1

THEDISQIPLINARY omITTEE OF
THE BAR COUN CIL bf INDIA
be APPEAL NO 3/199
UPENDRA D BHATT .Appolland

VIJAY SINGH' M KAPADIA .

Rapomdond
Pruaund:
SHR SN 9RINASTANA, e HAIRMAN
SHRI A K MISHRA ,
SHRI B
MEMBER De, e HARMAN BCI
RATHORE ,MEMBER
Advocalts Ad (Act No.2 196) Aatin
35 (A) faagasbnel
m
iacodund .Agpulland who wao earor punishe
d Aue
nd Ausciplimay maltuvs opn aLad chorged 8nd ian
ort miscondud eagpellant favocakl cellackad hoawy
amounta
a dome
Nold Hha +h Rppeland duhiuded yu
Complaunan
Le should haus baorn Hruu) om gumumal olage hon a
malhe
&uud
hunea 94o raaly untoalunate kha such a blacK skeap jo
3 l n he lp) paaeiontahuoh sD rogazdod aD ome q the
gbll n the ugadd Advocalu ata neB omla paalsdönA «f
dumacxacy aud alao ot indyidual huedb ugts a clionlo.
Ahoup u Bor louneu o 9ndLa ( plaharoshlia and

Groa) guapindod thu Raapondent Kqom eagclics (sa 2 yesr and

 mon-dhs.Shue allegoalugno Juhuch hauu bepn faund lo b
PNLd shOuo hu 3onuuo maluu th aneconduc omd -hulka
16 Punu&hound can bi mPosad onceph kol auvn Ju
(Mamt lo6 cndorad to Po1 Rb, 98.000 uilh sntoadoy.
P.a abn u dals doand Palad:Q1-09-1998
JUDE MENT
kppoland Adocale had beon punighed earon uuce
She stah ear tauntil o
and &ucpindod qqan paactics ay thi
md bmolia, bud Ha dd
alaytasrra amd (roa Ln searb
,#oag
had takin
081 immpaae nd plojed qaaud oq 3ouauDhonaiiA
nL&concoes, Logmlly umtnabl dyonor
thu complanmand s
AaD hold guulty aleo do b dahanlun thas alogdln
methan and ihe complaumand hu .gmmu fea hule .0

nd to be prouad u AGug msCOdued 4 OUmna

kht
Aoas amd houksnd ono Jood punushomind cauld mpoaad
of luo mam fam thu aall of OiNOcalls
cep aivng
the ebar Couneu o mahauehtra and Gn.
mainl and oy
he Coommitlo quudhul dinueled dhon am amdund q Rs
88,000 alory uh inluroal107 P, a by poud bythe
Advocals qawmd datu of danand o rund hi nbrey
-Makon qo hum tll thu dati a pgpmbrd
 TIE BISC IPLINARY COI TTEE OF THE
DAR COUNCIL OF INDIA
BCT TR. ASE No. 49/1993
ALLAHABAD CAINK FPrland
V/S
Gt1RISH PRASAD VER MA. Rizpomdend
Prasam
Shyu V.Y Hallappa, Chavuman
Shru Arwn Mahra lember
Shu mLoKLDh Membort
Hdvocatt As CArd No R5o 196) &uclim 85 kor Coune o Irdua
ulfaoasiomal Misconducd.su Complainard/Aeelland o
SULaaDal Bank. dh Bank haelad jhi complan o alsappu
alon 4Coud tea and aoB Jdung 4onmu_ Ca00o agauna iiu dvocdil
Guuah raakad uma.H aD ale0gd hal 50 &uid uou NBA
ugistoed aD maagpapkiaked amiaapplicatom Aon Juana PEpn

