and filed up with figurative
language and another element to beautify the tone, rhyme, and another
aspect which make the poem more interest. Poem deals with the deepest
emotions, it seeks to capture in a few linguistics sign the realities of life.
Poem can be analyzed from many aspects like structure and its elements,
styles, and point of view of the story. Poem appears and created by poet
illustrates the human life which is explored by using some figures of speech.
Poem is arranged by a good and a bright thinking. Pradopo said
“puisi itu mengekspresikan pemikiran yang membangkitkan perasaan yang
merangsang imajinasi panca indra dalam susunan yang berirama”.7 So that
poem is an experience that is explored in the beautiful words with many
poetic elements like figurative language or another speech act like rhyme,
tone, thyme, symbol, etc.
Poem has many meanings in a word, as Waluyo said “puisi adalah
karya sastra. Semua karya sastra bersifat imajjinatif. Bahasa sastra bersifat
konotatif karena banyak digunakan makna kias dan makna lambang”8. The
poem is literary work. All the characteristics of literary work are
imaginative. The literary language characteristic is connotative because it
uses many figurative language and sign.
6
Encyclopedia Americana. (1945). International Edition (Glorier Imorporated). p.277
7
Rachmat Djoko Pradopo. (2005). Pengkajian Puisi. (Yogyakarta: Gajah Mada University).
p.7
8
Herman J. Waluyo. (1991). Teori Dan Apresiasi Puisi. (Jakarta: Penerbit Erlangga). p. 22
This research is chosen because the writer is interested in studying
poem. Reading poems carefully automatically develops our knowledge and
it makes possible to arrange the works that are chosen by the author. Beside
that the writer can also get the authors feeling or experiences from the
poems, the writer wants to know what the reason of the author to wrote that
poems.
Mrs. Browning was born in London, England, in 1809, and she died
at Casa Guidi, Flo rence, June 29, 1861. In 1844 she came forth from her
seclusion in two volumes of “Poems by Elizabeth Browning”. The
melancholy though showed traces of the sadness of much of her former life.
Some of her poems are especially admirer. “Cowper’s Grave”, “The Cry of
the Children”, “ A Child Asleep”, and “He Giveth His Beloved Sleep”.
The writer is interested in choosing Elizabeth Barrett Browning as
the topic, because as we know Elizabeth Barrett Browning has produced
many poems and she was famous poem of 18th century, as well as one of the
most popular poems. Elizabeth Barrett Browning begin write the poem from
six years old and naturally it is based on his life experience. Because of that
the writer is interested to choosing the Elizabeth Barrett Browning poems as
the topic of research. The writer picks out some examples from the author,
such as in poem entitled: “A Thought for A Lonely Death-Bed”.
Quotes:
In this chapter, the writer conducts library research that gives theory of
research questions from some related literatures as references for this thesis. The
writer also make note some quotations from the experts to support the theory used
in this thesis. In addition, the writer presents theoretical background that becomes
the base of this thesis.
9
Wellek and Warren in Nyoman Khuta Ratna. Teori, Metode Dan Teknik Penelitian Satra,
p.56
10
Wilfred L. Guerin. (2005). A handbook of Critical Approach of Literature,( New York :
Oxford University Press), p.51
11
Jako sumardjo&saini K.M. (1986). Apresiasikesusateraan,(Jakarta :Gramedia),p.22
“biografi yang semata-mata menganalisis riwayat hidup, dengan
proses pemahaman mulai dari individu kemasyarakatan, namun
biografi juga menilai sejauh memberi masukan tentang penciptaan
karya sastra dan biografi juga dapat dianggap sebagai studi yang
sistematis tentang psikologi pengarang dan proses kreatif”.12
12
Nyoman Khuta Ratna. Teori Metode Dan Teknik Penelitian Sastra, p.59
Biographical approach is one of the most basic approach used in
analyze of poetry is referred to as the historical method of literary critics. It
means that the critic interprets the poem within the history, or contemporary
frame of reference, behind the poem. The biographical approach insists that
a poems meaning can only be understood within a historical setting. That is,
those who use this approach do not allow for possibility of making a
completely interpretative reading a poem.13
Biographical approach in order to understand to literary object, one
most appreciates the ideas and personality of the author, the followers of this
approach attempt to learn as much as they can about the life and
development of the author and to apply this knowledge in their attempt to
understand his writings. The biographical material provides useful facts that
could put the reader in better position to understand and appreciate the
literary object.
The biographical approach as the method of analyzed the poem by
examining the poem in relation to what is known about the poet’s life. If we
want to use this approach we have to know the poet’s life or the poet’s
biography. There are advantages in using the biography approach of the
author in the analysis, namely to illuminated the element within a work,
words, allusions to particular place and historical event, conflict, theme,
characters, and setting. Furthermore, biography gives ease to see the
expression of author’s deep concern and conflict. Therefore, Elizabeth’s
personal life, her time and works are taken into consideration.
13
Indiani, Eka Permatasari. (2016). An Analysis of Feminism Maya Angelou’s Poems By
Using Historical and Biographical Approaches, Vol. 3 Nomor 2. P.158
2.2 Expressive Theory
In this research, the writer analyzes about the reflection of the author’s
life as seen her selected poems. Expressive theory is meaning of something
that relates to research. Because of that, the writer chooses the expressive
theory for this research after that the writer analyzed it to find the answer of
the research.
