Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ISSN: 2319-7064
ResearchGate Impact Factor (2018): 0.28 | SJIF (2018): 7.426
Abstract: Tyre Industry is one of the mature and seasoned sectors in India. The industry has been a prominent ally in the
Government’s developmental agenda ever since independence and especially after economic liberalization. The tyre industry provides
the wheels on which an economy rides. India tyre market reached a consumption volume of 184 Million units in 2018. India represents
the fourth largest market for tyres in the world after China, Europe and the United States. In India, the market is currently being driven
by increasing radialization of tyres especially in buses and trucks. Moreover, the tyre industry consists of a vast consumer base; they are
used in all type of vehicles which include passenger cars, buses, military vehicles, motorcycles, trucks, etc. The demand of tyres is
primarily catalyzed from two end-user segments - OEMs and the replacement segment. The Replacement market currently dominates
the tire market accounting for most of the total sales. Demand by the OEM segment is driven by new automobile sales trend, whereas,
the replacement market is linked to the usage patterns and replacement cycles. The market for tyres is quite concentrated in India with
the top 10 manufacturers accounting for around 80 per cent of the total market. MRF, Apollo Tyres, CEAT Tyres and JK Tyres
currently represent the top players in this market. Globalization has led to the linking of the economies of all the nations and therefore
major Indian players in the tyre industry are pursuing global strategies to enhance their competitiveness in world markets. The main
purpose of this paper is to study and to do financial statement analysis on selected Indian Tyre Companies (like Apollo Tyres, CEAT
Tyres, JK Tyres, Modi Rubber and TVS Srichakra). This study was done based on secondary data collected from multiple sources of
evidence, in addition to books, journals, websites, and newspapers. “The best tyres in the world have Goodyear written all over them
(Goodyear Tyres advertising slogan)”
Keywords: Current Ratio, Inventory, Financial Statement, Profit, Mean and Standard Deviation
Interpretation: The above Table 1 describes that the Mean CEAT Tyres, Modi Rubber and TVS Srichakra; the
Combined Leverage % of JK Tyres is 285.44% which is combined leverage % varies between -525.88% to 148.62,
Maximum compared to Minimum of -525.88% for Modi thus it means that a smaller proportion of fixed operating and
Rubber between the Year 2014 and Year 2019.JK Tyre & financial costs results in a lower value Combined Leverage
Industries Ltd has a relatively higher level of combined ratio, which means lower incremental EPS on incremental
leverage, which is seen as riskier, as the high leverage means sales and lower sensitivity to the slippage in sales.
more fixed costs to the firm. Whereas for Apollo Tyres,
Interpretation: The above Table 2 describes that the Mean investors. A high debt-to-equity ratio also indicates that a
Debt Equity Ratio of JK Tyres is 1.94 which is Maximum company may not be able to generate enough cash to satisfy
compared to Minimum of 0.02 for Modi Rubber between the its debt obligations. Whereas for Apollo Tyres, CEAT Tyres,
Year 2014 and Year 2019.JK Tyre & Industries Ltd has Modi Rubber and TVS Srichakra; the debt to equity ratio
higher debt to equity ratio between the Year 2014 and Year varies between 0.02 and 0.63, thus it means that investors
2019 and which is considered riskier to both creditors and and creditors have an equal stake in the business assets.
Interpretation: The above Table 3 describes that the Mean Also, it doesn’t ensure the safety of the investments made by
Current Ratio of TVS Srichakra is 1.27 which is maximum the creditors. Whereas for Apollo Tyres, CEAT Tyres, JK
compared to minimum of 0.18 for Modi Rubber between the Tyres and TVS Srichakra; the Current Ratio varies between
Year 2014 and Year 2019. Modi Rubber Limited (MRL) has 0.90 and 1.27, thus it also indicates that the company may
lower Current Ratio (0.18) between the Year 2014 and Year have problems meeting its short-term obligations and doesn’t
2019; this indicates that the company may have problems ensure the safety of the investments made by the creditors.
meeting its short-term obligations (Current Liabilities). Since The current ratio measures the company's ability to pay
the current ratio is less than 1.0 indicates the poor quality and short- term and long-term obligations.
the debt repayment capacity of the firm is not satisfactory.
