-XUQDO,OPLDK'HOHJDV

-XUQDO,OPLDK'HOHJDVL
-XUQDO,OPLDK'HOHJDVL
9ROXPH1R1RYHPEHU
9ROXPH1R1RYHPEHU


3(1*$.8$11(*$5$7(5+$'$3+$.8/$<$7$7$67$1$+
3(1*$.8$11(*$5$7(5+$'$3+$.8/$<$7$7$67$1$+
0$6<$5$.$7$'$7'$/$06,67(03$75,/,1($/
0$6<$5$.$7$'$7'$/$06,67(03$75,/,1($/

(OLVDEHWK1XUKDLQL%XWDUEXWDU
)+8QLND6DQWR7KRPDV6XPDWHUD8WDUD
)+8QLND6DQWR7KRPDV6XPDWHUD8WDUD
HOLVDEHWKQXUKDLQL#\DKRRFRP


$%675$.


-



 
 
 



 




6






 



 








 









 






 

 

  





 










 



 

 
 



 



 

 
 







 











 








 
  









 
 




 
.OLEUDU\UHVHDUFK1*  

 



 

*  

 



 

 

*  

 



 

 


 












 6  
 


 


 


 


 


 




  
 



 





  
 



 


&











6






 
 









 






 



 








 







 

 
GLVDQHHU







6







 

 






6






 



 
"

,




 




 
"

,




 









$%675$&7
7KHUHVHDUFKDLPLVWRGHWHUPLQHWKHVHOHFWLRQRIFXVWRPDU\ODZYDOXHV
$EVWUDFW7KHUHVHDUFKDLPLVWRGHWHUPLQHWKHVHOHFWLRQRIF XVWRPDU\ODZYDOXHVLQVRFLHW\WRVHUYH
DVWKHEDVLVIRUWKHDSSOLFDWLRQRIFXVWRPDU\ULJKW
DVWKHEDVLVIRUWKHDSSOLFDWLRQRIFXVWRPDU\ULJKWVDVDPDQLIHVWDWLRQRIWKHIXOILOOPHQWRIKXPDQ
VDVDPDQLIHVWDWLRQRIWKHIXOILOOPHQWRIKXPDQ
ULJKWV DQG WKH PHFKDQLVP IRU GHWHUPLQLQJ XOD\DW ULJKWV DV ULJKWV WV WKDW PXVW EH SURWHFWHG LQ WKH
,QGRQHVLDQODQGODZV\VWHP7KHUHVHDUFKFRQGXFWHGLVQRUPDWLYHOHJDOUHVHDUFK
7KHUHVHDUFKFRQGXFWHGLVQRUPDWLYHOHJDOUHVHDUFKZKLFKHPSKDVL]HV
7KHUHVHDUFKFRQGXFWHGLVQRUPDWLYHOHJDOUHVHDUFK
PRUH RQ WKH DEVWUDFWLRQ DVSHFW DQG WR REWDLQ WKH GGHVLUHG HVLUHG UHVXOWV WKH HPSKDVLV LV RQ OLEUDU\
UHVHDUFK7KHGDWDFROOHFWLRQPHW
UHVHDUFK7KHGDWDFROOHFWLRQPHWKRGXVHGWRREWDLQVHFRQGDU\GDWDLVGRFXPHQWVWXG\
KRGXVHGWRREWDLQVHFRQGDU\GDWDLVGRFXPHQWVWXG\E\VWXG\LQJ
DQGDQDO\]LQJVHYHUDOODZVMXULVSUXGHQFHMRXUQDOV
DQGDQDO\]LQJVHYHUDOODZVMXULVSUXGHQFHMRXUQDOVDQGGHGXFWLYHDQGLQGXFWLYHPHWKRGVDUHXVHG
DQGGHGXFWLYHDQGLQGXFWLYHPHWKRGVDUHXVHG
WRGUDZDFRQFOXVLRQ7KHUHVXOWVVKRZHGWKDWWKHVHOHFWLRQRIFXVWRPDU\
7KHUHVXOWVVKRZHGWKDWWKHVHOHFWLRQRIFXVWRPDU\ODZYDOXHVLQFXVWRPDU\
7KHUHVXOWVVKRZHGWKDWWKHVHOHFWLRQRIFXVWRPDU\ODZYDOXHV
ODZ LV VWLOO YDOLG LQ UHDOLW\ E\ WDNLQJ LQWR DFFRXQ DFFRXQW W WKH YDOXHV WKDW KDYH EHHQ GLVDQHHU QDPHO\ WKH
YDOXHVRIFXVWRPDU\ZKLFKKDVEHHQFOHDUHGIURPLWVQHJDWL
RIFXVWRPDU\ZKLFKKDVEHHQFOHDUHGIURPLWVQHJDWLYHDVSHFWVDQGKDV YHDVSHFWVDQGKDVEHHQDGMXVWHGWRWKH
SULQFLSOHVRIWKH8QLWDU\6WDWHRIWKH5HSXEOLFRI
SULQFLSOHVRIWKH8QLWDU\6WDWHRIWKH5HSXEOLFRI,QGRQHVLD
7KH UHFRJQLWLRQ PHFKDQLVP IRU XOD\DW ULJKWV LV FDUULHG RXW E\ GHWHUPLQLQJ WKH H[LVWHQFH RI WKH
&XVWRPDU\ /DZ &RPPXQLW\ ILUVW EDVHG RQ WKH LGHQWLIL LGHQWLILFDWLRQ
FDWLRQ VWDJH WKHQ WKH YHULILFDWLRQ
YHUL DQG
YDOLGDWLRQ VWDJHV DFFRUGLQJ WR WKH DSSOLFDEOH SURYL SURYLVLRQV
VLRQV DQG UHFRJQLWLRQ DQG SURWHFWLRQ PXVW EH
JXDUDQWHHGLQWKHUHVSHFWLYHUHJLRQDOUHJXODWLRQV
JXDUDQWHHGLQWKHUHVSHFWLYHUHJLRQDOUHJXODWLRQV

