Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/245552287
CITATIONS READS
12 730
5 authors, including:
Wei Yintao
Tsinghua University
68 PUBLICATIONS 406 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
Magnetorheological elastomer's experimental study and constitutive modeling for its coupled magneto-mechanical
large deformation behaviour View project
Dynamic modeling and finite element simulation of rubber components for vehicle application View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Wei Yintao on 18 April 2016.
REFERENCE: Yin, H. S., Hu, Y. S., Zhang, H., Yang, M. M., and Wei, Y. T., ‘‘Truck Tire
Thermal-Mechanical FEA and DMA with Application to Endurance Evaluation,’’ Tire
Science and Technology, TSTCA, Vol. 34, No. 4, October – December 2006, pp. 220-236.
KEY WORDS: heavy-duty radial tires, thermal-mechanical analysis, FEA, endurance, DMA
Introduction
It is well recognized that the tire is a critical safety component for vehicles,
since it is related to driving/braking performance, fuel economy, and handling
properties of vehicles. Increasing interests in the field of vehicle safety leads to
more and more attention to tire endurance by automotive and tire industry
sectors. For the heavy-duty radial tires, the design lifetime is generally around
200,000 miles, and the tread wear life 50,000 miles; although by the design
intention, a truck tire should exhibit no failures during its useful life or while the
tread depth is still adequate. However, due to overload and/or structural-
materials design problems, some tires do fail unexpectedly. There exist several
1
Hangzhou Sunrise Rubber Co., Ltd., 23 1st Avenue, Hangzhou Economic and Technological
Development Zone, Zhejiang 310008, China.
2
Department of Automotive Engineering, Tsinghua University, State Key Laboratory of Automotive
Safety and Energy, Beijing 100084, China.
3
Corresponding author: Department of Automotive Engineering, Tsinghua University, Beijing
100084, China; email: weiyt@tsinghua.edu.cn
4
Presented at the twenty fourth annual meeting of The Tire Society, Akron, Ohio, September 20–21,
2005.
220
YIN ET AL. ON TRUCK TIRE THERMAL-MECHANICAL FEA 221
kinds of failure modes of heavy-duty radial tires observed in the field and in
drum endurance tests, which generally occur in the area of tire shoulder and/or
tire bead.
This paper presents a thermal-mechanical finite element analysis 共FEA兲 of
a typical heavy-duty radial truck tire on both drum and roadway to compare the
footprint pressures, strain energy density, and steady-state temperature distribu-
tion between two cases, which provides a base to evaluate the tire endurance. As
shown in Fig. 1, a semicouple thermomechanical FEM is developed in which
the heat generation rates are determined from the stress-strain cycles, based on
a rubber hysteretic model, and the temperature fields are calculated by a non-
linear heat-transfer analysis. In addition to the FE simulation techniques, a
series of DMA tests are conducted to obtain the dynamical mechanical proper-
ties of the rubbers of interest. Furthermore, the change of the rubber dynamical
mechanical properties with fatigue is investigated by performing DMA before
and after drum endurance tests, from which the potential failure mechanism can
be identified. Relative endurance of tire key areas can be evaluated based on the
local shear strain, strain energy density, and temperature field calculated, where
the rubber fatigue and aging properties should be considered.
and high inflation pressure makes the shoulder endurance problem more severe.