Longinus stated that Untuk menciptakan karya agung yang terpenting
adalah unsur kreatif penulis; passion and emotion.14 From that statement it
can be concluded to get good literary work is depend on the writer itself, the
important thing is the element of creativity of the writer such as her passion
and her emotion.
Andrew stated that the idea of the author is not a timeless given: the
figure and significance of the author varies across time and from one culture
to another, from one discourse to another and so on.15 It means that
expressive theory is analyzing about activity creative of human being, from
their imagination, develop and through to become an art.
Expressive theory treats a literary work primarily in relation to the
author. It defines literary work as an expression, overflow, utterance, or
projection of the though and feeling, or as the products of human feelings.16
Here, the writer decided to use expressive theory because it is suitable with
the research that will be analyzed about the author’s life with the poem
itself. According to Abrams In Partini Sardjono Pradotokusumo’s book:
“pendekatan kritis yang terkandung yang utama terhadap karya
sastra yaitu : 1). Pendekatan yang menitikberatkan pada karrya itu
sendiri (pendekatan objektif. 2). Pendekatan yang menitikberatkan
pada penulis (pendekatan ekspresif). 3). Pendekatan yang
menitikberatkan pada semesta (pendekatan mimetic)”17.
14
Longinus in Partini Sardjono Pradotokusumo. (2005). Pengkajian Sastra. (Jakarta:
Penerbit PT Gramedia Pustaka Utama). 72.
15
Andrew Bennett and Nicholas Royle. (2004). An Introduction to Literature, Criticism and
Theory. (Great Britain). Third Edition, 22.
16
M.H.Abrams. (1999). Romantic Theory and the Critical Tradition, (London, New York:
Oxford University).p.22
17
Pradopokusumo Partini Sardjono. (2005). Pengkajian Sastra”, (Jakarta: Gramedia). p.63
Based on means that expressive theory is theory that focus on the
writer or the author itself and usually the story tells about the author life that
has happened in the past event and the author through their life to the literary
work such as the selected poems by Elizabeth Barrett Browning that will be
analyzed, because some of the poems by Elizabeth is reflect of the her life.
According to Gerry Mackie said:
“Expressive theory studies the psychological aspects of the writer
during the creative process is projected through the works of creation,
both of in the relation to the writer as a person and the writer as a
representative of the community to choice in many circumstances of
life”18.
18
Gerry Mackie (2007). On The Expressive Theory Of Voting, (University Of California,
Sandiego). P.2.
thing. Cobley and Jansz also said “…discipline is simply the analysis of
signs or the study of the functioning of sign systems.”19 It means that,
semiotic focus on sign or study about functional of sign systems.
According to Riffaterre, Semiotika adalah metode pemaknaan yang
khusus, yaitu dengan memberi makna karya sastra sebagai sistem tanda-
tanda itu, istilahnya memproduksi makna tanda-tanda.20 It’s means that,
semiotic can give the meaning of poetry by the signs. There are three
Semiotic of Riffaterre in meaning of poem, they are:
a. Displacing of meaning, Displacing occurs when the sign shift from one
meaning to the other meaning, and also when a word represents to the
other word as it happen in figurative language.
b. Distorting of meaning, Distorting of meaning occur when there is
ambiguity in poetry, contradiction, or non-sense.
c. Creating of meaning, creating of meaning is caused by rhyme,
enjambemen (if the sentences is not complete means enjambemen) ,
homolog, and typography.
Semiotic of Riffaterre learn about how semiotic can give the meaning
of literary work, especially a poem. By some of steps: displacing meaning,
distorting meaning, and creating meaning.
Semiotic of Roland Barthes learns how humanity defines things.
Meaning in this case cannot be stirred by communication. Meaning means
that objects not only carry information, in which case the object are to be
communicated, but also constitutes a structured system of signs. One of the
important areas that Barthes encroached on his study of signs is the role of
the reader. In his mythological book, he expressly denotes denotative: 1)
signifier, 2) signified, 3) denotative sign, 4) connotative sign, 5) connotative
signified, 6) connotative sign. This opinion asserts that the literature has a
19
Alex Sobur. (2003). Semiotika Komunikasi. (Bandung: Remaja Rosda Karya). P.15-16
20
Michael Riffaterre. (2016). Teori Dan Aplikasi Semiotika Michael Riffaterre.
(Yogyakarta: Pustaka Pelajar). P.5
layer of meaning21. It means that, semiotic of the study of sign, sign
function, and the production of meaning.
“Semiotics is the study of how people make meaning through both
linguistic and non-linguistic ways. It is a philosophical theory
concerned with understanding how people use signs and symbols
meaning-making. Sign systems include words, images, number and
objects. These signs have meaning only because people have agreed
upon and use this shared meaning”22.
It means that, the sign is very important in life, before the reader
should know about the sign in novel, poems, lyrics, and so on. We must
understand first, what the meaning of that symbol. Symbol is about Words,
Body Language. Example, the word “house” refers to a structure designed
for people to live within only because a culture uses it in this way. How this
meaning of “house” came to be is what those who study and research
semiotics are interested in.