Interpretation: The above Table 4 describes that the Mean and TVS Srichakra; the proprietary ratio varies between 0.35
proprietary ratio of Modi Rubber is 0.99 which is maximum and 0.78, A low ratio indicates that the company is already
compared to minimum of 0.35 for JK Tyres between the heavily depending on debts for its operations. A large portion
Year 2014 and Year 2019. Modi Rubber Limited (MRL) has of debts in the total capital may reduce creditor’s interest,
higher proprietary ratio (0.99) between the Year 2014 and increase interest expenses and the risk of bankruptcy. Having
Year 2019, it means stockholders has contributed 99% of the a very high proprietary ratio does not always mean that the
total tangible assets and the remaining 1% have been company has an ideal capital structure. A company with a
contributed by creditors. The proprietary ratio shows the very high proprietary ratio may not be taking full advantage
contribution of stockholders’ in total capital of the company. of debt financing for its operations that is also not a good
A high proprietary ratio, therefore, indicates a strong sign for the stockholders.
financial position of the company and greater security for
creditors. Whereas for Apollo Tyres, CEAT Tyres, JK Tyres
Interpretation: The above Table 5 describes that the Mean make the principle payments. Most creditors look for
Interest Coverage ratio of Modi Rubber is 81.86 which is coverage to be at least 1.5 before they will make any loans.
maximum compared to minimum of 2.31for JK Tyres In other words, banks want to be sure a company make at
between the Year 2014 and Year 2019. Modi Rubber least 1.5 times the amount of their current interest payments.
Limited (MRL) has higher Interest Coverage ratio (81.86) The interest coverage ratio of a company states how easily a
between the Year 2014 and Year 2019. Whereas for Apollo company can pay its interest expense on outstanding debt. A
Tyres, CEAT Tyres, JK Tyres and TVS Srichakra; the higher ratio is preferable. The interest coverage ratio
Interest Coverage ratio varies between 2.31 and 9.00. Since deteriorated during FY18, from during FY17 for Apollo
Interest Coverage Measurement is above 1, it means that the Tyres, CEAT Tyres, JK Tyres and TVS Srichakra except
company is making more than enough money to pay its Modi Rubber.
interest obligations with some extra earnings left over to
Interpretation: The above Table 6 describes that the Mean measure the overall profitability of the business. A high ratio
Net profit ratio of Modi Rubber is 0.54 which is maximum indicates the efficient management of the affairs of business.
compared to minimum of 0.040 for JK Tyres between the There is no norm to interpret this ratio. To see whether the
Year 2014 and Year 2019. Modi Rubber Limited (MRL) has business is constantly improving its profitability or not, the
higher Net profit ratio (0.54) between the Year 2014 and analyst should compare the ratio with the previous years’
Year 2019. Whereas for Apollo Tyres, CEAT Tyres, JK ratio, the industry’s average and the budgeted net profit ratio.
Tyres and TVS Srichakra; the Net profit ratio varies between The use of net profit ratio in conjunction with the assets
0.040 and 0.070. Net profit ratio (NP ratio) is a popular turnover ratio helps in ascertaining how profitably the assets
profitability ratio that shows relationship between net profit have been used during the period.
after tax and net sales. Net profit (NP) ratio is a useful tool to
Interpretation: The above Table 7 describes that the Mean pay short term debts immediately. Inventories and prepaid
Quick ratio of JK Tyres is 0.65 which is maximum compared expenses are excluded from current assets for the purpose of
to minimum of 0.16 for Modi Rubber between the Year 2014 computing quick ratio because inventories may take long
and Year 2019. JK Tyre & Industries Ltd has higher Quick period of time to be converted into cash and prepaid
ratio (0.65) between the Year 2014 and Year 2019. Whereas expenses cannot be used to pay current liabilities. Generally,
for Apollo Tyres, CEAT Tyres, Modi Rubber and TVS a quick ratio of 1:1 is considered satisfactory. Like current
Srichakra; the Net profit ratio varies between 0.16 and 0.58. ratio, this ratio should also be interpreted carefully. Having a
Quick ratio (also known as “acid test ratio” and “liquid quick ratio of 1:1 or higher does not mean that the company
ratio”) is used to test the ability of a business to pay its short- has a strong liquidity position because a company may have
term debts. It measures the relationship between liquid assets high quick ratio but slow paying debtors. On the other hand,
and current liabilities. Liquid assets are equal to total current a company with low quick ratio may have fast moving
assets minus inventories and prepaid expenses. Quick ratio is inventories. The analyst, therefore, must have a hard look on
considered a more reliable test of short-term solvency than the nature of individual assets.
current ratio because it shows the ability of the business to
Overall, the total assets and liabilities for FY19 stood at Rs 73.71 billion as against Rs 71.48 billion during FY18,
thereby witnessing a growth of 3.12%. In India, the market is currently being driven by
The trailing twelve-month earnings per share (EPS) of the increasing radialization of tyres especially in buses and
company stands at Rs 8.3 (2019), an incline from the EPS trucks.
of Rs 1.9 recorded last year (2018). MRF, Apollo Tyres, CEAT Tyres and JK Tyres currently
Current Ratio: The Company’s current ratio improved represent the top players in this market.
and stood at 1.21 during FY19, from 0.95 during FY18. Indian tyre industry has almost doubled from ~Rs 30,000
Interest Coverage Ratio: The Company’s interest crores in 2010-11 to ~Rs 59,500 crores in 2017-18 of
coverage ratio improved and stood at 1.96x during FY19, which 90-95% came from the domestic markets.
from 1.23x during FY18. Demonetization, the GST rollout and a steep rise in raw
material costs had some impact on the tyre industry.
