Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Clinical Pharmacology
Biochemical
Mechanisms for Drug
Toxicity
Economic Impact:
Inpatient Outpatient
Adverse Drug Events
(ADEs) contribute an
additional $3.5 billion
to U.S. health care • 2 million stays • Most • > 3.5 million
costs (2006 USD) annually common post- office visits
• Increased discharge • ~1 million ED
length of stay complication visits
(~1.7-4.6 days)
U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Office of Disease Prevention and Health Promotion. (2014). National Action Plan for Adverse Drug Event
Prevention. Washington, DC
The Fate of Drugs
Non-Toxic
Drug Excretion
Metabolites
Bioactivation
Enzyme Reactive
Metabolites
Prostaglandin H 2 (PGH2)
1000
800
600
400
200
0
http://www.utsouthwestern.edu/labs/acute-liver/
Glutathione N-acetylcysteine
(GSH) (NAC)
N-acetyl-p-
benzoquinone imine
(NAPQI)
Hodgman M and Garrard AR. Crit Care Clin. 2012; 28, 499-516
Acetaminophen (APAP)
Acetaminophen
(APAP)
Glucuronidation
P450s 2EI, 5%
55-60%
1A2, 2A4
Eliminated in Urine
Sulfation Reactive
20-30% 10%M etabolite
Catechol Derivative
NAC
Glutathione N-acetylcysteine
Major Metabolites (~85%); (GSH) (NAC)
Inactive Form s (renal
elim ination) N-acetyl-p-
benzoquinone imine
(NAPQI)
Glutathione
(GSH) Depletion
Non-Toxic Glutathione Conjugate Cysteine adduct
Drug Excretion
Metabolites APAP APAP
Bioactivation
Enzyme Reactive Further Metabolism
Metabolites and/or Excretion
Covalent cell binding Mercapturic acid
and injury adduct APAP
Hodgman M and Garrard AR. Crit Care Clin. 2012; 28, 499-516
Acetaminophen (APAP)
Acetaminophen
(APAP) Drug
Non-Toxic
Excretion
Metabolites
uronidation
Bioactivation
P450s 2EI, 5% Enzyme Reactive
5-60% Metabolites
Bioactivation 1A2, 2A4 A
Eliminated in Urine
Sulfation Reactive GSH, etc.
20-30% 10%
M etabolite B
Catechol Derivative Macromolecular-Drug
NAC
Non-toxic Adducts
Excretion Oxidative Stress:
Product GSH Depletion
Glutathione N-acetylcysteine
(GSH) ↓ATP ↓↓ ATP
(NAC) • Tissue Necrosis
N-acetyl-p- • Hypersensitivity Reaction
benzoquinone imine • Carcinogenesis
Apoptosis Necrosis • Teratogenesis
(NAPQI)
Oxidative Glutathione
Stress (GSH) Depletion
Glutathione Conjugate Cysteine adduct
APAP APAP
Increase
Oxidative ↑ M itochondrial
Permeability (MPT)
Stress
Hepatocellular
Covalent cell binding Mercapturic acid
and injury Necrosis
adduct APAP
Hodgman M and Garrard AR. Crit Care Clin. 2012; 28, 499-516
Acetaminophen (APAP)
Acetaminophen Variations in APAP susceptibility
(APAP)
Alcohol • Alcohol consumption (increase metabolic activation)
uronidation Non-Toxic
Drug Excretion
5%
Metabolites
P450 2EI
5-60%
Bioactivation Eliminated in Urine
Sulfation Reactive Bioactivation
20-30% 10% Enzyme Reactive
M etabolite
Catechol Derivative Metabolites A
NAC
GSH, etc.