UHFRJQLWLRQFXVWRPDU\ULJKWVPHFKDQLVPVVWLSXODWLRQVOHJDOYDOXHV
.H\ZRUGVUHFRJQLWLRQFXVWRPDU\ULJKWVPHFKDQLVPVVWLSXO DWLRQVOHJDOYDOXHV



































































































































































, 3(1'$+8/8$1 



 



-










 
 















 








 














*



   

 


 



 


















 
 




 




 
70



70


S,661
,661H,661





-XUQDO,OPLDK'HOHJDV
-XUQDO,OPLDK'HOHJDVL
-XUQDO,OPLDK'HOHJDVL
9ROXPH1R1RYHPEHU
9ROXPH1R1RYHPEHU



G
>


 


 



 

-
)A(7
 

 

 










 
 

 


6 





 










 




8
 



 



 

 6
 


  

 

*
; 









$








 








6
 





 





 

%
 



 






"






 




 















"





)B8

.'1







"


G
>
-
)A(7



 6 













 



 







 
 
6














 



&


 
 




G
 
>

 




 



 






 

 


 





<
<!



  

7

.)1


EHVFKLNNLQJVUHFKW &

 









 




  






















6










 
 












  











 













 
& &


 






 



















 











 


(

.)1













 


 










 
W



 

G





9






 














 








 






 













 








 

 
 





 
 




6

 







 



 







 






"








$
 
 
 





 






 




 



 


 



 
  


"





 


 6 

  


-

 

  




 


 

6






 





&






 

 
  





6








 

6











 




 

 


 

NRPXQDOLGHDOLV
 


 
 

 6  


 

LQGXYLGXDOLVPSUDJPDWLV



 
 

 



 



 


   
  


6











;


 

 


 


!




