Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1
Building department, Faculty of Environmental Design and Management,
Obafemi Awolowo University,Ile-Ife, Nigeria
2
Building Department, Faculty of Environmental Studies, University of Uyo, Uyo, Nigeria
Abstract: The study investigated the effect of periwinkle shell ash (PSA) as cement substitute on the strengths
of concrete. Specimens were prepared from a mix of designed strength 25N/mm2 and the replacement of cement
with PSA was from 0% up to 40%. A total of 180 specimens were cast and tested for compressive and tensile
splitting strength at 7 and up to 180 days. The results revealed that compressive strength increased with the
increase in curing age but decreased as the PSA contents increased. The design strength was attained with 10%
PSA content at 28 days. The tensile splitting strength with 10% PSA was higher than the control (i.e. mix
only having cement as the binder) at ages above 14 days. The relationship between tensile splitting strength
and compressive strength of PSA blended cement concrete is similar to that of the conventional concrete. The
study concluded that 10% PSA content is adequate as cement substitution for structural concrete.
Keywords: Compressive strength; conventional concrete; periwinkle shell ash; tensile splitting strength
DOI: 10.7492/IJAEC.2012.023
213
Olusola and Umoh/International Journal of Architecture, Engineering and Construction 1 (2012) 213-220
much more beneficial to compressive strength develop- Ibom State in the South-south region of Nigeria. The
ment of concrete at later ages. Therefore this study shells were calcined in a furnace and stopped as soon as
investigates the effect of PSA on both compressive and the temperature reaches 800◦ C. At this temperature,
tensile strength of concrete up to 180 days based on the energy input is far less than what is involved in ce-
the minimum structural design strength of 25N/mm2 . ment production. Then, the ash was ground and sieved
In this study, PSA was added to the concrete in the with 45µm size. The specific gravities for cement and
form of a mineral admixture. The mechanism by which PSA were 3.13 and 2.13 respectively. Chemical and
the pozzolanic reaction exercises a beneficial effect on physical properties of the cementitious materials are
the properties of concrete is the same irrespective of shown in Table 1.
whether it is added to concrete in the form of a min- The fine aggregate used was river-bed sand passing
eral admixture or as component of a blended Portland 4.75mm sieve and falls within zone 2; while the coarse
cement (Mehta 2006; Bhatty and Taylor 2006). aggregate was crushed granite of maximum size 20mm
with specific gravity of 2.65. The sieve analyses con-
ducted on the aggregates are presented in Tables 2
2 EXPERIMENTAL WORK
and 3.
2.1 Materials
2.2 Proportioning and Mixing of Con-
Ordinary Portland Cement (OPC) produced to the stituents
specification of [NIS 444-1:2003] and [BS EN 197-
1:2000] was used for the research. The periwinkle shells The mix proportion involved mix-design strength of
for the production of PSA were collected from one of 25N/mm2 for normal weight concrete (i.e. mix only
the dumpsites in Otto market in Ikot Ekpene, Akwa having cement as the binder). This is taken as the ref-
Chemical composition
Elemental oxide Si O2 Al2 O3 Fe2 O3 CaO MgO SO3 K2 O Na2 O Mn2 O3 P2 O5 TiO2 LOI
(%) 33.84 10.2 6.02 40.84 0.48 0.26 0.14 0.24 0 0.01 0.03 7.6
Physical properties
Percentage Activity index with Portland cement Water Sound- Moisture Specific
retained on (% of control) requirement ness content gravity
45µm sieve 7 days 28 days (% of control) (mm) (%)
21 78.17 79.12 104 1 1.5 2.13
214
Olusola and Umoh/International Journal of Architecture, Engineering and Construction 1 (2012) 213-220
Table 5. Slump and compacting factor values for PSA blended cement concrete
PSA content Slump Compacting Actual water/ Amount of water
(%) (mm) factor cementitious materials ratio (% of Control)
0 (control) 29 0.86 0.58 100
10 28 0.87 0.59 101.72
20 28 0.85 0.6 103.45
30 26 0.84 0.62 106.29
40 25 0.83 0.64 110.34
erence control mix for the purpose of comparing the respectively and the mean values computed. A total of
improvement in strength performance with curing age 90 cubes and 90 cylinders were used to determine the
of specimens prepared from it with those of other spec- effect of PSA on the compressive strength and tensile
imens cast from binary mixes consisting of OPC and splitting strength respectively for the various curing
PSA as binders. A water/cement ratio requirement of ages.
