You are on page 1of 6

IAC-19.A3.2A.

Current Status of Japanese Lunar Polar Exploration Mission

Takeshi Hoshino a*, Sachiko Wakabayashia, Makiko Ohtakea, Yuzuru Karoujia, Takahiro Hayashia,
Hitoshi Morimotoa, Hiroaki Shiraishia, Takanobu Shimadaa, Tatsuaki Hashimotob, Hiroka Inoueb
Hiroyasu Mizunoc, Ryo Hirasawad, Yoji Shirasawad and Hiroshi Kanamorie

a
JAXA Space Exploration Center, Japan Aerospace Exploration Agency, Ochanomizu Sola City, 4-6
Kandasurugadai, Chiyoda-ku, Tokyo 101-8008, Japan, hoshino.takeshi@jaxa.jp
b
Institute of Space and Astronautical Science, Japan Aerospace Exploration Agency, 3-1-1 Yoshinodai, Chuo-ku,
Sagamihara 252-5210, Japan
c
Human Spaceflight Technology Directorate, Japan Aerospace Exploration Agency, 2-1-1 Sengen, Tsukuba-shi,
Ibaraki 305-8505, Japan
d
Research and Development Directorate, Japan Aerospace Exploration Agency, 2-1-1 Sengen, Tsukuba-shi, Ibaraki
305-8505, Japan
e
Space Exploration Innovation Hub Center, Japan Aerospace Exploration Agency, 3-1-1 Yoshinodai, Chuo-ku,
Sagamihara 252-5210, Japan
* Corresponding Author

Abstract
Recently, several polar explorations of the Moon are planned, because it has been suggested that water ice might be
present in the lunar polar region based on remote sensing observation of the lunar surface using a neutron
spectrometer and visible to infrared spectrometer. However, the precise amount and state of the water ice are still
unknown. At the Japan Aerospace Exploration Agency (JAXA), we are also studying on exploration to the lunar
polar regions for resources, especially cold-trapped volatiles such as water ice using a rover. Volatile materials are
expected to be useful for future human activity on the Moon and there is strong interest in the origin and
concentration mechanism of the water ice. Additionally, the polar regions are among the best candidates for long-
term activity because of their long sunlight duration. To realize the mission, we are currently developing various
technologies peculiar to exploration of lunar polar regions. This paper details the present status of the Japanese Lunar
Polar Exploration Mission.
Keywords: lunar pole, lunar water, volatile, landing exploration,

1. Introduction (OMOTENASHI)[3] mission. It will be the world’s


The moon is considered the next area of human smallest lunar lander and will be launched by the National
activity. The orbit of the manned space station succeeding Aeronautics and Space Administration’s (NASA’s) Space
the International Space Station (ISS) circling in low Earth Launch System (SLS) Exploration Mission-1 (EM-1)
orbit is cislunar space. The new space station is called with the spacecraft Orion. The mission of
the ”Gateway”. It is also studying the possibility of OMOTENASHI is to demonstrate nano-lander
manned lunar surface exploration via the Gateway in the technology and observe the radiation in the cislunar
Global Exploration Roadmap 3rd Edition (GER 3) [1], region. Another is the Smart Lander for Investigating the
published by the International Space Exploration Moon (SLIM)[4] mission. It intends to demonstrate the
Coordination Group (ISECG) in January 2018. In fact, pinpoint-landing technology needed for future lunar and
The United States has recently announced a plan to planetary surface exploration with a small spacecraft. In
conduct a manned lunar landing around the lunar south addition, JAXA is planning a landing mission to
pole in 2024 [2]. Prior to these manned space exploration, investigate lunar volatiles such as water ice using a rover.
many countries are planning unmanned missions. Many polar exploration missions of the Moon are
Under the circumstances, the Japan Aerospace planned owing to the existence of volatiles. There are two
Exploration Agency (JAXA) is also planning activities main reasons why lunar exploration is focused. The first
aimed at human lunar exploration in the future. Figure 1 reason is the possibility of the existence of water-ice as a
shows JAXA’s near-term exploration scenario. In the resource. Specifically, if it is possible to use water ice
scenario, lunar landings are considered as the next step expected in the polar regions as a propellant, it will
for the lunar orbiter Kaguya (SELENE). One is the greatly affect future exploration and activities. Recently,
Outstanding MOon exploration TEchnologies detailed analysis of remote sensing data showed the
demonstrated by NAno Semi-Hard Impactor existence of water [5,6]. However, the precise amount and

