Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Medical Center, Royal Medical Services, Amman-Jordan quantify the relationship between these dimensions by
4
Division of Dentistry, Prince Zaid bin Al-Hussein Hospital, Roy- geometric proportions several theories have suggested
al Medical Services, Tafela-Jordan
5
Division of Dentistry, Prince Hashim bin Al-Hussein Hospital, to relate teeth dimensions to each other, such as golden
Royal Medical Services, Aqaba-Jordan proportion, recurring esthetic dental proportion (RED),
Correspondence Address: Dr Ahmad M Alhabahbah, PO Box and golden percentage.4
541037 (Postal code: 11937) Abu Nsair Amman - Jordan
Tel: 00962777540548 The size and form of the maxillary anterior teeth
Email: ahmad1975@gmail.com
Received for Publication: June 3, 2016
are important factors in dental and facial esthetics.
Approved: June 19, 2016 The goal of dental techniques is to have the maxillary
Pakistan Oral & Dental Journal Vol 36, No. 2 (April-June 2016) 295
Validity of mathematical proportions in maxillary anterior teeth
anterior teeth restore optimal dentolabial relations in Dentistry and The Human Research Ethics Commit-
harmony with the overall facial appearance. Several tee (No:4 dated 7th March 2016) at the Royal Medical
studies have reported race and gender as effective services.
factors in the average dimensions of maxillary anterior
teeth.5 When evaluating the natural beauty of normal Inclusion/exclusion criteria
arches, we observe the presence of a mathematical Subjects with age ranged between 18 and 30 years
relation: 1:1.618. This ratio is termed the divine or who accepted to participate were fully dentate with
golden proportion; it is believed that this harmon- complete set (with no missing of anterior) teeth, with
ic composition generates beauty and well-being to no dental anomaly and with no history of congenital
the human perception, providing equilibrium and abnormality, no periodental diseases and with no spac-
symmetry.6 ing, crowding, extruded, intruded, or rotated anterior
When the Golden proportion formula is used, the teeth, those who were not exposed to any orthodontic
lateral incisor appears too narrow and the resulting treatment or orthognathic surgical procedure, and
canine is not prevalent enough. Therefore, Ward in- with no extensive restorative procedure (i.e. crown
troduced the RED Proportion concept, stating that and bridge work); and accepted to undergo clinical oral
clinicians may use a proportion of their own choice, and dental examination, were able to understand and
as long as it remains consistent, proceeding distally agreed with procedures carried out and used (such as
in the arch. The successive width proportion, when taking alginate maxillary impressions) in the study
viewed from the facial aspect, should remain constant and who were willing to accept the protocol and gave
as we move posteriorly from the midline. This offers informed consent were included. Exclusion criteria were
great flexibility to match tooth properties with facial subjects with history of orthognathic surgery, missing
proportions. Generally, the values of the RED proportion teeth, crown and bridge work, removable partial den-
used are between 60% and 80%.7 ture prostheses, as well as those who did not agree to
participate.
Snow considered a bilateral analysis of apparent
individual tooth width as a percentage of the total ap- Participants
parent width of the six anterior teeth. He proposed the A total of 150 (72 females and 78 males) fully dentate
golden percentage wherein the proportional width of Jordanian subjects with mean age of 24.8±4.2 (ranged
each tooth should be: canine 10%, lateral 15%, central between 18 and 30) years; were subjected to clinical
25%, central 25%, lateral 15%, and canine 10% of the examination, a specially designed form concerning
total distance across the anterior segment in order to the patient’s demographic data including age, gender,
achieve an esthetically pleasing smile.8 medical insurance number, occupation and residence
Finding the most accurate proportion between was filled by one of the authors.
maxillary anterior teeth widths will facilitate distrib-
Impressions, cast formation and Measurements
uting the space when restoring the anterior segment
or during orthodontic treatment. The null hypothesis For each participant a maxillary arch impression
of the study was that the golden proportion, RED and was taken with irreversible hydrocolloid (alginate) im-
golden percentage is not existed in maxillary anterior pression material and poured in type II dental stone to
teeth widths among Jordanians. Therefore this study form a stone cast (positive replica). The measurements
was conducted to investigate the best mathematical were performed by placing the cast on a flat surface
proportion that existed between the maxillary anterior and a grid lines are drawn for the perceived width
teeth widths in a young Jordanian population. of the six anterior teeth (Fig 1) and measured using
Fowler electronic digital caliper, the accuracy of the
METHODOLOGY
measurements was set at ±0.01 mm (Fig 2). Linear
A cross-sectional study of fully dentate Jordanian measurements were taken for central incisor, lateral
males and females in the City of Amman, who attended incisor and canine on both sides and recorded on a spe-
the Conservative Clinics, Department of Dentistry, cially designed sheet. Teeth dimensions were quantified
Al-Hussein Hospital, King Hussein Medical Center, by geometric proportions, related to each other and
Royal Medical Services. Random samples for the study compared with golden proportion, recurring esthetic
were selected from the general population, who fulfilled dental proportion (RED), and golden percentage.
