Professional Documents
Culture Documents
SET BY;
RUSSIA KADIR
ID NO; RBE/1027/11
ADIVISOR;
SEP,2021
ARBAMINCH ETHIOPIA
Declaration
I undersigned deader that this student Research proposal is my original work and has not been
presented for a degree in any other university and all the materials used for this study have been
duly acknowledged.
_________________ ______________
Name of student; Russia kadir Signature
Date-----------
II | P a g e
Approval sheet
This student research paper has been submitted for examination with my approval as university
advisor.
__________________ _____________
Name of advisor; Bizuneh Girma Signature
___________
Date
III | P a g e
Statement of certification
This is to certify that student Russia Kadir with ID NO RBE /1027/11 has conducted her senior
essay paper title: assessment of non-performing loan management in case of Aba minch and the
work is completed with satisfactory evaluation of the advisor and the examiner as per the
requirement of the university.
IV | P a g e
Acknowledgement
First of all, I would like to thanks my almighty God for his excellent protection and support.
Secondly I would like to express my sincere gratitude to my advisor Bizuneh Girma(Msc) for his
unreserved advice and assistance to develop this study in a proper manner and for her
professionally nice suggestion and correction. Finally, my heartfelt appreciation and reputation
passes to those people who helped me by giving supportive ideas and encouragements to develop
this research.
V|Page
Acronyms
CBE - Commercial bank of Ethiopia
NBE - National bank of Ethiopia
NPA - Non performing asset
NPL- Non-performing loan
NPLM - Non-performing loan management
VI | P a g e
Table of content
Contents pages
Declaration......................................................................................................................................II
Approval sheet...............................................................................................................................III
Statement of certification..............................................................................................................IV
Acknowledgement..........................................................................................................................V
Acronyms......................................................................................................................................VI
List of tables..................................................................................................................................IX
Abstract...........................................................................................................................................X
CHAPTER ONE..............................................................................................................................1
1. Introduction...........................................................................................................................1
1.1. Back ground of the study..................................................................................................1
1.2. Statement of the problem..................................................................................................3
1.3. Research question.............................................................................................................4
1.4. Objective of the study.......................................................................................................4
1.4.1. General objectives.....................................................................................................4
1.4.2. Specific objectives.....................................................................................................4
1.5. Significance of the study..................................................................................................4
1.6. Scope of the study.............................................................................................................4
1.7. Limitation of the study......................................................................................................4
1.8. Organization of paper.......................................................................................................5
CHAPTER TWO.............................................................................................................................6
2. LITERATURE REVIEW.......................................................................................................6
2.1. Meaning of bank and its functions....................................................................................6
2.2. What is loan?....................................................................................................................7
2.2.1. Types of loan.............................................................................................................8
2.3. Characteristics of Loan.....................................................................................................8
2.4. Non-performing loan and banking crises.........................................................................9
2.5. Non-performing loan management.................................................................................10
2.6. Problem of loans and losses............................................................................................10
2.6.1. Bank credit and lending procedures........................................................................11
2.7. Lending procedures........................................................................................................11
VII | P a g e
2.7.1. The interviews.............................................................................................................11
2.7.2. Loan application......................................................................................................11
2.7.3. Financial statement and property estimation...........................................................11
2.7.4. Insurance and security.............................................................................................12
2.8. Credit risk.......................................................................................................................12
2.9. The role of credit analysis in minimizing credit risk......................................................12
2.10. Empirical Literature......................................................................................................14
2.11. Research Gap................................................................................................................16
CHAPTER THREE.......................................................................................................................17
3. Research Methodology..........................................................................................................17
3.1. Research design and research approach.........................................................................17
3.2. Data source and Method of data collection....................................................................17
3.3. Target population and sample size.................................................................................17
3.4. Sampling techniques.......................................................................................................18
