Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Clinical Research
Incidental findings are observations discovered has released a white paper in managing incidental
while conducting a test or procedure unrelated to the findings on the abdominal computed tomography
clinical indication or the primary aim of that particular (CT).¹ Many factors have contributed to the increased
test,¹⁻⁴ and may have a potential clinical relevance.⁵ frequency of detecting incidental findings in medical
The management of incidental findings is still under imaging, such as the increased use of medical imaging,
debate, and the American College of Radiology advancement in radiological viewing technology,
Copyright @ 2021 Author. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License (http://
creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/), which permits unrestricted non-commercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and
source are properly cited. For commercial use of this work, please see our terms at https://mji.ui.ac.id/journal/index.php/mji/copyright.
mji.ui.ac.id
Medical Journal of Indonesia
Rashid, et al. | Incidental finding in lumbar spine MRI 257
median was 46 years old. Of all patients enrolled, 11.7% Simple renal cyst 51 (65.4)
and 10.0% were aged <30 and ≥70 years, respectively. Hydronephrosis 6 (7.7)
Females constituted 55.7% of the patients. The basic Prostate abnormality 5 (6.4)
characteristics of the subjects are shown in Table 1. Simple renal cyst & urinary bladder
diverticulum or irregularity of the bladder wall 4 (5.1)
The prevalence of extraspinal incidental findings
& prostate abnormality
was 32.1% (135 cases out of 420). The detailed
Urinary bladder diverticulum or irregularity of
distribution of each specific extraspinal incidental 3 (3.8)
the bladder wall
findings, either benign or suspicious, based on its Masses (renal, supra-renal, or bladder) 3 (3.8)
body system or organ of origin is presented in Table Absent one kidney, unilateral or bilateral small
2 (2.6)
2. Around one quarter (24.5%) of the patients had kidney
benign findings (in any body system), and 7.6% had Horseshoe kidney 1 (1.3)
suspicious or significant findings. The proportion of Simple renal cyst & urinary bladder
1 (1.3)
females with benign findings (30.8%) was significantly diverticulum or irregularity of the bladder wall
higher than males (16.7%, p = 0.002) as presented in Simple renal cyst & prostate abnormality 1 (1.3)
Table 3. Urinary bladder diverticulum or irregularity of
1 (1.3)
Urinary tract had the most common incidental the bladder wall & prostate abnormality
findings and the highest percentage of benign and Genital tract (n = 51)
suspicious findings among other systems (Table 2 and Uterine fibroid 18 (35.2)
3). The female genital tract was the next system to Nabothian cyst 10 (19.6)
show the highest prevalence of incidental findings, as Adenomyosis 7 (13.7)
seen in Table 2. Benign findings were found in 19.2% of Simple ovarian cyst 4 (7.8)
the females, while only 2.6% had suspicious findings Suspicious endometrial lesion 2 (3.9)
(Table 3). Figure 1 shows the MR images of urinary tract Absent uterus 1 (2.0)
findings (Figure 1a) and female genital tract findings Hydrosalpinx 1 (2.0)
(Figure 1b), which were incidentally discovered during Uterine fibroid & nabothian cyst 2 (3.9)
lumbosacral spine MRI evaluation for suspected disc Uterine fibroid & complex ovarian lesion 1 (2.0)
disease. Uterine fibroid & post-partum changes 1 (2.0)
Table 3 shows that extraspinal incidental findings Adenomyosis & simple ovarian cyst 1 (2.0)
in any body system were rarely found in the younger Nabothian & simple ovarian cysts 1 (2.0)
Nabothian cyst & complex ovarian lesion 2 (3.9)
mji.ui.ac.id
Rashid, et al. | Incidental finding in lumbar spine MRI 259
age group, with p<0.001. Similarly, incidental findings in lower prevalence than our study, which is likely
the lymphovascular system were commonly detected related to the lower mean age of their study sample.
in the older age group, especially in the ≥60 years old Meanwhile, a higher prevalence of incidental
group (p = 0.001). findings found by Lee et al⁸ was caused by the use
Benign extraspinal incidental findings were of CT scans that has a high sensitivity for urinary
detected in 37.3% of patients aged ≥60 years, and stone detection. The high prevalence of extraspinal
significant extraspinal incidental findings were seen in incidental findings should raise the awareness among
10.0% of the cases; meanwhile, other age groups had radiologists and clinicians to carefully assess the
significantly lower percentages (p<0.001). In contrast, extraspinal structures while evaluating lumbosacral
the 40–59 years old group had the highest genital tract spinal MRI to minimize missing findings and all its
incidental findings (p = 0.005). clinical consequences.
