Professional Documents
Culture Documents
SUMMARY
The objective was to describe the current epidemiology and trends in New Zealand human
leptospirosis, using descriptive epidemiology of laboratory surveillance and disease notification
data, 1990–8. The annual incidence of human leptospirosis in New Zealand 1990–8 was 4n4 per
100 000. Incidence was highest among meat processing workers (163n5\100 000), livestock farm
workers (91n7), and forestry-related workers (24n1). The most commonly detected serovars were
Leptospira borgpetersenii serovar (sv.) hardjo (hardjobovis) (46n1 %), L. interrogans sv. pomona
(24n4 %) and L. borgpetersenii sv. ballum (11n9 %). The annual incidence of leptospirosis
declined from 5n7\100 000 in 1990–2 to 2n9\100 000 in 1996–8. Incidence of L. borgpetersenii sv.
hardjo and L. interrogans sv. pomona infection declined, while incidence of L. borgpetersenii
sv. ballum infection increased. The incidence of human leptospirosis in New Zealand remains
high for a temperate developed country. Increasing L. borgpetersenii sv. ballum case numbers
suggest changing transmission patterns via direct or indirect exposure to contaminated surface
water. Targeted and evaluated disease control programmes should be renewed.
Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 192.188.53.214, on 10 Jan 2020 at 21:08:10, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms.
https://doi.org/10.1017/S0950268801006392
30 C. N. Thornley and others
system receives acute leptospirosis case reports from Sex was recorded in 98n1 % (1370\1397) of case
medical practitioners, as required by the Health Act records. The majority of cases were male (1238\1370 ;
1956. The laboratory surveillance system receives 90n4 %). The annual incidence among males was
details of positive leptospira tests from all lab- 8n0\100 000 (CI 7n5–8n4), and 0n8\100 000 among
oratories. Data from both systems were collected females (CI 0n7–1n0). Age was recorded in 91n6 %
from Institute of Environmental Science and Research (1281\1397) of case records. Cases were aged between
(ESR) databases. Case records were matched by 4 and 80 years, with a median age of 36 years at date
iteratively comparing combinations of name, date of of diagnosis. The majority of cases (56n9 %, 729\1281)
birth and address, to avoid double counting cases. were aged 25–44 years. Peak incidence occurred within
Cases were included if the laboratory result showed a the 35–44 year age group among males (14n4\100 000)
single serological titre 400 on the microscopic and females (1n7) (Fig. 1).
agglutination test (MAT), a greater than fourfold rise Information on occupation was obtained for 83n2 %
in titres between two sequential specimens, or isolation (1041\1251) of cases aged between 15 and 64 years. Of
of leptospires from appropriate clinical specimens. those in paid employment, 31n0 % (308\992) were
Disease notification case records without matching meat processing workers. Livestock farming workers
laboratory records were included if the case report made up 51n8 % (539\992) of cases in known paid
indicated that laboratory confirmation had been employment, predominantly dairy (212), pig (19),
obtained. Missing occupation or address information cattle (6) and deer (5) farming. Types of animal
were obtained from electoral rolls with closest farmed were not specified in 273 cases. Remaining
publication date to the date of illness onset in each cases in known paid employment included forestry-
case. Cases who had been overseas shortly before related occupations (17\992 ; 1n7 %) and occupations
becoming unwell were not excluded. The data were involving direct animal contact other than meat
analysed using Epi Info [7] and Microsoft Excel. processing, farming or forestry work (8\992 ; 0n8 %).
Analysis was conducted by age, sex, occupation, Individuals with occupations not considered to be at
territorial authority of residence, health district of high risk of leptospirosis in New Zealand comprised
residence and infecting serovar. Recreational risk 12n9 % of cases (128\992).
