Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Pubmed - Burnout and Personality Anestesi
Pubmed - Burnout and Personality Anestesi
ACO 310312
REVIEW
CURRENT
OPINION Occupational stress, burnout and personality
in anesthesiologists
Raymond A.B. van der Wal, Jacqueline Wallage, and Martin J.L. Bucx
Purpose of review
There is a growing awareness of the problem of occupational stress and burnout among anesthesiologists.
Occupational stress was found to be related to burnout, a process that is supposed to be moderated by
personality. This article will discuss the topic of stress and burnout in relationship to anesthesiologists’
personality based on recent literature.
Recent findings
Studies among anesthesiologists are in concordance with the broader body of literature on this topic.
Personality consistently influences stress appraisal and coping and consequently the development of
burnout. Neuroticism, negative affectivity and cooperativeness all contribute to burnout.
Summary
Strategies to alleviate stress and hence the development of burnout should not only be directed at adapting
occupational or organizational factors but also at equipping anesthesiologists with psychological tools to
deal with occupational stress. Furthermore, personality traits that predispose for development of burnout
could be taken into consideration in resident selection procedures.
Keywords
anesthesiologists, burnout, occupational stress, personality
of occupational stress and burnout in anesthesiolo- may be serious [3 ]. Stress and burnout may lead to
gists is gaining momentum.The annual number of dysfunction and even drop out of anesthesiologists,
new publications is increasing and the topic is also resulting in a reduction in quality of care, an increase
being addressed at our scientific conferences. The in healthcare costs and increased pressure on the
2016 American Society of Anesthesiologists (ASA) colleagues in the anesthesia departments.
meeting, for example, included 27 presentations
related to physician well being. This interest is not
THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN A STRESSOR
only limited to the scientific anesthesia community
AND STRESS
but also occurs in lay media. For instance, the French
documentary ‘Burning out, dans le ventre de l’hôpi- The term ‘stress’ is sometimes confused with
tal,’ is very illustrative of stress and burnout from the ‘stressor.’ Stressors are mental, emotional or physical
&
perspective of anesthesiologists [1 ].
The question arises why the problem of occupa-
Department of Anesthesiology, Pain and Palliative Medicine, Radboud
tional stress and burnout is increasingly acknowl-
University Nijmegen Medical Center, Nijmegen, the Netherlands
edged. On the one hand, it is possible that our
Correspondence to Raymond A.B. van der Wal, MD, Anesthesiologist,
working conditions have changed: patients are Department of Anesthesiology, Pain and Palliative Medicine, Radboud
increasingly complex and new technologies and anes- University Nijmegen Medical Center, Internal Postal Code 717, P.O. Box
thetic techniques are rapidly introduced [2]. On the 9101, 6500 HB Nijmegen, the Netherlands. Tel: +31 24 361 4406;
other hand, it is possible that, while working condi- fax: +31 24 354 0462; e-mail: Raymond.vanderwal@radboudumc.nl
tions may have changed, workspace culture also has Curr Opin Anesthesiol 2018, 31:000–000
changed. Discussing experience of occupational stress DOI:10.1097/ACO.0000000000000587
0952-7907 Copyright ß 2018 Wolters Kluwer Health, Inc. All rights reserved. www.co-anesthesiology.com
Copyright © 2018 Wolters Kluwer Health, Inc. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
CE: Tripti; ACO/310312; Total nos of Pages: 6;
ACO 310312
for exams, concern about future job prospects and [3 ]. These are, ultimately, the cause of occupational
critical clinical incidents [7]. stress and burnout. However, personality plays an
The experience of stress happens with the per- important role as well [17]. An informative descrip-
ception of a threat and the consequent physiologi- tion of personality is that of Larsen and Buss: ‘Per-
cal, psychological and behavioral reactions to that sonality is the set of psychological traits and
threat. A 2016 cross-sectional study found that mechanisms within the individual that are organized
40.1% of consultant anesthesiologists and 52% of and relatively enduring, and that influence his or her
residents were psychologically distressed [8 ]. A
&
interactions with, and adaptations to, the intrapsy-
study to compare occupational stress in 435 German chic, physical and social environments’ [18].
residents concluded that surgery residents experi- The interactions between personality, stress and
enced the highest levels of occupational distress, burnout are schematically represented in Fig. 1.
higher than residents of internal medicine, obstet- First, personality influences, which stressors people
rics, gynecology, pediatrics, neurology and anesthe- may seek out. Some people will self-select into pro-
siology. Interestingly, the 70 anesthesiology fessions, like anesthesiology, that will likely con-
residents had the highest scores on depressive symp- front them with stressful situations. It has been
toms [9]. Another recent study of 427 anesthesiol- postulated that certain personalities will be attracted
ogy residents found that 28% scored high on a to certain specialties [19]. Indeed, differences in
physiological distress scale and that 11% were cur- personality have been found between five medical
rently under treatment for anxiety or depression [7]. specialties, among which anesthesiology [20].