One of the failure modes for heavy-duty radial tires involves cracks or separa-
tions growing from the end of the belts and extending along the belts inwards
and/or outwards, which is generally attributed to strain concentration and/or
high temperature in the area. There are several published reports to explain this
problem from the point of view of stress/strain energy 关1,2兴 or from the heat
generation, thermal-oxidation aging analysis 关3–5兴. Singh 关6兴 pointed out that
elevated temperature is more important than flexural stress in affecting the
degradation of peel properties of aircraft tire coupons. Ebbott 关7兴 used a finite-
element-based method to analyze the severity of internal cracks in cord-rubber
structures and to predict tire rolling resistance and temperature distributions 关8兴
in which both the stiffness and the loss properties are updated as a function of
strain, temperature, and frequency. More recently, Mars 关9兴 created the concept
of the cracking energy density to predict multiaxial fatigue crack initiation in
rubber. Han and Becker 关10兴 performed a failure analysis of truck tires based on
fracture mechanics, using a global-local FE model. LaClair and Zarak 关11兴
discussed the important effects of surface curvature on truck tire endurance
testing and highlighted the impact that curvature has on tire operating tempera-
ture. Generally speaking, the failure analysis procedure includes material analy-
sis, load identification, and service trials. In the present work, thermomechani-
cal modeling techniques by FEM are used to identify service stress-strain
factors and temperature distribution, and several material tests are used to sup-
port the nonlinear finite element analysis and evaluate the relative endurance.
Both on-drum and on-roadway tires are considered and the corresponding re-
sults are compared with regard to tire footprint areas, contact stresses, tire
operating temperature, and strain energy distribution.
Material Characterization
Hardness Test
As a rule of the thumb, the rubber hardness is related to its modulus
through a simple analytical expression. In this work, an actual tire is cut into
sections to investigate the real shoulder separation mode. Hardness tests are
conducted directly with rubbers on the surface of the cut section from the test
tire. On the one hand, these hardness data could be used to find the potential
rubber compound problem or rubber-manufacturing problem. On the other
hand, the hardness data are transformed to modulus properties through Neo-
Hookean law, according to 关12兴, using the following relationship, in which E is
given in MPa:
Tensile Test
In order to get the large deformation properties of the rubber components as
well as the elastic modulus of the steel wires 共as rebar in the structural model兲,
tensile tests are conducted with rubbers and steel wires, respectively. Figure 2
shows the tensile engineering stress and strain curves for chosen coupons of
tread rubber, tread cushion, and shoulder wedge.
FIG. 3 — Temperature-dependent loss tangent of tread rubber: measured data (dot) vs curve fit
(solid).
FIG. 4 — Temperature-dependent loss tangent of tread cushion: measured data (dot) vs curve fit
(solid).
YIN ET AL. ON TRUCK TIRE THERMAL-MECHANICAL FEA 225
FIG. 5 — Temperature-dependent loss tangent of shoulder wedge: measured data (dot) vs curve fit
(solid).
共C兲 The variation of material temperature is small during one rolling cycle.
共D兲 The time scale of the mechanical problem is assumed to be smaller than
the thermal one; thus structural and thermal analysis could be solved
separately.
h̄in =
1
2
冕冕
0 0
2
hinddt 共4兲
⍀ ញT ញ
h̄in = S 关␣兴E 共5兲
2
FIG. 8 — Contact stress and shape on (a) roadway and (b) drum.
Figure 8 shows the contact shape and stress under 4.615 Tone vertical load
on both drum and roadway. For the former the contact area is
0.0488 square meters and for the latter 0.059 64 square meters. The footprint
YIN ET AL. ON TRUCK TIRE THERMAL-MECHANICAL FEA 229
FIG. 9 — Local SENR distribution on (a) drum vs (b) roadway, 4.615 Tone, 65 km/ h.
width on the drum is nearly the same as that on the roadway, while the length of
the latter is larger. The average pressure for the drum is a little bit larger than
that of the roadway, about 22% in this case.
Figure 9 shows the local strain energy density 共SENR兲 distribution in the
tread-shoulder areas, which clearly indicates that the tire on drum undertakes
more severe strain energy density distribution, especially in the tire shoulder
parts. Note that here the strain energy density represents the maximum that a
material element undergoes during one cycle of tire rolling.
ⵜ · K ⵜ T − h̄in = 0 共6兲
where h̄in is the average heat generation rate and K the material effective heat
conduction matrix.