the mix design for the requisite workability (slump: 10-
30mm) was adhered. Partial replacement of OPC by
PSA of various percentages of 0, 10, 20, 30 and 40 by 3 RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS
volume dictated by their differences in specific gravities
3.1 Effect of PSA on Workability of Fresh
was adopted. The ingredients, i.e., cement, PSA, ag-
Concrete
gregates and water, were manually mixed. The cement
and PSA blended was spread on already measured The results of the slump and compacting factor values
sand, and the three ingredients mixed thoroughly be- are shown in Table 5. To attain the same workability
fore the coarse aggregate and water were added. Slump level of 10-30mm in the mixes containing PSA with
and compacting factor tests were carried out to deter- that of conventional concrete (0% PSA), higher water
mine the workability of each mix. Detail of the mix content was required. This is reflected in the gradual
proportions of the concrete mixes are presented in Ta- increase in the ratio of water and cementitious mate-
ble 4. rials with a corresponding increase in the amount of
water over control as the PSA percentage content in-
2.3 Specimens Preparation creases. This higher water requirement in mixes con-
taining PSA could be attributed to the high fineness
Two types of specimens were prepared: 150mm cubes of PSA which meant a greater specific surface to be
and 150mm by 300mm cylinders. The specimens were wetted and lubricated. This is in agreement with the
cast in steel moulds as specified by BS EN 12390- earlier finding of the effect of rice husk ash in concrete
2:2009. As soon as the specimens were cast, they were by Zhang and Malhotra (1996). The values of the
stored in a place free from vibration and not exposed slump and Compacting Factor range between 25mm
to direct sunlight or other sources of heat and covered and 29mm and 0.83 and 0.87 respectively, which is
with wet wooden bags. The specimens were demoulded within the stipulated range of slump (10-30mm) and
within 24 hours, and cured in water kept at tempera- compacting factor (0.85 to 0.90) for low workability
ture of 29±1◦ C until the day of testing. concrete.
215
Olusola and Umoh/International Journal of Architecture, Engineering and Construction 1 (2012) 213-220
Table 6. Compressive strength of PSA blended cement concrete specimens at all curing ages
PSA having 77.63% and 40% PSA having the least than Koffi (2008). The strength development for con-
value of 65.66%). These values satisfied the require- trol mix (i.e. 0% PSA) is faster up to 28 days hydration
ment of normal concrete strength development which period whereas mixes containing PSA is slower. This
is stipulated to be between 50-66% (British Standard portrays the fact that the pozzolanic reaction depends
Institution 1985; lllston 1994). on the release of calcium hydroxide from cement hy-
At 14 days hydration period, the compressive dration.
strength of the control mix had exceeded the design The results at 90 days indicated that in all the mixes
strength with a value of 27.11N/mm2 , i.e., 108.44% there is continuous increase in the strength, show-
of the design strength. This is closely followed by ing that there is both hydration and pozzolanic reac-
10% PSA which had 85.33% of the design strength, tions particularly with 10% PSA having a higher rate
while 10%, 20% and 30% PSA replacement had com- of development than the control. At 120 days, 10%
pressive strength of 18.04N/mm2 , 17.01N/mm2 and PSA recorded compressive strength of 28.53N/mm2
16.30N/mm2 , i.e., 72.18%, 68.04% and 65.19% of the representing an increase of 6.89% of the strength at
design strength respectively. The strength develop- 90 days, while the control mix recorded strength of
ment at 14 days satisfied the 60-75% of the design 29.92N/mm2 which represents an increase of 3.26% of
strength stipulated by lllston (1994). the strength of 90 days. Other mixes had little or no
The compressive strength of 0% PSA and 10% PSA increase in the design strength beyond 90 days. The
at 28 days hydration period were 28N/mm2 and 20% PSA had strength of 24.89N/mm2 representing
25.56N/mm2 respectively which met the desired de- 99.56% (approximately 100%) of the design strength.
sign strength of 25N/mm2 , while that of 20%, 30% and It means that where later age strength is required at
40% PSA content were 24.15N/mm2 , 20.71N/mm2 120 days hydration period, 20% replacement of cement
and 15.91N/mm2 respectively. These values are com- with PSA is adequate.
