Professional Documents
Culture Documents
GfJ
Printed in Great Britain. 0 1990Pergamon Press plc
ADRIAN J. PARR, JOHN PAYNE, JOHN EAGLES,* BRIDGET T. CHAPMAN, RICHARD J. ROBINS and MICHAEL J. C.
RHODES
Plant Biotechnology Group, Department of Genetics and Microbiology; *Mass Spectrometry, Department of Chemical Physics,
AFRC Institute of Food Research, Norwich Laboratory, Colney Lane, Norwich NR4 7UA, U.K.
Key Word Index-Datum spp.; Hyoscyamusspp.; Scopolia spp.; Solanaceae; identification; accumulation; trans-
formed roots; tropane alkaloids; scopolamine; hyoscyamine.
-
Abstract-Petioles from over 1000 individual plants of the genera Datura, Scopolia and Hyoscyamus were analysed to
establish the variation in the levels and patterns of tropane alkaloids which occur between plants. Transformed root
cultures were initiated from plants of which analyses suggested extremely high or low alkaloid biosynthetic capacities,
or favourable alkaloid patterns. These root cultures were then studied in detail by HPLC, GC and GC-MS. Root
cultures showed substantial differences in alkaloid patterns between different species, but the quantitative differences in
tropoyl esters of cc-tropine (hyoscyamine plus scopolamine) observed between different lines were less than those seen
between plants. This difference is interpreted as to some extent reflecting the influence of transport and storage effects,
as well as biosynthetic capacity, in determining alkaloid levels in plant petioles. In addition, there is some indication
that the full biosynthetic capacity may not always be expressed in culture. Despite these limitations, the identification
of plants showing favourable characteristics still, however, proved a useful first step in the development of scientifically
and potentially biotechnologically interesting root cultures.
2545
PHI29-8-K
2546 A. J. PARRet ul.
order to allow for effects of leaf maturity on alkaloid either particularly efficient epoxidation during alkaloid
content [7]. transport in the shoot, or from epoxidation already
having begun in the root. They are thus candidates for the
generation of root cultures producing high levels of
Datura
scopolamine. Conversely, plants with low petiolar sco-
The alkaloid profile of the petioles of most Datura polamine to hyoscyamine ratios should include cases
species was dominated by hyoscyamine, scopolamine and where there is no epoxidation occurring in the roots, and
an alkaloid provisionally identified as meteloidine by they are thus candidates for the generation of root lines
HPLC comparison with reference material. Datura cer- producing only hyoscyamine.Within the Datura species
atocaula was atypical in containing apparently major we examined, the petiolar scopolamine to hyoscyamine
amounts of several other unidentified alkaloids [6], an ratio was found to show at least a 20-fold variation
observation in line with its other unusual taxonomic (Table 1). The lowest values were found in D. leichhardtii,
features. Even within the more typical Datura species, where Hashimoto and Yamada [8] have already found
substantial variation was however observed in the levels untransformed root cultures to be unable to synthesize
and relative proportions of the major alkaloids (Table 1). scopolamine. Some species exhibited wide variations
This variation operated at all levels, i.e. between species, between different accessions, although plants within each
between different accessions of the same species, and accession were more constant (Table 1); this suggests the
between individuals, presence of several physiologically distinct chemotypes.
Amongst the variation observed two features are of
particular biotechnological interest. Firstly, the absolute
Hyoscyamus
level of the tropic acid esters hyoscyamine and scopola-
mine should in part reflect the biosynthetic capacity of the The alkaloid profiles of Hyoscyamus petioles were
roots of the plant. Alkaloid levels (hyoscyamine and rather simple, being dominated by hyoscyamine and/or
scopolamine combined) were found to range from 52 to scopolamine. Alkaloid levels varied in much the same
1350 pgg- ’ fr. wt and even within the single species D. manner as for Datura, with standard deviations for results
stramonium a 20-fold difference in petiolar alkaloid levels from a single accession typically being 50% of the mean,
was observed. Overall the highest alkaloid occurred in D. and with a seven-fold difference in the means being
stramonium (though this to some extent may reflect the observed between species with the highest and lowest
larger number of accessions and individuals studied) and alkaloid content (Table 2). The absolute alkaloid levels
D. fastuosa (Table 1). Plants with a particularly high were, however, generally only one-tenth of those seen in
petiolar alkaloid level are good candidates for generating Datura--which hints at a difference in alkaloid partitio-
high-producing root cultures, for high leveis require a ning between the two genera, since the biosynthetic
high biosynthetic capacity. capacities are not generally thought to differ so greatly.