Based on the explanation above, there are many explanation of
Semiotic, here the writer only focus of semiotic Riffaterre, because the
writer thinks, semiotic Riffaterre is very suitable with the problem of
research. The meaning of semiotic is about the reader and the text. It means
that, the reader freely to interpret the literary works, especially a poem,
without a feeling bound by the author’s. The reader is really influences in
this theory.
2.4 Poem
Poem is one of literary work that expresses the ideas or the emotions in
a powerfully vivid imaginative style. A poem is comprised of a particular
rhythmic and metrical pattern. In fact, it is a literary technique that is
different from prose or ordinary speech.
21
Roland Barthes, P.39
22
http://www.Learning-theories.com (retired on saturday at November 17, 2018 at 04. 15
pm).
According to Riffaterre in Pradopo, “poem is indirect expression,
meaning that is describe something by using connotative meaning. Then
indirect expression caused by displacing of meaning, distorting of meaning
and creative of meaning.”23 Frost in Arp Thomas’s book stated that, “Poem
is provides the one permissible way of saying one thing and meaning
another”.24
From explanation above, the writer can take assumption that, the poem
is not only a tool to express the human’s ideas. But also often teaches the
readers a moral lesson, share something that have experienced, and give
pleasure to the readers. Indirectly, poem is enable the readers to look ‘into
the life of things’, while science sharpens our intellect, poem enriches our
moral insight.
There are some kinds of poem, those are:
a. Descriptive
Descriptive poem is the poem which describes people or
experiences, scenes, or objects.
b. Reflective
Thoughtful poems often containing a great deal of description
which the poet comments or from which he draws conclusion are
directly stated; at other times implied.
c. Narrative
Narrative is a telling of a story or a description of an event.
d. The lyric
The lyric is usually a short poems like a song which is usually the
expression of a mood or feeling.
e. The sonnet
The sonnet is a poem of fourteen lines which follows a very strict
rhyme pattern. It is usually divided into two parts: the ‘octave’ (the first
eight lines), and ‘sestet’ (the last six lines).
23
Pradopo. (2007). Pengajian Puisi. (Yogyakarta: University Press). P.77.
24
Thomas. (2012). Perrine’s Sound and Sense: an Introduction to Poetry. (Boson: Printed
in the United State of America).P.72.
2.5 Meaning
The word ‘meaning’ and it’s corresponding verb ‘to mean’ are among
the most eminently discussable in the English Language. Some people
would like semantic to pursue the study of meaning in a wide sense of all
that is communicated by language.
According to Kreidler: “The dimension of meaning included reference
and denotative, connotative, sense relations, lexical and grammatical
meaning, morphemes, homonymy, polysemy, lexical ambiguity, sentence
and meaning”.25 different from Kreidler, Abdul Chaer explained that kind of
meaning included a lexical, grammatical and contextual meaning, denotative
and connotative meaning, conceptual and associative meaning.26
From all of type meaning, in this research, the writer only focus on the
theory of meaning that related with this research such as lexical and
contextual meaning.
1. Lexical Meaning
The meaning of word or lexical meaning is a part of linguistic
knowledge and is therefore a part of the grammar. The term lexical
meaning, which is used in semantics, is interpreted as the meaning of the
lexeme whether it is word lexeme of phrasal lexeme.
Lexical meaning is the smallest meaning unit in the meaning system
of language that could be distinguished from other similar units. Lexical
meaning refers to the real meaning, meaning that proper with our sense
of observation, or granted meaning.27 it has been known that language
has an amount of lexical system by which the semantic with structure
could be based the meaning on paradigmatic and systematic. Many
people said that lexical meaning is the meaning in the dictionary or that
of the lexeme meaning event without any context. Lexical meaning is
usually considered as being the meaning of word.
25
Kreidler. (1998). Introducing English Semantics, (London and New York: Routledge
Publishing). P.41
26
Abdul Chaer. (2007). Linguistik Umum. (PT. Rineka Cipta). P.289.
27
Abdul Chaer, p.289
Lyons assumed that lexical meaning is a meaning describe in the
lexicon or dictionary. In addition, he also said that lexical meaning are
the meaning of a word or sentence which upon the meaning of it’s
constituent lexemes.28 It can be concluded that the lexical meaning refers
to the sense or meaning of a word that appears the real meaning without
need any context to explain the meaning.
2. Contextual Meaning
Contextual meaning is the meaning of word based on the situation in
which they are used. According to Abdul Chaer, “Contextual meaning is
the meaning of a lexeme or word inside a context”.29 Contextual
meaning could be regarded in the situation, the time and the
environment. It means that, different situation will give different
meaning. contextual meaning is found outside the text, namely
immediate context. The approach used is that every text is an act of
communication, not text that appeared without any purpose and intent.
As an act of communication, text producers would wish to have meaning
that can be understood by the recipient (reader or listener). It may be said
that contextual meaning is the meaning that related the context of
something or depending on the circumstances that form the function of
word in sentence formation since different arrangement of the same
word con covey different context.
