Professional Documents
Culture Documents
contact with CO2. These reactions lead to an impairment of the cement surface through a time-dependence phenomenon and may
material (Barlet-Gouédard et al. 2005). induce a decrease of compressive strength. Experimental results
Another important problem that will not be addressed here is are difficult to interpret because several minerals can dissolve or
the role and behavior of interface between caprocks and cement precipitate simultaneously, but a severe depletion of calcium on
on one hand and between cement and casing on the other hand. It the outer layer is generally observed. Recently, it was shown that
is suspected that interfaces degradation caused by chemical reac- the formation of a layer rich in calcium carbonate may retard the
tions or mechanical stresses occurring during the life cycles of the leaching phenomenon but does not stop it (Barlet-Gouédard et al.
well (injection/reservoir compression, abandonment) can lead to 2005; Duguid et al. 2005).
the formation of fluid-migration pathways. In that case, risks of When in contact with acidic aqueous solutions, acid attack of
leakage through these pathways could be much higher than those cement-based materials takes place. In the course of acid attack,
expected through bulk-altered cement or corroded steel casing. H3O+ ions penetrate within the cement matrix and dissolve solid
Published data on degradation mechanisms of cement-based hydration products. Experimental works have shown that the
materials exposed to pure H2S or H2S/CO2 environments are more alteration of the cement-based materials depends on the chemical
scarce (Krilov et al. 2000; Jacquemet et al. 2005). Jacquemet et al. composition of cement as well as the pH of the acid solution. The
(2005) investigated the durability of cement paste aged in brine rate of the degradation is strongly linked to acid concentration
with acid gas (66% molar H2S + 34% molar CO2) at 50 MPa and and to the type and amount of hydrated phases involved in the
200°C. They conducted experiments in carefully controlled con- reactions. For example, dissolution of ferrite or aluminate phases
ditions (pH, Eh) providing reliable results for chemical reactions. and the induced leaching of Fe3+ and Al3+ is slower and occurs at
They showed that the initial tobermorite phase has been converted lower pH values than the depletion of Ca2+ from portlandite. As
into a calcium-depleted one. The released calcium from calcium the pH decreases, portlandite (pH stability equal to 12.6), CSH
silicate hydrates (CSHs) was combined with carbon aqueous spe- (pH stability ≈ 10–11), calcium aluminate, and ferrite hydrates
cies to form calcite. Pyrite formation is observed because of the are successively dissolved. The ultimate material is a silica gel
reaction between H2S, C4AF, and steel. Nonetheless, the authors when pH is les than approximately 2. For pH ranging between 4
did not study the evolution of the microstructure (pore-size dis- and 6–7, depleted-calcium hydrates remain with residual aluminate
tribution for instance) or the physical properties (such as water and ferrite hydrates.
permeability) of their degraded cement pastes. Aging in sour gas
(150 ppm of H2S and 22% of CO2) brine has been studied by Krilov Experimental
et al. (2000). It is generally observed that carbonation occurs on the Aging of Cementitious Materials in a Reservoir Fluid. In this
experiment, the aging fluid corresponds to API fluid specification
16 (i.e., a mixture of seawater, hydrocarbon, and gas, as detailed
TABLE 1—COMPOSITION OF THE AGING FLUID in Table 1). Aging tests were performed in IFP facilities close to
Hydrocarbons (diesel type II) Lyon. This area was specifically designed for H2S safety environ-
47% parafins ment. Tests were performed at 120°C and 7 MPa in an agitated
50% vol vessel so that gas/liquid contact is maintained during aging. A
32% naphtens
photograph of the aging vessel is given in Fig. 2. Similar aging
11% alkylbenzene tests were performed in lime-saturated water for comparison.
Brine (sea water) Three cement systems have been tested: a high performance
4 g/L Na 2S04 cement, named Cement I; a classical mortar (which is a blend of
20% vol cement powder and sand); and an ordinary oilwell-cement slurry
11 g/L MgCl 2
(water/cement weight ratio of 0.44). The latter two are used for
1 g/L CaCl 2 comparison. The composition of the Cement I system is detailed in
Gas Table 2. Cement I is a low-permeability material, and its properties
85% CH 4 were described previously (Dubois et al. 1999; Noïk et al. 1998).
