Professional Documents
Culture Documents
BUSINESS MANAGEMENT
Research question: To what extent has DMart effectively used marketing strategies to
1
Contents
Introduction…………………………………………………………………………...………………3
Methodology………………………………………………………….……………...……………….5
Background Information……..…………………………………………………..………….……….6
Ratio Analysis…………………………………….………………………………………….22
Conclusion…………………………………………………………………………..…….…………23
Bibliography……………………………………………………………………………….…...…….25
2
Introduction
The purpose of this essay is to investigate and analyze the utilization of various marketing
techniques by DMart. Founded in the year 2002 by Mr. Radhakishan Damani, DMart is a one-
step supermarket chain that offers a vast range of basic home and personal products in the
same place. All of its basic home utility products are available at competitive prices and quality
which takes after the company’s strong belief in value retailing and is one of the many
business traits DMart has which attributes to its exceptional, retained success. With the
mission statement of “to provide the best value possible for our customers, so that every
rupee they spend on shopping with us gives them more value for money than they would get
anywhere else.” DMart opened its first branch in Powai 2002, and today it is established in 216
locations throughout 11 states [ CITATION Dmart \l 1033 ] . An approximate annual revenue of $3.3
Even after being founded in the early 2000s , in a world leading towards being dominated by
e-commerce retail giants such as Amazon, BigBasket, JioMart etc. a brick and mortar
supermarket found its own niche by making its play on consumer psychology.
Therefore, this essay will analyze the: business model, business decisions, pricing strategy,
growth trends, differentiating factors etc. of DMart and analyze it using various business tools
“To what extent has DMart effectively used marketing strategies to increase market
Because the purpose of this essay aims to establish the central reasons for DMart’s success
3
differentiating/limiting factors. I believe that DMart is a business from which countless new
entrepreneurs can take lessons from. It has positively affected infinite Indian households by
4
Methodology
The research put forward is solely undertaken via secondary means. A spectrum of sources
has been used to provide depth to the investigation. Including: textbooks, newspaper articles,
corporate reports etc. Authenticity of the research and analysis is verified to ensure the
integrity of the investigation. Ansoff matrix conveys how DMart has employed aspects of
growth strategies, while Porter’s 5 forces assess DMart’s external environment and its
distinctive USP. Lastly, employing Ratio Analysis has enabled us to gain insights about the
I have analyzed the organizational objectives/business philosophy of DMart and the manner in
which they have expanded their business (Unit 1.3, 1.6), Whilst paying attention to the
organizational culture and values of DMart with reference to their stakeholders (customers,
employees, vendors) (unit 2). Furthermore, in order to identify the key components of DMart’s
brand and how they constructed their identity, we have focused on the extended Marketing mix
(unit 4). Shedding light on several factors which may be the reason for its growth. As DMart is
a business in the retail industry, to a very large extent, their operations are also a part of their
branding. Which is why we have also considered several factors from DMart’s operations
However, as the organized retail sector of India is still relatively small, figures such as market
share are subject to a high degree of inaccuracy. Furthermore, this study will not take the
pandemic and recent acquisition of Future retail by Reliance into major consideration, as with
5
Background Information
DMart opened its first branch in Powai 2002, and today it is established in 216 locations
throughout 11 states[ CITATION Dmart \l 1033 ]. Radhakishan Damani ventured into the retail
business for the first time with a purchase of franchisee of Apna Bazaar, after which 2 years
later he opened DMart. Now DMart is the 3 rd largest supermarket chain in India and out of 12%
share of organized retail in the market, DMart accounts for 0.4% [ CITATION Jan20 \l 1033 ]
DMart operates in stores that are between 20k to 30k square feet in size and majorly targets
the average Indian household. They aim to be the lowest priced retail in the regions they chose
to establish themselves in[ CITATION Dmart \l 1033 ].During the start of the company its promoters
walked around the supermarkets and co-operatives existing then, to gain understanding of
what the customers bought and why and why they rejected the other products. Philosophically
the business followed the principles laid down by Sam Walton [ CITATION Dam17 \l 1033 ] . Giving
6
PORTER’S FIVE FORCES
circumstances is vital for the progress and survival of a firm within the market. DMart operates
in the Indian retail market which is one of the fastest growing markets in the world and is
expected to reach Rs.76.87 lakh crore in 2020[ CITATION Rav201 \l 1033 ]. Therefore 5 relevant