!





 

 


 6   
 
 6







 
















PDJLV6  6 

 




UHOLJLXV



"




ORJLF






 6 

 
UHDOLVWLF 












 






!





 







&



PDJLV6UHOLJLXV

 


 















7=



7=


S,661
,661H,661





 -XUQDO,OPLDK'HOHJDV
-XUQDO,OPLDK'HOHJDVL
-XUQDO,OPLDK'HOHJDVL
9ROXPH1R1RYHPEHU
9ROXPH1R1RYHPEHU
















 
'
?











































 
 










 
 
 

 

 


 6 




 






 




  















$












 






!
$!

 

DXWRULWDWLI


 





 








 
"

 

















 



2





 




 



 


 








 
 
   !
$!





 




6



 





 

 



 















 














 




 




 


 


 




 


6










*  

 







 



 
 


 
 





 





 




 
















 





 6 
 

 
 




 E
 E



 









G
7
-
)A0/
 




" 





 












 









 

 



 



 






 

 











 
















 




 









6 

 

(


6












 
 


 






 
 




  
 





 
 

 

*  
 

 
    

&






 

 


  
 







 











6 



6



6






 


 

 
  

 

 














  
 









 

 


 








6








6

 



















7




 










 



 


 
 





,, 0(72'(3(1(/,7,$1
0(72'(3(1(/,7,$1


$"





 















































































 


 

'

$ 
*

$+
'//)


*

$+
'//)
3HGRPDQ3HPEXDWDQ


)






8VXODQ 3HQHOLWLDQ 6HEXDK 3DQGXDQ 'DVDU
'DVDU -



 









 

2

F 

)/



 
* 
*Q

'/)(
3HQHOLWLDQ +XNXP
"
 
*


F 

)B)

"
 
*


F 


(

$
G

)AA'
0HWRGH 3HQHOLWLDQ
3HQ 1DWXUDOLVWLN



























































-

8 

'=

.XDOLWDWLI
-

8 

'=
) 7

%
 
G


8  
'/)B
0HWRGH
$ 
$

$

* 

'//=


$ 
$

$

* 

'//=


3HQHOLWLDQ+XNXP7DKDS7DKDS3HQHPXDQ.HEHQDUDQGDODP
7DKDS3HQHPXDQ.HEHQDUDQGDODP3HQHOLWLDQ+XNXP1RUPDWLI6XDWX7LQMDXDQ6LQJNDW-
>

3HQHOLWLDQ+XNXP1RUPDWLI6XDWX7LQMDXDQ6LQJNDW
,OPX+XNXP-
>

8 



 
 
F 

=7

7B



7B


S,661
,661H,661





 -XUQDO,OPLDK'HOHJDV
-XUQDO,OPLDK'HOHJDVL
-XUQDO,OPLDK'HOHJDVL
9ROXPH1R1RYHPEHU
9ROXPH1R1RYHPEHU
A
8





7
;





.WHULWRULDO1 .


 






$


 
 


  


 









 
 

 


  



  
.JHQHDORJLV1
1




 
 










 
 


 

 
 
 


 



 
 


 



 
 



 


 

 

 
 6 





 


 

" 

   6  





 



 



 





 
 



 



6










 


 







 

 




6



 
 

 
"





 















 
 







 

 








 
"
 

















  





  




!
$!




