Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Pages From Vikalpa36!3!119 130
Pages From Vikalpa36!3!119 130
W
hile going through the bullion rate and the sky-rocketing gold prices, the
only question that the board members at the Titan Industries, Bangalore
were deliberating was: Is gold inaccessible to the Indian customers living
in the semi-urban and rural markets? Can it be made a part of their purchase kitty?
Titan has been a pioneer in organized retailing in jewellery business. With its brand,
“Tanishq,” Titan became India’s largest jewellery brand. The focus of Tanishq was on
design differentiation and studded jewellery as a category. This resulted in alienating
consumers from smaller towns/villages. The rural and semi-urban India actually
contributes around 60 per cent of the total gold consumption in India. They started
perceiving Tanishq as a “Not for Me” brand. It was with this perspective in mind, that
Titan decided to foray into this market with a brand which was perceived as neither
upmarket nor premium, mentions Mr. Munish, Brand Manager of GoldPlus. Titan as
a company has various initiatives in place to ensure that the company remains com-
petitive both in the short term and long term. One such initiative is called “Future
Shock,” in which middle and senior management of the Titan Industries present fu-
ture business opportunities to a jury. Based on the recommendations of the jury and
evaluation by the board, the company evaluates the opportunities.
“GoldPlus” as a concept was presented in one of the Future Shocks in 2004-05. Subse-
quently, the company initiated pilot projects in two locations – Erode in Tamil Nadu
and Ratlam in Madhya Pradesh. Based on the performance of these stores, the com-
pany decided to expand its business. The focus was on overhauling the market and
creating awareness among customers about purity of gold. Since the historic times,
gold has always been a sought-after commodity in terms of investment, symbol of
KEY WORDS status, and display in cultural occasions. However, Munish felt that the feasibility of
launch and sale of branded jewellery in a market inundated with mom and pop stores
Gold Consumption was a great challenge that needed to be addressed.
Competition
TATA GROUP PIONEERS IN BOP GOLD MARKET
Gold Loans
Founded by Jamsetji Tata in 1868, Tata’s early years were inspired by the spirit of
Brand Marketing
nationalism. Currently, the Tata companies operate in seven business sectors: engi-
Buying Behaviour neering, materials, services, energy, consumer products, chemicals, communications
Rural India and information systems. The major Tata companies are Tata Steel, Tata Motors, Tata
Consultancy Services (TCS), Tata Power, Tata Chemicals, Tata Tea, Indian Hotels, and
Tata Goup
Tata Communications.
120 TATA GOLDPLUS: THE SUCCESS STORY OF THE ‘NANO’ OF THE JEWELLERY MARKET
GOLD BUYING BEHAVIOUR AND RURAL INDIA Gold Jewellery Loans
As per the WGC estimates, about 60 per cent of the gold in Many banks in India have provision for loans for pur-
India is bought in small towns and villages. According to chasing gold jewellery. These loans are generally targeted
these estimates, the Indian jewellery market is worth at working women between 18 and 55 years of age. The
around Rs. 70,000 crore ($16 billion). The urban jewellery willingness on the part of the banks to grant loan for this
market is valued at Rs. 28,000 crore ($6.4 billion), while purpose in itself is a reflection of the importance of gold
the rural and semi-urban market is valued Rs. 42,000 crore jewellery in India’s economy and traditions. The rise of
($9.6 billion).3 As estimated by L Natarajan, Vice Presi- India’s wealth and the increase in the middle class popu-
dent of GoldPlus, Jewellery Division of Titan, in five years’ lation will further increase the demand for gold jewellery
time, the rural jewellery market could grow up to in India.4
Rs.50,000 crore ($11.4 billion) at today’s gold prices.
GoldPlus sells gold jewellery only in semi-urban and ru- RATIONALE FOR GOLDPLUS
ral areas; unlike its sister concern, Tanishq, which has an The annual consumption of gold which was estimated at
urban focus. 65 tonnes in 1982, has increased to over 800 tonnes. Pres-
ently, about 80 per cent of the gold consumption is for
Currently, this market is dominated by small time mom-
jewellery fabrication (mainly over 22 carat purity) for do-
and-pop jewellery stores, which are largely local in na-
mestic demand while 15 per cent is for investor demand
ture. This means that the opportunity is really big and if
and barely 5 per cent is for industrial use. The remarkable
we look at the customer’s expectations, they are varied –
feature is the way the investment in jewellery has come to
wide range of jewellery for all occasions, purity, discounts,
dominate the market. The urban demand for gold is pri-
affordable prices, trust, good retail experience, states Mr
marily for adornment jewellery rather than investment,
Munish. However, the market has small fragmented play-
but in the informal barter economy of rural India, gold
ers, who offer traditional designs, low caratage, picked
still remains a part of the retail cottage industry and thus
up trends from city, negotiation, and inconsistent pric-
plays a distinct monetary role.
