Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ISBN 978-1-315-89681-6
,!7IB3B5-ijgibg!
www.crcpress.com
Polyur ethane
Foam Sorbents
in
Separation Science
Authors
A. B. Farag, Ph.D.
Associate Professor
Department of Chemistry
Faculty of Science
Mansoura University
Mansoura, Egypt
This book contains information obtained from authentic and highly regarded sources. Reasonable efforts have been made to publish
reliable data and information, but the author and publisher cannot assume responsibility for the validity of all materials or the
consequences of their use. The authors and publishers have attempted to trace the copyright holders of all material reproduced in this
publication and apologize to copyright holders if permission to publish in this form has not been obtained. If any copyright material has
not been acknowledged please write and let us know so we may rectify in any future reprint.
Except as permitted under U.S. Copyright Law, no part of this book may be reprinted, reproduced, transmitted, or utilized in any form
by any electronic, mechanical, or other means, now known or hereafter invented, including photocopying, microfilming, and recording,
or in any information storage or retrieval system, without written permission from the publishers.
For permission to photocopy or use material electronically from this work, please access www.copyright.com (http://www.copyright.
com/) or contact the Copyright Clearance Center, Inc. (CCC), 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, 978-750-8400. CCC is a
not-for-profit organization that provides licenses and registration for a variety of users. For organizations that have been granted a
photocopy license by the CCC, a separate system of payment has been arranged.
Trademark Notice: Product or corporate names may be trademarks or registered trademarks, and are used only for identification and
explanation without intent to infringe.
Braun, Tibor.
Polyurethane foam sorbents in separation science.
Bibliography: p.
Includes index.
1. Plastic foams. 2. Polyurethane. 3. Sorbents.
4. Separation (Technology) I. Navratil, James D.,
1941- . II. Farag, A. B., 1944- . III. Title.
TP1180.F6B73 1984 668.4’93 84-7701
ISBN 0-8493-6597-X
Publisher’s Note
The publisher has gone to great lengths to ensure the quality of this reprint but points out that some imperfections in the original copies
may be apparent.
Disclaimer
The publisher has made every effort to trace copyright holders and welcomes correspondence from those they have been unable to
contact.
Visit the Taylor & Francis Web site at http://www.taylorandfrancis.com and the
CRC Press Web site at http://www.crcpress.com
FOREWORD
The purpose of this book is to present in a monographic and systematized form a
review of all the literature devoted to polyurethane-based polymeric sorbents in sepa-
ration chemistry. The primary types of sorbents dealt with are polyurethane foams and
open-pore polyurethanes.
The structure of the monograph follows this dichotomy. A book of this nature
should stimulate thinking and incite its reader to consult the original literature. It will,
however, not make such a consultation superfluous.
A fair amount of the results described in this monograph constitute the main activity
of investigation which took place in the authors' laboratories during the past decade.
Notwithstanding, the authors realize the extent to which they are indebted to their
many colleagues worldwide who have also contributed largely to this topic, whose
studies are referenced in this work.
The editorial assistance of Sylvia Navratilova is greatly appreciated.
Tibor Braun
James D. Navratil
A. B. Farag
THE AUTHORS
Tibor Braun, Ph.D., D.Sc., earned his degree in Chemistry from the V. Babes Uni-
versity, Cluj, Romania. In 1956 he proceeded to the Institute of Atomic Physics, Bu-
charest, Romania, where he worked as a Research Scientist. From 1963 to the present
time Dr. Braun performs his academic activities at the Institute of Inorganic and An-
alytical Chemistry, L. Eotvos University, Budapest, Hungary where he holds the rank
of Professor of Chemistry.
From 1969 to 1971 he worked at the Institute of Nuclear Research, Lima, Peru and
from 1975 to 1976 in the Department of Chemistry at the University of the West Indies,
Kingston, Jamaica. At both places Dr. Braun served as an expert of the International
Atomic Energy Agency, Vienna, Austria. In Kingston, Jamaica Dr. Braun was ap-
pointed Visiting Professor. He is also Deputy Director of the Library of the Hungarian
Academy of Sciences.
Dr. Braun developed an interest in sorbents chemistry, radioanalytical chemistry,
and radiochemistry. He has written many articles on the subject in analytical chemistry
journals. His fields of interest include general analytical and radioanalytical chemistry,
nuclear chemistry, and scientometrics.
He is the founder and Editor-in-Chief of both the Journal of Radioanalytical and
Nuclear Chemistry Articles, and Journal of Radioanalytical and Nuclear Chemistry.
He is also founder and Managing Editor of Scientometrics.
James D. Navratil, Ph.D., earned his Ph.D. degree in Chemistry from the University
of Colorado, Boulder, and began working at Rocky Flats, operated by Rockwell Inter-
national for the U.S. Department of Energy, in 1961. He has held several positions in
the Analytical Laboratories and Research and Development. His current position is
Manager of the Chemical Research Group. From 1978 until 1981 Dr. Navratil was on
leave of absence to the International Atomic Energy Agency, Vienna, Austria. He was
named Rockwell International Scientist/Engineer of the Year in 1977.
Dr. Navratil's research interests are mainly chemical separations and actinide sepa-
rations. He is founder and Co-Editor of the journal Solvent Extraction and Ion Ex-
change and serves on the editorial board of six other journals. He is active in the
American Chemical Society and is Chairman of the ACS Subdivision of Separations
Science and Technology. He has received the ACS Colorado Section Award and In-
dustrial Research and Development IR-100 Award. Dr. Navratil has authored or co-
authored over 100 publications and co-edited six books.
A. B. Farag, Ph.D., earned his B.Sc. degree in Chemistry from the Faculty of Sci-
ence, Ain-Shams University, Cairo, in 1965. In 1966 he joined the National Research
Centre, Cairo, as a Research Assistant. In 1968 he earned his M.S. degree in Chemis-
try. In 1975 Dr. Farag obtained his Ph.D. degree in Analytical Chemistry from the
Hungarian Academy of Sciences, Budapest. From 1975 to 1977 Dr. Farag joined the
National Research Centre as a Researcher. In 1977 he moved to the Department of
Chemistry, Faculty of Science, Mansoura University, Egypt, as Lecturer. In 1981 he
was promoted to Associate Professor, a title he currently holds. He was on leave to
King Abdulaziz University, Jeddah, Saudia Arabia, as a Staff Member during 1982 to
1984.
Dr. Farag is the author of 45 scientific publications in the field of microanalysis and
foam separation methods. He is a member of the Egyptian Chemical Association and
the American Chemical Society.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Chapter 1
Polyurethane Foam Sorbents 1
I. Quasi-Spherical Solid Membranes in Separations Chemistry 1
II. Historical Overview 2
III. Foamed Polyurethane Polymers 4
IV. Fundamental Knowledge of Foamed Polyurethanes 4
A. Foam Definition 4
B. Foam Geometry 4
C. Cell Structure 7
D. General Methods of Foam Preparation 7
1. Chemical Methods 7
a. Thermal Decomposition of a Chemical Blowing
Agent 7
b. Blowing by In Situ Chemical Reaction 7
2. Physical Methods 8
a. Low Pressure Release of Dissolved Gas 8
b. Blowing by Vapor from a Volatile Liquid 8
c. Temporary Filler 8
3. Mechanical Methods 8
a. Mechanical Entrainment of Gas 8
b. The Use of Microspheres 8
E. Polyurethane Foam Synthesis 8
V. Physical and Chemical Properties of Polyurethane Foams 11
VI. Analytical Methods for the Characterization of Polyurethane Foams 13
A. Differentiation of Polyurethane Foams from Other Plastic
Foams 13
B. Qualitative Spot Reaction for Polyester- or Polyether-Based
Polyurethane Foam 14
VII. Experimental Techniques in the Analytical Use of Polyurethane Foam
Sorbents 14
A. Preparation of Resilient Polyurethane Foam Sorbents for
Analytical Use 14
B. Collection and Retention Techniques in Aqueous Media 15
1. Batch Methods 15
2. Column Methods 15
3. Pulsating Column Methods 16
C. Collection and Retention Techniques in Gaseous Media 17
VIII. Collection and Retention of Inorganic and Organic Species with
Resilient Polyurethane Foams 22
A. Unloaded Polyurethane Foams 22
1. Collection of Inorganic Species 23
a. Sorption from Aqueous Media 23
i. Acidic Halides 24
ii. Aqueous Nitrate 32
iii. Acidic Thiocyanate 33
iv. Neutral and Alkaline Cyanide 47
v. Acidic Thiourea 49
vi. Other Aqueous Media 49
b. Sorption from Nonaqueous Media 54
2. Collection of Organic Species 55
a. Sorption from Aqueous Media 55
i. Chlorinated Organic Compounds 56
ii. Polynuclear Aromatic Hydrocarbons 60
iii. Other Organic Compounds 65
b. Sorption from Gaseous Media 70
i. Chlorinated Organic Compounds 70
ii. Organophosphorous Compounds 83
iii. Polynuclear Aromatic Hydrocarbons 86
iv. Other Organic Pollutants 88
B. Loaded Polyurethane Foams 92
1. Foams Loaded with Solvent Extractants 92
a. Collection from Aqueous Media 92
b. Collection from Gaseous Media 102
2. Foams Loaded with Hydrophobic Chelating Reagents 102
a. Dithizone Foam 105
b. Diethyldithiocarbamate Foam 110
c. l-Nitroso-2-Naphthol Foam 113
d. Benzoylacetone Foam 113
e. Dimethylglyoxime Foam 113
f. o-Benzildioxime Foam 116
g. 1,2-Ethanedithiol Foam 116
h. Pyridylazo-Naphthol Foam 117
i. Other Reagent Foams 120
3. Reagent Foams in Qualitative and Semiquantitative
Analysis 121
4. Foams Loaded with Liquid Ion Exchangers 128
a. Anion Exchange Foams 128
b. Amberlite® LA-2 Foam 130
c. Aliquat Foam 130
d. Cation Exchange Foams 131
5. Heterogeneous Ion Exchange Foams 132
6. Foams with Anchored Functional Groups 133
IX. Other Analytical Uses of Unloaded and Loaded Resilient Polyurethane
Foams 135
A. Column Redox Reactions 135
B. Isotope- and Redox-Exchange Separations with Polyurethane
Foams 138
1. Isotope-, Redox- and Precipitate-Exchange Separations on
Finely Divided Precipitate Immobilized on Open-Cell
Polyurethane Foams 139
2. Isotope-Exchange Separations on Hydrophobic Organic
Phases Immobilized in Open-Cell Polyurethane
Foams 141
C. Polyurethane Foams for Trapping Volatile Combustion Products
in Organic Microanalysis 148
D. Polyurethane Foams for Trapping Enzyme Inhibitors and the
Immunoadsorption of Cells 155
Chapter 2
Open-Pore Polyurethane (OPP) Sorbents 159
I. Introduction 159
II. OPP Preparation 159
A. Synthesis and Reagents 159
B. OPP Column Preparation 161
III. Physical and Chemical Properties of OPP 162
A. Effects of Synthesis Conditions on OPP Properties 162
B. Compatibility and Other Properties of OPP 173
IV. Analytical Chemistry Applications 173
A. Gas-Solid Chromatography 176
B. Gas-Liquid Chromatography 179
Index 209
1
Chapter 1
-d —2 Lh-——1
1
(R + irJ
(R
where the value of n is 1/3 for the spherical, 1/2 for the cylindrical, and unity for the
planar geometry. In Figure 2 this function is plotted for each case. The spherical mem-
brane geometry, of course, results in the largest ratio of surface-to-volume and the
minimum ratio of membrane thickness-to-volume for a given R value.
2 Polyurethane Foam Sorbents in Separation Science
(R +1)
Finally we have to mention another very distinctive feature of the polyurethane foam
sorbents, namely its extremely favorable hydrodynamical and/or aerodynamical be-
havior. Columns filled with these sorbents permit the use of liquid and/or gas flow
rates which are much greater than columns filled with granular or bead-shaped sor-
bents.
inorganic and organic species in aqueous, nonaqueous, and gaseous media. Polyure-
thane foams were found to be quite effective for separation in static (batch) and dy-
namic (column flow) systems. Owing to their quasi-spherical membrane structure, po-
lyurethane foams and open pore microspheres allow very reasonable flow rates when
used in dynamic operations. These favorable flow characteristics which permit high
flow rates suggested application of polyurethanes in the preconcentration of various
trace components from large volumes of water in a relatively short time. The same
properties permitted application of polyurethane foam sorbents in high volume air
samplers. Additionally, easy handling of same facilitated rapid, effective, and inexpen-
sive separations. Furthermore, the resilient character of polyurethane foams allowed
their use in batch squeezing and pulsated column operations. Obviously, this unique
possibility could not be matched by any other known solid sorbent.
Figure 3 shows the cumulative growth curve of publications related to polyurethane
foam sorbents. As seen, there is a steadily growing interest in the topic. 96 9S
A. Foam Definition
Polyurethane foams can be defined 100 as plastic materials in which a proportion of
solid phase is replaced by gas in the form of numerous small bubbles (cells). The gas
may be in a continuous phase to give an open-cell material or it may be discontinuous
to give noncommunicating cells. Low density foams are dispersions of relatively large
volumes of gas in relatively small volumes of solids having, for example, a density less
than 0.1 g cm"3. Medium foams are classified101 as having a density of 0.1 to 0.4 g cm~ 3 .
High density foams, therefore, have a density higher than 0.4 g cm"3, i.e., contain small
volumes of gas in the matrix.
B. Foam Geometry
From the geometrical point of view, if the gas bubbles occupy a volume smaller than
76%, they may be spherical. If they occupy a volume larger than 76%, they will be
distorted into quasi-spherical polyhedra. 102 Figure 5 shows a typical polyurethane foam
in which the bubbles (cells) occupy about 97% of the volume. The polyhedral structure
is clearly visible, and the polyhedra on the average are quasi-spherical pentagonal do-
decahedra.
The polymer is distributed between the walls of the bubbles and the lines where
bubbles intersect. The bubbles are called quasi-spherical cells, the lines of intersections
are called strands, and the walls are the factual membranes. In open-cell flexible poly-
urethane foam, at least two windows (from the total) in each cell must be ruptured for
5
^ *;.<i^Jflw^JM«^HP'.,.,
fluids to pass freely through the foam. It is necessary for each window to be shared by
two cells, and each strand to be shared by three cells.
C. Cell Structure
The cell structure (i.e., presence or absence of windows in the cell or the number of
windows per cell) is a function of the process by which the foam is made. It was
noted100 that both rigid and flexible foams may be obtained with open- and closed-
cells. The structure made up of windowless cells (containing only strands) is called
reticulated foam. 102
It was reported100 that generally flexible polyurethane foams tend to have open-cell
structures while rigid foams tend to have closed-cells. However, there are many excep-
tions and, as the type of cell structure is largely determined by the method of expan-
sion, some materials which can be made by more than one method can exist in both
open- and closed-cell forms. Furthermore, methods are available by which closed-cell
structure can be converted into the open-cell form by rupture of the windows. Ruptur-
ing may be caused mechanically by applying pressure, or chemically by hydrolysis or
oxidation.
/. Chemical Methods
a. Thermal Decomposition of a Chemical Blowing Agent
This method involves the incorporation of a chemical blowing agent into the plastic
polymer in the liquid state. The blowing agent is usually an organic material which
decomposes under the action of heat to yield a gas. Heating the mixture of the polymer
and the blowing agent to a certain temperature causes a decomposition of the latter.
Subsequent expansion of the polymer occurs which under controlled conditions gives
rise to a foamed plastic.103
Generally, the chemical blowing agent must be chosen in such a manner that the
residue remaining in the polymer be nontoxic and not cause polymer breakdown. Sev-
eral chemical blowing agents are commercially available today. The most widely used
is p-toluenesulfonyl semicarbazide.104 This material, which decomposes at 235°C to
give mainly nitrogen and carbon dioxide, is useful for expanding plastics such as high-
density polyethylene, polypropylene, rigid polyvinyl chloride, etc.
of which is part of the polymer. In some systems and under certain conditions, volatile
materials may be split off as fragments from the polymer which act as blowing agents
representing the last category. For example, a-chloro acrylic esters may be polymerized
at room temperature but split off a volatile alkyl chloride when heated to 150 to
180°C.100
2. Physical Methods
a. Low Pressure Release of Dissolved Gas
This technique employs the dissolution of gas in the liquid polymer under high pres-
sure. Upon releasing pressure, the expansion of gas from the supersaturated polymer
causes the formation of foamed plastic. Expanded ebonite, polystyrene, and polyvinyl
chloride have been prepared by this method. 100
c. Temporary Filler
This system is used to make cellular material from polymers which are difficult to
expand. Particles of solid material are fixed with the polymer and processed to give a
filled solid plastic. The filler is subsequently removed by leaching with a suitable sol-
vent or by sublimation to leave the plastic material in a cellular form. A good illustra-
tion is the preparation of cellular polytetrafluoroethylene, 100 which results from mixing
and sintering polymer powder with naphthalene. Naphthalene is then sublimed away
leaving a porous form of polytetrafluoroethylene.
3. Mechanical Methods
a. Mechanical Entrainment of Gas
This is probably the oldest means of forming cellular plastics. Air beaten into the
polymer produces a stable liquid foam, which is then cured either chemically or by
heating. Urea-formaldehyde and polyvinyl chloride have been prepared in this way.100
urethane
0
II
R_N=C=0 + RNH, R-N-C-N-R (3)
I
H H
substituted urea
Alternatively, carbamic acid may react with another isocyanate molecule to produce
carbamic acid anhydride which decomposes to substituted urea and carbon dioxide:
0 0 0
The main reactions which lead to branching and cross-linking are the isocyanate-ure-
10 Polyurethane Foam Sorbents in Separation Science
O 0 0
Table 1
TRACE ELEMENTS IN POLYURETHANE FOAM
(ppm)
Ether-type Ester-type
Element (1)
(1) (2)
(2) (3)
(3) (4)
(4) (1)
From Braun, T., Abbas, M. N., Elek, A., and Bakos, L., J. Ra-
dioanal. Chem., 67, 359, 1981. With permission.
skeleton. The impurities measured in the polyurethane foam samples are shown in
Table 1. As is clear from these results, tin represents the main impurity in the polyether
type foam, while it is by far lower in the polyester foam. This high tin content results
from the use of organotin compounds as catalysts during the polymerization of the
polyether type polyurethane foam. Small amounts of chlorine, sodium, magnesium,
iodine, and bromine are also present. However, washing the foam material before
irradiation with 1 M nitric acid solution was found to decrease the amounts of alkali
metals, halogens, manganese, and vanadium, but does not affect the amount of tin
(Table 2). It was indicated that the amount of heavy metal impurities in polyurethane
foams are generally negligible or even absent. The impurities present are comparable
with or lower than those present in other organic sorbents, e.g., activated carbon," 4 115
chelating filters," 6 chelating resins,"7 or ion exchange resins.116-"8
On the other hand, Bidleman and Olney66 determined the organic extractable com-
pounds in a polyester polyurethane foam (diSPO plugs). They refluxed the foam ma-
terial for 2 hr with 150 mi of petroleum ether followed by another 2 hr extraction in a
Soxhlet extractor (30 c) with 175 ml of the same solvent. The extracts were then in-
jected into a gas chromatographic column after their appropriate concentration to
small volumes. As is evident from Figure 6, two major gas chromatographic peaks
were observed. These peaks were removed by passing the extracts through an alumina
column prior to the gas chromatograph. In using a deactivated silicic acid column for
cleaning up the extracts, the peaks were not detected in the petroleum ether eluate but
measured in the dichloromethane eluate.66 This thorough washing of foam materials
before use was shown to be a very important step, especially when employing such
substances for the collection of organic compounds from aqueous or gaseous media.
Surface areas for different polyether type polyurethane foams were measured.9 "'
The procedure involved 3 hr shaking of 50 mg portions of the foam with 5 g aliquot
portions of solution containing carboxy-14C stearic acid in n-heptane, which is itself
13
Table 2
TRACE ELEMENTS IN
POLYURETHANE FOAM
AFTER WASHING (ppm)
Tin 1096 23
Chlorine 43 93
Sodium 8 7
Magnesium 8 —
Aluminum 0.7 —
Iodine 1.9 8.7
Bromine 1 8
Manganese 0.1 0.08
Vanadium 0.01 ND
Indium 0.02 —
Arsenic 4.5 —
Antimony 0.48 —
Potassium 8 ND
absorbed to a negligible extent by the foam material. The bulk densities of the foams
examined ranged between 0.017 to 0.304 g cm~ 3 and their surface areas were found to
be 0.007 to 0.035 m 2 g"1. There was no correlation between the surface area and the
bulk density of the foams examined.
The surface areas of some batches of polyether17 and polyester21 polyurethane foams
were also measured by the BET method, using Krypton gas, and found to be 0.08 m 2
g to 0.081 m 2 g~', respectively. Unfortunately the densities of the foams tested were not
specified.
In this section, information is given which will permit identification and characteri-
zation by rapid and simple means of the most usual types of polyurethane foams used
as sorbents in separations chemistry. For more details on the analysis of other com-
ponents and instrumental procedures, the reader is directed to the relevant original
literature. 106
which contain —NCO groups, the test is positive without prior treatment. A positive
test is obtained even after these foams are extended with polyols. In glacial acetic acid
the yellow color that forms immediately with the isocyanate foam provides a specific
test for identification. Such probes are conducted by dissolving the foam in 5 to 10 mi
of glacial acetic acid with or without heating. A suitable solvent may be used first for
dissolving those foams not soluble in glacial acetic. m-Cresol, dimethylsulfoxide, or
dimethylacetamide are solvents which will often effect solution. Approximately 0.1 g
of p-dimethylamino benzaldehyde reagent is added and a bright yellow color develops
in a few minutes at room temperature if either isocyanate or urethane groups are pres-
ent.
A spot test permits polyurethane foams prepared from polyethers and those pre-
pared from polyesters to be differentiated. 106 Such determination is based on the fol-
lowing reactions where R and R' are di- or polyfunctional:
0 0
II II
R-C-OR' + H 2 NOH • HC1 + 2KOH -» R-C-NHOK + KC1 + 2H 2 0 + R'OH (7)
0 0
II II
R-C-NHOK + HC1 -> R-C-NHOH + KC1 (8)
O
II ^°---
R-C-NHOH+ 1/3 Fe 3+ -»• R-C " Fe/3 + H + (9)
X
N-0
I
H
The hydroxamic acid from the polyester reacts with the ferric ion to form a complex
which is water-soluble and violet or purple in color for most hydroxamic acids.
fore using for separation purposes. The foam materials generally employed are in the
form of small cubes (5 mm edge) or in a cylindrical (plug) form. In the latter case the
foam is cut such that each cylindrical rod has a little larger diameter than the column
employed. The diameters of the foam cylinders range between 1.0 and 8.3 cm and their
lengths vary from 1.0 to 12.0 cm. The cylindrical plugs can be cut from commercially
available foam sheets (having different thicknesses) by thin-wall stainless steel tubing
mounted in a drill press.65 Some workers 81 - 82 compressed the foam sheet between two
plywood boards, the upper board containing a number of holes of different diameter.
The plugs were then cut with a pre-cleaned hole saw mounted on a drill press. Other
workers instead soaked the foam material in liquid air or liquid nitrogen and used a
cork-borer for cutting the freezed foam into cylinders of the required diameter. Com-
mercially available foam plugs were also employed.10 45
Foam cubes or cylinders are usually washed with 1 M hydrochloric or nitric acid
followed by distilled water (until the washings are acid-free) and then with acetone or
other volatile organic solvents. However, the foam materials used for the collection
and separation of organic pesticides in aqueous or gaseous media are usually washed
with pesticide grade hexane and/or acetone or any other suitable organic solvent. Most
of the investigators recommend the extraction of the foam material in a Soxhlet ex-
tractor instead of simple washing to eliminate any organic material remaining in the
foam after the synthesis process. Once the washing step is completed, foam is either
air-dried, dried under vacuum, or dried in an oven at 80°C. The cleaned, dried sorbent
foams are then stored in stoppered flasks, aluminum foils, or nylon foil bags until
used.
1. Batch Methods
Batch methods can be classified into batch shaking and batch squeezing methods. In
the former, the sorption equilibrium is established by shaking a certain amount of the
foam cubes with a known volume or weight of the sample solution to the optimal time.
Stoppered flasks or tubes are used for this purpose. 9 In the case of batch squeezing,
the equilibrium is established by squeezing a foam cube (20 to 40 mm edge) in the
sample solution for a suitable time. 9 Some researchers21 placed a piece or pieces of
foam in a beaker with the desired amount of the solution and used the base of a
measuring cylinder to compress the foam periodically. Others 42 employed the cell
shown in Figure 7 for squeezing a piece of foam.
An automatic squeezing apparatus was also employed. 17 60 This consists of an eccen-
tric cam turned by a motor at 8.5 rpm which depresses and releases the plunger of the
cell once per revolution, i.e., squeezes and releases the foam piece placed in the vessel
beneath the plunger. Alternatively, also employed was a large multiple automatic
squeezer consisting of an eccentric cam (91 cm long, 14 cm diameter), turned by a
heavy-duty motor, which compresses and releases as many as 10 glass plungers (5 cm
stroke, 24 strokes/min). 21
2. Column Methods
Columns of various dimensions have been used in chromatographic foam separa-
tions and also in collection and retention processes on the foam. A vacuum method
for foam column packing has been developed120 and widely employed. In this method
the (loaded or unloaded) foam cubes or cylinders are packed in a column by applying
gentle pressure with a glass rod to reduce the foam volume to about one-third of its
original volume. Air bubbles are expelled during packing by connecting tap 1 (Figure
8) to a suction pump and closing tap 2. The flat-bottomed connection of tap 1 prevents
16 Polyurethane Foam Sorbents in Separation Science
20
Minutes
the foam sorbent from upward movement during suction. After about 10 min of evac-
uation, distilled water is allowed to fill the column gradually through tap 2. Then tap
1 and the column top are replaced with a separatory funnel as a reservoir.
Other workers 60 packed the foam material (in cylindrical form) in a glass column
filled with acetone, in such a manner that the foam plugs were merely touching each
other; i.e., not compressed. Acetone was then flushed out with a suitable volume of
distilled water and water was leveled at the top of the foam column.
a solution, brings the liquid, containing the substance to be sorbed, into repeated con-
tact with the foam sorbent. Figure 9 shows a schematic diagram of the manual pulsated
column method. 606
The pulsated column operation in a closed arrangement can be automated using a
motor to release and compress the plunger of the syringe cybernetically (Figure 10).
Suction
120cm
00 A U •-
1 i -2 t
lS&}
o- i; ^ '3
sinn
M&
S | * £
l-SSi
« 8 ~&
.a 5 -a 1
fcJ O H c/i
rt w™* ^ ~1
c £ C
2 - 5u8 ^
3 C 9-
< -2 t? 1 S
2 ^ -2 c
2 £ g 8g
« £-^
g | g 'S I
S I L- I 5
E 82& £
IHIil
i|i!||
!i!P
! « r I l^c
g ^ M^ o :
S g | §^«
^!l!lli
•a I .s ^ 8 2 .a
M
IB S
" I I
E "-o
„ c sI
^ c ' g 3. « a
-|:il-|
a e .2" c ?
ov a0 — -a 3 .
w *2 i '^5 f° ^
ca g I &M £
g a 0 ^ s a"
O 2 g>f I 2 £
E S 2 -i « fc. 2
20 Polyurethane Foam Sorbents in Separation Science
S §
D, ON
Is
rt o
i*,
v '£
Is
11
o .
M3
2
•*
«J
V-o <
si
t, C3
DO ^
CO • —
=5 S
0 -a
•£ C —
co a ^
P . c
u W .2
1M |
. « 6
a
«ai
2 «
"i-
o £ oo
E fe 2
(«
I* 2
i<l
w . .:2
u B e
£ S S.
•a
o «^ -S
.—
3d*.
£O. ai ON
P
S .» -
So * <»
- J*
« C -.
C O ?
u >- .
S fc. d
e« J£.«I
SE &
u ^
~:
3 £ ca
1s^
j= -o :
£00 0) Q
-• 5 c
!s
- -g g
w ^^
gO aT3 «•a
— c c
b « «
21
(e)
(-«8.7cm»-|
A more or less similar sampling apparatus (Figure 13) was also reported, 89 but the
allowed air flow rate was higher (750 to 800 i min' 1 ).
A high volume gas sampler was employed to determine the retention efficiencies of
polyurethane sorbents using a gas chromatographic method. 81 This apparatus consists
of 14 1 cm thick polyurethane foam plugs packed loosely in a 7 cm diameter x 2.5 cm
long aluminum barrel (Figure 14). A 15th plug was spiked with about 40 ^g of mixed
polychlorinated biphenyl isomers in hexane, the solvent allowed to evaporate, and the
spiked plug placed at the front of the sampling train. A layer of polyurethane foam
prefilter was placed at the front of the sampler to minimize any contamination from
the laboratory atmosphere. Air was drawn through the foam column using a vacuum
pump at a flow rate of 150 to 810 I min"1.
A low volume sampling apparatus was suggested'0 for the recovery tests of polynu-
clear aromatic hydrocarbons (PAH). It consists of a glass fiber filter and two poly-
urethane foam plugs connected in series as shown in Figure 15. PAH (25 /ug of each)
22 Polyurethane Foam Sorbents in Separation Science
PPF Prefllters
Screen Spiked
Support Plug
To Air Pump
1-cm Plugs
Air-
FIGURE 15. Low-volume air sampling train for recovery tests of polynuclear aro-
matic hydrocarbons, (a) Activated charcoal column (air purification column); (b) po-
lyurethane foam sorbent column (air purification column); (c) polyurethane foam sor-
bent column (glass tube: inside diameter 2 cm) 25 ^ig of each PAH was put on the glass
fiber-(GF). (d) GF; (e) stainless steel screen; (f) activated charcoal; (g) polyurethane
foam sorbent. (From Yamasaki, H., Kuwata, K., and Miyamato, M., BunsekiKagaku,
27, 317, 1978. With permission.)
were introduced on the glass fiber filter and air was passed through the tubes at 41 1
min"1.
Recently, a battery powered low-volume air sampling system utilizing polyurethane
foam as a trapping medium was evaluated.88 This portable sampler (Figure 16) pro-
vides air flow rates up to 4 i min"1 using a Dupont® P-4000 constant flow sampling
pump. The sampling cartridge (A) was constructed from a simple 20 mm (internal
diameter) x 10 cm borosilicate glass tube packed with a 22 mm diameter x 7.6 cm long
cylindrical polyurethane foam plug. Alternatively, two 3.8 cm long plugs separated by
a stainless steel wire may be used.
Timing Switches
Sampling Cartridge B'
Paniculate Filter
Table 3
DISTRIBUTION RATIOS AND SORPTION CAPACITIES FOR
FOAM EXTRACTIONS
Absorption
Distribution capacities Formula of
Substance Solvent ratios (mol kg"1) complex
sorption capacities summarized in Table 3. In most cases the foams become saturated
with sorbant more or less rapidly, so that the distribution ratio falls off as saturation
is approached. In these instances the most favorable distribution ratios were found for
the more dilute solutions.
The sorption isotherms for iodine, gold(III), and iron(III) were measured at two
different temperatures. The sorption of iodine (Figure 17) and gold (III) was better at
low than at high temperatures; while in the case of iron (III) (Figure 18) the reverse
was true. The curves of Figure 17 show that the sorption isotherm of iodine is a straight
line, i.e., the distribution ratio is constant over the iodine concentration range studied.
In some cases attempts were made to investigate the nature of the sorbed species on
the foam using chemical analyses and diffuse reflectance spectra of foams after sorp-
tion. 9 The spectra of sorbed gold (III) halides and iron (III) chloride showed qualitative
resemblance to the spectra of the same substances in acid solutions. However, the
sorbed iodine spectrum had a single broad peak between 397 and 562 nm and differs
from the spectrum of iodine in water. Also attempted has been elution of some species
sorbed on the foam using dilute alkali or ammonia and in some instances acetone or
carbon tetrachloride. 12
i. Acidic Halides
Using a batch procedure, Bowen 912 examined the sorption of mercury (II) and gold
(III) from 0.2 M hydrochloric acid solutions by polyurethane foams. The retention of
gold (III) has also been investigated from 0.2 Mhydrobromic and hydroiodic acid. The
extraction of iron (III), rhenium (III), thallium (III), antimony (V), and molybdenum
(VI) has been tested in 6 M hydrochloric acid solutions (Table 3). Generally, the
amount of metal ion sorbed by the foam was measured by comparing some property
(e.g., UV absorption or radioactivity) of equal aliquot portions of solution before and
25
400
O>
en 51° C
1= 200
re
o
0.1
I2: solution/g kg
after sorption. Since the original concentration in the solution was known, the final
concentration and the absolute amount sorbed could readily be calculated.
Schiller and Cook13 examined the separation of gold(III) chloride from natural
waters with resilient polyurethane foam sorbent and compared their results with those
obtained by coprecipitation with iron(III) hydroxide, lead sulfide, or aluminum hy-
droxide and also by separation with Dowex® 1-X8 ion exchange resin. All experiments
were carried out in batch systems and the gold collected on the foam was determined
by a neutron activation analysis procedure. Lead sulfide and polyurethane foam were
found to be the most efficient collectors. Furthermore, no interfering gamma peaks
were detected using these carriers. This method facilitates the nondestructive determi-
nation of gold at ppb levels after being quantitatively collected on the foam sorbent.
In a dynamic extraction system, Sukiman14 was able to collect gold(III) chloride in
acidic aqueous solution using foam columns of 20 mm diameter and 100 mm length.
The columns were packed with 0.5 g of unloaded foam cubes by squeezing several
times with water. Three different polyether foam samples were examined. Gold (III)
at trace levels (0.02 to 25 ppm) was recovered from acidic aqueous solution by perco-
lating the solution through the foam column at relatively fast flow rates (30 to 40 ml
min' 1 )- Acetone was then employed for the recovery of gold from the foam column at
3 mi min"1 (Table 4). It was also mentioned that 0.3 thiourea in 1 M hydrochloric acid
solution can be used for elution of sorbed gold at 50°C, but acetone elution was pre-
ferred. Gold concentrations were measured radiometrically, by counting the activity of
26 Polyurethane Foam Sorbents in Separation Science
0)
0.1 0.2
1
Fe: Solution/g kg
FIGURE 18. Uptake of iron(III) from 6 Mhydrochloric acid by foam at 22 and 51°C.
(From Bowen, H. J. M., /. Chem. Soc.,A, 1082, 1970. With permission.)
Table 4
THE UPTAKE AND RECOVERY OF GOLD FROM DISTILLED WATER AND
NATURAL WATER BY UNTREATED POLYURETHANE FOAM SOLVENT
(300 ml OF SOLUTION WAS EMPLOYED AND GOLD WAS MEASURED
RADIOMETRICALLY)
From Sukiman, S., Radiochem. Radioanal. Lett., 18, 129, 1974. With permission.
100-
6 8 10 12
Base
Molarity
FIGURE 19. Effect of acid and base concentrations on the recovery efficiency for
gallium from a foam plug. (From Gesser, H. D., Bock, E., Baldwin, W. G., Chow, A.,
McBride, D. W., and Lipruski, W., Sep. Sci., 11, 315, 1976. With permission.)
lution of the ore in 1:1 aqua regia. The solution was diluted (1:3) and foam cubes (0.5
g) were then shaken with the solution for 30 min. Gold was recovered from the foam
with hot thiourea solution and determined by an atomic absorption method.
Gesser et al.16 have shown that open-cell polyurethane foam of polyether type can
be used as a solid substitute for diethyl ether in extraction systems. They investigated
the extraction and recovery of gallium from acidic chloride solutions. The effect of
hydrochloric acid concentration on the extraction efficiency is more or less similar to
that found in diethyl ether extractions. It was proved that open-cell foam is by far
more efficient than closed-cell rigid foam. It was mentioned that silicone rubber sponge
does not extract gallium under similar experimental conditions. Water or a weakly
basic solution was found to be suitable in eluting gallium from the foam column.
Figure 19 shows the effect of acid and base concentrations on the recovery of gallium
from the column.
The effect of temperature and flow rate on the extraction and recovery of gallium
also has been investigated. As expected, the efficiencies are generally increased by de-
creasing the flow rate. After a detailed experimental study, Gesser et al.16 concluded
that foam column efficiency can be increased either by passing the solution through
several foam plugs or by passing the same solution through the same foam plug several
times. Under optimal experimental conditions, it was possible to sorb gallium in the
foam to the extent of 10% by weight. This relatively high sorption capacity was linked
to the dissolution of gallium chloride complex in the foam material rather than to
adsorption on the foam surface. That is, the foam material acts as a polymeric solid
extractant for gallium. It is worth mentioning that this foam sorption method was
applied for the separation of gallium and iron from aluminum in acidic chloride solu-
tions. Iron(III) and gallium(III) are sorbed from 7.5 M hydrochloric acid and eluted
from the column by water or dilute ammonia. Gallium and iron were determined in
the eluate by atomic absorption spectrometry. It was reported that the extraction effi-
28 Polyurethane Foam Sorbents in Separation Science
200
20 30 40 50 60
Time (min.)
FIGURE 20. Time dependence for (a) filled circles — the de-
sorption into 150 mt distilled water of gallium from loaded
(25.06 mg Ga) polyurethane foam; (b) other symbols — the
extraction of gallium of (150 ml, 200 ppm Ga) by polyurethane
foam at various HC1 concentrations. (From Gesser, H. D. and
Horsfall, G. A., J. Chim. Phys., 74, 1072, 1977. With permis-
sion.)
ciency of the polyurethane foam is 65 mg g ' for gallium(III) and 44 mg g'1 for iron(III)
with no interference from greater than 1000-fold amounts of aluminum.