3.4. Method of data analysis..................................................................................................18
CHAPTER FOUR.........................................................................................................................19
4. DATA PRESENTATION AND INTERPRETATION.........................................................19
4.1. Primary data analysis......................................................................................................19
4.2. Advance loan to customer..............................................................................................21
4.3. The interview covers.......................................................................................................25
4.4. Analysis of the secondary data.......................................................................................26
4.4.1. Non-performing loan portfolio................................................................................26
4.4.2. Trends of loan disbursements and collection...........................................................26
CHAPTER FIVE...........................................................................................................................27
5.Conclusion and Recommendation..........................................................................................27
5.1. Conclusion......................................................................................................................27
5.2. Recommendation............................................................................................................27
References.....................................................................................................................................XI
APPENDIX I................................................................................................................................XII
APPENDIX II.............................................................................................................................XIV
List of tables
VIII | P a g e
Table. 4.1. Analysis of personal background of respondents........................................................20
Table. 4.2. The way in which non-performing loan manage.........................................................22
Table 4.3. Recognized non-performing loan.................................................................................22
Table 4.4. cause for non- performing loan....................................................................................23
Table 4.5. Make non -performing loan to performing loan...........................................................24
Table 4.6. Working to the management of non-performing loan..................................................24
Table 4.7. Sequence of procedures when the payment are overdue..............................................25
IX | P a g e
Abstract
This research paper conducted to assess the non-performing loan management in Dashen bank
Arba minch branch. In this study the researcher used descriptive research design and also use
qualitative and quantitative research approach. For the purpose of the study both primary and
secondary data would be used. The primary data is collected through questionnaires and
structured interview. The secondary data is collected from Dashen bank annual report. The
researcher used judgment sampling technique, because this method helps to select respondents
who are believed that they can give necessary information. The target respondents that are used
by the researcher are manager, loan officer and selected employee of bank. After the data has
been gathered, it would be analyzed and presented. The data analysis would be carried out
based on tabulation and percentage method. Careful interpretation of analyzed information
would be carried out to arrive at reasonable generalization.
X|Page
XI | P a g e
CHAPTER ONE
1. Introduction
1.1. Back ground of the study
A bank is financial institution which deals with deposits and advances and other related services.
It receives money from those who wants to save in the form of deposit and lends money to those
who need it. Banks are financial institutions that accept deposits and make loans. Included under
the term of banks, firms such as loan association, mutual saving banks and credit unions.
Because banks are the largest financial intermediaries, most people keep a large proportion of
their wealth in bank in the form of checking accounts, on other types of bank deposits.
(Mishikin,1997)
major roles of banks are accepting deposits advancing loans receiving of valuables for safe
custody acting as reference issue letter of credit in foreign trade merchant banking service
provides deal in foreign exchange issuer of travelers cheque and credit cards sale and purchase of
stock exchange securities.Banks are among the most important financial institutions in the
economy. There are the principal sources of credit for many households for most local units of
government and for business men. The principal economic function of banks is to make loan for
most banks loan account for half or more of their total assets and above half- two thirds of their
revenue (Rose, 1999).
Loan is an arrangement in which a lender gives money or property to a borrower and the
borrower agrees to return the property or repay the money usually along with interest at some
future points in time. Usually, there is a predetermined time for repaying a loan and generally the
lender has to bear the risk that the borrower may not repay a loan.
Non-performing loan is sum of borrowed money upon which the debtor has not made his or her
scheduled payments for at least 90 days. A non-performing loan is either in default or close to
being in default. Once a loan is nonperforming, the odds that it will be repaid in full are
considered to be substantially lower. If the debtor starts making payments again on a non-
performing loan, it becomes re performing loan even if the debtor has not caught up on all the
missed payments. Institutions holding non-performing loans in their portfolios may choose to
sell them to other investors in order to get risky assets and clean up their balance sheets. Sales of
1|Page
non-performing loans must be carefully considered since they can have numerous financial
implications, including affecting the company’s profit and loss, and tax situations.
According to Rawlinset al(2012), the principal aim of any business is to make profits. That is
why any asset created in conduction of business should generate income for the business. Since
this issue is applicable for the banking sector business, banks should give due consideration on
the management of loans because lending is the main business and loan is normally the main
assets and vital source of revenue for the (Daniel andWandera, 2013). Deposits in banks are
offset by higher margins from creation of credits as loans. However, if such assets do not
generate any income, the banks` ability to repay the deposit amount on the due date would be in
question. Therefore, the banks with such asset would become weak and such weak banks will
lose the faith and confidence of the customers. Ultimately, unrecoverable amounts of loans are
written off as non-performing loan (Maliket al., 2010).
The study of Skarica (2013) on the non-performing loans in Central and Eastern European
Countries through fixed effect model was also found as Gross Domestic Product growth rate,
unemployment rate and inflation had negative and significant impact on non-performing loans.