ing. Therefore, there is an identifiable gap between the
expectations and market offerings, which can be ear- Apart from this, the entry of GoldPlus was attributable to
marked as a prospective market. GoldPlus being a fairly the lack of standardization in jewellery. The Tata’s en-
new brand in the business, and currently operating in tered the gold business in 2005 with the objective of intro-
only 30 locations, competes with over 10,000 big and small ducing standardization in the manufacturing and mar-
jewellers with an average market share of around 20 per keting of gold jewellery, catering not only to the elite but
cent. also to the urban, semi-urban, and rural clientele.5
Recycled Gold While the Tanishq showrooms are for the elite, the
GoldPlus showrooms are for the semi-urban and rural
According to WGC, recycled gold now accounts for 30
customers. While the purity and quality of the jewellery
per cent of the gold consumption in India. According to
in both categories of showrooms will be the same, the
GR Ananthapadmanabhan, Managing Director of GR difference is in the type of designs offered. The customers
Thanga Maligai, the rise in recycled gold could be par- in the semiurban and rural regions have been deprived of
tially due to couples buying gold coins as a wedding in- assured purity, transparency, and quality retail experi-
vestment and then melting them down into jewellery for ence. GoldPlus has revolutionized the jewellery business
the wedding celebrations. He also believes that the ma- by offering pure gold jewellery from a trusted player with
jority of Indians are reluctant to sell their gold and tend to
transparent business practices and amazing retail expe-
consult their family members if at all they do (Economic
rience and all that at a reasonable cost, states Mr.Munish.
Times, 2008)
4 “Indian Gold Jewellery” (2006). Gold Price, retrieved on Jun 1
2009, available at http://goldprice.org/gold-jewellery/2006/01/
indian-gold-jewellery.html
3 Bijlani, S (2009). “India’s $9.6 Billion Rural Jewellery Market,“ 5 “Tata Opens GoldPlus Showroom in Vellore,“ (2007). The Hindu,
retrieved on August 11,2009, available at http://www.idexonline. retrieved on May 5, 2009, available at http://www.hindu.com/
com/portal_FullMazalUbracha.asp?id=32005 2007/03/20/stories/2007032005830200.htm
122 TATA GOLDPLUS: THE SUCCESS STORY OF THE ‘NANO’ OF THE JEWELLERY MARKET
Indian cities where gold savings are comparable to eq- ent. The brand has opted for below-the-line activities to
uity holdings and financial assets and can be considered achieve a direct interaction with the consumer. In order
as the best territory for the product. The company focused to do that, GoldPlus decided to create a promo which
on a very region-specific assortment with the existing would grab the attention of the target customer; it created
vendor base. The retail strategy was developed on the a 24.5 kg gold bangle that gave it an entry into the Limca
location, ambience, and experience at the store, with the Book of Records and took the bangle on a roadshow in 17
idea of making the environment conducive for a perfect towns. Competitions were organized around the same
gold shopping experience. Apart from the outlook of the theme like a ‘guess the weight of the bangle’ contest. The
store, the display windows and panels were also taken company also offered a photo opportunity to visitors, with
care of. The marketing was completely localized, to achieve options to mail their photographs to five of their acquaint-
the right background for a strong relationship. The brand ances. Such exercises helped the company to establish a
sponsored various local events and took initiatives to sound network.
make a place in the hearts of the people. And with all
Other innovative promotions include new store openings
these endeavours, Titan (Tata) has been able to achieve a
being preceded by distribution of gold paper slips to po-
firm footing in the mass market and is all set to become a
tential customers in a 3-5 km. radius of the store. The
billion dollar company by 2009-10. Also the model pro-
posed a great opportunity for the society with increased slips carry the message: To convert paper into real gold,
awareness, improved business practices, enhanced em- visit the GoldPlus outlet. Similar promotions are con-
ployment opportunities to the karigars by elimination of ducted inside hotels by offering a free sweet dish and a
middle men, increased employment to rural community, paper coin along with the bill or gold paper with flowers
providing professional service, trusted quality at afford- while leaving a temple.
able prices, and variety to choose from ready-to-wear jew- There are many small and big events that team GoldPlus
ellery and value-for-money products. conducts throughout the year. These events are aimed at
bringing out the talent of locals. Also for GoldPlus, these
Building Customer Base
events act as a step towards becoming part of the family
Consumers from the B and C income groups react to dif- of the customers and as a result be their family jeweller.
