You are on page 1of 9

ARGIPA (Arsip Gizi dan Pangan). 2021. Vol. 6, No.

2: 131-139
Available online on https://journal.uhamka.ac.id/index.php/argipa
p-ISSN 2502-2938; e-ISSN 2579-888X
DOI: 10.22236/argipa.v6i2.7710

EFEK TELE-EXERCISE DIBANDINGKAN DENGAN KOMBINASI TELE-


EXERCISE DAN TELE-COUNSELING TERHADAP PENURUNAN BERAT
BADAN PEKERJA OBESITAS

Effect of tele-exercise versus combination of tele-exercise with tele-counseling on


obese office employee’s weight loss

Mury Kuswari1), Rimbawan Rimbawan1)*, Hardinsyah1), Mira Dewi1) Nazhif


Gifari2)
1Department of Nutrition Science, Faculty of Human Ecology, IPB University, Bogor, Indonesia;
2Department of Nutrition Science, Faculty of Health Sciences, Universitas Esa Unggul, Jakarta, Indonesia
Email korespondensi: rimbawan@apps.ipb.ac.id
Submitted: August 5th 2021 Revised: October 23rd 2021 Accepted: November 15th 2021

How to Kuswari, M., Rimbawan, R., Hardinsyah, H., Dewi, M., & Gifari, N. (2021). Effect of tele-exercise
cite: versus combination of tele-exercise with tele-counselling on obese office employee’s weight
loss. ARGIPA (Arsip Gizi Dan Pangan), 6(2), 131-139. https://doi.org/10.22236/argipa.v6i2.7710

ABSTRACT
Obesity is one of five death risks globally. This is worsened by the increasing sedentary nature
of work, where adults spend most of their time. The ongoing COVID-19 pandemic causes many
employees to work from home. Online exercise in home or tele-exercise may potentially manage this. The
purpose of this study was to analyze the effectiveness of tele-exercise on decreasing body weight of obese
employee, or if it must be combined with nutrition tele-counseling. The design of this study is Pre-Post-
Test Quasi-Experimental. This study was conducted on obese office employee in Jakarta with two
intervention groups, one who receive tele-exercise intervention and the other who receive tele-exercise
and nutrition tele-counseling. Subjects were divided into tele-exercise (n=25) and tele-exercise and
nutrition tele-counseling (n=38). Subjects received tele-exercise 30 minutes per session, three sessions
per week for six weeks. Tele-counseling was done by WhatsApp application every day, consisting of
balanced nutrition education and calorie restriction for weight loss. Paired t-test was done on subject’s
body weight before and after intervention. The group who received tele-exercise and tele-counseling
experienced weight loss significantly with average bodyweight from 77.36±11.83 kg to 75.49±11.58 kg
(Δ=-1.87 kg, p<0.05), while the same didn’t happen on another group (Δ=0.36, p>0.05). This research
showed that tele-exercise is not very effective on decreasing obese office employee’s body weight, but
must be combined with nutrition tele-exercise to achieve significant weight loss.
Keywords: Body weight, Tele-counseling, Tele-exercise, Obese employee

ABSTRAK
Obesitas adalah satu dari lima risiko kematian secara global. Masalah obesitas
diperparah oleh meningkatnya sifat sedenter dari pekerjaan, saat orang dewasa
menghabiskan sebagian besar waktu mereka. Pandemi COVID-19 yang masih melanda
Indonesia sejak tahun lalu menyebakan banyak pekerja yang Work from Home (WfH). Olahraga
di rumah dengan metode daring atau yang biasa disebut dengan tele-exercise berpotensi
menangani hal ini. Tujuan dari studi ini adalah menganalisis keefektifan tele-exercise dalam
mengurangi berat badan dari pekerja yang obesitas, atau harus dikombinasikan dengan
intervensi edukasi gizi. Desain penelitian menggunakan Pretest-Posttest Quasy Experiment