8 
 
* 

;





 

 
- 
>E
8 
 
G










G
)/
-
'/)0
 
- 













 
&

; 
-


 


"



"

*
&
; 

*





 

.YRONVJHLVW
YRONVJHLVW1

8 


-  

-  














 



 






 







 



O
 0
 


 

 


 

  




 





 






 







 







 



 
 

 



 
 

 




 




 
&









&







 
  

















 
 
 
 




 




 











 



 




 









 



)/

Q=




 





  




 



 








6









 

 








 


"








 




6























*
-
&B


 
 



 
 

 


 


 
 
 












G



 


 







 



"















 








Q



 
 











""


 
 

 
 
..JHQHDORJLV1
 


 































































0

#"
+
O
 
)A=7
7KH /HJDO 6\VWHP $














































































A
>
$




O 

G

6RFLDO6FLHQFH3UHVSHFWLYH
>
$




O 

G

>
$
)AB=
%DE%DEWHQWDQJ+XNXP$GDW
%DEWHQWDQJ+XNXP$GDW
M

)(
 

-
 


F 

(=

 

-
 


F 
= )/

 

Q
)AA7

&RPSDUDWLYH/DZLQ&KDQJLQJ
&RPSDUDWLYH/DZLQ&KDQJLQJ
$



;

'/)A
5HNRQVWUXNVL
:RUOG
!




# 
# 
2( 2(
.HELMDNDQ 7DQDK (NV .HUDMDDQ GL ,QGRQHVLD %HUEDVLV 1LODL
B

-
&
)AB/
$VDV$VDVGDQ6XVXQDQ+XNXP$GDW
$VDVGDQ6XVXQDQ+XNXP$GDW .HDGLODQ 6RVLDO
.$ 

$ 


-
%




-
G
$

 1
 


F  


F 
8
18

F
;


 
<
7
G
G '


=
G!
'/)A

A=

7A



7A


S,661
,661H,661





-XUQDO,OPLDK'HOHJDV
-XUQDO,OPLDK'HOHJDVL
-XUQDO,OPLDK'HOHJDVL
9ROXPH1R1RYHPEHU
9ROXPH1R1RYHPEHU

 






 





 
 




G



 
PDJLV6UHOLJLXV
UHOLJLXV  


6



 


  





 


  





 

6





;










"

"
 







" 
 


 
 
 

 

 









*
"



 




 


 
 6 






G



 






G


 


 





 














 




 


 
 























 














&









 

 

 
 


 



  





  









8
;



 




6










 



  
?


G




!

 





;


 














  





 


6








6


 





 


 


 




 









  
 



  
 




G




 



&












6











 





  



 


  




  

$ 

$ 









 








 

 














 

 

















 










"
"






"





G

















 


 





 


 



 
 

 

G







 




 








 







6












 


 

 


 


 





 





 




 

 

G






6







  







 



 
 
 




 











Q 

 




 




 


 




 





 


 


6


 



 




  






 


6






 




 

 







 

 




 




 

GLVDQHHU




,,, +$6,/'$13(0%$+$6$1
+$6,/'$13(0%$+$6$1 

6















$ 3HPLOLKDQ 1LODL +XNXP $GDW VHEDJDL 

 

 

 

'DVDUEHUODNXQ\D+DN8OD\DW
'DVDUEHUODNXQ\D+DN8OD\DW





6






F



 
















 

 


 

;
 





 





  







 


 







 
 

 



 
 





 



 

  

 



 

  





 
 
>


0/



0/


S,661
,661H,661





-XUQDO,OPLDK'HOHJDV
-XUQDO,OPLDK'HOHJDVL
-XUQDO,OPLDK'HOHJDVL
9ROXPH1R1RYHPEHU
9ROXPH1R1RYHPEHU

&
 






 



 








 


6















  



  




  




 

 



 
"














 


 
 
 














 

 

 6
 

 
"
 

 

" 

 6  








 





 
 

  
&
 


OLYLQJ ODZ



 



 

 

 6





 





6


6



 
 



!





 











&
 



 













 

 





G


















  
   







Q



 
















G


 


























 








 


 






 


 


 



 

 6 

   





G

6


8
;



   


















 






;
 






;





 


)


 


)'
;




;


 








 
















 

 




G
 








 

 







 

 

 6 







 















+G






 











 





+G


;

 

6







 










. 
 1








 
  
 


;

. ;1



 

 




 
 

+G






 6
  


 






















 6 

 
 
















. 
 1












 


;

. ;1



+G





 




+G





 





 
 

+G











 



6







 











 

 




 6 

 
 












?