fepund o eaud feon ouB qp ula. hu aduseatimiuagpupeia

4ed tha aumpaid to Jum oy i complainant son hu punpoas y
CouwT eD etr D allage tha u ocalt had muaagpupidd
fb 1,96,144 yn-total amd in gady ah mol tauo bu its
gilng a
ttl
ler callelog Cowd lw fom the Ban, ,0nderad pAunishrod
sHrving B namaa Responudonrd addvocals om he
.
tollo ttu bor Couned ov-P onvd to naund tha ovmvunt
i s (wh diucted tas t shalk e ogun to Hu banu vo
 20
claunto domagen ulh ruopuel e nbn tu 3ul
4lung
Per Shoi Ahun ahra
JUDGEMENT Aales1- 12-/99
Shu RMahabad Ban tad 4ded he inobond comhind aligng
Raoss mubconducd o musnpprapruakion ot Cauu fe by u
Ruspondend Alvocata. a Connpdaunand daimad had Au rotund a
1hu oyprabad 3um and p0xed hon dhu agfnopruali punighmilmd
9aunar huo mibcanduct dhe coonnulleo hakd that u Avocal
ad
misprpuasid tu amurd eAb 1, 8K, 14h and u0D guy
MoH 4thiwng tuo dhi suts al lez callgekung lhu Loudd Fap
ShoAou, Lhu Commuoe 6ndorod hu uyig of du mamo
Hu Aabvocals {2om dhu rall o 0.P Bor Csuncul and adao tuvd
Bu amaund y R» 1,36, 144 kawd ea»raaled adonguith Ae
melexoad a . P.a and coolo AD 10,000. Ahe CommuL
welhun eponud hat ituuGuld bi opon do tu Banu. to caum
olamega an Cosio dusto o ilong o hu suds
shy Cawmutes moda cloar that ihu lbqal pmokobdueno
a. mubl pafebaor, Shu oa ugh enpsclaliows gat the mumbos
ho ar . Shumfou, Ao mumber ud ad an Qnomplo o Conduwe
warty a emuualien any 4 Ko ailo Jhl punushmend huo to
bo commerbwlali uiht u doge owd gaanuty a mucandiued.
 THE DISCIPLINARY CommITTEE Of THE
DAR CO UNIL OF INbA
e TR. eASE No. 0 1995
Complaurarl
REG 1ONAL OFFICER,ALLAHABAD...
J.P SHRI VA STAVA RusPonderd
Prusand:
Shu Kumanan. ChoumanD'C
Shru Artun kumat lihra,lomber chanman, B e
Shvu Mand Kumat Maahta
Mamber
Aadvocals Aes CAc No.&5 1461) Aac 35 faalaainnad Miscomdu
Raponden. tavocals uao anpaged aoan favocals ay n
Conplarand Panu 4or iling 186 suls in Civil Courd and wao
aus fadkaidnal
teab, (oud Lewo and olhon enpenoD and u
handod evau original decumendo socwelied amd Vaualalranuo
Dut un&am CaQLD n0 Auls acu
Jilad ard h lalsely wpruc&mod
cbaud hauurg All thu &uls and aloo abed dabo earurg
stuRoaponderd édvocali engogad Auaponkri No.M uhe Vjed
|u agal mannt «tu AAvata ded hu Abvocalt uho Cauota
Jass o abeul Rb13 Jauhe and mioappopnuadod Rb 4,38,40
.
faus to hurn a Coud fes
AulA hat tHu Riapondond Bduocals hao oclad in vidlglion
fiojsanal chico andprAorbad sBandard o conduol
a
Shuuy os hu &hauld kofund liu Cana ulin peruolay Bmondhe
Shu oname o Aha Rosponmdend Bdvocal shall stand tumoued qn

Onpuhont ao on Hdvocali
fer 8hru Hruwn ishua.
JUDGEMENT Aalad'2-12-98

|Aisciplumay Camnu-leo. he Complaiunmd eank au4fentd huge

ls ohs el ohu Raspondod
u diseapinasy Camu4Hea huld dhas Jhu Rosponudond No.4
rivaouo uilhyq paskignal anisecondud 9n thui opm
9 hu COmetHea iu hao oetod un hu vidalion u puaba
ehues, and pweubed sundaró a Condud.Camaegkundly, Jul
Connamu-tea Paed baker debavung Ruaponmdlond No.4
{am
faacusmg anyrouhuna ad an advocade .shu CamiHes diadad
andhld loi ko,4.28,409 u musappropriaod
No.hu4pu hu luaoo awnd u semu to flu ebanby uthunRugordod
qALN sh banu
Cauld 4i oa e0omponoa[ion 4on loss tansed
Also Kupondod no.Q hudá Comdtae thal hu mao enallod ao
0n HavocalL in
M85 bud hu wad aot engaged b h Bank ;iMaugh
AAJuaD appeaung along uh Auapanwderd no4, uwo ao tu
maun Cauagd ou eanM.
Ahon, MuaD held uiHy
allulng u aimaluno al du perond Aithaul huo
Hie comduet sngo sououay vi euud and vauuladga.
nupumandod.
 THE DISe1PLINARY e0MITTEE OF
THE CAR COUNCIL OF INDIA
beAPPEAL No. 40/ 1995
PROF. KRI SHNARAT G03 NAMI- Appelland
V/S
VI3HWANATH D. MOKASIRAR Ruponderd

