Professional Documents
Culture Documents
doi: 10.1093/ve/veab032
Research Article
Abstract
Mycovirus diversity is generally analyzed from isolates of fungal culture isolates at a single point in time as a snapshot. The
stability of mycovirus composition within the same geographical location over time remains unclear. Not knowing how the
population fluctuates in the field can be a source of unpredictability in the successful application of virocontrol. To better
understand the changes over time, we monitored the interannual dynamics and abundance of mycoviruses infecting
Sclerotinia sclerotiorum at a rapeseed-growing field for three years. We found that the virome in S. sclerotiorum harbors unique
mycovirus compositions each year. In total, sixty-eight mycoviruses were identified, among which twenty-four were
detected in all three successive years. These twenty-four mycoviruses can be classified as the members of the core virome
in this S. sclerotiorum population, which show persistence and relatively high transmissibility under field conditions. Nearly
two-thirds of the mycoviruses have positive-sense, single-stranded RNA genomes and were found consistently across all
three years. Moreover, twenty-eight mycoviruses are newly described, including four novel, multi-segmented narnaviruses,
and four unique bunyaviruses. Overall, the newly discovered mycoviruses in this study belong to as many as twenty
families, into which eight were first identified in S. sclerotiorum, demonstrating evolutionarily diverse viromes. Our findings
not only shed light on the annual variation of mycovirus diversity but also provide important virus evolutionary clues.
Key words: Sclerotinia sclerotiorum; core mycoviruses; interannual dynamics; diversity; evolution.
1
2 | Virus Evolution, 2021, Vol. 7, No. 1
revealed a remarkable diversity of viruses sampled from various to obtain 100 isolates of S. sclerotiorum. A total of 300 isolates
cellular organisms in the past few decades (Zhang et al. 2019). were purified for three years. All isolates were cultured on po-
The uncovering of the virosphere diversity has rapidly trans- tato dextrose agar at 20 C and stored at 4 C.
formed our understanding of virus diversity and evolution
(Zhang et al. 2018). A typical virus has a coat protein that encap-
sidate the viral genome to form a virion (Krupovic and Koonin 2.2 Total RNA extraction and RNA sequencing
2017). However, many positive-sense single-stranded RNA vi- Total RNA of each isolate was extracted from mycelia using an
ruses are capsidless, including Narnaviridae, Mitoviridae, RNAiso Plus kit (TaKaRa, China) according to the manufac-
Hypoviridae, Endornaviridae, Umbravirus, among several others
turer’s instructions and then treated with DNase I. The concen-
From the pith of rapeseed stems in the late stage of the disease, We used the assembled contigs and S. sclerotiorum transcripts as
sclerotia were collected annually for three years from 2016 to templates for mapping with the program Bowtie2 (Langmead
2018. More than 100 sclerotia were collected each year from dis- and Salzberg 2012). Next, we measured the abundance of these
eased stems (one sclerotium from each diseased stem) that sequences as the number of transcripts per million (TPM) within
were randomly sampled from a single field (approximately each sequencing library. The relative abundance of each viral
667 m2) located in Wuxue City (N29 590 3.3600 , E115 270 58.8400 ), transcript was calculated as the TPM using RSEM (Li et al. 2011)
Hubei Province, China. All sclerotia were isolated and purified and visualized in a heat map by TBtools (Chen et al. 2020).
J. Jia et al. | 3
2.5 Phylogenetic analysis of mycoviruses 3.2 Novel positive-sense single-stranded RNA viruses
To determine the evolutionary relationships among the newly In this study, the forty-three putative viruses encoded by fifty-
identified viruses, the RdRp encoded by the putative mycovi- two contigs as diverse as previously characterized þssRNA vi-
ruses was subjected to BLASTp analysis with the NCBI-nr data- ruses (Supplementary Table S2), signifying that S. sclerotiorum
base. The core conserved domain of RdRp was aligned with does harbor abundant þssRNA mycoviruses with great diversity
MAFFT (version 7.427) using the E-INS-i settings (Nakamura regardless of the geographical origins.
