You are on page 1of 103

A SUPERWOMAN.

TOUGH PROBLEMS
INSPIRE ME.”
PRAETOR 600: CERTIFIED
OUTPERFORMANCE.
The Praetor 600 — the world’s most disruptive and technologically
advanced super-midsize aircraft that leads the way in
performance, comfort and technology.

Unveiled at NBAA in October 2018 and now certified by ANAC,


FAA and EASA, the Praetor 600 did not just meet initial
expectations, it exceeded them. Named for the Latin root that
means “lead the way,” the Praetor 600 is a jet of firsts. It is the
first super-midsize jet to fly beyond 3,700 nm at M0.80. The first
with over 4,000 nm range at LRC. The first with full fly-by-wire.
The first with turbulence reduction capability. The first with a
cabin altitude as low as 5,800 feet. The first with high-capacity,
ultra-high-speed connectivity from Viasat’s Ka-band. And all of
this, backed by a top-ranked Customer Support network.

Learn more at executive.embraer.com/praetor600

L E A D I N G T H E WAY
April/May 2021 Volume 204 | Number 2

12
INSIDE
CONTENTS

80 | A Billionaire a Day
This year Forbes tracked down
a record 493 new billionaires—
roughly one every 17 hours.
Just over 40% hail from China;
20% are from the U.S. Promi-
nent routes to new riches:
IPOs, SPACs, cryptocurrencies
and Covid-related health care.
Edited by Kerry A. Dolan with
Chase Peterson-Withorn and
Jennifer Wang

STEFEN CHOW FOR FORBES

FORBES.COM A P R I L / M AY 2 0 2 1
14
CONTENTS

106

April/May 2021

70 88 96 106
COVER CREDITS
COVER STORY
Operation One-Woman The Friendly PHOTOGRAPHERS:

Wealth Speed Show Revenge of Assassin


CAMERON AND TYLER
WINKLEVOSS:
Michael Prince for Forbes

Covid-19 brought Judy Faulkner, the The Winklevii David Vélez set out to KATE WANG:
Stefen Chow for Forbes
terrible suffering, eco- billionaire founder After losing an epic kill off the fat fees and
DAVID VÉLEZ:
nomic pain, geopolitical of Epic Systems, battle with Mark Zuck- lousy service of Brazil’s Gabriel Rinaldi for Forbes
tension—and the pioneered—then erberg over ownership big banks. The opera- AUSTIN RUSSELL:
greatest acceleration dominated—electronic of Facebook and being tion succeeded beyond Michael Prince for Forbes
of wealth in human medical records. She shunned in Silicon Val- his wildest dreams: JUDY FAULKNER:
Jamel Toppin for Forbes
history. Why this has been the industry’s ley, Cameron and Tyler Today, his no-fee
pandemic paradox leading actor for Winklevoss are back— Nubank is the most
could become cause decades, but now the as budding Bitcoin bil- valuable digital bank
for celebration, not pandemic is fueling a lionaires at the center in the world, with 35
concern. digital health-care race of not only the future of million customers—and
that may finally cost money but the creative he’s gunning for more.
GABRIEL RINALDI FOR FORBES

By Randall Lane
her the spotlight. economy, and quite pos-
By Jeff Kauflin,
sibly a new operating Maria Abreu and
By Katie Jennings
model for Big Tech itself. Antoine Gara
By Michael del Castillo,
Susan Adams and
Antoine Gara

FORBES.COM A P R I L / M AY 2 0 2 1
ETFs MAY BE GOOD FOR
THE PLANET.
YOUR BOTTOM LINE.
ETFs MAY BE GOOD FOR

Invest in something bigger.

Visit www.iShares.com to view a prospectus, which includes investment


objectives risks, fees, expenses and other information that you should read
and consider carefully before investing. Risks include principal loss. A fund’s
environmental, social and governance (“ESG”) investment strategy limits the types and number of investment opportunities
available to the fund and, as a result, the fund may underperform other funds that do not have an ESG focus. BlackRock
Investments, LLC distributor. ©2021 BlackRock, Inc. iSHARES and BLACKROCK are trademarks of BlackRock, Inc., or its
subsidiaries in the United States and elsewhere. ICRMH0920U-1323574
FRONTRUNNER

25 | The Sky’s No Limit


Jeff Bezos and Elon Musk’s battle to be the wealthiest
in the galaxy. Plus: The world’s 50 richest people.

16 30 | Left Their Mark


Twenty-three billionaires died last year. Sixty-one others
dropped out of the ranks entirely, including Kylie Jenner.
CONTENTS

32 | Goldfingers
Our 20th annual Midas List of the world’s most
successful venture capitalists.
36 | 30 Under 30: Indoor Outfitters
Work-from-home apparel, in 30 words or less.
38 | World of Forbes
Around the globe with our 35 international editions.
40 | Buy, Hold, Sell
Snap up that Manhattan pied-à-terre; sell the Chevy.
42 | Trump’s Bad Bet
Refusing to divest cost the former president some
$1.6 billion. Plus: President Biden’s growing net worth.
44 | Conversation
32 Readers debate the brusque management style of
software billionaire Frank Slootman, Snowflake’s CEO.

CONTRARIAN

INNOVATION

47 | Scene Stealer
Vimeo wasted its youth trying to be an oddball combo
of Netflix and YouTube. Refocusing on business users,
CEO Anjali Sud has transformed it into a $6 billion
blockbuster. By Steven Bertoni and Antoine Gara

CHRISTIE HEMM KLOK FOR FORBES; JAMEL TOPPIN FOR FORBES; MICHAEL HOEWELER FOR FORBES
STRATEGIES
50 | American Sun
Dean Solon built a multibillion-dollar fortune in solar
energy by manufacturing gear that can be made more
cheaply in China. How? Higher quality. By Chris Helman
CIO NETWORK

56 | The Road Less Traveled


Most tech unicorns are the product of Silicon Valley
VCs. Not Cloudinary. The marketing-software maker
has gone its own route since day one. By Martin Giles
MONEY & INVESTING
60 | The Teflon Trader
Wall Street legend Carl Icahn is on a seven-year
losing streak, but the market still loves his stock. 47
By Nathan Vardi

SPECIAL SECTION
21 | Fact & Comment States that have lifted lockdowns
65 | America’s Top demonstrate that the nation would be better off if all
followed their lead. By Steve Forbes
Women Wealth Advisors
By Jason Bisnoff and SHOOK Research 116 | Thoughts on Ownership

FORBES.COM A P R I L / M AY 2 0 2 1
SIDELINES

Today’s Opportunities, April/May 2021 • Volume 204 | Number 2

Tomorrow’s Leaders CHAIRMAN AND EDITOR-IN-CHIEF: STEVE FORBES; CEO AND PRESIDENT: MICHAEL FEDERLE
EDITORIAL

18 RANDALL LANE, Chief Content Officer


Executive Editors: Caroline Howard, Luisa Kroll, Kerry Lauerman, Michael Noer; Managing Editor: Joyce
This year’s Billionaires list, which over the course of Bautista Ferrari
Assistant Managing Editors: Jessica Bohrer (Editorial Counsel), Kerry A. Dolan, Alice Jackson-Jolley, Brett Knight,
the pandemic year added a net 493 new members Rob LaFranco, Rashaad Lambert (Culture & Community), Janet Novack, Michael Ozanian, Jennifer Rooney,
FORBES

Matt Schifrin, Michael Solomon, Jeff Taylor


and more than $5 trillion in wealth, will surely make Senior Editors: Susan Adams, Maneet Ahuja, Dan Alexander, Steven Bertoni, Jeremy Bogaisky, Abram Brown, Dawn
Chmielewski, John Dobosz, Amy Feldman, Antoine Gara, Martin Giles, Christopher Helman, Alex Knapp, Alex Konrad,
worldwide headlines for all the obvious reasons. Alan Ohnsman, Susan Radlauer (Research), Tina Russo McCarthy, Halah Touryalai, Nathan Vardi, Merrill Vaughn
Deputy Editors: Colleen Curry, Steven Ehrlich, Iain Martin, Andrea Murphy, Chase Peterson-Withorn, Helen
But as I note in our cover essay (page 70), we’re in A.S. Popkin, Glenda Toma, Vicky Valet, Jennifer Wang, Taesik Yoon; Associate Editors: Thomas Brewster, Michael
del Castillo, Julius Juenemann, Jeffrey Kauflin, Maggie McGrath, Marty Swant, Isabel Togoh, Alexandra Wilson
a moment of profound change, with so many good Staff Writers: Angel Au-Yeung, David Axe, Madeline Berg, Jason Bisnoff, Lauren Debter, Kevin Dowd, David Jeans,
Katie Jennings, Suzanne Rowan Kelleher, Noah Kirsch, Scott Mendelson, Dwight Silverman, Chloe Sorvino, Kristin
things portending a future of broad prosperity. Stoller, Rebecca Szkutak, Michela Tindera, William Yakowicz
Reporters: Justin Conklin, Katherine Love (Managers, Editorial Operations); Thomas Beer, Jack Brewster, Kenrick
Part of that change revolves around Cai, Deniz Çam, Elizabeth Daffin, David Dawkins, Alison Durkee, Brianne Garrett, Sarah Hansen, Sergei Klebnikov,
Tanya Klich, Jemima McEvoy, Jonathan Ponciano, Carlie Porterfield, Nicholas Reimann, Leah Rosenbaum, Rachel
companies recognizing their role as a Sandler, Christina Settimi, Ariel Shapiro, Andrew Solender, Alexandra Sternlicht, Giacomo Tognini, Hank Tucker,
Lisette Voytko, Joe Walsh IV
positive influence, including a commit- Assistant Editors: Maria Abreu, Nina Bambysheva (Digital Assets Analyst), Margherita Beale, Justin Birnbaum,
Elisabeth Brier, Abigail Freeman, Eliza Haverstock, Christian Kreznar, Sofia Lotto Persio, Aayushi Pratap, Kristin
ment to look more like the world around Tablang, Samantha Todd, Nina Wolpow
Art and Production: Alicia Hallett-Chan (Design Director); Merrilee Barton, Charles Brucaliere, Fernando Capeto,
them. That’s particularly true for places Nick DeSantis, Suzanne O’Neill, Robyn Selman, Philip Smith, Gail Toivanen
like Forbes, which help shape ideas and Audience Development: Social Media: Cliff Benston (Director); Lindsey Burns, Caroline Dilone, Dario Foroutan, Evan
Spadaccini. Newsletters: Nick Shippers, Rachel Thomas
terms of debate for millions. Video: Tim Pierson (Director); Greg Andersson, Leah Bottone, Meghan Christensen, Ivan Clow, Travis Collins, Julia
Ferrier, Marc Gomes, Nick Graham, Riley Hallaway, Matthew Kang, Kieran Krug-Meadows, Chad McClymonds,
In that spirit, we’re trying to do some- Juliet Muir, Bernard Osei, Jonathan Palmer, Brian Petchers, Morgan Sun, Kirsten Taggart
SALES AND MARKETING
thing that not only makes our newsroom JESSICA SIBLEY, Chief Revenue Officer
Ad Sales: Manni Arango, Maria Aiza Contro, Aaron Andrews, Julia Aziz, Jake Bell, Jessica Blitzer, Leann Bonanno,
better but helps repair the pipeline for busi- Marissa Brown, Jeremy Campbell, Shae Carroll, Seema Chaudhari, Julie Chisar, Ruth Chute-Manning, Alexandra
Cohn, Jennifer Cooke, Jennifer Crowe, Sarah Curry, Hannah Davidson, Leigh Day, Jessica Desmond, Sean Downey,
ness journalism overall. Please meet the Emilie Errante, Taylor Felgenhauer, Olivia Gelade, Louisa Goujon, Janett Haas, Shauna Haras, Megan Hennessey,
Matthew Herrmann, William Hosinski, Catherine Hughes, Victoria Kreher, Martina Landeka, Jordan Loredo, Brian
first class of Forbes Fellows, in partnership McLeod, Ayisha Mendez, Tara Michaels, Leah Monroe, Bianca Olivas, Akshay Patel, Ryan Queler, Paul Reiss,
Melanie Ruderman, Jesse Silberfein, Abbey Smith, Rebecca Taroon, William Thompson (SVP), Laura Villaraut, Kyle
with Morehouse College and other His- Vinansky, Elliot Vinzon, Adam Wallitt, Alex Wood, Casey Zonfrilli
Brand Strategy/Marketing/Partnerships: Lynn Schlesinger (Chief Marketing Officer); Gaston Alegre, Rachel
torically Black Colleges and Universities. Aquino, Kate Bishop, Erika Burho, Nicholas Clunn, James Colistra, Danielle Collins, Connor Davis, Krystle Davis,
William Delehanty, Meghan Donovan, Martine Ehrhart, Samantha Evans, Erica Ferraro, Moira Forbes (EVP, Forbes-
These talented HBCU students and recent Women), Kristine Francisco, Ross Gagnon, Cara Gilmartin, Sahara Gipson, Ashley Grado, Adelaide Hill, Olivia Hine,
Merryl Holland, Amani Hussain, Kari Jones, Nicolette Jones, Nicole Lamastra, Jessica Lantz, Juliana Longo, Brian
graduates will report and write stories, Lee, Douglas Lopenzina, Erika Maguire, Julie McGovern, Scott McGrath, James Mentzinger, Sophia Minassian,
Antonio Morales, Sade Muhammad, Alexis Murillo, Morgan O’Hare, Romy Oltuski, Jahcelyne Patton, Jennifer Ramos,
take classes with Forbes staffers and receive Allison Rickert, Claire Robinson, Joshua Robinson, Danielle Rubino, Claire Ryan, Peter Sarnoff, Andrey Slivka, Allyson
Souza, Kara Stiles, Ashka Thaker, Rashaad Denzel Toney, Meenal Vamburkar, Jason Webster, Janet Yin
direct mentoring. This idea stemmed from Digital Revenue Operations: Rebeca Solorzano (SVP), Alyson Williams (SVP); Ashley Alexander, James Barry, Sergiu
Bucur, Lisa Chiobi, Rachel Goroff, Lauren Gurnee, Jayson Ildefonso, Victor Lee, Emily Lewis, Nicole Lewitinn, Kelly
a breakfast I had just before the pandemic Mui, Melis Ocal, Casey Riordan, Steven Song, Jacqueline Subramaniam
ForbesLive: Sherry Phillips (SVP); Andrew Appelbaum, Jessica Charles, Chardia Christophe, Brett Cohen,
with Robert F. Smith, the richest Black Alex Engel, Madie Federle, Delisha Fields, Julieanna Gray, Kayla Jennings-Rivera, Nicole Kerno, Susan Kessler,
Michael Martin, Sydney Melin, Menaka Menon, Jimmy Okuszka, Mary Margaret Soderquist, Erika Speed,
American and a big HBCU supporter. It Elizabeth Pitonyak, Shelby Tompkins, Blair Walther
DIGITAL
came to life during the pandemic, courtesy NINA GOULD, Chief Product Officer; VADIM SUPITSKIY, Chief Technology Officer
of Assistant Managing Editor Ali Jackson- Product: Ebony Shears; Terrence Agbi, Jennifer Bruno, Youssef Drihmi, David Feldman, Nina Foroutan, Kelly Hanshaw,
Erica Ho, Mike Medric, Carlee Murray, Martin Navarrete, Alex Noonan, Ivan Parra-Orlandoni, Javier Paz, Dayne
Jolley. And it will pay dividends long after Richards, Grant Tunkel, Christina Wang, Katie Ward, Mila Wentrys
Corporate Tech: Peter Hahm; Jiten Bhojwani, Christopher Frank, Justin Harris, Joshua Hartzog, Adaze Idehen-
the pandemic. By tapping star HBCU Amadasun, Julia Kim
Design: Dan Revitte; Sara Amato, Andres Jauregui, Joy Hwang, Adrienne Michalski
journalists who didn’t have a clear path to E-Commerce: Emily Jackson; Samia Balbaky, Cory Baldwin, Kara Cuzzone, Jennifer Ford, Madeline Kaufman,
(From top) Sarah Lee, Kimberly Peiffer
Jair Hilburn, places like Forbes, we’re expanding the pool Engineering: William Anderson; Adrian Ali, Patrick Andre, Ken Barney, Stephanie Brown, Don Cao, Katie Delgado,
Eric Johnson, Igor Carrasco, Brian Chamberlain, Kay Chan, Chris DeLeon, Mudit Dhawan, Philip Diaz, Stephen Dotz, Gustavo
Whitney
for ourselves and our industry, referring Faria, Alec Gilchrist, Jae Kyung Ha, Benjamin Harrigan, Isabelle Ingato, Daryl Kang, Yanella Lopez, Charles Mor-
rissey, Marissa Orea, Drew Overcash, Sungmin Park, Sameer Patwardhan, Mads Pedersen, Joseph Pietruch, Tota-
Bronson, other Fellow finalists to our competitors. ram Ramrattan, Ronak Ray, Charles Rea, Rodney Rodriguez, Kyle Rogers, Aaron Romel, Alexander Shnayderman,
Joshua Burrell, Zachery Shuffield, Dmitri Slavinsky, Scott Warner, JD Weiner, Forrest Whiting, Raymond Wong, Heath Woodson,
Nathaniel With vaccines creating a true reopen- Boris Yakubchik
Business Intelligence: David Johnson; Ankit Dhall, Matthew Haensly, Evelyn Kanu, Alexi Potter, Robert Salgado,
Easington, ing of the country, and with the economy Rosa Seo, Kelsey Simmons, Gregory Spitz, Sukanya Tiwatne, Vivek Veerapandian
Kira Grant
poised to roar, now is the time for all of CORPORATE
Finance/Operations: Michael York (Chief Financial Officer); Cristina Baluyut, Noemi Baraket, Oneil Brodie, Adele
us to think big, both in terms of what we can do im- Cassano, Rosa Colon, Chelsea Deluca, Mike Deochand, Cindy Eng, Nancy Garcia, Iris Garcia, Christie Hansen, Maryann
King, Giedre Kristahn, Christopher Labianca, Nina LaFrance (SVP, Consumer Marketing), Stephanie Lewis, Jaclyn Liu,
mediately and how we can build for the long term. Christopher Lopiano, Andrea Maniscalco, Natalie Maquiling, Christine Martinez, Paul Motta, Nelson Osegueda, Willie
Osegueda, Amanda Pasquarello, Barbara Passarella, Jeanine Pecoraro, Gary Prasto, Ivette Reyes, Angel Sauri, Diane
Schmid, Lisa Serapiglia, William Simmons, Vera Sit, Courtney Stanton, Parag Tolia, Buddy Trocchia, Donald Walsh
After a year of challenges for all, and breakthroughs Corporate Partnerships: Peter Hung (Senior Liaison, Investment Group); Taha Ahmed, Rich Karlgaard, Matt
for some, I’ve rarely felt so optimistic. Muszala, Katya Soldak
Communications: Matthew Hutchison (Chief Communications Officer); Laura Brusca, Susan Masula, Jocelyn Swift,
Christina Vega Magrini
Human Resources: Ali Intres (SVP); Ashley Abendschoen, Brooke Dunmore, Amanda Osit, Rachel Shapiro
Legal: MariaRosa Cartolano (General Counsel); Paul Anderson, Lindsey Datte, Susy Garcia, Nikki Koval,
Josephine Love-Loftin
Forbes Asia: William Adamopoulos (CEO), Justin Doebele (Editor); FORBES CHINA: Sherman Lee (CEO),
Russell Flannery (Editor)
Print Magazine Consultants: Priest + Grace (design); Brian Dawson (editorial); Sarkis Delimelkon (production)
Founded in 1917
B.C. Forbes, Editor-in-Chief (1917–54) Malcolm S. Forbes, Editor-in-Chief (1954–90)
—RANDALL LANE, CHIEF CONTENT OFFICER James W. Michaels, Editor (1961–99) William Baldwin, Editor (1999–2010)

FORBES.COM A P R I L / M AY 2 0 2 1
DOW Jones + 8% * Bitcoin + 206% *

Buy Bitcoin, Baby


Returns 30x bigger than Wall Street. CoinFlip
makes buying Bitcoin simple, secure, and fast with
dedicated customer support whenever you need it.
coinflip.tech

*Tradingview 2020 Wall Street CFD versus Bitcoin XBT


“With all thy getting, get understanding”

FACT & COMMENT


By Steve Forbes, Editor-in-Chief

End the Lockdowns Now


21

The sweeping lockdowns imposed a little are doing better in terms of health and
over a year ago, during the world’s worst economic performance than those that are
pandemic since the Spanish flu of 1918-20, more restrictive.
were supposed to be a short-term solu- All of which makes perverse President
tion to avoid overwhelming our hospitals. Biden’s comment during his nationwide ad-
Yet here we are, over a year later, with re- dress in March, when he said that maybe on
strictions of varying degrees still with us. the Fourth of July—months from now—small
They’re being lifted, but at a pace that’s family gatherings might be safe. C’mon, Mr.
far too slow, which is doing unnecessary President: They’re safe—today!
damage to schoolkids in particular and the The president should urge state gov-
economy in general. ernors to immediately cease these unnec-
Soon, almost anyone who wants a vac- essary restrictions and fully reopen their
cine will be able to get one. Moreover, schools and economies. The general health
for months we’ve had highly effective therapeutics with of the nation would be immensely better off for it.
which to fight the disease when someone who contracts a
severe case of Covid-19 is hospitalized.
This is why the lockdowns should be ended right away.
It was clear by late spring of last year that the best ap- What’s the Matter With Germany?
proach was to focus efforts on the most vulnerable parts
of our population—that is, the elderly and those with se- Germany, the world’s fourth-largest economy and the most
rious preexisting conditions. However, instead of follow- powerful nation in Europe, seems to be pulling away from its
ing the science, too many politicians and health officials close alliance with the U.S., a partnership that was critical in
imposed—and continue to impose—sweeping restrictions winning the Cold War against the once formidable Soviet Union.
that have been useless, capricious or counterproductive. This is good news for China and Vladimir Putin’s Russia.
The country has paid and—this is outrageous—contin- Under its long-serving chancellor, Angela Merkel, Ger-
ues to pay a fearsome price. Low-income households have many is going all-out to ensure the completion of the Nord
been disproportionately harmed, as parents haven’t been Stream 2 pipeline, which will enormously increase Europe’s
able to work because they’ve had to stay home to take care dependence on Russian natural gas, even though Putin has
of kids who couldn’t go to school. never hesitated to use the fuel as a political weapon.
The biggest scandal has been the way that teachers’ A far sounder, more sensible alternative for Berlin would be
unions have kept public schools closed or on a hybrid sys- to import more U.S. natural gas, which we have in abundance.
tem long past the time when facts showed that kids were Germany should also beef up its mangy military as a means
the least vulnerable to Covid-19 and the least likely to trans- of countering Moscow’s ambitions to pry Europe from Wash-
mit the disease. Private schools, with proper precautions, ington. Unlike Sweden, which is dramatically increasing the
have been open for months, with virtually no ill effects. strength of its military because of Russia’s aggressive moves,
The numbers for various forms of depression and ad- Germany has been more hesitant. Intense pressure from the
diction are way up, as are those for suicides and deaths Trump administration got Berlin to boost military outlays. But
from overdoses. German reluctance remains significant, and efforts may flag if
Compare the statistics in states that took an enlight- President Biden doesn’t continue Trump-like goading.
ened, scientific approach, such as Florida, with those that Another recent move that bodes ill is Germany’s pushing
didn’t, such as New York. Florida, completely open today, through a China-EU investment deal that Beijing sees as a
has always been less restrictive after the initial lockdowns way to loosen U.S.-European ties.
than New York. The Sunshine State has a lower death rate Germany, so far, has refused to work closely with Wash-
than the Empire State, even with its larger population of ington to keep strategic technologies from getting into the
older people. Florida’s economy is booming, while New hands of Beijing, a contrast to its approach regarding the So-
York’s is still struggling. viet Union during the Cold War. Germany takes this tack even
This is the blunt truth: The states that are more open as China engages in major human-rights abuses and contin-

A P R I L / M AY 2 0 2 1 FORBES.COM
Steve Forbes Cont.

ues its highly aggressive foreign policy, core—held fast. A critical example was agreed to our stationing missiles on its
such as moving to dominate the South how closely the two countries worked soil. The Russian move failed, a crucial
China Sea, a critical international wa- together to counter Moscow’s attempts factor in the West’s winning the Cold War.
terway. Instead, Chancellor Merkel at blackmailing Germany into loosen- The Biden administration has a big
seems intent on keeping Germany at ing its transatlantic ties by threatening it job in getting Germany to realize that
some distance between Washington with intermediate-range nuclear missiles close cooperation between our two
22 and Beijing. in the late 1970s. Despite fierce pressure countries in all areas remains absolutely
During the Cold War, despite oc- from Moscow—including whipping up crucial to preserving democracy and the
casional differences, the NATO alli- domestic opposition—Germany, under free world’s security in the face of grow-
FACT & COMMENT

ance—with Germany and the U.S. at its the redoubtable Chancellor Helmut Kohl, ing pressures from China and Russia.

A Compelling Duo of Whodunits


This pair of mystery/thrillers by a true but his investigative instincts are ir- the trunk of his car, and forensics finds
master of the genre, Michael Connelly, repressibly aroused. Some ingenious the man had been killed there. Worse,
will keep you glued from beginning to sleuthing leads McEvoy to realize he’s Haller knew the victim well—a scam-
end. He has a marvelous way of spin- looking for a serial killer who calls him- mer he represented several times before
ning a gripping tale with impressively self “the Shrike,” after a bird that kills dropping him as a client. Alleged motive
precise details and excellent its prey by breaking its neck. for murder: The guy owed Haller money.
character development. Before this tale is over, Compounding things further, a vin-
If you haven’t yet gone McEvoy, the central character dictive judge sets bail at $5 million.
to one of the DNA websites of two previous Connelly nov- Haller decides to defend himself, know-
to trace your ancestry, you’ll els, reconnects with an old ing well the truism that a person who
think twice about doing so flame, ex-FBI agent Rachel does that has a fool for a client. But
after reading Fair Warning Walling, who had been fired given the stakes—life in prison—he
(Little, Brown & Co., $29). De- for leaking confidential infor- trusts no one else with the task. Haller
spite promises of confidenti- mation to him during a pre- also recognizes that a not-guilty verdict
ality, how truly secure is your vious case and who now runs wouldn’t suffice to save his legal reputa-
information? Your chosen an agency that does back- tion. He must uncover who set him up
vendor may make extra bucks by selling ground checks on potential hires for and why. As he puts it, “To prove true in-
your data to research labs or other par- clients. Connelly fans will eagerly await nocence, the guilty man must be found
ties. Safeguards are supposed to prevent future books involving this duo! and exposed to the world.”
those buyers from knowing who you are, The Law of Innocence (Little, Brown More daunting, Haller has to direct
but how good are those measures? And & Co., $29) brings back a character Con- things from the slammer, where prison-
it may be that those buyers resell the nelly hasn’t featured in years: aggressive, ers might kill him. Given his reputation as
data to others whose security is lax. smart-alecky defense lawyer a hard-driving defense lawyer,
Our protagonist, Jack McEvoy, is a Mickey Haller, who was made Haller knows the guards and
former investigative reporter and one- famous in the 2011 movie The the sheriff ’s office wouldn’t
time novelist who now works for a site Lincoln Lawyer, starring Mat- mind seeing him done in. His
that focuses on consumer fraud. thew McConaughey. Haller fears are well-placed; especial-
One day two detectives from the L.A. does much of his work in the ly dangerous are the bus trips
Police Department pay McEvoy a visit. back seat of his Lincoln. to the courthouse.
He’s a “person of interest” in the murder An establishment figure Haller, who needs all the
of a woman with whom he’d had a one- Haller is not. He runs ads for help he can get, mobilizes
night stand after they met at a bar. clients on benches. Until the characters familiar to fans of
McEvoy’s DNA ultimately clears him, California Bar stopped it, Haller’s slogan previous Lincoln novels, including his
was “Reasonable doubt for a reason- half-brother Harry Bosch, memorable
able fee.” Nonetheless, Connelly makes star of Connelly’s first legendary series.
Introducing Haller sympathetic. (By the way, Harry Bosch is the subject
What’s Ahead On his way home from a party cel- of a riveting television series—called
The podcast hosted ebrating a big courtroom victory, Haller Bosch, naturally—on Amazon Prime.
by Steve Forbes. is stopped by a police officer. He soon Leave aside plenty of time, because once
Subscribe now on iTunes finds himself under arrest for first- you tune in, you won’t want to stop
or GooglePlay Store. degree murder: There’s a dead body in viewing, episode after episode.)

FORBES.COM A P R I L / M AY 2 0 2 1
Introducing DaVinci Resolve 17
Edit and color correct video with the
same software used by Hollywood, for free!
DaVinci Resolve 17 is a major new update packed with over 300 Powerful New Edit and Cut Page Features!
features and enhancements! Colorists get new HDR grading tools, A new metadata ‘slate’ view with bin dividers makes it easy to sort and find clips
AI based magic mask, color warper and more. Fairlight adds based on scene, shot, camera, and more! There’s also new audio trimming on
lightning fast keyboard and mouse sound editing tools. Editors the cut page, AI based smart reframing for changing aspect ratio, a new portable
get new metadata ‘slate’ view, smart reframing, proxies, keying, proxy workflow that supercharges edit performance, render in place, timeline
Fusion effects and more! based syncing, compositing, keying, Fusion effects and more!

Next Generation HDR and Color Features! Fusion Effects, Titles and Transitions for Editors!
New HDR grading tools, redesigned primary controls, AI based magic mask and DaVinci Resolve 17 lets you save anything created on the Fusion page as an
more. The new HDR palette lets you create custom color wheels for targeted effect, title or transition that can be used on the edit and cut pages! New
corrections, magic mask uses the DaVinci Neural Engine to isolate and track animation curve modifiers automatically retime animations when clip length is
objects, and the color warper lets you morph colors in creative new ways! changed, there are new vector shape tools for motion graphics, shared
New DaVinci wide gamut image processing gives you even higher quality! markers, and audio playback with graphical waveform!

World’s Fastest and Highest Quality Pro Audio Tools! DaVinci Resolve ................................................................. Free
Fairlight features a powerful new engine that supports up to 2,000 realtime
tracks with effects, dynamic and EQ. The new context sensitive edit selection
tools and updated shortcuts make it even faster and easier to use, especially if
DaVinci Resolve Studio ... $295
you’re switching from another system. You can now reverse clips, analyze Free DaVinci Resolve Speed Editor
with purchase of DaVinci Resolve Studio
loudness, view transients, preview video, move automation and more!

Learn more at www.blackmagicdesign.com Available for Mac, Windows and Linux


PRATT
INDUSTRIES
HAS BUILT
5 OF AMERICA’S LAST
6 PAPER MILLS —
ALL 100% RECYCLED

PRATT
INDUSTRIES
HAS BUILT
5 OF AMERICA’S LAST
6 PAPER MILLS —
ALL 100% RECYCLED
www.prattindustries.com
W H AT ’ S WHO’S
NEW NEXT

25

FRONTRUNNER
Jeff Bezos | Elon Musk

$200 B

$150 B

$100 B

$50 B

$0 B
3/18/2020 3/5/2021

Billionaires

THE SKY’S NO LIMIT


WESLEY BEDROSIAN FOR FORBES

J EF F B E ZOS and E LO N MU S K saw their fortunes


reach the stratosphere in the past year—with each
rocket man amassing more than $150 billion as they
battled to be the wealthiest person in the galaxy.

A P R I L / M AY 2 0 2 1 FORBES.COM
I
10. Mukesh Ambani 16. Carlos Slim Helú
$84.5 BIL © • DIVERSIFIED & family
AGE: 63 • INDIA $62.8 BIL © • TELECOM
Ambani reclaims his spot as Asia’s AGE: 81 • MEXICO
28 richest person, adding nearly The telecom mogul was briefly
$48 billion to his fortune over the hospitalized with Covid-19 in January.
past year as shares of his conglom- His pan–Latin American wireless firm,
erate, Reliance Industries, have América Móvil, ended 2020 with 287
FRONTRUNNER

increased significantly. million subscribers, up 3% in a year.


