Sr.

RESOLUTION/
COMMENT/ OBSERVATION
No. ACTION

General:
Contractor/vendor has not provided the resolution against the
comment resolution sheet which is submitted against earlier revision.
Therefore these comments are again being
repeated here.
These comments pertain to C02 system documents which pertain to
electrical only.

Document: C02 system document

A
Review Code: R with following comments

Vendor to submit the filled up, signed and stamped data sheet of the
dean agent system (A286-000-16-50-DS-0024) for manned station
1 Ok
(4019) and CO2 system for unmanned station (A286--000-16-50-DS-
0021) (other stations).

As per the fire alarm data sheets attached with the tender, FA cum
2 Confirm
CO2 panel shall be microprocessor based. Confirm the same.

Provide different GA drawing for FA panel, repeater panel for SV

3 stations, SV- 4019 (G+1) and Bhatinda RT (ECS) stations as all GA given in panel document is typical
these stations differ in terms of their architectural layout.
Sr. RESOLUTION/
COMMENT/ OBSERVATION
No. ACTION
As per clause 7.1.1 of Ell spec, panel design and component
selections shall be done for future extension up to 10% of specified
zones or one zone whichever is maximum in each panel. 10% spare As per GIGL MBPL Phase - I philosophy 2/3 logic is required,
4
zone cards subject to minimum of 1 shall be provided. The design of hence the spare zones are used for it
common facility and hardware shall be provided for required future
extension of zones. Note and confirm the same.

Vendor to furnish the sizing calculations for arriving at the final Proposed detectors are having radius of 7.5 mtr. & considering
5
quantities of FA system components such as detectors etc. the room size the quantity is sufficient

6 Note that following for the input power supply:

All SV-stations 48V±10% DC power supply Ok
RT Bhatinda (ECS) 230V±1% AC single phase
Ok
power supply

Vendor has to submit the sizing of the battery as per the specification
6-51-0076 refer Clause D3 of the data-sheet for battery sizing. In
7 Already submitted
view of this note that duration for battery sizing shall be 24hrs
(Normal) +30min. (Alarm).

8 Refer clause 9.2 of EIL spec 6-51-0076 and note the following :

Selector switches for primary or secondary clean agent/ CO2 supply Selector switch for each room is not required. Common selector
for each protected area. switch is provided on panel
Manual push button for discharge of clean agent/ CO2 in each
As per GIGL MBPL Phase - I philosophy it is provided on panel
protected area. The actual release of clean agent/ CO2 shall
& guard room
however be delayed by 30sec after the alarm.
Sr. RESOLUTION/
COMMENT/ OBSERVATION
No. ACTION
For clean agent flooding will be done in any one room & for that
Clean agent/CO2 discharge inhibit push button for each protected abort is already porvided. Room wise abort not required.
area.
For CO2 flooding as per NFPA abort is not to be provided.
Please comply and indicate these in the GA.

Note that GA drawing is not properly prepared. In view of that note

9
the following:

Prepare the drawing in a standard format which mentions various

information such as name of vendor, contractor, client, project, This is typical drawing
drawing, rev no., drawing prepared by, checked by, approved by etc.
Provide a table in GA indicating a various parameters such as colour
Already provided in panel datasheet
shade, material of construction, IP protection etc.
Colour shade of the panel shall be 536 as per IS-5. As per standard provided in GIGL MBPL Phase - I
Various indications, controls as indicated in the GA are not clearly
This is typical drawing
visible. Provide a clearer drawing for these.
Following indications required as per 6-51-0076. Please explain
where these are provided.
Fire/Fault for each zone.
Required indication as per GIGL MBPL Phase - I philosophy
Battery low, battery backup ON
already provided
Battery charger status.
Following PBs required, as per 6-51-0076, are not clear from the
drawing
TESTPB Test PB is provided for each zone
ACCEPTPB Silence PB is provided on panel for Accept
AUTO/MANUAL control switch is to be provided. This is not clear System is desinged for auto mode & for manual mode zone
from the drawing. isolation switch is provided
Sr. RESOLUTION/
COMMENT/ OBSERVATION
No. ACTION
Clearly indicate which all are indications and which all are control in
This is typical drawing
the GA.
MIMIC in the GA does not reflect the actual layout. Correct the same. This is typical drawing