et al. 2018). All alignments were trimmed with trimAl (v1.4) Four novel multi-segmented narnaviruses were identified,
(Capella-Gutierrez et al. 2009) to remove low-quality regions which were temporarily named as Sclerotinia sclerotiorum nar-
2568 1 3453
A RNA1 5' G F A B 3'
RNA1 5' RdRp 3'
42 2513
SsNV3
2285 8 3271
RNA2 5' C D E 3' 1 3100
SsNV1
50 2188
173 523 664 1020 RNA2 5' Putative coat protein 3'
8 2874
1168
RNA3 5' 3' 1 3105
42 1088
257 505 RNA1 5' RdRp 3'
SsNV4
7 2970
899
RNA4 5' 3' 1 2477
2259
RNA2 5' C D E 3'
50 2173
730 1026
Nar
nav
PvNlV1 10
PVaNarna14
PVaNarna13
PVaNarna 30
PVaNarna9
PVaNa a11
3'
PVaN
RNA3 5' irid
PVa eyNLV1
PVaN
PVaNarna
PVa Narna 25
PVa arna38
1099
PvL aOrfP 4
ae
PVa arna3 7
56 805
BNlV22
Pv aOrfP lV2
PVa arna 4
BNlV23
PvL Narna2
WiNV2
NpNV1
Leps V1
Pv LaOrf lV1
PVa Narna 35
PiRV-4
PV
Pv LaOr PlV3
Narn
arn
N
PserN
PV Narn na36
arna3 2
Ss NV4 rfPlV 4
rna
N
Ss LaO fPlV
PV aNar NV1 0
5
a
N
PV Gn a2 1
aN
26
a3
a
arn 12
PV Hp SP a7
S N 20 a1
3
B
1
aN afN V1
a
3
RmcNV arn
S aN 3
a
P NlV V- S
a
FO NV
Sc VaN 4 20S
arn V
PV
Om ar V
S 21
aN PvN V2 1
2 3 rna
NV a
S
100
n 1
Af faN
PV 23 40
M
uN V
H
aN laN V- na
N ar 1
100
100
Af arn V3 m N V
e
R Va nN 1
100
ida
uN a6
100
P we NV
10
F
10
100 1 0 0 0
PV N pNV V1
10
0
B lun V2
0
vir
100
aN pN 2
100
100 B NL 1
O vNV 1
0
ar V 2
95
rna
10
PV
10
100
n
aN RsN a5 C xNV 1
0
1
0
10
C NLV rna4
10
arn V1
0
yna
100
95
100
P V uN L n a 4 2
10
a 10 1 0
PV Narn V3
0
10 0
Pol
0 0
Lh a N a r a 1 5
100
aN
a rn a 3
0
10
PV aNarn a43
10
97
0 10
AtN a 4 10 0
74
0
PV aNarn 23
10
0 10
10
97
Hla V 0
0
NV21
80
PV Narna 2
98
1 00
H
P V a N a rn a 2
3
PVa laNV1
10
0 99 9
0
0
99 0 10
Narn PVa Narn a 18
96
95 10
0
0
10
100
10
PVaN a2 10 10
1 100 PVa arna17
0 10
arn a 10000
0
10
0
SsNV 1 PVaN 1
10
1 00
99
10 0
Mm a N 1 100 99
10
0
10 0 FpNV rna16
V
MmaNV 3
100
1 74
PVaNa
10 0
SsOV5
10 0
99
MmaNV2
100 77
SsNV2 70 10 0 99
100
100 SsOV4
100 PVaOurmia91
Penoulivirus
CtNV1 100 99 100
76
HpafNV2 100
PmOLV1
98 80 84 CuOulV2
MfaNV2 100
100 84 SsOV7
100
100 SsOV6
100 100 AnOlV1
10 0
0
92 PlRV1
10 0 10 10
94 0 PoOLV
idae 98 7 79 100 100 SsOV9
Levivir
100 79 6
96 100 99 93
10
0 10
0 SsOV
98 10 10 10 74 SsOV 8
Boto
1 00 99 0 10 0
0
B631 SsO 13
85
10
V1-N
0 0
73
10
SsO V12
0
1
CpM DapiMV 1
10
99
0
SsO V3
Boto
rMV
10
80
u
100
Ama uMV1
0
EnO V2
0
r
10
10
99
92
mia
85
Bev aMV1
10 0
BO ulV1
10
10
100
0
uliv
Ss LV
0
Cas qMV17
96
100
10
100
Ss OV11
vir
0
0
C V2
10
99
10
100
M 9 Ss OV1
92
iru
100
Ss MV2 8
100
0
99
ida
0
10
99
10
Ss OV 0
0
Ss MV2 1
10
100
100
100 0
100
Sla OV1 14
s
100
10
100
Ss aMV 3
99
0
99
100
C O
100
10
A MV 3
99
S RM urV
S
100
100
100
Fp MV 5
0
cle
Ss sOV V 1-1
100
10
Bc V3 1 P O 1
ro
M V
Ss cM V4 3 C c O V1 6
M cO LV 5
u
B pM V
l
O ul 1
i
F sM
Ss Ss V3- V2
vir
LV V1
O C
M MV WX
S