IAC-19.A3.2A.6 Page 1 of 6
state of the water ice are unknown. The availability of surface, the mass of the spacecraft can be appreciably
water-ice as a propellant is believed to have a major reduced. This would also reduce launch costs. Moreover,
impact on future exploration scenarios and activities using if refueling a spacecraft becomes possible, the lander will
the Moon. The second reason is from the viewpoint of be reusable, and the cost of the lander and assent module
energy resources that can be easily obtained compared to will be eliminated. The same concept can be applicable to
other areas of the lunar surface. From the point of view of Mars exploration.
energy, it has been known that some hills and crater rims When LH2/LOX is produced as a propellant for a
in the polar regions of the Moon can obtain more than a reusable lander, the mass of the water must be at least a
half-year of continuous sunshine and more than 80% few tens of tons. Therefore, the total abundance of lunar
sunshine ratio [7]. water is an important issue. To use water for propellant,
In this situation, JAXA is planning a lunar polar the cost of production on the lunar surface must be
exploration mission that aims mainly to confirm the compared with that of transportation from the Earth. The
abundance of water-ice resources and to establish the production cost covers the facilities and operations
technology of planetary surface exploration. We expect required for mining water-ice, extracting water,
the mission to contribute to not only JAXA’s but also electrolysis from water to hydrogen/oxygen, liquefaction
international space exploration. This paper describes the of hydrogen and oxygen, storage in tanks, and refueling a
research and developmental status of the Japanese lunar reusable lander. JAXA has explored the cost trade-off
polar exploration mission in detail. between using disposable landers and using a reusable
lander with a propellant production plant. As a result, we
2. JAXA’s Vision have found that the cost strongly depends on the water
Fig.2 shows JAXA’s Vision for International Space content of the lunar soil. Per the results to date, we
Exploration. Though this figure includes all elements, the estimate that the lunar soil composition needs to be at
actual exploration scenario proceeds step-by-step. In this least 0.5% water by weight for this concept to be cost-
scenario, the reusable lander and the fuel plant (bottom effective.
center) play an important role. Most of the cost of However, the water concentration estimated from
exploring the lunar surface relates to carrying a payload remote sensing data to date varies from less than 0.1% to
from the Earth to the Moon. If we can use on-site more than 10% by weight. It is thus important to clarify
materials effectively such as lunar water, then supplies the concentration of lunar water. In other words, in this
from the Earth can be greatly reduced. Water-ice is scenario, lunar polar exploration is required at first in
expected to exist especially in the polar regions of the order to determine the availability of the lunar water-ice
Moon. If hydrogen and oxygen are produced from lunar as a resource.
water and LH2/LOX propellant is used for ascent from the

JAXA’s Space Exploration Scenario (Near Term)
Mars, others
Activities on/beyond Mars
©JAXA

MMX JFY2024

Kaguya

©JAXA ©JAXA
©JAXA ©JAXA
SLIM Lunar Polar Exploration
Moon Pinpoint Landing Water Prospecting
Robotic Sample Return Sustainable
Technology Demo
JFY2021 Early 2020’s Exploration/Utilization
Approx.2026‐‐

HTV‐X derivatives Gateway
Approx. 2026‐ Operation
OMOTENASHI EQUULEUS
CubeSat  Innovative
launched by  small mission Gateway (construction phase)
SLS/EM1 2022‐

Earth
Promote Commercialization

©NASA
International Space Station
Fig. 1. JAXA’s near term scenario for space exploration

IAC-19.A3.2A.6 Page 2 of 6
3. Lunar Polar Exploration Mission important that the water condition is suitable for utilize as
3.1 Study history a resource. Therefore, from the viewpoint of prospecting
JAXA has studied lunar missions with landers and lunar resources, the mission objectives are defined as
rovers for several years [8,11]. Since 2006, the SELENE-2 follows:
mission, which consists of a lander, an orbiter and rover,
had been studied as a Japanese first lunar landing mission - Obtain data on the quantity and quality of lunar
following KAGUYA orbiter. After that, JAXA had water to clarify whether it can be used for future
conducted a feasibility study of the polar lander with the activities.
NASA Resource Prospector mission. Unfortunately, the - Obtain data to understand the principle of the water
joint study with NASA ended in March 2017. Through distribution and concentration to estimate the
these histories, JAXA has been conducting a feasibility quantity and quality of water across the Moon.
study on lunar polar exploration with the Indian Space
Research Organisation (ISRO) since December 2017. Though resource investigation is the main objective
Based on the results of joint study, ISRO and JAXA held technology demonstration and environmental
the joint mission definition review in December 2018. At investigation will also be conducted. From a
present, we are continuing joint study aiming to realize technological viewpoint, the Moon is the best place for
the mission. demonstrating new technologies of planetary exploration,
especially for surface activities. In addition, surface
3.2 Mission objectives temperature, sunshine and radiation environment will be
To realize the above vision, the most important matter investigated in preparation for future manned exploration.
is to know whether the amount of water in the lunar polar
region is sufficient for fuel. In addition, it is also