objective diagnostic criteria and underwent clinical oral
and dental examinations. In this study the golden proportion was taken as
62%. Therefore, for estimation of the existence of golden
Ethical approval proportion the measured width of the central incisor
was multiplied by 62% and compared with that of the
The study was conducted for all patients who pro-
adjacent lateral incisor. Similar values indicated that
vided verbal informed consent after it was approved by
the width of the central incisor is in golden proportion
Head of the Dental Specialities of the Department of
Pakistan Oral & Dental Journal Vol 36, No. 2 (April-June 2016) 296
Validity of mathematical proportions in maxillary anterior teeth
to the width of the lateral incisor. Similarly by compar- examination 15 (10%) randomly selected subjects and
ing the width of the lateral incisor after multiplying by re-measuring their casts by each examiner. Student’s t-test
62% with that of the canine, it was determined whether were performed for inter-examiner reliability evaluation.
the width of the lateral incisor is in golden proportion
to the width of the canine. The golden percentage Statistical analysis
was calculated by dividing the width of each central Statistical analysis was performed using SPSS
incisor, lateral incisor and canine by the total width Statistic Version 17 (SPSS Corporation, Chicago, IL,
of all six maxillary anterior teeth and multiplying the USA). Student’s t-test were used to compare the means
resulting value by 100. If the resulting width of the of dimension measured on the casts between genders.
canines, lateral incisors and central incisors showed 2-sample t-test was used to compare differences in
10%, 15%, 25% respectively of the intercanine distance the mean widths between the right and left sides. Chi
they were taken as following golden percentage. For square test was used to test the association between the
RED proportion, ratio of the width of lateral incisor calculated ratios of the measured values in the study
and central incisor was compared to that of canine and with those in geometric proportions. Ninety-five percent
lateral incisor. Constant values indicated existence of confidence intervals about the mean was constructed
RED proportion. The method of estimating geometric for differences. Level of significance was set at 0.05.
proportion was essentially the same as that reported
by Azam et al.9 RESULTS
TABLE 3: THE GOLDEN PERCENTAGE IN RIGHT AND LEFT MAXILLARY ANTERIOR TEETH FOR
MALE AND FEMALE SUBJECTS
Pakistan Oral & Dental Journal Vol 36, No. 2 (April-June 2016) 298
Validity of mathematical proportions in maxillary anterior teeth
to males (48.5% vs 39.0%; respectively). However, existing relationship theories.10 In this study, more
there were no significant gender differences in lateral 52% of the participants were men, although there was
incisor/canine teeth ratios. In addition, right-left side no statistically significant difference in the mean age
differences for teeth in golden proportion were found between genders, women were slightly younger than
insignificant. The results showed that 18.6% of males men. In addition, the age distribution was limited with
and 23.4% of females have the widths of their right 18-30 in order to eliminate the variations in proportions
central incisors in golden proportion to the width of their related to age. In the present study, gender-related
right lateral incisors. However, 9.7% of male subjects differences were recorded in all width measurements.
and 10.5% of female subjects have the widths of their When comparing width dimensions with regard to gen-
right lateral incisors in golden proportion to the widths
der, it was found that they are remarkably higher in
of their right canines. Moreover, the data shows 20.4%
males than females. These findings are in accordance
of the male subjects and 25.1% of the female subjects
have the widths of their left central incisors in golden with a previous study.3,11 As it can be derived from
proportion to the widths of the left lateral incisors, these results, no statistically significant variances
while 11.5% of males and 12.4% of females have the were found between right and left sides in widths of
widths of the left lateral incisors in golden proportion maxillary anterior teeth.5,12
to the widths of their left canines (Table 2). Information concerning the existence of a mathe-
The golden percentage for male and female sub- matical or geometrical relationship is crucial so as to
jects are shown in Table 3. The results revealed no achieve the best esthetic restorative outcome. In this
statistical gender differences in the golden percentage study, poor correlations between the dimensions of the
(p>0.05). However, for calculated percentages, it was teeth and the various esthetic proportions suggested
shown that females recorded more values compared to in the literature were found.
males. In addition, although the right side values were
higher than that of left sides, but the differences were The results of the present study revealed the mean
statistically insignificant (p>0.05). value for golden proportion was approximately 22%
between the central incisor and the lateral incisor and
Table 4 compares the ratios of lateral incisor to only 11% between lateral incisor and canine widths.
