Professional Documents
Culture Documents
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: Recycling waste building materials from construction and demolition (C&D) sites is increasingly investi-
Received 7 June 2008 gated for economical and environmental reasons. Roller compacted concrete (RCC) is a special dry con-
Received in revised form 29 April 2009 crete mix; laid down and compacted like a soil, it is especially used for the construction of massive
Accepted 18 June 2009
structures like dams or large horizontal surfaces like road foundation. In this paper, natural concrete slabs
Available online 17 July 2009
were cured in water, sea water, chloride solutions or sulphate solutions and then crushed to obtain virgin
and contaminated (polluted) recycled aggregates. The aim of this research is the total replacement (100%
Keywords:
coarse and fine) of natural aggregates (NA) by recycled concrete aggregates (RA) in the composition of a
Recycling
Recycled aggregates concrete
roller compacted concrete. The natural and recycled aggregates are characterised and compared. The
Roller compacted concrete mechanical properties and durability performances of concrete with contaminated RA are analysed.
Contamination The experimental results showed that the polluted RA are much richer in chlorides than in sulphates
Durability and are leached if they are soaked in water. Significant differences were observed between the properties
of original and new concrete and the results demonstrated the need of taking these contaminations into
account.
Ó 2009 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
0950-0618/$ - see front matter Ó 2009 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.conbuildmat.2009.06.031
F. Debieb et al. / Construction and Building Materials 23 (2009) 3382–3387 3383
Table 1 Table 2
Identification of tests realised on aggregates and concrete. Mix proportion.
Concrete Time t0 40 t0 20 t0 10 t0 + 1 0 t0 + 20
Compressive strength and elastic Cylinder (£160, h 320) NBN B 15-203
Additions Aggregates – Cement Water –
modulus NBN B 15-203
Work Mixing Rest Mixing Mixing End
Splitting tensile strength Cylinder (£160, h 320) NBN B 15-218
Ageing (swelling) in water and in Prism (70 70 280) NBN B 15-216
sulphates solution (Na2SO4 –
5%)
Capillary absorption Core (£80, h 100) NBN B 15-217 reference concrete (NAC): natural concrete containing 100% of coarse and fine
Freeze–thaw resistance Prism (100 100 100) NBN B 05-203 NA;
reference RCC (NRCC): roller compacted concrete, containing 100% of coarse and
fine NA;
RRCC-V: roller compacted concrete, containing 100% of coarse and fine virgin
(not polluted) RA, resulting from the crushing of not polluted natural concrete;
The principal advantage of the use of RCC in dam construction is
RRCC-P: roller compacted concrete, containing 100% of coarse and fine polluted
the reduction of the quantity of cement (up to 100 kg/m3) [4,8] RA, resulting from the crushing of polluted natural concrete and is composed of
and, generally, the use of mineral additions such as fly-ashes three families:
[14]. When RCC is used in roads, it usually requires a greater quan- – RRCC–Cl: for concrete polluted by chlorides (NAC–Cl);
– RRCC–Su: for concrete polluted by sulphates (NAC–Su);
tity of cement [11] and a lower W/C ratio than for dams [11,15].
– RRCC–Sw: for concrete polluted in sea water (NAC–Sw).
3. Research program
virgins or not polluted (V): produced from crushing of the non ageing natural
concrete slabs; 4. Experimental results and discussions
polluted (Cl, Su or Sw): produced from crushing of natural concrete slabs aged in
the three different aggressive solutions.
4.1. Aggregates
The mixing water used for the different mixes is the distribution drinking water,
free of impurities with a pH equal to 7.9. The different tests realised on aggregates
4.1.1. Physical and mechanical characteristics
and concrete are summarized in Table 1. The grain size distribution of NA and RA used is presented on
