You are on page 1of 7

198 Arch Dis Child 1998;79:198–204

Nitrate and nitrite content of meat 15 year period have revealed no such decline.
products We determined the frequency of new cases of
LETTERS TO EDITOR,—Having read the case report by
coeliac disease from 1981 to 1995 in patients
resident in South Glamorgan (1995 total
THE EDITOR Kennedy and colleagues,1 we would like to
point out some aspects of the production of
population 415 900; population 14 years or
younger 83 500; total live births 5700 per
dry fermented sausage, salami, and sausage. year). Cases of coeliac disease were ascer-
We agree with Kennedy et al that food manu- tained from hospital activity data, pathology,
facturers should order ingredients specifi- dermatology, and dietetic records, general
“Cot death” rates on diVerent days of cally, in writing, and preferably by their practitioner lists, and the local coeliac society.
the week approved chemical name. All cases satisfied the revised ESPGAN
Nitrate and nitrite are widely used as addi- diagnostic criteria.2 Over the three five-year
EDITOR,—The series of reprints that have tives in meat products for eVects such as red- periods (1981–85, 1986–90, 1991–95) the
arisen from the New Zealand cot death study, dening, as preservatives, and as antioxidants. number of new cases in children younger
which took place around 1990, such as the Prolonged ingestion of nitrates and nitrites than 14 were 8, 10, and 9, respectively—
article by Williams and colleagues1 are repli- may cause methaemoglobinaemia and favour annual incidences of 2.08, 2.53, and 2.15 per
cating work that we carried out in SheYeld in the formation of carcinogenic nitrosamines.2 3 100 000. The incidence of childhood coeliac
the l950s.2–4 In the SheYeld studies, as well as The use of nitrates and nitrites as meat curing disease has therefore remained constant over
noting the significance of prone sleeping, we agents is restricted in Turkey by the Regula- the 15 year period at approximately 1 in 2500
also saw an increase in children presenting as tions of food additives,4 but it does not prevent to 1 in 3000 live births. In contrast, the inci-
unexpected deaths at the weekend. In addi- the use of overdose by food processors as the dence of adult coeliac disease has increased
tion, we found a relative increase on the night residual quantities in the end products are
over the three time periods from 1.3 to 2.15
not limited.
after the day when family doctors took their and 3.08 per 100 000. The incidence of adult
To investigate nitrate and nitrite contents
traditional half day oV and did not hold after- dermatitis herpetiformis has remained be-
in meat products for human consumption we
noon or evening surgeries. This feature tween 0.3 and 0.43 per 100 000.
collected 65 dry fermented sausages, 83
became most apparent when the cot death The age at diagnosis of children with
salamis, and 60 sausage samples from mar-
rates were seen as part of the total pattern of coeliac disease has risen from a median of 4
kets in Istanbul and analysed them with spec-
deaths—that is, a diminution in acute deaths years (1 to 10) between the period 1981 to
trophotometric methods.5 The average ni-
following admission to hospital was replaced 1990, to 7.6 years (1.7 to 14.9) between 1991
trate concentrations were 87.0 mg/kg (range
by greater numbers of home cot deaths. and 1995, whereas the age at presentation of
0–362.9) in dry fermented sausage, 102.4
This pattern of deaths in SheYeld changed mg/kg (0–390) in salami, and 147.4 mg/kg adult patients has remained constant with a
after we introduced the prevention pro- (0–370.9) in sausage. The average nitrite median of 49.5 years (19 to 88). From
gramme identifying children at increased risk concentrations were 42.8 mg/kg (0376.9) in 1981–90 the predominant presenting symp-
of unexpected death.5 We found that we had dry fermented sausage, 87.6 mg/kg (0–375) toms were gastrointestinal, with 70% of the
largely eliminated the partially explained in salami, and 102.8 mg/kg (0–420) in children having diarrhoea, and only three of
group of cot deaths, and the total infant and sausage. The nitrate contents in 3.6% of the 18 children being anaemic. Between
cot death rates in the city fell considerably. salamis and 11.7% of sausages were above 1991–95 anaemia associated with vague
The point that needs to be made is that 300 mg/kg. The nitrite contents in 3.0% of abdominal symptoms (such as discomfort or
such sociopathological studies on child dry fermented sausages, 15.6% of salamis, bloating) became a more common presenta-
deaths should always be carried out in and 20% of sausages were above 150 mg/kg. tion (44%) and diarrhoea was noted in only
relation to the pattern and site of deaths, and Therefore, nitrates and nitrites used during 11%.
to the total infant death rate in the local com- the production of meat products were higher Anaemia as the sole presenting feature
munity. Much of the confusion related to risk than the concentrations indicated by the remained rare at diagnosis (one of 27)
discriminants results from the false assump- Regulations of food additives and this might be compared with a figure of 25% of the adult
tion that with cot deaths one is dealing with a detrimental to human health. Therefore, the coeliac population over the 15 year period.
single cause. Particular causes can be in- concentrations of nitrate and nitrite in the Two asymptomatic children were diagnosed
creased, reduced, or eliminated. This has end product should be limited and control- following screening for IgA antigliadin anti-
been particularly striking during the past 50 led. bodies in siblings of aVected probands.
years relating to what are almost certainly We may be missing asymptomatic cases or
SUZAN YALÇIN those that present later with symptoms such
accidental suVocation deaths. An increase in Department of Food Hygiene and Technology,
the unexpected death rate occurred following Faculty of Veterinary Medicine,
as anaemia, so the true incidence is likely to
propaganda arising from neonatologists rec- Selçuk University, be much higher. Many adult cases are now
ommending prone sleeping in children. The Konya, Turkey identified from duodenal biopsies taken dur-
recent complete reversal of that policy seems ing upper gastrointestinal endoscopy for
S SONGÜL YALÇIN
to have resulted in the elimination of that Department of Social Pediatrics, investigation of iron deficiency anaemia and
group and hence the fall in “cot death” rates Institute of Child Health, Hacettepe University, non-specific gastrointestinal symptoms. The
to their original level. Ankara, Turkey incidence of adult dermatitis herpetiformis,
which shares the same genetic basis as coeliac
JOHN L EMERY disease,3 has remained stable, suggesting the
Emeritus Professor of Paediatric Pathology, 1 Kennedy N, Smith CP, McWhinney P. Faulty increased diagnosis of adult coeliac disease
Room C1, Department of Paediatrics sausage production causing methaemoglobi-
naemia. Arch Dis Child 1997;76:367–8. primarily because of increased clinical aware-
Stephenson Unit, University of SheYeld,
The Children’s Hospital 2 Hotchkiss JH, Cassens RG. Nitrate, nitrite and ness.
nitroso compounds in foods. Food Technology in We consider that although the classic
Western Bank, SheYeld S10 2TH, UK Australia 1988;40:100–5.