The other feature of interest is the variation in the Petiolar scopolamine to hyoscyamine ratios varied wide-
scopolamine to hyoscyamine ratio. Both hyoscyamine ly from less than 0.01 in H. muticus to over 10 in some
and scopolamine are of commercial interest, and it would individuals of H. desertorum. In general, though, ratios
be an advantage to have different cultures producing either were low (Table 2). This too indicates a difference in the
hyoscyamine or scopolamine as major products. In behaviour of the genera Dutura and Hyoscyamus, for
Datura, hyoscyamine is synthesized in the roots, then these low ratios seen in Hyoscyamus are not associated
epoxidized to scopolamine. This epoxidation can occur in with any inability to synthesize scopolamine in the roots
the root in some species, but in others it occurs only in the (see Table 4). Perhaps in Hyosqamus the role of aerial
aerial parts (e.g. [7, 81). Plants with high scopolamine to tissue in epoxidation is minor, whereas in Datura it seems
hyoscyamine ratios in the petiole are likely to result from more significant.
Table 1. The combined levels of scopolamine and hyoscyamine, and the ratios of these two
alkaloids, in petioles of various Datura species
Scopolamine + hyoscyamine
(fl’gg-’ rr. wt) Scopolamineihyoscyamine ratio
Figures quoted are means&standard deviation for plants from a single accession. Where
more than one accession of a particular species was studied that number is shown in
parentheses, and the observed range of mean values for each parameter is shown.
Tropane alkaloids in Solanaceae 2547
Table 2. The combined levels of scopolamine and hyoscyamine, and the ratios of these two
alkaloids, in petioles of various Hyoscyamusspecies
Scopolamine + hyoscyamine
(/Agg_’ fr. wt) Scopolamine/hyoscyamine ratio
Figures quoted are means *standard deviation for plants from a single accession.
Table 3. The hyoscyamine and scopolamine content of transformed root cultures generated from Datura
stramonium plants showing a range of petiolar alkaloid levels
Petioles Cultures
Hyoscyamine plus scopolamine Number of plants Hyoscyamine Scopolamine
(pcgg-’ fr. wt) (fig-’ fr. wt)
1001-1350 2 870-1053 0
801-1000 3 887-896 0
600-800 9 617-847 G-trace?
8CL-200 4 663-901 c-trace?
Values for the root cultures are the sum of intracellular and extracellular alkaloid, and are averaged over
two culture cycles.
Hyoscyamine Scopolamine
Species (pgg-.’ fr. wt)
Table 5. The alkaloid composition of transformed roots of a variety of solanaceous species as determined by gas chromatography*
Norhygrinet - - - 1 2 5
Hygrine 2 5 8 2 5 7 2 3 4
Tropinone - - - - - -
Tropine 4 1 5 2 8 3 2 3 2 15
Pseudotropine - - - 1 1
3-AcetoxynortropaneS - - - 1 8
3-a-Acetoxytropane 1 - 1 37 2 1 1 - 11
3-B-Acetoxytropane - - 1 - 1 - - 6
3-Acetoxy-6-hydroxytropane - 4 - - - - - -
3-Hydroxy-6-acetoxytropane§ 1 - - - - - -
3,6-Diacetoxytropane 11 2 2 4 1 - -
3-TigloyloxynortropaneT - - - - - - 6
3-Tigloyloxytropane - - 1 4 4 2 - - - - -
Cuscohygrine 1 2 1 1 2 - 2 7 1
3-Tigloyloxy-6-hydroxytropane 1 - 2 4 2 4 - - - - -
3-Hydroxy-6-tigloyloxytropane - - - 2 - - -
3-Tigloyloxy-6-acetoxytropane - - - - 2 - - -
@I,) 325** 1 2 2 - - - - -
Hyoscyamine 85 82 60 24 39 26 52 59 81 34 49
3,6-Ditigloyloxytropane 1 - 1 1 1 - - - - ?
Scopolamine - 1 3 1 18 25 9 16 2 14
3,6-Ditigloyloxy-7-hydroxytropane 2 3 4 3 - 1 - - - ?
6-Hydroxyhyoscyamine - - 3 - 3 1 1 -
W,) 414-w - - - 8 3 - - 1
Figures indicate the percentage contribution from each alkaloid at a level of 1% or more of the total alkaloid.