M nM
1
uM V
Ep sVC 7
Ss V7-W 12
us
C sV V
Ss S
S V X
V
W aN
Ss sMV 20
M
Tu N l V 3 1
Ss V3 7
ag
H NlV 36
0
M
W MV
Ss V37
ou
Ss MV1
MV 6
Sn MV4
M
SsM 11
Ss MV
liv
Bc V4
AbMV14
M
SsM V39
SN V1
Ou
SsM V2
CrM lV7
iru
FpM V1
HNlV V1
CfM V38
SsM 25
rm
CcMV 32
SsM
SsMV a
SsM 5
s
15
SsMV 8
7
SsMV
1
SsMV2
BcMV2
SsMV9
SsMV19
CfMV1
V
SsMV33
ia
AbMV1
AaMV1
SsMV1
SsMV8 FpMV1
in
vi
V1
Mi
ru
ve
Ou bra
tov
1
s
rte
0.5 irid
r m te
ae
ia- vir
lik us
e es
Figure 1. Genome organizations of narna-like viruses and phylogenetic relationships of the members in the ‘Narna-Mito-Botourmia’ clade. (A) Genome structure mod-
els for the narna-like viruses identified in this study. The colored boxes indicate hypothetical ORFs. (B) The ML tree was constructed based on the multiple amino acid
sequence alignment of the core conserved domain of RdRps using IQ-TREE with the best-fit model ‘Blosum62þFþR7’. The first identified viruses are marked by red col-
ors, and the identified polynarnaviruses from NCBI SRA or TSA database are marked by blue colors. Sequence information of all selected viruses were supplied in
Supplementary Table S4. The numbers next to each branch represent the bootstrap support based on 1,000 replicates. All branch lengths are drawn to a scale of amino
acid substitutions per site. Host taxa are shown by circles delineated in different colors. The abbreviation ‘WX’ represents Wuxue (WX) city, which was used to distin-
guish the identified viruses in this study from the previously reported mycoviruses with more than 90% amino acid identity.
J. Jia et al. | 5
Botoulivirus, and another three belong to the genus Scleroulivirus Solemoviridae, Ambiguiviridae, Endornaviridae, Botybirnavirus, and
(Fig. 1B). one unassigned virus species. Due to space limitations, these
We identified a novel virus belonging to the family mycoviruses are described in Supplementary Text S1.
Fusariviridae, tentatively named Sclerotinia sclerotiorum fusar-
ivirus 2 (SsFV2). The assembled genome of SsFV2 is 6,281 nt in 3.3 Novel negative-sense single-stranded RNA viruses
length and encodes two nonoverlapping ORFs (Supplementary
Fig. S6A). ORF1 encodes a polyprotein with conserved RdRp and We identified five -ssRNA mycoviruses belonging to the family
helicase (Hel) domains showing 51.29% identity with previously Mymonaviridae. The sequences of these five mycoviruses ranged
described Rutstroemia firma fusarivirus 1. ORF2 encodes a hy- from 9,623 to 9,982 nt, suggesting that the complete or nearly
Figure 2. ML phylogenetic analysis depicting the evolutionary relationships of the negative-stranded RNA viruses. The best-fit model for constructing the phylogenetic
tree is ‘LGþFþR8’. The name of the virus family or genus is shown on the right. This is same as that of Fig. 1.