3 Vösgen W. Curing. Are nitrite and nitrate neces- gastrointestinal presentation of coeliac dis-
sary or superfluous as curing substances? ease may be decreasing in children, the over-
1 Williams SM, Mitchell EA, Scragg R, and the Fleischwirtsch 1992;72:1675–8. all incidence may not have altered, and is
New Zealand National Cot Death Study 4 Regulations of Turkish food codex. The oYcial likely to be much higher than previously rec-
Group. Why is sudden infant death syndrome news of the Turkish Republic [Turkish],
1997;No 23172:44. ognised once screening tests become more
more common at weekends? Arch Dis Child
1997;77:415–19. 5 Yalçin S, Güneği S, Yalçin SS. Nitrate and widely employed. It is thus vital that we
2 Emery JL. Epidemiology of sudden unexpected nitrite levels of dry fermented sausage, salami remain aware of the diagnosis and how subtle
or rapid deaths in children. BMJ 1959;ii: and sausage consumed in Istanbul [abstract; in
Turkish]. I. National congress of environmen- its presentation may be, and screen actively
925–8. tal health, Ankara, Turkey, December 1997. for cases using IgA antigliadin antibody and
3 Emery JL. Sudden and unexpected death in
infant [abridged]. Proceedings of the Royal antiendomysial antibody, particularly in
Society of Medicine 1959;52:890 [Section of populations at higher risk (for example, fam-
paediatrics, pp 32–4.] Incidence of coeliac disease ily history, Down’s syndrome, insulin de-
4 Emery JL, Crowley EM. Clinical histories in pendent diabetes mellitus).
cases of sudden death in infants reported to the EDITOR,—We were interested to read the arti-
Coroner. BMJ 1956;ii:1578. cle by Challacombe et al reported a declining HUW R JENKINS
5 Carpenter RG, Gardner A, Jepson M, et al. Pre- Consultant Paediatric Gastroenterologist
vention of unexpected infant death. Evaluation
incidence of coeliac disease in West
of the first seven years of the SheYeld Somerset.1 Our observations on the incidence NEIL HAWKES
intervention programme. Lancet 1983;i:723–7. of coeliac disease in South Glamorgan over a Registrar in Gastroenterology
Letters, Book reviews, Meetings 199

GILLIAN L SWIFT Final height is determined by the height treatment for the prevention of excessive
Consultant Gastroenterologist attained at onset of puberty,3 a constant adult stature in girls. We were therefore very
University Hospital of Wales, amount of height (30 cm) being added to that surprised that such critical emphasis has been
Heath Park, CardiV CF4 4XW, UK height. This is why children with precocious placed by our colleagues on an unevaluated
puberty end up short; they have an insuY- opinion.
1 Challacombe DN, Mecrow IK, Elliott K, Clarke cient amount of time to grow along the child- When patients present with a height above
FJ, Wheeler EE. Changing infant feeding prac- hood curve of growth. For example, if a girl is the 97th percentile and ongoing puberty, a
tices and declining incidence of coeliac disease not to exceed a final height of 180 cm, she
in West Somerset. Arch Dis Child 1997;77:206– decision has to be made, and reports about
9. needs to have started breast development the experience with treatment regimens other
2 Walker-Smith JA, Guandalini S, Schmitz J, et al. (spontaneously or induced with low dose than low dose oestrogens will be welcome. As
Revised criteria for the diagnosis of coeliac dis- oestrogen) when she has attained a height of
ease. Arch Dis Child 1990;65:909–11. we are counselling healthy young girls, the
3 Reunala TL, Koskimies S. Familial dermatitis 150 cm. The only problem is if she is too indication for treatment is always the result of
herpetiformis. Clin Dermatol 1991;9:335. young to induce puberty when she has a thorough appraisal of all known treatment
attained this stature. This is a very rare situa- risks, and the consequence of the psychologi-
Dr Challacombe comments: tion, which is probably pathological. Exactly
cal impact of an excessive final height.
the same arithmetic applies to boys whose
The letter by Jenkins et al on the incidence of puberty can be induced with low dose testo-
coeliac disease in children younger than 14 sterone. Down’s syndrome in infants of diabetic
years in South Glamorgan raises some inter- mothers
C G D BROOK
esting questions. They have reported a R STANHOPE
constant incidence over three five-year peri- M A PREECE EDITOR,—In a recent paper Narchi and
ods (1981–85, 1986–90, 1991–95) of ap- A AYNSLEY GREEN Kulaylat1 analysed the prevalence (errone-
proximately 1:2500 to 1:3000 live births. An P C HINDMARSH
ously termed incidence2) of trisomy 21 in
earlier study in West Somerset reported a London Centre for Paediatric Endocrinology &
Metabolism, children of mothers with diabetes (7/1870)
declining incidence of coeliac disease be-
The University College, and in non-diabetic mothers (28/20 430) and
tween 1971–80 and 1981–92, in which the
London Hospitals NHS Trust, found it to be significantly higher in the
annual incidence peaked in 1974 and then
The Middlesex Hospital, former. All seven cases in the diabetes group
decreased, and further patients were not Mortimer Street, London WIN BAA, UK occurred in mothers with gestational
diagnosed annually for six years between
diabetes.