Zones as indicated do not reflect in the MIMIC. Further zones in the

GA shall be same as that in FA layout, MIMIC and in block diagram.
This is typical drawing
Currently all the zones, which are mentioned, in the schematic/block
diagram do not reflect in the GA.
In the open view drawing of the GA, clearly mention the name of the
This is typical drawing
components.
There is no clarity what right side section of the open view drawing
This is typical drawing
reflects. Please clarify and correct
Vendor shall also submit the drawings of repeater panel which is to We have provided manual release with indication at guard room
10
be installed in the guard room. as per GIGL MBPL Phase - I philosophy
Vendor to note that make of the components of fire alarm system
11 shall be as per the fire alarm system vendor list attached with the Confirm
tender. Please confirm.
Refer the fire alarm data sheet attached with the tender. In view of Siren having range of 1 km & 24 VDC operated as per GIGL
12
this note that, range of the siren shall be 2 Km. Please comply. MBPL Philosophy & PNGRB requirement is provided
Refer clause 12.11 of the hooter attached with the tender. In view of
13 this note that audible range of the hooter shall be 102 db at 1 meter. Hooter provided by us is as per standard practice & is audible
Please comply.
Refer block diagram of the FA cum CO2 system and note the
14
following:
Vendor has to provide a FLP BGU in the field. Include the same in There is no fire detector provided in process area. Hence MCP
the block diagram and provide a separate zone for this. This shall be for that area is not required. MCP at guard room will be
used only for detection and not for C02/clean agent actuation. provided.
In view of the above point, vendor has to furnish the document of
Not applicable
FLP BGU for review.
Sr. RESOLUTION/
COMMENT/ OBSERVATION
No. ACTION
For clean agent flooding will be done in any one room & for that
Refer clause 12.13 of ElIL spec 6-51-0076. In view of this, provide a
abort is already porvided. Room wise abort not required.
CO2/clean agent inhibit switches similar to a CO2/clean agent
release switches.
For CO2 flooding as per NFPA abort is not to be provided.
15 Refer MIMIC diagram of the FA cum CO2 system, note the following:
All the legends, which are mentioned, do not reflect in the MIMIC
diagram.
This is typical drawing
What does the legend which is indicated over Z1/2/3/...n ,describe?
As per GIGL MBPL Phase - I philosophy soft signals are
16 Provide a list of all potential free contacts.
provided
Provide a list of SOFT signals to be transferred to SCADA through
17 Ok
RS-485.
Refer clause 10.2.2 of EIL spec 6-51-0076 and note that battery shall Based on our past experience we recommend to keep battery
18
be mounted inside the panel. outside panel in seperate battery box.

Document: FA layout drawings (For SV stations) Review Code:

B
R with following comments

FA vendor has to prepare the drawing in the final approved trench

1 Noted
layout.

Furnish the basis for selecting the no. of detector and no. of zones.
2
In view of this note the following:
One detector in electrical room and in telecom room is clubbed into It is as per 2/3 logic philosophy of GIGL MBPL Phase - I
the zone of trench and false ceiling which appears incorrect. Please
explain.
Sr. RESOLUTION/
COMMENT/ OBSERVATION
No. ACTION
In view of the above point and as per clause 7 .1.9 of Ell spec 6-51-
0076 if zone is protected with clean agenV C02 system, the
detectors and BGUs of the zone shall be wired in cross-zones by
3 providing minimum two signaling circuits in a zone. The last device in It is as per 2/3 logic philosophy of GIGL MBPL Phase - I
each circuit shall be provided with end of line resistor of suitable
value as per circuit design to facilitate cable open circuit and short
circuit detection. Please ensure and explain.
For detectors below false floor/trench, RI shall be installed at the
nearest wall and at 1200mm above the floor; while for detectors
4 Noted
above false ceiling, RI shall be installed at the nearest wall and at
300mm below the false ceiling.
For detectors in the closed room, response indicators shall be
5 Not applicable
installed above the door outside the room.
Refer clause 13.2 of EIL spec 6-51-0076. In view of this, note that for
6 battery room flameproof detectors suitable for gas group llC and It is as per philosophy of GIGL MBPL Phase - I
temp. Class T3 shall be provided for battery room.
7 Indicate the details of the cable used for FA devices. given in schematic diagram

Document: FA layout drawings (For SV 4019)