131
Design. Penelitian ini dilakukan pada karyawan yang menyandang status gizi obesitas di
Jakarta, dan dibagi menjadi dua kelompok, yakni kelompok yang menerima intervensi tele-
exercise (n=25) dan kelompok yang menerima kombinasi tele-exercise dan tele-counseling
(n=38). Subjek mendapatkan intervensi tele-exercise latihan kombinasi selama 30 menit setiap
sesi, tiga kali seminggu selama 6 minggu secara live. Edukasi gizi dilakukan dengan
mengguakan media WhatsApp, yang terdiri dari edukasi gizi seimbang dan restriksi kalori
untuk penurunan berat badan dan IMT, dan dilakukan setiap hari. Paired t-test dilakukan
pada variable berat badan subjek antara sebelum dan sesudah intervensi. Kelompok yang
menerima dua jenis intervensi mengalami penurunan berat badan dari rataan sebesar
77,36±11,83 kg menjadi 75,49±11,58 kg (Δ=-1,87 kg, p<0,05), sementara hal yang sama tidak
terjadi pada kelompok lainnya (Δ=0,36 kg, p>0,05). Kelompok yang menerima intervensi Tele-
exercise dan Tele-counseling mengalami penurunan berat badan secara signifikan, namun
tidak pada kelompok intervensi Tele-exercise saja. Hal ini menunjukkan bahwa tele-exercise
saja tidak cukup efektif dalam penurunan berat badan, namun harus dikombinasikan dengan
tele-counseling gizi.

Kata kunci: Berat badan, Pekerja gemuk, Tele-counseling, Tele-exercise

INTRODUCTION obesity-related work stressors,


Obesity is one of the five biggest including night shift, (Karlsson et al.,
risks of death globally, contributing to 2003), work pressure (Georges et al.,
5% of death worldwide. In high- 1992), and the length of working
income countries, obesity is a third duration (Belkić & Nedic, 2007).
biggest leading cause of disability- WHO recommends employers to
adjusted life years. Increasing BMI is do a health promotion program in their
also associated with the risk of workplace, that can provide
cardiovascular disease, type 2 diabetes population-level intervention (World
mellitus, osteoarthritis, and cancer Health Organization, 2017). CDC
(World Health Organization, 2017). (Center for Disease Control) recommends
The prevalence of overweight and multicomponent intervention
obesity in Indonesia is currently 34.1%, including nutrition intervention and
doubled in the last two decades (World physical activity intervention to reduce
Health Organization, 2017). This global obesity (Katz et al., 2005). However, the
obesity pandemic is causing WHO to ongoing COVID-19 pandemic in
target the stopping of increasing Indonesia since last year is causing
obesity (Popkin et al., 2012; Roth et many employees to Work from Home
al., 2004; Swinburn et al., 2011). In (WfH), which potentially may cause
developing countries, the problem of the increase in overweight and obesity
obesity is worsened by the sedentary prevalence. In response to the
nature of work (Cawley, 2011), that is aforementioned problem, (Chen et al.,
when adults spend most of their time 2018) recommend people to do exercise
(Baicker et al., 2010). Also, some office at home without changing their
employee population is exposed to exercise routine. Tiksnadi et al. (2020)
recommended people to maximize

132
their home exercise with the online or other serious illnesses that may be
method or commonly referred to tele- worsened by doing exercise, not
exercise. Tele-exercise comes from the commuting by walking more than 2 km
prefix tele-, meaning from over a long or using bicycle, not having constraint
distance (Cambridge University Press, on doing high-intensity workout, does
2020), and exercise. Specifically, tele- not follow a specific diet, and willing to
exercise is described as exercise follow the research completely without
facilitated through the use of video pressure and/or coercion from other
conferencing technology where people. While the exclusion criteria are
individuals “meet” live via a as follows: having a chronic diseases,
laptop/television, and exercise with an currently not pregnant, or having an
instructor and classmates (Wu et al., injury. Total sampling method was
2010). utilized in this research, since the
The purpose of this study is to population of this research is under 100
analyze the effectiveness of tele- people. This research was done on two
exercise on decreasing the bodyweight group: tele-exercise intervention group
of an obese office employees, or if it and tele-exercise + nutrition tele-
must be combined with nutrition counseling group. The subjects of this
counseling and education inter- study are overweight and obese male
vention, as recommended by some and female office employees, with BMI
researchers (Anderson et al., 2001; 25-30 kg/m2. Subjects were divided
Jensen et al., 2014; Thom & Lean, 2017; into tele-exercise (n=25) and tele-
Wing & Phelan, 2005). As far as we exercise and nutrition tele-counseling
know, this is the first study that (n=38). All subjects followed this
compare the effectiveness of tele- research completely/ until the end of
exercise intervention vs. combined this study. Tele-exercise intervention
tele-exercise and nutrition counseling was given for as long as 30 minutes per
in office obese employee in Indonesia, session, three sessions per week, for 6
while the prevalence of obesity in weeks. Tele-exercises intervention was
office employee is still threatening. given online, done in every subject’s
laptop/ computer.
METHODS Nutrition education was done
The design of this study is Pretest- daily using WhatsApp media,
Posttest Quasy Experiment Design. This comprised of balanced nutrition
research was carried out from June to education and calorie restriction for
August, 2020, on obese office employee weight loss and BMI improvement.
working in Jakarta, Indonesia. The Individualized tele-counseling was
inclusion criteria are as follows: 18-45 done twice a week by an experienced
years of age, working as an officer, nutritionist, also using WhatsApp.
does not have a coronary heart disease