Fig. 2 and their physical and mechanical properties are summa-
3.2. Concrete identification rized in Table 4.
The sieve analysis (Fig. 2) show that the grain size distribution
Four concrete mixtures were made. Literary codes identify each mixture in a
of NA and RA used is comparable. However, RA are coarser than NA
precise way:
and fine content (<63 lm) is higher for NA than RA. RA present rel-
atively lower bulk density and higher water absorption compared
1
Composition of one liter of artificial sea water: 1000 g of distilled water, 30 g of
to NA: the higher water absorption of RA is clearly due to the mor-
Na Cl, 6 g of Mg Cl2 6H2O, 5 g of Mg SO4 7H2O, 1.5 g of Ca SO4 2H2O and 0.2 g of KH tar gangue. The RA used are less ‘‘hard” than the NA with an aver-
CO3. age Los-Angeles (LA) of 35% remaining lower than the allowable
3384 F. Debieb et al. / Construction and Building Materials 23 (2009) 3382–3387
NS RS NG 2-7 NG 7-14 pactness of the RCC. That is undoubtedly due to the crushing mode.
Similar results were observed by Hadjieva-Zaharieva [20].
NG 14-20 RG 4-14 RG 14-20
100
4.1.2. Contamination process
90
After one year of immersion into aggressive solutions
Cumulative passing (%)
80
(chlorides, sulphates or sea water), the rate of contamination by
70
chlorides (% Cl) and sulphates (% Su) of the concrete slabs is sum-
60
marized in Table 5. The results obtained confirm that the concrete
50
is highly polluted. European standard EN 206:2001 [21] limits the
40 maximal content of chloride in concrete to 1%, in reinforced con-
30 crete to 0.4% and in prestressed concrete to 0.2%.
20 Table 6 summarises the chlorides and sulphates contents in NA,
10 virgin and contaminated RA. These values are the average of mea-
0 surements taken on two samples (approximately 200 g by sample)
0 0 1 10 100 of aggregates for each type and each fraction, after 365 days of age-
Sieve size (mm) ing for RA.
One notes significant chlorides content in the contaminated RA,
Fig. 2. Grading of natural and recycled aggregates (S = sand, G = coarse aggregates).
while the sulphates content is near to that measured on the virgin
RA. The chloride and sulphate contents measured on fine aggre-
gates are higher than on coarse aggregates. This is due to the larger
Table 4 quantity of mortar in recycled sand.
Physical and mechanical properties of natural and recycled aggregates.
According to the standards, the maximum chloride content in
Properties NS RS NG RG the RA is limited to 0.06% [22,23]. The Swiss recommendation
0–2 0–4 2–7 7–14 14–20 4–14 14–20 (SIA 162/4), concerning the recycled concrete aggregates used for
structural concrete, imposes the limits of 0.12% (mass of the pri-
Specific weight (kg/m3) 2707 2309 2670 2691 2757 2329 2319
Bulk density (kg/m3) 1510 1364 1326 1312 1319 1164 1022 mary concrete) for reinforced concrete and of 0.03% for prestressed
Water absorption (%) 0.28 9.20 1.20 0.37 0.36 4.92 6.00 concrete [2]. The French standard (NF P 18-541) [24] limits the sul-
Sand equivalent 78.8 84 – – – – – phates content (expressed in SO3) in the aggregates for concrete to
Fineness modulus 2.72 3.33 – – – – – 0.15% by mass. In addition, the RILEM [25] recommendations and
Impurities (%) – – 0.27 0.60 0.24 0.52 0.93
Los-Angeles (%) – – 25 22 24 34 36
Cubicity (%) – – 71 31 55
Mortar gangue (%) – 14 – – – 13 Table 5
Average content in chlorides and sulphates in the contaminated concrete slabs.
Table 6
Chlorides and sulphates content in the aggregates.
the specifications of European Committee for Standardization [26] the RA is probably the main reason despite of the higher air
admit for the design of concrete with recycled aggregates a sul- content due to lack of concrete compaction.
phate content of 1% (expressed by mass of SO3).
In practice, the RA resulting from structural crushed concrete, 4.3. Hardened concrete properties
roadways concrete and masonry and building wastes, present a
sulphate content of 0.3–0.8% by mass of SO3 of which the greatest 4.3.1. Strength and elastic modulus
part is combined in hydrated cement structure (ettringite) and The compressive strength (Rc), the splitting tensile strength (Rt)
does not produce a significant expansion of mortar and of concrete and the elastic modulus (E) are presented in Table 7.
