Professional Documents
Culture Documents
EVALUATIO
N AND
CONTRIOL
PART-B
Topic: Concept of Strategy
1. Illustrate the detail components of strategic planning process Medium-AZ (16 M)
5. Explain Elaborately the concept of different levels of strategy and stakeholders of Business.
Medium-U (16 M)
PART-B
Topic: Porters Five Forces
1. Illustrate the Porters Five Forces for an auto mobile industry. Tough-AZ (16M)
Topic: COMPETITIVE ADVANTAGES
2. Illustrate the Generic Building blocks of competitive advantage. Tough-AZ (16M)
PART-A
TOPIC: THE GENERIC STRATEGIC ALTERNATIVES
1. Outline the levels of Strategy. [AZ]
2. Illustrate the various strategies to manage rivalry in mature industries [AZ] [16]
3. Illustrate the concentration and diversification strategy in detail [AZ][16]
STRATEGY:
➔What is our strategy?
➔How do we intend to achieve our objectives?
➔How do we deal with competitive pressure?
➔How are changes in customer demands dealt with?
➔How is strategy adjusted for environmental issues?
STRUCTURE:
➔How is the company/team divided?
➔What is the hierarchy?
➔How do the various departments coordinate activities?
➔How do the team members organize and align themselves?
➔Is decision making and controlling centralized or decentralized? Is this as it should be, given
what we're doing?
➔Where are the lines of communication? Explicit and implicit?
SYSTEMS:
➔What are the main systems that run the organization? Consider financial and HR systems
as well as communications and document storage.
➔Where are the controls and how are they monitored and evaluated?
➔What internal rules and processes does the team use to keep on track?
SHARED VALUES:
➔What are the core values?
➔What is the corporate/team culture?
➔How strong are the values?
➔What are the fundamental values that the company/team was built on?
STYLE:
➔How participative is the management/leadership style?
➔How effective is that leadership?
➔Do employees/team members tend to be competitive or cooperative?
➔Are there real teams functioning within the organization or are they just nominal groups?
STAFF:
➔What positions or specializations are represented within the team?
➔What positions need to be filled?
➔Are there gaps in required competencies?
SKILLS:
➔What are the strongest skills represented within the company/team?
➔Are there any skills gaps?
➔What is the company/team known for doing well?
➔Do the current employees/team members have the ability to do the job?
➔How are skills monitored and assessed?
UNIT IV STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION & EVALUATION 09Hours
The implementation process, Resource allocation, Designing organizational structure-Designing
Strategic Control Systems- Matching structure and control to strategy-Implementing Strategic
change-Politics-Power and Conflict-Techniques of strategic evaluation & control-case study.
PART-A
TOPIC: STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION
1. Define Reengineering.[U]
Reengineering is the fundamental re-thinking and radical redesign of business processes to
achieve dramatic improvements in critical, contemporary measures of performance such as quality,
cost service and sped. The aim of reengineering is to improve the corporate performance.
2. Define Intrapreneurship[U]
He is acting like an entrepreneur within a larger organization. The term is derived from a
combination of "intra" or internal, and "entrepreneurship." Intraprenuers are usually highly self-
motivated, proactive and action-oriented people who are comfortable with taking the initiative, even
within the boundaries of an organization, in pursuit of an innovative product or service
3. What is Job enrichment?[R]
Job enrichment is a conscious effort to build into jobs a higher sense of challenge and
achievement. In a job enrichment program, the worker decides how the job is performed, planned
and controlled and makes more decision concerning hi entire process job. Employee decides how the
job will be performed and receives less direct supervision on the job. Consequently the employee
receives a greater sense of accomplishment as well as more authority and responsibility and job
satisfaction. This in turn contributes for batten employee performance and higher productivity.
4. Explain strategy implementation.[R]
Strategy implementation is "the process of allocating resources to support the chosen
strategies". To effectively direct and control the use of the firm's resources, mechanisms such as
organizational structure, information systems, leadership styles, assignment of key managers,
budgeting, rewards, and control systems are essential strategy implementation ingredients" Strategy
implementation is "the process of allocating resources to support the chosen strategies".
