Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A THESIS
DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY
IN
POLITICAL SCIENCE
2018
CERTIFICATE
This is to certify that Ms. Jai Kiran a research scholar, Department of Political
Science, Himachal Pradesh University, Shimla-5 has completed her Ph.D. thesis
entitled, “Participation of Women in State Politics: A Case Study of Himachal
Pradesh” under my supervision and guidance. To the best of my knowledge, it is an
original piece of research work and no part of it has not been submitted elsewhere for
any degree or diploma. In my opinion the thesis is worthy of consideration for award of
the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in social sciences. The assistance and help received
during the course of this work and sources of literature have been duly acknowledged.
She has completed the following requirements as per the UGC-regulations,
2009 for the Ph. D. degree:
a) Course work as per the UGC/ University rules.
b) Residential requirements of the University.
c) Regularly submitted six-monthly progress report.
d) Presented her work in the departmental committee.
e) Published two research papers in the referred research journal and edited book.
I recommend the thesis for submission and evaluation.
The term ‘political participation’ has a very wide meaning. It is not only related
to ‘Right to Vote’, but simultaneously relates to participation in: decision making
process, political activism, political consciousness, etc. Women in India participate in
voting, run for public offices and political parties at lower levels more than men.
Political activism and voting are the strongest areas of women’s political participation.
To combat gender inequality in politics, the Indian government has instituted
reservations for seats in local governments. Women turnout during India’s 2014
parliamentary general elections was 65.7 per cent, compared to 67.1 per cent turnout
for men. Women have held the posts of president and prime minister in India, as well as
chief ministers of various states. Indian voters have elected women to numerous state
legislative assemblies and national parliament for many decades.
Women’s organizations in India first began to emerge in the early 19th century
and later in the 1970s after a period of limited activity from the 1950s to 1970s. One of
the earliest women’s organization, Bharat Stree Mahamandal, formed in 1910 and
focused on helping women escape oppression from men. Women’s associations had
traditionally began with the help of men giving few women access to work and
education, while limiting the expansion of traditional gender roles. In 1927, the All
India Women’s Conference (AIWC) was formed to advocate for women’s education
and was helpful in the passage of the Hindu Code of Bills between 1952 and 1960.
Women were also active in the freedom movement in protesting British colonial rule
over Indian holding protests and public meetings in support of independence. The new
wave of feminism in the 1970s was in response to gender inequality issues and stagnant
development in India. The Committee on the Status of Women in India released a
report in 1974, and had a significant influence in the re-emergence of activism towards
gender equality.
The present study has been divided into six chapters. The first chapter deals
with the introduction of the topic, problem formulation, objective of the study, universe
of the study, review of existing literature, research design and methodology used for the
undertaken study.
The second chapter deals with the socio-economic and political profile of
Himachal Pradesh. This study gives us little attention to the details of socio, cultural
and economic life of the people of the state.
The third chapter deals with the political participation of women-an overview.
This chapter gives us reflection on the historical background of women in India.
During ancient period women held a high place of respect in the society, as mentioned
in Rig-Veda and other scriptures. The Vedic era was the golden era so far as
equilibrium of status and freedom between men and women, with rights of knowledge
and freedom to marry is concerned. The Rig-Vedic women played significant role in
family, society and even in political life. The position of women especially registered as
gradual decline after the advent of Muslim rule in India. The study further deals with
the various initiatives undertaken after independence for bringing improvement in the
socio-economic status and empowerment of women.
The fourth chapter deals with the socio-economic and political variables in the
participation of the women. This chapter gives us the reflection on the historical
background and political participation of the women in Himachal Pradesh.
The fifth chapter deals with the hurdles in the participation of women in
politics. The lack of women’s participation in political process can be attributed to
various socio-economic constraints under our traditional social set-up.
The last chapter gives us the summary of the whole study, along with
conclusions and certain suggestions for the women participation in the political
process.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
I want to express my deep gratitude towards all those respondents who have
been a source of information and without their kind cooperation; it was not possible
to carry out my research work.
Dated:
Dated: .............
..................
............... (Jai Kiran)
Kiran)
Place: …..…
..….....….
.....….
CONTENTS
PAGE
CHAPTERS TITLE
NO.
I THE PROBLEM OF THE STUDY 1-74
• Review of Literature 22
• Hypothesis 68
• Sampling 70
• Methodology 73
• Scheme of Chapterisation 74
1
Shashi Ranjan Tewari, “People’s Participation: A Theoretical Framework”, in Ramesh K. Arora, and
Meenakshi Hooja (eds.), Panchayati Raj, Participation and Decentralization, Jaipur: Rawat
Publications, 2009, pp. 23-24.
1
There could be three modes of participation- direct at the community or project
level, indirect or mobilisation from above. In case of direct participation the main types
include turn out in elections, contesting elections and getting elected, taking part in
election campaigns, contacting or trying to influence government policies, associational
membership. The forms of participation which engage people between elections are
important. There could be two kinds of participation namely institutional and non-
institutional. The institutional participation refers to participation in the formal
structures while non-institutional participation refers to participation in meetings,
processions, rallies etc.2
2
Prabhat Dutta, Decentralisation, Participation and Governance, Delhi: Kalpaz Publications, 2006,
p.19.
3
J.L. Singh, Women and Panchayati Raj, New Delhi: Sunrise Publications, 2007, p.375.
4
Bhawana Jharta, Women and Politics in India: Impact of Family and Education on Women Political
Activists, New Delhi: Deep and Deep Publications 1998, p.10.
5
Seymour Martin Lipset, Political Man, Bombay: VFS, 1959, p. 82.
6
Hari Mohan Mathur, Administering Development in the Third World: Constraints and Choices, New
Delhi: Sage Publications, 1986, p.19.
2
political science since the days of Plato. The Aristotle defined citizen, as one who
shares in the administration of justice and in the holding of office. The declaration of
French Revolution of 1789 says that all citizens have the right to take part personally or
by their representatives in the formulation of law. The Marxists tradition also argued
about universal political participation as a means and end of the manifestation of
human freedom. The political participation generally requires two decisions. One must
decide to act or not to act, and one must also decide the direction of this action. The
participation of active citizens in the process of political decision making lies at the
core of any democratic system.7
7
Kalpana Roy, Women and their Environment, Vol. I, Delhi: Rajat Publications, 1999, pp. 289-291.
8
Herbert Mcclosky, “Political Participation”, International Encyclopaedia of the Social Science, Vol.
12, New York: Macmillan, 1968, p. 253.
9
Report: Development Cooperation, The Role of Development Cooperation in Participatory
Development, Paris: DECD Publication, 1973, pp. 45-46.
10
Canadian International Development Authority (CIDA), Mainstreaming Participatory Development:
Experiences and Lessons of the Inter Agency Group on Participation”, Draft Working Paper, CIDA,
1997, p. XIII.
11
United Nations Development Programme (UNDP), Human Development Report, New York: Oxford
University Press, 1993, p. 21.
12
D. Sundar Ram (ed.), Dynamics of Grass-roots Governance in India: Dreams and Realities, Vol.2,
New Delhi: Kanishika Publishers, 2007, p.46.
3
According to Norman D. Palmer, “Political participation as an involvement of
citizens in such political activities which directly or indirectly influence the behaviour
and actions of private citizens by which they seek to influence or to support the
government and politics.”13 Whereas, Huntington and Nelson define political
participation as, “Knowledge about politics, interest in politics, feeling of political
competence, and efficiency, perceptions of the relevance of political, all these may
often be closely related to political action, but at other times they are not. Their study
and measurement also require techniques that differ significantly from those needed to
study behaviour along.”14
Jan Leighley is of the view that “Participation in national problem- solving and
campaign activities enhances political conceptualisation (individual’s information
about politics); as individual’s are exposed to the conflict of ideas, through
participation they develop more abstract understanding of the political system.”18 Thus
13
Norman D. Palmer, Elections and Political Development: The South Asian Experience, New Delhi:
Vikas Publishing House, 1976, pp. 50-57.
14
Samuel P. Huntington and Joan M. Nelson, No Easy Choice: Political Participation in Developing
Countries, Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1976, pp. 4-5.
15
Myron Weiner, “Political Participation: Crisis of Political Process”; Quoted in Norman D. Palmer,
Elections and Political Development: The South Asian Experience, New Delhi: Vikas Publishing
House, 1976, p. 58.
16
Sandip Kumar Ghatak, “Political Participation of Women of West Bengal: Its Nature and Extent”,
The Indian Journal of Political Science, Vol. 71, No. 1, January-March 2010, p. 285.
17
Norman H. Nie, and Sidney Verba, “Political Participation”, in Fred I. Greenstein and Nelson W. Polsby
(eds.), Handbook of Political Science, Vol. 4, Massachusetts: Addison-Wesley Publishing Company,
1975, p. 1.
18
Jan Leighley, “Participation as a Stimulus of Political Conceptualization”, Journal of Politics, Vol.
53, No. 1, February 1991, p. 207.
4
political participation is the heart of democracy. Democracy is the form of government,
where majority of people possesses the right to share in the exercise of sovereign
power. In a democratic society, power is shared and the representatives of the people
make decision concerning the society.
Modes of Participation
19
Sidney Verba and Norman H. Nie, Participation in America: Political Democracy and Social
Equality, New York: Harper and Row Publishers, 1972, p. 58.
5
Participation includes (i) the activities designed to influence the decisions of
government through pressure or persuasion to attain ends such as retaining or replacing
the existing decision makers on changing some aspects of the political system as a
whole and the rules of the political game (ii) electoral activities such as voting,
campaigning, lobbying, (iii) protests strikes, demonstrations, resort to violence.20
Lester W. Milbrath has ranked these activities in a hierarchal order. At the top
he has given those activities in which an individual participates most and goes down to
lesser degrees of participation, until at the bottom where the degree of participation is
the least. Gladiatorial Activities: (i) holding public or party office, (ii) being a candidate
for the office, (iii) soliciting political funds, (iv) attending a caucus or a strategy
meeting, (v) becoming an active member in a political party, (vi) contributing time in a
political campaign. Transitional Activities: (vii) attending a political meeting or rally,
(viii) making a monetary contribution to a party or candidate, (xi) contacting a public
official or a political leader. Spectator Activities: (x) wearing a button or putting a
sticker on a car, (xi) attempting to talk to another to voting in a certain way, (xii)
initiating a political discussion, (xiii) voting, (xiii) exposing one-self to political
stimuli.21
Schonfeld has mentioned, ten types of activities, which are often cited in the
literature on political participation these include: (i) running or holding public (or
party) office, (ii) belonging to a party or other political organization, (iii) working in an
election, (iv) attending political meeting or rallies (v) making financial contribution to a
party or a candidate,(vi) contacting a public official (vii) publicly expressing a political
opinion to convince others (viii) taking part in political discussion (ix) voting and (x)
exposing one-self to political stimuli.22
Huntington and Nelson identify and define the following common variables of
political participation; Class: Individuals of similar social status, income, and
occupation; Communal group: Individuals of similar race, religion, language, or
ethnicity; Neighbourhood: Individuals residing in geographical proximity to each other;
Party: Individuals who identify with the same formal organization attempting to win or
20
Kalpana Roy, op.cit., 1999, pp. 292-293.
21
Lester W. Milbrath, Political Participation: How and Why do People Get Involved in Politics,
Chicago: Rand McNally, 1965, p.18.
22
William R. Schonfeld, “The Meaning of Democratic Participation”, World Politics, Vol. 28, No. 1,
1975, pp. 136-137.
6
maintain control of the executive and legislative branches of government, and Faction:
Individuals united by sustained or intense personal interaction with each other.23
The Centre for the Study of Developing Societies has considered the following
activities like, canvassing for candidates; getting out the voter; raising money;
organizing meeting’s and rallies; participation in procession and demonstrations;
distributing campaign literature; other types of campaign activities; involvement in
campaign through associations and groups; attending public meetings and rallies; being
member of a political party; contacting party leaders for help in solving problems;
contacting government officials for help in solving problems; and voting.24
The voting is considered as the simplest political activity which does not
require much information, initiative and motivation as do most other political activities.
Since vote determines who holds elective office, it exerts a great pressure upon the
leaders and is called the blunt instrument of control over the government. The
campaign activities require more initiative and are more difficult than the voting, but
these activities have more collective effective upon the decision-making process than
voting. The membership in political party or voluntary organisation is the co-operative
mode of political participation. However, this mode of participation requires much
initiative on the part of private citizens. Contesting election is the highest and most
serious form of political participation than the other modes of political participation.
Protest activities- marches, demonstrations and other such direct actions-which are also
called the unconventional political participation generally considered as unhealthy for
democracy.25
Variables
23
Samuel P. Huntington and Joan M. Nelson, op.cit, 1976, p.15.
24
S. Bhatnagar, Political Theory, New Delhi: Meenakshi Prakashan, 1984, p. 279.
25
Bhawana Jharta, op.cit., 1998, pp. 14-15.
26
Madan Lal Goel, Political Participation in a Developing Nation-India, Bombay: Asia Publishing
House, 1974, pp. 89-98.
7
education, occupation, income, religion, race, family background, residence, etc.,
greatly condition political participation.27 Participation tends to be higher among better
educated, members of the higher occupational and income groups, middle aged, the
dominant ethnic and religious groups, people with political family background, settled
residents, urban dwellers and members of voluntary organisations.28
The ideological, psychological, social and political factors affect the political
participation. Ideological factors as one of vital factors that patriarchy and gender
discrimination which still exists in society, shape women’s participation globally.
Patriarchy as a system of male domination shapes women’s relationship in politics. It
constructs the hierarchy of gender relations where men are privileged. Andrienne Rich
defines patriarchy, “A familial-social, ideological, political system in which men by
force, direct pressure or though ritual, tradition, law, and language, customs etiquette,
27
Ronald D. Hedlund, “The Electability of Women Candidates: The Effects of Sex Role Stereotypes”,
The Journal of Politics, Vol. 41, No. 2, 1979, pp. 515-516.
28
Bhawana Jharta, op.cit.,1998, p. 16.
29
Seymour Martin Lipset, op.cit., 1959, p. 82.
30
Hazel D. Lima, Women in Local Government: A Study of Maharashtra, New Delhi: Concept
Publishing Company, 1983, pp. 160-161.
31
Bhawana Jharta, op.cit., 1998, pp. 16-17.
8
education, and the division of labour, determine what part women shall or shall not
play in which the female is everywhere subsumed under the male.”32
The psychological factors are also responsible for women to have low
participation in politics. Generally, men are more psychologically involved in politics
because they have more ‘sense of civic duty’, ‘feelings of efficacy’ and above all they
regard politics as their respective sphere, while women are generally unfortunate in
these matters. But voting is only marginally dependent upon psychological involvement
in politics: many individuals vote because of patriotic sentiments, traditional
commitments and group or party pressures rather than personal involvement. The
psychological variables have the most complex modes of political participation.33
According to Milbrath, it is a tradition in almost all societies that politics is mainly an
affair of men and that women should fall in line with them politically. The changes
brought by modern industrial societies are eroding this sex difference but the impact of
tradition is still visible. The men tend to be more psychologically involved in politics
than women.34
The social factors are also important which effect women’s participation in
public spheres. The women find it difficult to participate in politics due to limited time
available to them because of their dual roles in the productive and reproductive spheres.
With their primary roles as mothers and wives and competing domestic responsibilities
and care work, they are left with little time to participate in politics. In some of the
countries, particularly in South Asia, women also face cultural constraints on their
mobility.35 Nie and Verba consider protest participation outside the orbit of their study
because they consider it an illegal activity. On the other hand, Ali Ashraf and L.N.
Sharma view of the political participation refers to activity that is designed to affect
governmental decision making and actions.36
32
Quoted in Farza Bari, “Women’s Political Participation; Issues and Challenges”, Paper Presented in
Expert Group Meeting, Division for the Advancement of Women (DAW), Bangkok, Thailand, 8-11
November, 2005, pp.3-4.
33
Bhawana Jharta, op.cit., 1998, pp.15-16.
34
Lester W. Milbrath and M.L. Goel, op.cit., 1977, p. 48.
35
Farza Bari, op.cit., 2005, p. 5.
36
Ali Ashraf and L.N. Sharma, Political Sociology: A New Grammar of Politics, Hyderabad:
Universities Press, 1983, pp. 140-145.
9
influence on the life of women, who are confined (mentally, if not physically) to the
home mainly. Her identity and course of life are normally considered to be determined
by her father, brother or husband. The limited political training and socialization that
takes place for her takes place within the family and home. Practices such as female
seclusion and sex segregation, the relative rigidity of the division of labour and the
notion of the ‘naturalness’ of males and females’ work and many subtle aspects of
gender relations all contribute to the shaping of and are themselves shaped by the
ideology underlying their practices and behaviour patterns.37
37
Herbert McClosky, op.cit., 1968, p. 253.
38
Neera Desai and Usha Thakkar, Women in Indian Society, New Delhi: National Book Trust, 2001,
p. 112.
39
Manuka Khanna, “Political Participation of Women in India”, The Indian Journal of Political
Science, Vol. 70, No.1, January-March 2009, p. 57.
40
Ronald D. Hedlund, op.cit., 1979, pp. 515-516.
10
Feminism
The feminist movement emerged in around the late 19th century, with the
beginning of the first wave of feminism. Feminism, as a whole, came in three ‘wave’
dealing with different aspects of the same issue; the first wave is being the feminist
movement in the 19th and 20th century, which dealt mainly with the suffrage movement.
The second wave (1960-1980s) dealt with the inequality of laws as well as unofficial
inequalities. The third wave of feminism (1900-current) arose from the perceived
failures of the second wave. The word “feminism” appeared first in France in the
1880s, Great Britain in the 1890s, and the United states in 1910. The oxford English
Dictionary lists 1894 for “feminism” and 1895 for “feminist”. Prior to that time
“Women’s Rights” was probably the term used most commonly, hence Queen
Victoria’s description of this “mad wicked folly of women’s rights” is significant. In
the 17th century John Locke and Thomas Hobbes had observed that maternal child bond
was a primary relationship, compared to the child’s relationship to the father. The
French Utopian socialists of the 1830s and 1840s challenged the “natural order’ stating
that in the Romantic tradition, the only natural order was the mother-child bond,
paternity being a legal bond defined by civil law. Women’s voices are often difficult to
discern in the ancient world, but classical Greek Philosophers such as Aristotle and
Plato sometimes claimed to be feminist (a role that is debated). The most important
feminist writer of the time was Mary Wollstonecraft, often characterized as the first
feminist philosopher. 41
Wollstonecraft believed that both sexes contributed to the inequalities and took
it for granted that women had considerable power over men, but that both would
require education to ensure that necessary changes in social attitudes. Her legacy
remains the need for women to speak out and tell their stories. Her own achievements
speak to her own determination. The French Revolution focused people’s attention
everywhere on the cry for egalite and hence by extension but in a more limited way,
inequality in the treatment of women. In 1791, the Declaration of the Rights of Man
and of the citizen elicited an immediate response from the writer Olympe de Gouges,
the amended it as the Declaration of the Rights of Woman and the female citizen,
arguing that if women were accountable to law, they must also be given equal
responsibility under the law. She also addressed marriage as a social contract between
41
Neeru Tandon, Feminism: A Paradigm Shift, New Delhi: Atlantic Publishers, 2008, pp. 1-4.
11
equals and attacked women’s reliance on beauty and charm, as a form of slavery.42
Therefore, Feminism is a social theory which is more associated these days with
political movement dealing primarily with the experience of women. There were
various feminist theories i.e. Liberal feminist theory, , Marxist school of feminism,
Radical feminist theory Psychoanalytic feminist theory, Existentialist feminist thought,
Cultural feminism, Lesbian feminism, Eco-feminism, Post-modern feminism, Post
feminism, Black feminism, French feministic theory.
The liberal feminism, also known as first wave feminism, strives to ensure a
more equitable and gender inclusive structural changes in the society. This school of
thought seeks women empowerment through various legal and administrative reforms.
Liberal feminism strives for the greater participation of women in the public realm.43
Liberal feminists, such as, Mary Wollstonecraft’s book, A Vindication of the Rights of
Women and J.S. Mill, The Subjection of Women, Harriet Taylor’s Enfranchisement of
Women44 focuses their study on the legal and political rights of women. This discipline
demonstrates the idea of equality before law and equal representation of women in
democratic institutions.
The liberal feminism has tried to explain and analyse the unjustified restrictions
imposed upon women in the male dominated socio-economic and political order the
society. The liberal feminism has inspired women to come out from private sphere to
public life, to ensure greater participation in order to secure more power in political
realm. Similarly, Margret Mend’s analysis focuses on the biological equality and
cultivated talent of each sex. Mend’s seeks an equal participation of women in the areas
of law and governance, religion, art and science. Her focus remains to ensure the
equitable and purposeful participation of women in the fields that were historically and
culturally supposed to be dominated by men. One of the important objectives of liberal
feminism remains to rescind the gender bias in the domain of art and aesthetics. A
number of liberal theorists are critical to the role of art in demonstrating and
perpetuating female inferiority. Women are generally considered an object of art rather
than a rational and creative being, to create and evaluate the aesthetical parameters.
42
Ibid.,
43
Pankaj Dodh, “Theorising Gender: A Way to Women Empowerment and Gender Justice”, in Sarbjeet
Singh and Pankaj Dodh (eds.), Gender Justice and Women Empowerment: An Integrated Approach,
New Delhi: Regal Publications, 2013, p. 23.
44
Neeru Tandon, op.cit., 2008, pp.1-4.
12
Therefore, it becomes imperative to demonstrate that the liberal feminist scholarship
dared to strike its earliest assault against the exploitation of women in both private and
public sphere. The movement initiated a very fervent criticism against the persistent
inequality and discrimination in the society. Consequently, public institutions were
reformed and made more inclusive, democratic and egalitarian in both structural as well
as functional level.
The Marxist and socialist feminism focuses primarily on the economic aspects
of women exploitation. Marx and Engels tried to understand women operation and
exploitations in terms of the nature of material production and the concept of
alienation. The Marxist thinking about women exploitation is essentially analogous to
the alienation of the working class in a capitalistic mode of production. The powerful
capitalist exploitative culture not only prevails in the economic sphere, but is equally
implied to the exploitation of women in the narrow confine of household affairs. Engels
vividly painted the picture of women subjugation in parallel to the emergence of the
private property over an extending period of history. Due to the expansion of
civilization and material possessions, male succeeded to assert greater control over the
exchange values of produced goods. This was further fortified with the emergence of
the family, a primary unit of the society. The exclusive controls of the male over the
domestic affairs as an owner of private property further worsened the condition of
women. Women were complexly marginalized in socio-economic and political life.
Therefore, Engels suggested for the complete demolition of private domestic labour
and supported the spread public industry for the liberation of women. One of the central
themes of the Marxist feminism is that, it tries to integrate women’s emancipation in
the wider context of a class struggle against the capitalistic society. 45
13
the male through patriarchal customs and the male dominated rules and regulations in
the family affairs. The theory is chiefly concerned with the issues arising out of
‘pornography, prostitution, sexual harassment, rape and woman battering. In order to
be liberated from sexual oppression, radical feminists prescribe a strategy to create an
exclusively female sexuality through celibacy, autoeroticism, or lesbianism; they are
against heterosexuality and traditional roles of women as faithful housewives and child-
bearing machines.47 It seeks to eventually deconstruct the patriarchal power prevalence
in both public and private spaces. Radical feminism makes a clear distinction between
gender and sex. The sex stands for biological difference; while, gender is a historically
and socially constructed idea. The sublime virtues of care, affection, nurture and
motherliness were deliberately overshadowed by the patriarchal rationality and power.
The artificially allotted ‘submission’ to women; and men desire to exert exclusive
control over the nature, has led to the construction of a patriarchal culture, value system
and an economic and political structure as a historical process. The radical feminist
thinkers want to destroy the socially constructed parameters of gender differences.48
To sum up with an optimism that a new era of peace, progress, equality, justice
and respect for human rights would prevail in the foreseeable future where women
would enjoy equal socio-economic and political rights as compared to men.
Women Participation
Women play an important role in determining the destiny of a nation and they
are an integral part of society. Their greater involvement in socio-economic and
political affair becomes more important. However, history reveals that women have not
been given their actual status in the society. Socially, women are an ignored a lot in the
society. They have been and still are the victim of various social taboos in general and
particularly in developing country like India. Though, they enjoy equality but this
equality is more in legal terms rather than in reality. Women are virtually excluded
from political power all over the world. There contribution to the social and economic
development of societies is also more than half as compared to that of men by virtue of
their dual roles in the productive and reproductive spheres. Yet, their participation in
formal political structures and processes, where decisions regarding the use of societal
47
Neeru Tandon, op.cit., 2008, p. 44.
48
Pankaj Dodh, op.cit., 2013, pp. 25-27.
14
resources generated by both men and women are made, remains insignificant.
Presently, women’s representation in legislatures around the world is 15 per cent.49
Political participation of women means not only using the right to vote but also
power sharing, co-decision-making and co-policy-making at all levels. The active
participation of women in political sphere is integral to empowerment of women and
helps to build a gender-equal society as well as to speed up the process of national
development. Women’s political empowerment is premised on three fundamental and
non-negotiable principles: the equality between women and men; women’s right to the
full development of their potentials; and women’s right to self-representation and self-
determination.51
49
R.Vijaya Kumari and K. Gangadhara Rao, “Women’s Political Participation in India”, Global
Journal for Research Analysis, Vol. 3, No. 8, August 2014, p. 1.
50
Molly Joseph, Women Participation and Development Strategies, New Delhi: Kanishka Publishers,
1997, pp. 53-54.
51
Meenu Agrawal (ed.), Women Empowerment and Globalization: A Modern Perspective, New Delhi:
Kanishka Publishers, 2009, p.178.
52
K. Shamatha, “Women’s Participation in Electoral Politics”, Global Journal for Research Analysis,
Vol. 3, No. 2, February 2014, p. 196.
53
K.C. Vidya, Political Empowerment of Women at the Grassroots, 2nd edition, New Delhi: Kanishka
Publishers, 2007, pp. 2-3.
15
1893.54 Subsequently, Finland became the first country to enfranchise women in 1906.
55
Australia and Canada provided the voting right to their women counterpart in 1908
and Norway in 1913. 56 After a continuous struggle for equal political rights, women
achieved voting right in 1920 in USA and 1928 in UK. In Germany, women were
enfranchised by the Weimer Constitution of 1919. Gradually, women got universal
suffrage in all the countries of Asia, Africa, Europe America, and Latin America.
However, in the Middle-East countries women are yet to gain equal suffrage.57 Japan in
1945, France in 1947, Pakistan in 1947, China in 1949, India in 1950, Argentina in
1952 and Iran in 1963.58 In Switzerland, women are provided with the full and equal
voting rights in federal and most cantonal elections by 1971 and in 1973 same rights
were granted to women in Syria in 197359 and Iraq in 1980. In most of the countries of
the world, the right to vote to women became a reality in the 20th century. The
developed nations of the world have granted right to vote to women in the first half of
the 20th century, whereas the newly independent third world countries have given the
right to vote to women after 1945 and with their freedom from the colonial rules.60
54
Anjana Maitra Sinha, Women in a Changing Society, New Delhi: Ashish Publishing House, 1993, p. 57.
55
Yogendra Narain, et al., “Empowerment of Women”, Mainstream, Vol. 43, No.1-5, December 2014,
pp. 68-69.
56
Anuradha Chadda, “Political Participation of Women: A Case Study in India”, International Journal
of Sustainable Development, Vol.7, No. 2, 2014, p. 93.
57
K.C. Vidya, op.cit., 2007, pp. 2-3.
58
Bhawana Jharta, “Marginalization of Women in Politics: Some Observations”, in Mamta Mokta (ed.),
Dimensions of Gender Inequality in Society, Chandigarh: Shree Ram Law House, 2016, p. 80.
59
Anuradha Chadda, op.cit., 2014, p. 93.
60
Bhawana Jharta, op.cit., 2016, p. 80.
61
United Nations Commission on The Status of Women, http://en.wikipedea.org/wiki/, Accessed on
09-07-2017.
62
Convention on the Political Rights of Women, 193 U.N.T.S.135, enforced on July 7, 1954, Article 3.
16
United Nations consisting of a preamble and 30 articles, aimed at to as constitute
discrimination against women and to setup an agenda to end such discrimination. It
also highlighted the participation of women in politics.63
The first world conference on women was held in 1975 in Mexico City. 64 The
conference, along with the United Nations Decade for Women (1976-1985) launched a
new era in global efforts to promote the advancement of women by opening a
worldwide dialogue on gender equality.65 The conference recommended the
governments to formulate national strategies and identify targets and priorities in their
efforts to promote the equal participation of women in political space.66 It was followed
by a second world conference on women at Copenhagen in 1980 and a third in Nairobi
in 1985. In the UN Conference on Environment and Development in Rio de Janiero
(1992), world leaders accepted women’s vital role in achieving sustainable
development. The World Conference on Human Rights in Vienna (1993), governments
acknowledged that women’s rights are human and headed the evidence of widespread
violence against women. Further, in the International Conference on Population and
Development in Cairo (1994), women’s empowerment was recognised as a cornerstone
for effective population policies. At the World Conference for Social Development in
Copenhagen (1995), gender equality was recognised as a prerequisite for the
achievement of productive employment, social integration and poverty eradication.67
The Fourth World Conference on Women held in Beijing in 1995, took actions
empowering women to take part in politics and decision making process.68 From each
of these global conference emerged, a more powerful recognition of the crucial role of
women in sustainable development and protecting the environment: of the human
rights; of violence against women as an intolerable violation of these rights; of health,
maternal care and family planning facilities, and of access to education and
information, as essential to the exercise by women of their fundamental rights. 69 These
rights were not easy to achieve because women had to fight and vociferously advocate
63
G.A.res.34/80. 3U.N.GAOR. supp.,(No.6) at 193 UN Doc. A/34/46, entered into force September 3,
1981.
64
Kuldeep Fadia, “Women’s Empowerment through Political Participation in India”, Indian
Journal of Public Administration, Vol. 60, No. 3, July-September 2014, pp. 537-539.
65
Anuradha Chadda, op.cit., 2014, pp. 95-96.
66
Farza Bari, op.cit., 2005, p.1.
67
Kuldeep Fadia, op.cit., 2014, pp. 537-539.
68
Anuradha Chadda, op.cit., 2014, p. 96.
69
Kuldeep Fadia, op.cit., 2014, pp. 537-539.
17
their rights at various forms. When the UN Charter was being discussed for adoption,
the draft neither contained the phrase “the equal rights of men and women” nor the
paragraph prohibiting discrimination on the basis of sex. Women participants fought
very hard against such discrimination and demanded that the rights for all human
beings irrespective of their gender should be included. The ardour and initiative of
women delegates to bring to light such exclusion of women and their demand that the
UN Charter reflect gender equality resulted in incorporation of the idea of equality of
men and women in the UN Charter. It is said that, the UN Charter became the first ever
international document in the history of making to have underlined the rights of all
human beings irrespective of gender. In a similar way, references such as “All men are
brothers” in the Universal Declaration of human Rights were changed to reflect the
equal rights of men and women.
70
Yogendra Narain, et al., op.cit., 2014, pp. 68-69.
71
S.P. Mathiraj and P.S. Nagarajan, “Empowerment of India: Then and Now”, Third Concept, Vol. 24,
No. 280, June 2010, p. 37.
18
earlier policy to induct women into local government bodies through reservation of a
few seats, as a form of tokenism, and recommended the establishment of statutory
women’s Panchayats at the village level to ensure greater participation in the political
process. The Report of the Committee on the Status of Women, the observance of
International Women’s Year in 1975, the formulation of a National Plan of Action for
Women, setting up of a National Committee with the Prime Minister as the head
proved the concern for women. Since then, scholars and policy-makers diverted their
attention to the issues of women, which culminated in establishing a National
Commission for Women in 1992 and the National Perspective Plan for Women (1988-
2000).72
Further, the historical 73rd and 74th Amendments to the Constitution have
enhanced women’s participation and representation in the decision-making process at
the grassroots level and also have reduced the disparity in male and female
participation in the political processes at the local levels. These amendment Acts have
provided at least 33 per cent reservation of seats for women in the Panchayati Raj
Institutions and Municipalities and have also laid down a strong foundation towards
equal access and more participation of women in the political power structure. Today,
through the Panchayati Raj Institutions, over a million women have entered political
life in India. The states like Madhya Pradesh, Bihar, Uttrakhand, Himachal Pradesh,
Andhra Pradesh, Chhattisgarh, Jharkhand, Kerala, Karnataka, Maharashtra, Orissa,
Rajasthan and Tripura have even implemented 50 per cent reservation for women in
PRIs. The majority of members/candidates in these Panchayats are women. The
currently, 100 per cent of elected members in Kodassery, Panchayat in Kerala are
women.73
72
Ratna Ghosh and Alok Kumar Pramanik, Panchayat System in India: Historical, Constitutional and
Financial Analysis, New Delhi: Kanishka Publishers, 2007, p.171.
73
Bhawana Jharta, op.cit., 2016, p. 85.
19
participation, through a wide and varied spectrum of activities, forms the central core of
the concept of political participation.74
74
S. Bhatnagar, op.cit., 1984, p. 266.
75
Meenu Agrawal (ed.), op.cit., 2009, p.163.
20
the low and inferior status of women in society in India especially in the context of the
declining sex ratio, increasing violence and crimes against women and their
marginalized status in employment education and health sectors.
21
Review of Literature
76
Madan Lal Goel, Political Participation in Developing Nation, Bombay: Asia Publishing House,
1974.
22
attitudes of the higher authorities must change in order to be viable agencies of
development. 77
A.R. Gupta (1976) in his book, “Women in Hindu Society”, the author deals
with the political status of women in a nation is reflected in extent of freedom granted
to women in regard to their participation in the political activity. With the advent of
independence, Indian women were granted the right to all political activities with men
and their participation in the political activities of the country has also increased
whereas, it has failed to make any profound impact on women’s participation in the
actual decision making process. However, the author sum up by saying that there is a
difference in the standard of values and norms of behaviour and the objective of new
social order proclaimed by the constitution of India.78
Neera Desai (1977) in her book, “Women in Modern India”, discussed the
political status of women in India. It emphasised on the study of women’s status in
different ages in history and attempted to find out the root causes affecting the status of
women. It is a comprehensive and multi-dimensional study of women dealing with the
changing status of women in the Indian society in the past. The contemporary women
are self-responsible and they can cope-up with the changing situations by leaving aside
the burden of religion, values, customs and superstitions.79
Ranbir Sharma (1977) in his study, “Party Politics in the Himalayan States”,
he studied the various political party of Himachal Pradesh to examine the potential role
of political parties in initiating, directing and managing social, economic and political
changes in Himachal Pradesh. He has observed the growth of political consciousness
amongst the hilly state of Himachal Pradesh. He analysed that the Praja Mandal
Movement in the hilly states stimulated the growth of political states, stimulated the
growth of political awakening, even though the areas are very economically backward.
During the course of struggle being launched, a simultaneous process of their
integration had also begun. This study is helpful to know that the integration of various
tribal and non-tribal communities of Himachal Pradesh has been begun from the period
of Praja Mandal Movement and national movement to achieve the common interest.80
77
S. Bhatnagar, Panchayati Raj in Kangra District of Himachal Pradesh, New Delhi: Orient
Longman,1974.
78
A.R. Gupta, Women in Hindu Society, Delhi: Songita Printers, 1976.
79
Neera Desai, Women in Modern India, Bombay: Vora Publishing House, 1977.
80
Ranbir Sharma, Party Politics in the Himalayan State, New Delhi: National Publishing House, 1977.
23
Inderjeet Kaur (1978) in this book, “Status of Hindu Women in India”, the
author discussed that a new concept of womanhood is gradually emerging in India,
which is at odds with the traditional concept of Hindu women as a devoted wife
confined to the home. The study indicated that participation of women in politics can
be seen in parliament, in the state legislative assemblies, in other policy and decision
making bodies due to higher education, self awareness and national consciousness of
women as they are now claiming equal status with men inside and outside the family.
They are passing through a transitional stage, in which they are neither wholly
traditional nor fully modern. The cultural inheritance and traditional values did not
wholly vanish from the attitude and behaviour of Hindu women. The result of study
indicated a positive change in behaviour and outlook of middle class Hindu women.81
Jana Matson Everett (1979) in her book, “Women and Social Change in
India”, the author discussed the historical development of the women’s movements in
India from the late 19th to the mid 20th century. The author examined two campaigns of
the Indian women’s movement. The campaign for political representation provoked
none of the hostility experienced by the British and American movements. However,
the Indian campaign was more complex than is usually realized. A weakness
characterising women’s movements in both India and the west was their inability to
mobilize large numbers of people. The Indian women enjoyed greater access to the
political elite relative to the American and British movements. However, in certain
circumstances, the politics of mass mobilization was crucial for success, and the
women’s movement was not able to adapt.82
Jana Matson Everett and B.R. Chawla (1981) in this book, “Women and
Social Change in India”, the authors deals with the problems of women in India and
stated that there is a great discrepancy between the idealized concept of women and the
real life situation in which women find themselves. All over the world, women are
denied equal access with men, in opportunities for personal growth and social
development in education, employment, marriage and family, professional and political
life. In India, as in other developing countries, women are less likely than men to
continue their education to higher levels and are more likely to find themselves
81
Inderjeet Kaur, Status of Hindu Women in India, Allahabad: Chugh Publication, 1983.
82
Jana Matson Everett, Women and Social Change in India, New Delhi: B.R. Chawala Heritage
Publishers, 1979.
24
constricted in female occupations like nursing, social work, typing and stenography all
of which have low status and low remuneration.83
Maithreyi Krishna Raj (1986) in his book on, “Women Studies in India: Some
Perspective”, has described about the aspects of equality and empowerment of women.
He says that the progress for women can be facilitated by government but will only
spread further, when there is change at the level of the family that inclusion of women
in development, that is not only a issue of equality, but also of necessity. The study
describes the reservation for women in legislatures as positive step for empowerment of
the women.86
Pam Rajput and Hem Lata Swarup (1994) in this book, “Women and
Globalisation: Reflections, Options and Strategies”, it is a selection of papers
presented at the Round Table forms part of this volume. It is encompassing experience
of four continents, some of the papers conceptualise the globalisation phenomenon;
83
Jana Matson Everett and B.R. Chawla, Women and Social Change in India, New Delhi: Macmillan,
1981.
84
Hazel D. Lima, Women in Local Government: A Study of Maharashtra, New Delhi: Concept
Publishing House, 1983.
85
Sachidananda and Ramesh P. Shina, Women Rights: Myth and Reality, Jaipur: Printwell Publishers,
1984.
86
Maithreyi Krishna Raj, Women’s Studies in India: Some Perspective, Bombay: Popular Prakashan,
1986.
25
ponder over the genesis of the debt-trap; the indiscriminately applied road-roller blue
print of IMF/WB conditionality’s. Other recount actual adverse impact of wiping away
of gains of more than a century of social and labour legislation; phenomenon of
‘jobless growth’ in developed countries and spectre of unemployment in the developing
countries; the mirage of promised long term gains and inevitability of short term
misery; feminisation of work force participation and its marginalisation, casualisation
and contractualisation. Some others expound the political dimensions of exaggerated
emphasis on expansion of markets and advocacy of rolling back of the nation state and
undermining its sovereignty, in a planned conspiracy of giving the cake to the elite and
crumbs to the poor and next to nothing to women and children. Almost all papers deal
with long term alternative strategies on global, national and grassroots levels for both
transformation of the systemic mal-development and disorder and redressal of
immediate miseries. However, further research has been suggested to probe and
analyse this phenomena in depth for advocacy and lobbying.87
Uma Shankar Jha and Prem Lata Pujari (1996) in this book, “Indian
Women: Tradition, Modernity and Challenge”, has done a comprehensive study of
87
Pam Rajput and Hem Lata Swarup (eds.), Women and Globalisation: Reflections, Options and
Strategies, New Delhi: Ashish Publishing House, 1994.
88
Kiran Devendra, Changing Status of Women in India, New Delhi: Vikas Publications, 1994.
26
Indian women in this volumes. The first volume contains the history of women
struggle, role of women in national movement, politics and women franchise. The
second volume deals with the evil practice of widow burning. This sacrifice was
prevalent in India since 4th century B.C., although widow burning was legally
prohibited in 1829 but was not completely abolished and this customs was again
revived in late twentieth century in Rajasthan. The third volume analyses women’s
participation in all professions dominated by men. Resurgence of feminism in India and
their organizational development encouraged women to come out their houses for equal
rights and opportunities. Women now are keen to shoulder the responsibilities as
professional in all concerned sphere.89
89
Uma Shankar Jha and Prem Lata Pujari (eds.), Indian Women: Tradition, Modernity and Challenge,
Vol. 3, New Delhi: Kanishka Publishers, 1996.
90
Molly Joseph, Women Participation and Development Strategies, New Delhi: Kanishka Publishers,
1997.
91
K.C. Vidya, Political Empowerment of Women at the Grassroots, New Delhi: Kanishka Publishers,
1997.
27
Bhawana Jharta (1998) in her book, “Women and Politics in India: Impact of
Family and Education on Women Political Activists”, has analysed the role and impact
of family and of education on women’s participation in politics. According to the
author, family and education are the two major determinants in the political
participation of women. These two variables act as both booster as well as hindrances
in their participation in politics. The author explored how and to what extent these
variables affect the nature and scope of women’s participation in politics and
determined the variation in their participatory level. She found that a political
motivation would provide an impetus to women’s initiation into politics. Women in
themselves should develop a favourable attitude towards politics. They should spare
time and should come out of their homes to take part in political activities. It is also up
to women to prepare themselves for participating in all the processes that they have
been demanding representation. Family members should also cooperate with women by
sharing their family responsibilities and encouraging them to take part in political
activities. She suggests that there is a need to replace the traditional value system,
which is based upon inequality of sexes, and in which women play a subordinate role.92
M.R. Biju (1998) in his study, “Dynamics of New Panchayati Raj System:
Reflection and Retrospection”, has tried to examine the problems of grass root
democracy in general and Panchayati Raj administration in particular. This book was
written at the time when the Kerala Panchayati Raj Act, 1994 and the launching of the
people campaign for the decentralized planning were started by the state government.
This was a unique model for the rest of the nation. The book is divided into ten
chapters, the first chapter is an introductory one. Second chapter depicts the historical
growth of Panchayati Raj Institution in India right from its inception to the present day
as briefly as possible. The third chapter intends to focus attention to the position of
Panchayati Raj in Kerala. This chapter is divided into two parts-first half is devoted to
analyze the growth of Panchayati Raj in Kerala during the pre-integration period and
the second half is for the post integration period (1956-1997). The fourth chapter is
devoted to analyze the structure powers, functions and authorities of the Panchayati Raj
Bodies in Kerala. The focus attention of Panchayati Raj system both of the revenue and
expenditure is given in the sixth chapter. The seventh chapter is devoted to analyze the
92
Bhawana Jharta, Women and Politics in India: Impact of Family and Education on Women Political
Activists, New Delhi: Deep and Deep Publications, 1998.