1980 and 1992. The cumulative incidence of
coeliac disease in West Somerset was 0.68 per 1 Weimann E, Bergmann S, Böhles HJ. Oestrogen The authors concluded, that: (1) Maternal
1000 live births during 1971–80 and 0.09
treatment of constitutional short stature: a gestational diabetes is an independent risk
risk-benefit ratio. Arch Dis Child 1998;78:148- factor for Down’s syndrome, irrespective of
during 1981–92. The diVerent findings could 51.
have been caused by diVerent sampling times. 2 Gasser T. Miller HG, Kohler W, et al. An analy- maternal age, as in an analysis of their data
A higher incidence of coeliac disease in the sis of the mid-growth and adolescent spurts of stratified by age, all five age groups showed a
height based on acceleration. Ann Hum Biol higher relative risk for Down’s syndrome in
late 1960s and early 1970s, possibly caused 1985;12:129-48.
by the early introduction of dietary gluten, 3 World Health Organisation collaborative study diabetic mothers; (2) Down’s syndrome
could have been followed by a relative decline of cardiovascular disease and steroid hormone should be added to the list of congenital
contraception. Venous thromboembolic dis- anomalies known to occur more frequently in
in incidence during the late 1970s and 1980s ease and combined oral contraceptives: results
with changing infant feeding practices. These of an international multi-centre case-control infants of diabetic mothers.
were characterised by the later introduction study. Lancet 1995;346:1575-82. Table 2 in their paper does not fully
of dietary gluten, an increased use of baby support their hypothesis. As can be seen from
rice and gluten free foods for weaning, and a Dr Weimann and Professor Böhles comment: their data, age is a confounding factor for
higher incidence of initial breast feeding. The gestational diabetes as fewer than 5% of
age at diagnosis of children with coeliac We were particularly concerned about this pregnant women develop this condition in
disease also increased in South Glamorgan harsh criticism because not all necessary the age group below 30 years but more than
and West Somerset, which could have been points of view have been taken into consid- 23% in those over 44 (assuming that females
yet another result of delaying the introduc- eration. Our paper is the result of a with pre-gestational diabetes are distributed
tion of dietary gluten in infancy. retrospective analysis of our data from 1985 randomly over the age groups—the authors
Although some children still present with to 1994. It describes our experience with high combine both types of diabetes in this table).
classic symptoms and signs of coeliac disease, dose oestrogen treatment for the prevention An analysis of their age stratified groups using
others present at school age or adolescence of excessive adult stature, which has been the Mantel-Haenszel method reveals an odds
with mild or atypical symptoms and signs. As used worldwide over the past 42 years. We ratio of 2.33 with a 95% confidence interval
a result, the diagnosis of coeliac disease has were well aware of the risk of hypercoagula- (CI) of 0.99 to 5.48 for the whole study
become more covert and diYcult to recog- bility. There was increased platelet aggrega- population, as opposed to the authors’
nise. The development of methods using tion in 60% of the 50 girls we examined. All unstratified analysis of the whole group (rela-
serum IgA antibodies to gliadin and to other coagulation parameters such as acti-
tive risk 2.75; 95% CI, 1.2 to 6.29).
endomysium to diagnose and follow up vated prothrombin time, partial thrombo-
Much more important for the discussion of
patients with coeliac disease has been oppor- plastin time, fibrinogen, and antithrombin III
the results is a violation of the rules of causal
tune. In association with small bowel intesti- were normal. Platelet aggregation can easily
inference. The authors laudably made a sharp
nal biopsy these methods will enable the true be avoided with low dose aspirin supplemen-
distinction between mothers with gestational
incidence of coeliac disease to be determined tation. The risk of carcinoma of the breast,
ovary, and uterus is a hypothetical specula- diabetes (n = 1748) and pre-gestational
more precisely and will shed further light on diabetes (n = 122) and found cases (seven in
the natural history of this disease in children tion when natural oestrogens are used, as in
our patients. all) with trisomy 21 only in the former group.
and adults. Thus their analysis of diabetes as a risk factor
The interesting approach of using low dose
oestrogen in girls at risk of attaining excessive for Down’s syndrome is only valid for
Oestrogen treatment of tall stature adult stature when they reach 150 cm may be gestational diabetes. Although the use of the
theoretically better with respect to possible term risk factor in the literature is rather
EDITOR,—We deplore the publication of a side eVects; however, practically it may be loosely defined, in aetiological research for an
paper that lends credibility to a therapeutic applicable only in some patients because they exposure in the broadest sense (gestational
regimen that is not only obsolete but also usually present at a later age when they are diabetes in this study) to become a genuine
dangerous.1 High dose oestrogen treatment deeply concerned about their possible final risk factor it must precede the occurrence of
has an unacceptable incidence of side eVects, height. In our study the mean age and mean the outcome (here, trisomy 21). As non-
which the authors record, and an unknown height at first presentation was 12.8 years and dysjunction leading to trisomy 21 occurs
risk of thromboembolic problems2 and carci- 175.5 cm. In addition, in most cases a height before or shortly after fertilisation, gestational
noma of the breast, ovary, and uterus. of 150 cm in girls above the 97th percentile is diabetes with onset during pregnancy can
The prevention of excessive adult stature is accompanied by a chronological age of less hardly be a risk factor for trisomy 21. The
attained much more benignly by the induc- than 10 years, when an accurate adult height study at hand does not justify adding trisomy
tion of puberty using low doses of sex steroid prediction is still diYcult. 21 to the known congenital anomalies associ-
at an age and height judged to achieve a sat- We know of no suYciently evaluated study ated with pre-gestational diabetes in the
isfactory end point. on the eYcacy of low dose oestrogen mother.
200 Letters, Book reviews, Meetings

What Narchi and Kulaylat may have shown next five days he remained afebrile. His facial emphasised that it has not been possible to
is that a woman with a trisomy 21 conceptus palsy resolved, but there was an increase in measure a dose–response relation, and it is
is more likely to develop gestational diabetes, acute phase reactants and an evolving throm- coordinating a prospective study to assess the
although the attributable risk may be small, bocytosis. On day 17 of the illness, desqua- adequacy of treatment and outcome using
and age, as can be seen from their data, seems mation of the toes was noted. Echocardiogra- two diVerent dosage schedules for the first 24
to be much more important. phy showing aneurysms of the left anterior months after birth.