TOPIC: STRATEGIC CHANGE-POLITICS-POWER AND CONFLICT
5. Define Corporate Culture.[U]
Corporate culture is the corporation of belief. Expectations and values learned and shared by
a corporate is members and transmitted from one generation of employees to another. The tern
corporate culture generally reflects the values of the founder and the mission of the format givens a
company a sense of identity. Corporate culture has two distinct attributes, intensity and integration
6. What is strategic change?[R]
A strategic change is a type of change where some general plans, policies and the initiatives of
the business are changed. These changes are quite common and also simple, something that is quite
ordinary. Strategic changes are market oriented and are the first and final steps for market conquests.
Strategic Change means changing the organizational Vision, Mission, Objectives and of course the
adopted strategy to achieve those objectives. Strategic change is defined as “changes in the content
of a firm's strategy as defined by its scope, resource deployments, competitive advantages, and
synergy"(Hofer and Schendel 1978)
7. What is power and conflict?[R]
Power is an ability to influence others and politics is carrying out activities though not
prescribed by any Policy to gain advantages and influence distribution. Corporate politics is not good
or bad but it creates divisiveness which is not good.
Organizational conflict is a state of discord caused by the actual or perceived opposition
of needs, values and interests between people working together. Conflict takes many forms in
organizations.
TOPIC: STRATEGIC EVALUATION & CONTROL
8. What is strategic control?[R]
Strategic control can be defined as process of monitoring as to whether to various strategies
adopted by the organization are helping its internal environment to be matched with the external
environment. Strategic control processes allow managers to evaluate a company's program from a
critical long-term perspective.
9. What are the primary measures of corporate performance?[U]
Most investors tend to focus on return on equity as their primary measure of company
performance. Many executives focus heavily on this metric as well, recognizing that it is the one that
seems to get the most attention from the investor community. If investors are not careful, it can divert
attention from business fundamentals and lead to nasty surprises. Companies can resort to financial
strategies to artificially maintain a healthy ROE (Return on Equity) for a while and hide deteriorating
performance in business fundamentals. Excessive debt leverage becomes a significant albatross for a
company when market demand for its products heads south, as many companies discovered during
the current economic downturn. It actually creates more risk for a company in hard times.
10. What is organizational life cycle?[AZ]
Organizational life cycle is the life cycle of an organization from birth level to the termination. There
are five level/stages in any organization. Birth, Growth, Maturity, Decline, Death
11. State the relationship between strategy formulation vs strategy implementation[AZ]
Following are the main differences between Strategy Formulation and Strategy
Implementation-
Strategy Formulation Strategy Implementation
Strategy Formulation includes planning and Strategy Implementation involves all those means
decision-making involved in developing related to executing the strategic plans.
organization’s strategic goals and plans.
VERTICAL DIVISION OF LABOUR is concerned with apportioning authority and for planning and
decision making
HORIZONTAL DIVISION OF LABOUR groups the basic tasks to be performed into jobs and then into
departments so organizational goals can be achieved.
An organization can be structured in many different ways, depending on their objectives. The
structure of an organization will determine the modes in which it operates and performs.
Organizational structure allows the expressed allocation of responsibilities for different
functions and processes to different entities such as the branch, department, workgroup and
individual.
FUNCTIONAL STRUCTURE
Employees within the functional divisions of an organization tend to perform a specialized set
of tasks, for instance the engineering department would be staffed only with software engineers. This
leads to operational efficiencies within that group.
As a whole, a functional organization is best suited as a producer of standardized goods and
services at large volume and low cost. Coordination and specialization of tasks are centralized in a
functional structure, which makes producing a limited amount of products or services efficient and
predictable.
FEATURES:
➔It typically works well for smaller and less complex organizations dealing with only one or a few
products or services.
➔Also work best in relatively stable environments that allow organizations to pursue consistent
strategies.