28
role of people and their participation in Panchayati Raj Institution in Kerala. The
chapter ninth deals with the significance of rural development and work section in
Panchayati Raj Institutions is in chapter nine. The last concluding chapter presents
briefly the major finding on the relevance of the study and also throws light on the
present problems of Panchayati Raj in Kerala with the suggestions to solve them.93
Uma Shankar Jha, Aarti Mehta and Latika Menon (1998) in this study,
“Status of Indian Women, Crisis and Conflict in Gender Issues”, analyses of the role
played by women in most of the society all over the world. In most of the society,
women role is confined to perform the household job, child bearing and care of entire
family. Due to the developments in education, communication, change in family life,
women participation in the outside job in the urban areas has gained momentum. The
study consists of volume, the first volume deals with discrimination based on gender
and with economic issues. Second volume gives an analysis of women participation in
politics and politicization of women issues. In the third volume social theories of
womanhood in India has been critically discussed.94
M.P. Dube and Neeta Bora (1999) in this book, “Social Justice and Women in
India”, have pointed out that women are always defined in relation to men who are
taken as the norm. Women are said to be naturally caring and subservient suited to their
role as home makers. They have been seen as more governed by emotions than men, a
less developed form of the species and closer to nature. After independence, many laws
have been passed to raise the status of women but despite these laws the mass of
women remain ignorant of their rights. The book is an outcome of a seminar held at
Nainital. The authors argued that there is a moreover social pressure to confirm the
traditional ways of behaving that is another factors contributes to the low progress of
women.95
Kalpana Roy (1999) in her study, “Women in Indian Politics”, deals with the
problems which women faced in their fight for representation. Firstly, no women
93
M.R. Biju, Dynamics of New Panchayati Raj System: Reflection and Retrospection, New Delhi:
Kanishka Publishers,1998.
94
Uma Shankar Jha, et al., (eds.), Status of Indian Women, Crisis and Conflict in Gender Issues, Vol. 3,
New Delhi: Kanishka Publishers, 1998.
95
M.P. Dube and Neeta Bora (eds.), Social Justice and Women in India, Delhi: Ajay Mishra Publishers,
1999.
29
organisation focus on getting women elected at the national level and most women
have not had the economic freedom to choose their life and career. The material
circumstances and the family made inhibitions in the participation of women, many
unattached young women may be politically active, but once married, they disappear
from the political scene. In spite of the progress since independence, lack of awareness
and education and absence of knowledge about the intricacies of party politics among
many non-elite women have limited their participation in the formal political arena.
The role of money, the corruption of politics and growing violence against women has
also constrained many potential activists. Above all, if women movement is to be as
violable, recognized and important political actor, it must not isolate itself either from
the diversity of, from the myriad and other social and political movements within the
country.96
Savita Thakur Joshi (1999) in her book, “Women and Development: The
Changing Scenario”, in her studies includes two areas of Himachal Pradesh in the
district of Mandi. The areas of Nagwain and Maloh in the same district have been
selected. The study determines, the status of women in both areas, the impact of
demographic and health indicators, socio-economic and political indicators that have
been empirically established. Which will provide right to the planners, policy makers
and researchers about the grass-roots realities prevailing in the rural economy of our
country, even after five decades of independence and planned development for growth
with social justice. She concluded by saying that economic development of a region
does not help in the elevation of the status of women, which is enshrined in the social
and cultural values. For the removal of inequality based on sex and discriminatory
practices against the women, we have to shift our focus on the properties of the society
and culture instead of depending upon the economic growth model. The status of
women can be elevated only, when they are made free from economic, social and
psychological dependency.97
96
Kalpana Roy, Women in Indian Politics, New Delhi: Rajat Publications, 1999.
97
Savita Thakur Joshi (ed.), Women and Development: The Changing Scenario, New Delhi: Mittal
Publications, 1999.
30
comprehensive study on Panchayati Raj. In the first phase of the book, there are three
special articles on Panchayati Raj (i) Panchayati Raj in India-a review by the editor
himself (ii) Panchayats in Scheduled Areas by S. K. Singh, and (iii) Panchayats and
Women by Nirmala Buch. Afterwards, there is a detailed discussion on the Panchayati
Raj Acts of 25 States and 7 Union Territories of India by different scholars, i.e. on
Himachal Pradesh by R. D. Sharma and on Haryana by Ranbir Singh. However, the
chapter on Himachal Pradesh is more relevant as far as our study is concerned. He has
made an attempt to review the socio-economic profile, traditional structure of the
Panchayati Raj in India, especially the post 73rd Amendment developments. The book
is an attempt to cover the status of PRIs of the states and Union Territories of India.
This study is devoted to the detailed discussion on socio-economic profile, structure of
PRIs, inclusion of maps of the concerned state. So, this is a very relevant and useful
study as far as the study of the PRIs is concerned.98
Mastan Vali (2002) in his study, “Women and Politics”, deals with women
participation in politics. In India women’s role has been marginal in the society,
although they constitute half of the country’s population. Their involvement in politics
98
George Mathew (ed.), Panchayati Raj in India: An Overview- Status of Panchayati Raj in the States
and Union Territories of India, New Delhi: Concept Publishing Company, 2001.
99
G. Palanithurai, Capacity Building for Local Body Leaders, New Delhi: Concept Publishing
Company, 2001.
31
has been negligible all along. Their number in the legislatures including parliament has
always remained at a very low, as it never exceed 10 per cent of the total membership
of these bodies at any point of time. Nevertheless, several women played an active role
in the National Movement and also in the recent past, there is wide spread realization
that they should be emancipated and all types of discrimination against them be
avoided to enable them to play a legitimate role in the society. He also emphasized that
the emancipation of women could be possible only through the social, economic and
political empowerment by taking necessary steps in this direction. The most important
among them are the 73rd and 74th constitutional amendments, which provided
reservations in the local bodies. A Women Reservation Bill was also introduced in the
parliament and state legislative assemblies. Today, women are making ways into every
sectors of society, with the gradual improvement in their position in different fields. He
makes a detailed survey of the extent of women participation in representative bodies at
various levels, at different points of time. He also highlights the role played by the
women in the nationalist movement and suggested that political training of women
should begin at the school stage and to be spread on the local, provincial, national and
international levels. Lastly, he argued by saying that women’s political participation
will be possible by creating multi-seat constituencies with women representing a part of
it.100
32
women in the economic and social development process in the country, which has
remained comparatively neglected area attracted the attention of the planners and
economists in a big way. Since, the UN declaration of women’s Decade (1974-85), the
basic aim was to end the existing discrimination towards women, practiced in varying
degrees throughout the world. The government of India has continuously been
formulating strategies and initiating processes to bring women into the mainstreams,
there have been various shifts in policy approaches during the last 50 years from the
concept of welfare. Since its inception, development of women and children has been
implementing special programmes to improve the socio-economic status of women.
The Bureau of women’s development and micro credit development in the department
play a major role in this national endeavour for the advancement and empowerment of
women.
Finally, she suggested that efforts at all levels should be made to improve health
and education status of women and work participation of women in all the spheres. To
remove the existing traditional bias that women are good only in feminine jobs and
encourage women to equip themselves with necessary professional skills and compete
with men to make an entry into new areas. Hence, a positive solution for improving
social and economic well beings of women lies in social empowerment, economic
empowerment, gender justice and legal protection. So, need of hour is to plan and
design such strategies, which may enhance the capability of women and empower them
to cope with the negative and social impacts of the globalization process. 102
102
Shakuntla Gupta, Women Development in India: A Comparative Study, New Delhi: Anmol
Publications, 2005.
33
Manas Chakravarti and Vidyawati Agrwala (2006) in their book, “Women
and Politics in India”, have stated that the women’s participation of politics has been
gradual process with great variations in time. During the period of freedom struggle,
there are numerous instances, where women not only participated but also became
conscious of their rights and opposed the dowry system, sati system, etc. A delegation
of the women under the stewardship of Smt. Sarojini Naidu demanded equal political
rights from the British parliament. In the post-independence phase women also made
their presence felt in the parliament and the legislative assemblies. The authors have
given comprehensive account of the bills introduced in the parliament from time to
time and argues that the role of the women parliamentarians are in no way less
significant than their male counterparts. The significance of the study lies in the fact
that, it provides information with regard to role of women in parliamentary laws.103
Lalit Upadhaya (2007) in his book, “Women in Indian Politics”, have stated
about the women participation in politics in India. As India is the largest democracy in
the world and is represented by women as well, though not in good numbers. In India
women have always shown their presence in all walks of life and politics is no
exception. Since the freedom struggle movement, contribution of women has been
phenomenal, not only this, they have made a good mark for themselves in politics as
well. The evolutionary women of the 21st century begin her personal campaign to
change the world by strongly infiltrating feminine heart and feminine opinion into her
daily field of endeavour.104
103
Manas Chakravarti and Vidyawati Agrwala, Women and Politics in India, Ambala Cantt: The
Associated Publishers, 2006.
104
Lalit Upadhyaya, Women in Indian Politics, Panchkula: Better Books, 2007.
34
political situation. It also investigates, whether election to Panchayat bodies has made
any significant change in the status of women in rural areas.105
In the last, she suggested that improving the economic status of poor women
working in the informal sector of the economy, we have to devise concrete strategies
which can help to enhance the ownership of and control over productive assets by these
women. Perhaps, it will be the single most important intervention towards their
empowerment and economic well-being. Some of the assets that women can be given
are plots of land, houses, tree pattas, livestock licenses, bank accounts, membership of
organizations and identity cards. By improving the social and economic conditions of
women the author calls for fundamental changes in the laws regarding the rights of
widows to property. Though belatedly, the Indian society has awakened to the need to
make women equal partners in the socio-economic development of the country by
creating protective legislations for women, however the enactments have not been easy
to implement. 106
105
Bhola Nath Ghosh, Women in Governance in Tripura, New Delhi: Concept Publishing Company,
2008.
106
Rameshwari Pandya (ed.), Women Welfare and Empowerment in India, New Delhi: New Century
Publications, 2008.
35
D. Sundar Ram (2009) in his study, “Women Empowerment in Political
Institutions: An Indian Perspective”, deals with the issue of women political
empowerment of women in India is very complex one and highly debatable, since the
introduction of the Women’s Reservation Bill in Lok Sabha. Although women
constitute half of the India’s Population, their participation in political life has been
negligible all along. It’s often noticed that the suitable representation of women in
legislatures remains a distant dream, excluding their representation in the local self-
government institutions.
107
D. Sundar Ram (ed.), Women Empowerment in Political Institutions: An Indian Perspective, New
Delhi: Kanishka Publishers, 2009.
36
The author explains that after the independence to revive the PRIs, government
made some efforts at union and state level but outcome was not effective. The author
argues by saying that till 1993, the participation at the local level was negligible in
most of the parts of the country. Finally, the 73rd Constitutional Amendment is a
landmark development in constitutional history of independent India. The Amendment
made mandatory provisions to facilitate the process at democratic decentralization. But
the implementation of the Amendment by the state governments according to their
convenience resulted into ineffective working of PRIS. The other major cause was the
social and cultural system, which is not prepared to adopt the democratic
decentralization in real manner. At the same time, the author examines the Panchayats
extension to the Schedule Area, (PSEA) Act. The author observes or analyses that in
spite of these provisions there are lack of functions, functionaries and funds. She has
suggested a concrete strategy for strengthening grassroots democracy in India. The
study is a valuable addition to the literature on grassroots democracy in India.108
S. Lal (2010) in this book, “Women in Indian Politics”, deals with the role of
women in Indian politics. This book divided into nine chapters. First chapter deals with
the introduction, in today’s era of modernization, women have made their presence felt
in almost every field and politics is no exception, although India is known for its male
chauvinist societies since ages, the ice is now gradually breaking. Indian politics is
108
Mridula Sharda, Evolution of Panchayati Raj in India: From Traditional to Constitutionalize
Panchayats, New Delhi: Kanishka Publishers, 2010.
109
Nirmala Buch, From Oppression to Assertion: Women and Panchayats in India, New Delhi:
Routledge, 2010.
37
now defined and governed by women politicians. In most parties, the women member’s
are by and large thin on the ground, if not invisible in the actual decision-making
bodies and rarely influence the more significant party policies. The majority of women
in the Indian parliament are from the elite class, while their public role challenges some
stereotypes; their class position often allows them a far greater range of options than
are available to poorer women. The author finds that caste has been an important
feature of Indian society and political life. It is important to guard against making an
easy correlation between caste and political representation. The influence of individual
national leaders is also an important factor that militates against the “male
equivalence”. The position of women has improved down the ages and there is hardly
any field without a women’s touch and politics is now exception.110
Sarbjeet Singh and Pankaj Dodh (2013) in this book, “Gender Justice and
Women Empowerment: An Integrated Approach”, provide an integrated analysis of the
dynamics of gender justice and women empowerment. The authors analyses various
dimensions of gender justice, gender equality and women empowerment by applying a
multi-disciplinary perspective. The main thrust remains on transforming the status of
women through enhancing socio-economic security supported by effective statutory
and political enforcement. The aim of the study is to ensure greater participation of
women in decision making process based on the universal values of equality, justice
and honour.111
Nandita Dutta and Sumitra Jha (2014) in this study, “Women and Politics”,
author discussed women’s participation in politics. In a major political movement of
this century, in all movements of social change, women have played an extremely
important role. But despite participation and mobilization of women in politics, in the
broad sense of the term, we have not seen a commensurate increase in the number of
women in different level of decision making. Women’s participation in mainstream
political activity has major implications for the broader arena of governance in any
country. Women’s participation in politics is very low. Finally, the authors say where
women constitute half of the population in political system, which supports equality
110
S. Lal, Women in Indian Politics, New Delhi: Kunal Books, 2010.
111
Sarbjeet Singh and Pankaj Dodh (eds.), Gender Justice and Women Empowerment: An Integrated
Approach, New Delhi: Regal Publications, 2013.
38
and where both women and men are legally eligible for political office, women’s
participation should be equal to that of men.112
112
Nandita Dutta and Sumitra Jha, Women and Politics, Delhi: Pacific Books International, 2014.
113
Omita Goyal (ed.), Interrogating Women’s Leadership and Empowerment, New Delhi: Sage
Publications, 2015.
39
gender sensitivity implies making plans which will not ignore and further marginalize
women, but will take care of women’s special needs and make efforts to involve and
empower women.
The author further points out that gender sensitization is necessary at all levels
in all organisations. Gender sensitivity also means acknowledging that all issue
economic, cultural, social or political are women’s issues because women represent
half the human race. Keeping this aspect of gender sensitivity in mind, the volume of
the study helped us to understand various dimensions of gender inequality and give
insight into various challenges relating to gender inequality.114
Articles
Annapurna Devi and N.M. Pati (1981) in this study, “Women in State Politics
(Orissa)”, deals with the women in states politics. Both the authors found that the most
114
Mamta Mokta (ed.), Dimensions of Gender Inequality in Society, Chandigarh: Shree Ram Law
House, 2016.
115
Usha Kiran, Participation of Women in Indian Politics: Gender Justice and Political Challenge,
Delhi: Globus Press, 2016.
40
of the able, educated women, especially those from the middle class background do not
wish to get themselves involved in political activities for many reasons. Lack of
training in political organizations and the poor political socialization process makes
women dependent and develop attitude of indifference towards politics. The social
traditions engulfed with various taboos continue to look down upon women as a part of
the households, not as a part of the public life. The attitude of men is the most
important factor, which retards women’s political involvement. Their political choice is
controlled, regulated and maintained by male members of the society. Finally, women
are kept out of all kinds of major decision-making processes and are therefore not given
any chance to improve the quality of leadership.116
Avijit Pathak (1998) in his article, “Looking beyond Reservation: Need for the
Feminisation of Politics”, has discussed the issue of reservation for women in
legislative bodies. According to the author, reservation has got the symbolic sense and
can inspire women to participate more actively and assertively in the process of nation
building. However, the reservation has been reported to lose its original purpose, it is
politically hijacked and used for immediate and temporal gains. Also in the name of
reservation, the collectivities are used and invented for political mobilization. He has
emphasised the need to think beyond the reservation and to feminize the culture to have
a long-term perspective. It has been advised to initiate a mass movement by women
activists.117
Neeta Bora and Munni Padalia (1999) in this article, “Involvement of women
in India’s Political Process”, deals with the brief description of the participation of
women candidates in elections. The authors observe, that a very insignificant number
of women members have been representing at the national and state levels. They
suggests to increase women’s participation, education, financial independence, role of
political parties and a liberal social view as an essential at all levels. A change in the
social outlook will not only provide a just position to women in society but would also
increase their participation in politics at all levels. Then there would be no need for
reservation to them.118
116
Annapurna Devi and N.M. Pati, “Women in State Politics (Orissa)”, Political Science Review, Vol.
20, 1981.
117
Avijit Pathak, “Looking beyond Reservation: Need for the Feminization of Politics”, Mainstream,
Vol. 36, No. 36, August 1998.
118
Neeta Bora and Munni Padalia, “Involvement of Women in India’s Political Process”, in M.P. Dube
and Neeta Bora (eds.), Social Justice and Women in India, Delhi: Swaraj Prakashan, 1999.
41
S. Shukla (1999) in this articles, “Reservation for Women and Multi-member
Constituencies”, the author discussed about male members for fearing the loss of
power on one side, do not prefer reservation for women and on the other, political
career is not based on meritocratic considerations but it is attributed by agitation,
organizational and even physical muscle capabilities. Thus, the author apprehended
capabilities and capacities of women activists in politics, in lives of their domestic and
social responsibilities and delivering goods in competition with male leaders. The
author discussed that reservation may help distribution and development of power but
the issue of giving representation to disadvantaged groups to be given a special
attention. Therefore, the author suggested multiple or double member constituencies in
order to give representation to male and females, besides on other socio-economic
variable considerations.119
119
S. Shukla, “Reservation for Women and Multi-member Constituencies”, Mainstream, Vol. 35, No.
27, June 1999.
120
S.K. Chaturvedi, “Women Participation in Political Process”, in M.P. Dube and Neeta Bora (eds.),
Social Justice and Women in India, Delhi: Swaraj Prakashan, 1999.
42
empowerment of women. However, now women are struggling for their legitimate
place in society. Political participation of the women constitutes the foremost step in
this direction. Even in the developing countries right to vote was given to women very
late. The study reveals that even today women’s political participation is less at the
world level as well as in India. She reported that we had Indira Gandhi, the longest
serving women Prime Minister of the world but there are not adequate seats for women
in parliament. It also signifies the emerging recognition of women factor in politics and
above all their role in overall development in an economy. But illiteracy, low economic
status, criminalization and violence in politics are the main hindrances. So, it is
necessary to impart education and promote women’s economic status. The author
suggested that there should be legal reform to make the lives of women safe, secure and
dignified.121
121
Usha Narayanan, “Women’s Political Empowerment: Imperatives and Challenges”, Mainstream,
Vol. 37, No.16, April 1999.
122
Manu Bhaskar, “Women and Grass-root Politics: Theoretical Issues and Social Concern of Kerala
Women”, South Asia Journal of Socio-Political Studies, Vol. 1, No.1, January-June 2000.
43
to the urban India. Thus several efforts have been made to improve the economic status
of rural women by providing them employment opportunities. The author points out
that, it is necessary to increase awareness among the women regarding available
opportunities, their rights and responsibilities through education from grass-roots level
in rural areas.123
Nirmla Buch (2001) in this article, “Panchayats and Women”, she has
discussed about the development and the status of women in Panchayati Raj
Institutions. After a great length of discussion, she observes that despite the women’s
mass participation, role of women in the mainstream activity has remained marginal.
The author took the pragmatic side after the 73rd constitutional amendment. According
to her a number of myths became current about women’s entry. In a study conducted in
the northern state led to four myths about their entry and likely performance; their
passivity and disinterest in the political institutions; only the well to do, upper strata
women will come through reservation; women’s political connectivity, only kinds of
powerful politicians will enter Panchayats to keep the seats for them and lastly and
most importantly; women’s are only proxy name sake members and they don’t
participate in the Panchayats activities. The field data collected in the study explores
these myths without discounting existence and behaviour of some women, who would
fit into this patriarchal, oriented from but the conclusion derived by the author is that it
is only transitory position of women members. Further, they would themselves learn by
their experience about the organization and working of the system.124
C. Jayanti (2001) in this article, “Empowering Women”, deals with the women
empowerment. This article is based on the speech of President K. R. Narayanan at the
Convention on Liberal Values in New Delhi on 5th January 1996. It would be seen that,
in the evolution of human civilization, economic, cultural, social, civil and political
aspects have some together to produce, what are now called human rights. The fact
that, women rights need to be safeguarded in every parts of the world cannot be
overemphasized. The government of India has made special efforts to increase its
support for social sectors and started a number of schemes aimed at the poor,
particularly weaker section among women and the informal sectors. Thus, the 73rd and
123
S. Mehartaj Begum, “Women Rights and Rural Employment”, Kurukshetra, Vol.48, No.7, April
2000.
124
Nirmala Buch, “Panchayats and Women”, Kurukshetra, Vol. 49, No. 7, April 2001.
44
74th constitutional amendment act of 1994, marks historical events in the advancement
of women, as it ensure the one third of total seats for women in all elected offices of
local bodies in rural and urban areas. Women’s empowerment in political right will be
a decisive factor that will fortify and save the democratic politics in India from the
deterioration of standards and values, as it is experiencing today.125
Rajinder Sachar (2003) in his study, “Need for a Mass Social Movement”, he
discussed that reservation of women is not a bounty but an honest recognition of their
contribution to social development. The author has advised the political parties to
involve women seriously so that the women’s Reservation Bill becomes a law. Further,
he has laid down the role that women have to play in making the bill a reality. He
suggested that women’s organizations irrespective of political affiliations should form a
common platform with single agenda. A need for the mass social movement has been
brought forward so that women representation in parliament and assemblies could be
achieved in order to achieve gender equality.126
45
election only 44 women (exactly 8 percent of the strength of Lok Sabha) have been
elected. The author argues, the pattern of voting by women in this election, clearly
establishes the fact that a large portion of women take voting decision at their own.
Women’s overwhelming supports for the issues relating to their public and political
participation can be definitely regarded as positive pointer towards strengthening of
women politics in future. The author further points out that, women acts as a single
unit in certain respects and do not act in certain others. Hence gender reality appears to
be a layered reality.128
Gail Omvedt (2005) in his article, “Women in Governance in South Asia”, the
author has discussed the women empowerment. Although, South Asia claims to be
some of the most powerful women leaders of the world, however in over all political
participation of women remain dismal. The obstacles to women’s equal participation in
governance in these countries are embedded in socio-cultural patterns of living and the
intensely competitive nature of politics. This article examines various women
empowerment initiatives, like community management, local governance and
reservation. It also analyses the representation of women in parliament of these
countries and suggests that, what is needed is not a retreat from demanding quotas but a
128
Rajeshwari Deshpende, “How Gendered was Women’s Participation in Election 2004?”, Economic
and Political Weekly, Vol. 34, No. 51, December 2004.
129
Ramesh K. Chauhan and S.N. Ghosh, “Himachal Pradesh: Bipolar Contest”, Economic and Political
Weekly, Vol. 39, No. 51, December 2004.
46
consideration of the most useful forms of such reservations. Along with this, author
sense the women’s representation in the bureaucracy and the structures of the political
parties also has to be increased.130
Girija Vyas (2008) in her study, “Women Empowerment: Remedy for Social
Elevation”, the author has discussed that empowerment is a continuous process for
realising the ideals of equality, human liberation and freedom for all. The need for
women’s empowerment was felt in India a long back. The state concern in
safeguarding the rights and privileges of women found its best expression in the
constitution. The important policies that have vital implications for women are
‘National Policy for Empowerment of Women’, 2001. The enactment of the 73rd and
the 74th amendment, is a landmark in women’s empowerment and leadership, needs to
be implemented effectively. The author puts her views forth, that a woman needs to be
oriented towards political goals. Therefore, empowerment lies in a strong willpower
and a gender just reform in the whole system, covering the major interrelated issues. It
requires involvement of every segment of society, women as well as men, government,
laws, judiciary, political parties, as well as social reformers, religious leaders, journalist
and media.132
130
Gail Omvedt, “Women in Governance in South Asia”, Economic and Political Weekly, Vol. 40, No.
44-45, October-November 2005.
131
A. Thanikodi and M. Sugirtha, “Status of Women in Politics”, The Indian Journal of Political
Science, Vol. 68, No.3, July-September 2007.
132
Girija Vyas, “Women Empowerment: Remedy for Social Elevation”, Yojana, Vol. 52, September
2008.
47
organization and social consciousness. Empowering of women pre-supposes a drastic,
dynamic and democratic change in the perception and expectation from women in our
society, to have a sustainable development. She described that the constitution of the
India, has explicitly conferred on women as well as political, social, educational and
empowerment opportunities equivalent with men. However, due to oppressive
traditions, superstitions, exploitation and corruptions, a great majority of Indian women
are not allowed to enjoy the rights and opportunities bestowed upon them. National
Policy for women empowerment 2001 has also been discussed.
The author found that women have been subjected to exploitation for ages and
cannot break the shackles of illiteracy, poverty and tradition over night. Even today
most of the women are uneducated, having little or no property and are live forced to
traditional bounds of society. So there is a little scope for them to participate in the
process of the reformation of society. Although in some cases women have initiated to
join the political power as a means of reformer, and participation in PRIs is one of
them. However, the problem with regard to women participation in the PRIs is that
many of them especially in the rural areas are not willing to come forward to contest
the elections. Even the leader of political parties and the official are opined that women
are not reluctant to participate in politics. In most cases the reservation merely
strengthened the grip of the rural elite. The funds meant for women welfare are not
used for the right purposes. They have been accepted as equals in local bodies by men.
She suggests that periodical training, orientation and sensitization make the women
leaders perform the assigned role in a better way. So, for a woman her real
empowerment begins, when she is able to raise her consciousness of herself, shape her
own worldview and form an association with other people whose consciousness is also
being awakened. 133
133
Kamini B. Dashora, “Women Empowerment and Panchayati Raj”, Third Concept, Vol. 22, No. 262,
December 2008.
48
“second class citizens”. However the 73rd constitutional amendment act, 1993 opened a
new chapter in the history of democratic decentralization in India by developing power
to the people and gives opportunities to women folk to express their voice in the
decision making process. He explained that there are so many factors upsetting the
process of participation and level of performance of women in the Panchayati Raj
Institutions. Broadly, these factors may be categorized as internal and external factor.
He point out that introduction of women’s organization and the consequent emergence
of women leadership at the grass root level have brought about social changes in the
rural women’s life, in general and village communities in particular. Reservation has
resulted in bringing a novel group of women representative in to Panchayati Raj
Institutions.
Further, the author suggested that in order to make their participation effective,
efficient and successful, there is a need of vital change in traditional, social attitude and
patriarchal values of society. There is also need for positive attitudinal change and
mental make-up of the male folk in favour of women’s participation. They should be
given appropriate training to improve their knowledge base and capacity level relating
to their rights responsibilities and duties in the functioning of Panchayats bodies. They
should be made acquainted with the procedures of Panchayati Raj rules, regulations and
financial management. There is also need for launching more and more awareness
campaigning in favour of women’s empowerment.134
Ashutosh Kumar and Jagroop Singh Sekhon (2009) in this study, “Punjab:
Resurgence of the Congress” the authors studied the electoral politics in Punjab, where
congress improved significantly on its electoral performance in Punjab as compared to
the previous Lok Sabha elections. The slender lead in terms of votes polled enabled the
congress to march ahead of Shiromani Akali Dal- Bharatiya Janta Party combine in
terms of the number of seats won. The number was much greater, if seen in terms of
assembly constituency segments, where the Congress took lead (65) as against 44
constituencies, which were being represented by the party legislators. As for the other
parties in the fray the Bahujan Samaj Party’s (BSP) poor electoral performance
continued despite a significant presence of the dalits, which constitute more than 23 per
cent of the state’s population as against the national average of 16 per cent. The article
further argues that presence of dalits is most visible in Ferozepur and Hoshiarpur
134
Dasarathi Bhuyan, “Participation in Panchayati Raj”, Yojana, Vol. 52, October 2008.
49
constituencies. The inability of the Bahujan Samaj Party to mobilise the dalit vote also
helped the Congress, which has had a relatively good support base amongst the dalits in
different religions. The Congress also benefited from the gradual slide of the left
parties, its erstwhile electoral allies.135
135
Ashutosh Kumar and Jagroop Singh Sekhon, “Punjab: Resurgence of the Congress”, Economic and
Political Weekly, Vol. 44, No. 39, September 2009.
136
Sandip Kumar Ghatak, “Political Participation of Women of West Bengal: Its Nature and Extent”,
The Indian Journal of Political Science, Vol. 71, No. 1, January-March 2010.
50
implemented several programmes to eradicate poverty and provided education to the
vulnerable sections of society. In the end, the author point out that women’s
empowerment is the hallmark of the government’s approach in its development
initiatives, especially in terms of social, political and economic.137
137
V. Deepa Nair, “Status of Women in Andhra Pradesh: A Paradigm Shift”, Man and Development,
Vol. 32, No. 1, March 2010.
138
Arpita Sharma, “Women Empowerment: Milestone and Challenges”, Kurukshetra, Vol. 59, No.11,
September 2011.
51
in all spheres of political life and electoral competition in particular, will not only
ensure political parity and equality with men, but would also serve the larger interest
that is empowerment of women.139
It was only in the aftermath of the 73rd constitutional amendment that has
created a space for women in political participation and decision-making at the
grassroots level by reserving one-third of the seats for women all over the country. The
article also expresses deep concern on the illiteracy, economic insecurity and male
interference in the functioning of women at grassroots politics. Above all, it has been
observed in the article, that the participation of women in PRIs has changed, the male
dominance at the grassroots politics. Today, women are taking interests in politics and
are becoming aware and conscious about their rights and duties. The participation of
women in panchayats is certainly one mechanism through such a change can take
place, and the strategic gender interest of women is getting advanced.141
139
Praveen Rai, “Electoral Participation of Women in India: Key Determinants and Barriers”, Economic
and Political Weekly, Vol. 46, No. 3, January 2011.
140
A. Prema, “Women Status in India”, Indian Streams Research Journal, Vol. 2, No. 1, February 2012.
141
Rakesh K. Singh, “Elected Women Representatives in Panchayat Raj,” Social Action, Vol. 62,
January-March 2012.
52
Saroj Choudhary (2012) in her article, “Political Participation and
Representation of Women in Indian Politics”, reveals that participation of women in
Indian politics is based on the principles of equality to all its citizens. The constitution
of India not only guarantees fundamental rights and freedom, but also prohibits
discrimination on the basis of religion, race, caste, sex, and place of birth. However,
these rights have remained de jure and have not been translated into de facto rights.
Lack of space for participation in political bodies has not resulted in their say in
decision making bodies but also neglected their concerned and experiences in policy
making. Women’s disproportionate absence from the political process would mean that
the concerns of the women cannot be sufficiently attended to or acted.
In the article, the author further examine that reservation would only help
women of the elitist groups to gain seats, therefore causing further discrimination and
under-representation to the poor and backward classes among women. The most of
members argue that, it is better to create reservation of women in political parties rather
than in parliament. Simultaneously, the provision of rotation of reserved seats is also
debated. It can reduce the incentive of the elected MPs to spend energy because he or
she may not be able to re-seek the mandate from the same constituency. The Bill has to
go through elaborative procedures, as it had been already passed by the Rajya Sabha
but the real impact will be only, when it passes through the Lok Sabha.142
142
Saroj Choudhary, “Political Participation and Representation of Women in Indian Politics”,
International Journal of Behavioral Social and Movement Sciences, Vol. 1, No. 4, October 2012.
53
activity at the grass-roots level at least. The present national level indicators are also
not encouraging for the future of political empowerment of women, provided that
women’s reservation bill get passed in the parliament.143
Further in this article, her study of five legislative state assemblies i.e. Goa,
Manipur, Punjab, Uttarakhand and Uttar Pradesh reveals that women have been
accepted as voters but not as policy formulators. Gender discrimination rules the scene
even in the state legislature, where women constitute a very small percentage vis-a-vis
men. The number of women candidates contesting for the state’s legislative assemblies
has been extremely discouraging. It is unfortunate that in India even after six decades
of independence, the status and position of women in political participation and their
representation, is a myth and still a distant dream. Lastly, the author argues for the
reservation of seats and due representation for women in national and state legislatures,
not only to improve the self respect of Indian women but also to ensure the political
empowerment of women in our society.144
143
Y. Sivaramaiah, “Women’s Empowerment and Indian Elections”, Indian Journal of Research, Vol.
1, No. 12, December 2012.
144
Manpreet Kaur Brar, “Political Participation and Representation of Women in State Assemblies”,
International Journal of Behavioural Social and Movement Sciences, Vol. 2, No. 4, November 2013.
54
mindsets. Finally, he suggests that women need a safe political environment, which
provides a level playing field for their participation.145
The authors further points out by examining the multi-dimensional facets of the
participation of women in politics. But conclude by saying that there is a dire need to
carry forward an extension of the reform at grass-roots democracy by reserving the
seats for women in parliament and state legislatures.146
145
Shreedhar Barki, “Issues of Women Representation and Women in Indian Parliament”, Global
Research Analysis, Vol. 2, No.10, October 2013.
146
Thapai Ananda, et al., “Political Participation of Women in India-An Overview”, International
Journal of Advanced Research, Vol.1, No.10, 2013.
147
Achla Sharma, “Status of Women: A Socio-Historical Analysis in Different Ages of Indian Society”,
Research Journal of Language, Literature and Humanities, Vol. 1, No.1, January 2014.
55
Barsha Kalita (2014) in her article, “Political Status of Women in Assam: An
Analysis”, argues that women’s participation in politics makes the democratic system
more efficient and viable. Women have been marginalised politically in our country
and have to confine within the four wall of their household. She find that, democracy
can never function in the real sense of the term, if there is no proper involvement of
women in the decision making process in the sphere of governance. The issues
concerning women always remained neglected area, without their proper representation
at all levels. However, only by enacting legislations will also not help. In this article
the author suggested an immediate change in the social attitude and mindset of people
and civil society. The proper education, economic and financial independence has been
of immense concern to bring women out of the shackles of social evils in our society.
They need to be properly represented in the decision and policy making bodies
otherwise, will always remain unrepresented and neglected. Finally not only this the
women also need to overcome from the social taboos, evil customs and traditional
myths, if proper representation is to be ensured, this will not only empowers women
but the society as a whole.148
In this article author studied, the presence of women and their participation in
public sphere and decision-making process in India has been very low both at the
national and state levels. They are not adequately represented in the parliament and in
the state legislatures. This shows that women do not enjoy the same privileges and
opportunities, as men. Although, the country has legislation that guarantees equality
before the law. For instance, while everyone has the right to seek public office, very
few women file certificates of candidacy because they lack access to the substantial
148
Barsha Kalita, “Political Status of Women in Assam: An Analysis”, Golden Research Thoughts, Vol.
4, No.1, July 2014.
56
resources needed for a political campaign. Besides, there are many barriers in public
and private space that hinder women participation in politics. Majority of women in our
country are still struggling to deal with the burden of responsibility and handle the
various obstacles that are coming their way from their traditional cultures.
Consequently, women have never been visible in great number in the political life of
the nation.
E. Sridharan (2014) in this study, “Class Voting in the 2014 Lok Sabha
Elections: The Growing Size and Importance of the Middle Classes”, analyses the
middle class and other classes voted in the 2014 elections. He focused on the voting for
the Bharatiya Janta Party and Indian National Congress, voter preferences along the
caste/community and age groups within classes, to the extent relevant, and economic
policy, particularly as concerns economic liberalization. Author found that in 2014 the
class-wise gradation of pro-BJP responses, with pro-BJP sentiment rising as we go up
the class hierarchy, as well as the caste hierarchy, indicate support for the emergence of
a loose, not compact, “new social bloc” of class and caste privilege. This supports the
Iversen Soskice (2006) finding that majoritarian electoral systems tend towards a top-
middle alliance in the absence of a corporatist economic structure. However, on
economic policy issues, particularly about liberalization and the role of the state, the
responses are much more mixed.
149
Durga Prasad Chhetri, “Women in Public Sphere: An Enquiry into Women’s Representation and
Participation in Politics”, American International Journal of Research in Humanities, Arts and Social
Sciences, Vol. 6, No.1, March-May 2014.
57
He argued earlier the Indian middle classes attitudes towards liberalization are
complex and contradictory because a large fraction of the middle class, though
declining gradually over time with the growth of the private sector and also as we go up
the class hierarchy are public employees broadly defined. Thus, an estimated 58 per
cent to 75 per cent of the broadest middle class of 26 per cent of the population as of
the turn of the century were either public employees or rich peasants and even of the
elite middle class of 6 per cent as of 2005-06 as many as 30 per cent belonged to these
segments. Even those of the middle classes who are self-employed persons or private
employees are like public employees or rich peasants, the beneficiaries of a range of
state subsidies including water, electricity fertilizer credit fuel higher education, public
transport and even food. Hence, one can accept the middle classes political alignments
to be complexly determined by competition for patronage interwoven with identity
politics, party loyalties and ideology. Besides, the poorer classes and lower castes have
also voted more for BJP than Congress or any other party in this election, a factor that
needs explanation, and one that cannot be explained in terms of redistributive
programmes or patronage politics except perhaps in the limited number of BJP-ruled
states. Class is therefore only one of several axes of polarization in India in 2014 and
class politics in the sense of developed democracies, particularly in Europe, or left-right
axis on economic policy as in the those countries, is still not the norm in India. Overall,
given the extremely regionally skewed nature of the BJP victory, with 244 seats of its
282 coming from the Hindi-belt states and western India, accounting for only 61 per
cent of the population, we need to have regionally disagreeable survey data to be able
to fully comprehend the voting trends by class, caste/community and age groups within
each region, as well as the attitudes towards minorities and majoritarianism and
towards economic policy. Author reveals that it is too early to be able to confidently
project the trends in this election into future, he suggest that we will need to observe a
couple of more elections to see whether these trends hold.150
150
E. Sridharan, “Class Voting in the 2014 Lok Sabha Elections the Growing Size and Importance of
the Middle Classes”, Economic and Political Weekly, Vol. 49, No. 39, September 2014.
58
unfortunately in this male dominating society, the education of women has been
neglected for a long time. Empowering women is an important end in itself and will
acquire the same status with men in terms of social, economic and legal sense, their
human well-being will be enhanced. The present study, explores the role of education
in women empowerment and the status of women education in India and suggested
that, education is most important part in the life of every woman.151
151
Manav Aggarwal, “A Study on Challenge for Women Empowerment”, Journal of Research in
Commerce and Management, Vol. 3, No. 5, May 2014.
152
Mamta Mokta, “Empowerment of Women in India: A Critical Analysis”, Indian Journal of Public
Administration, Vol. 60, No. 3, July-September 2014.
153
Kalidash Brahma, “Political Participation of Women in India: A Post Independence Scenario”, Asian
Journal of Multidisciplinary Studies, Vol. 2, No. 4, April 2014.
59
K. K. Kailash (2014), in his article, “Regional Parties in the 16th Lok Sabha
Elections: Who Survived and Why?”, the author attempts to explain, why some
regional parties flourished and other fizzled out in the 16th general elections to the Lok
Sabha. To explain this variation, he made a distinction between regionally-located
parties and regionalist parties. While, both are regional parties in the sense that they
have territorially limited arena of operation however, they are different in terms of their
programme and agenda. In the 2014 elections, the regionally-located parties fared
relatively poor in comparison to the regionalist parties. Further, he argues that success
and failure often depends on the efforts, strategies and tactics of competitors. The
strategy of the Bharatiya Janta Party was favourable to the electoral fortunes of
regionalist parties and disadvantageous to the regionally-located parties. This selective
emphasis and muting of issues depending on how, it fitted with its overall programme
that opened up enormous possibilities for the BJP and misfortune for the non-
regionalist party. Finally the author conclude by saying that the BJP will have to work
very hard to maintain its newly stitched social coalitions, if past experiences are
anything to go by.154
154
K.K. Kailash, “Regional Parties in the 16th Lok Sabha Elections: Who Survived and Why?”,
Economic and Political Weekly, Vol. 49, No. 39, September 2014.
155
Kuldeep Fadia, “Women’s Empowerment Through Political Participation in India”, Indian Journal of
Public Administration, Vol. 60, No. 3, July-September 2014.
60
the advancement of women throughout the globe. Participation in electoral process
involves much more than just voting. Political participation derives from the freedom to
speak out, assemble and associate; the ability to take part in the conduct of public
affairs; and the opportunity to register as a candidate to campaign, to be elected and to
hold office at all levels of government. Under international standards, men and women
have equal right to participate fully in all aspects of the political process. In this study
author finds that, in post-conflict countries there are frequently extra barriers to
women’s participation, and thereby special care is required to ensure, their rights are
protected in this regard.156
Simi Agnihotri and Vijay Singh (2014) in this study, “Women Empowerment
Through Reservation in Panchayati Raj Institutions in Himachal Pradesh”, deal with
the women empowerment through reservation in PRIs in Himachal Pradesh. In this
article author’s explained that, the situation of women representation in Panchayati Raj
Institutions (PRIs) in Himachal Pradesh through 73rd constitutional amendment act, has
changed a lot. This experiment is proving to be a big success, particularly by providing
opportunity to women to come out of their houses and participate in administrative and
political field. With the increasing violence against women in our society, it becomes
necessary to find out the problems of our society regarding women and give valuable
suggestions deals with the problem. To give the representation to the women, in a local
self-government is also a step to move forward in the direction of women
empowerment in our society.
The article further suggested that, with the establishment of PRIs in our country,
a woman got an opportunity to prove her worth as a good administrator, decision-
maker or a good leader. The government should provide extra financial, administrative
or political assistance to women for the success of the provision of the amendment. So,
it becomes necessary to encourage the women, in a largest democracy of the world. To
give a proper status to the women, government, NGOs and universities have to play a
vital role in this field.157
156
K. Shamatha, “Women’s Participation in Electoral Politics”, Global Journal for Research Analysis,
Vol. 3, No.2, February 2014.
157
Simi Agnihotri and Vijay Singh, “Women Empowerment Through Reservation in Panchayati Raj
Institutions in Himachal Pradesh”, Indian Journal of Public Administration, Vol. 60, No. 3, July-
September 2014.