central incisor and canine to lateral incisor measured These values are higher than those reported by Azam
for both right and left sides for comparison with RED et al, who found that golden proportion existed in the
proportion. Analyses of data using paired t test revealed
relationship between the maxillary central and lateral
that P value was found to be statistically insignificant
incisors in only 10% and 2% of the perceived canine
(P>0.05). So this suggests that RED proportion is not
constant in natural maxillary anterior teeth. In addi- to lateral incisor ratio on the right side and 6% on the
tion, the ratio of width of canine to lateral incisors as left side.9 The difference in results may be attributed
viewed from front is always less than that of lateral to several factors, the least of which are differences in
incisor to central incisor. Comparing the ratio of the research methodology as well as the differences in the
width of lateral incisor to central incisor with the ratio ethnicities of the subjects. However comparable findings
of the width of canine to lateral incisor in each subject have been reported previosly.10,13 The occurrence of
revealed that the recurring proportion existed in 16.7% golden proportion on the right and left side was found
of women, 14.1% of men, and 15.3% of all subjects. The in different subjects therefore it did not exist in the
Chi-squared homogeneity test revealed that there is maxillary anterior teeth.2,12,14-16
no significant difference between men and women (P >
0.05). (Table 5). The results in this study contradicts the golden
percentage theory as the values of 22.1%, 14.7% and
DISCUSSION 9.8% were recorded for centrals, lateral and canines,
respectively. The value for lateral incisors corresponds
This study was conducted to relate the best mathe- to that as proposed by Snow8 but the percentage ob-
matical proportion that existed between the maxillary tained for central incisors is slightly lower and for the
anterior teeth widths, the sample was representative canines is slightly higher than the one suggested by
of a group of Jordanian population of dental patients Snow.17 However, the results for golden percentage in
that attended conservative dental clinics. The size and this study correspond to the values reported by another
shape of the maxillary anterior teeth especially when study.10
perceived from front have considerable implications
for esthetic diagnosis and treatment planning. These Of all the esthetic proportions that have been sug-
have an effect on the space availability, stability of gested to relate the width of maxillary anterior teeth,
dentition, esthetics and health of the periodontium.2 golden percentage theory has been recommended if the
percentages are adjusted taking into consideration the
It is important to determine a mathematical or geo- ethnicity of the population. Therefore, the current values
metrical relationship between teeth in order to achieve which were calculated for the golden percentage might
an esthetic restorative result. It would be helpful if serve as a guideline to create harmonious proportions
statistically reliable relationships existed to support in maxillary anterior teeth for Jordanian population.18
Pakistan Oral & Dental Journal Vol 36, No. 2 (April-June 2016) 299
Validity of mathematical proportions in maxillary anterior teeth
In this study, in order to evaluate the existence of 3 Significantly male subjects had wider anterior teeth
the RED proportion, the ratio of the width of maxillary than females (p<0.05). However, right-left side
lateral incisor to central incisor was compared with the differences in the mean values of widths recorded
ratio of the width of maxillary canine to lateral incisor were not significant.
in each subject. The RED proportion was observed in
15.3% of subjects. The overall result revealed that REFERENCES
10%-20% of the population of the study has the RED 1 Chu SJ, Tamow DP, Tan JH-P, Stappert CFJ. Pappila propor-
proportion. Although more females reported RED tion in the maxillary anterior teeth. Int J Periodont Rest Dent.
proportion compared with males but the differences 2009; 29: 385-93.
2 Sah SJ, Zhang HD, Chang T, Dhungana M, Acharya L, Chen LL,
were insignificant. It has been concluded that the Ding YM. Maxillary anterior teeth dimensions and proportions
RED proportion is an unsuitable method for creating in a central mainland Chinese population. Chinese J Dent Res.
harmony in the width of the maxillary anterior teeth.4 2014; 17: 117-24.
Although, the results of this study are in agreement 3 Khan SH, Hassan GS, Rafique T, Hasan MN, Russell MSH.
Mesiodistal crown dimensions of permanent teeth in Bangladeshi
with a previous study13, it seems unsuitable to calculate population. Bangabandhu Sheikh Mujib Medical University
the proportional means and compare them together, Journal 2011; 4: 81-87.
because the recurring proportion should be evaluat- 4 Azimi M, Dinparvar M, Teimourian H, Farhadian M. Evalu-
ed for each person, one by one. So, by modifying the ating recurring esthetic dental proportion (RED) and golden
proportion in natural dentition. Avicenna J Dent Res. 2016;
evaluation method, considering the limitations of this (InPress): e30267. doi: 10.17795/ajdr-30267: 1-5.
study, it can be concluded that there is no evidence to 5 Al-Jabrah O, Al-Shammout R, El-Naji W, Al-Ajarmeh M,
support the application of RED proportion to natural Al-Quran A. Gender differences in the amount of gingival
teeth. This is also supported by several studies.2,18-20 display during smiling using two intraoral dental biometric
measurements. J Prosthodont. 2010; 19: 286-93.