+G





 




 


 






 


G





 




 




  


;


 


 





 6 

 












$


 


A

.'1


 


 
;

 


6



 


 



 




6








 
 





 


 

&














 

 
 
 









 














 
8 














 

 
 








 




 



7
;







6







 


0)



0)


S,661
,661H,661





-XUQDO,OPLDK'HOHJDV
-XUQDO,OPLDK'HOHJDVL
-XUQDO,OPLDK'HOHJDVL
9ROXPH1R1RYHPEHU
9ROXPH1R1RYHPEHU




 


 

GLVDQHHU



 


 


 



 
 















,

 

 

 





 $









6




 




  

 



% 0HNDQLVPH SHQHWDSDQ HNVLVWHQVL KDN





XOD\DW 



 



;







 




 
 


 




"


 


 





 $






 
EHVFKLNNLQJUHFKW
EHVFKLNNLQJUHFKW
&

 



  











 






  




 


 


 





 




  

"   





E


 
































 



 6
 
;






 

 



,

*

 


; 



 


; 

) $

 

. 1



 



G
2'

'//A










 
* 


G

G

 


 
;




7'
-
'/)(
*

02





 


 

 
#

&







 
 


 
"

 








 
*
&
;  
;  













 





 








 



















 




 

6 






 










 








 








 










 

 

' $











 













$ 
 




 
 
 

 




 E 
 
 


  

 
 6 




 
"



 









 








 
*
&
;  



 





 





 




2


7
;





 







)B
8

.'1

)A(7




 


 
 







 


 
 




 




$"









 
 6 

 





6








 
 
 6

 






















*
&
;  

&
;










!




!


*
&


 
>


 




; 


 
*
&


 


6








;  
-










 
" 



)B8
8
E+
 



 
 


.'1

G
>
-
)A(7




G
>
-
)A(7


6






 


 

 


 
 
 

 
 








 
 



0'



0'


S,661
,661H,661





-XUQDO,OPLDK'HOHJDV
-XUQDO,OPLDK'HOHJDVL
-XUQDO,OPLDK'HOHJDVL
9ROXPH1R1RYHPEHU
9ROXPH1R1RYHPEHU

*
&
;  
+

; 






 

&
;  
 

E 
  6 

-  
 

 

 
 

E
 



 
 









 
  






 



8 
 
* 

;




$
 




 

- 
>E
8 
 
G




















G
)/
-
'/)0
 
*


)/
-
'/)0
 
*
$ 




&
; 


 
"


 
8
E+
 
 

 







 
-

(-
 
 
 





  





 
 





 
 

 

 


-  
 








  


-

(-
 
-







 

 



 
  


 



-  


 







 
 

 





 

 E 


 



 

 
 



*

'

.)1
 





 
#E


*
&
; 



  



  



 




 

*
&
;  




 


 


 E 





E 






.
 1
 
 




 

8

 



  





& 



E8 






 
 E 








 





 



 




  
 



 



 




 
 






 *


& 









 
 
&
; 
 
 






 

 


 




  





"
-  
#
$ 
*










 


 







 






"
  6  

 


 
$ 




-


 




 
 


 
 

(-






"





  








!












!








