Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Learning Objectives
INTRODUCTION
Companies are placed on self – assessment from the YA 2001. Under Self
assessment, a company is required to submit only the Form C within 7 months after
the closing the company’s year end. The tax computation and audited accounts are
kept by the company for the inspection of IRB inspection during a tax audit:
Section 33 of the Act lays down the principles for determination of adjusted income,
which is:-
RM
Gross income xx
Less: Wholly and exclusively outgoings and (xx) (not prohibited by s39)
expenses
Adjusted income xx
The derivation of gross income from business is determined by virtue of s12. Business
income is assessed on an accrual basis and not on cash basis. As such, whether income is
received during the year is of no relevance as to its taxability.
Gross income of the business would be the ‘ revenue’ that is shown in the statements of
comprehensive income.
In practice the tax computation begins with the ‘profit before taxation’ as shown in the
statements of comprehensive income and appropriate adjustment is made to arrive at the
‘adjusted income’ or ‘adjusted loss’.
Derivation of business income (section 12) states that, any gross income of a person
derived from Malaysia from a business of his, then_,
Commencement of business:
It is important for you to determine the commencement date of the business
because:
i. Pre-commencement revenue expenses are not deductible (permanent loss).
ii. QPE of the capital allowance will be given in the first basis period from
the date of commencement.
FORMAT *
RM RM
Business income is chargeable under section 4(a) of the Income Tax Act 1967. It
includes profession, vocation and trade and every manufacturer, adventure, or
concern in the nature of trade, but excludes employment.
Vocation is a person who places bets systematically was held in a decided case law
to be carrying on a vocation. The gains derived were chargeable to tax even if the
vocation was unlawful.
The badges of trade may be used to determine whether the receipt or gains derived
from an insolate transaction constitute an adventure or concern in the nature of trade.
BADGES OF TRADE
Purpose/Intention:
Where an asset purchased for investment, was subsequently sold, the gain derived
is not taxable. If there were facts to show that there has been change of intention,
the gain derived would be taxable, as the investor has changed his intention to be
a trader.
In GDIR v LCW, the court took the difference between the selling price and the
market value of the land at the time when the change of intention took place.
Where the same object or article is repeatedly bought or sold, it would generally
lead to inference that there is trading in that article. In Pickford v Quirke, the
court held that although the transaction, considered separately, was capital, they
together constituted the carrying on of a trade.
There is no general rule laid down in deciding on the number of transactions for a
person to be considered a trader rather than investor. In Page v Pagson, the court
held that the profit of the second bungalow to be taxable but not for the first one,
Organization/Transaction by companies:
A company incorporated for the purpose of making profits for its shareholders,
any gainful use to which it put any of its assets prima facie amounts to the
carrying on of a business. As such, a company may hold a property for a long
period of time, any subsequent disposal may still be viewed as business income
because such a long holding may be viewed as waiting for the right opportunity to
realize profits.
The court would examine the nature of the company’s operation and not just the
capacity of the company alone. In CIR v Eccentric Club, it was always
presumed that a company was formed with the intention of carrying on a business.
Financing/Mode of acquisition:
The mode of finance placed great importance in determining whether the taxpayer
is trading in property or merely realizing its investment. If a company had the
intention to hold the asset as a long term investment, then the company should
inject more funds into the project rather than borrowing funds.
For example, a person may purchase an asset for purpose of development. His
financial position indicates that he does not have the adequate resources or fund to
Where there is a quick resale there will be an impression that a trade was
conducted and the gain would be taxable as decided in Turner v Last (1965).
In KLE Sdn Bhd v Ketua Pengarah Jabatan HDN (1995), the Special Comm.
held that the subject land’s commercial potential together with its good location,
being near developed areas was very good ready made advertisement in itself.
Therefore, there was no necessity to have a specialized organization with skilled
staff, and there was no further exertion needed to promote its resale. As such, the
disposal of land was held to be an adventure into nature of trade.