Similarly, Carlos (2012) based on ordinary least square model estimators found as non-
performing loans have negative association with gross domestic product growth rate whereas
positive association with unemployment rate. Similar to the Western and other African countries,
in Ethiopia also Wondimagegnehu(2012) Conducted a study on nonperforming loans and found
as poor credit assessment, failed loan monitoring, underdeveloped credit culture, lenient credit
terms and conditions, aggressive lending, compromised integrity, weak institutional capacity,
unfair competition among banks, and fund diversion for unexpected purposes and overdue
financing had an effect on the occurrence of non-performing loans.
It is fact that the bank plays important role in the economic development of the nation by
providing different service to the customer. Loan is one of the most important services that the
bank renders and relevant to this study. According to directives of national bank of Ethiopia
‘loan or advances’ or means any financial asset of the bank arising from the direct or indirect
advances by a bank to a person that are conditioned on the obligation of the person to repay the
fund, either on a specified date or dates usually within interest . .
The issue of non –performing loans has gained increasing attention in because the immediate
consequence of large amount of NPL in the banking system is bank failure. Thus the existence of
2|Page
non-performing loan in line with clients financed by Dashin bank arba minch area needs a
practical investigation.
3|Page
loan in becoming non-performing from both borrower and lending institution side and how the
manages it.
4|Page
1.7. Limitation of the study
The researcher’s faces different limitations to complete this study. From this limitation, some of
them are the researcher Lack Experience about research and carelessness and Unwillingness of
some respondent to give full information.
5|Page
CHAPTER TWO
2. LITERATURE REVIEW
In this chapter an attempt is given on some theoretical background and experience on the area of
non-performing loans and its management and bank crises in Dashen banks.
6|Page
one place to another by providing facilities such as discounting and accepting bill of exchange
and providing overdraft facilities. (Smith, 1991,)
Beside the above benefit, the banks help in monetary policy by faithfully following monetary
policy of the country, also the process of creating and destroying of money is done by the banks.
Generally, it contribute much more to the growth of developing economy through their loan and
advance provisions to trade and industry. It also help agriculture by directly financing
agriculturists for the market of their products and for modernizing their farms. (Posner, 1995)
In general the banks render domestic and international banking services. Domestic banking
services includes deposit mobilization, saving accounts, current account (demanded deposit
fixed) timed deposit, local money transfer and issuance of local guarantees. International banking
services include facilitation of foreign trade, foreign exchange service, facilitation of
international payment and international money transfer. (Smith, 1991) Major roles of banks are
accepting deposits, advancing loans, receiving of valuables for safe custody, acting as references,
issue letter of credit in foreign trade, merchant banking service provides, deal in foreign
exchange, issuer of travelers cheque and credit cards, sale and purchase of stock exchange
securities (http://www.social studieshelp.com/eco-banko.8:50Am)
7|Page
According to ( peter S.Rose,1992) loans are among the highest yielding asset a bank can add to
its portfolio, and they provide the largest portion of operating revenue. The principal business of
bank is to make loans to qualified borrowers. Far more important in dollar volume, however are
direct loans both business and individuals. This loan arises from negotiation between the bank
and its customer and result in written agreement designed to meet the specific credit needs of the
customer and the requirement of bank for adequate security and income.
Historically banks have preferred to make short term loans to businesses principally to support
purchase of inventory. in recent years however banks have long then end the maturity of their
business loans which have maturity over one years to finance the purchase of building machinery
and equipment. Because the longer term loans carry greater risk due to unexpected changes in
interest rates banks have also required a much greater proportion of new loans to carry variable
interest rates can be changed in response to shifting market condition.(S. Rose, 1992)
8|Page
A. Time to Maturity - the length of the loan contract. Loans are classified according to their
maturity into short term, intermediate - term debt and long-term debt. Revolving credit &
perpetual debt have no fixed debt for retirement banks provide revolving credit through
extension of a line of credit brokerage firms supply margin credit for qualified customer on
certain securities.
In this case the borrower constantly turns over the line of credit by paying it down and borrowing
the funds when needed a perpetual loan requires only regular interest payment. The borrower
who usually issued such debt through a registered offering determines the timing of the debt
retirement.