Competitive
rivalry
supplier threat of
power new entry
Porters's
5 forces
threat of
buyer power
subsitution
7
Competitive rivalry
The retail industry in India is filled with a spectrum of businesses, firms and shops. On one
hand you have giants like Future Retail, DMart, Reliance Retail and on the other hand you
have 12 million ‘kirana stores’ exclusive to every neighborhood in the country [ CITATION
Fin201 \l 1033 ]. After the sudden boost in modernization, number of supermarkets in India have
gone up to up to 8.5 thousand in 2016 from a mere 500 in 2006 [ CITATION Mad20 \l 1033 ] ;
despite the presence of numerous retailers, these local stores have thrived and sustained
themselves. Reflecting the magnitude of the demand from Indian consumers. The retail
industry in India accounts for approx. 12% of the GDP, out of which DMart only takes up
0.4%. Therefore, the cumulative potential of the whole industry is enough to encompass a
spectrum of retailers. As there is no predominant ‘winner’ in the physical retail market, many
DMart already has a eminent position within the market, as it earned a revenue of Rs.6450
Company No. of stores Cities
crores, procuring Rs.211 crores profit
DMart 214 69
in FY14-15. Which was higher than Reliance Retail 10901 6700
Reliance Retail’s Rs. 159 crores and Big Bazaar 2000 400
despite having fewer outlets [ CITATION Bal19 \l 1033 ]. Partly because DMart’s per store revenue
was close to Rs. 53 crores, while Reliance was making around Rs. 7.45 crores per
store[CITATION sou19 \l 1033 ]. However, The recent acquisition of Future group by Reliance
8
The combined revenue of both retailers is estimated to be 2 times that of DMart’s.
Brick&Mortar presence of Reliance will also rise with the addition of 290 large format Future
retail stores in the pre-existing 797 Reliance stores [ CITATION Ami20 \l 1033 ]. Also taking into
consideration the intensely competitive market and DMart’s weak e-commerce, this force is
relatively strong. DMart’s traditionalist approach will not be able to withstand the
This external factor co-relates with competitive rivalry. The Indian retail market is at the
boom stage and may seem very attractive to people on the outside. With the high
consumer demand in India there are likely to be a lot of new players trying to enter the
high of 21823.52 INR Billion in the fourth quarter of 2019 and India's retail market is
estimated to reach $1.75 Tn by 2026, the market can see been as an international
opportunity to businesses.
9
However, several barriers to entry could involve the inability to build economies of scale
due to dominant firms, expensive supply cost management, product differentiation, legal
Regardless, as DMart expands in clusters and strives to form a loyal customer base in
its locations, new entries in the market may not be majorly harmful. Furthermore, it is
difficult in distinguishing a firm in the retailing industry as all firms sell products
Threat of substitution
The threat of substitution for DMart is relatively high. As DMart stocks essential
products the demand is inelastic. However due to the availability of so many retailers,
consumers can easily switch to buying from other retailers. To ensure market relevance
DMart must maintain their phenomenal prices and humble customer service.
DMart’s business model is not easy to imitate wherein, the company lays emphasis on
cost-control over revenues with a belief that revenues will come if the processes are
D-Mart focused on getting the front-end right and invested in supply chain.
Retail is all about detail therefore even though business cloning is a serious problem, it
doesn’t pose much of a threat to brands like DMart who have earned consumer’s
edge vulnerable.
10
However, the pandemic has caused a change in the customer base of DMart.
Consumers from the upper middle-class income sector chose to stay safe within the
confines of their houses and shop online. Causing DMart to lose a segment of their
Buyer power
Within the Retail industry, Buyer power is quite a strong force. They hold massive sway
mentioned above, consumer expenditure just reached an all-time high in India, hence
creating a surge of demand. As all supermarkets and their information such product
range/prices are available for the customers to know and compare, consumer
awareness is quite high. Even though the bargaining power of buyers is weak at an
individual level, due to multiple substitutes; almost all business decisions aim to attract
customers. Despite product rates being fixed, firms with optimum customer service and
least price get the most benefit, Ecommerce has us taught that even a slight change in
However, with reference to DMart customers don’t have a low switching cost, As
DMart offers the lowest prices; Safeguarding them from customer turnover and
Supplier power
Suppliers are one of the 3 pillars which DMart is based upon. Due to the availability of
suppliers in the retail industry and their ability to support new competitors, they tend to
dominate when negotiating with retailers. However, that’s not the case for DMart.