In a further detailed study, 17 described were the thermodynamic properties of open-
cell polyurethane foam as a solid polymeric extractor for gallium from acidic chloride
media. A batch squeezing automatic technique was employed and gallium was deter-
mined in solution by atomic absorption spectrometry. The rate at which equilibrium is
established is shown in Figure 20, where the extraction of 200 ppm gallium in 150 ml
aliquots solution having various concentrations of hydrochloric acid was determined
as a function of time. As is evident from the curves, the rate of sorption of gallium
was elevated by increasing the hydrochloric acid concentration. This increase in hydro-
chloric acid concentration also raised the equilibrium extraction efficiency of gallium
(Figure 21). The results were found to be similar to those obtained in the extraction of
gallium by ether. 121 The extraction efficiency for gallium at 0.1 and 1.0 Mhydrochloric
acid containing various concentrations of lithium chloride was also examined (Figure
29
22). The effect of concentrations of acid, chloride, and gallium ions on the extraction
efficiency and the capacity of the foam has also been investigated. 17
The diffusion of gallium through thin polyurethane film sealed into a diffusion ap-
paratus was examined." The diffusion was found to be consistent with the solubility
of the HGaCl 4 complex in polyurethane. The "active transport" of gallium through
polyurethane membrane was explained by the hydrolysis of the complex after it had
passed through the membrane. On the premise of this study, Gesser et al.17 suggested
two alternative mechanisms for the sorption of gallium by polyurethane foam. One is
based on the close resemblance between foam sorption and liquid extraction with ether.
That is, gallium(III) forms a tetrachloro-complex in aqueous solution and the latter is
dissolved in polyurethane foam. In other words, the foam material behaves as a poly-
meric sorbent for the gallium chloride complex. The other mechanism results from
protonation of the ether sites in the polymer when coming into contact with acids in
aqueous solution. That is, the protonated sites act as anion exchangers in the extraction
of GaCU species:
H
I
H + + (-CH2-OCH2-)foam -> (_CH 2 -0-CH 2 -) foam (10)
+
H H
!
GaCU + (-CH2-0-CH2-)foam - (_CH 2 -O-CH 2 -) foam (11)
+ I
GaCl4
However, the results obtained by Gesser and co-workers17'18 do not permit distinc-
tion between the two proposed mechanisms. Some of the experimental results favor
one of the mechanisms while others could be better explained as a consequence of the
second mechanism.
In a further study, Gesser et al.18 investigated the transport of metal complexes, such
as HMX 4 of gallium and iron across thin polyurethane films to determine the mecha-
nism, but they reached a conclusion similar to that stated above.
The equilibria involved in systems employing a polyurethane foam material as com-
pared to systems using a liquid extractant in the removal of M3* from acidic aqueous
solutions was investigated further. 16 -' 9 For this purpose, the extraction of iron(III) by
open-cell polyurethane foam was studied as a function of acid, chloride, and iron
concentrations in the aqueous phase by an automatic batch squeezing technique. Iron
in the equilibrium aqueous phase was determined by spectrophotometry as the iron-
thiocyanate complex. The results obtained are generally explained on the basis of the
presence of the mixed extraction of FeCl3 and HFeCl4. They also show a dependence
of the metal distribution coefficient on iron(III) concentration in the aqueous phase
and give an indication for that dissociation of the extracted HFeCL, species in the foam.
It was concluded that flexible polyurethane foams can be considered as a solid poly-
meric extractant. 19
Further work on the extraction of iron (III) from acidic chloride solution by organic
solvents (ethers) and by foam under comparable conditions as above has been carried
out. It is worth noting that the electron paramagnetic resonance spectra of sorbed iron
studied19 were found to be identical to those obtained122 in liquid-liquid extraction of
iron from acidic chloride media.
Using a manual batch technique, Bowen9 reported that antimony(V) could be ex-
tracted with polyether polyurethane foams from 6 M HC1 solution with distribution
30 Polyurethane Foam Sorbents in Separation Science
100 r-f
5 6 7
HCI (M)
ratios of 75 to 500 and foam capacities of 0.25 to 0.59 mol kg"1. More recently, the
extraction of antimony(III) and (V) from aqueous hydrochloric acid solution by poly-
ether (open-cell) polyurethane foam has been investigated20 using an automatic batch
squeezing device. The sorbed antimony was determined indirectly by measuring the
radioactivity of the aqueous solution before and after extraction. In some experiments
direct measurements of the radioactivity on the foam were carried out. The maximum
extraction of both antimony(III) and (V) was obtained from 7 M hydrochloric acid
solutions. The distribution coefficients of antimony(III) and (V) were only 416 ± 13
and 500 ± 17, respectively. At higher or lower acid concentrations the distribution
coefficients were significantly decreased. However, in the presence of 7 MLiCl and 0.7
Macid solution the extraction of both antimony(III) and (V) is more or less quantita-
tive (Table 5) with quite high distribution coefficients using concentrations ranging
between 0.01 and 100 ppm. However, at 1000 ppm antimony concentration the extrac-
tion decreased by 50%. The capacities of the two polyurethane foams tested were
found to be 8.5 and 4.5% (Sb: foam, w/w). 20
Quantitative elution of antimony from the foam was possible using acetone. It was
31
100
3
LiCI (N)
suggested that the foam acts as a polymeric solvent extractant for HSb(III)Cl4 and
HSb(V)Cl6 species.20
The extraction behavior of tin(II) and tin(IV) from acidic chloride media with poly-
ether and polyester foams has been examined21 using batch squeezing and column sys-
tems. The polyester foam was found to extract tin(II) and tin(IV) from ^ 6 M hydro-
chloric acid solutions. Complete extraction of tin(IV) was achieved in column
experiments using a flow rate of 0.1 mi min~' (column diameter > 2.1 cm). However,
the polyester foam material has a poor stability at this acid concentration and conse-
quently, polyether polyurethane foam is preferable. The effect of the different halic
acids and halide ions on the extraction efficiency of tin(IV) was investigated in a batch
squeezing system. Tin(IV) concentration in the aqueous solution was measured either
radiometrically using tin-119m tracer or by atomic absorption spectrometry. In a few
cases, the amount of tin retained on the foam was determined directly by measuring
the radioactivity of the foam itself. The extraction efficiency of tin(IV) on polyether
foam is generally better than on polyester. Figure 23 shows the effect of hydrochloric
acid and lithium chloride concentrations on the extraction of tin(IV) by the polyether
foam. In this batch experiment the chloride ion concentration was held constant at 10
M and the hydrogen ion concentration increased. As is evident from the figure the
32 Polyurethane Foam Sorbents in Separation Science
Table 5
EFFECT OF LITHIUM CHLORIDE CONCENTRATION ON
PERCENT EXTRACTION AND DISTRIBUTION COEFFICIENT
(D) OF ANTIMONY (100 ppm) FROM 150 ml OF 0.7 MHC1
SOLUTION BY POLYURETHANE FOAMS (0.5 g)
4 2 6 1 3 1 3
5 — _ 1 0 33 30 129
6 — — 57 398 58 414
7 93 4,360 95.3 6,150 97.2 10,414
8 — — 88.0 2,200 98.0 14,700
9 — — 72 111 99.2 37,200
10 21 95 57 398 99.2 37,200
From Lo, V. S. K. and Chow, A., Anal. Chim. Acta, 106, 161, 1979. With permission.
LITHIUM CONCENTRATION, M
8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
100
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1 0
HYDROGEN ION CONCENTRATION, M
The effect of nitrate ion concentration on the extraction of uranyl nitrate into the
foam material (Figure 25) was examined in the presence of different cations, e.g.,
NH 4 + , Ca2+, and Al3*, and a comparison was made with the results repeated by the
same systems using diethyl ether as extractant. Polyurethane foam was found to be 10
to 100 times more effective than the liquid solvent. The effect of temperature and pH
of the aqueous solution was examined and it was concluded that polyurethane foams
have thermodynamic extraction parameters similar to organic solvents. The capacity
of the foam was found to be 160 mg U g~'. However, it was indicated22 that higher
capacities could be achieved at lower temperatures.
Table 6
EFFECT OF METAL
HALIDES ON THE
EXTRACTION OF TIN
(IV) BY REGULAR
POLYURETHANE
FOAM-
LiCl 14 ±2
NaCl 25 + 2
KC1 34 ± 2
LiBr 33 ± 2
NaBr 38 ± 2
KBr 40 ±4
Lil 28 ± 2
Nal 37 ± 2
KI 39 ±4
500r
25
10
25
O)
o
-6 -5 -4 -3 -2 -1
Log (UO*
100
FIGURE 26. Rate of sorption of cobalt and iron from 0.5 Macidic thiocyanate so-
lution, (a) Cobalt, (b) Iron. (From Braun, T. and Farag, A. B., Anal. Chim. Acta,9S,
133, 1978. With permission.)
Table 7
COLLECTION OF VARIOUS
CONCENTRATIONS OF COBALT OR
IRON FROM 0.2 MOR 0.5 M
THIOCYANATE SOLUTIONS,
RESPECTIVELY, ON UNLOADED
POLYETHER FOAM COLUMNS AT FLOW
RATES OF 20 Ml MIN-
Average
metal ion
Amount extracted
of metal on foam* Relative accuracy Std.
ion (fig) (x, %) of the mean (%) dev.(s)
Average of 5 determinations.
' Cobalt.
Iron.
Table 8
EFFECT OF SQUEEZING TIME
AND SOLUTION VOLUME ON
EXTRACTION OF COBALT
Extraction (%)"
5 I
(a)
(b)
1 1 1 1 1
0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0
I I I I
HCI
FIGURE 27. The effect of hydrochloric acid on the sorption of rhodium. Initial rhod-
ium concentration 16.67 jjg ml'1; volume of solution 145 ml; weight of foam 0.1 g: (O)
0.15 M thiocyanate, acid added before heating: (•) 0.004 M thiocyanate, acid added
after heating. (From Al-Bazi, S. J. and Chow, A., Anal. Chem., 53, 1073, 1981. With
permission.)
heating the solution to 90°C for 4 hr to ensure the formation of the Rh(SCN)3; complex.
In the case of iridium, however, the distribution coefficient is quite independent of the
acid concentration. It was observed that the formation of the extractable species of
both rhodium and iridium is slow at room temperature and thus heating the solution
to 90°C is necessary. The extraction of iridium decreases at thiocyanate concentration
below 0.02 M, but the extraction of iridium increases (Figure 28). On the basis of these
results 0.002 M thiocyanate concentration was chosen in the separation of iridium and
rhodium using 3 hr of batch squeezing. Finally, it was reported that the extraction of
iridium and rhodium depends on different interrelated parameters, i.e., on the amount
of the thiocyanate complex formed rather than on the distribution of the complex
between the foam and the aqueous phase. Attempts to improve the extraction of rhod-
ium by increasing the amount of foam were unsuccessful. Although this separation
method is not entirely convenient, because of the difficulty of the separation, in com-
paring the results with those obtained by other separation techniques the foam method
can be considered competitive.
Braun et al.30-31 examined the sorption of zinc(II), mercury(II), indium(III), and
gold(III) from aqueous thiocyanate solution with polyether and polyester polyurethane
foams. Special attention was given to the extraction properties of the polyester foam
as it contains less trace metal impurities than the ether type. This is of special impor-
tance when the neutron activation analysis method is used for trace metal determina-
tion after its preconcentration on foam.31
Both the polyether and polyester foams were found30'31 to extract the thiocyanate
complexes of zinc, mercury, gold, and indium from aqueous solution. Figure 29 shows
the effect of thiocyanate concentration on the sorption of zinc and indium using a
batch technique. The mercury thiocyanate complex is also extracted by both types of
foam.
39
o
o
(b)
The foam extraction of zinc from 0.2 M thiocyanate solution is almost quantitative
over the pH range 0 to 6, but the distribution ratios were improved as the pH increased
from 0 to 6.30 In the case of mercury, the sorption is almost quantitative up to pH 6,
but the polyester foam is less efficient. For indium, the extraction is quantitative in the
pH range 2 to 8, the distribution ratios being higher at lower pH values. In batch
experiments 1 min contact time was found to be sufficient for complete sorption of
zinc and indium on the polyether foam. Various concentrations of zinc and mercury
were successfully extracted with the polyether foam (Table 9).
Zinc(II), indium(III), and mercury(II) were quantitatively collected on the foam col-
umn from very dilute aqueous solutions using flow rates of 100, 87, and 28 mi min"1,
respectively.30 Nitric acid (1 M) was employed to elute zinc at 2 m,f min'1 flow rate.
However, mercury and indium were completely eluted with a 1 M potassium thiocya-
nate solution in 80% acetone at a flow rate of 15 mi min"1. It was noted that acetone
alone can be employed for the elution of mercury from the foam column but at a flow
rate of 1 mi min"1.
Conditions for the extraction of the thiocyanate complex of palladium by polyether
polyurethane foams have been reported32-33 and sorption mechanisms were suggested.
In a multiple automatic batch squeezing system, the extraction of palladium thiocya-
nate was first studied as a function of contact time. Palladium concentration in the
aqueous solution was measured by atomic absorption spectrometry. The percentage of
palladium extracted increased sharply with extraction time up to 15 min and then more
slowly up to 1 hr, after which it remained almost constant. It was reported that a rapid
increase in the extraction of palladium occurred as the thiocyanate concentration in-
creased up to 0.001 M. At higher thiocyanate concentrations the extraction decreased.
The same behavior was also observed in the presence of 2 M potassium chloride under
identical conditions (Table 10).
The effect of hydrochloric acid concentration and the pH of the aqueous solution
40 Polyurethane Foam Sorbents in Separation Science
Polyether
100i
(a)
n r _
80 - / if '" 'V %
— Polyester —'
/
— 60
UJ
40 -
20 —
I I I
0
0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.C
1 KSCN] (M)
(b) i— Polyether
100 1
80 f \— Polyester
5 60 £- —
40 -
20
1 1 1 1
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.C
[KSCN] (M)
Table 9
EFFECT OF METAL ION CONCENTRATION ON THE EXTRACTION
EFFICIENCIES FOR ZINC AND MERCURY ON UNLOADED POLYETHER-
TYPE FOAM FROM 0.2 MTHIOCYANATE SOLUTION AT pH 2 TO 3
" n = 5.
* (ts/n)'/2 for t = 95.
From Braun, T. and Abbas, M. N., Anal. Chim. Acta, 134, 321, 1982. With permission.
on the extraction efficiency of palladium by the foam material has also been investi-
gated.32 Extraction increased rapidly with hydrochloric acid up to 0.08 M. At higher
pH values extraction decreased considerably. However, sorption of the palladium com-
plex was quite quantitative and independent of pH in the presence of 2 M potassium
41
Table 10
EFFECT OF
THIOCYANATE ON
PALLADIUM
EXTRACTION AND
DISTRIBUTION RATIO
IN THE PRESENCE OF
POTASSIUM
CHLORIDE"
(SCN~) M E, % log D
chloride in aqueous thiocyanate solution (Figure 30). It is worth noting that the extrac-
tion of palladium is highly minimized by the presence of ammonia in the aqueous
solution. This fact is useful in the recovery of palladium from the foam material.
The ionic strength effect of various chlorides on the extraction of palladium thiocy-
anate by polyurethane foam was investigated32 using lithium, sodium, potassium, and
ammonium chlorides. The effect of the added salt on the extraction is virtually inde-
pendent of the nature of the salt at concentrations above 0.5 M (Figure 31). At lower
salt concentrations a very different behavior was observed. Also, the extraction effi-
ciency increases in the following order of the cation added: Li* < Na* < K+ < NHt, < Rb+
< Cs+. The ion-dipole interaction of ammonium ions with the oxygen sites of polyure-
thane foam was claimed to contribute to the extraction of Pd(SCN)2; the interaction
being higher in the presence of ammonium chloride than potassium chloride at concen-
trations above 0.5 M. However, the extraction of palladium as a function of the ionic
diameter of the added cation passes through a maximum which suggests that there are
other factors involved. On the basis of the above-mentioned results it was
concluded32 33 that polyurethane molecules behave as long acyclic chains and the ex-
traction of the anion complexes occurs through a cation chelation mechanism (de-
scribed below).
Recently, the mechanism of metal ion sorption by polyether polyurethane foam was
critically investigated using the extraction of cobalt(II)27 and palladium(H)33 thiocya-
nate complexes as models. The mechanisms considered were surface adsorption on the
42 Polyurethane Foam Sorbents in Separation Science
100-
40
0.5 1 1.5
Ionic strength
foam membranes, ether-like solvent extraction, ligand addition, ligand exchange, an-
ion exchange, and cation chelation mechanisms.27-33 Taking into account the low sur-
face areas measured for several polyether polyurethane foams 9 - 17 - 21 - 119 the surface ad-
sorption mechanism has been rejected by many investigators.' 192024 This is actually
confirmed by the relatively high capacity measured9 (0.5 to 1.8 mol kg"1) for various
43
species on the foam material. Coupled with the observation that several species, such
as I 2 , 9 GaCl;,16-17 Co(NCS)2;,3 3" Fed;,17 UO 2 2 3 1 8 are able to diffuse through intact
polyurethane membranes, confirms that true sorption into the bulk of the polymer
must occur.
The solvent extraction mechanism, which relies on the consideration that polyether
and polyester polyurethane foams can act as solid polymeric extractants,9-16-19 22-25-35
has also been criticized and excluded as a singular mechanism. 27 ' 33 Obviously, the sol-
vent extraction mechanism is based on the assumption that neutral metal complexes
are first formed in the aqueous solution and then extracted via dissolution in the hy-
drophobic foam material. However, this mechanism fails to explain the extraction of
e.g., Co(NCS)2; from aqueous alkaline solution in the presence of sodium chloride.
Under these conditions, the formation of the neutral protonated species H2Co(NCS)4
is not probable. Also, the abrupt drop in the extraction efficiency of polyurethane
foam for cobalt thiocyanate complex in more acidic media cannot be satisfactorily
explained on the basis of this mechanism. An increase in the extraction efficiency
rather than a decrease could be expected with increasing acid concentration. Finally,
the distribution ratios of various species on the foam sorbent were found 9 2 7 3 3 to be
several orders of magnitude higher than those obtained under comparable experimen-
tal conditions for ether extractions. Table 11 shows the distribution ratios reported in
the literature for ether extraction of some metal ions in various media and those ob-
tained for polyether polyurethane foam sorbent.
Ligand addition and ligand exchange mechanisms were also taken into consideration
but later discarded.27-33 Ligand addition (considering polyurethane as a ligand), for
example to Co(NCS)2^ will cause an increase in the coordination number of the metal
which is quite rare. Also, absorption spectra of the extracted cobalt-thiocyanate species
sorbed in polyurethane foam films suggested that the sorbed species is tetrahedral.
Furthermore, the colors obtained27 when some other complexes are extracted by poly-
urethane foam are typical to the tetrahedral species (e.g., Fed;;, Pd(NCS)2;) and seem
to confirm that appreciable complexation of the metal ion in the foam by the ligand
addition mechanism cannot be common.27'33
In the case of ligand exchange it was thought the symmetry of the complex would
change, which would be accompanied by some alteration of the absorption spectra.
This is not the case as the sorbed complexes of several metals were rapidly recovered
from the foam material into various organic solvents (e.g., acetone, methyl isobutyl
ketone and bis 2-(2-methoxyethoxy)ethyl ether). On the basis of these results the ligand
exchange mechanism is considered to be unlikely. 27 - 33
The possibility that polyurethane foam can behave as a weak-base anion exchanger
has also been mentioned by some authors. 9 - 27 " This could occur by the protonation of
some sites in the polymer, such as nitrogen-containing urea or urethane linkages, or
perhaps the ether linkages in polyether-base foams followed by exchange of the anionic
metal complexes on these protonated sites. Obviously, this mechanism could work in
the presence of high concentrations of strong acids, but it should not play a significant
role in the absence of appreciable amounts of acid. For this reason, Hamon et al."
came to the conclusion that if anion exchange does occur, it necessarily takes place at
sites generated by some other mechanisms. Consequently, they proposed a new sorp-
tion mode they call the cation-chelation mechanism. In their view many cations, such
as Na*, K% Ag+, NH}, Pb2*, Ba2*, and H3O% are capable of being multiply complexed
by the polyurethane polymer macromolecules at specific sites. This results in a solid-
phase (or matrix) species which can be regarded as equivalent to an ion-exchange ma-
trix or to a solvated cation in solid solution:
Table 11
COMPARISON OF COMPLEX METAL ANION SORPTION BY OXYGEN-
CONTAINING ORGANIC SOLVENTS AND POLYETHER-BASED
POLYURETHANE FOAM
Metal
ion Aqueous phase Organic phase
Distribution ratio in kg'1 for polyurethane foam. From Hamon, R. F., Khan, A. S. and Chow,
A., Talanta, 29, 313, 1982. With permission.
where species within the polymer phase are indicated by bars. The extraction of ion-
association complexes having these cations as counter-ions will greatly be facilitated
owing to the stability of the chelate. However, which anions will accompany the cat-
ions in largest numbers will be determined by a variety of factors, including the indi-
vidual hydrophobic nature and charge of the anions, and perhaps their ability to inter-
act in other ways with the polymer. Anionic metal complexes MeX"1;, particularly those
which are coordinatively saturated with nonhydrophilic ligands, might be expected to
be well extracted. It was reported27'33 that the sorption of the ion-association complex
can be regarded as taking place by a solvent extraction process in which the cation
happens to be more effectively solvated than usual. This results, of course, when little
or no sorption of anions other than MeXm; occurred. The extraction mechanism could
be represented by:
Therefore, the cation-chelation mechanism resembles both solvent extraction and ion-
exchange depending to some extent on solution conditions.
Hamon et al.27 confirmed their cation-chelation mechanism by comparing the results
obtained for the sorption of some species with polyurethane foam sorbent and those
reported with macrocyclic ("crown") ethers. They noted increased sorption of
Co(NCS)24 by polyether polyurethanes containing increased proportions of polyethylene
oxide relative to polypropylene oxide. This was explained on the basis of previous
work 124 126 on crown ethers. That is, polyethylene oxide has a strong cation complexing
ability giving rise to a helical pattern of inwardly directed oxygen atoms with the che-
lated cation. Moreover, the authors interpreted the superiority of the sorption efficien-
cies of polyether polyurethane foams over those of the polyester by the fact that the
latter has an inherent inability to become helically oriented about the central axis owing
to the geometry and limited flexibility of the ester bond. 27
Further compelling evidence in support of strong polyether involvement in the ex-
traction of ion pairs was reported. 27 Measurement of the infrared spectrum showed a
shift of about 30 cm"1 in the ether vibrational modes near 1100 cm"1 when cobalt(II)
was sorbed by the foam from aqueous sodium thiocyanate solution. This change is
indicative of metal-polyether interactions. Moreover, the strong infrared absorption at
2055 cm"1 indicates that the thiocyanate is bonded to cobalt through the nitrogen atom.
Additional evidence for the existence of strong polyether-metal ion interactions comes
from the observation that polyurethane foams which are nearly saturated with co-
balt(II) thiocyanate exhibit a marked increase in the polymer glass transition tempera-
ture (i.e., they fail to return to their original shape when compressed and lose much of
their flexibility, to the point of becoming brittle).
Furthermore, it was reported that some selectivity of the polyether chain is demon-
strated for particular cations.27 In the extraction of Co(NCS)24, Zn(NCS) 2 4 , picrate, and
8-anilino-l-naphthaline-sulfonate (ANS~) anions, the order of extractability follows
the series Li* < Na* < Cs* < Rb* < K* ^ NH*. < Ag* ^ Tl* < Ba2* < Pb2*. This order of
cation performance was found to be nearly identical to that of 18-crown-6 deriva-
tives127 and also noncyclic polyethers.128 The proposed helical structure of M2Co(NCS)4
sorbed on polyurethane foam is shown in Figure 32.
Al-Bazi et al.33 suggested two mechanisms for the sorption of palladium(II) thiocy-
anate complex by polyether type polyurethane foam. At low thiocyanate and chloride
concentration, palladium is most likely sorbed as the neutral species Pd(NCS)2 by a
ligand addition mechanism. At high thiocyanate concentration, Pd(NCS)2; is formed
and sorbed on the foam by the previously described cation chelation mechanism.
In a recent publication, Moody et al.36 reported on the extraction of Co2*, Fe3*, Zn2*,
Cd2*, and Mn2* from potassium thiocyanate solution by polyether polyurethane foam-
sorbent. They measured the metal-to-thiocyanate and potassium-to-metal ratios asso-
ciated with the foam phase at equilibrium (Table 12). They then compared these values
46 Polyurethane Foam Sorbents in Separation Science
Table 12
THIOCYANATE-METAL AND POTASSIUM-METAL
STOICHIOMETRICS ON D2 POLYETHER POLYURETHANE FOAM FOR
VARIOUS THIOCYANATE LEVELS IN SOLUTION
Taken: 0.5 g of foam + 10 mg M"* per 100 cm3 of solution. Thiocyanate data based on elemental
nitrogen determination (allowance made for foam nitrogen). Potassium data based on potassium
determination (allowance made for KSCN sorption on foam).
CoCl2 FeCl3 Zn(N03)2 CdCl2
[KSCN] in
solution NCS:Co K:Co NCS:Fe K:Fe NCS:Zn K:Zn NCS:Cd K:Cd
From Moody, G. J., Thomas, J. D. R., and Yarmo, M. A., Anal. Proc., 20, 132, 1983. With per-
mission.
with those predicted from the calculated stability constants for the participating com-
plexes using the ECCLES computer program. 129 In the case of zinc (100 ppm) the
predicted species likely to be present in 0.1 M thiocyanate are Zn(NCS)2; and
Zn(NCS)!. These were considered to be most important in equilibrium interaction with
polyurethane foam, for the thiocyanate-to-zinc ratio of 2 to 6 falls somewhat below
that for the predicted complexes. The ratio of potassium-to-zinc was consistent with
the expectations from the predicted complexes. However, for the cobalt system it was
difficult to draw conclusions from the potassium-to-cobalt ratios of Table 12. Here the
ECCLES program predicts the presence of Co(NCS)a, Co(OH)2; and Co(NCS)* in equal
amounts for approximately 90% of all species present in solution. The investigators36
47
finally indicated that the loading of the complexes seems to be related to their ability
to form thiocyanate complexes which presumably sorb via the cation-chelation mech-
anism.
Khan and Chow44 investigated the sorption mechanism of the phosphomolybdate
anion by polyether-based polyurethane foam and indicated that the cation-chelation
mechanism cannot account for the sorption by polyether foam. More recently, sorp-
tion of gold from acidic thiocyanate solution was examined.37 The effect of several
variables on sorption was studied and optimum conditions ascertained. The percentage
extraction of gold (III) in thiocyanate solution was found to decrease by the addition
of salts such as NaCl, KC1, and LiCl. The drop in extractability was found to increase
by increasing the salt concentration, suggesting that the cation-chelation mechanism
cannot account for the extraction of the gold-thiocyanate complex. Furthermore, it
was reported38 that Fe(NCS)3L3 (where L represents the line pair and two associated
atoms in the polyurethane) is the species sorbed from solutions containing iron and
thiocyanate in molar ratio 1:3. Again, this cannot be explained by the cation-chelation
mechanism.
The work of Hamon et al.27 and Al-Bazi et al.33 represents a remarkable attempt to
determine the most probable sorption mechanism on unloaded polyether polyurethane
foam. However, additional work is necessary to prove the exact sorption mechanism
of various inorganic and organic species on unloaded polyurethane foam.
Table 13
PERCENTAGE RECOVERY OF
PRECIOUS METALS FROM
BARREN SOLUTION
Method Ag Au
g Au L ' Solution
FIGURE 33. Sorption isotherms of gold from alkaline cyanide solution on polyether
Polyurethane foam, (a) Austrian foam, (b) Hungarian foam. (From Braun, T. and
Farag, A. B., Anal. Chim. Acta, 153, 319, 1983. With permission.)
was achieved by pressing and releasing the glass plunger of the 5 g foam syringe with
its tip in the alkaline gold-cyanide solution. The second fresh foam syringe was then
applied to the same gold solution. Ten pulses were recommended with each column.
In both normal and pulsated columns, gold sorbed on the foam material is success-
fully recovered either by direct dissolution of the foam (after squeezing) in aqua regia
or by burning the foam before acid dissolution. The latter procedure is preferred and
gold is obtained in the metallic form by precipitation with hydroquinone. The re-
covered gold was analyzed gravimetrically and titrimetrically and both methods
showed recovery of gold was quantitative. 40
A further advantage of the proposed foam sorption method is its possible use for an
industrial alkaline gold-cyanide waste solution. More than 95% of gold was recovered
from the waste solution using either the normal or pulsated foam column method.40
49
Table 14
THE RECOVERY OF GOLD FROM ACIDIC SOLUTIONS OF
THIOUREA WITH DIFFERENT POLYURETHANE FOAMS
AND ACTIVE CARBON
Note: Cell dimensions of sample 1 > sample 2; and sample 3 > sample 4 > sample
5.
From Braun, T. and Farag, A. B., Anal. Chim. Acts, 66, 419, 1973. With permis-
sion.
v. Acidic Thiourea
It was reported that unloaded polyurethane foams have good ability to retain gold-
thiourea complex from acidic aqueous solutions. 41 The sorption capacity of the gold
complex on various polyether and polyester polyurethane foams has been tested. Ali-
quots (10 mjf) of gold complex (5.10~6 JV1) were shaken with 0.1 g of each foam sample
in stoppered flasks for 90 min. After equilibration the activity of the aqueous solution
was measured and the concentration of gold determined. The results (Table 14) showed
that the uptake of gold-thiourea complex by the different foams depends to some ex-
tent on cell dimension; the uptake decreases as the cell size decreases.
Although the uptake of the gold complex by 10 g of foam material is approximately
equal to the uptake of 0.2 g of active carbon under identical experimental conditions130,
the application of the inexpensive foam material seems quite advantageous.41 Figure
34 shows the effect of foam charge on the recovery of gold from acidic thiourea solu-
tion; gold-free solution can be obtained by using a foam charge of about 30 g I"1.
Furthermore, the retention rates of the gold-thiourea complex on the different foam
samples were determined and compared with those obtained on active carbon. The
half-lives of sorption of the gold-complex on all foams tested ranged between 1.3 and
2.0 min which is comparable to that obtained with active carbon (0.6 min). 41 It was
also mentioned that the palladium-thiourea complex is sorbed on unloaded polyether
polyurethane foams and the complex retained firmly on the foam. 41
40
stable complex is formed. However, if the cation is too small or relatively large, either
incomplete complexation or formation of 2:1 (or 3:2) and 1:2 (or 2:3) (metal-to-ligand)
complexes, respectively, may result.
Khan et al.42 suggested that the overall sorption equilibrium between an aqueous
solution containing a metal ion (M*), picrate ion (A"), a crown ether (CE), and the
polyurethane foam could be represented by the following equation:
where MCEA represents the ion pair between the metalcrown cation MCE* and picrate
anion A". The labels "aq" and "f" denote the aqueous and foam phases, respectively.
A formula for calculating the distribution coefficient for the ion pair MCEA has been
derived. 42 The overall equilibrium was calculated taking into consideration the distri-
bution of free crown ether, picric acid, and the ion pair (MCEA) between the two
phases. Also, the dissociation of picric acid in both phases, reaction of metal ion with
the crown ether, association of the complexed cation with picrate ion, and dissociation
of the ion pair and the metal ion-crown ether complex have also been considered.
The dependence of sorption behavior of the alkali metal cations (Na% K + , Rb + , and
Cs*), in aqueous solution containing DCHC-6 and picric acid, on the total initial con-
centration of picric acid (Ar) or crown ether (Cr) has been measured.42 The sorption
efficiency of the metal ions was found to increase with increasing concentration of
picric acid or crown ether. Figure 35 shows the effect of picric acid concentration.
However, the sorption is independent of the concentration of metal and hydrogen ions
(pH in the range 2.5 to 8). It was also indicated that the values of the distribution ratios
of alkali metal complexes increase in the order Na* < Cs+ < Pb+ < K + . Worth mention-
51
600-
4 8 12 16
3 1
A T /10 mol L'
ing is that all these results are in agreement with those expected from the theoretically
suggested equations. Furthermore, similar results have been reported for the solvent
extraction of ion pairs of Na + , K*, and Ca2* complexes of DCHC-6 with picrate and
other anions.135
On the basis of the above-mentioned results, Khan et al." came to the conclusion
that the sorption of alkali metals from an aqueous solution by polyurethane foam in
the presence of crown ether and picric acid can be considered as ion-pair extraction of
MCEA by an organic solvent of moderate dielectric constant.
Recently, the sorption of silver(I), thallium(I), barium(II), and lead(II) ions from
aqueous solution containing picric acid has been investigated.43 In the absence of picric
acid, no detectable sorption was observed. However, in the presence of other bulkier
anions, e.g., 8-anilino-l-naphthalene sulfonic acid, the sorption of thallium(I) was
even better than that obtained from aqueous picric acid up to a certain concentration
(Figures 36 and 37). Formation of an ion-pair complex between the metal ion and the
picrate ion was suggested. Sorption of the ion pairs by polyurethane foam was found
to be independent of metal ion concentration.
52 Polyurethane Foam Sorbents in Separation Science
FIGURE 36. Effect of varing the initial concentration of picric acid on the sorption
of monovalent cations: (•) Ag*, (O) IT. Conditions; 0.4 g of foam, 100 ml of solution,
1 x 1Q-4 Min cations. (From Khan, A. S., Baldwin, W. G., and Chow, A., Anal. Chim.
Acta, 146, 201, 1983. With permission.)
6.01 1 I I i T
O,
5.0
o> 4.0
o
3.0
2.4 -
-77- I
1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0
PH
The distribution coefficient of silver ion was determined as a function of silver ion
concentration at several different initial picrate ion concentrations.43 The D values
remain constant up to 7 x 10~4 Minitial concentration of silver ion, then start to decline
with a slope of approximately 0.4. This drop was attributed to the continuous decrease
in the metal ion to picrate ratio. The authors43 came to the conclusion that this sorption
system cannot be easily explained by a simple ion-pair mechanism but rather by the
previously described cation-chelation mechanism.
On the other hand, it was reported that heteropolymolybdates of phosphorus, sili-
con, arsenic, and germanium, both in the reduced and nonreduced forms, are effec-
tively sorbed by polyether polyurethane foam. 44 No detectable sorption is observed for
the hetero-atom species in the absence of molybdate. The sorption of phosphate ion
from aqueous solution containing molybdate by polyurethane foam has been examined
in some detail.44 The distribution ratio of phosphomolybdate increases as the pH in-
creases, reaches a maximum at pH 1.2, remains constant up to pH 2.5, and then de-
creases steadily (Figure 38). The sorption of phosphomolybdate by the foam was found
to depend on the molybdate concentration in the aqueous solution, reaching a maxi-
mum at about 25-fold excess of molybdate-to-phosphate. However, above 750-fold
54 Polyurethane Foam Sorbents in Separation Science
3.0
-t"
0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0
(Alkali—Metal Chloride) (M)
excess of molybdate the distribution ratio decreases. This was attributed to the proba-
ble competitive sorption of /sopolymolybdate species into the polyether foam at high
molybdate concentrations.
The effect of alkali-metal chlorides on the sorption of phosphomolybdate has been
examined in order to evaluate the possible sorption mechanism.4'1 In the presence of
lithium chloride the distribution ratio remains constant up to a certain concentration
(depending on the initial concentration of lithium chloride); then the D decreases.
However, in the presence of sodium or potassium chloride the distribution ratio ini-
tially decreases rapidly, then slowly with increasing alkali metal concentration (Figure
39). Obviously, these results show that the cation-chelation mechanism cannot explain
this system.
240
FIGURE 40. Effect of water on the sorption of Na 2 IrCl 6 from acetone solution. So-
lution, 50 ml; foam, 0.08 g; flr(IV)], 10 Mg ml; temperature, 25.0 ± 0.05°C; manual
squeezing. (From Moore, R. A. and Chow, A., Talanta, 27, 315, 1980. With permis-
sion.)
type) for the sorption and recovery of organic contaminants from water. Since then
several investigations have been published describing the application of untreated
foams as collectors in separating and concentrating chlorinated organic com-
pounds, 1046 54 polynuclear aromatic hydrocarbons, 55 58 and other organic com-
pounds. 59 - 64
In this connection, it is important to note that the untreated polyurethane foams
(polyethers or polyesters) are used as collectors for the concentration of organic com-
pounds from fairly large volumes of polluted water. Generally the water is passed
through a chromatographic column containing several foam plugs, at flow rates rang-
ing between 10 and 270 mi min'1 (column diameters are in the range 20 to 76 mm).
The collected organic compounds are then recovered from the foam either by simple
elution or Soxhlet extraction with different combinations of hexane and acetone. After
the appropriate volume reduction of the leachate using a rotary evaporator, the re-
covered compounds are generally identified and determined by gas chromatography.
It is worth noting that unloaded polyurethane foam is not specific to a certain group
of organic compounds.
Consequently, the leachate produced from the recovery of a complex mixture would
require some separation prior to its injection into the gas chromatograph. The nonse-
lective character of polyurethane foams towards organic materials is not a serious dis-
advantage as identical behavior has also been reported with other sorbents. 138139
Table 15
SORPTION EFFICIENCY OF
POLYURETHANE FOAM FOR
AROCLOR® 1254 IN FILTERED VS.
UNFILTERED LAKEWATER
Recovered (jig)
Spiked ~~~~~~~~^~"~~~~
Water type (yg) Foam Effluent Total
quantitative extraction of PCBs, dieldrin, and some DDTs from industrial and agri-
cultural waters. The average recoveries of all spiked materials were generally > 90%.
The concentration levels measured by the foam sorption method are in good agreement
with those obtained by a solvent extraction method.
In a separate study, 48 polyurethane foam was employed for the retention and deter-
mination of PCB, DDT, and Clordane in Bermuda and Sargasso Sea surface water.
A detailed examination of the different factors affecting the extraction and recovery
of various organochlorine insecticides has also been carried out by Musty and Nick-
less,49 who investigated six different foam samples having different surface areas and
densities. The sorption efficiency of methylene blue by the foam material was taken as
a criterion to the relative extraction efficiency of organic insecticides from aqueous
solution. The higher the amount of methylene blue sorbed, the higher the efficiency of
the foam material for recovering insecticides from water. Polyurethane foams sorbing
approximately 250 m mol of methylene blue per kg of foam in 24 hr were recom-
mended for use in the extraction of chlorinated insecticides and PCBs. The effect of
flow rate on the collection efficiency of a polyurethane foam column (packed with two
foam plugs each 2.2 x 4 cm) is shown in Table 16. Quantitative recoveries of 13 insec-
ticides from water were obtained using flow rates of 10 to 100 ml min~', whereas at
higher flow rates (e.g., 250 mt min"1) the sorption was less efficient. 49 - 50 As usual,
acetone and n-hexane were used to elute the insecticides from the foam column.