B. Repayment schedule - this schedule is a schedule that shows two parts that is apportion of the
outstanding principal and the interest costs with the interest cost with the passage of time the
principal amount of loan is reduced, or repaid little by little until it is completely retired. It is
required at the end of the contract or on asserted interval, usually on a monthly or semi - annual
basis.
C. Interest - it is a cost of borrowing. The interest rate charged by lending institution must be
sufficient to cover operation & administrative costs on acceptable rate of return. It may be fixed
for the term of loan or adjusted to reflect the changing market condition; floating rates are tied to
some market index and are adjusted regularly.
D. Security - assets pledged as security against loan are known mortgages. Unsecured debt relies
on the earning as collaterals credit backed by collateral is secured. In many cases the asset
purchased by the loan often serves as the only collateral in other cases the borrower puts other
assets including cash, aside as collateral. Real estate or land collateralized power of borrower.
9|Page
asset quality. The impacts of non-performing loans are not limited to only a financial institution
loan loss also influences the unemployment rate .
10 | P a g e
procedures. Economic conditions may change adversely after the loan is granted so that the
borrower cannot meet debt service requirements.
Alternatively, a borrower may simply choose not to repay if circumstances permit. Problem
loans and loan losses essentially reflect the default risk inherent in borrower’s willingness and
ability to repay all obligations. (Koch, 1995)
11 | P a g e
the borrower intends to pay off the debt and the installment if monthly quarterly, in one lump
sum etc.
12 | P a g e
Credit analysis for dashen lending involves identifying inherent risks in the operation of
business by generating a list of factors that indicate what could harm a borrower’s ability to pay
examining what managers have done or failed to do in mitigating those risks, and structuring an
acceptable loan agreement and controlling the risk of the bank in the supplying funds. (Koch and
Macdonald, 2000) has been gathered, the firm faces the hard choice of either granting or refusing
credit. Many financial managers use the five “C’'s of Credit" as their guide (Holger M. Muller
2008).
1. Character: Character refers to the borrower’s reputation and the borrower’s willingness
to settle debt obligations. In evaluating character, the borrower’s honesty, integrity and
trustworthiness are assessed. The borrower’s credit history and the commitment of the
owners are also evaluated (Rose, 2000).
A company’s reputation, referring specifically to credit, is based on past performance. A
borrower has built up a good reputation or credit record if past commitments were
promptly met (observed behavior) and repaid timely (Rose, 2002; Koch & McDonald,
2003). Bankers recognize the essential role management plays in a company’s success.
Critically analyzing quality of management has been one of the ways of assessing
character. The history of the business and experience of its management are critical
factors in assessing company’s ability to satisfy its financial obligations. The quality of
management in the specific business is evaluated by taking reputation, integrity,
qualifications, experience and management ability of various business disciplines such as
finance, marketing and labor relations into consideration (Sinkey, 2002;
Nathenson,2004).
2. Capacity: Capacity refers to the business’s ability to generate sufficient cash to repay the
debt. Analysis of the applicant’s businesses plan, management accounts and cash flow
forecasts (demonstrating the need and ability to repay the commitments) will give a good
indication of the capacity to repay (Sinkey, 2002; Koch & MacDonald, 2003). To get a
good understanding of a company’s capacity evaluating the type of business and the
industry in which it operates is also vital. It plays a significant role since each industry is
13 | P a g e
influenced by various internal and external factors. The factors that form the basis of this
analysis includes:
Type of industry, Market share, Quality of products and life cycle, whether the business
is labor or capital intensive, the current economic conditions, seasonal trends, the
bargaining power of buyers and sellers, competition and legislative changes (Koch
&MacDonald, 2003; Nathenson, 2004). Besides, the financial position is also a critical
indication of a business’ capacity. The company’s financial position is evaluated by
assessing past financial performance and projected financial performance. A company’s
past financial performance is reflected in their audited financial statements (Koch &
MacDonald, 2003).
3. Capital: Capital refers to the owner’s level of investment in the business (Sinkey, 2002).
Banks prefer owners to take a proportionate share of the risk. Although there are no hard
and fast rules, a debt/equity ratio of 50:50 would be sufficient to mitigate the bank’s risk
where funding(unsecured) is based on the business’s cash flow to service the funding
(Harris, 2003).
4. Conditions: Conditions are external circumstances that could affect the borrower’s
ability to repay the amount financed. Lenders consider the overall economic and industry
trends, regulatory, legal and liability issues before a decision is made (Sinkey, 2002).
