How Wall Friction Affects Hopper Angles

8/26/2021 How Wall Friction Affects Hopper Angles
Industry Master Directory

Events
About
Subscribe
Advertise
Equipment Industries Business Safety & Compliance Features Direc
Home  Equipment  Material Handling & Transportation  How Wall Friction Affects Hopper Angles
How Wall Friction Affects Hopper Angles

     
https://www.powderbulksolids.com/material-handling-transportation/how-wall-friction-affects-hopper-angles 1/10

Events
About
Subscribe
Advertise

Events
About
Subscribe
Advertise
Aug 03, 2015
Measuring a bulk solid's wall friction is critical to ensuring reliable flow. The wall friction angle for a
given bulk material/wall surface combination is calculated from the results of a wall friction test. From
this angle, the hopper angle required to ensure mass flow is determined. Hopper shapes such as cones
and wedges, are determined. By the way, the tangent of the wall friction angle is the coefficient of
friction between the solid and the wall surface.

In order to measure wall friction properties, a Jenike Shear Tester -- the standard through ASTM in the
U.S. -- is used. Consider, that friction develops between a solid and the walls of a bin or hopper as it
interacts with the surface. This friction determines whether the solid will slide on the wall (mass flow) or
adhere to the wall and preferentially slide on itself (funnel flow).

Events
About
Subscribe
Advertise
Photo 1 shows that the bottom "cell" of the shear cell (normally used for cohesive properties testing),
arrangement has been replaced with a sample of wall material. The weight hanger applies the load
simulating pressures acting in a bin and shear force is recorded as a function of this pressure. The
Equipment
information gathered during this test,Industries Business
results in a wall Safety
friction angle that&isCompliance Features to aDirec
subsequently converted
hopper slope for mass flow.

A major consideration is that there is no "magic" angle for mass flow. The following is a common
statement: "all I have to do to develop mass flow is to design my hopper with an angle of 70°". What is
wrong with this statement? Mass flow is dependent on wall friction properties and is affected by the
smoothness and steepness of the hopper wall and the properties of the bulk material. If you design your
hopper for 70°, it may achieve mass flow; but, it may flow in mass flow at a shallower angle say, 65° or
may also require 85°. Wall friction testing is the only reliable way to determine the correct hopper angle
for mass flow.

Dr. Andrew W. Jenike in his Bulletin No. 123, provides design charts that are used to convert wall friction
angles to hopper angles for both conical and wedge shaped geometries. These charts are plots of wall
friction angles vs. hopper angles. They are categorized by values of "effective angle of friction", (delta,
δ), which are listed in 10° increments ranging from 30° to 70°. δ is a function of your material’s
flowability and is easily obtained from flow properties tests. For each value of δ, there are combinations
of wall friction angle, phi-prime, Φ' and hopper angle, theta, θc and θp (for conical hoppers and planar
hoppers, wedge type, respectively).


Events
About
Subscribe
Advertise
These charts may be used in several ways. However, the common approach is as follows:
Photo 2, shows a typical conical hopper chart. Hopper angle and wall friction angle values are plotted
on the X and Y axes, respectively. Notice that there is an uncertain region that lies between funnel flow
and mass f low. The flow pattern within this region should theoretically be mass flow; however, slight
differences in material properties or hopper angle due to fabrication, can result in funnel flow. A switch
back and forth between mass flow and funnel flow can cause severe bin vibrations and other problems.
This region represents a margin of safety to minimize the above effects.

Always remember, Jenike's charts give the hopper angles in degrees from vertical.