[27]. If we compare NRCC with NAC (with the same type of cement
and natural aggregates), we can conclude that the compaction
4.1.3. Leaching test improves well (an average increase of 13%) the compressive
After 15 days of total immersion in water, the coarse RG-Cl, lost strength of the RCC. The RRCC concrete presents an average 30%
up to 96% of their chlorides (Fig. 3); the content becomes compara- decrease in compressive strength and a significant decrease (DRt/
ble with that of NA. These chlorides are consequently free chlorides Rt) in splitting tensile strength of approximately 56% compared
because they can go out from concrete after an adequate leaching. to reference concrete (NRCC).
This result is very significant in practice where the use of RA It appears that the RA are the origin of this loss of strength. On
remains so far limited because of the aggressive agents which they the other hand, the contamination of the recycled aggregates does
can contain and especially the great mistrust of the users. not have a significant effect on strength. This result is confirmed by
This leaching means that chloride may diffuse during hardening Ouellet [9] who concluded that flexural strength of the RCC is not
and setting periods and eventually modify hydratation process. sensitive to the variations of the water/cement ratio but rather to
Moreover, because it is necessary to saturate recycled aggregate the nature of the aggregates. The marked influence of the type of
with water before mixing, they could loose a large part (more than aggregate tends to confirm that the tensile strength is largely
50%) of chlorides during saturation process. That is the reason why, affected by the propagation of the cracks in the material.
for the manufacture of the recycled concretes, these aggregates The RRCC presents an approximate loss of 32% in modulus of
have been soaked in contaminated solution 24 h before mixing. elasticity (DE/E) compared to its reference concrete NRCC. This
That means also that, with a good washing or a total immersion reduction can be explained by the lower modulus of elasticity of
into water during at least 2 weeks, the RA can be used in concrete the cement gangue of which the RA are partially made up [22]. Like
design even in reinforced or prestressed concrete without any risk for compressive strength, the RA contamination has not a signifi-
of chloride corrosion. cant effect on the tensile strength or the modulus of elasticity.
4.0
Table 7
3.0
Strength and elastic modulus of concrete.
2.0
Rc (MPa) DRc/Rc Rt (MPa) DRt/Rt Rt/Rc E (GPa) DE/E (%)
1.0 (%) (%)
0.12 NAC 40 0 3.1 0 0.08 30.8 0
0.0
NRCC 46 0 5.7 0 0.12 32.5 0
0 10 20 30
RRCC–V 32 30 2.6 56 0.08 22.8 32
Time (days) RRCC–Cl 31 2.4 22.7
RRCC–Su 32 2.5 21.9
Fig. 3. Chlorides content in coarse RA soaked in water (d) days (leaching of coarse RRCC–Sw 33 2.5 21.4
RA rich in chlorides).
3386 F. Debieb et al. / Construction and Building Materials 23 (2009) 3382–3387
Swelling (µm/m)
0.08 0.08 75
350
in the limits of this type of concrete, and sometimes reaches up to
300 NAC
the double of that of reference concrete NRCC.
Swelling (µm/m)
This result was foreseeable because of the high absorption of 250 NRCC
recycled sand (9%). Secondly, it is interesting to mention that, with
200 RRCC-V
100% of RA, the sorptivity of the RRCC concretes is comparable
with natural concrete (NAC): that is undoubtedly due to the effect 150 RRCC-Cl
of compaction. Recycled concrete (RRCC), seems to have a higher
capacity for water absorption than for natural concrete. The con- 100 RRCC-Su
tamination of the recycled aggregates does not seem to have any 50 RRCC-Sw
significant effect on water absorption of the RRCC.