The recoveries of the different insecticides by the foam material were found to be
pH dependent. Complete recoveries were generally obtained at pHs ranging between 6
and 9. At pH 5, however, slightly decreased recoveries were observed (Table 17). The
authors accentuated the superiority of polyurethane foam for the sorption of chlori-
nated insecticides over the conventional activated carbon. In the latter case the re-
covered material is often different from the original one owing to the catalytic effects
exhibited by the carbon. Obviously, these effects are not present in the case of poly-
urethane foam as shown from the quantitative recoveries obtained. Moreover, the
foam material showed a very high capacity for these pesticides, and the concentration
of chloride ions (up to 25 g (.'') did not significantly affect the performance of the
foam columns which is considered to be of importance for application of the proposed
foam method in the analyses of saline waters.50 A useful study was made for the sorp-
tion efficiency of polyurethane foam in comparison with other methods including Car-
bowax® -undecane, Amberlite® XAD-4, and solvent extraction for the extraction and
determination of organochlorine insecticides and PCB from water samples.51 Lindane
and o-BHC were detected in River Leaden sample (Table 18), while the presence of
58 Polyurethane Foam Sorbents in Separation Science
Table 16
THE EFFECT OF WATER FLOW RATE ON INSECTICIDE RECOVERY
FOR FOAM UNCOATED AND COATED WITH DC-200
Recovery (%)
10 30 250 10 30 250
Concentration ml ml ml mt mt mi
Insecticide (ppb) min~' min~' min"1 min"1 min"1 min"1
o-BHC 1 101 95 49 83 86 66
Lindane 1 101 91 40 77 77 61
/3-BHC 1 101 86 44 91 83 61
Aldrin 1 99 73 46 77 67 54
p,p'-DDE 2 106 77 68 81 81 77
Dieldrin 1 106 77 58 88 82 76
Endrin 10 100 94 54 106 91 64
o,p'-DDT 10 113 84 43 106 57 56
p,p'-DDD 2 102 89 57 81 80 52
p,p'-DDT 10 114 100 26 62 30
From Musty, P. R. and Nickless, G., J. Chromatogr., 100, 83, 1974. With permission.
Table 17
THE EFFECT OF pH OF DOPED WATER ON
RECOVERY WHEN USING UNCOATED FOAM;
WATER FLOW RATE 10 mi MIN'1
Recovery (%)
Concentration
Insecticide (PPb) pH 5 pH 6 pH 7 pH 8 pH 9
Lindane, a-BHC, and Aroclor® 1260 was proved in a broad oak sample (Table 19).
As a result of this investigation the application of a combined sorbent, made of 100 g
Chromosorb® W, 50 g of n-undecane and 5 g Carbowax® 4000 monostearate, was
recommended and claimed to be better than polyurethane foam.51
In a more recent investigation,53 54 different combinations of charcoal and polyure-
thane foam (40% charcoal and 60% foam wt/vol.) were evaluated for the separation
59
Table 18
CONCENTRATION OF ORGANOCHLORINES IN RIVER
LEADON SAMPLE
Concentration
Procedure Organochlorine (ng r-)
From Musty, P. R. and Nickless, G., J. Chromatogr., 120, 369, 1976. With
permission.
Table 19
CONCENTRATION OF ORGANOCHLORINES IN
BROAD OAK SAMPLE
Concentration
Procedure Organochlorine (ng/-)
From Musty, P. R. and Nickless, G., J. Chromatogr., 120, 369, 1976. With
permission.
Table 20
RECOVERY OF BENZO(A)PYRENE (BaP) FROM SPIKED WATER
From Saxena, J., Kozuchowski, J., and Basu, D. K., Environ. Sci. Technol., 11, 682, 1977. With
permission.
100
(a)
90
cc
LU
> 80
70
60
50 I I _L I I
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
decreased in the region of 40 to 50°C and finally increased beyond 50°C reaching a
plateau at 60°C (Figure 41). The initial increase in the retention efficiency was linked
to the presence of suspended particles in water; such an increase was less pronounced
when tap-water was Millipore-filtered prior to spiking and also was not observed when
distilled water was used (Figure 41). The increase in the retention efficiency by heating
the water was attributed to the desorption of BaP from suspended particles into water
as well as to a possible change in the foam itself. The recovery of BaP from distilled
water is generally higher than that from tap water at all temperatures examined.
For sampling 20 S. of water, it was recommended to use two foam columns (each
packed with two foam plugs) and to heat the water to 60 to 65 °C before its passage
through the foam columns at 250 ml min' 1 . 56 The BaP sorbed foam was found to be
quite stable and its recovery quantitative even after storing the plugs for seven days (at
4°C). Some losses of BaP were observed when the foam plugs were stored at room
temperature.
The possibility of using polyether polyurethane foam plugs for the recovery of other
PAHs from finished and raw waters has also been examined. 5 7 A mixture of
benzo(a)pyrene, fluoranthene (FL), benzo(j)fluoranthene (BjF), benzo(k)fluoranthene
(BkF), indeno(l,2,3-cd)pyrene (IP), and benzo(ghi)perylene (BPR) has been tested.
The retention efficiencies of the individual polynuclear aromatic hydrocarbons on the
foam were generally not less than 88 and 72% from finished and raw waters, respec-
tively. In all experiments the spiked water was heated to 62 ± 2°C prior to its percola-
tion through the foam column at 250 ± 10 mjf min"1 flow rate.
The retention of PAHs on the foam plugs from large volumes of water has also been
investigated with both raw (30 I) and finished (60 i) waters. Water was spiked with a
PAH's mixture containing 500 ng t~l of fluoranthene and 100 ng i'' from each of the
other compounds and passed through foam columns maintaining optimum retention
conditions.57 Foam columns were changed after every 20 t of finished water and every
10 i of raw water. The foam plugs were eluted with acetone and cyclohexane. The
62 Polyurethane Foam Sorbents in Separation Science
Table 21
FOAM RETENTION EFFICIENCIES FOR PAH FROM
TREATED WATER
Cone in
aqueous phase Amt retained by foam Retention
Compound (ng /"') from 1 I of water (ng) (%)
Note: Water source: laboratory tap water; water volume: 60 I; cone of fluoran-
thene: 500 ppt; all others: 100 ppt; detection method: TLC-fluorometric.
From Basu, D. K. and Saxena, J., Environ. Sci. Techno!., 12, 791, 1978. With
permission.
Table 22
FOAM RETENTION EFFICIENCIES FOR PAH FROM RAW
WATER
Cone in
aqueous phase Amt retained by foam Retention
Compound (ng f~') from 1 I of water (ng) (%)
From Basu, D. K. and Saxena, J., Environ. Sci. Technol., 12, 791, 1978. With
permission.
results of these investigations are summarized in Tables 21 and 22. In addition, the
recovery of PAH from unspiked finished water using 60 i of water was tried.57
The application of a direct gas chromatographic method for measuring the amount
of PAH in the eluate (after the preconcentration step on the foam column) was not
possible because of the presence of several contaminants, which are also concentrated
on the foam and eluted with acetone and cyclohexane. Some other impurities from the
foam itself could also be leached during the elution process. For these reasons a
cleanup step for the eluate was found to be necessary before the gas chromatographic
step.57 A cleanup procedure based on a solvent partitioning method was recommended
to eliminate some impurities.141 However, to remove all impurities, an additional
cleanup step involving a short Florisil® column was suggested (Figure 42).
The gas-liquid chromatographic conditions used failed to separate the isomers
benzo(j)fluoranthene and benzo(k) fluorancene and therefore combined values have
been given for them.57 The technique described detected as low as 0.1 ng I'1 of each
individual PAH.
63
BaP BPR
IP/v
Uncleaned
vJU
I
12 16 20 24 28 32 36
Time (min.)
D
<
oi
2 S
3
[T, vo ?
J
^ ^O , . ^O vo . . csl rt
>H — 0 I I 0 -' I I (Nl ^
Pi .S
W « H
1 0
^ O ^ l ^ ^ " ^ } ^ ^ O
Q d I O d d d <N t± D.
U ^
Pi oo ^ I °1 ^ "! 1 "i ^ u
^ /—s d —• d d <S —i *o JS
O O K
fc
D . M . . ." Q
Q >-J "^ ^ r^oo^qrnorn— ^^O-^*NOO " y
Q_, O TfTj-(s^^<*>^H^^ oi>noosd^^ ^ fc.
W '^
t_—
— <NI •* I^ r<» t^ Tt
—— ,
(^O^^Oi^i
— m
-
^ U«
' ^
R 2
W ^ rr> 2
Z . -" KC.
r-\
W ^ r- ^ °! ^ i i "l,1^. °. °^ i "° >.
c^O 6 o o ' o < l I 6 — •*'•* 5 , - g ^ . y
f* Sj
/"S
^ -5>> «
U
-o
^
|
( J P Q v o S i m - H r ^ O N O N i n T a ^ E ' ^ O
(/5Q d l d d d d - , ^ g £ S § S
m
g g
>—i r-1 os
5o <
I II 1
L > ^ i - 4 >
rr w (N
<StJ^ v^ °^ i l ! ^ ^ °1 ^ -^ nJ 1 *- a.
D^m o •v' wi o I d d r - i o d S H S S S - C
lH> g | 2 il ^
c3 z
, &
<
T
"
o
^.°°
moou-.
«
en
^
u-i
"i
0\
^.
O
°;
I-
i * S o & ^^
S C U i ^
I—I O <Nro - H I O t T j S i S v . —
&
Pn(J 2 U U 0 -
r j jhfH
fi _*.
d
cc -^t
d
rn (N »^i fN v-i —. * ^J ^ 0
- ' . C"a J "
°o ^ - . I S •= | I 1
W ^ \q m?
c \r-fr-)—<fs—•—'TTVOTTOOO^O <u J 5 £ « u "o
fT* 1 ^ 1 d oo'^ioda^drjr-'dd-^ovdm -S t;S«^ dJ
* W o o m « - « -* r- vo =o m , o vg g g « g , f-;
jir ^J cd i_ g g G 3
O < „ « . m N -* N t~. 00 >• g .9 g g ^
CO M1 d I 6 6 d - o <s § « 2 - o S §
Wt" „, u »^ « u C
CO « ^ g i -a '5
>H _, S ^ S g u C
0 1 0
nJ < ^ i i ^ ^ l ^ ^ . G S S ^ - ^
< < N O I I d d I m TT g
c
S u c o
o U 3 C ->
•
Z * * I o 2 g
« N « I i i <"! I >-. °; 1 S« I 8 S
3 o I I I o I o o ! fe £ 3 £ ,g
Cu S ° .S -o o -o
&•
O
- " . i ^ ^ i t -
d l I d o l o -
s Ǥ i i ^
3. g "3 » fi «
S
f"1 o ? >. "§ S Isl
s ; i 3§ o °^
s I o s i c s n r s c g r s r 8 ^ ^ 1^11 «
§
rf » o u o o g Ji g| > ^ I
W C " S U M ^ M f e M C L M S M O S M n o O « > H H H E
aj l i:L
OS (« £J5. i.£5S«£a,£- '£ = S £ £
OS s , « « ffl S « H < , < u •. b
65
Table 24
DETERMINATION OF ALKYLBENZENE SULFONATE
IN RIVER WATER
20 — 5 5.7
40 — 5 5.5
20 5 10 11.0
20 10 15 13.8
Small river water in Ikeda city, pH = 7; ABS content: 6.4 ppm by Meth-
ylene blue method.
From Tanaka, T., Hiiro, K., and Kawahara, A., Bunseki Kagaku (Japan
Analyst), 22, 523, 1973. With permission.
Table 25
RECOVERY OF A SERIES OF
PHTHALATE ESTERS UNDER FLOW
CONDITIONS
Recovery (%)
Note: For each test, 100 ml of water spiked with 0.1 pig of
each phthalate was run on a column of five foam
plugs at 10 mt min~'
methylene blue. The test was employed for the detection of alkylbenzene sulfonate in
river water (Table 24).
Gough and Gesser60 described a method for the collection and recovery of phthalate
ester (usually eroded from synthetic polymer tubing) from water with polyurethane
foam sorbents. They tested batches of polyurethane foams having different densities.
A series of column tests on phthalates, with side chains varying in length from one to
ten carbons, was run with batches A and B (Table 25). Each of the five foam plugs (50
67
O DMP
a DEP
o
o
<n
CC
Foam Number
(a)
FIGURE 44. Profiles of phthalate esters on foam (density 0.019 g
mt~') column of five plugs, numbered 1 to 5 from top to bottom. In
each test, 100 ml of water containing 0.1 mg of the phthalate was
passed at a flow rate of 10 ml min~' down the column, followed by
100 mi clean water. Each point represents the percentage of the initial
spike found on the foam, (a) DMP and DEP; (b) DnBP, DAP and
DnHxP; (c) DiBP, BBP, DHpP, DEHP, DOP, and DiDP. (See Table
25 for abbreviations.) (From Gough, K. M. and Gesser, H. D., J.
Chromatogr., 115, 383, 1975. With permission.)
Foam N u m b e r
FIGURE 44b
3 4
Foam Number
FIGURE 44c
69
Time
A further application of polyether polyurethane foam sorbents is their use for the
collection of phenol in nonaqueous media.63 The uptake of phenolics from /i-heptane
was examined in batch experiments by comparing the infrared band at 1600 cm"1 of
the solution before and after shaking. The sorption of phenol and mixed cresols by
polyurethane foam and three other sorbents was measured and compared. No phenol
could be detected on attapulgite clay and porcelalumina sorbents, and the uptake of
phenolics by polyurethane foam (60 to 85%) was found to be generally higher than
that of activated carbon (45%). Moreover, the flow method using polyurethane foam
sorbents gave better results for the collection of phenolics from n-heptane or methyl-
cyclohexane solutions. The break through capacity of the foam was found to be 0.8 to
0.9 g/g foam employing a flow rate of 5 to 10 ml min"1. For the clay sorbent, however,
it was 0.038 to 0.045 g/g sorbent under the same experimental conditions. In static and
dynamic experiments, the sorbed phenolics could be recovered from the sorbent by
acetone elution and the sorbent could thus be reused.
Another useful application of polyurethane foam sorbents is the collection of oil
from surface waters.64 This method depends mainly on the physical sorption of oil on
the surfaces of the foam material using a simple apparatus designed specially for this
purpose and carried by boats which move over water at speeds of 0.5 to 3 mph. It was
70 Polyurethane Foam Sorbents in Separation Science
possible to collect surface oil on the foam and recover it by squeezing. Thereafter the
foam can be reused.
Table 26
COLLECTION OF POLYCHLORINATED BIPHENYLS (PCB) VAPORS ON
POLYURETHANE FOAM PLUGS
% On GFA
PCB in air (ng nr3) % On first PUF plug6 filter
Flow rate Volume air
(I min'1) (m3) Tri- Tetra- Penta- Tri- Tetra- Penta- Tri- Tetra- Penta-
From Bidleman, T. F. and Olney, C. E., Bull. Environ. Contam. Toxicol., 11, 442, 1971. With per-
mission.
Table 27
COLLECTION OF PCB VAPORS IN
GREENBURG-SMITH IMPINGER
PCB in air
(ng nr3) % In impinger'
Flow rate Volume air
(jf min-1) (m3) Tetra- Penta- Tetra- Penta-
inants. Also, some investigators used a glass fiber filter to remove paniculate matter
present in ambient air. On the other hand, several researchers preferred to introduce
the tested compounds directly to the foam column by injecting a suitable amount of
their solution in an organic volatile solvent into the first foam sorbent plug.71
Bidleman and Olney66 examined, for example, the collection efficiency of polychlor-
inated biphenyls on a polyurethane foam sorbent by employing glass beads coated with
the compound of interest to serve as a known source of atmospheric PCB. The beads
were placed a few inches to several feet from the collection device, thus regulating the
levels in the air being sampled. After completing the sampling step, the foam plugs
were extracted with petroleum ether in Soxhlet extractors and the insecticides deter-
mined in the concentrated extracts by gas chromatography. It should be mentioned
that a cleanup step of the extracts is recommended on an alumina column to remove
peaks appearing in the blank foam itself.
A comparative study was made for the collection of PCB isomers on both polyure-
thane foam sorbent and a Greenburg-Smith impinger containing ethylene glycol.66 The
results presented in Tables 26 and 27 show the superiority of the foam sorbent for the
sorption of PCB isomers even when fast flow rates were used.
Polyurethane foam sorbent-containing air samplers were successfully employed for
the collection of PCB in open-ocean atmosphere.66 The GC patterns matched Aro-
72 Polyurethane Foam Sorbents in Separation Science
clor® 1248 and the concentrations in the air were calculated as both Aroclor© 1248
and 1254. Generally, most of the PCBs were found on the first foam plug.
In a recent investigation, Lewis et al. 71 employed a standard high-volume air sam-
pler146 as modified by SURC (Syracuse University Research Corporation 147 ) (Figure
11). The coated glass beads situated in the lower compartment of the SURC sampler
were substituted with a 5.5 x 7.6 cm cylindrical polyether polyurethane foam sorbent
plug (density 0.021 g cm"3). The foam plugs were held under a slight compression in
the 5 cm (i.d.) x 7.6 cm lower chamber of the glass sampling module. It was indicated
that the foam plug is at least as efficient a sorbent as the cottonseed oil for most
pesticides tested.71 PCBs and PCNs tested include y-BHC, Aldrin, pp'-DDE, pp'-DDT,
and Mirex.
In order to determine the ability of polyurethane foam to hold the sorbed PCBs and
PCNs, microgram quantities of the test compounds in n-hexane were injected into the
plug and air was passed through it into a second plug at 225 I min'1 (column diameter,
3 cm) for 24 hr. The chlorinated hydrocarbons remaining in the plugs were recovered
with 5% diethyl ether in /i-hexane by separate Soxhlet extractors. A cleanup process
was found to be necessary and carried out on the concentrated extracts before the gas
chromatographic analysis (Figure 46). Except for Aldrin, 88 to 106% of the pesticides
were retained on the fortified foam sorbent plug with only 2 to 6% recovered from the
second plug. The percentage of Aldrin remaining in the upper trap was found to be 61
and in the lower trap 4. This poor retention of Aldrin is linked to its probable oxidation
to dieldrin. The retention of Aroclor® 1242 and Halowax® 1001 was found to be 79
and 57%, respectively.
The collection efficiencies of separate mixtures of organochlorine pesticides were
also determined by volatilization from a wool felt filter into a tandem pair of foam
sorbent plugs. It was indicated that there is little dependency of trapping efficiency on
apparent air concentrations in the subnanogram to nanogram per cubic meter range
(Table 28).70 The retention efficiency was found to be generally increased by decreasing
the volatility of pesticide compounds. Similar conclusions were reported by others. 65 - 72
Two polyester polyurethane foam sorbent plugs placed in a suitable sampling appa-
ratus (Figure 11) were successfully employed for the collection of some chlorinated
insecticides (dieldrin, heptachlor, trans-chlordane, and lindane) in field analysis.75 The
equipment developed allowed the determination of the insecticide concentration levels
at different heights above the ground (within several meters). This permitted the deter-
mination of pesticide concentration profiles. High sorption efficiency and capacity
were reported for the foam sorbent examined.
Some measurements have also been carried out with two commercial mixtures of
PCB and PCN. 71 Using a flow rate of 225 I min"1, collection efficiencies (single plug)
for PCB mixture averaged from 70 to 85%, while the more volatile PCN mixture was
collected less efficiently (44 to 61%). The reduction of air flow to 140 i min"1 was
found to have little effect on the trapping efficiencies.
In another investigation, Erickson et al.76'78 recommended polyurethane foam as an
efficient collector for polychlorinated naphthalenes in ambient air. They used an air
sampler built of a glass fiber filter and two polyurethane foam sorbent plugs in tan-
dem. PCNs collected on the glass filter and the foam plugs were triply extracted with
toluene and the PCN concentrations measured by gas chromatography. The presence
of PCNs was confirmed by mass spectra or by monitoring the chloride isotope ratio.
It was reported that PCNs detected in air near a manufacturing site had an average
concentration of 150 and 1400 ng m"3 during two successive 24-hr sampling periods.
All isomers were found to have good abilities for sorption on polyurethane foams with
the majority (93%) sorbed in the first foam plug. The remainder was found in the
second foam plug and in the glass fiber filter. The percentages of mono-, di-, and
73
O
o.
C/3
LU
DC
QC
UJ
D
ca
O
o
8 10 12 14 16 18 20 22
TIME (minutes)
Table 28
COLLECTION EFFICIENCIES OF
POLYURETHANE FOAM FOR
CHLORINATED PESTICIDES VS. AIR
CONCENTRATIONS (225 I MIN'1)
Statistical
Calc. air Collection data
cone efficiency
(ng m'3)
10 11 12 13 14
about 50 mg of a single compound of interest. The slight vacuum in the system created
by high volume air flow caused a stream of air to be drawn through the coated bead
column, bleading sample vapors into the mixing chamber. The flow rate through the
lead column was adjusted to 6 to 25 ml miir'.
The frontal movements of hexachlorobenzene (HCB) and two PCB isomers (DCB
and TCB) through the foam material have been measured using the previously de-
scribed system. It was indicated that vapor penetration through the foam column is
dependent on both total air volume and the volatility of PCB compound. The break-
through volume (the point at which the concentration of solute in the column effluent
is half the concentration introduced to the column) was found 82 to be in good agree-
ment with the retention volume obtained in the high-volume elution experiments81 for
the same chlorinated biphenyl isomers. A method was developed for predicting the
movement of the more volatile chlorinated hydrocarbons through polyurethane foam
sorbent and the amount of the foam needed to prevent breakthrough. This can be seen
in Figure 49, where the quantity of the chlorinated compound found on the individual
foam plug was calculated and expressed as cumulative percentage of the total amount
recovered in all 15 plugs. At 500 m3, 90% of the TCB was found within the first 4 cm
of foam sorbent. At 900 m3, however, 7 cm of foam was required to retain 90% of
TCB.
Vannucchi and Berlincioni83 examined the possibility of using a polyurethane foam
sorbent for the sorption of Apirolio® 1431C vapors (a polychlorinated biphenyl die-
lectric fluid containing 42% chlorine). They designed an experiment using conditions
very similar to those present in electrical industry manufacturing capacitors. Polyure-
thane foam packed in a simple sampler consisting of a tube of 2.8 cm internal diameter
and 5 cm length was employed for the collection of Apirolio® vapors. These investi-
gators compared the sorption efficiency of the foam with a Greenburg-Smith impinger
filled with isopropyl alcohol or diethyl glycol using a flow rate of 17 i. min"1 and 1 m3
76 Polyurethane Foam Sorbents in Separation Science
100 -
15
sample volume. The foam plugs were extracted with petroleum ether in a Soxhlet ex-
tractor (60 discharge cycles) and the extracts were brought to a suitable volume and
analyzed by gas chromatography. The highest recovery was obtained with polyure-
thane foam plugs (99.9%), followed by diethylene glycol (99.45%), and finally by
isopropyl alcohol (98.6%).
Some authors 84 recommended the use of polyurethane foam sorbent for trapping
high molecular weight chlorinated organic compounds in air by a high-volume air flow
system (450 to 500 f min'1) and sample size of 1000 to 2000 m3. For more volatile
organic compounds, Florisil® sorbent was better using low-volume sampling condi-
tions (20 i min" 1 ). With these two systems it was possible to identify about 30 PCB
("fingerprint") isomers in air samples examined which match those in Aroclor® 1242.
Heavier PCBs (Aroclor® 1254) were estimated to be about 10% of the total present in
the samples. The data obtained confirm the presence of selected organic pollutants in
the atmosphere and remote marine regions and provide a baseline against which future
pollutants may be measured.
A comparative study of the collection efficiency and sampling reproducibility of
polyurethane foam and Tenax® sorbents for field sampling of PCB and chlorinated
hydrocarbon pesticides of different volatilities has been carried out.85 In this investi-
gation, air was pulled at 350 to 500 i min"1 through a 10 cm diameter or 20 x 25-cm
glass fiber filter followed by two 7.6 x 7.6-cm polyurethane foam plugs or two 10-g
Tenax® traps (54 cm2 cross-section) using a Ratron® DR-313 brushless pump. Petro-
leum ether was employed for the recovery of pesticides from the sorbents in a Soxhlet
extractor and the extracts were cleaned by alumina chromatography and then separated
on a silicic acid column. Fractions from the columns were shaken with 7% fuming
sulfuric acid and the PCB/DDE fraction was further treated with alcoholic potassium
hydroxide and determined as usual by gas chromatography. Comparisons were made
between the foam and Tenax® sorbents for collecting HCB (hexachlorobenzene),
PCB, chlordane, and toxaphene. The concentration levels of chlorinated hydrocarbon
pesticides determined by the two sampling methods were in good agreement except for
HCB which was very poorly retained by the foam owing to its high volatility.
In another comparative study,86 the retention and collection abilities of airborne
polychlorinated biphenyls by polyurethane foam (plug, 1.3 cm diameter and 3.8 cm
thick), Florisil® (0.3 g, 100 to 200 mesh), and Amberlite® XAD-2 resin (0.4 g, 20 to
50 mesh) were examined. The investigators employed two or three columns (0.9 cm
diameter) packed with each sorbent. The retention efficiencies were determined by the
direct spike of the sorbent with the PCB compound dissolved in a suitable volatile
solvent; after drying, air was allowed to draw through the column. Retention and
collection efficiencies were calculated by dividing the amount of 14C-labeled 2,5,2' ,5'-
tetrachlorobiphenyl (TCB) recovered by the first column by the total amounts of TCB
recovered from all columns used in tandem for each sorbent (Tables 29 and 30). Al-
though the Amberlite® XAD-2 and Florisil® gave higher TCB collection efficiencies
than polyurethane, the authors indicated that the use of larger amounts of foam sor-
bent could produce better collection efficiencies.
Lewis et al.72'87 stated that polyurethane foam can easily trap the less volatile com-
pounds and suggested the use of a combination of foam and a granular sorbent for the
retention of more volatile compounds in air. A comprehensive investigation of the
sorption of various insecticides by the foam alone and by its combination with
Chromo-102, Propak R, XAD-2, Tenax® GC, or Florisil®, has been made. The dual
sorbent trap used is shown in Figure 50. Measurements made with six PCBs are shown
in Table 31. The dichlorobiphenyl and one of the two trichlorobiphenyls tested were
more efficiently collected by the dual trap than by the trap containing polyurethane
foam alone. The chromatograms shown in Figure 51 indicate the preferential vapori-
78 Polyurethane Foam Sorbents in Separation Science
Table 29
TETRACHLOROBIPHENYL PARTICULATE RETENTION
EFFICIENCIES
From Doskey, P. V. and Andren, A. W., Anal. Chim. Acta, 110, 129, 1979. With permission.
Table 30
TETRACHLOROBIPHENYL VAPOR COLLECTION EFFICIENCIES
From Doskey, P. V. and Andren, A. W., Anal. Chim. Acta, 110, 129, 1979. With permission.
zation of the more volatile PCBs from the fortified felt pad (trace b) and more efficient
trapping of the less volatile PCBs by the polyurethane foam sorbent alone. However,
no differences were observed between the sorbent systems for seven other pesticides
(Table 32). Repetitive use of the sampling cartridges over long periods of time revealed
no problems associated with retention of chemicals or buildup of interfering back-
ground material.
In a more recent publication, Lewis and MacLeod88 used a combination of open-cell
79
^®
G'S -^ rvj oo fNj r~- m
£ -~ — ON oo ON ON ON
a \ ** "
g !
tf 5©
.8«o i oI —'00 -too moo oo
Z rtx oo
o * £a
oo a £
*
W as
z
ivl
<°
en \ N
L3J fi C '
r*i O SO *£> -H f) 00 *C 1/1
'•s r/3 -^ O<C <^OONOOO\Os
fa
g Z S x
R
°G
° 1§ §
d
8
« <
U S Q ~^
*
J<
'S
'§
£
P-l§ ° S « M t ^ C T \ O O f M < S S
** & rtB-oooooooo(7\a\ n>
SI I ! S
m R «
- SU ^ r^
^ U H C S S
JB Z Z f ^ •"
^>tL|W C § 2 < S O — — ON^f <N
C^hHfV^ O S « OOOOOOOOt^OO O
H U §
HH ^r1
S
«
(2 J32 T*
fc O ^ o S
b cw (3
WD^ J g
^7 ^ P ** "^3
^ ^ § S < S v o \ o ^ t M \ 0 G
Oi-J O.2 ^omoooNONOo
ba
Pg . 1
u5 t
r
3^ If"! a
O —•> O O O O O i« . Q
w
o
U
^' B 7 7 7 7 1 1 I s
crt I I I I I tz r
2? r-ir^'Nir1rirl S o
m ^i-5- 6 6 d d d - S O
S
"3
3 Ii
u !->
J ' TJ
S
O
<s
—
c
ca
^ 1 „, S 2 o
KH 0 5 ,2 «
nU £ -, c I s- (j!
(••i a 2 « .' o
S 3 S o. >o <«"
sc §
^5
.. E ^-««: s i
— fin H «n m TJ-
u
a> ^j
16
Time/Min.
foam sorbent were leached by various solvents; e.g., acetone n-hexane, petroleum
ether, etc., using a simple elution procedure or Soxhlet extractor. The extracts were
usually passed through an alumina or silica gel column for cleaning, and after their
concentration to the appropriate volume, injected directly into a gas chromatograph
using a suitable column. The pesticides were usually identified and quantitated on the
basis of GC peak heights, or areas of the corresponding standards. In some cases the
amounts of pesticides were determined on both the foam sorbent and the glass bead
column used as a feeder source for the pesticide under investigation.
In some other cases, especially with polychlorinated biphenyls which can be present
in many isomeric forms, a derivatization technique was employed.148 By using this
82 Polyurethane Foam Sorbents in Separation Science
Table 32
HIGH-VOLUME COLLECTION EFFICIENCIES OF PESTICIDES ON FOAM/
GRANULAR SORBENT COMBINATIONS
Foam/
Calc. air cone Foam Foam/ Foam/Po- Foam/ Tenax® Foam/
Pesticide (ng nr3) alone Chromo 102 rapak R XAD-2 GC Floi-isi!®
Aldrin 0.3—3.0 28 34 35 33 40
p,p'-DDE 0.6—6.0 89 83 93 135 71 138
p,p'-DDT 1.8—18.0 83 77 89 138 69 119
Mirex 1.8—18.0 93 94 95 132 78 123
Tech. Chlordane 15—150 73 85 74 87 73 97
a-Chlordane 1.5—15.0 114 108 96 102 100 98
y-Chlordane 1.5—15.0 126 104 91 96 93 100
From Lewis, R. G. and Jackson, M. D., Anal. Chem., 54, 592, 1982. With permission.
Table 33
COLLECTION EFFICIENCIES FOR ORGANOCHLORINE
PESTICIDES
Not vaporized. Value based on retention efficiency (RE) = 81.0 (RSD = 10%, n
= 6).
From Lewis, R. G. and MacLeod, K. E., Anal. Chem., 54, 310, 1982. With permission.
method all non-fully chlorinated PCB species were converted to a single isomeric spe-
cies, DCB (decachlorobiphenyl) with antimony(V) chloride, e.g.,
Cl Cl
o^o
Cl Cl Cl Cl Cl Cl
2,2,5,5', tetrachlorobiphenyl Decachlorobiphenyl (17)
and the gas chromatographic pattern greatly simplified as the many peaks were re-
placed by only one peak for decachlorobiphenyl.74 The detection limit is also enhanced
83
Table 34
COLLECTION EFFICIENCIES FOR SEMIVOLATILE
ORGANOCHLORINE COMPOUNDS AND PCB
From Lewis, R. G. and MacLeod, K. E., Anal. Chem., 54, 310, 1982. With
permission.
as the electron capture detector is much more sensitive to DCB than to partially chlor-
inated biphenyls. The advantages and disadvantages of this derivatization method have
been discussed in detail in Reference 74.
Although polyurethane foam sorbents have extensively been employed for the reten-
tion of many chlorinated pesticides in air, the type of foam used is rarely specified.
Fortunately, Adams and Caro65 made an excellent comparative investigation on the
sorption of various insecticides in air by polyether and polyester polyurethane foams
under otherwise the same experimental conditions. No significant differences between
the ester and ether forms of foam were observed with respect to the trapping and
extraction of the pesticides examined. The sorption of different organochlorine insec-
ticides in air has been investigated also as a function of temperature; complete recov-
eries were obtained even on using a temperature as high as 52°C (Table 35). The reten-
tion of organochlorine insecticides in aerosols was also tested. Generally collection of
the examined compounds from aerosol with polyurethane foams was inefficient (Table
36).
Table 35
ESTER-FORM PUF TRAPPING
EFFICIENCY FOR INSECTICIDES AT 52°C
(31.0 m3 OF AIR PASSED THROUGH THE
SYSTEM)
a-BHC 92 92
Aldrin 106 106
p,p'-DDE 99 99
o,p'-DDT 101 101
p,p'-DDD 88 88
p,p'-DDT 104 106
Lindane 95 95
/3-BHC 98 103
Heptachlor epoxide 88 88
Dieldrin 83 83
Endrin 98 101
Table 36
THE TRAPPING OF PESTICIDE AEROSOLS BY A 5-
CM ESTER-FORM PUF PLUG (8.5 m3 OF AIR
PASSED THROUGH THE SYSTEM)
In chamber In PUF
Compound In bomb washings trap Total
foams show about the same sorption ability towards organophosphorus pesticides. The
foam sorbent retained these compounds efficiently at room temperature as well as at
higher temperatures.
Table 37 shows, for example, the retention efficiency of polyurethane foam at 52°C.
As in the case of organochlorine insecticides, the trapping ability of polyurethane
foams for organophosphorus compounds injected as aerosols is substantially lower
than that of molecular vapors (Table 38).
85
Table 37
ESTER-FORM POLYURETHANE FOAM
PESTICIDE TRAPPING EFFICIENCY AT
52°C°
Methyl parathion 0 95 95
Ronnel 5 102 107
Parathion 0 88 88
,Ethion 0 96 96
Carbophenothion 0 82 82
Diazinon 5 90 95
Malathion 3 90 93
Table 38
THE TRAPPING OF ORGANOPHOSPHORUS
PESTICIDE AEROSOLS BY A 5-CM ESTER-FORM
POLYURETHANE FOAM PLUG0
Table 39
COLLECTION EFFICIENCIES FOR
ORGANOPHOSPHORUS PESTICIDES
Table 40
COLLECTION EFFICIENCIES FOR SEMIVOLATILE
ORGANOPHOSPHORUS COMPOUNDS
Diazinon 3.0—30.0 63 72 59 71 76 72
Methly parathion 1.8—18.0 91 82 72 80 87 83
Ethyl parathion 3.6—36 96 85 72 81 86 83
Malthion 0.9—9.0 97 88 78 89 91 81
• Average 6 to 12 determinations.
From Lewis, R. G. and Jackson, M. D., Anal. Chem.,54, 592, 1982. With permission.
t/i«
ffi P 5
H
D
Z «
"-I
.5C r<i Tf ^± t Tfr «n v£> ^>
3
O
J^ &H (V 5
§
Q O I
S3
CL(
OH &«
H-I -
° £ ^ "^ ""• ^ ^ ^
^
V)
^ Q
-
^ LJ *e n -^fn»o»rim ^t O O ,r t1
^Z ^ ^ 2 2 . 3 g
^ W 'S „• -a
e$3 r JS I
"^ O -J6 o o o v o - v r , ! - «
r,c/5 ™S ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ~ **: *-*. ---^^ ^ ^
t^-^ [2^ iO«nO\nw-l r<i(Sm ^4> g/ O
2N
pq 3 » " 2 & S- 1
«o ^ i s ^ §
HH ^ 3. U C nJ C
?£
^ y "^
Is
Z^
& 5
3 •-
Z < T £ * - O Q Q Q Q Q - g ^ £
02Z zzz
_il
"* o W
|
*
6 ^ ?' l i-^ s"
= >
^ p n O i M S ( j i -
6 1
• ° p 2 ^ 3 - G ^ " "
H<!^! "o & oo«in"o ^ Q Q U<N ft, pf
m
fj"J D, K c\Tf'oomm OZZ rr <u
X O
O ^ M aQC ^
^ ^ <^ —' P p
s •• 6c a
•*<
2 ^ ?
§ ^ r - > . a
Q Q K <3a a I I
^5 JS £ ssss^ §;s;s ||§ | ?
^ X ° -ooo<N ^r,m 3 ^ 2 S g
p£ 11.2 I 5
<S s ill 1 J
S|
<d . SJt§ l§|
g hi -gr-"^
is'i |! I3
^S 2 Sx *|| ,§tS 8 '
<Jo< v ^ Ss sD< ..—a c «
Sg < | ¥«I||l--SSs
^ ^
! ' -si,itllli
Sli! 1
§ ^ ^Q
ft? n Z
I^ ^I
!!
J3 c C u A g | s g . 3
fO
t Q i ^§t - S
^ C ^ I & K^ §n -^ ^C 1
^ H f t ii aO s
CH J 3 ^ X u J 3 j - i « J j U ' S £
ft,u,fl,cau«6aa Z . b
88 Polyurethane Foam Sorbents in Separation Science
filter for the PAHs examined were less than 5% except for chrysene +
benzo(a)anthracene 4- triphenylene, benzo(a) pyrene + benzo(e)pyrene, o-phenyleno-
pyrene, and benzo(ghi)perylene + anthracene, where the percentages of trapping are
43.4, 94.6, and 100%, respectively. Most of the PAHs tested were efficiently collected
on the first foam plug except for phenanthrene + anthracene.
The same investigators90 made a recovery test for the different PAHs from air using
a glass fiber filter (2 cm diameter) and two polyurethane foam plugs (2.3 cm diameter)
placed into glass tubes (2 cm diameter) in series (Figure 15). Each PAH (25 ^g) was put
on the glass fiber filter and clean air was allowed to pass through the tubes at 41 I
min~' for 24 hr. The PAHs, except phenanthrene, were moved away from the glass
fiber filter and trapped efficiently on the first polyurethane foam plug. Recoveries were
more than 90%, but for phenanthrene it was only 79.2%.