Once finance is approved, it is normally subject to terms and covenants and conditions,
which are specifically related to the compliance of the approved facility (Leply, 2003).
5. Collateral: Collateral (also called security) is the assets that the borrower pledges to the
bank to mitigate the bank’s risk in event of default (Sinkey, 2002) .It is something
valuable which is pledged to the bank by the borrower to support the borrower’s intention
to repay the money advanced. Security is taken to mitigate the bank’s risk in the event of
default and is considered a secondary source of repayment (Koch & MacDonald, 2003).
The purpose of security is to reduce the risk of giving credit by increasing the chances of
the lender recovering the amounts that become due to the borrower. Security increases
the availability of credit and improves the terms on which credit is available. The offer of
security influences the lender’s decision whether or not to lend, and it also changes the
terms on which he is prepared to lend, typically by increasing the amount of the loan, by
14 | P a g e
extending the period for which the loan is granted and by lowering the interest rate
(Norton and Andenas, 1998: 144).
15 | P a g e
However, Konfi (2012) who conducted study on the determinants of nonperforming loans on the
operations of SINAPI ABA TRUST microfinance institutions in Ghana found as high interest
rate was not significant factors causing the incidence of non- performing loans. This study
justifies as interest rate is only applicable to loan defaulters who have managed to pay off
outstanding principal and are in default in only interest payment. If a borrower is in default of
both principal and interest, then one cannot assert that high interest rate is the actually the cause
of the loan default.
Besides, the study conducted in Ethiopia by (Wondimagegnehu ,2012) on “the assessment non-
performing loan on commercial banks of Ethiopia” also found as poor credit assessment, failed
loan monitoring, underdeveloped credit culture, lenient credit terms and conditions, aggressive
lending, compromised integrity, weak institutional capacity, unfair competition among banks,
will full defaults by borrower and their knowledge limitation, fund diversion for unexpected
purposes and overdue financing has significant effect on non-performing loans. Besides, the
study of (Wondimagegnehu 2012) considers interest rate as bank specific factors and revealed as
interest rate has no impact on the level of non- performing loans of commercial banks in
Ethiopia.
The study conducted in Ethiopia by on ‘determinants of non-performing loans ‘in commercial
bank the finding revealed as loan to deposit ratio had positive whereas inflation rate had
negative, but insignificant effect on non-performing loans of commercial banks in Ethiopia.
However, bank profitability measured in terms of return on equity, banks capital adequacy ratio
and lending rate had negative and statistically significant effect whereas bank profitability
measured in terms of return on asset and effective tax rate had positive and statistically
significant effect on non-performing loans. The finding of this study is significant since once
identifying the determinants of non-performing loans might enable management body to make
appropriate lending policies that prevent the occurrence of non-loans.
16 | P a g e
there is no enough research that shows the current status of Dashen bank in non-performing loan
management in Arba minch sikella branch. Due to this fact the researcher initiated to conduct
research in Arbaminch town on the title of assessment on non-performing loan management in
management
CHAPTER THREE
3. Research Methodology
3.1. Research design and research approach
The researcher was used descriptive type of research design because the objective of a
descriptive research is to describe the state of affairs as it exists. The study was used both
qualitative and quantitative approach of research because quantitative approach enables to
conduct the study with intent of quantify report and assess multiple realities and evidences based
on actual words of different prospective from individuals and organization itself. And qualitative
in this study consider to as suitable for gaining in depth understanding of reasons and motivation.
17 | P a g e
3.3. Target population and sample size
The target population study is employees of organization specifically who is close to loan
advance and credit management in organization the reason is the researchers assume that those
employees are full awareness about non-performing loan management. The researcher selected
12 employees as sample from 21 total population of organization, those who have an approach to
management of bank / organization/. These researchers selected manager, assistant manager,
loan officer and employees from total of (12) employees.
18 | P a g e
CHAPTER FOUR
4. DATA PRESENTATION AND INTERPRETATION
This chapter presents and interpretation non-performing loan management in Dashen bank in
Arba minch District. The primary and secondary data presented and interpretation in descriptive
way. Primary data is collected from Dashen bank in Arba minch District through questionnaires
and interview. The questionnaires are distributed to 12 employees of bank and the interview was
conducted to manager, assistant manager and loan officer of the bank. The secondary data is
from Dashen bank annual report 2017-21.