The heat generation rates calculated are brought into the commercial pro-
gram 共Abaqus兲 heat-transfer model as specified distributed fluxes 共through Key-
word *DFLUX兲 for each element. Also it should be pointed out that these heat
fluxes are dependent on tire real temperature, which is dealt with by adopting
the following empirical equation:
冢 冣
Kxx Kxy
K̄ = Kxy Kyy 共8兲
Kzz
where
nates in the commercial program. Two types of thermal boundary conditions are
considered; the first is thermal convection boundary conditions expressed as
冏 冏
Kn
T
n 0
= TR共T − Ta兲 共10兲
It can be shown from the thermal-mechanical FEA that the tire shoulder
area will undertake a high strain energy density cycle, as well as high heat
generation and high temperature. Due to these, the materials in the area of the
tire shoulder might fail by strain fatigue, thermal oxidative aging, or thermal
reversion-anaerobic aging. But which degradation type is dominant for shoulder
wedge, tread cushion, or tread compound? To answer this question, these rubber
materials have been chosen to perform a series of DMA tests before and after
tire endurance tests. Figure 11 shows the rubber samples cut from the tires after
drum endurance tests.
232 TIRE SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY
FIG. 10 — Temperature distribution: (a) drum vs (b) roadway loading, 4.615 Tone, 65 km/ h.
It has been found from Figs. 12 and 13 that the dynamical properties of
materials in different areas show different changes in tread, which might indi-
cate different failure mechanisms. Table 1 summarizes some generally accepted
conclusions concerning change of storage modulus and loss tangent of general
carbon black-filled rubber compound with different degradation type, i.e., strain
fatigue, thermal oxidative aging, and thermal revision-anaerobic aging. This
generally accepted knowledge helps us identify the rubber failure mechanism of
the tire tested.
Figure 12 shows the change of the dynamical mechanical properties of the
tread cushion compounds before and after drum tests, where E1 indicates the
storage modulus before drum tests; E1G31, E1G32, E1G33 the storage modulus
YIN ET AL. ON TRUCK TIRE THERMAL-MECHANICAL FEA 233
FIG. 11 — Rubber samples cut from the tires after drum endurance test.
after drum tests; TAND the loss tangents before drum tests; and TANDG31,
TANDG32, TANDG33 the loss tangents after drum tests. It can be found that all
storage moduli decrease after drum tests, however, loss tangent 共TANDG31兲
may increase after drum endurance tests. Referring to Fig. 9, the strain energy
density distribution; Fig. 10, the temperature distribution; and Table 1, it might
be concluded that the main failure mechanism of the tread cushion is due to
strain fatigue plus thermal revision-anaerobic aging.
Figure 13 shows the change of the dynamical mechanical properties of the
shoulder wedge before and after drum tests, where E1 indicates the storage
modulus before drum tests; E1G21, E1G2 the storage modulus after drum tests;
TAND the loss tangents before drum tests; and TANDG21, TANDG22 the loss
tangents after drum tests. It can be found that all storage moduli and loss
FIG. 12 — DMA of tread cushion compounds before and after drum tests: E1, storage modulus
before drum tests; E1G31, E1G32, E1G33, after drum tests; TAND; loss tangents before drum tests;
TANDG31, TANDG32, TANDG33, after drum tests.
234 TIRE SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY
FIG. 13 — DMA of shoulder wedge compounds before and after drum tests: E1, storage modulus
before drum tests; E1G21, E1G22, after drum tests; TAND, loss tangents before drum tests;
TANDG21, TANDG22, after drum tests.
tangent decrease after drum tests. Referring to Fig. 9, the strain energy density
distribution; Fig. 10, the temperature distribution; and Table 1, it might be
concluded that the main failure mechanism of the shoulder wedge is due to
strain fatigue plus thermal oxidative aging.
Recently, Baldwin and Bauer 关16,17兴 reported that shoulder wedge of pas-
senger radial tires undertake aerobic aging in both laboratory and field aging
processes, which is similar with our results concluded here from DMA. How-
ever, the degradation mechanism of tread cushion may be different from shoul-
der wedge, which is omitted by Baldwin and Bauer.
Summary
Change of storage
Degradation type Modulus Change of Loss Tangent
Strain fatigue Decrease Decrease
Acknowledgment
Support by the “Tsinghua University Fundamental Research Foundation” is
gratefully acknowledged.