61
Srinivasan (2014) in this article, “Women Empowerment and Parliament in
India”, the author emphasized on the need and urgency of empowering women,
especially in the Indian context. He takes a brief look at various initiatives, undertaken
during the past five-year plans in respect of empowering women and thereafter, he
proceeds to the political representation of women in the parliament. In final analysis,
he stresses on the need for enacting the legislation ensuring 33 percent quota for
women representation in the legislatures as an effective measure to ensure female
empowerment, keeping in view the total population of women in the country. Though,
India is already ahead of many other countries in terms of women’s participation in
politics but still the percentage of women in legislature and decision-making process
has remained low.158
Vikas Nandal and Rajnish (2014) in this article, “Status of Women Through
Ages in India” deal with the status of women in India. In ancient India status of women
to some extent was satisfactory. However, in recent years, the role of women has
undergone through drastic changes due to globalization and commercialism. It is in this
context the author in this article examined the status of women in modern Indian
society with regard to equality, education, health, employment, marriage and family life
has maintained or deteriorated. It explores that, as the society is moving toward in the
21st century, the position and respect of women is deteriorating even after so many
constitutional provisions. Both argue that, the women have equal participation in
human development but she is still lacking the honour in society women is not treated
at par with men, in comparison to ancient Indian society. Finally the article says that,
there is a lot of crime against women in modern society, even the constitutional
provisions are not sufficient to get the respectable position in society. There is a need
for change in the mind-set of both the men and women. In modern times, the
technological advancement, globalization and commercialism came in to existence but
the status and position of women has rather deteriorated.159
158
Srinivasan, “Women Empowerment and Parliament in India”, Third Concept, Vol. 28, No. 331,
September 2014.
159
Vikas Nandal and Rajnish, “Status of Women Through Ages in India”, International Research
Journal of Social Sciences, Vol. 3, No. 1, January 2014.
62
of family, religion and public life, but as centuries rolled on, the situation went on
changing adversely. He pointed out that, some of the grievances, from which women
were suffering during the last two thousand years, were either theoretical or common to
both men and women. The detailed survey of the position of women that the author has
made in this article would be of considerable use to us in understanding and solving
most of the problems that confront us today. Luckily, the need and advantage of female
education is now fully understood. When girls of 17 or 18, equipped with proper
education, enter matrimony, they cannot but be treated with instinctive respect and
consideration by all the society around. Family responsibility and not inherent
incapacity would be the normal cause of their not being earning members of their
families; they would, therefore, receive the same respect that is instinctively given to
the breadwinner. Their practical attainments would add to the beauty of their husbands,
lead to economy in its expenditure and promote sounder education of the children of
the family. This would surely ensure for them an equality of status with their husbands
in all cultured families. In the sphere of marriage and marital relations, some reforms
are necessary, very urgently. It is high time now that polygamy should be legally
prohibited. Women have already obtained political rights and privileges, more or less
coextensive with those of men. They will figure more prominently in public life when
there is a wider spread of education and a further improvement in the economic
condition of society. The few changes that are suggested above are not in any way
against the spirit of our culture.160
160
A.S. Altekar, “The Position of Women in Hindu Civilization: Retrospect and Prospect”, in
Kumkum Roy (ed.), Women in Early Indian Societies, New Delhi: Manohar Publishers, 2015.
63
needs and obsolete social customs have made women bold, outspoken and conscious of
dignity and rights.161
Nibha Rathi and M.M. Semwal (2016) in this article, “Women’s Political
Participation in Uttarakhand”, reveals that the women’s participation in the political
process in India has ensured voting rights for women, as early as in the 1st Lok Sabha
poll held in 1951-52, on the basis of gender equality. The women’s political
participation at national level is still negligible even today and the we rank amongst the
worst faring countries in the world. Author’s highlights women’s participation in the
political process, since ancient times to, with special emphasis on the state of affairs in
the hill state of Uttarakhand. Both argue that, women’s participation in the political
process in Uttarakhand is increasingly getting stronger. However, prior to 73rd and 74th
constitutional amendments, women’s presence in the politics of Uttarakhand was only
exceptional. But once these amendments became law, not only women’s participation
and representation increased in local bodies and Panchayats, but also started realizing
that, their enhanced representation in the political arena holds the key to the resolution
of many women related issues.
161
Swati Chattopadhyay, “Political Participation of Women”, Third Concept, Vol. 29, No. 339, May
2015.
162
Nibha Rathi and M.M. Semwal, “Women’s Political Participation in Uttarakhand”, Third Concept,
Vol. 29, No. 347, January 2016.
64
turnout. The difference in male and female voter turnout has slimmed down to 1.5 per
cent by 2014. This narrowing gender gap establishes beyond doubt that more women
are exercising their electoral rights. Similarly, women’s participation in election
campaigns increased significantly between 1999 and 2014. However, it is equally clear
that this feminisation of Indian politics is being resisted by the male dominated political
establishment and party personnel, apparatuses and procedures.
In the last the author says that the political parties played a destructive role in
scuttling the Women’s Reservation Bill in the last Lok Sabha have become redundant
after the general elections in 2014. The current government has given a positive signal
for women-inclusive politics, providing six cabinet ministerial positions to women,
raising hopes that it would build an all party consensus and pass the long-standing Bill
in due course.163
163
Praveen Rai, “Women’s Participation in Electoral Politics in India: Silent Feminisation”, South Asia
Research, Vol. 37, No.1, 2017.
164
Srinivasa Murthy, “Women Empowerment: Issues and Challenges”, The International Journal of
Indian Psychology, Vol. 4, No. 2, January-March 2017.
65
After reviewing the study, we are able to chart the course of our problem. The
following inferences can be drawn from the above study. These various books, journals
and articles give us a deep understanding of the concept of political participation and
empowerment of women in politics. This will not only help in data interpretation but
also gives a broader view of the concept of women empowerment. All these writers
have analysed the problem in a particular historical perspective, in a uni-dimensional or
multi-dimensional context. But we have made a humble effort to update the
participation of women in state politics, while taking a case study of Himachal Pradesh.
In the present context, when the world has focused on equality of gender the
micro study of the women as a part of political system has gained a tremendous
importance. In the national context for the last two decades, the central and the state
governments have made some efforts to improve the level of women political
participation. Women’s participation in politics goes far beyond their numbers in
elected bodies. In all major political movements of this century, in all movements of
social change, women have played an extremely important role. But despite of
participation and mobilization of women in politics, in this broad sense of the term, we
have not seen a commensurate increase in the number of women in different levels of
decision making.
The study has immense importance today, when the women issues are
dominating the national and international scenario. Women’s participation in
mainstream political activity has major implications for the broader arena of
governance. In India, women’s role has been marginal in the society, although they
constitute half of the country’s population. Their involvement in politics has been
negligible all along. Their number in the legislatures including parliament has always
remained at the very low. Nevertheless, several women played an active role in the
national movement and also in the political process after independence. In recent past,
there is wide spread realization that they should be emancipated and all types of
discrimination against them to be avoided to enable them to play a legitimate role in the
society. It is also emphasized that the emancipation of women could be possible only
through their social, economic and political empowerment and necessary steps to be
mooted out in this direction. The present study is an attempt to know about the
awareness amongst the women. The limited nature of female participation and
66
representation in national decision making institutions has important consequences for
women and for the legitimacy of the institutions. In this study, an attempt has been
made to analyse the participation of women in state politics.
Political participation of women is still a less than men. Women for centuries
have received unequal treatment in almost all spheres of life because of patriarchal
setup of Indian society. Despite of this, women have shown their presence in many
fronts, but a lot remains to be done in order to achieve real gender equality in social,
economic and political spheres, that are interrelated and give way to one another. Since
India became independent, many policy and programmes have been adopted to
improve the condition of women but women in general have not been in a position to
avail benefits mainly due to their political backwardness. Women are considered as
dependent, poor, kitchen object, and reproductive machine and less of human being. It
has been attributed to low level of education, ignorance, poor negotiating skills,
dependency, nature and individualistic approach of women that influence their extent
of participation in politics.
67
Objectives of the Study
(ii) To study the socio-economic and political profile of the women in Himachal
Pradesh.
(iii) To know about the issues and factor affecting the level and nature of political
participation of women.
(v) To know the pattern and level of participation of the women leadership in
Himachal Pradesh.
(vi) To explore the implications of new trends that has emerged as a consequence of
73rd Amendment.
(viii) To find out the various hindrances in the participation of the women.
(ix) To evaluate the existing strategies devised by the state machinery in the form of
various interventions to include women in decision making process at different
levels.
Hypothesis
The hypothesis which proposed to be tested through the present study relates to
participation of women in state politics. Following are the main hypothesis of present
research:
(i) There are many obstacles for the women in politics, which hampers their
participation and performance.
(ii) The awareness level of women is very low, even after reservation there is no
change in the participation and effectiveness of women’s performances.
(iii) Women’s are divided among different economic class, caste, religion and the
region. They need to break barriers of inequality and powerlessness for
participatory development at grass-root levels, state and national levels.
68
Universe of the Study
The Mandi district came into existence on 15th April 1948, as one of the first
four districts at the time of the emergence of the state of Himachal Pradesh. It is one of
the fastest developing towns of Himachal Pradesh. The economy of the region is
predominately agrain, as around 79 per cent of the total population is dependent on
agriculture. Agriculture and animal husbandry are the major occupation of the people.
The production of food grains and cash crops (i.e. apple, potato, peas, etc.), are the
main source of its economy. The Mandi district is currently the second largest
economy in the state, next to the Kangra district. The district is also second largest in
population among twelve districts of Himachal Pradesh. Total Literacy rate of Mandi
district is 81.53 per cent out of which 89.56 percent of male and 73.66 per cent of
females. The district Mandi in the state is having third highest sex ratio of 1007
females per thousand males. The people of Mandi are informally called Mandyalis, the
Mandyali language Mandyalis is generally used at local level for communication. The
district has mixed population of people from different religion mainly Hindu, Muslim,
Sikh and Bodh. The Mandi district has been the second largest parliamentary
69
constituency (area-wise) in India including the area of Mandi, Kullu, Lahaul & Spiti
and Bharmour of Chamba and Rampur of Shimla districts. The district Mandi consists
of total ten Developmental Blocks viz. Chauntra, Drang, Gohar, Gopalpur, Karsog,
Mandi Sadar, Balh, Seraj, and Sunder Nagar. However, the present study has been
conducted on four blocks of Mandi district i.e Balh, Gohar, Mandi Sadar and Seraj.
These blocks were selected mainly because the Panchayat Samiti of these blocks was
headed by women as chairperson. Further, from each blocks only five Gram
Panchayats have been selected, which were headed by women as Panchayat Pradhans.
The district Kangra was a part of the state of Punjab and was merged in
Himachal Pradesh on 1st November 1966 and the newly merged areas, as called “New
Himachal”. Before the merger of these areas into Himachal as a district, it was part of
Punjab and there was an influence of Punjabi culture on the people of this area.
Therefore, the boundary of district Kangra touches to Punjab and the people of this area
speak Punjabi or mixture of Hindi and Punjabi both. The agriculture is the mainstay of
the majority of the rural population. Green and black tea is both produced in the
district. District Kangra has the distinction of having largest production of mangoes in
the state. It has no big industry worth the name. There are only small scale and cottage
industries based on local raw materials. On the basis of population Kangra is
considered the biggest district and is having second highest sex ratio of 1012 females
per thousand males. The total literacy rate of Kangra district is 85.67 per cent out of
which 91.49 percent of male and 80.02 per cent of females. The district Kangra consists
of total fifteen development blocks viz. Baijnath, Bhawarna, Lambagaon, Panchrukhi,
Kangra, Nagrota Bagwan, Rait, Dehra, Pragpur, Nagrota Surian, Nurpur, Indora,
Fatehpur, Sulah, Dharamshala. The study has been carried out in four Blocks of distrit
Kangra i.e Dharamshala, Nagrota Bagwan, Pragpur, Sulah. These blocks were selected
mainly because the Panchayat Samiti of these blocks was headed by women as
chairperson. Further, from each blocks only five Gram Panchayats have been selected,
which were headed by women as Panchayat Pradhans.
Sampling
70
Mandi and 146 from Kangra have been interviewed. In these 291 elected female
respondents from both the reserved and the open categories have been taken. To ensure
the nature of purposive representative sampling, special attention has been given to
wide representation of women with variables like age, caste, education, income, family
background and political participation etc. Thus the sample may constitute elected
female representatives from varied socio-economic and political background.
71
Himachal Pradesh
Seraj Bali Chowki Bali Chowki General Dharamshala Barwala Barwala Women
Narwana Narwana
Cheuni Cheuni SC
Khas Khas (M)
Sounkni da
Tungadhar Tungadhar General Sounkni Women
kot
Mandi
Aut Aut General Pragpur Dhounta Dhounta Women
Sadar
OBC
Takoli Takoli General Siyul Siyul
Women
Nagrota
Gohar Chhaprahan Chhaprahan General Bhuned Bhuned Women
Bagwan
72
Methodology
Primary Sources
The primary data for the present study has been collected through
questionnaires. The field study was conducted through the methods of questionnaire-
cum-interview schedule, discussions, dialogues and observations. The personal
interviews were conducted with the elected women representatives of the Panchayati
Raj Institutions and the state politics, to know about the extent of their participation in
the politics and the problems faced by them to discharge their duties in the functioning
of these institutions. An attempt has been made to observe the various problems faced
by women representatives to discharge their duties. Also efforts also have been made to
know about the role of education, age, caste, party politics, reservation, economic status
of women in political process.
Interview
73
Sometimes the respondents were reluctant to disclose their personal belongings and
secrets. In most of the cases the respondents were not aware of the exact position of the
women in politics.
Secondary Data
The secondary data was collected from published and unpublished sources. The
various published documents with regard to the women participation in politics
constitute the main sources of secondary data. It includes various books pertaining to
women participation in politics, articles, reports, seminars, etc. The various articles
related to the subject in different journals, magazines and newspaper were one of the
important sources of secondary data. The reports of different committees constituted by
the centre as well as by the state governments, also forms the main sources of
secondary data.
Tools of Data
There are many methods of analyzing the data. In the present study the
processing of data and the preparation of the tables for analysis and interpretation has
been done manually. The master charts were prepared manually and coding and
decoding was done accordingly. The percentage method was applied to analyse the
data.
Limitation of Study
The area of present study was limited to only two district out of twelve districts
of Himachal Pradesh. Out of these two district, 43 women members Zila Parishad, 40
Panchayat Samitis and 40 Gram Panchayats were selected for the purposive sampling.
But the limitation of our research was that, it was confined to only elected
representatives taken as respondents.
Scheme of Chapterisation
74
CHAPTER-II
The word Himachal derives its origin from the Hindi words, ‘Him’ and ‘Achal’
meaning ‘Snow’ and ‘Lap’ respectively. Etymologically, Himachal Pradesh stands for
the region, which lies in the slopes and foothills of snow i.e. the Himalayas.1 Himachal
was also known as Dev Bhumi to the ancients. It is situated in the heart of the Western
Himalayas. According to the Puranas, Himachal is the Jalandhara Khand of the
Himalayas.2 Himachal Pradesh is bounded on the north by the picturesque valley of
Kasmir; on the South by the fertile plains of the Punjab and Uttar Pradesh; on the west
by the districts of Ambala (Haryana) and Hoshiarpur (Punjab); and on the north-east by
Tibet.3
The Greater Himalaya and Zaskar ranges also house many glaciers. For
glaciers, the local term is Shigri, perhaps derived from a big Shigri glacier that once
created great havoc. The Diyamir is another glacier of large dimensions that descends
to the level of 9400 feet above sea level near the village Tarshing.5
1
M.S. Ahluwalia, History of Himachal Pradesh, New Delhi: Intellectual Publication, 1988, p. 2.
2
Mian Goverdhan Singh, Himachal Pradesh History, Culture & Economy, Shimla: Minerva
Publishers, 2010, p.1.
3
V. Verma, The Emergence of Himachal Pradesh: A Survey of Constitutional Developments, New
Delhi: Indus Publishing Company, 1995, p. 19.
4
Mian Goverdhan Singh, op.cit, 2010, p.1.
5
Himachal Past, Present and Future, Directorate of Correspondence Courses, Himachal Pradesh
University, Shimla, 1975, p. 3.
75
There are five rivers flowing through Himachal Pradesh. The eastern most river
is the Yamuna, which rises from Yamunotri in the Garhwal range of the Himalayas and
from the states in eastern boundary with Uttar Pradesh. Its most important tributaries
are the Tons, Giri and Pabar. The Satluj is the largest among five rivers. It enters the
eastern part of Himachal Pradesh at Shipki from the north-west. Following through
Kinnaur, Shimla Hills, Bilaspur district, it leaves Himachal Pradesh to enter the plains
of Punjab and Bhakra, where the World’s Largest Dam is constructed. The Beas which
forms the world valleys of Kullu and Kangra, rises from the 3,987 meters high Rohtang
Pass. Its tributaries are Parbati, Phojal and Sarvari streams. The Ravi river originated
from an amphitheatre like basin called Bara-Banghal, a branch of Dhauladhar. The fifth
river is Chandrabhaga or Chenab. The Chandra and Bhaga streams rise on the opposite
side of Baralacha Pass at an elevation of 4,891 meters, to stream from one river at
Tandi.6
The whole area may be classified in five zones on the basis of different soils as-
(i) low-hill soil zone (ii) mid-hill soil zone (iii) high-hill soil zone (iv) mountainous soil
zone and (v) dry-hill soil zone. The first zone covers area upto an altitude of 900
metres above sea level. The quality of the soils of this region is suitable for the
cultivation of maize, wheat, sugar-cane, ginger, paddy and citrus fruits. The second
zone covers area lying between 900 metres and 1500 metres above sea level. The soils
of this region are suitable for the cultivation of table potatoes, stone fruits, wheat and
maize. The high-hill soil zone, covering areas between 1,500 metres and 2,100 metres
above sea level, is the most suitable for the cultivation of seed potatoes and temperate
fruits. The mountainous-soil zone covering the altitudes between 2,100 metres and
3,000 metres is suitable for the cultivation of dry fruits only.7
6
Rajender Attri, Introduction to Himachal Pradesh, Shimla: Sarla Publication, 2002, p. 320.
7
Himachal Past, Present and Future, op.cit., 1975, pp. 156-157.
76
The majority of the Buddhists are concentrated in the districts of Lahaul and Spiti,
Kinnaur and Kullu, whereas the Sikhs live mostly in Kangra, Shimla and Mandi
districts. The Christians, though in a very small numbers are sprinkled over the whole
of state and so are the Jains.8 The people living in the Outer Himalaya or the Shiwaliks
have much in common with those in the plains of Punjab except that the former are
fairer in complexion because of the climatic factors. In fact, both in the medieval and
later period, there have been inter-migrations to these areas, being comparatively easily
accessible, and thus they are somewhat similar in their habits and cultural moorings to
the people of the plains.
The Brahmans and the Rajputs has migrated from the plains during the
lawlessness of Aurangzeb. The Sikhs settled in parts of Himachal, while fighting the
hilly rulers or having been driven by the Mughals. Himachal Pradesh also had its share
of displaced persons numbering about 4660 as a result of the partition. In general, the
people are honest, hospitable, peace-loving, and deeply religious and follow their
community codes very rigidly. The hilly women work harder than the men folk and are
robust. They are beautiful, modest and known for their sweet voice. Tribes or semi-
nomadic, semi-agricultural and semi-pastoral people are living in the Great Himalaya,
the Zaskar, the Pir Panjal, the Pangi, and the Dhauladhar ranges, or to be more precise,
in the Lahaul & Spiti region, Kinnaur, some part of Shimla, Kullu, Chamba districts
etc., there are an admixture of the Indo-Aryan and Mongolian races. The main tribes of
Himachal Pradesh are the Gaddis, Gujjars, Kinners of Kanaurs, Jads (Lambas,
Khampas and Bhots or Bhods), Lahaulis, Pangwalas and Swanglas.9
Due to the geographical conditions of the Pradesh, these tribes have to live a
very hard life. Most of these tribes, till recently, lived a nomadic life, wandering here
and there in search of food and grass for their animals. Also they remained practically
out of touch from the rest of the world, due to lack of modern facilities. It is believed
that most of the tribal’s in Himachal, migrated from the plains of Punjab and adjoining
areas from time to time. The early history of these tribes is shrouded in mystery.10
The cultural aspect plays an important role in shaping the progress of a region
and its society, as they are closely related to the mental attitudes of the people. As far as
8
M.S Ahluwalia, Social, Cultural and Economics History of Himachal Pradesh, New Delhi: Indus
Publishing Company, 1998, p. 66.
9
Himachal Past, Present and Future, op.cit., 1975, p. 11.
10
M.S. Ahluwalia, op.cit., 1998, p.80.
77
Himachal Pradesh is concerned, its social institutions, particularly the fairs and
festivals, have a considerable impact on its development. The fairs and festivals
represents, one of the important facets of state’s rich cultural heritage.11 Important fairs
in Himachal Pradesh are Minjar (Chamba), Dussehra (Kullu), Shivarati (Mandi), Mani
Mahesh (Chamba) and Renuka (Sirmour). Lavi fair is perhaps the only fair, which is
not connected with any legend or religion. It is an economic or trade fair, as are the
Nalwar fairs of Sundernagar (Mandi) and of Bilaspur; their origin is not as old as of the
hoary Lavi fair of Rampur Bushahr.12
Language
In Himachal Pradesh about ninety per cent people speaks western Pahari
popularly known as Pahari. The Indo-Aryan languages are spoken in the Northern
India. In Himachal Pradesh as many dialects have been counted almost at par with the
number of existing hill states. In the North of Churdhar Peak, these separates Sirmaur
district from Chopal tehsil of Shimla district. This area was known as Bishshaw in the
past. The dialect spoken there is akin to Giripari, which is named by Dr. Grierson as
Bishwai. So, the appropriate name for Giripari now is Bishwai dialect. The Brari
dialect is spoken in Pargana Brar of Jubbal Tehsil. Kirni dialect is spoken in Pargana
Kiran of Chopal Tehsil, which is influenced by Jaunsari dialect of Jaunsar-Bawar area
of Uttar Pradesh. Dami dialect is prevalent in South-East of Bilaspur. The Kinnauri
dialect called Homskad is the mother tongue of nearly 75 per cent of the population of
Kinnaur. In Lahual and Spiti, four main dialects are spoken. Bhoti is spoken in Spiti,
Chandra and Bhaga Valleys. The Gaheri is spoken around Keylong, while Manchot and
Changsa are spoken in Chenab Valley. The Lahaul in turn makes use of four dialects-
Tibetan, Boonuum, Manchat and Teenuum. In Kangra, apart Kangri, the Dogri dialect
is also spoken. Some linguists are even of the opinion that despite the fact that the
Pahari language has been surrounded by Hindi, Dogri and Punjabi Languages, but it is
more closely akin to Rajasthani. The main reason behind to be stated, is that Rajasthan
and the hilly areas of Himachal Pradesh were once inhabited by the same type of
people like Khasa, Rajput, Gujjar etc.13
11
Ibid., p. 86.
12
V. Verma, op.cit., 1995, p. 24.
13
Ramesh Chauhan, Himachal Pradesh: A Perspective, Shimla: Menerva Book House, 1998, pp. 286-
288.
78
Table 2.1
Himachal at a Glance According to 2011 Census
Description Detail
Area 55673 (Sq.Kms.)
Population 68, 64, 602
Male 3481873
Female 3382729
Rural Population 6176050
Urban Population 688552
Scheduled Castes Population 1729252
Scheduled Tribes Population 392126
Literacy Rate 82.80 (%)
Growth Rate 12.94 (%)
Density of Population 123 (Persons)
Total No. of Main Workers 20.63 (Lakh)
Birth Rate 16.4 (Per 1000)
Death Rate 6.7 (Per 1000)
Religion Hindu
Annual Rainfall 180 cm
Maximum Temperature 38.60 C
Capital Shimla
Language Hindi, English, Himachali
Per Capital Income 1, 30, 067 (Rs.)
Urbanization Ratio 90:10
Best time to Visit March to October
Total Districts 12
Divisions 3
Sub-Divisions 62
Legislative Assembly Constituencies 68
Blocks 78
Tehsils 97
Sub-Tehsils 49
Panchayats 3226
Villages 20690
Source: Census of India, 2011, and Government of Himachal Pradesh, Statistical Abstract of Himachal
Pradesh, Shimla: Department of Economics and statistics Government of Himachal Pradesh, 2015-16.
79
Area and Population
Himachal Pradesh has an area of 55,673 sq. kms. The population of Himachal
has been increasing continuously over the years. However, the growth rate of total
population shows a decreasing trend over the last three decades. In 2011, the total
population of Himachal Pradesh is 68, 64, 602 out of which 34, 81,873 were males
(51%) and 33, 82,729 (49%) were females. The composition of population shows that,
90 per cent of the total population is rural and only 10 per cent is urban. The trend
shows that, since 1981 the urban population is increasing continuously. It has been
increased from 7.61 per cent in 1981 to 8.6 per cent in 1991 and from 9.80 per cent in
2001 to 10.00 per cent in 2011.14
Table 2.2
14
Government of Himachal Pradesh, Socio-Economic Indicators of Himachal Pradesh, Shimla:
Economic and Statistics Department Himachal Pradesh, 2014-15, p. 1.
80
20
15.54
16.26
14.76
15
12.63
15.93
12.77
12.67
12.05
10.92
10.19
10
7.39
5 Growth Rate of
Population 2001-2011
-5
-5
-10
Sex Ratio
As per census 2011, there are 972 females per 1000 of male in Himachal
Pradesh as compared to 968 females as per 2001 census. This adverse trend in the sex
ratio is mainly attributed to female foeticide and infanticide. The government of
Himachal Pradesh has put a total ban on the prenatal diagnostic test by enacting the
legislation. The district wise sex ratio is given below.
Table 2.3
District Wise Sex Ratio
District Male Female Female Per 1000 Males
Bilaspur 192764 189192 981
Chamba 261320 257760 986
Hamirpur 217070 237698 1095
Kangra 750591 759484 1012
Kinnaur 46249 37872 819
Kullu 225452 212451 942
Lahaul and Spiti 16588 14976 903
Mandi 498065 501712 1007
Shimla 425039 388971 915
Sirmaur 276289 253566 918
Solan 308754 271566 880
Una 263692 257481 976
Himachal Pradesh 3481873 3382729 972
Source: Census of India 2011.
81
Female Per 1000 Males
1095
1200
1007
981
1012
942
918
976
1000
986
903
915
880
800
819
600
400
200
Participation of Women
According to census 2011, the total worker population in Himachal Pradesh was
35.59 lakh, of which 15.16 lakh were women and 20.43 lakh were men. Out of the total
women workers, 41.13 per cent were main workers, 58.87 per cent were marginal
workers. The female workforce participation rate (WPR), on an average in 2001 was
43.67 per cent, which has increased to 44.82 per cent in 2011. This has become an
evident through various census. Similarly, the male workforce participation rate
(WPR), on an average in 2001 was 56.62 per cent, which has increased to 58.69 per
cent in 2011. In respect of women employed in the government services, it was
revealed from the census of Himachal Pradesh that in 2012-13, only 21.2 per cent of
total government employees were women. However, this share of women government
employees, during in 2013 has moderately improved from 20.4 per cent in 2012.15
Historical Profile
The early history of Himachal Pradesh is not fully established. This is mainly
due to the absence of adequate archaeological and literary sources. However, some
recent explorations and research or have thrown significant light on the political and
15
Government of Himachal Pradesh, Women and Men in Himachal Pradesh, Shimla: Department of
Economics and Statistics Government of Himachal Pradesh, 2014, p.29.
82
cultural history of the state, going as far back as the pre-historic age.16 Due to difficult
terrain, cold climate and inaccessible nature of the hilly state, it was impossible for any
major empire to annex the entire area of Himachal Pradesh. The history and traditions
of Himachal Pradesh can be traced from the earliest dawn of human civilization. The
Pre-History of Himachal Pradesh is the history of migration of the people of the
affiliated races from Indian plains and Central Asia. Its history is perhaps the most
unique and remarkable as compared to any other region of the Himalayas.17 That is in a
chronological order in a periodic form- (i) Pre-Aryan and Aryan Period up to A.D. 500
(ii) Early period A.D. 500 to A.D. 1000 (iii) Medieval Period A.D.1000 to A.D. 1800
(iv) British Period A.D. 1800 to A.D. 1947 (v) Modern Period A.D. 1947 onwards.
16
M.S. Ahluwalia, op.cit., 1988, p. 38.
17
Mian Goverdhan Singh, op.cit., 1985, p. 13.
18
Ibid., p. 2.
19
M.S. Ahluwalia, op.cit., 1998, pp. 38-39.
20
Ibid., p.40.
83
The second group of people were of the Aryan origin. They were known as the
Khasas, who penetrated from the north-west and settled in the mid-mountain belt of the
Himalayas from Kashmir to Nepal. They developed a specific Indo-Aryan culture and
religion.21 According to the Mahabharata the tract, which forms the present day
Himachal Pradesh was made up of a number of small republics known as Janapadas,
each of which constituted both a state and a cultural unit. The Audumbras were the
most prominent ancient tribes of Himachal, who lived in the lower hills between the
Pathankot and the Jawlamukhi.22 The Trigrata kingdom occupied the foothill tract
drained by the Ravi, Beas and Satluj. It was an independent state which flourished
during this period. Another contemporary Kingdom was that of Kuluta, situated in the
upper Beas valley, which is also known as the Kullu Valley. Its capital was Naggar and
they issued copper coins. The Chitravaram of Kuluta, was one of the five Kings of this
region, who formed an alliance to oppose the influence of Chandragupta Maurya.23
The Kulindas was another important kingdom that covered the area lying
between the Beas-Satluj and Yamuna rivers, i.e. the Shimla and Sirmaur hills. They
issued silver coins. Their administration resembled a republic with members of central
assembly sharing the powers of the King. The Ashoka, the grandson of Chandragupta
extended his boundaries to the Himalayan region. He introduced Buddhism to this tract.
He built many stupas, one of which is in the Kullu valley. A major inscription is at
Kalsi (now in U.P.), which was once a part of Sirmaur state.24 After the collapse of the
Gupta Empire and before the rise of Harsha, this region was again ruled by small petty
chiefs known as Thakurs and Ranas, whose states were of small size with constantly
changing boundaries due to wars with neighbours. It is believed that in Chamba area
alone, there were hundred such small chiefdoms. In the early seventh century, rule of
Harsha became paramount and most of these small states acknowledged his overall
supremacy, though a number of local powers continued to be exercised by the chiefs.
During this period, the Huien Tsang, one of the greatest travellers visited many
parts of Himachal Pradesh and wrote a detailed account of the socio-political set-up of
Himachal Pradesh at that time. According to Huien Tsang, Bharmour (Brahmapura)
21
Ibid., pp.40-41.
22
S.S. Negi, Himachal Pradesh: The Land and People, New Delhi: Indus Publishing Company, 1993,
p. 124.
23
S.S. Negi, Discovering the Himalaya, Vol. 2, New Delhi: Indus Publishing Company, 1998, pp. 343-
344.
24
S.S. Negi, op.cit., 1993, pp. 124-125.
84
was the capital of Chamba state, whose boundaries touched with those of Jalandhra in
the south-east and Mandi and Suket in the east. The hill states of the interior parts of
Himachal Pradesh were outside the jurisdiction of Harsha. During this period,
Thaneshwar was a flourishing Kingdom. The Srughna was a state to the North-East of
Thaneshwar, whose frontiers flow the Yamuna River with the capital located on the
banks of the river. It is believed that Paonta or Kalsi were probably the capital of this
kingdom.25
Early Period
The outside invaders during this period exploited the internal strifes of the petty
hill chiefs and chaos prevailing in their territories. The history of this area in a way
marched ahead with these events of internal strifes and rivalries. During this period,
some foreign invaders also invaded few parts of Himachal Pradesh. It may be recalled
here that, the internal warfare of kings and chiefs did not result in any significant
political changes and administration was partly of the primitive type. The lack of
King’s personal interest in state craft could have offered opportunities to Thakurs and
Ranas, to declare themselves independent. The army had to be fed and organised by the
people. The King took the responsibility of the army only during war periods. Only the
major states like Kangra, Kullu and Chamba had organised armies.26
Medieval Period
In this period, the old and larger states of Kullu, Kangra, Mandi etc. were
broken and many new small states of Guler, Siba, Datarpur, Handur, Koti, Bhajji,
Kumarsain, Khaneti etc. came into existence. During this period, Mughals, Muslims,
Dutch, Portuguese and French invaded many parts of India. The relations between
Mughals and these hill states commenced with Akbar, who wanted to include this
valuable area in his empire and he sent Todarmal to annex Kangra. The history stands
as witness that, erstwhile ruler of Kangra, Dharm Chand readily accepted suzerainty of
Akbar. In 1620 A.D. Jahangir also got hold over Kangra. On the other hand, the hill
states of Chamba, Kullu, Lahaul and Spiti, Bushahr had strifes amongst themselves but
the Mughals never intervented in the internal matters of these hill rulers. Because of
25
S.S. Negi, op.cit., 1998, pp. 344-345.
26
Sukhdev Singh Chib, This Beautiful India: Himachal Pradesh, New Delhi: Light and Life, 1977,
pp.4-5.
85
their relations outside hills, the hill rulers also brought about changes in public
administration. In fact, the system of administration evolved during this period,
continued till the integration of these states into one unit with minor changes. However,
the general condition of the hill subjects had improved a bit as compared to the earlier
period.27
British Period
After the death of Aurangzeb, the last great Mughal, the Mughal Empire in
India stated declining. In these hilly states, Raja Sansar Chand of Kangra had earned
reputation as a warrior and ruler. In the second half of the 18th century, a new nation
known as Gurkhas in the Himalayan history rose to power. Under the leadership of
Prithvi Narain Shah, they spread like a wild fire and engulfed the whole of Western
Himalayas including Kangra. They occupied Kumaon and Garhwal in 1803 A.D. and
by 1805 A.D. they captured Kangra Fort.28 But people were tired of their harsh
tyrannical rule. They united themselves and took a stand against them. The Britishers
also came to their help and in 1815 A.D. the Gurkhas were compelled to leave the
country. The help by the Britishers turned out to be a trap for them. They compelled the
local rulers to sign certain treaties, through which the paramount power from the hands
of these rulers passed on the British government in India.29
Freedom Struggle
The people of the hills also participated in the freedom struggle from 1914-
1947. Praja Mandal launched agitations against the British yoke in areas under direct
British rule. In other princely states, agitations were launched for social and political
reforms. However, these were directed more against the princely states rather than
against the British and as such were mere extensions of the freedom movement. The
Mandi conspiracy was carried out in 1914-15 under the influence of the Gadhr Party.
The meetings were held in Mandi and Suket states in December 1914 and January
1915. It was decided to murder the superintendent and Wazir of Mandi and Suket, to
loot the Treasury, blow up the bridge over the Beas River and bring the territories of
these states under the control of the revolutionaries.
27
Ibid., pp.6-8.
28
Mian Goverdhan Singh, op.cit., 1985, p.30.
29
Shiv Raj Singh, Bureaurcacy and Rural Development: Policy Making, Planning and Implementation,
New Delhi: Mittal Publications, 1989, p. 24.
86
The Pajhota agitation in which the people of part of Sirmaur state revolted, is
regarded as an extension of the Quit India Movement in 1942.30 At last the fateful day
arrived, when the British said good-bye for ever to India and the tri-colour was unfurled
on the ramparts of the Red fort in Delhi on the midnight of the 15th August, 1947. But
that was not the end of the drama for the hill people. The National leaders invited the
prince’s to join the ocean of masses. They felt the pulse of the time and signed the
instrument of accession. In March 1948, thirty old princes of Shimla and Punjab hills
met in Delhi and inscribed their signatures on the document and surrendered their
centuries old Raj to the masses and thus Himachal Pradesh in the form of a unit came
into existence on the 15th of April 1948.31
30
S.S. Negi, op.cit, 1993, pp.130-131.
31
Mian Goverdhan Singh, op.cit., 1985, p. 20.
32
Shiv Raj Singh, op.cit., 1989, p. 26.
33
Ramesh Chauhan , op.cit., 1998, p.183.
34
Ibid, pp.183-184.
87
‘C’ state of Bilaspur was merged with Himachal Pradesh as fifth district of the state and
strength of the assembly seat was raised to 41 members.35
Himachal Pradesh maintained its status of part ‘C’ state of the Indian union till
1956, when the state reorganisation commission headed by Mr. Justice Fazil Ali and
two members i.e. H.N. Kunzru and K.M. Pannikar, submitted its recommendation to
abolish the categorization of state as part A.B.C.37 The parliament passed the territorial
council act in December 1956. According to the provision of this act, Himachal
Pradesh was made an union territory under the chairmanship of Thakur Karam Singh.
According to the government of union territory act, the territorial council re-elected in
1962 and it was turned into legislative assembly. A three member’s popular ministry
headed by Dr. Y.S. Parmar was sworn in on July 1, 1963, other two ministers were
Thakur Karam Singh and Hari Das. Another new district, the sixth one which was
carved out of the Mahasu district formed the new Kinnaur district ceded from the entire
Chini Tehsil and 14 villages from Rampur Tehsils.
35
Mian Goverdhan Singh, op.cit., 1985, pp. 85-87.
36
Himachal Past, Present and Future, op.cit. 1975, p.122.
37
M.S. Ahluwalia, op.cit., 1993, p.35.
88
Hoshiarpur district and Pathankot tehsil of Gurdaspur district with Himachal. The
integration came about on 1st November 1966.38
After granting the statehood to Himachal Pradesh, the strength of the state
legislative assembly had been fixed and increase in sixty to sixty-eight. Out of sixty
eight constituencies, nineteen seats were reserved to scheduled caste and scheduled
tribes ( i.e. Sixteen for SCs and Three for STs). Simultaneously, four seats for Lok
Sabha and three seats for Rajya Sabha were also fixed for Himachal Pradesh. At
present, all the four parliamentary constituency ( i.e. Hamirpur, Kangra, Mandi and
Shimla) consists of seventeen assembly constituencies each, will come under the sixty-
eight assembly constituencies. In 1971, mid-term election were held in centre as well as
in the state, in which congress party got majority at centre and won all four
parliamentary seats in Himachal Pradesh. In 1972, Vidhan Sabha election the Indian
National Congress got 53 seats, Bhartiya Jan Sangh 5, Independents and others 10
seats. In the 68 Vidhan Sabha the Indian National Congress got ¾ majority, as there
was hardly any opposition to the Indian National Congress at that time from any
national or regional political outfits. The Indian National Congress had projected itself
as the only party of masses in general and SC/ST’s in particular. Once again, Dr. Y. S.
38
Mian Goverdhan Singh, op.cit., 1985, p. 216.
39
Himachal Past, Present and Future, op.cit., 1975, pp. 128-129.
40
Ramesh Chauhan, op.cit., 1998, pp.187-188.
89
Parmar became the Chief Minister of Himachal Pradesh. We can see the performance
of various parties in Himachal Pradesh legislative assembly election during in 1952-
1972, in which the congress party ruled with strength in the state. It has been illustrated
in the table below:
Table 2.4
Performance of Parties in Himachal Pradesh Legislative Assembly Election from
1952-1972
Furthermore, the political scene at national level became very turmoil because
central government under Indira Gandhi suffered a setback on account of adverse
judgement of Allahabad High Court against her. In 1975, Mrs. Indira Gandhi imposed
internal emergency and put all opposition leaders in jail. The emergency continued for
nineteen months. However, the emergency proved to be a blessing in disguise, as it
brought discipline and a genuine sense of responsibility in the government
functionaries. The strikes became outdated and files started moving fast vanishing red
tapism etc. The twenty point programme for the welfare of the general masses was
taken with all earnestness. The state to some extent, witnessed virtual transformation by
90
the year 1976, when it stood in the threshold of self-sufficiency in food production, etc.
But various restrictions imposed on the fundamental rights annoyed the people at large.
However, the various welfare programmes became torturing, humiliating and fanatic in
its implementation and consequently, the farmers as well as the government employees
reacted very strongly against it. On account of the restrictions imposed on speech and
press, the government could not get realistic feed back with the result that the congress
was replaced in 1977 general elections. In February 1977, Dr. Y. S. Parmar stepped
down at the instance of the central leadership, when youth wing of the congress party
had emerged powerful and Thakur Ram Lal became the chief minister.
As a result of change in government at the centre, for seeking fresh mandate the
Himachal Pradesh government was dissolved and President’s Rule promulgated on 30th
April 1977, which remained enforced up to 21st May 1977. Subsequently, the Janta
Party was voted to thumping majority having won 54 seats out of total 68 seats in June,
1977 general elections, thus Janta Party in the state formed the government. The
Congress-I had secured only 9 seats while 5 seats were won by the independent
candidates.
Mr. Shanta Kumar became the chief minister of Himachal Pradesh on 24th June
1977. However, the Janta government made several achievements but the internal
conflicts and contradictions inherent in the party were responsible for several setbacks.
Its fall came earlier than it could be foreseen and the government collapsed under its
own weight before it could complete its full term. The careful accommodation of
interests of different groups was essential for keeping such a party intact and the
leadership then probably lacked this quality. The emergence of Janta party had raised
expectations that India was heading toward a two party system, but in vain. The Indian
social conditions and its overall structure did not conform to the conditions necessary
for such a political development. The clash of personalities and the absence of
commonly accepted ideologies were responsible for the failure of Janta government.
In 1980 Lok-Sabha elections Congress-I won all four seats and this victory of
the congress party proved last nail in the coffin of Janta party government in the state.
The politics of defection transformed the fortune of nine members congress party to
emerge as a ruling Janta under the chief-ministership of Thakur Ram Lal, Janta
government lasted for thirty months.41 In 1982, Vidhan Sabha election, Janta party has
41
Ibid., pp. 188-190.
91
virtually lost its political significance. In these elections, congress too faced a big loss.