parable with Dahunsi and Bamisaye (2002) but lower A further increase in the rate of strength develop-
216
Olusola and Umoh/International Journal of Architecture, Engineering and Construction 1 (2012) 213-220
ment was observed with 10% PSA at 180 days when it concrete at 95% confidence level (Table 7). This indi-
attained strength of 29.04N/mm2 which is not signifi- cates that whenever any of the factors varies, the com-
cantly different from the control which had the strength pressive strength of the concrete changes and the de-
of 30.15N/mm2 . The continuous increase in the 10% gree of the variation is proportional to the magnitude
PSA can be attributed to the fact that the quantity of of the change. The coefficient of determination (ad-
calcium hydroxide liberated from cement hydration is justed R-Square value) is 0.995 (99.5%). This implies
adequate to be consumed by the pozzolanic reaction. a strong statistical association among the two inde-
The statistical analysis using analysis of variance pendent variables and the compressive strength. The
(ANOVA) of the compressive strength results showed independent variables were estimated to account for
that the independent factor (i.e., PSA content and cur- 99.5% of the variance in the compressive strength of
ing age), when considered individually and jointly had the concrete. The correlation coefficient (square root
significant effects on the compressive strength of the of adjusted R-Square) was obtained as R = 0.997. This
Table 8. Tensile splitting strength of PSA blended cement concrete cylindrical specimens
Curing age PSA Compressive strength (N/mm2 ) Attainment of
(Days) (%) Sample 1 Sample 2 Sample 3 Mean design strength (%)
0 2.68 2.62 2.69 2.66 92.36
10 2.36 2.36 2.26 2.33 80.21
7 20 2.26 2.26 2.26 2.26 78.47
30 1.84 1.84 1.77 1.82 63.32
40 1.56 1.41 1.49 1.49 51.74
14 0 2.55 2.62 2.69 2.62 90.97
10 2.69 2.62 2.62 2.64 91.67
14 20 2.33 2.33 2.26 2.31 80.21
30 1.87 1.84 1.91 1.87 64.93
40 1.53 1.49 1.56 1.52 52.78
0 2.83 2.83 2.97 2.88 100
10 2.86 2.86 2.94 2.89 100.35
28 20 2.41 2.33 2.48 2.41 83.68
30 2.16 2.12 2.19 2.16 75
40 2.09 2.05 2.05 2.06 71.88
0 3.11 3.25 2.97 3.11 107.99
10 3.31 3.32 3.25 3.3 114.58
90 20 2.55 2.48 2.48 2.5 86.81
30 2.35 2.33 2.32 2.33 80.9
40 2.09 2.12 2.12 2.11 73.26
0 3.54 3.61 3.47 3.54 122.92
10 3.68 3.68 3.61 3.66 126.74
120 20 2.97 2.97 2.76 2.9 100.69
30 2.55 2.69 2.55 2.59 89.93
40 2.48 2.55 2.41 2.48 81.11
0 3.82 3.89 3.82 3.84 133.33
10 3.96 3.96 3.89 3.94 136.81
180 20 3.37 3.32 3.4 3.36 116.67
30 2.9 2.86 2.9 2.89 100.35
40 2.8 2.76 2.76 2.77 96.18
217
Olusola and Umoh/International Journal of Architecture, Engineering and Construction 1 (2012) 213-220
further confirms the very strong statistical relationship concrete. The coefficient of correlation was obtained as
noted above. R = 0.996. This shows a very strong linear relationship
exist between the two sets of variable.
3.3 Tensile Splitting Strength
3.4 Relationship Between Tensile Splitting
The results of the tensile splitting strength of the and Compressive Strengths
concrete cylinders are presented in Table 8. It was
noted that the tensile splitting strength increases with The ratios of tensile splitting strength to compressive
the increase in the amount of PSA incorporation in strength of PSA blended cement concrete lies between
the concrete up to 10% PSA content, and beyond 0.10 and 0.14 (10-14%) for the percentage replacement
10% PSA content the strength decreases with in- of OPC with 0-40% PSA content. These values fall
crease in percentage PSA. The values of tensile split- within the general range of 0.08 to 0.14 (Mindess et al.
ting strength for 10% PSA content exceed that of 2003; Neville 2000) for normal-weight concrete. It is
the control. These values for 7, 14, 28, 90, 120 and also in agreement with the values obtained by Ade-
180 days were 2.31N/mm2 , 2.64N/mm2 , 2.89N/mm2 , sanya and Raheem (2009a) on the use of corn cob ash
3.30N/mm2 , 3.65N/mm2 and 30.15N/mm2 , (i.e., as partial replacement of cement.