*A small amount of decomposition of tropoyl eaters occurs during extraction and chromatography; any of the apoderivatives
detected have been included in with the parent compounds for quantitation, since broadly similar amounts were also seen in
chromatograms obtained from the purified parent alkaloids. No values are quoted for the low levels of 3-phenylacetoxytropane and
3-phenylacetoxy-6,7-epoxytropane found since a proportion of these too may be artifactual.
t-t? Massspeetral data for new or unusual alkaloids. CC-MS 70 eV, m/z (rel. int.):
t: 127 (10) 84 (15) 70 (100) 56 (21)
$: 169 (10) 126 (3) 110 (100) 80 (23)
0: 199 (30) 156 (6) 140 (10) 122 (12) 113 (100) 96 (43)
I(:241 (30) 198 (5) 182 (24) 155 (13) 138 (11) 122 (58) 94 (100)
7: 209 (19) 194 (10) 126 (2) 110 (100) 80 (20) Two isomers (a, /3?)detected
**: 325 (1) 307 (15) 237 (6) 220 (11) 138 (65) 137 (52) 94 (100)
tt: 414 (2) 292 (2) 290 (2) 142 (3) 124 (48) 84 (100)
variation in the ratio of hyoscyamine to scopolamine, differences in plants no doubt to some extent reflect the
differences between species proved to be the dominant influence of transport and partitioning on alkaloid levels,
factor. additional factors probably act to cause the decreased
Clearly a large pool of genetic variation exists which variation seen in root cultures. For instance in many root
can be exploited in the production of tropane alkaloids. It cultures there is a substantial utilisation of the tropane
has been found that Agrobacterium rhizogenes-trans- nucleus in the formation of simple acetoxy esters rather
formed root cultures tend to reflect the genetic character- than hyoscyamine or scopolamine. This is particularly
istics of the parent plants [2,3], so one way potentially to true in D. wrightii where almost 50% of the root alkaloid
exploit this variation is to develop transformed root lines. is in the form of 3-acetoxy derivatives. A similar accumu-
Our evidence indicates that substantial variation is in- lation of 3-acetoxytropane is also seen in transformed
deed carried over to the in oitro transformed root system, roots of Withania somnifera Dunal (unpublished observa-
as for example shown by the characteristic differences in tions). On the other hand, although small amounts were
the patterns of tropane alkaloids found in different genera detected in D. wrightii (data not shown), in intact plants
and species. On a quantitative level, the amounts of acetoxytropanes are rarely observed in substantial
hyoscyamine and/or scopolamine found in root cultures amounts (J. G. Woolley, personal communication) and
do not, however, show such marked variation as is some of the compounds identified in root cultures, e.g.
observed in the aerial parts of intact plants. While such 3,6_diacetoxytropane, have yet to be found [13]. It would
2550 A. J. PARR et al
appear that in culture ‘excess’ tropine is being generated necessary to base identification on similarity of retention times
and, rather than being left as the free alcohol, is acetyla- with compounds positively identified in other cultures. Quan-
ted. Why it is not esterified to form the normal tropane titation of alkaloids on CC was possible by assuming all
alkaloids has yet to be elucidated. This effect might occur compounds containing one nitrogen atom to respond similarly
because sub-culturing disturbs the normal patterns of on the nitrogen detector. Where standards were available to test
tropine and esterifying acid production, or perhaps be- this assumption, it was found to be substantially correct. It
cause the presence of the growth medium perturbs metab- should be noted that because the last step in the extraction of the
elite compartmentation by providing an alternative stor- alkaloids involves a partition into chloroform under alkaline
age pool. In contrast to the situation in many systems [2, conditions, highly polar alkaloids such as tropine will be slightly
33, in the case of tropane alkaloid production by solan- under-represented in the final sample. No effort was made to
aceous species the conditions in culture may thus some- correct for this, because the possibility of artifactual production
times be unfavourable for the full expression of a line’s of tropine by hydrolysis of alkaloid during the extraction process
potential biosynthetic capacity. Nevertheless, we have means that there are already other uncertainties in the pool size
found that many features identified in selected plants are of this particular alkaloid.
carried over into culture. The initial screening of plant
populations, perhaps followed by a further round of Acknowledgements---We thank the following Botanic and other
screening on the cultures produced, thus appears to be Gardens for supplying seed material: Kew, U.K.; Chelsea Physic
valuable in the generation of scientifically and biotec- Garden, U.K.; University of London, U.K.; Cluj-Napoca, Rum-
hnologically useful root cultures. ania; Research Centre for Agrobotany, Tipioszele, Hungary and
Zentralinstitut fur Genetik und Kulturpflanzenforschung, Gate-
rsleben, D.D.R. Dr W. C. Evans kindly provided shoot cuttings
of the Datura candida x aurea hybrid ‘B5’. We are grateful to Dr
EXPERIMENTAL
N. J. Walton for advice and assistance in many areas; to Judith
Plants. Seeds were obtained from a variety of Botanic Gardens Furze, Elizabeth Bent and Abigael Peerless for excellent tech-
and commercial sources throughout Europe. The following nical help; and to John Nicol (AFRC Institute of Plant Science
material was investigated: Datura stramonium L. (including Research, John Innes Institute), for help in obtaining many of the
varieties stramonium, inermis, tatula and godronii), D. innoxia seeds.