Thrane and Mikalsen91 examined several sorbents for the collection of PAHs in the
gaseous phase; polyurethane foam was found to be the most appropriate. They used a
simple air sampler (Figure 12) made of a glass fiber filter (14.2 cm diameter; for col-
lecting particulate matter) and cylindrical polyurethane foam plugs (11 cm diameter, 5
cm thick). Air was drawn through the sampler at a rate of 417 I min"' employing a
vacuum pump. This system was used for the collection of PAH in real air samples and
the organic pollutants were recovered from the filter and foam plugs with cyclohexane
in a Soxhlet apparatus. It was reported that cleaning of the foam plugs before use is a
very important step to eliminate any interference in the subsequent gas chromato-
graphic analysis." The plugs were squeezed in toluene at 100°C and then extracted
with acetone for 24 hr in a Soxhlet apparatus followed by extraction with cyclohexane
for the same period. Although the cleaning procedure suggested is time consuming, the
plugs once cleaned can be used several times with the same efficiency. Following the
recommended procedure, it was possible to collect a wide range of volatile PAHs on
polyurethane foam plugs. Only a minor part of the volatile PAHs is found in the glass
fiber filter. In some samples an average of 5 to 6% of the total PAHs collected was
found to be retained by the glass filter, 65 to 70% on the first polyurethane foam plug
and 25 to 30% on the second plug. However, it was noted that the distribution of
PAHs between the glass filter and the foam plugs can be influenced by the concentra-
tion and the composition of air pollutants as well as sampling conditions."
Table 42
RETENTION AND COLLECTION EFFICIENCIES FOR CARBAMATES,
UREAS, TRIAZINES, AND PYRETHRINS
Carbamates
Propoxur 5 61.4 10 6 77. 6 37 6 96.7 11 6
Carbofuran 15 55.3 12 6 64. 2 46 6 87.2 14 6
Bendiocarb 50 57.3 11 6 69. 8 43 6 62.1 14 6
Mexacarbate 10 62.8 19 6 62. 7 41 6 89.8 14 6
Carbaryl 100 56.6 14 6 63. 6 53 6 b
13 6
Ureas
Monuron 19 87.0 6 6 91. 2 6 5 NV
Diuron 20 84.1 8 6 90 .0 2 5 NV
Linuron 20 86.7 8 6 92 .5 4 5 NV
Terbuthiuron 18 85.0 8 6 88 .8 8 5 NV
Fluometuron 20 91.4 10 6 101 3 5 NV
Chlortoluron 20 86.2 11 6 92 .0 7 5 NV
Triazines
Simazine 10 103 6 5 101 9 6 NV
Atrazine 10 104 7 5 98 .9 7 6 NV
Propazine 10 105 11 5 99.9 14 6 NV
Pyrethrins
Pyrethrin I (9.7)< 90.5 10 6 95..6 22 5 NV
Pyrethrin II (6.1)' 88.6 11 6 69.9 29 5 NV
Allethrin 25 69.2 9 5 58..3 12 6 NV
D- trans-allethrin 25 76.8 9 6 74..4 9 5 NV
Dicrotophos 25 72.0 22 6 71 .7 8 5 NV
Resmethrin 25 76.5 14 6 66.7 14 6 NV
Fenvalerate 25 87.9 3 6 57 .2 20 3 NV
From Lewis, R. G. and MacLeod, K. E., Anal. Chem.,54, 310, 1982. With permission.
97% collection efficiencies at concentration levels of 5.6 to 111 pg m"3. The retention
of some pyrethrins was also examined and retention values of 57 to 96% were given
(Table 42). Furthermore, retention measurements have indicated that both ureas (89 to
101%) and triazines (99 to 101%) could be quantitatively trapped on polyurethane
foam if present in air (Table 42). These pesticides were detectable at 1 ^g m"3 or less in
1 m 3 air samples.
The collection of various carbamate compounds, e.g., 2,3,5-Landrin® , Methiocarb,
Mexacarbate, Aminocarb, Carbaryl, Carbofuren, and Propoxur in air by polyurethane
foam has also been tried.65-72 Unlike other organic pollutants, the retention efficiencies
of carbamates in air samples were very low. However, their collection from aerosols
was quite high (Tables 43 and 44). These results suggested that polyurethane foam can
be used as an effective trap for these pesticides when present in airborne aerosols.65
Tests of the derivatization of the carbamate insecticides for analysis by electron-cap-
ture gas chromatography showed that the pentafluoropropionic anhydride proce-
90 Polyurethane Foam Sorbents in Separation Science
Table 43
ESTER-FORM POLYURETHANE
FOAM TRAPPING EFFICIENCY FOR
PESTICIDES AT 52°C°
Propoxur 82 10 92
Carbaryl 78 0 78
Carbofuran 88 8 96
Aminocarb 68 5 73
Methiocarb 91 3 94
Mexacarbate 62 2 64
Table 44
THE TRAPPING OF PESTICIDE AEROSOLS BY
A 5-CM3 ESTER-FORM PUF"
Table 45
COLLECTION EFFICIENCY FOR 2,4-D BUTYL
ESTER ON 45 x 50 MM POLYURETHANE PLUGS
OVER 24-HR PERIOD
Amount
Amount in U- found in
Air flow Total tube foam plug
rate air vol- (us) (eg) Total
(1
V* ume recovery
min"') (m3) Added left 1 2
From Grover, R. and Kerr, L. A., J. Environ. Sci. Health, B16, 59,
1981. With permission.
Table 46
COLLECTION EFFICIENCY FOR TRIALLATE ON 45 x
50 MM POLYURETHANE PLUGS OVER 24-HR
PERIOD
Amount
found
Amount in U- in foam plug
Air Total air tube (t*g) Total
flow rate volume recovery
(/ min"') Added Left
From Grover, R. and Kerr, L. A., J. Environ. Sci. Health, B16, 59, 1981.
With permission.
dition of aluminum hydroxide or magnesium trisilicate to the foam filter has also been
suggested.
Table 47
THE TBP-LOADING CAPACITY OF VARIOUS TYPES
OF POLYURETHANE FOAM (IN EACH CASE, 5 G OF
DRY FOAM WAS TAKEN)
Weight of
Sample loaded TBP in loaded
no. Type of foam° foam (g) support (%)
° Cell dimensions of sample 1 > sample 2 = sample 3 > sample 4 > sample
5.
From Braun, T. and Farag, A. B., Anal. Chim. Acta, 66, 419, 1973. With
permission.
V2 L
N = 8 -^^ = (18)
U
W2 HETP '
I 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
0.8 |t"
0.6
\
0.4
\
\
\\
\ \
i \
02
\ N. (g) |l
o \ 11
<J \
-^ 0.1
o
~~ \ "•
_ \
0.08
\
0.06 — \> —
0.04 \
\M
\
\
0.02 \ ~
\
' H
i H
0.01 i i i\ i i i i i i i i i i i i!|
C) 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 1 5' 3(
TIME (minutes)
V V
N = (19)
(V - V') 2
where V = volume of effluent at the center of the S-shaped breakthrough curve where
the concentration is one-half the initial concentration and V = volume at which the
effluent has the concentration 0.1587 of the initial concentration.
The value of HETP calculated by both methods was found to be the same (1.7 mm
± 7%). It is worth noting that the HETP determined under the same experimental
conditions for TBP supporting Voltalef columns is 2.8 mm. The HETP is increased
(column efficiency decreased) with increasing flow rate in the range of 2 to 13 ml mhr1
(column diameter 15 mm) at all the temperatures tested (25, 35, and 45°C), but this
effect is only pronounced at 25 °C (Figure 54). Consequently, relatively high flow rates
could be applied at 35 or 45°C without any appreciable loss in column performance.
The Vmo, value is not affected by flow rate but decreases with increasing temperature,
yielding sharper peaks.
The breakthrough capacity of the foam was found to be better than that of the
Voltalef column but was dependent to some extent on the foam structure. Also, the
overall capacity of the TBP-loaded foam is about double that of TBP-loaded Voltalef.
Quantitative separations of palladium from various concentrations of nickel and
bismuth in thiourea-perchloric acid systems were possible using TBP-loaded foam col-
umns.153 Nickel does not form a complex with thiourea and consequently is not re-
95
100
H 2 O, ml
2 3 4 5
FLOW-RATE, ml-cm" 2 -min''
FIGURE 54. Effect of temperature and flow rate on the HETP of the palladium-
thiourea complex. (From Braun, T. and Farag, A. B., Anal. Chim. Acta,6l, 265, 1972.
With permission.)
0.1M HCI04
24 ^Containing: ^
thiourea and
22 1% NaCIO 4
20
18
16
14
12
10
0
20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200 220
EFFLUENT, ml
The elements which can interfere with the analytical and industrial separation of
gold are Zn2*, Co2*, Ni2*, Cu2*, Fe3+, Sb3+, Bi3*, Pd 2+ , and Ag*. These elements were
grouped into three categories: (1) elements which do not interact with thiourea under
the experimental conditions used, e.g., Zn2+, Co2*, and Ni2*; (2) elements which form
thiourea complexes, but are not retained or only partially retained with TBP-loaded
97
10
<
o
o
X
o
CJ
5 10 15
Au-COMPLEX IN AQ PHASE
foam, e.g., Cu 2+ , Fe3+, and Sb3*; and (3) elements which form stable thiourea com-
plexes which are strongly retained by the loaded foam sorbent, e.g., Pd2*, Bi3*, and
Ag+.
Zinc(II), iron(III), and bismuth(III) were selected to be representative of a variety of
elements, and the effect of these elements on the rate of extraction of the gold-thiourea
complex was tested. Generally, the rate of extraction of the gold-complex was quite
fast and not effected considerably by the presence of these elements. The half-lives of
sorption of gold-thiourea complex alone and in the presence of Zn2*, Fe3*, or Bi3* were
found to be 0.4, 0.6, 1.0, and 0.9 min, respectively.
In column experiments using the undiluted TBP solution in loading the foam, the
efficiency of extraction of 10 \t% gold from 100 ml of 0.1 M perchloric acid solution
containing 3 g thiourea and 1 g sodium perchlorate was not affected by the solution
flow rate up to 100 mi min"' (column diameter, 25 mm). On a short foam column (25
mm diameter, 12 cm length and containing 5 g TBP-loaded foam), trace amounts of
gold(III) could be separated from high levels of zinc(II), cobalt(II), nickel(II),
iron(III), antimony(III), copper(II), bismuth(III), and palladium(II) by sorption from
a thiourea-perchloric acid solution (Table 48) at a fast flow rate (50 to 60 ml min"1).
However, the silver-thiourea complex could not be completely removed without af-
fecting the retention of the gold complex.
A comparative batch measurement was made for the sorption capacity of gold-thi-
ourea complex on TBP-loaded and unloaded foams and also active carbon. 41 All
loaded and unloaded foams tested gave more or less similar retentions for gold and the
uptake of the gold-thiourea complex by 10 g foam was approximately equal to that of
0.2 g of active carbon. The half-life sorption of gold-thiourea complex on all foam
98 Polyurethane Foam Sorbents in Separation Science
Table 48
SEPARATION OF GOLD FROM VARIOUS ELEMENTS
— 10 — — 6 1.60 98.40
Zn 2 * 10 1000 1:105 5 2.30 97.70
Co2* 10 1000 1:105 5 2.86 97.14
Ni2* 10 1000 1:10S 5 2.30 97.70
Fe3* 2 200 1:10S 5 4.24 95.76
Sb3* 2 200 1:105 5 6.02 93.98
Cu2* 2 2 1:103 4 2.05 97.95
Cu2* 2 20 1:10" 4 3.07 96.93
Cu2* 2 200 1:105 5 11.38 88.62
Bi3* 2 10 1:5 -10 3 5 2.34 97.66
Pd2* 2 10 1:5 -103 5 2.40 97.60
From Braun, T. and Farag, A. B., Anal. Chim. Acta, 65, 115, 1973. With per-
mission.
samples tested (polyether and polyester) was between 0.4 to 1.0 and 1.5 to 2.0 min for
loaded and unloaded foams, respectively. The rate of gold sorption on active carbon
was very close to that of loaded foam (0.6 min ± 5%).
The separation of iron(III) from cobalt(II), copper(II), or nickel(II) has been inves-
tigated by reversed-phase foam chromatography in a TBP-HC1 system.155 Cobalt(II),
copper(II) and nickel(II) ions are not retained by the foam column and move with the
solvent front. Their elutions were completed with 5 M hydrochloric acid solution at a
flow rate of 1 mi min"1 (column diameter, 20 mm). Elution of iron(III) was then
carried out with 0.01 M hydrochloric acid. In view of the results obtained, cobalt(II),
copper(II), and nickel(II) cannot be separated from each other using this system.
The separation of iron and cobalt was studied in more detail as it was considered to
be of special practical importance. Carrier-free 59Fe isotope could be separated from
cobalt target material, used in its preparation, by the proposed reversed phase foam
chromatographic system.
From the mechanistic point of view the retention of iron, cobalt, and copper from
hydrochloric acid medium by TBP-loaded foam is quite similar to the liquid-liquid
extraction process. The distribution ratios and the optimal acid concentration for each
of aqueous-TBP (liquid) and aqueous-TBP (foam) systems are not significantly differ-
ent (Figure 57).
Furthermore, loaded and unloaded polyurethane foams behave differently during
the extraction of palladium and gold-thiourea complexes. The palladium-complex, for
example, which is completely retained by both loaded and unloaded foam columns,
was quantitatively eluted from the TBP-loaded foam columns by 100 ml water; similar
to the behavior in liquid-liquid extraction of palladium in a TBP-perchloric acid-thi-
ourea system. In contrast, the palladium complex which is retained on the unloaded
foam column is not eluted completely even by using 300 ml of water.41
Polyurethane foams loaded with methyl isobutyl ketone, diethylether, isopropyl
ether or ethyl acetate have been tested for the retention of gold(III) from aqueous
chloride medium.14 Using a short foam column it was possible to collect gold traces
(0.06 to 25 ppm) by percolating the aqueous solution (200 ml) through the column at
30 to 40 mi min"1 (column diameter, 20 mm). Gold(III) chloride was completely
DISTRIBUTION RATIO
"833
MS
a . s»
5-~ffl
3 ^ (^i
0
HH
tj03 q
?!
fr
3 o
sr 3
» -
gs
p0 i'
§M °^
DC o
o o*
— g.
» r-
^ o
n O
35
rt
"•il -"*
3 g
3 o.
» S'
1§
-° ^
* •<
w S-
g-§
o sr DISTRIBUTION RATIO
- o"
r g-
§ o.g.
o.
C/3 o
N °
» a
cr o
°3
? I
• 36'
>•
|»
O n
S" »
3 .g
fD
>o
S S
-61 -a
o a-
o\ »
"u, !"
-J ^
P
3 H
^ U
' -0
?i
ff Q
66
100 Polyurethane Foam Sorbents in Separation Science
Table 49
UPTAKE OF GOLD BY DIFFERENT TREATED FOAMS
WHEN 200 ml OF SOLUTION WAS PASSED THROUGH
THE COLUMN
Recovery
Solvent used for treatment Uptake (%) Uptake (%) (%)
From Sukiman, S., Radiochem. Radioanal. Lett., 18, 129, 1974. With permis-
sion.
stripped from the foam column with 20 to 50 mi acetone at 3 mjf min"1 flow rate (Table
49).
On the other hand, polyester polyurethane foams loaded with several members of
the OV series of greases, SE-30, QF-1, DECS, and DC-200, have been prepared by
soaking the foam cylinders in a 5% solution of the coating agent in a pesticide grade
solvent (e.g., ethyl acetate), followed by squeezing several times to expel air bubbles
and then drying in air. 47 - 156 Preliminary experiments showed that the recovery of the
organochlorine pesticides examined from aqueous solution is generally improved by
loading the foam material with these stationary phases. The OV greases performed
very poorly and SE-30, QF-1, and DEGS gave relatively poor recovery with aldrin and
DDT pesticides. However, DC-200 gave better than 90% recovery of all the ten pesti-
cides examined [lindane (Lin), heptachlor (Hep.), aldrin (Aid.), heptachlor epoxide
(Hep Ep), endrin (End.), dieldrin (Diel), p,p'-DDE, o,p'-DDT, p,p'-TDE and p,p'-
DDT].
Four-liter aliquots of water spiked with the tested pesticides were allowed to perco-
late through columns (20 mm diameter) packed with four loaded polyurethane foam
plugs at a flow rate of 250 mjf min"1. Pesticides remaining in the effluent solution were
extracted repeatedly with 20% acetone solution in hexane and measured by gas chro-
matography after reducing the extracts to an appropriate volume. In some experiments
pesticides retained by the foam plugs were recovered with acetone and hexane and then
determined by gas chromatography. It was noted that the glass walls of the columns
sorb about one-third of the pesticides (cf. Table 50) and therefore care must be taken
to wash the inner walls of the column carefully with the solvents used to extract the
foams.156 On flushing loaded-foam columns (which previously sorbed the examined
pesticides) with clean water, some removal of eldrin, heptachlor, aldrin, and p,p'-DDT
was noticed. However, the major environmental contaminants, dieldrin and p,p'-
DDE, were not removed. It was also reported that the uptake of the tested pesticides
from very dilute solutions (0.0125 ppb level) by the foam is not ideal, but still the
majority of them are extracted (Table 51).
The possibility of using loaded foam columns for the extraction of organochlorine
pesticides from suspensions of two different types of soil has also been examined.156
The suspensions were allowed to stand for one day then 3 t were decanted into a 4-jf
bottle and the volume was made up to 4 I. The latter solution was then allowed to
percolate through the foam column at 30 mi min"1 flow rate. The foam columns were
found to perform reasonably, but both soils have the ability to retain tightly certain
pesticides especially p,p'-DDE (Table 52).
101
Table 50
EXTRACTION OF ADDED ORGANOCHLORINE PESTICIDES FROM
DISTILLED WATER BY POROUS POLYURETHANE COATED WITH DC-200.
FOUR PLUGS ONE ON TOP OF THE OTHER IN THE COLUMN WERE USED
AND ANALYZED INDIVIDUALLY (SPIKED AT 1 PPB - 4 t WATER)
% Recovery
Plug no. Lin Hep Aid HepEp End p,p'-DDE Diel o,p'-DDT p,p'-TDE p,p'-DDT
1 60 54 53 49 63 56 59 60 66 62
2 0 2 2 3 0 2 2 0 0 0
3 0 2 1 1 0 1 2 0 0 0
4 0 1 1 1 0 0 1 0 0 0
Column walls 40 39 40 32 35 39 33 38 32 38
Total recovery 100 98 97 86 98 98 97 98 98 100
From Uthe, J. F., Reinke, J., and Gesser, H. D., Environ. Lett., 3, 117, 1972. With permission.
Table 51
EXTRACTION OF ORGANOCHLORINE PESTICIDES FROM WATER
BY POLYURETHANE COATED WITH DC-200; FOUR LITERS OF
WATER WERE USED IN EACH CASE
% Recovery
From Uthe, J. F., Reinke, J., and Gesser, H. D., Environ. Lett., 3, 117, 1972. With permission.
Table 52
EXTRACTION OF ADDED ORGANOCHLORINE PESTICIDES FROM
LIGHT VARFED CLAY SUSPENSIONS BY POLYURETHANE FOAM
COATED WITH DC-200
Note: 4 I of suspension were used in each case. All values are expressed as a percentage of the added
material.
From Uthe, J. F., Reinke, J. and Gesser, H. D., Environ. Lett., 3, 117, 1972. With permission.
102 Polyurethane Foam Sorbents in Separation Science
H
^ "8- §*?-
±J *- V »riO^O—i^O^O^OOTfTj-
Z o "5 U ^o^o^ov-ir-r--t--vir-Tj-
W ^ 0 Q ~
«
fc
I
fe
^
% .o oooor-mooTt-Tj-tooN
|r, 5 S^- r--vovo«/^ooi--oo\ot--«r>
HH C '""''
Q :=>
n
^ ""S 8- - - 1
11 -
i vS <Nt--^OO\t--<NOO<SOOOO
o'Su^- >^«^voiocy\r-oor-^ovo
< I 3^
?* OT? r-oom«fnO-^ooN<^
pL^ o*" «ri»^i^O1OCT\r-CT\r-\O^O
>< ^
CO -e Q
O -2 "S r^ ^ rsoeNOf^vO«^iooOf^
rt-ti « ^ t-~-r-oo\ooo-ooooNr-
S
5S ° u H ^
W HH B
" "
Dfc | |
Q r/)
^
fe rt'O
Oj?
»n^oi---*m'^ONOr-iTt
^o\or-voo<^ooooo^o
W Z g t.
Z
i-j «
Q 3
< s> •o § c
H i S^^Ie —i«r-\OCTvOvoo«o\— .2
nQi-J o'iU vovor~-rrr-vooo\ow-i^o jg
U
O § g ° " |
^ H * ^f ^ S^ -<tTtm(Nvow-i—•'^•^•oo •£
£> Qi ~l §S- « v o \ O ^ C T v O O O \ r - « V O ~
of m <. c ^ £
D
> < ?
g g . j'^^ — — — — — s-
O^~> rt*^*^^ ^OOOOCT\OOOO-HOOt--O ^
§S | i.
S^
f j r£
§ S^
8^
—O ( N O O — - a \ < S T t r - ~
^oSvoiXrir-vo^'S^-
,"
^
M V 51 ^ 2
H £5 - «
U ^
W
-o o E
W "fiS-? mr--r--HOovovo-.oo 2
r/3 <"•-,'*& oor~CT\r~oooooOoooo J5
Z < O S U ^ - - O
** a T• ^r
aS °fa i
8? o- o- o- S S S S S S S
e
e Q^.
H gt |
O c 2 ^
2 -S « S
O 2£ s i
C/3 C O , " "" ~ ~ fS — 0 0 ( N O CS t3
2 8
§3 "" •" i «'
SS5 o «
?- a<>•;
n 3 W H Q H ^ S
R • S M S M Q . a - D Q D ^ S
2
<
S
g
sis-S 9*1^99
B5iCCQ2"a.ii^O;O.D.
i; 1
O O
" i j i < n D w o " d d < (b
104 Polyurethane Foam Sorbents in Separation Science
Table 54
RECOVERY OF
PHTHALATE ESTERS ON
FOAM COATED WITH 5 MG
OF DOW-200 SILICONE OIL
PER PLUG
Dimethyl phthalate 13
(DMP)
Diethyl phthalate 70
(DEP)
Di-n-butyl phthalate 98
(DnBP)
Diamyl phthalate 49
(DAP)
Di-n-octyl phthalate 9.0
(OOP)
Butylbenzyl phthalate 74
(BBP)
Table 55
BENZO(A)PYRENE RETENTION FROM TAP WATER
WITH FOAM PLUGS COATED WITH
CHROMATOGRAPHIC PHASES"
Temp of
Cone of coated spiked % Reten-
on plug wt % water tion on
Chromatographic phase of foam foam
Uncoated 23 62.0
Uncoated 62 85.3
DC-200 5 62 87.5
DC-200 10 62 92.6
SE-30 10 62 91.2
Nematic liquid crystal 3.7 23 66.0
[N,N'-bis(p-methoxy-
benzylidine)-a,a'-bi-p-
toluidine]
Water volume, 4 I; flow rate, 250 mf min"' ± 10 ml; BaP cone 0.1 ppb.
From Saxena, J., Kozuchowski, J., and Basu, D. K., Environ. Sci. Tech-
nol, 11, 682, 1977. With permission.
solvents that can be employed. Solvents suitable for the first method are relatively
limited, as they have to play a dual purpose;158 they have to act as efficient nonvolatile
solvents for the chelating agents in question as well as plasticizers for the plastic foam
itself. Plasticizers are defined as essentially nonvolatile liquids used to modify synthetic
polymers. They do not chemically react with the polymers, but modify them through
the reduction of Van der Waals forces. The plasticized polymer is a dynamic system in
which individual plasticizer molecules have a varying degree of mobility within the
polymer matrix. Consequently, it was suggested that the application of plasticizers
could increase the permeability of the foam material which will enhance the rate of
sorption of metal ions from aqueous solution on the plasticized reagent foams. 158 This
was proved practically as will be described latter.
The plasticizers employed in plasticized reagent foam preparation include, TBP, a-
di-n-nonylphthalate, di-n-octylphthalate, dibutyl adipate, and some tertiary amines.
a. Dithizone Foam
Polyurethane foams immobilizing dithizone have been employed for the collection
of silver158 and mercury(II) 159 161 ions, and also methylmercury(II) chloride160 using
batch, column, and pulsated column methods. Zinc dithizonate was used instead of
dithizone alone as the latter is known to be chemically unstable and its instability is
enhanced when loaded on the foam. 158159
In batch experiments the collection rates of traces of silver and mercury have been
determined for plasticized and unplasticized dithizone foams. Both metal ions were
measured radiometrically in the aqueous solution. The collection rates with the plasti-
cized zinc dithizonate foams are generally better than with the unplasticized ones. Fig-
ures 58 and 59 show the effect of plasticizer on the rate of collection of silver and
mercury, respectively. Silver can be extracted from acidic and neutral aqueous solu-
tions on the reagent foam, but the rate of extraction from aqueous solutions of pH 4.5
to 6.5 is higher than that from more acidic solutions. Mercury is quantitatively ex-
tracted even from 2 M nitric acid solutions, but again the rate of extraction from
neutral aqueous solutions (pH ~ 6) is faster than from acidic media.
Silver and mercury were successfully recovered from the plasticized foam in batch
experiments by shaking with sodium thiosulfate solution. The optimum dithizonate
concentration of the loading solution is about 4 x 10~3 M.
Using short foam columns (1 cm diameter) packed with 1 g plasticized zinc dithizon-
ate foam (loaded with 1% zinc dithizonate solution), the breakthrough and overall
capacities were determined by allowing silver or mercury solution, containing 100 ^g
metal ion ml" 1 , to percolate through the foam column at 2 mi mm'1 flow rate. For
silver, the breakthrough and overall capacities were 11.6 and 18.5 peq g"1, respectively;
for mercury, they were 11 and 22.3 /^eq g'1. Figure 60 shows, for example, the break-
through curve of silver. It was reported159 that breakthrough and overall capacities are
significantly decreased by washing the plasticized foam column with 1 I of distilled
water before capacity determination. However, the measured capacities are still higher
than those reported for other dithizone loaded granular supports.162-163
The separation of silver from a wide range of relative concentrations of lead and
copper was investigated using batch mode collection. Complete collection of silver was
obtained in the presence of as high as six orders of magnitude of lead (Table 56) but in
the case of copper, low recoveries were observed using the straight forward method.
The addition of a masking agent, e.g., EDTA, yielded a quantitative separation of
silver from copper even in the presence of a high excess of the latter (Table 56).
The preconcentration of small amounts of silver (1 pigl"1) and mercury (0.72 ^g!~')
has successfully been achieved by percolating the aqueous metal ion solution through
106 Polyurethane Foam Sorbents in Separation Science
100 r--~
o
o
<
30
TIME (minutes)
20 30
TIME (minutes)
100
LLJ 50
x
10 20 30 40 50
EFFLUENT (ml)
Table 56
COLLECTION OF TRACES OF SILVER IN THE
PRESENCE OF VARIOUS CONCENTRATIONS OF
LEAD AND COPPER
Amount Average
Ag in Ag* in acj Average Ag
Ag* Matrix matrix soln° on foam
Matrix (MB) (mg) (ppm) (%) (%)
• Average of 4 determinations.
From Braun, T. and Farag, A. B., Anal. Chim. Acta, 69, 85, 1974. With
permission.
Table 57
EFFECT OF CONCENTRATION ON
EXTRACTION OF MERCURY
ond method using dithizone solution in acetone) has been tested for the collection of
mercury(II) and methylmercury(II)chloride from aqueous media. 160 The effect of ac-
idity on the extraction of both mercury compounds by dithizone foam columns has
been evaluated using 100 ml samples at flow rates of 1 and 3 mjf miiT1 (column diam-
eter, 20 mm). In both cases, mercury is retained efficiently on the foam column. Mer-
cury(II)chloride was extracted efficiently from aqueous solutions at pH values of about
5 to 10, while methylmercury(II)chloride is best extracted at pH 1.2. The extraction of
both mercury compounds in a wide range of concentrations has been investigated in
column mode experiments. As is clear from the results of Table 57, both merucry
compounds are quantitatively collected by the foam column up to a concentration of
5 to 10 ppm. At higher concentrations, however, the results were less satisfactory.
The mercury(II) ions and methylmercury(II)chloride were found to be firmly re-
tained on the reagent foam columns.160 Additional water (400 mi) washing only re-
moved 0.1% mercury. Mercury could, however, be quantitatively removed from the
foams simply by eluting with 100 mi of acetone. This procedure removed both the
dithizone and the mercury dithizonate simultaneously. Mercury in natural samples,
containing calcium, magnesium, aluminum, iron, zinc, chromium, lead, copper, man-
ganese, nickel, silver, lithium, and bismuth (of which the first four were above 1 ppm
level) and spiked with 0.002 ppb mercury(II) and methylmercury(II)chloride was suc-
cessfully collected by the dithizone foam column (Table 58).
The collection of mercury(II) from aqueous solutions by a pulsating column packed
with zinc dithizonate foams has also been examined.161 Closed and open pulsating
column arrangements were considered. In the open arrangement (Figure 9) each frac-
tion taken from the sample into the syringe on the upstroke (2) is rejected on the
downstroke (3) to the waste and the process is repeated with further fresh fractions of
sample. In the closed arrangement the syringe content is returned to the bulk sample
109
Table 58
EXTRACTION OF MERCURY FROM
VARIOUS MATRICES
Table 59
THEORETICAL (E,) AND
EXPERIMENTAL (E.) EFFICIENCY
OF 203Hg SEPARATION FROM
VARIOUS VOLUMES OF AQUEOUS
P H A S E (W0) I N T H E O P E N
ARRANGEMENT
Separation efficiency "fo, for
foam loaded with:
No. of Zn (HDZ)2 +
20m* Zn (HD)2 TBP
fractions W0
(n) ml E, E. E, E.
Several organic solvents have been examined for the recovery of the sorbed mercury
by the pulsated column method (Table 60). With the exception of methanol, all the
solvents tested gave quantitative elution.
It was also reported50 that cadmium and lead can be collected at pH 9 by a dithizone
foam column at 5 ml min"1 flow rate. Both metal ions can be recovered from the foam
column with a 4 Mnitric acid solution.
b. Diethyldithiocarbamate Foam
The possibility of using zinc diethyldithiocarbamate-foam (ZnDDC) for the collec-
tion of mercury(II) from aqueous solution (pH ~ 6) has also been reported.159 Quan-
titative and rapid collection of mercury from aqueous solutions (containing 0.72 ^g)
was possible using TBP-plasticized ZnDDC foam in batch experiments. More than
97% of mercury was collected after ~10 min shaking.
Braun and Farag164 indicated that sodium diethyldithiocarbamate is unsuitable for
the preparation of plasticized DDC-foam owing to its chemical instability and low
solubility in most nonvolatile organic solvents. Although the use of zinc foam of DDC
offers a solution to this problem, the diethylammonium form is more soluble in or-
ganic solvents and consequently it is recommended for the preparation of plasticized
DDC-foams. However, Valente and Bowen'65 employed NaDDC for loading the foam
material as saturated carbon tetrachloride solution (5% m/V). The unplasticized DDC
foam produced was found to immobilize loosely most of the NaDDC and only about
4% of the reagent is more strongly loaded.
The collection of cobalt (1 ppb) from aqueous solutions by TBP-plasticized diethy-
lammonium DDC foam was found to be pH-dependent.1" The collection is quite com-
plete from aqueous solutions of pH 4.5 to 5.5. Quantitative and fast collection of trace
amounts of cobalt were obtained in column operations using a short foam column (25
mm diameter, packed with 2 g plasticized foam) at a flow rate of 50 to 60 mi min"1.
A method for the separation of antimony(III) from antimony(V) using unplasticized
DDC-foam has been described using batch and column modes of extraction."5 At pH
9.5 antimony(III) is completely extracted while antimony(V) is not. The rate of reten-
Ill
Table 60
ELUTION OF 203Hg FROM FOAM
FILLINGS LOADED WITH
Zn(HDZ)z + TBP (FIVE
PULSATIONS FOR EACH
ALIQUOT
Methanol 10 78
Chloroform 5 100
Toluene 5 98
10 99
Acetone 5 98
10 100
Table 61
EFFECT OF pH ON THE SEPARATION OF
ANTIMONY (HI) FROM ANTIMONY (V) IN FOUR
TYPES OF WATER
Retention on foam (%)
tion of antimony(III) is quite fast, the percentage of extraction reaching 100% after
about 15 min shaking. In batch experiments, antimony(III) was separated from anti-
mony(V) in four types of natural waters after adjusting their pH to 9.5 and adding a
sufficient amount of the solid NaDDC reagent (Table 61). The presence of arsenic(III),
tin(II), and zinc does not cause any interference as their DDC complexes are not sorbed
112 Polyurethane Foam Sorbents in Separation Science
Table 62
EFFECT OF FLOW RATE ON THE EXTRACTION
EFFICIENCY OF MERCURY (II),
METHYLMERCURY AND PHENYLMERCURY
IONS AT pH 2 WITH PLASTICIZED DDC-FOAM
Confidence
Cone Flow rate E" Standard limit
Ion (fig I'1) (ml min"1) (%) deviation (± ts n"2)
From Braun, T., Abbas, M. N., Bakos, L., and Elek, A., Anal. Chim.
Acta, 131, 311, 1981. With permission.
on the foam. However, some other ions, e.g., silver, cadmium, iron(III), and mer-
cury(II) are largely sorbed, but the addition of EDTA to the aqueous solution prevents
the sorption of cadmium and iron(III). The application of the unplasticized DDC'foam
for the same separation in column operation has also been reported using a flow rate
of 5 ml min"1 (column diameter, 20 mm). The foam becomes saturated at antimony
concentrations of 130 mg g"1 foam. In both static and dynamic systems, antimony is
recovered from the foam with acetone and measured by atomic absorption spectrom-
etry or neutron activation analysis.
Antimony, indium, and mercury at parts per billion concentration levels have also
been preconcentrated using DDC-loaded polyester polyurethane foam in batch exper-
iments.31 In this case, 20 to 50 ml of the sample solution, containing a suitable concen-
tration of the element to be determined and adjusted to pH 2, were shaken with DDC-
polyester-foam for 1 hr. The foam was then squeezed to dryness and packed into pure
polyethylene capsules for irradiation for 5 or 10 min in the pneumatic tube system of
the reactor at a neutron flux of 3.1013 n-cm^-s" 1 . Under these conditions indium and
mercury were quantitatively collected by the reagent foam, while the percentage of
antimony collected was only 70%.
Braun et al.166 suggested the use of plasticized diethylammonium DDC foam for the
preconcentration of mercury(II), methylmercury(II), and phenylmercury(II) com-
pounds from natural waters. The extraction of mercury(II) ions was found to be quan-
titative over a wide pH range (0.5 to 8) using the column mode of extraction at 50 ml
min"1 flow rate (column diameter, 25 mm). A pH of ~2 was chosen because at this pH
organomercurials are also completely extracted. Using plasticized DDC foam columns,
flow rates up to 120 ml min"1 could be achieved without affecting the retention of
trace amounts of the inorganic mercury compound. The unplasticized DDC foam col-
umns gave lower retention efficiencies. The extraction rate of organomercurials is
slower than that of inorganic mercury(II) compounds (Table 62).
The collection of inorganic mercury and organomercurials (1 ng I"' level) from tap
water and water containing NaCl was found to be quantitative at a flow rate of 50 ml
min"1 (Table 63).166 It was indicated that mercury is firmly held on the DDC foam; i.e.,
113
Table 63
EXTRACTION OF MERCURY (II),
METHYLMERCURY, AND PHENYLMERCURY
IONS ADDED TO TAP WATER AND 0.5 MNaCl
SOLUTION AT pH 2 WITH PLASTICIZED DDC-
FOAM FOR FLOW RATES OF 50 Ml Min'1
Confidence
Concn E° Std. limit
Sample Ion (^g 1~') (%) dev. (± ts n""2)
Braun, T., Abbas, M. N., Bakos, L., and Elek, A., Anal. Chim. Acta,
131, 311, 1981. With permission.
less than 0.3% of the total amount retained is leached by percolating 1 I of water
through the column. Inorganic mercury, organomercurials and the reagent itself are
completely eluted from the foam column with 100 ml of acetone.
c. l-Nitroso-2-Naphthol Foam
The collection of cobalt(II) from aqueous solution on plasticized l-nitroso-2-naph-
thol foam has been reported at an optimal pH value of 6.6 to 9.0 (Figure 61).1M The
rate of extraction of cobalt on this reagent foam is quite fast. Cobalt concentrations
ranging between 1 and 1000 /^g were quantitatively collected from aqueous solution
(pH 6.8) at a flow rate of 50 to 60 ml mirr1 (column diameter, 25 mm, packed with 2
g plasticized reagent foam).
d. Benzoylacetone Foam
Benzoylacetone-loaded polyurethane foam has been prepared by soaking the washed
and dried foam in an acetone solution of benzoylacetone followed by vacuum
drying. 167 The produced reagent foam was tested for the extraction and separation of
copper and cadmium. The extraction of both metal ions is pH-dependent and their
extraction curves are quite similar to those of the liquid-liquid extraction system. Table
64 shows the effect of flow rate on the completeness of the extraction of copper and
cadmium. Recovery of both ions from the reagent foam columns was successfully ac-
complished using 1.5 M hydrochloric acid solution.
The separation of copper and cadmium was possible with consecutive reagent foam
plugs. When the solution is adjusted to pH 4.86 and extracted with 5 foam plugs, 99.8
± 0.2% of copper is collected together with less than 1.0 /^g of cadmium. However,
separation in a dynamic system utilizing the pH-dependency of the extraction curves
was found to be less effective.
e. Dimethylglyoxime Foam
Polyurethane foams immobilizing dimethylglyoxime (DMG) have been prepared by
shaking the foam material with a solution of DMG in acetone for about 1 hr. 168 The
treated foam is squeezed first between sheets of filter paper to remove excess reagent
solution then dried under vacuum at room temperature to remove acetone. It was
114 Polyurethane Foam Sorbents in Separation Science
100
o
LLJ
50
O
o
o
O
10
PH
Table 64
EXTRACTION OF COPPER AND CADMIUM
BY BENZOYLACETONE-TREATED
POLYURETHANE FOAM
From Lypka, G. N., Gesser, H. D., and Chow, A., Anal. Chim.