JÖRG PELZ descending and circumflex coronary arteries In the absence of randomised, prospective
JURGEN KUNZE confirmed the diagnosis of Kawasaki disease. outcome studies, previous authors have
Institut fur Humangenetik, Neurological complications of Kawasaki recommended that any treatment strategy
Humboldt Universitat zu Berlin, disease are well recognised. Hemiplegia, epi- should aim to “achieve euthyroidism as soon
Charité Campus Virchow Klinikum, lepsy, and myositis have been reported.1 In as possible”3 4 and there is a persuasive argu-
Augustenburger Platz 1, one large series, neurological complications ment that TSH suppression is the only and
13353 Berlin, Germany arose in 1.1% of cases.2 There have been 18 most relevant neurobiological marker of
previously reported cases of facial nerve palsy eVective or optimal thyroid hormone concen-
1 Narchi H, Kulaylat N. High incidence of in Kawasaki disease.3 A review of these cases3 trations and hypothalamic feedback.5 6
Down’s syndrome in infants of diabetic moth- noted that six of the 10 children in whom Surprisingly, Raza et al chose an unusual
ers. Arch Dis Child 1997;77:242–4. cerebrospinal fluid was sampled had a
2 Hook EB. Incidence and prevalence as meas- neonatal dosage regimen based on body sur-
ures of the frequency of birth defects. Am J pleocytosis. At diagnosis, coronary artery face area (100 µg/m2/day) with all its inaccu-
Epidemiol 1982;116:743–7. involvement was found in 55%, compared to racies, and sought to evaluate whether the
20–40% of all cases of Kawasaki disease.4 lack of TSH suppression was influenced by
Drs Narchi and Kulaylat comment: This is the first case reported in the UK the underlying thyroid disease or basal TSH
presenting with this complication of Kawa- concentrations, studies of which have been
We read with interest Pelz and Kunze’s com- saki disease. He presented at an early age; the reported previously.3 It would have been
ments on our study and thank them for the peak incidence of Kawasaki disease is 9–11 more helpful to have chosen a dosage sched-
opportunity to clarify our findings. months4 and only one of the reported cases of ule similar to those recommended previously
We agree that the term prevalence is more facial palsy arose in a child younger than 6 (8–15 µg/kg/day) and to have accepted TSH
appropriate than incidence, but our data do months.3 Kawasaki disease should be consid- suppression to < 10 mU/l to compare with
not support maternal age as a confounding ered when an acquired facial palsy occurs as other studies.
factor. Although maternal diabetes (mainly an isolated neurological finding in an infant, When screening for congenital hypothy-
gestational) was more common with advanc- particularly where fever has occurred in the roidism started in the Trent Region in 1980
ing age, when the prevalence of Down’s syn- previous month. several consultant paediatricians discussed a
drome was broken down by maternal age, it
D MCDONALD “best guess” dose of thyroxine; in Leicester
remained 1.6 to 3.01 times more common in
J BUTTERY we decided that as suspensions of thyroxine
infants born to mothers with gestational M PIKE have questionable stability7 and the smallest
diabetes within each age group. If maternal Department of Paediatrics, tablet available is 25 µg we would initially use
age was a confounding factor, the prevalence John RadcliVe Hospital,
of Down’s syndrome, although increasing 25 or 50 µg on alternate days (that is 37.5 µg/
Headington, Oxford OX3 9DU, UK
with advancing maternal age, would not be day), which would be near to 10 µg/kg/day for
expected to be diVerent within the same age most infants.
1 Laxer RM, Dunn HG, Flodmark O. Acute We have looked at the results of our last 29
group regardless of the presence of hemiplegia in Kawasaki disease and infantile
gestational diabetes. Even using the Mantel- polyarteritis nodosa. Dev Med Child Neurol
cases of congenital hypothyroidism to com-
Haenszel method for age stratified groups as 1984;26:814–21. pare TSH suppression with Raza et al’s and
suggested by Pelz and Kunze, the relative risk 2 Terasawa K, Ichinose E, Matsuishi T, Kato H. other reports (table 1).
Neurological complications in Kawasaki dis- The starting dose in our infants weighing
for a diabetic mother to have a baby with ease. Brain Dev 1983;5:371–4.
Down’s syndrome was 2.34 (95% CI, 1.02 to 3 Gallagher PG. Facial nerve paralysis and Kawa- 2.5–4.7 kg ranged from 8–15 µg/kg/day
5.33), not very diVerent from the crude data saki disease. Reviews Infect Dis 1990;12:3:403– (mean 10.5 µg/kg/day) compared with a
5. calculated dose of 5–8 µg/kg/day based on
relative risk of 2.35 (95% CI, 1.2 to 6.2) in 4 Levin M. Kawasaki disease: recent advances.
our initial analysis. Arch Dis Child 1991;66:1369–74. Raza et al’s recommendation using body sur-
We also disagree that the rules of causal face area. Using our regimen the concentra-
inference were violated: we implied an associ- tions of circulating total thyroxine at the time
ation rather than a causal relation, as we Factors involved in the rate of fall of of TSH suppression ranged from 103 to
could prove none. We made it very clear that thyroid stimulating hormone in treated 279 nmol/l (mean 174 nmol/l) and we saw no
as mothers with gestational diabetes were hypothyroidism clinical evidence of hyperthyroidism. These
euglycaemic at conception, hyperglycaemia data and a recent French study,6 where
was ruled out as a potential mechanism for EDITOR,—We would like to comment on the frequent dose titration was used, demonstrate
non-dysjunction; and we suggested the need recommendations on the management of that TSH suppression is related to thyroxine
for further studies of advanced biological congenital hypothyroidism by Raza et al.1 dosage and that there is considerable varia-
aging, autoimmunity, and the role of bio- Although thyroxine dosage recommendations tion in thyroxine concentrations, presumably
chemical factors such as apolipoprotein E. have been available for the treatment of con- owing to variability in thyroxine absorption
The lack of a direct causal relation should not genital hypothyroidism for many years2 it has and metabolism. We therefore agree with
lead to complacency in ignoring the increased not been possible to answer the crucial ques- Touati et al that early and regular individuali-
prevalence of Down’s syndrome in infants of tion as to what concentrations of circulating sation of dosage is required to achieve TSH
mothers with gestational diabetes. thyroid hormones and degree of thyroid suppression.6 Thyroid hormone concentra-
stimulating hormone (TSH) suppression are tions often seem to be high but fall within
required to provide the optimal environment reported normal ranges for infants.9
Neurological complications of Kawasaki for maximising neurobehavioural and intel- We are concerned that following Raza et
disease lectual development. The working group on al’s recommendations will lead to an accept-
congenital hypothyroidism of the European ance that significant non-suppression of TSH
EDITOR,—A 14 week old boy was referred for Society for Paediatric Endocrinology has is unimportant, whereas it almost certainly
neurological review with a 24 hour history of
an isolated, left sided, lower motor neuron Table 1 Comparison of TSH suppression
facial nerve palsy. Twelve days earlier, he had
presented with fever, irritability, and a macu- Cases of TSH suppression (%)
lar rash. A septic screen was negative, includ- Thyroxine Definition of TSH
ing normal cerebrospinal fluid indices. The Study n dose/day 3 months 6 months 12 months suppression
fever settled on day 5, the rash improved, and
he was discharged. He remained irritable, London1 32 100 µg/m2 19 37 72 < 6 mU/l
re-presenting when facial asymmetry devel- SW England8 42 Variable 48 62 67 < 10 mU/l
Leicester 25* 37.5 µg 52 80 88 < 10 mU/l
oped. Norway5 42 50 µg 86 – – < 10 mU/l
Computed tomography and magnetic reso-
nance imaging of his brain were normal. Ini- *Four cases excluded: one because of definite non-compliance and three because of late treatment in mildly
tial haematology was unremarkable. Over the aVected cases.