Second, personality is expected to influence
how people experience stress. The transactional
STRESS AND BURNOUT model of stress, developed by Lazarus and Folkman
Although some stress may help people perform at a in 1984, emphasizes the active psychological inter-
higher baseline state, it has been shown that too action between the stressor and the individual. Dur-
much stress can impair both technical and nontech- ing the primary appraisal, based on perceived
nical skills in anesthesiology [10–12]. In addition to, demands, an individual identifies whether the
enduring work-related stress can lead to negative stressor is a threat, a neutral or a positive challenge.
Copyright © 2018 Wolters Kluwer Health, Inc. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
CE: Tripti; ACO/310312; Total nos of Pages: 6;
ACO 310312
0952-7907 Copyright ß 2018 Wolters Kluwer Health, Inc. All rights reserved. www.co-anesthesiology.com 3
Copyright © 2018 Wolters Kluwer Health, Inc. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
CE: Tripti; ACO/310312; Total nos of Pages: 6;
ACO 310312
dominance. Openness to experience, as opposed to to burnout. The more selfless the resident, the greater
conventional or conservative, is associated with the likelihood of burnout [35].
terms such as originality, creativity, nonreligious-
ness, independence and having broad interests. Con-
scientiousness concerns a person’s attitude to work OTHER PERSONALITY CONSTRUCTS AND
and achievement. The last trait is agreeableness, as BURNOUT
opposed to hostility, also known as altruism and Type D personality is characterized by feelings of
associated with qualities such as love, empathy, psychological stress and high levels of negative
friendliness and cooperation [30]. affectivity and social inhibition. This corresponds
Already in 1998, a comprehensive review of 250 roughly to the Big Five personality traits of neuroti-
studies on burnout and personality reported that cism and introversion. High negative affectivity is
neuroticism was strongly correlated with burnout described as having negative feelings such as dys-
[31]. More recent studies show the same: in a lon- phoria, anxiety and tension. The social inhibition is
gitudinal study from 2012 that controlled for time, explained as failure of revealing feelings because of
age, sex, work hours and depression, it was found fear of disapproval. A 2016 study among Turkish
that neuroticism was positively associated with healthcare professionals found that Type D person-
burnout. Conscientiousness was also positively ality was strongly related to burnout [36]. The Type
associated with burnout [32]. A study in healthcare D personality is known as a distressed personality
workers from 2015 found emotional stability (the profile. An analogous personality profile was also
opposite of neuroticism) to be negatively related to found in an analysis of Big Five Inventory results of
burnout [33]. A cross-sectional study among anes- Dutch anesthesiologists [21].
thesiologists, published in 2016, found neuroticism Recent studies outside of our specialty have
to be an important risk factor for burnout, whereas looked into the concepts of emotional intelligence
extroversion and agreeableness seemed to work pro- and empathy. Emotional intelligence has been
&
tectively [8 ]. described as awareness of one’s own emotions and
The relationship between neuroticism and burn- thoughts and the ability to use this awareness to
out is expected, because neuroticism is characterized guide further actions and thoughts. The trait is
by fearfulness, low self-esteem, social anxiety, poor considered flexible rather than static; it can be
inhibition of impulses, helplessness and irritability. learned, and thus evolve. It has been postulated that
It may seem obvious to state that it is a desirable trait emotional intelligence is important in managing
for an anesthesiologist to be emotional stable, but it stressful situations. In surgical residents, it was
is also shown to be the case: the body of literature found that high emotional intelligence is associated
seems conclusive about the relation between burn- with improved job satisfaction and a predictor of
out and neuroticism, for anesthesiologists well being [37,38]. Empathy is important for estab-
and others. lishing interpersonal relationships and is empha-
sized as a necessary tool for integrating emotional
and cognitive factors. It is a construct of personality
Temperament and Character Inventory and has a relationship with burnout. Studies found
Another instrument to describe personality is the negative correlations between lower scores on
Temperament and Character Inventory (TCI). The empathy and burnout [39,40]. However, the ques-
TCI evaluates personality under the assumption that tion is whether empathy protects against the devel-
personality structure is composed of temperament opment of burnout or that empathy decreases as a
and character [34]. Temperament includes four traits result of burnout, analogous to the depersonaliza-
(novelty seeking, harm avoidance, reward depen- tion that is part of the burnout syndrome.