MODI RUBBER Financial Analysis:
Since Automakers are reporting pressure on sales due to
Net profit for the year inclined by 262.32% YoY (2018 &
Demonetization, thus reflecting impact on tyre industry.
2019).
The tyre makers in India are gearing up to intensify their
The company's current liabilities during FY19 stood at Rs
role in the modernization phase, largely driven by
33.35 crore as compared to Rs 40.07 crore in FY18, demand and supply conditions as also directly
thereby witnessing a decrease of 16.77%.
proportional to automobile sales to some extent.
Current assets fall37.32% and stood at Rs 8.75 crore.
The present study on “Financial Statement Analysis of
Overall, the total assets and liabilities for FY19 stood at Selected Indian Tyres Companies” using the ratios and
Rs 200.86 crore as against Rs 200.49 crore during FY18, leverage helps to have a better insight about the financial
thereby witnessing a growth of 0.1845%. background and financial performance of the company.
The trailing twelve-month earnings per share (EPS) of the From the analysis it was found that the overall financial
company stand at Rs. 1.84 (2019), an incline from the performance of the company was moderate, this was due
EPS of (-) Rs 1.13 recorded last year (2018). to steep rise in raw material costs and largely driven by
Current Ratio: The Company’s current ratio demand and supply conditions as also directly
deteriorated and stood at 0.26 during FY19, from 0.35 proportional to automobile sales to some extent.
during FY18. Net profit was in a declining tread for all the selected tyre
Interest Coverage Ratio: The Company’s interest companies.
coverage ratio deteriorated and stood at 10.91x during Total assets and Liabilities for CEAT Tyres & TVS
FY19, from 39.1x during FY18. SRICHAKRA was Satisfactory and Good, whereas for
J.K Tyres and Apollo Tyres; Growth was minimal
TVS SRICHAKRA Financial Analysis: between 3 and 3.5%. Modi Rubber Ltd faced a minimal
Net profit for the year declined by 12.28% YoY (2018 & growth of 0.1845% as far as Total assets and Liabilities is
2019). concern.
The company's current liabilities during FY19stood at Rs Modi Rubber Limited (MRL) has very low Current Ratio
634.06 crore as compared to Rs 474.52 crore in FY18, between 2014 and 2019, this indicates that the company
thereby witnessing an increase of 33.62%. may have problems meeting its short-term obligations
Current assets rise 40.31% and stood at Rs 828.84 crore. (Current Liabilities).Whereas for Apollo Tyres, CEAT
Overall, the total assets and liabilities for FY19 stood at Tyres, JK Tyres and TVS Srichakra; the Current Ratio
Rs 17.87 billion as against Rs 14.30 billion during FY18, varies between 0.90 and 1.27 which is moderate. Hence
thereby witnessing a growth of 24.97%. depict that none of the companies has been able to
The trailing twelve-month earnings per share (EPS) of the maintain ideal current asset ratio i.e. 2:1.
company stands at Rs 134.74 (2019), a decline from the
EPS of Rs 153.6 recorded last year (2018). References
Current Ratio: The Company’s current ratio improved
and stood at 1.31 during FY19, from 1.24 during FY18. [1] Annual Reports of Selected Indian Tyres Companies for
Interest Coverage Ratio: The Company’s interest Six consecutive years: Apollo Tyres, CEAT Tyres, JK
coverage ratio deteriorated and stood at 5.4x during Tyres, Modi Rubber and TVS Srichakra.
FY19, from 6.7x during FY18. [2] Apollo Tyres, JK Tyres, CEAT Tyres, TVS Srichakra &
Modi Rubber - Key Financial Ratios
10. Conclusion (https://www.dynamiclevels.com) [Accessed:
17/02/2020].
India tyre market reached a consumption volume of 184 [3] C.R Kothari (1990), Research Methodology, second
Million Units in 2018 and expects the market to reach a revised – edition, New Age international (P) Limited,
volume of 239 Million Units by 2024 growing at a Publishers, New Delhi
CAGR of nearly 5% during 2019 - 2024. India represents [4] Gupta S P (2007), Statistical Tools and Techniques, GK
the fourth largest market for tyres in the world after Publications
China, Europe and the United States. [5] India Tyre Market: Industry Trends, Share, Size,
The Indian Tyre Industry is an integral part of the Auto Growth, Opportunity and Forecast 2019-2024;
Sector. https://www.imarcgroup.com/india-tyre-market
[Accessed: 17/02/2020].
[6] Statistical Data Analysis using Excel 2016.
[7] Source: Dion Global Solutions Limited - Apollo Tyres,
CEAT Tyres, JK Tyres, Modi Rubber & TVS Srichakra
[8] Understanding The Indian Tyre Industry, Key Players
& The Road Ahead;an article available at
https://www.alphainvesco.com/blog/understanding-the-
indian-tyre-industry/ [Accessed: 22/07/2019].