3hiRam chandnoiha ,Chaiuaram

Shuu 9ndajii
mahandy, mymber
Shuu Mana Kumat Mumban
a Complaunt uioo ilos qpavnas an advocala alloginruu
ditewd poinmúb a Hime Ab29, 06f uoo paid to Advocal
COncuvnad bul hu Conearus AAvotatu dulay in ilug u au
nd dud nutl fo 4ull cauad Lea and alas slay in mby"g
Imrum
apPlication omd camplainga wJos uge logao
iscpunmay Comtlea o tar Counel y Sndia (Malhangshtta and
und h commnud fvocals ailtt Hon dakayun i
ilirg a tha dw and upnded ihu Lionos 4 Aavocads jon S/earu
ta oppkiutd ANocals ilad iu afpad qom 301d ondon.
HMold, Mgs al pcoper on parda u hocalt io hold back
Ju tea ploa q dhualurg bu amaunt ruayuud oaenpmalo oqwsd

Canaldeung ln eadones gn agconda, longas ncuR

wAD {ud byt hepokand avnd Congwunet iao huld uilh sn
AD Apunamdod no wo fiuen uae
Laws, u apolond
ual Lo rapeal Such typa q antslna..
 JUDGEMENT bated1-1/-999
hu appoal D Prafarored by Jha sppaland sdaecals agaund
jMdgoment doakd s4-o8-99 pabad byhl hirciplina
Commutfee q tht Bon Council ef makanahba. and froo in e
No.94 1994 pumishirg u agulaod by suoponaLo piunm
PRAches ot a poruod 3 years.
Sha agpulland Aducali oarged tlt said dtcosin q
4e iu Da Counad q makatnehlu and toa byou du bon (aun
9nduon, Me ecvalungad hu docasion om u geund At fuu
had been gobb vislatism qpainiplen q Natual juolict bj oat
allsuwng paayn (oa adyouwrnnd and Huguaol foa vamunalurt
othoa dmase
hu Commultea hld Ahu Aduoaall guilly Pabjsaiana
PLisConducs. Nowonen kaaung into conoidonation u facbo and
Crcumdanc ,hu Comanilke f Dan touneil q mahaMaohtla and
Graa. hn
punushmend waD amoalyLed by Ju Don Cauneul ndta
M adugcatt Auo
tuprianandad fon guch conduat hi
Kun&hmend duopunoLar ua Sed aaudl and omedyal vo
exlnd, iao uavnud by jiu comittea m fulawL h
hould oul commet anv pl pasl231gnal iucbpndiuet
 Mas Suush Joghi . L.e Goyad
beT Tr.Coas No.
441999
ma
sddvocals ped (Acd No.26 o 19%1) Seliom 36 Payesaigona
u9condud Riopomdend aduocab raalbaud an amdund
as
o
|162 cau te and in lhu sul foadaclanalion 0nd olomageD
paud on Ab lool"8o caud fo.e alaa uilhdoaw an inunidion
Pplucalion Abu {on Complamad.9n perauanct of mallce dalad
ete
109 by Jhu Complaunant domandung coumd fa
u quapondend iseuos
ANpPnseD
achaqua beaing Rs 38, 006/ Luhuct (u
dighomoxad tuica om aeceunt o jmbutficwnd
Jundo U
Huopondend dloniud alugalion and alugtd Myt'q dogu book
Mun omay Je buw u ciscumeaneu danol o JU Lard
nu nineiplo of eualulin enidunea
JUDGE MENT balod: - 3 - /998