However, BJP expanded its influence in Himachal Pradesh for the first time under the
leadership of Shanta Kumar winning 29 seats. These elections were mainly contested
between Ram Lal and Shanta Kumar, the two personalities in the state politics. At that
time, there was no political party to form the government on its own. But the congress
party once again formed the government, with the help of independent candidate
Thakur Ram Lal became the chief minister. But later on, Thakur Ram Lal was
appointed Governor of Andhra Pradesh and Virbhadra Singh became the chief minister
of Himachal Pradesh.42 Thus, in Vidhan Sabha elections of 1982 Congress-I recaptured
power in the state. As there was a short change in leadership, Ram Lal Thakur was
replaced by Virbhadra Singh. He again went to snap poll in 1985 and returned his party
with thumping majority.43
In 1985 Mid-term poll, congress party once again got thumping majority in the
state legislative assembly. The period from 1980 to 1991 was the period of great
turmoil and instability in Indian politics. The problem of terrorism was taking heavy
toll all over the country. Mrs. Indira Gandhi was assassinated by her own Sikh security
guards in New Delhi on 31st October 1984. After the gap of seven years, Mr. Rajiv
Gandhi was killed in Tamilnadu by a suicide bomber, while on his way to address an
election rally at Sriparambadur. When congress remained in power from 1985-90 in
the state, it was during this period B.J.P. strengthened its party cadre and exploited the
weakness of congress party within and outside the Vidhan Sabha. Mr. Shanta Kumar
led a Yatra from Palampur to Shimla, which received overwhelming support. In 1989
Lok Sabha election, Shanta Kumar won from Kangra seat. 44
In 1990, Himachal Pradesh Vidhan Sabha election, BJP came to power. Mr.
Shanta Kumar was sworn in as chief minister of the state for the second time on 5th
March, 1990. His council of ministers included Jagdev Chand, Radha Raman Shastri,
Nagin Chander Pal, Kishori Lal, Roop Singh Thakur, Kunj Lal Thakur, Vidya Sagar
and Dile Ram. The vital political change at the centre (Congress-I) did not bring any
change initially in Bhartiya Janta Party (BJP) government in Himachal Pradesh.
However, due to dismantling of Babri Masjid at Ram Janam Bhumi, Ayodha led to the
ouster of the three BJP ruled states including Himachal Pradesh on 15th December
42
Ibid., p.190.
43
Har Gopal Singh, A Period of Hot Politics in Himachal Pradesh and Other Notes, Solan: Har Gopal
Singh Publishers, 1996, p. 5.
44
Ibid, p.190.
92
1992, while the fourth (UP) had resigned of its own. After their dismissal the
President’s Rule was promulgated in these states. After the President’s rule of about
one year the tenth Vidhan Sabha election were held on 9th November 1993. The
congress has returned to power winning 52 of the total 68 assembly seats. Mr.
Virbhadra Singh again became the chief minister of the state for the third time on 3rd of
December 1993. On the recommendation of the council of ministers of Virbhadra
Singh the Governor Mrs V.S. Rama Devi dissolved the Vidhan Sabha under article
174-2b on the 24th December 1998 to sought simultaneously Lok Sabha and assembly
elections under the presumed favourable political scenario in the state.45 The elections
to the Lok Sabha and state assembly again were held on February 1998. The chief
minister Mr. Virbhadra Singh dissolved the legislative assembly one year earlier
schedule, to pave the way for simultaneous election for the Lok Sabha and the state
legislative assembly. But mandate of the people went against congress party. These
elections changed the whole political scenario in the state.
For the first time, the Himachal Vikas congress (HVC) emerged as “Third
Force” under the leadership of former union communication minister Pandit Sukh Ram,
who was expelled from the congress party on corruption charges. Due to Kinnaur,
Lahaul and Spiti and Bharmour, these elections were postponed in three assembly seats
and in one parliamentary constituency (Mandi). Elections in these areas were held on
3rd June 1998. There were no clear cut verdicts in favour of any political party. In three
parliamentary constituencies, BJP got two seats (Kangra and Hamirpur) while the
congress got only one seat i.e. Shimla.
As far as in sixty eight state assembly seats were concerned Indian National
Congress got 31 seats, while BJP got 29 seats. The HVC got 4 seats (Mandi Sadar,
Dharampur, Balh, Karsog), first time as a third party in Himachal Pradesh, while its
candidate contested 61 seats, one seat was rested by an independent candidate. The
HVC join hands with BJP under the leadership of Prof. Prem Kumar Dhumal as the
10th chief minister of Himachal Pradesh. It was first time in Himachal the coalition
government came into power.46 Therefore, 13th Lok Sabha elections were held on
September 25, 1999 in Himachal Pradesh BJP and HVC alliance captured all the four
seats i.e. three by BJP (Kangra, Hamirpur and Mandi) and one seat (Shimla) by HVC.
45
Ramesh Chauhan, op.cit., 1998, pp 192-193.
46
T. R. Sharma, “Himachal Pradesh: Two Party Competition in a Small State”, Journal of Indian
School of Political Economy, Vol. 15, No. 1-2, January-June 2003, pp.182-183.
93
In the by election of Solan assembly seat, Dr. Rajeev Bindal of BJP got elected in
February 2000.
In 2003 assembly election, electronic voting machines (EVMs) were used for
voting for the first time in the state and 9500 EVMs was requisitioned by Himachal
Pradesh chief election commissioner. There was a little more growth of electors than 30
per cent since 1990 election. The total electorate has increased for 3058107 in 1990 to
4088844 now. The ratio of men and women voters has remained unchanged.
Interestingly, while the number of men contestants has been constantly coming down,
that of women contestants have been on the rise. Election to the 10th Himachal Pradesh
legislative assembly except the total tribal constituencies was held on 28 February
2003. The house was constituted on 4th March 2003. The Indian National Congress
with 40 seats was swept back to power. The party raised its tally to 43 as it won all the
three tribal constituencies by election to which were held on June 8, 2003.47
In April 2004, HVC supreme Pandit Sukh Ram rejoined the congress.
Therefore, in May 2004 parliamentary election, India National Congress scored an
impressive victory wresting three of the four seats in the state. The BJP survived a
clean sweep by the congress as one of its candidate Suresh Chandel managed to scrape
through by a slender margin in Hamirpur Lok Sabha constituency.
Whereas in 2007, assembly elections, the hill state reverted to bipolar polity
with the realignment of political force during these election. The efforts to form a third
political front in the past to challenge the two main political parties, which have been
occupying the centre stage for the past three decades, have not been successful. The
emergence of the Bahujan Samaj Party (BSP) had raised the vision of a third political
force in the state, where the electoral arena has been traditionally dominated by the
Congress and BJP. Largely, it seems that the emergence of third force like the Janta
Dal, HVC and BSP during assembly elections, had dented the vote banks of main
parties to an extent but the politics in the state has largely remained bipolar. Such
emergence provided a platform to the rebels of the main parties and dependents, but
failed to create a permanent space and virtually vanished from the scene.
47
Report on General Election to Himachal Pradesh State Legislative Assembly 2003, Chief Electoral
Officer, Shimla: Himachal Pradesh.
94
seats were concerned, BJP got 41 and Congress party got 23, seats. BSP got 1 and 3
seats was rested by independent candidate. Prof. Prem Kumar Dhumal became 11th
chief minister of Himachal Pradesh.48
Table 2.5
The Position of Political Parties since (1977- 2012) in Himachal Pradesh
Sr. No. Political Parties 1977 1982 1985 1990 1993 1998 2003 2007 2012
1. Janta Party 53 02 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
2. Congress (I) 09 31 58 9 52 31 43 23 36
3. C.P.I 0 0 0 01 0 0 0 0 0
4. CPI(M) 0 0 0 0 01 0 0 0 0
5. BJP 0 29 07 46 08 31 16 41 26
6. Janta Dal (JNP) 0 0 0 11 0 0 0 0 0
7. Lok Dal 0 0 01 0 0 0 0 0 0
8. HVC 0 0 0 0 0 5 1 0 0
9. Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 1 1
10. Independents 06 06 02 01 07 01 06 3 5
Total 68 68 68 68 68 68 68 68 68
Sources: Reports on General Election to Himachal Pradesh State Legislative Assembly from
1977- 2012, Chief Electoral Officer, Shimla: Himachal Pradesh.
48
Himachal Pradesh Assembly Election Result in 2007, https://en.m.wikipedia, Accessed on 30-10-
2015.
49
Report on General Election to Himachal Pradesh State Legislative Assembly 2012, Chief Electoral
Officer, Shimla: Himachal Pradesh.
95
On 1st November 1966, the hilly area of Punjab was merged in the state and as a result
the number of Gram Panchayats were increased to 1695. In the merged areas, a three
tier Panchayati Raj System was already in existence under the provisions of Punjab
Panchayat Samiti and Zila Parishad Act, whereas two tier systems was prevalent in the
state of Himachal Pradesh. With a view to bring uniformity in the Panchayati Raj
system in the old and the newly merged areas, the Himachal Pradesh Panchayati Raj
Act, 1968 was enacted on November 15, 1970 and the two-tier Panchayati Raj system
was established throughout the state. Beside this, the Nayaya Panchayats were also in
the existence in the state for discharging judicial functions, but during the year 1977
Nayaya Panchayats were abolished and the judicial functions were transferred to Gram
Panchayats. After the enactment of the act in 1970, the existing Gram Sabha were
recognised or bifurcated from time to time and new Gram Sabha/ Gram Panchayats
were established. It was in 2005-2006 government created 206 new Gram Sabha
circles, thereby raising the number to 3243 Panchayats.50 At Present, there are 3226
Gram Panchayats 78 Panchayat Samitis and 12 Zila Parishads constituted in the state.
Table 2.6
The Number of Gram Panchayats Since 1952-2015
Sr. No. Year No. of Gram Panchayats
1 1952 280
2 1954 466
3 1962 638
4 1966 1695
5 1972 2035
6 1978 2357
7 1985 2597
8 1991 2757
9 1995 2922
10 2000 3037
11 2005 3243
12 2010 3243
13 2015 3226
Source: Government of Himachal Pradesh, Annual Administrative Report, Panchayati Raj Department,
Shimla: Himachal Pradesh, 1952 to 2015-16.
50
Government of Himachal Pradesh, Annual Administrative Report, Panchayati Raj Department,
Shimla: Himachal Pradesh, 2014-15, p. 1.
96
3243
3500
3226
3243
3000
3037
2922
2757
2597
2500
2357
2000
2035
No. of Gram Panchayats
1695
1500
1000 638
500
466
280
0
1952195419621966197219781985199119952000200520102015
With a view to bring law relating to the Panchayats in conformity with the
provisions of the 73rd Constitutional Amendment Act, the Himachal Pradesh
Panchayati Raj Act, 1968 has repealed and the Himachal Pradesh Panchayati Raj Act,
1994 was enacted with effect from April 23, 1994. This act provided for a Gram Sabha
and Gram Panchayats, Panchayat Samitis and Zila Panchayats at village, block and
district level respectively.51
Gram Sabha which forms the core of the democratic decentralization needs to
be given utmost attention. Thus the state government has already taken steps to
strengthen the institution of Gram Sabha. Gram Sabha have been empowered to form
vigilance committees from amongst its members to supervise Gram Panchayats works,
schemes and other activities, no member of the Gram Panchayat shall be eligible to
become member of the vigilance committee. It has been made mandatory for every
Gram Sabha to hold four general meetings in every year, besides special meetings.
These meetings are required to be held in January, April, July and October.52
51
Government of Himachal Pradesh, Annual Administrative Report, Panchayati Raj Department,
Shimla: Himachal Pradesh, 2010- 2011, p. 4.
52
Himachal Pradesh Panchayati Raj Act 1994, Section 7, p. 23.
97
Under section 7-A of HPPR Act (Second Amendment) Act, 2000, there shall be
a Up-Gram Sabha for each ward of a Gram Sabha. All members of the Gram Sabha
residing within the area of the ward shall be members of the Up-Gram Sabha. Every
Up-Gram Sabha shall hold two general meetings in each year, and it shall be the
responsibility of the member of the Gram Panchayat representing the ward to convene
such meetings. The meeting of the Up-Gram Sabha shall be presided over by the
member of the Gram Panchayat representing the ward, who shall also record the
proceedings. The time and place of the meetings of the Up-Gram Sabha shall be fixed
and notified by the member of the Gram Panchayat representing the ward. The Up-
Gram Sabha shall nominate its members to represent it in the general meeting of the
Gram Sabha and these members shall be nominated in such a manner, that 50 per cent
of the total families residing in the area of the ward get nominated, provided that one-
half of the nominations shall be of women. The village level functionaries of the
agriculture, animal husbandry, primary education, health and family welfare,
horticulture, irrigation and public health etc. shall attend the meetings of Gram Sabha in
the jurisdiction they are posted. The Up-Gram Sabha may deliberate on issues relating
to its area and make recommendations to the Gram Panchayat or Gram Sabha.53
Quorum
The quorum for a Gram Sabha meeting (according to HPPR Act 1994, Act
No.15 of 2010) shall be 1/3rd of the total number of its members (i.e. voters) and
decision will be taken by the majority of members present and voting. If a meeting is
adjourned for short of quorum, at least 1/5th of the total number of its members shall be
required for holding the adjourned meeting.54
Gram Panchayat
Under section 8 HPPR Act 1994, there shall be a Gram Panchayat for a Gram
Sabha and every Gram Sabha shall, in the prescribed manner, elect from amongst its
members a Pradhan and Up-Pradhan of the Sabha. Who shall also be called the Pradhan
and Up-Pradhan of the Gram Panchayat and shall also elect from amongst its members
an Executive Committee called the Gram Panchayat, consisting of such number of
persons not being less than seven and more than fifteen, including Pradhan and Up-
53
Government of Himachal Pradesh, Annual Administrative Report, Panchayati Raj Department,
Shimla: Himachal Pradesh, 2014-2015, pp. 9-10.
54
The Himachal Pradesh Panchayati Raj (Amendment) Act, 2010(Act No.15 of 2010), p. 9.
98
Pradhan. The number of members excluding Pradhan and Up-Pradhan to be assigned to
each Gram Sabha, shall be determined on the following scale:
(b) With a population exceeding 1750 but not exceeding 2750 would be seven
(c) With a population exceeding 2750 but not exceeding 3750 would be nine
(d) With a population exceeding 3750 but not exceeding 4750 would be eleven
(e) With a population exceeding 4750, the number of members would be thirteen.55
Qualification
Reservation of Seats
The act provides the reservation of seats in Gram Panchayat for SCs and STs in
proportion to their population to the total population by rotation. Not less than 1/3 of
the total number of seats shall be reserved for women belonging to SCs and STs.
Similarly, not less than one-third (including the number of the seats reserved for
women belonging to SCs and STs) of the total number of seats to be filled by direct
election in every Gram Panchayat shall be reserved for women.57 The government can
also reserve seats for backward classes in a Gram Panchaayat. According to HPPR
Adhiniyam 2001, maximum 15 per cent seats shall be reserved for backward classes in
all tiers of PRIs and one third of the total number of seats shall be reserved for
women.58
Tenure
Every Panchayat shall continue for five years from the date appointed for its
first meeting and no longer unless, sooner dissolved under this Act. An election to
constitute a Panchayat shall be completed- before the expiry of its duration specified in
sub-section. And before the expiration of a period of six months from the date of its
55
Himachal Pradesh Panchayati Raj Act, 1994 (Act No.4 of 1994) Section 8, p.7.
56
Himachal Pradesh Panchayati Raj Act 1994 (Act No. 4 of 1994) Section 8, p. 7.
57
Himachal Pradesh Panchayati Raj (Amendment Act, No. 8 of 2000), p. 1.
58
Panchayati Raj Adhiniyam or Ewam Niyam, Department of Panchayati Raj, Shimla: Himachal
Pradesh, 2001, p.6.
99
dissolution: Provided that where the remainder of the period for which the dissolved
Panchayat would have continued is less than six months, it shall not be necessary to
hold any election under this clause for constituting the Panchayat for such period. A
Panchayat constituted upon the dissolution of a Panchayat before the expiration of its
duration shall continue only for the remainder of the period, for which the dissolved
Panchayats would have continued under sub-section (1) had it not been so dissolved.
Meeting
The meeting of the Gram Panchayat have been declared a public meeting and is
to be held at least once a month. Meeting are convened by the Up- pradhan and in his
absence by the Pradhan. One half of members of the Panchayat form the quorum. All
the decisions are taken by majority votes. In case of equal voting, Pradhan or Up-
Pradhan shall have the right or casting vote.59
According to Himachal Pradesh Panchayati Raj Act 1994 under section 11, the
Gram Panchayat has been entrusted with 29 functions, which included sanitation,
constructional and maintenance of records of birth and death, plantation and
preservation of Panchayat forest, removal of social evils like dowry, providing medical
care and in general carrying out functions entrusted to be by Panchayat Samiti, Zila
Parishad of the state government.60
Panchayat Samiti
Intermediate body of the three-tier Panchayati Raj system in the state is called
Panchayat Samiti. This institution is co-terminus with the development blocks.
Members of Panchayat Samitis are elected directly, whereas the Chairperson and Vice-
Chairperson are elected indirectly by the elected members. The number of elected
members of Panchayat Samiti are determined by the government at the rate of one
member of every 3500 population or part there of subject to a minimum of 15
members. There is no separate office of Panchayat Samitis but office function as
Samitis office. Block Development Officer has been designated as Chief Executive
Officer of the Panchayat Samitis, wheras Panchayat inspector is the secretary of the
Panchayat Samiti. The member of the Zila Parishad representing the ward which
59
Himachal Pradesh Panchayati Raj Act, 1994, Section 11.
60
Himachal Pradesh Panchayati Raj Act 1994 (Act No. 4 of 1994), pp. 70-71.
100
comprises wholly or partly the Panchayat Samiti area, shall also be the member of
Panchayat Samiti. Under section 78 of the Act Panchayat Samiti Consists of :
• The members of the Lok Sabha and the MLAs of the state representing
constituencies, which comprise wholly or partly the Panchayat Samiti area;
• The members of the council of states, where they are registered as electors
within the Panchayat Samiti area;
The act provides one-half of the total number of seats reserved under sub-
section (4) shall be reserved for women belonging to the SCs or, as the case may be the
STs. One-half (including the number of seats reserved for women belonging to the SCs
and the STs) of the total number of seats to be filled by direct election in every
Panchayat Samiti shall be reserved for women. Basic qualification for a candidate, who
is seeking to contest the election of Panchayat Samiti is 25 of age. The election of first
Panchayat Samiti was held by secret ballot and direct vote.61 Before the statehood
(1971), election of first Panchayat Samiti was held in 1972 and second in 1991 after
73rd Amendment in Indian constitution, thereby more elections were held in 1995,
2000, 2005, 2010 and 2015. At present there are 78 block in Himachal Pradesh.62
Table 2.7
Panchayat Samitis in Himachal Pradesh, 1972 to 2015
Sr. No. Election Year Total Blocks
1 1972 69
2 1991 69
3 1995 72
4 2000 75
5 2005 75
6 2010 77
7 2015 78
Source: Government of Himachal Pradesh, Annual Administrative Report, Panchayati Raj Department,
Shimla: Himachal Pradesh, 2015.
61
Himachal Pradesh Panchayati Raj Act 1994 (Act No. of 1994), pp. 21-22.
62
Government of Himachal Pradesh, Annual Administrative Report, Panchayati Raj Department,
Shimla: Himachal Pradesh, 2015-16.
101
78
78 77
76 75 75
74
72
72
Total Block
70 69 69
68
66
64
1972 1991 1995 2000 2005 2010 2015
Before the statehood, the elections of all the PSs were not held regularly and
after the statehood first election of PSs was held in1972 in all the blocks and second
election was held in 1991. In December
Decem 1995 with the increase of 3 Blocks,
locks, the total
numbers of Blocks were 72. At
A present there are 78 PSs (Blocks)) in Himachal Pradesh.
After the declaration of result of election of the elected members of the Panchayat
Samiti in the prescribed manner, the Deputy Commissioner concerned or any gazetted
g
officer
fficer appointed by him in this behalf shall,
shall as soon as possible but not later than one
week of such declaration, call under his President ship a meeting of all elected
members for the purpose of oath, or the affirmation of allegiance under section 127.
Immediately after oath or affirmation of allegiance under section 127 of the Act,
the elected members of a Panchayat Samiti elect one of its members to be the Chairman
and another member to be the Vice-Chairman.
Vice If the office of the Chairman or Vice-
Vice
Chairman, as the case may be, is vacated or falls vacant during the tenure on account of
death, resignation or no-confidence
confidence motion, a fresh election within a period of two
months from the date of occurrence of vacancy
vaca shall be held and the post will be filled
up. Panchayats Samiti members will hold their officer for five years.63
63
Himachal Pradesh Panchayati Raj Act, 1994, Under Section 127, p.73.
102
Under section 81 of the Himachal Pradesh Panchayati Raj Act 1994, the
Panchayat Samiti in the state performs a variety of functions:
e) Any other function with the approval of the state government or Zila Parishad.64
Zila Parishad
This is uppermost body of the Panchayati Raj System. In our state Zila Parishad
were constituted for the first time after the enactment of new law relating to Panchayati
Raj system, consequent upon 73rd Constitutional Amendment. Presently, there are 12
Zila Parishad in our state. The members of Zila Parishad are elected directly by the
people, however the Chairperson and Vice-Chairperson are elected by the elected
members indirectly. Elected members of Zila Parishad are determined by the state
government at the rate on, one member for every 25000 populations or part there of
subject to a minimum of 10 members. The members of lok sabha, members of state
legislative assembly representing a part or whole of the district and the members of
council of states, where they are registered as voters and chairpersons of Panchayat
Samiti of the district will also be the members of Zila Parishad. Additional Disrict
Magistrate, Project Officer, ITDP in scheduled areas has been designated as Chief
Executive Officer, whereas District Panchayat Officer is the Secretary of Zila Parishad.
In addition to this district planning officer will be Planning Secretary.65 Under section
89 of the Act, every Zila Parishad shall consist of following members: The directly
64
Himachal Pradesh Panchayati Raj Act 1994, Section 81, pp. 48-49.
65
Government of Himachal Pradesh, Annual Administrative Report, op. cit., 2015-16, p. 5.
103
elected members from territorial constituencies; The Members of the House of People
and the Members of the State Legislative Assembly representing a part or whole of the
district, whose constituencies lie within the district; The members of the council of
states, where they are registered as electors within the district; The chairmen of all
Panchayat Samitis in the district.66
(c) One-half (including the number of seats reserved for women belonging to the
SCs and the STs) of the total number of seats to be filled by direct election in
every Zila Parishad shall be reserved for women of this category by rotation.
Qualification
Term: the term of the members of Zila Parishad is five years. But they continue in
office till the election of new Zila Parishad members.
a) It control, co-ordinate and guide, the Panchayat Samiti and Gram Panchayat
within the district; It co-ordinate and consolidate the Panchayat Samiti plans;
b) It co-ordinate the demands for grants for special purpose received from the
Panchayat Samiti and forward them to the state government;
c) It secure the execution of the plans, projects schemes, or other works common
to two or more Panchayat Samitis in the district;
e) Exercise and perform such other powers and functions as the state government
may, confer on or entrust to it by the government.67
66
Himachal Pradesh Panchayati Raj Act 1994 (Act No. of 1994), p. 23.
67
Himachal Pradesh Panchayati Raj Act, 1994, Section 92.
104
Economic Profile of Himachal Pradesh
The era of economic planning started in Himachal Pradesh in 1948. The first
five year plan allocated about Rs. 52.7 million to Himachal. More than 50 per cent of
the expenditure was spent on transport facilities, since then it was felt that without
proper management, the process of planning and development couldn’t be carried out.
The community development programme was launched in 1952 with in the state. In
Mandi and Kangra, package programmes were undertaken in collaboration with the
West Germany for popularising modern techniques of cultivation among the farmers.
Suitable agriculture machinery and animal husbandry were introduced in these areas.
Well equipped soil testing laboratories, dairy farms and agricultural workshops were
setup at various centres, besides an Agriculture University at Palampur.69
Himachal is one of those states in India, which was rapidly transformed from
the most backward part of country to one of the most advanced states. At present it
ranks fourth in respect of per capita income among the states of the Indian union.
Himachal education system is well established, its agriculture is enough for its self-
sufficiency, its horticulture is highly impressive in the country and even in abroad, its
68
Mian Goverdhan Singh, op.cit.1985, p. 293.
69
Economy of Himachal Pradesh, https://en.m.wikipedia.org., Accessed on 14-07-2017.
105
road connectivity system has emerged as best in the mountainous areas in India. The
infrastructure for its industrial development are well laid out, its rich forest resources
being augmented and above all, the increasing attention of the nation towards the
exploitation of its hydel resources are the signs for its bright future.70 The economy of
the state also appears to be in resilient mode in terms of growth. As per advance
estimates, the growth rate of Gross State Domestic Product during 2016-17 will be 6.8
per cent.
Gross State Domestic Product or state income is the most important indicator
for measuring the economic growth of a State. According to quick estimates, the total
State Domestic Product for the year 2015-16 is Rs. 96, 289 crore against Rs. 89, 095
core in 2014-15, thereby registering a growth of 8.1 per cent at constant prices (2011-
2012). As per the quick estimates the value of Gross State Domestic Product of the
Pradesh at current prices, which was estimated at Rs. 1, 04,177 crore for 2014-15
increased to Rs. 1, 13, 667 core during 2015-16, registering an increase of about 9.1 per
cent. This increase is attributed to the agriculture and allied activities sector besides
other sectors of the economy. The food grains production increased to 16.34 lakh MT
in 2015-16 from 16.08 lakh MT in 2014-15 and also the production of apple increased
to 7.77 lakh MT in 2015-16 from 6.25 lakh MT in 2014-15.
70
Ibid.
106
Primary sector, which includes: Agriculture, Forestry, Fishing, Mining and
Quarrying, during 2015-16, witnessed growth rate of 0.7 per cent. The Secondary
sector, which comprises Manufacturing, Construction and Electricity, Gas and Water
Supply, registered a growth of 9.3 per cent during 2015-16. Transport storage,
communications and trade, this group of sectors shows a growth of 8.6 per cent during
2015-16. The transport by other means component of this sector has shown a growth of
5.9 per cent. Finance and Real Estate, this sector comprises Banking and Insurance,
Real Estate, Ownership of dwellings and Business Services. It witnessed a growth of
7.5 per cent in 2015-16. Community and personal Services the growth in this sector
during 2015-16 was 12.3 per cent. The overall contribution of local bodies in the Gross
State Domestic Product for the year 2015-16 was 0.24 per cent.71
Agriculture
Agriculture is the main occupation of the people of Himachal Pradesh and has
an important place in the economy of the state. Agriculture has played a predominate
place in the prosperity and economic development of Himachal Pradesh.72 Himachal
Pradesh is the only state in the country whose 89.96 per cent of population (Census
2011) lives in rural areas. Therefore, dependency on Agriculture/Horticulture is
eminent, as it provides direct employment to about 62 per cent of total workers of the
state. Agriculture happens to be the premier source of State Income (GSDP). About 10
per cent of the total GSDP comes from agriculture and its allied sectors. Out of the total
geographical area of state (55.67 lakh hectare) the area of operational holdings is about
9.55 lakh hectares and is operated by 9.61 lakh farmers. The average holding size
comes to 1.00 hectare. According to 2010-11 agricultural census the distribution of
land holdings shows that 87.95 per cent of the total holdings are of small and marginal
farmers. About 11.71 per cent of holdings are owned by Semi Medium/Medium
farmers and only 0.34 per cent by large farmers. The distribution of land holdings in
Himachal Pradesh has been depicted in table below:
71
Government of Himachal Pradesh, Economic Survey, Shimla: Economics and Statistics Department
Himachal Pradesh, 2016-17, pp. 10-12.
72
Mian Goverdhan Singh, op.cit., 2010, p. 245.
107
Table 2.8
Distribution of Land Holdings
(in years)
Size of Holdings Category No. of Holdings Area (Lakh Av. Size of
(hect.) (Farmers) (Lakh) hect.) Holding (hect.)
1 2 3 4 5
Source: Government of Himachal Pradesh, Economic Survey, Shimla: Economics and Statistics
Department Himachal Pradesh, 2016-17.
Table 2.8 shows that marginal and small farmers constitute 87.95 per cent of
total land holdings. The semi-medium and medium holding together constitute 11.71
per cent and the large holdings cover only 0.34 per cent. Thus, in Himachal Pradesh
bulk of holdings constitutes small and marginal holdings.
About 80 per cent of the total cultivated area in the state is rainfed. Rice, Wheat
and Maize are important cereal crops of the state. Groundnut, Soyabeen and Sunflower
in Kharif and Rapeseed/Mustard and Toria are important oilseed crops in the Rabi
season. Urd, Bean, Moong, Rajmash in Kharif season and Gram Lentil in Rabi are the
important pulse crops of the state. Agro-climatically, the state can be divided into four
zones viz:- sub tropical, sub-mountain and low hills, sub temperate, sub humid mid
hills, wet temperate high hills and cold deserts. The agro-climatic conditions in the state
are congenial for the production of cash crops like seed potato, off-season vegetables
and ginger. There is limited scope of increasing production through expansion of
cultivable land. Like whole country, Himachal too has almost reached a plateau in so
far as cultivable land is concerned. Hence, the emphasis has to be on increasing
productivity levels besides diversification towards high value crops.
Due to an increasing shift towards commercial crops, the area under food grains
is gradually declining, as the area which in 1997-98 was 853.88 thousand hectares is
likely to be declined to 764.85 thousand hectares in 2015-16. Increase in production
thus reflects gain in productivity as is evident from the table:
108
Table 2.9
Food Grains Area and Production
(in years)
In order to increase the production of food grains, emphasis has been laid on
distribution of seeds of high yielding varieties to the farmers. The area brought under
high yielding varieties of principal crops viz. Maize, Paddy and Wheat during the last
five years and proposed for 2016-17 is given in table.
Table 2.10
Area Brought Under High Yielding Varieties
(‘000 hect.)
Source: Government of Himachal Pradesh, Economic Survey, Shimla: Economics and Statistics
Department Himachal Pradesh, 2016-17.
109
There are 20 seed multiplication farms from where foundation seed is
distributed to registered farmers. There are 3 Vegetable Development Stations, 12
Potato Development Stations and 1 Ginger Development Station in the state.
According to 2011 census, out of total population, 30.05 per cent was main
workers, 21.81 per cent marginal workers and the 48.15 per cent were non-workers. In
other words, if we combine main and marginal workers, they constitute of 51.85 per
cent of the state as a whole.
Table 2.11
The total main workers, majority of 919.8 per cent were cultivators, 68.7 per
cent agricultural labourers, 32.7 per cent engaged in household industries and 1041.4
110
per cent in other activities. The highest percentage of workers in the state is in Kinnaur
district (55.61%), and Chamba district is at the bottom (23.05%). Due to difficult
geographical terrain, small size of land holdings and inadequate irrigation facilities are
main handicaps in the way of development of the agriculture in the state.
Horticulture
Himachal has resulted in shifting of land use pattern from agriculture to fruit
crops in the past few decades. The area under fruits, which was 792 hectares in 1950-51
with total production of 1,200 tonnes increased to 2, 26,799 hectares during 2015-16.
The total fruit production in 2015-16 was 9.29 lakh tonnes, which during 2016 -17
(upto December, 2016) has been reported as 5.10 lakh tones. During 2016-17, it was
73
Rajinder Attri, op.cit., 2010, pp. 627-628.
111
envisaged to bring 3, 000 hectares of additional area under fruit plants against which 2,
816.72 hectares of area was brought under plantations and 7.53 lakh fruit plants of
different species were distributed upto 31st December 2016.
The area under temperate fruits other than apple has increased from 900
hectares in 1960-61 to 27,908 hectares in 2015-16. Nuts and dry fruits exhibit area
increase from 231 hectares in 1960-61 to 10, 491 hectares in 2015-16, Citrus and other
sub tropical fruits have increased from 1, 225 hectares and 623 hectares in 1960-61 to
24,063 hectares and 53,658 hectares in 2015-16, respectively. This development has
further jeopardized due to the erratic apple production, owing to weather vagaries and
market fluctuations. The advent of WTO, GATT and liberalisation of economy is
further imposing many challenges on the dominance of apple in fruit industry of
Himachal Pradesh.
In warmer area of the state mango has emerged as an important fruit crop.
Litchi is also gaining importance in certain regions. Mango and litchi are fetching
better market prices. In the mid hill zone, the agro-climatic conditions are highly
suitable for the successful cultivation of new fruits like kiwi, olive, pomegranate, pecan
and strawberry.
74
Government of Himachal Pradesh, Economic Survey, op.cit., 2016-17, pp. 53-54.
112
Himachal Pradesh government and the farmers have seized this opportunity and
today this Pradesh has emerged as the ‘Horticultural State of India’. Apple is the major
horticultural crop, the production of which was 777.13 lakh tonne during 2015-16. Bulk
of the apple is produced in five districts viz. Shimla, Kullu, Mandi, Kinnaur, and
Chamba. For Integrated Developjmment of Horticulture, Centrally Sponsored
Development of Horticulture, Rashtriya Krishi Vikas Yojna and Pradhan Mantri Krishi
Sinchayee Yojna are being implemented in the state. Under this scheme various
activities of development, such as production of horticulture crops, strengthening of
basic infrastructure and development of irrigation facilities are being implemented. To
promote protected cultivation in horticulture, the state government has enhanced
subsidy under Poly Houses from 50 per cent to 85 per cent and 1.10 lakh sq. metre area
is targeted under Green Houses during year 2016-17. Rashtriya Krishi Vikas Yojna, in
which old apple orchards are being rejuvenated and replaced with the new improved
and regular bearing Spur varieties. To promote micro-irrigation facilities, 659 hectare
area has been brought under Pradhan Mantri Krishi Sinchayee Yojna upto December
2016. In addition to this, for strengthening irrigation facilities in the Orchards, Water
Storage Tanks and Borewells are being established in the state.75
Animal Husbandry
Animal Husbandry plays an important role to boost the rural economy of the
state. For any rural economy, raising up of live stock is considered to be a very
significant component. The topographical relationship in Himachal Pradesh established
an unique and dynamic relationship between common property resources such as
forests, water resources, live stocks, crops and grazing land. The number of live stocks
depends upon the fodder and grass able land to the large extent. The live stocks play an
important role in the sustainable development of the economy of Himachal Pradesh.76
Thus, the livestock is not only contributing towards agricultural production, but also is
even a source of self-employment to rural artisans. According to figures of 1966
census, the livestock population in Himachal Pradesh was about 42 lakh, 47.2 lakh in
1972, 49.9 lakh in 1977, 52.3 lakh in 1992 and 62.4 lakh as per 2010-11. The total
population of live stock, according to 2011-12 censuses has reached 48, 44,431. The
Government of Himachal Pradesh has initiated various development programmes of
75
Ibid., p.55.
76
Mian Goverdhan Singh, op.,cit., 2010, p.258.
113
animal husbandry in the state, which includes Animal Health and Disease Control,
Cattle Development; Sheep Breeding and Development of Wool, Poultry Development,
Feed and Fodder Development, Veterinary Education and Livestock Census.
Himachal Pradesh is one of the state amongst a few in the union of India,
which has been gifted by mother nature with rivers emanating from glaciers that
traverse through filly terrains and finally enrich the semi-plain area of the state with
77
Government of Himachal Pradesh, Economic Survey, op.cit., 2016-17, p. 58
114
their oxygen rich water. Under fisheries about 18,641 fishermen families in the Pradesh
depend directly or indirectly on the occupation and earn their livelihood by fishing. The
reservoir of Himachal Pradesh has the distinction of highest per hectare fish production
in Govind Sagar and highest sale price value of fish catch in Pong Dam in the country.
During the year 2016, 13.06 tonne trout has been sold from the state farms and earning
revenue to the tune of Rs. 86.64 lakh.
The total livestock in Himachal Pradesh in the year 2012 was 48, 44,431 and
various steps have been taken by the state government to improve the animal
husbandry. However, dairy production also is an integral part of the Animal
Husbandry. The recent trend towards the development of a market-oriented economy
emphasized the importance of milk production, especially in areas falling in the vicinity
of urban consumption centres. This motivated farmers to replace local non-descript
breeds of cows with cross-breed cows.78
The dairy development activities continued in the state under the animal
husbandry department upto 1983. In order to boost dairy products, similar methods as
used by the Anand Dairy Co-operatives Society of Gujarat were adopted by the
Himachal Pradesh Government and then a decision was taken to form a Himachal
Pradesh State Co-operative Milk Producers Federation in 1980. The dairy development
activities in the districts of Mandi, Bilaspur, Hamirpur, Solan, Sirmaur and parts of
Shimla was transferred from Animal Husbandry Department to the Milk Federation in
1983. In the remaining part of the state, it was transferred in 1992.79
78
Livestock Census-Directorate of Land Record and Animal Husbandry, Shimla: Department of
Himachal Pradesh, 2012-17.
79
Rajender Attri, op.cit., 2010, p. 750.
115
However, three big plants with a capacity of more than 10, 000 LPD are located in
Chakkar (Mandi), Tutu (Shimla) and Dagwar (Kangra). The production of various milk
products in the organised sector (Milkfed) including milk sold in the market, paneer,
butter ghee and dahi etc.80
Irrigation
In Himachal Pradesh the fields are terraced, sloppy and small size. The water
canals called Kuhls are the main source of irrigation in all districts except Sirmour, Una
and Solan. In Kangra and Una districts wells are also found but their share to the net
irrigated area is very less. Land of Himachal Pradesh is depending on the rain water.81
Total geographical area of Himachal Pradesh is 55.67 lakh hectares. Out of this, a high
percentage of area is under perpetual snow or under forests and steep barren slopes. As
per latest available figures, only 5.83 lakh hectares is the net area sown. It is estimated
that, ultimate irrigation potential of the state is approximately 3.35 lakh hectares, out of
which 50,000 hectares can be brought under irrigation through major and medium
irrigation projects and 2.85 lakh under minor irrigation schemes. Irrigation projects are
classified into three categories major, medium and minor. Projects having Cultivable
Command Area (CCA) of more than 10,000 hectares are classified as ‘Major Irrigation
Projects’ projects, which have a CCA of more than 2,000 hectares but less than 10,000
hectares are classified as ‘Medium Irrigation Projects’ and projects with CCA of 2,000
hectares or less are classified as minor irrigation projects. Under minor irrigation
projects, both types of water development viz. surface and ground is included.82
Forest
Himachal Pradesh has extensive forests which cover almost an area of 37.033
Sq.kms. This accounts for about 65.52 per cent of the total geographical area of the
state. Most of the forest belongs to the government and private forest is very small in
extent. The strategy of Himachal Pradesh government in forestry management is
conservation along with rational utilization and side by side expanding its base. The
forest of the state can be broadly classified into coniferous forests and broad-leaved
forests. Deodar, Kail, Chil, Spruce, Silver fir and Neoza Pine are the coniferous species
80
Government of Himachal Pradesh, Economic Survey, op.cit., 2016-17, pp. 58-62.
81
M. S. Ahluwalia, op.cit, 1998, pp.114-115.
82
Government of Himachal Pradesh, Economic Survey, op.cit., 2016-17, pp. 70-71.
116
growing in Himachal Pradesh whereas, Neoza Pine which produces edible nuts, is
grown in Kinnaur district. These are the only forest of Neoza in India.83 Among the
broad-leaved species, sal, ban, oak, mohru oak, kharshu oak, walnut, maple, birdcherry,
horse-chestnut, poplar, seemal, tun, and shisham are the important species in this forest.
These forest provide a large number of medicinal herbs and aromatic plants, which are
in great demand by pharmacetutical industry and perfuneries. Medicinal herbs like
dioscorea, belladonna, banafasha, mushakbala, patish, karru are already being exploited
in large quantities from these forest. The oil of skimia laureola, valeriana wallichi, kuth
and cedar wood oil and oak moss resin are in great demand in perfume making
industry. Coniferous woods provide excellent raw material for the manufacturers of a
number of products. These are fairly extensive areas of coniferous forests in this state
and there is a great scope for the establishment of wood-based industries.
The forest of the state till now has been exploited to produce mainly timber and
railway sleepers. This type of primitive usage has resulted in a great wastage of
valuable wood, which could otherwise be utilized to feed wood-based industries like
the manufacture of newsprint pulp. The manufacture of packing cases for apples from
this wood is also becoming an established cottage and medium scale industry in the
state. Some steps have been taken to establish suitable industries based on the forest
resources. Two government owned Rosin and Turpentine factories at Nahan and
Bilaspur are capable of handling about 1,11,000 quintals of oleo-resin. More factories
are being established for the processing of oleo-resin, rosin and turpentine oil. These
industries will play a very important part in the overall economy of the state.84
Himachal Pradesh covers an area of 37,033 Sq. kms. of the total geographical
area of the state. The government of India is well aware of the importance of the forest
and a large number of schemes and projects are being implemented in the state.
Productive forestry schemes and soil conservation schemes, wild life and nature
conservation, Indo-German, Eco Development Project (ODA) UK Forestry, Research
Education and Extension Project (REEP) and Watershed Development Project for
Himalayan Hills (Kandi Projects).85
83
Mian Goverdhan Singh, op.cit., 2010, p.170.
84
Ibid., pp. 270-273.
85
Government of Himachal Pradesh, Economic Survey, op.cit., 2016-17, pp. 66-69.
117
Industries
Industrially, Himachal Pradesh has been lagging behind other states of the
Indian union despite of many efforts being made in this field. Although, there have
been a number of cottage industry units engaged in the traditional crafts, such as shawl-
making and large-scale industries have been set up in the state. The reasons for the
industrial backwardness of Himachal Pradesh in industry apparently, have been due to
its difficult terrain and lack of speedy transport.
Between 1948 and 1966 i.e., upto the integration of Punjab hill areas into
Himachal Pradesh in November 1966, the industrialization of the state progressed
steadily but at a slow pace. By 1st November 1966, the number of small scale units in
the state had risen to 750. The government on its own had setup nearly 60 training cum-
production centres to promote such crafts as shawl making, footwear, carpets, etc. The
concerted efforts being made by the state government since 1967, indeed, have yielded
fairly impressive results on the industrial front. By 1976, the number of small-scale
units multiplied to 1,663 including cottage, village and other industries.86
As on 31st January 2017, there were 43,420 units working in the state. Out of
these, 138 Industrial Units are large and 438 are Medium Scale Units. The industry
department on permanent basis having the total investment of 17, 339.89 crore is
providing employment to 2,78,528 persons. Out of these 494 industrial units are
medium and large scale units.87 After the notification of special incentives package by
government of India in January, 2003, 8,375 small scale industrial units and 298
medium and large scale units having a total investment of 13, 923.22 crore have been
actually set in the state up to October 2012 and employment opportunities were
provided to 1,15,013 persons.88 The Ministry of Commerce and Industry (DIPP),
Government of India has accorded final approval for setting up of two state of art
industrial area at Pandoga district Kangra under modified industrial infrastructure
upgradation scheme. During the financial year 2016-17, an amount of Rs. 35.51 crore
has been allocated of development of these two states of art industrial areas, which has
been booked. The Government/Forest Land measuring 515 Bighas has been identified
for development of third state of the art industrial area at Dabhota, Tehsil Nalagarh in
district Solan. The FCA case has been submitted to the forest department for forest
86
Mian Goverdhan Singh, op.cit., 2010, pp. 265-266.