In another decided case, IRC v Fraser, the court held that the gain so derived was
trading receipt as a large quantity of whisky was purchased greatly in excess of
what could be use by himself, his family and friends, a commodity which yield no
pride of possession and which cannot be turned to account except in the process
of realization.
The above badges of trade are only broad guidelines in determining whether a
particular set of circumstances constitutes a trade. You may be able to remember
the various badges of trade by the words “PROFITSWIN”.
P = PURPOSE
R = REPETITION
O = ORGANIZATION
F = FINANCING
I = IMPROVEMENT
T = TIMING
S = SURROUNDING FACTORS
W = WAYS OF DISPOSAL
I = INTEREST IN SIMILAR FIELD
N = NATURE
Question 1
Julian retired at the age of 55 in 2018 and received a gratuity of RM100,000. She used
his gratuity and his EPF withdrawal of RM 150,000 to partly finance the cost of
acquisition of a piece of agricultural land costing RM300,000. The balance of the
acquisition cost was financed through borrowings from a bank.
Part of the agricultural land was developed into a durian plantation and the balance of the
land was rented out.
In 2020, he and his wife migrated to Melbourne to be with their children. Before he left
Malaysia, he sold the agricultural land for a gain of RM300,000. The sale was made
through a real estate agent. Neither he nor his wife disposed of any real property.
Required:
State, with reasons, whether the gains derived is taxable. (Whether this is a capital gain
or revenue receipt)
DETAIL OF DEDUCTIONS
Deductible and non-deductible expenses:
Types of expenses which qualify for deduction (section 33 and section 34):
Must be revenue expenditure in nature and not capital expenditure. Capital assets are
not deductible for tax purposes. Thus, this capital expenditure expensed off to the
profit and loss account has to be excluded. There are 4 characteristics o differentiate
between capital and revenue expenditure.
1) Initial expenditure.
Pre-commencement expenditure (all expenses incurred before the starting of
the business) for examples, legal fees to set up business, renovation to rented
property, etc.
Expenses incurred to a newly acquired assets.
2) Fixed capital or revenue expenditure?
Fixed assets are used for production which there will be no intention for resale
in the near future whereas a revenue expenditure is what the owner makes
profit by parting with it.
3) An asset is brought into business for the long-term benefit of a trade; it will be
classified as capital expenditure. E.g. purchase of plant and machinery.
CAPITAL REVENUE
(Not deductible) (Deductible)
Improvement on an asset /
Acquisition repair /
Replacement on whole of the asset /
Repairs of any fixed assets used in the /
business
Replacement on part of the asset /
Renewal /
Example: Wright Sdn Bhd incurred RM113,800 for the year ended 31.12.2020.
Details are as follows
RM
Salaries 60,000
Employer’s EPF contribution 23,800
Answer
EPF contribution 23,800
19% ( 60,000) (11,400)
Non-deductible expenses 12,400 (add back)
d) W.e.f. 2007, expenditure incurred for sponsoring any local or foreign arts, cultural
or heritage activity approved by Ministry of Culture, Arts and Heritage will be
given tax deduction of up to RM500 000. However, the amount of the expenditure
DOUBLE DEDUCTIONS
Double deduction refers to revenue expenses incurred that is given twice the amount as
deduction in arriving at the adjusted income of a business. This is a tax incentive
provided by the government to provide tax relief to business persons to encourage the
used of promoted activities such as research , local facilities, etc. To qualify for double
deduction, such expenses must be:
- Revenue expenses
- Not prohibited by s 39 of the Act
a) Remuneration for disabled employees.
b) Revenue expenditure incurred on research.
c) Cash contribution to approved research institution or payment use of services of
approved research institution or company. This includes payment for the use of
R&D Company.
d) Premium paid on export credit insurance taken with a company approved by the
Minister of Finance or any local insurance company.
e) Expenditure incurred in international trade fair held in Malaysia for promotion of
export.
f) Cost of a new personal computer as a gifts given by the employer to employees in
ascertaining the adjusted income of that company
g) Double deduction of for qualifying advertising expenditure
h) Double deduction for the promotion of exports of goods agriculture produce
i) Double deduction for promotion of export of services
j) Double deduction for promotion of international or private school
k) Child care centre
l) Vendor development programme
CAPITAL EXPENDITURE
The manufacturing company must be 70% Malaysian owned. Proprietor rights mean
patents, industrial design or trademarks.