ADVANTAGES:
The major potential advantages include:
➔Economies of scale with efficient use of resources
➔Task assignments consistent with technical training
➔High quality technical problem solving
➔In-depth training and skill development within functions
➔Clear cut career paths within functions
DISADVANTAGES
➔Poor communication and coordination across functions, having too many decisions referred upward
in the hierarchy,
➔One of the most serious disadvantages occurs when members of functional departments become
overspecialized, develop self-centered, narrow viewpoints, and lose the total system perspective.
➔However it could also lead to a lack of communication between the functional groups within an
organization, making the organization slow and inflexible.
DIVISIONAL STRUCTURE
Also called a "product structure", the divisional structure groups each organizational function
into a division. Each division within a divisional structure contains all the necessary resources and
functions within it. Divisions can be categorized from different points of view. One might make
distinctions on a geographical basis or on product/service basis (different products for different
customers: households or companies).
Each division may have its own sales, engineering and marketing departments.
FEATURES:
Divisional structures are popular among organizations with diverse operations cutting across
many products, areas, and customers.
ADVANTAGES:
➔Greater flexibility in responding to environmental changes
➔Improved coordination across functional departments
➔ Clear points of responsibility for product or service delivery
➔ Expertise focused on specific customers, products and regions
➔Easier growth or reduction in size by adding or deleting divisions
DISADVANTAGES
➔ May reduce economies of scale, disperse technical competence and expertise,
➔ Even create unhealthy rivalry among operating units.
➔ May also increase costs by duplicating resources and efforts across divisions and causing an
overemphasis on divisional versus organizational goals.
MATRIX STRUCTURE
The matrix structure groups employees by both function and product. This structure can
combine the best of both separate structures. A matrix organization frequently uses teams of
employees to accomplish work, in order to take advantage of the strengths, as well as make up for
the weaknesses, of functional and decentralized forms.
➔Weak/Functional Matrix: A project manager with only limited authority is assigned to oversee the
cross- functional aspects of the project. The functional managers maintain control over their
resources and project areas.
➔Balanced/Functional Matrix: A project manager is assigned to oversee the project. Power is shared
equally between the project manager and the functional managers. It brings the best aspects of
functional and projectized organizations. However, this is the most difficult system to maintain as the
sharing power is delicate proposition.
➔Strong/Project Matrix: A project manager is primarily responsible for the project. Functional
managers provide technical expertise and assign resources as needed.
FEATURES:
Matrix structures are often found in organizations pursuing growth in dynamic and complex
environments
ADVANTAGES:
➔More inter functional cooperation: The matrix provides a way of coordinating different
functional contributions to serve specific program needs
➔Flexibility: The matrix makes it easier to add, remove and change the focus of teams to reflect
new program directions or basic changes in business size.
➔ Customer service: The customer or client of a matrix structure always has a program manager
available to respond to questions, provide status reports and address problems.
➔ Improved decision making: The matrix forces decision making and problem solving down to the
team level, where the best information exists.
➔Improved strategic management: The matrix helps keep top managers free of routine decisions
and enables them to apply their time to more strategic management concerns.
DISADVANTAGES
➔ Power struggles, which may result from the two boss system
➔ Team members may become too focused on themselves and develop “groupies’” losing sight of
important goals.
➔Often creates increased costs as overhead rises in the form of extra salaries for program managers
Product based Structures:
In large volume scenario it makes a sense to have a separate organisation dedicated to a
product. This enables optimum use of specialised skills. Product separation helps organisation in
addition /deletion decisions.
Customer based Structures:
Assuming that sales volume justifies the need of separate setup; it enables organisation to
concentrate on specific customer group and provide exclusive attention required for that particular
product / services. It helps in creating specialised skills and timely response to changing needs of the
customers.
GEOGRAPHIC STRUCTURES:
Set ups at different sites sometimes evolve due to expansions and mergers. It also offers
advantage of nearness to raw materials or to markets / customers. It helps in fair degree of de-
centralisation. It needs a very good top level co-ordination and communication amongst all locations
and corporate office.
