Professional Documents
Culture Documents
support their professional judgment analyses. It is not applicable to reviews of Title IV aid eligibility
during academic year 2023-2024.
When using the 2021 tax return as documentation of income adjustment professional judgments,
remember to apply the appropriate need analysis formula for the year you are awarding aid.
Professional judgments must be considered on a case-by-case basis.
Readers are reminded that they must stay up-to-date with Department of Education guidance and that
guidance supersedes anything published in this document.
Important Notes
This document was published on February 28, 2022. The FAFSA cited in this document is the
Read Me!
November 30, 2021 draft of the 2023-2024 FAFSA for non-incarcerated applicants.
FAFSA line numbers are pulled from that document.
This document will be reissued if subsequent drafts of the FAFSA, or the final version,
have been changed in a way that makes the information contained herein obsolete. See
https://www.regulations.gov/docket/ED-2022-SCC-0024/document for the source draft document.
1 Line numbers are from the November 30, 2021 draft of the 2023-2024 FAFSA for non-incarcerated applicants, which was released to the public for comment on February
24, 2022. Note that some of the tax line references in this FAFSA draft are incorrect. This table contains the correct line numbers from the tax returns.
2 Income earned from working is not a verification item if you are verifying the student or family member as a tax filer. However, you must review it for conflicting information.
It is evaluated separately for each person in a couple and if the total from any of these components (Schedule 1 line 3, Schedule 1, line 6, or Schedule K-1 (Form 1065), box
14, Code A) is negative, the negative value for that component is ignored in the calculation.
3 The fourth component of the income earned from working questions may not be available on the tax return or return transcript. If you are concerned that the income earned
from work may be incorrect, you’ll need to collect this tax form from the applicant or their family member if they have reported partnership income on Schedule E, part II.
4 The “other untaxed income” question on the FAFSA cites this tax item as one of several kinds of income that should be reported. If the answer in the ISIR to these
questions is smaller than the value on these tax lines, the FAFSA question cannot be correct and must be reviewed to resolve the conflicting information.
5 For the first time in 2021, taxpayers are required to report Archer Medical Savings Account deductions (on Schedule 1, line 23). This is very similar to the Health Savings
Account deduction and is reportable untaxed income. I have written the Department to ask whether they will include line 23 in the instructions and if this item is reportable.
Copyright 2022 | Iron Bridge Resources, LLC 4
The “Did You File a Schedule 1?” Question
FAFSA questions 35 and 82 (2022-2023 FAFSA) and questions 32 and 79 (2023-2024 FAFSA draft)
ask the applicant or the dependent student’s parent(s) if they filed a Schedule 1 with their Form 1040.
They are instructed to answer “No” if they did not file Schedule 1, or if they did file Schedule 1 but did
not report any income or deductions not listed in the instructions on page 9 of the FAFSA.
Students (and spouses) or dependent student’s parent(s) who filed a Schedule 1 to report only the
income or adjustments (deductions) listed in the table below should answer “No” to this question.
Location on Schedule 1
Schedule 1 Tax Item
2020 Tax Forms 2021 Tax Forms
This question is related to the applicant’s eligibility for an automatic Zero EFC or for their EFC to be
calculated using the simplified EFC formula. For dependent students, the answer provided by the
student’s parent(s) factors into this eligibility. For independent students, the answer is asked of the
student and, if they have one, their spouse. To qualify for one of these alternative formulas, the
applicant must meet a non-income-based criterion and an income-based criterion.
The applicant can meet the non-income-based criterion if they meet one (or more) of the criteria listed
here8:
• The student/spouse or one of the dependent student’s parents is a dislocated worker.
• Anyone in the FAFSA household) qualified for certain means-tested federal benefits in the base
year or the year after the base year.
• The answer to the “Did you file a Schedule 1?” question is “No”.
If the applicant does not qualify for an alternative formula based on one of the first two bullets, then,
effectively, a “Yes” answer to the Schedule 1 question disqualifies them from the simplified formulas.
See the EFC Formula Guide for the income-based criteria for each aid year. Note also that an
independent student must have a dependent other than the spouse who is included in their FAFSA
household size to qualify for an automatic zero EFC.