28
John, Lyons. (1984). Language and Linguistic. (Cambridge: Cambridge University
Press). P.40
29
Abdul Chaer. Linguistik Umum. P.290
2.6 Review of Related Studies
The first, literary research is in Muhammad Sofian’s research, student
of English Literature Department of Adab Faculty, in Islamic University
Sulthan Thaha Saifuddin Jambi 2013. His thesis title is “The Senses
Through the Meaning of Life that Correlated with Khalil Gibran as Depicted
on Khalil Gibran’s selected Poetries”.30 He applied Biographical Approach
and the sense of life concept by to support his research. He uses qualitative
method, which also uses descriptive technique to describe and analyze the
data. As result, he found the answer from two problems as found in the
poetry of Khalil Gibran are 1) there are three sense of life in Khalil Gibran
selected poetry, they are happiness, sadness, and anger and fear. 2) Khalil
Gibran’s poetry have many correlation with his life such as his family,
friends, environment, government, and love.
The second, the literary research is in Fajar Aditya Yunarto’s research.
His titled is “The reflection of Sylvia Plath’s Suicidal Manner and Suicidal
Attempts in ‘Lady Lazarus’ as Seen Through the Imagery”.31 The objectives
of this study are : 1) to find out how the imagery in the poem is inferred. 2)
to reveal how the inference of the imagery reflects Sylvia Plath’s suicidal
manner and suicidal attempts. This study applies library research and uses
biographical approach, and applies three theories (theories on imagery,
theories on suicide, and the relationship between literature and biography).
In this research, he found that there are various kinds of images that are used
in the poem, the biography of Silvia Plath proves that Sylvia Plath also
suffered from similar severe stresses. Through the imagery the poem reflects
Sylvia Plath’s suicidal manner and suicidal attempts.
30
Muhammad Sofian. (2013). The Senses Through the Meaning of Life that Correlated with
Khalil Gibran as Depicted on Khalil Gibran’s selected Poetries. (Jambi: Universitas Islam
Negeri). P.1
31
Fajar Aditya Yunarto. (2006). The reflection of Sylvia Plath’s Suicidal Manner and
Suicidal Attempts in ‘Lady Lazarus’ as Seen Through the Imagery. (Yogyakarta: Sanata Darma
University). P.1
The third, literary research is in Siti Mustofiah’s research, student of
English Literature Department of Adab Faculty, in Islamic University
Sulthan Thaha Saifuddin Jambi 2012. Her thesis title is “The Reflection of
Khaled Hosseini’s Life as Seen in His Novel, ‘The Kite Runner’” 32. She
uses Expressive Theory for analyzing about the author’s life, so she uses this
theory to make this thesis. And also she uses biographical approach that is
really suitable with her thesis. She has found the problems in this novel such
as: 1) what are the similarities of life between the author’s life, Khaled
Hosseini, and main characther’s life, Amir, that happen in his novel The
Kite Runner? 2) how is the life of the author influence to the novel The Kite
Runner.
The fifth, literary research is in Dwi Retno’s research, student of
English Literature Department of Adab Faculty, in Islamic University
Sulthan Thaha Saifuddin Jambi 2018. Her thesis titled is “The Analysis of
Symbolisms Found in Khalil Gibran’s Selected Poems”.33 The objectives of
this study are: 1) to know the classification of symbols by C.S. Peirce in the
Khalil Gibran’s Poems. 2) to describe the performance of semiotic
expression in Khalil Gibran’s Poems. 3) to know meaning of symbols used
in Khalil Gibran’s poems. She uses Semiotic Theory for analyze about the
symbols to make this thesis. She can distinguish five classification of
symbols (based on Peirce); they are: nature symbol, conventional symbol,
genuine symbol, singular symbol, and abstract symbol. She found four types
of Peirce’s symbols. There are 7 (seven) data of natural symbols, 14
(fourteen) data of genuine symbols, 3 (three) data of singular symbols, and 3
(three) data of abstract symbols. Whilst, the conventional symbols were not
found.
32
Siti Mustofiah. (2012). The Reflection of Khaled Hosseini’s Life as Seen in His Novel,
‘The Kite Runner’. (Jambi: Universitas Islam Negeri). P.1
33
Dwi Retno. (2018). The Analysis of Symbolisms Found in Khalil Gibran’s Selected
Poems. (Jambi: Universitas Islamic Negeri). P.1
From the previous research above, different from previous research, in
this research, the writer is going to focus on the reflection of Elizabeth
Browning’s life as seen in her selected poems such as: “A Thought for A
Lonely Death-bed poem by Elizabeth Barret Browning”, “Exaggeration
poem by Elizabeth Barret Browning”, “How do I love thee poem by
Elizabeth Barrett Browning”, “Irreparableness poem by Elizabeth Barret
Browning”, “The Cry of The Children poem by Elizabeth Barret
Browning”, “A curse for A Nation poem by Elizabeth Barrett Browning”.
So the title in this proposal is “Elizabeth Barrett Browning’s Life As
Reflected by Her Selected Poems”.
CHAPTER III
METHOD OF RESEARCH
34
Margono. (2007). Metodologi Penelitian. (Jakarta: Rineka Cipta). p.36
35
Siswantoro. (2010). Metode Penelitian Sastra. (Yogyakarta: Pustaka Pelajar). p.56
unification. It means that, descriptive method can be defined as a problem
solving procedures investigated by describing the state of the subject or
object in the research. According to Jalaludin Rahmat in Ibrahim’s book
state that, “Metode Deskriptif dapat diartikan sebagai sebuah penelitian
yang dilakukan untuk melukiskan variabel, satu demi satu dengan
mengumpulkan data secara unvarian, yang digunakan untuk mencari teori-
teori tentative bukan mengkaji teori.”36
On the other hand, descriptive method refers to method that provides
an accurate portrayal of characteristics of a particular individual, situation,
or group. In short, descriptive method deals with everything that can be
counted and studied, which has an impact of the lives of the people it deals
with.