The axial plane was the most common plane Considering the clinical potential of the
to detect the lymphovascular incidental findings extraspinal incidental findings, we observed that 7.6%
regardless of its significance (p = 0.037) (Table 4). In of the examined patients had clinically significant
the urinary system, the axial plane detected 87.7% of findings, which constituted 23.7% of all the detected
the benign findings and 38.1% of the clinically suspicious incidental findings. Although this result is similar to
findings (p<0.001). No significant association was Ibrahim et al,¹¹ Maxwell et al⁹ found higher clinically
detected between the MRI plane and genital tract significant findings due to different samples’ age
findings (p = 0.186). The other findings are presented (older than this study), the use of wider MRI FOV,
in Table 4. and additional use of the coronal plane in the spine
protocol. Early detection of the clinically significant
lesion could reduce morbidity and mortality.
DISCUSSION
We have observed a statistically significant
The prevalence of extraspinal incidental findings association between extraspinal incidental findings
in this study was 32.1%, which is close to the result and age. The younger age groups had fewer
of Maxwell et al.9 However, our result was higher extraspinal incidental findings compared with the
than Tuncel et al10 who found a low prevalence of higher age groups. The association between age and
extraspinal incidental findings due to the exclusion extraspinal incidental findings is in line with some
of cases with renal cysts, ovarian cysts, and fibroids previous studies.12⁻14 However, we found different
measuring 1–1.5 cm size. Ibrahim et al11 also reported results between age groups for the most incidental
mji.ui.ac.id
Rashid, et al. | Incidental finding in lumbar spine MRI 261
findings. The three previous studies showed that and address potential problems to the other kidney,
most extraspinal incidental findings were found in especially when observed early.7,17
patients aged <60 years. In contrast, we found only Other significant findings in the urinary system in
15.4% of patients aged <40 years had extraspinal our study were few cases with either renal, adrenal
incidental findings. This difference is caused by more or bladder masses, unilateral small or absent kidney,
than 25% of our subjects were aged >60. Meanwhile, and horseshoe kidney. This result is in line with
Qasim et al13 and Sobhan et al14 had much lower previous studies;⁸,¹² however, Tuncel et al¹⁰ found
proportion of cases aged ≥60 years. 11 adrenal masses as their axial MR sections were
Considering the association between age and captured at the upper lumbar level descending from
particular organ incidental findings, older patients L1 vertebra, which likely ran through the adrenal
showed more extraspinal incidental findings in the gland level and resulted in a clearer view of the
urinary and lymphovascular systems, while younger adrenal gland. Detection of these masses could
patients were more likely to have findings in the increase survival rate and improve prognosis, since
female genital tract. This result agrees with Qasim the incidental detection of renal cell carcinoma would
et al13 who observed a similar pattern. Our result carry better prognosis than tumors presenting with
is supported by an increased incidence of simple symptoms, mostly due to lower tumor stage at time
renal cysts with age.15 Meanwhile, the cumulative of diagnosis.17
incidence of uterine leiomyoma tends to increase Of 19 patients with incidental findings in the
from the age of 35 to 50 years and slow down at lymphovascular system, five were clinically significant,
older age.16 including dilated abdominal aorta or enlarged lymph
In the present study, a significant association nodes. Although this result is different from other
was observed between the presence of extraspinal previous studies,7,10,11 all studies including our study
incidental findings and sex. Similar to Zidan et al¹² and found a similar result of a lower incidental findings
Qasim et al,¹³ most extraspinal incidental findings in frequency in the lymphovascular than in the urinary
this study were found in females. In contrast, Sobhan and genital tracts. These difference may be caused by
et al¹⁴ showed no such association as they excluded the age, ethnicity, technique used such as FOV, and
any extraspinal incidental findings related to genital use of signal saturation anterior to the spine, thereby
tracts, such as uterus, ovary, or prostate. limiting proper retroperitoneum evaluation (aorta
We found that the urinary tract has the highest and the nearby lymph nodes). Aortic aneurysm could
number of incidental findings and the highest have serious clinical consequences, mainly from the
percentage of benign (simple renal cyst) and risk of rupture, and enlarged lymph nodes may signal
suspicious findings (hydronephrosis) among all the presence of primary lymphoproliferative disease
body systems, followed by the female genital tract. or deposits from a hidden primary.7 The detection
Our result agrees with many previous studies.6,10,12,14 of these incidental findings could help in saving
This is because the urinary tract is affected by patients’ life and reducing mortality.