-
4.3.3. Freeze–thaw resistance 0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350
After 14 cycles of freeze–thaw, the visual specimen’s examina- Time (days)
tion did not detect any significant deterioration for all the con-
Fig. 7. Swelling of concrete in sulphates solution (Na2SO4 – 5%).
cretes, except a very light scaling on some faces of the RRCC
concrete specimens. The correlation between the loss of mass
and the capillarity is presented on Fig. 5. The RCC with only natural
Contrarily to the swelling in water, the storage (almost a year)
aggregates (NRCC) resists very well to the winter severe climate;
in the sulphates (Na2SO4 – 5%) causes a new swelling which is
its behaviour after freeze–thaw cycles is comparable with that of
higher, for all RRCC concretes (on average 100%), than the reference
the natural concrete (NAC).
concrete NRCC (Fig. 7). The energetic compaction of concrete does
The RRCC concrete family, with small capillaries, loses slightly
not prevent additional swelling due to sulphates. Exceptionally for
more in mass than its reference concrete NRCC. RRCC–Sw presents
RRCC-Sw, the swelling is higher and can exceed 200%; the substi-
a loss of mass approximately the double of other types of RRCC.
tution of the ions Na2+ by Mg2+, due to the Na2SO4 solution, induces
This due to small scaling on some faces of the concrete specimens
an additional swelling which is added to primary swelling due to
in question (mainly on the face on which the specimen is posed).
the sea water (secondary ettringite).
4.3.4. Swelling
Figs. 6 and 7 illustrate the swelling of concrete in water and in 5. Conclusions
sulphates solution (Na2SO4 – 5%).
After one year of conservation into water, we did not observe The following conclusions may be reached from the present
significant swelling (Fig. 6) for all tested concretes. It seems that investigations:
the RA, and even the polluted RA, do not induce more swelling of
RCC in water. It is clear that the energetic compaction of the con- Recycled aggregates are different from natural aggregates
crete may act on swelling prevention. because of cement gangue of old mortar which remains attached
to the natural aggregates after crushing the original concrete
and induces lower densities and greater capacity of water
0.8
absorption.
NAC Recycled aggregates resulting from crushing of polluted con-
0.7
crete are richer in chlorides than in sulphates.
Loss of mass (%)
0.6 NRCC
Recycled aggregates with chloride content are leached if they
0.5 RRCC-V are soaked into water. That is the reason why, after a good wash-
0.4 RRCC-Cl ing or total immersion into water during a minimum of 2 weeks,
0.3 these aggregates can be reused in concrete and even in rein-
RRCC-Su
0.2 forced or prestressed concrete without any risk of corrosion.
0.1 RRCC-Sw Vibration weighting test (VWT) is simple and allows to obtain
0.0 cylindrical samples suitable for testing.
0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 The RCC containing only crushed concrete is comparable in com-
2 pactness with the RCC containing only natural aggregates. How-
Water absorption (kg/m ) during 24 hours
ever, the compressive strength is better for the second type
Fig. 5. Correlation loss of mass due to the freeze–thaw cycles and capillarity. because of the better quality of the aggregates.
F. Debieb et al. / Construction and Building Materials 23 (2009) 3382–3387 3387
The mechanical and durability tests realized on RCC containing [9] Ouellet E. Formulation et étude du comportement mécanique des bétons
compactés au rouleau. Master thesis, University of Laval; 1998.
only crushed concrete, show that this type of concrete has an
[10] Projet national BaCaRa 1988–1995. Le béton compacté au rouleau: les
acceptable behaviour with time, which is favorable for road con- barrages en BCR. France: Presse de L’ENPC; 1996.
struction (for example sub-base). [11] Jofré C. Emploi du béton compacté dans les chausses. Paris: Association
internationale permanente des congres de la route; 1993.
[12] Delhez P, Willem X, Michel F, Courard L. Use of concrete recycled aggregates in
Consequently, the chloride or sulphate ion content does not roller compacted concrete. In: Vazquez E, Hendriks ChF, Jansen GMT.
seem to have any influence on the mechanical properties of roller Proceedings of an international RILEM conference on use of recycled
compacted concrete. As RCC does not usually requires reinforce- materials in buildings and structures. RILEM; 2004. p. 675–83.
[13] Burns CD, Saucier KL. Vibratory compaction study of zero-slump concrete. ACI
ment, the chemical degradation that could be induced by chlorides J 1978;75(12):90.
are not fundamental however, swelling in presence of sulphates, [14] Pouliot N, Sedran T, de Larrard F, Marchand J. Prédiction de la compacité des
probably caused by ettringite formation and Na to Mg substitution, bétons compactés au rouleau à l’aide d’un modèle d’empilement granulaire.