87
Government of Himachal Pradesh, Economic Survey, op.cit., 2016-17, p.67.
88
Ibid., p.73.
118
clearance under FCA, 1980 and is under process. Prime Minister’s Employment
Generation Programme (PMEGP), Assistant to the States for Development of Export
Infrastructure and Allied Activities (ASIDE) has been made by the government of
India. 89
Sericulture Industry
Hydel Power
Power sector play a significant role in the economy of Himachal Pradesh. It has
registered its significance in the economy by contributing in terms of revenue
generation, providing employment opportunities and enhancing the quality of life of
general public. Himachal Pradesh has been blessed with vast hydroelectric potential in
its five river basins, namely Yamuna, Sutlej, Beas, Ravi and Chenab. It is estimated
that about 23, 000 MW of hydel potential can be exploited in the state by constructing
various major, medium, small and mini/micro hydel projects on these five river basins.
89
Ibid.,
90
Ibid., p. 73.
91
M.S. Ahluwalia, op.cit.,1998, pp. 126-127.
119
Out of this hydel potential only 8, 432.47 MW has been harnessed by various agencies,
which also include 477.50 MW by H.P.S.E.B. Ltd. uptill 31st March 2014.
The main projects which are going on in the state are Andhra (16.95 MW), Giri
(60.00 MW), Gumma (3.00 MW), Rukti (1.50 MW), Chaba (1.75 MW), Rongtong
(2.00 MW), Nogli (2.50 MW), Bhaba (120.00 MW), Ganvi (22.50 MW), Binwa (6.00
MW), Gaj (10.50 MW), Baner (12.00 MW), Uhl-11 (Bassi) (66.00 MW), Larji
(126.00 MW), Khauli (12.00 MW), Sal-II (2.00 MW), Holi (3.00 MW), Bhuri Singh
P/H (0.45MW), Killar (0.30 MW), Sissu (0.10 MW), Thirot (4.50 MW), Bhaba
Augmentation (4.50 MW) and Himurja (Under State Sector) (2.37). The main projects,
which are ongoing with the Central/Joint Sector/ HP Share are Yammuna Project
(131.57 MW), Ranjeet Sagar Dam (27.60 MW), Bhakra (1,478.73 MW), Nathpa Jhakri
(1,500.00 MW), Baira Siul (198.00 MW), Chamera-I (540.00 MW), Chamera-II
(300.00 MW), Uhl-I (Shanan) (110.00 MW), Pong Dam (396.00 MW), B.S.L. (990.00
MW) and Chamera-III (231.00 MW).
As a result the Himachal Pradesh government has given thirteen hydro electric
projects in private sector for implementation. These projects are Baspa II (3.00 MW),
Malana-I (86.00 MW), Patikari (16.00 MW), Toss (10.00 MW), Sarbari II (5.40 MW),
Allain Duhangan (192.00 MW), Karchham Wangtoo ( 1, 000 MW), Upper Joiner
(12.00 MW), Sumez (14.00 MW), Beas Kund (9.00 MW), Malana II (100.00 MW),
Budhil (70.00MW), Neogal (15.00 MW) and Mini/ Micro Hydel Projects upto 5 MW
through Himurja (220.25 MW). The increasing activities on construction of hydel
projects, there is an immediate need to lay emphasis on adequate transmission and
distribution network in order to transmit power from these projects and its distribution
for utilisation within the state.92 Electrification of rural areas has great significance for
Himachal Pradesh, where as much as 91.3 per cent of its population lives in villages.
The state has made remarkable achievements in the field of rural electrification. 93
92
Government of Himachal Pradesh, Economic Survey, op.cit., 2016-17, pp. 79-86.
93
Ibid., p. 87.
120
no exaggeration to state that the construction of roads in a mountainous region is, in
fact, the beginning of the process of development. The total length of motorable roads
in Himachal Pradesh at the time of its formation in 1948 was 290 Kilometres in
addition to about 300 Kilometres of jeep able roads. In the rest of the areas there were
either foot-path or mule tracks.94 The revenue of the corporation is expected to increase
by 58 crore during the year 2013-14. Roads are an essential ingredient of infrastructure
of economy. In the absence of any other suitable and viable modes of transportation
like railways and waterways, roads play a vital role in boosting the economy of the
hilly state like Himachal Pradesh. Starting almost from a scratch the state Government
has constructed 36, 256 Kms. of motorable roads till December, 2016. The State
Government has been assigning a very high priority to road sector. For the year 2016-
17, there was an outlay of Rs. 912.73 crore. The process of improvement of National
Highways in the state having total length of 2, 027.00 Kms., which includes urban links
and bye-passes, continued during the year also. By the end of December 2016, an
expenditure of Rs. 184.00 crore has been incurred. There are only two narrow gauge
railway lines connecting Shimla with Kalka (96 Km.) and Jogindernagar with
Pathankot (113Km.) and one 33 Km. broad gauge railway line from Nangal Dam to
Charuru in District Una.
Road transport is the main stay of economic activity in the Pradesh as other
means of transport namely Railways, Airways, Taxies, Auto Rickshaw etc. are
negligible. Therefore, the road transport corporation assumes paramount importance.
The growth of means of communication as telephone, telegraphs, newspapers, radio,
roads, post office and televisions are playing an important role in the development of
Himachal Pradesh.95 The passenger transport services to the people of Himachal
Pradesh within and outside the state are being provided by Himachal Road Transport
Corporation (HRTC), with a fleet strength of 3,012 buses as on October, 2016. HRTC
is plying bus services on 2,530 routes with coverage of 5.504 Lakh Kms. daily.96
94
Mian Goverdhan Singh, op.cit., 1988, p. 203.
95
Government of Himachal Pradesh, Economic Survey, op.cit., 2016-17, pp. 57-58.
96
Ibid., p. 94.
121
Tourism
Himachal Pradesh has mountains and hills but even more important the people
to provide both the adventure and walking tour holidays that cannot be matched
anywhere in the world. The towering middle, low series of mountains and the deepest
gorges form the picturesque scenes for tourists. The different ecological belts from sub-
tropical to perpetual snow with various climatic zones, differentiation, give pleasure for
mountain tourists throughout the year. Everywhere the mountain tourists experience
peace and happiness in the land, which is far from the madding crowd. The sparsely
populated valleys and ridges provide relief and healing touch to people of the plains,
who suffer from heat and over crowdedness and seek the desired peace and tranquillity.
Almost all the regions of Himachal Pradesh are attractive to the tourists. While trekking
in Himachal, one can see the spectacular snowy peaks, beautiful lakes and meet
interesting people living in the remote villages in the rugged mountains. Although the
trekking trails are sometimes steep and lonely, almost all the seasons are tourist’s
seasons in Himachal Pradesh. Tourists who wants to enjoy mountain life and traditions
can visit the state throughout the year.97
97
Rajender Attri, op.cit., 2010, pp.778-779.
122
The department has released advertisements in the print and electronic media to
promote the tourism from time to time during the financial year. The department has
prepared the 20 years perspective tourism master plan for the planned and sustainable
development of the tourism sector. Tourism policy, 2013 and sustainable plan for
Dharamshala, 2013 have also been formulated. The department has organized various
adventure and general training courses for the unemployed youths of the state like
trekking guide, water sports, skiing EDP, Bird watching and river rafting etc. in the
state.98
The State Government has prevention and treatment intervention are accessible
to people and are applied efficiently. In Himachal Pradesh, health and family welfare
department is providing services which include curative, preventive, promotive and
rehabilitative services through a network of 75 Civil Hospitals, 87 Community Health
Centres, 533 Primary Health Centres, 13 ESI Dispensaries and 2,078 Sub-Centres.99
A brief descriptions of various health and family welfare activities carried out in
the state during 2016-17 are as under: National Vector Borne Disease Control
Programme, National Leprosy Eradication Programme, Revised National T.B. Control
Programme, National Programme for Control of Blindness, National Family Welfare
Programme, Universal Immunization Programme, Mukhya Mantri State Health Care
Scheme, National Rural Health Mission and National AIDS Control Programme. These
all programmes are being implemented as per the guidelines of government of India.
98
Government of Himachal Pradesh, Economic Survey, op.cit., 2016-17, p.108.
99
Ibid., p.124.
123
RPGMC Tanda. Indian system of medicines and homoeopathy plays a vital role in the
health care system of the state. The separate department of Ayurveda was established in
1984 and health care services are being provided to the general public through 2
Regional Ayurvedic Hospitals, 2 Circle Hospitals, 3 Tribal Hospitals, 16 Ten/Twenty
bedded Ayurvedic Hospitals, 9 District Ayurvedic Hospitals, One Nature Care
Hospital, and 1,150 Ayurvedic Health Centres, 3 Unani Health Centres, 14
Homoeopathic Health Centres and 4 Amchiclinics. The department has inbuilt system
of production of medicines through 3 Ayurvedic Pharmacies, at Jogindernagar in
Mandi District, Majra in Sirmaur district and Paprola in Kangra district.
These pharmacy catering to the needs of the Ayurvedic health institutions of the
department and also give boost the employment to local people. The department of
Ayurveda is also associated with health programmes like malaria, family welfare and
anaemia free, AIDS, immunization and pulse polio etc. during the financial year 2016-
17, there was a budget provision of Rs. 250.00 crore. To provide better health services
to the people, the government is strengthening the existing infrastructure by providing
modern equipments, specialized services, increasing the strength of the medical and
para-medical staff in the medical institutions.100
Education
Education is the key instrument for development human capability. The state is
committed to provide education to all. Literacy is an important indicator of the socio-
economic development of any area and it is the base of socio-economic change.
Initially, Himachal was considered as a backward region of the north India. The view
came up in the report of state reorganization commission published in 1953, literacy
rate of the Himachal Pradesh was 21 per cent for female as per the 1961 census, well
below the corresponding all India literacy rate. In spite of difficult terrain and many
socio-political cultural barriers, Himachal Pradesh has been making consistent efforts
for the development of education in the Pradesh. After the independence, the overall
literacy rate has shown significant upward trend both for male and female. At present,
there are 10,738 notified primary schools out of which 10,735 are functional and 2,113
middle schools were notified out of which 2,103 are functioning in the state. To
100
Ibid.,
124
overcome the shortage of trained teachers efforts are being made to make fresh
appointments of teachers in the needy schools. An attempt has also been made to cater
the educational need of disabled children.101
There are four agricultural institutions in the state for agricultural education and
research. These institutions are, Central Potato Research Institute (Shimla); Farmers
Training Institute (Sundernagar); Himachal Agriculture College and Research Institute
(Solan-Nauni); Regional Bee Research Centre of the Central Bee Research Institute
(Kangra). These institutions are Indian Institute of Technology (IIT), Mandi at
Kamand, National Institute of Technology, Hamirpur, one National Institute of Fashion
Technology (NIFT), Kangra, Indian Institute of Management (IIM), Sirmour, Indian
Institute of Information Technology, Una, Central Institute of Plastic Engineering and
Technology (CIPET), Baddi in district Solan, Regional Vocational Training Institute
(RVTI) for Women at Jhundla, Tehsil Shimla Rural, district Shimla, Jawahar Lal Nehru
Government Engineering College, Sundernagar, Atal Bihari Vajpayee Government
Institute of Engineering and Technology, Pragatinagar, district Shimla, Rajiv Gandhi
Government Engineering College, Kangra at Nagrota Bagwan, Mahatma Gandhi
Government Engineering College, Kotla Tehsil Rampur (Jeori) district Shimla, 2
Government Pharmacy College, Rohroo District Shimla and Nagrota Bagwan District
Kangra, 13 B-Pharmacy Colleges (Private Sector), 14 Engineering Colleges (Private
Sector), 15 Polytechnics ( Government Sector), 18 Polytechnics (Private Sector), 02 D-
Pharmacy Colleges (Private Sector). There are seven, 2nd Shifts in Diploma Courses
(Private Sector), 108 Co-educational Industrial Training Institutes (Government
Sector), and nine Industrial Training Institutes (Women) (Government Sector).
However, there is one ITI for Persons with disability at Sundernagar (Government
Sector), 1 Motor Driving School at Una in Government Sector and 143 ITIs Private
Sectors.102 The literacy, rate in Himachal Pradesh which was 7.98 per cent during
1950-51, has gone upto 82.80 per cent in 2011, and the same is 89.53 per cent for males
and 75.93 per cent for females. The district wise literacy rates in Himachal Pradesh are
as under:
101
Ibid., p.101.
102
Ibid., pp.111-114.
125
Table 2.12
Bilaspur
86.53 84.59
Chamba
81.53 Sirmaur
80
Solan
76.81 79.4
Una
126
The table 2.12 shows that the highest literacy rates have been recorded in
Hamirpur district with 88.15 per cent for the total population in which 94.36 per cent
are males and 82.62 per cent are females. The lowest literacy percentage is in the
district of Chamba i.e. 72.17 per cent of the total population in which 82.59 per cent are
male and 61.67 per cent are females. Further analysis shows that apart from the
Chamba, the female literacy rates are less than the state average in other district.
Mineral Wealth
103
Ibid., p.74.
104
Mian Goverdhan Singh, op.cit., 2010, p. 272.
127
allocated amongst three banks viz. PNB, UCO Bank and State Bank of India. The UCO
Bank is the convenor Bank of State level Bankers Committee (SLBC). Up to
September, 2016 the State has a network of 2, 061 and more than 80 per cent branches
are functioning in rural areas. Banks have opened 106 new bank branches during
October, 2015 to September, 2016. At present 1, 661 branches are located in rural areas
and 308 in semi-urban areas and 92 are functioning at Shimla, the only urban centre in
the State classified by Reserve Bank of India (RBI).
Himachal Pradesh State Cooperative Bank is performing dual function viz. that
of Apex Cooperative Bank in Himachal Pradesh to play lead role in development in
Cooperative in the state and that of a Cooperative Bank in six districts viz. Bilaspur,
Chamba, Kinnaur, Mandi, Shimla and Sirmaur. The Himachal Pradesh Cooperative
Bank is serving the people of the state through a network of 198 branches and 21
extension counters, all these branches are on CBS mode. The State Co-operative Bank
is the first State Co-operative Bank on the National financial switch through which the
customers are getting ATMs facilities all over the Nation and about 71 own ATMs on
strategic locations. Bank is actively participating in government of India social security
scheme i.e. Pradhan Mantri Jeevan Jyoti Bima Yojana (PMJJBY) and Pradhan Mantri
Suraksha Bima Yojana (PMSBY).
The Kangra Central Cooperative Bank, Dharamshala had 204 branch offices
including head office as on 2016 with deposits of Rs. 8, 42,753 lakh. Similarly, the
Jogindra Central Co-operative Bank Ltd., Solan had 29 branches, including head office
with deposits of Rs. 70,784 lakh in 2016. Himachal Pradesh Gramin Bank, sponsored
by Punjab National Bank having total branch network of 244 as on September,
2016.105
Rural Development
128
Rural Livelihood Mission (NRLM); Deen Dayal Upadhaya-Gramin Kaushal Yojna;
Watershed Development Programme; Pradhan Mantri Awaas Yojana Gramin (PMAY-
G); State Rural Housing Schemes-Rajiv Awaas Yojana; Mukhaya Mantri Awaas
Yojana (MMAY); Rajiv Awaas Repair Yojana (RARY);Saansad Adrash Gram Yojana
(SAGY); Matri Shakti Bima Yojana; Swachh Bharat Mission (Gramin); Maharshi
Valmiki Sampooran Swachhata Puruskar (MVSSP); Mahila- Mandal Protsahan Yojna;
Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme (MGNREGS).106
The present District of Mandi was formed with the merger of two princely
states Mandi and Suket on 15th April, 1948, when the state of Himachal Pradesh came
into existence. Ever since the formation of the district, it has not witnessed any changes
in its jurisdiction. The state of Suket is said to have been founded by Bir Sen, an
ancestor of the Sen Dynasty of Bengal. The separation of Mandi from Suket took place
about the year 1200 AD. Upto that time, it was the single state of Suket. Mandi
emerged as a separate state in the beginning of the sixteenth century. Ajbar Sen was the
first great ruler of Mandi, who founded Mandi Town in 1927 AD. He was probably the
first to assume the designation of Raja. He built a palace here and the temple of Bhut
Nath. Down the line of descendants was Raja Sidh Sen, who succeeded Raja Gur Sen
in 1678 AD. Mandi had never been so powerful before and after his reign. Guru
Govind Singh, the tenth Guru of the Sikhs visited Mandi during his reign in the close of
the 17th century. He built the great tank before the palace. He also built the temples of
“Sidh Ganesh” and “Trilok Nath.”108
106
Ibid., pp.134-142.
107
Gazetteer of the Mandi State, New Delhi: Indus Publishing Company, 1920, p. 14.
108
Government of Himachal Pradesh, District Human Development Report Mandi, Shimla: Planning
Department Himachal Pradesh, 2001, p. 14.
129
The history of both the state of Mandi and Suket is full with wars among
themselves and other adjoining states. These two states had always been rivals and
generally enemies, but there was no great result of their warfare. On 10th November,
1921, both the states of Mandi and Suket were transferred from the political control of
Punjab Government to that of Government of India till 15th August, 1947. The only
place in the district that has an early mention in literature is Rewalsar and it is
mentioned in the Skanda Purana as a sacred place of pilgrimage. It is believed that
Karnpur, a small village, was founded by Karan, a hero of Mahabharta. According to
the Tibetan tradition, Padam Sambhab (750-800 AD), the great Buddist Patriarch, who
was summoned by King Tisong-De-Tsen of Tibet for preaching Buddhism, hailed from
Zohar, which represents the country round about Rewalsar. On the basis of this, it is
concluded that Mandi must have been a great place of Buddist learning as well about
this time.109
Geography
The district is situated between 31º-13-50” and 32º-04-30” north latitude and
76º-37-20” and 77º-23-15” east longitudes. It is bounded by Kangra on the north-west,
Hampirpur and Bilaspur in the west, Arki tehsil of Solan district in the south, Shimla
district in the south-west and Kullu district in the east. The district has two main rivers
viz; the Beas and the Satluj. The river Beas enters the district from close to Bajaura, at
the boundary of Kullu and leaves the district at Sandhol. The Mandi town is also
located on the banks of this river. For the greater part of its length, it runs between high
banks and as it is never of great width, though the current is swift, especially during the
rains. Practically, the whole of the district drains into the Beas with only the southeast
corner situated on the Satluj watershed. Within the district the principal tributaries of
the Beas on the north bank are Uhl, Luni, Rana and Binu and on the south bank are the
Hanse, Tirthan, Bakhli, Jiuni, Suketi, Ranodi, Son and Bakar. The greater part of the
district is mountainous terrain with the main ranges of mountains running from the
north to the south with the system being broken up by innumerable transverse spurs.
The most conspicuous is the Jalori range which is crossed by a high road from Kullu to
Shimla by a pass named as Jalori pass. It divides the watersheds of the Satluj and the
109
Ibid., p.15.
130
Beas and on its northern slopes is unusually well wooded with deodar (Cedrus
Deodara) and blue pine (Pinus Wallichiana) forests of great value. The highest peak in
the range is Shikari Devi (11,060 feet). Its summit being crowned by a shrine to a local
goddess. The range throws off three main spurs which extend throughout the tract
known as the Mandi Saraj. To the north of the Beas is the Nargu range, a continuation
of the Bir Bhangal, separating Mandi from Kullu proper and crossed by the Bhubu pass
(9,480 feet). The mountains here run upto 13000 feet and the slopes often being very
precipitous, while the valleys are deep. Almost parallel and running down the centre of
the district is the Ghoghar-ki-Dhar, of which the slopes are fairly gentle. It is not well
wooded, but contains large expanses of excellent grazing and the salt quarries of Drang
and Gumma. The Sikandar Range commences from the trijunction with Suket and
Bilaspur and from there runs northward for fifty miles. The range contains some good
forests of chil pine, but the greater part of it consists of rich grass slopes. Its name is
attributed to Sikander Lodhi, who, 375 years before the reign of Akbar, is supposed to
have crossed it on his way to the conquest of Kangra.110
Climate
110
Ibid., pp.15-17.
111
Mandi, Himachal Pradesh, https://en.wikipedia.org.,Accessed on 29-12-2016.
131
Area and Population
As per 2011 census, the district has a population of 9,99,777 persons with a
population density of 253 persons per sq. km. Mandi district population constituted
14.56 per cent of total Maharashtra population. Out of the total population of the
district, 293,739 persons are scheduled castes and 12,787 persons are scheduled tribes.
The male and female population in the district is 4,98,065 and 5,01,712 respectively,
with a sex ratio of 1007 females per 1000 males. The schedule caste population in the
district is 29.4 and the schedule tribe population is 1.3. As per the census of India 2011,
rural population in the district is 937,140 persons and the urban population is 62,637
persons. 112
Mandi has an average literacy rate of 81.53 per cent, higher than the national
average of 74.04 per cent and almost equal to state’s literacy rate 82.80 per cent, male
literacy is 89.56 per cent and female literacy is 73.66 per cent. Mandi has a mixed
population of Hindus, Sikhs, Buddhists and Christians with more than 90 per cent
population being Hindu. As per 2011 census, the area of Mandi district is 3,950 km2.
and covers 7.10 per cent area of the state.113
Culture
132
in the month of March every year. The celebration of Shivratri of Mandi is said to have
started in the year 1526 to commemorate the foundation of present day Mandi. Before
this, the capital of Mandi was on the right bank of the river Beas, which is now known
as Old Mandi (Purani Mandi). Mandi also hosts a half marathon every year.
Once, the tenth guru of the Sikhs was on a visit to Mandi, the king of Mandi
invited him to stay at the royal palace. The guru accepted the invitation to stay in
Mandi but not with the king. He put up outside the town in a secluded place, which had
once been the hermitage of a Rishi (Indian sage). The guru was touched by the king’s
devotion and prophesized that Mandi would ever remain safe and if any enemy tries to
harm it, bolts from heaven would crush the invader. He considered Mandi the safest
place on the planet.114
Economy
Many hectares of land in Mandi are also under apple production. Apples are
generally planted during December every year. The area under fruit cultivation in
Mandi is about 15 per cent of the total area, under fruits in Himachal Pradesh. Mandi
raw silk has acquired wide fame but the salt mines at Drang and Guma are the special
features of the economy. With abundant deposit of salt and limestone, possibilities are
114
Mandi, Himachal Pradesh, https://en.wikipedia.org.,Accessed on 29-12-2016, pp. 7-8.
133
being investigated for the existence of magnasite coal and china-clay. Mandi also has
fish markets, where brown trout is one of the most demanded fish species. In Mandi, a
farmer gets around Rs.200 per kg. for Brown Trout.115
As per the census of India 2011, out of the total population of the district,
2,84,154, persons are main workers, 2,88,517 persons are marginal workers and
4,27,106 persons are non-workers in the district. Out of the total workers, 5, 72,671 are
main workers (Main Marginal Workers), 3, 87,944 are cultivators, 15,822 are
agricultural labourers, 7,134 are engaged in household industries and 1, 61,771 are
engaged in other activities.116
Education
The city has Anganwadis, primary as well as high schools. Some of the popular
school in the city are DAV Centenary Public School, Kendriya Vidyalaya, Mandi
Public School, Indus World School, The Phoenix School of Integrated Learning, Vijay
Government Senior Secondary School, Government Senior Secondary School (Girls),
Sarswati Vidya Mandir, Sai Public School, St. Xavier Residentia School, DAV Sr.
Secondary School, Anglo Sanskrit Model School. The Medical Institutes in Mandi is
Himachal Dental College. Jawaharlal Nehru Government Engineering College, T. R.
Abhilashi Memorial Institute of Engineering and Technology, and Vallabh Bhai
Government College are also located in the city. The Indian Institute of Technology
Mandi, is an autonomous and top university of the state for Graduation in
B.Tech/M.Tech offering many courses. The Abhilashi University is also based in
Mandi, is having several branches offering engineering and technology, pharmacy,
management studies, vocal training institute. There are many other private institutes of
higher education and research located in Mandi, like M.G. Institute of Engineering and
Technology, Sirda Institute of Engineering and Emerging Technology for Women,
Noble College of Education and Centre for Computer Education and Software
Development.117
115
Ibid., pp. 5-6.
116
Government of Himachal Pradesh, Socio-Economic Indicators of Himachal Pradesh, op.cit., 2014-
15, p.19.
117
Mandi, Himachal Pradesh, https://en.wikipedia.org.,Accessed on 29-12-2016, pp. 8-10.
134
Mandi district comprises seven tehsils namely, Joginder Nagar, Sarkaghat,
Sunder Nagar, Sadar Mandi, Chachiot, Thunag, Karsog and Nine sub-tehsils, i.e.,
Ladbharol, Padher, Sandhole, Dharmpur, Baldwara, Nihri, Kotli, Aut, Bali Chowki.
For the purpose of development activities, the district has been divided into 10
Blocks. The district has six city including Pandoh as census city. These are namely
Mandi, Sunder Nagar, Joginder Nagar, Rewalsar, Sarkaghat and Pandoh. Recently,
Mandi has become Zonal Headquarter of Central Zone, which covers the districts of
Bilaspur, Hamirpur, Kullu and Mandi itself and has gained much importance from
administrative point of view. Nagar Parishad Mandi was constituted during 1950.118
Kangra district derives its name from Kangra town that was known as Nagarkot
in ancient times. Kangra proper originally was a part of the ancient Trigarta
(Jullundur), which comprises of the area lying between the river “Shatadroo” (probably
Sutlej) and Ravi. A tract of land to the east of Sutlej that probably is the area of Sirhind
in Punjab also formed a part of Trigrata. Trigrata had two provinces that is one in the
plains with headquarters at Jullundur and other in the hills with headquarters at
Nagarkot (the present Kangra).
The present Kangra district came into existence on the 1st September 1972
consequent upon the re-organisation of districts by the government of Himachal
Pradesh. It was the largest district of the composite Punjab in terms of area, till it was
transferred to Himachal Pradesh on the 1st November 1966, and had six tehsils namely
Nurpur, Kangra, Palampur, Dehragopipur, Hamirpur and Una. Kullu was also a tehsil
of Kangra district up to 1962 and Lahaul & Spiti, which also formed a part of Kangra
was carved out as a separate district in 1960. On the re-organisation of composite
Punjab on the 1st November 1966, the area constituting Kangra district were transferred
to Himachal Pradesh along with the districts of Shimla, Kullu and Lahaul & Spiti and
tehsils of Una and Nalagarh and three villages of Gurdaspur district.119
118
Ibid.,
119
Government of Himachal Pradesh, District Human Development Report Kangra, Shimla: Planning
Department Himachal Pradesh, 2009, p. 5.
135
Location
Topography
As per 2011 census, the district has a population of 15, 10,075 persons with a
population density of 263 persons per sq km. Population wise, it ranks first in the state.
Out of the total population of the district, 3, 19,385 persons are scheduled castes and
84,564 persons are scheduled tribes. The male and female population in the district is 7,
50,591 and 7, 59,484 respectively with a sex ratio of 1012 females per 1000 males. The
schedule caste population in the district is 21.2 per cent and the schedule tribe
120
Kangra, Himachal Pradesh, www.himachaltouristguide.com., Accessed on 29-12-2016.
121
Government of Himachal Pradesh, District Human Development Report Kangra, op.cit.,2009, p. 14.
136
population is 5.6 per cent. As per the census of India 2011, rural population in the
district is 14, 23,794 persons and the urban population are 86,281 persons.122
Kangra has an average literacy rate of 85.67 per cent, higher than the national
average of 74.04 per cent and almost equal to state’s literacy rate 82.80 per cent, male
literacy is 91.49 per cent and female literacy is 80.02 per cent.123
Economy
Kangra being the largest district accounting for more than one fifth of the state
population and 10.31 per cent of total geographical area plays an important role in the
economy of the state. The economy of district is primarily agrarian with two- thirds of
the population directly dependent on agriculture.124 The district is covered by fertile
valleys and agriculture is the mainstay of rural population. The agro-climatic conditions
obtaining in the district are most suitable for the growing of food crops such as wheat,
rice, maize oil seeds, sugarcane, potatoes and tea.125 Tea cultivation was introduced in
1850 into the Kangra valley. The Palampur fair, established by government with a view
to fostering commerce with central Asia, attracts a small concourse of Yarkandi
merchants. The Lahaulis, carry on an enterprising trade with Ladakh and countries
beyond the frontier, by means of pack sheep and goats. Rice, tea, potatoes, opium,
spices, wool and honey are the chief exports.126 Tourism is also an important part of the
economy, with Bir in particular becoming a strong hub for ecotourism and aero sports.
This area was significantly damaged by an earthquake on April 4, 1905.127
As per the census of India 2011, out of total population of the district, 3, 13,915
persons are main workers, 3, 61,255 persons are marginal workers and 8, 34,905
persons are non-workers in the district. Out of the total workers, 6,75,170 are the main
workers, 3, 03,007 are cultivators, 54,849 are agricultural labourers, 15,662 are
engaged in household industries and 3, 01,652 are engaged in other activities.128
122
Government of Himachal Pradesh, Statistical Abstract of Himachal Pradesh, op.cit., 2015-16, pp. 2- 15.
123
Ibid., p. 64.
124
Government of Himachal Pradesh, District Human Development Report Kangra, op.cit., 2009, p.32.
125
Jag Mohan Balokhra, The Wonderland Himachal: An Encyclopedia on a Tiny State of Western
Himalayas, New Delhi: H.G. Publications, 2007, p. 541.
126
Kangra, Himachal Pradesh, http://en.m.wikipedia.org., Accessed on 29-12-2016, p. 2.
127
Kangra District, http://en.m.wikipedia.org., Accessed on 29-12-2016.
128
Government of Himachal Pradesh, Socio-Economic Indicators of Himachal Pradesh, op.cit., 2014-
15, p.19.
137
The Beas river forms the major drainage system in the district. The river Beas
and its tributaries drain almost the entire district, except the north eastern part which is
drained by the river Ravi. There are two important lakes in the district, namely Dal
Lake and Kareri. The population of Kangra district comprises a multi religious
community of Hindus, Muslims, Buddhists, Sikhs, Christians and Jains.
Culture
The traditional dress for men was the Kurta, Pyjamas, and a woolen jacket used
in winter. Women generally wear the Salwar Kameez and with the Salwar kameez girls
and women taken Chuenni (“Chaddru” in local language).
Kangra valley is one of the most picturesque, green and luxuriant valleys of
lower Himalayas sheltered by the sublime Dhauladhar range. This is one of the most
important and famous districts of Himachal Pradesh due to its popularity. Kangra is
mainly famous for its natural beauty and tea gardens. Number of people visit here. It is
the home of Masroor Rock Cut Temple, also known as Himalayan Pyramids and
Wonder of the World, for being likely contender for the UNESCO World Heritage Site.
Many ancient temples like the Jawalaji Chamunda Devi Temple, Chintapurni Temple
Baba Baroh, Masroor Temple built by Pandvas and Baijnath Temple are found here.
One can also pay a visit to Gopalpur Nature Park in Gopalpur village and can also see
tea gardens there. The Kangra fort is also a popular tourist attraction. Mcleodganj near
Dharamshala is the home in exile to the his Holiness Dalai Lama, the Tibetan spiritual
guru and “Bhagsunag Temple” at Bhagsu. Cricket ground of Dharamshala is also a
major attraction because of its location and good quality pitch for players. Maharaja
Sansar Chandra Museum adjoins the Kangra fort. Available at the Museum are audio
guides for the Kangra fort and the museum.129
129
Kangra, Himachal Pradesh, http://en.m.wikipedia.org., Accessed on 29-12-2016, pp.2-3.
138
Kangra district consists of total fifteen Development Blocks: Baijnath,
Bhawarna, Lambagaon, Panchrukhi, Kangra, Nagrota Bagwan Rait, Dehra,
Dharmshala, Pragpur, Nagrota Suria, Nurpur, Indora, Fatehpur, Sulah.
Tehsils in Kangra : Nurpur, Nagrota, Indora, Jwali, Kangra, Palampur, Badoh, Kasba
Kotla, Jaswan, Dehra Gopipur, Khundiyan, Jaishinghpur, Baijnath, Fatehpur,
Dharamshala, and Shahpur.
130
Kangra District, http://en.m.wikipedia.org., Accessed on 29-12-2016.
139
CHAPTER-III
The statistics shows that even in the developed countries like United States of
America (19.4%), United Kingdom (32.0%), Germany (37.0%), Canada (26.3%), Italy
(31.0%), France (39.0%), Japan (9.3%), etc., the participation of women in the
Lower/Single House of National Parliaments /Legislatures is very low as compared to
men. The highest representation of women in parliaments/legislatures is found in the
countries like Rawanda (61.3%), Cuba (48.9%), Iceland (47.6%), Sweden (43.6%),
South Africa (42.0%), Finland (42.0%), Norway (39.6%), Argentina (38.9%), Denmark
(37.4%) and Netherlands (36.0%). In Scandinavian Countries, women enjoy an equal
status with men and their representation in national legislatures is found between 38.0
to 47.0 per cent, whereas the lowest representation is noted in the countries like Nauru
(10.5%), Bahrain (7.5%), Iran (5.9%), etc. There are also countries like Yemen, Qatar,
Papua New Guinea and Vanuatu, etc., where there is no representation of women in the
national legislatures/ parliaments. In the developing countries, women representations
in lower house like Nepal (29.6%), Pakistan (20.6%), China (24.2%), Bangladesh
141
(20.3%), India (11.8%), Maldives (5.9%), and Sri Lanka (5.8%), etc., the women
representation is very low.1 In 1960, Sri Lanka became the first country to have a
woman Prime Minister.2 In the 1970s, Indira Gandhi became Prime Minister of India
and in the 1980s Benajir Bhutto achieved yet another feat, when she became Prime
Minister of an Islamic country, Pakistan. However in spite of this, women constitute a
marginal proportion of representatives in the legislatures and various decision-making
bodies of these countries. It has been pointed out that, in modern South Asian countries
like India, Pakistan, Bangladesh and Sri Lanka, the largest number of women leaders
have held power (or served in the opposition) for the longest periods of time. But, all
these women leaders (Indira Gandhi, Banajir Bhutto, Hasina Wajed, Khalida Zia,
Sirimao Bandarnaike) succeeded male relatives (husbands, fathers); all of them were
propelled to their positions by party support. Therefore, none of them was a grassroots
politician, all belonged to affluent families and came from elite or ruling classes and in
all these countries weak institutionalization allowed dynastic succession to prevail even
under the democratic system of government. These women assumed leadership
generally during periods of crisis. The women leaders in modern South Asian nations
emerged as a type produced under sharply specific historical conditions. The general
women masses are however poor, illiterate, often veiled and indifferent towards
politics. Thus, the world-wide picture regarding women’s participation in politics is not
very praise-worthy. Women, who constitute half of the human population, have been
denied their due share in politics not only in India but also in the whole world.3
Ancient India
1
Women in Parliaments: World Classification-Inter-Parliamentary Union, www.ipu.org/wmn-
e/classif.htm., Accessed on 31-10-2017.
2
K.C. Vidya, Political Empowerment of Women at the Grassroots, New Delhi: Kanishka Publishers,
2007, p. 3.
3
Bhawana Jharta, “Marginalization of Women in Politics: Some Observations”, in Mamta Mokta (ed.),
Dimensions of Gender Inequality in Society, Chandigarh: Shree Ram Lal House, 2016,
pp. 81-82.
142
“Women are deities of prosperity. By cherishing women, one cherishes the
goddess of prosperity herself and by afflicting her, one is said to pain the goddess of
prosperity”.
(Anusasana Parva, Mahabharata)
Where the women are held in reverence, there do the Gods reside, is an old
Sanskrit adage. A society grows, if the women grow, if they partake of the spirit of
progress, for they are the proverbial domestic legislators, they are the matrix of social
life. In India, till the advent of the Turks Indian women enjoyed great freedom and
prestige, but due to certain social, economic and political exigencies and the unhappy
impact of alien ideologies, inhuman restrictions clamped upon them, they were
relegated to a position of servility and insignificance and they were burdened with
several taboos and restrictions. Indian society has been a tradition bound society in
which the traditionalists would present an idealised picture of women substantiating
their claims on the basis of certain references from the Vedic and classical literature.
The Indian woman is part of a culture that goes back into the past. If she has a
particular conviction of acts in a specific manner, it is due to the pattern that has been
ingrained in her by the fairly stable social structure of a thousand years.4 The highest
place has been accorded to women in Indian religious and philosophical thought. The
primordial one is conceived as a harmony of ‘Purusha’ (male) and ‘Prakrati’ (female).
The concept of ‘Ardhanarishwara’ describes god-head as half female and half male.
The ‘Shakti’ cult is centred on the superiority and destructive strength of the females.
Rivers and streams, dawn and twilight, flowers and seasons, knowledge and music are
conceived of as feminine.
The position of power, status and disabilities of the daughter, wife, and the
widow went on changing in course of time. Women enjoyed considerable freedom and
privileges in the spheres of family, religion and public life, but as centuries rolled on,
the situation went on changing adversely. The position which women occupied in
Hindu society at the dawn of civilization during the Vedic age is much better.5
4
Preeti Misra, Domestic Violence Against Women, Legal Control and Judicial Response, New Delhi:
Deep and Deep Publications, 2007, p.1-2.
5
Ibid.,
143
Vedic Period
During ancient times, women held a high place of respect in the society, as
mentioned in Rig-Veda and other scriptures.6 The Vedic era was the golden era so far
as equilibrium of status and freedom between men and women, with right of
knowledge and freedom to marry is concerned.7 The Rig-Vedic women played
significant role in family, society and even in political life.8
In the early Vedic Period, women were taking an active part in the industrial
life. They were manufacturing arrows and bows, making baskets, weaving cloth and
participating in outdoor agricultural (work) activities. These outdoor professions and
activities show early Vedic society. The girl’s were given education at par with boys
and had to pass through a period of Brahamcharya. They had equal right of Vedic
study as of men. They not only studied Vedas but also figured among the authors of
Vedic hymns.
Upanishads
6
Shiv Raj Singh, et al. (eds.), Public Administration in the New Millennium: Changing and Prospects,
New Delhi: Anamika Publishers, 2003, p. 253.
7
Mridula Bhadauria, Women in India: Some Issue, New Delhi: APH Publishing Corporation, 1997, p.1.
8
A.S. Altekar, The Position of Women in Hindu Civilization, New Delhi: Motilal Banarsidass, 1962,
p. 339.
9
Anant Sadashiv Altekar, “Ideal and Position of Indian Women in Social Life”, in Swami
Madhavananda and Ramesh Chandra Majumdar (eds.), Great Women of India, Almora: Advaita
Ashrama, 1953, pp. 26-28.
10
Kalpana Roy, Women and their Environment, Delhi: Rajat Publications, 1999, pp. 83-88.
144
Gargi even out questioned and out-wearied the Chief Philosopher of the Upanishads,
Yajnavalkya. Maitreyi was a discourser on sacred knowledge. In the Upanishads,
woman is referred to as having been created by the primeval being. Brihad-Aranyaka
says that ‘a man’s wife is his voice’.11
Manu for the first time legally assigned to woman her definite place in the scale
of society. But his laws reflect a conflict even within himself between his valuation of
woman as a spiritual entity on the one side and as a unit in society on the other. He
averred that a mother is more to be revered than a thousand fathers, yet his laws place
woman socially on a level with the lowest of all groups in Aryan society, the Sudra.12
Manu enumerates many laws directing a wife’s conduct-he says that a wife
must show to her husband such utter devotion that he must be treated like a God, even
when he is conspicuously lacking in virtue. No sacrifice, no vow, no fast must be
performed by women apart. If a wife obeys her husband, she will for that be exalted in
heaven. In childhood, a female must be subject to her father, in youth to her husband;
when her lord is dead, to her sons. A woman must never be independent. The laws of
Manu state that women were created to be mothers and that they may perform religious
rites along with their husband. The tenets of Manu have fostered a deep rooted belief in
the intellectual and otherwise inferiority of women. He says that women should never
be given independence. He equated women with slave and his laws epitomize complete
submission of women to men and there are still the sanctioned codes of conduct
ascribed for and by and large accepted by women. But Manu was not a woman hater,
for it was Manu who said in Manu Samriti that-
145
for a girl and advocated child marriage, though he warned fathers not to give away their
daughters to men devoid of good qualities. Though polygamy was practiced, he
strongly advocated monogamy and attached the greatest importance to sexual restraint
and fidelity to one’s spouse. He laid down different rules even for a man contemplating
separation. A woman deserted by her husband was given the right to marry after the
lapse of certain number of years. Thus, Manu was the principal law-maker of the
conservative Hindu period. His prime objective was to safeguard the interests of the
family and society at the expense of individual liberty. Thus, the laws of Manu, as do
all the earlier documents of Hinduism shows various attitudes, both appreciative and
depreciative, towards women.13
Epic Period
The status of women and their participation in politics during the epic period is
discussed in the context of Ramayana and Mahabharata periods. 14
The Ramayana is one of the most effective of all Hindu sacred writings. In the
laws of Manu and in the Mahabharata, it is taught that a wife should reverence her
husband, as if he were a veritable deity. This teaching is reaffirmed in the Ramayana.
Women have no individual identity; their personality is blended with men. The
Ramayana enjoys the lifelong inseparability of wives and husband.
The dependence of a woman upon her husband, son and relatives is continued
from the antecedent laws of Manu. A wife’s service to her husband is taken as the best
method of attaining heaven. The Ramayana reaffirmed the deep-seated Hindu
conception that husband is a women’s greatest deity.15
13
Preeti Misra, op.cit., 2007, pp. 13-18.
14
Roma Choudhuri, “Women’s Education in Ancient India”, in Swami Madhavananda and Ramesh
Chandra Majumdar (eds.), Great Women of India, Almora: Advaita Ashrama, 1953, pp.102-104.
15
Preeti Misra, op.cit., 2007, pp. 28-29.
146
The high standard of women’s education set up during the Vedic Age was
fortunately continued to a large extent during the Epic Age as well. Women were given
full opportunities for education of various kinds. Like men, they were entitled to
Upanayana or initiation and Brahmacharya or Vedic studentship is proved by the right
they enjoyed to take part in various Vedic rites and utter the holy Vedic Mantras.
Ascetic women engaged in the study, teaching and preaching of the highest Truth for
example, Shramani Shabari, the disciple of Matanga. With her hermitage on Lake
Pampa, is described as wearing barks and matted locks having reached the highest
point of ascetic perfection, and being honoured by great ascetics.