Geographic regions may become the basis for grouping organizational activities when
companies expand nationally through internal expansion, horizontal integration, or mergers.
Expanding nationally – geographic structure
➔More responsive to needs of regional customers
➔Can achieve a lower cost structure and economies of scale
➔Provides more coordination and control than a functional structure through the
regional hierarchies
TOPIC: STRATEGIC CHANGE-POLITICS-POWER AND CONFLICT
5. Write a short note on corporate politics and power [U][08]
Power is an ability to influence others and politics is carrying out activities though not prescribed
by any Policy to gain advantages and influence distribution. Corporate politics is not good or bad
but it creates divisiveness which is not good.
Sources of Power:
‘Reward Power’ ability of Manager to reward people of his choice. ‘
Coercive Power’ Ability to penalise negative results.
‘Legitimate Power’ Ability of Mangers to influence behaviour of sub ordinates
Referent Power is Managers to create liking among subordinates due to charisma or knowledge.
Expert Power is due to competence, knowledge and experience of Managers.
TOPIC: STRATEGIC EVALUATION & CONTROL
6. Explain the process of Strategic Evaluation and Control [U][08]
7. State the different strategic evaluation technique in detail [[AZ][08]
Gap Analysis
The gap analysis is one strategic evaluation technique used to measure the gap between the
organization's current position and its desired position. The gap analysis is used to evaluate a variety
of aspects of business, from profit and production to marketing, research and development and
management information systems. Typically, a variety of financial data is analyzed and compared to
other businesses within the same industry to evaluate the gap between the organization and its
strongest competitors.
SWOT Analysis
The SWOT analysis is another common strategic evaluation technique used as a part of the strategic
management process. The SWOT analysis evaluates the organization's strengths, weaknesses,
opportunities and threats. Strengths and weaknesses are internal factors, while opportunities and
threats are external factors. This identification is essential in determining how best to focus resources
to take advantage of strengths and opportunities and combat weaknesses and threats.
PESTEL Analysis
Another common strategic evaluation technique is the PEST analysis, which identifies the
political, economic, social ,technological, Eco Environmental, and Legal factors that may impact the
organization's ability to achieve its objectives. Political factors might include such aspects as
impending legislation regarding wages and benefits, financial regulations, or even the risk of a military
invasion in another country. Economic factors include all shifts in the economy, while social factors
may include demographics and changing attitudes. Technological pressures are also inevitable as
technology becomes more advanced each day. These are all external factors, which are outside of the
organization's control but which must be considered throughout the decision making process.
Benchmarking
Benchmarking is a strategic evaluation technique that's often used to evaluate how close the
organization has come to its final objectives, as well as how far it has left to go. Organizations may
benchmark themselves against other organizations within the same industry, or they may benchmark
themselves against their own prior situation. A variety of performance measures, as well as policies
and procedures, may be evaluated regularly to identify where adjustments are necessary to maintain
the sustainable competitive advantage.
8. State the relationship between strategic Implementation and Formation in detail[ EV][08]
Following are the main differences between Strategy Formulation and Strategy
Implementation-
Strategy Formulation Strategy Implementation
Strategy Formulation includes planning and Strategy Implementation involves all those means
decision-making involved in developing related to executing the strategic plans.
organization’s strategic goals and plans.
In short, Strategy Formulation is placing the In short, Strategy Implementation is managing
Forces before the action. forces during the action.
Strategy Formulation is an Entrepreneurial Strategic Implementation is mainly
Activity based on strategic decision-making. an Administrative Taskbased on strategic and
operational decisions.
Strategy Formulation emphasizes Strategy Implementation emphasizes
on effectiveness. on efficiency.
Strategy Formulation is a rational process. Strategy Implementation is basically
an operational process.
Strategy Formulation requires co-ordination Strategy Implementation requires co-ordination
among few individuals. among many individuals.
Strategy Formulation requires a great deal Strategy Implementation requires
of initiative and logical skills. specific motivational and leadership traits.
Strategic Formulation precedes Strategy STrategy Implementation follows Strategy
Implementation. Formulation.