No Percentage
1 Sex Male 7 58.333
Female 5 41.667
19 | P a g e
Total 12 100
2 Age 20-25 2 16.667
26-30 6 25
31-35 3 21.43
36-40 1 38.333
Above 40 0 0
Total 12 100
Single 6 50
Divorced 2 16.667
Total 12 100
4 Educational status Diploma 0 0
First degree 10 83.83
Masters 2 16.667
Above masters 0 0
Total 12 100
5 Position in bank Manager 1 8.333
Assistant manager 1 8.333
Loan officer 1 8.333
Employee 9 75
Total 12 100
20 | P a g e
most of respondents are in between 26 and 30. The researcher asked about educational status of
the employees, the respondents answered as follows and analyzed as, Diploma no choose it. 10
respondents or 83.83% of respondents have first degree, one of them has second degree and
none of them has above second degree. 2 respondents or 16.667% from this the researcher can
conclude that most of employees in the bank are 1st degree.
The researcher asked about marital status of the employees, and in according to the table 4.1
above 4 respondents or 33.33% is married, 6 respondents or 50% of respondents are not
married /single and 2(16.667%) of them are divorce. So, from this the researcher can conclude
that most of employees in the bank are unmarried. The researcher asked about respondent
position in the bank, in above table 4.1, 8.33% or 1 respondent is manager, 1 respondents or
8.33% are assistant manager, 8.333% or one respondent is loan officer, 75% of respondents or 9
respondents are employees of bank. So, from this I can conclude that most of the respondents are
employee of bank.
21 | P a g e
The researcher asked to the respondents to know that the bank have recognized ever non-
performing loan. The table 4.2 .2 shows that 4 respondents or 33.33% of respondents said agree
and 5 respondents or 41.67% agree. So, from this the researcher can conclude that the bank has
recognized any non-performing loans.
A Poor performance 4 8 12
performance 33.33% 66.667% 100%
B Political instability 3 6 3 12
Percentage 25% 50% 25% 100%
C Lack of credit policy 2 5 3 2 12
Percentage 16.66% 41.67% 25% 16.667% 100%
D Error in 2 6 4 12
documentation
percentage 16.667 50% 33.33 100%
% %
E Fraudulent practice 3 4 5 12
percentage 25% 33.33% 41.667% 100%
Source: survey and interview, 2021
The researcher asked those who say agree, the reasons/causes of non-performing and
respondents answered: 6 respondents or 50% are responded the poor management, 4 respondents
or 33.33% of respondents answered political instability, 2 respondents or 16.67% answered error
in documentation none of them choose the fraudulent practice and from manager response there
is lack of credit practice lack of effective follow up by the branch, approval of loan without
adequate collateral and absence of employee motivation. So, from this researcher can conclude
that the bank has poor loan management system instability and error in documentation ability
have its part.
22 | P a g e
Table 4.5. Make non -performing loan to performing loan
No Item (activities the bank performs) SA A N DA SD Total
4 The bank is tried to make non- 2 2 3 5 12
performing loan to the performing
loan
Percentage 16.6 16.6 25 41.7 100%
% % % %
Source: survey, 2021
The researcher asked to know whether the bank tried to make the loan performing loan back,
according to table 4.2.4 the respondents answered as follows;16.6 % of respondents assured that
strongly agree 16.6% of respondents said agree, 25% are neutral and majority group are said that
disagree. So, from this the researcher can conclude that the bank is not trying to make non-
performing loan to performing loan.
Table 4.6. Working to the management of non-performing loan
No Item (activities the bank performs) SA A N DA SD Total
5 Your bank is working to the management non- - 5 7 12
performing loan
Perce - 41.7% 58.33% 100%
ntage
Source: survey, 2021
From the above table 4.2.5 the major respondent are disagree that is 7(58.33%) and 5(41.7%)
are agree. Therefore, the researcher can conclude that the bank is not working to the
management of non-performing loan.