It’s been a year like no other, and
we aren’t talking about the pandemic. 11. Amancio Ortega 17. Alice Walton
There were rapid-fire public offerings, $77 BIL © • ZARA $61.8 BIL © • WALMART
AGE: 85 • SPAIN AGE: 71 • U.S.
surging cryptocurrencies and sky-
The founder of clothing giant
rocketing stock prices. The number Inditex—best known for its Zara 18. Jim Walton
retail chain—weathered the storm: $60.2 BIL © • WALMART
of billionaires simply exploded. Forbes Sales fell by nearly 30% in 2020 but AGE: 72 • U.S.
found an unprecedented 2,755 around its stock is up 34% over the year.
19. Rob Walton
the world—660 more than a year ago. $59.5 BIL © • WALMART
A staggering 86% are richer than they 12. Françoise Bettencourt AGE: 76 • U.S.
Meyers & family The children of Walmart founder
were then. Altogether they’re worth $73.6 BIL © • L’ORÉAL Sam Walton own, with other family
$13.1 trillion, up from $8 trillion in 2020; their average AGE: 67 • FRANCE members, about half of the world’s
The granddaughter of cosmetics largest retailer. Walmart introduced
net worth is $4.7 billion, $900 million more than last giant L’Oréal’s founder benefited free delivery as part of an Amazon
year. The U.S. still has the most billionaires, with 724, from a 38% jump in the company’s Prime–like membership program,
stock despite the fact that profits helping boost online sales 69%
followed by Greater China with 698. We used stock prices fell 6% in 2020. in the year through January.
and exchange rates from March 5, 2021, to calculate net
worths. For the full list of the world’s billionaires and our 20. Michael Bloomberg
$59 BIL © • BLOOMBERG LP
methodology, please visit forbes.com/billionaires.
AGE: 79 • U.S.
He smashed political spending
records last year, pouring more
than $1 billion into his own presi-
dential campaign and $150 million
1. Jeff Bezos has yet to dent Zuckerberg’s to support other Democrats.
$177 BIL © • SOURCE: AMAZON fortune. Facebook shares are
AGE: 57 • CITIZENSHIP: U.S. near record highs.
21. Colin Zheng Huang
Bezos’ $64 billion jump keeps the
$55.3 BIL © • E-COMMERCE
Amazon founder, who is stepping
down as CEO later in 2021, in the top 6. Warren Buffett AGE: 41 • CHINA
spot for a fourth consecutive year. $96 BIL © • BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY The founder of online discounter
AGE: 90 • U.S. Pinduoduo stepped down as its
Berkshire Hathaway bought
13. Zhong Shanshan chairman in March to pursue
2. Elon Musk Dominion Energy’s natural-gas $68.9 BIL © • BEVERAGES research in food and life sciences;
$151 BIL © • TESLA, SPACEX pipelines for $8 billion in July, AGE: 66 • CHINA he gave up his CEO role in July.
AGE: 49 • U.S. but the Oracle of Omaha has The September 2020 IPO of his
Musk’s fortune rocketed $126 billion otherwise been relatively quiet bottled-water firm, Nongfu Spring,
during the pandemic. drove up his fortune by 3,345%,
22. MacKenzie Scott
since March 2020 as Tesla shares
making him the year’s biggest $53 BIL © • AMAZON
soared; he briefly overtook Bezos
as the world’s wealthiest in January. percentage gainer and China’s AGE: 50 • U.S.
7. Larry Ellison new richest person. Jeff Bezos’ ex-wife (above right)
$93 BIL © • SOFTWARE rocked the philanthropy world in 2020
3. Bernard Arnault & family AGE: 76 • U.S. with nearly $6 billion in grants to 500
$150 BIL © • LVMH The Silicon Valley titan reportedly
14. Steve Ballmer nonprofits across the U.S., including
AGE: 72 • FRANCE moved to Hawaii during the $68.7 BIL © • MICROSOFT Puerto Rico. She recently remarried.
The richest person in Europe closed pandemic. Oracle, meanwhile, AGE: 65 • U.S.
several major deals, most notably which he cofounded in 1977, has The former Microsoft CEO, who is
LVMH’s long-delayed acquisition of relocated its headquarters from worth $16 billion more since last
23. Daniel Gilbert
iconic jeweler Tiffany for a reduced the Bay Area to Texas. year amid a 67% surge in the $51.9 BIL © • QUICKEN LOANS
price of $16 billion in January. software firm’s stock price, donated AGE: 59 • U.S.
$54 million in 2020 to Covid-related His Rocket Companies—America’s
8. Larry Page causes such as vaccine testing and largest mortgage lender—went
4. Bill Gates $91.5 BIL © • GOOGLE child care for essential workers. public in August, boosting Gilbert’s
$124 BIL © • MICROSOFT AGE: 48 • U.S. net worth by $38 billion in one day.
AGE: 65 • U.S.
9. Sergey Brin 15. Ma Huateng
IMAGINE CHINA/NEWSCOM

The Microsoft cofounder, who left


its board last year, is wealthier than $89 BIL © • GOOGLE $65.8 BIL © • INTERNET MEDIA 24. Gautam Adani & family
he’s ever been, buoyed in part by AGE: 47 • U.S. AGE: 49 • CHINA $50.5 BIL © • INFRASTRUCTURE,
the software firm’s surging stock. The Google cofounders still serve His web-media giant, Tencent, COMMODITIES • AGE: 58 • INDIA
on the board of Alphabet but which owns stakes in Tesla and The infrastructure tycoon is nearly
otherwise maintain low profiles. Snap, notched another win with $42 billion richer than a year ago
5. Mark Zuckerberg Google has been under fire in the February public offering of as shares of five publicly traded
$97 BIL © • FACEBOOK Australia recently for what critics video-sharing app Kuaishou. companies in his Adani Group hit
AGE: 36 • U.S. say is the search engine’s role in Tencent owns 18% of the firm. their all-time highs.
Continued congressional scrutiny weakening the media there.

FORBES.COM A P R I L / M AY 2 0 2 1
(d. January 2021) now controls videoconference firm Zoom and
56% of casino operator Las Vegas energy-drink maker Celsius.
Sands, which is cashing out of
Vegas to focus on Asia.
44. Qin Yinglin & family
$33.5 BIL © • PIG BREEDING 29
37. He Xiangjian AGE: 55 • CHINA
$37.7 BIL © • HOME APPLIANCES
Qin founded China’s top hog
AGE: 78 • CHINA producer in 1992 with wife Qian

FRONTRUNNER
The cofounder of electric- Ying and just 22 pigs. He’s still the
appliance maker Midea Group chairman; she sits on the board.
reportedly escaped a kidnapping
attempt last June, when several
men tried to break into his home 45. William Lei Ding
using explosives. $33 BIL © • ONLINE GAMES
AGE: 49 • CHINA
38. Dieter Schwarz Revenue at his Nasdaq-listed
NetEase rose 24% in 2020 as
$36.9 BIL © • RETAIL pandemic lockdowns drove
AGE: 81 • GERMANY demand for its online-gaming
Sales of the Schwarz Group, owner and remote-learning products.
of Kaufland and Lidl discount
supermarkets, are expected to
have risen 23%, to $170 billion, in
the year through February 2021.
25. Phil Knight & family 31. Tadashi Yanai & family
$49.9 BIL © • NIKE $44.1 BIL © • FASHION RETAIL
AGE: 83 • U.S. AGE: 72 • JAPAN
The latest philanthropic effort from The net worth of the Japanese
Nike’s retired founder is a luxe, newly apparel billionaire more than
renovated track stadium at his alma doubled as demand for Uniqlo’s
mater, the University of Oregon. comfortable everyday clothes
and its triple-layer masks surged
during the pandemic.
26. Jack Ma
$48.4 BIL © • E-COMMERCE
AGE: 56 • CHINA 32. François Pinault &
family
The Alibaba cofounder has been
$42.3 BIL © • LUXURY GOODS
46. Len Blavatnik
lying low since the dual listing of his $32 BIL © • MUSIC, CHEMICALS
fintech giant, Ant Group, was halted AGE: 84 • FRANCE
AGE: 63 • U.S.
by Chinese regulators in November. The founder of luxury conglomer-
ate Kering is finally opening his 39. Zhang Yiming Blavatnik’s Warner Music is worth
long-awaited art museum in the $35.6 BIL © • TIKTOK nearly $18 billion after going public
27. Charles Koch 19th-century Bourse de Commerce in June 2020, more than five times
AGE: 37 • CHINA
$46.4 BIL © • KOCH INDUSTRIES building in Paris this year. what the mogul paid for it in 2011.
Zhang founded ByteDance, creator
AGE: 85 • U.S. of popular short-video app TikTok,
33. David Thomson & family in a four-bedroom apartment in 47. Lee Shau Kee
27. Julia Koch & family 2012. Its December funding round $31.7 BIL © • REAL ESTATE
$46.4 BIL © • KOCH INDUSTRIES $41.8 BIL © • MEDIA
valued the unicorn at $180 billion. AGE: 93 • HONG KONG
AGE: 58 • U.S. AGE: 63 • CANADA
Canada’s richest person is the Shares of his Henderson Land
Koch Industries, which Charles seesawed during the pandemic
chairs, topped Cargill to become chairman of publicly traded media 40. Giovanni Ferrero
but ended up for the year, though
JAVIER ROJAS/NEWSCOM; VGC/GETTY IMAGES; GREGG DEGUIRE/GETTY IMAGES

America’s largest private company giant Thomson Reuters, whose $35.1 BIL © • NUTELLA,
shares are up 16% in the past year. still well off their all-time high.
(as measured by revenue); the CHOCOLATES • AGE: 56 • ITALY
conglomerate hauled in $115 billion The chairman of the Ferrero Group,
in sales in 2019. He and the family
34. Beate Heister & known for its Nutella, Tic Tac and 48. Jacqueline Mars
of Julia, the widow of his younger Kinder brands, added a stake in $31.3 BIL © • CANDY, PET FOOD
brother David (d. 2019), each have Karl Albrecht Jr. Britain’s Fox’s Biscuits to his choco- AGE: 81 • U.S.
a 42% stake in the business. $39.2 BIL © • SUPERMARKETS late and confectionery empire.
GERMANY 48. John Mars
The siblings inherited the discount $31.3 BIL © • CANDY, PET FOOD
29. Masayoshi Son retailer Aldi Sued. During the 41. Alain Wertheimer AGE: 85 • U.S.
$45.4 BIL © • INTERNET, TELECOM pandemic, its stores began using $34.5 BIL © • CHANEL
AGE: 63 • JAPAN AGE: 72 • FRANCE Each of the Mars siblings owns
3D sensors to measure customer an estimated one-third of the
After his SoftBank Vision Fund traffic and regulate access. $40 billion (sales) candy, pet care
suffered a very public blow from 41. Gerard Wertheimer
$34.5 BIL © • CHANEL and food company. Best known
its fraught WeWork investment, for M&M’s and Skittles, Mars Inc.
Son came roaring back with wins 35. Wang Wei AGE: 70 • FRANCE
$39 BIL © • PACKAGE DELIVERY acquired snack bar maker Kind in
including IPOs for food-delivery The brothers—grandsons of Chanel November 2020, three years after
app DoorDash and Korean AGE: 50 • CHINA cofounder Pierre Wertheimer—are it took a minority stake.
e-commerce company Coupang. Revenue of his S.F. Express—the each $17 billion richer than last year
“FedEx of China”—rose 37% in 2020 amid a rebound in the luxury sector.
as e-commerce boomed during 50. Yang Huiyan & family
30. Michael Dell China’s Covid-19 lockdowns. $29.6 BIL © • REAL ESTATE
$45.1 BIL © • COMPUTERS 43. Li Ka-shing AGE: 39 • CHINA
AGE: 56 • U.S. $33.7 BIL © • DIVERSIFIED The heiress is the largest sharehol-
His fortune nearly doubled as
36. Miriam Adelson AGE: 92 • HONG KONG der of real estate developer Coun-
shares of Dell Technologies hit $38.2 BIL Ø • CASINOS Hong Kong’s richest person gained try Garden Holdings; she also chairs
an all-time high, thanks in part AGE: 75 • U.S. $12 billion, thanks to his holdings U.S.-listed education firm Bright
to record sales of $94.2 billion. The widow of Sheldon Adelson overseas, including stakes in Scholar Education Holdings.

A P R I L / M AY 2 0 2 1 FORBES.COM

CHANGE IN WEALTH KEY: ©UP ªDOWN §


¨UNCHANGED RETURNEE ØNEW
Deceased
IN MEMORIAM
LEFT THEIR MARK
Listicle

Marcel Adams THE AI 50


AGE: 100 • Real estate
Which artificial
30 Twenty-three billionaires from 15 countries died intelligence
Edmund Ansin
in the past year, including the list’s two centenarians, companies are
84 • Television
for real? Forbes
Chang Yun Chung and Marcel Adams. partnered with
FRONTRUNNER

Jeronimo Arango
venture firms
94 • Retail
Sequoia Capital
and Meritech
David Barclay
Capital to create
86 • Media, retail
our third annual
list of today’s most
Stephen Bechtel Jr.
promising private
95 • Construction
businesses using
AI. The full list is
Dmitry Bosov
available at forbes
52 • Coal mining
.com/ai50. Here
are five standouts,
Chang Yun Chung
along with
102 • Shipping
recent PitchBook
Sheldon Adelson Lee Kun-hee valuations:
AGE: 87 AGE: 78 Eduardo Cojuangco
85 • Food, drinks
The casino magnate and GOP mega- Lee inherited Samsung Group in FARMWISE ($45 MIL)
Olivier Dassault Makes AI-powered
donor built Las Vegas Sands into 1987 from his father, founder Lee farm equipment that
69 • Diversified
an empire, amassing a $35 billion Byung-chull, and built it into South can eradicate weeds
from fields without
fortune, and made bold gambles to Korea’s biggest conglomerate. Twice Aloysio de
the use of herbicides.
Andrade Faria
rescue the company from near-failure pardoned for bribery and tax charges, 99 • Banking
during the Great Recession. he had been in a coma since 2014. GATIK ($58 MIL)
Walmart is testing its

MARTIN SCHOELLER FOR FORBES; LEE JIN-MAN/AP; NEWSCOM; GARI GARAIALDE/GETTY IMAGES; JAMEL TOPPIN FOR FORBES
Manuel Jove
autonomous-driving
78 • Real estate trucks as a new
means of delivery.
Suna Kirac
79 • Diversified SENTROPY ($50 MIL)
Aids online platforms
Manuel Moroun in moderating online
93 • Transportation abuse, increasing
engagement and
Park Yeon-cha decreasing churn.
74 • Sneakers
VERGE GENOMICS
Sumner Redstone ($60 MIL)
97 • Media AI to help discover
new drugs for
Joseph Safra Benjamin de Rothschild Randall Rollins brain diseases like
88 • Pest control Parkinson’s and
AGE: 82 AGE 57
Alzheimer’s. The field’s
The world’s richest banker, worth The heir to Edmond de Rothschild, Sheldon Solow first candidate, for
92 • Real estate ALS, will enter human
$23 billion, he owned three banks on the European bank founded in trials next year.
three continents, London’s Gherkin 1953 by his father, he died of a Heinz Hermann Thiele
79 • Brakes WHISPER ($198 MIL)
skyscraper and 50% of banana heart attack in January. His widow, Its hearing aids offer
producer Chiquita. Ariane de Rothschild, has been Arne Wilhelmsen better sound quality
thanks to AI.
chair of the bank since 2015. 90 • Cruise ships
DECEASED/DROP-OFFS BY HANK TUCKER

Drop-offs Number of billionaire drop-offs (excluding deceased)

KYLIE’S FANTASTICAL FORTUNE 250


200
Just 61 of last year’s billionaires fell out of the ranks due to
150
fortunes that dropped below $1 billion. That’s one-fourth as
many as in 2020 and the lowest number in a decade. One 100
noteworthy departure: Kylie Jenner, gone after Coty’s filings 50
revealed that revenues for Kylie Cosmetics were less than 0
half of what her team trumpeted to inflate her net worth. 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021

FORBES.COM A P R I L / M AY 2 0 2 1
Manufactured entirely in Switzerland
Parmigianiamericas.com

%CNNQTVGZVQWTEQPEKGTIGUGTXKEGVQƂPFQWVOQTG 
 
The Midas List

GOLDFINGERS
32 Our annual ranking of the world’s top 100 venture capitalists.
FRONTRUNNER

A
new era of tech giants
such as Coinbase,
Kuaishou and Stripe
means a changing of
the guard among the
world’s leading VCs. Now in its 20th
year, Forbes’ Midas List welcomes
24 newcomers, including its first
South American investors. Here are
highlights from this year’s ranks,
including the biggest deals, the Top
20 and a new No. 1. For the rest of the
Midas 100, bios, analysis and more,
please visit forbes.com/midas.

COOL IN A CRISIS
In just two days last year, Alfred Lin
enjoyed two of the 10 biggest-ever
exits among U.S. tech firms. On
December 9, food-delivery service
DoorDash went public on the New
York Stock Exchange; it ended the
day with a market capitalization of
$60 billion. The next day, home-rental
leader Airbnb listed on the Nasdaq,
scoring a $79 billion market cap.
Those two outcomes alone generated
profits—on paper, at least—of more
than $21 billion for Lin and his VC
firm, Sequoia. They’re also a big part of
the reason why the Bay Area resident,
who also backs wholesale marketplace
Faire and social media platform Reddit,
has vaulted to No. 1, from No. 32, on
our annual Midas List.
Lin’s specialty: helping build
organizations the way he did at
Zappos, where he was chairman and
COO for a time. He and his Harvard
GUTTER CREDIT

classmate, the late Tony Hsieh, sold


their first startup for $265 million and
plowed some of the proceeds into an Alfred Lin
incubator that bet early on Zappos;

FORBES.COM A P R I L / M AY 2 0 2 1
THE TOP
they sold the shoe retailer to Amazon GROWTH EQUITY
in 2009. A year later Lin joined From deal values to the sheer number of funds, the global

TWENTY
Sequoia, which had recently written VC industry has ballooned in recent years. Below,
several early-stage checks to Brian a comparison of 2002, the earliest data available,
and 2020, adjusted for inflation.
Chesky’s fledgling Airbedandbreakfast
.com. Reportedly offered a job there, 2020 33
1. Alfred Lin
Lin joined its board in 2012 and soon Firm: Sequoia
spent one day a week in its office. Notable Deal: Airbnb
2002

FRONTRUNNER
FUND VALUE:
When the pandemic hit and Airbnb’s 2. Neil Shen
Sequoia China
$119.5 bil
business faced the “abyss” in March Xpeng FUND VALUE:
$30.4 bil
2020, Lin dived in, working closely 3. Hans Tung
LIN AND HERSHENSON: CHRISTIE HEMM KLOK FOR FORBES; DOERR: ERIK MILLETTE; MORITZ: SIMON DAWSON/BLOOMBERG; LEONE: ERIC MILLETTE; KHOSLA: DAVID PAUL MORRIS/BLOOMBERG

with Chesky and the rest of Airbnb’s GGV Capital


Wish
board to slash costs, lay off employees,
take out debt to cover refunds and 4. Richard Liu
5Y Capital
pivot the business to focus on work- Xiaomi
DEAL VALUE:
from-anywhere travel. Likewise, Lin 5. Michael Speiser $34.4 bil
helped DoorDash’s Tony Xu, whom he’d Sutter Hill Ventures DEAL COUNT:2,888
Snowflake
backed in a Series A round in 2014, # OF FUNDS: 261
6. Satish Dharmaraj
secure safety equipment for its delivery Redpoint Ventures DEAL VALUE: $328.5 bil
contractors, cut commissions and set Snowflake DEAL COUNT: 27,798
up free meals for first responders. 7. Chris Dixon S O U R C E : PitchBook # OF FUNDS: 712

“It’s helpful to have a supporting Andreessen Horowitz


Coinbase
partner when things are that stressful,”
8. Zhen Zhang
Xu says. “Then, when things are less Gaorong Capital HOME RUN HITTERS
stressful, they’re someone who will Pinduoduo These internet standouts have helped consumers
challenge you. . . . Alfred knows when 9. Roelof Botha around the world work from home anywhere,
Sequoia listen to music, shop online and stay connected as
to balance those two sides of him.” Unity our lives moved virtual. They also helped put the
Adds Lin: “I think these trying 10. Lee Fixel most investors on this year’s Midas List.
times are fun. Not because I’m a Addition
masochist, but I do think you don’t Roblox
Airbnb 14
know if you’ve built something of 11. Navin Chaddha
Mayfield Meituan 11
enduring value until you’re tested.” Poshmark Spotify 11
12. Sameer Gandhi
Accel
Stripe 10
CrowdStrike Xiaomi 9
13. Jeff Jordan
N O TA B L E N E W C O M E R Andreessen Horowitz 0 3 6 9 12 15

After founding three startups and teaching Airbnb


EDITOR: ALEX KONRAD; REPORTING BY BECCA SZKUTAK AND NINA WOLPOW

engineering at Stanford, Spain-born 14. Jan Hammer


Mar Hershenson started Pear VC with for- Index Ventures
mer rug dealer Pejman Nozad (No. 15). Their Robinhood THE MIDAS LEGENDS
early bet on DoorDash propelled them onto 15. Pejman Nozad Just one venture capitalist has appeared on all
the Midas 100. Ranked No. 29, Hershenson Pear Ventures 20 iterations of the Midas List: billionaire John Doerr,
is one of 12 women on this year’s list. DoorDash
a partner at Kleiner Perkins who was an early investor
16. Peter Thiel in Amazon, Compaq and Google, as well as DoorDash,
Founders Fund Slack and many more. Sequoia partner and former
Airbnb journalist Michael Moritz—an inaugural member who
17. Scott Shleifer dropped off for one year in 2018—comes close.
Tiger Global Management
Postmates Most appearances by active Midas List members:
18. Joe Lonsdale
8VC
Wish
19. Jeremy Liew
Lightspeed
Venture Partners John Michael Doug Scott Vinod
Affirm Doerr Moritz Leone Sandell Khosla

20 19 16 15 14
20. Bill Gurley
Benchmark
Uber

A P R I L / M AY 2 0 2 1 FORBES.COM
CUSTOM ADVERTISING SECTION

TR ANSPORTATION 2025
Achieving Resilience Amid Profound Change
By Poornima Apte example, RyderShare™, a collaborative cost. A narrow focus on only one of these
digital platform, helps users visualize pillars can potentially derail the best-
The transportation industry is complex relay operations that truck laid plans. Balance all three priorities for
bracing for significant changes. fleets routinely execute. Since every optimal results, Martin advised.
node of transit operations is laid bare,
While e-commerce is projected to expand, glitches become easier to pinpoint 4. Embrace Change. The pandemic has
a shortage of truckers who haul freight and fix. been an abrupt disruptor, but it’s by no
across the country is expected to linger. means going to be the only one in the
Add in rising freight rates, escalating The platform enables store managers years to come. By accepting that change
consumer demands for quicker deliveries to know when shipments will arrive and is inevitable, it encourages innovation
and penalties for missing delivery windows, manage exceptions in case of delays, within organizations, Martin said. “Build
and companies have a steep hill to climb such as those caused by traffic. This partnerships, experiment and run pilots
when it comes to transporting goods. allows companies to schedule personnel so that you learn what’s happening,”
to receive the deliveries, improving he said.
Given that nearly 73% of goods in the p ro d u c ti v i t y an d l owe r in g c o s t s .
United States moved by truck in 2019, Managers used RyderShare™ this way
according to the American Trucking early in the pandemic, when demand When Outsourcing Makes Sense
Associations, there’s a lot at stake. for certain goods outpaced availability.
Considering the changes ahead and
It’s why Steve Martin, senior vice president 2. Prioritize Flexibility. Having digital the importance of having the right
of transportation logistics at Ryder, platforms that can facilitate collaboration strategy, businesses might benefit
recommends that business leaders focus among stakeholders and readily accept from outsourcing their transportation
on developing a clear transportation new technology solutions will enable and logistics needs.
strategy that prioritizes optimization a c o m p any to p i vot m o re e a sil y.
and resilience while positioning “Technology is changing very rapidly,” Transportation and logistics providers
their business to take advantage of Martin said. “Having your platforms that are investing in new technology
new opportunities. designed to continue to adapt and modify and staying ahead of the changes
with changes is really important.” that are reshaping the industry are
More specifically, to improve their most likely to succeed, Martin said.
transportation networks and gain a Predictive analytics and autonomous
competitive advantage, Martin said vehicles are among the innovative forces “If the partner is not paying attention
companies should take the following that will disrupt the transportation industry to the disruptors and what’s happening
four steps: and require businesses to build flexibility on an innovation standpoint, I think
into their plans, Martin said. you’re going to find yourself being
1. Improve Visibility. Martin encourages left behind by others that have that
businesses to use data to improve visibility 3. Stay Balanced. Transportation managers type of capability,” he said.
into their supply chain networks. For need to factor in safety, service and
EVER
MOVING
Transportation logistics that put your supply chain in motion
Whether it’s a single pallet, several truckloads a day, or managing a private fleet and drivers,
you need transportation logistics that keep your freight and business moving forward. With
an entire portfolio of transportation logistics that includes freight management & brokerage,
truckload capacity, transportation management, and dedicated transportation, Ryder helps
you reduce freight costs, improve service levels, and drive efficiencies while getting your
goods to consumers on-time and in-full. Discover how Ryder Transportation Logistics can
make you Ever better™ at ryder.com/everbetter.

SUPPLY CHAIN SOLUTIONS | DEDICATED TRANSPORTATION | FLEET LEASING & MAINTENANCE


36

30 Under 30
FRONTRUNNER

INDOOR
OUTFITTERS
Work-from-home apparel
with the Forbes 30 Under 30,
in 30 words or less.

Mia Park 29 Lior Ohayon 28 Sophia Danner-Okotie 29 Leah O’Malley 26


Dae Lim 28 Aaron Spivak 26 FOUNDER Tori Robinson 26
COFOUNDERS COFOUNDERS BESIDA COFOUNDERS
SUNDAE SCHOOL HUSH BLANKETS BOYS LIE
Besida’s brilliantly hued,
Cannabis connoisseurs Ohayon learned about sustainably made $140 robes These Philly-raised friends
gotta be comfy, and this “weighted therapy” to mitigate are handcrafted in Nigeria. uprooted to L.A. and poured
duo’s “smokewear”—$350 anxiety while counseling The pandemic crushed her heartbreak into the best revenge:
bomber jackets, $140 track special-needs campers. retail, but Atlanta-based a $5 million (revenue) business

30 UNDER 30 BY ALEXANDRA STERNLICHT. DIEGO PATIÑO FOR FORBES (TOP)


pants—sparked $2 million He and Spivak crowdfunded Danner-Okotie still sold 3,400 whose sweatsuits boast cheeky
in funding. Fans include $1.2 million to make soothing pieces last year, mostly masks. slogans like “1-800-BOYS-LIE.”
Aussie actor Jacob Elordi 15-pound blankies; 2020 And girls profit.
and model Kaia Gerber. revenue hit $15 million.

ForbesLife
THE FASTER TRACK
Would you pay $80,000 for a car that doesn’t move—
but can still go 200 mph? That’s the idea behind the
new racing simulator collaboration between Aston
Martin and Curv. The AMR-C01, partly inspired by
Aston Martin’s Valkyrie hypercar, features a carbon-
fiber monocoque, a customizable seat and an F1-style
wheel (with high torque) and dual clutch paddles.
Straight ahead is a 47-inch curved QHD monitor that
can take you around several famous tracks, including
almighty Nürburgring. The simulators are limited to
150 models and, fittingly, they’re selling fast.

FORBES.COM A P R I L / M AY 2 0 2 1
CUSTOM ADVERTISING SECTION

Soft leadership: Enel’s new way to be


2020 was a life-changing year for all of us. The pandemic led Corporate culture will be increasingly based on a concept of
to profound changes in our understanding of life. This period “soft leadership”, which aims to empower people using soft
has presented us with new questions and challenges, which are VNLOOVWREHFRXSOHGZLWKWKHKDUGVNLOOVWKDWFRPSDQLHVDOUHDG\
LQH[RUDEO\UHÀHFWHGLQWKHZD\WKDWZHWKLQNDERXWZRUN possess.
0DQ\FRPSDQLHVDURXQGWKHZRUOGKDYHEHJXQWRUHWKLQNWKHLU
operating models. We will move from “me” to “we”.
,Q WLPHV OLNH WKHVH LW LV HVVHQWLDO WR PDNH WKH PRVW RI WKH
RSSRUWXQLWLHVIRUUHÀHFWLRQSUHVHQWHGE\WKHFULVLVZHDUHOLYLQJ The concept of leadership is moving away from “command
through. Many companies are realizing - some after over 100 and control” - which is all about achieving results - towards a
years - that established ways of operating and organizing have leadership model that is attentive to relationships, trust and
become outdated in a very short span of time. respect for each person’s talents, while continuing to focus on
achieving objectives.
3HRSOH ZRUNLQJ LQ WKHVH FRPSDQLHV PD\ KDYH EHHQ LQLWLDOO\
disconcerted, but have discovered that they are The focus will be on “caring for people”,
able to face the new reality with great courage listening and helping them seize the
and responsibility. They have mastered smart opportunities presented by the transformation
ZRUNLQJ DQG WKH DVVRFLDWHG DXWRQRP\ DQG that we are experiencing. This will help create
have become even more digitised. DQLQFUHDVLQJO\SHDFHIXOZRUNLQJHQYLURQPHQW
in which people feel empowered and
Now we must capitalize on these experiences autonomous. Caring for people starts by having
and incorporate the lessons we have learned an empathic connection with them: the ability
LQWRRXUZRUN to listen and to recognise their talents, with the
NQRZOHGJHWKDWDOOSHRSOHDUHJLIWHG
We are all showing great resilience and
responsibility on a professional level, which is The role of the manager is therefore transformed
rewarded by trusting, caring and listening to into the job of accompanying people on their
each other in our interpersonal relationships. professional path, enabling each person to put
Once this terrible pandemic is defeated, it their passions into play, and helping people and
ZRXOG EH XQWKLQNDEOH IRU SHRSOH WR UHYHUW WR WHDPV WR SRVLWLRQ WKHPVHOYHV LQ D IUDPHZRUN
WKHLUIRUPHUZD\VRIZRUNLQJ Guido Stratta, Head of
WKDWDOORZVWKHLUWDOHQWVWRÀRXULVK
People and Organization at Enel
1RZ LV WKH WLPH IRU FRPSDQLHV WR UHWKLQN WKH ,QUHFHQWWLPHVZRUNDQGSDVVLRQKDYHUDUHO\
ZD\WKH\ZRUN7RGRWKLVLWLVH[WUHPHO\LPSRUWDQWWREHDEOH gone hand in hand and it was widely believed that only a few
WRFRPELQHWKHYDOXHRIWKHLQWHUSHUVRQDODVSHFWVRIZRUNZLWK people had the privilege of combining the two.
what we have learned in this particular period.
However, the extremely dramatic experience that we are all
In this context, all the things that can be done from a distance, living through has also given us new insights. The issue of
DYRLGLQJ WKH VWUHVV RI WUDYHOOLQJ WR WKH Ṙ FH DQG UHGXFLQJ FRPELQLQJZRUNDQGSDVVLRQVLVUHODWHGWRWKHDELOLW\WRPRYH
SROOXWLRQ ZLOO FRQWLQXH WR EH GRQH IURP KRPH FRZRUNLQJ WRZDUGVWKLVJRDORYHUWLPHLIDSHUVRQNQRZVZKHUHWKH\QHHG
VSDFHVQHZDUHDVDQG³+XE4XDUWHU´Ṙ FHVZLWKQRLQGLYLGXDO to go, then it paves the way for them to foster relationships and
ṘFHVEXWZLWKDPSOHVSDFHIRUFROODERUDWLRQDQGVKDULQJ contacts within organizations that can lead them towards their
passions.
There will also be periods of high relational quality, where
SURMHFWV FDQ EH ODXQFKHG EUDLQVWRUPLQJ FDQ WDNH SODFH DQG 1RZDGD\VSHRSOHOLYHLQLQFUHDVLQJO\ÀH[LEOHZRUOGVZLWKOHVV
departmental meetings can be held, once a month or more, KLHUDUFK\7KHWDUJHWHQYLURQPHQWLVWKHIUDPHZRUNLQZKLFK
in order to build team spirit and a sense of community and they can tap into their talent and an organization that provides
LQFOXVLRQ3HRSOHZLOOKDYHDFFHVVWRWKHṘFHDVDQGZKHQWKH\ the conditions to do so.
QHHG LW ERRNLQJ LQ DGYDQFH DQG VKRZLQJ WKH VDPH VHQVH RI
responsibility that they have shown during this period. The future of organizations will be this digital-analogue (digi-
ORJLF PL[IDFLOLWDWHGE\WKHVLPSOL¿FDWLRQRIEXVLQHVVSURFHVVHV
7KH ZD\ FRPSDQLHV ZRUN ZLOO EH UHZULWWHQ DV LV FXUUHQWO\ and procedures, and made up of trust, responsibility, listening,
happening in the Group where I am Head of People and passion and new leadership methods.
2UJDQL]DWLRQ ZH ZLOO EH IRFXVLQJ HYHQ PRUH RQ WKH VSHFL¿F
needs of our internal and external customers, with the aim to This is Enel’s vision of the new way to be.
VLPSOLI\ WKH ³PDFKLQH´ :H ZLOO DOVR EH ORRNLQJ WR HVWDEOLVK
relationships with all start-ups, new developments and
innovations, in order to be at the forefront of change, which
today is essential.
In order to move forward in this new scenario, it is crucial to
determine how to redesign the relationship between leadership
and collaboration, between people’s talents and business areas.
ANGOLA ARGENTINA
Finance Minister Vera The pandemic—and the resulting
Daves, 37, says she won’t increase in home cooking—helped
rest until she launches the Ignacio Noel turn around century-
Angolan stock market—this old Buenos Aires flour maker
year, she hopes. The Luan- Morixe Hermanos. Its stock is
da native expects telecom up fourfold since early 2020.
Multitel and construction
company Mota-Engil to be

WORLD
among the first IPOs.
BAHRAIN
38
Forbes Middle East
features Najla Al Shirawi
on its list of Power Busi-
FRONTRUNNER

OF nesswomen. The CEO of

FORBES
SICO, a Manama-based
investment bank with
$2.3 billion in assets, is
leading its expansion
into Saudi Arabia.