30% vol Aging tests lasted from 1 to 12 months. More than 200 cement
5% CO2
specimens have been tested. For each exposure time, different mea-
10% H2S surements were performed: variation of sample weight, variation
of sample volume, variation of compressive strength, and variation cylinders 2.5 cm in diameter and 5.0 cm in height. During the first
of flexural strength and water permeability. hours, a decrease of the pressure was observed because of the
solubilization of H2S in the brine. The pressure of H2S was then
Aging of Cementitious Materials in an H2S-Saturated Brine. In adjusted to maintain a value of 15 MPa.
this experiment, aging fluid is a brine pressurized with H2S. The These samples were aged for 7 and 21 days. The ratio of the vol-
composition of the brine is given in Table 3. ume of fluid to the volume of cement specimens was approximately 2.
Experiments were carried out in pressurized cells of the type The fluid was not renewed during the aging, but the control of H2S
shown in Fig. 2. Two cement-based materials have been tested. pressure maintained a constant pH (≈ 4) throughout the test. Only
The first one is a conventional portland oilwell-cement slurry with the results of the 21-day aging are presented in this paper.
a water/cement weight ratio equal to 0.44. No additives, except a
defoamer, were incorporated in the formulation. The second tested Results and Discussion
formulation, named Cement II hereafter, is a high performance Aging of Cement-Based Materials in a Reservoir Fluid. As can
cement whose composition is given in Table 4. be seen in Fig. 3, diesel is absorbed into the different materials and
All the samples were cured at 80°C and 7 MPa. Tests were per- especially into those presenting the higher permeability. Diesel is
formed at 120°C and 15 MPa in a nonagitated cell. All the cement even desorbing from the mortar specimen after its removal from
specimens were immersed in H2S-saturated brine. Specimens were the aging vessel. This observation is correlated with the increase
350 Mortar
Cement I
250
200
150
100
50
0
0 2 4 6 8 10 12
Time (month)
Fig. 4 —Variations of the compressive strength of Cement I, mortar, and cement paste vs. time.
Fig. 5 —X-ray tomography images of an ordinary cement slurry (left) and Cement II (right) after aging in H2S-saturated brine.
brine. With such high porosity values, one can expect high perme- that of conventional cement materials (oilwell-cement slurry and
ability levels. Table 6 summarizes the results of water-permeability mortar) because of the very low porosity impeding the transport
measurements for the tested materials. of aggressive species within the cement matrix.
As expected, the increase of water permeability after H2S Conditions prevailing after the abandonment of H2S-injector
exposure is very high. The permeability of degraded cement slurry wells are dramatic for the integrity of Portland-cement-based
is increased by two orders of magnitude, and the permeability of materials. Ordinary Portland-cement slurry and the Cement II
the degraded Cement II is multiplied by 104. Although the initial system are rapidly and highly damaged. The very-acidic condi-
permeability of Cement II is very low, its final value is similar to tions explain such a behavior. Hydrated phases present in the
that of the degraded cement slurry. The increased porosity and per- cement matrix are leached: Portlandite is totally dissolved from the
meability are probably linked to strong chemical modifications of ordinary cement paste, and silicate calcium hydrates are severely
the matrix. Therefore, the mineralogy of degraded cement systems decalcified. Both phenomena induce a sharp increase of the poros-
has been investigated by X-ray diffraction (XRD). Phase identifica- ity and the mechanical weakening of the materials. Because of the
tion showed the presence of pyrite, ettringite, and calcium sulfates. extreme environmental conditions tested, the kinetics of the deg-
Peaks of very low intensity corresponding to calcium carbonate radation observed in the laboratory is undoubtedly overestimated
(CaCO3) (aragonite, calcite) were also observed; the presence of when compared to an actual in-situ alteration rate. However, the
CaCO3 is caused by a partial carbonation of the samples occurring evidenced degradation state of the cement will occur in the well
during the specimen handling. The diffuse peak at 0.27–0.31 nm after a certain time. Future research projects should be initiated to
corresponding to CSHs still exists, but its intensity is very low. determine the time scale at which this degradation state will appear,
This low-intensity and diffuse peak probably means that CSHs are implying that, at that time, Portland cement will no longer play
leached and amorphous silica gel is formed. XRD did not reveal the its barrier role. Finally, to ensure the long-term confinement of
presence of anhydrous phases (for instance C2S or C4AF), nor port- reinjected H2S, alternative cementing materials have to be designed
landite and hydrogarnet, also named katoite [Ca3Al2(SiO4)(OH)8]. to plug and abandon wells successfully.