From the explanation above, the writer can conclude that qualitative
descriptive method is a way of working in the research that emphasized on
aspects of the deepening of the data. It also help the writer collecting the
data to interpret and report in order to get the result of a research.
36
Ibrahim. (2015). Meodology Penelitian Kualitatif. (Bandung: Alfabeta). p.59
3.3 Technique of data Collection
In this research, the writer applied documentation as technique of data
collection. The writer analyzed Elizabeth Barrett Browning of six selected
poems to collect the data which related this research.
According to Creswell, “The data collection procedures in qualitative
research involve four basic types: observation, interview, documentation and
visual image”.37 Sugiyono statet that “Dokumen merupakan catatan
peristiwa yang sudah berlalu. Dokumen biasa berbentuk tulisan, gambar
atau karya-karya monumental dari seseorang”.38 According to Atkinson
and Coffey stated that:
“Documents contain text (words) and images that have been recorded
without a researcher’s intervention. For the purposes of this discussion,
other mute or trace evidence, such as cultural artifacts, is not included.
Documents as ‘social facts’, which are produced, shared, and used in
socially organized ways.39
37
John W Creswell. Research Design: Qualitative, Quantitative, and Mixed Methods
Approaches. (United Stated of America, 1994). P.148.
38
Sugiyono, Metode Penelitian Kualitatif. p.240
39
Glem A Bowen. (2009). Document Analysis as a Qualitative Research Method. (Western
Carolina University). p.1
The writer has some steps in collecting the data, in order to make this
research more specific. They are :
1. Prepare data collection sheet, after getting all important sources, the
writer read it to make sure that the data are collecting suitable with the
research.
2. Selecting the data, to get the data, the writer reads carefully some poems
that were chosen as data for analyzing. And also the writer will searches
the poem that has correlation with Elizabeth’s real life.
3. Give a description, the writer make description or brief information
about the data. Making a note of data, after reading the sources carefully,
the writer marks any important statement to make the writer easier in the
analyzing process for the research.
4. Drawing conclusion, effort to obtain certainly about the correctness of
the data. The writer processes the data to analyze them. finally, the
writer made a good arrangement for the thesis proposal itself as the last
in finalizing research.40
40
Siswantoro. (2010). Metode Penelitian Sastra. (Yogyakarta: Pustaka Pelajar). P. 73
41
Lexy J. Moleong. (2014). Metodology Penelitian Kualitatif, Ed Revisi. (Bandung:
Remaja Posdakarya). P.248
be development and evaluated.42 It can be concluded that data analysis is an
important part and also foundation of scientific research. Because data
analysis is process of systematically examining data with the purpose of
spotlighting useful information, to evaluating data. Besides that, data
analysis will draw conclusions about the information.
In this research, the writer used technique descriptive analysis to
describe of the data, descriptive analysis will help the writer to summarize
the data in meaningful way. According to Nawawi:
“Metode deskriptif dapat diartikan sebagai prosedur pemecahan
masalah yang diselidiki dengan menggambarkan dan melukiskan
keadaan subjek atau objek penelitian (novel, drama, cerita pendek,
puisi) pada saat sekarang berdasarkan fakta-fakta yang tampak atau
sebagaimana adanya.”43
42
Sugiyono. (2007). Memahami Penelitian Kualitatif. (Bandung: Alfabeta). P.88
43
Siswantoro. (2010). Metode Penelitian Sastra. (Yogyakarta: Pustaka Pelajar). P.54
provides a new way of arranging and thinking about more textually
embedded data. The writer will make the narrative display by retrieving
data from the text which has correlation with the problems of research.
3. Conclusion / verifying
Conclusion or verifying is the result of analyzing that answer the
research problem based on the data analyzing. The conclusion is the last
phase of research. The writer concludes the result of analysis and the
answer the formulation of the form of descriptive data.44
44
M.B. Miles and Huberman, A.M. (1984). Qualitative Data Analysis: a Source Book of
New Method. (London: Sage Publication). p.21
CHAPTER IV
FINDING AND ANALYSIS
In this line ‘I love thee to the depth and breadth and height’.
According to Oxford Dictionary, the word ‘depth’ means distance from the
top to the bottom or from the front to the back45, the word ‘breadth’ means
distance from size to size, and the word ‘height’ means measurement of how
tall a person or thing. But in this poem, Elizabeth wants to show how big her
love her sweetheart, her love cannot reach by anything. This line
Ambiguities, the meaning of Ambiguity is mempunyai makna yang lebih
dari satu (polyinterpretable), dapat ditapsirkan bermacam-macam menurut
konteksnya.46 The words Depth, Breadth, and Height are for distance and
thing. So, those words have many meanings, the reader feels confuse when
they read it.
45
Hornby. (2008). Oxford Learner’s Pocked Dictionary Fourth Edition. (Oxford
University Press). P. 120
46
Pradopo. (1999). Semiotika: Teori, Metode, Dan Penafsiran Dalam Pemaknaan Sastra.