factors were not investigated because no notified cases The crude incidence rates for livestock farm workers
had recreational exposure recorded. Proportions were (91n7\100 000), meat processing workers (163n5) and
compared using χ# tests. Trends in case numbers were forestry-related workers (24n0) were significantly
analysed using χ# tests for linear trend. Incidence rates greater than other workers (1n0) (rate ratio (RR) for
were compared using rate ratios, and differences in livestock farm workers compared to other paid
incidence rates over time were performed by com- workers with listed occupation 91n2 % (95 % confi-
paring rates in 1990–2 with those in 1996–8. Oc- dence interval (CI) : 75n2–110n6) ; for meat processing
cupational coding used the 1995 New Zealand workers 163n5 (133n1–200n1) ; for forestry-related
Standard Classification of Occupations [8]. Cases with workers 24n0 (14n5–39n7)). Among livestock farm
known paid employment were grouped as either workers, leptospirosis incidence among males
livestock farm workers, meat processing workers, (121n2\100 000) was significantly greater than among
forestry-related workers or other workers. Individuals females (18n4) (rate ratio (RR) for male compared
aged younger than 15 or older than 64 years were with female livestock workers 6n6 (95 % confidence
excluded from occupation analyses. Denominators interval (CI) : 4n6–9n4)). There were no significant
were drawn from the 1991 and 1996 censuses, and differences between male (164n7\100 000) and female
incidence rates were calculated annually. Denomin- (149n5) meat processing workers (RR for male meat
ators for intercensal years were calculating by inter- processing workers compared with female 1n1 (CI
polating between the two census years. 0n8–1n6)), or between male (23n3) and female (20n1)
forestry workers (RR 1n2 (0n2–8n7)).
Geographical distribution of leptospirosis cases was
RESULTS
examined by health district and territorial authority
Records were obtained on 1397 cases with disease area, categorization was possible in 98n9 % (1382\
onset between 1990 and 1998, giving an overall annual 1397) of case records. Crude health district incidences
incidence of 4n4 per 100 000 in the New Zealand ranged from 17n9\100 000 in Ruapehu health district
population (95 % confidence interval (CI) 4n1–4n7). to 0n9\100 000 in Wellington. Significant positive
Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 192.188.53.214, on 10 Jan 2020 at 21:08:10, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms.
https://doi.org/10.1017/S0950268801006392
Leptospirosis epidemiology in New Zealand 31
16
14
Leptospirosis incidence (per 100000 per year)
12
10
0
0–14 15 –24 25 –34 35 – 44 45 –54 55 – 64 65 –74 75+
Age group
Female Male
Fig. 1. Age-specific incidence of leptospirosis among New Zealand males and females, average annual rate, 1990–8.
7.00
6.00
Incidence (per 100 000 per year)
5.00
4.00
3.00
2.00
1.00
0.00
1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998
Year
Fig. 2. Annual incidence of human leptospirosis in New Zealand, 1990–8, combined laboratory surveillance and disease
notification data.
linear correlation was found between the leptospirosis recorded was L. borgpetersenii sv. hardjo (584\
incidence and the ratio of dairy cattle numbers 1266, 46n1 %), followed by L. interrogans sv. pomona
(obtained from [9]) to human population in each (309\1266, 24n4 %) and L. borgpetersenii sv. ballum
territorial authority area (R# l 0n28 ; F l 28n0, (151\2366, 11n9 %). Other serovars detected were L.
P 0n0001). Only four cases in the dataset indicated interrogans sv. bratislava (58), L. borgpetersenii sv.
that they had been overseas during the incubation tarrassoi (54), L. interrogans sv. copenhageni (52), L.
period of their illness. Infecting serovar was recorded interrogans sv. canicola (11) and L. interrogans sv.
in 90n6 % (1266\1397) of cases. The most commonly australis (3). The remaining cases (44) reacted to more
Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 192.188.53.214, on 10 Jan 2020 at 21:08:10, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms.
https://doi.org/10.1017/S0950268801006392
32 C. N. Thornley and others
Crude annual
Number incidence Rate 95 % confidence
of cases (per 100 000) ratio* interval of RR†
Livestock farm
workers
1990–2 227 112n4
1996–8 134 70n6 0n64 (0n51–0n79)
Meat processing
workers
1990–2 118 176n6
1996–8 84 144n9 0n82 (0n62–1n09)
Forestry-related
workers
1990–2 5 26n4
1996–8 4 14n3 0n51 (0n14–2n0)
Other workers
1990–2 48 1n04
1996–8 37 1n0 0n63 (0n40–0n97)
than one serovar, and could not be assigned to a single were observed among livestock farm workers and
serovar group. ‘ other ’ workers.