ferent triggers, have different tastes, and need to be com-
municated very differently (Kotler, 2007). A significant Golden Chariot
chunk of GoldPlus’ target customer group comprises peo-
Despite the fact that the country is the world’s biggest
ple who invest in the yellow metal rather than buying it
consumer of gold, knowledge about the metal itself, the
for immediate use – this includes people saving for their
processes that the metal has to undergo, and how it is
weddings, or those putting aside a little something for
finished into jewellery, is extremely poor, particularly in
their daughters’ trousseau.
rural and semi-urban areas in India. The company there-
Over 40 per cent of the estimated annual gold purchases fore decided to launch an initiative to educate people in
of Rs 70,000 crore is accounted for by customers who start rural areas about gold purity, hallmarking and other proc-
buying for their daughters’ marriages when the child is esses. GoldPlus has a custom-built bus called the thanga
barely six. For such customers, purity of gold is more im- ratham (gold chariot) which goes from village to village in
portant than the variety of designs and quality of work- Tamil Nadu with an on-board video educational cam-
manship (important issues with the SEC A).6 paign. The bus has covered 1,500 villages in three months.
Moreover, every Saturday, GoldPlus invites more than 40
Brand Marketing customers to visit their Hosur factory and has an interac-
tive session with them. GoldPlus is clear that more than
Brand Tanishq has been heavily advertised on television
anything else it has to win over the trust of the consumer.
which has been seen as a medium to reach the masses
And for that, GoldPlus has the ‘Golden Chariot’ initia-
whereas Goldplus’ marketing strategy has been differ-
tive that involves taking a vehicle with a carat-meter, to
6 “Golden Management Lessons from Titan” (2007). Rediff Business, customer hubs. Customers are then encouraged to come
retrieved on Mar 28, 2009, available at http://in.rediff.com/money/ and check the purity of the gold they already own using
2007/mar/28Titan.htm
124 TATA GOLDPLUS: THE SUCCESS STORY OF THE ‘NANO’ OF THE JEWELLERY MARKET
Corporate Social Responsibility franchisee-driven. The logic behind this move is quite
GoldPlus has also been able to discharge their corporate evident: jewellery is a localised business and especially
social responsibility. It has launched two major initia- in smaller towns, the store manager needs to have local
tives in 15 districts for auto rickshaw drivers to help them contacts and be a trusted individual so as to be able to
buy gold with their savings. In other social initiatives, the inspire confidence in customers. The franchisee is the face
company has held a free eye check-up camp, distributed of the brand in every town and is the key to the success of
5,000 eyeglasses, and performed 100 cataract operations. the model. Potential franchisees – typically, the most
Ananta, the loyalty programme of GoldPlus, ensures that prominent jewellers in the area – are decided on the basis
20 per cent of the gifts are procured from the institutes of their network and their potential business worth. (They
run by the NGOs. GoldPlus customers and non-purchas- have to be capable of investing Rs 50 lakh in the new
ers are invited for factory visits. They are taken to Hosur venture). Even the options GoldPlus extends to its cus-
where Titan has a state-of-the-art jewellery manufactur- tomers – programmes like chit funds and savings schemes
ing factory and are shown the process of manufacturing (where money saved with the company earns interest,
and how GoldPlus ensures purity in making every piece which is later used to buy jewellery) – are more typical of
of jewellery. At the end of the visit, they also get to interact traditional jewellers than the corporate organizations.
with the senior team of Titan, where a question-answer Titan currently has 30 GoldPlus stores in South India.
session is held. Over the next couple of years, it plans to expand in very
small towns across the country. When the whole world
THE BRAND PROMISE was talking about standardizing the retail look and feel
of stores, GoldPlus went ahead and decided to give a
Promise of Purity local touch to every store. As a result, there is reflection of
The absence of standardized practices in markets often local nuances in the store. This helps in avoiding aliena-
leads to a latent fear among consumers about the purity tion of the local customers and making them feel comfort-
of gold. GoldPlus aims to create awareness about gold able, states Mr. Munish. GoldPlus works on the franchisee
purity and thereby set new jewellery standards. It aims to model. The key lies in selecting the right franchisee who
establish an emotional connect by participating in every could be a local face for the brand. The importance is
gold purchase need of the consumers whether it is festi- given more to the image than the financial strength or
vals, marriages or harvest season with the promise of retail experience. Also the franchisee partner has to be
purity. A range of over 5,000 designs in 22 carat plain one who is involved in the business and interacts with
gold and diamond jewellery are offered in the showroom the customers and ensures quality standards.
to cater to the needs of quality-conscious consumers. The
brand stands for purity and fulfilling promises, and in SEGMENTATION AND EXPANSION
line with this, purity certificates are provided with all Consumers in South are emotional and are driven by fam-
GoldPlus products as a guarantee for purity. ily values. For example, they do not buy diamonds be-
cause of the firm belief of Dosha (ill-effects because of
Backed by Titan’s Experience
inclusions in diamonds). On the other hand, consumers
GoldPlus leverages the design and retail expertise of the in the North are driven more by Value. This is the reason
Titan Industries to present market relevant offerings ca- that the Southern stores have a low mix of diamond jew-
tering to local tastes and preferences. The product range, ellery whereas the Northern stores have a healthy mix of
showroom ambience, and marketing efforts showcase the diamonds.
company’s superior understanding of local consumers.