Letters, Book reviews, Meetings 201

represents undertreatment and so may not hospital in whom vomiting, which may be a Rural hospitals in Africa sometimes have a
encourage the best achievable long term manifestation of UTI in infants, did not small library, often in the senior doctor’s
intellectual development. resolve after surgical treatment, to assess the oYce, where the books are not accessible to
PETER G F SWIFT possibility that concomitant UTI is the cause the staV who would benefit from reading
NASSOS THOMAS for post-pyloromyotomy emesis in IHPS them. They are usually old editions of stand-
VIPAN DATTA infants. We examined all records of IHPS ard British or American textbooks, long
CHRIS CUTTS patients aged 2 to 7 weeks admitted to our winded, with drug doses in minims and guid-
Endocrine and Pharmacy Departments, hospital during a 10 year period between ance for making tincture of belladonna.
Children’s Hospital, 1985 and 1995. Occasionally, there would be a paperback
Leicester Royal Infirmary, In all, 170 infants (138 male, 32 female) edition of Clayton’s Ten Teachers, Bailey and
Leicester LE1 5WW, UK
who presented within the first seven weeks of Love’s Textbook of Emergency Surgery, or one
life (mean 4.4 (2.6) weeks) with progres- of the other subsidised books of the admira-
1 Raza J, Hindmarsh PC, Brook CGD. Factors sively worsening emesis and clinical signs
involved in the rate of fall of thyroid stimulating ble English Language Book Society, now
hormone in treated hypothyroidism. Arch Dis compatible with IMPS, had radiological con- sadly defunct. Many of the hospitals have no
Child 1997;77:526–7. firmation of the diagnosis and underwent money for books or journals and rely on
2 Foley TP. Sporadic congenital hypothyroidism. Ramstedt pyloromyotomy.
In: Dussault JH, Walker P, eds. Congenital infrequent donations.
hypothyroidism. New York: Marcel Dekker, Of them, 24 (14.1%) patients had post- If one asked rural health workers what
1983:231–60. pyloromyotomy emesis and were evaluated educational material they had, they might
3 Germak JA, Foley TP. Longitudinal assessment for the possibility of UTI; urine analysis and produce a well thumbed thin pamphlet
of L-thyroxine therapy for congenital hypothy- cultures were obtained by either suprapubic
roidism. J Pediatr 1990;117:211–19. produced by AMREF (the African Medical
4 Grant DB. Monitoring TSH concentrations aspiration or bladder catheterisation. If urine and Research Foundation). Those who were
during treatment for congenital hypothy- analysis suggested the presence of UTI, very fortunate will have a copy of Child
roidism. Arch Dis Child 1991;66:669–71. empiric antibiotic therapy was initiated with
5 Heyerdahl S, Kase BF. Significance of elevated Health. A new edition is now available, 20
serum thyrotrophin during treatment of con- urine culture until urine culture results were years after the first. The contents move easily
genital hypothyroidism. Acta Paediatr 1995;84: obtained. between primary health care, curative medi-
634–8. Four patients (three male, one female) out cine, and social medicine. It is an intensely
6 Touati G, Leger J, Toublanc JE, et al. A thyroid of 24 post-pyloromyotomy emesis patients
dose of 8 µg/kg per day is appropriate for the practical book, although not as rich in
initial treatment of the majority of infants with (16.6%) were found to have concomitant diagrams as Where There is No Doctor (David
congenital hypothyroidism Eur J Pediatr 1997; clinically manifested UTI and IMPS. Symp- Werner) or Primary Health Care (WHO).
156:94–8. tomatic UTI occurs in 0.14% of live
7 The stability database. St. Mary’s Hospital, However, it is aimed at practitioners who
Penarth, South Glamorgan: Welsh Pharmaceu- newborns.2 know how to do a lumbar puncture but need
tical Service. In a previous report of 276 infants with advice on when, why, and what to do with the
8 Abureswil SSA, Tyfield L, Savage DCL. Serum IMPS, two of them (0.72%) had confirmed result. The clarity of the English makes the
thyroxine and thyroid stimulating hormone UTI.1 In our series of 170 IHPS patients, four
concentrations after treatment of congenital text accessible to health workers whose first
hypothyroidism. Arch Dis Child 1988;63:1368– of them (2.35%) were found to have language is not English or who have not
71. concomitant UTI, clinically manifested by attended secondary education.
9 Corcoran JM, Eastman CJ, Carter JN, Lazarus continuity of vomiting after surgical repair of
L. Circulating thyroid hormone levels in If your rural medical aides, clinical officers,
children. Arch Dis Child 1977;52:716–20. the IHPS. and nurses know this book inside out, then
This figure is 17-fold higher than the they will have the knowledge to manage what
Drs Brook and Hindmarsh comment: expected incidence of UTI in young infants comes in front of them. It does not tackle the
and it makes one wonder about the true aeti- lack of resources, but having this knowledge
We agree with Dr Swift and colleagues that a ology of vomiting at the presentation of will help them to prioritise situations.
prospective randomised trial of diVerent regi- symptoms. Thus, as post-pyloromyotomy Sections of the book acknowledge the great
mens of thyroxine in congenital hypothy- emesis occurs in 5–15% of surgically treated gaps in levels of health care in Africa by
roidism is needed. As the European Society infants,3 we recommend that any child who accepting that neonatal special care is now
for Paediatric Endocrinology trial he men- continues to vomit after adequate surgical practised in larger centres. This still sits well
tions will not look at long term sequelae it will treatment of IHPS be evaluated for the beside advice on how to control the flow of
not answer the question; we are trying to set possibility of concomitant UTI. patients through a clinic and safeguard the
up a UK multicentre trial that will address
M NUSSINOVITCH vaccine cold chain.
the problem.