133
6 Weeks of tele-exercise and combination tele-exercise + nutrition tele-counselling

• Circuit Exercise
• Circuit Exercise • Tabata Exercise
• Tabata Exercise • Aerobic Exercises
• Aerobic Exercises • Individualized tele-counselling
(n=25) (n=38)
Baseline Week 6

Figure 1.
Study design

Exercises were done proportional face mask, keeping a distance of 2


to each subjects’ ability, guided by a meters minimum, and using hand
professional fitness coach and trainer. sanitizer each time data was collected
The tele-exercises intervention was from a single subject. Measurement of
done using Zoom application and was bodyweight was done by trained
consisted of strength training (circuit nutritionists, utilizing Omron HBF 375
exercise and Tabata exercise, three Karada Scan scale as a weighing tool.
sessions a week) and aerobic exercises The accuracy of this scale was up to one
(low-to-moderate aerobic exercises and decimal. Measurement was taken twice
Zumba, once a week). Every session of per measurement session.
exercises was started by 2-5 minutes The data then were entered, edited,
warm-up, followed by main exercises and cleaned in Microsoft Excel 2013.
for 20-25 minutes, and ended by 2-5 Analysis of data was done using SPSS
minutes cooling down session. The 26.0 for Mac. Kolmogorov-Smirnov test
length of exercise intervention was 6 was utilized to see the data
weeks, with bodyweight assessment distribution. Paired sample t-tests were
was done before and after an used to compare the average body
intervention. weight before and after the
Data collected were sample intervention, while an independent
characteristics and bodyweight, sample t-test was used to compare the
assessed by interview methods and mean difference between each
bodyweight scale, respectively, with intervention group. This research was
weighing that was done in office. All ethically approved with protocol
data collection procedures follow number 20-10-1309 by Komite Etik
COVID-19 prevention protocol: All Penelitian Kesehatan, Fakultas
subjects and enumerators are using a Kedokteran Universitas Indonesia.

134
Table 1.
Characteristics of subjects
Male Female
Intervention Mean Age
n % n %
Tele-Exercise 34.77± 8.66 3 12.00 22 88.00
Tele-Exercise + Tele-
37.85± 10.5 10 26.32 28 73.68
Counselling

RESULTS loss of obese office employees. There


Characteristics of subjects was was no significant weight loss for the
shown in Table 1. Most of subjects were intervention group who received only
female in both intervention group. tele-exercise, while the group who
Mean age for subjects in tele-exercise received both tele-exercise and
only intervention group was 34.77± nutrition tele-counseling intervention
8.66 years, while mean age for subjects loss their weight significantly. This
in combined group were 37.85± 10.5 proved that tele-exercise only did not
years. Table 2 shows that there was a cause weight loss, but must be
weight loss after the intervention was accompanied by nutrition education.
done. There was a significant decrease The use of online-based weight loss
in weight loss on the combined (tele- programs is gaining popularity
exercise + nutrition tele-counseling) recently. Many media introduced in the
intervention group (p<0.05), while last three decades such as hand phone,
weight loss in tele-exercise group only short message service, email and live
was not significant (p>0.05). There was video showed promising results for
a significant difference in weight loss weight loss (Das et al., 2017;
between each group (p<0.05). Hutchesson et al., 2014; Neve et al.,
2010). Other research showed that
DISCUSSION weight management programs were
This research aimed to test the effective in providing feedback from
effectivity tele-exercise and nutrition subjects, but there was not enough
tele-counseling technology on weight research that analyzed the effect of tele-
exercise (Neve et al., 2010).