11
One of DMart’s strategies form the get-go was to ‘go local’. Their reliance on local
supplies instead of complex supply chains [ CITATION 10s17 \l 1033 ] enabled the business
to form close, personal relations with their suppliers. Vendors are usually small,
Because supermarkets buy goods from reputed MNCs via distributers, small traders in
India are perpetually short on capital. DMart decided to capitalize on this opportunity, by
paying vendors faster that most of its competitors; therefore, building themselves a
Because of this, vendors are loyal towards DMart and want them to succeed [ CITATION
Dam17 \l 1033 ]. DMart has also made itself appealing to suppliers and manufactures by
being a giant point of sales, even towards massive FMCG firms such as Hindustan
Unilever,etc[ CITATION BAN20 \l 1033 ] ; they even charge a slotting fees in exchange of
Which is why, when the industry suffers from the strong force of supplier power; for
DMart it is weak.
From the analysis of the external factors we can deduce that DMart has created an eco-
system for themselves that helps them overcome the complexities of the retail industry.
For example, their ability to inspire loyalty from not only customers, but vendors have rewarded
them with paramount progress. Regardless of competitive forces, strategic planning seems to
be an asset for DMart. To comprehend how DMart operates in these external circumstances
and analyze the role of various growth strategies in their success we will refer to the Ansoff
matrix.
12
ANSOFF matrix
Market penetration
require a distinct competitive edge. DMart is known for its ‘conservative’ approach. In
order to play safe: they stock common, well knows brands in their stores. However,
existing markets pose the challenge of pre-existing competitors with a wide customer
By offering prices which are 6-7% lower than that of the competition’s[CITATION Bal19
13
Within 65% of the Indian population who come under the categories of lower middle
class, middle class and upper middle class; all of whom are its potential customers
[ CITATION Jan20 \l 1033 ] . Following the strategy of EDLC (every day low cost) has
enabled them to practice EDLP (every day low price) and perpetually offer products
following the penetrative pricing strategy, not only attracts customers, but also acts as
a promotional strategy. Complementing this, DMart’s tagline is- ‘Daily Savings, Daily
one location, is a play of DMart’s on the traditional Indian ‘kirana stores’(local grocery
stores which can be found in almost every street). Because of which DMart has the
‘convenience’ factor to woo customers into shopping with them. This has also led to
DMart establishing an influencing market presence in West and South India which in
turn reduces logistic costs as well. Due to DMart’s dominant presence in their clusters,
competitors are discouraged to open outlets where DMart stores are found.
The slow pace of expansion allows DMart to focus on profitability. Which is exactly
why DMart has never shut down a single store since it started and [CITATION Anu17 \l
1033 ]. Due the company’s stringent belief in the ownership model, the company has
spent up to Rs. 23 billion on acquiring land and buildings or they enter into long term-
lease agreements. Because of this the company has never turned in a loss since its
14
Number
of
stores
per
year
expansion policy and rigorous focus on its core products, diversification for DMart
is minimal and rare. DMart follows Market penetration, with little to none product
their risk averse approach, they employ market development as patiently, diligently and
market DMart must increase its expansion rate, as their competitors can surpass
DMart’s cost advantages by using Economies of Scale. Essentially every strategy which
enables DMart to increase market share and customer base within the existing market,
15
However, to further increase market share in the industry; market development will be
vital[ CITATION San20 \l 1033 ]. Amalgamating low-cost strategies with marketing objectives has
been very effective for DMart; When low costs transform into low prices, consumers get
To decipher how each of these objectives and policies fit into DMart’s brand identity, their
PRODUCT
PHYSICAL
PRICE
ENVIRONMENT
TARGET
MARKET
PROCESS PROMOTION
PEOPLE PLACE
16
PRODUCT
DMart is an ‘all in one’ supermarket chain that strives to offer their consumers a wide
range of basic home and personal products all in one place. They stock home utility
appliances. DMart doesn’t have to pay attention to the product life cycle of these
The product range provided by DMart is limited because they want to maintain low
margins.
However, all of their products are branded and of optimum quality. Branding is an
important factor which differentiates a firm’s products from that of competitors. DMart’s
brand is based upon ‘Value retailing’ in accordance with its customer base. Products in
each cluster are stocked with the local needs and preference of customers in mind.