The absence of peaks corresponding to these crystallized phases
indicates that the matrix has been severely leached. This explains Acknowledgments
the very high porosity and permeability values observed. The authors would like to thank Elisabeth Rosenberg and Corinne
Although Cement II specimens were not homogeneously Fichen for X-ray tomography experiments and Jean-François Pillot
degraded, uniaxial-compressive-strength measurements have been for his help in preparing samples and measuring the mechanical
performed on the two tested cement systems. The results are given properties. They are also grateful to Joseph Martin, Frederic Hil-
in Table 7. lion, Pascal Clermont, and Denis Bonnet for having performed
We can notice a sharp decrease of the mechanical resistance aging tests in IFP-Lyon.
of the degraded samples. The compressive strength of the cement
paste is divided by 23.5, and the compressive strength of Cement References
II by only 9. The impairment of mechanical integrity of Cement II Barlet-Gouédard, V., Ramakrishnan, T.S., Bennaceur, K., Supp, M., Goffé,
is lower compared to that of the ordinary-cement paste. B., Rimmelé, G., and Nelson, E. 2005. Mitigation Strategies for CO2
To summarize, the aging of Portland-cement-based materials Migration through Wellbores. Presented at the Fourth Annual Confer-
in H2S-saturated brine under pressure and temperature is critical. ence on Carbon Capture and Sequestration DOE/NETL, Alexandria,
Portlandite and katoite are dissolved. The weakening of the materials Virginia, USA, 2–5 May.
is related to calcium leaching (dissolution of Portlandite and decalci- Benge, G. and Dew, E.G. 2005. Meeting the Challenges in Design and
fied CSH), inducing a high porosity increase. The impairment of the Execution of Two High Rate Acid Gas Injection Wells. Paper SPE
properties of the cement system cannot be explained by strength ret- 91861 presented at the SPE/IADC Drilling Conference, Amsterdam,
rogression occurring above 120°C. Indeed, Cement II incorporating 23–25 February. doi: 10.2118/91861-MS.
silica fume for impeding strength retrogression (Le Saoût et al. 2004) Bosma, M., Ravi, K., van Driel, W., and Schreppers, G.J. 1999. Design
appears also highly degraded. Therefore, the severe deterioration of Approach to Sealant Selection for the Life of the Well. Paper SPE
Portland-cement-based materials properties is a direct consequence 56536 presented at the SPE Annual Technical Conference and Exhibi-
of the calcium leaching of the matrix. However, it is worth noticing tion, Houston, 3–6 October. doi: 10.2118/56536-MS.
that the aging tests were performed at pH ≈4, which is a very low Dubois, N., Noïk, C., Rivereau, A., and Vernet, C. 1999. Improvement
value, probably much lower than expected in the field. of Low-Permeable Cement for Zonal Isolation at High-Temperature
Conditions. Paper SPE 50782 presented at the SPE International
Conclusions and Perspectives Symposium on Oilfield Chemistry, Houston, 16–19 February. doi:
Laboratory results show that the production period should not be 10.2118/50782-MS.
critical from a chemical point of view for the integrity of cement Duguid, A., Radonjic, M., and Scherer, G. 2005. Degradation of well
annulus located in the reservoir. Even when sour gases are present, cements exposed to carbonated brine. Presented at the Fourth Annual
the limited amount of water should impede deleterious chemical Conference on Carbon Capture and Sequestration DOE/NETL, Alex-
reactions inducing a degradation of Portland cement. However, andria, Virginia, USA, 2–5 May.
these conclusions should be confirmed on a longer time scale Jacquemet, N., Pironon, J., and Caroli, E. 2005. A new experimental pro-
and/or for higher content of sour gases. Indeed, presence of acid cedure for simulation of H2S and CO2 geological storage: application
gases dissolved in water should lead to the degradation of the to well cement ageing. Oil & Gas Science and Technology—Rev. IFP
Portland-cement matrix. But in the conditions tested during this 60 (3): 193–203.
work, the acid attack is less obvious than the degradation occurring Krilov, Z., Loncaric, B., and Miksa, Z. 2000. Investigation of a Long-Term
in acidic aqueous solutions (typically brine saturated with sour Cement Deterioration Under a High-Temperature, Sour Gas Downhole
gases). The aging behavior of the Cement I system is better than Environment. Paper SPE 58771 presented at the SPE International