The social position of women was high. The wife was regarded as the very prop
of family life and the mother an object of supreme honour. In the Ayodhya-Kanda, the
mother is enjoyed to be honoured as much as the father. In the political sphere also,
women were granted equal rights. For instance, when Sita desired to accompany Rama
to the forest, the great sage Vasishtha, the spiritual preceptor of the royal family, tried
his best to dissuade her with the proposal that she should reign over the kingdom during
the absence of her husband. This instance shows the political recognition of women’s
equal rights with men. The above is sufficient to show that during the age of the
Ramayana, too, the women of India kept their colours flying in all spheres of learning
and progress, and achieved notable success in them all.16
Mahabharata, the great epic depicts the social life of India. The eminent
Professor Macdonell calls the Mahabharata “a moral encyclopaedia in Indian
Literature”. In this heroic age, the poets of Mahabharata portray, on the whole,
womanhood which was noble, intelligent and active. In this document, we see women
in the home, at court, on the battlefield, and in intellectual and spiritual capacities.
Although in some of the earlier Hindu documents, women are sometimes pictured as
helpless females. In the Mahabharata, we find many accomplished women, they are not
only beautiful in appearance, but they possess real tact and graciousness of character. 17
In the age of the Mahabharata also, women’s full rights to Naishthika Brahmacharya or
a life of celibate asceticism is recognized. The most celebrated of these is perhaps
Sulabha, who’s not finding a suitable husband, embraced a life of celibate studentship
and roamed about alone from place to place in search of the highest truth. Until, she
16
Roma Choudhuri, op.cit., 1953, pp.102-104.
17
Preeti Misra, op.cit., 2007, p. 24.
147
reached the court of king Janaka in Mithila, a great scholar versed in the highest lore
leading to salvation. Even such a celebrated scholar was compelled to recognize
Sulabha’s deep learning after a thorough examination, and was taught by her.
Shiva was another women ascetic, who studied all the Vedas and attained
spiritual perfection. The daughter of Shandilya also embraced a life of celibate
studentship and achieved the maximum perfection in asceticism. Not only the ascetic’s
women, but those women who entered the family life also versed in philosophical
knowledge. 18 In the Mahabharata period, women were versed not only in the highest
philosophy but also in other branches of knowledge. But many women of the royal
family were well grounded in politics. Gandhari, wife of the blind King Dhritarashtra
engaged in a learned political discussion with her son in the open court. Other royal
ladies, like Kunti and Draupadi are also the example of versatility and scholarship of
women of Mahabharata period. From the above brief account, it is clear that in the age
of the Mahabharata, women enjoyed equal rights with men.19
Thus, in Mahabharata, there is the highest praise for women and at the same
time the bitterest denunciation. Despite of prohibitions, the priest attempted to enforce
upon the women of the epic, on the whole, these women stand out significantly. They
are resolute and spiritual. They are not isolated but are in close contact with events of
their time. They are capable and serviceable members of society. As a matter of fact,
the epic seems to have produced outstanding portraits of women, which have helped to
stir Hindu women with hope and faith.20
Buddhism rose as a protest against the rigid rules of Brahmanism. In the Post-
Vedic period, the dominance of rituals increasingly grew, which gave indomitable
power to the Brahmanism. Buddhism opened the doors of religion to all human beings
without any distinction. Buddhism is in its essence, a religion of self-culture and self
restraint. If a woman could achieve these two qualities, she was entitled to achieve
Nirvana like men.21 The status of women in Buddhism and Jainism was assigned. Both
these were ascetic re-religions, and they have not devoted much attention to the duties
18
Roma Choudhuri, op.cit, 1953, pp. 104-105.
19
Ibid.,
20
Preeti Misra, op.cit., 2007, p. 28.
21
Ibid., p.30.
148
and ideals of lay women. The Buddha was reluctant to admit women to his Church, and
the Digambara Jains hold that women can never get salvation except by first being
reborn as men. Both Budhism and Jainism placed nuns under a more rigorous discipline
than monks. They should not stay alone without the protection of monks. They should
avoid the company of men of doubtful character; that only monks of unquestioned
purity and integrity should be allowed to preach before nuns; that they should always
live together in groups of two and three etc. Some other rules, however, betray a lack of
confidence in the character and judgement of women. Thus the admission of a new nun
was to be sanctioned by a joint meeting of the monks and nuns; new monks, however,
could be admitted without consulting the nuns at all. A nun could never preach before a
congregation of monks. The permission that was given to women to join the church by
Jainism and Buddhism raised a new and respectable career before them. 22
In Brahmanical religion, there were also some nuns like Sulabha and Gargi
Vachaknavi; their number, however, seems to have been much larger in Buddhist and
Jain circles. Buddhism declared that womanhood was no bar to salvation, and
Svetambara Jains concurred with the view. Marriage was not necessary for women;
nay, it was a fetter which women were advised to avoid. Therefore it was urged to
become nuns without entering into matrimony. Among the nuns of the Therigatha the
majority consists of women, who had renounced the world during their maidenhood.
The career of preaching was opened before women by Jainism and Buddism attracted a
large number of talented ladies, and they distinguished themselves as teachers and
preachers. Sanghamitra, the daughter of Ashoka, went to far off Ceylon to spread the
gospel of the Buddha. 23
When discipline became slack and unworthy persons began to be admitted into
monasteries and nunneries, the tone of moral life deteriorated. It hastened the process
of the downfall of Buddhism. Later, Hinduism took a lesson from it and declared
women to be ineligible for renunciation. But women have realised that improvement in
this direction in modern days depends mainly upon the spread of education and the
acquisition of economic rights and independence. They therefore naturally feel no
inclination for initiating an agitation for the restoration of their old religious rights and
22
A.S. Altekar, The Position of Women in Hindu Civilization, Delhi: Motilal Banarsidass, 1959, pp.
207-209.
23
Ibid., pp. 207-217.
149
privileges.24 Thus, the position of women in the Buddhist period could not have
changed very much from that of the earlier days. However, there was some
improvement in their condition, due to the basic principles, which Buddha laid down in
his teachings. Buddha made no distinction between a man and a woman regarding the
attainment of spiritual ends. Buddha discarded the Brahmanic rituals, in which the wife
played a secondary part and a barren women or a widow had no place. The education
given to female novices and nuns was not different from that imparted to their male
counterparts. The status of women was raised in the Buddhist period, it cannot but be
admitted that in the monastic order, the place accorded to the nuns was lower than that
of the monks.25
Medieval Period
The Indian women’s position in the society deteriorated during medieval period.
In this period the women were deprived of different social and economic rights and
26
were brought out under the overall control of their male family members. Life
became insecure. Restrictions on her rights and freedom and her resultant hardships
were aggravated. Women were forcible taken away to be slaves or to marry into
Muslim homes. The consequent insecurity and instability further narrowed down
woman’s social liberties. On the one hand, the foreign Muslim conquerors attempted to
impose their coercive norms on the conquered Hindu population. On the other hand, the
Hindu society itself became more and more rigid curtailing thereby, the rights and
freedom of the lower castes and women. Due to this two-fold reason, the post-puranic
period is one of the darkest periods for women in Indian history. The steady
deterioration of her status continued till the 19th century. Polygamy and the Purdah
were two of the most important social institutions of the Muslim conquerors of India.
Under the Purdha system, not only were women required to live in a secluded
apartment in the house, but also they had to dress in apparel which completely covered
their body excepting the eye.27
24
Ibid., pp. 207-217.
25
Nalinaksha Dutt, “Great Women in Buddhism”, in Swami Madhavananda and Ramesh Chandra
Majumdar (eds.), Great Women of India, Almora: Advaita Ashrama, 1953, pp.253-255.
26
G.S. Mehta, Participation of Women in the Panchayati Raj System, New Delhi: Kanishka Publishers,
2008, p.4.
27
Neera Desai, Women in Modern India, Bombay: Vora Publishers, 1957, p. 23.
150
Before the Muslim conquest, the Buddhism had not followed the custom of
Sati. Social sanction for the self-immolation of widows came in with Muslim invasion.
Before Muslim rule, the practice of Sati did occur off and on, but not as a regular
feature. As a result of repressive social and religious custom, a woman sometimes even
preferred Sati to widowhood.28 Instance of Brahmin women who practiced Sati are also
recorded in the 15th century and after the foreign chroniclers record, the Hindu widows
who did not observe Sati were held in great dishonor. The practice of Sati was also
extended to the southern parts of India. The widow in the case was persuaded to believe
that her act of self-immolation was even more auspicious than the nuptial ceremony,
since it guaranteed the continual association with her husband in life after death.29 Due
to lustful proposal of Alauddin Khilji, Rani Padmavati with about 700 Rajput
committed themselves to flames, which came to be known as “Jauhar Vrata”.
Gradually child marriages were preferred in the society and the death of a widow was
welcome news as she would not fall into evil hands. A woman in Hindu society has
always been considered an appendage to her husband. She has no life apart from him.
Consequently, on her husband’s death, there was no reason for her to live on. Also the
husband was her sole protector. During foreign invasions by the Turkas, Muslims and
others, when their men folk were killed, the widows were very naturally expected to
commit Sati. Hence, immolation of widows and killing of girl child infanticide started
in a large number. Even the Muslims were not spared of this fate, when they became
subjugated by the white rulers of England. They developed Purdh, illiteracy, disease,
legal discrimination and handicaps but the worst part of their fate is the male
dominance in their society.30
The Muslim conquest in the Indian subcontinent brought the Purdhah practice
in the Indian society.31 As a strict security measure, the prohibition of free movement
of woman was advocated and the Purdhah with its elaborate from was also installed.
Women participating in public discussions on vital social and philosophical problems
or in popular festivals became only a memory of the past. Along with child marriage,
marital infidelity on the part of males became more common. Polygamy was a practice
adopted frequently among upper classes and restriction on or conditions laid down as
28
Preeti Misra, op.cit., 2007, p.35.
29
Neera Desai, op.cit., 1957, p. 24.
30
Niroj Sinha, Women and Violence, New Delhi: Vikas Publishing House, 1989, pp.47-48.
31
A. Prema, “Women Status in India”, Indian Streams Research Journal, Vol. 2, No.1, February 2012,
p. 2.
151
necessary for the second marriage were also dropped. Even during this darkest period,
when the black cloud of social reaction completely submerged the freedom of woman,
a silver lining was visible. Some of the Mughal emperors through social reforms tried
to relieve the hardships of women. As regards Sati, Akbar did not permit it in cases,
where there was the slightest disinclination on the part of the widow or when a young
widow’s marriage was not consummated. During this period, two schools of law
emerged viz. Mitakshara and Dayabhaga, the exponents of these schools being
Vijnaneshwara and Jimutavahana respectively. These commentators attempted to
improve the position of women. They give a definite share of property to women.
However, in the total setting of complete subordination, these meagre rights hardly
brought any benefits to women.32 The Hindu did not assimilate the customs like
divorce, widow remarriage and a large share of property for women, which governed
the Muslim society. The Hindu society had come so static and rigidified that their
contact with the Muslims, whose social relations were relatively democratic, did not
prompt them to adopt the democratic elements of the Muslim society. 33
British Period
32
Preeti Misra, op.cit., 2007, p. 36.
33
Ibid., pp. 36-37.
34
Lalit Upadhayay, Women in Indian Politics, Panchkula: Better Books, 2007, p. 17.
35
Achla Sharma, “Status of Women: A Socio-Historical Analysis in Different Ages of Indian Society”,
Research Journal of Language, Literature and Humanities, Vol. 1 No. 1, January 2014, pp.12-13.
152
pertaining to the spirit and the practice of religion, Christianity accepts equality
between men and women. Everybody is baptised in the name of Christ. The Bible lays
great emphasis on the image of women as a strong and steady influence for the good.
Christianity also forbids polygamy and it lays emphasis on the establishment of a
mutual relationship between husband and wife and on their duty towards each other.36
The impact of British rule, English education and Christianity propagated by
missionaries resulted in a number of movements for social change and religious reform
in the nineteenth century. The first impact of western teaching on those who received, it
was to include them strongly in favour of the western way of looking at things and
under this influence they bent their energies. In the first instance, to the re-examination
of the whole of their ancient civilisation or social usages and institutions, religious
beliefs, literature, science and their art in fact their conception and realisation of life.37
There have been three distinct phases in the modern struggle for a better status, life and
opportunity for women in India. The first was in the 19th century by male reformers
aided by religious groups both Hindu and Christian. The second was participation in
the freedom movement which culminated in Independence in 1947 and the third, the
post-Independence period up to women’s International year, 1975.38
During the 19th and early 20th centuries, a number of movements (both religious
and social) were launched to reform the Indian society in general and to improve the
status of women in particular. These movements had a great impact on women’s
identity and women’s life in India. The most well-remembered social reformer of the
19th century was Raja Ram Mohan Roy, who established Brahmo Samaj in 1828 at
Calcutta, (Brahmo literally means the Supreme; Samaj means Society) which worked
for the welfare of women. Freedom and equality of women and widow remarriage were
the focus of the Samaj the cruel system of sati (sati means ‘a virtuous woman). The act
of widow immolating herself on the funeral pyre of her husband) was abolished by the
efforts of Roy. The spiritual succession of Roy was Keshav Chandra Sen, who
popularised Brahmo Samaj and fought for women’s education and established a school
for girls. Due to the struggle of Keshav Chandra Sen, Civil Marriage Act III of 1872
was brought, which included abolition of child marriage (minimum age of marriage
36
C.K. Jain, Women Parliamentarians in India, New Delhi: Surjeet Publications, 1993, p. 10.
37
Government of India, Towards Equality: Report of the Committee on the Status of Women in India,
New Delhi: Ministry of Education and Social Welfare Department of Social Welfare, 1974, p. 50.
38
Tara Ali Baig, Indian’s Woman Power, New Delhi: S. Chand and Company, 1976, pp. 24-25.
153
was fixed at 14), permission for widow remarriage and inter-caste marriage. A religious
reform movement in the form of Prarthana Samaj (worship) was started by Justice
Mahadeo Govind Ranade in Poona. Swami Dayanand Saraswati founded the Arya
Samaj, (revered) whose main objective was to give equal opportunities to all person
men and women (to acquire knowledge and to qualify themselves for whatever position
in life they would like to fill) without any discrimination.
39
K.C. Vidya, op.cit., 2007, pp.1-10.
40
Shantha Mohan, “Facilitating the fulfilment of State Obligations towards Women’s Equality”,
Baseline Report, Women and Political Participation in India, pp. 4-6.
154
was in the 1917 the women’s Indian Association was founded in Madras by Annie
Besant.41
Mahatma Gandhi’s called to women to join the freedom struggle that a new era
has dawned. He recognized the importance of women’s participation in the freedom
struggle. Gandhi appraised the women’s potential for Satyagraha and for the social
reconstruction as higher than that of men.43 Most strikingly, mass population of women
was recognized during the Civil Disobedience movement in 1930.44 In 1931, at the
Karachi session of the Indian National Congress, Nehru piloted the ‘Fundamental
Rights Resolution’, which accepted the principle of complete equality of men and
women in political life. 45 The Government of India Act 1935 invariably provided equal
right to vote to both men and women without gender bias. Consequently, in the election
of 1937, eight women were elected from general constituencies and forty-two from the
reserves constituencies. Six women were appointed as ministers.46
41
M.P. Dube and Munni, Padalia (eds.), Democratic Decentralization and Panchayati Raj in
India, New Delhi: Anamika Publishers, 2002, pp. 174-175.
42
A. Thanikodi and M. Sugirtha, “Status of Women in Politics”, The Indian Journal of Political
Science, Vol. 68, No.3, July-September 2007, p. 600.
43
Bhawana Jharta, Women and Politics in India: Impact of Family and Education on Women Political
Activists, New Delhi: Deep and Deep Publications, 1998, p. 58.
44
Rameshwari Pandya (ed.), Women Welfare and Empowerment in India, New Delhi: New Century
Publications, 2008, p. 564.
45
Bhawana Jharta, op.cit., 1998, pp. 4-5.
46
A.K. Shukla, Women Chief Ministers in Contemporary India, New Delhi: APH Publishing
Corporation, 2007, p. 58.
155
In the 1942 Quit India Movement; when all the top leaders were arrested and
the movement became practically leaderless, women joined hands with others and
carried it on by taking out processions, holding meetings, demonstrations and
organizing strikes. Aruna Asaf Ali, Kalpana Joshi, Preeti Waddadar, Kanaklata Barua,
Roopvati Jain, Durga Bai, Sushila Devi and Usha Mehta were the famous figures of
this movement. Kasturba Gandhi died in jail during the Quit India campaign. In July
1943, in response to the clarion call of Subhash Chandra Bose, a women’s regiment
named ‘The Rani of Jhansi Regiment’ was formed in Singapore with Laxmi Sehgal as
its Captain.
The Constituent Assembly was set up in October 1946, a body elected by the
existing legislatures, had among its members Sarojini Naidu, Durgabai, Renuka Roy
and Hansa Mehta, among others to frame the Constitution for India on Independence.47
In the Constituent Assembly which met in December 1946, there were 14 women
members. But there were no proportionate increase in women as representatives or in
power positions.
It has been noted that women who were active in politics or politically
successful belonged to wealthy and progressive families. They were supported by
husbands or family members who were active in congress. This is being followed even
after independence. But, there were large number of unknown women who participated
in the freedom struggle. It provided an opportunity for large number of women to enter
into active politics, which was not seen earlier. They were willing to join processions,
and to go to prisons. Women joined revolutionary groups, helped in distributing
newspapers and helped in the manufacturing bombs. Innumerable number of women
provided support to freedom fighters by looking after their families.48
During Post-Independence
47
Tara Ali Baig, op.cit., 1976, p. 218.
48
Vina Mazumdar, “Women in the Political Process”, in Maithreyi Krishnaraj (ed.), Women Studies in
India: Some Perspectives, New Delhi: Popular Prakashan, 1986, p. 97.
49
G .S. Mehta, op.cit., 2008, p.7.
156
India resolves to secure to all its citizens: Justice, social, economic and political;
Liberty of thought, expression, belief, faith and worship; Equality of status and
opportunity; and to promote among them all; Fraternity assuring the dignity of the
individual and the unity and integrity of the nation. To attain these national objectives,
the constitution guarantees certain Fundamental Rights to all the citizens. Again the
Directive Principles of State Policy enunciated in the constitution embody the major
policy goals of a welfare state. 50
The Constitution of India has granted women equal rights of participation in the
political process of the country along with equal opportunity and rights in education
and employment. The Indian Constitution guarantees political equality through the
institution adult franchise. Article 15 prohibits any kind of discrimination against any
citizen on grounds only of religion, race, caste, sex, place of birth, or any of them.
However, Article 15(3) which empower the state to make any “special provisions for
women and children” even in violation of the fundamental obligation of non-
discrimination among citizens, on the basis of sex. This provision has enabled the state
to make special provisions for women, particularly in the field of labour legislation like
the Factories Act, the Mines Act, etc. Reservation of seats for women in local or
educational institutions has been held to be valued in view of the provisions of Article
15 (3). Article 16 (1) guarantees that, “There shall be equality of opportunity for all
citizens in matters relating to employment or appointment to any office under the
state”. Again Article 16 (2) forbids discrimination in respect of any employment in
office under the state on grounds of “religion, race, caste, sex, descent, and place of
birth, residence or any one of them”. All these have assured normatively a significant
position and status to Indian women.
50
C.K. Jain, op.cit., 1993, pp.11-12.
51
K.C. Vidya, op.cit., 2007, p. 9.
157
enter occupations unsuited for their age or strength. Article 39 (d) which directs the
state to ensure that there is equal pay for equal work for both men and women. Again
Article 39 (e) which directs the state to ensure that the health and strength of workers,
men and women, and the tender age of children are not abused and that citizens are not
forced by economic necessity to enter avocations unsuited to their age or strength; and
Articles 42 which directs the state to make provision for ensuring must and humane
condition of work and maternity relief.52 However, Article 42 guarantees, just and
humane condition of work and maternity relief. This is in accordance with Article 23
and 25 of Universal Declaration of Human Rights. Article 51 (a) clause (e) says that it
shall be the duty of every citizen of India-to promote harmony and spirit of common
brotherhood amongst all the people of India, transcending religious or sectional
diversities, to renounces practice derogatory to the dignity of women.
The committee on the status of women was appointed as early as 1976. The
draft national policy on empowerment of women was envisaged equal flow of benefits
in physical and financial terms to women. A National Commission for Women was
appointed. The constitution of India guarantees certain rights and privileges to women
as fundamental rights and directive principles. It confers on man and women equal
rights and opportunities in political, economic and social spheres.
52
C.K. Jain, op.cit., 1993, p. 13.
53
Saroj Choudhary, “Political Participation and Representation of Women in Indian Politics”, International
Journal of Behavioural Social and Movement Sciences, Vol. 1, No. 4, October 2012, p. 203.
158
Acts of 1951; the Special Marriage Act of 1954 (Amended 1984). The Hindu
Succession Act of 1956 (later Amended 1976 and 1986), the Dowry Prohibition Act of
1961; the Maternity Benefit Act of 1966 (Amended 1976); Medical Termination of
Pregnancy Act of 1971; the Equal Remuneration of Act of 1976 (amended 1984); the
Indian Evidence Act, 1983; Family Court Act, 1984; Indecent Representation of
Women Prohibition Act 1987; Indian Marriage Act, 1995 (amended 1996); the New
Bill 2001 for Protecting Women against Violence, etc. were passed;54 The Protection
of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 defines the expression “domestic
violence to include actual abuse or threat of abuse-physical, sexual, verbal, emotional
or economic violence etc.55
Panchayati Raj Institutions in India have their roots since time immemorial. The
system has evolved through the ages, acquiring a definite programme or action.
Rajasthan was the first state in the country to adopt Panchayati Raj. Rajasthan
government passed the Rajasthan Panchayati and was formally inaugurated by the
Pandit Nehru at Nagour on 2nd October 1959. In this Act, three tier systems of
Panchayati Raj Institutions were created. Zila Parishad at district level, Panchayat
Samiti at block level and Gram Panchayts at village level were constituted under this
Act. Women who constitute almost half of India’s total population, have been given an
opportunity for participation in local affairs as not less than third of the posts of
Chairpersons have been reserved in their favour. This provision would bring in
qualitative change in the composition of local bodies and make women and weaker
sections equal partners in the nation’s progress and development.56 The committee on
status of woman in India (1974) not only recommended representation of women in
PRIs but also established of statutory women Panchayats at village level as a
transitional measure for managing the programmes for women and children.57
54
Nagaraju Battu, Empowerment of Women in India: New Strategies, New Delhi: Regal Publications
2014, p. 49.
55
Shashi Goel, Domestic Violence Against Women, Jaipur: Literary Circle, 2013, p. 26.
56
J.L. Singh, Women and Panchayati Raj, New Delhi: Sunrise Publications, 2007, pp. 284-285.
57
Ibid.,
159
the total number of seats to be filled by direct election in every Panchayats and urban
local body, as also designated offices in the local self-government institutions, both in
rural and urban areas. The opportunity of sharing of power on equal terms with men
and exercising an effective role in decision-making process would lead to vast
improvements in the status of women.58
The Constitution’s 110th Amendment Bill 2009, provides reservation for women
from 33 per cent to 50 per cent in PRIs. The Bill seeks to amend the Article 243D to
enhance the quantum of reservation for women from one-third to one-half of the total
seats in the Panchayats. Similar reservation shall be provided among the total number
of offices of chairpersons.59 However, Articles 325 and 326 of the Constitution of India
guarantee political equality-equal right to participation in political activities and right to
vote respectively. While the latter has been accessed, exercised and enjoyed by a large
number of women, the former i.e., right to equal political participation is still a distant
dream. Lack of space for participation in political bodies has not only resulted in their
presence in meagre numbers in these decision making bodies but also in the neglect of
their issues and experiences in policy making.60
By 1970 the political atmosphere began to change and many leading political
parties realized the importance of women. Thus the efforts of the early leaders like
Jotibha Phule, B.R.Ambedkar, E.V. Ramaswami and the leaders of the later period like
Sharat Patil, Sharat Joshi and Vandana Shiva not only fuelled the women’s movement
but also intensely motivated the Indian women by touching their inner core of
consciousness. No doubt, women of India are highly active today in this area. Sarojini
Naidu, Vijay Lakshami Pandit, Sucheta Kriplani were the torch bearer for the women
of India. Mrs. Vijay Lakshmi Pandit was the first Indian Women to hold position in the
cabinet and paved the way for other women. The most important name in the category
of women politicians is Mrs. Indira Gandhi. She was the first women Prime Minister of
independent India. Today her daughter-in-law Ms. Sonia Gandhi is following her
footsteps and leading the Indian National Congress. Other women who have played a
pivotal role in politics of India are Sheila Dixit, Uma Bharti, Jayalalitha, Vasundhra
Raje, Mamata Banerjee and Mayawati,61 Anandiben Patel, Mehbooba Mufti and
Nirmala Sitaraman.
58
V. Mohini Giri, “Women and Politics” in Yashoda Bhat and C. N. Mangala (eds.), Beyond the
Threshold: Indian Women on the Move, Delhi: B.R. Publishing Corporation, 1995, p. 24.
59
Kuldeep Fadia, “Women’s Empowerment in India”, Indian Journal of Public Administration,
Vol. 60, No. 3, July-September 2014, p. 543.
60
Baseline Report on Women and Political Participation in India Prepared by NIAS et al. and
Coordinated by IWRAW Asia Pacific Advanced Unedited Version, p.1.
61
Subrat Biswal, “Women and Political Participation”, Third Concept, Vol. 28, No. 328, June 2014, p. 12.
160
Thus, women have served in the both houses of parliament and in the state
legislatures and many women have become heads of different department in the
government. Women have also been appointed as India’s diplomats and envoys in
different countries. 62
Table 3.1
1901 972
1911 964
1921 955
1931 950
1941 945
1951 946
1961 941
1971 930
1981 934
1991 927
2001 933
2011 943
62
Bhawana Jharta, op.cit.,2016, pp. 82-83.
161
980
972
Female per 1000 Males
970
964
960
955
950
946
950
943
941
940
934
945
933
930
927
930
920
910
900
1901 1911 1921 1931 1941 1951 1961 1971 1981 1991 2001 2011
Years
Fig. 3.1: Decennial Sex Ratio in India (Females per 1000 Males)
If you educate a man you educate an individual, however, if you educate a woman you
educate a whole family. Women empowered means mother India empowered”.
Education means an all round drawing out of the best in child and man-body,
mind and spirit. Education plays a vital role in playing human beings proper equipment
to lead a gracious and harmonious life. Education is a fundamental means to bring any
desired change in society, which is an accepted fact through the world. This can be
attained only if schools become real centres of learning. Education not only helps in the
development of personality of the child but also determines his future. Education gives
solutions for any type of problems. Through education we promote values and good
habits and awareness towards corruption, terrorism and disease. Education strength to
the persons, they get knowledge and distinguish between right and wrong with the help
of education.63
Women constitute almost half of the population in the world. But the
hegemonic masculine ideology made them suffer a lot, as they were denied equal
opportunities in different parts of world. The rise of feminist idea has, however, led to
tremendous improvement of women condition throughout the world in recent times.
63
Jitendra Kumar and Sangeeta, “Status of Women Education in India”, Educationia Confab, Vol. 2,
No. 4, April 2013, p. 163.
162
Access of education has been one of the most pressing demands of these women’s
rights movements. Women education in India has also been a major preoccupation of
both the government and civil society as educated women can play a very important
role in the development of the country. India is poised to emerge as one of the most
developed nation by 2020, more literate knowledgeable and economically at the
forefront. No doubt, women will play a vital role in any country. In India, this is yet to
meet the requirements despite reforms. Little has been achieved in the area of women
empowerment but for this to happen, this sector must experience a chain of reforms.64
64
Ibid.,
65
Nagaraju Battu, op.cit., 2014, pp. 228-230.
66
Chandni Sinha, “Education and Empowerment of Women”, Third Concept, Vol. 21, No. 243,
May 2007, pp. 49-50.
67
Jitendra Kumar and Sangeeta, op.cit., 2013, pp. 172-173.
163
Table 3.2
Literacy Rate in India
80
74.04
Literacy Rate
70
65.38
60
52.1
50
40
36.2
30
29.5
16.1
24
20
7.2
5.3
16.7
5.9
10
9.5
0
1901 1911 1921 1931 1941 1951 1961 1971 1981 1991 2001 2011
164
The Table 3.2 reveals that in pre-independence period literacy rate for women
had a very poor spurt in comparison to literacy rate of man. This is witnessed from the
fact that literacy rate of women has risen from 0.7 per cent to 7.3 per cent where as the
literacy rate of men has risen from 9.8 per cent to 24.9 per cent in the first four decades.
During the post-independence period literacy rates have shown a substantial increase in
general. However the literacy rate of male has almost tripled over the period, i.e. 24.9
per cent in 1951 and 76 per cent in 2001. Surprisingly, the female literacy rate has
increased at a faster pace than the male literacy during the decade 1981-2001.
In the year 2011 the difference between the two was, the female literacy
(65.46%) and male literacy (82.14%), this rate is very small as compared to the year
1901 (0.7%) to 2011 (65.46%). From this analysis one can infer that still the female
literacy rate (only half of the female population are literates) is lacking behind male
literacy (three-fourth of the male population are literates). The higher rate of illiteracy
subordinate role. The lack of education is the root cause for women’s exploitation and
negligence. Only literacy can help women to understand the Indian’s constitutional and
empowering them to accomplish their goals at par with men in different spheres of life.
After the independence period the female literacy rate was increased. Education is a
basic requirement and fundamental right for the citizens of a free nation. It also brings a
reduction in inequalities and functions as a means of improving their status with the
family.
Education Equality
result of adult literacy programmes is the area of enrolment of boys and girls in
schools.
165
Table 3.3
State Wise Percentage of Female Literacy in India
Percentage of Female Percentage of Male
Sr.No. Name of the State
Literacy Literacy
1 Andhra Pradesh 59.74 75.56
2 Arunachal Pradesh 59.57 73.69
3 Assam 67.27 78.81
4 Bihar 53.33 73.39
5 Chattisgarh 60.59 81.45
6 Goa 81.84 92.81
7 Gujarat 70.73 87.23
8 Haryana 66.77 85.38
9 Himachal Pradesh 76.60 90.83
10 Jammu and Kashmir 58.01 78.26
11 Jharkhand 56.21 78.45
12 Karnataka 68.13 82.85
13 Kerala 91.98 96.02
14 Madhya Pradesh 60.02 80.53
15 Maharashtra 75.48 89.82
16 Manipur 73.17 86.49
17 Meghalaya 73.78 77.17
18 Mizoram 89.40 93.72
19 Nagaland 76.69 83.29
20 Orissa 64.36 82.40
21 Punjab 71.34 81.48
22 Rajasthan 52.66 80.51
23 Sikkim 76.43 87.29
24 Tamil Nadu 73.86 86.81
25 Tripura 83.15 92.18
26 Uttar Pradesh 59.26 79.24
27 Uttarakhand 70.70 88.33
28 West Bengal 71.16 82.67
29 Delhi 80.93 91.03
Union Territories
1 Andaman Nicobar Islands 81.84 90.11
2 Chandigarh 81.38 90.54
3 Dadra & Nagar Haveli 65.93 86.46
4 Daman & Diu 79.59 91.48
5 Lakshadweep 88.25 96.11
6 Pondicherry 81.22 92.12
All India 65.46 82.14
Source: Census of India, 2011.
166
The Table 3.3 depicts that the state wise female literacy rate had an average of
65.46 per cent in all India basis in 2011 census, the high literacy rate is 92.0 per cent in
Kerala and least literacy rate is 52.7 per cent in Rajasthan in 2011 census, while
comparing literacy rate of female in 2011 census, there is increase of 11 per cent from
54.16 per cent to 65.46 per cent. Women’s are growing well in the last 10 years.
Government of India has been taken various steps and plans especially for women in
every moment. The table shows that Kerala and the Mizoram shows the smallest
difference in terms of female literacy with their male counterpart. In Kerala female
literacy is (91.98%) with a difference of 4.22 per cent from the male literacy (i.e.
96.02%). Similarly, in Mizoram female literacy is (89.40%) with a difference of 4.32
per cent from the male literacy (i.e.93.72%). Thus, Kerala is having the highest female
literacy in India. Tamil Nadu state female literacy is (73.86%) with difference (12.95%)
from the male literacy (i.e. 86.81%) in India. Rajasthan (52.66 %) is having the
minimum of female literacy in India. As a result, data shows that even after seventy
years of independence, women occupy a secondary position in our social hierarchy.
Inspire of being aware of her position, women can’t transform the situation due to lack
of education. Therefore, women’s empowerment can’t be effected unless we persuade
the importance of women’s education.
167
numbers of men and women have gone to the polling booths to vote.68 The number of
women filing their nomination papers in any election, national or state is only a fraction
of the corresponding number of men. Some withdraw at the last moment and the
contesting candidates become fewer in number. Ultimately, the number of women
winning elections will be so small that their percentage in the legislative body will be
nominal.69 Women participation and representation in Lok Sabha is given below.
Table 3.4
Women Representation in Lok Sabha (1952-2014)
68
Usha Kiran, Participation of Women in Indian Politics: Gender Justice and Political Challenge,
Delhi: Globus Press, 2016, p.134.
69
Ibid.,
168
12
11.23
%age of Women
9.02
8.9
10.86
10
7.92
7.2
8
6.76
8.28
5.93
5.4
7.18
6
5.15
5.22
4
4.41
4.22
3.29
2
0
1952 1957 1962 1967 1971 1977 1980 1984 1989 1991 1996 1998 1999 2004 2009 2014
The Table 3.4 shows that the first Lok Sabha was held in 1952 where only 22
women members were elected out of total 499 members, which was just 4.4 per cent.
Though, the number of women representation were increased in second and third
election of Lok Sabha from 27 to 34 respectively, but starts declining from the fourth
election held in 1967. The number was increased only in the year 1996 (i.e. in the
eleventh election of Lok Sabha), where 39 women candidates were elected. In 1999
polls, 284 women had contested the election and 49 were elected and in 2004 election,
355 women contested the election of whom, 45 won. A record of 61 women candidates
have been elected in the sixteenth Lok Sabha election (2014), which account to 11.23
per cent of total, the highest ever since independence. Women representation in the
present 16th Lok Sabha has gone up to 61, which are the highest ever.
However as India has over half of the population of women, this number is still
too small. No doubt, the parliament had the privilege of having many prominent
women as its members, over the years who have championed the cause of women in
the house but parliament still needs more women MPs for safeguarding the women’s
rights and interests. It may be mentioned here that the women in two houses of
parliament largely belong to the privileged middle class and are educated. Many of
them are wives daughter, sister, daughter-in-law and relatives of prominent politicians.
169
The right to vote can be said to be the starting point in the struggle of women for their
political equality and participation. Therefore, the political participation of women by
way of voting has been growing but with variations. The following table reveals the
percentage of female voting in Lok Sabha election in 1952-2014.
Table 3.5
Voting Turnout Lok Sabha
Table 3.5 presents the percentage of female voting in different lok sabha
elections. In 1952 general elections, women’s voting was 37.10 per cent as compared to
170
56 per cent of men. The difference in the turnout was 15.9 per cent. Only in half
dozen out of fourteen general elections, women’s voting percentage has crossed 55 per
cent, which highlights their potential participation in the voting level. In 1967, 1977,
1989, 1998, 1999 and 2014 elections women witnessed an increase in the voting
percentage. In the table 3.5 reveals that 2014 elections have witnessed the record
increase in the voting percentage of women compared to men. According to the
Election Commission data (Statistical Report, 1952-2009), women’s voting percentage
has increased from 55.8 to 65.7 per cent in the last election. There is an increase of
nearly 10 per cent. During the same period, the voting percentages of men have also
increased but percentage of increase is lower compared to women. Therefore, there is a
common assumption that increase in men’s voting percentage, also leads to the rise in
the women’s voting percentage. However, the data clearly refutes this assumption.
Despite of decrease in the voting percentage of men, in 1999, 2004 and 2009 election,
there was an increase in women’s voting percentage.
Women as Contestants: the table depicts the total percentage of women who have
contested the Lok Sabha elections since 1952 till 2014.
171
Table 3.6
The Table 3.6 depicts that the number of women contesting election has always
been low. The highest number of women contestants has been merely 636 in 2014,
while the number of male contestants has always been in thousand, the highest being
13,353 in 1996. Yet, it is encouraging to note that the percentage of winners among
women has consistently been more than that of the men, although the fact that more
often than not, the losing seats are offered to women candidates by the respective
political parties, for instance, in 1996, only 3.8 per cent of male candidates won in
172
comparison to 6.7 per cent of female candidates. Likewise, the percentage of winners
was 11.2 per cent for men and 15.7 per cent for women in 1998, 12.3 per cent and 17.3
per cent in 1999, 6.44 per cent and 10.61 per cent in 2009 and 6.39 per cent and 9.74
per cent, respectively in 2014 (16th Lok Sabha).
Political parties during the election campaign propagate 33 per cent reservation
for the women in the national and state legislatures. But the numerical strength of
women parliamentarians indicates the difference between the perception and practices
of the political leaders. Half of the women population is represented by only 11 per
cent in the Parliament. Under representation of the women also reflects that women
issues are represented by their counterparts. Sometime they are not able to understand
these issues. Although the number of women contestants is very less in comparison to
men but their percentage of winnability is higher than to men. Thus, the winnability of
women remained higher in every Lok Sabha election than that of men.
National Parties
70
R. Yadagiri, “Growth of Regional Political Parties in India: Influence and Impact on Federal
System”, in D. Sunder Ram (ed.), Federal System and Coalition Government in India-Conflict and
Consensus in Centre-State Relations, New Delhi: Kanishka Publishers, 2007, pp. 142-143.
173
role of political parties in elections in mobilizing people opinion and also in governance
process cannot be over emphasized.71 Therefore, the backing of a political party for the
success of a candidate in election is also imperative. The following table shows the
seats allocated to women contestants in general election by the national political
parties.
Table 3.7
Seats Allotted to Women Contestants in General Elections by National Parties
Congress 45 12 43 23 57 4
BJP 30 10 44 13 37 28
Table 3.7 reveals that the number of women candidates who contested the
elections has increased and almost doubled from 355 in general elections held in 2004
to 668 in general elections of 2014. But the number of women candidates fielded by
national parties, except for the Bharatiya Janta Party, has remained almost the same
during this intervening period. Thus national parties have followed a discriminatory
and gender exclusionist policy in allotment of seats to women in elections for Lok
Sabha over the years and discouraged active participation in formal politics. The policy
of exclusion of women in granting seats at the national and state level is not only being
followed by national parties, but also by regional political parties that are in completion
in various states of the country. The political decision to not allot seats to women by
political parties at the national and state level electoral has been attributed to lack of
“winnability” of women. However, an analysis of the success rates of women
candidates in Indian general elections as compared to men reveals that it has been
higher in the last three general elections.
71
Government of India, Women Members of Rajya Sabha, New Delhi: Rajya Sabha Secretariat, 2009,
p. 9.
174
Rajya Sabha
18
%age of Women
15.5
16
14
11.83
12
11.4
10.2
11.1
10
8.3
7.6
8.97
9.8
8.6
8
8.6
7
7.6
6
7.3
4
2
0
1952 1957 1962 1967 1971 1977 1980 1985 1990 1996 1998 2004 2009 2014
175
Table 3.8 shows that the representation of women in Rajya Sabha has ranged
from 16 to 29 which are 7.3 per cent to 11.83 per cent in 2011, of the total strength of
the house. It was in 1990, there were 38 women representatives out of a total 245
members in Rajya Sabha accounting to 15.5 per cent, the hightest ever independence.
Thus, the low representation of women in the decision-making organizations is due to
the political parties that harbour very conservative view about women. Different parties
though champion the cause of women in their manifesto, but during election time they
give tickets mostly to men and only to few elite women.
Council of Ministers
Table 3.9
The Representation of Women in the Union Council of Ministers
In the Table 3.9 reveals that women have remained poorly represented in
council of Ministers. Since Independence, we had so far 15 women chief ministers and
176
23 women governors. Only one women so served as president of India but so far we
had no women as vice- president and chief justice of India. Only one woman has got
the opportunity to serve as chief election commissioner and one as chairperson UPSC
but none as CAG.
Women constitute about half of the total population in Himachal Pradesh. But
their participation in state legislative assembly, parliament and other prominent
decision making bodies is very low. Their participation in voting is almost equal to
their male counterparts and sometimes, it is even more than that of men. Women
participation at grassroots level to some extent is also better due to the 33 per cent
reservation for women in Panchayati Raj Institutions and municipalities. Himachal
Pradesh Government has further undertaken a historic step by raising the reservation
limit for women in PRIs and Municipalities from the existing 33 per cent of the total
number of seats. It was on 8th April 2008, Himachal Pradesh Panchayati Raj
(Amendment) Bill was presented and passed in the house, and then Himachal became
the third state after Rajasthan and Madhya Pradesh to give 50 per cent reservation to
women in Panchayati Raj Institutions. This will definitely help in empowering women
and in creating sensitivity to women related development issues.72
72
Sarbjeet Singh and Pankaj Dodh (eds.), Gender Justice and Women Empowerment: An Integrated
Approach, New Delhi: Regal Publications, 2013, p. 296.
177
most of the citizens participate in governmental affairs only through voting. Therefore,
voting is the most widespread and regularized political activity and in terms of the
overall impact of the citizenry on governmental performance, it may be the single most
important act. It is the simplest most common and least demanding but an effective
mode of political participation. It represents a mass involvement of most citizens at
scheduled times. As a part of the electoral process, it exerts great pressure upon the
leaders, hence is called a blunt but powerful instrument of control upon the government
and decision-makers. The citizens of a democratic country have the right to participate
in governing that country by means of voting.73 The table below shows the voter’s
turnout in different assembly elections in Himachal Pradesh from 1972-2012.
Table 3.10
Women Voter’s Turnout in Different Assembly Elections in Himachal Pradesh
Year Men Women Total Men %age Women %age Total %age
1972 929337 876111 1805448 508416 54.71 393335 44.90 901751 49.95
1977 1027616 969713 1997329 638849 62.16 531045 54.76 1169894 58.57
1982 1101563 1109961 2211524 807311 73.29 764263 68.85 1571574 71.06
1985 1173219 1183713 2356932 843623 71.91 814803 68.83 1658426 70.36
1990 1512419 1481280 2993699 1054484 69.72 973927 65.75 2028411 67.76
1993 1653296 1624329 3277625 1188656 71.90 1154957 71.10 2343613 71.50
1998 1827060 1801804 3628864 1283632 70.26 1301152 72.21 2584784 71.23
2003 2081015 2020078 4101093 1522140 73.14 1533570 75.92 3055710 74.51
2007 2336839 2267604 4604443 1597473 68.36 1678296 74.01 3297252 71.61
2012 2373378 2234980 4608359 1646899 69.39 1702953 76.20 3349852 72.69
Source: Reports on General Elections to Himachal Pradesh State Legislative Assembly from 1972-2012,
Chief Electoral Officer and Financial Commissioner, Shimla: Himachal Pradesh.