9. Evaluate the characteristics of effective control systems [EV][08]
Effective control systems have certain characteristics. For a control system to be effective, it must be:
Accurate Information on performance must be accurate. Evaluating the accuracy of the information
they receive is one of the most important control tasks that managers face.
Timely Information must be collected, routed, and evaluated quickly if action is to be taken in time
to produce improvements.
Objective and Comprehensible The information in a control system should be understandable and
be seen as objective by the individuals who use it. A difficult-to understand control system will cause
unnecessary mistakes and confusion or frustration among employees.
Focused on Strategic Control Points The control system should be focused on those areas where
deviations from the standards are most likely to take place or where deviations would lead to the
greatest harm.
Economically Realistic The cost of implementing a control system should be less than, or at most
equal to, the benefits derived from the control system.
Organizational Realistic The control system has to be compatible with organizational realities and
all standards for performance must be realistic.
Coordinated with the Organization's Work Flow Control information needs to be coordinated
with the flow of work through the organization for two reasons: (1) each step in the work process may
affect the success or failure of the entire operation, (2) the control information must get to all the
people who need to receive it.
Flexible Controls must have flexibility built into them so that the organizations can react quickly to
overcome adverse changes or to take advantage of new opportunities.
Prescriptive and Operational Control systems ought to indicate, upon the detection of the deviation
from standards, what corrective action should be taken.
Accepted by Organization Members For a control system to be accepted by organization members,
the controls must be related to meaningful and accepted goals.
These characteristics can be applied to controls at all levels of the organization.
10.Create the Effective Control System for Strategy Implementation in an organization[C][08]
Steps in Designing an Effective Control System
Strategic control is concerned with tracking a strategy as it is being implemented, detecting
problems or changes in its underlying premises, and making necessary adjustments
Strategic control involves tracking a strategy as its being implemented. It's also concerned with
detecting problems or changes in the strategy and making necessary adjustments. As a manager, you
tend to ask yourself questions, such as whether the company is moving in the right direction, or
whether your assumptions about major trends and changes in the company's environment are
correct. Such questions necessitate the establishment of strategic controls
Premise Control
Every strategy is based on certain planning premises or predictions. Premise control is
designed to check methodically and constantly whether the premises on which a strategy is grounded
on are still valid. If you discover that an important premise is no longer valid, the strategy may have
to be changed. The sooner you recognize and reject an invalid premise, the better. This is because the
strategy can be adjusted to reflect the reality.
Special Alert Control
A special alert control is the rigorous and rapid reassessment of an organization's strategy
because of the occurrence of an immediate, unforeseen event. An example of such event is the
acquisition of your competitor by an outsider. Such an event will trigger an immediate and intense
reassessment of the firm's strategy. Form crisis teams to handle your company's initial response to
the unforeseen events.
Implementation Control
Implementing a strategy takes place as a series of steps, activities, investments and acts that
occur over a lengthy period. As a manager, you'll mobilize resources, carry out special projects and
employ or reassign staff. Implementation control is the type of strategic control that must be carried
out as events unfold. There are two types of implementation controls: strategic thrusts or projects,
and milestone reviews. Strategic thrusts provide you with information that helps you determine
whether the overall strategy is shaping up as planned. With milestone reviews, you monitor the
progress of the strategy at various intervals or milestones.
Strategic Surveillance
Strategic surveillance is designed to observe a wide range of events within and outside your
organization that are likely to affect the track of your organization's strategy. It's based on the idea
that you can uncover important yet unanticipated information by monitoring multiple information
sources. Such sources include trade magazines, journals such as The Wall Street Journal, trade
conferences, conversations and observations.
Control Systems
The measurement and correction of the performance of activities of all the people in structure
in order to make sure that enterprise objectives and plan devised to achieve the same is accomplished
Information Systems
The Organisational Arrangements that provides information to managers to perform their
tasks and relate their works to others. This is also known as MIS
Appraisal Systems
To evaluate the managerial performance Appraisals are used for salary fixation, awards,
incentives, management development, etc.