Swruah Joshi om 01-7-93 filad eomplaunt agaunaf shi L.e

toyal, sdocals praclisung9 in duthi Hgh Coaud
allag
amudoppaopLalpm oae
caund o Rs 25, 102/ rucoyoud om accuni
raymund caunt fer
Hoperdund adnuscaiu gaan 1hu Rall f Bon loumel o Alhi
md Coto R hooo Juao auanded.
 THE NSCIPLINARY COmm/TTEE OF THE DAR Co UNCIL
OF INDIA
beT 7R CASE NO 92/1998
TER CHAND Complaynaat
VIS
PRAHOD KU MAR Rucpondod
fruaend CHAUDHARY
Shru babu Ram dendrù, chauan
Jhu AdighQ.
Shvu artnal , Momber
Rajnudaa Rana Mombu
Advo catu ed, 1961 Saclim Bh oalo uuth
hu Canplamam Protdbionad
allagad that thu tuopondoni tos k a um Muscondua
o Ro 12,
O06an hum haa halprng him in enaculiem
rulation uidh AlJiloma qakaos ao Ao dMOD goal
Aishuc Na ilhon ttu ouonk ,
apodend auaD don mr mon noaislnatu
CradL tias rotunhu ComplaLnda
doyplaun koa musconduct lon owl rAumdnq Au d
andd
nolicos. ha
Ropondend did mol åpean and tok
0apuiencs 0q thu othon aiguwnmerd &
6RDER
shu Plamod kumare
chauduy is taund fullf undon sscluom 85
Hu Advocals Acd amd is
duband am paacic b6u am Caud
Law, rbural, auholh pa amy pUTwgm {onoa porusd 5 yeaMs
Am-ttu daiu q acapl oj ondon and Ju enmallsnurd csriii eal
SUAd Jum a hubycalled.A Cogd a
Rb5,006f o imposad
Agunal u nopoomdlend ¥o be paud to tu lgon
Complaimand uhurt ona mlanth (om Ju dadna pjomlai we d tMa
ueu a ttwy otdn
L Sab eoa launeu s lfa flodsoh iaus
0 pavidad unden Ahl aulon
mali4icaluomo
 THE DISCIPLINARY COmnyTTEE Of THE BAR
O0NCIL Of INDIA
6'e'T TR. CABE No. 4/ 199%
Sm1. 8UbE SH RANI OTHERS. Complanan
.9
Aeppordord
MUNISH CHANDRA &OEL
Probond
Shu3Ralho channman
Shyu Fhruun plushaa , Mombon
uu Aanan Ahaiya
,Membe
Sdocaltb fed (Ael No 26a 194d.and Can. Caunelndia
Ruloo 197a Chaplor -I , 30ckon Paambls Ruls D5 doal
Aua paolesoLoral amiconduct
Ruopondond oduscat1 aihnad ab a iniAd in agnavmanld ,
34 plals o land anld bs ladhun -im- lawo andnuce coma
all@r onry by uay dl Conpooiol docro0o in |( Auo flod
Cnplainaito uho conbucad houQIP On thun plols shuaaalite
tuporidendtled eniclian guio shauing all complaman) ad
fonamlõ, aFpNBU aL h nadnua töc
Dafed'. 9 -12- 1998
JUDGEMENT
Gn ao amuch ao l petooUs hauo hed hio Romplont agaunal
uopodend-aduacale om thi allognuDo thoy suu rodLdonl)
o Caye Nagan, Dloudabad gnthi caos Topomdono
aduocall &gnad ana uknupd in agaeRmot o(0 Sull Pas
-