Mill., D.ferox L., D. fastuosa L., D. aiba Nees, D. metel L., D.
discolor Bernh., D. quercijoliu H.B.K., D. leichhardtii F. Muell. ex
Benth. subsp. pruinosa, D. sanguinea Ruiz et Pav., D. wrightii
REFERENCES
Regel, D. ceratocaula Ort., Scopolia stramonijolia Semenova, S.
lurida Dunal, Hyoscyamus aureus L., H. albus L., H. muticus L., 1. Hamill, J. D., Parr, A. J., Rhodes, M. J. C., Robins, R. J. and
H. canariensis Ker., H. desertorum Tlckh., H. turcomanicus Walton, N. J. (1987). Bio/technology 5, 800.
Pojark., H. pusihus L. and the hybrid H x gyoerfji Hammer et 2. Hamill, J. D., Parr, A. J., Rhodes, M. J. C. and Robins, R. J.
Melchers. In addition cuttings of the tree Datura hybrid D. (1986). Plant Cell Reports 5, 111.
candida Pasq. x aurea Lagerh. ‘BS described by El-Dabbas and 3. Parr, A. J. and Hamill, J. D. (1987). Phytochemistry 26. 3241.
Evans [IO] were also available. 4. Parr, A. J. (1989) J. Biotechnol. 10, 1.
Seeds were treated overnight with 250 mg 1-r gibberellin GA, 5. Knopp, E., Strauss, A. and Wehrli. W. (1988). Plant Cell
(Sigma) to facilitate germination, then planted in soil. The Reports 7. 590.
resulting plants---l0 to 40 per accession--were grown under 6. Parr, A. J., Hamill, J. D., Payne, J., Rhodes, M. J. C., Robins,
greenhouse conditions, during June and July. When the fourth R. J. and Walton, N. J. (1988). in Maniptdating Secondary
true leaf had expanded to equal the size of the third (typically by Metabolism in Culture (Robins. R. J. and Rhodes, M. J. C.,
334 weeks post-germination), this fourth leaf was excised and the (eds), p. 101. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
alkaloid content of the petiole determined by HPLC. 7. Plank, K.-H. and Wagner. K. G. (1986) %. Natmforsch. 41C,
Root cultures. Surface-sterilized leaves or stems were in- 391.
oculated with Agrobacterium rhizogenes LBA9402, in order to 8. Hashimoto, T. and Yamada, Y. (1986) Plant Physiol. 81,619.
generate transformed root cultures [I]. Such cultures were 9. Rhodes, M. J. C., Robins, R. J., Aird, E. L. H., Payne, J., Parr,
maintained on a medium based upon Gamborg’s B.5 nutrients A. J. and Walton, N. J. (1989) in Primary and Secondary
(Flow Labs Inc., Irvine, Scotland) plus 30 gl-’ sucrose as Metabolism of Plant Gel/ Cultures, II (Kurz, W. J. W., ed.),
described in ref. [14], who also give details of the other culture p. 58. Springer, Berlin.
conditions employed. While roots of most species grew well in 10. El-Dabbas, S. W. and Evans, W. C. (1982) Pianta Med. 44,
media containing full strength salts, Hyoscyamus albus and H. 184.
pusillus required the B5 nutrients at half strength for best growth. 11. Robins, R. J., Parr, A. J., Payne, J., Walton, N. J. and Rhodes,
Alkaloids were extracted from the roots and culture medium M. J. C. (1990). Planta (in press).
after 3&35 days and prepared for quantitation of hyoscyamine 12. Mano, Y, Nabeshima, S., Matsui. C. and Ohkawa, H. (1986)
and scopolamine by HPLC. Subsequently a full analysis of Agric. Biol. Chem. SO, 2715.
tropane alkaloids in these samples was performed by CC and 13. Lounasmaa, M. (1988) in The Alkaloids vol. 33 (Brossi, A.,
CC/MS. ed.), p. 1. Academic Press, San Diego.
Analytical methods. Procedures for alkaloid extraction and 14. Payne, J., Hamill, J. D., Robins, R. J. and Rhodes, M. J. C.
HPLC analysis were described in ref. [14]. CC and GC-MS (1987) Planta Med. 53, 474.
analysis were essentially as described in refs [ 15, 161. Alkaloids 15. Hartmann, T., Witte, L., Oprach, G. and Toppel, G. (1986)
were identified on CC traces principally on the basis of their Planta Med. 390.
fragmentation patterns observed in parallel CC-MS runs, but in 16. Witte, L., Miiller, K. and Arfmann, H.-A. (1987) Planta Med.
the case of some more minor components it was sometimes 53, 192.