Humaniorah N0. 10. P.79
b. A Thought for A Lonely Death-Bed (Line 11 – 14)
To die alone, with none beside thy bed
To ruffle round with sobs thy last word said
And mark with tears, the pulses ebb from thee
Pray then alone, ‘O Christ, come tenderly!
In this line, ‘that by the grief of ONE came all our good’. According
to Oxford Dictionary, the word ‘grief’ means thing that causes great
sadness50 and the word ‘good’ means behavior which is morally right of
acceptable51. But in this situation, the meaning of this line does not think
about the tears but you must focus on your future. Life is not about sadness
anymore, but there is happiness also.
47
Hornby, P. 12
48
Hornby, P. 457
49
Pradopo, P. 78
50
Hornby, P. 195
51
Hornby, P. 192
d. Irreparableness (Line 13 – 14)
Sweet counselors, dear friend? That I should go
Back straightway to the fields and gather more?
Another, south, may do it, but not I
My heart is very tired, my strength is low
My hands are full of blossoms plucked before
Held dead within them till myself shall die.
In that line, the word ‘Love’ and ‘Blood’ is Ambiguity because the
meaning of love in this poem different with dictionary, the meaning of love
here about happiness or smile and the meaning of word Blood also different
with the meaning of dictionary, the meaning of blood here about sadness or
52
Hornby, P. 466
53
Hornby, P. 262
54
Gorys Keraf. (2009). Diksi Dan Gaya Bahasa. Jakarta: Gramedia Pustaka Utama
tears. So in this poem, the meaning of this sentence is Elizabeth Barrett
Browning felt confuse with this situation, because her heart and her brain is
not in one feeling. She wants to write a curse but she is afraid about the
effect when she does that. In this sentence he gave her thankful with the
tears and the smiles.
In this line, ‘the old tree is leafless in the forest, the old year is
ending in frost’. According to Oxford dictionary, the word ‘old’ means
having lived for a long time55, the word ‘tree’ means tall plant with a
wooden trunk and branches56, the word ‘year’ means period of 12 months;
measured from any particular time57, and the word ‘frost’ means weather
with the temperature below freezing point58. ‘the old year is ending in frost’
is ambiguity, the meaning of Ambiguity is mempunyai makna yang lebih
dari satu (polyinterpretable), dapat ditapsirkan bermacam-macam menurut
konteksnya.59 In line ‘the old year is ending in frost’, the word frost in that
line has different meaning from dictionary, in this poem, frost means
55
Hornby, P. 304
56
Hornby, P. 474
57
Hornby, P. 517
58
Hornby, P. 178
59
Pradopo, P.79
sadness and tears. So the meaning of this line is the years that full of sadness
and tears.
A. Reflection of Happiness
Happiness is an emotion that is often associated with a state of mind
that reflects contentment, satisfaction, pleasure or joy. Happiness is one of
the most popular emotions. Happiness is characterized by a facial
expression that causes someone to raise the corners of their mouth upwards.
By Elizabeth Barrett Browning selected poems, the writer found a poem
that reflect her happiness in a poem, entitle: How do I love thee
This poem wrote in 1850 at Italy. “sonnet 43” begins with ‘How do I
love thee? Let me count the ways’ a line that itself would have sealed
Barrett Browning place in the literary canon if all else had somehow failed
to do so. This poem she wrote for her sweetheart. Their romance was
bitterly opposed by her father, who did not want any of his children to
marry. In 1846, the couple eloped and settled in Florence, Italy, where
Elizabeth health improved and she bore a son, Robert Wideman Browning.
Her father never spoke to her again. Elizabeth Barrett Browning’s sonnet
from the fortugies, dedicated to her husband (Robert Browning) and written
secret before their marriage, was published in 185060.
Elizabeth Barrett Browning describes about her life when she felt
happy after marry with someone who she loves. She felt grateful to have
been loved by a men like her husband. She loves her husband purely,
sincerely, and freely. He came when some of the special people who she
loved was go away, her mother and two her brothers. Her husband gives
new happiness for remove her tears. Elizabeth Barrett Browning loves her
husband with her breath, her smiles, and also her tears. But if she died with
all of this happiness, she will always love her husband with the same love,
and also with the more feeling of love. This poem is one of Elizabeth
Barrett Browning famous works, this poem was published by her husband
after her death.
The line above shows that how deep Elizabeth Barrett Browning’s
love is for her sweetheart. She expresses the extent of her love using
measurements of places where her soul can reach. It makes a point that her
love cannot be measured. Even if the world ends, she will always still love
him. Her love for him will never change.
60
Alice Meynell. (2012). Elizabeth Barrett Browning Poems. (Poemhunter.com – The
World’s Poetry Archive). P.6
I love thee to the level of every day’s.
Most quiet need, by sun and candlelight.
From this line, ‘in my old griefs, and with my childhood’s faith’. It
figures out that there is a past experiences of Elizabeth Barrett Browning. It
is proven by the word ‘my childhood’s faith’. It means that when she was
child she felt something that she will tell in the next line. The next line is ‘I
love thee with a love I seemed to lose’. It imagines that she loves someone
but there is an obstacle in her love that makes her loves become a little bit
fade or lose. Then, Elizabeth Barrett Browning wants tell through her line
that her love seems to lose her out as she lost her saints. ‘Saints’ here can
be interpreted as spirit, soul or holy wish of Elizabeth Barrett Browning.