B
Glutathione Macromolecular-Drug
N-acetylcysteine
(GSH) Non-toxic
(NAC) Adducts
Excretion Oxidative Stress:
N-acetyl-p- Product GSH Depletion
benzoquinone imine
(NAPQI) ↓ATP ↓↓ ATP
• Tissue Necrosis
• Hypersensitivity Reaction
Oxidative Glutathione • Carcinogenesis
Apoptosis Necrosis •
Stress (GSH) Depletion Teratogenesis
Hepatocellular
Covalent cell binding Mercapturic acid
and injury Necrosis
adduct APAP
Hodgman M and Garrard AR. Crit Care Clin. 2012; 28, 499-516
Acetaminophen (APAP)
Acetaminophen Variations in APAP susceptibility
(APAP)
• Inflammatory stress
*APAP-induced Hepatocellular Necrosis via Immune Response
uronidation
P450s 2EI, 5%
5-60%
Bioactivation 1A2, 2A4
Eliminated in Urine
Sulfation Reactive
20-30% 10%
M etabolite
Catechol Derivative
NAC
Glutathione N-acetylcysteine
(GSH) (NAC)
N-acetyl-p-
benzoquinone imine
(NAPQI)
Oxidative Glutathione
Stress (GSH) Depletion Necrotic Hepatocytes
Krenkel O,Conjugate
Glutathione Mossanen JC and Tacke F. Hepatobiliary
Cysteine adduct Surg Nutr. 2014 Dec; 3(6): 331-43.
APAP APAP
Increase
Oxidative ↑ M itochondrial
Permeability (MPT)
Stress
Hepatocellular
Covalent cell binding Mercapturic acid
and injury Necrosis
adduct APAP
Hodgman M and Garrard AR. Crit Care Clin. 2012; 28, 499-516
Type B- Idiosyncratic DILI
• Drugs usually eliminated during preclinical testing
• Idiosyncratic DILI accounts for large percent of post-marketing restrictions by FDA
• Hepatotoxicity not related to pharmacological action of
drug
• Wide range in the severity of toxic effects
• Limited mechanistic understanding
• Theories for Toxicity
• Reactive Intermediate Hypothesis
• Mitochondrial Dysfunction Hypothesis
• Genetic Polymorphism Hypothesis
• Hapten Hypothesis
• The Danger Hypothesis
• Failure-to-Adapt Hypothesis
• Multiple Determinant Hypothesis
• Inflammatory Stress Hypothesis
Shaw PJ, Ganey PE, and Roth RA. Toxicol Sci. 2010 Nov; 118(1): 7-18
Idiosyncratic DILI
Theories for Mechanism of Action
Reactive Intermediate Hypothesis
Mitochondrial Dysfunction Hypothesis
Genetic Polymorphism Hypothesis
Genetic Polymorphisms
Bioactivation
Enzyme Reactive Macromolecular-Drug
Drug DILI
Metabolites Adducts
Increase
Oxidative
Stress ↑ M itochondrial
Permeability (MPT)
Hepatocellular
Necrosis
Roth R.A. and Ganey P.E. J Pharmacology and Experimental Therapeutics. 2010; 332(3), 692-697)
Shaw PJ, Ganey PE, and Roth RA. Toxicol Sci. 2010 Nov; 118(1): 7-18
Isoniazid
• First-line agent in the treatment of active or latent tuberculosis
• Mechanism of Action
• Bactericidal action: Block formation of mycolic acids
• Mycolic acid: essential component of mycobacterial cell wall synthesis
• Disruption of cell wall results in cell death
• Animal model used to elucidate biochemical mechanism
• ~20% of treated patients develop elevated liver enzymes and bilirubin (small percentage develop hepatitis)
Isoniazid N-acetylisoniazid
Theories of Toxicity
Reactive Intermediate Hypothesis
Mitochondrial Dysfunction Hypothesis
Amidase Amidase
Genetic Polymorphism Hypothesis*
Isonicotinic Acid
NAT2
NH2-NH2 CH3CO-NH2-NH2 NAT2 CH3CO-NH2-NH-COCH3
Hydrazine Aceytlhydrazine Diaceytlhydrazine
Amidase
CYP2E1 ↑ Mitochondrial
GSH Binding/ Permeability
Depletion (MPT)
Toxic ↑ Oxidative Hepatocellular
Metabolite Stress Apoptosis
Cho T and Uetrecht J. Chem Res Toxicol. 2017 Jan 17: 30(1): 295-314
Hapten Hypothesis
• Drug-induced hepatotoxic reaction mediated by an immune response
• Chemically reactive drug or reactive metabolite (hapten) binds endogenous protein that
initiates an immune response
• Macromolecule-drug adduct: neoantigen
• Example Drug: Halothane
• Volatile general anesthetic
• 2 types of hepatotoxicity of Halothane
Lipid Peroxidation
Halothane Type 1 2-chloro-1,1,1-
trifluoroethyl radical
Trifluoroacetyl-chloride
Liver Protein
Thiazolidine ring
β-lactam ring
Major
Side Chain
Penicilloyl-Protein (antigen)
Penicillin
Bhattacharya S. J Adv Pharm Technol Res. 2010 Jan; 1(1): 11-17. Gonsales-Estrada A and Radojicic C. Cleve Clin J Med. 2015 May; 82(5): 295-300.