Table 2.
Mean differences of bodyweight on different intervention groups
Average Bodyweight (kg)
Intervention
Before After Δ p-value
Tele-Exercise 58.82±10.31 58.78±10.43 -0.036±1.19 0.88 *
Tele-Exercise + Tele-
77.36±11.83 75.49±11.58 -1.87±2.05 0.0001 *
Counseling
p-value 0.0001 **
*Paired t-test of mean bodyweight before and after intervention
**Paired t-test of mean bodyweight differences after intervention between two groups

135
In this research, subjects who related to fitness or purchase Health
received both treatments had more devices (Blomfield et al., 2014; Mattila
positive feedback since they received et al., 2008; Neve et al., 2010; Rivera et
individualized counseling. McTigue et al., 2016). Also, the act of someone in
al. (2009) studied the approaches of putting their health-related
weight management programs in a information on the aforementioned
virtual setting. Subjects of the mobile applications provided instant
aforementioned research that complete feedback. Without direct feedback
the program lost their weight from the health service providers, self-
significantly (4.8 kg on average) after monitored weight loss was often not
12 months and gained significant enough to induce behavioral changes
improvements on health metabolic and support subjects’ engagements
markers (McTigue et al., 2009). with their original reason and intention
The significant weight loss that when that they set first on the start of a
was happening in that combined weight loss program (Rivera et al.,
intervention group was caused by 2016). All of those were proven in this
nutrition education and counseling study. No direct feedbacks that were
intervention. Nutrition education going on in tele-exercise only
intervention, if combined with intervention group may not cause a
exercises was proven to be able to direct behavioral change that led to a
decrease percent body fat (Avissa et al., decline in weight loss.
2021) and improved blood lipid profile However, this can’t all be
(Gifari et al., 2021). This combination attributed to the type of intervention
was also able to improve BMI, which only. Much electronic-based or online-
was determined by body weight based weight management programs
(Gifari, Kuswari, et al., 2021); and even were low in their compliance level and
able to improve fitness level (Kuswari engagement to purpose level (Norman
et al., 2020). Nutrition education et al., 2007). On the intervention group
provided positive effects on weight who received combined treatment, the
loss (Aldana et al., 2005; Calderon et al., compliance level was higher (63%) than
2008), since in counseling sessions, those who received tele-exercise only
subjects had a greater knowledge on (24%). Significant weight loss in this
proper diet to induce weight loss. The group, with a high level of compliance,
nutrition tele-counseling session, supports the usage of combined
nutritionist gave their individualized intervention in the workplace setting.
feedback to guide subjects on positive Moreover, this also proved that the use
behavioral change. Even though it is of this combined intervention was as
known that self-monitored weight loss effective as primary and community
is the most common reason for programs (Leahey et al., 2015; Thomas
someone to download mobile app et al., 2015; Wing et al., 2010).