Titan’s investment in IT and retail will further enable GoldPlus today offers a wide range of gold jewellery, dia-
GoldPlus to achieve cost-effective supply chain logistics, mond jewellery, Cubic Zircon (American diamond), and
which will deliver greater value for the customers. coloured stones (ruby, emeralds, pearl). In each of the cat-
egories, the brand ensures that the products are of world
DISTRIBUTION NETWORK class quality. Also all the products come with a quality
certificate that gives the details of every element used.
Unlike the Tanishq stores, which are a mix of company-
owned and franchises, the GoldPlus chain is entirely
126 TATA GOLDPLUS: THE SUCCESS STORY OF THE ‘NANO’ OF THE JEWELLERY MARKET
addressed by Tata GoldPlus. It needs to sustain and en- wipe out the thin margin on which GoldPlus works. The
hance its position in the market through its success mantra challenges are too many and might influence the success
or even change as per market dynamics. Market innova- or even existence of this innovation by Tata.
tion, extensive market research, opportunity of tapping
the bottom of the Indian pyramid and many more suc- THE ISSUES
cessful milestones to cover are on the cards of this first of • What strategies should GoldPlus adopt to compete in
its kind rural jewellery brand. GoldPlus offers its custom- the market?
ers trust that comes from the House of Tatas. Also the
• How can GoldPlus compete with inundated unorgan-
process followed by the retail chain offers transparency
ized jewellery mom-and-pop stores?
which is not very usual in jewellery business. Providing
access to customers to equipments like caratmeter and • Would it be advisable to launch the brand in the Delhi
electric furnace makes it possible for the customer to physi- NCR market, given the profile of the rural and semi-
cally see the entire process. The team at GoldPlus realizes urban customers in this region? What problems are
that as the government enforces Hallmarking, purity will they likely to face while implementing this expansion
no longer be an advantage. Keeping this in mind, they strategy?
have also started working on a design leadership plat- • What innovative marketing strategies can GoldPlus
form which the brand wants to own in the next three adopt to increase its market share in the Indian mar-
years, as informed by Mr. Gaurav of Tata GoldPlus. It ket?
also faces competition from other jewellery brands offer- • As Brand Manager of GoldPlus, what strategies would
ing discounts and gifts which GoldPlus, being a thin- you have recommended for strengthening Tata
margin business, cannot afford. Any external factor can GoldPlus brand?
ANNEXURES
EDUCATION
Thanga Ratham
• Mobile caratmeter
• Increase awareness on purity
• Screening of educative film
• Drive traffic to stores
- Bangaru Ratham for AP
• Planning to start after 6 stores in AP
• Also studying the viability for other states
128 TATA GOLDPLUS: THE SUCCESS STORY OF THE ‘NANO’ OF THE JEWELLERY MARKET
Exhibit 4: The Store
Acknowledgement. The authors are grateful to Mr Munish, providing strategic insights into the case but also providing
Brand Manager, GoldPlus from the Titan Industries, Banga- relevant information through a comprehensive interview
lore and Mr. Gaurav Khanna, Marketing Manager, Titan, schedule. Acknowledgement is also due to Ms. Yukti Ahuja,
Banglore for extending all the support in terms of not only researcher for her help in data collection.
Anu Singh Lather is currently the Dean and Head, University Puja Khatri is currently the coordinator of International Af-
School of Management Studies and the Director, International fairs at the Guru Gobind Singh Indraprastha University, Delhi.
Affairs, Guru Gobind Singh Indraprastha University, Delhi. She is a Post-graduate in Business Management from
She has about 120 papers published in journals of national Kurukshetra University. She holds a doctorate degree in
and international repute and in proceedings of national and management and has over 11 years of experience in teaching
international conferences. She has been extensively conduct- and research. She is Associate Professor in the University
ing workshops and corporate training programmes in the School of Management Studies. She has published 50 research
areas of HRM, Organizational Development, and Business papers in journals of national and international repute and in
Communication in India and abroad. She has been conferred proceedings of national and international conferences.
with the ‘Best Researcher’ award by the University in 2010
and 2011. e-mail: pujakhatri12@gmail.com
e-mail:usms.dean@gmail.com