Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Zirconia Ceramic
Stefan M. Wegnera/Matthias Kern^
Purpose: The airr of this in vitro study was to evaluate the iong-term bond strength of adhesive bonding
systems to yttrium-oxide-partiaily-stabiiized zirconia ceramic (YPSZ).
Materials and Methods: Piexiglas tubes fdled with resin composite ware bonded to industrially manufac-
tured zirconia ceramic disks (96% ZrO2 stabiiized by 4% VïOa). After air abrading the ceramic and ultra-
sonic cleansing, groups of 15 samples were bonded in an aiignment apparatus using 7 different bonding
methods. Subgroups of S bonded sampies were tested for tensiie strength foiiowing storage in distiiied
water at 37^C either for 3 days or 2 years. In addition, the 2-year samples were thermccycled 37,500
times. The statistical anaiyses were conducted with the Kruskai-Wallis test followed by muitipie pair-wise
comparison of the groups using the Wilcoxon rank sum test
Results: A moderate to relatively high initial bond strength was achieved by air abrasion alone, the addi-
tional use of a siiane, or acryiizing the YPSZ surface in combination with a conventional bis-GMA resin
oomposite. However, these methods failed spontaneously over storage time. The use of the bis-GMA resin
oomposite after tribochemicai siiica coating of YPSZ and the use of a poiyacid-modified resin composite
after air abrasion of VPSZ resuited in a high initiai bond strength which decreased significantly over stor-
age time, A durable resin bond strength to YPSZ was achieved only after air abrasion of YPSZ and using
one of two resin composites containing a speciai phosphate monomer.
Conclusion: A durable bond strength to YPSZ was achieved oniy by using resin composites containing a
special adhesive monomer.
J Adhesive Dent 2000:2:139-147. Submitted for publication:05.08.99: accepted for pubiication: 14.01.00.
aiso been tested,^^ After water storage of up to 150 samples were air abraded with 110-pm AI2O3 at 2,5
days with thermocyciing, some bonding methods bars pressure (13 s) at a distance of 10 mm and
faiied completeiy, while others showed only a de- then ultrasonically cleaned in isopropanol for 3
creased or even an unchanged bond strength. How- min.
ever, the siianization of YPSZ ceramic resulted in a Seven different bonding systems were used. The
resin bond which faiied during water storage of 150 materiais utilized and their characteristics are
days. This result questions the conclusion men- listed in Table 1, In group T, a dual-curing conven-
tioned above, which was based on only 1 week of t i o n a l bis-GMA l u t i n g composite (Adhesive
water storage. To the knowiedge of the authors, Bond/Twinlook) was applied directly to the air-
however, there are no longer-term data currently abraded ceramic surface. In group ST, the ceramic
available on the durability ofthe resin bond to YPSZ surface was silanized (Espe-Si!, 3-methacryloy-
ceramic exceeding 150 days of water storage. loxypropyi trimethoxysiiane in isopropanol) prior to
Therefore, the purpose of this study was to evaiu- the application o f t h e conventional bis-GMA com-
ate the long-term bond durabiiity to YPSZ ceramic posite. In group RT, the ceramic surface was tribo-
with a storage time of two years and to investigate chemically silica coated (Rocatec system) prior to
the bond failure modes by SEM characterization. the application of the silane (Espe-Sii] and the bis-
GMA composite, in group KT, an acrylonitrile iayer
was fused to the ceramic surface (Kevioc oven
MATERIALS AND METHODS method] prior to the application of the bis-GMA
composite. In group P, a chemicaliy cured resin
composite modified with phosphate monomer {10-
Industrially manufactured yttrium-oxide-partially-
methacryloyloxydecyi dihydrogenphosphate, MDP)
stabilized zirconia ceramic disks (94,9% ZrO2Stabi-
(Panavia EX) was appiied directly to the air-abraded
iized by 5 , 1 % Y2O3, BCE Special Ceramics,
ceramic surface. In group P21, another chemically
Karlsruhe, Germany) with a diameter of 7.0 mm and
cured resin composite modified with MDP (Panavia
a thickness of 3,4 mm were used for this study. Ail
2 1 EX) was applied directly to the air-abraded ce- inhomogeneity of variances between groups, and
ramic surface. In group D, a chemicaily cured poly- the data were found to be non-normaliy
acid-modified resin composite (Dyract Cem) was distributed.19
used directly on the air-abraded ceramic surface. The fractured interfaces on the YPSZ samples
Plexiglas tubes (inner diameter 3.3 mm) were were examined under a light microscope at 30X
fiiled with self-curing resin composite Clearfil F2. magnification to calcuiate the debonded area as-
After 8 min, these tubes were bonded with the cho- signed to adhesive and cohesive failure modes.