6 On the 2020 tax forms, Schedule 1, line 8 collected several different tax items. Taxpayers indicated the items reported by
writing in a word or code on lines provided on the Form. In aid year 2022-2023, if an applicant or family member reported
income or deductions on Schedule 1, line 8, they were required to answer “Yes” to the “Did you file a Schedule 1?” question if
they reported anything other than Alaska Permanent Fund dividends or the unemployment compensation exclusion. Note: the
FAFSA instructions did not mention the unemployment compensation exclusion, but it does not force a “Yes” answer to the
“Did you file a Schedule 1?” question in academic year 2022-2023.
7 The unemployment compensation exclusion (UCE) was only available in tax year 2020.
8 Again, it is the independent student (and spouse), or dependent student’s parent(s), who must meet one of these criteria.
The Refundable Child Tax Credit and Its Impact on Form 1040, line 22
The American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) “enhanced” the child tax credit in 2021 (and at the time of this
document’s publication, only in tax year 2021). From 2018 to 2020, the child tax credit for children
under the age of 18 by the end of the year was $2,000, of which $1,400 was refundable. In 2020, the
child tax credit was reported on Form 1040, line 19 and reduced the income tax after credits (Form
1040, line 22), The refundable part of the credit became available only if the child tax credit was larger
than the taxpayer’s tax burden after non-refundable credits, including the child tax credit, were applied.
In other words, the child tax credit reduced the income tax figure that used in the need analysis.
In 2021, the credit increased to $3,600 (for each child under the age of six) or $3,000 (for each child
from ages 6 to 17) and was made fully refundable. Eligible taxpayers and non-filers received half of
their child tax credit as a series of payment from the IRS during the last half of 2021. Note that these
“enhancements” (the increase in the amount of the credit, its refundability, and the pre-payments) were
limited to taxpayers with modified adjusted gross incomes below certain thresholds.
Because the credit was pre-paid to some taxpayers, the IRS changed the way the credit is claimed on
the 2021 Form 1040. For most taxpayers, the entire child tax credit is reported on 2021’s Form 1040,
line 28, as a refundable credit, instead of any of it appearing on 2021’s Form 1040, line 19, as it was in
2020. Since the FAFSA asks for the income tax after credits (Form 1040, line 22) minus the excess
advance premium tax credit repayment (Schedule 2, line 2), the child tax credit will not reduce the
FAFSA “income tax for 2021” as it had in prior years, for most taxpayers.
Here's an example. Let’s assume that a taxpayer had a tax table tax (2020/2021 Form 1040, line 16) of
$7,000, and was entitled to a child tax credit for their three-year-old child. In 2020, a $2,000 child tax
credit would have claimed on Form 1040, line 19, and would have reduced the tax after credits, (Form
1040, line 22), to $5,000 ($7,000 from line 16, minus the $2,000 child tax credit). In 2021, the entire
$3,600 tax credit is claimed on Form 1040, line 28, and the tax after credits on line 22 is the entire
$7,000. Since we subtract the income tax for 202X from the need analysis total income as part of the
federal methodology, and since the child tax credit reduced the income tax in tax year 2020 but does
not do so in 2021, the amount of tax we subtracted from the income in 2022-2023 was smaller than the
amount of tax we will subtract from the income in 2023-2024. This will result, all other things being
equal, in lower EFCs in 2023-2024 (because the tax allowance is larger) than in 2022-2023.
If you are looking at the 2021 tax return as documentation for an income reduction professional
judgment, you may want to recalculate the value on Form 1040, line 22, using the 2020 tax code, to
account for this change. You are not required to do this, but if you do, your results would be more in-
line with the results of cases where you do not use professional judgment.
Recovery Rebate Credit vs. the Third Economic Impact Payment
Taxpayers who did not receive the full amount of their third economic stimulus payment (EIP3) in 2021
can get the rest of it by claiming the recovery rebate credit on Form 1040, line 30. For taxpayers with
modest incomes, the EIP3 was $1,400 each for the taxpayer, spouse, and dependent, as long as each
of these people had a valid social security number on the date for the tax return was due. A family of
IRS Form 8915-F, Parts II and II will show evidence that income on Form 1040, lines 4 or 5 are from
2020 CRDs. If the taxpayer did not make any other IRA or pension withdrawals in 2021, the 2020 CRD
is reported on 2021’s Form 1040, line 4b or 5b, and Form 1040, line 4a or 4b will be blank.
Copyright 2022 | Iron Bridge Resources, LLC 7