23 | P a g e
Table 4.7. Sequence of procedures when the payment are overdue
No Item (activities the bank SA A N DA SD Total
performs)
6 The borrowers
whose payments are
overdue in
following sequence
of procedures
A Calling,billing, 6 4 2 12
applying to court
Percentage 50% 33,33% 16.667% 100%
B Billing, calling 4 5 3 12
applying to court
Percentage 33.33% 41.7% 25% 100%
C Applying to court 3 5 4
Percentage 25% 41.7% 33.33% 100%
Source: survey, 2021
From the above table 4.2.6 the respondent replied that the payment sequence of procedure start
from calling ,billing, applying to court which is 6(50%) are strongly agree,4(33.33%) are agree
and 2 (16.66%) .Some respondent said that the sequence of payment procedure is start from
billing, calling, applying to court to 4(33.33%) are agree,5(41.7%) are neutral and 3(25%) are
disagree. So, from this the researcher can conclude that the borrowers whose payment are
overdue in the sequence of procedure to calling, billing and applying to court .
24 | P a g e
the credit advisor will conduct a detailed face to face interview with the applicant to obtain full
information pertaining to the credit request the interview. Under this circumstance the interview
with the manager response advance loan to customer is done by receiving all required documents
as per the bank policy and procedure as well as NBE directive for instance; commercial
registration certificate, business license , income statement and balance sheet , collateral and so
on.
In addition to the information document that collect detailed information about the business
activities of the customer from the independent sources to have well detailed customer diligence.
The manager says that the effects from NPL in Dashen bank is very rare cause as per NBE
directive state beyond 5% NPL out of total outstanding loan balance could cause the bank to
suspend granting loan to customer. Once the loan become non-performing the bank officials try
to exert effort in collecting the loan balance. The first step is communicating the borrower
through different means to repay the loan. The first resort is to acquiring the collateral is for
closed acquiring the collateral property is not readily sold in the market the bank has to incur
maintenance and administrative cost thus disposing non-performing loans through sale proceeds
of its collateral is not easily successful. However, these does not help much banks and yet been
proceeding large number of collateral property that should have been sold. Dashn bank Arba
minch District takes NPL measures when borrowers cannot repay the debt, communicate with
borrowers, give advice there by extend the repayment period. However, this adds the loan to be
default. According to answer of respondents, the Bank is working to manage non-performing
loan. However according to question about the performance/degree hard working in managing
NPL the performance in managing is not satisfactory. Some loans are still becoming non-
performing loan. Managements are not running as much as possible to manage non-performing
loans even if they work to recovery the NPL. Therefore there are some loans that are becoming
non-performing in the bank. The researcher asked respondents to know for the non -performance
of the loan who is responsible and accountable, so specifically the responsible person for non-
performing loan is branch manager. The researcher asked to know the length of time to make the
non-performing loan in to performing loan, and most respondents answered that the length of
time to recover or to make it performing the loans that become non-performing is above 3
months.
25 | P a g e
4.4. Analysis of the secondary data
The researcher could not secondary data about branch bank, which reveals NPL of branch rather
than primary data. The researcher used secondary data from financial statement reports of
Dashen bank. The researcher mainly used balance sheet and expense status to know portfolios
and its collection as well as trends of NPL. The data were selected from seven years financial
statements, from 2016-2021 years financial statements. And analysis and explanation is given
based on the data believed and concentrated on objective study. The data used for following
analysis is bonded on the back of this paper.
26 | P a g e
CHAPTER FIVE
5.Conclusion and Recommendation
This chapter deal with conclusion based on primary and secondary finding and finally to make
recommendation to Dashen bank Arba minch District.
5.1. Conclusion
From the analysis part of this research based on the data gathered from primary and secondary
data I conclude that: The bank is advancing or providing loan to customer, manufacturer,
domestic and foreign traders. The bank is using calling, billing and applying to court are an
instrument for collection of non-performing loans from defaults. The basic cause for non-
performing loan are poor performance, political instability, lack of credit policy ,fraudulent
practice, lack of customer awareness, approval of loan without adequate collateral, absence of
employee motivation. The length of time to recover or to make it performing the loans that
become non-performing is above 3 months. There are many types of loan done by the bank
advance to customers: overdraft facilities, term loan merchandize loan import and export trade
finance loan, consumer loan, project or investment loan and guarantee loan. The bank is not
properly working and making follow up on non-performing loans and also has poor
management. On performing loan have substantial negative impact on existing potential
performance of the bank the responsible person in the nonperforming loan is branch manager.