These charts can be used to determine if an existing hopper that is 20° from vertical and fabricated from
carbon steel with a 15° Φ' will ensure mass flow. Using both values shows that the hopper will flow in
mass flow; however, we all know what happens with carbon steel--it rusts! A rusted carbon steel surface
may have a Φ' value of 30° now and that would force the hopper to flow in funnel flow.
A second, and more common way to use the charts is to use the Φ' value of 15° (from horizontal), you
can determine the minimum hopper angle required to ensure flow along the walls (see Photo 3). The
resulting hopper angle required for mass flow is determined by reading over to the outer edge of the
uncertain region and then reading down to (in this case) about a 32° from vertical. In actuality, Jenike’s
charts indicate the outer boundary line of the uncertain region and the user has to back off 4° on the
hopper angle, as a safety factor. This makes the recommended hopper angle, θc (degrees from vertical),
28°.
Events
About
Subscribe
Advertise
Different design charts are used for wedge hoppers (refer to Photo 4). Notice that there is no uncertain
region in this chart as on the conical hopper design chart, because there is no definite boundary line
between mass flow and funnel flow in wedge-shaped hoppers. Thus, wedge shaped hoppers are more
forgiving than a conical hoppers and can handle materials with a wide range of flowability. You read the
chart the same as a conical hopper chart except that you do not have to allow for a safety factor.
Using the correct hopper angle for mass flow is critical to your design. If you decide to use a different
solid in your bin, (even if it is the same material, but from a different vendor), you would be wise to
check wall friction values to ensure the proper hopper angle.
Joseph Marinelli is a consulting engineer and president of Solids Handling Technologies, Fort Mill, SC.
He has been providing testing and consulting services since 1972. As a former consultant with Jenike &
Johanson Inc., he has years of experience testing powders and designing bins and feeders for reliable
flow. He lectures frequently on the topic of powder handling, and has published several papers,
including an article in a chemical encyclopedia and two in a food powder book. For more information,
call 803-802-5527 or email joe@solidshandlingtech.com.

Events
About
Subscribe
Advertise
TAGS: STORAGE OPTIMIZATION
RELATED
Process Expo OSHA Signs Alliance with Ohio

Agribusiness Association to
JUL 15, 2021
The Marvelous Multi-Tasking New Bulk Material Handling

Feeding Device System Increases Manufacturer’s
JUN 29, 2021 JUN 24, 2021
Scenes from the 2021 Powder Show

     
Image courtesy of Sara Mineo/Informa Markets

Events
About
Subscribe
Advertise
 START SLIDESHOW ›
Take a look at this year's International Powder & Bulk Solids Conference& Exhibition at
the Donald E. Stephens Center in Rosemont, IL.
John S. Forrester | Aug 25, 2021
The International Powder & Bulk Solids Conference & Exhibition is underway at the Donald E. Stephens
Center in Rosemont, IL. Known as “The Powder Show,” this is the only event in the western hemisphere
bringing together the powder & bulk solids handling and dry processing sector – the community of OEMs,
process engineers, and executives whose activity accounts for 70% of the manufacturing lifecycle of every
product on earth.
For over forty years, the Powder Show has been the one-stop-shop for equipment, expertise, and
education for the powder and bulk processing community. This year the event runs from August 24 – 26.
Here is a look at some of the action happening on the show floor, in conference rooms, and during
networking sessions at North America's #1 processing event.
 START SLIDESHOW ›

Events
About
Subscribe
Advertise
TAGS: BUSINESS FOOD & BEVERAGE CHEMICAL PHARMACEUTICAL & MEDICAL PRODUCTS CAREER
DEVELOPMENT
RELATED
Process Expo #PowderJams: “Keep Your Powder

Dry” by The Rasters
AUG 20, 2021
Stir Foods Plans $4M Manufacturing Columbia Machine Adds Capability

Plant Expansion for Building Robotic and
AUG 20, 2021 AUG 18, 2021
Sign up for the Powder & Bulk Solids Weekly newsletter.
Email address Select Country GO
Logo
About PlasticsToday
Advertise Packaging Digest
Subscribe International Powder & Bulk Solids Conference & Exhibition
Sitemap Powder & Bulk Solids Montréal

Battery Technology Industry Master Directory Powder

Events
&About
Bulk Solids

Toronto
Subscribe
Advertise
Design News Content Licensing and Reprints
MD+DI
Follow us:
   
Copyright © 2021. All rights reserved. Informa Markets, a

trading division of Informa PLC.
Accessibility
Privacy Policy
Cookie Policy
Terms of Use
Visitor Terms and Conditions

How Wall Friction Affects Hopper Angles

Uploaded by

Document Information

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

How Wall Friction Affects Hopper Angles

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

8/26/2021 How Wall Friction Affects Hopper Angles

Industry Master Directory

Equipment Industries Business Safety & Compliance Features Direc