Professional Documents
Culture Documents
To cite this article: Felaza E, Findyartini A, Setyorini D, Mustika R. How motivation correlates
with academic burnout: study conducted in undergraduate medical students. Education in Medicine
Journal. 2020;12(1): 43–52. https://doi.org/10.21315/eimj2020.12.1.5
ABSTRACT
Burnout is found among medical students as they become overwhelmed by stressors. On the other
hand, students’ motivation act as the force that maintains learning. This study aims to capture the
association between motivation type and burnout in students. This cross-sectional study involved
students across all year levels with a total of 1,036 students participated in the study. Data was
collected using Academic Motivation Scale to determine type of motivation, and Maslach Burnout
Inventory to measure burnout’s components (emotional exhaustion, cynicism and perception of
personal accomplishment). Correlations and multivariate analyses were conducted to discover
associations between motivation, burnout components and performance. Significant negative
correlations were found between motivation type and perception of personal accomplishment in pre-
clinical year (PCY) 2 (r = –0.206; p = 0.004), clinical year (CY) 1 (r = –0.242; p = 0.000), and CY2
(r = –0.189; p = 0.012). In PCY1 the correlation was significantly positive (r = 0.061; p = 0.003),
while in PCY3 no significant correlation was found. Negative correlations found indicate that the
more external the motivation, the lower the perception of personal accomplishment. Motivation types
correlates with perception of personal accomplishment as one of the subscales of burnout; showing
perceptions’ tendency to lowered as motivation becomes more external. This study highlights the
importance of addressing students’ motivation in preventing burnout. Efforts to strengthen intrinsic
motivations may help develop better perceptions of personal accomplishment and protect students
from burnout.
Corresponding author Estivana Felaza, Medical Education Department, Faculty of Medicine, Universitas
Indonesia, Salemba Raya 6, Jakarta 10430, Indonesia | Email : estivanafelaza@gmail.com
the medical education process. Academic type (3). Individuals with HIHC motivational
burdens, social pressures and unsupportive profiles possess both high intrinsic and
learning environments contribute to extrinsic motivation for conducting their
development of burnout. Students with learning efforts, while for those with HILC,
burnout experience emotional exhaustion, the majority of the drive to learn comes from
depersonalisation and low perceptions of their intrinsic source of motivation. Due to
personal accomplishments, which later are the more stable nature of intrinsic motivation,
identified as the three components of burnout these two types were predicted to have better
(1). Without proper interventions, this performance compared to the others (2, 3).
condition might lead to depression and has On the other hand, individuals with LIHC
been associated with suicidal ideation (1). based their motivation from external sources.
The last type, LILC was the most vulnerable,
Students’ motivation can be seen as the because their low levels of motivation from
driving force that ensures learning takes either internal or external source.
place. Based on self-determination theory,
motivation has been modelled as a spectrum While burnout can be conceptualised as
ranging from the self-determined end, also students’ decreased passion for learning,
known as intrinsic motivation, to extrinsic motivation can be seen as the spirit that
motivation and to amotivation at the other keeps the flame alive. Intrinsic motivation is
end (2). The source of intrinsic motivation supported by three components: students’
emanates from within, whereas extrinsic sense of autonomy toward their actions, a
motivation relies more on external factors, feeling of competence in their learning and
such as rewards for learning. Studies have a sense of relatedness to their environment.
shown that intrinsically motivated students A positive perception of one’s capability
tend to use deep learning approach that is (competence) to master certain tasks makes
correlated with better academic performance. students more motivated to learn. As
These students also showed higher intention students feel supported and belong as part of
to continue their medical studies and their educational environment (relatedness),
become lifelong learners (2, 3). In medical their intrinsic motivation increases (2).
education, altruism can also be considered Based on Bandura’s social cognitive theory
an intrinsic type of motivation, as students (SCT), an individual’s behaviour results
strive to learn with the intention of being from interactions between personal factors
able to help others later as future doctors (4). (motivation, self-efficacy and attributions),
On the other hand, extrinsic motivation is behaviour (previous successful or failed
considered as a controlled type of motivation behaviour, and self regulation process), and
because of the way individuals’ motives the environment (social support) (5).