BLPC 2001;233(4370):23–36.
has to be taken into account in the evolution of durability. The [15] Pouliot N. Formulation, mécanismes d’hydratation et propriétés mécaniques
chemical characterization of recycled aggregates potentially con- des bétons de ciments fabriqués à partir de matériaux granulaires et de béton
taining hazardous ions is of prime importance in order to avoid bitumineux recycles. Ph.D. thesis, University of Laval; 2002.
[16] Cahier des charges – type RW 99. Clauses administratives et techniques
disturbance. applicables à l’exécution des routes et autoroutes situées en Région Wallonne.
Belgium; 1999.
[17] Faury J. Le béton: influence de ses constituants inertes: règles à adopter pour
References sa meilleure composition. Paris: Dunod; 1942.
[18] NF P 18-591. Granulats – Essai de Los-Angeles. Paris: AFNOR; 1990.
[19] Kenai S, Debieb F, Azzouz L. Mechanical properties and durability of concrete
[1] Munck-Kampmann B. European trends in waste generation and waste
made with coarse and fine recycled aggregates. In: Dir RK, Dyer TD, Halliday JE,
management. In: Dir RK, Newlands MD, Halliday E, editors. Proceedings of
editors. Proceedings of an international symposium on sustainable concrete
an international symposium on recycling and reuse of waste materials.
construction’. London: Thelford T; 2002. p. 383–92.
London: Thelford; 2003. p. 1–22.
[20] Hadjieva-Zaharieva R. Durabilité des bétons à base de granulats recycles. Ph.D.
[2] Hansen TC, Lauritzen EK. Concrete waste in a global perspective. In: Liu TC,
thesis, University of Artois; 1998.
Meyer Ch, Editors. Recycling concrete and other materials for sustainable
[21] EN 206-1. Béton – spécification, performances, production et conformité,
development. ACI International, Special Publication SP-219. USA: ACI; 2004. p.
Bruxelles; 2001.
35–46.
[22] Hansen TC. Recycling of demolished concrete and masonry. RILEM report 06,
[3] Debieb F, Kenai S. The use of fine and coarse crushed bricks as aggregates in
London: E&FN Spon; 1992.
concrete. Constr Build Mater 2008;22(5):886–93.
[23] Vyncke J, Rousseau E. Recycling of construction and demolition waste in
[4] Debieb F. Performances et durabilité du béton à base de granulats recyclés
Belgium: actual situation and future evolution. In: Lauritzen EK, editor. Third
contaminés par les chlorures et sulfates. Ph.D. thesis, Department of Civil
international RILEM symposium on demolition and reuse of concrete and
Engineering, University of Houari Boumediene of Algiers; 2007.
masonry. Denmark: E&FN Spon; 1993. p. 57–69.
[5] Tabsh SW, Abdelfatah AS. Influence of recycled concrete aggregates on
[24] NF P 18-541. Granulats pour bétons hydrauliques. Paris: AFNOR; 1994.
strength properties of concrete. Constr Build Mater 2009;23:1163–7.
[25] RILEM TC 121-DRG. Specifications for concrete with recycled aggregates.
[6] De Juan SK, Gutiérrez PA. Study on the influence of attached mortar content on
Mater Struct 1994; 27: 557–9.
the properties of recycled concrete aggregate. Constr Build Mater
[26] Hendricks ChF. European standard for recycled aggregates in construction. In:
2009;23:872–7.
Proceedings of the international recycling world congress R’99, vol. III.
[7] Casuccio M, Torrijos MC, Giaccio G, Zerbino R. Failure mechanism of recycled
Switzerland: EMPA Dudendorf; 1999. p. 108–13.
aggregate concrete. Constr Build Mater 2008;22:1500–6.
[27] Gallias JL. Sulphate content threshold for recycled aggregates used in concrete.
[8] Tremblay S. Méthodes de formulation de bétons compactés au rouleau et effet
In: Proceedings of the international recycling world congress R’99, vol. III.
des agents entraîneurs d’air sur la maniabilité. Master thesis, University of
Switzerland: EMPA Dudendorf; 1999. p. 161–6.
Laval; 1997.