The distribution of infecting serovars differed The declining leptospirosis incidence trend for New
significantly between the main occupational groups Zealand as a whole was not consistently observed in
(χ# l 183n5, 9 .., P 0n0001). Livestock farmers all health districts. Significant downward trends were
were most commonly diagnosed with L. borgpetersenii observed in Auckland, Waikato, Taranaki, Mana-
sv. hardjo infection (285\508, 56n1 %), meat pro- watu and Wellington health districts only.
cessing workers were most commonly diagnosed with The overall reduction in leptospirosis cases in New
L. interrogans sv. pomona infection (130\279, 46n6 %), Zealand between 1990 and 1998 is largely due to an
forestry-related were most commonly diagnosed with absolute reduction in the numbers of cases of L.
L. borgpetersenii sv. ballum infection (8\14, 57n1 %), borgpetersenii sv. hardjo and L. interrogans sv. pomona
as were other workers (39\113, 34n5 %). during the time period. The combined number of L.
borgpetersenii sv. hardjo and L. interrogans sv. pomona
cases fell by 55 % from 1990–2 to 1996–8, while
Trends in leptospirosis case numbers and incidence,
combined numbers of other serovars, including L.
1990–8
borgpetersenii sv. ballum, increased by 25 % over the
The annual incidence of leptospirosis declined from same interval. The incidence of L. borgpetersenii sv.
5n7\100 000 in 1990–2 to 2n9 in 1996–8 (rate ratio for ballum infection increased significantly from 0n2 to 0n6
1996–8 compared with 1990–2 : 0n51 (95 % CI 0n45– per 100 000 between 1990–2 and 1996–8, while the
0n59)) (Fig. 2). The overall age and sex distribution of incidence of L. borgpetersenii sv. hardjo and L.
cases was unchanged over the 9-year period (age- interrogans sv. pomona infection declined significantly
group : χ# l 31n1, 26 .., P l 0n23, sex : χ# l 9n1, 8 (Table 2).
.., P l 0n33). The annual number of L. interrogans sv. pomana
The number of cases with a ‘ high-risk ’ occupation cases among livestock farm workers declined from 52
as a proportion of all cases remained static between per year in 1990–2 to 14 per year in 1996–8, the annual
1990 and 1998 (χ# test for linear trend l 1n95, n.s.). number of L. borgpetersenii sv. hardjo cases declined
The incidence of leptospirosis in each occupational slightly from 96 to 61 per year, and the annual number
category fell between 1990–2 and 1996–8 (Table 1). of cases attributable to L. borgpetersenii sv. ballum
Significant reductions between the two 3-year periods climbed from 13 to 27 per year during the same
Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 192.188.53.214, on 10 Jan 2020 at 21:08:10, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms.
https://doi.org/10.1017/S0950268801006392
Leptospirosis epidemiology in New Zealand 33
Crude annual
Number incidence Rate 95 % confidence
of cases (per 100 000) ratio* interval of RR†
L. borgpetersenii
sv. ballum
1990–2 24 0n2
1996–8 62 0n6 2n38 (1n48–3n81)
L. borgpetersenii
sv. hardjo
1990–2 228 2n3
1996–8 116 1n1 0n47 (0n37–0n59)
L. interrogans
sv. pomona
1990–2 160 1n6
1996–8 60 0n5 0n35 (0n26–0n46)
Other serovar or
mixed infection
1990–2 78 0n8
1996–8 66 0n6 0n78 (0n56–1n08)
intervals. Among meat processing workers, the annual [12]. The 1990–2 incidence in the current study was
number of cases due to L. interrogans sv. pomona 5n7\100 000, lower than that previously reported for
declined from 62 per year in 1990–2 to 26 per year in the same period [6]. The reason for this discrepancy is
1996–8, while the annual number of L. borgpetersenii not clear, as both estimates combined notifications
sv. hardjo cases increased slightly from 23 to 30 per and laboratory-reported cases. The current study used
year during the same interval. a systematic approach to preventing double-counting
single disease episodes, but the approach used in the
1993 study was not reported.