Aand sols by huo da-lben in -lau M dugciplunauy Camnulloo

Bc1 that An LaND Aaß boon {lhd by At
dhi {ound
 28
Rqpeodend Asucali on bolall o Rama Kond. fathon-nJao
hl Raopeaderi aduscal ahgutig al i CAmpkainant
0 konanh and hesupprtabed gn al t plaunb dhe Aspynolond
aduacals uao Juld gulya hanurg Camnilled brunch
Rl 95 u uwao illy ey AuppubB acl
rugpo mdend aduecals a o Jeld puity of hauu
Cemarulod paatesbiona o tuoll ap ohu omioconmduot. o
to would B
Comonill oadonad that hio Licores pracucs
 SUPREME CoURT OF JNEJA
ATEK. 18-10-84
e IVIL APPEAL NO 1019 oF1978
M VEE RABHADRA OAO Appolland
VS
TEK H AND Ruopondond
Pasoend
Juaics D' H Asca
Justic . Calayishna &odi
Juolics N Khald
kOCatoo Add (25 146) Judion 35 dealo uith p14sdional
Mwcondut.She apaland (orgud ayidanutq fhu Auopormdd and
altustad il on tht kaois ol ieh an inCom an cbolaUN
Cordyuca uas josued bihu gncou dan Hicn ulueh
facilialid rogigtalion a alo daod in ropic uuc
icene conadenalion Jad mat beon paid 1o ihi tuApondond
P%len heariury bolh i padies, Jhi kaut ioound onelica. dotho
Jum hauld
appoland oo io uly jthi piniskmunt auaides ggino
olienaanced
JUD GE MENT
dhe an
appeal bpu i Aieiplinay Cammill
oppellan /dod
mado by
Ban Coancl q Sndia,uhich afimod tlu oaden
Stali Commillis and colvaying o uarnury do thi ofpolla
and
hat he shuls bi canhud in Jalut in duol amqltors
aloo oadoned tnpurguny corlain abwrnalueno iii slatb
Commlbe
 30 PR EME COURT OF INDIA
ORBER DT 2 ND NOVEMBER 196
IN THE MAT TER OF 'A an fdvocals

Pasaend
Chiy Juoic 0 PSinha
uolucs k Subha Rao.
utucr JC Sha
uolic Roghulbun Baya
uoler J.R Mudhdkon
-

upuma Caut o ondia Rauleo ( 1950)oodon IvA ,Ruo R1

Pnogaional PUAcondaucl -dsaOcatt o( upuma oud
NriHing letlon to thw nunis4er o law. govt. Makoalna (o
Soliciking buels,mallin rupmabd t upmomu Caud Chiy julica
ducidad Roishat snyavmally to ergus fom tht aduacall,
Juho adrilh d hid ruben gfamp and sjgnaliut gn th httn
olispalehadby hun
Muld dhas i
aduscalt Jhao oddnped hu lelton akgaMOaLd
Di govl oq Mlakonahha selicifimg then brups and hu dud 3o
dO duSgand Juo po8ikionmo a0 an adugpcali and uo dul
uilHlem the
AMeuung postand n
-uth Me hao in dhuo cout uao aiuen ullbn d cgpnd
o ond uho 0 eihon conduned humol oo a lan and
hao
igmanand a hu elumonany rulo of Pyobein
eluco on ms ngnnd hon hom naun cponian ka fully desuJ
th unishmSuopanLgn m
oaan that a laugen muoi ouuon bRpnacdus on flue reono. Lt Jum
a liant Parna

AAA Aupoakad n PIR 19K2,IC 186)

oduocals punushed oo por chuy JuolcB.P&unba
 31
THE BISCIPL INARY COmITTEE OF THE BAR
COUNCIL OF INDIA BCT.TR.CASE No 63/1987
SURINDRANA TH, MIT1 AL. Complaunant
VIS
DAYANAND SUAROOP Ruapondend
PruDen
3HRI KUMARAN KUTTY, CHAIRMAN
3HRI ARUN MISHRA mEMBER {CHAIRDIAN
6AR COONCIL OF INDIA
Auscalon Ad (Ad No. @5 a 961) &uclion 95 doalo uuh pMjaorm
ikeorduclo. nterpataliom in thí udgemund and duco by
addunn ih uOTd ma s00d'muanung Anclndir inferuod (uuot
LALRLA al huu ad Ha tau of Pupanatwn o udgend.
Shs ruPandend asad guihy manipulafung i cawu (UONd

JUDGEMENT
n a cas, Camyplind uao addruood 1o lu
ohu yotic o
Sababas Cowl by 3wndaralh ullal
3uLAH and Jio lhn tilad asuid opainasagaina ap. Nomd
thu Comptaunand (00
CONLO errlatm amound kyrat omd ecoupaluon, o
0CCOnModalon and sd waD dwwo8 en- Parts amd en
a dacl ODdnawn

Ahvaton,Aeya Nond -Juononpomado imlnpaliom

dhu ydgemnd ano dsous by addilo hu und "mai 9eod",
ineluding imeuo) itun in huo own handuwri img 6a othuuua
CaaR o be addo thiot us uudo. eshoo uido wnt abdod
An tho aponalius poatien ef tu
wdembnd. Bud diseipluraiy
Commukto Aound thu auopoMdon adnocall
wao
gultyy addg
JAuONdD amd auapnded fon cut ean Jubaoguondly
 3
L