Y FINKELSTEIN The final chapter is on child abuse and
One factor that Swift et al has not G KLINGER neglect. When I worked in rural Tanzania 15
considered is whether feedback mechanisms A KAUSCHANSKY years ago people told me that child abuse did
of thyroxine on TSH are the same in infancy I VARSANO not exist as “there is no word for it in our lan-
as in older patients. We never use suspensions Department of Pediatrics “C”,
guage”. It does exist, particularly in the
of any hormone replacement and it seems Schneider Children’s Medical Center of Israel,
Sackler Faculty of Medicine, Tel Aviv University, deprived urban sprawls, and in the refugee
intrinsically inappropriate to overtreat one
Petach Tikvah, Israel communities. A short section on the particu-
day and undertreat the next.
lar problems of refugee children—physical
We remain as concerned as ever about the
1 Atwell JD, Levick P. Congenital hypertrophic and emotional—would be a welcome addi-
eVects of pursuing TSH suppression by
pyloric stenosis and associated anomalies of the tion next time round.
increasing free thyroxine concentrations: we genitourinary tract. J Pediatr Surg 1981; Sunlight, rain, termites, and frequent use
reiterate that the long term eVects of clinically 16:1029–35. will take their toll on this book. The price is
undetectable hyperthyroidism are much 2 Gonzales R. Urinary tract infections. In: Behr-
man R, Kleigman RM, Arvin AM, eds. Nelson 360 Kenyan Shillings (£3.60). The next time
more damaging than the same degree of
textbook of pediatrics. 15th ed. Philadelphia: WB you want to assist colleagues in a developing
hypothyroidism. There are simply no data to Saunders, 1996:540. country, do not send them your former
support the contention of Swift et al’s last 3 Garcia VF, Randolph JD. Pyloric stenosis: diag-
nosis and management. Pediatr Rev 1990; professor’s weighty tome. Send them 10 cop-
paragraph.
11:292–6. ies of Child Health. It will make a diVerence.
PAUL EUNSON
Post-pyloromyotomy emesis caused by Consultant paediatrician
concomitant urinary tract infection in
pyloric stenosis patients
BOOK REVIEWS Paediatric Images. Case Book of
An association between infantile hyper-
trophic pyloric stenosis (IHPS) and concomi- DiVerential Diagnosis. By E Blank. (Pp
tant urinary tract infection (UTI) has been 1260; £142.) Lippincott-Raven Publishers,
reported previously.1 Two consecutive infants 1997. ISBN 0-316-09991-0.
Child Health: A Manual for Medical and
with IHPS who continued to vomit after suc-
Health Workers in Health Centres and There are over 1000 images in this large book
cessful surgical and medical treatment in our
institution were found to have concomitant Rural Hospitals. 2nd ed. Edited by covering the whole spectrum of childhood ill-
UTI. P Stanfield, B Balldion, Z Versluys. (Pp 525; nesses. Some of the radiological examinations
This prompted us to examine all cases of KSh360.) African Medical and Research are no longer performed, such as pneumoen-
radiologically proven IHPS diagnosed in our Foundation, 1997. ISBN 9-966-87407-0. cephalography, but it seems likely that such
202 Letters, Book reviews, Meetings

studies are included for historical interest. a core textbook based on these key desiderata This book deals primarily with three
Each case contains a detailed history, bio- of the student mind set. organelles: lysosomes, peroxisomes, and mito-
chemical and other laboratory data, radio- Paediatrics: An Illustrated Colour Text is an chondria. Some lysosomal diseases, such as
logical images, and a final diagnosis or enjoyable multiauthor book that oVers help the mucopolysaccharidoses, have been well
diagnoses. to students in a symptom based approach. It known to paediatricians and pathologists for
There are too many deficiencies to recom- wants its photographs and (excellent) illus- many years. In contrast to disorders aVecting
mend this book. To begin with, the title is trations to do the teaching. These and a three intermediary metabolism, the slow accumu-
misleading as no diVerential diagnostic pos- column format of text enable it to boast com- lation of substrate may lead to progressive
sibilities are ever considered in the text. Lit- prehensive cover of paediatrics in a slim 120 neurological disease often with associated
tle or no justification is made for any diagno- pages. dysmorphic features.
sis, and yet in some cases diagnostic accuracy To the student familiar with browsing the The peroxisome was first identified in the
is debatable. A true diVerential diagnostic internet this book is a boon for a paediatric 1950s by a Swedish PhD student but its sig-
approach would have strengthened the text. attachment—much of the layout has a nificance in human disease was only identi-
For example, a number of neuroradiological Windows feel to it. But one student’s path of fied in 1973 when peroxisomes were found to
cases could have been caused by non- least resistance is another’s dumbed down
be absent in cerebrohepatorenal (Zellweger)
accidental injury—an important diagnosis to soft option and its A4 size and lack of margin
syndrome. We now know that disorders of
consider and exclude for obvious reasons. space make carrying and annotating “on the
peroxisomal function are responsible for at
The chapter grouping and organisation are hoof” diYcult.
What of the symptom based approach? It is least 15 diVerent disorders including X linked
somewhat unusual—for example, the larynx, ALD, rhizomelic chondrodysplasia punctata,
pharynx, and oropharynx sections contain true that much of paediatric diagnosis rests
on the history. Plus, history taking is what a Refsum disease, and hyperoxaluria type 1.
only one case each and the abdominal wall
student does most of (and is most comfort- Investigations of these and other peroxisomal
section (chapter) has just two cases. The first
able with). Unit headings, such as “noisy disorders have led to identification of new
chapter is entitled “Skull and brain”, the
breathing” and “spots and rashes” deal with biochemical pathways and an understanding
second “Brain” yet both include similar cases
common problems and reflect the language of their importance in human metabolism.
with computed tomography or magnetic
of concerned parents. These criteria break Mitochondria are primarily responsible for
resonance brain images. More significantly,
down somewhat with “oliguria” and “ab- cellular energy production. There has been
the chapter on the urinary tract places too
much emphasis on intravenous urography dominal lumps” (not classic symptoms) an enormous increase in our understanding
where it seems disease entities have been shoe of mitochondrial disease and the rate of
with no nuclear medicine studies
horned in for completeness. acquisition of knowledge is likely to increase.