Erath Sample Return
Robotic Exploration

【Transportation between  Full‐fledged  
earth and moon orbit】 Crew Vehicle Exploration
(NASA, Russia)
Lunar Orbiting Platform
Large Human Rated  Mars
Rocket Gateway
(NASA, Russia) International
Cooperation
Logistics Vehicle
Cargo Rocket

Human Lunar Lander
(JAXA, etc.)
【Transportation between moon 
orbit and Moon surface】
Lunar  Logistics  Full‐fledged Lunar 
Exploration 
Vehicle Human  Exploration and 
Support Lunar Infra Utilization
【Transportation 
Fuel  between sites】
Resupply Pressurized 
ISS
Small Scientific  Rover
Instrument Deploy

Full‐fledged Lunar 
Exploration and Utilization

Moon
Fig. 2. JAXA’s Vision for International Space Exploration.

IAC-19.A3.2A.6 Page 3 of 6
3.3 Mission outline and spacecraft configuration
As mentioned above, this mission is being studied in
collaboration with ISRO. The outline of the mission is
shown in Table 1. A schematic image of the spacecraft on
the Moon is shown in Fig. 3.
The spacecraft system comprises a lander system and a
rover system. The system does not have a communication
relay satellite but is based on direct communication with Rocket Rover Lander
the Earth. The minimum target for the landing payload
mass is more than 350 kg. The landing site is planned for JAXA ISRO
a long-term sunlit area close to the permanently shadowed
region (PSR) around the lunar south pole. Therefore, the Fig. 4. Assignment of roles and responsibilities.
mission duration is assumed to be more than half a year
because sunshine continues around the landing site. The launch orbit is the same as the KAGUYA launch
The current assignment of roles and responsibilities for orbit. After the spacecraft reaches the Moon it is
spacecraft developments are shown in Fig. 4. As shown in inserted into a circular orbit having a 100-km altitude
this figure, the ISRO side will provide the lander and the via a few orbital changes. In the lunar orbit, it waits
JAXA side will provide the rover and launch rocket. This until the orbital plane passes over the landing site, then
plan is the current baseline and may change as the joint transitions to an orbit of landing preparation. In the
study progresses. powered-descent phase, the lander decelerates by
continuous thruster injection and control of the velocity
Table1: Mission outline in the horizontal direction relative to the lunar surface
Launch year Early 2020s to about 0 m/s. During this phase, the position of the
Launcher H3 lander is estimated by landmark navigation. In the
Launch orbit Same as KAGUYA
vertical-descent phase, the lander performs altitude
Launch mass Around 6 ton
Mission duration One half year
control and obstacle avoidance and corrects the position
Landing site Lunar polar region error generated in the powered-descent phase. It shuts
Rover and instruments for water down all thrusters immediately before landing on the
Payloads prospecting and environmental lunar surface. After landing, the rover is deployed on
observation the lunar surface using ramps. The rover then prospects
water ice with its observation instruments.

Fig. 3. Schematic image of the spacecraft

IAC-19.A3.2A.6 Page 4 of 6
3.4 Operational plan of observation 4. R&D of enabling technologies
Though various methods can be considered for We currently focus on technologies to realize
observation of water-ice, the following observation exploration of lunar polar regions and are promoting the
instruments and their operation are considered as an following research and development.
example.
A) Power system
A) Coarse observation (Fig. 5) The sunshine in the polar regions is mostly from the
- The rover runs around the waypoint in the pre-defined horizontal direction. In addition, the point where the
exploration area. possibility of water ice is high does not have much
- At this time, the rover observes lunar surface and blow sunshine. Therefore, the surface temperature is generally
water distribution with an underground radar, a neutron low. To meet these conditions, we aim to realize a tower-
spectrometer and imaging spectroscopic camera. like solar cell for power generation and a high-energy-
- Based on these data, an area where water-ice may exist density lithium-ion battery for heating.
is identified.
Support arm