were not detected in the L proteins encoded by the four other We therefore propose the establishment of a new family,
bunyaviruses. A phylogenetic tree was constructed using the Mycophenuiviridae, to accommodate these similar bunyavi-
core regions of the L protein. Seven sclerotinia bunyaviruses ruses that infect fungi and invertebrates (Fig. 2).
were assigned into two clades. Four bunyaviruses (SsNYV1-4)
were well supported in one phylogenetic cluster, which was sig-
3.4 Diversity of the S. sclerotiorum virome in a single
nificantly distant from the other bunyaviruses, suggesting that
rapeseed field
these four bunyaviruses represent a new virus lineage.
Therefore, we propose the establishment of a new family, We examined the proportion of mycovirus-associated reads in
Sclerobunyaviridae, to accommodate these similar bunyavi- each library, which we found to be 4.07% for 2016SS, 9.51% for
ruses. The other three bunyaviruses (SsNYV5-7) formed well- 2017SS, and 2.89% for 2018SS (Fig. 3A). The sixty-eight mycovi-
supported clades with an invertebrate virus (Wuhan spider vi- ruses we identified from these three libraries represent four ge-
rus) and several fungal bunyaviruses but were significantly phy- nome types: positive-sense single-stranded RNA (þssRNA),
logenetically distant from members of the Phenuiviridae family. negative-sense single-stranded RNA (-ssRNA), double-stranded
J. Jia et al. | 7
A D
25 Genome type
2018
5 +ssRNA
2018 4
1 −ssRNA
2017
dsRNA
33 ssDNA
2016 10
2017 8
1
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
Proportion 36
2016 6
S. sclerotiorum Viruses Others 4
Figure 3. The diversity of mycoviruses detected in S. sclerotiorum. (A) Proportion of each taxonomic category in each library based on read counts. (B) The percentage
of each virus genome type. (C) The percentage of each positive, single-stranded RNA virus at the family level. (D) Mycoviruses belonging to different genome types
presented in each library. (E) Sankey diagram showing the compositions of mycovirome from different years of S. sclerotiorum field isolates.
RNA (dsRNA), and single-stranded DNA (ssDNA) (Fig. 3B). Botourmiaviridae and Mitoviridae families were most prevalent,
Among these sixty-eight mycoviruses, the amino acid sequen- accounting for up to 44.2% (Fig. 3C). The eleven identified
ces of twenty-two mycoviruses showed high identity (90%) to dsRNA mycoviruses included seven botybirnaviruses and four
previously reported viruses, twenty-eight mycoviruses repre- fusagraviruses (Supplementary Fig. S13). We also identified an
sented novel mycoviruses sharing low amino acid sequence ssDNA mycovirus that shared 100% identity to Sclerotinia scle-
identity (<70%) with previously recognized viruses, and eigh- rotiorum hypovirulence-associated DNA virus 1 (SsHADV-1) be-
teen mycoviruses had 70% and <90% amino acid identity with longing to the Genomoviridae family. Finally, the mycoviruses
previously recognized viruses (Supplementary Table S2). The with -ssRNA genomes were classified into three orders:
characteristics of all identified mycoviruses, including their Bunyavirales (seven viruses), Mononegavirales (five viruses), and
contig length and best hit in the NCBI-nr database, are summa-
Serpentovirales (one virus). These results suggest that mycovi-
rized in Supplementary Table S2. Based on the amino acid
ruses present in S. sclerotiorum are diverse, even though all iso-
sequences of the replicase encoded by the assembled contigs,
lates originated from a single rapeseed field.
