Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A kinetic study of the activity of mushroom polyphenol as ascorbic acid,2 thus ensuring that the reaction products
oxidase in an organic system was carried out to obtain are o-dihydric phenols.
detailed enzyme kinetic data in relation to optimization Developments in the field of nonaqueous enzymology
of reaction conditions and substrate specificity. A simple
method for consistent measurement of reaction rates have revealed the versatility of biocatalysts employed in
in the heterogeneous enzymelorganic solvent system organic media, and an attractive option for the production
(consisting of immobilized polyphenol oxidase and a of o-quinones using polyphenol oxidase is its application in
hydrated solution of the substrate in chloroform) was nearly anhydrous organic solvents. This enzyme has been
designed. The aqueous content of the system was shown to retain activity in various solvents, provided that,
optimized using pcresol as the substrate. With this
system, a crude extract of Agaricus bisporus was as with the majority of enzymes in organic systems, a small
used to hydroxylate and oxidize a range of selected proportion of water is present in the system.22The water is
psubstituted phenolic substrates, yielding o-quinone generally considered to maintain conformational flexibility
products. Michaelis-Menten kinetics were used to in the protein molecule^.^
obtain apparent KM and V,,, values with respect to each The advantages afforded by the use of nonpolar organic
of these substrates. Results from this analysis indicated
a correlation between the enzymic kinetic parameters solvents include increased solubility of hydrophobic sub-
obtained and the steric requirements of the substrates, strates and reactants, which is of relevance in the case of
which could be rationalized in terms of the restricted certain substituted phenols which are potential substrates of
flexibility of the enzyme when it is in chloroform and polyphenol oxidase. Chloroform is a particularly suitable
also in terms of substrate and solvent hydrophobicity. medium for this enzyme since oxygen has a high solubility
In the course of the investigation UV molar absorption
coefficients of several o-quinones were measured by a in chloroform and thus the availability of oxygen for the
novel method: 'H nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) reaction need not be a limiting factor." Furthermore, the
spectroscopy was employed to determine component enzyme is not soluble in chloroform and can be conve-
concentrations in reaction mixtures resulting from the niently separated from the reaction mixture. The feasibility
transformation of phenols by polyphenol oxidase in of a purified polyphenol oxidase/chloroform system has
chloroform. Thus the UV molar absorption coefficients
could be obtained directly, avoiding the necessity to been demonstrated using gas liquid chromatography (GLC)
isolate the water-sensitive, unstable o-quinones. 0 1993 and high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) to
John Wiley & Sons, Inc. monitor the transformation of various p-substituted phe-
Key words: Polyphenol oxidase tyrosinase enzymes nolic substrates.'" This study reported enzyme kinetic data
in organic media o-quinones for one substrate only, viz., p-cresol. An aim of the present
study has been to obtain further quantitative data on the
enzyme kinetics of polyphenol oxidase in a chloroform
INTRODUCTION
medium as a function of substrate structure. Reports of
Polyphenol oxidase (EC 1.14.18.1) is a monooxygenase quantitative kinetic studies are relatively scarce in the
which catalyzes the o-hydroxylation of phenols and the oxi- literature,I6 but they are essential in the development of
dation of o-dihydric phenols to o-quinones using molecu- a theoretical basis for the application of enzymic catalysis
lar oxygen.17 Since these products are often difficult to in organic media. Thus, the transformation by polyphenol
synthesize by classical methods, the potential of this en- oxidase of a range of selected p-substituted phenols was ex-
zyme for catalyzing the reactions in vitro is clear, and amined under standardized conditions. Initial reaction rates
various investigations have shown that a wide range of were measured spectrophotometrically using chloroform
substrates can be transformed in conventional aqueous- (containing a specific quantity of aqueous buffer) as solvent.
based enzyme ~ y s t e m s . ~ ~ ' ~The
- ' ~ drawbacks
~'~ associated Since application of the system to a larger scale process is
with the formation of o-quinones in aqueous systems, viz., an objective of this research, a crude mushroom extract,
polymerization yielding melanin-like, insoluble products, immobilized without further purification, was utilized as
can be overcome by the addition of reducing agents such a source of polyphenol oxidase. The level of enzyme
hydration in such systems would be governed by the
* To whom all correspondence should be addressed. initial water content of the solvent and that of the protein
MATERIALS AND METHODS Polyacrylamide disc gel electrophoresis was carried out
using 3% stacking and 7.5% resolving gels in Tris-glycine
Materials buffer (pH 8.3), but in the absence of sodium dodecyl
sulfate (SDS), using a Hoefer “Mighty Small” apparatus.