Sun trucking

Thin‐film  solar  cell 

Fig. 5: Coarse observation


Solar  cell  container
B) Fine observation (Fig. 6)
- The following observations will be made using samples
Deployment  mast
acquired while excavating up to 1.5 m underground by
an earth auger.
 Soil temperature measurement. Fig. 7 Solar cell tower deployment test
 Thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) of the sample
(measuring the content of volatile substances from B) Image-based navigation
the mass loss with heating). As mentioned above, the polar sunshine is mostly from the
 Analyzing volatile molecular species by a mass horizontal direction. At the time of landing, it might be
spectrometer. difficult to use terrain such as a crater for image-based
 D/H ratio measurement by a cavity ringdown navigation. Therefore, we are considering shadow-image-
spectroscopy. based navigation using shadows caused by terrain.

In the observation series, steps A and B are repeated at


each predefined waypoint in the exploration area.

Fig. 8 Image-based navigation using the feature points


of shadows.
Fig. 6: Fine observation

IAC-19.A3.2A.6 Page 5 of 6
C) Rover system Acknowledgments
In addition to observation instruments, various The authors would like to thank the members of the
functions such as lunar drilling and sample ISRO team for their contributions to the concept study
collection/transport are required for water ice prospecting. described in this paper.
Therefore, we are developing a rover test model equipped
with an earth auger drill for exploring subsurface water References
ice to examine required functions (Fig. 9). [1] The International Space Exploration Coordination
We have also conducted a long-distance traveling test Group (ISECG), Global Exploration Roadmap (3rd
of the wheel system in a vacuum-regolith environment to edition), January 2018,
increase the reliability and travel distance of the rover https://www.globalspaceexploration.org/wordpress/
(Fig.10). In the test, simulated lunar soil, FJS-1, is used. wp-content/isecg/GER_2018_small_mobile.pdf
(accessed 15.09.18).
[2] Sending American Astronauts to Moon in 2024,
NASA Accepts Challenge,
https://www.nasa.gov/feature/sending-american-
astronauts-to-moon-in-2024-nasa-accepts-challenge
(accessed April 22, 2019)
[3] T. Hashimoto et al., System design of CubeSat
Semi-hard Moon Impactor: OMOTENASHI, 69th
International Astronautical Congress, IAC-
18,A3,IP,9,x42452, Bremen, Germany, 2018.
[4] S. Ueda et al., A Study on Guidance Technique for
Precise Lunar Landing, 26th International
Symposium on Space Flight Dynamics, Matsuyama,
Japan, ISTS-2017-d-053 / ISSFD-2017-053.ISTS
2017, 2017
[5] S. Li et al., Direct evidence of surface exposed water
Fig. 9: Rover BBM with earth auger ice in the lunar polar regions. Proceedings of the
National Academy of Sciences. 115. 201802345.
10.1073/pnas.1802345115., 2018
[6] A.B. Sanin et al., Hydrogen Distribution in the Lunar
Polar Regions. Icarus. 283.
10.1016/j.icarus.2016.06.002., 2016
[7] Diego de Rosa et al., Characterization of potential
landing sites for the European Space Agency's Lunar
Lander project, Planetary and Space Science,
Volume 74, Issue 1, December 2012, pp. 224-246
[8] T. Hashimoto et al., Japanese moon lander
SELENE-2-Present status in 2009, Acta
Astronautica 68 (2011), pp. 1386–1391.
[9] T. Hashimoto et al., Japanese Lunar Polar
Fig. 10: Wheel traveling test in a vacuum-regolith Exploration Mission, 67th International
environment Astronautical Congress, IAC-16,A3,2A,2,x32474,
Guadalajara, Mexico, 2016.
5. Conclusion [10] T. Hoshino et al., Japanese Lunar Polar Exploration
JAXA is planning a lunar polar exploration mission in Mission -SELENE-R, 68th International
collaboration with ISRO that aims mainly to confirm the Astronautical Congress, IAC-17,A3,2B,4,x38622,
abundance of water-ice. In this paper, we have reported Adelaide, Australia, 2017.
on the current study status of the mission. We expect the [11] T. Hoshino et al., Japanese Lunar Polar Exploration
mission to contribute to the international space Mission: 69th International Astronautical Congress,
exploration roadmap and expect to carry it out in the early IAC-18,A3,2A,6,x45769, Bremen, Germany, 2018.
2020s.

IAC-19.A3.2A.6 Page 6 of 6

You might also like