whatsoever—serious omission considering
What students find diYcult is presenting New diseases with strange acronyms, such as
the particular importance of isotope studies
cases, either on consultant ward rounds or NARP, MELAS, MERFF, and MNGIE,
in modern paediatric urology. The chapter
eventually at finals’ long cases. Terminology, have appeared over recent years. Additionally
on the “Normal skeleton” includes disorders
bandied eVortlessly by senior house oYcers there are now new genetic concepts to
such as Perthé’s disease and osteochondritis and registrars, can be daunting. The authors
dissecans. The single greatest weakness, understand—for example, maternal inherit-
are to be applauded therefore for taking the ance and heteroplasmy.
however, is the excess of unnecessary and trouble to define and distinguish basic terms
frequently irrelevant information in the Organelle Diseases provides an in depth
such as respiratory noises (snuZes, stridor, review of our present knowledge of these
form of historical, biochemical, and labora- wheeze, grunting, etc) and the terminology of
tory data. Better editing could have helped in three organelles. As stated in the subtitle it
rashes.
this regard. In addition, according to the deals with clinical features, biochemical and
The diagrams are well designed to stay in
author, some laboratory errors are deliber- the memory, although the usefulness of this molecular diagnosis, pathogenesis, and man-
ately included in the text but it is not clear book as a revision aid is thwarted by a lack of agement. Professor Charles Scriver, in his
when they appear or what relevance they depth in all areas. The problem arose when— foreword, describes this book as linking
have. for example, I wanted to read up, as students science with medical practice. Science he
The radiology images overall are of good are often asked to, on meningitis. There are describes as an attack on ignorance, and
quality. Arrows on selected radiographs five references in the index, each to rather medical practice as a private relationship
would have helped identify some of the more meagre entries in the text, while dehydration between practitioner and patient. Certainly
subtle abnormalities. Myelography is no is not listed at all in the index. The air of there is a great deal of detailed science, and
longer contemplated in the diagnosis of disci- superficiality is compounded by the absence for those with a particular interest in this field
tis nor angiography to diagnose a hepatoblas- of “further reading” sections. it is a delight to see it brought together so
toma. Many ultrasound images are reversed Overall, Paediatrics: An Illustrated Colour well. Medical practice is also covered in some
with a white background, which is no longer Text would be a useful companion for a first depth. Unfortunately our new knowledge has
the convention. year clinical student. Its format is undoubt- not yet translated into eVective treatment for
The author has achieved what he set out to edly alluring, even addictive, but may frus- most organelle disorders. There are impor-
do, to present many fascinating paediatric trate students with designs on a career in tant exceptions, such as enzyme replacement
stories and images “free of opinion and paediatrics. If book budgets are tight, it treatment in Gaucher disease, but sections on
pronouncement”. There is a commendable cannot truly be recommended as a sound treatment are, as a consequence, somewhat
meticulousness throughout the text. Many of investment. limited.
the cases are interesting and worth browsing This book is a rather curious mixture of
through; however, the book is not topical nor NANU GREWAL
Senior house oYcer, paediatrics detailed science and more basic clinical prac-
is the intended target audience clearly tice. For example, there is a section on the
defined. stoichiometry of ATP synthesis and, in
Organelle Diseases. Clinical Features, contrast, a chapter on how to take a family
KIERAN MCHUGH
Consultant radiologist Diagnosis and Management. Edited by D history. However, the format works well and I
A Applegarth, J E Dimmick, J Hall. (Pp 454; would certainly strongly recommend it to cli-
£150 hardback). Chapman and Hall nicians, biochemists, and anyone with an
Medical, 1997. ISBN 0-412-54910-7. interest in biochemical genetics. Any book
Paediatrics: An Illustrated Colour Text.
that has its text positioned between a
Edited by D J Fields, J Stroobant. (Pp 120; Hands up all of you who know what an foreword by Professor Charles Scriver and a
£17.50) Churchill Livingstone, 1997. ISBN organelle is. I asked a colleague, a general postscript by Professor Victor McKusick is
0-443-05254-9. practitioner, what he thought one was. “A likely to have a lot going for it!
small thing with long arms”, he replied. That What is an organelle? Fortunately Organelle
When I teach medical undergraduates I pitch is not exactly right but patients rarely present Diseases contains an excellent glossary and
at three levels: things that if you do not know, stating “It’s my organelles doctor”. Knowl- provides the following definition “A mem-
you will fail (for example, what is Kernig’s edge of organelle disease is not really required brane bound intracellular cytoplasmic struc-
sign); things to know that will secure you a in general practice. However, at least a ture having specialised functions”. Now you
safe pass (for example, knowing the ABC of rudimentary knowledge of organelle function know.