Across the planet, our 35 licensed


editions span five continents,
BOLIVIA BRAZIL
PepsiCo, which is beginning Santos native Djamila
24 languages and 13 time zones. to make Cheetos at a Bolivian Ribeiro’s three books—
They all share the same mission: manufacturing plant, has com- comprising essays on such
celebrating entrepreneurial capitalism mitted to buy an estimated topics as Black female
30 tons of locally grown corn empowerment and race-
in all its forms. each month and is hiring about quota policies—have sold
300 people for production, dis- more than 500,000 copies
tribution and marketing jobs. and been translated into
French, Spanish and Italian.

BULGARIA CHINA COLOMBIA CYPRUS


Named one of China’s most “Telecommunications
successful businesswomen became the unexpected
by Forbes China, Wang Feng hero of the battle against
Ying is the first female presi- social isolation and the

BY KATHERINE LOVE. ANGOLA: WALTER FERNANDES; BAHRAIN: SICO; BOLIVIA: PEPSICO; BULGARIA: IVAN KOLOVOS; COLOMBIA:
dent of Great Wall Motor, threat of financial paraly-
China’s largest manufacturer sis,” says Andreas Neocle-
of SUVs and pickup trucks. ous, CEO of the country’s

CLEVER LEAVES; CYPRUS: DIMITRIS VATTIS; CZECH REPUBLIC: DAVID TURECKY; GREECE: KONSTANTINOS LYMPEROPOULOS
international voice and
data-services leader, Cyta.

CZECH REPUBLIC
Sara Kyurkchieva launched Offering medical
Orpheus, a cosmetics line cannabis—what Colom-
that claims to harness the bians call “the new green
restorative powers of the gold”—Bogotá-based
Orpheus flower, in 2018 Clever Leaves debuted
to help her sensitive skin. on the Nasdaq via a SPAC
The flower grows along Bul- in December. Recent mar-
garia’s border with Greece. ket cap: $330 million.
Forbes Czech 30 Under 30
honoree Veronika Kamen-
DOMINICAN REPUBLIC FRANCE GEORGIA ská, 21, created a mental-
health app after surviving
Lucile Houellemont Having designed Heineken Skeptics questioned the a suicide attempt. Avail-
de Gamundi took over bottles, trams and a superyacht, future of Guram Gvasalia’s able in nine languages,
Dominican Watchman after multidisciplinary artist Ora ïto’s streetwear brand, Vete- Nepanikař (“Don’t Panic”)
her father’s death in 2016. next project is transforming a ments, after his brother, a has been downloaded
The 50-year-old security Marseille fortress into a seaside fashion designer, departed nearly 200,000 times.
company is now preparing attraction promoting environ- the company in 2019. Yet
to begin exporting its mentalism. “Entrepreneurial sales grew during the
products—such as elec-
tronic entry cards and
success today is no longer [about]
turnover, but what the business
pandemic, he says. “If your
house is built well . . . it will HUNGARY
surveillance cameras—to will generate,” he says. sustain any strong wind.” After making a million-
other Caribbean islands. dollar fortune in roofing
and façades across Eastern
GREECE Europe, József Kreinbacher
is pouring his time into his
Boosting Greece’s export mountainside winery, which
GDP, which lags behind that produces 200,000 bottles
of most EU countries, is of award-winning Hungar-
key to climbing out of its ian champagne each year.
decade-long financial tur-
moil, says academic Kon-
stantinos Lymperopoulos.
He believes the country’s
problems have been exac-
erbated by the pandemic
and reduced consumption.

FORBES.COM A P R I L / M AY 2 0 2 1
INDIA INDONESIA ISRAEL
Southeast Asia’s most-followed Omri Schanin, 31, is the cofounder
YouTuber with 26.5 million of MeaTech, a Tel Aviv–listed
subscribers, Atta Halilintar fronts company that debuted on the
Forbes Indonesia’s inaugural list of Nasdaq in March. The startup,
top digital-content creators. The founded in 2018, sustainably
26-year-old has made his name in 3D-prints meat from the stem
acting, rap and prank videos. cells of chickens and cattle.

39
Philanthropist Azim
Premji’s foundation and ITALY JAPAN KAZAKHSTAN
Wipro, the Indian IT giant Hiromasa Tsuchiya chairs Last year Alim Khamitov, 34 (far
he scaled, committed CAINZ, a $4 billion (sales) left), and Mirat Akhmetsadykov,

FRONTRUNNER
$155 million toward fighting discount home-goods cen- 33, launched a $10 million venture
the pandemic. Wipro also ter testing innovative ways fund to support Kazakh and Central
converted one of its facili- to improve the retail experi- Asian startups as part of MOST, an
ties to a 450-bed hospital ence, including a robot or entrepreneurship community that
for Covid-19 patients. app that guides customers has emerged over the past decade.
to specific items.

LATVIA Forbes Italy adds a social MEXICO MONGOLIA


media category to its 30 Guadalajara native Sergio
Under 30 list, honoring viral “Checo” Pérez, 31, will rep-
stars such as Norma Cer- resent Red Bull Racing in
letti, a 29-year-old English Formula 1 this year. He
teacher who has more than clocked his first big win in
800,000 followers across December at the Sakhir
Instagram and TikTok. Grand Prix in Bahrain.
S.BATSAIKHAN FOR FORBES MONGOLIA; POLAND: PIOTR WANIOREK; PORTUGAL: VICTOR MACHADO; ROMANIA: SHUTTERSTOCK; SLOVAKIA: ONDŘEJ PÝCHA;

Tatsuya Hamada heads Mo-


POLAND
INDONESIA: WS PRAMONO; ISRAEL: NIR SLAKMAN; ITALY: SILVIA PASQUETTO; MEXICO: BRYN LENNON / GETTY IMAGES FOR RED BULL RACING; MONGOLIA:

In order to promote bicom, the nation’s leading


SPAIN: XAVIER TORRES-BACCHETTA; SOUTH KOREA: LEE WON-KEUN FOR FORBES KOREA; UKRAINE: ALEXANDER CHEKMENEV; ZIMBABWE: SASHA MUSA

farming and production, and telecom and web provider,


support increased interest Gabriel Chojak’s Dekorglass which has expanded into
in buying property, Latvia in molds 200 tons of glass digital payments. More than
February increased the loan each day into decorative 1.6 million users have made
limit to purchase agricultural bottles for products such as PORTUGAL secure purchases via its
Monpay smartphone app.
land to €1 million. Hugo Boss fragrances and
Johnnie Walker whiskey.
Annual revenue was roughly
ROMANIA $50 million pre-pandemic.
RUSSIA
Early Facebook investor Yuri Milner
says he donates nearly $100 million
to science and space exploration
each year. “There should be people
or institutions that will finance
projects with little chance of suc-
Twenty years of stagnant cess but with great potential signifi-
economic growth is a cance,” he tells Forbes Russia.
“national shame,” says oil
executive António Costa e
Silva, who has been tasked
“The residential market SLOVAKIA by the government with SOUTH KOREA SPAIN
recorded exceptional drafting a decade-long
recovery plan. “We have to Baek Joon-ho heads
results in 2020,” says Ionuţ
create conditions for the Seoul-based Furiosa AI, a
Nicolescu, president of SVN
country to create wealth.” maker of AI-enabled semi-
Romania’s property port-
conductor coprocessors.
folio. The number of real
Competing against Nvidia
estate transactions nation-
and Intel types, the chips’
ally rose 11.6% in 2020.
SWITZERLAND decision-making capabili-
ties are used in everything
from autonomous driving
THAILAND Slovak Olympic medalist
to language translation.

When Amorn Thongthew, and Hall of Fame profes- The Spanish-language You-
37, takes the reins of sional basketball coach Tube yoga classes of Xuan
Viriyah Insurance from Natália Hejková has led Lan—a Vietnam native liv-
his mother, he plans to teams to five EuroLeague ing in Barcelona—have at-
expand the 74-year-old Women titles. She names tracted 1.4 million followers.
Bangkok company’s non- 11-time NBA championship She fronts Forbes Spain’s
automotive categories, coach Phil Jackson as issue titled “Who’s Who in
such as health care. her role model. the Business of Yoga.”

UKRAINE Lukas Langenegger’s ZIMBABWE


startup, Hemotune, which
Near-billionaire Yuriy Kosiuk and his grew out of public research Chef Nicola Kagoro, 32, is
company, MHP, Ukraine’s largest university ETH Zurich, seeks building a business promoting
poultry producer, are rolling out an effective antidote for veganism across Africa as an
initiatives to promote healthy, af- sepsis. The body’s extreme affordable, nutritious diet. She
fordable cooking. MHP is opening response to infection— partners with the International
meat markets, planning a restau- as seen in many Covid-19 Anti-Poaching Foundation to
rant concept and posting chef- patients—kills 11 million provide dozens of rangers with
guided recipes on social media. people each year. three plant-based meals a day.

A P R I L / M AY 2 0 2 1 FORBES.COM
BUY, HOLD, SELL Book Value
Leaders from the worlds
of business, academia,
Trucks entertainment and
40 politics share what’s on
Ken Gross their bedside table.
Author, curator, former
FRONTRUNNER

director of the Petersen


Automotive Museum

1962-69 1946-68 1947-55


Jeep Gladiator J3000 Dodge Power Wagon Chevrolet Advanced Niraj Shah
Rugged and straight- An Army truck toned down Design Thriftmaster Billionaire cofounder and
edged, early 4x4 Gladiators for the road, the civilian CEO of online furniture
Despite their timeless
were Spartan rock crushers. model still has the torque styling, these trucks are
and home-goods retailer
Forget the second- to pull tree stumps all day. short on upside potential Wayfair
generation J-Series Good examples go for (unless it was given the
(1970-87) and hunt down $50,000 to $70,000 but rare and expensive
an old-school Thriftside are in high demand. NAPCO 4x4 conversion).
“longbox”—a truck with an If yours isn’t rusted out,
ultralong bed and sharply it’s possible to get $30,000
angled sides—for $20,000. to $40,000 for it.

Sparkling Wine
Victoria James The Black Widow
By Daniel Silva
Author, sommelier,
beverage director The Black Widow
and partner at Cote (Harper, 2017) is the 16th
in Manhattan
of Daniel Silva’s Gabriel
Allon thrillers. The series
begins with Allon, an
Israeli ex–intelligence
operative, living a quiet

BUY, HOLD, SELL BY CHRISTIAN KREZNAR. CHRIS LYONS (3) FOR FORBES, LEFT; SHAH: SAM KERR FOR FORBES
A. Margaine Spécial Club Nyetimber’s 1086 Peter Lauer’s 1992 Réserve
life as an art restorer.
Blanc de Blancs Prestige Cuvée Riesling Sekt Nature
He’s soon called back
This “club” of Champagne Grown in soil similar Pure sommelier catnip. into the game to hunt
growers make some of to that of Champagne, If you have a bottle of this
France’s best bubbly. At this English wine is chal- German gem squirreled down terrorists. I’ve
$105, this wine from the lenging its French counter- away, you have a tough always been interested
small village of Villers- parts. Northern climes decision: Drink it in its in espionage, but before
Marmery will merit its own are warming; admission prime or sell for a neat $90. the pandemic, I had
celebration in 20 years. to this up-and-coming little time to read. In
bottle starts at $250 and this installment, Allon
will go up from there. is about to become the
chief of Israel’s secret
intelligence service
Real Estate but ends up back in
the arena when an ISIS
Bradley Nelson operative detonates
a bomb in Paris. As
Chief marketing officer, Allon tracks down the
Sotheby’s International man responsible, The
Realty
Black Widow shows, in
methodical, step-by-
step detail, how he does
it. Each book in the
series is self-contained,
New York or London Portuguese Hotspots Family Vacation Condos though Silva’s character
Pieds-à-Terre development is so
Lisbon and Porto are the Remote work has made
Nashville and Austin of seasonal homes viable
intoxicating that
Pandemic-driven urban
flight caused prices to drop Europe: Google has already year-round. Say farewell you want to start the
in 2020, but as the economy set up shop in Lisbon; to the vacation pad you next one as soon as
reopens, the market is heat- expect more companies haven’t used in a while. you finish. It’s great
ing back up. Apartments in to follow. Affluent tech If you’re lucky, you might escapism, a different
new developments, like this buyers will do wonders for have something akin to kind of entertainment.
$2 million loft in Brooklyn’s property values. this 2002 Naples condo, There’s only so much TV
waterside Dumbo neighbor- asking $9.5 million.
you can watch.
hood, are prime investments.

FORBES.COM A P R I L / M AY 2 0 2 1
© 2021 FGP, LLC. All Rights Reserved. Forbes Global Properties® is a pending trademark registration used under license.

Showcasing the world's finest homes...


and the stories behind them
Neal Norman • neal@hawaiilife.com
ForbesGlobalProperties.com Hawai'i Life Real Estate Brokers
+1 808.651.1777 • RB-18048
F
rom the time he entered the White House in
January 2017 to his departure a few months
ago, Donald Trump’s fortune fell by nearly a
third, from $3.5 billion to $2.4 billion. The
S&P 500, meanwhile, increased 70%.
42 Every investor at some point has kicked himself for hold-
Politics ing an asset too long. Perhaps none, however, has made such
a monumental miscalculation. By refusing to divest his port-

TRUMP’S
FRONTRUNNER

folio upon taking office, Trump bogged down his presidency


with ethics issues for years, while also missing a chance to

BAD BET cash in on a market boom he helped propel.


If he had sold everything on Day 1, paid the maximum
capital-gains taxes on the sales, then put the proceeds into a
The former president refused to conflict-free fund tracking the S&P 500, Trump would have
divest his assets when he took office in 2017. ended his presidency an estimated $1.6 billion richer than he
It cost him some $1.6 billion. is today. Below are his four biggest losers and top two gainers.

ABOVE-AVERAGE JOE
President Biden’s net worth has
soared in recent years.

TRUMP: CHIP SOMODEVILLE/GETTY IMAGES; BIDEN: ERIN SCOTT/GETTY IMAGE;CRAIG WARTGA/BLOOMBERG; EPICS/GETTY IMAGES;
MATTHIAS LERVOLG/GETTY IMAGES; JULIE THURSTON/GETTY IMAGES;MICHELE EVE SANDBERG/GETTY IMAGES; JOSE MORE/ALAMY
6 East 57th Street • New York 40 Wall Street • New York 555 California St • San Francisco
NET VALUE: $148 million WHAT HE OWNS: Leasehold WHAT HE OWNS: 30% stake in
CHANGE DURING PRESIDENCY: TOTAL VALUE: $304 million
three-building complex
$217 million DEBT: $137 million
TOTAL VALUE: $1.9 billion
Online shopping has wreaked NET VALUE: $168 million
DEBT: $538 million
havoc on buildings like this, a glitzy NET VALUE: $422 million
65,000-square-foot space just off CHANGE DURING PRESIDENCY: THROUGHOUT HIS career, Joe
Fifth Avenue in the middle of what $195 million CHANGE DURING PRESIDENCY: Biden was fond of saying he
was once one of the busiest retail Profits at Trump’s Financial District $102 million was the “poorest,” or one of the
locations in the world. It hasn’t tower, home to dozens of small Two of Trump’s major tenants poorest, officials in Congress.
helped that Nike abandoned its firms, plummeted 32% during the here, Goldman Sachs and Bank of That’s no longer the case. Dur-
five-story flagship in 2018. Tiffany, first three quarters of 2020, the America, made a show of distanc- ing a campaign stop last year
which has been subleasing Nike’s most recent period on record. ing themselves from Trump after in South Carolina, he said he
old space while its own Fifth Avenue the Capitol riot. Behind the scenes, was “stunned” by his post-
hub is being renovated, is slated to however, both re-upped their leases vice-presidential earnings,
vacate in 2022. in Trump’s most valuable property. citing the success of Promise
Me, Dad, his book about his
son Beau, who died of cancer
in 2015: “I didn’t realize it, but
I made a lot of money.”
Thanks to his book deal and
the speaking circuit, Biden and
his wife, Jill, raked in about
$11 million in 2017 and another
almost $6 million in 2018 and
2019. He used some of that to
TRUMP BY DAN ALEXANDER; BIDEN BY MICHELA TINDERA

buy a 4,800-square-foot seaside


escape in Rehoboth Beach,
Delaware, for $2.7 million in 2017.
Hotel Management & Licensing Trump National Doral, Miami Mar-a-Lago • Palm Beach, Florida His most valuable asset, it’s now
NET VALUE: $57 million TOTAL VALUE: $135 million NET VALUE: $250 million worth an estimated $3.4 million,
up some 25% in four years—
CHANGE DURING PRESIDENCY: DEBT: $125 million CHANGE DURING PRESIDENCY: lifted in part by surging home
$163 million NET VALUE: $10 million
$75 million values during the pandemic.
Trump’s branding business didn’t When the coronavirus hit, northeast- Forbes pegs Biden’s net
CHANGE DURING PRESIDENCY:
benefit from four years of polariza- erners flocked south and Floridians worth, after taxes and spend-
$160 million ing, at an estimated $9 million,
tion and the January 6 Capitol riot. stayed put. Huge demand and lim-
Several licensees have dropped the Business at this golf resort was ited supply were welcome news for including the beach house, a
Trump name from their properties, already bad before the pandemic. the state’s homeowners, including home in Wilmington, Delaware,
and no one seems eager to step Then revenue plunged more than Trump. He bought the Palm Beach a federal pension worth more
in and replace them. “He has done 40%. With $125 million of Deutsche club, where he decamped after than $1 million, plus cash and
permanent damage to the Trump Bank debt coming due in 2023, leaving D.C., in 1985 for about $10 investments. That’s to say noth-
name and image, at least for two rumors are circling that the Trump million: $5 million for the oversized ing of his recent raise: Biden
or three decades,” concludes real Organization may consider turning home, a reported $3 million for fancy earns $400,000 a year as presi-
estate analyst Kevin Brown. the property into a casino. furnishings, plus another $2 million dent, up from $230,700 as VP.
for beachfront land across the road.

FORBES.COM A P R I L / M AY 2 0 2 1
30 Beverly Park Terrace
Beverly Hills, California
3.47 Acres
$110,000,000

Rick Hilton • rickhilton@rhilton.com


Jeff Hyland • jeff@hiltonhyland.com
Barron N. Hilton • barron@hiltonhyland.com
Tessa Hilton tessa@hiltonhyland.com
+1 310.278.3311
DRE: 01160681
Architectural Rendering

Kahala Beachfront Development


Opportunity • Oahu, Hawaii
$25,000,000

4607 Kahala Avenue, Honolulu


Erik Hinshaw • erik@hawaiilife.com
+1 808.800.6278
Matt Beall • matt@hawaiilife.com
+1 808.346.7413

Providing unrivaled access to the


world's finest homes
© 2021 FGP, LLC. All Rights Reserved. Forbes Global Properties®
ForbesGlobalProperties.com is a pending trademark registration used under license.
C H E AT W AV E
For homebound students, dishonest
schoolwork during the pandemic has
gotten much easier. One big reason is
Chegg, a company minting money by
answering test (er, homework . . . cough,
44 cough) questions on demand. A market
need being filled, or sign of academic
apocalypse? Readers raised their
FRONTRUNNER

hands to weigh in.

COLIN EDWARDS:
“Gotta love technology
that contributes to the
degradation of society for
the gain of profit.”
@OLIVIER_AMAR:
Conversation “This is total BS.
Soon they’re going to

MR. CONGENIALITY
call out Google for kids
looking up answers
there, too.”
@CUPIDEANSO:
“It isn’t that serious. Anything

F
rank Slootman is a bare-knuckled serial CEO who runs ev- truly comprehensive
ery company he helms like a one-man fief. (“I exercise execu- still [requires that you] do
tive prerogative,” he told Forbes for our February/March cover the work.”
story. “I don’t have to justify it.”) The latest stop in his peripa-
tetic career has paid off handsomely: Last September, Sloot- DREW BATES:
“Colleges cheat
man guided cloud-tech firm Snowflake to a $3.9 billion IPO, the largest ever students every day.
for a software maker, turning himself into a billionaire in the process. But They’re still getting
while his aggressive nature has filled corporate coffers (Snowflake was his that tuition
money, right?”
third IPO), readers were split on the merits of his brusque management style. LARRY CHAO:
“For every one Slootman,” tweeted @moseskagan, “there are 1,000 overcon- “You can cheat on a test,
but you can’t cheat your
fident dipshits who don’t listen, don’t appreciate their employees/partners way through life without
and make stupid decisions.” In others, though, Slootman’s no-nonsense mien getting caught.”
sparked admiration—and a comparison to Harvey Keitel’s famed tuxedo-clad
celluloid fixer. Tweeted @TrungTPhan: “[Slootman] is basically the corpo- @VETCAPITALGROUP:
rate world’s version of Mr. Wolf from Pulp Fiction.” “The problem isn’t Chegg.
The problem is that people
want to cheat to get ahead.”

THE INTEREST GRAPH


758,794 Meet Jared and Ivanka’s New Neighbors—Including Tom and Gisele—on Miami’s Billionaire’s Bunker

96,054 Inside the Billion-Dollar Plan to Kill Credit Cards

87,933 The Manipulative, Little-Known Billionaire Who Nearly Ruined the Country’s Richest Black Person

84,915 This $12 Billion Company Is Getting Rich Off Students Cheating Their Way Through Covid

83,837 The Blockchain 50 2021

65,410 The Outsider: How CEO-for-Hire Frank Slootman Turned Snowflake Into Software’s Biggest-Ever IPO
BY LEAH ROSENBAUM

36,294 Instacart Survived Covid Chaos—but Can It Keep Delivering After the Pandemic?

17,890 THE BOMB: Gold in Your Closet: The Startup Helping Patagonia and Levi’s Cash In on the Resale Boom

FORBES.COM A P R I L / M AY 2 0 2 1
Vail • Beaver Creek • Bachelor Gulch • Breckenridge • Keystone • Copper • Aspen • Snowmass • Denver

1 4

2 5

3 6

Nesting has never felt more natural


1 Breckenridge • 1020 Gold Run Road • $3.86M 4 Vail • 354 Beaver Dam Road S • $23.9M
We’ve found our natural fit Jeff Moore • jeffmoore@slifersummit.com Paul Gotthelf • pgotthelf@slifer.net
with Forbes Global Properties. 2 Vail • Four Seasons Residence 8201 • $15.9M 5 Snowmass • Electric Pass Lodge
Now find yours with Dana Gumber • dgumber@slifer.net
Rebekah Zenor • rzenor@slifer.net
Starting at $1.4M
Rod Woelfle • rodw@sliferrfv.com
Slifer Smith & Frampton Real Estate. Sarah Woelfle • sarahw@sliferrfv.com
3 Snowmass • One Snowmass East 603 • $3.5M 6 Bachelor Gulch • 2201 Daybreak • From $5.7M
SliferSmithandFrampton.com © 2021 FGP, LLC. All Rights Reserved. Forbes Global Properties® Chris Searles • chris@sliferrfv.com Ed Swinford • eswinford@slifer.net
is a pending trademark registration used under license.
ForbesGlobalProperties.com Brent Rimel • brimel@slifer.net
D A R E T O D O D I F F E R E N T LY

47

INNOVATION
By Steven Bertoni and Antoine Gara Photograph by Jamel Toppin for Forbes

Scene Stealer
VI MEO wasted its youth striving to be an oddball combo of Netflix and a
commercial-free YouTube. After a hard refocus on business users, CEO A NJAL I S U D
has transformed the near-forgotten brand into a $6 billion blockbuster business
that lets both mom-and-pop shops and giant corporations shoot, edit and post
millions of videos across the internet’s most influential sites.

A P R I L / M AY 2 0 2 1 FORBES.COM
S
and made Sud the CEO.
In November 2020, Vimeo raised $150 million
at a $2.8 billion valuation from Thrive Capital
and GIC, Singapore’s sovereign wealth fund. Just
two months later, it got $300 million more at a
48 nearly $6 billion valuation from T. Rowe Price
and San Francisco–based Oberndorf Enterprises.
HOW TO PLAY IT This spring, IAC plans to spin off Vimeo tax-
C O N T R A R I A N • I N N OVAT I O N

According to
Dennis Hong free to shareholders. It will be Diller’s eighth spin-
Vimeo has been
off. Over the last 25 years, IAC has incubated, re-
a big hit for Barry habbed, flipped and spun misfit web assets worth
Diller’s IAC, but $100 billion, including household names like
Dennis Hong, of
$1.3 billion (as- Match.com, Expedia and Angie’s List. The strategy
Seven years ago, Vimeo sets) ShawSpring has worked: A buck invested in IAC at its dawn in
had Hollywood dreams. The internet video out- Partners, thinks 1995 is now worth about $40, a compound annual
the stock, which is
fit—owned by Barry Diller’s IAC—had found a up 94% in the last return of 16% versus the S&P 500 Index’s 10% re-
niche hosting flicks for artsy filmmakers who six months, has turn over the same stretch. “In digital life and its
more room to run.
didn’t want their works to be tossed into You- Hong thinks Diller’s
possibilities, Vimeo’s not even in the first round,”
Tube’s unruly, ad-driven stew. But it was a tiny, August 2020 Diller says. “It has extraordinary potential.”
money-losing business with annual revenue un- purchase of 12% of Vimeo should be another star spin-off. In the
gaming operator
der $40 million. Vimeo was pinning its hopes on MGM for $1 billion current frothy cloud software market, Bank of
the booming streaming business, betting it could lays the ground- America predicts Vimeo (which IAC tried to un-
leverage its relationship with creatives to build work for a major load to Kodak for around $10 million more than
online-gaming
a subscription service to rival Netflix, Amazon play. He also be- a decade ago) could hit a valuation of $10 bil-
Prime and HBO. It hired studio execs from Para- lieves Diller’s asset lion—about 50% of IAC’s current market cap.
trove contains
mount and Hulu and signed distribution deals businesses that
For customers, Vimeo is a digital crop duster
with Lionsgate, CBS Interactive and Spike Lee will thrive post- whose software enables them to spread videos
for content to stock the new service. Covid, including across social media, email marketing campaigns,
online child-care
But Anjali Sud, then Vimeo’s 31-year-old di- network Care websites, digital marketplaces and streaming
rector of marketing, had a hunch the company’s .com and ANGI channels. Subscriptions start at $7 a month for
future was not in Hollywood hits but Silicon Val- Homeservices. a basic package and climb to more than $20,000
Homebuyers who
ley plumbing. Her plan: shift its focus from en- have fled to the a month for big enterprise deployments at places
tertainment to entrepreneurs. “Vimeo had long suburbs will need like Amazon and Starbucks.
ANGI’s handymen.
been a software company for filmmakers, but the Hong estimates
Because Vimeo is commercial-free, its videos
market was too small,” says Sud, now 37. “There that ANGI (worth are allowed on ad-supported outlets like Facebook,
was another, much bigger market—businesses. $7 billion today) LinkedIn, YouTube, Pinterest and Twitter. Ad-free
could reach a $50
What Squarespace and GoDaddy did for web- billion valuation. is also vital for distribution on online retailers like
sites, we could do with video.” With $2.9 billion Amazon, Etsy and Shopify. And Vimeo’s corporate
She pitched the idea to Joey Levin, Diller’s in cash, IAC trades clients don’t have to fret about random advertise-
at a discount
handpicked IAC CEO. “Anjali said, ‘This is a real despite decades ments—or, worse, ones from competitors—appear-
business that’s relevant to a much larger audi- of spinning straw ing in the middle of their branded content. HOW TO PLAY IT BY ANTOINE GARA. PATRICK WELSH FOR FORBES
into gold.
ence than anyone thinks,’ ” Levin says. He gave Companies like Deloitte, Pottery Barn, Rite Aid
Sud a small team to test the idea. “We like to find and Forbes use Vimeo to deliver training and on-
smart, talented, ambitious people, throw them boarding videos in addition to livestreaming cor-
into the deep end and see if they can swim.” porate events to employees now spread worldwide.
Sud was soon doing the backstroke, transform- Meanwhile, a million-plus smaller businesses use
ing Vimeo from a dusty web relic into the show- Vimeo to distribute advertising, product demos
stopper of IAC’s tech portfolio. A one-stop shop to and how-to videos. Vimeo may have failed to launch
shoot, edit, store and distribute video, Vimeo post- its own streaming channel, but thousands of oth-
ed sales of $84 million during the fourth quarter of ers—from indie filmmakers to Pilates instructors—
2020, a 54% jump from the same period the previ- use it to create subscription channels on streaming
ous year. Last quarter, net subscribers increased by services such as Apple TV, Roku, Fire TV and Xbox.
300,000, to a total of 1.5 million—a gain of nearly Says Sud, “We’re both a 16-year-old video platform
25%. Annual revenue is on track to top $300 mil- and a three-year-old software startup.”
lion. IAC shut down the streaming division in 2017 Vimeo came aboard IAC in 2006 as a stowaway

FORBES.COM A P R I L / M AY 2 0 2 1
Little Big Picture The internet’s biggest video stars rule separate
fiefdoms—gamers on Twitch, dancers on TikTok,
LIVING THE STREAM celebrities on IGTV—and have larger followings than
major media outlets. Here are the most popular
upon Diller’s purchase of Connected Ventures, the accounts and the year each first signed on.
parent of lowbrow comedy site CollegeHumor. The
$30 million deal included the comedy studio, its TWITCH:
17M FOLLOWERS (2011)
Ninja
companion merch site BustedTees—and Vimeo,
the web player for CollegeHumor’s sketches. “We YOUTUBE:
109M SUBSCRIBERS (2010)
bought Vimeo almost by accident,” says IAC’s PewDiePie 49
Levin. For much of the subsequent decade, the
TIKTOK:
company tried to make money off viewers through 111M FOLLOWERS (2019)
Charli D’Amelio

C O N T R A R I A N • I N N OVAT I O N
an iTunes-like on-demand service, and later the ill-
fated studio and streaming channel. Nothing really INSTAGRAM IGTV:
273M FOLLOWERS (2012)
Cristiano Ronaldo
worked. “Vimeo always had an identity crisis,” Sud
says. “We had an amazing brand and platform, but
it was hard to see what to do with it.”
Sud certainly had the smarts and the credentials content studio sputtered. It was impossible to
to give Vimeo a makeover. She grew up the daugh- compete against deep-pocketed giants like Ama-
ter of two immigrant doctors in a tight-knit Indi- zon Prime Video and Netflix, which were plowing
an community in Flint, Michigan. After her pub- billions into movies and shows. In the summer of
lic school lost its accreditation, Sud applied to 12 2017 Levin told Sud that Vimeo was dropping the
boarding schools and got into Massachusetts’ elite studio and going all-in on software—with Sud as
Phillips Academy Andover. Next came a Wharton CEO. “It never occurred to me that they would of-
degree and then a few years doing mergers at Sa- fer me the position,” Sud says. “I asked, ‘Is this a
gent Advisors. Sud later attended Harvard Business joke?’ and then immediately tried to play it cool.”
School and did stints at Amazon as a toy buyer and Already growing fast—revenue increased 27%
in marketing at Diapers.com before joining Vimeo. in the last quarter of 2019—Vimeo saw demand
A year into the job, Sud began seeing short stoked by the pandemic. “Overnight, video went
advertising clips and product demos posted be- from nice-to-have to need-to-have,” Sud says. As us-
side Vimeo’s usual documentaries and art-house age soared, she hired quickly to scale Vimeo’s tech
flicks. “It was everything from mom-and-pops and customer service. Today it has more than 700
to tech startups to the marketing department of employees, about half in R&D and the rest spread
large corporations,” she says. “They were so di- across sales, marketing and customer support.
verse, it had to be a trend.” Sud is now building for a post-Covid hybrid work
She discovered the new customers were using world in which she expects video’s dominance to
Vimeo to post marketing videos on Facebook, Twit- accelerate. She wants to make virtual events and
ter, Instagram and their own websites. “There was meetings more interactive, intimate and collabor-
a huge group of users that no one was serving.” Her ative. Vimeo is also testing AI to edit raw footage
team developed tools for businesses to upload lo- into slick marketing content for industries such as
gos, insert buy-now buttons and add email capture restaurants and real estate.
to their videos. After a year of solid growth, IAC Then there’s the impending spin-off. Sud says
added 50 more people to Sud’s skunkworks. the move will make it easier to recruit talent,
While the software business soared, Vimeo’s make acquisitions, promote the brand and sell
services to large corporations. (And access capital
Spin Doctor
in a market that values software firms at around
IAC founder Barry 40 times earnings.) As for going from a market-
Diller (net worth
$4.2 billion) made ing director to CEO of a publicly traded compa-
millions as a Holly-
wood mogul in the
ny in less than four years? “As a woman, a mother
1970s and ’80s, and and a tech CEO, I’m unique in the software world,”
billions off the internet
in the decades since. Sud says. “I’m excited to bring my perspective and
“Once you focus style to the industry. It’s going to be fun.”
with clarity, if your
base idea is good,
JAMEL TOPPIN FOR FORBES

you thrive,” he says.


“Vimeo has thrived.” FINAL THOUGHT

“WHATEVER GOOD OR BAD FORTUNE


MAY COME OUR WAY, WE CAN ALWAYS
GIVE IT MEANING AND TRANSFORM
IT INTO SOMETHING OF VALUE.”
—Hermann Hesse

A P R I L / M AY 2 0 2 1 FORBES.COM
CONTRARIAN STRATEGIES
By Chris Helman Photograph by Jamel Toppin for Forbes

American Sun
50
C O N T R A R I A N • S T R AT EG I E S

D E AN S O LO N built a multibillion-dollar fortune in solar energy by manufacturing


precisely the sort of commodity gear that can be made more cheaply in China.
His secret: higher prices for higher quality.