many pathologies such as renal cyst, stone/ We have observed that axial plane was the most
hydronephrosis, and bladder changes secondary to common plane to detect extraspinal incidental
prostate enlargement, especially with advancing findings within the lymphovascular and urinary
age; and the female genital tract can be affected by systems. In the urinary tract, the axial plane could
simple ovarian cyst and uterine fibroids. show 87.7% of the benign findings and 38.1% of the
Simple renal cyst becomes more prevalent in suspicious incidental findings, while the sagittal plane
older age because of progressive nephron loss displayed most of the incidental findings related
with aging,12 confirming that the simple renal cyst to female genital tract. This observation is related
formed the largest proportion of the detected to the location of organs and scanning where the
extraspinal incidental findings. Although the etiology uterus, cervix, and vagina are midline structures and
for hydronephrosis may not be recognized in best viewed in the sagittal section. Axial sections for
lumbosacral spinal MRI because of the limited study lumbosacral spinal MRI are usually taken through the
protocol, the detection of this finding is important to selected lumbar intervertebral discs level, which is a
prevent irreversible damage to the affected kidney section higher than uterine level and less likely to run
through the female genital organ. Adrenal glands, particularly for the urinary system. A structured and
kidneys, and ureters are located paracentrally, and proper review of all extraspinal anatomical organs
the sagittal plane for lumbosacral spinal MRI may within the scanned field is recommended.
not run through them; therefore, incidental findings
Conflict of Interest
related to these structures are most often seen in The authors affirm no conflict of interest in this study.
the axial images.17
Acknowledgment
Lumbosacral spine MRI, as one of the commonly We would like to thank the Radiology staffs of PAR Hospital.
performed study in the Department of Radiology,
Funding Sources
involves radiologists from different levels to None.
interpret and report the scan and practitioners from
other specialties to evaluate the scan based on
their expertise. The high prevalence of extraspinal REFERENCES
incidental findings with a non-ignorable percentage 1. Berland LL, Silverman SG, Gore RM, Mayo-Smith WW, Megibow
AJ, Yee J, et al. Managing incidental findings on abdominal CT:
of suspicious extraspinal incidental findings in the white paper of the ACR incidental findings committee. J Am Coll
lumbosacral spinal MRI should raise the awareness Radiol. 2010;7(10):754–73.
2. Ells C, Thombs BD. The ethics of how to manage incidental
of radiologists and other involved specialties
findings. CMAJ. 2014;186(9):655–6.
in improving clinical practice and considering a 3. Park HJ, Jeon YH, Rho MH, Lee EJ, Park NH, Park SI, et al.
structured evaluation of all extraspinal structures Incidental findings of the lumbar spine at MRI during herniated
intervertebral disk disease evaluation. Am J Roentgenol.
within the scanned field, thus avoid missing a 2011;196(5):1151–5.
significant finding that affects the patient care and 4. Varghese B, Babu AC, Kumar A, Priya PS, John JS, Noufal M, et al.
Cross-sectional study on incidental spinal findings in magnetic
medicolegal consequence. resonance imaging lumbar spine of patients with low back pain.
Many worldwide screening programs are aimed West Afr J Radiol. 2017;24(1):38–44.