Acta, 78, 367, 1975. With permission.
reported that in this unplasticized DMG-foam the major part of the reagent is impreg-
nated in the foam membrane as a solid solution of DMG in polyurethane, while some
of it may be chemically bonded to the polyurethane molecules, e.g., covalent bonding
between DMG and the foam polyol and urethane bonds. The optimal pH for the ex-
traction of nickel is in the range 8 to 10, but quantitative extraction is possible from
solutions of slightly lower or higher pH too, if the reagent foam contains excess DMG.
115
Table 65
EFFECT OF FOREIGN IONS ON THE SORPTION OF
Ni (II) BY DMG-TREATED FOAM"
° Content of DMG on the treated foam: 5.8 x 10~2 mmol g"' foam; Me-
dium: 15.0 ~ 20.0 ml of 0.1 MNH«C1-NH 4 OH buffer; Foam taken:
ca. 50 ~ 90 mg
* The values determined with the treated foam containing DMG of 6.8 x
10"' mmol g~' foam.
From Lee, D. W. and Halmann, M., Anal. Chem., 48, 2214, 1976. With
permission.
However, in strongly alkaline solutions (pH ~ 11) the amount of nickel extracted is
significantly decreased.
It was reported that nickel reacts immediately with the DMG loaded on the foam to
form a pink colored complex, but the latter takes some time (30 min) to be held quan-
titatively on the foam. Consequently, shaking for 1 hr was chosen to ensure complete
sorption. From the mechanistic point of view, it was suggested that nickel in solution
reacts first with DMG released from the loaded foam to form insoluble Ni(II)-DMG
colloidal particles. The latter are sorbed by the foam and diffuse into the foam to form
a complex with the foam matrix. This mechanism was confirmed by the capability of
the untreated polyurethane foam to sorb Ni(II)-DMG colloidal particles from aqueous
solution producing a clear solution. This is considered to be a selective process as silver
chloride or ferrous hydroxide colloidal particles are not sorbed by the unloaded polyu-
rethane foam. Contrariwise, Ni(II)-salicylaldoxime and Cu(II)-salicylaldoxime colloi-
dal particles are sorbed by the unloaded foam. The extraction of Ni(II) by the DMG-
foam is unaffected by temperature in the range 20 to 60°C.
The mole ratio of Ni(II):DMG in the foam was found to be 1:2.6,16B which is smaller
than the theoretical ratio for Ni(DMG)2 complex (1:2). Therefore it seems that a part
of DMG in the foam is unavailable for the reaction with nickel. Separation of low
concentrations of nickel(II) (~5 ppm) on DMG-foam was found to be possible by both
static and dynamic methods. A mixture of 1 MHC1 and ethanol (1:1) was successfully
employed for the recovery of nickel from the reagent foam. In retention and elution
processes a flow rate of less than 1 ml min"1 (column diameter 15 mm) was used. The
presence of iron(III), zinc(II), cadmium(II), iron(II), and copper(II) ions did not affect
nickel retention by the DMG-foam (Table 65). Cobalt(II) interferes seriously, but its
116 Polyurethane Foam Sorbents in Separation Science
FIGURE 62. Effect of time on the sorption of nickel on loaded polyurethane foams
at room temperature, (a) DMG-TBP: 3% DMG-TBP foam (100 mg), 900 ^g Ni 15 ml''
solution; (b) DMG: 9.3 x 10~s mmol DMG g"1 foam taken, 200 Mg Ni 13 mjT' solution;
(c) benzildioxime-TBP: 1.5% benzildioxime-TBP foam (100 mg), 900 ^g Ni 15 mr 1
solution; (d) benzildioxime: 1.2 x 10"4 mmol benzildioxime g"1 foam (60 mg), 400 ng Ni
20 mr 1 solution. (From Halmann, M. and Lee, D. W., Anal. Chim. Acta, 113, 383,
1980. With permission.)
/. a-Benzildioxime Foam
The main drawback of the DMG-loaded foam is that ca. 90% of the reagent is
removed from the foam during one elution step. TBP-plasticized DMG-foam was
suggested170 "' to solve this problem and also to improve the separation of nickel.
TBP-plasticized a-benzildioxime and 1,2-cyclohexanedione dioxime foams were also
prepared and critically evaluated for the extraction and separation of nickel. It was
reported that the addition of TBP plasticizer improves the performance of the reagent
foam. This is in agreement with the previously described conclusions with other reagent
foams. 158159164 Figure 62 shows that the fastest equilibration is achieved with the TBP-
plasticized DMG-foam and the slowest with the unplasticized benzildioxime-foam.
Sorption of nickel(II) on different TBP-plasticized dioxime foams is optimal at pH 9
to 10. In all cases 1 to 2 MHC1 was used for the recovery of nickel(II).
The retention of nickel(II) from aqueous alkaline solution by the dioxime loaded
foams was unaffected by the presence of the following ions and chelating agents:
Cu(II), Cd(II), Fe(II), Co(II), citrate, tartarate, and EDTA. In the presence of cyanide
ion, the sorption decreases.171
g. 1,2-Ethanedithiol Foam
Polyurethane foam loaded with a 1% solution of 1,2-ethanedithiol in benzene has
been examined for separation and preconcentration of antimony from natural
117
Table 66
INVESTIGATION OF SELECTIVITY
OF RETENTION ON LOADED
POLYURETHANE FOAM
"Na 0.14 0
82
Br 0.04 0
203
Hg 8 x 10-3 82.0
"Zn 0.5 0
"3Sn 5 0
'0'Cd 0.2 0
"As 0.07 97.9
waters.172 Both antimony(III) and (V) were found to be sorbed from distilled, river and
sea water independently of their oxidation state and type of water used. In batch mode
extraction, 50 and 95% of antimony were sorbed after 1 and 3 min shaking, respec-
tively.
More than 97% antimony was extracted from aqueous solution at pH between 1 and
2.5. Above pH 4, the percentage sorbed sharply decreased. The sorption isotherm of
antimony measured at pH 1 was found to be linear over a wide range of antimony
concentrations. The formula of the extracted species was suggested to be Sb
(CH 2 -CH 2 -S 2 )C1. 172
The collection of traces of antimony (6 ^g Sbf"') on ethanedithiol-foam columns was
successfully carried out at a flow rate of 5 ml min"1 (column diameter, 15 mm). Anti-
mony was recovered from the foam columns with acetone at 1 ml min"1 flow rate.
The presence of sodium, zinc, cadmium, and bromine ions does not affect the col-
lection of antimony as they are not sorbed by the ethanedithiol-foam. However, mer-
cury and arsenic ions are quantitatively retained. No trials were made to separate these
metal ions from antimony. Table 66 shows the sorption of a series of elements in
solution at pH 1 by the reagent-foam.
h. Pyridylazo-Naphthol Foam
Plasticized and unplasticized l-(2-pyridylazo)-2-naphthol (PAN) foams have been
prepared and evaluated for the separation and extraction of cobalt(II), 24 - 172 " 175
iron(III),24 38 manganese(II),24 zinc(II),30 35•'" 17S mercury(II), 3031 ' 35 ' 173 175 copper(H),35
gold(III),31 indium(III),30 and cadmium(II) 173174 using batch and column techniques.
The collection of cobalt(II) and iron(III) from aqueous solutions by plasticized
PAN-foam was found to be quantitative over a wide pH range (4 to 9).24 Man-
ganese(II), however, is sorbed only above pH 9 (Figure 63). This behavior is the basis
for the separation of cobalt from manganese. The effect of 23 anions on the extraction
of cobalt, iron and manganese with plasticized PAN-foam has been examined.24 Cya-
nide, peroxide, periodate, and citrate mask all three metal ions, while borate, fluoride,
phosphate, and tartarate mask iron more than cobalt and have no effect on manganese
(Table 67).
The sorption rate of cobalt decreases in the order thiocyanate > oxalate, phthalate
> iodide > bromide, > nitrate, but the sorption rate of iron is highest from water. The
sorption rate of the three metal ions decreases in the order cobalt > manganese > iron.
The sorption rate of cobalt in thiocyanate medium on PAN-polyester foam is slower
118 Polyurethane Foam Sorbents in Separation Science
FIGURE 63. Sorption of cobalt, iron, and manganese as a function of pH; (a) iron,
(b) cobalt, (c) manganese. (From Braun, T., Farag, A. B., and Maloney, M. P., Anal.
Chim. Acta, 93, 191, 1977. With permission.)
Table 67
EFFECT OF VARIOUS SALTS (0.1 M) ON THE EXTRACTION
OF COBALT, IRON, AND MANGANESE WITH PAN-FOAM
Extraction Extraction
Salts Co Fe Mn Salts Co Fe Mn
Saturated solution.
From Braun, T., Farag, A. B., and Maloney, M. P., Anal. Chim. Acta, 93, 191, 1977.
With permission.
than on the PAN-polyether foam. However, the sorption rate of cobalt on PAN-po-
lyester foam is improved in the presence of a plasticizer (cr-dinonyl phthalate).
Microgram amounts of cobalt were quantitatively collected on plasticized and un-
plasticized PAN-polyester foam from aqueous thiocyanate solution at flow rates up to
ca. 10 ml min~' (column diameter, 25 mm, packed with 5 g loaded foam). However,
cobalt could be quantitatively collected from aqueous thiocyanate solution at flow
rates up to at least 40 mi min"' using plasticized and unplasticized PAN-polyether
foam columns.24 In both cases cobalt could be recovered together with the PAN re-
agent from the foam columns by elution with acetone.
The quantitative collection of manganese by plasticized and unplasticized PAN-po-
lyester foam columns was possible only at flow rates as low as 1 mi min~'. The collec-
tion of various concentrations of manganese and cobalt was achieved at flow rates 1
119
Table 68
COLLECTION OF VARIOUS
CONCENTRATIONS OF COBALT
OR MANGANESE ON
PLASTICIZED AND
UNPLASTICIZED PAN-
POLYESTER POLYURETHANE
FOAM COLUMNS
Relative
Amount of Average accuracy
metal taken extracted of mean Std.
(jig) (X, %) (%) dev. (s)
Cobalt
Carrier- 98.6° 1.4 0.235
free 98.7' 1.3 0.497
0.2 98.6° 1.4 0.273
98.6* 1.4 0.187
2.0 98.8° 1.2 0.464
98.6* 1.4 0.141
20.0 99.2° 0.8 0.212
98.7* 1.3 0.570
200.0 95.8° 4.2 1.868
97.1* 2.9 0.540
Manganese
0.2 98.5° - 1.5 0.700
2.0 98.4° - 1.6 0.510
20.0 98.2° -1.8 0.866
200.0 96.7° -3.3 1.520
° Plasticized
* Unplasticized
and 5 to 10 ml min"1, respectively (Table 68). The separation of cobalt from man-
ganese was successfully carried out from aqueous thiocyanate solutions adjusted to pH
4 to 5. At this pH manganese is not retained by the PAN-foam column while cobalt is
quantitatively sorbed. Cobalt is then eluted with acetone.
Unplasticized PAN-polyether foams were subjected to an investigation of the
amount of the leached reagent. Generally, leaching of PAN from the foam-column by
the percolation of distilled water was found to depend on the initial concentration of
the reagent on the foam and the volume of water percolated (Figure 64).172° As is
obvious from these curves the amount of reagent leached is relatively small at the lower
PAN concentration (0.86 wt%) on plasticized PAN-foam.
Unplasticized PAN-polyether foam columns have been successfully employed for
the preconcentration of cobalt from extremely dilute aqueous solutions (0.1 ppb) con-
taining potassium thiocyanate.1720 The solution was adjusted to pH 4 to 9 and perco-
lated through the column at a flow rate of 100 ml min"1 (column diameter, 25 mm).
The retained cobalt and the reagent were completely eluted from the foam column with
acetone at a flow rate of 3 mi min"1 and cobalt determined spectrophotometrically
using PAR reagent. The collection of traces of cobalt from 10-i water samples has also
been reported.172"
120 Polyurethane Foam Sorbents in Separation Science
30r-
T
i? 20
o
LU
X
LU
_1
<
10
I
3 4 5
WATER VOLUME (L)
An automatic batch squeezing procedure has been described for the collection of
cobalt(II), zinc(II), cadmium(II), and mercury(II) from large volumes of water by a
PAN foam. 173 - 174 A semiquantitative determination of cadmium in river water has also
been reported. 174
Unplasticized and a-dinonyl phthalate-plasticized PAN-foams can be used also for
the collection of zinc(II), mercury(II), and copper(II). 35 The optimum pH of the sorp-
tion of these metal ions is 8 to 9.
Further work on the sorption of zinc(II), mercury(II), gold(III), and indium(III)
from aqueous thiocyanate solutions onto unplasticized PAN-foams has also been re-
ported. 3031 The distribution ratios were found to depend strongly on the thiocyanate
concentration. For example, in the case of zinc at pH 6, distribution ratios of 32 and
22,600 were measured in the absence and in the presence of thiocyanate (0.2 M), re-
spectively. In the case of mercury, the distribution ratio increases by increasing the
thiocyanate concentration and reaches a constant value of about 2000 at thiocyanate
concentrations above 0.05 M. The distribution ratios of indium were 4 and 6270 in the
absence and presence (0.2 M) of thiocyanate, respectively.
10
TIME (minutes)
FIGURE 65. Sorption rates of the LIX 65N and Kelex 100 foams with copper (II) and
iron (III). (From Vernon, F., Sep. Sci. Technol., 13, 587, 1978. With permission.)
Table 69
RETENTION OF VARIOUS METAL IONS BY THE FOAM
COLUMNS FROM pH 6 SOLUTIONS USING AN ELUTION
RATE OF 0.3 mi MIN M
Column Cd Co Cr Cu Hg Mn Ni Pb U Zn
From Vernon, F., Sep. Sci. Technol., 13, 587, 1978. With permission.
all ligand molecules are available for bonding with the formation of a 1:2 (metal-to-
ligand) complex (the measured value on the foam was 1:1.95). However, in the case of
Kelex®-foam, about 25% of the reagent is not available for chelation as the total
capacity of the foam represents a metal:ligand molar ratio of 1:2.7. This was attributed
either to the presence of some impurities in the Kelex® reagent or to some steric hindr-
ance. The rate of sorption of copper and iron is shown in Figure 65. The half-lives of
equilibrium sorption of copper are 1.25 and 0.25 min for LIX and Kelex®, respec-
tively. In the case of iron(III) they are 4.5 and 3.25 min.
The collection capabilities of the reagent foams were examined by percolating a so-
lution containing ten trace metals buffered at pH 6 through foam columns at a flow
rate of 0.3 ml min'1 (column diameter, 10 mm). As is clear from the results of Table
69, Kelex®-foam is more efficient for the recovery of all metal ions tested. However,
the LIX-foam is more selective. Attempts were made to separate these metal ions on
the reagent foam columns making use of the differences in kinetical behavior and
stability of metal complexes. A flow-rate of 3 m£ min'1 was employed.
solutions. Foams loaded with chromogenic organic reagents (they are called "Chrom-
ofoarns" by Braun and Farag178) will develop characteristic color reactions on the foam
membranes in contact with aqueous solutions containing traces of ions chelated by the
chromogenic reagents. Plasticizing the foam increases the sensitivity of color forma-
tion. A qualitative detection test is usually done by shaking one or more cubes of the
appropriate chromofoam with 1 to 3 m£ of the aqueous metal ion solution for 1 to 2
min in a normal test tube. The chromogenic reagent solution which is homogeneously
distributed on the relatively high available surface area of the foam material can func-
tion as an effective collector for metal ion traces. This together with the relative ease
of observing colored reaction products on the surfaces of the white foams allows a
high sensitivity for the chromofoam test. Furthermore, the chromofoam can be packed
in columns producing foam beds suitable for the detection of very low concentrations
of several metal ions by percolating their aqueous solution through the foam column
at reasonable flow rates. Detections at the ppb level could be easily achieved by per-
colating relatively high volumes of the aqueous solution (up to 1 i) through the foam
columns. 178 In this multistage column sorption process, the reagent foam collects metal
ions from aqueous solution up to the observable sensitivity limit of the color reaction
with the reagent on the foam. Consequently, this column foam test significantly im-
proves the sensitivity of detection tests by allowing detections in extremely dilute solu-
tions. Also, chromofoams could be employed in pulsated column operations.
A further advantage of the chromofoam test is its suitability for semiquantitative
analyses. This was achieved by using comparation color scales in batch operation or
by measuring the length of foam color zones on columns after percolation of the test
solutions. In the case of batch and pulsated methods, the color density on the reagent
foam cube was found to depend on the concentration of metal ions in aqueous solu-
tion.
Qualitative and semiquantitative determinations of zinc(II),178 lead(II),178 cop-
per, 178182 cobalt(II),178 chromium(VI), 179 nickel,180 iron(III),181 cadmium(II), 173174 mer-
cury(II), 173174 and tin(II)173'174 have been carried out using various chromofoams. As a
general rule, the sensitivity of the reagent foam tests is better than that of normal spot
tests.178 Also, the performance of plasticized reagent foams was found to be better
than the unplasticized one.
Plasticized dithizone foam was prepared by loading foam cubes (5 mm edge) with
0.05% (w/v) solution of dithizone in a-dinonylphthalate.178 Saturated rubeanic acid
solution in a-dinonylphthalate (0.1% w/v) was used for loading the foam to produce
rubeanic acid foam. Amberlite® LA-1-foam was prepared by using 50% solution of
Amberlite® in a-dinonylphthalate. The loading solution of 1,5-diphenylcarbazide-
foam was prepared by dissolving 0.1 g of the solid reagent in 10 mjf benzene followed
by the addition of 10 ml of Alamine 336.179 The dimethyl glyoxime loading solution
was prepared by dissolving about 0.2 g of DMG in 10 mi Alamine 336.18° Saturated
solution of biacetylmonoxime-benzoylhydrazone in dibutyl or dioctyl phthalate (ca.
0.1% w/v) was employed for preparing plasticized biacetylmonoxime benzoylhydra-
zone foam.182
Table 70 shows a comparison between the results obtained with several chromo-
foams in batch and column tests and those reported in the literature with the usual and
modified spot tests. The standard color scales used in the different foam tests for
semiquantitative analyses are shown in Table 71. The effect of relatively high concen-
trations of diverse ions on the detection of 1 /^g of cobalt(II) and chromium(VI) with
Amberlite® LA-1 and diphenylcarbazide foams, respectively, are presented in Tables
72, 73, and 74.
Squeezing173-174 and pulsating column181 methods have also been employed for the
detection of some metal ions in aqueous phases. In the later method181 color compari-
123
•S S3
'% *
£|
s.0 :ss no
z g s- s
s .sa I
a s
£
(,_;£ oc oo oo <s oo o> O ~<
ajrt r-- r~ r-- oo r- r--oooo
(^ O —, ^ —< —• —, —< -H —<
(/I "~
(« ^. -a
H | I
S .
H ^
o £
up,
«
c
C
v-iO^O
|ooqo
w-i >r^
«^HQ
ooq
—t
o ^r §
^ « CX C O O O O O O O
§S §ii
3§
a
§2s ^lB *-s
HH -M P
c
Si v> »ri \n
CJ i B o cs <n — rn _q_
3° js d d o o d doci
C/3 2 o
P I m
|
o
H^
^ <1 3 x c-
JS^ g£ & . . .
x>P-, ^ 2 3 PfTiA
(2 o
•V-
2 « s ^
G f l j £ i 00 jj „
„
,'
sss.
u O B O
C 3 T 3 W ^ °°. ^*. ^ ^ ^ ^ ^
H 2 c 3 ° ^ U o O O « X iXr^»n
>
h—4
| -s »
H
HH
x
5
Z S
G vo
O fl
W N m
w 2 i> v
^ si ?
1
P
;>
%
«
C
If
xO N _
G i
51
-^ B
o rt
O! E i^< H<x
J
< f 5 g J^JS ^
| « S-1* S.S-2 g,
« -00= ° > < C o > S
o •§ g 6 B I- e S1 &
U u u™ 6 | S 3^3 a 2 ° .
D Q M W w -Q« 2s"°
(A •- CX ^"
a M B -S
1
C o '3 c S
c t & = °2
° S =• Be- «SS§
2 « ST ~ -2 ™ s § - - •o
1
111 OI
NJU
lit lc
UZi
"a|"
.< „ ,
124 Polyurethane Foam Sorbents in Separation Science
<+l 00 00 00 (N 00 O\ O —<
w l^r- r~ oo r^ r~ oooo
C/3 &
r . O. -Q -O "O
" O. C C C O
C/3 ^ « nJ nJ vi o
" 1 8 8 8 1 |
qj O ™
S
^ s
I8 8 8 t o
^li C3 (S (S (N O ^
g .8 ! 8 8 8 1 o- 8 2"
O S °
w
- g - g -. § | « | „•
M o-<to^tOTroo o-
^ •? «O (N >n */~» — —« ^^
o 1
$ 2 8
M « °
U
c ? "g
C/3 « O. « o
M
D « 3 o o o
o -g §1 o S a « si
~3 I ^ •§ S s o -gS -g 2^.
^ < I S 1 S o ^-
N
".
JB ^ -g o2 o " "" 2 -
•g <* S " _r "" " «" •"" --«
£ O CO - " . - . " - " IN' 6 .6
~ r r ,IT1 - - ^ - V - l -
^* v ^ r ^ i o - H t n ^ H O — ^
c/3 d d d o o d c J o
W
<J
u Ie i e
<« « § §3 g
I I ii i IP! 1*
O
^
r)
u
l f i £ ' g § - | ® f | . S
i i i
CC
S B £ £ S
•- — _ •- -°
MC?
X U
Q oo c >, •>, -s a js c
«
<
I s l s•§ S .2- gS6 Q
%$.
l l e
.A o .§ «
Q DO at ca ^ < - Q<
Z
^ § ^^
1
!! I II i!
N J U U U Z i
125
Table 72
EFFECT OF DIVERSE IONS ON THE DETECTION OF 1 OF COBALT (II)
Amount Volof
Foreign Compound added aq soln Cobaltrforeign
ion added (mg)- (ml) ion Notes
Other ions
Table 72 (continued)
EFFECT OF DIVERSE IONS ON THE DETECTION OF 1 ^g OF COBALT (II)
Note: Except where mentioned otherwise, the color of the foam in a blank test was white. In case of
ions which interfere by their own colors in solution, it was found better to take out the foam cube
(after shaking with the test solution) and to shake it with few milliliters of water. The blue color,
which appears in the presence of cobalt (II), was then better observed.
The amount of the foreign ion below which the detection of 1 f/g of cobalt can easily be achieved.
6
Value obtained by comparison with a blank test.
' 0.5 ml 1 MHC1 and 1 ml Na2(COO)2 (10 mg mf' 1 ) added, and mixture heated to ca. 80°C. After
cooling 1 ml KSCN solution added; cobalt is then detected as usual with reagent foam.
From Braun, T. and Farag, A. B., Anal. Chim. Acta, 73, 301, 1974. With permission.
Table 73
EFFECT OF DIFFERENT CATIONS ON THE
DETECTION OF 1 ^g OF CHROMIUM (VI)
Maximum tolerable
Maximum tolerable concentration of
Foreign Compound amount of the interfering ion
ion added foreign ion/mg" relative to Cr (VI)
From Farag, A. B., El-Wakil, A. M., and El-Shahawi, M. S., Analyst 106,
809, 1981. With permission.
son was made using a constant number of pulses in a fixed volume of solution. A
standard color scale was developed under identical experimental conditions. In the
other method,173'174 variable numbers of squeezes were employed until the colored re-
action products first appeared on the reagent foam. In this case, the number of
squeezes needed is a function of solution concentration, and by comparison with a
standard known concentration, the concentration of the unknown solution could be
determined semiquantitatively. The formal method was employed for the detection of
iron with plasticized amine-foam, while the latter has been used for the detection and
semiquantitative determination of cadmium, tin, and mercury with PAN foam. 173174
The detection and semiquantitative determination of phosphate ion has been devel-
127
Table 74
EFFECT OF VARIOUS ANIONS ON THE DETECTION OF 1 Mg OF
CHROMIUM (VI)
Maximum tolerable
Maximum tolerable concentration of
amount of the interfering ion
Foreign ion° Compound added foreign ion/nig* relative to Cr (VI) Notes
With metal ions that interfere due to their own color in solution, it was found better to take out the foam
cube (after shaking with the test solution) and to shake it with a few milliliters of water. The red-violet
color that appears in the presence of chromium (VI) was then better observed.
The amount of the foreign ion below which the detection of 1 ^g of chromium (VI) in 2 ml of aqueous
solution can be easily achieved.
The foam color in the blank test [i.e., in the absence of chromium (VI)] was yellow.
From Farag, A. B., El-Wakil, A. M., and El-Shahawi, M. S., Analyst, 106, 809, 1981. With permission.
128 Polyurethane Foam Sorbents in Separation Science
oped using TBP-plasticized Amberlite® LA-2-foam in the molybdate form. 184 The
reagent foam was prepared by loading the clean dried foam cubes (20 pieces, 10 mm
edge) with 5 nuf of 10% tetrahydrofuran solution of Amberlite® LA-2 (molybdate-
form) and 0.5 mi TBP. The solvent was then evaporated slowly from the foam mate-
rial at room temperature. The batch version of the foam test involves first collection
of the phosphate on the reagent foam cube followed by reduction with tin(II) chloride
solution. As low as 0.2 ppm phosphorus as phosphate could be detected by this pro-
cedure. The semiquantitative determination of phosphate was also possible by com-
paring the blue color produced on the foam with that of a standard color scale (0, 0.2,
0.5, 1.0, and 2.0 ppm phosphate). The investigators184 plasticized the foam with TBP
which is actually an organic phosphate compound and mentioned that the color inten-
sity on the foam decreases with the decrease the amount of plasticizer. Moreover, no
color was developed in the absence of TBP. It was also reported that a high color
intensity of the foam is obtained in blank tests when high concentration of tin(II)
chloride solution is used.184 In our opinion more work must be done to clarify the role
of TBP in this process.
It is worth mentioning that unloaded polyether polyurethane foam has also been
employed for the detection and semiquantitative determination of alkylbenzenesulfon-
ate (ABS) from aqueous media containing Crystal Violet (CV) or Methylene Blue
(MB).59 It was indicated that polyester polyurethane and other foams such as polyvi-
nylchloride, polystyrene, and polyethylene give less satisfactory results for this test.
In the batch version of the above-mentioned method, 1 mf of 1 Nsulfuric acid and
2 to 5 mjf of 10~3 M CV solution were added to the sample solution and the whole
mixture diluted to 100 nuf with distilled water. A polyurethane foam chip was then
soaked in the produced solution for 5 min. As low as 5 ppm ABS could be detected
using a suitable standard color scale. The limit of detection could be decreased to 0.1
ppm by employing columns (8 mm diameter, containing 0.19 g foam) at a flow rate of
20 to 30 mi min"1.
1. Tri-n-Octylamine-Foam
The preparation and application of a polyurethane foam loaded with a liquid anion
exchanger was first described by Braun et al.185 They used tri-n-octylamine (TOA)-
foam for the separation of cobalt from nickel in a hydrochloric acid system. As is
known, TOA reacts with hydrochloric acid according to the equation:
where
R = -CH2-(CH:)6-CH, (23)
The amine salt thus formed acts as a liquid anion exchanger and reacts with the
metal chloride complex present in aqueous solution:
where o and aq, stand for organic and aqueous phase, respectively.
129
100
LU
O
CC
LU
Q_
250 300
The separation of cobalt from nickel by extraction with TOA-foam from hydrochlo-
ric acid medium is based on the tendency of cobalt to form relatively stable extractable
chlorocomplexes (mainly CoCl42"). Nickel, however, is not extractable from hydro-
chloric acid solutions with long-chain amines. This was exactly the case with TOA-
foam as the distribution ratio of nickel was found to be negligible at all the acid con-
centrations tested (0 to 9 MHC1).
It was mentioned that as the amount of TOA-HCI loaded on the foam increased the
elasticity of the foam decreased. High amine salt loading (ca. 67 wt%) was found to
be unsuitable for efficient separation. However, separation on very low amine salt
loading (3.8%) was incomplete. Loadings in the range 11.4 to 17.7% were found to be
the most suitable in batch and flow modes of separation. The breakthrough capacity
curve (Figure 66) obtained on columns loaded with 17.7% TOA-HCI, and cobalt feed
solution with a concentration of 0.07 mg mi"1 was found to be quite sharp.
Figure 67 shows, for example, the separation of carrier-free 58Co from nickel. Nickel
was eluted with 8 MHC1, while cobalt is completely retained. Cobalt is then quantita-
130 Polyurethane Foam Sorbents in Separation Science
4MHCI IMHCk
20
16
Ni Co
4.67mg 40/jg
LU 12
O
cr
I t
20 40 60 80
ml
lively eluted with 1 M HC1. The separation of traces of cobalt from a wide range of
relative concentrations of nickel (1:108) is shown in Table 75.
It is worth noting that TOA-loaded silicone rubber foam has also been employed for
the separation of rhodium and iridium in hydrochloric acid solution containing chlor-
ine using batch and columns methods.186 Iridium was completely retained (98.5 ±
0.9%) by this reagent foam from 6 MHC1 containing sodium chlorate (as a source of
free chlorine) while rhodium (99%) remains in the aqueous solution.
Table 75
NICKEL-COBALT SEPARATION
Taken Found
Ni to Co Ni Co Ni Co Ni Co
ratio (mg) (mg) (mg) (mg) (%) W
From Braun, T., Huszar, E., and Bakos, L., Ana/. Chitn. Acta, 64,
77, 1973. With permission.
cobalt, nickel, and cadmium from hydrochloric and hydrobromic acids has been
tested. Nickel and cobalt showed no extraction in the range of acidity examined (1 to
8 M HC1 or HBr). However, cadmium and iron were retained on the Aliquat-foam.
The retention of cadmium was found to be quantitative at all conditions studied, while
the extraction of iron was noticed at acidities above 5.8 and 8 Min hydrobromic and
hydrochloric acids, respectively.
On the basis of these results it was possible to separate iron or cadmium from cobalt
and nickel in batch and flow systems. In 6 M hydrochloric acid solution cadmium and
iron were completely retained by the reagent foam while cobalt and nickel were not
absorbed by the foam. The elution of cobalt or nickel was achieved with 3 M HC1,
then iron with 0.1 ML-ascorbic acid, 0.1 MHNO 3 or 1 MNaF, and finally cadmium
with 1 M nitric acid solution. The quantitative separation of various relative concen-
trations of these metal ions has also been carried out using Aliquat-foam columns at a
flow rate of 2 to 4 mt min'1 (column diameter, 15 mm).
Table 76
INTERFERENCE OF FOREIGN IONS BY THE
DETERMINATION OF THORIUM
Amount
added Th found Absolute Relative
Ion added (mg) (Mg) error error (%)
From Xie Chang-Sheng, Acta Chim. Sinica,40, 605, 1982. With permission.
100 a-
50 70 90
TIME (min)
Sharp breakthrough curves were obtained for copper(II) on columns packed with het-
erogeneous cation exchange foam.
The elution of copper with 0.5 M hydroxylammonium chloride solution was exam-
ined at 50°C using flow rates ranging between 2 and 10 mi min"1 (column diameter,
15 mm). Only a slight increase in peak width with increased flow rate occurs but the
elution of copper is quantitative even at flow rates as high as 10 mf min"1. Figure 69
shows the effect of flow rates on the elution of copper from cation exchange foam
column and cation exchange bead columns (Varion KS). With the foam columns, mi-
crogram and milligram amounts of copper could be retained and eluted quantitatively
with hydroxylammonium chloride solution.
The selectivity of the ion exchange foam was determined by measuring the cation
exchange distribution ratios of cadmium(II), zinc(II), iron(III), and calcium(II) over a
wide range of HCl-ethanol mixtures.1960 The results obtained show that the selectivity
of the ion exchange foam is about the same as the original exchange beads (Varion
KS). Evidently this experiment indicates that the ion exchange foam functions well in
water-miscible organic solvents, and swelling of the foam support in this medium does
not limit its application. This was further confirmed by the results obtained for the
separation of cadmium, zinc, iron, and calcium on foam columns. It was found that
these cations are eluted by HCl-ethanol mixtures (Figure 70) in the same order as for
AG 50 W-X8 sulfonated polystyrene cation exchange resin (100 to 200 or 200 to 400
mesh particle size).
4ml min
o u
6? 59
.(b)
5.0
0.0 0.0
0 100 200 0 100 200 0 100 200
EFFLUENT (ml) EFFLUENT (ml) EFFLUENT (ml)
FIGURE 69. Effect of flow rate on the elution of copper (II) with 0.5 Mhydroxylam-
monium chloride solution at 50°C. (a) Ion-exchange foam column; (b) ion-exchange
bead column. (From Braun, T. and Farag, A. B., Anal. Chim. Acta, 68, l\9, 1974.
With permission.)
25.0
20.0
15.0
10.0
5.0
0.0
100 200 300 400 500 600 700
EFFLUENT, ml
copolymer was prepared by this method and the anion exchange groups then intro-
duced by chloromethylation and amination. The mechanical properties of this foam
depend on the polymerization conditions and the amount of styrene. At about 20%
polystyrene content the elasticity of the foam significantly decreased, i.e., permanent
deformation occurred on pressure. Further increase in the polystyrene content led to a
rapid breakdown of mechanical properties; at about 40% polystyrene the foam be-
haved as a rigid material of brittle structure. The second method is based on radiation
grafting of open-cell polyurethane foams with methacrylic acid. This process fixes an
ionogenic group on the foam membranes and leads to the final product in a single step.
Foams prepared by this method are weak carboxylic ion exchange with excellent prop-
erties and fair ion exchange capacities.
3 4 5
NUMBER OF PULSES
FIGURE 71. Effect of the number of pulses on the reduction efficiency of the pulsed
column, (a) With 2 g of loaded foam; (b) with swollen foam. Cerium (IV) sulfate con-
centration 0.005 M; volume of the solution 5 ml; at room temperature. (From Braun,
T.,Farag, A. B., and Klimes-Szmik, A., Anal. Chim. Acta, 64, 71, 1973. With permis-
sion.)
Table 77
DETERMINATION OF CERIUM
(IV), VANADIUM (V), AND IRON
(III) BY COLUMN "MEMORY"
Amount (mg)
Ion
determined Present Found Average
100 I I
o
CJ 50
Q
LLI
L.
oc
I I
10 20 30 40 50 60
ml Ce(S0 4 ) 2
Table 78
DETERMINATION OF CERIUM (IV), VANADIUM (V), AND
IRON (III) BY THE PULSED COLUMN TECHNIQUE
" Elution with 1 Msulfuric acid. Cerium (IV) solution at room temperature.
* Elution with 1 Msulfuric acid. Vanadium (V) solution at 80°.
e
Elution with 0.03 Mhydrochloric acid. Iron (III) solution at 80°.
From Braun, T. and Farag, A. B., Anal. Chim. Acta, 65, 139, 1973. With permission.
rations using batch, normal column, and pulsating column operations. The membrane-
like structure of the polyurethane foams together with the excellent hydrodynamic
properties of columns packed with them, allowed in these cases relatively fast flow
rates in column experiments. The resilient character of open-cell polyurethane foams
enabled their application in pulsating column operations. The automation of the latter
procedure provides a simple method which can be very useful in routine field analysis.
It eliminates the transportation of bulky samples into the laboratory for analysis as
preconcentration can easily be made in the field.
Table 79
COLLECTION OF VARIOUS
CONCENTRATIONS OF
RADIOSILVER BY ISOTOPE
EXCHANGE REACTION ON
COLUMNS PACKED WITH Ag2S"
FOAM
Average' Ag Relative
Amount of exchanged accuracy
Ag taken on foam of the mean
(X, %)
in the foam. Obviously, this procedure could be employed also for the immobilization
of other precipitates in foam membranes. The rate of isotope exchange separation of
silver on Ag2S foam was found to be quite fast as the exchange yield reaches 99% after
less than 10 min shaking. The exchange yield is slightly decreased by increasing nitric
acid concentration in the aqueous solution. It reaches 96% in 4 M nitric acid. Fast
collection of various concentrations of radiosilver has successfully been carried out on
columns packed with 2 g of Ag2S-foam using a flow rate of 40 mi min"1 (column
diameter, 15 mm) (Table 79). Polyurethane foam immobilizing finely divided copper
has also been prepared by a similar procedure.217 In this case heterogeneous ion ex-
change foam is changed to copper-form followed by the reduction of ionic copper in
the foam to metallic form with a sodium hydrosulfite (Na2S2O4) solution.
Copper-foam has successfully been used for redox-exchange separation of radiosil-
ver from aqueous solution. The rate of redox-exchange retention of silver as measured
in batch experiments was found to be quite fast. The retention was increased by in-
creasing the acid concentration up to 2 M HNO3 and decreased as the acid concentra-
tion was increased. This was attributed to the significant dissolution of copper at high
acid concentrations. Good separation yields of silver were obtained with copper foam
columns employing flow rates of 20 mjf min'1 (column diameter, 15 mm).