136
SUMMARY Occupational Stress Index. Journal of
A combination of tele-exercise and Occupational Health, 49(1), 61–71.
nutrition tele-counseling was proven to Blomfield, R. L., Collins, C. E.,
be able to induce weight loss Hutchesson, M. J., Young, M. D.,
Jensen, M. E., Callister, R., &
significantly for obese office
Morgan, P. J. (2014). Impact of self-
employees. Tele-exercise alone was not
help weight loss resources with or
able to induce weight loss for obese without online support on the
office employee, and may happen since dietary intake of overweight and
its compliance level was low. Further obese men: The SHED-IT
research should include compliance randomised controlled trial. Obesity
level as a confounding factor in tele- Research & Clinical Practice, 8(5),
e476--e487.
exercise-based weight loss programs.
Calderon, K. S., Smallwood, C., &
REFERENCES Tipton, D. A. (2008). Kennedy space
Aldana, S. G., Greenlaw, R. L., Diehl, H. center cardiovascular disease risk
A., Salberg, A., Merrill, R. M., & reduction program evaluation.
Vascular Health and Risk
Ohmine, S. (2005). The effects of a
Management, 4(2), 421–426.
worksite chronic disease prevention
program. Journal of Occupational and Cambridge University Press. (2020).
Environmental Medicine, 47(6), 558– TELE- | meaning in the Cambridge
564. English Dictionary.
https://dictionary.cambridge.org/
Anderson, J. W., Konz, E. C., Frederich,
dictionary/english/tele
R. C., & Wood, C. L. (2001). Long-
term weight-loss maintenance: a Cawley, J. (2011). The Oxford Handbook of
meta-analysis of US studies. The the Social Science of Obesity. Oxford
American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, University Press.
74(5), 579–584. Chen, J. J., Cooper, D. M., Haddad, F.,
Avissa, A., Kuswari, M., Nuzrina, R., Sladkey, A., Nussbaum, E., &
Gifari, N., & Melani, V. (2021). Radom-Aizik, S. (2018). Tele-
Pengaruh program latihan olahraga exercise as a promising tool to
dan edukasi gizi terhadap promote exercise in children with
komposisi tubuh, lingkar perut, dan cystic fibrosis. Frontiers in Public
lingkar panggul pada wanita usia Health, 6, 269.
produktif di Depok. Physical Activity Das, S. K., Brown, C., Urban, L. E.,
Journal (PAJU), 2(2), 176–192. O’Toole, J., Gamache, M. M. G.,
Baicker, K., Cutler, D., & Song, Z. (2010). Weerasekara, Y. K., & Roberts, S. B.
Workplace wellness programs can (2017). Weight loss in video
generate savings. Health Affairs, conference and in-person iDiet
29(2), 304–311. weight loss programs in worksites
and community groups. Obesity,
Belkić, K. & Nedic, O. (2007). Workplace
25(6), 1033–1041.
stressors and lifestyle-related cancer
risk factors among female Georges, E., Wear, M. L., & Mueller, W.
physicians: Assessment using the H. (1992). Body fat distribution and

137
job stress in Mexican-American men workers with rotating three-shift
of the hispanic health and nutrition work. Results of the WOLF study.
examination survey. American International Archives of Occupational
Journal of Human Biology, 4(5), 657– and Environmental Health, 76(6), 424–
667. 430.
Gifari, N., Kuswari, M., Nuzrina, R., Katz, D. L., O’Connell, M., Yeh, M.-C.,
Pratiwi, P., & Wulandari, F. (2021). Nawaz, H., Njike, V., Anderson, L.
Pengaruh latihan dan konseling gizi M., Cory, S., & Dietz, W. (2005).
terhadap perubahan status gizi Public health strategies for
dewasa obesitas. Ilmu Gizi Indonesia, preventing and controlling
4(2), 107–116. overweight and obesity in school
and worksite settings: a report on
Gifari, N., Hardinsyah, Martianto, D.,
recommendations of the Task Force
Kuswari, M. (2021). Effect of high-
on Community Preventive Services.
intensity interval training and pre-
Morbidity and Mortality Weekly
meal water consumption on lipid
Report: Recommendations and Reports,
profile in overweight and obese
54(10), 1–12.
students. Malaysian Journal of
Nutrition, 27(1), 159-168. Kuswari, M., Gifari, N., & Nuzrina, R.
(2020). Latihan bootcamp membantu
Hutchesson, M. J., Collins, C. E., Morgan,
meningkatkan kebugaran
P. J., Watson, J. F., Guest, M., &
Karyawan Indofood. JMM (Jurnal
Callister, R. (2014). Changes to
Masyarakat Mandiri), 4(1), 93–100.
dietary intake during a 12-week
commercial web-based weight loss Leahey, T. M., Subak, L. L., Fava, J.,
program: a randomized controlled Schembri, M., Thomas, G., Xu, X.,
trial. European Journal of Clinical Krupel, K., Kent, K., Boguszewski,
Nutrition, 68(1), 64–70. K., Kumar, R., et al. (2015). Benefits
of adding small financial incentives
Jensen, M. D., Ryan, D. H., Apovian, C.
or optional group meetings to a
M., Ard, J. D., Comuzzie, A. G.,
web-based statewide obesity
Donato, K. A., Hu, F. B., Hubbard,
initiative. Obesity, 23(1), 70–
V. S., Jakicic, J. M., & Kushner, R. F.
(2014). American college of 76.
cardiology/American heart Mattila, E., Pärkkä, J., Hermersdorf, M.,
association task force on practice Kaasinen, J., Vainio, J., Samposalo,
guidelines; obesity society. 2013 K., Merilahti, J., Kolari, J., Kulju, M.,
AHA/ACC/TOS guideline for the Lappalainen, R., et al. (2008). Mobile
management of overweight and diary for wellness management—
obesity in adults: a report of the results on usage and usability in two
American college of user studies. IEEE Transactions on
cardiology/American heart. Information Technology in
Circulation, 129(25 Suppl 2), S102-- Biomedicine, 12(4), 501–512.
S138.
McTigue, K. M., Conroy, M. B., Hess, R.,
Karlsson, B. H., Knutsson, A. K., Lindahl, Bryce, C. L., Fiorillo, A. B., Fischer,
B. O., & Alfredsson, L. S. (2003). G. S., Milas, N. C., & Simkin-
Metabolic disturbances in male Silverman, L. R. (2009). Using the