A At Shoals Technolo-
gies’ 100,000-square-foot factory in
Portland, Tennessee, Dean Solon’s quest
for simplicity starts with the color-
coded shirts, inspired by Sesame Street,
that his workers wear. “The SunPower
logo was yellow, so that’s Big Bird. First
Solar was red, for Elmo,” he says. Those
working on an order for Blattner Ener-
gy, a big solar contractor, sport Cookie
Monster blue. “And then we have the
Count, in purple. He’s always counting.
Those are the quality control people.”
Shoals’ nonunionized workers at four
factories in Tennessee and Alabama
make the guts for big solar installa-
tions—basically, everything you need
other than those shiny photovoltaic
panels and the inverters necessary to
feed power onto the grid. They craft
cable assemblies, combiner boxes, exter-
nal fuses. It’s exactly the sort of unsexy
manufacturing that nearly everyone
thinks fled to China years ago.
Indeed, most of Solon’s competitors
are Chinese companies like GCL Sys-
tem Integration and Wuxi Sun King.
The Chinese-made components are

FORBES.COM A P R I L / M AY 2 0 2 1
cheaper than Shoals’, but Solon has an edge: His cess as foolproof as he can. Screens mounted on
stuff is seen as safer, more reliable and easier to the front of each machine show workers how to
install. That means companies are willing to pay do each task—from stripping and crimping wires
5% to 10% more for it, believing they’ll make to installing fuses and finishing cable assemblies—
up for it in lower labor and maintenance costs. with cycle times measured not in man-hours but
Last year, that premium added up to earnings of man-seconds. It’s a “Pavlov’s dog” world, Solon 51
$34 million on $176 million in sales. After a Janu- says, in which workers are trained to self-correct
ary IPO, the 57-year-old Solon is worth some HOW TO PLAY IT when a light atop their station starts blinking, in-

C O N T R A R I A N • S T R AT EG I E S
According to
$2.2 billion, thanks to his 40% stake in the compa- Lucas White dicating they’ve slipped behind schedule and have
ny and after-tax proceeds from prior equity sales. “If you want to
about 15 minutes to sort it out before the blink-
To keep that made-in-America premium as low overhaul the ing gets faster and “maintenance” is summoned.
as possible, Solon makes the manufacturing pro- electric grid, you They’re told never to worry about messing up. “If
need copper,” says
Lucas White, natu- this process makes something wrong, shame on
ral resources and us—we designed it wrong, we didn’t bulletproof
climate-change enough for you not to make mistakes,” he says.
portfolio manager
at $63 billion (as- Plant managers sit above the factory floor on a
sets) GMO, based mezzanine platform Solon calls Pride Rock, after
in Boston. Solar,
wind and electric
the prominent slab in The Lion King. They rarely
vehicles all need get involved; teams help one another sort out prob-
more of it than lems, because if one person slows down for too
fossil-fuel plants:
“Copper is the long, the next in line runs out of parts. “Don’t yell
oil of the clean- at anyone; let them have a self-win,” Solon says.
energy economy.” “I don’t need to squeeze another 10 seconds out of
White likes
Grupo Mexico, them. If the green light is on, we’re making money.”
a conglomer- Solon has taken his family to Disney World
ate—controlled by
billionaire German
twice a year for decades and has long been in-
Larrea Mota spired by the park’s orchestrated perfection. “On
Velasco (net worth the surface everything is calm and happy and se-
$27 billion)—that
has a 90% stake in rene, but underneath there’s hundreds of people
Southern Copper, making sure the magic is right.” On a recent trip to
which has mines Orlando, however, he’s headed not to Disney but
in Mexico and the
Andes mountains to a nearby solar field owned by Origis Energy. On
of southeastern sunny days, this 270-acre installation generates 60
Peru. Also attrac-
tive is Sandfire
megawatts—enough to provide around a quarter
Resources Ltd., a of the Magic Kingdom’s power needs. Michael
western Australia Eyman, managing director of Origis Services, says
gold-and-copper
miner. U.S. inves- Shoals products “are not always the cheapest, but
tors can buy both always the best.” Origis tried installing competi-
stocks over the tors’ gear, “and without exception they all failed in
counter.
their warranty period.”
HOW TO PLAY IT BY CHRIS HELMAN. PARTICK WELSH FOR FORBES
Shoals’ “plug-and-play” hardware eliminates the
need for a crew of expensive electricians out in the
field stripping wires and crimping millions of con-
nections by hand. “We don’t turn our customers’
fields into our proving grounds,” Solon says, show-
ing off a wall of five testing chambers, fridge-size
boxes where he can subject prototypes to 40 days
and nights of heat, cold and 100% relative humidity.
Wire Work Solon is the named inventor on 30 granted and
pending patents. He owns at least that many pairs
Dean Solon, founder
of Shoals Technologies, of jean shorts, his preferred uniform, along with a
designed this Portland, black Shoals collared T-shirt. He prides himself on
Tennessee, factory,
where each day 500 being so uninterested in bean counting and SEC fil-
of his employees ings that 15 months ago he handed the CEO reins
make enough cable
to rig “megawatts to longtime chief technical officer Jason Whitaker.
upon megawatts”
of solar power.
A P R I L / M AY 2 0 2 1 FORBES.COM
American Sun Cont. Insider Info

“I’M GOING TO DISNEY WORLD!”


Dean Solon got hooked on the Magic Kingdom
Solon remains on the board of directors, focusing as a kid in the 1970s and most years takes his
on new products. Shoals’ chairman, Brad Forth, family twice. Here are some of his favorite
corners of the Orlando paradise.
is also a senior advisor to Oaktree Capital, which
bought more than half the company from Solon in Carousel of Progress
2017 and cashed out $2 billion in the recent IPO. “Walt’s creativity was all over it. The
52 Now that it’s public, is there any impetus to squeeze ride is all about America innovating
and moving into the future with hope
out a few more margin points by loosening some of and optimism. We need more of that.”
Solon’s obsessions? “We are never going to sacrifice
C O N T R A R I A N • S T R AT EG I E S

Contemporary Resort
quality or reliability for anything,” says Whitaker, Solon prefers to sleep inside the park
41, “because it’s built into the process itself.” at the 655-room luxury hotel famous
Solon got his start at age 8 carrying a toolbox for the monorail running through
its lobby. “I’m captivated by the The “Utilidors”
for his dad, who did air conditioning and refriger- enormous mural by a Disney designer, “Underneath the whole park is a maze
ation repair and taught at the vocational school in Mary Blair, who was instrumental in of passageways and shortcuts via
Gary, Indiana. Young Dean took apart everything making the ‘It’s a Small World’ ride.” utilidors”—short for utility corridors.
“I would love to go on a tour of them,
to see how it worked and put it back together, Liberty Tree Tavern but it might destroy some of the
from lawnmowers to V8 engines, sometimes with This Frontierland all-you-can-eat magic—like seeing behind the curtain.”
joint is one of Solon’s faves. “One time
a few pieces left over. By 16, he had his own cli- I asked a worker what they do with The Gift Shops
ents and his own truck. He studied engineering at all the leftover food. Turns out they “I’ve had Fendi and Gucci wallets,
Purdue but dropped out. He quit an internship at convert it into biodiesel—that’s why but the best one, which I’ve been
when you’re behind a bus at the park carrying for 10 years, is my $11.95
Inland Steel when it refused to give him credit for sometimes it smells like French fries.” Mickey Mouse murse.’’
innovations he had developed. By the late 1980s
he was engineering and selling automotive parts
for a joint venture between General Electric and I would retire making car parts.” Instead, he in-
Bosch. He made a point of cutting his commis- troduced manufacturing perfectionism to the
sion in order to keep customers coming back for “Ph.D. thinkers and basement tinkerers” of solar,
more—then quit when his bosses resented that he who had no idea how to efficiently scale up their
was still making more money than they were. output. “All I knew was scale.”
In 2003 he got a call from First Solar, which The solar revolution is still in its early days.
needed some wiring and junction boxes to con- In 2020, U.S. solar power generation grew 25%
nect solar panels. Soon Cypress Semiconductor to 130 gigawatt hours, but renewables, excluding
wanted the same gear for its SunPower solar spin- hydroelectric, still account for only 12.5% of total
off. “I’d been a gearhead my whole life—I thought domestic energy supply. Beyond higher quality,
there’s another window of opportunity through
which native players can shine: In late 2019, Chi-
na’s Huawei shuttered its U.S. solar business after
Here Comes the Sun Congress made public its concerns that Huawei’s
AT LESS THAN 3 CENTS PER KILOWATT HOUR, SOLAR IS THE equipment could serve as vectors for cyberattack.
CHEAPEST SOURCE OF NEW POWER—AND THE FASTEST-GROWING, For someone so process-driven, it’s refreshing
UP 25% LAST YEAR. IT’S STILL EARLY DAYS: SOLAR PROVIDES
JUST 3.3% OF AMERICA’S ENERGY.
that Solon remains dedicated to the human ele-
ment of his business. Animatronics might be fun
100k at the theme park, but not in Shoals’ factories.
Concentrating-mirror solar
“It’s cool that a robot can work 24/7, but the robot
80k
Utility-scale photovoltaic (PV) doesn’t go home to a family and have to feed it at
Commercial PV
Residential PV the end of the evening,” Solon says. “I could install
automation and do this completely robotically,
60k
this whole factory. But then I’m just a jerk.”

40k
FINAL THOUGHT

20k
“THERE IS SCARCELY ANYTHING IN
THE WORLD THAT SOME MAN CANNOT
MAKE A LITTLE WORSE AND SELL
0k A LITTLE MORE CHEAPLY. THE
2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020
PERSON WHO BUYS ON PRICE ALONE
ALAMY

Installed solar generation capacity, in megawatts of direct current. IS THIS MAN'S LAWFUL PREY.”
S O U R C E : Solar Energy Industries Association/Wood Mackenzie Power & Renewables —John Ruskin
U.S. Solar Market Insight 2020 Year in Review.

FORBES.COM A P R I L / M AY 2 0 2 1
She was watching the water
but looking out for me.
By the time I found out there was a water leak at
my property in Palm Springs, Brandi had already
discovered it and had the leak fixed. It would’ve
caused tens of thousands of dollars in damage
by the time I discovered it because I never go
out there. Neither does Brandi, for that matter.
Why would she? She’s my financial advisor. But
she noticed the water bill was high so she drove
out there to see why. If paying bills and fixing
plumbing don’t seem like the job of a wealth
management firm, maybe yours should be doing
more. Because a big picture approach to wealth
management starts with the little things.

— John, Los Angeles

CONTACT TIM MCCARTHY | 626.463.2545 | WHITTIERTRUST.COM/FORBES


$10 MILLION MARKETABLE SECURITIES AND/OR LIQUID ASSETS REQUIRED. Investment and Wealth Management Services are provided by Whittier Trust Company and The Whittier Trust Company of Nevada, Inc. (referred to herein individually and collectively as “Whittier Trust”),
state-chartered trust companies wholly owned by Whittier Holdings, Inc. (“WHI”), a closely held holding company. This document is provided for informational purposes only and is not intended, and should not be construed, as investment, tax or legal advice. Past performance is no
guarantee of future results and no investment or financial planning strategy can guarantee profit or protection against losses. All names, characters, and incidents, except for certain incidental references, are fictitious. Any resemblance to real persons, living or dead, is entirely coincidental.
TOGETHER WE ARE The Leukemia & Lymphoma Society (LLS)

UNSTOPPABLE.
challenged these executives to raise
$10,000 or more. Together they raised
over $12 million to help LLS fund life-saving
research and provide support to blood
cancer patients and their families.

CHALLENGER

HEATH MELTON NICOLE ALBSTEIN DAVID SHEVSKY ERIKA SCHIMMEL-GUILES BASSIL DAHIYAT
The Howard Hughes Mount Sinai Hospital Ally Financial San Diego Gas & Electric Xencor, Inc.
Corporation

BECKY MANCUSO-WINDING CHUCK CUDA CHRISTINE FINLEY JEFF SHAW DWAYNE WILSON
UCLA Health OPES Commercial Real Estate Entrepreneur Bridge Investment Group Salesforce

Michael Adelman, Goldman Sachs Kim Carpico, Salesforce Omotayo Fasan, Novant Health
Allison Adler, BeiGene Nancy Carr, Claims and Risk Management Services Scott Feighner, Colliers International
Michael Agostino, Hy-Vee, Inc. Steve Castleman, Spectrum Environmental Services, Inc. Al & Jackie Fernandez, ANF Group
Tom Alban, Ohio’s Electric Cooperatives Patrick Chairs, Prudential Financial, Inc. Sanford Feuer, Best Buy Co., Inc., VP Retiree
Rob Allred, UBS AG Mark Chao, Gilead Sciences Mark Fitlin, The Clearing House
Leslie C Amendola, Johnson and Johnson Paul Chodak III, AEP - American Electric Power James Fitzgerald, MarketOne Builders, Inc.
Tamara Amini, Bank of America Dan Church, DairyChem, Inc. Earlene Fontana, Brinkley Farms
Jeffrey Anbinder, Attorney Mike Clark, “Quittired” Adam Ford, Salesforce.com
Paul Anbinder, Retired Founding Publisher and Billy Classen, KFW Engineers Jim Forker, Robert Paul Properties
President of Hudson Hills Press Richard Cole, Cole, Scott & Kissane, P.A. Karel Foti, Florida Paradise Properties/ Berkshire
Amy Anderson, Manchester Memorial Hospital Bob Cole, Kimray, Inc. Hathawat Home Services EWM Realty
Adam Andolina, KeyBank Ronda Conger, CBH Homes Andrew Frankenfield, Exscribe, Inc.
Ashley Arbolino, HITT David Conway, Morgan Stanley Allie Fujarski, Paycom
Steve Armstrong, MSC Industrial Supply Co. Nikki Copas, Bristol Myers Squibb Patricia Gallagher, Science Rocks!!
Greg Armstrong, The Signorelli Company Elizabeth Cote, The Long Group Steve Garcia, Patriot General Engineering, Inc.
Norman Armstrong, King & Spalding Ari Crandall, Premier Wealth Advisors Hillary Gelfman, Kellogg’s
Aubrey Arreola, Viticus Group David Crow, SailPoint Technologies Bobby Ghoshal, ResMed
Colton Austin, The Signorelli Company Jeannie Cullen Schultz, JP Cullen Shelly Glenn, Florida Cancer Specialists
Mark Bachleda, Bristol Myers Squibb Daniel Damon, US Bank Linda Glover
Derek Baden, Citrix Systems Thuy Dancik, Team Dancik Bob & Lynn Goldschmidt, DKMG Consulting
Martin and Terrill Bahar, USC John Daniels, TI - Texas Instruments Tamara Grabowski, San Diego Gas & Electric
Mario L. Barnaba, Barnaba & Marconi LLP Shannon Dauchot, Parallon Revenue Cycle Point Rick Gray, The Wynn Las Vegas
Dave Barnhart, The Signorelli Company Solutions Division Dustin Greene, HCA Healthcare
Tedd Barr, Converze Media Eric Davis, Messer Construction Dayton John Greene, Salesforce
Lisa Barton, AEP - American Electric Power Steve Dearborn, Miller Paint Jim Griffin, Citrix Systems
Missy Bass, C & F Mortgage Corporation Heather DeBolt, CombOver, LLC Brad Grimsley, Carter’s, Inc.
Jeff Beall, Digital Commercial Systems Steve DeMattos, Xencor David Grish, Acurity/Premier
Zane Beard, The Signorelli Company Vince DeRose, Peak Resources, Inc. Albert Guida, Guida & McCubbin Financial Consultants
Lynda Bennett, Lowenstein Sandler Joseph DeSabia, Barclays Tami Gunsch, Berkshire Bank
Scott Bennett, Colliers International Janice Deverell, AT&T Melinda Hancock, VCU Health System
Seth Berkowitz, The Leukemia & Lymphoma Society Jeff Dewese, The Signorelli Company Ava Handel, MaskUp4BloodCancer
Laura Berra, Wells Fargo Advisors Karl Dicker, Capital Bank Alison Handel, MS, Bristol Myers Squibb
Scott Birkhead Robert Dickinson, Dickinson Fleet Services Kathryn Hansen, The Leukemia & Lymphoma Society
Thomas Black, BMC Jimmy Diehl, MassMutual Financial Group Jeff Hare, JH/PR
Michael Blackman, Retired, IBM Executive Donald Dixon, Retired, Deloitte Sam Haskel, Goldman Sachs
Barry Blanton, Blanton Advisors Mary Cushing Doherty, High Swartz, LLP Holly Heer, Barnes & Thornburg LLP
Dave Borkowski, Harkins Builders, Inc. Tom Doll, Subaru of America Jeff Hennessy
Tom Bosch, Avera Rebecca Dooley, SSC Operations, Parallon Ed Hetherington, Doosan Financial Solutions
Marsha Bourque, Marsha Bourque and Associates Jim Doyle, RSM Marlow Hicks, Thermo Fisher Scientific
Charles Boyd, HCA Healthcare Tam Driscoll, City of Gresham Donnie Hill, Precision Manufacturing Co, Inc.
Mike Brannock, WorkForce Unlimited, LLC Allie Dudenhoeffer, Centene Corporation Paul Hoelscher, Horizon Therapeutics
Harris Brett, Gibson Energy James Dugan, Novant Health Bill Hollett, Cousins Properties
Adam Brock, Brock Built Homes Martin Einhorn, Retired-Wall, Einhorn & Chernitzer Juliet Hommes, Bristol Myers Squibb
James Brown, Barclays Bill Eisig, BDO USA, LLP Mike Hunsaker, BMC
Kristin Brown Jason Ellington, Brasfield & Gorrie Harry Irwin, Electric Supply, Inc.
Karen Burns, Sensiba San Filippo Jesse Essex, Hendrick Motorsports Brian Jaramillo, Tilden-Coil Constructors, Inc.
Erich Cabe, Compass Realty Glenn Falk, Falk, Waas, Hernandez, Solomon, Heath Jehlik, The Signorelli Company
Maria Caldwell, National Association of State Mendlestein & Davis, P.A. Brett Jenkins, Intel Corp
Boards of Accountancy Mike Farmer, BMC Elizabeth Jordan
Become a 2021
Executive Challenger
LightTheNight.org

Maxwell Kagan, WellStar Medical Group Chris Pacchiana, Aerotek Mike Simons, EY
David Kahn Joanna Palmieri Jason Sirek, Fox Television Stations - Fox 9 Mpls
Dan Kaplan, Sierra Land Group Brett Panter, Panter, Panter & Sampedro Keith Sitzman, Skanska
Gary Kaplan MD, Virginia Mason Health Systems Pranav Parekh, Apigee | Google Cloud Kelly Sizemore, Kimley-Horn
Aaron Kaplowitz, Johnson and Johnson Dr. Taral Patel, Zangmesiter Cancer Center Brad Slomsky, Towne Properties
Amy Kappen, Best Day Ever Foundation Dr. Debra Patt, Texas Oncology Amy Smedley, Huntsman Corporation
Jennifer Keating, Cisco Sara Patterson, Belk Colette Smiley
Harold Keer, Astex Pharmaceuticals, Inc. Stan Patterson, IQVIA Mike Smith, The Rockport Group
Jared Keller, Financial Independence Planning, LLC Daniel Patton, SailPoint Technologies Steven Smith, Leopardo Companies, Inc.
Sumeet Khemani, ComplySci Martha Pavlakis, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center Kathy Smith, Passion Growers
Jimmy Khun, Florida Cancer Specialists Keith Pence, Caler, Donten, Levine, Cohen, Porter & Veil, P.A. Monte Smith, Terumo BCT
Kevin Kieran, Exelon Debra Perelman, Huntsman Corporation Johnese Spisso, UCLA Health
David & Louise Kingsley Nicki Perrin, Salesforce Clark Spoden, Burr & Forman LLP
Jennifer Kipphut, Fortitude Fitness Tracy Peters, Lument Don Stamas, Defender Capital
Stuart Klein, CPA, Self Employed Leanne Peterson, Southland Electric, Inc. Lisa Stark, American University
Nicole Kline, Merck & Co. Jennifer Petresky, Natural Designs Landscaping Jeffrey Stern, Houlihan Lokey
Grant Knowles, Ardon Health Ginger Phelps, Dominion Energy Ralph Stingo, Bernhard
Bryan Kocher, WESCO Dominic Pitocco Jayne Stockton
Tyler Kowal, Pitch CPA, LLC Chris Pitrof, FIS Global Karen Stoffiere, Cleveland Clinic
Lynn Kuckelman, LK Design Group, Inc. Kevin Pohle, Energy Reps Steve Stouthamer, Skanska
Emily LaMarque, Emily LaMarque Design Studio Blake Pond, Johnson and Johnson Suzanne Strothkamp, SSM Health Legal Affairs
John Lambert, US Bank Ryan Pratt, Ernst & Young Heather Stubblefield, Florida Power & Light Company
Andrew Larew, Larew, Doyle & Associates Andy Priddy, Merrill Lynch Jennifer Swanton, Ritoch-Powell & Associates
Ralph Lawson, LLS National Board of Directors and Matthew Pruitt, PharmD, Walgreens Larry Sweeney, Citrix Systems
Navigant Healthcare Ron Pusey, Corbett Techonology Solutions, Inc. Jason Swift, Best Egg Loans at Marlette Funding
Jim Lazzari, Best Day Ever Foundation Timothy Quick Shandell Szabo
Glenn Leier, Wespac Construction, Inc. Randy Quickel, UFCW Local 1059 Alberto Tano M.D., Kidz Medical Services
Robert Lemaster, Bilbrey Construction Meg Quigley Karen Terry, Memorial Health
Michelle Leon Cordova, Intuit Gene Rapisardi, CIGNA Corporation Melissa Thomas, VyStar Credit Union
Alanna Levine, Boston Children’s Health Physicians Ryan Rehmann, Dynamic Systems, Inc. Larry Thornton, Thornton Enterprises, Inc.
Ross Lissuzzo, CIBC BANK USA Steve Reiss, Willis Towers Watson Jay Tilley, Costco Wholesale Corporation
Judith Lofurno, Headquarters Physical Therapy Rich Reynolds, PwC Michael Tooley, Tooley Oil Company
Brad Lontz, CopperPoint Insurance Companies Bob Reynolds, Brady Ware Michael Touloupas, Touloupas Dentistry
Bailey Lyden, TrueNorth Paul Ricci, Best Egg Loans at Marlette Funding Kelly Trahan, Bridge Investment Group
Amanda Maggiotto, Cleveland Clinic Taussig Cancer Center Raul Rios, RSM US LLP Beth Trammell, 5280 Gymnastics
Fred Magnanimi, Luca + Danni Paul Rittman, Helsinn Therapeutics Greg Trayer, Trayer’s Troop
Carol Markway, Markway Strong Cole Robertson, BP Energy Partners Barry Treahy, Terumo BCT
Ryan Martin, U.S. Bank - Community Banking South Dakota Debra Robinson, Centennial Revenue Management Winselow Tucker, Bristol Myers Squibb
Jordan Mayer, Katz, Sapper & Miller Emily Robinson Gorelik, CBC Specialty Beverage Bryce Unger, CG Schmidt
John T. McCauley, Wells Fargo Advisors Patrick Rohan, Medical City Frisco Michelle Urban, Nabriva Therapeutics
Scott McClintock, Fifth Third Richard Rohrbaugh, Retired, Kimley-Horn Dave Van Brunt, Van Brunt Consulting, LLC
Mark McCullough, AEP - American Electric Power Adam Romero, Sehlke Consulting Ada Varchola, Goldman Sachs
Mark Merz, FIS Kimberly Ross, United Parcel Service (UPS) John Venable, McKesson Corporation
Steve Mikulcik, PayPal Neal Roth, Grossman Roth Yaffa Cohen Adam Viente, Jones Lang LaSalle (JLL)
Jason Miller, Citizens Bank Seth Rubin, Stifel Financial Corp. Ginger Villanti, Broadcom
Kenneth Miller, Federal Home Loan Bank Dr. Peter Ruehlman, OHC - Retired Elizabeth Vlassopoulos, Swinerton Builders
Jud Miller, Woodforest National Bank Kim Rupert, SAIC (Science Applications Jen Wahl, Sun Life Financial
Brad A. Molotsky, Duane Morris LLP International Corporation) Stephen Wall, Dell Technologies
Michael Mondin, Bristol Myers Squibb Randy Rusing, Sundt Construction, Inc. Whitney Wall, Wells Fargo
Brandon Moore, JE Dunn Construction Amanda Salas, Fox 11 Los Angeles Eric Ward, Parallon Business Performance Group
Courtney Morgan, SIMON Markets Maggie Sandwith, Waller Lansden Dortch & Davis Jason Ware, MCI USA
Ken Morris, Business Environments Pierce Sandwith, UBS Bob Weintraub, Industrial Controls Supply
Emmalee Morris, Skanska Sahil Sanghvi, Boston Consulting Group Jonathan Wells, McGriff Insurance Services
Sarina Moss, Florida Power & Light Company Manolis Saridakis, US Bank Melissa Wilkinson, CBH Homes
Cliff Mossberger, Cliff’s Corner/Halloween Town Tracey Sawyer, Mission Pharmacal Greg Williams, Carruthers & Roth, P.A.
Sonya Arnold Motes, Merrill Lynch Bryan Schachter, Watermark Retirement Communities Barry Willis, Costco Wholesale Corporation
Patrick Mulloy, RSM US LLP Robert Schmid, The Schmid Group, LLC Allie Wilson, Dutch Bros Coffee
Monica Mulvihill, Marex Spectron Mike Schmidt, Generac Power Systems Meron Winkler, Twilio, Inc.
Lee Murphy, Glaukos Laura Schmitt, Desert West Surgery Niels Winther, Think Patented
Jamie Myers, Premier Companies Terry K. Schmoyer, Jr., Schmoyer And Company, LLC James Wishbow, James P Wishbow Company
Swati Navani, Seattle Genetics Michael Schnee, Goldman Sachs Group John Wright, RSM US LLP
Marjie Nealon, Bilzin Sumberg Baena Price & Axelrod LLP Brian Schneider, Phyl-Mar Electrical Brian Wulfestieg, Toll Brothers Seattle Division
Robert Newton, Morgan Stanley Eduardo Schur, Ernst & Young Susan Yaeger, Merrill Lynch
Jim Noles, Barze Taylor Noles Lowther, LLC Jennifer Sciarra, Team CharLouRi Chuck Yagla, Kirk Gross Company
Mike Norcia, Integrated Copy Solutions, Inc. Helena Scott, The Leukemia and Lymphoma Society Michele Yakovee, Humana
Mark Nylander, Nylander + Associates Chad Scripps, Black Lake Capital Jim Yancey, The Clearing House
Susan O’Brien, MD, UCI Health Chao Family Chad Sehlke, Sehlke Consulting Ken Yoder, Baker Tilly US
Comprehensive Cancer Center Faisal Shaikh, Deloitte Mark Yoffe, MD, UNC Health
Matthew OBryan, KLA Laboratories, Inc. Heather Shaw, Saks Fifth Avenue Wael Younan, Goldman Sachs
Archie Ojeda, Blue Line Construction Co. Cory Shaw, Nebraska Medicine Melissa Young, Corporate Incentives, Inc.
CONTRARIAN CIO NETWORK
By Martin Giles Photograph by Christie Hemm Klok for Forbes

The Road Less Traveled


56
CONTRARIAN • CIO NETWORK

Most tech unicorns are the product of Silicon Valley’s well-oiled VC machine.
Not CLO U D INA RY. The maker of marketing software was profitable from day one

I
and has bootstrapped its way close to a billion-dollar valuation.

Itai Lahan is ada-


mant that ambitious entrepreneurs
should certainly fill their coffers with
venture capitalists’ money if they get
the chance. “The only consistent way
to get to be a billion-dollar company
is to go the VC route,” the Cloudinary
CEO declares. “That, hands down, will
always win.”
In a classic case of “do as I say, not
as I do,” though, Lahan has repeat-
edly turned down venture funding
since launching Cloudinary in 2012.
Instead, he and his fellow Israeli co-
founders, Nadav Soferman and Tal
Lev-Ami, have bootstrapped their
Santa Clara, California–based startup
to near unicorn status. The company
makes software that helps the CIOs
of almost 7,500 customers, including
household names like Nike, Peloton
and Neiman Marcus, manage their
online marketing content—think vid-
eos, logos and product photographs.

Photo Finisher

Cloudinary CEO and cofounder Itai Lahan stands


outside a folding door at its California headquarters,
which was once leased to a Nissan R&D center.
Almost a million developers now use his software.

FORBES.COM A P R I L / M AY 2 0 2 1
Our advisors listen, so you
know you’ve been heard.
When you talk to a Dell Technologies Advisor, they’re focused on
you — to provide tailored solutions on everything from laptops
to the cloud, to keep your Small Business ready for what’s next.

Call one today at 855-341-5261


Dell.com/SmallBusinessPartner

Vostro 15 5502 with up to an 11th Gen Intel® Core™ i7 processor


Starting at $799

Intel and the Intel logo are trademarks of Intel Corporation in the U.S. and/or other countries. Copyright © 2021 Dell Inc. or its subsidiaries. All Rights
Reserved. Dell Technologies, Dell, EMC, Dell EMC and other trademarks are trademarks of Dell Inc. or its subsidiaries. Other trademarks may be
trademarks of their respective owners. 390685
The Road Less Traveled Cont.

Revenue grew by some 40% last year, to around sian and Qualtrics, the Utah data analysis com-
$70 million, and the company is worth at least pany that was ultimately acquired by SAP for
$900 million. Cloudinary has appeared on the $8 billion, bootstrapped themselves to a consid-
Forbes Cloud 100 list each of the last three years. erable size before going public. If cloud start-
Lahan says the company simply never needed ups find a core group of fans early on, word-
58 venture money. The founders came up with the of-mouth marketing can keep costs low, says
idea for the business while running a consult- Jason Lemkin, CEO of SaaStr, a venture firm:
ing firm in Israel that built technology for other HOW TO PLAY IT “Once you get to a few million of revenue . . .
CONTRARIAN • CIO NETWORK

By Jon D. Markman
startups. The clunky software they had to use you can be cash-flow positive because your [cur-
One of the best
to manage videos and photos convinced them ways to play the
rent] customers will create a stream of future
to create something better. Their consulting cli- growth in digital customers for you.”
ents were Cloudinary’s first customers, which content manage- Few startups are that lucky, which is why
ment is Adobe
enabled it to turn a profit as soon as it opened Systems. The San Lahan thinks nearly all entrepreneurs should
its doors. Since then, it has generated enough Jose, California, take venture capital as they hunt for revenue.
money—cash flow as measured by Ebitda last company makes “It’s a numbers game,” he says. “It’s well
software tools to
year was an estimated $6 million, or about 9% help customers thought-out. [Venture financing has] tons of
of sales—to finance its growth plans every year create, manage pluses, an incredible amount of pluses.”
and promote
and to build a 300-person team. digital media. Its
There are minuses, too. Startups often have
“We were lucky enough early on to grow re- Experience Cloud to put up with investors on boards directing
ally fast,” Lahan says. “We were getting money platform lets them along a tight track toward a hoped-for
businesses and
from our customers, and it was more than brands measure public offering. That’s not something Cloudi-
enough to hit our next-year goals, which were the effectiveness nary’s founders have had to worry about. (The
incredibly high.” of and monetize company doesn’t even have a board.) After the
that content. It’s
Cloudinary’s software automates the drudgery a powerful com- pandemic began, they pulled back on hiring
of resizing and reformatting digital content for bination. Adobe but didn’t fire anyone. They also cut the com-
reported record
devices and web browsers, and it ensures that quarterly revenue
pany’s 2020 revenue target by almost $8 mil-
videos and photos load lightning-fast—a must of $3.91 billion in lion to take some pressure off staff and help
in an era when consumers will click elsewhere March, up 26% customers in financial distress by postponing
year-over-year.
upon encountering the slightest delay. Cloudi- Earnings per share payments and offering discounts. Lahan says
nary also uses artificial intelligence to suggest grew 33% year- he’s not sure a board would have supported
the best way to present photos and videos to over-year to $2.61. those moves.
As more businesses
capture people’s attention. The more digital raw reach out to Another key advantage of not having outside
material that churns through its algorithms, customers, online investors is that the three founders still own just
sales may grow
which currently process between 500 and 2,000 further. Shares
over half of the business. Some of the remain-
pieces of content a second, the better they get at could reach $580 ing equity is held by staff; Cloudinary has orga-
predicting what will attract eyeballs and clicks. within 12 months, nized a couple of secondary transactions to let
a gain of 29% from
It protects brands as well as promotes them. a recent $451. employees sell shares. That has enabled two VC
Companies like Bleacher Report use Cloudinary’s Jon D. Markman
firms, Bessemer Venture Partners and Salesforce
software to comb through videos uploaded by is president of Ventures, to get their fingers in the pie, although
people to determine if they contain pornographic Markman Capital their collective holding is small.
Insight and editor
images or other offensive material. of Fast Forward Still, Lahan might finally be willing to take his
To get CIOs hooked, Cloudinary offers a Investing. own advice. “I’m confident we will need [out-
free service with strict volume limits. It makes side] funding,” he says. “The moment we need
money by charging heavy users. Annual deals it, if an IPO is the right way forward, we’ll do an
can reach high-single-digit millions of dollars. IPO.” But he hints at other options, including the
At the end of 2018, it managed 25 billion digital possibility of tapping late-stage venture funds. If
assets; by the end of last year, that figure had Cloudinary does pursue that route, it will be a
vaulted to 50 billion—and should keep growing case of Lahan taking a lot of money from where
PATRICK WELSH FOR FORBES

even if the pandemic-fueled e-commerce boom his mouth has been.


subsides. In 2020, total U.S. online sales hit
$813 billion, a 42% year-over-year increase, ac-
FINAL THOUGHT
cording to Adobe, which forecasts they’ll pass
$1 trillion for the first time in 2022. “THE FIRST OF EARTHLY BLESSINGS,
Some other notable cloud companies, includ- INDEPENDENCE.”
ing project-management software maker Atlas- —Edward Gibbon

FORBES.COM A P R I L / M AY 2 0 2 1
CONTRARIAN MONEY & INVESTING
By Nathan Vardi Illustration by Israel G. Vargas for Forbes

The Teflon Trader


60
CONTRARIAN • MONEY & INVESTING

Wall Street legend CA R L I CA HN is on a seven-year losing streak that

I
has cost him billions, but the market still loves his stock.