73
Bhawana Jharta, op.cit., 1998, p. 82.
178
Table 3.10 presents that women voter’s turnout in different assembly elections
in Himachal Pradesh over the years. The data clearly reveals that women electors have
outnumbered their male counterparts in exercising their voting rights especially in the
recent years the women voters and their turnout have increased over the years in
Himachal Pradesh. In the assembly election of 1982 and 1985, the number of women
voters increased as compared to the men voters. Further, the percentage of voting
turnout of women is more than the men in the assembly elections of 2003, 2007 and
2012. This indicates that over the years, more women have exercised their right to vote
and choose the government of their choice for the governance. It can be attributed to
the increased awareness amongst women about their voting rights and their desire to be
remained appallingly low before 1972. Women who have been the members of the
state legislative assembly, territorial council before 1972 are: Umavati, Satyavati Dang,
Devindra Kumari, Subhadra Amin Chand and Sarla Sharma. Uma Vati was elected to
Himachal Pradesh Legislative Assembly after the integration of Part ‘C’ state of
Bilaspur with Himachal Pradesh in 1954. Satyavati Dang was nominated to the
Pradesh legislative assembly after the re-organization of the state of Punjab in 1966.
There was no women member in the state legislature from 1967-1971.74 Table shows
that the participation of women in voting during the different assembly elections from
74
Himachal Pradesh Legislative Assembly, Who’s Who Members of Himachal Pradesh Legislative
Assembly 1952-1971, Shimla: Legislative Assembly Secretariat.
179
Table 3.11
Women’s Representation in Himachal Pradesh Legislative Assembly 1972-2012
Contestants Success
No. of
Rate of
Total Winning Political
Year Women
Seats Women Party
Total Men Women %age Contestants
Contestants
%age
1972 68 297 290 7 1.34 4 INC 4 57.14
1977 68 330 321 9 2.72 1 JP 1 11.11
INC 2
1982 68 441 432 9 2.04 3 33.33
JP 1
JD 1
1993 68 416 399 17 4.08 3 INC 3 17.64
INC 4
1998 68 369 344 25 6.78 6 24.00
BJP 2
2003 68 408 377 31 7.60 4 INC 4 12.90
INC 1
2007 68 336 311 25 7.44 5 20.00
BJP 4
INC 2
2012 68 459 425 34 7.40 3 8.82
BJP 1
Source: Reports on General Elections to Himachal Pradesh State Legislative Assembly from 1972-2012,
Chief Electoral Officer and Financial Commissioner, Shimla: Himachal Pradesh.
In the Table 3.10 depicts that over the year’s women’s representation in the
legislative assembly is not very satisfactory, as very less number of women contested
the elections as compared to their male counterparts. The number of winning women
contestants ever remained one to six. Till date, the highest number of winning women
contestants was six in the assembly elections held in the year of 1998 and the lowest
number of winning women contestants was only one in the year of 1977. Thus, the
number of winning women contestants never exceeded from six. But if we see the
winning rate of women contestants, it is satisfactory as the data show that in the year of
1982 and 1985, it is 33.33 per cent and 30.00 per cent respectively. But, in the year
2012, it went very low to 8.82 per cent. It is rather a disappointing and discouraging
number of women contestants in comparison to their strength. The political parties
seem very reluctant to field women candidates and a very few women are put up by
180
them as candidates in the elections. Though, some women contested elections as
independent candidates but they never won any seats. Thus, contesting election still
remains a male prerogative.
Table 3.12
Total
Women Political
Year No. of Name of Candidate Constituency
Members Party
Seats
1952 43 1 Smt. Uma Vati Geharwin Independent
1957 45 1 Smt. Satya Vati Dang Nominated Congress
1962 58 3 Sarla Sharma Barsar Congress
Subhdra Amin Chand Nominated Congress
Devindra Kumari Chamba Congress
1972 68 5 Ms. Chandresh Kumari Bamson Congress
Sarla Sharma Kutlehar Congress
Padma Bhattiyat Congress
Lata Lahaul & Spiti Congress
Theog Congress
*Vidya Stokes
1977 68 1 Shyama Sharma Nahan Janta Party
1982 68 3 Ms.Vidya Stokes Theog Congress
Shyama Sharma Nahan Janta Party
Chandresh Kumari Thural Congress
1985 68 3 Asha Kumari Banikhet Congress
Vidya Stokes Theog Congress
Viplov Thakur Jaswan Congress
1990 68 4 Ms.Vidya Stokes Theog Congress
Shyama Sharma Nahan Janta Party
Sushma Sharma Chintpurni BJP
Ms.Leela Gopalpur BJP
1993 68 4 Krishna Mohini Solan Congress
Viplov Thakur Jaswan Congress
Asha Kumari Banikhet Congress
**Anita Verma Hamirpur Congress
1998 68 7 Ms.Vidya Stokes Theog Congress
***Krishna Mohini Congress
Solan
Urmila Thakur Hamirpur Congress
Viplov Thakur Jaswan Congress
Shahpur BJP
Sarveen Choudhary
Asha Kumari Banikhet BJP
Ms.Nirmla Devi Pragpur BJP
181
2003 68 4 Vidya Stokes Kumarsain Congress
Anita Verma Hamirpur Congress
Chandresh Kumari Dharamsala Congress
Asha Kumari Banikhet Congress
Table 3.12 shows that the constituency and party wise women members of
Himachal Pradesh legislative assembly/territorial council from 1952-2012.
Subsequently, women’s representation in the Himachal Pradesh state legislative
assembly has improved to some extent. In 1998-2012, there were maximum seven
women members in the legislative assembly.
182
ministers. These were Vidya Stokes, Asha Kumari and Chandresh Kumari. But, later
on Asha Kumari had to resign due to a judicial case lying in the Hon’ble court and
Chandresh Kumari had to lose the ministry due to the downsizing of the council of
ministers to 15 per cent of the total number of members of the State Legislative
Assembly, according to the 91st Constitutional Amendment Act of 2003. In 2005, Anita
Verma was made Parliamentary Secretary and was dropped after four months. In this
way, the representation of women again got reduced to one in the eleven member’s
Council of Ministers. In the (BJP) Dhumal government of 2007, only one woman,
Sarveen Chaudhary included in the council of ministers as a cabinet minister, while
Urmila Thakur was made parliamentary secretary. After 2012 Vidhan Sabha election,
Vidya Stokes was made cabinet minister and no other women member could find place
in the state cabinet.75
Lok Sabha
Table 3.13
Women’s Representation in Lok Sabha from Himachal Pradesh
75
Himachal Pradesh Legislative Assembly, Who’s Who Members of Himachal Pradesh Lok Sabha
1952-2012, Shimla: Legislative Assembly Secretariat.
183
Table 3.13 reveals that Himachal Pradesh is far behind in women’s
representation to Lok Sabha. During 2004, only two women candidates from Himachal
Pradesh namely Smt. Pratibha Singh and Ms. Rameshwari Kanwar contested the
election for the Lower House of Union Parliament. Smt. Pratibha Singh contested from
Mandi parliamentary constituency on Indian National Congress ticket securing 3,
57,623 votes and was declared elected, whereas Ms. Rameshwari Kanwar another
women candidate contested from Hamirpur parliamentary constituency as Independent
Candidate and secured only 5,566 votes and lost the election. During 2009, only
women candidates Nirmala Sharma contested the election for Lok Sabha from Kangra
constituency and lost the election. Pritibha Singh was elected in the bye-election held
on 2013. During 2014 only two women candidates from Himachal Pradesh namely
Smt. Pratibha Singh and Ms. Urmila Sharma contested the election for the lower house
of union parliamentary and lost the election. All women’s who were elected to the Lok
Sabha from the state belong to the Congress Party. In 2014 Lok Sabha Election women
voted (65.83%) more than men (64.55%). In Hamirpur constituency their voting
percentage was highest (71.73%), while men’s share only 69.61 per cent. In Kangra,
women voted 67.32 per cent and men 62.00 in Shimla constituency women were a little
behind with 62.05 per cent than men’s 65.10 per cent. In Himachal Pradesh women are
positively expressing their political will and wisdom.
Rajya Sabha
Table 3.14
Women’s Representation in Rajya Sabha from Himachal Pradesh
S. No Period Name of MPs in Rajya Sabha
1. 1956-1962 Smt. Leela Devi
2. 1968-1974 Smt. SatyaVati Dang
3. 1978-1984 Smt. Mohinder Kaur
4. 1980-1986 Smt. Uma Malhotra
5. 1996-2002 Ms. Chandresh Kumari
6. 2006-2012 Smt.Viplove Thakur
7. 2010-2016 Smt. Bimla Kashyap
8. 2014-2020 Smt.Viplov Thakur
Source: Election Commission of India.
184
Table 3.14 presents that women participation from Himachal Pradesh in Rajya
Sabha is also very low. Only eight women of this state have represented the upper
house of the parliament. Leela Devi (1956-62) of Mandi was the first women to
represent the State in the Rajya Sabha. After that, Satyawati Dang (1968-74), a
prominent politician of State; Mohinder Kaur (1964-67 and 1978-84); Usha Malhotra
(1980-86); and Chandres Kumari (1996-2002) remained members of the Rajya Sabha.
Viplop Thakur (2006-2012); and Bimla Ksahyap (2006-2016) became member of
Rajya Sabha. Further, Viplov Thakur got an opportunity to become the member of the
Rajya Sabha in 2014-2020. Chandresh Kumari is the only woman in Himachal who
has got an opportunity to be a member of both the House of Parliament i.e., Lok sabha
as well as the state legislative assembly. She also remained a cabinet and deputy
minister in the state cabinet. At the national level party politics, she also remained the
president of all India Mahila Congress. This shows that women’s representation from
Himachal Pradesh has remained comparatively better in the Rajya Sabha than in the
Lok Sabha. However, the overall, representation of women in parliament from
Himachal Pradesh is very marginal and unsatisfactory.
The 73rd and 74th Constitutional Amendment Acts (1993) are a very
revolutionary landmark in the history of women’s participation in politics in India.
These amendment acts have provided 33 per cent reservation of seats for women in the
Panchayati Raj Institutions (PRIs) and Municipalities. This has laid down a strong
foundation for women’s participation in decision making at the grass-roots level. These
amendments have worked as a break-through towards ensuring equal access and more
participation of women in the political power structure. The Panchayati Raj Institutions
and Municipalities are playing a very significant role in the process of enhancing
women’s participation in public life at the local levels. In consonance of the 73rd and
74th Constitutional Amendment Act, Himachal Pradesh Government has also passed its
Panchayati Raj and Municipalities Act in 1994 and first elections to the Panchayati Raj
and Municipalities, according to this new Act were held in December 1995. Till date,
five general elections have held to the Panchayat, at village level and urban bodies in
the state in the years 1995, 2000, 2005, 2010 and 2015.76
76
Bhawana Jharta, “Women in the Politics of Himachal Pradesh: An Analysis”, Himachal Pradesh
University Journal, July 2011, pp. 9-10.
185
The latest Amendment to Panchayati Raj Act (2008) provided 50 per cent
reservation of seats for women in Panchayats at village level and urban local bodies,
which is a historical step for the political empowerment of women in this hill state. In
2010, the elections to Panchayats at village level and urban local bodies were held as
per the provisions laid down in the Himachal Pradesh Panchayati Raj Amendment Act,
2008, vide which 50 per cent seats were reserved for women in Panchayats at village
level and urban local bodies.77 The experiment of 50 per cent reservation of seats for
women in Panchayat at village level and urban local bodies has been successful in the
state. Before 1995, women’s representation in Panchayats at village level and
Municipalities was maximum upto two women in all the bodies. After 1995, it has
increased to minimum 33 percent and now 50 per cent, since 2010 elections to the
panchayats at village level and urban local bodies. The representation of women in
these institutions has shown an increasing trend. In the last five elections to the
Panchayats at village level and urban local bodies, women have been more than the
fixed quota allotted to them.
77
Ibid.,
78
Ibid.,
186
Table 3.15
Panchayat
12252 6013 18265 32.92 11727 6822 18549 36.78
Members
Panchayat
1952 970 2922 33.19 2011 1026 3037 33.78
Pradhan
BDC
1103 558 1661 33.59 1090 562 1658 33.89
Members
BDC
49 23 72 31.91 48 27 75 36.00
Chairpersons
ZP
8 4 12 33.33 8 4 12 33.33
Chairperson
Table 3.16
Women’s Representation in PRIs in Himachal Pradesh Year: 2005-2010 to 2010-2015
2005-2010 2010-2015
BDC Members 1097 579 1676 34.54 819 863 1682 51.30
187
Table 3.17
Table 3.15, 3.16 and 3.17 shows women’s representation in Panchayati Raj
Institutions in Himachal Pradesh since 1995-2015. The data in the table reveals that the
percentage share of women for the post of Panchayat members was 32.92 per cent in
the year 1995, which increased to 36.78 per cent in 2000 and further increased to 38.43
per cent in 2005. The percentage of women who were elected for the post of Pradhan
was 33.19 per cent in the elections of 1995, 33.78 per cent in the elections of 2000 and
34.28 per cent in the elections held in the year 2005. Thus, the recent elections indicate
more representation of women than the reservation provision of 33 percentages. For the
post of BDC member, the percentage share of women has been found almost same in
all the three elections. However, the percentage share of women who were elected for
the post of Chairperson of BDC has increased from 31.94 per cent in1995 to 45.33 per
cent in the year 2005. The data also reveals for the post of Zila Parishad member has
been almost as per the provision of reservation of 33 per cent except in 2000, when
34.66 per cent women were elected to this post in the state. The percentage share of
women who were elected for the post of chairperson-Zila Parishad increased from
33.33 per cent in the years of 1995 and 2000 to 58.33 per cent in the year 2005. Before
1995, women’s representation in local self-governments was up to two women in all
the bodies. After 1995, it has increased to minimum 33 per cent and 50 per cent, since
2010 elections to the PRIs and urban local bodies.
In 2010-11 election in PRIs it has been proved that the participation of women
has increased considerably. At all the three tiers in Himachal Pradesh, women
participated. At the Gram Panchayat level total women contestants were 11317
188
(58.30%), Panchayat Samiti contested 863 (51.31%) and Zila Praishad level contestants
were 128 (51%). The Pradhan of Gram Panchayat were between 1639 (50.54%), at
Panchayat Samiti Level 42 (54.54%) and Zila Parishad the total chairpersons were 6
(50%).
Similarly in 2015 election in PRIs, it has been proved that the participation of
women has considerable increase due to fifty per cent of reservation. Therefore, at the
Gram Panchayat level total women contestants were 11778 (57.88%), Panchayat Samiti
contested 862 (51.52%) and Zila Praishad level contestants were 127 (50.08%). The
chairpersons of Gram Panchayat were between 1631 (50.55%), at Panchayat Samiti
Level 42 (53.84%) and Zila Parishad the total chairpersons were 6 (50%).
79
Nagaraju Battu, op.cit., 2014, p. 51.
80
Sarbjeet Singh and Pankaj Dodh (eds.), op.cit., 2013, p. 309.
189
services in the remotest rural areas of the Pradesh. Disease control and eradication
programmes have given rich dividends. Total number of medical institutions in
government sector stood at 3, 911 on March 2016.81
Table 3.18
Life Expectancy at Birth, Himachal Pradesh and India
(per thousand)
The table 3.18 shows that life expectancy for men and women in Himachal
Pradesh has been higher than that of all India Level. Himachal Pradesh women’s life
expecting marked 62.9 years during 1981-1985 as against the 55.9 years of the all India
level. The life expectancy of Himachal Pradesh women reached 72.4 years during
2006-2010, while the national average came only up to 67.7 years. The table also
81
Government of Himachal Pradesh, Statistical Abstract of Himachal Pradesh, Shimla: Department of
Economics and Statistics Government of Himachal Pradesh, 2015-2016.
190
indicates that in Himachal Pradesh itself the rise in the life expecting of women has
surpassed that of men during the period of 1981-2010.
Birth Rate
The birth rate in Himachal Pradesh was also much lower than that of the all
India average. The following table provides the data regarding the birth rates in
Himachal Pradesh and India.
Table 3.19
Birth Rate in Himachal Pradesh and India
Year Himachal Pradesh India
1971 37.3 36.9
1981 31.5 33.9
1991 28.5 29.5
2000 21.1 25.8
2001 20.7 25.4
2002 20.7 25.0
2003 20.6 24.8
2004 19.2 24.1
2005 20.0 23.8
2006 18.8 23.5
2007 17.4 23.1
2008 17.7 22.8
2009 17.2 22.5
2010 16.9 22.1
2011 16.5 21.8
2012 16.2 21.6
2013 16.0 21.4
2014 16.4 21.0
Source: Sample Registration System, Bulletin Registrar General, India or Himachal Pradesh
82
Sarbjeet Singh and Pankaj Dodh (eds.), op.cit., 2013, p. 309.
191
Table 3.19 depicts that Himachal Pradesh birth rate during 1971 period marked
37.3, whereas the same in the all India Level was 36.9 per thousand. During the 2004
period the birth rate of Himachal Pradesh was 19.2 per thousand against the all India
rate of 24.1. During the 2014 period the birth rate in Himachal Pradesh is 16.4 per
thousand, while the same with regard to India was 21 per thousand. It is found that the
birth rate of Himachal Pradesh came down to 16.4 per thousand, whereas the same in
India stood at 21 per thousand.
Death Rate
The following table provides the data regarding the death rates in Himachal
Pradesh and India.
Table 3.20
Death Rates, Himachal Pradesh and India
(Per thousand)
192
The Table 3.20, shows that during 1971 period the death rate of Himachal
Pradesh stands at 15.6 per thousand, whereas the same in India was 14.9. During the
2004 period the death rate in Himachal Pradesh registered 6.8 per thousand as against
the national rate of 7.5. In the 2014 period, the rate in Himachal Pradesh comes down
to 6.7, whereas the all India rate moved to 6.7 per thousand.
Infant Mortality
Table 3.21
Infant Mortality Rates, Himachal Pradesh and India
(Per thousand)
The above Table 3.21, reveals the fact that infant mortality rate in Himachal
Pradesh came down 32 per thousand in 2014 from 118 per thousand in 1951.
Therefore, it can be compared to the all India rate of 129 per thousand in 1971 and 37
83
Nagaraju Battu, op.cit., 2014, p.52.
193
per 1000 in 2014. While Himachal succeeded in bringing down infant mortality rate
from 118 per thousand to 32, the all India rate comes down only to 37 from 129 over a
period. It is definitely a notable achievement not only for the entire society but more
particularly for the womenfolk in Himachal Pradesh.
Women in India a better half of Indian society, today are becoming the most
vulnerable section, as far as their safety and security is concerned. Violence against
women in India is an issue rooted in societal norms and economic dependence.
Discriminatory practices are underlined by laws favouring men. Inadequate policing
and judicial practices deny female victims proper protection and justice, it is pertinent
to note that a crime against women is committed every three minutes in India.84 The
table clearly shows that the crime against women has increasing trend in Himachal
Pradesh and India.
Table 3.22
Violence against Women in Himachal Pradesh and India
Table 3.22 shows that in Himachal Pradesh crime against women has
increasedover the years, as total numbers of crime against women reported has gone
from 1106 in 2008 to 1576 in 2014. According to the National Crime Records Bureau
of India, reported incidents of crime against women were a total of 3 37 922 in 2014. It
has increased in Himachal Pradesh and India.
84
Anju Sharma, “ Violence and Safety Scenario of Women- A World Wide Concern”, in Mamta
Mokta (ed.), Women Safety & Security: Issues Challenges, Chandigarh: Mohindra Publishing House,
2015, p. 200.
194
Therefore, it was noted that education has helped Himachal Pradesh women to
reduce infant mortality considerably and improve the health conditions of women.
Thus compared to the status of women belonging to India, the women of Himachal
Pradesh enjoy not only better educational and health facilities but also better indices of
standard of living. Death rate connected with delivery has also come down
considerably. As far as the security of women is concerned, transport facilities and
accommodations are of paramount importance. Agriculture is the main occupation of
the people of the state. About 69 per cent of the main workers are engaged in
agricultural pursuits. Agriculture is the best with the disadvantage of small holdings.
The villages in Himachal Pradesh are inter-linked with transport facilities.
The Government of India has been trying to empower the women through
various schemes some of schemes related to women empowerment in India are:
The Rashtriya Mahila Kosh (RMK) 1993: National Credit Fund for Women
was set up in 1993 to make credit available for lower income women in India.
85
Welfare Schemes for Women in India, https://en.m.Wikipedia.org., Accessed on 01-10- 2015.
195
The National Plan of Action for the Girl Child (1991-2000): The plan of
action is to ensure survival, protection and development of the girl child with the
ultimate objective of building up a better future for the girl child.
86
Mamta Mokta (ed.), Dimensions of Gender Inequality in Society, Chandigarh: Shree Ram Lal House,
2016, p. 259.
87
Welfare Schemes for Women in India, https://en.m.Wikipedia.org., Accessed on 01-10-2015.
88
Mamta Mokta, op.cit., 2016, p. 259.
196
acquiring the skills necessary for improving the economic status and well-being of
women, imbibing the value of women’s equality empowerment.89
Swayam Siddha (2001): This scheme organizing women into self-help group.
Empowerment of women through SHGs is the needs of the hours. It is basically
concerned with equality, participation, influencing decision and access to opportunity.
It has been realized that organizing of women group is one of the most effective tools
for involving women in the development process and this task can be fully performed
by the involvement of self-help groups in women’s empowerment.90
National Rural Health Mission (NRHM) (2005): The National Rural Health
Mission (NRHM) was launched by the Government of India in April 2005, with a view
to bringing about dramatic improvement in the health system and the health status of
the people, especially those who live in the rural areas of the country. The mission
seeks to provide universal access to equitable, affordable and quality health care, which
is accountable at the same time responsive to the needs of the people. The NRHM also
aims to achieve the goals set out under the National Health Policy and the Millennium
Development Goals during the mission period.91
The Mother and Child Tracking System (MCTS) (2009): This program
helps to monitor the health care department to ensure that all mothers and children have
access all the required services and medical care, during pregnancy and delivery. Also
the system maintains a database of all pregnancies registered and all births from 2009,
December.
89
Ajit Kumar Sinha (ed.), New Dimensions of Women Empowerment, New Delhi: Deep and Deep
Publications, 2008, p.142.
90
Ibid., p. 87.
91
Shahin Razi, “Rural Infrastructure-A Gateway to Rural Prosperity”, Kurukshetra, Vol. 61, No.12,
2013, p. 31.
197
money to help better health and nutrition of the pregnant women/- in 3 instalments.
Any government employee doesn’t come under this scheme.
Women State Homes: Women and wayward girls Women State Home is
being run at Mashobra (Shimla) by the department. The main purpose of this scheme is
to provide shelter, food, clothing, education and vocational training to the young girls,
widows, deserted, destitute and women, who are in moral danger. For rehabilitation of
such women, after leaving State Home, Financial Assistance of Rs.20,000 per women
is provided. In case of marriage, assistance of Rs. 51,000 also provided to women.
Mukhya Mantri Kanyadaan Yojna: Under this scheme, marriage grant of Rs.
40,000 is given to the parents/ guardians of the girls to solemnize her marriage
provided their annual income does not exceed Rs. 35,000. During 2015-16 a budget
92
Welfare Schemes for Women in India, https://en.m.Wikipedia.org., Accessed on 01-10-2015.
93
Pradhan Mantri Ujjwala Yojana, https:// en.m. Wikipedia.org., Accessed on 04-08-2017.
198
provision of 566.25 lakh has been kept for this purpose, out of which an amount of
378.98 lakh has been spent and 1516 beneficiaries were covered up to December 2015.
Mother Teressa Asahay Matri Sambal Yojna: Under this scheme Rs.3000
per child per annum given is to the destitute women belonging to the BPL families or
having income less than Rs. 35,000 for the maintenance of their children, till they attain
the age of 18 years. The assistance will be provided only for two children.
Indira Gandhi Matritva Sahyog Yojna : Under this scheme free institutional
deliveries of expectant mothers, irrespective of their income are being done in all
government hospitals in the state.
Vishesh Mahila Utthan Yojna: State government has started “Vishesh Mahila
Utthan Yojna” as 100 per cent State Plan Scheme for training and rehabilitation of
women in mortal danger in the state. There is a provision to provide stipend Rs.3,000
per month per trainee through the department of women and child development.
199
upon the needs of rape victims. An affected woman shall be entitled to financial
assistance and restorative support/ services adding up to a maximum amount of Rs.
75,000 additional assistance of Rs. 25,000 can also be given in a special cases. During
the current financial year 2015-16, there is a budget provision of 66.00 lakh and upto
December 2015, 30 women have been benefited.
Beti Bachao Beti Padhao Scheme: This scheme has been launched on 21st
January 2015 in 100 districts of India with the objective of preventing gender biased
sex selective elimination ensuring survival, protection and education of the girl child.
The scheme is an initiative to arrest and reverse (improve) the decline in child sex ratio.
In the state, this scheme is implemented in Una district, were the child sex ratio was
reported lowest. Through this process, efforts are made to create awareness among
masses about the adverse effects of declining sex ratio.
Beti Hai Anmol Yojna: With a view to change negative family and community
attitude towards the girl child at birth and to improve enrolment and retention of girl
children in schools, Beti Hai Anmol Scheme is being implemented in the state on 5th
July 2010. Under this scheme Post Birth Grant of Rs. 10,000 is provided to two girls
only belonging to BPL families and scholarships are provided from 1st Class to 10+2
Classes for their education. The State Government has made 50 per cent increase in
scholarship rates on 23rd July 2015, with a new rates of scholarships ranging from Rs.
450 to Rs.2, 250 per annum. For the year 2015-16, there is a budget provision of 946.65
lakh and an amount of 518.70 lakh has been spent upto December 2015 and 16, 111
girls have been benefited.
200
Rajiv Gandhi Scheme for Empowerment of Adolescent Girls: Rajeev
Gandhi Scheme for empowerment of Adolescent Girls (RGSEAG)–SABLA is a central
sponsored scheme for empowerment of the adolescent girls (AGs from the age 11-18).
The main objectives of the scheme is to improve their nutrition and health status,
spread awareness among them about health, hygiene, nutrition, Adolescent
Reproductive and Sexual Health (ARSH), and family and child care, upgrades their
home-based skills, life skills and vocational skills. The cost sharing ratio of nutrition
component of the scheme was 50:50 and non-nutrition component was 100 percent
central share upto financial year 2014-15, which has been revised to 90:10 between the
centre and state from current financial year 2015-16. This scheme has been started in
four districts viz. Solan, Kullu, Chamba and Kangra. Nutrition and non-nutrition are
two major components of the scheme.94
State Commission for Women: State women commission has been set up in
the state for redressal of grievance of women and to make them aware about their legal
rights. This commission is providing counselling services and legal aid to women. The
commission also looks into the complaint of violence and atrocities against women.
State Level Council for Empowerment of Women: State level council for
empowerment has been set up in the state for effective implementation and monitoring
of national policy for empowerment of women.95
First Five Year Plan (1951-56): First five year plan set up the central social
welfare board in 1953 to promote welfare work through voluntary organizations,
charitable trusts etc.
Second Five Year Plan (1956-61): Second five year plan supported the
development of Mahila Mandals to work at the grassroots.
94
Government of Himachal Pradesh, Economic Survey, Shimla: Economic and Statistics Department
Himachal Pradesh, 2016-17, pp.131-134.
95
Government of Himachal Pradesh, Women and Men in Himachal Pradesh, Shimla: Department of
Economics and Statistics Government of Himachal Pradesh, 2014, pp. 12-15.
201
Third Five Year Plan (1961-1966): Women education was recognized as most
important and main welfare indicator in third five year plan. More thrust was given for
the programmes relating to their health, mother and child welfare, health education,
nutrition and family planning.96
Fourth Five Year Plan (1969-1974): In the fourth five year plan, special focus
was made towards women education and family welfare.
Fifth Five Year Plan (1974-78): There was a major shift in the approach
towards women, from welfare to development.
Sixth Five Year Plan (1980-1985): Sixth five year plan accepted women’s
development as a separate economic agenda took a multi-disciplinary approach with a
three-pronged thrust on health, education and employment.
Seventh Five Year Plan (1985-1990): It had the objective of bringing women
into the mainstream of national development.
Eighth Five Year Plan (1992-97): It saw a paradigm shift from development to
empowerment and benefits to women in the core sectors of education, health and
employment. Outlay for women rose from Rs. 4 crore in the first five year plan to Rs.
2000 crore in the eighth.97
Ninth Five Year Plan (1997-2002): In the 9th five year plan the effective steps
were taken by central government for social economic and educational development of
women. In this five year plan, thirty per cent funds were kept reserved for the
development of women through self help groups. Adequate attention was given
towards women health. Many programmes were stated for improvement of women
nutrition such as mid-day meal.
Tenth Five Year Plan (2002-2007): Tenth five year plan suggests specific
strategies, policies and programmes for the empowerment of women.98
96
Anju Pal, “Women Empowerment in India: Globalization and Opportunities”, in Meenu Agrawal
(ed.), Women Empowerment and Globalization: A Modern Perspective, New Delhi: Kanishka
Publishers, 2009, p.344.
97
Ibid.,
98
Ibid, p.344.
202
Eleventh Five Year Plan (2007-2012): In the eleventh five year plan 2007-
2012 twenty five main sectors have been identified, wherein women development has
been given the place in two sectors viz., social justice and women empowerment,
women and child development, forty one members working committee has been
constituted for women empowerment.99
Twelfth Five Year Plan 2012-2017: The twelfth five year plan entitled as
faster, sustainable and more inclusive growth. Twelfth five year plan has emphasized
on single women by providing ‘quota’ in jobs. Moreover, women’s inclusion in
inclusive growth is only possible, when inclusive democracy turned to be reality not the
myth.100
99
Public Welfare Plan of Government of India, Directorate of Ministry of Information and
Broadcasting, Advertisement, New Delhi, p. 24.
100
Satarupa Pal, “Women in Twelfth Five Year Plan in India: An Analysis”, A Journal of Humanities,
Vol. 2, No.I, 2013, pp.121-124.
203
CHAPTER-IV
1
M.P. Dube and Neeta Bora (eds.), Social Justice and Women in India, Delhi: Swaraj Prakashan,
1999, p.137.
2
Savita Thakur Joshi (ed.), Women and Development: The Changing Scenario, New Delhi: Mittal
Publications, 1999, p. 32.
3
S.S.Chahar (ed.), Governance at Grassroots Level in India, New Delhi: Kanishka Publishers, 2005,
p. 399.
205
Social background is still more significant in the context of leadership, because
it does not only decide the descriptive status style of life and class position, values and
aspirations but also the capacity of leaders of sustain struggle for power and authority.
In an ascription-oriented society as Indian, the social existence of an individual
becomes all the more significant in nature and structure of leadership.4 Democracy is
never complete unless active involvement and participation of people at all levels is
assured.5 Panchayati Raj is regarded as the heart and soul of Indian democracy. The
health and strength of Indian democracy depends on its sound functioning. It is an
agency of social progress, economic prosperity and political development.
4
Ibid., pp. 399-400.
5
Ibid., p. 351.
6
M. R. Biju, Dynamics of New Panchayati Raj System: Reflections and Retrospections, New Delhi:
Kanishka Publishers, 1998, p. 203.
7
Thapai Ananda, et al., “Political Participation of Women in India- An Overview”, International
Journal of Advanced Research, Vol.1, No. 10, 2013, p. 632.
8
Rameshwari Pandya (ed.), Women Welfare and Empowerment in India, New Delhi: New Century
Publications, 2008, p. 571.
206
empowerment as well as participation in the decision-making process lead to
empowerment in the true sense.9 The collected information and data were classified on
the basis of age, caste, religion, marital status, education, occupation, landholding and
family size and political involvement of women.
Age
9
Meenu Agrawal (ed.), Women Empowerment and Globalization: A Modern Perspective, New Delhi:
Kanishka Publishers, 2009, p. 163.
10
Manjunath S. Hosagur, “Role of Panchayats in Rural Development: A Political Study”, Third
Concept, Vol. 26, No. 300-301, February-March 2012, p. 41.
11
Anupama Singh, Bureaucracy at the Grassroots Level in India, New Delhi: Kanishka Publishers,
2006, p. 26.
12
Arun Kumar Singh, Political Orientation of People in Rural India, New Delhi: Mittal Publications,
1987, p. 42.
13
B.S. Bhargava, Grassroots Leadership, New Delhi: Ashish Publishing House, 1978, p.18.
207
influences one’s ideas and views. As one grows up, one gets exposed to the prevailing
social and cultural patterns and develops a particular kind of attitude.14
Rural society is predominantly traditional and conservative, but the need of the
hour is an orientation towards the progress and change. Such changes can be initiated
and promoted only by the young leaders.19 In the tradition-bound and patriarchal Indian
society, social mobility of women usually occurs very marginally and therefore, entry
of the young unmarried women in politics was restrictive. But the situation has been
changed after the new dispensation, which inducts younger women in rural politics.20
The age wise composition of the respondents has been given below.
14
Reena Singh, Gender Composition Values, Preference and Behaviour, New Delhi: Rawat
Publications, 2001, p. 46.
15
S.S Chahar (ed.), op.cit., 2005, p. 400.
16
S.K. Singh and A.K. Singh, OBC Women: Status and Educational Empowerment, Lucknow: New
Royal Book Company, 2004, p.143.
17
B.S. Bhargava, op.cit., 1978, p.18.
18
K.C.Vidya, Political Empowerment of Women at the Grassroots, New Delhi: Kanishka Publishers,
2007, p. 103
19
Ibid.,p. 20.
20
D. Sundar Ram (ed.), Women Empowerment in Political Institutions: An Indian Perspective, New
Delhi: Kanishka Publishers, 2009, p.115.
208
Table: 4.1
Age Wise Classification of the Respondents
No. of Respondents
Age in Grand Total
Sr.No Mandi Kangra
Years
No. % age No. % age No. % age
1 18-30 46 31.73 9 6.16 55 18.90
2 31-40 72 49.66 74 50.69 146 50.17
3 41-50 23 15.86 41 28.09 64 22.00
4 Above 50 4 2.75 22 15.06 26 8.93
Total 145 100
50.69 146 100 291 100
60
49.66
50
31.73
40
Percentage (%)
28.09
30 Mandi
15.86
15.06
Kangra
20
6.16
2.75
10
0
18-30 31-40 41-50 Above 50
Age in Years
Table 4.1 shows that out of the total, 291 respondents were interviewed, out of
which 55 respondents were from the age group of 18 to 30 years,
years which constitute
18.90 per cent of the total sample, while 146 respondents were from the age group of
31 to 40 years, which constitute 50.17 per cent of the total sample. There were 64
respondents who were from the age group of 41 to 50 years, which constitute 22.00 per
cent of the total sample. Similarly, from the age group of above 50 years,
years the number of
respondents was 26 which constitute 8.93 per cent of the sample.
209
In district Mandi out of the total 145 respondents were interviewed, out of
which 46 respondents were from the age group of 18 to 30 years which constitute 31.73
per cent of the total sample, while 72 respondents were from the age group of 31 to 40
years which constitute 49.66 per cent of the total sample. There were 23 respondents
who were from the age group of 41 to 50 years, which constitute 15.86 per cent of the
total sample. Similarly, from the age group of above 50 years the number of
respondents was 4 which constitute 2.75 per cent of the sample.
Similarly, in district Kangra out of the total 146 respondents were interviewed,
out of which 9 respondents were from the age group of 18 to 30 years, which constitute
6.16 per cent of the total sample, while 74 respondents were from the age group of 31
to 40 years which constitute 50.69 per cent of the total sample. There were 41
respondents, who were from the age group of 41 to 50 years, which constitute 28.09 per
cent of the total sample. Similarly, from the age group of above 50 years the number of
respondents was 22 which constitute 15.06 per cent of the sample.
The comparative analysis of two districts reveals that as far as the age factor
was concerned there was little variation in the age group of women respondents in two
districts. The old women had very little share in the participation of politics. The study
reveals that the younger generation takes more interest in the politics.
Caste
210
pursuit by tradition of a particular occupation and was usually associated with a more
or less distinct ritual status in a hierarchical status. The Indian society was highly
stratified into the age-old division of castes and sub-castes. The Indian caste system
manifests itself as a vertical structure, in which individual castes were hierarchically
graded and kept permanently apart, and at the same time, were linked by well-defined
expectation and obligations which integrate them into the village social system.22
Historically, according to the verna scheme of cast grouping, there were four
varnas; the Brahmins (Priests), the Kshatriyas (Warriors), the Vaishyas (Business and
Trade) and the Shudras (Craftsman) ranking of this classification was generally agreed
upon and by custom and consensus. Brahmins had been placed above all, followed by
Kshatriyas, Vaishayas and Shudras in that order. The caste structure in Indian context
cannot be completely overruled, since it has deep roots in our history. The Indian
society was greatly divided into various castes and sub-castes. The main purpose of this
query was to see, whether all castes were well represented in the bureaucracy or not. 23
Caste has played an instrumental role in raising issues related to the more
marginalised among women. In a highly hierarchical society, women belonging to the
lower castes have lesser access to public fora, which is compounded by their gender.
22
Anupama Singh, op.cit., 2006, p.28.
23
Ibid.,
24
Rajni Kothari, Caste in Indian Politics, Bombay: Orient Longman, 1973, p.8.
25
Andre Beteille, Ideology and Social Science, United Kingdom: Penguin Books 2006, p. 43.
26
Savita Thakur Joshi (ed.), op.cit., 1999, pp. 39-40.
211
This exclusion makes it difficult for these women to represent and articulate the voices
of their constituency and their demands are often overlooked or subsumed by the
dominant sections of the society. Social divisions on the basis of caste often limit the
potential for gender solidarity between women, thereby thwarting attempts at
developing a common political agenda. Caste is a significant variable in the functioning
of the Indian political system. In ancient India, the caste Panchayats used to deal with
the matters pertaining to their castes only and also to the matter of wider importance
affecting the whole village that was dealt by the village council. This was the manner in
which the British transferred the political functions. In the independent India, the
provisions of constitutional safeguard to the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes
have given a new lease of life to the caste.27
Caste has been the most powerful institution in rural power structure in India.28
On attribute of caste, the leader should belong to the dominant caste, which is usually
the most numerous and economically dominant caste group.29 According to A. R.
Desai, “Caste largely determines the function, the status, available opportunities as well
as handicaps for individuals.30 The influence of caste is marked more in rural society.
Caste plays a significant role in moulding the emergence of leadership at the village
level. It has been observed that the people belonging to the ‘dominant castes’ have
usually been found elected to these grassroots level institutions. 31
27
K.C. Vidya, op.cit., 2007, p. 103.
28
R.S. Singh, Rural Elite Entrepreneurship and Social Change, Jaipur: Rawat Publications, 1985, p. 60.
29
Dharam Raj Singh, Rural Leadership Among Scheduled Castes, Allahabad: Chugh Publications, 1985, p. 28.
30
A.R. Desai, Rural Sociology in India, Bombay: Oxford University Press, 1969, p. 39.
31
K.C. Vidya, op.cit., 2007, p. 103.
32
K.L. Sharma, op.cit., 2007, p.8.
212
decision making process. Caste system is a hereditary classification of people in a
society. The status of a person gets pre-determined
pre in a caste system. The social
stratification that categories people into different groups called caste,
caste is usually based
on your family tree. The caste wise composition of the respondents has been given
below.
Table 4.2
Classification of the Respondents on the Basis of Caste
No. of Respondents
Grand Total
Sr.No Caste Mandi Kangra
No. % age No. % age No. % age
1 General 65 44.83 46 31.51 111 38.15
2 SCs 72 49.66 37 25.34 109 37.46
3 STs 3 2.06 13 8.90 16 5.49
4 OBCs 5 3.45 50 34.25 55 18.90
Total 145 100 146 100 291 100
49.66
44.83
50 Mandi
45
34.25
Kangra
31.51
40
25.34
Percentage (%)
35
30
25
20
8.9
15
3.45
2.06
10
5
0
General SCs STs OBCs
Caste
The table 4.2 indicate that in all 291 respondents were interviewed through a
questionnaire in which the information regarding caste factor in the society has been
presented. Out of the total 291,
291 respondents 111 respondents were from the general
category, which constitutes 38.15 per cent of the total sample. Whereas,
Whereas there were 109
213
respondents from Scheduled Caste which constitute 37.46 per cent of the sample, while
there were 16 respondents from Schedule Tribe, which constitute 5.49 per cent of the
sample and there were 55 respondents from OBCs which constitute 18.90 per cent of
the total sample.
In district Mandi out of 145 respondents 65 respondents were from the general
category, which constitutes 44.83 per cent of the total sample. Whereas, there were 72
respondents from Scheduled Caste, which constitute 49.66 per cent of the sample,
while there were 3 respondents from Schedule Tribe, which constitute 2.06 per cent of
the sample and there were 5 respondents from OBCs, which constitute 3.45 per cent of
the total sample.
In district Kangra out of 146 respondents 46 respondents were from the general
category, which constitutes 31.51 per cent of the total sample. Whereas, there were 37
respondents from scheduled caste, which constitute 25.34 per cent of the sample, while
there were 13 respondents from schedule tribe, which constitute 8.90 per cent of the
sample and there were 50 respondents from OBCs which constitute 34.25 per cent of
the total sample.
From the above analysis it appears that the share of general category of the
respondents in district Mandi was higher (44.83%) in comparison to district Kangra
(31.51%). And Scheduled Caste share is concerned, district Mandi has higher (49.66%)
to district Kangra (25.34%). As far as the OBCs share was concerned district Kangra
had higher share in comparison to district Mandi. The Scheduled Tribes have very
nominal existence in both districts. It appears that the share of STs was still very low. It
may be due to less population of their groups. It was observed during the field study,
that there were mainly two dominant castes in the districts i.e. Brahmin and Rajput in
the general category. People were still graded on their caste position and this was truer
of hilly areas of Himachal Pradesh.
Education
33
Anupama Singh, Contemporary Discourses on Gender Justice, New Delhi: SSDN Publishers, 2016,
p. 53.
214
ready for social life. Its objective was to awaken and develop in the child those
physical, intellectual and moral states, which were required to him both by his society
as a whole and by the milieu for which he was specially destined. Education, in fact,
helps in social and occupational mobility for the members in social hierarchy.