DISCUSSION
The higher leptospirosis incidence among males in
This study used a combined dataset of leptospirosis comparison with females in New Zealand has been
notifications and laboratory-reported cases to give a documented previously [4, 6]. The male leptospirosis
comprehensive assessment of the epidemiology of this incidence is tenfold that of females. Much of this
disease in New Zealand in the 1990s. By combining difference is likely to be due to male predominance
data from two surveillance systems, this study miti- within the main occupations at risk of leptospira
gated the effect of underreporting of cases to the exposure. There were no differences in gender-specific
disease notification system [6]. leptospirosis incidence rates among meat processing
workers or forestry-related workers. Gender dif-
ferences remained among livestock farmers or ‘ other ’
Descriptive epidemiology
workers and suggest gender differentiation of work-
According to this study, the average annual incidence tasks or personal hygiene within certain occupational
of leptospirosis in New Zealand (4n4\100 000) has categories leading to differences in leptospira ex-
declined since the last New Zealand estimate of posure.
6n2\100 000 reported in 1993 for the 1990–2 period [6], The age distribution of cases has not changed
continuing a trend noted previously [4]. At 4n4\ appreciably since the 1990–2 study [6] or during the 9-
100 000, the rate of leptospirosis in New Zealand year period analysed in this study. Leptospirosis cases
remains higher than that reported for other developed remain concentrated among individuals aged 20–40
temperate climate countries, such as 0n8–2n2 in years.
Portugal [10], 0n7 in Australia [11] and 1n0 in Ireland This study suggests that the overwhelming majority
Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 192.188.53.214, on 10 Jan 2020 at 21:08:10, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms.
https://doi.org/10.1017/S0950268801006392
34 C. N. Thornley and others
Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 192.188.53.214, on 10 Jan 2020 at 21:08:10, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms.
https://doi.org/10.1017/S0950268801006392
Leptospirosis epidemiology in New Zealand 35
the study period, while rates among other occu- from inclusion of data comparing vaccination rates
pational groups showed no significant decline. Simi- between health districts, but this information is not
larly, leptospirosis incidence fell in most areas with currently available. Leptospirosis surveillance in New
heavy dairy farming industry, with several exceptions Zealand would be considerably enhanced by de-
discussed below. velopment of an associated hazard-surveillance system
The incidence of L. borgpetersenii sv. hardjo and L. that could allow active monitoring of such infor-
interrogans sv. pomona infection, concentrated among mation.
livestock farm workers and meat processing workers If rates of vaccination are shown to vary between
respectively, declined significantly between 1990–2 health districts, then research should be conducted to
and 1996–8. Conversely, the incidence of L. borg- address reasons for variation. Despite gains made in
petersenii sv. ballum infection climbed significantly so the last two decades, leptospirosis remains New
that by 1996–8 L. borgpetersenii sv. ballum had Zealand’s most important occupational infectious
overtaken L. interrogans sv. pomona as the second disease and is poorly controlled in comparison with
most commonly-recognized serovar. L. borgpetersenii other developed countries. Considerable scope re-
sv. ballum has long been tested for in New Zealand, so mains for further improvement, particularly among
the observed increase in this study is not an artefact of meat processing workers. Further gains will require
changes in testing schedule. L. borgpetersenii sv. greater investment in targeted and evaluated disease
ballum is maintained in rodents and occurs secondarily control programmes.
among livestock animals. The emergence of L.
borgpetersenii sv. ballum as a more frequent cause of A C K N O W L E D G E M E N TS
human infection suggests a change in the prevalence
of L. borgpetersenii sv. ballum in the zoonotic The authors thank the Ministry of Health for use of
reservoir, increasing exposure of humans to this their dataset. ESR would like to thank the hospital
serovar either by direct animal contact or through and community laboratories in New Zealand for
contaminated surface waters. Further clarification of continuing to supply specimens and data.
causal pathways underlying this epidemiology shift
would require collaboration with veterinary epidemio- DISCLAIMER
logists and zoologists. The views of the authors do not necessarily represent
the views or policy of the New Zealand Ministry of
Recommendations Health. The Ministry makes no warranty, express or
implied, nor assumes any liability or responsibility for
Collection of accurate information on exposures to use of or reliance on the contents of this article.
potential sources of infection should be encouraged as
part of ongoing improvement of the leptospirosis
REFERENCES
disease notification dataset as collected on the case-
report form. Future reviews of leptospirosis epi- 1. Speelman P. Leptospirosis. In : Fauci AS, Braunwald E,
demiology should make use of exposure data, and a Isselbalcher KJ, et al., eds. Harrison’s principles of
internal medicine, 14th edn. New York : McGraw-Hill,
study comparing exposures among leptospirosis cases
1998 : 1036–8.
with those of the population, matched for geographic 2. Faine S. Leptospira and leptospirosis. Boca Raton :
area of residence, would be necessary to determine the CRC Press, 1995.
proportion of leptospirosis cases attributable to 3. Kirschner L, Gray WG. Leptospirosis in New Zealand.
recreational exposure. The overall decline in cases of N Z Med J 1951 ; 50 : 342–51.