Since DMart’s products are analogous to that of the competitor’s, there isn’t much
scope of distinction. Diversifying into related sectors such as apparel and e-retailing can
17
PRICE
DMart follows perennial penetration pricing. It is vital that while deciding their pricing
sustain low margins from selling products at discounts, DMart has to tweak its business
model to save finance on marketing and operations. As DMart stocks FMCG products
and sells them to price sensitive customers, their pricing strategy also acts as their
brand. In FY19, when DMart faced an increase in discounting by other brick &
mortar/online grocers, it cut prices across the board. Regardless of downfall in gross
margins, they retained their ‘lowest price’ position. This compels consumers to trust
PROMOTION
they develop a presence in that area. Which is why with the help of ‘Word of Mouth’,
consumers get attracted to the heavy discounts. Other than this DMart sends out
newspaper adverts and depends on sales promotions and point of sales promotion from
the perpetual discounts and offers. DMart doesn’t believe in promotional strategies such
Their focus and determination to provide EDLP, has created a strong association of
18
PLACE
DMart expands itself in clusters to facilitate easy supply chain with local vendors, so
that inventory can be transformed into sales swiftly, they deliberately situate themselves
near residential areas which are population dense and cost effective in comparison to
DMart eliminates all intermediaries so that they don’t have to pay other middlemen
and can control the quality and quantity of stock themselves [ CITATION Bal19 \l 1033 ].
Quick payments and personal relationships with suppliers further smoothen the supply
chain. The network of local vendors facilitates them to provide its below MRP rates.
DMart grabs the opportunity of economies of sales, bulk buys and pays the suppliers
upfront within 48 hours(while other organized retailers buy goods on credit of 30-
However, as DMart has already occupied the low-cost spaces, further expansion
might raise costs as the real estate prices of existing properties might be higher and
cause short-term cash flow problems as DMart believes in the ownership model.
19
PEOPLE
DMart’s employees are one of the firm’s 3 pillars. DMart employs simple, hardworking
people and then trains them to become efficient retail associates. Because the
employees don’t have a heavy job description, they aren’t extremely pedigreed
people. The simplicity of the staff is balanced with global-standard store equipment.
Employees are pressure-free as they don’t have a sales target. Even if the staff is
rewarded and trained, DMart lives by its ‘self-service’ policy and rather devotes focus on
its products and supply chain[ CITATION Dam17 \l 1033 ]. DMART's operational costs with
respect to employee expense are significantly lower than its competitors, as they
20
PROCESS
experience at their stores. Because DMart puts such focus in testing than doing, they
training programs for employees, improve their skills and service standards, while
reducing attrition rates. Because DMart has high footfall, there is always a crowd in the
stores, even still the payment method goes on in flow and there are staff members who
constantly help customers locate products etc. Regardless, for middle incomed
households the benefits of discounts is so great, that they might forgive slight flaws in
customer service but still come back for the unparalleled prices of the products
PHYSICAL ENVIRONMENT
DMart aims is to provide their customers with quality products at less prices, and
they don’t let any factor deviate themselves from this goal. Whatever comes in between
profitability and low costs is abandoned, including posh interior, wide lanes, attractive
DMart could have tried to achieve all of these elements as well, but then it would have
lost its competitive edge. Their No-Frills policy inspires a minimalistic but hygienic
interior.
21
Therefore, it can be concluded that DMart delineates utmost importance to PRICE, and all the
other P’s are somehow interconnected with that factor. In order to prove this statement in a
quantitative manner we shall conduct a ratio analysis on DMart in comparison with Future
Retail.
DMart’s main area of focus has always been their expenses. The business model is built with a
cost minimizing foundation. All further decisions directly or indirectly help achieve this
objective. the cost-efficient system that D-mart has built for themselves, right from the discount
from vendors, higher focus on asset turns, lower employee costs and a strategy to own stores
to name a few; has exemplified within their expenses, which are consistently low. By passing
down these boost benefits, they fortify themselves in the market. There has been a congruous
rise in profits from 2017-2020, even during the pandemic when DMart faced operational
issues, such as an absentee workforce [ CITATION For20 \l 1033 ] etc. In comparison with Future
22
Group, DMart’s Net profit margin has been constantly higher; even after having lesser
operational capacity.
DMart ensures EDLP by maintaining low expenses. However, repercussions of the Future
Group acquisition can only be analyzed once 2021 financial reports come out. It can be
assumed that DMart will need to increment revenue from Brick&Mortar whilst establishing an
e-commerce does protect its profitability, and it aims to focus on developing DMart ready only
in large towns while keeping focus on Brick&Mortar. In the long run Dmart might capture online
potential, however too conservative an approach remains a bigger risk with the acquisition in
Conclusion
conversion of low expenses to low prices is their trademark. Their observant nature has
brought value within their corporate culture. The interconnectivity between the firm’s 3 pillars:
establish a strong foothold within the market. The community of vendors and employees
23
enabled them to do so. Their risk averse behavior-maintained profitability; however, it now
threatens to weaken their competitive advantage as competitors gain more market share.