In October 2013,
when Carl Icahn started selling his
large position in Netflix, many be-
lieved the vaunted billionaire inves-
tor had done it again. The company
had successfully transitioned from a
DVD-by-mail rental service to video
streaming, and Icahn had made a
457% return in just 14 months.
“As a hardened veteran of seven
bear markets,” Icahn announced, it
was time for him “to take some of
the chips off the table.” Icahn’s son,
Brett, begged his father not to sell.
By 2015 Icahn was out, making a tidy
$2 billion profit on Netflix. But since
his departure the stock has appreci-
ated another tenfold. Had Icahn held
onto it, his profit would have been
$19 billion.
Icahn’s Netflix miss isn’t just a
fluke. Last year, while the U.S. stock
market returned 18% during a vola-
tile pandemic bull market, Icahn’s
hedge fund plunged by 14%. In 2019,

The Raider’s Rough Ride

Carl Icahn’s fund has lost money in five of the


last seven years. He hopes to turn things around
with big bets on Occidental, Bausch Health,
Cheniere Energy, Newell Brands and Xerox.

FORBES.COM A P R I L / M AY 2 0 2 1
Stand Up To Cancer is a division of the Entertainment Industry Foundation (EIF), a 501(c)(3) charitable organization.
The Vault By the mid-1980s, corporate raiders like
BOND JUNKIES Carl Icahn, Ron Perelman and T. Boone
Pickens had invaded Wall Street—fueled by
stock has returned six times more than the
junk bonds issued through Drexel Burnham S&P 500 over the last 20 years.
Lambert’s Michael Milken. Forbes was first Icahn’s recent trading problems stem from
to shine a light on Milken’s money machine being overweight energy and short the mar-
and the cast of “buccaneers” it bankrolled:
ket, including growth stocks. His short posi-
“Are there common threads among special
Drexel customers? Only that all are aggres- tions alone have produced $7 billion of losses
sive, are outsiders to the conventional finan- in five years. “I got too concentrated in some
cial community, have a trading mentality
62 and can make quick multimillion-dollar in-
of the energy stocks—they were dirt-cheap and
vestments without going through a corporate management was not good, and I just kept pil-
bureaucracy. A conventional observer would ing in,” Icahn says in the unmistakable accent
CONTRARIAN • MONEY & INVESTING

say they tend to be buccaneers, much more


interested in money than in running businesses. of someone born in Brooklyn and raised in a
An admirer would call them financial entre- working-class Queens neighborhood. “The bot-
preneurs, redeployers of capital.” tom fell out of the energy market. You grit your
—November 19, 1984
teeth and you come out of it.”
Icahn also insists the net asset value of Icahn
Enterprises understates the intrinsic value of
it tumbled by 15%. In fact, the great trader has his company’s assets. Take Icahn Automotive
lost more than $5 billion trading over the last Group. Icahn is quick to point to the current
seven calendar years. His hedge fund has suf- takeover talk surrounding Mavis Tire Express
fered so much that its average annual return Service, which is in a similar business and
since its inception in 2004 has fallen to 3%, has a similar number of stores. Mavis is being
versus 10% for the S&P 500. priced at $6 billion, nearly four times the value
Icahn’s struggles illustrate a major shift oc- Icahn Automotive is listed for on Icahn Enter-
curring on Wall Street. In the era of Amazon, prises’ balance sheet.
Tesla, GameStop and Bitcoin, growth, momen- Even big energy bets like Occidental Petro-
tum and investor psychology are the most im- leum are beginning to look more promising as
portant drivers of success. But at 85, Icahn is the price of U.S. crude has risen from effective-
sticking to fundamentals. He is one of the last ly less than zero during the pandemic to $60 a
remaining OG corporate raiders on Wall Street, barrel recently. In February, Icahn took a major
and he still likes asset- and cash-rich compa- stake (and two board seats) in Ohio’s First-
nies in need of a shake-up. “I am a value guy, Energy, a utility whose performance tumbled
and the activism model is still the best model if after one of its subsidiaries became embroiled
you can find a company with hidden value and in a federal racketeering case. Icahn wants it
the board is not taking advantage of it,” Icahn to settle quickly. Another new buy for Icahn is
insists from his new office digs in Florida. “It Canadian medical device and pharmaceutical
is still the best on a risk-reward basis, but you company Bausch Health, which owns eye care
need a lot of patience.” and contact lens giant Bausch & Lomb. Bausch
Wall Street still believes. Shares in Icahn’s has been in the midst of a turnaround since
most important asset, Nasdaq-listed Icahn En- 2013, when it went by the name Valeant Phar-
terprises, which invests in Icahn’s hedge fund maceuticals. Icahn wants to split the company
and holds companies like oil refinery CVR En- in two. “In positions like Bausch Health and
ergy and auto-parts retailer Pep Boys, trade FirstEnergy, we are on the board and can help
at around $60, up some 20% over the last 12 make a difference,” he says.
months. The underlying assets, as measured by Icahn is spooked by America’s massive fed-
net asset value, are worth only $14.70 a share. eral spending but thinks there are still oppor-
Icahn Enterprises’ net asset value has tumbled tunities in this market. “We are in uncharted
from $9.1 billion at the end of 2013 to $3.5 bil- waters and will pay a price for huge deficits
lion. Meanwhile, Icahn has mostly been taking and loose money in the future,” he says, “but
dividends in shares, doubling the share count. that time is not here yet—and while I am some-
Icahn’s 92% stake in Icahn Enterprises what hedged, I am fairly bullish.”
amounts to most of his estimated $15.8 bil-
lion net worth. Had Forbes used IEP’s net asset
value for his net worth instead of its market FINAL THOUGHT

price, Icahn would be worth $6 billion today. “THANKS TO GOD THAT HE


The rest is the Icahn premium. And in the long GAVE ME STUBBORNNESS WHEN
run it makes total sense: Icahn Enterprises’ I KNOW I AM RIGHT.”
—John Adams

FORBES.COM A P R I L / M AY 2 0 2 1
ATHENS ROUNDTRIP ABU DHABI TO MUMBAI
AUGUST 1-14, 2021 | Crystal Symphony OCT. 27 - NOV. 8, 2021 | Crystal Symphony

MoneyShow presents

The GET PERSONALIZED


PORTFOLIO ADVICE
FROM FORBES’ LEADING
Cruise for Investors EXPERTS ABOARD A
SIX-STAR CRYSTAL CRUISE!
2021-2022

Come sail with me and


our renowned roster of
world-class financial
experts on one of our
upcoming voyages!
– STEVE FORBES

COPENHAGEN TO REYKJAVIK
AUGUST 10-21, 2022 | Crystal Symphony

Call 800-530-0770 Today to


Request Your Free Brochure!
Mention Priority Code 052645 MIAMI TO CALDERA
NOVEMBER 4-15, 2022 | Crystal Serenity
OPER
T H E E S S AY

70

WEALTH Covid-19 brought terrible suffering, economic pain, geopolitical


tension—and the greatest acceleration of wealth
in human history. Why this pandemic paradox could become
a cause for celebration, not concern.

FORBES.COM
ATION
71

The World’s Billionaires $13.1 TRIL


2,755 BILLIONAIRES 2500

Number of billionaires worldwide


$12,000
Combined net worth (billions)

2000
$9,000

1500

$6,000
1000
$295 BIL
$3,000 140 BILLIONAIRES
500

SPEED
$0 0
1987 2021

BY R A N DA L L L A N E

FORBES.COM
O
list—a newly minted billionaire every 17 But as miraculous vaccines chart a
hours. Rising asset prices vaulted an- course back to normalcy, the factors
other 250 previous drop-offs back over driving these numbers conjure a differ-
the ten-digit mark. Amid widespread ent emotion: optimism. The pandemic’s
economic insecurity, precious few bil- most enduring positive legacy will turn
lionaires fared worse financially: Just out to be as an accelerant, compressing
61 dropped off the list for reasons oth- decades of change into one year. And
er than death, representing the lowest the newly super-rich, proxies for oppor-
72 percentage of drop-offs for any year on tunity, or lack thereof, have never felt
record. All told, Forbes estimates that more different, looked more different or
there are now 2,755 billionaires globally, acted more different. It’s worth spend-
T H E E S S AY

up from 2,095 last year, and the notion ing some time to deduce why.
that the rich get richer has never been We’re at that rarest of inflection
more apt: They’re worth, in aggregate, points—the kind that’s apparent even
$13.1 trillion—a staggering $5.1 trillion as it happens. Vaccines will wash across
more than at the start of the pandemic. the planet at the same time the glob-
These figures will engender end- al economy seems primed to roar back.
less amounts of consternation, most of And while the initial reaction to the bil-
it justified. There’s no getting around lionaire surge of 2021, a newcomer tally
a collective $5 trillion wealth surge 70% larger than any we’ve logged before,
during a pandemic, when most of the will lean toward outrage, the underlying
world felt scared, sick, besieged. Capi- trends offer a road map to greater pros-
On March 18, 2020, the United States talism, the greatest system ever for perity for all. Like anything else salvaged
registered its 150th coronavirus- generating prosperity, rests upon a so- from a once-a-century plague, we just
related death while trying to gauge, cial compact of expansion, unequal by need to be brave enough to harness it.
along with most of the world, just design, ultimately lifting all boats. The
what was happening. Major market Covid-19 economy has strained that
indices fell 5% after jumping 6% the concept; yawning economic disparity For pretty much all of human history,
previous day. Spring breakers partied poses arguably the greatest threat to wealth has been dynastic. The John D.
blithely in Florida while officials de- modern social order. Rockefellers and Henry Fords of a cen-
cided to close the border with Can-
ada. And a statistical team at Forbes
locked the numbers for our 34th an-
nual ranking of the world’s billion-
aires, unwittingly creating a snapshot
of global wealth at the precise moment
Asia Ascendant
the world lurched into its most disrup-
2011
tive 12 months since World War II.
Total Worth (in billions) 2021
Over the ensuing year, those 150 U.S. $5,000
deaths swelled to 550,000; some 3 mil-
lion souls were lost worldwide. Tens of
millions of jobs evaporated, along with $4,000

hundreds of thousands of small busi-


nesses. Remote work went from exot-
$3,000
ic to standard. The suburbs went from
dull to desired. The death of George
Floyd triggered a reckoning concerning $2,000
race and social justice. The presidential
election tested democratic norms. Si-
multaneously, though, many individu- $1,000
als, industries and investments thrived.
One year after that fortuitously timed
snapshot, we repeated our March bil- $0
Asia-Pacific Europe Middle East The Americas United States
lionaires audit, taking the measure, at & Africa
the point of the pyramid, of the past Profile Count
year’s seismic changes. The results defy 2011 332 299 89 76 413
hyperbole. Over the past 12 months,
2021 1,149 628 85 169 724
493 people worldwide joined the Forbes

FORBES.COM A P R I L / M AY 2 0 2 1
tury ago launched the first era of en-
trepreneurship, but even those suc-
cesses turned into entrenched family
wealth. The very first Forbes 400 list
of the richest Americans, in 1982, re-
mained chock-full of their progeny,
as well as plenty of Mellons, DuPonts
and the like—some 63% of that inau-
gural Rich List pretty much inherited 73
it. Many of the rest had a background
that involved starting life on first, sec-

T H E E S S AY
ond or third base, in the mold of Ru-
pert Murdoch or Donald Trump.
The technology revolution changed
that dynamic, here and around the
world. By 2002, a slim majority, 52%,
of the Forbes global billionaires were
self-made, including 59% of Amer-
icans. Ten years ago, that total had
jumped to 69% globally.
The 493 new members of the Covid
Newcomers of 2021, however, are in a
class by themselves: 84% of them are
self-made (including 90% of Ameri-
cans), swelling the figure among bil- John Arnold, “Give
While You Live”
lionaires overall to 72%—a record in
“The real joy isn’t
each case. People like Whitney Wolfe putting money into a
Herd, who flipped the script on dating foundation,” says the
billionaire, who wants
apps by empowering women; Tyler his peers to give away
Perry, who started producing his own at least 5% of their
wealth each year. “It’s
movies and television shows in Atlan- putting in money to
ta because no one would give him a make the world better.”

break in Hollywood; and Uğur Şahin,


the Turkish immigrant to Germany
whose BioNTech helped produce a
Covid-19 vaccine in months rather turn changed what a billionaire looks How do these more meritocratic,
than years—all embody economic dy- like. While women continue to have more dynamic, more diverse billion-
namism, not bloodline dynasties. a far harder time getting good ideas aires run their companies? In ways that
Opportunity stems from this dyna- funded than men, they’ve nonetheless are better for all of us. Forbes contract-
mism, as these new billionaires illus- steadily nudged up the tables and now ed with our partners at JUST Capital,
trate. A decade ago, the median length encompass 11% of global billionaires, which measures corporate citizenship,
of time it took a new billionaire in 12% of American billionaires and 13% to gauge the civic performance of the
America to create his or her fortune, of new billionaires, all high-water 88 new self-made U.S. billionaires. We
according to our data, was 18 years. marks. More importantly, female en- took the companies that drove each bil-
Historically speaking, that’s extraordi- trepreneurs now account for 4% of all lion-dollar fortune and, leaning on in-
narily fast. Among this year’s 88 new billionaires, more than double the per- dustry averages, calculated each score
self-made Americans, that number centage even five years ago. based on how they treat their work-
has decreased drastically, to 13 years. And while in America extreme suc- ers, their customers and the environ-
The ability to rapidly translate ideas cess remains disproportionately white, ment, among other factors. The net re-
into riches helps level the playing field. the global business aristocracy in- sult: Not only did these new billion-
Code (intellectual resources) trumps creasingly reflects the world itself. Chi- aires found or run companies that rank
capital (accumulated resources), with na alone, including Hong Kong, added above average in terms of the three fac-
the latter desperate for the former. A a staggering 210 billionaires this past tors mentioned above, but they’ve also
generation ago, fortunes went to those year. Factor in 19 new faces from In- improved in each of these categories
BRENT HUMPHRIES

with the luck or pluck to secure fund- dia, 14 from Japan and multiple de- when measured against the new bil-
ing; today, a good concept chooses buts from seven other Asian countries, lionaires of 10 years ago.
which funding to accept. and people of color made up a majori- Take Chris Britt, who in eight
That increased opportunity has in ty of new billionaires worldwide. years has built Chime into one of the

A P R I L / M AY 2 0 2 1 FORBES.COM
world’s largest digital banks. In a fee- where they lived or refinanced with
based industry that’s often adversar- record-low interest rates. Equally in- Founding Fortunes
ial to those who need it most, Britt credibly, he’d never taken on partners
grabbed market share during the pan- or investors, so he and his family owned
demic with low-risk, customer-cen- 100% of the company going into the 2001
Total worth: $1.8 trillion
tric gestures. “We’re on the front line,” pandemic. When he took the compa- Total number of billionaires: 565
he says. “We see how Americans are ny public this January through a SPAC,
INHERITED:
stressed out.” Leveraging customer pushing his net worth at the time to $489.9B
76 records, Chime comfortably advanced $12.6 billion, he carved out $35 million 140 billionaires
people against their stimulus checks in stock for his 8,000 workers. INHERITED
& GROWING:
at no cost, and offered overdraft pro- “We all won together as a company,”
$452.5B
T H E E S S AY

tection via a program called SpotMe. says the former Michigan State basket- 147 billionaires
(By comparison, payday-loan compa- ball player. Well, to some degree. Throw- SELF-MADE:
nies lend against things like stimulus ing your employees about one-quar- $881.3B
checks at usurious interest rates as ter of 1%—an average payout of about 278 billionaires
high as 650%.) Such customer-friend- $4,000—when you’re sitting on 99.7%
ly policies, Britt says, help him recruit and almost 11 digits seems exceedingly
better employees—his payroll has tri- paltry. But it’s also progress. Go back to 2011
pled to 800 in a year—which leads to that original Forbes 400 list from 1982, Total worth: $4.5 trillion
better returns. “You get those pieces and you’ll find hundreds of tycoons who Total number of billionaires: 1,209
right, with a good business model, the didn’t think of their employees as much INHERITED:
equity shareholders will manage just more than a cost or liability. $669.7B
160 billionaires
fine.” Apparently so. As of September, Others took stands for their home-
INHERITED
Chime was valued by venture capital towns, including Jeff Lawson, the co- & GROWING:
investors at $14.5 billion, with Britt’s founder of surging cloud communica- $904.6B
stake worth $1.3 billion. tions business Twilio, who hit the list 220 billionaires
Still more new billionaires are taking SELF-MADE:
steps to support their employees. Mat Sam Bankman-Fried, “Effective Altruism” $2.92T
829 billionaires
Ishbia, the 41-year-old CEO of United “I want to figure out how I can have the most
Wholesale Mortgage, had an incredible positive impact on the world,” says the 29-year-
old, who has promised to put virtually all of his
past 12 months, as millions changed $8.7 billion fortune into causes he believes in. 2021
Total worth: $13.1 trillion
Total number of billionaires: 2,755
INHERITED:
$1.56T
281 billionaires
INHERITED
& GROWING:
$2.33T
499 billionaires
SELF-MADE:
$9.20T
1,975 billionaires

this year at a cool $2.2 billion. Silicon


Valley saw many companies and lead-
ers decamp from the Bay Area, Elon
Musk and Larry Ellison most nota-
bly. Lawson felt that he had an obli-
VIRGILE SIMON BERTRAND FOR FORBES

gation to his community, which is an-


other factor measured by JUST Cap-
ital. So he publicly declared in Janu-
ary that his company would stay in
San Francisco. Another civic booster,
Rocket Mortgage founder Dan Gil-
bert, whose net worth exploded past
$50 billion over the last year, recent-
ly committed $500 million from his

FORBES.COM A P R I L / M AY 2 0 2 1
JON RIMANELLI

Founder and CEO, ASX.US

“ W E A RE
D ES IGN ING
T H E FU TU RE
I N M IC H IGAN .”

Innovation. Resilience. Agility. It’s how Michigan businesses continue


to build the future. Tech companies, engineering talent and innovators
in manufacturing are all coming here for a reason. Our expertise,
talented workforce and proven adaptability are making a difference
now and shaping the future. Join us and make your mark
where it matters.

Put your plans in motion by visiting


michiganbusiness.org/pure-opportunity
interview about this initiative. “Let
this generation handle this genera-
Routes to Riches
tion’s problems.”
How the 88 new self-made American billionaires got on the list. The Give While You Live concept is
a more time-urgent spin on the Giving
Pledge, which has admirably pushed bil-
Stock Increase 44 lionaires to publicly commit to give away
Traditional IPO 17 half of their wealth while they’re still
78 alive—or after they die. “It hasn’t neces-
Private Company 11
sarily spurred giving in the short term,”
Crypto 8 says Arnold, a Giving Pledge signatory.
T H E E S S AY

Pretty much every new billionaire Forbes


SPAC 4
spoke to, while expressing general sup-
VC Funding 4 port for the Giving Pledge and an open-
ness to committing to it, focused instead
0 10 20 30 40
on what they can do immediately.
Over the past 12 months, the world’s
third-richest woman, MacKenzie Scott,
company and his personal founda- That group evolved into the Initia- who joined the Forbes Billionaires list
tion to bolster low-income residents tive to Accelerate Charitable Giving. last year after divorcing Amazon’s Jeff
of Detroit, where he’s headquartered, Its primary targets: the $142 billion in Bezos, went on a giving spree as nota-
which included wiping out the prop- donor-advised funds, or DAFs, which ble as anything in recent philanthrop-
erty-tax debt of 20,000 homeowners. allow donors to take upfront tax de- ic history. Rather than endow a founda-
“Our commitment to Detroit is abso- ductions for parking money in com- tion, Scott enlisted advisors to generate
lute,” Gilbert tells Forbes. munity foundations or financial-ser- data on the ways her money can help
vices firms, even if there’s no mandate the most people now. Then, in July and
or visibility for when or how the mon- December, she transparently wrote 500
All this acceleration comes with a ey goes to the public good; and perpet- checks, totaling $5.8 billion, no strings
heightened realization among those at ual foundations that try to end-run an- attached, to grantees in all 50 states,
the very top about the obligations that
come with extreme success—and the
possible repercussions, from confisca-
tory tax regimes to social unrest, that RATHER THAN ENDOW A
could follow inaction. It’s not hard to
read the tea leaves—altruism, in this FOUNDATION, SCOTT GOT DATA
case, mirrors self-interest. Speaking
with a half-dozen members of the new-
ON WHERE HER MONEY HELPS
comers of 2021, along with a hand- THE MOST PEOPLE RIGHT NOW.
ful of younger billionaires, the post-
pandemic attitude change is palpable.
John Arnold sensed a shift as the nual minimal giving requirements by many of whom were utterly surprised
pandemic approached. While the path sliding in expenses when they report. when the money arrived.
he took to his estimated $3.3 billion But Arnold also feels the super- “The pandemic has been a wrecking
fortune—trading energy contracts for rich need to go further individually. ball in the lives of Americans already
disgraced and defunct Enron—won’t So he became the first billionaire to struggling,” Scott wrote in a public
earn him any Nobel laurels, he and his get behind a new “Give While You statement. (She hasn’t given an inter-
wife, Laura, have spent the past decade Live” promise—a public commitment view since the divorce.) “Meanwhile, it
creating a plan to maximize their im- to grant at least 5% of his personal has substantially increased the wealth
pact—“the benefit,” he says, “of looking net worth to good causes each year— of billionaires.”
at 100 years of great wealth in Ameri- which is being organized by the ad- It certainly increased the wealth of
ca.” Alarmed at the state and standing of vocacy group Global Citizen. (Disclo- Jared Isaacman, CEO of Shift4 Pay-
philanthropy in the U.S. today, he con- sure: I’m a board member at Glob- ments, a Square competitor that fo-
vened a handful of philanthropists, ac- al Citizen.) Merely holding money in cuses on restaurants and hotels. His
ademics and foundation heads in New a DAF or a foundation doesn’t cut it, roller-coaster year took him from pre-
York in January 2020, posing a ques- nor does the excuse that rich people paring for a public offering to worry-
tion: How can we get those sitting on are better off compounding their mon- ing if his customers—and his compa-
trillions of dollars to take bigger, faster ey and giving it away later. “Problems ny—would survive, to becoming an in-
action, with more accountability? compound too,” Arnold says in his first dispensable tool for his clientele, to

FORBES.COM A P R I L / M AY 2 0 2 1
pulling off an IPO after all. ton Children’s Hospital. He also put
After ringing the bell at the New York about $5 million into a little startup
Speed to Wealth
Stock Exchange, which gave him a $1.4 called Moderna—a stake that brings
billion net worth, Isaacman, 38, wrote him onto the Billionaires list this year The median number of years after
starting their company that individuals
a $100 million check to St. Jude Chil- with a net worth of $2.2 billion. appeared as a newcomer on
dren’s Research Hospital. His motiva- Springer has already put forth $30 the Billionaires list.
tions mimicked Scott’s. He gave im- million to establish the Institute for
mediately after coming into immense Protein Innovation, a nonprofit that 2011 2021

18 13
wealth. Rather than set up a founda- creates tools and provides expertise 79
tion, he steered money to people al- for biotech researchers and entre-
ready doing good work. He did so trans- preneurs. But the urgency of the mo-

T H E E S S AY
parently. And he did it with scale, after ment has him rethinking things phil-
his business’ brief near-death experi- anthropically—later this year, he says,
ence underscored for him how many he’ll announce a bigger donation. He’s
people were hurting. “If you had asked coy about it, though he does say he’ll
me before the pandemic, ‘Could you likely be “adding another zero.” And
imagine writing a $100 million check?’, that’s just the beginning. “I want to
I never would have expected it.” give more money. That’s my motiva- MacAskill. “You’re not the best leaflet-
Then Isaacman, who owns and flies tor to start companies now,” he says. terer we’ve found.”
his own MiG fighter jet, applied some le- “If I’m successful, as I think I could Mission accomplished. Bankman-
verage. He announced he would lead the be, [with] the scale of things, we could Fried, in pursuing a vocation less
first all-civilian mission to space, in part- add yet another zero.” than noble—a zero-sum, notoriously
nership with Elon Musk’s SpaceX. He And if starting businesses de- cutthroat exc hange in which new-
would bring a St. Jude frontline work- signed specifically to create billion- comers face a slew of sharp-elbowed
er—as well as a random St. Jude donor, dollar charitable windfalls sounds far- pros—has created a massive source of
a stunt he hopes will raise another $200 fetched, meet 29-year-old Sam Bank- wealth that he promises to deploy al-
million for the hospital, which he publi- man-Fried, who’s already doing exact- most entirely for what he sees as the
cized through a Super Bowl commercial. ly that. Perhaps the most interesting public good. (He says he will keep only
He even got Musk, a charitable skinflint new billionaire in the world, Bankman- a few percentage points for himself,
to date, to commit to St. Jude. Fried started the FTX cryptocurrency and even that might prove too much.
Immunologist Tim Springer’s coro- exchange two years ago, making a big- “If it’s used to justify buying a few
navirus epiphany has been a matter ger fortune—$8.7 billion—more quick- yachts, that’s pretty bad.”) And while
of scale. Twenty years ago, he netted ly than anyone under 30 ever has, Mark he’s already placing bets, backstop-
$100 million founding a biotech com- Zuckerberg included. ping a few charitable initiatives and
pany, and in turn he made the kinds of From Carnegie to Rockefeller, Gates giving $5 million to help get Joe Biden
donations you might see from people to Buffett, philanthropy was always elected (Effective Altruists like Bank-
at that wealth level, endowing chairs the byproduct of entrepreneurship. man-Fried don’t differentiate much
at Harvard Medical School and Bos- Bankman-Fried is surely the first bil- between nonprofits and politics; they
lionaire for whom entrepreneurship merely look at outcome ROIs), he an-
was the byproduct of philanthropy. He ticipates accelerated scale starting in
embraces a philosophy called Effec- five years, when he’s more liquid.
tive Altruism, which has cropped up The only reason he won’t give it all
Rising Grades over the last decade and applies ratio- away as fast as possible is so that he
nal logic to maximizing good. “It’s for can keep some powder dry for the mo-
How new billionaires’ companies people who like math and people who ment, sooner rather than later, when
rank (as a percentile) in JUST Capital’s
categories of corporate citizenship. like giving,” Bankman-Fried says. Ef- he sees an “outlier opportunity.”
fective Altruists try to quantify things “When you find one of those, every-
like lives saved per dollar. Or wheth- one tends to go too small,” Bankman-
2011 2021 er it’s more urgent to quell malaria or Fried says. “F--king go all in.”
potentially malevolent technologies. We’re at an all-in moment in histo-
Overall Score 49th 55th
Or whether a brilliant MIT student ry, actually, and those at the top have
Workers 53rd 57th named Sam should follow his dream raised their own stakes to a level that’s
Environment 52nd 61st
and become an animal-rights activist. unfathomable considering the year
“Honestly, you should go to Wall Street we’ve all experienced. Changes are
Customers 42nd 52nd and give it to us,” Bankman-Fried re- upon us faster than we could possibly
Communities 49th 49th members hearing from one of the Eth- have conceived last March. Now is not
ical Altruism movement’s leaders, the time for the world’s billionaires, or
Shareholders 45th 47th 34-year-old Oxford professor William any of us, to go small.

A P R I L / M AY 2 0 2 1 FORBES.COM
A DAY
A BI L L ION A I R E
THIS YEAR, FORBES
TRACKED DOWN A
RECORD 493 NEW
BILLIONAIRES—
ROUGHLY ONE EVERY
80 17 HOURS. JUST OVER
40% HAIL FROM
CHINA; 20% FROM
THE U.S. PROMINENT
ROUTES TO NEW
RICHES: IPOS, SPACS,
CRYPTOCURRENCIES
AND COVID-RELATED
HEALTH CARE.

THE LIST

IPOS Matt Moulding


$2.9 billion • E-commerce • U.K.
His e-commerce empire, The Hut Group,
Since mid-March 2020, 1,489 IPOs went public in London in September. Two
months later he got a $1 billion share bonus
(including SPACs) raised $314 billion that the board had approved.
globally. More than half went public in
Tony Xu
the U.S., where they raised $277 billion. $2.8 billion • Food delivery service • U.S.
These 10 billionaires land on the list as Xu is cofounder and CEO of food delivery
company DoorDash, which listed on the
a result of such public offerings. NYSE in December. It delivers meals
from 390,000 restaurants in the United
States, Canada and Australia.

Jared Isaacman
Pan Dong $2.3 billion • Payment processing • U.S.
$8.3 billion • Consumer goods • Canada Isaacman, 38, founded payment processing
The richest woman new to this year’s list, firm Shift4 Payments in his parents’ base-
she chairs laundry detergent maker Blue ment at age 19 and took it public on the
Moon Group Holdings, which listed in NYSE in June. He flies fighter jets for fun,
Hong Kong in December. Her husband, including a Soviet-era MiG-29.
Luo Qiuping, is the company’s CEO.
Bang Shi-hyuk
Vyacheslav Kim $2.3 billion • Entertainment • South Korea
$3.3 billion • Fintech • Kazakhstan Founder of music label and agency Big Hit
Mikhail Lomtadze Entertainment, which represents the wildly
$3.2 billion • Fintech • Georgia popular K-pop band BTS, he took the compa-
CEO Lomtadze and chairman Kim have ny public on the Korea Exchange in October.
steered Kaspi—a payments, e-commerce and
mobile-banking app used in Kazakhstan— Gong Yingying
from a small-time retail bank to a London $2.1 billion • Health IT • China
public listing. Half of Kazakhstan’s 18 million She is CEO, chair and founder of health-care
people use the service. analytics firm Yidu Tech, which listed its
shares in Hong Kong in January.
Pablo Legorreta
$2.9 billion • Investments • U.S. David Helgason
The former investment banker founded $1 billion • Software • Iceland
private equity firm Royalty Pharma in Helgason cofounded video-game software
1996 to buy future revenue streams of developer Unity Software in Denmark in 2004
pharmaceuticals. He took it public on and served as CEO until 2014; the company
the Nasdaq in June. listed on the NYSE in September.

FORBES.COM A P R I L / M AY 2 0 2 1
WHITNEY
WOLFE HER D
$1.3 billion • Dating app • U.S.
Wolfe Herd, 31, took her woman-centric dating 81
app, Bumble, public in February—becoming
the world’s youngest self-made female
billionaire. The $582 million (revenue) company
has 42 million customers in 150 countries. She
cofounded dating app Tinder in 2012. That
relationship turned sour, and she settled a
sexual-harassment lawsuit with Tinder in 2014.
Andrey Andreev, the Russian founder of dating
site Badoo, offered Wolfe Herd a $10 million
investment and Badoo’s infrastructure, and
the duo launched Bumble in 2014. In late 2019,
Andreev sold his majority stake to investment
firm Blackstone, four months after a Forbes
investigation revealed a toxic work culture at its
London offices. Badoo denied the allegations.

JAMEL TOPPIN FOR FORBES

A P R I L / M AY 2 0 2 1 FORBES.COM
S PAC S

Special purpose acquisition companies,


or SPACs, have become all the rage.
More than 500 of these “blank-check”
companies have gone public in the U.S.
in the past year, nearly seven times the
82 number in the previous year. But only
a handful minted new billionaires.
BILLIONAIRES • NEWCOMERS

Mat Ishbia
$9.7 billion • Mortgage lending • U.S.
Justin Ishbia
$3 billion • Mortgage lending • U.S.
The Ishbias’ father, Jeff, launched a mort-
gage firm in 1986. Mat joined the mom-and-
pop outfit in 2003. He and his brother Justin,
a private equity investor, eventually bought
most of their dad’s stake in United Wholesale
Mortgage. Now the nation’s second-largest
mortgage lender, UWM merged with the
Gores Holdings IV SPAC in January; Mat is

AUSTIN
CEO and Justin is a board member.

Andrew Paradise
$2.3 billion • Mobile games • U.S.