Since esthetics is subjective and depends on the 6 Gallao S, Lucia C, Ortolani F, Santos AD, Faltin K. Photographic
analysis of symmetry and aesthetic proportion of anterior teeth.
patient’s and clinician’s perceptions, it is therefore Rev Inst Cienc Saude. 2009; 27: 400-404.
difficult to obtain specific guidelines that will lead to 7 Ward DH. Proportional smile design using the recurring esthetic
consistent results.21 Therefore, it is suggested that nei- dental (red) proportion. Dent Clin North Am. 2001; 45: 143-54.
ther of the proportions can be taken as a sole criterion 8 Snow SR. Esthetic smile analysis of anterior tooth width: the
golden percentage. J Esthet Dent. 1999; 11: 177-84.
to determine the width of maxillary anterior teeth and 9 Azam S, Shahnawaz A, Qureshi B. Validity of esthetic propor-
modifications should be done according to age, sex, tions in maxillary anterior teeth. POJ. 2014: 6: 7-11.
ethnicity, personality and profession of the individual.9 10 Fayyad MA, Jamani KD, Aqrabawi J. Geometric and math-
ematical proportions and their relation to maxillary anterior
Although many researches studied the differences teeth. J Contemp Dent Pract 2006; 7: 1-9.
11 Rose AK. Esthetic impact of width/length ratios of the maxillary
in the maxillary anterior proportions in various types central incisor in patients with different racial types. MSc thesis.
of geometric patterns, but it was difficult to compare 12 Shahid F, Alam MK, Khamis MF. Maxillary and mandibular
their results with ours due to variations in the variables anterior crown width/height ratio and its relation to various
incorporated and racial differences. One of the limita- arch perimeters, arch length, and arch width groups. Eur J
Dent. 2015; 9: 490-99.
tion of this study was small sample size and limited 13 Al-Marzok MI, Majeed KRA, Ibrahim IK. Evaluation of maxil-
participation rate, thus it does not represent Jordanian lary anterior teeth and their relation to the golden proportion
population as a whole. In addition, the method used in Malaysian population. BMC Oral Health 2013; 13: 9.
gives information about tooth width ratios mathmati- 14 Pini NP, Marchi LM, Gribel BF, Ubaldini ALM, Pascotto RC.
Analysis of the golden proportion and width/height ratios of
cally ignored the percieved personal judgment. maxillary anterior dentition in patients with lateral incisor
agenesis. J Esthet Rest Dent. 2012; 24: 402-14.
Therefore, further research is still needed to 15 Pesson MD, Bakou DO, Didia EE, Konate YN, Djeredou BK,
overcome the limitations of this study which includes Goga VK. Determination of the golden proportion and its im-
studying a larger sample and including other methods plications in the esthetic setting of prosthetic teeth in African
of anterior teeth esthetic determination, different age melanoderm subjects. Int Dent Med J Adv Res. 2015; 1: 1-6.
16 Sandeep N, Satwalekar P, Srinivas S, Reddy CS, Reddy GR,
groups and incorporation of mandibular arch form Reddy BA. An analysis of maxillary anterior teeth dimensions
may be needed before the results of this study can be for the existence of golden proportion: Clinical study. J Int Oral
applied on the general population. Health. 2015; 7: 18-21.
17 Rita ME, Kinga J, Carmen B, Diana C, Horga C, Bogozi B, Alina
I. Aesthetic principles of the upper front teeth: Application of
CONCLUSION golden proportion (Levin) and golden percentage (Snow). Acta
Medica Marisiensis. 2013; 59: 25-27.
Within the limitations of this study, the following 18 Murthy BVS, Ramani N. Evaluation of natural smile: golden
conclusions can be withdrawn: ratio, RED or golden percentage. J Conserv Dent. 2008; 1: 16-21.
19 Ahmad N, Abbas M, Maqsood A. Evaluation of recurring es-
1 The golden proportion and RED were not existed thetic dental proportion in natural smile in Pakistani sample.
between the perceived widths of maxillary anterior Pakistan Oral Dent J. 2014; 34: 739-42.
20 Shah DS, Vaishnav K, Duseja S, Sheth RS. Evaluation of recur-
teeth. ring esthetic dental proportion in natural mandibular anterior
dentition. Adv Hum Biol. 2015; 5: 1-4.
2 The golden percentage although can not be applied 21 Chander NG, Kumar VV, Rangarajan V. Golden proportion
on subject of this study, but it seems to be considered assessment between maxillary and mandibular teeth on Indian
for Jordanian population. population. J Adv Prosthodont 2012; 4: 72-75.
Pakistan Oral & Dental Journal Vol 36, No. 2 (April-June 2016) 300