References
关1兴 DeEskinazi, J. et al., “Towards Predicting Relative Belt Edge Endurance With Finite Element
Method,” Tire Science and Technology, TSTCA, Vol. 18, 1990, pp. 216–236.
关2兴 Wei, Y. T., Tian, Z. H., and Du, X. W., “Finite Element Model for the Rolling Loss Prediction
and Fracture Analysis of Radial Tires,” Tire Science and Technology, TSTCA, Vol. 27, 1999,
pp. 250–276.
关3兴 Beringer, C. W., Kwon, Y. D., and Prevorsek, D. C., “Sensitivity of Temperature Rise in a
Rolling Tire to the Viscoelastic Properties of the Tire Components,” Tire Science and Technol-
ogy, TSTCA, Vol. 15, 1987, pp. 123–133.
关4兴 Sarkar, K., Kwon, Y. D., and Prevorsek, D. C., “New Approach for the Thermomechanical
Analysis of Tires by the Finite Element Method,” Tire Science and Technology, TSTCA, Vol.
38, 1987, pp. 261–275.
关5兴 Nasdala, L. K. et al., “Aging of Tires With Respect to Oxidation,” in WCCM6. 2004. Beijing
China.
关6兴 Singh, M. et al., “Testing and Evaluation of Aircraft Tire Coupons,” Tire Science and Technol-
ogy, TSTCA, Vol. 22, 1994, pp. 42–59.
关7兴 Ebbott, T. G., “Application of Finite Element-Based Fracture Mechanics Analysis to Cord-
Rubber Structures,” Tire Science and Technology, TSTCA, Vol. 24, 1996, pp. 220–235.
关8兴 Ebbott, T. G. et al., “Tire Temperature and Rolling Resistance Prediction With Finite Element
Analysis,” Tire Science and Technology, TSTCA, Vol. 27, 1999, pp. 2–21.
关9兴 Mars, W. V., “Multiaxial Fatigue Crack Initiation in Rubber,” Tire Science and Technology,
TSTCA, Vol. 29, 2001, pp. 171–185.
236 TIRE SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY
关10兴 Han, Y. H. et al., “Fatigue Life Prediction for Cord-Rubber Composite Tires Using a Global-
Local Finite Element Method,” Tire Science and Technology, TSTCA, Vol. 32, 2004, pp.
23–40.
关11兴 LaClair, T. J. and Zarak, C., “Truck Tire Operating Temperatures on Flat and Curved Test
Surfaces,” Tire Science and Technology, TSTCA, Vol. 33, 2005, pp. 156–178.
关12兴 Qi, H. J., Joyce, K., and Boyce, M. C., “Durometer Hardness and the Stress-Strain Behavior of
Elastomeric Materials,” Rubber Chemistry and Technology, Vol. 76, 2003, pp. 419–435.
关13兴 Allen, D. H., “Thermomechanical Coupling in Inelastic Solids,” Applied Mechanics Reviews,
Vol. 44, 1991, p. 361.
关14兴 Oden, J. T. et al., “New Approach to the Finite-Element Formulation and Solution of a Class of
Problems Created in Coupled Thermoelastoviscoplasticity of Crystalline Solids,” Nuclear En-
gineering and Design, Vol. 24, 1973, pp. 420–430.
关15兴 HIBBITT, K. S., INC, ABAQUS/Standard Users Manual, Version 6.4, Vol. 1, 2004.
关16兴 Bauer, D. R., Baldwin, J. M., and Ellwood, K. R., “Correlation of Rubber Properties Between
Field Aged Tires and Laboratory Aged Tires,” Rubber Chemistry and Technology, Vol. 78,
2005, pp. 777–792.
关17兴 Baldwin, J. M., Bauer, D. R., and Ellwood, K. R., “Accelerated Aging of Tires, Part III,”
Rubber Chemistry and Technology, Vol. 78, 2005, pp. 767–776.