RUSSELL
Skillz, the e-sports company Paradise
cofounded in 2012, provides a mobile
platform for developers to host daily
tournaments of games like solitaire and
bingo. Its $230 million in revenue comes
from its cut of users’ entry fees.
$2.4 billion • Sensors • U.S.
William Foley
Russell, 26, spent his teens $1.9 billion • Financial services • U.S.
doing research at the The former insurance tycoon was quick to
University of California capitalize on the SPAC boom, sponsoring
at Irvine’s Beckman Laser six blank-check companies to date. Two
have recently announced mergers—with
Institute. The lanky 6-foot-4 cloud-based software provider Alight
entrepreneur dropped out Solutions and digital-payments platform
of Stanford in 2012 to found Paysafe—in deals valued at just over
laser lidar (an acronym $7 billion and $9 billion, respectively.
for light, detection and
Shalom Meckenzie
ranging) startup Luminar $1.7 billion • Sports betting • Israel
Technologies after getting His gambling-technology provider, SBTech,
a $100,000 fellowship from merged with sports betting site DraftKings
billionaire tech investor and went public via a SPAC in April 2020. He
Peter Thiel. Its sensors now serves on the board and is one of DraftKings’
help self-driving cars of largest shareholders, with a nearly 6% stake.
customers such as Volvo, Geeta Gupta-Fisker
Toyota and Intel’s Mobileye $1.6 billion • Electric vehicles • U.K.
see in 3D by bouncing laser Henrik Fisker
beams off nearby objects $1.6 billion • Electric vehicles • U.S.
and vehicles’ surroundings. Famed car designer Henrik Fisker and his
The company listed on the wife, Geeta, who has a Ph.D. in biotech,
Nasdaq via a SPAC merger took their eponymous EV maker public in
October; production of its first vehicle, a
with Gores Metropoulos in midsize SUV, is planned to start in late 2022.
December 2020. Russell,
who owns about one-third Trevor Milton
of it, became the world’s $1.4 billion • Electric vehicles • U.S.
youngest self-made His hydrogen-electric truck startup, Nikola,
billionaire overnight. went public via a SPAC in June 2020. He
resigned as chairman in September after
allegations by a short seller that he lied
about Nikola’s technology to investors,
spurring a review by the SEC.
MICHAEL PRINCE FOR FORBES

Chamath Palihapitiya
$1.2 billion • Facebook, venture capital • U.S.
After helping open the SPAC floodgates by
taking Richard Branson’s space tourism com-
pany, Virgin Galactic, public in 2019, SPAC
sponsor and venture capitalist Palihapitiya
acquired two more firms via SPACs in the
past year: homebuying marketplace Open-
door and insurance company Clover Health.

FORBES.COM A P R I L / M AY 2 0 2 1
CHINA

The world’s most populous nation boasts


a record 626 billionaires (excluding
Hong Kong and Macau); its red-hot stock
market helped mint 205 new ten-figure
fortunes, with half coming from manufac-
turing or tech. All but two were self-made. 83
Here are 11 standouts.

BILLIONAIRES • NEWCOMERS
Chen Zhiping
$15.9 billion • E-cigarettes
The founder of the world’s largest
manufacturer of vaping devices, Smoore
International, Chen took the firm public on
the Hong Kong Stock Exchange last July.

Li Hua
$7.1 billion • Financial services

K AT E
An early employee at Tencent, Li founded
Nasdaq-listed online brokerage Futu
Holdings in 2007. The Robinhood-style
fintech boasts nearly 12 million users.

Wang Junlin
$6.3 billion • Liquor
The turnaround artist revived two state-
owned companies before arriving at
WANG
struggling liquor producer Sichuan
Langjiu in 2001. It now churns out more $5 billion • E-cigarettes
than 40,000 tons of alcohol a year.
One of the world’s youngest self-made
Wang Ning female billionaires, Wang, 39, is CEO of
$6.3 billion • Toys Chinese vaping company RLX Technology.
In December, Wang took public his toymaker, The Columbia Business School grad got the
Pop Mart, which is known for concealing the idea for the company in 2017, when she was
identity of its figurines in “blind boxes.”
trying to persuade her father to quit smoking.
Jian Jun “I tried out all the [vaping] products. Most
$5.6 billion • Biomedical products of them were terrible,” she tells Forbes. RLX
Her Shenzhen-listed Imeik Technology posted $324 million in sales in the first nine
Development makes medical cosmetic months of 2020 and listed on the New York
products like skin fillers and facial implant Stock Exchange in January. Wang has a 20%
threads, as well as face and neck masks.
stake. Shares fell 54% over three days in late
Cao Renxian March (after Forbes measured net worths for
$5.3 billion • Solar power the Billionaires list) in response to Chinese
A university professor, Cao founded Sungrow authorities publishing draft rules that would
Power Supply in 1997. Its products, used in 150 regulate e-cigarettes as tobacco products.
countries, convert direct-current electricity
from solar panels into alternating current for
the power grid.

Steven Meng Yang


$4.2 billion • Electronics
A former Google engineer, he founded
popular Amazon seller Anker Innovations
Technology, known for its battery packs,
phone chargers and other electronic
accessories.

Liu Fangyi
$4.2 billion • Medical equipment
Stock of his Intco Medical Technology,
which makes disposable medical prod-
ucts like masks and gloves, shot up 650%
in the past year amid the pandemic.

Li Xiang
$4 billion • Electric vehicles
The 39-year-old founded NYSE-listed
STEFEN CHOW FOR FORBES

online car dealer Autohome before


creating electric vehicle startup Li Auto,
which debuted on the Nasdaq last July.

Jin Baofang
$3.9 billion • Solar panels
Jin is founder and chair of JA Solar, a Beijing-
based solar panel producer that boasts
33,000 clients in 135 countries and regions.

A P R I L / M AY 2 0 2 1
C RY P TO

Boom times (again) in cryptocurrency—


Bitcoin has skyrocketed 800% since the
middle of March 2020 and Ripple’s
XRP is up 200%—have landed these
nine fresh faces on the list.
84
Cameron Winklevoss
$3 billion • U.S.
Tyler Winklevoss
BILLIONAIRES • NEWCOMERS

$3 billion • U.S.
The twin brothers own an estimated 70,000
Bitcoin, plus the crypto exchange Gemini,
which processes about $200 million a day
in trades. (See story, page 96.)

Michael Saylor
$2.3 billion • U.S.
The CEO of software firm MicroStrategy
made, and lost, a fortune during the first
dot-com bust. He debuts now after snapping
up Bitcoin ahead of the boom—for both him-
self and his company—pushing its stock up.

Jed McCaleb
$2 billion • U.S.
He created Mt. Gox, the first major Bitcoin
exchange, before cofounding Ripple in 2012.
He soon left due to reported disagreements
with fellow founders but still holds an esti-
mated 3.4 billion XRP, Ripple’s token.

Fred Ehrsam
$1.9 billion • U.S.
The former Goldman Sachs trader owns 6%
of crypto exchange Coinbase, which he co-
founded in 2012 and which is poised to go public
on the Nasdaq; he remains a board member.

Barry Silbert
$1.6 billion • U.S.
His Digital Currency Group, a conglomerate
of five blockchain-focused companies,
includes crypto asset manager Grayscale,
which oversees some $44 billion worth of

SAM BANKMAN-FR IED


Bitcoin, ether and other assets.

Tim Draper
$1.5 billion • U.S.
The Silicon Valley VC bought $18.7 million
$8.7 billion • U.S. worth of Bitcoin confiscated by U.S. Marshals
from the shuttered Silk Road black market in
An MIT grad and former Wall Street trader, Bankman-Fried, 29, is the founder and CEO of 2014. They are now worth $1.5 billion.
quantitative crypto trading firm Alameda, which manages $32 billion in Bitcoin and other
major cryptocurrencies as well as their derivatives. He also founded Hong Kong–based Matthew Roszak
crypto exchange FTX, which achieved unicorn status in January 2020, less than a year after $1.5 billion • U.S.
its May 2019 launch. The exchange will soon replace American Airlines as the naming-rights A longtime crypto evangelist, Roszak worked
sponsor of the home arena of the NBA’s Miami Heat. The vast majority of Bankman-Fried’s in venture capital and as an entrepreneur
wealth is in FTX’s equity and FTT tokens, the native cryptocurrency of FTX. In 2020, he gave before amassing a portfolio of Bitcoin, ether
$5 million to a pro-Biden super PAC, making him one of the president’s biggest donors. and other cryptocurrencies starting in 2012.
VIRGILE SIMON BERTRAND FOR FORBES

Editor: Kerry A. Dolan Deputy Editors: Chase Peterson-Withorn, Jennifer Wang Country Editors: Graham Button, Grace Chung, Russell Flannery, Naazneen Karmali,
Nathan Vardi Wealth Team: Angel Au-Yeung, Kenrick Cai, Deniz Çam, Maggie Chen, David Dawkins, Anastassia Gliadkovskaya, John Hyatt, Max Jedeur-Palmgren,
Momina Khan, Sergei Klebnikov, Elaine Mao, Andrea Murphy, Krisztián Sándor, Ariel Shapiro, Giacomo Tognini, Hank Tucker, Lisette Voytko and reporters at Forbes-licensed
editions in Austria, the Czech Republic, Hungary, Kazakhstan, Mexico, Poland, Romania, Russia, Slovakia and Ukraine.
Reporters: Susan Adams, Dan Alexander, Anderson Antunes, Megha Bahree, Nina Bambysheva, Margherita Beale, Madeline Berg, Justin Birnbaum, Tim Boreham,
Igor Bosilkovski, Thomas Brewster, Nilgun Cavdar, Shu-Ching Jean Chen, Muhammad Cohen, Lachlan Colquhoun, Lauren Debter, Michael del Castillo, James Dunn,
Steven Ehrlich, Amy Feldman, Antoine Gara, Eliza Haverstock, Christopher Helman, Alvaro Hernandez Zorrilla, Jane Ho, Katie Jennings, Jeff Kauflin, Sean Kilachand,
Noah Kirsch, Alex Knapp, Alex Konrad, Nicole Lindsay, Katherine Love, Iain Martin, Anis Shakirah Mohd Muslimin, Suzy Nam, Lan Anh Nguyen, Alan Ohnsman, Robert Olsen,
Phisanu Phromchanya, Jonathan Ponciano, Anu Raghunathan, Natalie Robehmed, Leah Rosenbaum, Matt Schifrin, Lucinda Schmidt, Leonard Schoenberger, James Simms,
Chloe Sorvino, Deborah Steinborn, Jessica Tan, Michela Tindera, Ozer Turan, Elisa Valenta, Yue Wang, Jennifer Wells, Will Yakowicz, Itai Zehorai
Research: Sue Radlauer Photo Research: Merrilee Barton, Gail Toivanen Database: Dmitri Slavinsky
Acknowledgements: Special thanks to Sara B. Potter, FactSet Research Systems, Orbis by Bureau Van Dijk, PitchBook Data, Real Capital Analytics, Reonomy, S&P Capital IQ,
VesselsValue and the other experts who helped us with our reporting and valuations.

FORBES.COM A P R I L / M AY 2 0 2 1
COVID-19 SERGIO
At least 40 new billionaires join the list
this year thanks to their involvement in
the global effort to fight the Covid-19
ST EVA N ATO
pandemic. Some made their for- $1.9 billion • Medical
tunes developing new vaccines and packaging • Italy
promising antibody treatments, Covid-19 vaccines 85
while others sell much-needed are housed in tiny
glass vials—many
diagnostic tests and personal of them made by

BILLIONAIRES • NEWCOMERS
protective equipment. the family-owned
Stevanato Group, where
Stevanato, 78, is the
chairman of the board
Stéphane Bancel
$4.3 billion • Biotech • France emeritus. Stevanato
Shares of Moderna, where he has been Group is supplying
CEO since 2011 and whose Covid-19 vaccine vials for about 15% of
was approved in the U.S. in December, rose the Covid-19 vaccines
319% in the past year. tracked by the World
Uğur Şahin Health Organization.
$4 billion • Biotech • Germany That includes 100 million
The Turkish-born physician cofounded vials shipped to a Gates
BioNTech, which developed a Covid-19 Foundation–backed
vaccine in partnership with Pfizer; his group that’s helping
wife, Özlem Türeci, is chief medical officer. to scale 10 different
The stock doubled since mid March 2020.
vaccines, including
Yuan Liping those from Moderna
$3.6 billion • Pharmaceuticals • Canada and AstraZeneca.
Yuan got a 24% stake in Chinese vaccine Founded on the
producer Shenzhen Kangtai Biological outskirts of Venice in
Products after her divorce from the com-
pany’s chairman (and fellow billionaire), 1949 by Sergio’s father,
Du Weimin, last year. Giovanni, the Stevanato
Group started out
Hu Kun
$2.5 billion • Medical devices • China
making glass bottles
for wine before pivoting
Chairman of newly public Contec Medical
Systems, which makes pulse oximeters and to the pharmaceutical
devices used to check lung conditions. industry in the 1960s.
Sergio stepped down
Noubar Afeyan
$1.9 billion • Biotech • U.S.
as CEO in 2010 but still
owns a 68% stake in
The founder of life-sciences VC firm Flagship
Pioneering, through which he owns shares in the company; his son
a dozen publicly traded biotech companies, Franco is executive
is also chairman of Moderna. chairman.
Carl Hansen
$1.8 billion • Biotech • Canada
Former college professor cofounded
AbCellera Biologics to identify antibody
treatments; it partnered with Eli Lilly, which
led to an FDA-authorized Covid-19 therapy.
Robert Langer
$1.6 billion • Biotech • U.S.
One of four new Moderna billionaires,
the MIT professor dubbed “the Edison
of Medicine” owns a 3% stake in the
company, which he helped start in 2010.
Arvind Lal
$1.5 billion • Laboratories • India
Shares of his listed diagnostics chain, Dr. Lal
PathLabs, soared 57% amid the pandemic
as it ramped up testing for Covid-19.
Prathap Reddy
$1.5 billion • Hospitals • India
A doctor, he runs publicly traded hospital
chain Apollo Hospitals Enterprise. Shares
doubled in the past year amid the hospitals’
STEVANATO GROUP

focus on treating and diagnosing Covid-19.


Jack Schuler
$1.1 billion • Diagnostics • U.S.
Former Abbott Labs president, now a biotech
investor, he owns 7% of diagnostics firm
Quidel Corp., which makes Covid-19 tests.

A P R I L / M AY 2 0 2 1 FORBES.COM
KIDA by Stephen Burks
88
THE PROFILE

U DY FAU L K N E R , THE BILLIONAIRE FOUNDER OF


E P I C S Y S T E M S , P I O N E E R E D —T H E N
D O M I N AT E D — E L E C T R O N I C M E D I C A L
R EC O R D S . S H E ’ S B E E N T H E I N D U S T RY ’ S
LEADING ACTOR FOR DECADES, BUT
N O W T H E PA N D E M I C I S F U E L I N G A
D I G I T A L H E A LT H - C A R E R A C E T H A T M AY
F I N A L LY C O S T H E R T H E S P O T L I G H T.

FORBES.COM A P R I L / M AY 2 0 2 1
THE PROFILE

89

THE PROFILE

BY K AT I E J E N N I N G S P H OTO G R A P H Y BY J A M E L T O P P I N F O R F O R B E S

A P R I L / M AY 2 0 2 1 FORBES.COM
nicely with others. The company’s product is
generally referred to as an electronic health rec-
ord, but its reach is far broader, including reve-
nue cycle management, customer retention tools
and data analytics.
Epic’s suite of offerings has proven particular-
ly popular among large academic medical cen-
ters and children’s hospitals, such as the Cleve-
90 land Clinic, Johns Hopkins and Boston Children’s
Hospital. The company’s 564 customers represent
nearly 2,400 hospitals worldwide and 225 mil-
THE PROFILE

lion patients in the U.S., or about two-thirds of the


country’s population. This translated into more
than $3.3 billion in revenue in 2020, despite what
Faulkner estimates to be around $500 million
in foregone revenue for Covid-related software it
provided free of charge, including infection man-
agement tools and extensions for pop-up hospi-
tals. “It never seemed right to me to make money
off Covid,” she says.
Her success has been decades in the making.
A victorious swell of brass instruments reverberates across Since Epic’s founding in 1979, the 77-year-old
the 1,100-acre Epic Systems campus in Verona, Wisconsin, a Faulkner has steadfastly rejected outside inves-
sleepy suburb just outside Madison. It’s February 2020, and tors, Wall Street financing and acquisitions. Epic
except for China and a couple of ill-fated cruise ships, there was still just a $500 million (sales) company in
are few signs of the coronavirus pandemic that’s about to en- 2007. Ten years ago, it hit $1 billion in revenue,
velop the world. It’s certainly business as usual at Epic: The and growth has compounded at an annual rate of
familiar strains of a baroque wedding march fill the hallways, 15% every year since. It’s highly profitable: Esti-
stopping the health-care software company’s 10,700 employ- mated cash flow as measured by Ebidta is north
ees in their tracks. On cue, a new customer announcement of 30%, and the company has no debt. Forbes
follows: Florida-based AdventHealth plans to deploy Epic’s estimates Faulkner’s 47% stake in Epic to be
electronic health record system across 37 of its hospitals. The worth $6 billion, which makes her the second-
full installation will take over three years and cost around richest self-made woman in America. Employees
$650 million, not counting ongoing and around a dozen other cofound-
maintenance, which will cost mil- ers and initial investors own the
lions more annually. “It’s a very long other 53%.
relationship for many of our cus- The move-fast-and-break- In 2019, Epic had a 39% share
tomers,” Epic’s founder and CEO, of the more than 880,000 hospi-
Judy Faulkner, says in a rare inter-
things ethos of Silicon tal beds in the U.S., the health-care
view. She got the idea for the wed- Valley doesn’t work in IT firm KLAS Research estimates.
ding theme from a visit to the Mayo health care: “You can’t The rest of the market is fragment-
Clinic several decades earlier, where ed among publicly traded Cern-
she heard lullabies play whenever a tell a doctor it’s okay to er, the Massachusetts-based Medi-
new baby was born. A new customer fail. It’s not okay to fail. tech and a few other firms, in-
“didn’t feel like a new baby,” she says. That’s death.” cluding Allscripts and CPSI. Ep-
“It felt more like a wedding.” ic’s dominance has made it an
Indeed, hospital execu- industry target, with critics and
tives are often more commit- competitors accusing the company
ted to Epic than most Americans are to their marriag- of being a closed network that makes it difficult to
es. Epic’s average customer has been using its software exchange data with other systems. Faulkner con-
for 10 years, and Faulkner claims the company has nev- tends Epic does share data but puts patient pri-
er lost an in-patient hospital client, except in the case of vacy above all.
an acquisition. Partly that’s because it’s so hard to leave. Epic’s biggest strength, this build-it-alone
Epic’s software helps manage a patient’s entire journey, mentality, could become its biggest liability in
starting with scheduling an appointment, moving into the the post-Covid world. The pandemic is forcing
clinic or operating room as the doctor records allergies or fast change in the U.S. health-care system. Doc-
X-rays and then to the back office for billing and follow- tors and other providers have rapidly adopted
ups. It’s a proprietary system that infamously doesn’t play new technology over the last year as patients sud-

FORBES.COM A P R I L / M AY 2 0 2 1
denly took a strong interest in staying as far away from the doesn’t work in health care. “You can’t tell a doctor
hospital as possible. it’s okay to fail,” Glaser says. “It’s not okay to fail.
Venture capitalists were already gunning for Epic before That’s death.”
the pandemic struck. After all, the company’s big-system

FAULKNER
mindset and hundred-million-dollar installations seem out
of step in the era of cloud computing and cheap, ubiquitous
mobile apps. Then, shortly before lockdown, the U.S. gov-
ernment finalized new federal data-sharing rules empower-
ing patients to have ownership over their own digital medi- 91
cal records—potentially further eroding what has historically
been a health-data oligopoly dominated by Epic and Cerner. has loved tackling tough problems since she was a

THE PROFILE
“We are right in the middle of this phenomenal transfor- kid growing up near Haddonfield, New Jersey, in
mational swirl,” says John Glaser, a former Cerner executive the 1950s. In seventh grade, her math teacher put
who currently lectures at Harvard Medical School. It’s not riddles on the blackboard, and she’s been hooked
that electronic health records will go away, he says, but more on math and logic ever since. She majored in math
nimble and agile startups will enter the market. Just as the at Dickinson College in Carlisle, Pennsylvania, and
web and smartphones crushed Microsoft’s seemingly unas- had a summer job in particle physics at the Uni-
sailable 1990s-era desktop monopoly, this new era may pose versity of Rochester, where she was introduced to
the same challenges for Faulkner. But there’s one huge differ- computer programming and Fortran (the ancient
ence. The move-fast-and-break-things ethos of Silicon Valley coding language invented by IBM). “I always liked
making things out of clay,” Faulkner says. “And the
computer was clay of the mind. Instead of physical,
it was mental.”
In 1965, she started a doctorate in the University
of Wisconsin’s nascent computer science program.

Through the Looking Glass

Office spaces based on Alice in Wonderland and The Wizard of Oz at


Epic’s “Intergalactic Headquarters” in Verona, Wisconsin. “How do we
expect people to develop software that’s going to be beautiful for our users
if we keep people in a boring, sterile environment?” Judy Faulkner asks.

A P R I L / M AY 2 0 2 1 FORBES.COM
In Madison, she met psychiatrist and professor Warner Slack, The year after Epic inked the Kaiser deal,
who was teaching one of the first-ever courses on computers it moved to a new corporate campus, which
in medicine. A few years later, Slack introduced Faulkner to is often compared to an adult Disney World.
John Greist, then chief resident in medicine and now profes- Headquarters features one of the world’s larg-
sor emeritus at the University of Wisconsin, who was looking est underground auditoriums, a Hogwarts-
for a better way to schedule on-call doctors. In 1969, Faulkner inspired Great Hall, an elevator to Hell, an enor-
developed a system in which a secretary could punch data mous tree house and myriad other strange and
cards to generate the schedule for an entire year in 18 seconds fantastical buildings and sculptures amid the
92 at a cost of $5. rolling hills of southern Wisconsin. At Epic’s an-
Faulkner graduated without completing a dissertation (“I nual customer meeting, Faulkner is known for
never could figure out what to write a thesis on,” she says) and dressing up in costumes, ranging from Lucille
THE PROFILE

in the early 1970s started working for a physicians group at Ball to the Mad Hatter from Alice in Wonder-
the University of Wisconsin, developing a database to keep land. It all seems somewhat at odds with the self-
track of patient information over time. It would take a few proclaimed nerd who shies away from the public
more years (and lots of convincing from colleagues) before eye. “Introverts can act like extroverts,” she offers
Faulkner was ready to start her own software company. “It al- by way of explanation. “What they say is extro-
most seemed like a joke to start a company,” she recalls. “How verts can’t act like introverts.”
do you do that?” The company sees a lot of turnover. Each year,
In 1979, Faulkner and Greist borrowed from friends and Epic hires around 2,000 employees, who are re-
family—and against their homes—to scrape together the quired to pass a series of aptitude tests measuring
capital to launch Human Services Computing (later re- things like coding skills and logic. The company
named Epic), which was originally valued at $70,000 (about motto is “Do good. Have fun. Make money,” and the
$270,000 in today’s money). Faulkner had six or seven oth- culture is fast-paced and hypercompetitive. Former
er collaborators, but from the begin- employees talk about burnout from
ning it was the Judy show; the com- an environment filled with over-
pany was her idea, and she served achievers. But even Epic’s employ-
as its first president. At first, it op- ees can be pushed too far: There was
erated after-hours from a Madi- “I have never, in the a revolt when the company tried to
son basement. Faulkner wrote all force all staffers to return to campus
the original code on a Data Gener-
history of health care in amid the pandemic last August. Af-
al Eclipse 16-bit minicomputer the the United States, seen ter several stories about the contre-
size of a refrigerator. this kind of supernova of temps appeared in the local press,
After a few years, Greist had a dis- the company reversed course.
agreement with Faulkner over the innovation with a flurry Florida’s AdventHealth, which
company’s direction. Greist says he of investment activity signed its $650 million contract in a
stepped down from Epic’s board into digital health.” pre-Covid world, will be Epic’s larg-
in 1983 but still holds onto some est fully remote build and installa-
shares. “Part of my difficulty with her tion. In a blow to Cerner and Athe-
was me saying, ‘Gosh, why don’t we nahealth, CEO Terry Shaw decided
get some venture capital and we can it would be better for his 5.5 million
build it faster?’ ” Greist says. “And she said, ‘No, we’re not go- patients to switch to Epic rather than trying to get
ing to do that. Because we’ll lose control.’ And certainly that’s its current combination of three electronic health
been her policy. And she has lived it out and proven it. I was record companies to talk to one another. While it’s
wrong. She was right.” expensive upfront, he says, the move will lower op-
Epic saw slow but steady growth in its first two decades, erating costs in the long term. Epic’s system “has
gaining a handful of new customers every year as it expanded tentacles that go out through amazing networks,”
its offerings. In the late 1980s, the company added billing soft- he adds. “You can actually help a person get the
ware; in the early 1990s it adopted a graphic user interface for care they need, wherever they need to get it.”
outpatient clinics. Aside from Faulkner’s obsessive focus on its

EPIC’S
customers, Epic had another advantage: computer code that
worked. “It’s not perfect, but it’s quite reliable,” Faulkner says.
In 2004 the company landed its biggest deal yet: a three-
year project with Kaiser Permanente that would cost the
health giant $4 billion. Epic’s cut would be around $400 mil-
lion. “[Epic] brought that safety factor that if you chose them,
they were actually going to deliver on implementation and tentacles are notorious for reaching only so far,
they were going to do it on time,” says George Halvorson, who however—and that seems largely by design. It’s
was the CEO of Kaiser Permanente at the time. “That’s huge.” super-easy for, say, a hospital to share a cancer

FORBES.COM A P R I L / M AY 2 0 2 1
patient’s records with an outside chemotherapy clinic—as
long as both places are running Epic’s software. If the che-
motherapy clinic is using software from a big competitor,
it’s still probably going to be able to access the patient’s re-
cords. But if the clinic wants to experiment with a cheaper
third-party app, it may be quite a struggle. Epic works with
health-care apps only on a case-by-case basis.
Geeks call this “interoperability”—getting different soft-
ware systems to talk to each other, in essence—and the is- 93
sue came to a head in January 2020 during a debate over
the new federal rules. Sharing medical records with third

THE PROFILE
parties—even at the patient’s own request—could pose “se-
rious risks to patient privacy,” Epic said in a statement at
the time.
Nearly every other tech company—including Cerner, Ap-
ple, Microsoft and Google—disagreed, arguing that Epic’s
stance is bad for patients and stifles innovation. Even fed-
eral officials took veiled digs at Faulkner’s business. “The
disingenuous efforts by certain private actors to use priva-
cy—vital as it is—as a pretext for holding patient data hos-
tage is an embarrassment to the industry,” former Centers
for Medicare and Medicaid director Seema Verma said at a
conference. In the end, the feds prohibited health-care data
blocking by Epic or any other company.
Big Tech has flirted with health-care data for more than
a decade, with companies like Google trying and failing
to launch an internet-based personal health record in the
late aughts. Microsoft HealthVault similarly crashed and
Corporate Climber
burned. Apple’s attempt to measure heart rhythms with its
Faulkner says she didn’t have a grand plan for growth.
watch was panned by doctors. And Amazon had a giant flop “It’s always been, like, you climb a mountain. And you just
with Haven, its joint venture with Berkshire Hathaway and see the hill ahead of you. You don’t see the whole mountain.
And then you get on top of that hill, you see the next hill.
JPMorgan Chase, which was supposed to dramatically re- And you just keep climbing.”
duce employer health-care costs.
Where the whales failed, the minnows might win. With In 2019, Epic unveiled a big-data initiative called
the new federal guidelines rolling out over the next cou- Cosmos, which aims to mine more than 100 mil-
ple of years, plenty of venture capitalists are now betting lion de-identified patient records.
big that one of many tiny upstarts can breach Epic’s moat. Despite being just 28 months shy of her 80th
Health IT venture funding hit an all-time high in 2020 of birthday, Faulkner says she has no plans to retire.
more than $3.6 billion, a 51% increase from 2019, accord- She has not named a successor, and none of her
ing to CB Insights. “I have never in the history of health three children works at Epic. Faulkner has se-
care in the United States seen this kind of supernova of cured Epic’s future only insofar as the company
innovation with a flurry of investment activity into digital will never be taken public. She has split her stock
health,” says Missy Krasner, a former Google Health and into voting shares that can’t be sold and have
Amazon executive who recently joined New York–based gone into a trust controlled by family members
venture shop Redesign Health. “Covid has totally made in- and employees. Her nonvoting shares are being
teroperability sexy again.” left to a foundation she established with her hus-
Faulkner says she’s not concerned about all the Silicon band called Roots & Wings, which funds her in-
Valley players entering the health-care space. “I think that terests in child brain development and criminal
what will happen is that a few of them will do very well. And justice reform (she signed the Giving Pledge in
the majority of them won’t,” she says. “It’s not us as much as 2015). “I enjoy what I do and I’d like to do it as
the health systems who have to respond to the patient say- long as I am effective and can bring value in the
ing ‘send my data here’ or ‘send my data there.’ ” job,” she says. She worries about what happens
The new federal rules concern individual patient records, to people when they retire, having read that the
but the industry is rapidly heading toward aggregating bulk average person dies two years after leaving the
data. It’s a space in which many, including Epic, want to workforce. “They seem to lose that edge that says,
play. These large, anonymous medical data sets can be used ‘Why am I waking up in the morning? What is
for everything from drug discovery to unearthing emerging my day going to be?’ I wake up and think, ‘How
national health trends and could be worth a lot of money. do I get everything done in my day?’ ”

A P R I L / M AY 2 0 2 1 FORBES.COM
W/WZKDKd/KE

FINA NCING
THE FUTURE:
M A RC R E N É
DESCHENAUX
>D<ZDZZE^,Ehy,^/WK^/Ed,tKZ<^&ZKD,K>>ztKKdK
&Z/ dK ZKd/ E zKE t/d, E z KE /EEKsd/KE E WZK&/d/>/dz
d, /EdZEd/KE> &/EE/Z ,^ dK d E'/EZ ϭϳ* ^h^^&h> /E/d/>
Wh>/K&&Z/E'^EϮϰϯWZ/sdK&&Z/E'^&/E/E''ZKtd,KWWKZdhE/d/^/^
WZWdh>WhZ^h/d&KZ^,EhyE,/^dD