sen resin to the YPSZ samples using an alignment Representative sampies were examined using a
apparatus. The alignment apparatus consists of scanning electron microscope (Phiilips XL30,
parallel guides, the tube holder, a siiicone pad, and Einthoven, Netherlands) with an acceieration voit-
an added weight of 750 g. The apparatus ensured age of 15 keV and a working distance of 10 mm,
that the tube axis was perpendicular to the sample after sputtering using a goid-alloy conductive layer
surface. The bonding method has been described of approximateiy 30 nm.
in detaii previously.^^
Excess resin was removed from the bonding mar-
gin using cotton pellets, and an oxygen-blocking gel RESULTS
was applied (Airblock, DeTrey, with Twinlook and
Dyract Cem; Oxyguard, Kuraray, with Panavia and The tensile bond strength vaiues are summarized in
Panavia 21). After 7 min, ail sampies were light Fig 1 for all seven bonding groups and the two stor-
cured from two sides, 180 degrees apart, for 30 s age conditions. Statistically significant differences
with a dental curing light (Heliomat, Vivadent, between the bonding groups are shown in Tabie 2,
Schaan, Lichtenstein), then further cured in a while the statisticaiiy significant differences be-
xenon strobe light-curing unit (Dentacolor XS, Her- tween the storage times are shown in Table 3.
aeus-Kulzer, Wehrheim, Germany) for an additional The bond strength of the bis-GMA resin compos-
90 s. Samples employing the chemically cured resin ite to air-abraded or air-abraded and siianized YPSZ
were also subjected to the light-curing step, as this (groups T, ST) was initiaiiy relatively low with means
applies some heat to the samples. In this manner, of 14.2 MPa and 13.9 MPa, respectiveiy. During the
all samples were subjected to similar curing condi- 2-year storage time with 37,500 thermal cycles, ail
tions. samples of these two groups debonded sponta-
Each bonding group with a total of 16 samples neously.
was divided into two subgroups (each with eight Tribochemical silica coating of the air-abraded
samples] with the foiiowing storage times and ther- ceramic (group RT) increased the bond strength of
mal cycles (TC) between 5°C and 55°C: 3 days with bis-GMA resin composite significantly to 29.0 MPa,
nc TC, and 2 years with 37,500 TC. Sampies were However, the bond strength decreased significantly
stored in distilled water at 37"C, duringthe storage time to 15.8 MPa.
The tensile bond strength test was performed at Acrylizing the air-abraded ceramic (group KT) re-
a crosshead speed of 2 mm per min in a tensiie suited in an initially higher bond strength (mean
tester (Zwick, Ulm, Germany) using a speciai test 37,9 MPa) than did silica coating. However, during
configuration, which provides a moment-free axial the 2-year storage time with 37,500 thermal cycles,
force application. A coilet held the tube while an all samples of group KT debonded spontaneously.