Gimesi and Banyai218 immobilized finely divided silver chloride (or silver iodide) or
colloidal silver on open-cell polyurethane foams by soaking the foam material in 10
vol% TBP solution in ethanol followed by mixing the squeezed foam with 0.1 M silver
nitrate solution. The foam thus produced is heated either with acidic sodium chloride
(or sodium iodide) solution to precipitate finely divided silver halide in the foam mem-
branes, or with ascorbic acid to produce colloidal silver on the surfaces of the mem-
branes. The researchers described rapid procedures for the retention and concentration
of radioiodine using these silver foams. Radioiodine in the iodide form was retained
by precipitate-exchange on silver chloride foam columns and by isotope-exchange on
silver iodide foam columns. Polyurethane foam impregnated with colloidal silver binds
141
Table 80
ANALYSIS OF SAMPLES BY
APPLICATION OF POLYURETHANE
FOAMS
13>
Moisture I added Radioactive
Sample (%) (Bq/g)" yield (%)
Cereals 8 0.04
Potato 75 0.04—4 75—80
Salad 90 0.04—4
• Dried sample
10 —
0.01
FIGURE 73. Effect of the concentration ratio of iodide ion in aqueous solution and
on foam on the isotope exchange yield with TBP-plasticized iodine foam. (From Braun,
T. and Farag, A. B., J. Radioanal. Chew.., 25, 5, 1975. With permission.)
iodine solution in TBP.219 This foam was found to retain iodine firmly and is suitable
for the isotope exchange separation of radioiodide in batch and flow operations. The
reaction of radioiodide and the immobilized iodine in the foam can be represented by
the following equation:
where the asterisk denotes the radioisotopes of iodine. The exchange of the iodide ion
by the iodine foam was found to be quite fast as the equilibrium value is reached after
less than 10 min of shaking in the batch extraction mode. The highest exchange yield
was obtained from aqueous solutions having pH values lower than one. In flow exper-
iments, the exchange yield (the percentage retention of radioiodide on the foam col-
umn) was determined as a function of the ratio of total amount of exchangeable ion in
solution (I~) and total amount of exchangeable ion in foam (I 2 ). A flow rate of 6 to 8
mi min~' (column diameter, 15 mm) has been employed in these experiments. Figure
73 shows that the experimental points are more or less on the theoretical curve (solid
line) calculated by Eckhardt et al.220 using the equation:
— = _ = (!- e (26)
a L
143
Table 81
COLLECTION OF VARIOUS
CONCENTRATIONS OF
RADIOIODIDE BY ISOTOPE
EXCHANGE REACTION ON
COLUMNS PACKED WITH TBP-
PLASTICIZED IODINE FOAM
Average Relative
Amount of I" exchanged accuracy
r taken on foam" of the mean
(^g) (X, %) (%)
When the concentration of the exchangeable ion in the foam bed is equal to its
concentration in the aqueous solution, L = F (L/F = 1), the fraction of the exchanged
ion b°°/a will be equal to 0.632. That is, the exchange yield is equal to 63.2%, assum-
ing that the isotope-exchange equilibrium is attained rapidly and all iodine in the foam
is available for this exchange reaction. The experimental value was found to be about
63% which indicates that the entire iodine-coated membranes of the plasticized foam
were involved in the exchange process under the experimental conditions used.219 That
is why the mobility of iodide ion in the iodine foam is very high.
The separation of radioiodide on iodine foam columns proved to be quite selec-
tive.219 Complete retention of iodide ion was obtained in the presence of as high as
100-fold excess of each of 24 Na, 42K, 38C1, and 83Br. Collection of various concentra-
tions of radioiodide by isotope exchange reaction on columns packed with TBP-plas-
ticized iodine foam has successfully been carried out (Table 81).
Palagyi et al. 221 - 222 suggested the preparation of an iodine foam by immobilizing a
solution of I2 in toluene diluted liquid anion exchanger (e.g., Alamine 336 or tri-n-
octylamine) in the foam membranes. They employed the I2-(Alamine)-foam columns
for collection of radioiodide from fresh milk and also from formaldehyde preserved
milk samples. It was indicated that the presence of formaldehyde did not affect the
separation of radioiodide. On the contrary formaldehyde improved separation (Figure
74). The separation efficiency of radioiodide is also influenced by the quality of milk,
flow rate of the sample, and to some extent the age of column filling. In the case of
milk with high fat content it was necessary to use lower flow rates. In all the cases, it
144 Polyurethane Foam Sorbents in Separation Science
80 -
50 -
20 40 60 80 100
FORMALDEHYDE, ml
FIGURE 74. Effect of formaldehyde (given in ml I ' of milk) on the separation effi-
ciency (%) under static conditions. (From Palagyi, S. and Markusova, R., Radiochem.
Radioanal. Lett., 32, 103, 1978. With permission.)
was possible to separate 131I from a 1-jf milk sample with over 80% separation effi-
ciency in less than 15 to 20 min, including washing the foam cubes and their prepara-
tion for radioactivity counting. Since 1 g of foam filling can easily be pressed into a
volume of 3.5 mi, a higher than 250-fold preconcentration of the separated radioiod-
ine could be attained.
Distribution of the radioactivity of the collected iodine is shown in Figure 75. Ob-
viously, this distribution is a function of the method used for packing the foam into
the column.
Iodine solutions in toluene in the presence and absence of a liquid anion exchanger
(e.g., TOA) have also been employed for the preparation of iodine foam. 222 The rate
of separation of radioiodide by iodine foams was found to be quite high with equilib-
rium attained in less than 10 min. Generally polyurethane foams treated with the iodine
solution containing TOA showed better separation efficiencies than those loaded with
iodine solution only. In the absence of TOA, the separation of radioiodide by iodine
foam proceeds by an isotope exchange mechanism according to the equation:
whereas in foams treated with a solution of I 2 in TOA, the mechanism is more compli-
cated.
The efficiency of iodine separation is slightly decreased by increasing the flow rate,
but separation is quite complete at flow rates as high as 150 mi. min"1 (column diame-
ter, 10 mm) (Table 82). The separation efficiency is generally decreased by increasing
the volume of the sample analyzed. The proposed method was successfully employed
for the separation of 13II from natural waters and there is practically no interference
from foreign ions usually present in hard water. 222
The application of pulsated column methods for the separation of radioiodide by
iodine foams has also been described.223'226 The separation of radioiodide in these sys-
145
10 15 20 25
FIGURE 75. Distribution of the I3 'I radioactivity along the column (radioiodine was separated at 60 ml
min~' flow rate, gamma-radioactivity was measured under a 0.5-cm Pb-slit, the column bed height is indi-
cated by arrows and the background level by dotted line). (From Palagyi, S. and Markusova, R-, Radi-
ochem. Radioanal. Lett., 32, 103, 1978. With permission.)
Table 82
SEPARATION OF 131I UNDER VARIOUS CONDITIONS (100 AND
1000 ml OF 0.0001 MNal IN 0.1 M HC1 AND 1.0 g OF FOAM
TREATED WITH 2.5 mi OF 0.1 MI 2 SOLUTIONS);
THEORETICAL VALUES IN PARENTHESIS
Separation efficiency in
From Palagyi, S. and Bila, E,, Radiochem. Radioanal. Lett., 32, 87, 1978. With permis-
146 Polyurethane Foam Sorbents in Separation Science
Table 83
THEORETICAL (Et) AND
EXPERIMENTAL (E«)
EFFICIENCY OF >31I
SEPARATION FROM VARIOUS
VOLUMES OF AQUEOUS
PHASE (W0) IN THE OPEN
ARRANGEMENT, USING I2-
AMINE-FOAM FILLING
terns in an open or closed arrangement depends on the number of pulses and the resi-
dence time of the aqueous phase in the syringe assuming that all other factors (e.g.,
solution pH, concentration of I2 on the foam, concentration of I" in aqueous solution,
etc.) are kept at the optimum values. It was found that for foam loaded with I2-amine
complex,606 2 to 3 pulses were quite enough to reach equilibrium (practically 100%
separation efficiency), but for foams loaded with iodine, about five or more pulses
were necessary. The effect of residence time of the aqueous phase in the iodine foam
syringe (pulsed column) during one particular pulsation was found to be insignificant.
In closed and open arrangements of the pulsated column operation, the separation
efficiencies measured were in good agreement with those theoretically calculated.60b
Slight differences were observed in the case of adding a liquid anion exchanger to the
iodine loading solution (Table 83). The most suitable concentration of iodide carrier
lies between 10~5 to 10'3 MNal (Figure 76).
The pulsating column method was successfully employed for the separation of 131I
from natural waters.60* Radioactivity was measured directly in the syringe. The results
obtained in an open arrangement and given in Table 84 show that foam cylinders
loaded with I2-Alamine 336 complex can be stored for more than 10 days.
It was also reported that the closed arrangement of the pulsated column method can
be easily automated.224 This offers the basis for a new type of device applicable in
environmental radioactivity monitoring. Iodine was separated from tap water (1 jf)
using the automatic pulsating column method with almost 95% efficiency after 500
pulses (i.e., 1 hr). Increasing the iodine content (e.g., 2.5-fold) on the foam, the num-
ber of pulses could be reduced to 200 to obtain the same separation efficiency of ra-
dioiodide(i.e., 95%).
The separation of radioiodide from fresh and formaldehyde preserved milk samples
147
100
80
,,r 60
40
FIGURE 76. Effect of the concentration of I" on the efficiency of 13I I separation
from 200-m.f sample in the open arrangement. (From Braun, T. and Palagyi, S., Anal.
Chem., 51, 1697, 1979. With permission.)
Table 84
EFFECT OF STORAGE OF THE FOAM
FILLING ON EXPERIMENTAL
EFFICIENCY (E.) FOR W a = 200 mi
0 93.4 98.8
1 93.5 98.9
2 92.1 98.9
4 92.6 98.7
7 90.0 98.5
11 89.5 98.5
by the pulsating foam column method has also been reported.225 Both open and closed
arrangements gave good separation yields. A concentration factor of more than 500
with recoveries of greater than 95% could easily be achieved.
The separation of radiosilver by isotope exchange separation of silver dithizonate
foam has been described.219 The isotope exchange reaction of silver on silver dithizon-
ate foam can be represented by the following equation:
where the asterisk denotes the radioisotope of silver. The rate of retention of radiosil-
ver from nitric acid solution on TBP-plasticized silver dithizonate foam as examined
148 Polyurethane Foam Sorbents in Separation Science
Table 85
COLLECTIONS OF VARIOUS
CONCENTRATIONS OF
RADIOSILVER BY ISOTOPE
EXCHANGE REACTION ON
COLUMNS PACKED WITH
SILVER DITHIZONATE FOAM
Average Ag Relative
Amount of exchanged accuracy
Ag taken on foam of the mean
^g X(%) (%)
1900-9501 r
Soda-
Asbestos
Pure Dry 1^ 1£ II I 1 Polyurethane Anhvdronp
to- U Combustion Run! Electric Furnace Foam Tube Tube Anhydrone
Oxygen ^ M
I
Combustion Run ^=5^U. Compressed Air
'^ Butane Gas
Mixture
Anhydrone Soda-
b. Internal Retention of Iodine Tube Asbestos
|900 - 950[
Anhydrone
FIGURE 77. The rapid straight empty tube apparatus. (From Farag, A. B., Attia, M. E., and Hassan, H.
N. A., Indian J. Chem., B20, 693, 1981. With permission.)
depending on the percentage of iodine. Presence of other halogens and sulfur interfere
with the proposed method because they are sorbed to a certain extent on the foam.
Polyurethane foam was suggested as a suitable material to form a filter bed on which
mercury vapors, 228 produced during the decomposition of organomercury compounds
with various dry-combustion methods, could be retained. A layer of about 7 cm packed
in the cooler part of the combustion tube was examined by repeatedly analyzing phen-
ylmercuric acetate and other organomercury compounds employing the rapid straight
empty tube combustion method. Correct carbon and hydrogen results were obtained
in more than 20 runs by using the same sorption tube which indicate the complete
retention of mercury vapors produced during the decomposition of organomercury
compounds. The use of a short foam layer eliminates the troubles frequently caused in
the determination of carbon and hydrogen in organomercury compounds due to the
high volatility of mercury produced during the decomposition of these compounds.
Also, the application of the foam sorbent, at room temperature, for the retention of
mercury in organic compounds is more convenient than any other expensive reagent
(e.g., gold, 232 usually employed for the same purpose). Furthermore, 0.5 g untreated
polyurethane foam packed in a standard Pregl absorption tube connected between the
combustion and water absorption tubes was successfully employed for the quantitative
retention of mercury in organic compounds.228 In this case, mercury could be deter-
mined together with carbon and hydrogen from the increase in weight of the absorp-
tion tube. The foam tube was found to function efficiently also with other combustion
methods; namely, the rapid empty tube method of Belcher-Ingram, the rapid flash
combustion method, and the cobaltocobaltic oxide method. Table 87 shows, for ex-
ample, the results obtained for the simultaneous determination of carbon, hydrogen
and mercury in various organomercury compounds using the rapid straight empty tube
method. A manganese dioxide tube or silica gel (suitably treated with a sulfuric-
chromic acid mixture) tube connected as usual between the water and carbon dioxide
absorption tubes was employed for the elimination of nitrogen combustion products
produced from the combustion of organic compounds containing nitrogen.
Organomercury compounds containing halogens have been successfully analyzed
(Table 87). The halogens (chlorine or bromine) were sorbed on a silver wool layer
placed in the combustion tube after the main combustion furnace and kept at 550°C
by means of a short furnace.
Table 86
SIMULTANEOUS MICRODETERMINATION OF CARBON, HYDROGEN,
AND IODINE IN ORGANIC COMPOUNDS
Found (%)
^•dlV,.
Compound (%) A B C D
lodobenzoic acid C 33.95 33.90 + 0.153 34.02 + 0.144 34.19 + 0.126 34.04 ± 0.232
H 2.03 2. 16 ±0.067 2.10 ± 0.122 2.21 ±0.126 2.20 + 0.083
I 51.17 51. 39 ±0.102 51.02 ±0.148 50.96 ± 0.071 51.03 ±0.251
Phenyl(trimethyl)- C 41.08 41.18 ± 0.235 41.18 + 0.232 41. 17 ±0.155 41.03 ±0.315
ammonium iodide H 5.36 5.46 ± 0.092 5.39 ± 0.293 5.47 ±0.158 5.29 + 0.214
I 48.23 48.27 + 0.369 48.31 ±0.145 48.26 + 0.184 48. 14 ±0.373
lodoform C 3.05 3.24 ± 0.093 3.31 ±0.045 3.29 ± 0.032 3.30 + 0.055
H 0.26 0.39 ± 0.048 0.64 + 0.045 0.60 ± 0.083 0.56 ± 0.071
I 96.69 96.53 ± 0.248 96.54 + 0.338 96.54 ± 0.228 96.57 ± 0.114
p-Iodoanisole C 35.92 36.04 ±0.319 36.16 ± 0.138 35.89 + 0.148 35.87 ± 0.232
H 3.02 3.17 + 0.057 3.32 + 0.032 3.16 + 0.214 3.17 ±0.129
I 54.23 54.27 ± 0.337 54.22 + 0.342 54.24 + 0.226 54.23 ± 0.277
o-Idophenol C 32.76 32.85 + 0.174 33.02± 0.077 32.86 + 0.236 32.76 ± 0.182
H 2.29 2.37 ± 0.022 2.64 ± 0.077 2.38 ±0.241 2.43 + 0.235
I 57.68 57.55 ± 0.227 57.49 ± 0.311 57.59 ± 0.254 57.48 + 0.084
Research (I) C 49.12 49. 30 ±0.261
C, 6 H V4 N 3 OI H 3.61 3. 80 ±0.107
I 32.44 32.57 ±0.161
Research (II) C 44.92 44.99 ± 0.283
C 16 H, S N 3 0 5 I H 3.35 3. 54 ±0.188
I 26.37 26.38 ±0.172
Research (III) C 50.39 50.47 ±0.149
C17H16N,OI H 3.98 4.04 ± 0.227
I 31.32 31.31 +0.218
Research (IV) C 31.96 31.06 ±0.212
C7H6O NI H 2.30 2.43 ± 0.239
I 48.25 48.28 ± 0.186
Research (V) C 37.66 37.65 ±0.189
C,H6NO2I H 2.11 2.13 + 0.214
I 44.21 44.24 ±0.179
Research (VI) C 35.45 35.41+0.199
C,H8N03I H 2.64 2.77 ± 0.099
I 41.60 41.60 ±0.223
Note: Each datum given for percentage is an average of four determinations. A = rapid straight
empty tube method; B = rapid empty tube method of Belcher-Ingram: C = rapid flash com-
bustion method; D = cobalto-cobaltic oxide method.
From Farag, A. B., Attia, M. E., and Hassan, H. N. A., Indian J. Chem., 20B, 693, 1981. With
permission.
152 Polyurethane Foam Sorbents in Separation Science
Table 87
SIMULTANEOUS MICRODETERMINATION OF CARBON,
HYDROGEN, AND MERCURY IN ORGANOMERCURY
COMPOUNDS BY THE RAPID STRAIGHT EMPTY TUBE
METHOD OF KORSHUN AND KLIMOVA
31U
Av found' dev
Compound Element Calc W (s)
From Farag, A. B., Attia, M. E., and Hassan, H. N. A., Anal. Chem., 52, 2153,
1980. With permission.
Untreated polyurethane foam retains to some extent chlorine and bromine produced
from the combustion of chlorinated and brominated organic compounds. Unfortu-
nately, the retention of these halogens is not quantitative.229 On the other hand heter-
ogeneous cation exchange foam in the silver form was found to retain these halogens
more efficiently than the untreated foam.229 A standard Pregl absorption tube filled
(two-thirds) with 1 g of the vacuum-dried silver foam, backed with anhydrone (anhy-
drous magnesium perchlorate) and connected between water and carbon dioxide ab-
sorption tubes, proved to retain quantitatively chlorine and bromine produced in the
153
, j c >
MH^ O « ' - ^ O O O ^ t o o ' < t O o r * -* m fS TJ- oo m ON
O ^r "•£ B^ <N(N<S(S(Nfnrn<S<N « ro M <S ~-« —• ~i
" S3 _ 3'"-' d d d d d d d d d O O O - ^ O O O
W C* S: ? «
Z W
>"H [-H O
E6
U
PN y ^ E _ t--wiOf^*n^<Nm«^ so HI ON ON ON <? \ vo
1
O i "« c ^ - s ^ : ^ ^ ^ "H°^cJlr!rt; — «n o TJ- r-_ "^ ^
1 W rt P^ ^r fn (S ^t r-' \dv vd
4 f r i
»X i-"
r i C
o\ v^ o «i ^ *s" ON
i—' r/5 E o ^ * ^ ' ~ ' ^ f S « r » ^ o o T f f n
ffi x* C/0 fc
U 52
Q SO
Z * f — ' 3 -ri'~v O—"(M<Svor-fnOS'-<Os«riV^r-vO>A\O^O'^-vO'«*O\«nm(N
^O^< *^ ^ «N—-fieNO — — - p r < i — ' O f S — ' p < N * S — . f ^ < N - H ( N r n O O r s
PHS >^_ "3 -*" d d d d d o o d o o d o d d o d d o d o d d d d d
Z
g » § !«
0! S | o OT
H
ts ~ S S "•
§8|
Si r v Z OO^t — OOr^iTj-ONt--'-'fSmOr--OON^t<^'^^-l ^ ' ^ i ' N — < f)
r^^™ r^r^sooi^ocp^triONr^irioornoNTtt^r^f^t^ — Osoov^r^
vll S Si "rt r^fnr^^r^soNOv^t^Mrio^Tr«rioo\OTi:r--ONr^ dov-^<soN
<^|2Q o vi r^m — in (svi --TJ- — ( v - i C ^ t S i o ^ o o T f r^
z<o I g-
§0 J §t
ptfQp-j H uKGuKuuKuoaGuKuuKUUuuOcjlw
H Q PS
wD wH o fe
O <H
u« w S
§8§ |-1 1 3
Sf f^i S || S „ 15
|
H — <
^ 3 «1 c
jj, i
K ._ « 8
•= 1
c 811
"
Z/H
i—i
-
g
S
u
^ o
c ™
t C
«
r r
o
t —
p
.
s
r
5
x )
o
^« - 2 - S :?
2 ' 2 - > o 2 - g E
r t
M^y j s - « N o c ^ o 2
SS U f f g l ^ ^ l? g c
p^ 6 . < c Q ( J a < c 1 , u K D ,
So
HH ~J '
1 0 0
C/Dg Z " " ( N f n ^ t n v o " * ^
154 Polyurethane Foam Sorbents in Separation Science
<
55 ^ ° •O ^^tvi|^^O'^:|nOvr--sOro(N
0 Z T3 ^ <s -« o <N es <s <s o <s r) oo
W & ! "" £ ^ 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Z W 65
<-< f-< o u
01
J J ^C
N °
.n s -a v o r - m ^ i ^ a v u v — r - — oo
ODJ "^ c -^ ""; °°. ""; ~ ^ o ^ "^ o "t ^
_] JS 3 ^ d —' r~' -.' <s « iX m — r~' m
LJ C/} ^-^ [i< O ^ m
fe
vo-st rf\o m — r-
W <" O)
u z
s
<ob 3 ^f 2s222S 28SS-32amR S
•T-'Z ^ "O ^^^ ddddddddddddddddd
II s fl I
O ^njnj
<
PM -S," T3 ^Oootor~-Tt^c3Oiri(N — •<tOOvor^ <tO •«
2P c^^ s o r ^ o o o o o m - < t r ^ ( s o — • o o ^ - i n v o s o ' ^ c
O i«C
QCOC-"
g
>3
3 ^ 6 - r ~ V' -Om
O S ^ m ^f
v O 'Tnt v<oX - ; rm- -—.' >r-o —
T
w vTdf vmi - f M10' Jj
g^
>H BC n " 5
BfcS i
^•" ^ D
1^-1^,-N _
S Tu3 / Z > o o r - ~ o o t - ~ O ' ^ i < f — < f s r ~ v o d
oo
'—^ O c / 5 S ^-^fS(NfSrirSfn-H(N<sp 5\
"uCQQ^ M-O " ^ d d d d d d d d d d d -
3 Q/ z fc « S m
•S < D O s | 2
§^25
" t B ^
1
«
-3g ^^ s0S —
R S[ - i- .R( Savqo i- ot Sm S— sI-s >na R-
,
^^OJSW O ^ m * - * ' » * f » > - H l - oj
-zo s I
•u o u ^
^hHriX-i io-^iriw-i-^CT\<^moo—'TtON(Sw-ioovc»n
S^
lAJ^Wr-j ^ »o r-- r-t v e s O N ^ r n i n p O ^ t oo »n -*t ^q \o r-;
r j*< S F-K ?
? o « t - - ' — i <s * vi en ^ I r - » n - H r ^ \ d w ~ i — <N J
H^^-iVJ .H r^ O't ^vo r^^r-Tj- Ttm i^ ^
Sr§3 |£ ^
^ S<
rtnffi H
I . .
uXcQUKosoKcnucQUSCmulDa
, . , . a-
c
So* I
§S2 I *
O ^H
^ Z Z
§a 1t
U « S g H
§§§ 1 § | s
wjo a = 5 1 1-
§M
Z 2
<W
M i l l 6
S S
&
S
&
S
*
o
a
r
2
S
m
<
H Z r S S S B S O -
JK Q f f l « o g r i »
P5 i, 6, ok « « in" M
So . ^
2^0^ 5 0 — <s m 1- >n O
OP Z - - - - - - £
155
CH 3 r
' Ch F
CH 3 -N + —CH 2 -CH 2 -S-C-C 3 H 7 —>
I II
CH3 0
CH3r
CH 3 -N + -CH 2 -CH 2 -SH + C 3 H 7 COO" (29)
CH3
* 5/8 Dia. ».
3/B
t /
1 Dia.
1 I
O
O
o O O
I C ) ° 0 § 0 ° C>
^
1
1/4
Thickness .003
Platinum
™w<r~(\CKv.tt'/.Ks:p*
HolderS.
O—Ring
° Enzyme Pad
Platinum Anode
Fritted Disc
FIGURE 78. Details of enzyme pad, O-ring and grid electrode assem-
bly. (From Bauman, E. K., Goodson, L. H., Guilbault, G. G., and Kra-
mer, D. N., Anal. Chem., 37, 1378, 1965. With permission.)
The immobilized cholinesterase can be used analytically in much the same way that
the soluble enzyme is used, that is, to determine concentration of a substrate, an inhib-
itor that inactivates the enzyme, or an activator that provides an acceleration in enzyme
activity.
On the basis of this work, Goodson and Jacobs236 designed an automatic system for
monitoring water supplies for organophosphates (Figure 79). Ten gallons of river water
can be passed through an enzyme pad without any detectable loss in enzyme activity.
In one test, the authors pumped city tap water through a single enzyme pad for 68 hr;
more than half of the enzyme activity was lost, but the residual enzyme activity was
still enough to produce an alarm in the instrument.
Several proteins and aluminum hydroxide were tested for sorption of cholinesterase
to increase its retention by a starch gel matrix.237 The sorbed cholinesterase was then
applied to sheets of open-pore polyurethane foam for evaluation. Enzyme pads pre-
pared by coprecipitation of cholinesterase with aluminum hydroxide gel followed by
entrapment in starch gel on the surface of open-pore polyurethane foam gave improved
157
ate
Water/Air Inlet
-Enzyme Holder
f- to> Waste
FIGURE 79. Cross section of electrochemical enzyme cell showing connections for the constant current
supply and the electrometer. (From Goodson, L. H. and Jacobs, W. B., Control of Hazardous Material
Spills, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Washington, DC, 1973, 129. With permission.)
activity and washout resistance. The foam pads have high enzyme activity and are easy
to prepare in large quantities, uniform in their activities, and suitable for use in the
electrochemical cell system for monitoring either air or water for cholinesterase inhib-
itors. When 2700 i of water were pumped through an enzyme pad to monitor organo-
phosphates in a water supply, a useful quantity of enzyme remained in the pad at the
end of the test period.
A detailed study has been made of the sensitivity of the "Continuous Aqueous Mon-
itor System" with cholinesterase-treated polyurethane foam pads for a variety of pes-
ticides.238 The sensitivity of the system was greater for P=O than for P=S compounds.
Response of the system to carbamate-type insecticides is good, and there is no response
to chlorinated hydrocarbon insecticides, herbicides, fungicides, or rodenticides.
Reticulated polyester polyurethane foams, the cells of which are free of residual
membranes, proved to be a suitable matrix for immunoadsorption of cells without
appreciable mechanical entrapment.239 Although the untreated foam has a high affinity
for guinea pig erythrocytes, the adsorption is not specific. The nonspecific affinity can
be greatly reduced by pretreating the foam with various polyanions, e.g., carboxyme-
thyl cellulose, polyacrylic acid, gammaglobulin, and gum arabic. Immunospecific
binding of erythrocytes can be achieved by adding antierythrocyte antibody to a gum
arabic solution used to protect the foam. The foam columns are mounted in a horizon-
tal position and rotated centrifugally to prevent rapid sedimentation of cells before
they come in contact with the foam surfaces. A single antibody-coated foam disk (1
in. diameter, 0.5 in. thick) can bind up to 3 x 10* guinea pig erythrocytes. The specific-
ity of this method was further proved by the finding that erythrocytes coated with
heptens were bound specifically to foam coated with their corresponding antihepten
antibodies, with a low background of cross-reactivity.
159
Chapter 2
I. INTRODUCTION
As shown, foamed polyurethane sorbents have been utilized for numerous analytical
chemistry applications, mostly in the area of collection, separation, and recovery of
inorganic and organic compounds from aqueous solutions and gaseous media. On the
other hand, however, open-pore polyurethane (OPP) sorbents have been employed
mostly in column chromatographic applications. OPP was first applied to column
chromatography by Salyer et al.240 241 and it subsequently found utility in gas242 24S and
liquid chromatography. 242 ' 246 " 248 Recently it has been applied for the recovery and/
or removal of various compounds from water. Navratil et al. 249 ' 251 tested it to recover
some polynuclear aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) and surfactants from water, and
others 61 - 252 have tested it for the removal of amines, nitrogen heterocyclics, phenols,
and PAHs from coal conversion waste water streams.
The favorable properties of OPP are what make it a useful separation material and
chromatographic support. Its unique polymer structure is not a resilient network of
membranes on dodecahedral cells as found in foamed polyurethane but is composed
of agglomerated hollow spherical membranes bonded to each other in a rigid, highly
permeable structure; its permeability facilitates high solvent and gas flow rates. The
spheres are very uniform with diameters of 1 to 10 ^irn, much smaller than cells of
foamed polyurethane. OPP is unique among supports used in column chromatography
in that it is polymerized in situ and adheres to the column walls thus reducing channel-
ing effects.
Jefferson and Salyer253 were the first to prepare OPP by relatively slow precipitation-
polymerization of an isocyanate and a polyol in carbon tetrachloride-toluene solution.
By controlling the reaction conditions, a polymer with specific density, porosity, and
surface characteristics can be prepared. It can be tailored to specific separation appli-
cations by chemically bonding functional groups at the —OH and —OCN sites. It is a
high-capacity support material, and stationary phases can be added to coat it or pref-
erably incorporated into its structure during its preparation.
The synthesis, properties, and applications of OPP have been admirably re-
viewed, 3.96.97.254-256 {,ut no); (.Q jjjg (jgpjh attempted here. An extensive overview follows
on its preparation, effect of synthesis conditions on OPP properties, compatibility and
other properties of OPP, analytical applications (gas and liquid chromatography and
collection and concentration methods), and miscellaneous applications (removal and
recovery of various organic compounds from waste water).
Usmani and Salyer256 point out that OPP structures can also be made from other thermosetting resins
and especially urea/formaldehyde/melamine/formaldehyde and copolymers thereof.
160 Polyurethane Foam Sorbents in Separation Science
OCN
NCO
where n has an average value of 0.5 to 2.0, containing about 40 to 50°7o diisocyanate,
the balance being tri-, tetra-, and pentaisocyanates. The material, referred to as "crude
MDI," has a functionality of about 2.5 NCO groups per molecule and an equivalent
weight of 131. Kaiser Chemicals' NCO-10, having an average functionality of ~2.3
and an equivalent weight of 132 to 135, has also been used, but is not now commer-
cially available.243 244 Most of the reported work have used OPP prepared with Mobay
Chemical Company's (Pittsburg, Pennsylvania) Mondur MR. 61 - 243 ' 253 Both NCO-10
and Mondur MR are mixtures of 4,4'-diphenylmethane diisocyanate and lesser
amounts of the tri-, tetra-, and pentaisocyanates.243 247 Mondur MR has an average
functionality of approximately 2.7 and an equivalent weight of 132.247
The usual polyol used is Union Carbide's (New York, New York) NIAX Polyol LA-
475 (polypropylene glycol), a mixture of pentahydroxyl compounds synthesized from
the total oxypropylation of diethylene triamine. The oxypropylation of the amine hy-
drogens yields the following intermediate pentahydroxyl compound:
OH
I
CH 3 —CH—CH 2 OH
and oxypropylation proceeds at the hydroxyl hydrogens until the average equivalent
weight of the mixture has reached 118 (functionality of five hydroxyl groups per mol-
ecule). 247
OH
I
-N-CH 2 -CH-CH 3 + CH 2 CH-CH 3 ->
\/
0
CH 3 OH
(60 °C). Denton et al. 252 report that flushing the OPP with n-heptane, methanol, water,
and again with n-heptane, and drying and storing in air, increased the life of the col-
umn.
The monomer reactants should be between 15 wt% and 30 wt% to produce good
OPP columns. 254 If the concentration of monomers is less than 15 wt%, the matrix
will be fragile and the resulting shrinkage will cause the OPP to pull away from the
column walls. If >30 wt% monomers are used, it will crack and open undesirable
channels.
The polymerization proceeds readily at ambient temperatures. Lower temperatures
increase gel time whereas higher temperatures decrease gel time. Reaction at both ex-
tremes of temperature may produce an undesirable OPP structure. 254 The lower reac-
tion temperature produces a less rigid structure while high temperatures may cause
convection currents in the reaction mixture, which could disrupt gel formation and
weaken the OPP structure. These and other preparation factors also have an effect on
its properties; they will be discussed in the next section.
Table 89
THE EFFECT OF REACTANT CONCENTRATION AND
SOLVENT ON SOME PROPERTIES OF OPP°
Density Shore A Porosity"
Total monomer (g cm'3) hardness"
reactants
ecu Toluene ecu Toluene ecu Toluene
12 0.26 0.14 0 0 79 90
15 0.32 0.18 40 0 77 86
17 0.33 0.24 57 0 74 82
20 0.38 0.27 65 28 74 81
25 0.38 75
25" 0.36 79 74
25' 0.24 0 80
From Jefferson, R. T. and Salyer, I. O., U.S. Patent 3, 574, 150, 1971.
10
9
OH/NCO = 0.5
8
I 5
I I
0.1 0.2 0.3
BULK DENSITY (g/cm 3 )
FIGURE 80. Dependence of the average OPP particle diameter on the initial mon-
omer bulk density for OPP prepared at 21 °C, Bulk density defined as the total grams
of monomers per milliliters of monomers and solvent. (From Herman, D. P. and Field,
L. R., J. Chromatogr. Sci.,99, 123, 1974. With permission.)
164 Polyurethane Foam Sorbents in Separation Science
3!
Sin,
165
SES
II "I
•g.2
h
03
~ •?
5,8
f£
£&
Ov <*5
W"J
» J
"Sfc
« .
II
]1
1 ^
'•• wi
8 S
.1 S
~n
c .
.2 -;
RJ K^
N ^
li
1 2
on
D. -
S «
t>
s^
it- t>
•3 o
S g
•a .S
2 D
« .
o. •
u «
£a
Sg
•s- Qg
si
^b
!^
§^d
i <N" .2
cj ts• K
u w
i2 i 'e
o «3
_' <J &
s
00
Z -S
s'^"
§°g
E £ £
166 Polyurethane Foam Sorbents in Separation Science
13
12
11
(a) -22 C
10
_ 8
E
-S 7
Q.
' 6
(b)21"C
5
FIGURE 82. Dependence of average OPP particle diameter on the amount of catalyst
added and reaction temperature for OPP with a bulk density of 0.215 g cm'3, (a) OH/
NCO = 0.5; (b) OH/NCO = 2. (From Herman, D. P. and Field, L. R., J. Chromatogr.
Sci.,99, 123, 1974. With permission.)
spherule diameters result.243 Figure 82 shows the dependence of the average OPP par-
ticle diameter on the amount of catalyst added and the reaction temperature.248 The
particle diameters decreased with increased catalyst concentrations and reaction tem-
perature. Herman and Field248 showed that increasing the temperature of reaction re-
sults in decreasing the magnitude of the effect of catalyst concentration on particle size
and vice versa. Denton et al.252 observations are in agreement with the above data.
Figures 83 and 84 show electron micrographs of OPP prepared with various catalysts
and under different temperatures, respectively. There is a general increase in the for-
mation of more uniform spheres as the catalyst was added and changed from DBTDL
and EuFOD. The OPP particles became more oblong and mishappen as the reaction
temperature was decreased, but the low-temperature formations exhibited more fine
structure.
The effect of isocyanate functionality was briefly studied and found to exert little
influence on the OPP density and porosity, 3 9 6 9 7 2 5 3 2 5 7 but was claimed to influence the
average surface area (0.4 m2 g~'). 242 However, the OH/NCO functionality ratio does
appear to affect the OPP density, shore A hardness, and porosity (Table 90), and
average particle diameter (Figure 80). Scanning electron micrographs of polyurethane,
prepared with OH/NCO functionality ratios of 1 and 2.2 (Figure 85), show that the
lower functionality produces a more uniform and well formed OPP.
The OH/NCO ratio can be varied to leave either excess hydroxyl groups or isocyan-
ate groups on the OPP and change the surface functionality of the OPP. 246 OH/NCO
ratios were varied from 1:30 to 10:1. Useful gels were found to be formed in the range
of 1:2.0 to 2.0:1; gels just outside this range were slow in forming. 249 The OPP pre-
pared from a 1:2 ratio of Mondur MR-LA-475 as compared to the 1:1 formulation
had less polar character.245
167
(DBTDL)
FIGURE 83. Electron micrographs of OPP prepared using different catalysts. DBTDL = dibutyltindilaur-
ate; EuFOD = 2,2-dimethyl-6,6,7,7,8,8,8-heptafluro-3,5-octanedione, europium(III). OH/NCO = 2.2;
24°C; 59 hr. (From Denton, M. S., Dinsmore, S. R., Brand, J. I., Beams, J., and Ball, F. L., Sep. Sci.
Technol., 15, 587, 1980. With permission.)
168 Polyurethane Foam Sorbents in Separation Science
(EuFod)
FIGURE 83 (continued)
169
(NONE)
FIGURE 83 (continued)
170 Polyurethane Foam Sorbents in Separation Science
FIGURE 84. Electron micrographs of OPP prepared at different temperatures. OH/NCO = 2.2; 59 hr.
(From Denton, M. S., Dinsmore, S. R., Brand, J. I., Beams, J., and Ball, F. L., Sep. Sci. Technol., 15,
587, 1980. With permission.)
171
FIGURE 84 (continued)
172 Polyurethane Foam Sorbents in Separation Science
(24° C)
FIGURE 84 (continued)
173
Table 90
THE EFFECT OF OH/NCO FUNCTIONALITY RATIO
ON SOME PROPERTIES OF OPP
Total monomer
reactants Density Shore A Porosity'
(wt%) OH/NCO (gem" 3 ) hardness- (%)
18 0.95 0.23 — 86
1.00 0.24 10 81
25 1.00 0.38 88 75
1.03 0.38 90 74
1.05 0.33 85 77
1.11 0.41 91 70
The unique preparation method and properties of OPP make it valuable for many
types of analytical chemistry applications, including chromatographic separations. The
174 Polyurethane Foam Sorbents in Separation Science
FIGURE 85. Electron micrographs of OPP prepared with different OH/NCO functionality ratios (left
micrograph = OH/NCO = 1.0; right micrograph = OH/NCO = 2.2). 0°C, 59 hr. (From Denton, M. S.,
Dinsmore, S. R., Brand, J. I., Beams, J., and Ball, F. L., Sep. Sci. Technol., 15, 587, 1980. With permis-
sion.)
175
FIGURE 85 (continued)
176 Polyurethane Foam Sorbents in Separation Science
Table 91
OPP-SOLVENT COMPATIBILITY
From Hansen, L. C. and Sievers, R. E., /. Chromatog.,99, 123, 1974; and Navratil, J.
D., Sievers, R. E., and Walton, H. F., Anal. Chem.,49, 2260, 1977. With permission.
method of polymer synthesis allows easy preparation of almost any size or configura-
tion of gas or liquid chromatographic column. The packing is uniform and adheres
tightly to column walls, preventing channeling. OPP can be tailored to many specific
applications by addition of liquid phases to the starting monomers to give a polymer
with a uniform phase distribution. If the liquid phase contains groups capable of re-
acting with the OPP, then a bonded phase can be obtained. Various types of fillers
(including particulate nickel, activated carbon, etc.) can be incorporated into OPP
during polymerization. 258 The narrow spherical size distribution and openness of the
gross packing structure of the polyurethane result in good mechanical strength, high
permeability, and high capacity supports for high-speed, low-pressure drop chromat-
ographic separations as well as for collection, recovery, and concentration purposes.