80.21%, 91.67%, 100.35%, 114.53%, 126.74% and The data generated from the plot of relationship be-
136.81% of the tensile splitting strength of the control tween tensile Splitting Strength and cube compressive
at 28 days respectively) whereas that of 0% PSA were strength of PSA blended cement concrete based on the
2.66N/mm2 , 2.62N/mm2 , 2.88N/mm2 , 3.11N/mm2 , generalised relationship expressed by the equation:
3.54N/mm2 and 3.84N/mm2 , (i.e., 92.36%, 90.97%, ft = K · (fc )n (1)
100%, 107.99%, 122.92% and 133.33% for 7, 14, 28, 90,
where ft = tensile strength, fc = compressive strength,
120 and 180 days respectively). It can be concluded
and K and n are coefficients of correlation presented
that the improvement of tensile splitting strength of
in Table 10. It reveals that n increases and K de-
concrete with the incorporation of PSA is enhanced
creases as the PSA content increases up to 10% and
with 10% replacement of the cement with the ash.
between 20% and 40%; however, the pattern of varia-
The improvement in tensile splitting strength at early
tion between 10% and 20% does not follow this trend
age and lower PSA (10% content) replacement level
and may need further investigation. Without this ex-
could be attributed to the initial filling of voids by the
ception, it therefore means that the relationship be-
PSA. At higher levels of PSA (i.e. > 10%) substitu-
tween tensile splitting strength and cube compressive
tion, the voids must have been filled while the excess
strength of PSA blended cement concrete is similar to
cause reduction in strength. This finding was reported
that of the conventional concrete; hence the general-
by Bhanja and Senguptab (2002), which stated that
ized equation is applicable to the PSA blended cement
initial filling of voids by silica fume significantly im-
concrete.
proves the tensile strength, but at higher levels, the
improvement decreases. Table 10. Correlation coefficients of tensile splitting
The statistical analysis of tensile splitting strength and cube compressive strengths relationship of PSA
results presented in Table 9 indicated that the inde- blended cement concrete
pendent factors (i.e. PSA content and curing age),
when considered individually and collectively had sig- PSA content Model parameters R2
nificant effects on the tensile splitting strength of the (%) n K
concrete. The coefficient of determination (adjusted R- 0 0.646 0.365 0.484
Square value) is 0.992 (99.2%). This implies a strong 10 1.112 0.087 0.907
statistical association among the variables. The inde- 20 0.65 0.367 0.419
pendent variables were estimated to account for 99.2% 30 1.427 0.032 0.745
of the variance in the tensile splitting strength of the 40 1.787 0.012 0.502
218
Olusola and Umoh/International Journal of Architecture, Engineering and Construction 1 (2012) 213-220
219
Olusola and Umoh/International Journal of Architecture, Engineering and Construction 1 (2012) 213-220
New Jersey, United States. ploitation levels.” Proceedings of the 4th Annual Con-
Mmom, P. C. and Arokoya, S. B. (2010). “Mangrove ference of the Fisheries Society of Nigeria (FISON),
forest depletion, biodiversity loss and traditional re- Port-Harcourt, Nigeria.
sources management practices in the Niger Delta, Sumaila, S. A. and Job, O. F. (1999). “Properties
Nigeria.” Research Journal of Applied Sciences, En- of SDA-OPC concrete: A preliminary assessment.”
gineering and Technology, 2(1), 28–34. Journal of Environmental Sciences, 3(1-2), 155–159.
Neville, A. M. (2000). Properties of Concrete. Pitman, Tangchirapat, W., Jaturapitakkul, C., and Chin-
New York, United States. daprasirt, P. (2009). “Use of palm oil fuel ash as a
Okon, B. I. (1987). Utilization of Periwinkle Flesh by supplementary cementitious material for producing
Broilers feed Palm Kernel Based Ratios. Ph.D thesis, high-strength concrete.” Construction and Building
University of Ibadan, Nigeria University of Ibadan, Materials, 23(7), 2641–2646.
Nigeria. Udoeyo, F. F. and Dashibil, P. U. (2002). “Sawdust ash
Olorunoje, G. S. and Olalusi, O. C. (2003). “Periwinkle as concrete material.” Journal of Materials in Civil
shell as alternative to coarse aggregate in lightweight Engineering, 14(2), 173–176.
concrete.” International Journal of Environmental Zhang, M. H. and Malhotra, M. H. (1996). “High per-
Issues, 1(1), 231–236. formance concrete incorporating rice husk ash as a
Powell, C. B., Hart, A. I., and Deekae, S. (1985). “Mar- supplementary cementing material.” ACI Materials
ket survey of the periwinkle tympanotonus fascatus Journal, 93(6), 629–636.
in rivers state: Sizes, prices, trade routes and ex-
220