alignment jig allowed self-centering of the sample. The use cf phosphate-modified bis-GMA resin
The jig was attached to the load cell and crosshead composite with air-abraded ceramic (groups P and
by upper and lower chains, allowing the whole sys- P21) resulted in the highest bond strength values to
tem to self-align. YPSZ after 3 days (means: 49,7 and 46.0 for P and
P21, resp.) and 2 years (means: 39,8 and 44,2 for
Statistical analyses of the test results were con-
P and P21, resp.). Aithough the bond strength of
ducted with the Kruskal-Wallis test followed by mul-
groups P and P21 decreased siightly over 2 years,
tiple pair-wise comparisons of the means using the
this decrease was not statistically significant. Fur-
Wilcoxon rank sum test for independent sampies.i^
ther, there was no statistically significant difference
Significance ievels were adjusted with the Bonfer-
between the bond strength of groups P and P21.
roni-Holm correction for multiple testing.^ Nonpara-
metric statisticai test procedures were used for Using the chemically cured poiyacid-modified
group comparisons, because Bartiett's test showed composite on air-abraded ceramic (group D), a rela-
ST - P21 »* •*
ST-D «*
RT-KT *
RT-P ••
RT - P21 *«
RT-D N.S, **
KT-P *
KT-P21 N.S. **
KT-D N.S. **
Global KRUSKAL.WALLIS rest followed by pairwise comparison using tlie WILCOXON test modified by BON-
FEfiONI-HOLM;
-p<0,05;N,S,:p>O05
- • psO.Ol
3 days vs 2 years
T
ST
RT
KT
P N,S,
P21 N,S,
D
GloCial KRUSKAL-WALLIS test followed by comoarison usmg tlie WILCOXOM test modified By BON-
FERONI-HOLM.
• D50.05;N.S.: p> 0.05,
" p s 0.01.
90%
80%
70% -
60% -
• adhesive
50%
Ö cohesive
40% -
30%
20% - —
10% -
.--Í
D/2
D/1
P/2
RT/2
P/1
KT/1
RT/1
KT/2
P21/1
ST/2
P21/2
T/1
ST/1
T/2
Fig 2 Mean percentages of areas assigned to the failure modes obsewed in the seven bonding groups after different storage
times.
tively high bond strength to YPSZ was noted after 3 hesive for the groups P and P21, However, after the
days, but it decreased statisticaily significantiy over 2-year storage period with thermocycling, the failure
2 years of storage with 37,500 thermai cycles to mode was mixed for samples of group RT, where a
merely 3.1 MPa, mean of 80% of the bonding area failed adhesively.
The distribution of two types of failure modes for Figures 3 to 6 show representative SEM pho-
all samples is shown in Fig 2. After 2 years of stor- tographs of the fracture interfaces after the tensile
age with thermocyciing, the failure mode was purely test following 3 days or 2 years storage time with
adhesive for all samples in the bonding groups T, 37,500 thermai cycles.
ST, KT, and D. The failure mode was exciusively co-
143
Vol 2, No 2, 2000
Wegner/Kern
Fig 3 SEM photograph of air-abraded YPSZ disk (onginai Fig 4a Sample of group RT after 3 days' water storage show-
magnification lOOOX, white bar = 20 Mm). ing a mixed faiiure mode (SEM photograph, original magnifi-
cation 75X, white bar = 200 um).
Fig 4b Sampie of group RT after 3 days' watei stotage show- Fig 4c Sample of group RT after 2 years/37,500 thermal cy-
ing a mainly adhosiveiy debonded area of the specimen with cies, sdhesiveiy debonded area of the specimen (SEM photo-
remains of the resin composite (SEM photograph, original graph, originai magnification lOOOX, white bar = 20 pm).
magnification lOOOX, white bar = 20 um).
Fig 5a Sair.iîic of group KT after 3 d¿ys '.víilür storage show- Fig 5b Sample of group KT after 2 yesrs/37,500 thermai cy-
ing a totally cohesive failure mode. Note that the ceramic sur- cles demonstrating a change in failure mode during storage
face is covered with a relatively smooth acryi coating from totaiiy cohesive (compare Fig 5a) to totaiiy adhesive
indicating a faiiure between the bonding interface (SEM pho- (SEM photograph, original magnification lOOOX, white bar =
tograph, original magnifioation lOOOX, white bar = 20 ) 20 Mm).