5. Vernooij MW, Ikram MA, Tanghe HL, Vincent AJ, Hofman A,
to detect diseases at an early stage when treatment
Krestin GP, et al. Incidental findings on brain MRI in the general
may be more effective.18 The role of an appropriate population. N Engl J Med. 2007;357(18):1821–8.
evaluation of lumbosacral spinal MRI in detecting 6. Wagner SC, Morrison WB, Carrino JA, Schweitzer ME,
Nothnagel H. Picture archiving and communication system:
potentially significant or life-threatening incidental effect on reporting of incidental findings. Radiology.
findings, such as hydronephrosis, aortic aneurysm, 2002;225(2):500–5.
7. Quattrocchi CC, Giona A, Di Martino AC, Errante Y, Scarciolla L,
or tumor, is higher than relying on the available Mallio CA, et al. Extra-spinal incidental findings at lumbar spine
screening tools in increasing patient survival rate MRI in the general population: a large cohort study. Insights
and improving patient outcome. Imaging. 2013;4(3):301–8.
8. Lee SY, Landis MS, Ross IG, Goela A, Leung AE. Extraspinal
This study has some limitations. The data findings at lumbar spine CT examinations: prevalence and
collection was obtained from a single center; clinical importance. Radiology. 2012;263(2):502–9.
9. Maxwell AW, Keating DP, Nickerson JP. Incidental
hence, the result may not be generalized. Surgical abdominopelvic findings on expanded field-of-view lumbar
confirmation and/or follow-up was not achieved spinal MRI: frequency, clinical importance, and concordance in
interpretation by neuroimaging and body imaging radiologists.
for every case with clinically significant incidental
Clin Radiol. 2015;70(2):161–7.
findings. The diagnosis of some cases was based 10. Tuncel SA, Çaglı B, Tekataş A, Kırıcı MY, Ünlü E, Gençhellaç H.
on the observations from lumbosacral spinal MRI, Extraspinal incidental findings on routine MRI of lumbar spine:
prevalence and reporting rates in 1278 patients. Korean J Radiol.
so the actual prevalence of these findings may be 2015;16(4):866–73.
inaccurate. Limitations of lumbosacral spinal MRI in 11. Ibrahim H, Elsadawy ME. Incidental findings in lumbar
spine MRI: their prevalence and potential impact on patient
finding extraspinal incidental findings included the management. Egypt J Radiol Nucl Med. 2019;50(59).
use of limited sequences and planes and its narrow 12. Zidan MMA, Hassan IA, Elnour AM, Ali WM, Mahmoud MZ,
FOV, especially with the use of saturation bands. Alonazi B, et al. Incidental extraspinal findings in the lumbar
spine during magnetic resonance imaging of intervertebral
In conclusion, the prevalence of extraspinal discs. Heliyon. 2018;4(9):e00803.
incidental findings in lumbosacral spinal MRI is 13. Qasim HA, Al-Bayati H, Mahmoud NA. Incidental finding
during MRI evaluation of lumbosacral disc prolapse in adults
high and clinically significant in some cases, with a in Al-Hilla Teaching Hospital. Med J Babylon. 2017;14(3):537–
significant correlation to age and sex. The urinary 49.
14. Sobhan M, Samiee M, Asgari Y, Ahmadi M. Incidental findings of
system displayed the highest percentage of the
the lumbar spine at MRI in patients diagnosed with discopathy.
incidental findings, and the axial MR section was the Int J Med Imaging. 2016;4(5):44–7.
most common plane to display the incidental findings, 15. Ozveren B, Onganer E, Türkeri LN. Simple renal cysts:
mji.ui.ac.id
Rashid, et al. | Incidental finding in lumbar spine MRI 263
prevalence, associated risk factors and follow-up in a health 17. Gebara NV, Meltzer DE. Extraspinal findings on lumbar spine MR
screening cohort. Urol J. 2016;13(1):2569–75. imaging. J Radiol Case Rep. 2009;3(8):5–13.
16. Stewart EA, Cookson CL, Gandolfo RA, Schulze-Rath R. 18. Wilken D, Baur X, Barbinova L, Preisser A, Meijer E, Rooyackers
Epidemiology of uterine fibroids: a systematic review. BJOG. J, et al. What are the benefits of medical screening and
2017;124(10):1501–12. surveillance? Eur Respir Rev. 2012;21(124):105–111.