5.2. Recommendation
In addition to having a well-organized credit management system, the bank needs to make
exhaustive effort in implementation as well as for better improvement of handing and controlling
problems of non-performing loan in the further I insist that the following changes and
adjustments could be good for the bank's future career. Frequency and non-performing loans
should be minimized. The bank should have good loan management practice and proper follow
up before loans become NPL.The bank should try to make non-performing to normal loans. The
bank is should properly decide on the non-performing loans. The bank should protect and detect
the problems, cause and consequences of non-performing in the banks operation and
profitability. The manager should take care/great attention on the loans given to the borrower
27 | P a g e
References
Ajayi. (1992). journal article on an analysis of default in Residential Mortgages of federal
mortgage bank of Nigeria.
Fofack, H. (.-p.-S.-p.-S. ( Fofack, H, (2005). Non-performing loans in sub-Sahara Africa: causal
analysis, investigated the determinants of non-performing loans2009.).
Fofack, H, (2005). Non-performing loans in sub-Sahara Africa: causal analysis, investigated the
determinants of non-performing loans in sub-Saharan Africans Macroeconomic
statistics, IMF Working paper, and W.
Jems. (n.d.). Financial Intermediation. (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/loan): Financial system and
its function (accessed March 15).
Joseph. (2011). Conduct study on effects of interest rate speed on the non -performing loan.
Koch. (1995). Problem of loan and losses become Problem credit as a result of Many factors.
Levees. (2012). Assessment of non -performing loan management. Assessment of non -perform
management.
Millan, M. (n.d.). principle of banking, Indian institute of banking and finance. 2005.
Muller, H. M. (2008). • Holger M. Muller, (2008). bank capital structure and credit decisions,
university of (http: // teach me finance.com); Non-performing loan and its occurrences
(accessed on March 28, 2010), Frankfurt (IMFS), p.295-314.
Muller, H. M. (n.d.). • Holger M. Muller, (2008). bank capital.
Pandy. (1999). financial management, 8th edition, Indian institute management.
Peter S, R. (1992). Loan among the highest yielding. asset a bank can add to its portfolio.
Poser. (1995). Help agriculture by directly Finance agriculture for the Market.
Rose. (1995). Fundamental management and corporative Finance, 3rd edition, mc-grow hill.
s. Mishkin. (1995). Assessment of non-performance loan management. Assessment of non
-performing loan management.
Sinkey. (2002). Capital refers to the level of investment in the business owner.
Tomothy, W. (1995). banking, and money management.3rd edition. New York.
Ttacy.G. Herikk. (1978). bank analysis, 2nd edition wisterias edition.
Wondimu. (2007). Analysis of technical efficiency of banks in loan delivery United Dashen bank
and construction and Business.
XI | P a g e
APPENDIX I
ARBAMINCH UNIVERSITY
COLLEGE OF BUSINESS AND ECONOMICS
DEPARTMENT OF BANKING AND FINANCE
Questionnaires to be fill by employees of Dashen bank of Arbaminch District.
Dear Respondent
The aim of conducting these questionnaires is to assess the non-performing loan management in
Dashen bank of Arbaminch District. In addition, it also aims to partially fulfillment of BA degree
in accounting and finance. So, dear respondents you are kindly request to fulfill the following
questionnaire appropriately. The information that you will give keep in secret and will be used
only for academic purpose.
Note: - Make your responses on boxes and write down on spaces provide.
Thank you in advance for your responses.
Personal Back Ground
1. Sex: male female
2. Age: 20-25 26-30 31-35 36-40 above 40
3. Marital statutes: married Unmarried divorced
4. Educational statutes: diploma degree master above master
5. Position in bank: manage assistant manager loan officer other, please
specify________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________
XII | P a g e
I. To what extent do you agree or disagree to the following statements about Dashen bank?
Please use 1, strongly agree, 2, agree 3, Neutral, 4, disagree 5, strongly disagree, tick
the boxes according to your reasons.
APPENDIX II
INTERVIEW QUESTION
How do you advance the loan to customers?
XIII | P a g e
What are basic causes of non-performing loan in your bank?
What are effects of non-performing loan on your bank?
Do you experience any non-performing loan in your bank?
What are measures taken to deal with non-performing loan?
How can your bank know that it is managing non-performing loan or not
managing Non performing loan?
What is your performance regarding to working to manage none performing
loans?
Who is responsible for non-performing loan?
What is the length of the time that loan can become Non performing loan in
your branch?
What type of loan do you advance?
THANK YOU!!!
XIV | P a g e