4. Anonymous. Leptospirosis in New Zealand. Commun
leptospirosis among livestock farmers, and hence the
Dis N Z 1991 ; 91 : 105–6.
decline in cases overall, is likely to be the result of 5. Marshall R. A nationwide experiment to control human
improved prevention of disease in livestock and leptospirosis by vaccinating dairy cattle. Isr J Vet Med
consequent reduced transmission to farm workers. 1987 ; 43 : 271–6.
Several districts have not followed the nationwide 6. Chereshsky A, Baker M. Leptospirosis in New Zealand.
trend, but the data presented in this study are Commun Dis N Z 1993 ; 93 : 94–6.
7. Dean AG, Dean JA, Coulombier D, et al. Epi Info,
insufficient to advance explanations for the failure of
Version 6 : a word processing, database, and statistics
these health districts to maintain declining lepto- program for public health on microcomputers. Atlanta :
spirosis rates. Valuable information could be gained Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 1994.
Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 192.188.53.214, on 10 Jan 2020 at 21:08:10, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms.
https://doi.org/10.1017/S0950268801006392
36 C. N. Thornley and others
8. Statistics New Zealand. New Zealand Standard Classifi- 15. Ciceroni L, Pinto A, Benedetti E, et al. Human
cation of Occupations 1995. Wellington : Statistics New leptospirosis in Italy, 1986–1993. Eur J Epidemiol 1995 ;
Zealand, 1995. 11 : 707–10.
9. Livestock Improvement. Dairy Statistics 1997–1998. 16. Bovet P, Yersin C, Merien F, Davis CE, Perolat P.
Hamilton : Livestock Improvement Corporation Ltd., Factors associated with clinical leptospirosis : a pop-
1998. ulation-based case-control study in the Seychelles
10. Falcao JM, Nogueira PJ, Matias Dias C, Pimenta ZP. (Indian Ocean). Int J Epidemiol 1999 ; 28 : 583–90.
Leptospirosis in Portugal : epidemiology from 1991 to 17. Ashford DA, Bruce MG, Morgan J, et al. Recent
1997. Eurosurveillance 1999 ; 4 : 44–7. leptospirosis outbreaks investigated by the CDC :
11. O’Brien E, D’Souza R, Gilroy N, et al. Australia’s lessons and dilemmas. In : Proceedings of the In-
notifiable diseases status, 1997. Commun Dis Intell ternational Leptospirosis Society, Second Meeting.
1999 ; 23 : 1–27. Marysville : International Leptospirosis Society, 1999.
12. Pate G, FitzSimon N, Mellotte GJ. Leptospirosis in the 18. Weinstein P, Cameron AS. Occupation-related lepto-
South-Eastern Health Board region of the Republic of spirosis in South Australia. Med J Aust 1991 ; 155 :
Ireland : 1990 to 1996. Commun Dis Publ Hlth 1999 ; 2 : 132–3.
217–8. 19. Everard CO, Maude GH, Hayes RJ. Leptospiral
13. Blackmore DK, Schollum LM. The occupational infection : a household serosurvey in urban and rural
hazards of leptospirosis in the meat industry. N Z Med communities in Barbados and Trinidad. Ann Trop Med
J 1982 ; 95 : 494–7. Parisitol 1990 ; 84 : 255–66.
14. Blackmore DK, Schollum LM. Risks of contracting 20. Sasaki DM, Pang L, Minette HP, et al. Active
leptospirosis on the dairy farm. N Z Med J 1982 ; 95 : surveillance and risk factors for leptospirosis in Hawaii.
649–52. Am J Trop Med Hyg 1993 ; 48 : 35–43.
Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 192.188.53.214, on 10 Jan 2020 at 21:08:10, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms.
https://doi.org/10.1017/S0950268801006392