Hapten Hypothesis: Penicillin
• Adverse reaction (immune response) is mediated by IgE antibodies
that recognize the β-lactam-modified proteins
Thiazolidine ring
β-lactam ring
Major
Side Chain
Penicilloyl-Protein (antigen)
Penicillin
Bhattacharya S. J Adv Pharm Technol Res. 2010 Jan; 1(1): 11-17. Gonsales-Estrada A and Radojicic C. Cleve Clin J Med. 2015 May; 82(5): 295-300.
Inflammatory Stress Hypothesis
• Drug therapy coupled to inflammatory stress precipitates Type B adverse drug reaction
• Inflammatory stress induced by several factors:
• Infection, intestinal microbial disturbance, cell death, etc.
Bacterial DNA
B B Trovafloxacin B B B B
B B A A A A A A
A A DNA-DNA gyrase Complex Trovafloxacin stabilizes DNA-DNA Broken DNA strands are released,
forms (DNA strands broken but gyrase Complex (Broken DNA this results in cell death
Bacterial DNA strands cannot be released and
held together via DNA gyrase)
Gyrase DNA replication is blocked)
http://www.antibiotics-info.org/levofloxacin.html
Example: Trovafloxacin (TVX)
• Mode of action for hepatotoxicity: inflammation-drug interaction animal models
Shaw PJ, Hopfensperger MJ, Ganey PE, and Roth RA. Toxicol Sci. 2007; 100(1): 259-266
Example: Trovafloxacin (TVX)
• Mode of action for hepatotoxicity: inflammation-drug interaction animal models
Veh: Sterile Saline; LPS: Lipopolysaccharide; ALT: Alanine Transaminase; Etan: Etanercept
Shaw PJ, Hopfensperger MJ, Ganey PE, and Roth RA. Toxicol Sci. 2007; 100(1): 259-266
Example: Trovafloxacin (TVX)
• Mode of action for hepatotoxicity: inflammation-drug interaction animal models
Gene Expression after TVX/ LPS-Induced Liver Injury
• Global Gene Profiling:
•Genes involved in interferon signaling (IFN-γ) play a role in TVX/LPS co-exposure
•Early Marker of Hepatotoxicity
TVX/LPS
↑ 193 ↑ JAK/STAT and IFN
↓ 580 Signaling Pathways
↑ 116 ↑ 534
↓ 284 ↓ 230
↑ 114
TVX/Veh ↓ 105
Veh/LPS
↑ 197 ↑ 10 ↑ 364
↓ 168 ↓9 ↓ 173
Total R&D cost: $2.6 billion on average (in 2013 USD) http://phrma-docs.phrma.org/sites/default/files/pdf/rd_brochure_022307.pdf
How do we develop safe drugs?
• Integration of risk assessment strategies early in drug development phase
• Minimize risk of attrition during preclinical phase, clinical trials and post-market
• Early risk assessment during drug development phase
Total R&D cost: $2.6 billion on average (in 2013 USD) http://phrma-docs.phrma.org/sites/default/files/pdf/rd_brochure_022307.pdf
How do we develop safe drugs?
• Integration of risk assessment strategies early in drug development phase
• Minimize risk of attrition during preclinical phase, clinical trials and post-market
• Early risk assessment during drug development phase
Toxicity Pathway
Adverse Chemical
Macro-
Cellular Tissue Organ Individual
Outcome molecular
Insult Response Response Response Response
Pathway Interaction
Formation of
Reactive
Metabolites
Thompson RA, et al. Chem Res Toxicol. 2016 Apr 18; 29(4): 505-533.
Risk Assessment Approaches
• Existing Risk Assessment Approaches
• Formation of Reactive Metabolite
• Reactive metabolite formation combined with dose
• Reactive metabolite formation integrated with measures of cellular response
Thompson RA, et al. Chem Res Toxicol. 2016 Apr 18; 29(4): 505-533.