dence and persistence), which are influenced by
genetic predisposition and contribute to behavioral
decisions. Character includes three traits (self-direct- TOOLS TO INCREASE PERSONAL
edness, cooperativeness and self-transcendence), RESILIENCE
which mature in adulthood and influence personal To reduce physician stress and burnout, it is important
and social effectiveness. This personality inventory both to reduce stressors through structural or organi-
has previously been used to describe personality in zational interventions and to focus strategies on the
&&
anesthesiologists in comparison with other physi- individuals [41 ]. A personalized approach to prevent
cians and the general population [26]. A recent study the culmination of stress into burnout might work to
in Japanese residents found that the TCI could predict increase resilience by equipping individuals with tools
the risk for future burnout because residents with to cope with stress. For example, some residency
high cooperativeness were significantly more prone curricula are now implementing resident wellness
Copyright © 2018 Wolters Kluwer Health, Inc. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
CE: Tripti; ACO/310312; Total nos of Pages: 6;
ACO 310312
0952-7907 Copyright ß 2018 Wolters Kluwer Health, Inc. All rights reserved. www.co-anesthesiology.com 5
Copyright © 2018 Wolters Kluwer Health, Inc. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
CE: Tripti; ACO/310312; Total nos of Pages: 6;
ACO 310312
24. Dawson BF, Thompson NJ. The effect of personality on occupational stress in 36. Tekin A, Karadag H, Yayla S. The relationship between burnout symptoms and
& veterinary surgeons. J Vet Med Educ 2017; 44:72–83. Type D personality among healthcare professionals in Turkey. Arch Environ
This study, although not among anesthesiologists, highlights the importance of Occup Health 2017; 72:173–177.
personality in predicting occupational stress. The need for a greater awareness of 37. Hollis RH, Theiss LM, Gullick AA, et al. Emotional intelligence in surgery is
potentially susceptible personality traits in the selection process is implicated. associated with resident job satisfaction. J Surg Res 2017; 209:178–183.
25. Reeve PE. Personality characteristics of a sample of anaesthetists. Anaes- 38. Lin DT, Liebert CA, Tran J, et al. Emotional intelligence as a predictor of
thesia 1980; 35:559–568. resident well being. J Am Coll Surg 2016; 223:352–358.
26. Kluger MT, Laidlaw TM, Kruger N, Harrison MJ. Personality traits of anaes- 39. Park C, Lee YJ, Hong M, et al. A multicenter study investigating empathy and
thetists and physicians: an evaluation using the Cloninger Temperament and burnout characteristics in medical residents with various specialties. J Korean
Character Inventory (TCI-125). Anaesthesia 1999; 54:926–935. Med Sci 2016; 31:590–597.
27. Kam P. Occupational stress in anaesthesia. Anaesth Intensive Care 1997; 40. Picard J, Catu-Pinault A, Boujut E, et al. empathy and their relationships: a
25:686–690. qualitative study with residents in general medicine. Psychol Health Med
28. Luedi MM, Doll D, Boggs SD, Stueber F. Successful personalities in 2016; 21:354–361.
& anesthesiology and acute care medicine: are we selecting, training, and 41. West CP, Dyrbye LN, Erwin PJ, Shanafelt TD. Interventions to prevent and
supporting the best? Anesth Analg 2017; 124:359–361. && reduce physician burnout: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Lancet
Interesting article discussing the question of selecting individuals into anesthesia 2016; 388:2272–2281.
with desirable personalities and what these could be. To consider emotional This very interesting review discusses, respectively, 15 RCTs and 37 observational
intelligence is proposed. studies into strategies for prevention and reduction of physician burnout. It
29. Grucza RA, Goldberg LR. The comparative validity of 11 modern personality concludes that both individual-focused and structural or organizational interven-
inventories: predictions of behavioral acts, informant reports, and clinical tions can reduce burnout. Additional research is recommended, for example, into
indicators. J Pers Assess 2007; 89:167–187. the long-term effects of interventions.
30. Costa PT, McCrae RR. Four ways five factors are basic. Personal Individ Differ 42. Chakravarti A, Raazi M, O’Brien J, Balaton B. Anesthesiology Resident
1992; 13:653–665. Wellness Program at the University of Saskatchewan: concept and devel-
31. Schaufeli W, Enzmann D. The burnout companion to study and practice: a opment. Can J Anaesth 2017; 64:185–198.
critical analysis. Florida, USA: CRC press; 1998. 43. Lapa TA, Madeira FM, Viana JS, Pinto-Gouveia J. Burnout syndrome and
32. Armon G, Shirom A, Melamed S. The big five personality factors as predictors wellbeing in anesthesiologists: the importance of emotion regulation strate-
of changes across time in burnout and its facets. J Pers 2012; 80:403–427. gies. Minerva Anestesiol 2017; 83:191–199.
33. Magnano P, Paolillo A, Barrano C. Relationships between personality and 44. Roberts MJ, Gale TC, McGrath JS, Wilson MR. Rising to the challenge: acute
burn-out: an empirical study with helping professions’ workers. Int J Human & stress appraisals and selection centre performance in applicants to post-
Soc Sci Res 2015; 1:10–19. graduate specialty training in anaesthesia. Adv Health Sci Educ Theory Pract
34. Cloninger CR, Svrakic DM, Przybeck TR. A psychobiological model of 2016; 21:323–339.
temperament and character. Arch Gen Psychiatry 1993; 50:975–990. This study explores the usefulness of a stress appraisal measure. Performance
35. Miyoshi R, Matsuo H, Takeda R, et al. Burnout in Japanese residents and its under stress can be assessed, but for recruitment decisions, the authors report
associations with temperament and character. Asian J Psychiatr 2016; that the results are not strong enough to support this measure for recruitment
24:5–9. decisions, yet.
Copyright © 2018 Wolters Kluwer Health, Inc. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.