for learning are controlled by an external
cause (2, 5). Furthermore, four motivational Self-regulation indicates that individuals
profiles have been introduced by namely high orient their behaviour toward certain
intrinsic high controlled (HIHC) type which standards and continually analyse the
reflects high intrinsic motivation/interest discrepancies found between their
and controlled/status motivation and high performance and the standards they have set.
intrinsic low controlled (HILC) type which As individuals analyse their accomplishments
reflects high intrinsic motivation/interest and and progress in reaching their goals, their
low controlled/status motivation. In addition, self-efficacy would be affected. Self-efficacy
low intrinsic high controlled (LIHC) type defined as a belief in one’s capabilities to
refers to low intrinsic motivation/interest conduct the necessary course of action to
and high controlled/status motivation, achieve a desired goal, was appraised by
whereas both intrinsic motivation/interest and analysing actual performance, experiences,
controlled/status motivation are low in low forms of persuasion and physiological
intrinsic low controlled (LILC) motivational reactions. Students rated their performance
against the intended standard they had set
44 https://eduimed.usm.my
ORIGINAL ARTICLE | Motivation and Academic Burnout
for themselves and by comparing it with the Several studies have shown relationship
performance of other students. Perceived between motivation and burnout. A study
success would enhance self-efficacy, conducted in China on secondary students
whereas failures would lower it (6). This showed that students without burnout had
ability seemed to be lacking in individuals the highest scores on intrinsic motivation,
experiencing burnout. When individuals with while distressed students were those with
burnout compare their current performance high scores on extrinsic motivation and
with their set of desired standards, their amotivation (14). A study on career choice
performance tends to be seen as unsatisfying. motivation in medical students, showed that
This could be the result of utilising an a lack of altruistic motivation correlated
unobjective method of perceiving one’s with the burnout variables of cynicism and
performance, or it could be due to setting reduced academic efficacy (4). Kusurkar
unrealistic standards for themselves. Several et al. have profiled undergraduate medical
studies have found a negative correlation students’ motivation in The Netherlands
between self-regulation and burnout, context (3). Given the challenge of
indicating that increased self-regulation undergraduate medical students to commit
ability might result in decreased burnout (7). to studying medicine for a long period of
time and that medical schools should be
Self-efficacy can also be strengthened by able to support the students along the way
receiving positive feedback from others and by considering contextual aspects such as
by detecting decreased anxiety, as anxiety culture, resources, etc, current authors
was considered a physiological reaction aim to explore the association of students’
associated with failing to conduct certain motivation type, burnout and academic
tasks (8, 9). Self-efficacy was found to be performance, especially in Indonesia context.
positively correlated with intrinsic motivation
in which high self-efficacy would contribute
to increased intrinsic motivation (10, 11). METHOD
Correlation analysis from a study on burnout
and motivation has shown that burnout is Participants
negatively correlated with self-efficacy and
with intrinsic motivation altogether (12). The study was conducted with students of
the undergraduate medical programme at the
Furthermore, individuals with burnout Faculty of Medicine, Universitas Indonesia
tend to detach themselves from their (FMUI) in 2018. The programme consists
environment (not seeing themselves as part of seven to eight semesters of the pre-clinical
of their environment would then lead to phase and four semesters of the clinical
cynicism) and from their own performance phase. A competency-based curriculum with
(resulting in a low perception of personal an integrated, student-centred and problem-
accomplishment). Due to the detachment, based approach has been implemented in the
individuals with burnout might also attribute past 12 years.