all identified mycoviruses were classified. Nineteen of sixty-
eight (27.9%) mycoviruses had a lower identity (<45%) than pre-
viously characterized viruses, and eleven of these nineteen 3.5 Interannual dynamics of members in the
could not be placed into any established family. At the genus S. sclerotiorum virome
level, thirty-eight mycoviruses could be assigned to eleven
established genera, while the remaining thirty mycoviruses The composition of virome was different among the three
could be assigned to thirteen proposed genera and one unas- libraries. The list of putative mycoviruses was summarized for
signed genus. each library, and we found that 47, 52, and 35 different mycovi-
þssRNA mycoviruses were the most diverse class within the ruses were detected in the 2016SS, 2017SS, and 2018SS libraries,
three libraries, compared to other types (Fig. 3B). Forty-three respectively (Fig. 3D). In all three libraries, the number of
mycoviruses were þssRNA viruses, accounting for up to 63.2% þssRNA mycoviruses was greater than that of -ssRNA mycovi-
of the identified viruses, suggesting that S. sclerotiorum ruses. The number of dsRNA mycoviruses was less than that of
harbors abundant þssRNA mycoviruses with high diversity -ssRNA mycoviruses, and the number of ssDNA mycoviruses
(Fig. 3B). Among the þssRNA mycoviruses, members of the was the lowest, with only one of these viruses found in all
8 | Virus Evolution, 2021, Vol. 7, No. 1
libraries (Fig. 3D). The libraries and the taxonomy of mycovi- the Botybirnavirus genus, and one ssDNA mycovirus in the
ruses were summarized in a Sankey diagram (Fig. 3E). Gemycircularvirus genus (Supplementary Table S2).
Mycovirus occurrence changed within sampling times as fol- The relative abundances of the identified viral families
lows: 35.3% of mycoviruses were detected in all three years, showed differences among the years. Mycoviruses within the
25.8% were detected twice, and 39.4% were detected once. More Mitoviridae family were the most abundant, and their TPM
than 60% of the identified dsRNA mycoviruses and -ssRNA values accounted for more than 63.4% of all mycovirus TPM val-
mycoviruses were detected once, suggesting that these mycovi- ues (Fig. 4B). Botourmiaviruses were the second most common
ruses may have difficulty spreading widely in S. sclerotiorum or after mitoviruses in the 2016SS library, accounting for 23.2% of
that they may be easily eliminated. In total, twenty-four myco- the mycovirus TPM values, while the family accounted for only
A C 100 SsBV1
2016 2017 Not detected 98 SsBV2 Sclerobunyaviridae
SsBV3
1.2 100 SsBV4
98 SsBV5
0.9 SsBV6 Mycophenuiviridae
100 SsBV7
9 0.6 76 SsNSRV11
9 15 95 SsNSRV10
0.3 SsNSRV2-WX Mymonaviridae
SsNSRV1-WX
0.0 95 99 SsNSRV9
24 SsOpLV1 Mycoaspiviridae
-0.3 92 SsGFV1 Gammaflexiviridae
5 4 92 SsMTV1-WX Tymoviridae
-0.6 SsULV3-WX1 Ambiguiviridae
71 98 100 SsULV3-WX2
-0.9 94 SsDFV1-WX
SsDFV3 Deltaflexiviridae
2 -1.2 100 SsDFV2-WX
99 SsEV8
86 100 Endornaviridae
SsEV1-WX
80 SsEV9
SsBNV1 Barnaviridae
2018 88 HuSRV1-WX Solemoviridae
85
SsVV1 Mycovirgaviridae
B 94 SsBRV4
100 Family/Genus 99 SsBRV1-WX
SsBRV5-WX1 Botybirnavirus
100 96 SsBRV5-WX2
Mycoaspiviridae 84 SsBRV3-WX
Mycovirgaviridae SsBRV2-WX
98 93 SsFGV1
Narnaviridae SsFGV2 Fusagraviridae
Solemoviridae 100 SsNsV-L-WX1
75 Fusariviridae SsNsV-L-WX2
97 SsHV8-WX1
Relative abundance (%)
Figure 4. The abundances of mycoviruses in S. sclerotiorum from different years. (A) The number of shared mycoviruses in the virome of S. sclerotiorum in three years. (B)
The relative abundance of mycoviruses at the family level in the same year, normalized by column. (C) Heat map displaying the relative abundance of the mycoviruses
in different years according to the TPM values, normalized by row. The red columns show high abundance, and grey columns indicate not detected. Mycoviruses
detected in all three libraries are marked with green dots.