Innovative, disruptive and sustainable ventures


In Deschenaux’s spotlight right now is ĐĂƉŝƚĂůƉƌŝǀĂƚĞĞƋƵŝƚLJĚĞďƚƐĞĐƵƌŝƟĞƐ dŚĞ ŐƌŽǁŝŶŐ ĂƉƉĞƚŝƚĞ ĨŽƌ ƵŶůŝƐƚĞĚ
Intellectual Property Securities Cor- ĂŶĚŝŶǀĞƐƚŵĞŶƚďĂŶŬŝŶŐdŚĞĨŝƌŵŝƐ ƐĞĐƵƌŝƚŝĞƐŚĂƐĂůƐŽůĞĚĞƐĐŚĞŶĂƵdž
ƉŽƌĂƟŽŶ;/W^ŚƩƉƐǁǁǁ
ŝƉƐĞ
ŝŶĐ ŵĂŶĂŐĞĚďLJĂŐƌŽƵƉŽĨĞŶƚƌĞƉƌĞŶĞƵƌƐ ĂŶĚƚĞĂŵƚŽŶƵƌƚƵƌĞĂŶĚƐƵƉƉŽƌƚƚŚĞ
/W^ǁŝůůĮŶĂŶĐĞŶĞǁŵŽƟŽŶƉŝĐƚƵƌĞƐ ĂŶĚĞdžƉĞƌƚƐŝŶĨŝŶĂŶĐĞŝŶŶŽǀĂƚŝŽŶ ƌĞĐĞŶƚĞƐƚĂďůŝƐŚŵĞŶƚŽĨWƌĞ/WKΘWƌŝ
ŵƵƐŝĐƉƌŽũĞĐƚƐƉĂƚĞŶƚƐĂŶĚƚĞĐŚŶŽůŽ ƐƚĂƌƚƵƉĨƵŶĚŝŶŐŐŽǀĞƌŶĂŶĐĞŵĂŶĂŐĞ ǀĂƚĞ^ƚŽĐŬĂŶĞdžĐŚĂŶŐĞĂŐŽƌĂǁŚŝĐŚ
ŐŝĞƐƚŚƌŽƵŐŚŵĂƌŬĞƚĂďůĞƐĞĐƵƌŝƟĞƐ/ƚ ŵĞŶƚĂŶĚůĞĂĚĞƌƐŚŝƉ ŽīĞƌƐĂŶ/ĚƌŝǀĞŶǀĂůƵĂƟŽŶĮůƚĞƌĂŶĚ
ŝŶƚĞŶĚƐƚŽŽƉĞŶĂŶĞǁŵĂƌŬĞƚƐĞĐƚŽƌ ŚƩƉƐƐǁŝƐƐĮŶĂŶĐŝĞƌƐ
ĐŽŵĂďŽƵƚ ŵĂƌŬĞƚƉůĂĐĞĨŽƌƉƌŝǀĂƚĞĐŽŵƉĂŶŝĞƐ
on the NASDAQ to list a new genera- ŚƩƉƐƉƌĞŝƉŽ
ĐŽŵ
ƚŝŽŶŽĨƉĂƐƐƚŚƌŽƵŐŚƐĞĐƵƌŝƚŝĞƐ/W^ /ŵǁŽƌŬŝŶŐǁŝƚŚĂĚƌĞĂŵƚĞĂŵǁŚŝĐŚ
ĂŝŵƐƚŽŝŶĐŽƌƉŽƌĂƚĞŝŶƚĞůůĞĐƚƵĂůƉƌŽƉ ŝŶĐůƵĚĞƐŚƌŝƐƚŝĂŶ&ƌĂŵƉƚŽŶŽƌŝŶ ^ŽŵĞŽĨƚŚĞŽƚŚĞƌ/WKƐĞƐĐŚĞŶĂƵdž
ĞƌƚLJƌŝŐŚƚƐŝŶƚŽƐĞĐƵƌŝƚŝĞƐĂŶĚƚŚĞŝƌ ŝƚƵůĞdž<ƵŵŵĞƌŵĂŶ'ůĞŶŶWƌŽĞů ŚĂƐ ŽŶ ĚĞĐ Ŭ ŶŽǁ ĂƌĞ ĐŽŵƉĂŶŝĞƐ
ŵĂŶĂŐĞŵĞŶƚƌĞŵŽǀŝŶŐƚŚĞƌŝƐŬŽĨůŽƐƐ ůŽĐŚƐŽƵƌŐĂŵ<ƵŵŵĞƌDĂdžŝŵĞ>ĂŐ ŝŶǀŽůǀĞĚŝŶƌĂŝŶĐƌĞĂƟŶŐĞŶǀŝƌŽŶŵĞŶ
ŽĨƌŽLJĂůƟĞƐƌĞůĂƟǀĞƚŽƚŚĞǁŽƌŬƐŽĨƚŚĞ ĂŶĞĂŶĚ,ĂLJĞƚŽƵnjŝĚ!ĞƐĐŚĞŶĂƵdž ƚĂůƚĞĐŚŶŽůŽŐLJƐĞĐƵƌĞŵŽďŝůĞƚƌĂŶƐ
ĂƵƚŚŽƌĂƌƟƐƚŽƌŝŶǀĞŶƚŽƌ ƐĂLJƐDLJůĂǁƉĂƌƚŶĞƌƐZŝĐŚĂƌĚD ĂĐƟŽŶƐĂŚŽƐƉŝƚĂůŝƚLJ#ǁĞůůŶĞƐƐŐƌŽƵƉ
'ƌĞĞŶďĞƌŐĂŶĚZĂůƉŚ,ŽƌŶďůŽǁĞƌ/// ŝīĞůĚŝƐƚƌŝĐƚƉƌŽũĞĐƚƐĂŶĚƐƵƐƚĂŝŶĂďůĞ
/W^ŚĂƐƐƵĐĐĞƐƐĨƵůůLJƐƚĂƌƚĞĚƚŚĞƉƌŽ ĂƌĞŬĞLJƚŽŵĂŶĂŐŝŶŐƚŚĞƐĞĚĞĂůƐƐƵĐ ůƵdžƵƌLJƌĞĂůĞƐƚĂƚĞƉƌŽũĞĐƚƐ
ĐĞƐƐŽĨďĞĐŽŵŝŶŐĂůŝƐƚĞĚĞŶƟƚLJƵƐŝŶŐ ĐĞƐƐĨƵůůLJ!ĞƐĐŚĞŶĂƵdžĂŶĚŚŝƐƚĞĂŵ
^ǁŝƐƐ &ŝŶĂŶĐŝĞƌƐ /ŶĐ Ă ŶĞǁ Ĩŝƌŵ ĂƌĞ ĐŽƐƉŽŶƐŽƌŝŶŐ dŚĞ ,ŽůůLJǁŽŽĚ tĞĂ ƚ Ś Ğ ƌ   Ž ƌ Ɖ  Ĩ ŝ ů ŝ Ŷ Ő  Ĩ Ž ƌ  ŝ ƚ Ɛ  / W K
ƌĞǀŽůƵƚŝŽŶŝnjŝŶŐ ƚŚĞ ĚĞĂůŵĂŬŝŶŐ ŝŶ ^W  Ă ƐƉĞĐŝĂů ƉƵƌƉŽƐĞ ĂĐƋƵŝƐŝ  ƵŶĚĞƌƚŚĞŶĂŵĞtĞĂƚŚĞƌŽƌƉŽƌĂ
/WKƐĂŶĚůĂƌŐĞĨŝŶĂŶĐŝĂůƚƌĂŶƐĂĐƚŝŽŶƐ ƚŝŽŶĐŽŵƉĂŶLJĂŝŵŝŶŐƚŽĐŽŶƐŽůŝĚĂƚĞ ƚŝŽŶ;tKZWĐƌĞĂƚĞƐƌĂŝŶĂŶLJǁŚĞƌĞ
ĞƐĐŚĞŶĂƵdžŝƐŽŶĞŽĨƚŚĞĨŽƵŶĚŝŶŐ ,ŽůůLJǁŽŽĚƐƚƵĚŝŽƐĂŶĚƉƌŽĚƵĐƚŝŽŶ ŶĞĞĚĞĚ ŝŶ ƚŚĞ ǁŽƌůĚ ǁŝƚŚŽƵƚ ĂŶLJ
ƉĂƌƚŶĞƌƐŽĨ^ǁŝƐƐ&ŝŶĂŶĐŝĞƌƐĂƚĞĂŵ ĐŽŵƉĂŶŝĞƐ ĐŚĞŵŝĐĂůƉƌŽĚƵĐƚƐdŚĞĐŽŵƉĂŶLJƐ
ǁŝƚŚĞdžƉĞƌƟƐĞŝŶŝŶǀĞƐƚŵĞŶƚƐǀĞŶƚƵƌĞ ŚƩƉƐǁǁǁ
ŚŽůůLJǁŽŽĚƐƉĂĐ
ĐŽŵ ƚĞĐŚŶŽůŽŐLJĨŽƌƌĂŝŶĨĂůůĞŶŚĂŶĐĞŵĞŶƚ

1 /ŶŶŽǀĂƟǀĞ&ŝŶĂŶĐŝĞƌƐďLJWĂƵůdƌƵƐƞƵůů
PAID PROMOTION

is environmentally friendly, solar orchestrate its IPO processes. EIC is set NY, in June 2021, ŚƚƚƉƐƉĂĐĐŽŶĨĞƌ
powered and zero- CO2. It mimics ƚŽŐŽƉƵďůŝĐƚŽĮŶĂŶĐĞƚŚĞĐŽŶƐƚƌƵĐƟŽŶ ĞŶĐĞ
ĐŽŵand atƚŚĞ/WKĐŽŶĨĞƌĞŶĐĞ
nature’s ionization processes in local ŽĨϭϬŝĐŽŶŝĐŝīĞůdŽǁĞƌƐĂŶĚ&ƌĞŶĐŚ ŚƩƉƐŝƉŽĐŽŶĨĞƌĞŶĐĞ
ĐŽŵ
ĂƚŵŽƐƉŚĞƌĞǁŚŝĐŚŝŶŇƵĞŶĐĞƐŐƌŽǁƚŚ Quarters in key locations around the
of raindrops in clouds by means of ǁŽƌůĚĂĐŚŶĞǁůĂŶĚŵĂƌŬŝīĞůdŽǁĞƌ Deschenaux has served on the board
ŐƌŽƵŶĚďĂƐĞĚƐLJƐƚĞŵƐĂŶĚŚĂƌĚǁĂƌĞ will be the centerpiece of a district of directors for more than 80 compa-
ŚƩƉƐǁĞĂƚŚĞƌĐŽƌƉ
ĐŽ steeped in French culture, savoir-vivre nies. From 2012 to 2020 he served as
ĂŶĚƐŽƉŚŝƐƟĐĂƟŽŶ ƚƌĞĂƐƵƌĞƌĂŶĚũƵĚŐĞŵĞĚŝĂƚŽƌĂƚƚŚĞ
DŽďŝ'ƌŽƵƉŝƐĐƵƌƌĞŶƚůLJĐŚĂŶŐŝŶŐƚŚĞ ŚƩƉƐǁǁǁ
ĞŝīĞůĐŽƌƉŽƌĂƟŽŶ
ĐŽŵ /ŶƚĞƌŶĂƟŽŶĂůŽƵƌƚŽĨDĞĚŝĂƟŽŶĂŶĚ
way people pay in Africa and soon will Arbitration (CIMEDA). He is now an
ĐŚĂŶŐĞƚŚĞǁĂLJŐŽǀĞƌŶŵĞŶƚƐĐŽůůĞĐƚ Adriatica Real Estate Corporation, Ambassador of the African Court of
Value Added Tax. “MobiGroup is one ĚŽŝŶŐďƵƐŝŶĞƐƐĂƐĚƌĞĂůŝƐĐƌĞĂƚŝŶŐ DĞĚŝĂƟŽŶĂŶĚƌďŝƚƌĂƟŽŶ;DZ7
of the companies that will be taken ƚŚĞůƵdžƵƌLJƌĞƐŝĚĞŶƟĂůĐŽŵŵĞƌĐŝĂůĂŶĚ
public by Swiss Financiers to major ŵĂƌŝŶĂƉƌŽũĞĐƚEŝŬŽůĂǀŝůůĂŐĞŽŶƚŚĞ Deschenaux’s leadership activities
ŝŶƚĞƌŶĂƟŽŶĂůƐĞĐƵƌŝƟĞƐŵĂƌŬĞƚƐǁŝƚŚŝŶ Dalmatia Adriatic coast near Sibenik, extend to a number of nonprofits.
the next 24 months,” says Deschenaux. Croatia. This operation is based on ŵŽŶŐƚŚŽƐĞŚĞŚĂƐĨŽƵŶĚĞĚĂƌĞƚŚĞ
dŚĞĐŽŵƉĂŶLJƐƉĂLJŵĞŶƚƚĞĐŚŶŽůŽŐLJ Jean-Paul Uldry’s CHR-EKO Projekt SA. /WK/ŶƐƟƚƵƚĞŚƩƉƐŝƉŽŝŶƐƟƚƵƚĞ
ĐŽŵ
bypasses merchant collection proce- The Swiss company has invested more the Experts Without Borders Federa-
dures to deliver tax payments directly than USD 90 million to date. Adreal ƟŽŶŚƩƉƐǁǁǁ
ĞdžƉĞƌƚƐǁŝƚŚŽƵƚďŽƌ
ƚŽƚĂdžƌĞǀĞŶƵĞĂƵƚŚŽƌŝƟĞƐ ĚĞǀĞůŽƉƐƉƌŽƉĞƌƟĞƐƵƐŝŶŐĚƵƌĂďůĞĂŶĚ ĚĞƌƐ
ŶŐŽ and the Perpetual Charity
ŚƩƉƐŵŽďŝǀĂƚ
ĐŽŵ ƐƵƐƚĂŝŶĂďůĞƚĞĐŚŶŝƋƵĞƐƚŚĂƚƌĞŇĞĐƚƚŚĞ ŽƌƉŽƌĂƟŽŶŚƩƉƐƉĞƌƉĞƚƵĂůĐŚĂƌŝƚLJ

ůŽĐĂůĐƵůƚƵƌĞ*tŚŝůĞƚŚŝƐŵŝŐŚƚƐĞĞŵ ĐŽŵ
Earth and Sky is active in 3 distinc- ůŝŬĞƚŚĞůĞĂƐƚŝŶŶŽǀĂƟǀĞŽĨŽƵƌĐƵƌƌĞŶƚ
ƚŝǀĞŝŶĚƵƐƚƌŝĞƐŚŽƐƉŝƚĂůŝƚLJĂŐƌŝĐƵů- /WKƐŝƚĐŽƵůĚďĞŽŶĞŽĨƚŚĞŵŽƐƚƉƌŽĮƚ-
ture and the production of essential able,” says Deschenaux. To lea r n more about
oils. Focused on wellness tourism ŚƩƉƐǁǁǁ
ĂĚƌĞĂůĐŽƌƉ
ĐŽŵ
and healthcare, the company’s lux- Marc Deschenaux visit
ƵƌLJŚŽƚĞůƐǁŝůůƉƌŽǀŝĚĞŐƵĞƐƚƐǁŝƚŚ
ƵŶŝƋƵĞƌĞĐƌĞĂƟŽŶŚŽůŝƐƟĐƚƌĞĂƚŵĞŶƚƐ 'ůŽďĂůĐŝƟnjĞŶĂŶĚůĞĂĚĞƌ marc.deschenaux.com
ĂŶĚƚŚĞƌĂƉŝĞƐ/ƚƐĮƌƐƚƉƌŽƉĞƌƚLJŶŽǁ ĞƐĐŚĞŶĂƵdžĚŝǀŝĚĞƐŚŝƐƟŵĞďĞƚǁĞĞŶ
underway in Marrakech, will produce Geneva, Marrakech, New York and Los
ŝƚƐŽǁŶĞĐŽĞŶĞƌŐLJ ŶŐĞůĞƐŽŶƐŝĚĞƌĞĚĂǁŽƌůĚĞdžƉĞƌƚ
ŚƩƉƐĞĂƌƚŚĂŶĚƐŬLJĐŽƌƉ
ĐŽŵ ŝŶĐŽƌƉŽƌĂƚĞĨŝŶĂŶĐĞŚĞŚĂƐƚĂƵŐŚƚ
at various universities around the
Eiffel International Corporation (EIC) world. Deschenaux will be a keynote
has selec ted Swiss Financier s to speaker at the SPAC conference in Rye,

/ŶŶŽǀĂƟǀĞ&ŝŶĂŶĐŝĞƌƐďLJWĂƵůdƌƵƐƞƵůů 2
96

P H OTO G R A P H BY M I C H A E L P R I N C E A N D
I L LU S T R AT I O N BY YO S H I S O D E O K A F O R F O R B E S

FORBES.COM
THE TREND

BY
M I C H A E L D E L C A S T I L LO,
S U S A N A DA M S A N D
ANTOINE GARA

After losing an epic battle with Mark Zuckerberg over ownership of Facebook
and being shunned in Silicon Valley, CAMERON and TYLER WINKLEVOSS are back—
this time as budding Bitcoin billionaires at the center of the future of money,
the creative economy and quite possibly a new operating model for Big Tech itself.
the 255-year-old auction house’s first-ever sale of a non-
fungible token (NFT) artwork, a one-of-a-kind comput-
er file tracked on a digital ledger known as a blockchain.
Nifty Gateway put the artist, Mike Winkelmann, who goes
by Beeple, on the map through a series of “drops” start-
ing last year. Before the day ends, Gemini’s custodial busi-
ness, which houses digital assets securely, will receive a
$69 million cryptocurrency payment for Beeple on behalf
98 of Christie’s, making his “Everydays: The First 5,000 Days”
the third-most-expensive work sold by a living
artist, after Jeff Koons and David Hockney.
THE TREND

Much of the world still thinks of the 6-foot-5


twins as the crew-rowing chumps played by
Armie Hammer in The Social Network, the
hit 2010 movie about Facebook. At Harvard,
classmate Mark Zuckerberg had swiped their idea for a
social networking site, building an empire with 2.8 bil-
lion worldwide users and a personal fortune now worth
$97 billion. A dozen years after they settled with Zuck-
erberg for $65 million in Facebook stock and cash, the
Winklevii, as they are widely known, have emerged as
leaders of a technological movement whose core operat-
ing principle involves digitizing the records of all assets
billionaires Cameron and Tyler Winklevoss saunter into globally, decentralizing control and cutting out gate-
their empty 17th-floor offices in Manhattan’s Flatiron dis- keepers—including Facebook.
trict wearing designer high-tops, black jeans and match- Blockchain, the technology underlying Bitcoin and
ing sweatshirts made by the high-end streetwear brand other cryptocurrencies, is already disrupting money and
Heron Preston. The sweatshirts—Cameron’s is red, Ty- banking, as giant financial firms such as PayPal, Square,
ler’s white—are emblazoned with a NASA logo, which JPMorgan, Fidelity and Northern Trust embrace Bitcoin
the twins picked because it echoes the space-exploration and jockey for position in a future awash in digital assets.
theme behind the brand of their seven-year-old crypto- At the same time, big companies including Boeing, Sam-
currency trading operation, Gemini. In addition to being sung, Tesla and Novartis are using the new technology
the Zodiac sign symbolized by twins, it was the name of to improve their supply chains, share customer data and
NASA’s second space mission—the one just prior to Apol- speed up business processes. In some cases they’re add-
lo 11, which put the first man on the moon. ing Bitcoin to their balance sheets. In 2020, Bitcoin re-
“We actually call our employees astronauts,” Cameron turned more than 300%, against 18% for the S&P 500.
says. “We’re all astronauts building on the frontier of mon- The Winklevii say they’re just getting started. Through
ey and the frontier of art and the frontier of finance.” Accus- their holding company, Gemini Space Station, which
tomed to finishing his brother’s thoughts, Tyler chimes in: owns their crypto exchange and Nifty Gateway, and via
“We feel like we’re on a spaceship, exploring a new frontier.” investments made by their family office, Winklevoss Cap-
On this sunny March day, the spaceship is hitting warp ital, the duo have invested in no fewer than 25 digital-
speed. The price of Bitcoin is about to reach an all-time asset startups. These fledgling companies are laying the

“The idea of a centralized social network is just not going to exist five or
ten years in the future,” Tyler predicts, when asked about Facebook.
“There’s a chasm between the old world and this new crypto-native universe.”

high of $58,000 (it sold for $8 in 2012 when the brothers foundation for what the brothers hope will be a new vir-
began investing some $10 million in the digital currency), tual world that they and others call the “metaverse,” in
rocketing their combined net worth to $6 billion. Their lat- which digital assets like art, music, real estate and even
est investment, fast-growing Bitcoin lending giant Block- entire businesses are created, bought and sold—and,
Fi, just announced it has raised $350 million, valuing the most importantly, governed—by the blockchain. Many
company at $3 billion. of the companies they’re backing are positioned to thrive
And the 39-year-old brothers’ hottest venture, digital in this three-dimensional version of the internet ruled
art auction platform Nifty Gateway, is basking in the glow via peer-to-peer computer networks, where participants
of a sale at Christie’s, where the gavel is about to fall on rather than powerful companies profit.

FORBES.COM A P R I L / M AY 2 0 2 1
Doubling Down

Within 24 hours of meeting with the


Winklevoss twins in 2019, Griffin (left)
and Duncan Cock Foster had received
an overture from Gemini to buy Nifty
Gateway. The NFT auction house was
recently valued at $1 billion.

99

THE TREND

A P R I L / M AY 2 0 2 1 FORBES.COM
“The idea of a centralized social network is just not go-
ing to exist five or 10 years in the future,” Tyler predicts
when asked about Facebook. “There’s a membrane or a
chasm between the old world and this new crypto-native
universe. And we’re the conduit helping people transcend
the offline into the online.”

100 The fact that two Greenwich, Connecticut–raised


men of Harvard, both former Olympians, find themselves
at the center of an antiestablishment movement whose
THE TREND

most notable use case to date has been a thriving online


bazaar selling illegal drugs speaks volumes about how far
the Winklevii have come from their days in Cambridge,
Massachusetts, grappling with Mark Zuckerberg.
After settling their arbitration with Facebook and com-
peting in the 2008 Olympics in Beijing, the Winklevoss
brothers headed to Oxford University to earn their MBAs
in 2010 and then formed Winklevoss Capital to make
venture investments. Eager to join the cadre of firms on
Sand Hill Road funding today’s great technology com-
panies, the twins soon realized that they were effectively
shunned in Silicon Valley. Startup after startup, fearful of
reprisals from juggernaut Facebook and its growing net-
work, refused to take their capital.
As recounted in Ben Mezrich’s 2019 book Bitcoin Bil- marketplace they needed to be hands-on—and, more
lionaires, it was during a vacation on the Mediterranean importantly, they needed to bring order to a chaotic,
resort isle of Ibiza in June 2012 that the twins were first unregulated industry. In 2014, they founded their own
introduced to Bitcoin by early adopters who, like the cryptocurrency exchange, Gemini.
Winklevii, were traditional-tech outsiders. The notion In the early days, Gemini was little more than a place
that money was the ultimate social network, and that to buy and sell Bitcoin, but today it offers trading and
Bitcoin was free from central-bank control and backed custody for 33 cryptocurrencies, including ether, a coin
by mathematical certainty, appealed to the highly disci- equipped with a native computer language that lets de-
plined athletes. velopers build applications without central servers; zcash,
After the brothers returned to New York, they began us- a privacy-protecting token based on Bitcoin; and mana,
ing their Facebook money to buy up Bitcoin. “We found the the native cryptocurrency of a virtual-reality world called
community super-welcoming,” says Tyler, who tends to be Decentraland. The twins also have their own ethereum-
the more analytical twin. (Cameron is the more creative.) based token called Gemini Dollar, which is pegged to the
In May 2013, they invested $1.5 million in a Brooklyn- value of the U.S. dollar and therefore stable.

A poster on the wall of their office from Gemini’s recent New York
subway marketing campaign depicts the Founding Fathers of the
United States with the words THE REVOLUTION NEEDS RULES.

based exchange called BitInstant, which charged people Among crypto exchanges (there are now more than
a fee to exchange dollars for Bitcoin in just minutes. The 300), Gemini became, in October 2015, one of the first
business grew rapidly—reportedly accounting for 30% of Bitcoin-focused financial institutions to be designated a
all Bitcoin purchases. Unfortunately, some of those pur- trust bank by the New York State Department of Finan-
chases were laundering money for drug dealers selling on cial Services. This meant it was subject to the same regu-
the dark-web drug bazaar Silk Road, and by the end of latory requirements as banks like State Street and North-
BEEPLE-COLLECT.COM (2)

the year the site was shuttered. Its computer-genius CEO, ern Trust and enabled it to take deposits in all 50 states.
Charlie Shrem, whom the Winklevii embraced, was ar- Though Gemini’s trading volume ($29 billion in the last
rested and spent a year in federal prison for running an 12 months) is much lower than that of giants like Binance
unlicensed operation. and Coinbase, it rivals them in industry “trust” scores,
Facing another brush with ignominy, the brothers de- which carry considerable weight in a market where ex-
cided that if they were going to succeed in this nascent changes are often hacked and fake trading volume is com-

FORBES.COM A P R I L / M AY 2 0 2 1
The Beeple Bubble Today, there are six crypto ETF applications pending at
NFTs by graphic designer Beeple from early 2020: the SEC from the likes of Wisdom Tree, Van Eck, Fidel-
“tom hanks beating the shit out of coronavirus” and
“SPONGEBOB HILLARYPANTS,” which sold for $107,000
ity, First Trust and Anthony Scaramucci’s Skybridge Fi-
and $55,000, respectively. In February 2021, one of his nancial. Gemini, which now offers customers a Bitcoin
NFT singles traded for $6.6 million. Warns Beeple, “This
is not some magical money fountain.” rewards credit card and a savings account that pays 7%
interest on crypto deposits, has an application pending
with the SEC to open an alternative marketplace for trad-
ing stocks and other securities issued on a blockchain.
“Gemini is the bridge where people can migrate away 101
from centralized finance, from their current bank, and
into this new world,” Cameron says. “Our business mod-

THE TREND
el is not based on information or monetizing privacy. It’s
based on marketplaces and trading fees.”

Among the twins’ growing collection of crypto-


focused startups, none is getting more buzz and showing
more potential than its NFT marketplace, auction plat-
form Nifty Gateway.
The company was founded in November 2018 by Dun-
can and Griffin Cock Foster, 26, also identical twins and
rowers, who say they took up the sport after watching The
Social Network in high school. Both had just graduated
from college in 2017—Duncan from Washington Univer-
sity in St. Louis with a degree in computer science and
Griffin from Emory in mathematics. During his senior
year, Duncan began dabbling in CryptoKitties, a digital
craze similar to the decades-ago mania for Beanie Babies,
only one in which users create, collect and trade unique
animated felines, registering each using a non-fungible
token on the ethereum blockchain.
“Everyone had the same complaint,” Duncan said in a
2019 interview. “Buying NFTs was too complicated. We
started Nifty Gateway to solve access issues, and we will
not rest until 1 billion people are collecting NFTs.”
At first the Cock Fosters designed Nifty Gateway not as
an NFT auction platform but simply as a way to buy NFTs
monplace. Given the current environment of nosebleed with Mastercards and Visas instead of going through
valuations like Coinbase’s $68 billion, Gemini could likely the arduous process of purchasing them with ether. In
fetch $5 billion if it ever needed outside funding. fact, the Winklevii first stumbled upon Nifty Gateway
While Facebook’s early corporate mantra was “move in July 2019 at the Contemporary and Digital Art Fair
fast and break things,” the Winklevii, who famously asked in New York. A work called “CryptoPunk 4530,” featur-
then–Harvard president Larry Summers to enforce the ing a woman with a mohawk smoking a cigarette, ren-
college’s “Standards of Conduct” against Zuckerberg, dered in the blocky style of an old-fashioned video game,
have always operated under an “ask permission first, not had caught Tyler’s eye. The image was one of 10,000 sim-
forgiveness later” ethos. A poster on the wall of their of- ilar but unique portraits created by Google veterans Matt
fice from Gemini’s recent New York subway marketing Hall and John Watkinson and initially given away free.
campaign depicts the Founding Fathers of the United The price was $5,000. Tyler used his phone to create an
States with the words THE REVOLUTION NEEDS RULES. account on Nifty Gateway, paying with his credit card.
Heavily promoting its operation as the “regulated” As soon as the Winklevii returned to their office, Gem-
crypto exchange, Gemini is positioning itself to profit ini’s vice president of engineering, Eric Winer, told them
when the Securities and Exchange Commission finally he had been keeping an eye on Nifty Gateway, which had
approves crypto exchange-traded funds, which have al- just emerged from Adam Draper’s BoostVC accelerator
ready been approved in Canada and overseas. Starting in boot camp. A month later, Gemini struck a deal to buy
2013, the Winklevii began applying to the SEC to launch the seven-month-old startup. The Cock Fosters moved
a Bitcoin ETF. So far they’ve been turned down twice, to an Airbnb in Brooklyn and worked with Gemini’s en-
the last time in 2018, with the SEC citing the immatu- gineers to build what is now the world’s most exclusive
rity of the industry. digital-art platform. While numerous digital platforms

A P R I L / M AY 2 0 2 1 FORBES.COM
102
THE TREND

Merchants of the Metaverse


operate more like eBay and are open to all creators, Nif-
“We very much saw ourselves in Duncan and Griffin [far right],”
ty Gateway selectively curates its artists and sells their says Tyler (second from right) of the Cock Foster twins. “These guys
works in “drops,” taking a page from fashion brands like had this passion, this conviction, and everyone around them was
saying they were crazy. That’s how we felt our whole life.”
Nike and Supreme.
The NFT art market has exploded. In February,
Nifty Gateway accounted for $75 million of the $91 mil- Last fall, Nifty Gateway began reaching out to artists,
lion in NFT art auctioned on the top seven online plat- trying to populate its new exclusive platform with in-
forms, according to data compiled by CryptoArt.io. As of teresting and valuable digital art. Given Beeple’s 1 mil-
late March, it had sold $132 million of the $188 million lion Instagram followers, he was an obvious choice. Af-
worth of such work bought by collectors. When the Cock ter educating Winkelmann about NFTs, engineers at Nif-
Fosters launched Nifty Gateway a year ago, monthly sales ty Gateway explained how he could program art to be dy-
were less than $100,000. namic, changing at different points in time, or based on
No NFT artist has gotten richer off the craze than Mike a given outcome. He was already touching on political
Winkelmann, a.k.a. Beeple_Crap, a 39-year-old father of themes in his “Everydays” and saw the 2020 election as
two in Charleston, South Carolina, who earned a com- his opportunity to make a mark.
puter science degree at Purdue and studied no art past If Trump were reelected, Beeple’s “Crossroad” NFT
high school. He uses 3D-graphics software to generate would transform into a naked, sweaty, muscular strong-
artwork that is outrageous and often revolting. One piece man walking menacingly through fire. If he lost, the NFT
depicts a naked Donald Trump eating a hamburger while would turn into a looping video of Trump lying face-
sitting atop a train wreck that’s being consumed by gi- down beneath a rainbow, with words like loser painted
ant coronavirus particles. Another shows Kim Jong-un on his naked body, as a bird styled after Twitter’s logo
dressed as Toy Story’s Buzz Lightyear with fake breasts. chirped away. On October 31, “Crossroad” became the
MICHAEL PRINCE FOR FORBES

As a hobby, Beeple created a digital image every day for hottest ticket on Nifty Gateway, selling for $66,666.66 to
more than ten years, posting his provocative “Everydays,” a 32-year-old Miami-based digital-asset speculator with
depicting dystopian visions of pop culture and politics, a Columbia MBA. The buyer put the work back up for sale
to social media sites like Facebook and Instagram. The on Nifty Gateway and sold it in February for $6.6 million,
work earned him a cult following on the internet, but he making a 90-fold profit. Beeple earned about $660,000
couldn’t monetize the digital medium, which was as easy due to the platform’s fee structure, which invites artists to
to copy as simply right-clicking a mouse. collect a 10% royalty on all aftermarket sales.

FORBES.COM A P R I L / M AY 2 0 2 1
PAID PROMOTION

RALLYING
YOUTH TO
MOVE DRC
FORWARD
Congolese pro-democracy activist and human rights ŶŽƚŚĞƌƉƌŽŵŝƐŝŶŐĂĚǀĂŶĐĞŝƐƚŚĞĐŽŵŵƵŶŝĐĂƟŽŶďĞƚǁĞĞŶ
defender Carbone Beni is working to engage more young Tshisekedi and Mike Hammer, U.S. Ambassador to the DRC.
people in shaping the political future of the Democratic dŚĞĂŵďĂƐƐĂĚŽƌŚĂƐĞdžƉƌĞƐƐĞĚƚŚĞhŶŝƚĞĚ^ƚĂƚĞƐŝŶƚĞƌĞƐƚ
Republic of Congo. in hearing directly from the Congolese, and in partnering to
ĂĚǀĂŶĐĞƉĞĂĐĞĂŶĚƉƌŽƐƉĞƌŝƚLJŝŶƚŚĞŶĂƟŽŶ/ƚŝƐŝŵƉĞƌĂƟǀĞ
/Ŷ&ĞďƌƵĂƌLJϮϬϮϭĞŶŝůĂƵŶĐŚĞĚǀŝĂǀŝĚĞŽĂƉůĂƞŽƌŵĐĂůůĞĚ for the Congo that this partnership with the U.S. is concrete
“Nothing as Before,” calling on Congolese youth to stand up ĂŶĚƉĂůƉĂďůĞƐŽƚŚĂƚŝƚƐŽŶŐŽůĞƐĞďĞŶĞĮĐŝĂƌŝĞƐǁŝůůĨĞĞůƚŚĞ
ĂŶĚǁŽƌŬƚŽŐĞƚŚĞƌĨŽƌƉŽƐŝƟǀĞĐŚĂŶŐĞƐŝŶƚŚĞZ ďĞŶĞĮƚƐ!ƐĂLJƐĞŶŝ

dŚĞĐŽĨŽƵŶĚĞƌŽĨƚŚĞ&ŝůŝŵďŝĐŝƟnjĞŶƐŵŽǀĞŵĞŶƚƐĂLJƐƚŚĂƚ /ŶƚĞƌĞƐƚƐŽĨWĞŽƉůĞŽŵĞ&ŝƌƐƚ
group and the Lucha youth movement were important in the
ϮϬϭĞůĞĐƟŽŶŽĨ&ĞůŝdždƐŚŝƐĞŬĞĚŝĂƐZƉƌĞƐŝĚĞŶƚEŽƚŚŝŶŐ Beni has long spoken out on behalf of whistleblowers. “It
as Before” seeks to focus their is important to protect those do
energy and momentum. a civic duty by denouncing any

“It will be our philosophical



ĨŽƵŶĚĂƟŽŶĂŶĚŽƵƌƐŽƵƌĐĞŽĨ Nothing as Before movement led
motivation and action,” says
ŚŝŶĚƌĂŶĐĞƚŽĐŽƵŶƚƌŝĞƐůĂǁƐĂŶĚ
rules,” he says. “They are an echo
of the call for good governance.”