ILLttiIrn111111i iiis
CUUUVLILINNINNNNNNNNJIJNIN.
 Conduet a ho tuaptondlemd aduacal suao unbeco0nuda
tho launw
Jla had ilad io digghoagP hio dludao ao onfuld
mao
cn hu Cawd AA AAOPsdend aduocadt
Commdlloo YUbm pracuce lon a geus.d el Aaut mntto s
Corulleo umpased a Cog ol l0, 006 rwpe on hum o ha a
NO L Cmplairand and in Caos q lalun in pamind utu
uo months, Je ugs to undeng Suspentaion Aam praclieo
401 an adaijional pouad on yean &ubanguemtl
 BAR
THE DISC PLINARY CONpuTTE E OF THE
COUNCIL Of TNDI
15-11-1998
B'C TR CASE No 401999,DATED:
Complaunad
PRATAP NARATN..
VS
upond ond
yP RAME JA
Pauund
SHRI ARUN MiSHRA,HAIRMAN
3HRI 3 RATHORE MEMBER
SHRI AMAN DHAIYA, ME MBER
NNOcatrs ed Chcd no 9bcd 196) dclim 35 dealo uth palabuon
fliscowdud.Ro
Racpomdlond Advocalí handod oel a yged/fabricatd
|
y bndon ip conplainand juhon oo stay ondon had beon paabe
Htu Caad ald fhot toqponodonl opuilly af poohaaional amioCardu
a SAruaus anatuu
DATED ISr 1998
JVDGEMENT
Sh Coonplaimd suao flod b hu Paalop Noraun bakou hi pan
Cuncd Alhu apuna niu Raheja, Aovocadli .u noapondond uap
0dcali ncmy fon dhu Cewplamant jn acaos. uaD allogrd Ia
uapoavdend hande oyel.Jim ahongpb skay øndon uhuls sle a
Ondo caad
paubad by dhu Caunl n lhu Caoslen enanunung a
eudorea dnd nulouand faeo khu nspocdi
disciplinaruy Comnulot
u Bbon Couneidg 9nda cami 1o thu Coneluoian traf ti awopnd
aduocale humon hande vn kum lhu paged stay odn tuhue

Shu Comanttu otler naminwn thu (asn, enAcdenci.ele held

rat u upovdlend u0o udly o prayebaiomal ocomduel aa
Quua naluu .Cambsquomly, -tha Aisciplimary Comani Hes otdoud
umual o hD aumu 4am u alo qban Counc Gndia (du)
 THE DISCIPLINARY CCMINUTTEE OF THE BAR
COUNCIL 0F INDIA
bL APPEAL DATED' 21-09-1913
No 1/1916
VIKRAMADITYA Apolland
SPT. JAMLA KHATOON Kipondant
rusond
3HRI 6.9 CHANDE L, CHAR MAN
8 HRI ARUN SHRA MEMbER- CHARDMAN
BAR COUNCIL OF
INDIA
8HRI M-LOLE
SH, MLNMbER
dvocats Acd CAd 2 196) dion S5 daalb auil
3comdu.pelland adncalu dblaunud
tueaaibrul
on Haualadnama and banK Papaisloa airauto Hu Conplamas
Puncharad amulalkd in hn ouni in guttion hu land uhuoh 3hi Jad
Hhoo ooumano oncoiamur a lh cHawens acondb kud an3L
Cuunathunb {ilag a af ogaino komlomuaL daoI An aaunuo
iu Conplainand tth
h agallant aduocatu wan plot Sabuui
iscondacd and sugpondod foa 6 year fand gudy o paolosaignud
JUDGEMENT
9n thun coaa bu apalland adWacatL
gada siguans u Cannpdauard an
blank Vavalabngama. and blank twalolavarkid
PapgmD. hu Complauant
agpolland did oud s thi auladiom 3uu Aiaciplimay Canwnucdaa
thn on Couneil y ndia diamisad Mu apel and hdd Ahl oadan
Hh Aiaopbinay Commuieles o h ulan
faaduah Counl rugt
although it opnud had ibut o u punisbmundBancoul ba nnposed
 6

