30/09/2019 New GDP math puts UPA behind NDA on economic growth

e-paper

HOME LATEST TRENDING MY READS

Companies Money Markets Start-ups Mutual Funds NRI Investment Queries Insurance Technology

The government said the GDP data had been recalibrated to reflect a more appropriate picture of the economy.
Photo: Bloomberg

New GDP math puts UPA behind NDA on economic

growth
3 min read . Updated: 29 Nov 2018, 07:23 AM IST
Remya Nair, Gireesh Chandra Prasad, Anuja

Indian economy never grew in double digits, according to GDP back-series data

Topics
mint-india-wire GDP data GDP growth GDP growth 2010-11 Indian economy GDP UPA
GDP NDA Modi government NITI Aayog BJP Congress National Statistical Commission

New Delhi: India’s economic growth under the previous Congress-led coalition
government was slower than estimated earlier
Close and was never in double digits,

according to the revised GDP numbers released by the government on Wednesday.

https://www.livemint.com/Industry/vl0ZT0Cct1OlWtqG6mEUPM/New-GDP-data-knocks-UPA-off-growth-pedestal.html 1/12
30/09/2019 New GDP math puts UPA behind NDA on economic growth

The new GDP data, pertaining to the years between 2005-06 and 2011-12, has sparked
e-paper

off a heated exchange between the Congress and the ruling Bharatiya Janata Party
HOME LATEST TRENDING MY READS
over the performance of the economy during their respective terms.

With general
Companies elections
Money due next
Markets year, the
Start-ups Narendra
Mutual Funds Modi-
NRI ledQueries
Investment NationalInsurance
Democratic
Technology

Alliance government is likely to use the new data to claim that its management of the
economy has been superior to that of the Congress-led United Progressive Alliance
(UPA) when it seeks a second term.

According to the back-series data, the Indian economy grew at an average of 6.67% in
the nine years ended 31 March 2014 when UPA was in power, slower than the 7.35%
achieved in the four years ended 31 March 2018, with Modi as the prime minister. It
also shows that the highest growth rate the Indian economy has so far achieved is
8.5% in 2010-11, against the 10.3% estimated using the older base.

Expand

The link between the old and new GDP series through the back-series data is crucial
as it helps in better economic forecasting. The link has so far been missing after the
government shifted the base year to 2011-12 from 2004-05.

Anticipating criticism of the numbers as they drastically scale down growth in the
UPA era, Rajiv Kumar, vice chairman of NITI Aayog said the new series, based on the

https://www.livemint.com/Industry/vl0ZT0Cct1OlWtqG6mEUPM/New-GDP-data-knocks-UPA-off-growth-pedestal.html 2/12
30/09/2019 New GDP math puts UPA behind NDA on economic growth

2011-12 base year, is superior to the earlier one. “It is in complete sync with the UN
e-paper
system of national accounts. Any feeling around the new series that it is
overestimating
HOME should completely
LATESTbe dispelled." TRENDING MY READS

Senior
CompaniesCongress
Money leader and former
Markets Start-ups finance
Mutual minister
Funds P.Investment
NRI Chidambaram
Queries criticized
Insurance NITI
Technology

Aayog’s revised GDP numbers, terming them a joke.

“They are a bad joke. Actually, they are worse than a bad joke. The numbers are the
result of a hatchet job," Chidambaram said in a post on Twitter. He also questioned
whether the National Statistical Commission had been disbanded as it did not
calculate these numbers.

Congress leader Randeep Singh Surjewala accused the government of “resorting to

malicious and fraudulent jugglery of GDP figures to hide the enormous body blow
caused by them to India’s economy".

The new data shows that growth in the tertiary sector was much slower than initially
estimated on account of changes to unorganized trade, communication and financial
services.

Also Read: Consumption-driven GDP growth unhealthy for Indian economy

The government attributes the lower growth rate in the unorganized sector in years
prior to 2011-12 to better estimation of trade data using sales tax.

The numbers released by the government on Wednesday are also vastly different from
the estimates put out by a subcommittee of the National Statistical Commission
headed by N.R. Bhanumurthy in July. Its back-series calculation had showed that the
Indian economy grew at a much faster pace during UPA’s tenure and had registered
double-digit growth in two years—10.23% in 2007-08 and 10.78% in 2010-11.

Statisticians and economists questioned how the back-series data shows slower GDP
growth compared to the old series for the years before 2011-12 and higher for the
period after 2011-12.

Also Read | Three messages from India’s Q1 GDP data

“By and large, one methodology does not apply to every sector and this is the correct
way to do it. But having said that, what I am concerned about is that for the entire
period from 2004-05 to 2011-12, for all the sectors, the growth has been scaled down,"
said Pronab Sen, programme director for the India programme of the International
Growth Centre and former chief statistician of India. “I don’t know how this
https://www.livemint.com/Industry/vl0ZT0Cct1OlWtqG6mEUPM/New-GDP-data-knocks-UPA-off-growth-pedestal.html 3/12