Beni. “ We have the moral by activist Carbone Beni is working “Just as we encourage any good
responsibility to ensure that ŝŶŝƟĂƟǀĞĨŽƌƚŚĞŝŶƚĞƌĞƐƚŽĨŽŶŐŽ
what we have fought for is for positive social, political and and the Congolese, we condemn
done in the way we intended.” ŵĂŶŝƉƵůĂƟŽŶŽĨLJŽƵŶŐŽŶŐŽůĞƐĞ
economic change in the and conduct that does not respect
ĞŶŝϯϱƐƉĞŶƚƟŵĞĂƐĂƉŽůŝƟ- our laws,” Beni says. He was
cal prisoner during the term of Democratic Republic of Congo. among those leading the plea for
former DRC president Joseph ƐĂŶĐƟŽŶƐĂŐĂŝŶƐƚ/ƐƌĂĞůŝďŝůůŝŽŶĂŝƌĞ
Kabila. He is encouraged by
dƐŚŝƐĞŬĞĚŝƐůĞĂĚĞƌƐŚŝƉƐŽĨĂƌ
“ ĂŶ'ĞƌƚůĞƌĨŽƌĞdžƚĞŶƐŝǀĞĐŽƌƌƵƉ-
ƟŽŶŽǀĞƌŵŝŶŝŶŐĚĞĂůƐŝŶƚŚĞZ
“The President of the Republic is a born patriot who has “We had hoped to see Mr. Gertler begin to respect our
known the vagaries of the opposition,” says Beni. “We ĞdžƉĞĐƚĂƟŽŶƐŽĨƚƌĂŶƐƉĂƌĞŶĐLJĂŶĚŐŽŽĚŐŽǀĞƌŶĂŶĐĞǁŚĞŶ
ĨŽƵŐŚƚƚŽŐĞƚŚĞƌĨŽƌĂƟŵĞ! he was granted a license by the U.S. Department of State.
However, that license has since been revoked.”
WŽƐŝƟǀĞĞǀĞůŽƉŵĞŶƚƐ
EŽƚŚŝŶŐĂƐĞĨŽƌĞ!ƌĞŵŝŶĚƐĞǀĞƌLJŽŶĞƚŚĂƚƚŽĚĂLJƐŽŶŐŽ
ĞŶŝƐĞĞƐdƐŚŝƐĞŬĞĚŝƐƌĞĐĞŶƚƐĞƉĂƌĂƟŽŶĨƌŽŵƚŚĞ<ĂďŝůĂ wants to move forward, says Beni. “We are determined to
ĞƌĂ&,ĐŽĂůŝƟŽŶĂƐĂƉŽƐŝƟǀĞƐŝŐŶdŚĞWƌĞƐŝĚĞŶƚ put the interests of the Congo and the Congolese people
now has free rein to move forward. He is aware of the hope ĂďŽǀĞĂůůĞůƐĞƐŽƚŚĂƚƚŚŝŶŐƐĐŚĂŶŐĞŶLJŽŶĞǁŚŽŝƐŵŽƟ-
he has raised in Congolese hearts. He will not let anything ǀĂƚĞĚƚŽĚŽƚŚŝŶŐƐĚŝīĞƌĞŶƚůLJƚŚĂŶďĞĨŽƌĞǁŝůůďĞĐĂůůĞĚĂ
stand in the way of improving the well-being of his compa- ƚƌƵĞƉĂƚƌŝŽƚĂŶĚƚŚĞŽŶŐŽǁŝůůďĞďĞƩĞƌŽīĂƐĂƌĞƐƵůƚ!
ƚƌŝŽƚƐdŚĞŶĞdžƚƚŚƌĞĞLJĞĂƌƐǁŝůůďĞĚĞĐŝƐŝǀĞ!

1 Carbone Beni
Drops Beeple auctioned for $1 each now trade for linked into a decentralized cloud computer. Filecoin has
hundreds of thousands of dollars, earning him at least recently been on a tear: Its tokens have surged 350% so
$10,000 per transaction. His various NFTs sold for a to- far this year, and it has a market capitalization in excess
tal of $10 million on Nifty Gateway in the weeks before of $6 billion.
his $69 million sale on March 11. The Winklevii’s NFT In June, Protocol Labs is hosting a workshop to build
platform, which charges artists 15%, has been a life- decentralized versions of Amazon, Google and Facebook
changer for Winkelmann. It has also created a booming that instead of relying on revenue from advertising tar-
business for Nifty Gateway. geting their users’ personal information will reward them
“We’re doing $4 million in five minutes now,” says Cam- with filecoin tokens. One day filecoin-connected comput-
104 eron of drops that a year ago would have brought $50,000 ers could rival the cloud services of these tech giants.
on a good day. Adds Tyler: “Basically, the entire art world, Oasis Labs, based in San Francisco, is another prom-
the entire entertainment world, is knocking down the door.” ising Winklevii-owned startup. Run by a security and
THE TREND

artificial-intelligence professor at the University of Cali-


fornia at Berkeley, the company specializes in ultrasensi-
The gold rush in digital art and collectibles being tive data like human genome codes. The idea is that us-
minted and sold on Nifty Gateway and other NFT plat- ers will control their own data and be compensated for its
forms like NBA Top Shot won’t last forever. But just as use by corporations.
some dot-com-bubble companies like Amazon survived Winklevoss Capital portfolio member Stacks supports
and eventually thrived, the Winklevii are building Nifty multiple projects aimed squarely at challenging central-
Gateway and Gemini for the long run as a marketplace ized control by Big Tech. Boom is its decentralized wallet
and custodian for all manner of assets, including prop- for creating and sending NFTs; Pravica is a decentralized
erty deeds, passports, commodities, collectibles, video- communication platform that integrates email, chat and
game characters, movies, music and event tickets. video into a single place; Sigle is a decentralized version
“You want to pick that niche where there’s real market of WordPress for making websites.
uptake,” Cameron says. “You don’t want to boil the ocean.” “Within the next decade, you’re going to see social pro-
Ultimately, the twins see their two marketplaces, Gem- tocols take off and people building decentralized forms of
ini and Nifty Gateway, integrated into a single dashboard these services,” Tyler says.
where NFTs will be used as collateral for loans, enabling The twins’ most recent investment, Artie, builds video
owners to tap their digital assets for funding without hav- games that don’t need to be downloaded and in-game digi-
ing to sell them. Tyler and Cameron also envision a future tal assets that can be exported, traded on open markets and
in which the due diligence they perform to verify a user’s even imported into competing games. Artie’s “app-less”
identity could be issued as an NFT, letting users prove games use assets issued on the ethereum blockchain and

“We’re doing $4 million in five minutes now,” says Cameron of drops that a
year ago would bring $50,000 on a good day. “Basically the entire art world,
the entire entertainment world, is knocking down the door,” Tyler adds.

they’ve passed strict requirements—think Facebook, but can stream from anywhere, similar to how YouTube embed
with irrefutable identity confirmation. codes allow its videos to be played on any website.
“It’s almost like compliance as a service could be baked Billionaire Zynga founder and CEO Mark Pincus is
into an NFT token that Gemini issued,” Tyler says. among the investors in Artie, as is YouTube cofounder
Another major area of investment for the Winklevii is Chad Hurley. “We’re seeing that consumers want to break
blockchain-based applications that support decentraliza- down these walled gardens,” says Artie cofounder Ar-
tion—the idea that tech companies like Google, Facebook mando Kirwin. “They want more choices, they don’t want
and Microsoft will no longer be necessary because web monopolies, they want a return to the free and open web.
services and applications will be created, operated and And that’s the last sanctuary that we have.”
governed by users. Of course, the irony of any serious effort to build a de-
Back in 2014, Winklevoss Capital joined forces with centralized metaverse is that its chief architects will ulti-
San Francisco’s open-source developer Protocol Labs, mately become unnecessary. Tyler and Cameron Wink-
investing in a seed round to finance various projects levoss seem unconcerned. Goldman Sachs recently pre-
that would create a new internet infrastructure that dicted that the price of Bitcoin could easily climb to
doesn’t rely on centralized servers. One of its efforts, $300,000 in the next five years.
Filecoin, is intended to power a network for computer “Decentralization is a spectrum,” says Cameron, look-
storage in which users around the world rent out their ing out his window toward New York’s Chrysler Building.
unused hard-drive space and in return receive ethereum “Our goal was not to be the gatekeepers.”
blockchain–based tokens called filecoins as payment. It’s still early days in the blockchain revolution. Mark
There are already 250,000 such computers, or “nodes,” Zuckerberg, take note.

FORBES.COM A P R I L / M AY 2 0 2 1
107

THE PROFILE David Vélez SE T O U T TO K I L L O F F TH E FAT F E ES A N D


LO U SY S E RVI C E O F B RA Z I L’S BI G BAN KS. T H E OP E R ATI ON
SU CC E E DE D B E YO N D H IS W IL D EST D R EA M S:
TO DAY, HI S NO -F EE Nubank IS THE MOST
VA LUABLE DIGITAL BANK IN THE WORLD, WITH 35 MILLION
C U STO ME R S—A N D H E’ S G U N N I N G FOR M O R E.

Assassin BY J E F F K AU F L I N , M A R I A A B R E U A N D A N T O I N E G A R A
P H OTO G R A P H Y BY G A B R I E L R I N A L D I F O R F O R B E S
they were. Less than a decade after its found-
ing, Vélez’s São Paulo–based Nubank has 35 mil-
lion customers and is valued at $25 billion. Vé-
lez, who is Nubank’s CEO, retains a 23% stake
that Forbes values at $5.2 billion. “What’s hap-
pening in Brazil is nothing short of a real revo-
lution. And it’s waking up the incumbent banks,
108

In
who have had the going really easy for a long
time,” says Nigel Morris, the cofounder of Capi- Rebel Leader
tal One and a Nubank investor. “If banks are
THE PROFILE

“David is going to build a $100 billion–plus fi- Darth Vader,


credit cards
nancial powerhouse in Latin America,” predicts are the Death
Star,” says
TCV partner Woody Marshall, another one of Cristina
the investors who have poured a total of $1.2 bil- Junqueria,
Nubank’s
lion into Nubank. Among the billionaire-backed cofounder.
firms betting on Vélez: Yuri Milner’s DST Glob- “They’re
the horrible
al, Peter Thiel’s Founders Fund, Chase Coleman’s weapon the
Tiger Global—and yes, Leone and Sequoia. banks used.”

Equally impressive, Vélez built his fintech jug-


gernaut while previously booming Brazil suf-
fered through recession, corruption scandals and
Covid-19. And he did so despite warnings from
Brazilians that the banking establishment would
block him—or worse. “ ‘They’re going to kill you,’ ”
Vélez says one friend told him. “ ‘They’re going to
kidnap your kids.’ ”

the summer of 2012, David Vélez moved to São

G
Paulo with a newly minted Stanford MBA and rowing up, Vélez saw how entre-
a plum job as a Sequoia Capital partner. Doug- preneurs persevere through adver-
las Leone, the head of Sequoia, had recruited the sity. Born in Colombia in 1981 into
then-30-year-old Colombian to stake the venture a family of small-businessfolk (his
capital powerhouse’s claim in Brazil—a youth- father’s 11 siblings are mostly en-
ful, resource-rich country of 200 million that had trepreneurs), he watched as his hometown of Me-
grown 4% a year for a decade to become the world’s dellín was ravaged by drug wars. He remembers
seventh-largest economy. But on October 1, leaving a shopping center with his family min-
Leone called Vélez with bad news: After consider- utes before it was bombed. After an uncle was kid-
ing the uninspired pitches from Brazilian entre- napped and rescued, the then-9-year-old Vélez,
preneurs and hearing that top-ranked University his parents and his two sisters (both now also en-
of São Paulo had produced just 42 computer sci- trepreneurs) moved to Costa Rica. There, Vélez’s
ence graduates the prior year, he was pulling the dad, who had co-owned a small button factory
plug. Sequoia’s Brazilian adventure was over. with two brothers in Colombia, built a new one.
“It was the day before my birthday and it was a bit Vélez attended a local German-language prep
of a shock,” Vélez admits. Still, he had always want- school, graduating as valedictorian and winning
ed to launch his own startup and saw opportunity admission to Stanford, where he majored in engi-
in the very dearth of Brazilian innovators that had neering and yearned to join Silicon Valley’s start-
turned his VC compatriots off. “You want to posi- up frenzy. But while Google had been birthed
tion yourself on the side of the market where there’s in Stanford’s dorms, as an undergraduate Vélez
scarcity,” Vélez explains. “In the U.S., there’s an couldn’t come up with his own big idea. So he
oversupply of good entrepreneurs. Somebody with played it safe after graduation, taking an invest-
my experience and background is a commodity. ment banking job at Morgan Stanley. Two years
In Latin America, there was significant scarcity.” later, he joined private equity firm General At-
Before long, he had a target: Brazil’s big and— lantic to build up its investments in Latin Amer-
to hear Brazilians tell it—bulletproof banks. Yet ica. In 2010 he returned to Stanford for his MBA
as Vélez saw it, the banks, with their notoriously and, he hoped, to develop the concept for his own
high fees, poor service and seeming oblivious- startup and the killer instincts to execute it. But
ness to new technology, were sitting ducks. And while still a student, he was recruited by Leone

FORBES.COM A P R I L / M AY 2 0 2 1
Brazilian banks, with their notoriously high fees, poor service
and seeming obliviousness to how technology was
quickly changing consumers’ expectations, were sitting ducks.

109
to develop Sequoia’s Latin American
business. When that opportunity evap-

THE PROFILE
orated, Vélez retreated to his parents’
Costa Rican home to plot his assault.
Vélez is an unlikely assassin. He’s an
even-keeled manager who, before the
pandemic, began meetings with a min-
ute for meditation. In his spare time, he
reads fiction. His favorite novel is Gabri-
el García Márquez’s One Hundred Years
of Solitude. But he’s also a fan of Ayn
Rand’s Atlas Shrugged, and he learned
in his VC and Stanford days that an en-
trepreneur can hit it big by using tech-
nology to take out fat, complacent in-
cumbents. “What’s the biggest industry
in Brazil? Banking. And what’s the most
profitable? Banking,” he says.
Back then, five banks—Itaú, Brades-
co, Santander, Banco do Brasil and
Caixa—controlled 80% of the Brazil-
ian market, earning massive profits
by lending at high interest rates and
charging exorbitant fees while provid-
ing lousy customer service. “ ‘Brazilian
banks suck. It has always been like this
and will always be like this,’ ” Vélez says
one Brazilian friend told him.
But in the early 2010s Vélez saw
broadband internet and smartphones
spread quickly across the enormous
country. “You had these gigantic op-
portunities [to disrupt] industries like
banking that no one was really looking
at because nobody thought it was pos-
sible.” He adds: “Nubank could nev-
er have been started by a local. . . . It
required a Silicon Valley investor who
has seen this story of the tiny ant go-
ing against the elephant and succeed-
ing. A Latin American investor sees
that and says, ‘No way, the elephant is
going to crush you.’ ”
Vélez spent months chatting up Bra-
zilian bank insiders and studying digi-
tal bank upstarts like Capital One in
the U.S. and ING Direct in Europe.

A P R I L / M AY 2 0 2 1 FORBES.COM
He began to chart his course. Nubank would vious: Nubank charged no annual fee and han-
start with credit cards and then expand to oth- dled applications entirely through its app. Those
er services, using technology to undercut the big who qualified were notified within minutes, and
banks’ fees and beat them on convenience. He re- the eye-catching purple credit cards arrived as
turned to Sequoia’s Menlo Park, California, offi- soon as two days later. Plus, everything—from
ces, securing $1 million from his mentor Leone credit-line increase requests to bill paying and
and his former VC partners. Argentine venture fraud reports—could be done through the app.
110 firm Kaszek pitched in another $1 million. By contrast, almost all Brazilian banks charged
Sequoia partner Roelof Botha told Vélez that annual fees for even basic credit cards—$20 the
he needed a cofounder with banking experience. lowest. And that was just the start; the banks also
THE PROFILE

Through an acquaintance, Vélez met and re- charged monthly fees for everything from fraud
cruited Cristina Junqueira, a 30-year-old Brazil- protection to text-message alerts. In 2019, fees
ian engineer with an MBA from Northwestern’s made up nearly 40% of Brazilian banks’ revenue,
Kellogg, who had just quit her job running Itaú’s compared with 15% to 20% for banks in Mexi-
largest credit card division. To build Nubank’s co, Argentina, Peru and Chile, according to a JP-
technology, he recruited as the third cofounder Morgan analysis. The big banks are still resisting,
an American he knew from his Sequoia days, Ed- but Nubank is putting those fat fees under tre-
ward Wible, a 30-year-old Princeton computer mendous pressure.
science graduate.
The trio set up shop in a rented São Pau-

B
lo house, with Wible living upstairs. In August “ razil is the country of the future and
2014, they raised $15 million in Series A fund- always will be,’’ the old saw goes.
ing led by Sequoia, with Nigel Morris buying in That captures both the boom-
through his specialty fintech VC firm, QED. To and-bust nature of its resource-
close the deal, Vélez took papers to the hospital based economy and a sense that
for Junqueira’s signature—while she was in labor its vast potential has repeatedly been squan-
with her first child. dered. “The fact that everybody sees the macro-
The next month, Nubank rolled out its first economic picture and 99% of people get scared
product: a credit card. Nubank couldn’t start with means it’s an opportunity for us to play the con-
bank accounts because it faced a high hurdle to trarian,” Vélez says. “We think that over a period
getting a bank charter—a Brazilian constitutional of ten or 20 or 30 years, Brazil will find its way.”
provision barring foreign bank ownership. But it At the end of 2014, Brazil slipped into a deep
didn’t need a banking license to offer credit cards. recession. Yet just 12 months later, more than
Plus, Brazilian credit cards had sky-high interest a million people had applied for a spot on the
rates, then running 200% to 400% a year, mean- Nubank card’s waiting list. To protect itself from
ing customers would either have to pay off their losses, Nubank approved only 20% of appli-
cards in full each month or pay Nubank a small cants and gave some ultralow spending limits
fortune. While Vélez aimed to make money pri- of $14, raising that only if payments were time-
marily from interchange fees—the 5% of credit ly. And Nubank continuously tested new ways to
card sales merchants kick back to issuers and the use data to gauge risk—for example, considering
banks—he wasn’t going to be shy about penaliz- not only an applicant’s own credit history, but the
ing late payers with interest and fees. payment record of the referring customer.
Rather than burn scarce cash on marketing, In 2016, Nubank hit 1 million accepted credit
Nubank used the “velvet rope” strategy common card customers—almost entirely through word
in Silicon Valley—at the start you had to be invit- of mouth and referrals—and Vélez was ready
ed by a friend to apply for its credit card. Faux ex- to step on the gas. That December, he closed
clusivity aside, the appeal for Brazilians was ob- an $80 million funding round led by Yuri Mil-

“Nubank required a Silicon Valley investor who has seen


this story of the tiny ant going against the
elephant and succeeding. A Latin American investor sees that
and says, ‘No way, the elephant is going to crush you.’ ”

FORBES.COM A P R I L / M AY 2 0 2 1
We got this.
SPECIAL
34TH ANNUAL WORLD’S BILLIONAIRES LIST ISSUE INSIDE ZOOM, THE APP CONNECTING AMERICA

MIDAS LIST: TOP 100 VENTURE CAPITALISTS TRUMP’S FORTUNE TAKES A COVID-19 HIT

The Oracle
L A R RY E L L I S O N

“I WILL BUILD A
SYSTEM SO

SAVING
DOCTORS AND
PATIENTS

AGENTS
CAN KNOW WHAT’S
HAPPENING.”

THE SEAFOOD
Aq ua-Sp ark
C ofoun de r
THE Movie Mogul
T Y L E R P E R RY

ULTIMATE
AMY
N OVO G R AT Z

INDUSTRY
“I HAD NO MENTORS.

OF CHANGE
“I DON’T KNOW I DIDN’T GO TO
BUSINESS SCHOOL.

ONE-MAN SHOW
WHY WE LIVE
EVERYTHING

FROM ITSELF
IN A WORLD THAT
IS SO OPPOSED I’VE LEARNED,
TO CHANGE.” I’VE LEARNED IN
AS THE CORONAVIRUS UPENDS THE ECONOMY,
HEALTH-CARE SYSTEMS AND GLOBAL ORDER, SHUT OUT OF ENTERTAINMENT’S MAINSTREAM,
PROGRESS.”
ENTREPRENEURS MUST REINVENT THEMSELVES, THE IMPACT 50: HOW ONE WELL-CONNECTED INVESTOR THE NEW BILLIONAIRE WROTE, PRODUCED AND STARRED
THEIR INDUSTRIES—AND THE WORLD AT LARGE IS CASHING IN BIG WHILE DOING OCEANS OF GOOD. IN HIS OWN AMERICAN SUCCESS STORY.

TOMORROW’S SUCCESS BEGINS WITH A COMMITMENT TO TODAY

More than ever, leaders are emerging with smart solutions for the trickiest problems facing
our society. From vertical farming’s disruption of agriculture to artificial intelligence’s
transformation of our daily lives to socially conscious investing, philanthropic gifting, and
innovative startup solutions, the world is transforming into one where success is measured
by more than numbers on a balance sheet. And Forbes is committed to covering it.

With rich reporting, insightful analysis, and spotlights on the disruptors changing the world
as we know it, Forbes goes beyond the headlines to provide the most authoritative, reliable,
and thought-provoking journalism possible. Here’s how:

• The iconic Forbes 400 list, ranking the wealthiest Americans in 2020, now includes
a Philanthropy Score, counting “out the door” gifts (rather than money put into
billionaire’s foundations).  

• Award-winning reporting on the thought leaders, entrepreneurs, and businesses


shaping our economy, our lifestyles, and our futures.

• Deep coverage of the most consequential technology, money and leadership stories.

Discover the stories today that will impact all of us tomorrow. And find out how you can
be the agent of change you’ve always wanted to be.

SUBSCRIBE OR GIVE A GIFT TODAY.

If you’re already part of the Forbes community of readers, consider giving a Forbes magazine
subscription as a gift. It’s a timely and thought-provoking present that will be appreciated all
year long. If you’re not a subscriber to Forbes, we invite you to join us.

TOGETHER, WE ARE A COMMUNITY OF DETERMINED, RESOURCEFUL INDIVIDUALS


READY TO FACE WHATEVER COMES NEXT.

TO GIVE: TO SUBSCRIBE:

Forbes.com/GiveAGift Forbes.com/SubscribeNow
accounts were free, save for a passed-along $1.20
charge to use other banks’ ATMs. Within five
months, 1.5 million of Nubank’s 4 million cred-
it card customers had signed up.
Nubank was growing fast—it booked $523
million in revenue, with a $78 million loss, in
2019—when the pandemic hit. Then it started
112 growing faster. Like other fintechs serving con-
sumers, it benefited mightily from lockdowns
and fear, as even older Brazilians took to bank-
THE PROFILE

ing via mobile phones and the web. In 2020,


Nubank’s revenue nearly doubled, to $963 mil-
lion, while losses narrowed to $44 million.
Not surprisingly, copycat digital banks are crop-
ping up in Brazil, and the old-line banks are in-
vesting more heavily in technology. Some are even
launching their own digital-only services. In re-
sponse, Vélez is piling on new features. Last year,
Nubank acquired a pioneering digital investing
platform and rolled out a life insurance product,
selling 100,000 policies in the first two months.
Such diversification is a holy grail for digi-
tal banks, but few have done it so successful-
ly. “Nubank is the exception that proves the
rule,” says QED’s Morris. Customer satisfac-
tion remains strong. In a recent JPMorgan sur-
vey, Nubank’s net promoter score (a measure of
satisfaction) was 86, compared with 53 for Itaú
and 43 for Bradesco. “With Nubank, they show
you what you can do, you press a button and it
works,” says Bruno Alves, a 28-year-old customer
from Salvador, a city in northeastern Brazil.
Nubank expanded to Argentina and Mexico in
2019, and into Vélez’s native Colombia last year.
While most meetings are conducted in English to
accommodate its international staff, Vélez has no
plans to compete north of the border.
Vélez met his wife, Mariel Reyes Milk, in 2013
at a gathering for international business types in
a São Paulo bar. They are a global-village pow-
er couple: She has an American mother and Pe-
ruvian father and has lived in Uruguay, the U.S.
Trifecta ner’s VC firm. To put the sheer size of that in and the Philippines while working for the World
“Nubank was able to context, by PitchBook’s count, the rest of Brazil- Bank. Their three young children hold Brazilian
be in the right place ian startups combined raised just $340 million citizenship; Vélez himself is a citizen of both Co-
at the right time with
the right strategy,” in venture capital that year. Vélez used his por- lombia and Costa Rica. “My wife and I usually
says cofounder say that we have no nation, no roots,” he joked
and CTO Edward
tion of the stash to hire hundreds of tech work-
Wible. “All banks are ers, opening an office in Germany to get access to a Brazilian magazine in 2019. “We have lived
becoming software
companies.” to additional talent. in so many places and are considered gringos in
Finally, in May 2017, after a presidential de- all of them.”
cree gave it an exemption from foreign owner- So while Vélez doesn’t plan to set up shop in the
ship rules, Nubank received a Brazilian banking United States, he’s considering taking Nubank
license. Now it could offer its checking and sav- public there, mostly as “a marketing event.” But
ings accounts—all digital, naturally. While estab- he’s in no rush. “We’re in the first second of the
lished banks were then charging as much as $10 first minute of the first half of the soccer game,”
a month per account—with extra fees for ATM the congenial assassin says. “You always have to
withdrawals and other basic services—Nubank’s use a soccer analogy in Latin America.”

FORBES.COM See more members of the Covid fintech billionaire class (page 114). °
In Schools
and Now Beyond
Across America, schools are closed. Millions of students are facing challenges that threaten to stand in
the way of their success in school and life. At Communities In Schools, we go wherever we’re needed and
do whatever it takes to connect vulnerable students to the support they need in the classroom and beyond.
While schools are closed, we’re working in and across communities to bring resources like meals, household
supplies, and educational materials to the kids that need them most.

See how you can help students impacted by school closures: CISnational.org/COVID19

© 2020 Communities In Schools, Inc.


F I N T EC H
FRENZY
NUBANK FOUNDER
DAVID VÉLEZ IS ONE OF
MORE THAN A DOZEN
114 COVID FINTECH BILLIONAIRES,
THANKS TO PANDEMIC-DRIVEN
CHANGES IN THE WAY
PEOPLE SAVE, INVEST AND
THE PROFILE

PAY. HERE ARE EIGHT


NOTABLE NEWCOMERS.

VICTOR JACOBSSON
Klarna • $2.7 billion

SEBASTIAN SIEMIATKOWSKI
Klarna • $2.2 billion
Swedes Jacobsson and Siemiatkowski
cofounded Stockholm-based Klarna in
2005, pioneering the buy-now, pay-later
fintech model that lets consumers easily
use small installment loans, instead of
credit cards, to finance purchases. The
pandemic pushed privately held Klarna
to a $31 billion valuation in March,
tripling its value from six months prior.
CEO Siemiatkowski owns an 8% stake;
cofounder Jacobsson owns 10%, although
he’s no longer involved.

MAX LEVCHIN
Affirm • $2.2 billion Afterpay’s Nick Molnar

In 1999, eight years after immigrating


to the United States from Ukraine, Levchin
cofounded PayPal. He later launched
CHRIS BRITT
Chime • $1.3 billion
a media-sharing startup and fertility-
tracking app, but he didn’t reach After stints at Visa and prepaid-card is-
billionaire status until Affirm, his pay-later suer Green Dot, Britt cofounded Chime as FORBES (ISSN 0015 6914) is published six times a year
in February, April (double issue), June, August, October
fintech, took off thanks to Covid and a no-fee digital bank catering to middle- and December (double issue) by Forbes Media LLC,
Affirm’s financing of Peloton bikes, a income U.S. customers. The pandemic has 499 Washington Blvd, Jersey City, NJ 07310. Periodicals
postage paid at Newark, NJ 07102 and at additional
pandemic must-have. When it went pushed its valuation to $14.5 billion. mailing offices. Canadian Agreement No. 40036469.
public in January, its stock doubled Return undeliverable Canadian addresses to APC Postal

VLAD TENEV
on the first day of trading, propelling Logistics, LLC, 140 E. Union Ave, East Rutherford, NJ
07073. Canada GST# 12576 9513 RT. POSTMASTER: Send
its value north of $20 billion. address changes to Forbes Subscriber Service, P.O. Box
Robinhood • $1 billion 5471, Harlan, IA 51593-0971.

NICK MOLNAR BAIJU BHATT CONTACT INFORMATION


For Subscriptions: Visit www.forbesmagazine.com; call
Afterpay • $1.8 billion Robinhood • $1 billion 1-515-284-0693; or write Forbes Subscriber Service, P.O.
Box 5471, Harlan, IA 51593-0971. Prices: U.S.A., one year

ANTHONY EISEN When stock markets cratered at the start


of the Covid crisis, investing app Robin-
$34.99; Canada, one year C$52.99 (includes GST). We
may make portions of our mailing list available to repu-
Afterpay • $1.8 billion table firms. If you prefer that we not include your name,
hood suffered debilitating outages, leav- please write Forbes Subscriber Service (address above).
In 2014, then-24-year-old Molnar (above ing customers unable to trade on several For Back Issues: Visit www.forbesmagazine.com; email
getbackissues@forbes.com; or call 1-212-367-4141. For
right) was living with his parents in Syd- volatile days. But the brokerage thrived Article Reprints or Permission to use Forbes content
ney, Australia, selling jewelry on eBay, later in 2020 as millions of novice traders including text, photos, illustrations, logos and video: Visit
www.forbesreprints.com; call PARS International at 1-212-
when he joined his neighbor, former plowed their stimulus checks into stocks 221-9595; visit http://www. forbes.com/reprints; or email
investment banker Anthony Eisen, to and crypto. Robinhood was at the center permissions@forbes.com. Permission to copy or republish
articles can also be obtained through the Copyright
launch Afterpay. Today they’re co-CEOs of the GameStop fiasco of January and Clearance Center at www.copyright.com. Use of Forbes
of the publicly traded pay-later company February as margin calls depleted its cash content without the express permission of Forbes or the
copyright owner is expressly prohibited.
AFTERPAY

that’s worth some $22 billion. Afterpay and forced a $3.4 billion capital raise. Now
Copyright © 2021 Forbes Media LLC. All rights reserved.
has more than 16 million customers in both billionaires are looking to tap into Title is protected through a trademark registered with the
the United States. the roaring stock market they helped fuel. U.S. Patent & Trademark Office. Printed in the U.S.A.

FORBES.COM A P R I L / M AY 2 0 2 1
THOUGHTS ON

Ownership
116

“Freedom begins the moment “You can have it all, but don’t
you realize someone else expect to have it at exactly the
has been writing your story same time.”
and it’s time you took the pen —Jane Fraser
from his hand and started
writing it yourself.”
“The stupid mind thinks only in
—Bill Moyers
terms of possession. The man
of insight thinks of utility.”
“Ownership is the only way to —Osho
influence decisions—the right
decisions.”
“To have so little, and it of so little
—Geeta Gupta Fisker
value, is to be quaintly free.”
—Wallace Stegner
“That’s what makes [the land]
ours: being born on it, working
“Once you have something—
on it, dying on it. That makes
knowledge, skills, possessions—
ownership, not a paper with
or have achieved something—
numbers on it.”
climbing Mount Everest, for
—John Steinbeck
example—it becomes banal.”
—Reinhold Messner
“We own what belongs to us
whether we claim it or not.”
“I felt lonely, and in full
—Sarah M. Broom
possession of my loneliness.
It was the first time I had
“When you own your story, you owned anything of value.”
get to write the ending.”
—Brené Brown King of Broadway —Ben Greenman

February 1, 1972 “Whatever is best for a human


“What you really value in life is being lies outside human
ownership, not money. If ever Fiddler on the Roof debuted in September 1964, and control. It can be neither given
there is a choice—more money over the next eight years proved a bona-fide blockbuster. nor taken away.”
or more responsibility—you It cost only $375,000 ($3.2 million in current dollars) —Seneca
must always opt for the latter.”
to stage and took in close to $60 million (nearly $450
—50 Cent
million today) at the box office. That performance made “Wealth and honor come from
it the second-most-profitable musical ever at that point, you; you are the ruler of all
“Our business in every things. In your hands are
generation is to reclaim a little behind only My Fair Lady. “I didn’t see how it could strength and power to exalt
more land, to add something fail,” said Hal Prince, Fiddler’s producer. “There are at and give strength to all.”
to the extent and solidity of least 3 million Jews in New York, and I thought that —1 Chronicles 29:12
our possessions.” should be enough to keep the show running.” Prince,
—Thomas Henry Huxley
who was the driving force behind such hits as West Side
Story and Cabaret, had his share of flops too, including
“You own your own body, and
Baker Street, a Sherlock Holmes musical that premiered
with it your own voice—and
that’s the most revolutionary in 1965. But he needn’t have worried too much about
insight of all.” his investors. “Show business offers psychic returns
—Erica Jong no oil well can match,” as Forbes put it, “and for many
investors it may almost be enough to be able to say,
“By what right can anyone ‘Oh yes, I own a piece of that show.’ ”
whatever appropriate the
least morsel of this immense SOURCES: PREDICTABLY IRRATIONAL, BY DAN ARIELY; THE GRAPES OF WRATH, BY JOHN
FINAL THOUGHT
whole and say, ‘ This is mine, STEINBECK; THE YELLOW HOUSE, BY SARAH M. BROOM; THE 50TH LAW, BY 50 CENT; “If you have it, you make it.”
THE CONQUEST OF BREAD, BY PYOTR KROTOPKIN; INTUITION, BY OSHO; ALL THE LITTLE —Malcolm Forbes
not yours’?” LIVE THINGS, BY WALLACE STEGNER; MY LIFE AT THE LIMIT, BY REINHOLD MESSNER;
—Pyotr Kropotkin WHAT HE’S POISED TO DO, BY BEN GREENMAN; ON THE SHORTNESS OF LIFE, BY SENECA.

FORBES.COM A P R I L / M AY 2 0 2 1
You Can
Help
Turn Things
Around

You might think ending extinction


means going to the ends of the Earth.
But sometimes, saving the world is as
easy as showing up. Your support is
vital to the San Diego Zoo’s mission of
protecting animals all over the world.
Join us in making a difference—together,
we can be heroes for wildlife.
ENDextinction.org

San Diego Zoo Global is involved in


conservation projects in more than 70
countries, including for gelada monkeys,
African penguins, and lemurs, species
you can see in the San Diego Zoo’s
Conrad Prebys Africa Rocks.

;*/*0

You might also like