their performance failure to external factors
(the difficulties of the task, or lack of
Instruments
chances) and perceive the result of their
performance as being beyond their control. In this cross-sectional study, questionnaires
This might lead students’ motivation to were distributed to first- to fifth-year
decrease because they cannot see any hope students. This study used total sampling
for future improvements. An internal locus of approach and students voluntarily filled out
control (attributing the current performance the questionnaires. Motivation was measured
to factors that are changeable within the using the Academic Motivation Scale (AMS),
individual) is considered a healthier attribute a 28-item questionnaire that aimed to identify
and correlates better with success (13). students’ type of motivation for learning,
https://eduimed.usm.my 45
Education in Medicine Journal 2020; 12(1): 43–52
while the Maslach Burnout Inventory- and academic performance. The results
Student Survey (MBI-SS) was used to showed a negative correlation between
measure the burnout experienced during the motivation type and perception of personal
education process. All the instruments were accomplishment in Year 1, Year 2 and
presented in the Indonesian language and Clinical Year (CY) 2 (with r ranging from
have been validated in the previous study –0.229 to –0.166 and the p-value ranging
with good internal consistencies; 0.913 for from 0.001 to 0.028) (see Table 2).
MBI-SS and 0.950 for AMS respectively
(15). Students’ academic performance To further confirm the correlations between
was measured by their grade point average motivation type and the components
(GPA) in respective semesters. of burnout (cynicism and perception of
personal accomplishment), multivariate
Data derived from the questionnaires analysis was conducted. Statistically
were analysed using SPSS 22.0. Based on significant associations were found between
the AMS results, students were grouped motivation and perception of personal
into HIHC, HILC, LIHC and LILC accomplishment in all year levels, except
or amotivation categories (3). Scores Year 3. Students whose motivation show a
on burnout were measured based on more extrinsic form and amotivation (with
its three scales: emotional exhaustion, intrinsic motivation diminished), tend to
depersonalisation and perception of personal have a decreased perception of personal
accomplishment (14). For numerical data, a accomplishment (r ranging from –0.138
test of normality was conducted to measure to –0.242), except in Year 1, when a weak
the distribution of the results. A correlation positive correlation was found (r = 0.061)
between motivation and the components (see Table 3).
of burnout was identified and multiple
regression was conducted to confirm the
results and identify confounding factors. DISCUSSION
This study has been approved by Research The aim of this study was to seek correlation
Ethics Committee of FMUI No. 451/UN2. between motivation, components of burnout
F1/ETIK/IV/2018. Information regarding and academic performance. Motivation
the study was given to the participants and was found to be corrrelated with burnout
those agreed to participate voluntarily filled on one of its components of perception of
out the questionnaires. personal accomplishment. Students with
less intrinsic motivation and more extrinsic
(controlled) motivation tend to have
RESULTS lower perception of accomplishment. This
phenomenon was found in Pre-Clinical
A total of 1,036 Year 1 to Year 5 students Year (PCY) 2, CY 1 and CY 2. A similar
responded to the questionnaires with finding was evident in a study conducted
a response rate per year level ranging in China, which showed that students with
from 89% to 98%. Two incomplete high intrinsic motivation did not experience
questionnaires were excluded from the burnout and on the contrary, those with
analysis. The respondents in the current high extrinsic motivation tend to experience
study consisted of 439 female students burnout (14). Other study in Korean
(42.46%) and 595 male students (57.54%) students showed the role of motivation in
across all year levels at FMUI (see Table 1). mediating the relation between the type of
perfectionism and academic burnout. Self-
Analysis on motivation type was conducted oriented perfectionism, which defined as