138
internet to translate an evidence- Thom, G. & Lean, M. (2017). Is there an
based lifestyle intervention into optimal diet for weight
practice. Telemedicine and E-Health, management and metabolic health?
15(9), 851–858. Gastroenterology, 152(7), 1739–1751.
Neve, M., Morgan, P. J., Jones, P. R., & Thomas, J. G., Leahey, T. M., & Wing, R.
Collins, C. E. (2010). Effectiveness of R. (2015). An automated internet
web-based interventions in behavioral weight-loss program by
achieving weight loss and weight physician referral: a randomized
loss maintenance in overweight and controlled trial. Diabetes Care, 38(1),
obese adults: a systematic review 9–15.
with meta-analysis. Obesity Reviews, Tiksnadi, B. B., Sylviana, N., Cahyadi, A.
11(4), 306–321. I., & Undarsa, A. C. (2020). Olahraga
Norman, G. J., Zabinski, M. F., Adams, rutin untuk meningkatkan imunitas
M. A., Rosenberg, D. E., Yaroch, A. pasien hipertensi selama masa
L., & Atienza, A. A. (2007). A review pandemi COVID-19. Indonesian
of eHealth interventions for Journal of Cardiology, 41(2), 113–119.
physical activity and dietary Wing, R. R., Crane, M. M., Thomas, J. G.,
behavior change. American Journal of Kumar, R., & Weinberg, B. (2010).
Preventive Medicine, 33(4), 336–345. Improving weight loss outcomes of
Popkin, B. M., Adair, L. S., & Ng, S. W. community interventions by
(2012). Global nutrition transition incorporating behavioral strategies.
and the pandemic of obesity in American Journal of Public Health,
developing countries. Nutrition 100(12), 2513–2519.
Reviews, 70(1), 3–21. Wing, R. R., & Phelan, S. (2005). Long-
Rivera, J., McPherson, A., Hamilton, J., term weight loss maintenance. The
Birken, C., Coons, M., Iyer, S., American Journal of Clinical Nutrition,
Agarwal, A., Lalloo, C., & Stinson, J. 82(1), 222S--225S.
(2016). Mobile apps for weight
World Health Organization. (2017). The
management: a scoping review. WHO STEPwise approach to
JMIR MHealth and UHealth, 4(3), noncommunicable disease risk
e5115.
factor surveillance. World Health
Roth, J., Qiang, X., Marbán, S. L., Redelt, Organization.
H., & Lowell, B. C. (2004). The Wu, G., Keyes, L., Callas, P., Ren, X., &
obesity pandemic: where have we Bookchin, B. (2010). Comparison of
been and where are we going? telecommunication, community,
Obesity Research, 12(S11), 88S--101S. and home-based Tai Chi exercise
Swinburn, B. A., Sacks, G., Hall, K. D., programs on compliance and
McPherson, K., Finegood, D. T., effectiveness in elders at risk for
Moodie, M. L., & Gortmaker, S. L. falls. Archives of Physical Medicine
(2011). The global obesity pandemic: and Rehabilitation, 91(6), 849–856.
shaped by global drivers and local
environments. The Lancet, 378(9793),
804–814.

139

You might also like