A. Gas-Solid Chromatography
The application of uncoated OPP for gas-solid chromatographic separation was sug-
gested in 1968.240 Salyer, Ross, and Jefferson 2 4 1 2 4 2 showed that eight normal hydrocar-
bons could be separated and eluted in the order of their increasing boiling points (Fig-
ure 87). Hileman et al.243 reported that polar compounds containing protons capable
of hydrogen bonding are separated and eluted in the probable order of the acid
strength (Table 92) of the available proton. The elution order results from the abun-
dant tertiary nitrogen atoms and carbonyl groups which make the uncoated OPP very
susceptible to hydrogen bonding.
The polar nature of OPP was used to separate geometrical isomers of various metal
chelates. C/sand trans isomers of Cr(tfa)3 (Figure 88) were completely resolved within
177
3000
1000
cc
H
tn
500
100
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
STRAIN, %
FIGURE 86. Compression stress-strain curves of conventional rigid and flexible ure-
thane foams compared with OPP. (From Doyles, E. N., The Development and Use of
Polyurethane Products, McGraw-Hill, New York, 1971. With permission).
6 min.243 The complete separation of cisand trans isomers of Rh (tfa)3 were also com-
pletely resolved on OPP.244 The difference in the polarity of the isomers results in the
elution of the trans isomer in half the time of the polar cis isomer. This separation
technique was used to perform rate and equilibrium studies of cis-trans isomerization
of Cr(tfa) 3 in the gas phase.259
Separations on uncoated OPP involve gas-solid adsorption as demonstrated in a
study of retention times and peak shapes of dodecane with varying sample sizes. 243 - 244
Decreasing retention times and increasing tailing was observed with larger samples,
typical of gas-solid chromatography. Overloading becomes a problem with sample
sizes over 0.4 mg.
An important consequence of the gas-solid behavior of OPP is that once the mini-
mum HETP has been obtained, the efficiency of the column does not decrease with
increasing flow rate over a wide range. 243 244 Hileman 244 showed, using a van Deemter
plot, that there was no loss in plate number with flow rates as high as 150 ml min"1.
This behavior corresponds to a small mass transfer term in the van Deemter equation
and shows that equilibrium in the adsorption process is achieved very rapidly.
The permeability of OPP columns was found to be substantially better than micro-
range silica columns and comparable with Chromosorb® W.243 Table 93 lists the
permeability, porosity, and theoretical plate number of OPP of varying bulk density
and Chromosorb® W of varying mesh size. OPP bulk densities of 0.15 to 0.18 g cm"3
are recommended. Higher OPP densities give columns with low permeability and re-
duced efficiency in plate number and resolution; lower densities result in column chan-
neling. A summary of conditions used for gas chromatographic separations of various
materials on OPP is given in Table 94.
178 Polyurethane Foam Sorbents in Separation Science
C8
C9
C12
VI
12 16 20 24
MINUTES
Table 92
RELATIVE RETENTION DATA OF
VARIOUS POLAR COMPOUNDS ON
UNCOATED OPP"
1.0
Trans
LU
C/5
O
Q-
cc
cc
tr
O
o
LU
CC
oL /
L I
0 2 4 6
RETENTION TIME (minutes)
B. Gas-Liquid Chromatography
Less polar gas chromatographic columns of OPP can be prepared by using station-
ary phase. The liquid can be either coated on the OPP or incorporated into the polymer
by addition of the stationary phase to the precursor solutions. Coating the OPP with
a stationary phase masks the gas-solid properties completely, so that the material
adopts the characteristics of a gas-liquid substrate. Thus, instead of an adsorption
mechanism occurring, a solution process takes place and yields a more linear isotherm,
resulting in symmetrical peaks and constant retention times over a wide range of sam-
ple sizes. The liquid phase yields greater sample capacity with efficiencies of 900 to
1200 plates per meter. 243 The resolution and theoretical plate number improve for cer-
tain compounds. 244
Loss of the polar character of OPP in using liquid coatings was illustrated by Hile-
man et al.243 Although various metal chelates could be separated on an OPP column
coated with DC-550 (Figure 89), the c/sand trans isomers of Cr(tfa) 3 and Rh(tfa) 3 are
180 Polyurethane Foam Sorbents in Separation Science
Table 93
CHARACTERISTIC PARAMETERS FOR 1-METER OPP
AND CHROMOSORB® W COLUMNS
Theoretical
Column Permeability Porosity plate
type (cm1 x 10-') number* Resolution*
OPP
g cm'3'
0.106 16.0 90.9
0.130 6.26 88.2 483 4.30
0.154 2.92 87.0 772 5.13
0.178 1.14 85.5 800 5.50
0.198 1.05 84.5 700 5.14
0.243 0.44 75.8 602 4.65
Chromosorb* W
mesh size
40/60 8.86 89.0
60/80 4.71 87.6
80/100 3.14 88.6
100/120 2.71 85.5
For dodecane.
* Average of resolution between three pairs of n-hydrocarbons (n-C,, and n-C,2,
n-Cu and n-C13, n-C13 and n-C14).
' Bulk density.
d
Serious channeling.
From Hileman, F. D., Sievers, R. E., Hess, G. G., and Ross, W. D., Anal.
Chem.,45, 1126, 1973. With permission.
Be (tfa), I
Al ( t f a ) ,
Cr (tfa).,
Rh (tfa)..
12
MINUTES
programmed runs, an upper limit of 200°C can be used. However, with OPP prepared
with the polyol EPON 1001, the column can be operated at temperatures as high as
225 ° C 245
Besides improving the temperature stability of OPP, Chen, et al.245 also reported
reducing peak tailing for chromatograms of polar molecules. They found by increasing
the OH/NCO functionality from 1 to 2 decreased the polarity of the OPP and gave
good gas chromatographic separations of, and symmetrical peaks for, polar com-
pounds including alcohols. Figures 94 and 95 illustrate these improvements.
OPP has proven to be useful for both gas-solid and gas-liquid supports for gas
chromatographic separations. Although the range of separations that can be per-
formed by GC is limited, the prospects from improvement are bright because of the
variety of OPP columns which can be prepared. However, OPP has found a wide
acceptance as a separation media in liquid chromatography.
183
' , n-Butanol
n-Propanol ~
n-Pentanol
o
Q-
n-Hexanol
to
LU
QC
DC
O
O
LU
I-
LU
Q
I
12 16 20 24
MINUTES
C. Liquid Chromatography
Successful liquid chromatography (LC) separations have been achieved with OPP
columns by various investigators. Applications have included the separation of metal
chelates,242 alcohols,247 dichloroanilines, aromatic hydrocarbons, 247248 keto-steroids,
etc. 249 The high permeability and small particle size of OPP allow efficient separations
to be made using inexpensive high-speed, low-pressure LC equipment. Table 95 sum-
marizes the conditions used for LC separations of various materials on OPP columns.
The chemical and physical stability of OPP, coupled with the ability to change po-
rosity and functionality, make it an excellent support for LC. A wide variety of sol-
vents are compatible with OPP as described in Section III.B. The mechanical proper-
ties of OPP permit injections of samples directly on the column without any syringe
needle blocking. No inlet or outlet filters, which contribute to band spreading, are
required since the OPP bonds to the column wall. Column length can be significantly
increased to generate a greater total number of theoretical plates before exceeding the
pressure (100 kg cm~2) wherein the polymer begins to collapse. However, because of
the excellent permeability of OPP, low pressures (<10 kg cm"2) yield typical high speed
LC flow rates; the requirement for expensive high pressure pumps is thus eliminated.
OPP has a wide dynamic sample loading range compared to alumina and silica type
adsorbents used in LC. Columns of 2 mm diameter and 1 meter length will take up to
50 ^g of 2,4-dichloroaniline before the peak broadens, and even larger sample sizes do
184 Polyurethane Foam Sorbents in Separation Science
I C6 C7 C8 C9 T
cc
o
I-
o
LU
I-
m
D
MINUTES 12
MINUTES
FIGURE 91. Separation of aromatic hydrocarbons by FIGURE 92. Separation of C6-C, aliphatic hy-
GC on OPP coated with Carbowax^ 400. Column: 1 m drocarbons by GC on OPP coated with 10 wt%
x 4 m m I.D. and 110°C. Helium flow rate: 40 ml min"1. Dow Corning Silicone Fluid 550. Column: 0.5 m
(From Hileman, F. D., Sievers, R. E., Hess, G. G., and x 6 mm I.D. and 30 to 100°C at 10° min-. He-
Ross, W. D., Anal. Chem., 45, 1126, 1973. With per- lium flow rate: 60 ml min"1. (From Ross, W. D.
mission.) and Jefferson, R. T., /. Chromatogr. Sci., 8,
386, 1970. With permission.)
not decrease peak symmetry indicating a more liquid-liquid partitioning type of chro-
matography. 246
Compared to GC, slightly higher bulk density formulations of polymer result in
more efficient LC columns. Lynn et al.,246 used an OPP with a density of 0.18 g ml'1
while Hansen and Sievers247 found better results using a 0.197 g mi~' material. Herman
and Field248 observed that polyurethane with densities as high as 0.243 g mi' 1 yielded
favorable results.
Herman and Field248 found that plate number efficiencies of OPP columns can be
increased by ~60% when multiple in situ polymerizations are performed. They ob-
served that a normal polymerization yields OPP with a packed bed matrix having an
abnormally large, open structure compared to a packed column of porous spherical
silica of comparable size; thus band broadening is increased with OPP because of
extensive axial molecular diffusion and mass transfer. The OPP matrix also contains
local inequalities in the packing density; i.e., the individual particles formed in clusters
185
leaving large voids between the clusters, which causes significant band broadening due
to eddy diffusion.
The multiple in situ polymerizations were performed by quickly pumping fresh so-
lutions of premixed reaction monomers into previously formed, in situ polymerized
OPP columns and allowing particle formation to occur within their interstitual
voids. 248 By partially filling the voids of the columns, the resulting matrices possess
lower intestinal porosities as well as more uniform distributions of particle density,
thus resulting in more efficient columns. Figure 96 shows flow-efficiency plots of re-
duced plate height vs. reduced velocity for singly, doubly, and triply polymerized OPP
columns. Although OPP column efficiencies were improved by multiple polmeriza-
tions, the performance of these columns does not compare favorably with that of mi-
croparticulate silica columns. Further significant improvements in OPP column effi-
ciencies may require a new set of reaction conditions that reduce interparticle bonding
(clustering) and yield more uniform packed bed structures. 248
LC separations have been improved by altering the synthesis conditions of OPP.
The effect of OH/NCO functionality was evaluated by Lynn et al.246 Figures 97 and
98 show the separation of dichloroanilines on OPP with different OH/NCO function-
alities. Measurements on the 2,6-dichloroaniline peak indicate an efficiency of 1085
theoretical plates per meter with an inlet pressure of only 4.9 kg cm"2 and a flow rate
of 0.25 mi min' 1 . The OPP with an OH/NCO of 2 gave 1720 theoretical plates per
186 Polyurethane Foam Sorbents in Separation Science
6 12
TIME (mm)
C/3
D
2 s- N
04 « "e R . ""! I "! °1 "1 I I I
<J Q. o — d •* m fi •* -»
I> u ^
fc 5
o
en
z
O rt
s rC "">
HH t- — c T l < x
v-t r
v o ^M o ^ o . m
H * B i ! ! " . " I ™ . ^ 1 ° !
^ o ^ ~ o o o c > c > o' o o
E B
(4
<
IX
1/3
W
U
a
5
u »
5
s !
J.
^5 v -x ^
«-i ^ J J K c1^ S c d
5C « > 22 csXu u
c u Sta^v
5 S> <u o o -S°S S •S'O
* c o 5 ; > c S 2 _ u ^ 2 S 2 ^ « 't
^1 s i 1 I I i m f I tt a|Si
g § II § 5 ^
2 j = wg ' 2 ^ ^ ^
! p3
5 g ^
3
N
^ l^il
^ l o ^ g V :
I ! ! ! a-*!"! il 6 sll -9
§ III isii ii ! srg |
| ? ||| Jill I e s I US, I
$ TJ s * * ^ • S -?
" ' § - - 3 § S S . SBS3| |
8 I I I I i!5i *i I I 1|H i
0
< *I ! f U 1| I II 1 1 Idlll |? v
M
1
to
"S 5 ! 1 4i*i|3J!I ! ill!!! § ss
« « * s s - " -2 " -S .s « « S tt ,a e e "g x | \ $ s
g - S ?• . g g&S^-gg'-S^g g SS,«£2^ EgKDC
s o g - s o g a g 8 « | a « | a s g'ss.^g ° < ° o
a - a s ,8 =• a a * « « s « M 2 ,s s l & ^ ^ u ^ _ _
188 Polyurethane Foam Sorbents in Separation Science
I—
I
C3
UJ
I
UJ
5
Q.
Q
01
u
D
Q
CC
FIGURE 96. Plots of reduced plate height vs. mobile phase reduced velocity for (a) 0.48 m x 3.9 mm I.D.
column of singly polymerized OPP column; (b) doubly polymerized OPP; and (c) triply polymerized OPP.
All OPP columns were OH/NCO = 0.5, bulk density = 0.243 g m/~'. Mobile phase and the solute were 1,2-
dichloroethane and p-chlorophenol, respectively. (From Herman, D. P. and Field, L. R., /. Chromatogr.
Sci., 20, 55, 1982. With permission.)
15 20 25
ELUTION TIME (minutes!
meter at 0.26 mi min"1 using an inlet pressure of 3.5 kg cm 2. The values of HETP for
OPP are similar to those obtained with porous layer bead, Corasil® II, and consider-
ably larger than the values obtained with small particle porous silica 5 to 10 mm. 246
Hansen and Sievers247 evaluated the performance of OPP with OH/NCO = 2.2 and
1.0. With the excess polyol, phenol eluted later, gave a more symmetrical peak and
had much higher sample loadings.
Herman and Field248 investigated retention and selectivity differences of OPP having
excess surface hydroxyl or nitrile functional groups. Table 96 shows that EPON-type
columns are less retentive for acidic solutes than their LA-475 counterparts because of
the tertiary nitrogens in the monomer backbone of the LA-475 (which are not present
in the EPON). Nitrile surface-bonded OPP exhibits a lower degree of selectivity for
acidic solutes than the excess polyol types because of more potential hydrogen bonding
on a hydroxyl surface compared to that on a nitrile surface.
Larger selectivity differences were observed between polyol and nitrile surface
190 Polyurethane Foam Sorbents in Separation Science
Table 96
ELUTION BEHAVIOR OF PHENOL AND p-
CHLOROPHENOL ON EXCESS POLYOL
AND ON NITRILE BONDED OPP COLUMNS
Capacity factors
Sep.
Column Phenol p-Chlorophenol factor
bonded OPPs when a mobile phase of low polarity was used."8 Several polar com-
pounds were not retained on an excess polyol OPP when 10% dichloroethene/heptane
mobile phase was used. Similar behavior was observed by others,247 where OPP acted
as a zero capacity support using .n-heptane as the eluting solvent, but adding only small
amounts (10%) of a polar solvent to n-heptane retained polar solvents to some extent.
This behavior was believed to result from nonswelling of the polymer in a nonpolar
solvent, resulting in reduced effective surface area. However, the polar solvents tested
above were retained on a LA-475 nitrile column showing that this polymer swells under
nonpolar conditions.
Herman and Field248 found that OPP prepared with no polar hydroxyl or nitrile
surface bonded functional groups (prepared by terminating the urethane chains of the
EPON-based OPP with ethoxyl groups) had greater selective hydrophobic retention
characteristics.
Stainless steel microcapillary columns of OPP were demonstrated for several sepa-
rations. Figures 99 and 100 show the separation of eight polar compounds and keto-
steroids in less than 25 and 30 min, respectively. These results indicate that microcap-
illary OPP, in conjunction with low dead volume injectors and detectors (to reduce
band broadening), may have some utility because of the relative ease of OPP prepa-
ration.248
12 16 20 24 28
MINUTES
LAS in detergent.250•"' Figure 102 shows the breakthrough capacity and elution behav-
ior of LAS on an OPP column. Table 99 shows that OPP has the highest breakthrough
capacity for LAS, but the lowest capacity for total organic carbon (TOC) compared to
Amberlite® XAD-4 (Rohm and Haas) and Amoco GX-31, active carbon; the differ-
ence in breakthrough capacities was suggested as a method for separating LAS from
TOC.250
Other analytical chemistry uses of OPP include its use as a thin-layer chromatogra-
phy support for the separation of Camptothecin from a crude extract of Camptotheca
acuminata using benzene-acetone-methanol as the developing solvent.241
V. MISCELLANEOUS APPLICATIONS
A. Preparative Chromatography
Several properties of OPP make it a very attractive material for preparative chro-
192 Polyurethane Foam Sorbents in Separation Science
(b)
(c)
10 20 30 40
MINUTES
matographic work. OPP adheres tightly to the walls of the column thus preventing
channeling at the adsorbent-wall interface which is a potential problem with granular
adsorbents. The high liquid phase loading of the polymer yields high capacity columns.
These two properties, along with the lower cost of the material, make OPP useful as
preparative columns.
Ross and Jefferson 241 - 242 demonstrated the preparative-scale gas chromatographic
separation of nonane, heptane, and pentane; the support was 2.4 m x 5.7 cm and
coated with Dow Corning Silicone Fluid 550. No commercial preparative-scale liquid
chromatographic separations of the polymer have been reported, although the appli-
cations appear promising because of its versatility, high capacity, and low cost.
B. Wastewater Treatment
OPP has been used for the removal and recovery of various compounds from waste-
water. The polymer was tested for its ability to remove detergents, corrosive anions,
and coal conversion by-products from wastewater streams. 251 - 252
A comparison of OPP to activated carbon and other popular adsorbent materials
for detergent and chloride removal from wastewater was reported. 252 Several other
adsorbents outperformed polyurethane for detergent removal, but not for chloride or
193
i n i
O = OPP (OH.'NCO - 1.0)
A = BIO - RAD AG MP - 50
O -Amberhte XAD - 2
O =-- OPP (OH/NCO - 2.2)
o
o >
o
z
LU
y
LL
LL
LU
z
g
i-
o
LU
_1
0.2 _)
O
0
0.1
20 40 60 80 100
Table 97
VOLUMES OF METHANOL AND ETHANOL
REQUIRED TO ELUTE PYRENE FROM
VARIOUS POLYMERS-
the anionic surfactant constituent of the detergent, LAS (see Section IV.D). Open-pore
polyurethane prepared under a variety of conditions was compared to three common
commercial adsorbents for TOC, total phenol, etc., removal from both synthetic and
actual coal conversion wastewater, 612 " Figures 103 and 104 show respectively TOC
and phenol breakthrough curves for these materials. The data indicate that in compar-
194 Polyurethane Foam Sorbents in Separation Science
Table 98
RECOVERY OF PAH WITH OPP (OH/NCO = 2.2)
PAH Flow rate (I hr1) PAH Loaded (/jg) Recovery %
Benzo[a]pyrene 1.8 4 95 ± 6
Biphenyl 0.9—1.5 5—6 98 ±5
Fluoranthene 0.5—1.0 4—5 77 ±4
0.5—1.0 1—2.5 97 ± 3
Naphthalene" 0.1 5 56 ± 3
0.1—1.0 1—2.5 98 ± 10
Phenanthrene 0.8—1.0 5 58 ±1
0.8—1.0 1—2.5 92 ±9
Pyrene 0.6—0.8 1—4 100 ± 2
1.2—1.7 4—5 89 ±3
Pyrene (XAD-2)° 0.6 4 79 ± 8
From Navratil, J. D., Sievers, R. E., and Walton, H. F., Anal. Chem., 49, 2260,
1977. With permission.
ison to other polymers, OPP has an intermediate capacity for TOC and exhibits very
little breakthrough of phenols. The in situ polymer also has the advantage of eluting
better than the other sorbents. 61252 Table 100 shows the breakthrough data of the in-
dividual organic compounds making up the TOC.61 For both OPP and XAD the pri-
mary amine and the pyridine break through readily, and phenol to a slight degree.
OPP ranks nearly as well as activated charcoal on a capacity per weight of sorbent
basis; the low density of the polymer is an important factor in large-scale usage. With
individual compound class breakthrough data, a tertiary water cleanup process can be
tailored to suit particular needs. OPP offers a promising alternative to commonly used
charcoals and polymers for wastewater cleanup. Comparative cost and elution char-
acteristics are among its advantages. 61252
195
Table 99
BREAKTHROUGH AND ELUTION DATA FOR
SORBENTS"
Breakthrough capacity*
Elution'
Sorbent LAS TOC TOC
From Smith, C. M. and Navratil, J. D., Sep. Sci. Technol., 14, 255,
1979. With permission.
• X A D -2
O OPP
D Columbia
A Ambersorb X E - 348
o.o
7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
ALIQUOT NUMBER
FIGURE 104. Breakthrough curves for phenol on various adsorbents. Columns: 0.3
m x 2.5 cm l.D. C/Co = concentration (i.e., TOC in ppm) of effluent divided by con-
centration of feed. One aliquot = 34 mt. (From Denton, M. S., Dinsmore, S. R.,
Brand, J. I., Beams, J., and Bali, F. L., Sep. Sci. Technol., 15, 587, 1980. With per-
mission.)
_c QC
< II 111 s t l l l l ^ 5 £ | ^ l l ^ ^
r« B S S S I S 1 I § 8 S 3 S K s , K s ? S S S S £ K 2
VJ ^ — ( s ^ S ~ . t T * t r r * T W W t CM
H «
Z» |* ~ _
04 £ uS i e3 e Ss;s;sistssa£s£sI°SslsRs
Is
H ^
!o ,s « s
<r-.
*7
A
feH
<->
-
G
r Q
K <
lix
x * ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ * — ^ ^f^'O
_
S
r- ^fN~°o
P
m
g
°
J«S ^ | g ; S § S 5 S 5 g : g 5 S ° £ 2 i 6 S -
o3 <I " " """ " "
2o i, s
<u
^> HH
!§ p X S ^ S f s — - - — • S o
I'
I ^ f N ' ^ o S o c °
*^^ H H ^ T j - o o o o o o c r O o o - o S o ^ S "
2 ^ - - - - - - - M- - „• ~- ^- «
O Jj
CO ^ .= t „ ^
Q H H
HH 7; O
0
< - o o r M v o o x ( N v o ^ f ^ w o f N
x
O
o ; J i c
O
o S S
O "
Z O l 5 g ; K ^ 3 S S S S 8 8 K ° E ° 2 R ° - §
33x^
£? >:; < rf <M' m •»' •» N m fl-' <sT S is S o
_ _ _ _ ^ *>" S m. o
2S^ , a I
§ g A P I | I g = !
SQJ |" S » I S ? * S 3 iS S S*|g| S.i3= -
§||B - - I
on^Z
" < ^ f c ' °
- ^ _ - - ^ ^
S S i ° S R K
M
5
^ K » S ^ S S ~ O
S g S s l ^ S 5 s l
£
1
I^QS I s
H O2 2 s g 1 I
i ^ i J l - i n V R § S E
^^ ^^ MM O O \ o ^ > r - - r « i r ^ O S ' * i ' N c >
' o o c r - - ' O ' - ' O. <
O ) r n 2 ' 2 » 2 S S S S g R ° 2 g S 5 S
^ fc ^ s I
o* 2 ? > 'a 3 1
a
^O2 ° . I I •;" • 5
< U£ " i s S s s i i a l l s § § s I s| |°| g
Q
S* " " " ^oS 1
ac^
<i
=^ ° g8 ^-oT . ^ s <t
g8 ™
O
_^PJ ^ ^ « ^ r - - , f o o ^ r N q _ _ . ^ , 0 ^ ; g ™ £
f o T 1 a c
* " N fS (M ^ ^ — r ^ r - C h ^ — | M ^ O
2o | ^1! I
Kg I 2« I I 11-I ^
H 2 O = o , - S 5 S 8 S S S 5 S R S 2 6 2 E o 3 |
^<; a. ^ ^ - - _ _ - _ ^ _ _ _ _ „ a o
<S s ili§ ^
m
B O °^f ^ R = ^ ^ - f N
f f l § § i = s S 3 s s § i s 5 S s I S s |I|I |
&u 11=3 ?
o a t s i-s- s
8 s
bS
(^ fc t
.§ S " E V ' ^•I
<° IG s||l °"i
Sp< !: ! = ol^ S!
sg &i f3 = 1?i II
Sg \t jsl! I !l
i s „ -1«s i ' s
6 , 1 1 ISfca * "J
! 5 i 1 i g 'fa? i =-a
1
c £ .5 *> -^ ^ i O ^ - ^ S ^
i
U
o H
l g l i | , ^ i
11111
S u & l |
_ I ! I I 1|«I ^ l< l | 12 | | |° «
£ > i S E X X X X > < - 5 £ Q & E S S<g.a£= E«
J 2 - » U U v o < i A n ; i T f - D Q . V o Z < ! j : 2 w
0- M" 6 "^ rN ri r-i" r^" ''i — ffl (N (a. r^l H- . * v i . U- Z
199
REFERENCES
1. Braun, T. and Farag, A. B., Cellular and foamed plastics as separation media. A new geometrical
form of the solid phase in analytical liquid-solid contact, Talanta, 22, 699, 1975.
2. Flinn, J. E. and Cherry, R. H., Jr., Separation processes based on spherical membrane systems,
Chem. Eng. Progr. Symp. Ser.,65, 90, 1969.
3. Braun, T. and Farag, A. B., Polyurethane foams and microspheres in analytical chemistry. Improved
liquid-solid, gas-solid and liquid-liquid contact via a new geometry of the solid-phase, Ana/. Chi'm.
Acta, 99, 1, 1978.
4. Brunschwig, H., Liber de Arte Distillandi, 1512. (See also Bittel, A., Dissertation, Tubingen, 1957.)
5. Bayer, E., Gaschromatographie, 2nd ed., Springer-Verlag, Heidleberg, 1962, p. 4.
6. Lai, D., Arnold, J. R., and Somayajulu, B. L. K., Method for the extraction of trace elements from
sea water, Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta, 28, 1111, 1964.
7. Bauman, E. K., Goodson, L. H., Guilbault, G. G., and Kramer, D. N., Preparation of immobilized
cholinesterase for use in analytical chemistry, Anal. Chem., 37, 1378, 1965.
8. Van Venrooy, J. J., Polymeric foam column packaging for gas chromatography, U.S. Patent
3,347,020, 1967.
9. Bowen, H. J. M., Absorption by polyurethane foams; new method of separation, /. Chem. Soc. A,
1082, 1970; Braun, T. and Farag, A. B., Reversed-phase foam chromatography. Separation of pal-
ladium, bismuth and nickel in the tributyl-phosphate-thiourea-perchloric acid system, Anal. Chim.
Acta, 61, 265, 1972.
10. Gesser, H. D., Chow, A., Davis, F. C., Uthe, J. F., and Reinke, J., The extraction and recovery of
polychlorinated biphenyls (PCB) using porous polyurethane foam, Anal. Lett.,4, 883, 1971.
11. Braun, T. and Farag, A. B., Foam chromatography. Solid foams as supports in column chromatog-
raphy, Talanta, 19, 828, 1972.
12. Bowen, H. J. M., Recovery of substances from a fluid medium, British Patent 1,305,375, 1973.
13. Schiller, P. and Cook, G. B., Determination of trace amounts of gold in natural sweet waters by
nondestructive activation analysis after preconcentration, Anal. Chim. Acta, 54, 364, 1971.
14. Sukiman, S., The extraction of gold from aqueous solution with treated and untreated polyurethane
foam, Radiochem. Radioanal. Lett., 18, 129, 1974.
15. Te-Shang Lo, Liu Chou, Chien-Chun Tu, Hsin-Liu Liu, and Ming Li, Plastic foam adsorption and
thiourea desorption in atomic absorption determination of gold, Fen Hsi Hua Hsuch, 8, 77, 1980;
Chem. Abstr., 94, 40790e, 1981.
16. Gesser, H. D., Bock, E., Baldwin, W. G., Chow, A., McBride, D. W., and Lipruski, W., Open-cell
polyurethane foam sponge as a "solvent extractor" for gallium and iron, Sep. Sci., 11, 315, 1976.
17. Gesser, H. D. and Horsfall, G. A., Separation and concentration of gallium by polyurethane, J.
Chim. Phys.,14, 1072, 1977.
18. Gesser, H. D., Horsfall, G. A., Gough, K. M., and Krawchuk, B., Transport of metal complex
chlorides through plastic film membrane, Nature (London), 268, 323, 1977.
19. Oren, J. J., Gough, K. M., and Gesser, H. D., The solvent extraction of iron (III) from acidic
chloride solutions by open cell polyurethane foam sponge (OCPUFS), Can. J. Chem.,57, 2032, 1979.
20. Lo, V. S. K. and Chow, A., The extraction of antimony with open-cell polyurethane foam, Anal.
Chim. Acta, 106, 161, 1979.
21. Lo, V. S. K. and Chow, A., Extraction of tin by the use of polyurethane foam, Talanta, 28, 157,
1981.
22. Gesser, H. D. and Gupta, B. M., The extraction of uranyl nitrate from aqueous nitrate solutions by
open-cell polyurethane foam sponge (OCPUFS), Paper 80-122, Proc. I.S.E.C. Conf., Grenoble,
1980.
23. Korkisch, J., Steffan, I., and Navratil, J. D., Recovery of uranium with polyurethane foam, in
Actinide Recovery From Waste and Low Grade Sources, Navratil, J. D. and Schulz, W. W. (Eds.),
Harwood Academic Publishers, New York, 1982, 349.
24. Braun, T., Farag, A. B., and Maloney, M. P., Polyurethane-pyridylazonaphthol foams in the pre-
concentration and separation of trace elements, Anal. Chim. Acta, 93, 191, 1977.
25. Braun, T. and Farag, A. B., Polyurethane foam of the polyether type as a solid polymeric extractant
for cobalt and iron from thiocyanate media, Anal. Chim. Acta, 98, 133, 1978.
26. Chow, A., Yamashita, G. T., and Hamon, R. F., X-ray fluorescence determination of cobalt on
polyurethane foam, Talanta, 28, 437, 1981.
27. Hamon, R. F., Khan, A. S., and Chow, A., The cation-chelation mechanism of metal-ion sorption
by polyurethanes, Talanta, 29, 313, 1982.
28. Hamon, R. F. and Chow, A., Extraction of cobalt by polyurethane foam, Abstr. 60th C.I.C. Conf.,
Chem. Institute of Canada, Montreal, 1977.
200 Polyurethane Foam Sorbents in Separation Science
29. Al-Bazi, S. J. and Chow, A., Extraction of rhodium and iridium with polyurethane foam, Anal.
Chem.,53, 1073, 1981.
30. Braun, T. and Abbas, M. N., Unloaded polyurethane foams as solid extractants for some metal
thiocyanate complexes from aqueous solution, Anal. Chim. Acta, 134, 321, 1982.
31. Braun, T., Abbas, M. N., Elek, A., and Bakos, L., Reagent-loaded and unloaded polyurethane foam
as a preconcentration matrix in neutron activation analysis, /. Radioanal. Chem.,67, 359, 1981.
32. Al-Bazi, S. J. and Chow, A., Extraction of palladium thiocyanate with polyurethane foam, Talanta,
29, 507, 1982.
33. Al-Bazi, S. J. and Chow, A., Mechanism of the extraction of palladium(II) thiocyanate complex by
polyether foam, Talanta, 30, 487, 1983.
34. Hamon, R. F., Extraction of cobalt by polyurethane foam, Ph.D. thesis, University of Manitoba,
1981.
35. Maloney, M. P., Moody, G. J., and Thomas, J. D. R., Extraction of metals from aqueous solution
with polyurethane foam, Analyst, 105, 1087, 1980.
36. Moody, G. J., Thomas, J. D. R., and Yarmo, M. A., Mechanism of metal sorption from aqueous
potassium thiocyanate by polyether type polyurethane foam, Anal. Proc.,20, 132, 1983.
37. Ibrahim, S. A., M.Sc. thesis, Mansoura University, 1983.
38. Abbas, M. N., Vertes, A. and Braun, T., Mossbauer study of the sorption of ferric ions from thio-
cyanate media by polyether and polyester type polyurethane foams, Radiochem. Radioanal. Lett.,
54, 17, 1982.
39. Bowen, H. J. M., Testing the recovery of silver and gold from liquid mineral wastes, Radiochem.
Radioanal. Lett.,!, 71, 1971.
40. Braun, T. and Farag, A. B., The recovery of gold from alkaline cyanide media with a polyurethane
foam sorbent, Anal. Chim. Acta, 153, 319, 1983.
41. Braun, T. and Farag, A. B., The recovery of gold from thiourea solutions with open-cell polyurethane
foams, Anal. Chim. Acta, 66, 419, 1973.
42. Khan, A. S., Baldwin, W. G., and Chow, A., The extraction of alkali metal picrates by polyurethane
foam using crown ether, Can. J. Chem., 59, 1490, 1981.
43. Khan, A. S., Baldwin, W. G., and Chow, A., Extraction of monovalent and divalent cations by
polyether-based polyurethane foam, Anal. Chim. Acta, 146, 201, 1983.
44. Khan, A. S. and Chow, A., Studies on the extraction of phosphomolybdate by polyether foam,
Talanta, 30, 173, 1983.
45. Moore, R. A. and Chow, A., The extraction of iridium and platinum from organic solvents by
polyurethane foams, Talanta, 27, 315, 1980.
46. Bedford, J. W., The use of polyurethane foam plugs for extraction of polychlorinated biphenyls
(PCB's) from natural waters, Bull. Environ. Contam. ToxicoL, 12, 622, 1974.
47. Uthe, J. F., Reinke, J., and O'Borodvich, H., Field studies on use of coated porous polyurethane
plugs as indwelling monitors of organochlorine pesticides and polychlorinated biphenyl contents of
streams, Environ. Lett.,6, 103, 1974.
48. Bidleman, T. F. and Olney, C. E., Chlorinated hydrocarbons in the Sargasso Sea atmosphere and
surface water, Science, 183, 516, 1974.
49. Musty, P. R. and Nickless, G., The extraction and recovery of chlorinated insecticides and polychlor-
inated biphenyls from water using porous polyurethane foams, J. Chromatogr., 100, 83, 1974.
50. Musty, P. R. and Nickless, G., Foams as extractants for organochlorine insecticides, polychlorobi-
phenyls and heavy metals from water, Proc. Anal. Div. Chem. Soc., 12, 295, 1975.
51. Musty, P. R. and Nickless, G., Extractants for organochlorine insecticides and polychlorinated bi-
phenyls from water, J. Chromatogr., 120, 369, 1976.
52. Murphy, T. J. and Rzeszutko, Ch.P., Precipitation inputs of PCBs to Lake Michigan, J. Great Lakes
Res.,3, 305, 1977.
53. Chau, A. S. Y. and Babjak, L. J., Column chromatographic determination of Mirex, photomirex
and polychlorinated biphenyls in lake-sediments, J. Assoc. Off. Anal. Chem., 62, 107, 1979.
54. Babjak, L. J. and Chau, A. S. Y., Evaluation of fourteen charcoal-polyurethane foam mixtures for
the separation of Mirex and photomirex from Aroclor* -1254, J. Assoc. Off. Anal. Chem.,62, 1174,
1979.
55. Smith, S. R., Tanaka, J., Futoma, T. J., and Smith, T. E., Sampling and preconcentration methods
for the analysis of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in water systems, CRC Crit. Rev. Anal. Chem.,
10, 375, 1981.
56. Saxena, J., Kozuchowski, J., and Basu, D. K., Monitoring of polynuclear aromatic hydrocarbons in
water. I. Extraction and recovery of benzo(a)pyrene with porous polyurethane foam, Environ. Sci.
Technol., 11, 682, 1977.
201
57. Basu, D. K. and Saxena, J., Monitoring of polynuclear aromatic hydrocarbons in water. II. Extrac-
tion and recovery of six representative compounds with polyurethane foams, Environ. Sci. Technol.,
12, 791, 1978.
58. Basu, D. K. and Saxena, J., Polynuclear aromatic hydrocarbons in selected U.S. drinking waters and
their raw water sources, Environ. Sci. Technol., 12, 795, 1978.
59. Tanaka, T., Hiiro, K., and Kawahara, A., A simple method for the determination of alkylbenzene-
sulfonate by visual colorimetry, Bunseki Kagaku (Japan Analyst), 22, 523, 1973.
60. Gough, K. M. and Gesser, H. D., The extraction and recovery of phtalate esters from water using
porous polyurethane foam, J. Chromatogr., 115, 383, 1975.
60a. Braun, T. and Farag, A. B., Pulsed column, redox techniques using flexible foam fillings, Anal.
Chim. Acta, 65, 139, 1973.
60b. Braun, T. and Palagyi, S., Pulsating column separations with a polyurethane foam syringe, Anal.
Chem.,51, 1697, 1979.
61. Denton, M. S. and Dinsmore, S. R., A comparison of synthetic adsorbents, including open-pore
polyurethane, as applied to coal conversion process aqueous effluent cleanup, presented 2nd Chem.
Congr. N. Am. Continent, American Chemical Society, Las Vegas, Nevada, August 24—29, 1980.
62. Gesser, H. D., Sparling, A. B., Chow, A., and Turner, C. W., The monitoring of organic matter
with polyurethane foam, J. Am. Water Works Assoc., 65, 220, 1973.
63. Schlicht, R. C. and McCoy, F. C., Selective adsorption of phenols from hydrocarbons solutions using
polyurethane foam, US Patent 3,617,531, 1971.
64. Will, R. G. and Grutsch, J. F., Purifying oil-contaminated water by filtration, US Patent 3,617,552,
1971.
65. Adams, J. D. and Caro, J. H., Polyurethane foam as a trapping agent for airborne pesticides, EPA
Research Rep. EPA-600/4-80-008, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Washington, D.C., 1980.
66. Bidleman, T. F. and Olney, C. E., High-volume collection of atmospheric polychlorinated biphenyls,
Bull. Environ. Contam. Tox., 11, 442, 1974.