based on the burnout components setting high expectations and goals for one
(emotional exhaustion, cynicism and self, is closely linked to intrinsic motivation,
perception of personal accomplishment)
46 https://eduimed.usm.my
ORIGINAL ARTICLE | Motivation and Academic Burnout
https://eduimed.usm.my 47
48
Table 1: Characteristics of respondents in terms burnout components, academic performance and motivation type
Student level
Characteristics
PCY 1 PCY 2 PCY 3 CY 1 CY 2
n = 227 n = 198 n = 210 n = 221 n = 175
Burnout
https://eduimed.usm.my
Emotional exhaustion Mean 16.53 17.13 16.25 19.8 19.38
(MBI-S 5 items, score 0–30, Median 17.00 (0–45) 17.00 (2–30) 16.00 (0–30) 20.00 (1–38) 19.00 (2–40)
MBI-HSS 9 items, score 0–54) (Min–Max)
Cynism/depersonalisation Mean 10.40 10.72 10.70 8.200 9.29
Education in Medicine Journal 2020; 12(1): 43–52
(MBI-S 5 items, score 0–30, Median 10.00 (0–30) 10.00 (0–30) 10.00 (0–30) 7.00 (0–28) 9.00 (0–24)
MBI-HSS 5 items, score 0–30) (Min–Max)
Perceptions towards personal Mean 20.70 19.57 19.76 36.44 34.13
accomplishment
(MBI-S 5 items, score 0–30, Median 21.00 (3–30) (3–30) 20.00 (5–30) 38.00 (15–48) 35.00 (6-48)
MBI-HSS 8 items, score 0–48) (Min–Max)
Academic performance Mean 3.62 3.35 3.32 3.45 3.56
Median 3.67 (2.91–3.99) 3.38 (2.64–3.83) 3.325 (2.77–3.87) 3.48 (2.74–3.88) 3.57 (3.15-3.84)
(Min–Max)
Motivation types
HIHC 191 (84.14%) 158 (79.79%) 171 (81.42%) 178 (80.54%) 147 (84.0%)
HILC 23 (10.13%) 24 (12.12%) 22 (10.48%) 28 (12.67%) 15 (8.57%)
LIHC 2 (0.88%) 8 (4.04%) 10 (4.76%) 3 (1.36%) 4 (2.29%)
LILC 11 (4.8%) 8 (4.04%) 7 (3.33%) 12 (5.42%) 9 (5.14%)
ORIGINAL ARTICLE | Motivation and Academic Burnout
Note: *Type of motivation (HIHC, HILC, LIHC and LILC) was converted into scores of 0–3 respectively so that the higher score
represents more external and lower motivation type.
Motivation
Academic Academic Academic
Variable CY 1 CY 2
Year 1 Year 2 Year 3
r p r p r p r p r p
MBI-Perception
of personal 0.061 0.003 –0.206 0.004 –0.138 –0.188 –0.242 0.000 –0.189 0.012
accomplishment
A tendency to rely on certain standards they are capable of doing the task in order
(i.e., comparing their own performance to perform. One possible way of acquiring
with peers) can also be attributed to first- self-efficacy could be by comparing their
year students’ limited knowledge about the performance to that of their peers (19).
curriculum (including what is expected of
them) because they are still adjusting to the Despite findings supporting the association
new environment. When these standards between intrinsic motivation and better
were somehow met, students might then academic performance, in the present study
feel that they have accomplished their no significant correlation was found between
goals. A study conducted on the role of the two aspects. This might imply that
self-efficacy on different type of motivation students’ academic peformance is affected
revealed that for individuals with lower by many factors, including self-regulated
intrinsic motivation, the role of self-efficacy learning ability. Self-regulated learning
in forming perceived competence was emphasises three aspects contributing
found to be important, but for those with to the success of learning, which are the
high intrinsic motivation, the role of self- use of self-regulated learning strategies,
efficacy becomes less important (19). It responsiveness to self-oriented feedback
seems that when students have high intrinsic and motivations. Many factors contribute
motivation, they do not rely much on to performance, such as the implementation
self-efficacy to deliver their performance; of an appropriate learning strategy and
instead, they perform the task due more to self-monitoring ability. Learning strategies
their love of performing it. But those with may include planning, information seeking,
low intrinsic motivation (or who are more record keeping, environmental structuring,
extrinsically motivated) need to believe that rehearsing and memorising, seeking social
https://eduimed.usm.my 49
Education in Medicine Journal 2020; 12(1): 43–52
50 https://eduimed.usm.my
ORIGINAL ARTICLE | Motivation and Academic Burnout
2. Kusurkar RA, ten Cate TJ, van Asperen M, 9. Klassen R, Klassen J. Self-efficacy beliefs
Croiset G. Motivation as an independent of medical students: a critical review.