 

 













6







 



 




 
"

 
 

$ 





 







 


-

(-




 




 




 








*

 


 


 



 





 




 

 



-  


7

.)1
 
* 

;


- 
&





 



>E
8 
 
G



 


 

G
)/
-
'/)0





 




 



 
8
E+

8
E+
 
 
 


 
 

 


.'1


 



  



















 





 




 



-

(-







  






 
8
E+
 

>






)/
 

-

(-


 

.1

 


"
 
.1

 


"
  6  
*
&
; 
 



02



02


S,661
,661H,661





-XUQDO,OPLDK'HOHJDV
-XUQDO,OPLDK'HOHJDVL
-XUQDO,OPLDK'HOHJDVL
9ROXPH1R1RYHPEHU
9ROXPH1R1RYHPEHU

 


-  

 
8
" 
 











 




 
 

 
*
&
; 
 



G
)/
-
'/)'

'/)'  

 


 




 
&6&
&

-  

 



*

; 




 
*








E 

 

 
-
$




 


 
G
)
-
'/'/
 
&


*
&
 


 
*
&
; 
8 
-
$


8
E+
 
 



 

 



8
E
 

 

 
*


 




 

*
&
; 
 


 
 
 




$

 

*
&
; 

 








,9 .HVLPSXODQ
 
 


'
. 1
 



8 

6



  

 E 



 

 





 

 











 
8



 
8





















 
*
&
 


) 




6







 



 
8
E+
 
 











 

 
 

 

 
 
 

 


 

 

 


 









 

 

 
 
 

 
GLVDQHHU

GLVDQHHU 




6



  

 














 



 

 
  



6










 

 






6




 







" 



)B8

.'1


 








G
>
-
)A(7



G
 
>

 



G
 
>

 


 
*
&
; 


' *






 

 







 

 


 


6










*
&
; 





 
 

 
*



 
8
E+
 

8

 
*
&
; 

 
 










 6 

 


 

!





!





8
E+
 



  


 


 











 







!





!



 


6


 






 


 
 






 





 
9 5()(5(16,







*


&


; 



 
) 8  
%
 
G


'/)B


 







0HWRGH 3HQHOLWLDQ +XNXP 7DKDS 7DKDS



 





7DKDS 3HQHPXDQ .HEHQDUDQ GDODP

 



-
>

8 

,OPX+XNXP-
>

8 
  




  
' 
Q

 
)AA7
&RPSDUDWLYH


 

$ 


:RUOG !


/DZ LQ &KDQJLQJ :RUOG






 
*



# 
# 




# 
# 
&
; 



 

 
2 O
 
#"
+
)A=7
7KH


 
















/HJDO 6\VWHP $ 6RFLDO 6FLHQFH




 


0(



0(


S,661
,661H,661





-XUQDO,OPLDK'HOHJDV
-XUQDO,OPLDK'HOHJDVL
-XUQDO,OPLDK'HOHJDVL
9ROXPH1R1RYHPEHU
9ROXPH1R1RYHPEHU

>
$




O 


3UHVSHFWLYH
>
$




O 


 
<
7
G
'
G!


 
<
G
M
'/)A

( & 
*;
'//7
6RVLRORJL B $ 
$

$

* 


+XNXP GDQ 3HQJDUXK 3HUXEKDQ '//=

3HQHOLWLDQ +XNXP 1RUPDWLI
0DV\DUDNDW GDQ +XNXP $


6XDWX 7LQMDXDQ 6LQJNDW -
>

$

 
 
F 


 
 
F 
7 *Q


 
* 
'/)(
A $ 
*

$+
'//)

3HQHOLWLDQ +XNXP "
 
3HGRPDQ3HPEXDWDQ8VXODQ3HQHOLWLDQ
*


F 
'DVDU -



6HEXDK 3DQGXDQ 'DVDU

0 G

$
)AA'
0HWRGH
HWRGH 3HQHOLWLDQ  

F 


F 
1DWXUDOLVWLN.XDOLWDWLI

-

)/$

$
)AB=
%DE%DE WHQWDQJ
8 
+XNXP $GDW  

-

= $



;

'/)A
 


F 

 


F 
> 



-
%
))-
&
)AB/

$VDV
$VDV$VDVGDQ6XVXQDQ



 

8

G



-
G
$


+XNXP $GDW -


$

.$ 


-
%
 1
 






8
18

F
;

F 



07



07


S,661
,661H,661