Further analysis showed that another critical reason for DMart’s success was their cluster-
based expansion strategy, which fulfilled marketing objectives as well. DMart’s Promotion is a
byproduct of its operational activities, therefore negating a lot of expense and focus. This
allows them to focus on only the products. The analysis revealed opportunities for DMart to
diversify into related product sectors and work towards trying to better in-store experience
Due to focus in certain areas, even after being founded before the retail boom in India, DMart
has not been able to achieve market prominence. Which makes it vulnerable to dominant
underdeveloped and the firm has not been able to capitalize on the e-commerce growth
Therefore, this essay concludes that: DMart has very effectively and uniquely used marketing
strategies to establish themselves within their present areas. However, it has been staggering
to increase market share in other parts of the country. Rapid market growth is surfacing to be a
Further investigation can be conducted solely based on DMart Ready (e-commerce) and how
24
Bibliography
CHANDA, SANKARSH. The Story Of Radhakishan Damani & DMART. 20 Feb 2020. <https://savart.in/blog/story-
radhakishan-damani-dmart/#:~:text=DMART%20was%20the%20first%20retail,quitting%20the%20stock
%20market%20business.&text=He%20started%20small%20when%20he,largest%20supermarket
%20chain%20in%20India.>.
Dash, Sanchit. Radhakishan Damani has a string of challenges ahead of him and falling profits at DMart don’t
DMart Competitors, Revenue and Employees - Owler Company Profile. 11 July 2020. article .
<https://www.owler.com/company/dmartindia>.
url/AtRCQ9Hv9MOyhOOX26FXOv5yOZ1.pdf>.
Economic times . 10 secrets behind the stunning success of D-Mart's Radhakishan Damani. 22 mar 2017. 16 oct
2020. <https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/company/corporate-trends/10-secrets-behind-the-
stunning-success-of-d-marts-radhakishan-damani/articleshow/57755064.cms>.
Financial Epress . How India’s 12 million kirana stores becoming cornerstone of growth plans of Reliance Retail,
25
Finology . 15 feb 2020. article . 16 oct 2020 .
Gandhi, Forum. DMart faces operational issues as staff attendance decline drastically. 26 March 2020. article .
IDBI capital . "Avenue Supermarts-Perfect proxy to India’s consumption growth story ." Initiating coverage .
2019. document .
Jaganmohan, Madhumitha. Consumer spending in India 2016-2020. 7 may 2020. 17 oct 2020 .
Jefferies . "DMart 'D' for Dynamic, Driven & Deep-Rooted; Initiate at ." franchise report . 2020. Document .
M, Ravichandra. 2020:RETAIL MARKET CHALLENGES IN INDIA. 25 aug 2020 . report . 16 oct 2020 .
Mall, Damodar. How DMart became a solid, homegrown regional supermarket chain in India. 22 Feb 2017.
<https://www.forbesindia.com/blog/supermarket-wala/how-dmart-became-a-solid-homegrown-
regional-supermarket-chain-in-india/>.
Maloo, Mangalam. D-Mart will never get extremely aggressive on store expansion in new states, says CEO
Pawar, Balkrishan Sangvikar and Avinash. Strategy and Success of DMart: The Case of Retail Chain in India. June
2019 .
<https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Avinash_Pawar2/publication/340081826_Strategy_and_Success
_of_DMart_The_Case_of_Retail_Chain_in_India/links/5e7612c4299bf1892cfd4c59/Strategy-and-
Success-of-DMart-The-Case-of-Retail-Chain-in-India.pdf>.
of-dmart/#:~:text=One%20of%20the%20major%20reasons,in%20urban%20localities%20like
%20Mumbai.>.
26
Shah, Ami. Economic Times . 11 Sep 2020. https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/markets/stocks/news/should-
avenue-supermarts-investors-worry-about-the-rise-of-reliance-retail/articleshow/78053927.cms?
from=mdr.
Sourav. The Rise and Rise of D-Mart – Building Supermarts the Right way. 16 may 2019. 17 oct 2020.
Srivas, Anuj. What Explains the Success of Damani's D-Mart, India's Walmart in the Making? 21 mar 2017.
<https://thewire.in/business/indian-walmart-making-explains-d-mart-success>.
https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/IC.BUS.NREG?view=chart.
<https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/IC.BUS.NREG?
end=2018&locations=IN&most_recent_value_desc=false&start=2006&view=chart>.
27
28