B. Reflection of Sadness
Sadness is an emotion that is often associated with the feelings of
disadvantage, loss, and helplessness. Sadness is considered to be the direct
opposite of happiness, and can also be characterized as sorrow, grief,
misery, and melancholy. By Elizabeth Barrett Browning selected poems,
the writer found three poems that reflect her sadness. They are those
poems:
61
Alice Meynel, P.6
physically shattered. Because of that situation Elizabeth Barrett Browning
wrote this poem to give spirit for her family about what happen in their
family.62
In this poem Elizabeth Barrett Browning describes about her life,
when she wants to give spirits for her sisters and her brothers, because of
many problems that happen before. For example, her mother was died, and
also her brothers was died in the same year, her family’s economy declined,
with this poem, Elizabeth Barrett Browning gives a support for her sisters
and her brothers with a sentences “one sadness will change to many
happiness” its mean that this life not only about sadness, but also about
happiness, believe it !
62
Alice Meynell, P.6
63
Alice Meynell, P.6
to live with her brother Edward near the Sea of Torquay for a period, but
tragedy would strike again when he drowned, and she returned to London,
emotionally and physically shattered.
In this poem, Elizabeth Barrett Browning describes about her life
when her death will come soon. In this poem, Elizabeth Barrett Browning
describes her expressions of sadness. ‘my heart is very tired, my strength is
low’. From that sentences, explain that she was give up, tired, and weak.
Elizabeth Barrett Browning felt surrendered with the fate that was happen
in her life. She has gives up to fight with her illness. She needs to take a
rest before God came to take her away forever.
C. Reflection of Sympathy
Sympathy is the act of showing support for or approval of an idea,
cause, and many others. Sympathy expression is an expression or feeling of
pity and sorrow when we know and see someone or people are unlucky or
have trouble and in bad condition. By expression sympathy we want to
show our concern or carefulness on other people condition. By Elizabeth
Barrett Browning selected poems, the writer found two poems that reflect
her sympathy. They are:
64
Alice Meynell, P.7
65
Hornby, P. 194
66
Hornby, P.262
67
Hornby, P. 41
68
Pradopo, P.79
b. The Cry of The Children
Do you Question the young children in the sorrow,
Why their tears are falling so?---
The old man may weep for his to-morrow
Which is lost in Long Ago---
The old tree is leafless in the forest---
The old year is ending in the frost---
The old wound, if stricken, is the sorest---
The old hope is hardest to be lost:
But the young, young children, O my brothers,
Do you ask them why they stand
Weeping sore before the bosoms of their mothers,
In our happy Fatherland?
69
Alice Meynell, P.5
This poem tells about, she wants to describe about broken of the
future the children, when they are old, what will they get? There is
happiness anymore, only tears will accompany their old. Because what,
their childhood was gloomy, was broken, their youth all about tears and
sadness. With this poem, may the government of this homeland be
aware and abolish slavery and child labor.
CHAPTER V
CONCLUSIONS AND SUGGESTIONS
A. Conclusions
After analyzing the reflection of Elizabeth Barrett Browning’s life as
seen in her selected poems, they are:
Elizabeth Barrett Browning’s poems are varied, there are: happiness,
sadness, and sympathy. The first poem is about her love, the second poem is
about has feeling when she felt scared to face the death alone, the third poem
is about her sympathy with the Italian cause after the outbreak of fighting. The
fourth poem is about her condemned child labor and helped abolish child
labor, the fifth poem is about her life when she wants to give spirits for her
sisters and for her brothers, because of many problems that happen before, and
the last poem is about her sadness, in this poem she describing about her life
when her death come soon.
Six selected poems reflect Elizabeth Barrett Browning’s life in the first
poem “How Do I Love Thee” wrote in 1850 at Italy, this poem tells about her
life when she felt happy after marry with someone who she loves. This poem
her dedicated for her sweetheart (Robert Browning) and written secret before
her marriage. The second poem “A Thought for A Lonely Death-Bed” wrote
in 1845 at England, this poem tells about her feeling of scared when she has to
face the death alone. No one accompanies her, and she was really sad because
of her destiny. The third poem “A Curse for A Nation” wrote in 1860 at
Italian. This poem tells about her sympathy with the Italian cause after the
outbreak of fighting, in this poem she send a curse for a nation. The fourth
poem “The Cry of The Children” wrote in 1842 at England. This poem tells
about child labor, she want to abolish slavery and child labor in England. This
poem tell about the sadnesss of children. The fifth poem “Exaggeration”
wrote in 1845 at England. This poem tells about her life when she wants to
give spirits for her sisters and for her brothers, because of many problems that
happen before, like her mother died, her father business foundered, and also
her poor health. And the last poem “Irreparableness” wrote in 1845 at
England, this poem describes about her expression of her sadness, when her
death will come soon. She has given up to fights with her illness. She needs to
take a rest before God came to take her away forever.
The writer uses Semiotic of Riffaterre to interpret the poems, and also
the writer used lexical and contextual meaning. Based on the theory of
Semiotic Riffaterre, the writer found three ambiguities sentences, a metonymy
sentence, and a personification sentence. As we know, interpret the poems has
many way, as the writer does here, the writer used some of meaning to
interpret the poems.