THE DISC IPLINARY COmpITTEE OF THE BAR COUNCIL

Of INDIA 81-67-99
14/1997 DATED:
b.e AtPEAL No
S'K NQGAR sppclland
v.9
VP JAIN Kuopondeni
PaundSHRT 8'3 RATHORE , CHAIR MAN
SHRI ARON MSHRA , CHAIRDUAN, 6C]
SHA1 0 LOKES|, MEMBER
dduoals lcd CAcl No 25 190) olion 95,37deab uilh gusas
faagexBmal Ruxmdud by fnand, inung q{abt ikrnalon ar Pg
alon and fabucakd dacunenl conu clontaboud pondonoj q
Cao lorow caot Man ded eon Councd Ropoithan mpos
in Cowu
Punu&hnendyan d&uopenoionfonmt paacdcs Ban Counelda
nhaniaoPlunialyawnd do Riu pard uaponoLon. gan paaciucd tulh
Cag ad Ab. 5,000 Pert au
i
drol Msna
JUbGEMENT DATED S1.7./999
Shuo
Ja an aealauouing aul qtlu onden dalad &-3-97 uducA
Julao paped by iu ear Cauned o Rainsthan al jalhpur u m
oVan allgod ihat tu had nnaedslvu 3-K nagan, adnscall D5
a Cpmplaud ogunot Shui cuai oland and hu gnil uman o
DMnauar posboADon q thu Rom and arlicloo yog ntn
aaoius eo uduu poud o thu naopronderd Shu nphoudleni2
thl asuanck p u Camdanant tiat caon waD beury mocobao.
Dul.u Caplanant stalid hat pu facto oauyalad by u
qupondord kts.baks tros> ebjecluono uo tded.
Fimalby, a punshmend u yavd suepenoon Luikh tos
RB,00 1o bi pand ky i asponmdond toJt an Counel a Ondal
 SOPREIE COORT OF JNDIA
IvIL APPEAL No l124 1998 05-2-20oo
b.PeHADHA VS
Hpelland
KUal NARAIN NISHRA GOTHERS. . Rupomdunis
Praend: JUSTICE DP A9 ANAND
JUSTICE RC LAHOTI
JUS1I CE kG« BALAKR13HWAN
Sdcalid Acl, 1961, actin 95 daado ith putisrd istnduel
Kaopondlond ilas tanplaznt aggunet agpollaod and thi othub in Uu bat
Ctunod oy 9ndla (Rojaihan) Jhat Jusad enged thu sPRlaa
o Counael
ondapomdung thi
caal a eniehan
om 1ananllo panu
0D, duhthË was Kiun a dchonl and o he dad Aomo
60n conlnony) an aud m Y,F
electuon thnou hi qqpollant Aank
Vanalanama ond a blaau prolsimad by du Carplanand,Uu
blank yakaatnanra uoaA doi enadoimg shai AridShauma, Adrocad
u CompnomRI uao
ddsmntedsto th imoneot a hu copana
yet facim a ConplmioA and io wuaihucolion.
1u
begt fo ih aHics s Cavplaundnt in 3pl uan menn,
anpll Lnt
and opontumuly boung auaulabll foa M purpa3s
Shu appaland uuao hold guilty a papkebxuonal onacor daç
y opathan Ban Coumed and uao punioeb uith suaperolan
a pund 5 goand Kom praelves pin juolica. Lahadi
Shai b P Chadha , aduecals, th agpelandho ben hatu
8ualH Pignal ucanduot ej Rajethan on Caunail
and Punsksd lh sugperbtan f praotics hoa 6 yearp
hi nl &hana, aduocali nao alos paareelod 9gaunof
 38
along uilh Siui bP ChoJpa , adnacal! and hi to hau
eDn ound gulby uao uprimandad, dn appeal pouysred
h i b P chadha adudcall undon Ackon 914 th
,
Bar
ndcall ed.196/haomul only hen diaminsd bs iu
Coumcl o ndia jaochoun to ua1 Tu punihnuri hl
agpollant y enhaury fo peuad o uopenoLen {m
Paacuc fol a peniod ey fiu as.
 THE DISCIfLINARY COmmITTEE OF THE DAR
COUNCIL OF INDIA
eAfPEAL No 9/1999 Doled 5-9-99
RN TIHARI. pealland
VS
KETAN SHAH Runpondord
Prupand
SHRI RAM CHANBRA JHA, CHAIRMAN
SHRI RAVI KIRAN MATHUR, MEMBER
SHRI SANTAY KR JHA,
MEMBER
hocalt el 1961, &ic 96(9(a) and Car Cauneil qhda Kobi
97, Chacb daalo Auth paojosaiomal Maconducd
sppellaxd ahugeati uuas dolondura thuaccuand in ih
Couul, ap
accuond Juab ønfonad o doalh, egaunat auhuol -rual
0d apealkuojous (Ligh Coud e adya faadoh. e audden aDNan
aPpolkand (iled wrat peilion n' High Chud alorg ulh hu
|44dauten bohal o thu accuoRd hon botten Artadnd nporaona a
|Lwhunten Khu avads slali Nd a.dnitlng thuwn that uoo accnaLd
LALD Shel doad khu daceomd.No wuen mvblsucluon u
acouAR io b auch a Juut appliraian Jaud in Jhu &iud wutby
enam
dauf uD ahtum by hu coreamod adwocads Juhuoh
wa0 ma\
Perymisebl in any vuoA G tu amallua .91 io movn ihu poocluei
Semo ayfdani bu lhu adwocoli om btraly o cdunh
discpluna comnufed o lhu Bon Coumod Ondia hao b0m
Conatod uilh pouon Jo e thar samdando
paedalom h
elunli
apenoom w agpolland ahall bi allomad lo coninu en
 l
Legal patiDn thi {alh al gnunal public honuando
fdvocaus sall bi ahakon
JUDGE MENT
punishmurd by u Trual
falton malah uao auuordod caatas
uao rdiuoloo
COud and ua Anocod o doalh uhos caog
uwoo Alod the
apaa
y u apolland and if uaothu agpollad uhuch uno
baou to igh Caunl udicaluu ad Jabalpu
oUmbened ao cumunal appeal No.131||1497, u0D Jug
m lgaJ
thal agpolland shauld oef ps alloud 1o conbnus
ofepdean 00 faud shaud ma1kbs alons to tti cleant) and
a ugll ao uoK ahadd u cavued aul un a han uay
 THE DISCIPLINARY CO MMITTEE Of THE BAR
COUNCIL OF INDIA
D.e APPEAL No 1811999 baled t5, 4.9000
ASHOR KUM AR KAPUR
IS
APpoland
DAR COUNCIL OF
PlRAond
PUNT BG HARYANA . . kupondrd
SHRI RC JHA
SHRI CIAIRDAN
,