Mushroom polyphenol oxidase was extracted from fresh Two identical gels were loaded with 100-130 p g of crude
mushrooms (Agaricus bisporus) generously donated by extract and run simultaneously. One of these was then
Tongaat Mushrooms, Natal, South Africa. Glass beads (250 stained with Coomassie blue using a standard procedure.21
p M acid washed) were purchased from Supelco. Phenolic The second gel was placed in a solution of L-DOPA (5 mM;
substrates were obtained from commercial suppliers. Chlo- 100 mL) in phosphate buffer (50 mM; pH 7) at room
roform was distilled prior to use, and its water content was temperature for 0.5 h, after which the reaction was halted
determined by Karl Fischer titration. by placing the gel in 15% trichloroacetic acid solution
for 15 min and then washing with 10% glycerol solution.
This electrophoretic procedure was repeated using solu-
Preparation of Biocatalyst
tions (5 mM) of each of the phenols listed in Table I and
Fresh mushrooms (1 kg) were frozen and then homog- L-tyrosine, in place of the L-DOPA to stain the second gel
enized in cold acetone (2.5 L) using a Waring blender. in each case.
The resulting slurry was filtered rapidly on a Buchner
funnel, and the residual pulp was air dried briefly before
freezing with liquid N2 and stirring into H2O (500 mL).
The mixture was kept overnight at 4”C, filtered through Table I. Nondenaturing electrophoresis of crude mushroom extract.
cheesecloth, and then allowed to stand in ice while N2 Mobility of protein components detected
was bubbled gently through the solution to remove residual Stain by staining of gela
acetone. The aqueous extract was freeze dried to yield a Coomassie blue 0.26 0.41 0.60 0.75
pale brown powder (9.5 g) which was kept frozen until L-DOPA 0.40 0.75
required. L-Tyrosine 0.40
Immobilization was effected by precipitation onto non- p-Cresol 0.41
porous glass beads. A mixture of the crude, freeze-dried p-Ethylphenol 0.40
p-Isopropylphenol 0.40
extract (6 g) with phosphate buffer (50 mM; pH 7; 12 mL)
p-t-Butylphenol 0.40
and dry glass beads (36 g) was stirred gently in a petri dish p-Methoxyphenol 0.40
and allowed to stand at room temperature with adequate p-Fluorophenol 0.40
ventilation and occasional stirring until no visible liquid p-Chlorophenol 0.40
remained. Portions of the (slightly sticky) biocatalyst were p-Bromophenol 0.40
kept frozen in closed containers and thawed as required. a Calculated as a fraction of the distance moved in the resolving gel by
Samples were not refrozen or reused. bromothymol blue indicator during the electrophoresis.
0 2 4 8
Time (minuted
8 10 12
zyme and substrate and to allow saturating aeration, thus - p-Cresol * p-Chlorophenol
* p-Methoxyphenol + p-Ethylphenol
obviating the possibility of oxygen depletion slowing the
reaction rates. The highest initial reaction rate corresponded Figure 1. Typical time courses of polyphenol oxidase-catalyzed
to the system where the chloroform had an aqueous content oxidations of some phenolic substrates. Substrate concentration for
these reactions is 50 mM,
of 0.338% (v/v). In addition, the freshly prepared biocata-
lyst was found to contain 2.83% water (w/w), determined
by weighing before and after freeze-drying and heating at
large error margins for this substrate are attributable to the
100°C for 12 h and thus, assuming that no water is stripped
very slow conversion rates measured and to some turbidity
from the protein by the hydrophobic s ~ l v e n t , 'the
~ volume
produced in reaction mixtures as the product was formed.
of water available to hydrate the protein was 5.9% (w/w)
The substrates chosen represent a series in which
with respect to protein or 0.65% (v/v) with respect to
the steric bulk and the electronic characteristics of the
chloroform.
p-substituent vary gradually. The kinetic parameters
obtained show trends which correlate to some extent
Enzyme Kinetics in Chloroform with the steric parameters. Thus a correlation between
the efficiency of substrate transformation by polyphenol
The choice of p-cresol as a standard substrate arises from
the wide range of concentrations over which its trans-
formation rate remains constant, indicating no substrate
or product inhibition under these conditions. Thus the S/v (rntd/min.mg)
3000
reaction rates for p-cresol could be compared with the
other substrates whether these were used in relatively 2500 -
high concentrations (in cases of slow reactions) or low 2000 -
concentrations (in cases of low solubility).