Section 39 (1)(a) to (m) of the ITA list out the deductions which are not allowed for
the business income:
(a) Domestic or private expenses - Expenditure incurred for the private used of
business owner such as telephone bill for personal use.
(c) Any capital withdrawn or any sum employed intended to be employed as capital.
(e) Any capital expenditure incurred in relation to a business which would qualify for
Schedule 2,3, or 4 Allowances.
(f), (i), (j) Any payment (income in nature) made to a non-resident person where
withholding tax provision under section 107A,109 and 109B have not
been complied with.
(g) Any sum by whatever name called made otherwise than to the State Government,
a statutory authority for the use of license or permit to extract timber from a forest
in Malaysia.
(h) Deleted
(k) Lease rental paid in respect of a motor vehicle other than commercial vehicles for
goods or passengers in excess of RM50 000 or RM100 000.
Generally, legal or professional expenses are deductible where these are incurred in the
maintenance of trade rights trade facilities, existing or alleged to exist. And legal or
professional expenses are not deductible, as being of a capital nature, where incurred for
the purpose of acquiring new rights or facilities. The deductibility of expenses incurred to
maintain alleged trade rights does not depend on whether the action is successful or not.
Debt collection
Renewal of loans
Preparation of accounts
Defending tittle to property
Legal expenses incurred by landlord
Defending an action connected with a trade or breach of trading contracts
In ascertaining the adjusted income of a person resident in Malaysia from his business in
the basis period for a year of assessment, a deduction shall be allowed:
(a) Secretarial fee not exceeding RM5,000 in respect of secretarial services provided
by a company secretary registered under the Companies Act 1965 to comply with
the statutory requirements under the Act.
(b) Tax filling fee not exceeding RM10,000 charged by a tax agent approved under
Income Tax Act 1967 (ITA) in respect of:-
i. Preparation and submission of tax return under Section 77,77A,77B, 83
and 86 of the ITA for the basis period for the immediate preceding year of
assessment; and
ii. Preparation and submission of prescribed forms for purpose of Section
107c of the ITA
APPROVED DONATIONS
The gift of money made to the Government, State Government, local authority or an
approved institution or organisation shall be given a deduction in arriving at total income.
Where there is no sufficient aggregate income or the current year business loss exceeds
the AI, ant excess approved donations made during the year made during the basis period
is not permitted to be carried forward and thus result in a permanent loss for such
donations incurred.
Generally, the donation has to be in cash and not in kind. However, with effect from YA
1997, any gifts of artefacts, manuscript or painting to the Government or State
Government would be given a deduction. The amount deducted would be based on
valuation by the Department of Museum or National Archives.
A deductions not exceeding RM20,000 (cash contribution) made by the company for the
provision of library facilities which are accessible to the public and in respect of
contributions to public libraries and libraries of schools and institutions of higher
education shall be given a deduction in arriving at the total income.
A deduction equal to the value of painting (as determined by National Art Gallery or any
State Art Gallery) for the donation of painting to the National Art Gallery or any State
Art Gallery would be allowed a deduction against aggregate income.
Zakat Perniagaan
Zakat Perniagaan paid to Pusat Zakat of the various states in Malaysia shall be given tax
deduction provided such amount does not exceed 2.5% of AI of the company.
With effect from YA 2020, the total amount of the cash donations to approved institution,
organisation of fund and shall not exceed 10% of the AI of the company.