B. Suggestions
At the end of this thesis, the writer would like to give some suggestion
based on the analysis in this research, there are some suggestion related to this
research. The writer hopes and suggests this research can give contribution
knowledge for junior of English Literature Department, especially about the
same poet, same object, and about the reflection with author’s life to the
reader.
The writer suggests that the other researchers can continue the research
about Elizabeth Barrett Browning’s life, because there are many other cases
which are good to be discussed and analyzed, for example about symbols of
the poems, and study of linguistic in the poems. Since this study only
discussed about the poem reflected Elizabeth Barrett Browning’s life, the
writer suggests the next researcher to conduct further research focus on one of
his life, like education, career, or struggle and so on. The researchers should
not be afraid to do a literary research because analyzing a literary work in
linguistic and literature, because analyzing a literary work is not hard and we
are never wrong in literature, there is only the different perception about
linguistic and literature related to many other field of science. Besides that,
this thesis is not far away from mistakes, therefore the writer needs some
critics and suggestions to make this thesis more better.
REFERENCES
Abrams, M.H. (1999). Romantic Theory and the Critical Tradition. London, New
York: Oxford University.
Avis, Paul. God and Creative Imagination, Metaphor, Symbol, and Myth in
Religion and Theology.
Guiren, L Wilfred, Labor Earle, Morgan Lee, Ressman C. Jeanne and Willingham
R. John. A Hand Book of critical Approaches To Literature. Ed fifth.
Keraf, Gorys. (2009). Diksi Dan Gaya Bahasa. Jakarta: Gramedia Pustaka Utama
Kreidler. (1998). Introduction English Semantics. London & New York:
Roudledge Publishing
Miles, M.B and Huberman, A.M. (1984). Qualitative Data Analysis: a Source
Book of New Method. London: Sage Publication.
Mustofiah, Siti. (2012). The Reflection of Khaled Hosseini’s Life as Seen in His
Novel, ‘The Kite Runner’. Jambi: Universitas Islam Negeri.
Yunarto, Fajar Aditya. (2006). The reflection of Sylvia Plath’s Suicidal Manner
and Suicidal Attempts in ‘Lady Lazarus’ as Seen Through the Imagery.
Yogyakarta: Sanata Darma University.
WEBSITES
Encyclopedia Americana. (1945). International Edition Glorier Imorporated..
(retired on friday at November 16, 2018 at 04. 13 pm).
APPENDIXES I
Elizabeth Barrett Browning’s Selected Poems
The Curse
Because ye have broken your own chain
With the strain
Of brave men climbing a Nation's height,
Yet thence bear down with brand and thong
On souls of others, -- for this wrong
This is the curse. Write.
Irreparableness
I HAVE been in the meadows all the day
And gathered there the nosegay that you see
Singing within myself as bird or bee
When such do field-work on a morn of May.
But, now I look upon my flowers, decay
Has met them in my hands more fatally
Because more warmly clasped,--and sobs are free
To come instead of songs. What do you say,
Sweet counsellors, dear friends ? that I should go
Back straightway to the fields and gather more ?
Another, sooth, may do it, but not I !
My heart is very tired, my strength is low,
My hands are full of blossoms plucked before,
Held dead within them till myself shall die.
Victorian poet Elizabeth Barrett Browning is perhaps best known for her
'Sonnets From the Portuguese' and 'Aurora Leigh' as well as the love story
between her and fellow poet Robert Browning.
Synopsis
Early Life
Emerging Writer
At age 14, Barrett developed a lung illness that required her to take
morphine for the rest of her life, and the following year, she suffered a spinal
injury that would serve as another setback. Despite her health issues, Barrett lived
the literary life to the fullest, teaching herself Hebrew, studying Greek culture and
publishing her first book in 1820, The Battle of Marathon, which her father bound
and released privately.
Advertisement
Barrett’s poor health forced her to live with her brother Edward near the
Sea of Torquay for a period, but tragedy would strike again when he drowned, and
she returned to London, emotionally and physically shattered. Whether it was
despite or because of her continued struggles, Barrett continued writing, and in
1844 her collection titled Poems was published. Besides catching the eye of the
reading public, it also drew the attention of established English poet Robert
Browning. Browning wrote Barrett a letter, and the pair exchanged nearly 600
letters over the following 20 months, which culminated in their elopement in
1846. Barrett’s father was very much against the marriage, and he never spoke
with his daughter again.
Established Poet
Life in Florence was good to the poet’s creative process, as was the roiling
political and social atmosphere in Italy. She published the politically charged
poem "Casa Guidi Windows" in 1851. Barrett Browning followed it up in 1856
with Aurora Leigh (a blank-verse novel/poem), which is her longest work, and
then Poems Before Congress in 1860. Included in the Poems Before
Congress collection is “A Curse for a Nation,” which criticized slavery in
America (although she doesn't specifically mention the country's name). The
Boston abolitionist publication, The Independent, first published the poem in
1856.
She could never overcome her generally weak constitution though, and
Barrett Browning died in Florence on June 29, 1861 at the age of 55 as one of the
most beloved poets of the Romantic Movement.