Risk Assessment Approaches
• Existing Risk Assessment Approaches
• Formation of Reactive Metabolite
• Reactive metabolite formation combined with dose
• Reactive metabolite formation integrated with measures of cellular response
Thompson RA, et al. Chem Res Toxicol. 2016 Apr 18; 29(4): 505-533.
Example of Trapping Approach
• Characterization of 1,3-Bisphosphoglycerate (1,3-BPG)
• Primary intermediate of glycolysis pathway
• Sensitive to hydrolysis or isomerization
• Naturally converted to 3-PG and 2,3-BPG (enzyme-mediated)
• Reported Value: combined level of 1,2-BPG and 2,3-BPG
Glucose Pyruvate
2,3-Bisphosphoglcerate (2,3-BPG)
Glucose Pyruvate
2,3-Bisphosphoglcerate (2,3-BPG)
3PGha
Fragmentation Transition:
199.98→79
Thompson RA, et al. Chem Res Toxicol. 2016 Apr 18; 29(4): 505-533.
Risk Assessment Approaches
• Existing Risk Assessment Approaches
• Formation of Reactive Metabolite
• Reactive metabolite formation combined with dose
• Reactive metabolite formation integrated with measures of cellular response
Thompson RA, et al. Chem Res Toxicol. 2016 Apr 18; 29(4): 505-533.
Risk Assessment: Multifactorial
Multifactorial Approach 36 drugs: 27 severe or marked
idiosyncratic ADR concern and 9
Integrated In Vitro with low concern
Hazard Matrix
No Hazard
Thompson RA, et al. Chem Res Toxicol. 2012 Aug 20: 25(8): 1616-1632.
How do we develop safe drugs?
• Integration of risk assessment strategy early in drug development phase
• Minimize risk of attrition during preclinical phase, clinical trials and post-market
• Early risk assessment during drug development phase
Toxicity Pathway
Macro-
Chemical Cellular Tissue Organ Individual
molecular
Insult Response Response Response Response
Interaction
Formation of
Reactive
Metabolites
Microphysiological Models:
Spheroids, Bioreactors, Media Flow
Thompson RA, et al. Chem Res Toxicol. 2016 Apr 18; 29(4): 505-533.
Risk Assessment Approaches
• New Risk Assessment Approach: Microphysiological Models
• Risk of sensitization and severity of clinical symptom
• State of immune system of patient
• Dose
• Frequency, route and duration of exposure
• Sex
• Immunogenetic predisposition
• 3D Spheroid Hepatic Cultures
• Enhanced liver phenotype
• Metabolic activity
• Stability in culture not attainable with conventional two-dimensional hepatic models
• Coculture
• Bioreactors
• Media Flow
• Removal of metabolites and bile
• Concentration gradients
Thompson RA, et al. Chem Res Toxicol. 2016 Apr 18; 29(4): 505-533.
Inflammatory Stress Hypothesis
What if we can use an in vitro model
to determine inflammation-mediated
drug toxicity?
B B Trovafloxacin B B B B
B B A A A A A A
A A DNA-DNA gyrase Complex Trovafloxacin stabilizes DNA-DNA Broken DNA strands are released,
forms (DNA strands broken but gyrase Complex (Broken DNA this results in cell death
Bacterial DNA strands cannot be released and
held together via DNA gyrase)
Gyrase DNA replication is blocked)
http://www.antibiotics-info.org/levofloxacin.html
Coculture: Trovafloxacin
• Human Liver Microtissue Model
• 3D liver microtissue
• 96-well format: HTP screening
• Primary human hepatocytes in combination with non-parenchymal cells (Kupffer and endothelial cells)
Thompson RA, et al. Chem Res Toxicol. 2016 Apr 18; 29(4): 505-533.
How do we develop safe drugs?
• Integration of risk assessment strategy early in drug development phase
• Minimize risk of attrition during preclinical phase, clinical trials and post-market
• Early risk assessment during drug development phase
Total R&D cost: $2.6 billion on average (in 2013 USD) http://phrma-docs.phrma.org/sites/default/files/pdf/rd_brochure_022307.pdf
Thank you!