Results of the enzyme kinetic analysis of polyphenol 1500 -
oxidase using a range of phenolic substrates are shown in 1000 -
Figures 1-3 and Table 111. It is clear from Figures 1 and 2
that the method used, albeit a simple one, provides consis-
tent data within acceptable error margins. (For the purpose 0
0 50 100 150 200 250
of observing trends from the data obtained, standard errors Conc. S (mM)
of less than 10% in experimental data and calculated
parameters were regarded as acceptable.) The data obtained - p-Cresol
a Karl Fischer titration indicated that the original H 2 0 content of CHC13 Figure 2. Examples of Hanes plots to obtain KM and V,,, values
was 0.038%, amounting to 3.8 pL/lO mL using (a) p-cresol and (b) p-methoxyphenol.
:i
I I hence giving rise to the high apparent KM values obtained.
The trend of increasing KM with increasing hydrophobicity
is reflected in Table 111. Thus, the present investigation
20 concurs with the findings of Ryu and Dordick16 in their
investigation of peroxidase activity.
F OMe CI Br Me Et i-Pr t-But On the other hand, the relationship between substrate
Substrate utilization by polyphenol oxidase and the electronic char-
V l K m values = E8 (size) [7Km
acteristics of the p-substituent are less clear. Although the
mechanism of the reaction is regarded as a nucleophilic at-
Es value8 x -10, V l K m value8 x 10
tack by the phenolic aromatic ring, on a polarized peroxide
Figure 3. Correlations between substrate p-substituent size and bridge in the enzyme active centre,'* this mechanism has
reaction kinetic constants. (Es values times -10, V m a X / Kvalues
~ not been fully established, and it is a matter for conjecture
times 10, to show trends relative to K M ) . as to whether or not electron donation by p-substituents
facilitates the reaction.
oxidase and the steric bulk of the p-substituent is suggested
by Table 111 and Figure 3 since the E, values are indicative
of steric size.12 The KM value reflects the ability of an Determination of Molar Absorption
Coefficients of o-Quinones
enzyme to bind a substrate, and V m a X / K the ~ , catalytic
efficiency,16 indicates the ability of the enzyme to transform The polyphenol oxidase/chloroform system lends itself to
this substrate. An inverse relationship between V,,,/KM investigation of the composition of reaction mixtures be-
and ES can be observed for the various substrates, regarding cause the organic solvent phase can be separated from the
them in two groups. In the p-alkylphenols, as the steric biocatalyst by simple decantation. Use of CDC13 and D20
size of the alkyl group increases from methyl to tert-butyl, in place of CHC13 and H20 permitted examination of the
the V m a x / Kvalues
~ decrease. Similarly, for the remaining reaction mixtures by 'H NMR spectroscopy to determine
phenolic substrates, taken in the order fluoro-, methoxy-, the nature and the extent of reaction, as illustrated by the
chloro-, and bromo-, there is a decrease in V,,,/KM as example shown in Figure 4. The calculation of UV molar
the steric size increases. (It should be noted that a large absorption coefficients was carried out by correlating UV-
negative E, value correlates with a large steric volume.) visible absorbances with NMR-determined concentrations
One effect of hydrophobic solvents on enzymes is a of o-quinone products in the reaction mixtures, as shown
reduction in conformational fle~ibility,~ and these results in Table IV. The E values obtained correspond well to
support this. In aqueous systems, polyphenol oxidase is literature values where these are available.2o This method
known to be capable of hydroxylating molecules of con- provides a means of calculating E values without the
siderable size such as steroids,' but in chloroform, access necessity of isolating the o-quinone products, which is a
of bulky substrates such as p-tert-butylphenol to the active major advantage for compounds which are air sensitive and
site may well be restricted by the rigidity of the protein have a strong tendency to polymerize. The NMR spectra
pocket of the enzyme. also show unambiguously that under these experimental
A further factor, the hydrophobicity of the substrate, conditions the reactions proceed cleanly and that only the
should also be considered in rationalizing observations o-quinone products are formed.
Table 111. Kinetic parameters determined for formation of o-quinones from p-substituted phenols by polyphenol oxidase in chloroform.
a ~ (min . mg protein)-'
The units of V,, are mM/min. mg protein and units of V m a X / Kare
Apparent K M values.