Motivation Systems
To enforce the desirable behaviour Motivation can be monetary such as Salary, Bonus,
Rewards and non monetary such as recognition, designation, perks
PART-B
TOPIC: STRATEGIC ISSUES FOR NON-PROFIT ORGANIZATIONS
1. What is Not-for-Profit organization and explain its types?
NONPROFIT ORGANIZATION
Nonprofit organization (abbreviated as NPO) is neither a legal nor technical definition but
generally refers to an organization that uses surplus revenues to achieve its goals, rather than
distributing them as profit or dividends. States in the United States defer to the IRS designation
conferred under United States Internal Revenue Code Section 501(c), when the IRS deems an
organization eligible. They may or may not have shareholders.
While Not-for-profit organizations are permitted to generate surplus revenues they must be
retained by the organization for its self-preservation, expansion, or plans. NPOs have controlling
members or boards. Many have paid staff including management, while others employ unpaid
volunteers and even executives who works without compensation (or that work for a token fee, such
as $10 per year). Where there is a token fee, in general, it is used to meet legal requirements for
establishing a contract between the executive and the organization.
Designation as a non-profit and intent to make money are not related in the United States.
This means nothing can be conferred by the declaration. It is unclear whether or not this holds outside
of the U.S. In the United States, such inference is the purpose of the Internal Revenue Code, Section
501(c). The extent to which an NPO can generate surplus revenues may be constrained or use of
surplus revenues may be restricted.
Not-for-Profit (NFP):
An organization that provides some service or good with no intention of earning a profit. NFP
includes Private nonprofit corporations (such as hospitals, institutes, private colleges, and organized
charities) as well as Public governmental units/agencies (such as welfare departments, prisons and
state universities)
Types of Not-for-Profit Organizations
2. What is impact of Strategic Management on Not-for-Profit organization?
Impact of Constraints on strategic management: Several characteristics peculiar to the not for
profit organisation constrain its behavior and affects it strategic management. The constraints are as
follows:
➔Service is often intangible/hard to measure
➔Client influence may be weak
➔Strong employee commitments to professions
➔Resource contributors intrude on internal management
➔Restraints on use of rewards and punishments
Impact on Strategy Formulation:
➔Goal conflicts with rational planning: because NFPs typically lacks a single clear cut
performance criterion, divergent goals and objectives are likely, especially with multiple sponsors.
➔An integrated planning process tends to shift from results to resources: because NFPs
tend to provide services that are hard to measure planning becomes more concerned with resource
inputs, which can be easily measured than with service which cannot.
➔Ambiguous objectives create opportunities for internal politics and goal
displacement: the combination of vague objectives and heavy concerns with resources allows
managers a considerable scope in their activities. Such attitude created opportunities for politics.
➔Professionalization simplifies detailed planning but adds rigidity: In NFPs professional
values and traditions can prevent the organizations from changing its conventional behviour patterns
to fit new service mission tuned to changing social needs. Goals of the professionals and their
representative bodies may not align with organizational goals
Impact on Implementation
➔Decentralization is complicated: the difficulty of setting objectives for an intangible service
complicates the decision making authority.
➔Increased requirement for an environmental buffer role: because of the heavy
dependence on outside sponsors a special need arises for people in buffer roles to relate to both inside
and outside organizations. The job of a “dean for external affairs” for example consists primarily of
working with the school alumnae and raising funds.
➔Job enlargement and executive development can be restrained by professionalism: in
organisations that employ large number of professionals, managers must design jobs that appeal to
prevailing professional norms.
Impact on Evaluation & Control
➔Rewards & penalties have little or no relation to performance: when results are vague
and the judgement of success is subjective, predictable and impersonal feedback cannot be
established.
➔Inputs rather than outputs are heavily controlled: because its inputs can be measured
much more easily than outputs, the not for profit organisation tends to focus more on the resources
going into performance than on the performance itself.
8. R&D:
The following best practices can be considered as benchmark for a company’s R&D
activities.