13, Kern M, Wegner SM, Bonding to zirconia oeramic; adhesion The Complete Denture:
methods and their durabiiity. Dent Mater 1998; 14:64-71,
14, Koutayas SO, Kern M, All-ceramic posts and cores; The state A Clinical Pathway
of the art. Quintessence Int 1999;30;3S3-392.
15, Luthardt R, Herold V, Sandkuhl 0, Reitz B, Knaak JP, Lenz E,
Michael I, MacEntee. PhD. LDS(I). Dip Prosih FRCD(C)
Kronen aus Hochleistungskeramik, Zirkonoxid-Keramik, ein The University of British Columbia
neuer Werkstoff in der Kronenprothetik, Dtsoh Zahnarzti Z
1998:53;280-2S5,
16, Luthardt R, Musil R. CAD/CAM-gefertigte Kronengerûste aus
Zirkonoxid-Keramik, Dtsch Zahnarzti Z 1997;53:380-384. In a society
17, Mars R. Das Kleben von Metaii für Adhäsivbrücken, Zahn- aging rapidly,
arzti Miü 19S7;77:117-123, there remains ' COMPLETE DENTURE
18, Rieger W, Medioal appiications of ceramics. In; Kostorz G a substantial A CMnicat Paihway
(ed|, High-Tech Ceramics, London: Academic Press, 1989:191- and pressing
228, need for com-
19, Siegei J, Statistix, Version 4,0. User's Manual, St, Paul: Ana- plete dentures.
lytical Software, 1992.
This step-by-
20, Söderholm K-JM, Roberts MJ, Influence of water exposure on
the tensile strengte of composites, J Dent Res 1990:69;
step mantial
1812-1816, provides the
21, Sóderholm K-JM, Shang S-W, Molecular orientation of silane knowledge and 3 Miiligel I. UicEnlee, PliD, m i Dip lm«i
at the surface of oolloidal silica. J Dent Res 1993;72:1050- skill needed for
1054, clinicians to
22, Takagi H, Nishioka K, Kawanami T, Okuda H, The properties effectively treat
of a closeiy sintered zirconia, Ceram Forum Int 1985;62:195- denture-wearing patients.
198, Treatment involving complete dentures is not
23, Vogel K, Salz U, Factors influencing adhesion to AI2O3- and simply a mechanical skill: it demands an accu-
ZrO2-Ceramics [abstract 2475]. J Dent Res 1998;77:941,
rate diagnosis of systemic and local problems
24, Wada T, Deveiopment of a new adhesive material and its
properties. In; Gettleman L, Vrijhoef MMA, Uchiyama Y (eds).
before attention is paid to prosthesis design, and
Proceedings of the International Symposium on Adhesive it requires a mixture of scientific and artistic
Prosthodontics, 24 June 1986, Amsterdam, Netherlands, skills. In this book the author offers one pathway
Chicago; Academy of Dental M ate rials, 1986 ;9-18, based on scientific principles to master the art of
25, Wohlwend A, Studer S , Schärer P, Das Zirkondioxidabutment constructing a complete denture.
- ein neues Konzept zur ästhetischen Verbesserung der
SupraStruktur in der Implantoiogie. Quintessenz Zahntech
1996;22:364-381.
1, Identifying the Problem
26, Vanagida H, Kawamoto K, Miyayama M, Chemistry of Ceram-
2, Impressions for Study Casts
ics, Chichester; Wiley, 1996:225-228,247-249,
3, Master Casts
4, Selecting Maxillary Anterior Teeth
5, Recording the Maxiilomandibular Relationship
and Arranging the Maxillary Anterior Teeth
6, Arranging the Mandibular Anterior Teeth and All
of the Posterior Teeth
7, Clinical Evaluation of cheTeeth in Wax
8, Processing Acr/lic Resin
9, Adjustment and Insertion of the Dentures
10, Relining a Complete Denture
11, Immediate Dentures
12, Implant Overdenture
Appendix I, The Complete Denture;
A Step-by-Step Summary
Appendix II, Living with Your Complete Dentures