basic resuscitation); and things that will get and the recognition of organelle disorders are
you into the honours class (for example, use becoming increasingly important for paedia- JOHN H WALTER
of DNAses in cystic fibrosis). I have yet to see tricians. Consultant paediatrician
Letters, Book reviews, Meetings 203

Theoretical and practical approaches to Neonatal study day


the management of eating and drinking 6 November, London
MEETINGS diYculties in people with learning Further details: Christine Massey, Postgradu-
disabilities from infancy to adult life ate Centre Manager, Hillingdon Hospital,
30 September, London Uxbridge UB8 3NN, UK
Further details: Lisa Spicer, Royal Society of
Medicine, 1 Wimpole Street, London W1M
1998 8AE, UK The child’s perspective: a collaborative
approach
XXII International congress of 8-10 November, London
pediatrics Drugs in school Further details: The Training Department,
9-14 August, Amsterdam 2 October, London The Institute of Family Therapy, 24-32
Further details: XXII International Congress Further details: Symposium OYce, Institute of Stephenson Way, London NW1 2HX, UK
of Pediatrics, Eurocongres Conference Man- Obstetrics & Gynaecology, Queen Char-
agement, Jan van Goyenkade 11, 1075 HP lotte’s & Chelsea Hospital, Goldhawk Road,
Amsterdam, Netherlands London W6 0XG, UK Molecular biology for paediatricians
9 November, London
British Association of Perinatal Further details: Symposium OYce, Institute of
Women and children with HIV and
Medicine and Neonatal Nurses Obstetrics & Gynaecology, Queen Char-
AIDS
Association: perinatal care towards the lotte’s & Chelsea Hospital, Goldhawk Road,
12 October, London
millennium London W6 0XG, UK
Further details: Symposium OYce, Institute of
3-5 September, Cambridge Obstetrics & Gynaecology, Queen Char-
Further details: Conference Secretariat, Bell lotte’s & Chelsea Hospital, Goldhawk Road, British Society for Paediatric
Howe Conferences (BAPM/NNA), 1 London W6 0XG, UK Endocrinology and Diabetes autumn
Willoughby Street, Beeston, Nottingham
meeting
NG9 2LT, UK
Childhood onset diabetes and 12-13 November, CardiV
disordered metabolism Further details: Dr J W Gregory, University
Training in child public health, social, 15 October, Bristol Department of Child Health, Heath Park,
and community paediatrics in Europe Further details: Dr Ruth Williams, Institute of CardiV CF4 4XN, UK
10-12 September, Bordeaux, France Child Health, Royal Hospital for Sick Chil-
Further details: Congress Rive Droite, 28, rue dren, St Michael’s Hill, Bristol BS2 8BJ, UK
Baudrimont, 33100 Bordeaux, France Community child health
13 November, London
British Paediatric Rheumatology Further details: Symposium OYce, Institute of
Paediatric Research Society Group: autumn meeting Obstetrics & Gynaecology, Queen Char-
11-13 September, Elgin 15-16 October, Canterbury lotte’s & Chelsea Hospital, Goldhawk Road,
Further details: Dr A Attenburrow, Consultant Further details: Dr Alison Leak, Consultant London W6 0XG, UK
Paediatrician, Dr Gray’s Hospital, Elgin, Rheumatologist, Queen Elizabeth The
Morayshire IV30 1SN, UK Queen Mother Hospital, St Peters Road,
Margate, Kent CT9 4AN, UK British Society for Paediatric
Dermatology annual meeting
11th Congress of the International 13-14 November, London
Pediatric Nephrology Association International conference on adolescent Further details: Rosemary Cope, Academic
12-16 September, London health Secretary to Dr D Atherton, Great Ormond
Further details: IPNA 98, Concorde Services 22-23 October, London Street Hospital for Children NHS Trust,
Limited, 10 Wendell Road, London W12 Further details: Youth Support Conference Great Ormond Street, London WC1N 3JH,
9RT, UK Administration, Youth Support House, 13 UK
Crescent Road, London BR3 2NF, UK
8th International child neurology Controversies in paediatrics
congress Ninth annual course in paediatric 17 November, London
13-18 September, Slovenia gastroenterolgy Further details: Symposium OYce, Institute of
Further details: President of the Organising 26-28 October, London Obstetrics & Gynaecology, Queen Char-
Committee, Department of Developmental Further details: Professor J A Walker-Smith, lotte’s & Chelsea Hospital, Goldhawk Road,
Neurology, University Paediatric Hospital, University Department of Paediatric Gastro- London W6 0XG, UK
Vrazov trg 1, 61104 Ljubljana, Slovenia enterology, The Royal Free Hospital, Pond
Street, London NW3 2QG, UK
European Society for Pediatric Eating disorders: mysteries, paradoxes,
Research conference Joint RCP/RCPCH conference: alcohol and challenges
13-17 September, Belfast and the young 20 November, London
Further details: Project Planning Inter- 27 October, London Further details: The Training Department,
national, Montalto Estate, Spa Road, Bally- Further details: Miss Amanda Ambalu, The Institute of Family Therapy, 24-32
nahinch, Northern Ireland BT24 8PT, UK RCPCH, 50 Hallam Street, London W1N Stephenson Way, London NW1 2HX, UK
6DE, UK
RCPCH Accident and Emergency Infection and immunological disorders
Group: international aspects of Fetal, neonatal, and childhood in childhood
paediatric accident and emergency haematology: paradoxes, problems, and 20 November, London
medicine progress Further details: Dr M Abinun/Dr S Hoare,
22 September, Liverpool 28 October, London Consultant Paediatricians, Newcastle Gen-
Further details: Dr W J Robson, Consultant in Further details: Scientific Meetings OYcer, eral Hospital, Westgate Road, Newcastle-
Paediatric A&E Medicine, Royal Liverpool Royal College of Pathologists, 2 Carlton upon-Tyne NE4 6BE, UK
Children’s Hospital, Alder Hey, Liverpool, House Terrace, London SW1Y 5AF, UK
Merseyside L12 2AP, UK
Neonatal course for senior
Bone marrow transplantation in paediatricians
Diabetes mellitus childhood 23-27 November, London
30 September, London 28-30 October, Manchester Further details: Symposium OYce, Institute of
Further details: Scientific Meetings OYcer, Further details: Index Communications Meet- Obstetrics & Gynaecology, Queen Char-
Royal College of Pathologists, 2 Carlton ing Services, Crown House, 28 Winchester lotte’s & Chelsea Hospital, Goldhawk Road,
House Terrace, London SW1Y 5AF, UK Road, Romsey, Hampshire SO51 8AA, UK London W6 0XG, UK
204 Letters, Book reviews, Meetings

International symposium: 1999 Royal College of Paediatrics and Child


periventricular leucomalacia—a Health 3rd annual scientific meeting
British Paediatric Neurology
research priority for neonatology and 13-16 April, York
Association Annual Scientific Meeting
public health Further details: Miss Amanda Ambalu,
8-10 January, Belfast
30 November to 1 December, Paris, France RCPCH, 50 Hallam Street, London W1N
Further details: Dr David Webb, Consultant
Further details: Professor J C Gabilan, Départ- 6DE, UK
Paediatric Neurologist, Royal Belfast Chil-
ment of Neonatology, Hôpital A Béclère, 157
dren’s Hospital, Grosvenor Road, Belfast
rue de la Porte de Trivaux, 92141 Clamart,
BT12 6BE
France

Autistic disorders in people with Joint Meeting of British and Italian


learning disability: diagnosis and 5th International congress of tropical Societies of Paediatric Gastroenterology
management paediatrics and Nutrition
3 December, London 10-15 February, Jaipur, India 22-24 September, Oxford
Further details: Lisa Spicer, Royal Society of Further details: Dr Ashok Gupta, Secretary Further details: Dr Peter Sullivan, Department
Medicine, 1 Wimpole Street, London W1M General, 25, Chetak Marg, M. D. Road, India of Paediatrics, John RadcliVe Hospital, Ox-
8AE, UK Jaipur-302 004 (India) ford OX3 9DU, UK

You might also like