C
Review Code: R with following comments

FA vendor has to prepare the drawing in the final approved trench

1 Noted
layout.
Furnish the basis for selecting the no of detector and no. of zones. In
2
view of this note the following:
One detector in electrical room and in telecom room is clubbed into It is as per 2/3 logic philosophy of GIGL MBPL Phase - I
the zone of trench and false ceiling which appears incorrect. Please
explain
Sr. RESOLUTION/
COMMENT/ OBSERVATION
No. ACTION
In view of the above point and as per clause 7 .1.9 of EIL spec 6-51-
0076 if zone is protected with clean agent/ C02 system, the detectors
and BGUs of the zone shall be wired in cross-zones by providing
minimum two signaling circuits
3 It is as per 2/3 logic philosophy of GIGL MBPL Phase - I
in a zone. The last device in each circuit shall be provided with end
of line resistor of suitable value as per circuit design to facilitate
cable open circuit and short circuit detection. Please ensure and
explain
For detectors below false floor/trench, RI shall be installed at the
nearest wall and at 1200mm above the floor; while for detectors
4 Noted
above false ceiling, RI shall be installed at the nearest wall and at
300mm below the false ceiling.
For detectors in the closed room, response indicators shall be
5 Not applicable
installed above the door outside the room.
Refer clause 13.2 of EIL spec 6-51-0076. In view of this, note that for
6 battery room flameproof detectors suitable for gas group llC and It is as per philosophy of GIGL MBPL Phase - I
temp. Class T3 shall be provided for battery room.
Increase the no of zones in the first floor. Complete area is covered Only alarm is required & one zone is sufficient for the detectors
7
in one zone only. provided
8 Also provide FA layout of false ceiling at first floor Already provided
One detector of control room (Ground floor} is clubbed in the zone of
9 the first floor which is incorrect. There should not be common zones Two separate panel for GF & FF is provided
between first floor and ground floor.
10 Indicate the details of the cable used for FA devices given in schematic diagram
Sr. RESOLUTION/
COMMENT/ OBSERVATION
No. ACTION
Document: FA layout drawings (For ECS)
D
Review Code: R with following comments

One detector in electrical room and in telecom room is clubbed into

zone of trench and false ceiling which is incorrect. There should not
1 It is as per 2/3 logic philosophy of GIGL MBPL Phase - I
be common zones between room void area and trench/false ceiling
area

Furnish the basis for selecting the no of detector and no. of zones. In
2 view of
this note the following:
It is as per 2/3 logic philosophy of GIGL MBPL Phase - I
One detector in electrical room and in telecom room is clubbed into
the zone of trench and false ceiling which appears incorrect. Please
explain.

In view of the above point and as per clause 7 .1.9 of Ell spec 6-51-
0076 if zone is protected with clean agenV C02 system, the
detectors and BGUs of the zone shall be wired in cross-zones by
3 providing minimum two signaling circuits in a zone. The last device in It is as per 2/3 logic philosophy of GIGL MBPL Phase - I
each circuit shall be provided with end of line resistor of suitable
value as per circuit design to facilitate cable open circuit and short
circuit detection. Please ensure and explain.

FA vendor has to prepare the drawing in the final approved trench

4 Noted
layout. The one attached appears wrong. Please check.
Sr. RESOLUTION/
COMMENT/ OBSERVATION
No. ACTION
For detectors below false floor/trench, RI shall be installed at the
nearest wall
and at 1200mm above the floor; while for detectors above false
5 Noted
ceiling, RI
shall be installed at the nearest wall and at 300mm below the false
ceiling.
For detectors in the closed room, response indicators shall be
6 Not applicable
installed above the door outside the room.
Refer clause 13.2 of Ell spec 6-51-0076. In view of this, note that for
7 battery room flameproof detectors suitable for gas group llC and It is as per philosophy of GIGL MBPL Phase - I
temp. Class T3 shall be provided for battery room.
Refer clause 13.2 of Ell spec 6-51-0076. In view of this, note that for
8 battery room flameproof detectors suitable for gas group llC and It is as per philosophy of GIGL MBPL Phase - I
temp. Class T3 shall be provided for battery room.
Increase the no of zones in the first floor. Complete area is covered Only alarm is required & one zone is sufficient for the detectors
9
in one zone only. provided
One detector of control room (ground floor) is clubbed in the zone of
10 the first floor which is incorrect. There should not be common zones Two separate panel for GF & FF is provided
between first floor and ground floor.
One area of battery room and store is clubbed into one zone, both of Battery Room & Store is combined to maitain the required level
11
which far from each other. This appears incorrect. Please explain of concentration as per NFPA
Similarly conference room, store, electrical workshop T&I workshop,
Only alarm is required & one zone is sufficient for the detectors
12 manual call point is clubbed into one zone which appears incorrect.
provided
Please explain and correct.
13 Increase the no of detectors in conference room. Already increased
14 Provide detector in pantry Not applicable as per GIGL MBPL Phase - I philosophy
15 Indicate the details of the cable used for FA devices. given in schematic diagram