J. Jia et al. | 9
mycoviruses had changing abundances between sampling the mycovirus composition in a single field was found similar
years. to the previously reported virome, although the numbers of spe-
cies were more diverse. Moreover, most of these mycoviruses
did not exhibit any specific association to geography or plant
4. Discussion host. This result also revealed that the virome of S. sclerotiorum
Metatranscriptomics sequencing has dramatically expanded from a single crop field in the same region might not differ sig-
our understanding of virus diversity and allowed novel mycovi- nificantly from the overall virome of S. sclerotiorum sampled
ruses to be increasingly discovered in phytopathogenic fungi from other plant hosts and geographical origins. Whether
(Marzano et al. 2016; Kotta-Loizou and Coutts 2017; Mu et al. viromes in other species of fungal populations have similar
discovered in S. sclerotiorum (Jiang et al. 2013; Marzano et al. the earmarked fund for China Agriculture Research System
2016; Mu et al. 2017). Secondly, some mycoviruses could not (CARS-12).
only confer hypovirulence on S. sclerotiorum but also have the
potential to convert S. sclerotiorum into an endophyte and en-
hance the resistance of rapeseed against the phytopathogens,
Supplementary data
for example Botrytis cinerea and S. sclerotiorum (Zhang et al. 2020). Supplementary data are available at Virus Evolution online.
Third, biopriming with hypovirulent strain DT-8 could reduce
the total abundance of the potential phytopathogenic fungi (Qu Conflict of interest: None declared.
et al. 2020). Therefore, we speculate that the interannual dy-
Deakin, G. et al. (2017) ‘Multiple Viral Infections in Agaricus bispo- Liu, L. et al. (2014) ‘Fungal Negative-Stranded RNA Virus That is
rus - Characterisation of 18 Unique RNA Viruses and 8 ORFans Related to Bornaviruses and Nyaviruses’, Proceedings of the
Identified by Deep Sequencing’, Scientific Reports, 7: 1–13. National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 111:
Dell’Anno, A., Corinaldesi, C., and Danovaro, R. (2015) ‘Virus 12205–10.
Decomposition Provides an Important Contribution to Benthic Lowen, A. C. (2018) ‘It’s in the Mix: Reassortment of Segmented
Deep-Sea Ecosystem Functioning’, Proceedings of the National Viral Genomes’, PLOS Pathogens, 14: e1007200.
Academy of Sciences, 112: E2014–E2019. Marquez, L. M. et al. (2007) ‘A Virus in a Fungus in a Plant:
Dolja, V. V., and Koonin, E. V. (2012) ‘Capsid-Less RNA Viruses’, Three-Way Symbiosis Required for Thermal Tolerance’,
in eLS. J. Wiley and L. Sons, Ltd: Chichester. Science, 315: 513–5.
Suttle, C. A. (2007) ‘Marine Viruses — Major Players in the Global Yu, X. et al. (2010) ‘A Geminivirus-Related DNA Mycovirus That
Ecosystem’, Nature Reviews. Microbiology, 5: 801–12. Confers Hypovirulence to a Plant Pathogenic Fungus’,
te Velthuis, A. J. (2014) ‘Common and Unique Features of Viral Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States
RNA-Dependent Polymerases’, Cellular and Molecular Life of America, 107: 8387–92.
Sciences: CMLS, 71: 4403–20. et al. (2013) ‘Extracellular Transmission of a DNA
Thapa, V. et al. (2015) ‘Determinants of Taxonomic Composition Mycovirus and Its Use as a Natural Fungicide’, Proceedings of the
of Plant Viruses at the Nature Conservancy’s Tallgrass Prairie National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 110:
Preserve’, Virus Evolution, 1: vev007. 1452–7.
Whelan, S. P. J., Barr, J. N., and Wertz, G. W. (2004) ‘Transcription Zhang, H. et al. (2020) ‘A 2-kb Mycovirus Converts a Pathogenic