and dependent variable in medical Perspectives on Medical Education.
education: a review of the literature. Med 2018;7:76–82. https://doi.org/10.1007/
Teach. 2011;33(5):e242–62. https://doi.org/ s40037-018-0411-3
10.3109/0142159X.2011.558539
10. Pellacia T, Delplancq H, Triby E, Bartier
3. Kusurkar RA, Croiset G, Galindo-Garré F, JC, Leman C, Dupeyron JP. Impact
Cate OT. Motivational profiles of medical of training periods in the emergency
students: association with study effort, department on the motivation of the
academic performance, and exhaustion. healthcare students to learn. Med Educ.
BMC Med Educ. 2013;13(87):1–8. https:// 2009;43(5):462–9. https://doi.org/10.1111/
doi.org/10.1186/1472-6920-13-87 j.1365-2923.2009.03356.x
4. Gyorffy Z, Birkas E, Sandor I. Career 11. Roohi G, Asayesh H, Bathai SA, Shouri
motivation and burnout among medical Bidgoli AR, Badeleh MT, Rahmani H.
students in Hungary: could altruism be The relationship between self-efficacy
a protection factor. BMC Med Educ. and academic motivation among students
2016;16:182. https://doi.org/10.1186/ of medical sciences. Journal of Medical
s12909-016-0690-5 Education and Development. 2013;8(1):45–
51.
5. Stajkovic A, Luthans F. Social cognitive
theory and self-efficacy: implications for 12. Mataroria PL, Henning MA, Alyami
motivation theory and practice. In: Steers H, Krishna S, Zeng I, Yu TC, Hill AG.
RM, Portert LW, Bigley GA, editors. Burnout, quality of life, motivation, and
Motivation and work behavior. 7th ed. academic achievement among medical
United States: McGraw-Hill/Irwin; 2003. students: a person-oriented approach.
p. 126–40. Perspect Med Educ. 2017;6:108–14. https://
doi.org/10.1007/s40037-017-0340-6
6. Schunk DH. Self-efficacy for reading and
writing: influence of modelling, goal setting, 13. Rinn AN, Boazman J. Locus of control,
and self evaluation. Reading and Writing academic self-concept, and academic
Quarterly. 2003;19:159–72. https://doi dishonesty among high ability college
.org/10.1080/10573560308219 students. Journal of the Scholarship of
Teaching and Learning. 2014;14(4):88–114.
7. Karamooz M, Narafshan MH. The https://doi.org/10.14434/v14i4.12770
relationship between self-regulation
strategies and burnout: a teacher analysis in 14. Zhang X, Klassen RM, Wang Y.
EFL context of Iran. Studies in Linguistics Academic motivation and burnout of
and Literature. 2017;1(2):186–97. https:// Chinese secondary students. International
doi.org/10.22158/sll.v1n2p186 Journal of Social Science and Humanity.
2013;3(2):134–8. https://doi.org/10.7763/
8. Bandura A. Perceived self-efficacy IJSSH.2013.V3.212
in cognitive development and
functioning. Educational Psychologist. 15. Qomarasandhi J. Pengaruh tipe motivasi
1993;28(2):117–48. https://doi.org/10.1207/ terhadap burnout pada mahasiswa tahap
s15326985ep2802_3 klinik Fakultas Kedokteran Universitas
Indonesia [dissertation]. Jakarta: Universitas
Indonesia; 2017.
https://eduimed.usm.my 51
Education in Medicine Journal 2020; 12(1): 43–52
16. Chang E, Lee A, Byeon E, Lee SM. Role 19. Buch R, Safvenbom R, Boe O. The
of motivation on the relation between relationship between academic self-
perfectionism and academic burnout in efficacy, intrinsic motivation, and perceived
Korean students. Personality and Individual competence. Journal of Military Studies.
Differences 2015;82:221–6. https://doi 2015;6(1):19–35. https://doi.org/10.1515/
.org/10.1016/j.paid.2015.03.027 jms-2016-0195
52 https://eduimed.usm.my