67. Oehme, M. and Stray, H., Quantitative determination of ultra-traces of chlorinated compounds in
high-volume air samples from the the Arctic using polyurethane foam as collection medium, Z. Anal.
Chem.,311, 665, 1982.
68. Lewis, R. G. and Zimmerman, N. J., Anal. Qua/. Contr. Newslett.,2S, 7, 1976.
69. Rice, C. P., Olney, C. E., and Bidleman, T. F., World Meteorological Organization Special Environ-
mental Report, No. 10, WMO-460, 1977, p. 216.
70. Stratton, C. L., Whitlock, S. A., and Allan, J. M., A method for sampling and analysis of polychlor-
inated biphenyls (PCB's) in ambient air, EPA Research Rep. EPA-600/4-78-048, U.S. Environmental
Protection Agency, Washington, D.C., 1978.
71. Lewis, R. G., Brown, A. R., and Jackson, M. D., Evaluation of polyurethane foam for sampling of
pesticides, polychlorinated biphenyls and polychlorinated naphthalenes in ambient air, Anal. Chem.,
49, 1668, 1977.
72. Lewis, R. G., MacLeod, K. E., and Jackson, M. D., Sampling methodologies for airborne pesticides
and polychlorinated biphenyls, Paper No. 65, Chemical Congress, Am. Chem. Soc. -Chem. Soc.
Japan, Honolulu, Hawaii, April 2-6, 1979.
73. Margeson, J. H., Methodology for measurement of PCBs in ambient air and stationary sources. A
Review Environmental Monitoring and Support Lab., Research Triangle Park, N.C., Report PB 269
500, Springfield, Virg., 1977.
74. Stratton, C. L., Witlock, S. A., and Allan, J. M., A method for sampling and analysis of polychlor-
inated biphenyls (PCBs) in ambient air, EPA Research Rep. EPA600/4-78-048, U.S. Environmental
Protection Agency, Washington, D.C., 1978.
75. Turner, B. C. and Glotfelty, D. E., Field air sampling of pesticide vapors with polyurethane foam,
Anal. Chem.,49, 7, 1977.
76. Erickson, M. D., Michael, L. C., Zweidinger, R. A., and Pellizzari, E. D., Development of methods
for sampling and analysis of polychlorinated naphthalenes in ambient air, Environ. Sci. Technol.,
12, 927, 1978.
77. Erickson, M. D., Michael, L. C., Zweidinger, R. A., and Pellizzari, E. D., Sampling and analysis for
polychlorinated naphthalenes in environment, J. Assoc. Off. Anal. Chem.,61, 1335, 1978.
78. Erickson, M. D., Zweidinger, R. A., Michael, L. C., and Pellizzari, E. D., Environmental monitoring
near industrial sites: polychloronaphthalenes, EPA Research Rep. EPA/560/6-77/019, U.S. Envi-
ronmental Protection Agency, Washington, D.C., 1977.
79. Turner, B. C., Taylor, A. W., Glotfelty, D. E., and Watson, D. R., Volatization of microencapsu-
lated and conventionally applied chlorpropham in field, Agron. J., 70, 933, 1978.
80. Cliath, M. M., Spencer, W. F., Farmer, W. J., Shoup, T. D., and Grover, R., Volatization of S-
ethyl N,N-dipropylthio-carbamate from water and wet soil during and after flood irrigation of an
alfalfa field, /. Agr. Food Chem., 28, 610, 1980.
202 Polyurethane Foam Sorbents in Separation Science
81. Simon, C. G. and Bidleman, T. F., Sampling airborne polychlorinated biphenyls with polyurethane
foam. Chromatographic approach to determining retention efficiencies, Anal. Chem., 51, 1110, 1979.
82. Burdick, N. F. and Bidleman, T. F., Frontal movement of hexachlorobenzene and polychlorinated
biphenyl vapors through polyurethane foam, Anal. Chem., 53, 1926, 1981.
83. Vannucchi, C. and Berlincioni, M., Sampling and analytical method to determine PCB concentra-
tions in the air of the working areas of an electrical industry, Am. Ind. Hyg. Assoc. J.,41, 352, 1980.
84. Atlas, E. and Griam, C. S., Global transport of organic pollutants ambient concentrations in the
remote marine atmosphere, Science, 211, 163, 1981.
85. Billings, W. N. and Bidleman, T. F., Field comparison of polyurethane foam and tenax-GC resin for
high-volume air sampling of chlorinated hydrocarbons, Environ. Sci. Technol., 14, 679, 1980.
86. Doskey, P. V. and Andren, A. W., High-volume sampling of airborne polychlorobiphenyls with
Amberlite* XAD-2 resin, Anal. Chim. Acta, 110, 129, 1979.
87. Lewis, R. G. and Jackson, M. D., Modification and evaluation of a high-volume air sampler for
pesticides and semivolatile industrial organic chemicals, Anal. Chem., 54, 592, 1982.
88. Lewis, R. G. and MacLeod, K. E., Portable sampler for pesticides and semivolatile industrial organic
chemicals in air, Anal. Chem., 54, 310, 1982.
89. Oehme, M. and Stray, H., Quantitative determination of ultra-traces of chlorinated compounds in
high-volume air samples from the Arctic using polyurethane foam as collection medium, Z. Anal.
Chem.,311, 665, 1982.
90. Yamasaki, H., Kuwata, K., and Miyamoto, M., Collection of atmospheric polycyclic aromatic hy-
drocarbons using polyurethane foam plugs, Bunseki Kagaku, 27, 317, 1978.
90a. Yamasaki, H. and Kuwata, K., Collection of atmospheric phthalate esters using polyurethane foam
plugs, Bunseki Kagaku, 26, 1, 1977.
91. Thrane, K. E. and Mikalsen, A., High-volume sampling of airborne polycyclic aromatic-hydrocar-
bons using glass-fiber filters and polyurethane foams, Atmos. Environ., 15, 909, 1981.
92. Giam, C. S., Chan, H. S., Neff, G. S., and Atlas, E. L., Phthalate ester plasticizers. New class of
marine pollutant, Science, 199, 419, 1978.
93. Yamasaki, H. and Kuwata, K., Collection of atmospheric phthalate esters using polyurethane foam
plugs, Bunseki Kagaku, 26, I , 1977.
94. Grover, R. and Kerr, L. A., Evaluation of polyurethane foam as a trapping medium for herbicide
vapor in air monitoring and worker inhalation studies, J. Environ. Sci. Health, B16, 59, 1981.
95. Strickman, R. L., Tobacco smoke-filtering materials, U.S. Patent 3,618,618, 1971.
96. Moody, G. J. and Thomas, J. D. R., Extractions and separations with foamed plastics and rubbers,
Analyst, 104, 1, 1979.
97. Moody, G. J. and Thomas, J. D. R., Chromatographic Separation and Extraction with Foamed
Plastics and Rubbers, Marcel Dekker, New York, 1982.
98. Braun, T., Trends in using resilient polyurethane foams as sorbents in analytical chemistry, Z. Anal.
Chem.,314, 652, 1983.
99. Bailey, M. E., Polyurethanes. Study in chemical principles, /. Chem. Educ., 48, 809, 1971.
100. Thomas, C. R., The formation of cellular-plastics, Br. Plastics, 552, 1965.
101. Benning, C. J., Plastics Foams: The Physics and Chemistry of Product Performance and Process
Technology, Vol. 1. Chemistry and Physics of Foam Formation, John Wiley & Sons, New York,
1969.
102. Cellular Plastics, Proc. Conf., Natick, Massachussetts, 1966, National Academy of Sciences, Na-
tional Research Council, Washington, D.C., 1967.
103. Ferrigno, T. H., Rigid Plastic Foams, Reinhold, New York, 1963.
104. Hunter, B. A. and Kleinfeld, M. J., Rubber World, 153, 84, 1965.
105. Gross, S., Ed., Modern Plastics Encyclopedia, Vol. 46, McGraw-Hill, New York, 1969, 248.
106. David, D. J. and Staley, H. B., Analytical Chemistry of the Polyurethanes, Vol. 16, Part 3, John
Wiley & Sons, New York, 1969.
107. Corish, P. J., Identification and analysis of polyurethane rubbers by infrared spectroscopy, Anal.
Chem. ,31, 1298, 1959.
108. Murphy, E. B. and O'Neil, W. A., Infrared and dielectric analysis of structural polyurethane foam,
Soc. Plas. Eng. J., 18, 191, 1962.
109. Greth, G. G., Smith, R. G., and Rudkin, G. O., The determination and effect of unreacted isocyanate
groups in rigid urethane foams, J. Cellular Plastics, 1, 159, 1965.
110. Merten, R., Braun, G., and Lauerer, D., Structure of polyurethane foams, Kunststoffe, 55, 249,
1965.
111. Kuposov, L. I. and Zharkov, V. V., Metod opredelenija vtorichnikh svjazij poliuretanah, Plastic
Massy, 63, 1972.
203
112. Sumi, M., Chokki, Y., Nakai, Y., Nakabayashi, M., and Kanzawa, T., Structure of polyurethane
elastomers. I. Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectra of the model compounds and some linear
polyurethanes, Makromol. Chem.,IS, 146, 1964.
113. Brame, E. G., Ferguson, R. C., and Thomas, G. J., Identification of polyurethanes by high resolu-
tion nuclear magnetic resonance spectrometry, Anal. Chem.,39, 517, 1967.
114. Lieser, K. H., Calmano, W., Heuss, E., and Neitzert, V., Neutron activation as a routine method for
determination of trace-elements in water, /. Radioanal. Chem., 37, 717, 1977.
115. Vanderborght, B. and Van Grieken, R., Reduction of trace-metal levels in analytical grade activated
carbon, Anal. Chim. Acta, 89, 399, 1977.
116. Bergerioux, C., Blanc, J. P., and Haerdi, W., Preconcentration of environmental trace elements on
organic support for neutron activation and high resolution photon spectrometry, /. Radioanal.
Chem.,37, 823, 1977.
117. Kramer, H. J. and Neidhart, B., Determination of trace amounts of dissolved mercury compounds
by instrumental neutron activation analysis following a selective preconcentration, /. Radioanal.
Chem.,37, 835, 1977.
118. Sava, S., Zikovsky, L., and Boisvert, J., Determination of arsenic, cadmium and zinc in river water
by neutron activation analysis, /. Radioanal. Chem., 57, 23, 1980.
119. Bowen, H. J. M., Measuring surface areas of polyurethane foams using stearic acid-l-' 4 C, Radi-
ochem. Radioanal. Lett., 2, 169, 1969.
120. Braun, T. and Farag, A. B., A new method for column packing in reversed-phase chromatography,
Anal. Chim. Acta, 62, 476, 1972.
121. Nachtrieb, N. H. and Fryxell, R. E., The extraction of gallium chloride by isopropyl ether, /. Am.
Chem. Soc., 71, 4035, 1949.
122. Hertel, G. R. and Clark, H. M., Paramagnetic resonance behavior of tetrachloroferrate ion in iso-
propyl ether, /. Phys. Chem.,65, 1930, 1961.
123. Furman, N. H., Mundy, R. J., and Morrison, G. H., The distribution of uranyl nitrate from aqueous
solutions to diethyl ether, U.S. Atomic Energy Commission Report AECD-2938, 1950.
124. Sotobayashi, T., Suzuki, T., and Tonouchi, S., Liquid-liquid extraction of various metal ions with
polyethyleneglycol and its derivatives, Chem. LeH.,585, 1976.
125. Sotobayashi, T., Suzuki, T., and Yamada, K., Liquid-liquid extraction of cobalt(II) with polyethy-
leneglycol and its derivatives, Chem. Lett.,77, 1976.
126. Sotobayashi, T., Suzuki, T., and Kudo, H., Liquid-liquid extraction of some actinides with polyethy-
leneglycol and its derivatives, /. Radioanal. Chem., 36, 145, 1977.
127. Christensen, J. J., Eatough, D. J., and Izatt, R. M., The synthesis and ion-binding of synthetic
multidentate macrocyclic-compounds, Chem. Rev.,74, 351, 1974.
128. Yanagida, S., Takahashi, K., and Okahara, M., Metal-ion complexation of noncyclic
poly(oxyethylene) derivatives. I. Solvent-extraction of alkali and alkaline-earth metal thiocyanates
and iodides, Bull. Chem. Soc. Jap.,50, 1386, 1977.
129. May, P. M., Linder, P. W., and Williams, D. R., Computer simulation of metal-ion equilibria in
biofluids: models for low-molecular-weight complex distribution of calcium(II), magnesium(II),
manganese(II), iron(III), copper(ll), zinc(II) and lead(Il) ions inhuman-blood plasma, /. Chem. Soc.
Dalton Trans., 588, 1977.
130. Lodeishchikov, V. V. and Panchenko, A. F., Sorption of gold from acid solutions of thiourea by
activated carbon, Tsvet. Metal.,41, 25, 1968.
131. Pedersen, C. J., Cyclic polyethers and their complexes with metal salts, /. Am. Chem. Soc., 89, 7017,
1967.
132. Pedersen, C. J., Cyclic polyethers and their complexes with metal salts, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 89, 2495,
1967.
133. Izatt, R. M., Eatough, D. J., and Christensen, J. J., Thermodynamics of cation-macrocyclic com-
pound interaction, Struct. Bonding (Berlin), 16, 161, 1973.
134. Bright, D. and Truter, M. R., Crystal-structure of a cyclic polyether complex of alkali-metal thiocy-
anate, Nature (London), 225, 176, 1970.
135. Jawaid, M. and Ingman, F., Ion-pair extraction of Na', K* and Ca2* with some organic counter-ions
and dicyclohexyl-18-crown-6 as adduct-forming reagent, Talanta, 25, 91, 1978.
136. Jorgensen, C. K., Complexes of the 4d- and 5d-groups. II. Crystal field and electron transfer spectra
of ruthenium(II) and (III), iridium(IV) and platinum(IV), Acta Chem. Scancf., 10, 518, 1956.
137. Martin, D. S., Jr., Advances in Chemistry, No. 98, American Chemical Society, Washington, D.C.,
1971.
138. Armour, J. A. and Burke, J. A., Method for separating polychlorinated biphenyls from DDT and its
analogs, /. Assoc. Off. Anal. Chem.,53, 761, 1970.
204 Polyurethane Foam Sorbents in Separation Science
139. Fehringer, N. V. and Westfall, J. E., Separation and identification of DDT analogs in presence of
polychlorinated biphenyl compounds by two-dimensional thin-layer chromatography, /. Chroma-
togr.,57, 397, 1971.
140. Hutzinger, O., Safe, S., and Zitko, V., The Chemistry of PCB's, CRC Press, Buca Ratua, Fla.,
1974.
141. World Health Organization, Monograph on the Evaluation of Carcinogenic Risk of Chemicals to
Man: Certain Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons and Heterocyclic Compounds, Vol. 3, World
Health Organization, Geneva, Switzerland, 1973.
142. Fowler, D. L. and Mahan, J. N., The Pesticide Review, 1977, Agricultural Stabilization and Conser-
vation Service, U.S. Dept. of Agriculture, Washington, D.C., 1978.
143. Yule, W. N., Cole, A. F. W., and Hoffman, I., Survey for atmospheric contamination following
forest spraying with fenitrothion, Bull. Environ. Contain. Tox.,6, 289, 1971.
144. Miles, J. W., Fetzer, L. E., and Pearce, G. W., Collection and determination of trace quantities of
pesticides in air, Environ. Sci. Techno!., 4, 420, 1970.
145. Stanley, C. W., Barney, J. E., Helton, M. R., and Yobs, A. R., Measurement of atmospheric levels
of pesticides, Environ. Sci. Technol.,5, 430, 1971.
146. Jutze, G. A. and Foster, K. E., /. Air Pollut. Contr. Assoc., 11, I , 1967.
147. Compton, B. and Bjorklund, J., Design of a high-volume sampler for airborne pesticide collection,
Paper presented at the 163rd Natl. Meet. American Chemical Soc., Boston, Mass., April, 1972.
148. Armour, J. A., Quantitative perchlorination of polychlorinated biphenyls as a method for confir-
matory residue measurement and identification, J. Assoc. Off. Anal. Chem.,56, 987, 1973.
149. Suess, M. J., The environmental load and cycle of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, Sci. Total
Environ., 6, 239, 1976.
150. Paniculate Polycyclic Organic Matter, National Academy of Science, Washington, D.C., 1972.
151. Lunde, G. and Bjorseth, A., Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in long-range transported aerosols,
Nature (London), 268, 518, 1977.
152. Sherma, J. and Shafik, T. M., A multiclass, multiresidue analytical method for determining pesticide
residues in air, Arch. Environ. Contam. Tox., 3, 55, 1975.
153. Braun, T. and Farag, A. B., Reversed-phase foam chromatography. Separation of palladium, bis-
muth and nickel in tributylphosphate-thiourea-perchloric acid system, Anal. Chim. Acta, 61, 265,
1972.
154. Braun, T. and Farag, A. B., Reversed phase foam chromatography. Chemical enrichment and sepa-
ration of gold in the tributyl phosphate perchloric acid system, Anal. Chim. Acta, 65, 115, 1973.
155. Braun, T., Bakos, L., and Szabo, Zs., Reversed phase foam chromatography. Separation of iron
from copper, cobalt and nickel in the tri-n-butylphosphate-hydrochloric acid system, Anal. Chim.
Acta, 66, 57, 1973.
156. Uthe, J. F., Reinke, J., and Gesser, H. D., Extraction of organochlorine pesticides from water by
porous polyurethane coated with selective absorbent, Environ. Lett., 3, 117, 1972.
157. Braun, T. and Farag, A. B., Use of cellular plastics in extraction chromatography, in Extraction
Chromatography, Braun, T. and Ghersini, G., Eds., Elsevier-Akademiai Kiado, Amsterdam-Buda-
pest, 1975, 334.
158. Braun, T. and Farag, A. B., Plasticized open-cell polyurethane foam as a universal matrix for organic
reagents in trace element preconcentration. I. Collection of silver traces on dithizone foam, Anal.
Chim. Acta, 69, 85, 1974.
159. Braun, T. and Farag, A. B., Plasticized open-cell polyurethane foam as a universal matrix for organic
reagents in trace element preconcentration. II. Collection of mercury traces on dithizone and die-
thyldithiocarbamate foams, Anal. Chim. Acta, 71, 133, 1974.
160. Chow, A. and Buksak, D., The extraction of mercury and methylmercury by diphenylthiocarbazone-
treated polyurethane foams, Can. J. Chem., 53, 1373, 1975.
161. Braun, T. and Palagyi, S., Pulsating column separations with a polyurethane foam syringe, Anal.
Chem.,51, 1697, 1979.
162. Carritt, D. E., Separation and concentration of trace metals from natural waters: partition chromat-
ographic technique, Anal. Chem.,25, 1927, 1953.
163. Pierce, T. B. and Peck, P. F., A rapid method for determining indium by neutron activation, Analyst,
86, 580, 1961.
164. Braun, T. and Farag, A. B., Plasticized open-cell polyurethane foam as a universal matrix for organic
reagents in trace element preconcentration. III. Collection of cobalt traces on l-nitroso-2-naphthol
and diethyldithiocarbamate foams, Anal. Chim. Acta, 76, 107, 1975.
165. Valente, I. and Bowen, H. J. M., Method for the separation of antimony(IIl) from antimony(V)
using polyurethane foam, Analyst, 102, 842, 1977.
205
166. Braun, T., Abbas, M. N., Bakos, L., and Elek, A., Preconcentration of phenylmercury, methylmer-
cury and inorganic mercury from natural waters with diethylammonium diethyldithiocarbamate-
loaded polyurethane foam, Anal. Chim. Acta, 131, 311, 1981.
167. Lypka, G. N., Gesser, H. D., and Chow, A., Foam chromatography. The extraction and separation
of a copper cadmium system by benzoylacetone-treated polyurethane foam, Anal. Chim. Acta, 78,
367, 1975.
168. Lee, D. W. and Halmann, M., Selective separation of nickel(II) by dimethylglyoxime-treated polyu-
rethane foam, Ana/. Chem.,4%, 2214, 1976.
169. Gregoire, D. C. and Chow, A., Separation of platinum and palladium with silicone-rubber foam
treated with dimethylglyoxime, Talanta, 22, 453, 1975.
170. Halmann, M. and Lee, D. W., Recovery of nickel from ammoniacal media with dioxime-loaded
open-pore polyurethane foams, Anal. Chim. Acta, 113, 383, 1980.
171. Halmann, M. and Lee, D. W., Conf. Cellular and Noncellular Polyurethanes, Strassbourg, Hauser
Verlag, Miinchen, Wien, June, 1980, 821.
172. Valente, I. and Bowen, H. J. M., A method of concentrating antimony from natural waters, Anal.
Chim. Acta, 90, 315, 1977.
172a. Braun, T. and Abbas, M. N., Spectrophotometric determination of traces of cobalt in water after
preconcentration on reagent-loaded polyurethane foams, Anal. Chim. Acta, 119, 113, 1980.
173. Srikameswaran, K. and Gesser, H. D., A novel method for the concentration and determination of
trace elements in water, J. Environ. Sci. Health, A13, 415, 1978.
174. Srikameswaran, K., Gesser, H. D., and Venkateswaran, M., Monitoring trace amounts of cadmium
in natural waters, J. Environ. Sci. Health, A15, 323, 1980.
175. Maloney, M. P., Moody, G. J., and Thomas, J. D. R., Extraction and separation of metal ions by
foam-supported reagents, Proc. Anal. Div. Chem. Soc., 14, 244, 1977.
176. Vernon, F., Ion exchange on LIX 65N and Kelex 100 impregnated foams, Sep. Sci. Techno!., 13,
587, 1978.
177. Braun, T., Trends in using resilient polyurethane foams as sorbents in analytical chemistry, Z. Anal.
Chem.,314, 652, 1983.
178. Braun, T. and Farag, A. B., Chromofoams. Qualitative and semiquantitative tests with chromogenic
organic reagents immobilized in open-cell polyurethane foams, Anal. Chim. Acta, 73, 301, 1974.
179. Farag, A. B., El-Wakil, A. M., and El-Shahawi, M. S., Qualitative and semiquantitative determina-
tion of chromium(VI) in aqueous solution using 1,5-diphenylcarbazide-loaded foam, Analyst, 106,
809, 1981.
180. Farag, A. B., El-Wakil, A. M., and El-Shahawi, M. S., Detection and semiquantitative determination
of nickel with dimethyl-glyoxime-loaded foam, Talanta, 29, 789, 1982.
181. Farag, A. B., El-Wakil, A. M., and El-Shahawi, M. S., Qualitative and semiquantitative determina-
tion of iron(III) in aqueous thiocyanate solution using tricapylylamine foam, Ann. Chim. (Roma),
72, 103, 1982.
182. Farag, A. B., Morsi, M. A., and Ibrahim, S. A., Qualitative and semiquantitative determination of
copper(ll) in aqueous solution using biacetylmonooxime benzoyl hydrazone, to be published.
183. Fujimoto, M. and Nakatsukasa, Y., Microanalysis with aid of ion exchangers XXI. Modifications of
resin spot test with high molecular weight amines, Anal. Chim. Acta, 27, 373, 1962.
184. Tanaka, T., Hiiro, K., and Kawahara, A., Simple colorimetric determination of phosphate ion using
polyurethane foam loaded with a mixture of liquid anion exchanger of molybdate form and tributyl
phosphate, Bunseki Kagaku (Jap. Analyst), 31, El23, 1982.
185. Braun, T., Huszar, E., and Bakos, L., Reverse-phase foam chromatography. Separation of trace
amounts of cobalt from nickel in the tri-n-octylamine-hydrochloric acid system, Anal. Chim. Acta,
64, 77, 1973.
186. Baghai, A. and Bowen, H. J. M., Separation of rhodium and iridium using silicone-rubber foam
treated with tri-n-octylamine, Analyst, 101, 661, 1976.
187. El-Wakil, A. M., Farag, A. B., and Ez-Eldin, A. Kh., Separation of iron, cobalt, nickel and cadmium
in aqueous acid halide solution using Aliquat-foam columns, Sep. Sci. Technol., 17, 1085, 1982.
188. Xie Chang-Sheng, The enrichment with impregnated polyurethane foam and Spectrophotometric de-
termination of trace thorium in natural water, Acta Chim. Sinica, 40, 605, 1982.
189. Kirkland, J. J., Techniques for high-performance liquid-liquid and ion exchange chromatography
with controlled surface porosity column packings, /. Chromatogr. Sci., 1, 361, 1969.
190. Horvath, C. G., Preiss, A. B., and Lipsky, S. R., Fast liquid chromatography: an investigation of
operating parameters and separation of nucleotides on pellicular ion exchangers, Anal. Chem., 39,
1422, 1967.
191. Skafi, M. and Lieser, K. H., Preparation and properties of superficially sulfonated exchange resins,
Z. Anal. Chem.,249, 182, 1970.
206 Polyurethane Foam Sorbents in Separation Science
192. Skafi, M. and Lieser, K. H., Selectivity of superficially sulphonated exchange resins, Z. Anal. Chem.,
250, 306, 1970.
193. Skafi, M. and Lieser, K. H., Rapid column separations by means of a superficially sulfonated ex-
change resin, Z. Anal. Chem.,25\, 111, 1970.
194. Pinfold, T. A. and Karger, B. L., The coagulation of finely-divided ion exchange resins and use of
coagulated material for rapid ion removal, Sep. Sci., 5, 183, 1970.
195. Braun, T., Bekeffy, O., Haklits, I., Kadar, K. and Majoros, G., Ion-exchange foam chromatogra-
phy. I. Preparation of rigid and flexible ion-exchange foams, Anal. Chim. Acta,64, 45, 1973.
196. Mazurski, M. A., Chow, A., and Gesser, H. D., Extraction of mercury from aqueous-solution with
sulfide-treated polyurethane foam, Anal. Chim. Acta, 65, 99, 1973.
196a. Braun, T. and Farag, A. B., Ion-exchange foam chromatography. II. Rapid separations on hetero-
geneous cation exchange foams, Anal. Chim. Acta, 68, 119, 1974.
197. Braun, T., Farag, A. B., and Klimes-Szmik, A., Reversed phase foam chromatography. Redox re-
actions on polyurethane foam columns supporting tetrachlorophydroquinone, Anal. Chim. Acta, 64,
71, 1973.
198. Braun, T. and Farag, A. B., Pulsed column redox techniques with flexible foam fillings, Anal. Chim.
Acta,65, 139, 1973.
199. Cerrai, E. and Testa, C., Electron-exchange processes on simple columns of Kel-F supporting tetrach-
lorohydroquinon, Anal. Chim. Acta, 28, 205, 1963.
200. Environmental Surveillance Around Nuclear Installations, Vols. 1 and 2, Proc. Ser., IAEA, Vienna,
1974.
201. Faure, M., Nuclear-power plants and environment, Kerntechnik, 16, 490, 1974.
202. Meyer, P., Nuclear-energy and environment, Kerntechnik, 19, 9, 1977.
203. Mielken, G. and Will, M., Release and deposition of fission-products in high-temperature reactors,
Kerntechnik, 18, 61, 1976.
204. Sunderman, D. N. and Meinke, W. W., Evaluation of radiochemical separation procedures, Anal.
Chem.,29, 1578, 1957.
205. Rudstam, G. and Sorensen, G., Fission and spallation yields in iodine region, J. Inorg. Nucl. Chem.,
28, 771, 1966.
206. Schiissler, H. D. and Herrmann, G., Schneller Austausch von Metallionen an Metallsulfidcellulosen,
Radiochim. Acta, 13, 65, 1970.
207. Erdey, L., Gimesi, O., Szabo, E., and Csajka, M., Determination of trace contaminants in hydro-
genation catalysts by neutron-activation analysis, Talanta, 17, 1157, 1970.
208. DeVoe, J. R., Kim, C. K., and Meinke, W. W., Radiochemical separations by amalgam exchange,
Talanta, 3, 298, 1960.
209. Qureshi, I. H. and Nagi, F. I., Radiochemical separation of lead by amalgam exchange, Talanta, 14,
323, 1967.
210. Kim, C. K. and Silvermann, J., Determination of mercury in wheat and tobacco leaf by neutron
activation analysis using mercury-197 and a simple exchange separation, Anal. Chem., 37, 1616,
1965.
211. Okashita, H., Rapid separation of radionuclides by spontaneous electrodeposition of metallic mer-
cury. I. Metallic mercury-mercury ion system, Radiochim. Acta, 7, 81, 1967.
212. Ikeda, N., Kimura, K., Hasebe, N., and Shoji, H., A new possibility for method of activation anal-
ysis of uranium, Radiochim. Acta, 12, 72, 1969.
213. Palagyi, S., Some theoretical aspects of use of isotopic-exchange in a heterogeneous liquid-system for
radiochemical separations, J. Radioanal. Chem., 21, 47, 1974.
214. Heurtebise, M. and Ross, W. J., Application of an iodide-specific resin to determination of iodine in
biological-fluids by activation analysis, Anal. Chem.,43, 1438, 1971.
215. Heurtebise, M. and Ross, W. J., Radiochemical separations with halogenated resins, Anal. Chem.,
44, 596, 1972.
216. Braun, T. and Farag, A. B., Static and dynamic isotope exchange separations on finely divided
precipitates immobilized in open-cell polyurethane foams, Radiochem. Radioanal. Lett., 19, 275,
1974.
217. Braun, T. and Farag, A. B., Static and dynamic redox exchange separations on finely divided copper
immobilized in open-cell polyurethane foam, Radiochem. Radioanal. Lett., 19, 377, 1974.
218. Gimesi, O. and Banyai, E., New micro-methods for the determination of radio-iodine, Mikrochim.
Acta,2, 313, 1981.
219. Braun, T. and Farag, A. B., Static and dynamic isotope exchange separations on hydrophobic organic
phases immobilized open-cell polyurethane foams, J. Radioanal. Chem., 25, 5, 1975.
220. Eckhardt, W., Herrmann, G., and Schiissler, H. D., Schnelle radiochemische trennungen durch iso-
topen- und ionenaustausch an vorgeformten niederschlagen, Z. Anal. Chem., 226, 71, 1967.
207
221. Palagyi, S. and Markusova, R., Rapid separation of radioiodine from milk by a polyurethane foam
column-filtration method, Radiochem. Radioanal. Lett.,32, 103, 1978.
222. Palagyi, S. and Bila, E., Separation of radioiodine by static and dynamic isotope exchange on hydro-
phobic organic phases immobilized in open-cell polyurethane foam, Radiochem. Radioanal. Lett.,
32, 87, 1978.
223. Palagyi, S. and Braun, T., 180th Natl. A.C.S. Meeting, Las Vegas, American Chemical Society,
Washington, D.C., 1980.
224. Palagyi, S. and Braun, T., Pulsating column separation and preconcentration of radioiodine on hy-
drophobic organic reagent loaded resilient open-cell polyurethane foam, J. Radioanal. Chem., 51,
267, 1979.
225. Palagyi, S. and Braun, T., Open-cell polyurethane foam as sorbent in the extraction of iodine-131,
Analyst, 106, 1326, 1981.
226. Palagyi, S., Preparation of samples for radioactivity measurements using pulsed bed column separa-
tion and preconcentration, Proc. 2nd Int. Conf., Low Radioactivities '80, The High Tatras, Strbske
Pleso, Czechoslovakia, 1980.
227. Farag, A. B., Attia, M. E., and Hassan, H. N. A., Polyurethane foam as a new external absorbent
in elemental microanalysis. Simultaneous determination of carbon, hydrogen and iodine in iodo-
organic compounds, Indian J. Chem., B20, 693, 1981.
228. Farag, A. B., Attia, M. E., and Hassan, H. N. A., Simultaneous microdetermination of carbon,
hydrogen and mercury in organomercury compounds by various combustion methods, Anal. Chem.,
52, 2153, 1980.
229. Farag, A. B., Attia, M. E., and Hassan, H. N. A., Simultaneous microdetermination of carbon,
hydrogen, and chlorine or bromine in organic compounds by various rapid empty-tube combustion
methods, Talanta,21, 1093, 1980.
230. Klimova, V. A. and Dubinskii, R. A., Formation of nitrogen oxides during the determination of
carbon and hydrogen by the flash burning of aromatic nitro-compounds in an oxygen stream, Izv.
Akad. Nauk SSSR, Ser. Khim., 191, 1969.; Analyt. Abstr., 18, 3146, 1970.
231. Gawargious, Y. A. and MacDonald, A. M. G., in Proc. 1961 Int. Symp. Microchemica/ Techniques,
Vol. 2, Wiley-Interscience, New York, 1962.
232. Belcher, R., Gibbons, D., and Sykes, A., Determination of metals in organic compounds, Mikro-
chim. Acta, 40, 76, 1952.
233. Gawargious, Y. A. and Farag, A. B., The simultaneous microdetermination of carbon, hydrogen and
halogen in highly chlorinated or brominated organic compounds, Mikrochem. J., 16, 333, 1971.
234. Bauman, E. K., Goodson, L. H., Guilbault, G. G., and Kramer, D. N., Preparation of immobilized
cholinesterase for use in analytical chemistry, Anal. Chem., 37, 1378, 1965.
235. Bauman, E. K., Goodson, L. H., and Thomson, J. R., An immobilized cholinesterase product for
use in the rapid detection of enzyme inhibitors in air or water, Anal. Biochem., 19, 587, 1967.
236. Goodson, L. H. and Jacobs, W. B., A rapid detection system for organophosphates in water, in
Control of Hazardous Material Spills, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Washington, D.C.,
1973, 129.
237. Goodson, L. H., Jacobs, W. B., and Davis, A. W., An immobilized cholinesterase product for use
in the rapid detection of enzyme inhibitors in air or water, Anal. Biochem., 51, 362, 1973.
238. Goodson, L. H. and Jacobs, W. B., Proc. Natl. Conf. Control of Hazardous Material Spills, Amer-
ican Institute of Chemical Engineers, New Jersey, 1974, Environmental Protection Agency, Washing-
ton, D.C., 1974, 292.
239. Evans, W. H., Mage, M. G., and Peterson, E. A., A method for the immunoabsorption of cells to
an antibody-coated polyurethane foam, J. Immunol., 102, 899, 1969.
240. Salyer, I. O., Schwendeman, J. L., and Jefferson, R. T., Polyurethane precipitation foam, presented
at the 156th Natl. American Chemical Society Meeting, September 8-14, 1968.
241. Salyer, I. O., Jefferson, R. T., and Ross, W. D., Chromatographic medium and method, U.S. Patent
3,580,843, 1971.
242. Ross, W. D. and Jefferson, R. T., In situ-formed open pore polyurethane as chromatography sup-
ports, /. Chromatogr. Sci., 8, 386, 1970.
243. Hileman, F. D., Sievers, R. E., Hess, G. G., and Ross, W. D., In situ preparation and evaluation of
open pore polyurethane chromatographic columns, Anal. Chem.,45, 1126, 1973.
244. Hileman, F. D., In-situ preparation and evaluation of open pore polyurethane chromatographic col-
umns, Master of Science thesis, Wright State University, Dayton, Ohio, 1973.
245. Chen, T. M., Hess, G. G., and Sievers, R. E., Improvements in gas-chromatographic columns
formed by in-situ polymerization, J. Chromatogr., 134, 170, 1977.
246. Lynn, T. R., Rushneck, D. R., and Cooper, A. R., High resolution low pressure liquid-chromatog-
raphy, /. Chromatogr. Sci., 12, 76, 1974.
208 Polyurethane Foam Sorbents in Separation Science
247. Hansen, L. C. and Sievers, R. E., Highly permeable open-pore polyurethane columns for liquid-
chromatography, /. Qiromarogr., 99, 123, 1974.
248. Herman, D. P. and Field, L. R., Surface-modified open-pore polyurethane packings for liquid chro-
matography, /. Chromatogr. Sci.,20, 55, 1982.
249. Navratil, J. D., Sievers, R. E., and Walton, H. F., Open-pore polyurethane columns for collection
and preconcentration of polynuclear aromatic-hydrocarbons from water, Anal. Chem., 49, 2260,
1977.
250. Smith, C. M. and Navratil, J. D., Removal and preconcentration of surfactants from wastewater
with open-pore polyurethane, Sep. Sci. Technol., 14, 255, 1979.
251. Smith, C. M., Navratil, J. D., and Plock, C. E., Waste management analysis for the nuclear fuel
cycle. II. Recycle preparation for wastewater streams, U.S. Department of Energy Report RFP-2813,
Rockwell International, Golden, Colorado, 1979.
252. Demon, M. S., Dinsmore, S. R., Brand, J. I., Beams, J., and Ball, F. L., Open-pore polyurethane
as a medium for coal conversion process aqueous effluent cleanup, Sep. So'. Technol., 15, 587, 1980.
253. Jefferson, R. T. and Salyer, I. O., Open-pore polyurethane product, U.S. Patent 3,574,150,1971.
254. Ross, W. D., Open-pore polyurethane. A new separation medium, in Separation and Purification
Methods, Vol. 3, Perry, E. S., van Oss, C. J., and Grushka, E., Eds., Marcel Dekker, New York,
1974, 111.
255. Navratil, J. D. and Sievers, R. E., Chemical separations with open-pore polyurethane, Am. Lab.,9,
38, 1977.
256. Usmani, A. M. and Salyer, I. O., Open-pore polymer structures. A review, Polym.-Plast. Technol.
Eng., 12, 61, 1979.
257. Doyles, E. N., The Development and Use of Polyurethane Products, McGraw-Hill, New York, 1971.
258. Salyer, I. O., Jefferson, R. T., Pustinger, J. V., and Schwendeman, J. L., Preparation and properties
of open-pore polyurethane (OPP), J. Cell. Plast., 9, 25, 1973.
259. Kutal, K. C. and Sievers, R. E., A rate and equilibrium study of the cis-trans isomerization of
tris(l,l,l-trifluoro-2,4-pentanedianato) chromium(III) in the gas phase, presented 166th Natl. Meet.,
American Chemical Society, Chicago, Illinois, August, 1973.
260. Salyer, I. O. and Jefferson, R. T., Cigarette filter, U.S. Patent 3,746,014, 1975.
261. Salyer, I. O. and Jefferson, R. T., Porous structure and method, U.S. Patent 3,647,721, 1973.
262. Navratil, J. D., Rockwell International, Golden, Colorado, private communication, 1983.
209
INDEX