INDRAJIT MAANTY
SHRIMANOJ kUAR MISHRA,MEMBER
sdvocalus Aicd (Ad MEBEK
9ndun Rul, 1918 no
a601961)
CHAPTER
Aac 355 C)
(D and baa
, Saclion 1, Raulb1 ban Cauned
Payaaonad uacandud.loelland uo0 and 4 daabo uth
o bislTue ban
paetialiom umonad 4am ontmb
Qd blocwmaudiung gnd on 1hi
allonlion al jnaud, chualrg
Apalland had fled s miliatad
Ca0D
guomolu discplinay acanolan
gauno Mon'bli High Cauvd,Abolu Aigbuct ConaunmuA foauwm
glau d,Aub-Judgyo and ohA
Juducal cong
Meldthal u appollani sith oblqu meliue jad Lils ho8
Caw burg Junu aual u farl !hat it tuao oel maumlaimabll
@nd uao Auolauo. Amadvocalltaking
Shald a|bi adniantag q uo posi-li
allouad anisulijia Jun posiliom do an advocal
to
o vicimg amd Jar0od ggnunal puhlie includung
ocaAD, ond hulb guilHy Pahasainnad ristomdidjadicial
JUDaEMENT
hun agpoa arag ad oh jdgzmund
askad by ihe ban louno
rdLaCPuniabd Haypna) im digciplinwuy Cannnmy fe eniie
No.46 1998 mposuno PuATishmard umbual q hu oramtl 6qp
ard uon Lii qall
gslab Ban Cauned q ndia ndu dicllon8b
t(D %h1 odduocali D, 1961