Educational attainments, to a large extent determine the nature and type of job
opportunities. Johnson rightly argues that there was a broad tendency for people with
higher education to have higher-ranking occupations.34
Education in a broad sense, from infancy to adulthood, was thus a vital means
of social control, and its significance has been greatly enhanced in the last two decades
by the rapid expansion of education at all levels in the developing countries. Through
education, new generations learn the social norms and the penalties for infringing them;
they were instructed also in their station and its duties within the system of social
differentiation and stratification.35 Women constitute almost half of the population of
the world. Education for women is the best way to improve the health, nutrition and
economic status of a household that constitute a micro unit of a nation’s economy.36
Education has far reaching input on the march of women towards empowerment.
Education is the key to all ways and means of women’s empowerment. Virtually, it
opens new vistas to overall achievement of women and consequently leads to their
empowerment.37
34
Anupama Singh, op.cit., 2006, p. 30.
35
Ibid., p. 42.
36
M. Tarique Anwer, “Development of Female Education”, Third Concept, Vol. 31, No. 362, April
2017, p. 25.
37
Chandni Sinha, “Education and Empowerment of Women”, Third Concept, Vol. 21, No. 243, May
2007, p. 51.
215
During the first half of the 19th century, education for women was limited only
to a small number of aristocratic families, who imparted education to their women, so
that they could help them the management of their huge estates. The charter Act of
1813 passed by the East India Company provided them with more opportunities to send
their children to schools and colleges. Missionaries and a few philanthropic
Englishmen entered this field and began rendering support to the establishment of
special schools for girls. Among the Indians, who took a keen interest in women’s
education were Ram Mohan Roy, and Iswar Chandra Vidya Sagar (1813-1854).
However the education was confined to a few privileged women. At the time of
Indian’s independence in 1947, not only was a large percentage of its population
illiterate, but there was a marked discrimination so far as imparting education to the
men and women were concerned.38 In this context, it can be argued that lack of women
education can be an impediment to the country’s economic development. In India
women achieved for less education that of men. The growth of women’s education in
rural areas is very slow. This obviously means that still large womenfolk of our country
are illiterate, the weak, backward and exploited.
Higher Education in India is provided by both the public and private sector.
India has the largest number of higher educational institutions. According to the data
published by the Ministry of Human Resource Development, Government of India, the
38
Savita Thakur Joshi (ed.), op.cit., 1999, pp. 80-81.
39
M. Tarique Anwer, op.cit., 2017, p. 25.
40
Sunil Kumar Sain and Sudhir Sudam Kaware, “A Present Status of Women Education in India”,
Educationia Confab, Vol. 2, No. 9, September 2013, p. 50.
41
Shailendar Sharma, “Access to Education”, Yojana, Vol. 60, January 2016, p. 49.
216
number of Universities/University-level institutions has increased 18 times from 27 in
1950 to 504 in 2009. The sector boasts of 42 Central Universities, 243 State
Universities, 53 State Private Universities, 130 Deemed Universities, 33 Institutions of
National importance (established under Acts of Parliament) and five Institutions
(Established under various State legislations). The number of colleges has also
registered a manifold increase with just 578 in 1950 growing to be more than 30,000 in
2011.42
Education is the process that liberates mind. It is liberation from all forms of
darkness and ignorance. Women’s literacy is essential for economic viability and
independence. Acquisition of knowledge is one of the prerequisites of human
development. Today all development agencies agree on the importance of educating
women in order to promote and maintain family education, health, nutrition and general
well-being. The aim of education should be to train women in such a way that they
apply their acquired knowledge to the pursuits of daily life and fit them for the position
they have to fill. Education for women should always be directed towards their holistic
development. Education enhances a women’s sense of her own health needs and
perspectives, and her power to make any health and family planning decisions.43 It is
considered an important variable not only for widening mental horizon of the
individual but also it helps a person to make use of rational and scientific approach to
different problems.44 Therefore, according to census report 2011, in Himachal Pradesh
the literacy rate of women is 75.93 per cent and that of men is 89.53 per cent. As per
the census report 2011, in India the literacy rate of women is 65.46 per cent and that of
men is 82.14 per cent. There has been a sincere effort to improve the education
attainment of women by both government and voluntary organizations. The changes in
the policies and in-frastructural supports on primary, secondary and higher education
reflect the initiatives of the government of India towards women education.45 Higher
educational level of citizen is an important prerequisite for greater role in political
process. Education enables one to act rationally. Some previsions study shows that
higher education leads to greater commitment. In the opinion of Jorgan, education is
not to be regarded as an important factor for political participation. Duverger is
42
Jyoti Gautam, “Gender Issues in Higher Education”, Third Concept, Vol. 29, No. 345, November
2015, pp. 20-21.
43
Rameshwari Pandya (ed.), op.cit., 2008, p. 165.
44
Savita Thakur Joshi (ed.), op.cit., 1999, pp. 35-36.
45
M. Tarique Anwer, op.cit., 2017, p. 25.
217
convinced that education is the most decisive
decisive factor for women’s political
participation.46 Table shows the educational levels of the respondents.
Table 4.3
Educational Levels of the Respondents
No. of Respondents
Educational Grand Total
Sr.No Mandi Kangra
Qualification
No. % age No. % age No. % age
1 Illiterate 00 00 4 2.74 4 1.37
2 Primary 14 9.65 17 11.64 31 10.66
3 Middle 16 11.04 28 19.18 44 15.12
4 Matric 52 35.86 44 30.14 96 32.99
5 Plus Two 45 31.03 33 22.60 78 26.81
6 Graduation 8 5.52 13 8.90 21 7.22
Post
7 8 5.52 4 2.74 12 4.12
Graduation
8 Others 2 1.38 3 2.06 5 1.71
Total 145 100 146 100 291 100
35.86
31.03
30.14
40
Mandi
22.6
Percentage (%)
19.18
30 Kangra
11.64
11.04
20
9.65
8.9
5.52
5.52
2.74
2.74
2.06
1.38
10
0
Educational Qualification
Table 4.3 depicts that out of 291 respondents there were 4 respondents who
were illiterate, which constitute 1.37 per cent of the total sample,
sample while 31 respondents
46
Usha Kiran, Participation of Women in Indian Politics:
Politics Gender Justice and Political Challenge,
Delhi: Globus Press, 2016, p.122.
122.
218
were having educational qualification level up to primary which constitute 10.66 per
cent of the sample, 44 respondents were with middle standard which constitute 15.12
per cent of the total sample. Whereas 96 respondents were matriculates which
constitute 32.99 per cent of the sample, 78 respondents were upto ten plus two which
constitute 26.81 per cent of the sample and 21 respondents were graduates which
constitute 7.22 per cent of the sample. There were 12 respondents were post graduates
which constitute 4.12 per cent of the sample. There were only 5 respondents having
some other type of educational qualification, which constitute 1.71 per cent of the
sample.
The comparative analysis of both districts reveals that the education level of
respondents of Mandi was higher than that of Kangra. Majority of the respondents were
educated up to matriculation level. The analysis of education standard also proves that
the majority of the leadership in state politics is in the hands of educated elected
219
women. In rural area educational system is not well developed. Hence educational level
and their understanding of the current issues were very poor.
Marital Status
47
Savita Thakur Joshi (ed.), op.cit., 1999, p. 34.
48
Priyanka Tomer, Indian Women, New Delhi: Shree Publishers, 2006, p. 52.
49
M.R. Biju (ed.), Dynamics of Modern Democracy: The Indian Experience, Vol. 2, New Delhi:
Kanishka Publishing House, 2009, p. 353.
50
K.L. Sharma, op.cit., 2007, p. 144.
220
case of late marriages, when the man and women will have developed set attitudes. But
from the physiological point of view, Velde (1976) maintains that marriage is the
permanent form of monogamous erotic relationship. Sexual urges cannot be ignored
from marriage. It is one of the marital right and duties.51 Johnson (1970) argues that
wherever we look in history or in the contemporary world, whether at civilized people
or the most primitive, we find that social life is molded to a great extent by social
institutions like marriage. There is no society on record, which is without this
institution, whatever the cultural pattern may be. The idea of marriage, however, differs
from society to society and conditioned always by time and place. As a culturally and
socially recognized institution, people almost believe that family and sexual relation
should be within legal marriage. Marriage brings love, affection, happiness, etc. It is
absolutely a sacred bond of individuals and there is need to remark the marriage intact,
marriage has to be made a permanent bond between two individuals.52
Table 4.4
Classification of the Respondents on the Basis of their Marital Status
No. of Respondents
Grand Total
Marital
Sr.No Mandi Kangra
Status
No. % age No. % age No. % age
51
M.R. Biju, op.cit., 2009, p. 353.
52
Ibid.,
53
S.S Chahar (ed.), op.cit., 2005, pp. 405-406.
54
A.R. Desai, Rural Sociology in India, Bombay: Popular Parkashan, 1992, p. 21.
221
98.62
93.84
100 Mandi
Kangra
80
Percentage (%)
60
40
6.16
20
0.69
0.69
0
0
Married Unmarried Widow
Marital Status
Fig. 4.4: Classification of the Respondents on the Basis of their Marital Status
The table 4.4 indicate that out of 291 respondents 280 respondents were
married, which constitute 96.22 per cent of the total sample, whereas 1 respondent was
unmarried which constitute 0.34 per cent of the sample. There were 10 respondents
were widow, which constitutes 3.44 per cent of the sample.
As far as inn district Kangra out of 146 respondents, 137 respondents were
married, which constitute 93.84 per cent of the total sample
sampl and there were 9
respondents was widow, which constitutes 6.16 per cent of the sample.
Thus, the comparative analysis of table indicate that the majority of the
respondents in the whole sample in both districts were married which indicated that
more married women was getting family support to join politics. Marital status of the
women enjoys more freedom as compared to the unmarried women. Due to patriarchal
character, familyy members and society does not permit girl to actively involved in the
public issues. The findings of the study indicated
indicate that married women have more
acceptability as women leaders in the society as compared to unmarried women
leaders.
222
Type of Family
Family holds a central position in social life. It is the family which lays the
foundations of the child’s personality and his emotional stability. The quality of the
generation is determined more especially by the family. India is one such nation where
agriculture is the main occupation for its population, and size of a family has a role to
fulfil in order of birth. Large families are one of the characteristics of the third world
nations. Family size tends to be particularly large in the communities, whose
subsistence economy is agriculture, where kinship ties are strong and large families are
taken as symbols of social prestige. The size of the family and number of children
count a lot in every one’s life. The limited size family can help to create conditions in
which happier families can grow and parents can be able to give their children the due
care. The large size of the family entails heavier responsibilities and burdens in meeting
the obligations of the family towards feeding, clothing, education, housing
accommodation, entertainments etc. In the Indian society two types of families are
identified viz., the Joint family and the nuclear family. 55 The type of family also affects
the political behaviour and participation of women in politics. In the family structure
generally distinction is made between joint family and nuclear family. The joint family
is associated with a traditional, agricultural society, where conservatism and family
status tend to dominate over individual interest. On the other hand, the nuclear family is
more a development of a mobile, industrialised society permit of a greater degree of
flexibility and self- expression among its members.56
223
community. The basic unit of our democracy will be the individual family.58 Data in
this regard are presented in Table 4.5
4.
Table 4.5
Family Structure of the Respondents
No. of Respondents
Family Grand Total
Sr.No Mandi Kangra
Structure
No. % age No. % age No. % age
56.85
52.41
Mandi
47.59
43.15
60 Kangra
50
Percentage (%)
40
30
20
10
0
Nuclear Joint
Family Structure
Table 4.55 shows that all 291 respondents were interviewed, out of 132
respondents were living in nuclear family system,
system which constitutes 45.36 per cent of
the total sample, whereas, 159 respondents were living in the joint family. The
percentages of such respondents were 54.64 of the total sample.
58
S. K. Dey, Panchayati Raj: A Synthesis,
Synthesis, Bombay: Asia Publishing House, 1961, pp. 102-103.
102
224
As far as district Kangra was concerned, out of 146 respondents 63 respondents
were living in nuclear family system, which constitutes 43.15 per cent of the total
sample, whereas 83 respondents were living in the joint family. The percentages of
such respondents were 56.85 of the total sample.
From the comparative analysis of the two districts reveals that joint family
system is still prevailing in the rural and urban areas of Mandi and Kangra districts. It is
not possible for a woman to choose joint family or nuclear family especially in the rural
areas, where the system of joint family is still common. It was observed that in a
sample where all the respondents come from agricultural households, the greater
number would live in joint families. There seems no big difference between styles of
family life in terms of percentage in both districts.
Number of Children
59
Rameshwari Pandya (ed.), op.cit., 2008, p. 171.
60
Marcia Manning Lee, “Why Few Women Hold Public Office: Democracy and Sexual Roles”,
Political Science Quarterly, Vol. 91, No. 2, 1976, pp. 304-10.
225
potential to participate in political activities. The number of children that a citizen
c has
can impede his/her participation in elections.61
Table 4.6
Classification of Respondents for the Basis of Number of Children
No. of Respondents
Number of Grand Total
Sr.No Mandi Kangra
Children
No. % age No. % age No. % age
1 None 6 4.14 1 0.69 7 2.41
2 One 14 9.66 20 13.69 34 11.68
3 Two 103 71.03 89 60.96 192 65.98
4 Three 16 11.03 29 19.87 45 15.46
5 Above Three 6 4.14 7 4.79 13 4.47
Total 145 100 146 100 291 100
71.03
80 Mandi
60.96
70 Kangra
60
Percentage (%)
50
40
19.87
13.69
30
11.03
9.66
20
4.79
4.14
4.14
0.69
10
0
None One Two Three Above Three
Number of Children
Table 4.6 reveals that out of 291 respondents, 7 respondents were having no
child, which constitute 2.41 per cent of the total sample, 34 respondents were having
single child which constitute 11.68 per cent of the sample, whereas 192 and 45
respondents were having two and three children respectively. The percentage of such
respondents was 65.98 and 15.46 of the sample. And 13 respondents were having more
than three children they constituted about 4.47
4.47 per cent of the total sample.
61
S. Lal, Women in Indian Politics, New Delhi: Kunal Books, 2010, p.110.
226
In district Mandi out of 145 respondents 6 respondents were having no child,
which constitute 4.14 per cent of the total sample, 14 respondents were having single
child which constitute 9.66 per cent of the sample, whereas 103 and 16 respondents
were having two and three children respectively. The percentage of such respondents
was 71.03 and 11.03 of the sample. And 6 respondents were having more than three
children, they constituted about 4.14 per cent of the total sample.
Occupation
62
Savita Thakur Joshi (ed.), op.cit., 1999, p. 42.
227
occupational change and mobility among these communities and caste was accelerated
only after the state enacted the policy of safeguards and reservations.63
63
Dharam Raj Singh, op.cit., 1985, pp. 41-42.
64
Usha Sharma and B. M. Sharma, Women and Profession, New Delhi: Commonwealth Publishers,
1995, p. 68.
65
S.S Chahar (ed.), op.cit., 2005, pp. 401-402.
66
S.N. Mishra, Pattern of Emerging Leadership in Rural India, Patna: Associated Book Agencies,
1977, pp. 62-63.
67
Reena Singh, op.cit., 2001, p.58.
68
Madan Lal Goel, Political Participation in a Developing Nation: India, Bombay: Asia Publishing
House, 1974, p.116.
228
study attempts has been made to know about the occupation
occupation of the respondents in the
Table 4.7.
Table 4.7
Occupational Patterns of the Respondents
No. of Respondents
Occupational Grand Total
Sr.No Mandi Kangra
Pattern
No. % age No. % age No. % age
1 Agriculture 113 77.93 100 68.49 213 73.19
2 Horticulture 6 4.14 00 00 6 2.06
3 Business 15 10.34 22 15.07 37 12.72
4 Others 11 7.59 24 16.44 35 12.03
Total 145 100 146 100 291 100
77.93
68.49
80
Mandi
70
Kangra
60
Percentage (%)
50
40
30
16.44
15.07
10.34
20
7.59
4.14
10
0
0
Agriculture Horticulture Business Others
Occupational Patterns
Table 4.7 shows that the occupation distribution of the respondents. It is clear
from the table that out of 291 respondents, 213 respondents were engaged in agriculture
which constitutes 73.19 per cent of the total sample, whereas 6 respondents engaged in
horticulture which constitutes 2.06 per cent of the total sample. There were 37
respondents were from the business,
busine which constitute 12.72 per cent of the sample and
229
35 respondents were having occupation other than above, which constitute 12.03 per
cent of the sample.
The comparative analysis of Mandi and Kangra districts reveals that the number
of respondents on agriculture based profession was higher in district Mandi than that of
district Kangra. Whereas, people engaged in business activities and small scale
industries were higher in district Kangra than that of district Mandi. But overall,
majority of the respondents were in agriculture. It is clear from this table that leadership
in India as well as in Himachal Pradesh is dominated by the agricultural class and
particularly by the women leadership. This is the fact that the economy of Himachal
Pradesh is dependent upon agriculture.
Income
69
K.C. Vidya., op.cit., 2007, p.109
70
D. Sundar Ram (ed.), op.cit., 2009, p. 121
230
important indicator to judge the status and influence of the respondents on the society.
People who had good financial position in the rural areas wield good influence in the
village. Lack of financial institutions in the past had made the people dependent on the
money lenders in the villages. After the independence, banking facilities were available
to the rural people. Now, the exploitation by the money lenders has been reduced to a
greater extent. With the upcoming of co-operative credit institutions poor people got
their financial needs fulfilled through these institutions.71 Agriculture plays a vital role
in India’s economy, as 54.6 per cent of the population is engaged in agriculture and
allied activities and it contributes 17.4 per cent of the country’s Gross Value Added.72
In Himachal Pradesh, the economy of state is highly dependent on three sources:
agriculture, hydro-electric powers and tourism. Agriculture is the main source of
income and employment in Himachal Pradesh. Agriculture in Himachal Pradesh
provides direct employment to about 62 per cent of its people. Hydro power and
tourism is also one of the major sources of income generation for the state. The
economy of the state also appears to be in a resilient mode in terms of growth. As per
advance estimates the Growth Rate of Gross State Domestic Product (GSDP) during of
2016-17 will be 6.8 per cent against 7.9 per cent at the national level. GSDP or state
income is the most important indicator for measuring the economic growth of a state.
According to the quick estimates based on the new series, Per Capita Income of the
Himachal Pradesh at current prices in 2015-16 stood at Rs. 94,178.73 Income of family
is an important determinant in the election of the state. It is generally said that, money
plays an important role in electoral process of the state politics. The criterion adopted
here for determining the economic status of respondents was to enquire about their
annual income from all sources. The amount of income largely determines the status of
the family in the society and also affects their participation and involvement in politics.
The table shows that distribution of the respondents by their annual income.
71
O.C. Sud, Administration Problems of Rural Development, Delhi: Kanishka Publishing House,
1992, p.102.
72
Government of India, Annual Report, Department of Agriculture, Cooperation and Farmers, New
Delhi: Welfare Ministry of Agriculture and Farmers Welfare Government of India, 2015-16, p.1.
73
Government of Himachal Pradesh, Economic Survey, Shimla: Economics and Statistics Department
Himachal Pradesh, 2016-17, pp.1-13.
231
Table 4.8
Distribution of the Respondents of the Basis of Annual Income
No. of Respondents
Grand Total
Sr.No Annual Income Mandi Kangra
No. % age No. % age No. % age
1 5000-15000 20 13.79 32 21.92 52 17.87
2 15000-25000 31 21.38 44 30.14 75 25.77
3 25000-50000 48 33.10 21 14.39 69 23.71
4 50000-75000 15 10.35 7 4.79 22 7.56
5 75000-one Lac 14 9.66 7 4.79 21 7.22
6 Above one Lac 17 11.72 35 23.97 52 17.87
Total 145 100 146 100 291 100
33.1
30.14
35 Mandi
Kangra
23.97
30
21.92
21.38
25
Percentag (%)
14.39
13.79
20 11.72
10.35
9.66
15
4.79
4.79
10
0
75000-one
Above one
15000
15000-
25000-
50000-
5000-
25000
50000
75000
Lac
Lac
Annual Income
Table 4.8 depicts that out of 291 respondents, 52 respondents were having
annual income Rs. 5000-15000
15000, which constitute 17.87 per cent of the total sample,
while 75 respondents were having income Rs.15000-25000, which constitutes 25.77
per cent of the sample, whereas 69 respondents were having income Rs. 25000-50000,
25000
which constitute 23.71 per cent of the sample,
sample while 22 respondents were having
havin
annual income Rs. 50000-75000
75000, which constitute 7.56 per cent of the sample. There
were 21 respondents were having Rs.75000-One
Rs.75000 Lac, which constitute 7.22 per cent of
232
the sample and 52 respondents were having income above One Lac, which constitute
17.87 per cent of total sample.
The comparative analysis of Mandi and Kangra districts reveals that the power
of politics was in the hand of middle class society in both districts. The study reveals
that most of the respondents came under the low income group. Due to uneconomic
size of holding most of the poor people cultivate only field crops like maize, wheat etc.
They were not able to produce cash crops at large like vegetables such as cabbage,
cauliflower, potato, peas and tomato etc. Due to non-fertile and small land holding, lack
of irrigation facilities and their poor economic standards.
Land Holdings
233
power in the Indian rural society.74 In India, for a long time land ownership played a
very significant role as an element of influence in community power structure, land
ownership is crucial factor in establishing dominance ownership of land not only
insured a stable and secure income but also symbolized high social and economic
status. Generally the pattern of land is concentrated in the hands of a relatively small
number of big owners (Landlord) as against a large number, who either owns very little
land or no land at all.
The power and prestige which land owning castes command, affect their social
and economic relations in the society.75 If land ownership is not always an
indispensable passport to high rank, it certainly facilities upward mobility.76 Land
constitutes the basic foundation of agrarian social structure in India. Whereas, it
determines the nature of occupational and economic activities and the rewards flowing
from them, it also serves as a pointer towards status and prestige in society.77 Land
ownership was a crucial factor in establishing dominance in the village. The pattern of
land ownership in rural India was such that bulk of the arable land was concentrated in
the hands of a relatively small number of big owners, as against a large number, who
either owned very little land or no land at all.78
74
R. Indira and Deepak Kumar Behera (eds.), Gender and Society in India: Rural and Tribal Studies,
Vol. 2, New Delhi: Manak Publications, 1999, p.112.
75
S.S. Chahar (ed.), op.cit., 2005, pp. 406.
76
M.N. Srinivas, Social Change in Modern India, New Delhi: Orient Longman, 1982, pp. 12-13.
77
Dharam Raj Singh, op.cit., 1985, p. 38
78
K.C. Vidya, op.cit., 2007, p.110.
79
D.S. Chaudhary, Emerging Rural Leadership in an Indian State: A Case Study of Rajasthan, Rohtak:
Manthan Publications, 1981, pp. 55-56.
234
operated by 9.61 lac farmers. The average holding size is about 1.00 hectare. About 10
per cent of the total GSDP comes from agriculture
agriculture and its allied sectors.
Table 4.9
Size of Land Holding of the Respondents
No. of Respondents
Land Grand Total
Sr.No Holding Mandi Kangra
(Bighas)
No. % age No. % age No. % age
1 0-10 111 76.55 112 76.71 223 76.63
2 11-20 24 16.55 18 12.33 42 14.43
3 21-30 6 4.14 6 4.11 12 4.13
4 31-40 3 2.07 2 1.37 5 1.72
5 Above 40 1 0.69 8 5.48 9 3.09
Total 145 100 146 100 291 100
76.55
76.71
80
Mandi
70
Kangra
60
Percentage (%)
50
40
16.55
30
12.33
20
5.48
4.14
4.11
2.07
1.37
0.69
10
0
0-10 11-20 21-30 31-40 Above 40
Size of Land Holding
The table 4.9 indicate that out of 291 respondents, 223 respondents whose total
size of land holding was 0-10
0 bighas, which constitute 76.63 per cent of the total
sample, whereas 42 respondents whose size of land holding was 11-20
11 bighas, which
constitute 14.43 per cent of the sample,
sample while 12 respondents whose size of land
holding was 21-30
30 bighas,
bighas which constitute 4.13 per cent of the sample. There were 5
respondents who were having land 31-40
31 bighas, which constitute 1.72 per cent of the
235
sample and 9 respondents who were having land above 40 bighas, which constitute
3.09 per cent of the sample.
In district Mandi out of 145 respondents, 111 respondents whose total size of
land holding was 0-10 bighas, which constitute 76.55 per cent of the total sample,
whereas 24 respondents whose size of land holding was 11-20 bighas, which constitute
16.55 per cent of the sample, while 6 respondents whose size of land holding 21-30
bighas, which constitute 4.14 per cent of the sample. There were 3 respondents who
were having land 31-40 bighas, which constitute 2.07 per cent of the sample and 1
respondent who was having land above 40 bighas, which constitute 0.69 per cent of the
sample.
The comparative study of two district reveals that the size of land holding in the
study areas was very small. Majority of the respondents at all levels were found holding
land below 10 bighas. However, the size of the land holding of the respondents in
Kangra district was slightly better than that of the district Mandi. This shows that
majority of women political activists in Mandi and Kangra districts have their own
land. But the size of land holding is not very large. It was observed that due to the
growth of population, the size of land holding was going down day by day at village
level and poor people compel to sell their land for the requirement of some domestic
social needs. It is evident that the high land holding farmers are minority in comparison
with the large number of small farmers and agricultural labourers, who constitute the
back-bone of the rural population.
Role of Newspaper
Newspaper is a collection of news from all over the world which keeps us up-
to-date about everything going outside. Now-a-days the newspaper has been a necessity
236
of the life. It gives us all about what is happening in our own country as well as whole
world. It is essential to be aware of with day to day happening in the society as well as
at the governmental level. Attempt was made to analyse the awareness of the
respondents in the day to day life. Table shows that the respondents take interest in
reading newspapers daily.
Table 4.10
Respondents
spondents Awareness Role of Newspapers
No. of Respondents
Regarding Grand Total
Sr.No Mandi Kangra
Newspapers
No. % Age No. % Age No. % Age
1 Yes 115 79.31 104 71.24 219 75.26
2 No 26 17.93 35 23.97 61 20.96
3 No Opinion 4 2.76 7 4.79 11 3.78
Total 145 100 146 100 291 100
79.31
71.24
80 Mandi
70
Kangra
60
Percentage (%)
50
23.97
40
17.93
30
20
4.79
2.76
10
0
Yes No No Opinion
Response
Fig.4.10
10: Respondents Awareness Role of Newspapers
Table 4.10 shows that 291 respondents were interviewed regarding their habits
of reading newspapers. Out of which 219 respondents responded positively,
positively which
constitute
te 75.26 per cent of the sample and there were 61 respondents replied
negatively.
y. The percentage of such was 20.96 of the total sample. While 11 respondents
who gave no opinion, which constitute 3.78 per cent of the sample.
237
As far as in district Mandi was concerned, out of 145 respondent’s 115
respondents who responds positively, constitute 79.31 per cent of the sample, which
whereas 26 respondents did not show any interest in the reading of newspapers. The
percentage of such respondents was 17.93 of the sample respectively. There were 4
respondents who gave no opinion, which constitute 2.76 per cent of the sample.
The comparative analysis of the two district shows that the number of
respondents, who were in habit of reading newspaper was higher in district Mandi in
comparisons to district Kangra. Majority of the respondents take interest in the reading
of newspapers.
Media has been the source of shared images and messages relating to political
and social context. India is a multilingual, multiethnic and multi-religious country. In
India, internet and cable television have about meaningful change to public and private
spheres of life more quickly than education, industrialization or any other socio-
economic factor. Electronic media had no role to play for a decade after independence.
Print media and radio served as the primary means of political information and
mobilization. Mass media received a boost in September 1959, as a result of the
introduction of television to urban India. The emergence of television to post-colonial
India was characterized by competing visions, its deeply segmented political sphere
witnessed several rounds of intense debating between politicians and bureaucrats, who
were concerned with the efficacy of investing in television, considering only a few
could manage access to the medium.80
80
Sayantani Satpathi and Oindrila Roy, “The Impact of the Electronic Media on the Modern Indian Voter: A
Study of the Post Liberalization Era”, Global Media Journal, Summer Issue, June 2011, pp. 1-3.
238
restricted to educational and entertainment based programs. In 1991, the Indian
television network was deregulated and cable-satellite network emerged for the first
time from its modest beginning with two channels by June 2010. Moreover, there were
thirty three for hour news channels that would constantly engage in political and
economic debates and conduct opinion/exit polls in election years.81
Radio is a vehicle for projecting personality through which it attracts and hold
an audience. Radio is an efficiency instrument for getting a message to a large number
of people at the same time. Radio is a powerful instrument in the area of public
enlightenment. Not been constrained by the barriers of time space, illiteracy, and
electricity supply, radio is one of the ideal means of mass communication in both
developed and developing societies because it is easy to establish, own operate and
maintain, and does not demand much intellectual exertion from listeners. It is capable
of offering tutorial support and resources to stimulate discussions, reflections and
practical learning on the socio-economic, socio-political and cultural activities of a
society or a nation. The radio has different roles some of which are: Informing Role:
the radio performs the role of keeping women informed. It has an important job in
providing political information to women and the general public. Influencing role: the
media may not always be successful in telling people what to think, but are usually
successful in telling them, what to think about. Mobilising people: through
commentaries and programmes, the radio acts as secondary agents of mobilization. The
radio facilitates and enhances the process by which, individuals partake in collective
decision making. This role is one, the radio adapts through political programmes in
mobilizing women for participation.82
Thus, radio and television play a vital role in the life style of the people. At the
basic level, they inform people about the various things in various ways and through a
variety of programmes. Radio and the television are the most effective media to
achieve the much desired rural development. Radio and television constitute the
effective media for national awareness and the mood of advancement of the society, the
need of the society and the objective of the government as laid down in the national
interest of the country. In the present time television and radio have become an integral
81
Ibid.,
82
Adekoya, Helen Odunola, et al., “The Role of Radio in the Mobilization of Women towards Political
Participation: A Study of Ogun State Nigeria”, Research on Humanities and Social Sciences, Vol. 5,
No. 24, 2015, p.13.
239
part of our life. The people who are sitting in the rural areas are the well aware of day
to day happenings in the state. In the present study, an attempt has been made to know
the opinion of the respondents,
respondents whether they see and hear news in television or in radio.
Table 4.11
Respondents Awareness Role of Radio and Television
No. of Respondents
Regarding Radio Grand Total
Sr.No Mandi Kangra
and Television
No. % Age No. % Age No. % Age
1 Yes 124 85.52 119 81.51 243 83.51
2 No 16 11.03 23 15.75 39 13.40
3 No Opinion 5 3.45 4 2.74 9 3.09
Total 145 100 146 100 291 100
85.52
Mandi
81.51
100
Kangra
80
Percentage (%)
60
15.75
40
11.03
3.45
2.74
20
0
Yes No No Opinion
Response
Table 4.11 reveals that 291 respondents were interviewed, out of which 243
respondents replied positively they were in habit of hearing news in the radio or in the
television, whereas only 39 respondents expressed their ignorance regarding news in
television or in radio
adio and while 9 respondents did not express their opinion. The
percentage of all the three types of respondents was 83.51, 13.40 and 3.09 respectively.
240
the sample, whereas 16 respondents were not in habit of hearing news. The percentage
of such was 11.03 respectively. There were only 5 respondents who gave no opinion
which constitute 3.45 per cent of the sample.
The comparative analysis of two districts Mandi and Kangra depicts that in
district Mandi the respondents were slightly higher in habit of hearing news in
television or in the radio in compared to district Kangra. Hence, it has been revealed
that television and radio programmes are very effective in mobilizing women to
participate in politics. It was observed that there was a tendency among the rural
leaders to hear news in television and radio. These sources gave information about the
state, national and international level. Thus television and radio become an integral part
of our daily life.
Political Interest
83
Jan Leighley, “Participation as a Stimulus of Political Conceptualization”, Journal of Politics, Vol.
53, No. 1, February 1991, p. 190.
84
Joel. D. Schwartz, “Participation and Multisubjective Understanding: An Interpretivist Approach to
the Study of Political Participation”, The Journal of Politics, Vol. 46, 1984, pp. 1128-1129.
241
Political interest is the first
first and psychological component of political
participation. The interest of a person in political institutions, elections, the processes of
struggle for power, political events and national and local issues are important indices
of his psychological participation
ipation in political structure and process. The political
interest of a person does not only reflect his commitment and attachment to state and
polity but also expresses his will to participate and understand their complexities.85
Though, the power struggle is an incessant fact of democratic political life, life no all
members of political community are always and alike involved in it. People are
interested and involved in the country’s politics at all time.86 Mumtaz Soysal defines,defines
“Participation
Participation as all forms of action by which citizens ‘take part’ in the operation of
administration. The taking part refers to any level from macro to micro region or it may
be of any type e.g. advisory in nature or in participate through public or private bodies
or other organizations”.87
Table 4.12
Respondent’s Opinion Regarding Interest in Politics
No. of Respondents
Grand Total
Sr.No Response Mandi Kangra
No. % Age No. % Age No. % Age
1 Yes 85 58.62 94 64.38 179 61.51
2 No 42 28.96 32 21.92 74 25.43
3 No Opinion 18 12.42 20 13.70 38 13.06
Total 145 100 146 100 291 100
64.38
70 58.62
60
Percentage (%)
50
40 28.96
30 21.92 Mandi
20 12.42 13.7 Kangra
10
0
Yes No No Opinion
Response
242
Table 4.12 depicts that out of 291 respondents, 179 respondents were interested
in politics, which constitute 61.51 per cent of the total sample, whereas 74 respondents
were not interested in politics, which constitute 25.43 per cent of the sample, while 38
respondents did not give their opinion, which constitute 13.06 per cent of the sample.
The comparative analysis of both the districts reveals that vast majority of the
respondents in the whole sample 61.51 per cent, as well as individually in Mandi (58.62
%) and Kangra (64.38%) districts were interested in politics. However, the respondents
in Kangra district were found to be slightly more interested in politics, as compared to
Mandi district.
88
S. Waseem Ahmad, et al., “Women’s Political Participation and Changing Pattern of Leadership in
Rural Areas of U.P”, The Indian Journal of Political Science, Vol. 69, No.3, July- September 2008,
p. 664.
89
Vijay Agneu, Elite Women in Indian Politics, New Delhi: Vikas Publishing House, 1986, p. 133.
243
Table 4.13
Politicall Participation of Respondents Father/Husband
F
No. of Respondents
Grand Total
Sr.No Response Mandi Kangra
No. % age No. % age No. % age
1 Yes 57 39.31 53 36.30 110 37.80
2 No 67 46.21 69 47.26 136 46.74
3 No Opinion 21 14.48 24 16.44 45 15.46
Total 145 100 146 100 291 100
47.26
46.21
50 Mandi
39.31
45 Kangra
36.3
40
Percentage (%)
35
30
16.44
25
14.48
20
15
10
5
0
Yes No No Opinion
Response
Table 4.13 shows that out of 291 respondents 110 respondents father/husband
participate in politics, which constitute 37.80 per cent of the total sample, whereas 136
respondents, the father/ husband had no participation in politics, which constitute 46.74
per cent of the sample, while 45 respondents gave no opinion on the question,
question which
constitute 15.46 per cent of the total sample.
244
In district Kangra out of 146 respondents, 53 respondents father/husband
participates in politics, which constitute 36.30 per cent of the total sample, whereas 69
respondents had no participation in politics, which constitute 47.26 per cent of the
sample, while 24 respondents gave no opinion on either side question, which constitute
16.44 per cent of the total sample.
The comparative analysis of the two districts reveals that majority of the
respondent’s father and husband did not participate in politics. However, a few
respondents’ father and husband did participate in political activities. On the other
hand, a very lesser number of the respondents were completely active in politics.
Voting
Voting has a tremendous strength and weakness and has impact for equalizing
and mobilizing women. Yet, it has to be noted that voting requires the least initiative
and interval motivation. Many times women treats the day of voting as a welcome
break from her dull and tiring routine and does not appear to have a notion of, why she
should vote for a particular candidate.
90
Wan Asnal, et al., “Political Attitude and Voting Behaviour”, International Journal of Humanities
and Management Sciences, Vol. 1, No. 1, 2013, p. 126.
91
Sidney Verba, et al., Participation and Political Equality: A Seven-Nation Comparison, New York:
Cambridge University Press, 1978, p. 313.
92
Rashmi Shrivastava, “Minority Representation of a Political Majority Group: Women in Indian
Democratic Process”, The Indian Journal of Political Science, Vol. 66, No.2, April-June 2005, pp.
234-235.
93
Savita Thakur Joshi (ed.), op. cit., 1999, p.148.
245
Though, women’s participation in the political process has increased both in the
elections and their readiness to express their view on issues directly concerning their
life. But their ability to produce an impact on the political process has been negligible
because of the inadequate attention paid to their political education and mobilization by
both political parties and women’s organizations, as political parties see women voters
as appendages of the males. Political parties seem uniformly reluctant to field women
candidates. The high cost of electioneering is another deterrent to most women
candidates. Because of these factors there is an increasing tendency among women to
contest election as independent candidates.94 Political participation denotes such
activities by which the citizens share in choosing the government and directly or
indirectly in the formation of public policy. These activities are voting, seeking
information about the policy of political parties and of the government, attending
election meetings, contributing money to the party or election funds of its candidate,
enrolment in a party, canvassing for a party and working in campaigns. Among these,
making contributions to the party fund, enrolment in a party, canvassing and working in
campaigns are considered to be more active forms of participation. In a democracy, the
citizens’ participation in election is a basic norm. It is the right by which, they grant or
withdraw consent in a democracy.95 Table shows the participation in voting in different
past election.
Table 4.14
No. of Respondents
Grand Total
Sr.No Response Mandi Kangra
No. % Age No. % Age No. % Age
1 Yes 134 92.41 137 93.84 271 93.13
2 No 8 5.52 7 4.79 15 5.15
3 No opinion 3 2.07 2 1.37 5 1.72
Total 145 100 146 100 291 100
94
Rameshwari Pandya (ed.), op.cit., 2008, pp.570-571.
95
Sachchidananda, The Tribal Voter in Bihar, New Delhi: National Publishing House, 1976, p. 36.
246
93.84
92.41
100
Percentage (%) 80
60
Mandi
40
Kangra
5.52
4.79
2.07
1.37
20
0
Yes No No opinion
Response
In district Mandi out of 145 respondents, 134 respondents casted their vote in
last election, which constitute 92.41 per cent of the total sample, whereas 8 respondents
did not cast their vote in the last election,
election which constitute 5.52 per cent of the sample.
There were 3 respondents,
respondents who did not give their opinion about the cast of vote in
election, which constitute 2.07 per cent of the sample.
In district Kangra out of 146 respondents, 137 respondents casted their vote in
last election, which constitute 93.84 per cent of the total sample, whereas 7 respondents
did not cast their vote in the last election,
election which constitute 4.79 per cent of the sample.
There were 2 respondents,
respondents who did not give their opinion about the cast of vote in
election, which constitute 1.37 per cent of the sample.
247
Factors Influence on the Voting
The interest of the voters and accordingly their behaviour at the time of voting
is also influenced by the nature or purpose of the elections or the extent of the suffrage.
The force of charisma has its own part to play, whereby the voters are influenced by a
slogan like “Garibi Hatao”, or “A vote for a pair of bullocks is vote for Panditji and
progress”, or “Indira means India, India means Indira”, or “Indira means Dictatorship,
“My heart beats for India” versus “Rajiv means Bofors” and the like. The role of all
these factors can be examined in the study of Indian electoral behaviour. There are
several factors responsible for voting behaviour in India. In India following are main
political and socio-economic factors, which act as determinants of voting behaviours in
our democratic system. 96 In elections there are so many factors which affect the voting
behaviour, such as candidate, religion, caste, education and political party etc. Table
shows the responses of the respondents regarding the factors, which they keep in mind
while casting their votes.
Table 4.15
Respondents Views Regarding Influence on the Voting
No. of Respondents
Grand Total
Sr.No Response Mandi Kangra
No. % age No. % age No. % age
1 Candidate 60 41.38 64 43.83 124 42.61
2 Religion 00 00 00 00 00 00
3 Caste 18 12.42 11 7.54 29 9.97
4 Education 21 14.48 29 19.86 50 17.18
5 Party 46 31.72 42 28.77 88 30.24
Total 145 100 146 100 291 100
96
Biraj Hazarika, “Voting Behaviour in India and its Determinants”, Journal of Humanities and Social
Science, Vol. 20, No.10, October 2015, pp.22-25.
248
43.83
41.38
Mandi
45
Kangra
40
31.72
28.77
35
Percentage (%)
30
19.86
25
14.48
20
12.42
15
7.54
10
5
0
0
0
Candidate Religion Caste Education Party
Response
Fig.4.15: Respondents
Respond Views Regarding Influence on the Voting
249
while 42 respondents gave importance to political party affiliation of the candidate,
which constitute 28.77 per cent of the sample.
The comparative analysis of the two districts reveals that in majority the
respondents casted their votes in elections, keeping in mind the merits of the candidate.
There were so many factors, which affected the voting behaviour such as caste, religion
political party and education of the candidate. It was observed that the respondents
gave less importance to other factors, while casting their votes.
The election campaign provides another sphere for women to participate in the
political process. The campaign strategy plays an important part in the electoral
process. The partied have organised regular forums, cell to mobilise and campaign
among women. The handbills, posters and public meetings etc. emphasise specific
promises for women. Recognising the significance of women voters, many political
parties of late, are deploying their women workers as campaigners to deal with women
voters. Women campaigners are sent for house to house visits. They usually enjoy the
advantage of mixing freely with all the members of the family during such visits.
However, it is obvious that the numbers of women are engaged in this sort of activity.
They attend a meeting only for a short time. It appears that, broadcasts through radio
and television also have been effective among women to an extent. Propaganda,
97
Sidney Verba and Norman H. Nie, Participation in America: Political Democracy and Social
Equality, New York: Harper and Row, 1972, p. 52.
98
B. B. Jena and J. K. Baral, Election Politics and Voting Behaviour in India, Delhi: Discovery
Publishing House, 1989, p.140.
99
K.S. Pandhy and Purna Chandra Satapathy, Tribal India, New Delhi: Ashish Publishing House, 1989, p. 103.
250
publicity slogans and symbols generally kindle the interest of the illiterate women
voters.100
Table 4.16
Respondents Views Regarding Participation of Women in Campaign Activities
No. of Respondents Grand
Sr.No Campaign Activities Mandi Kangra Total
No. % age No. % age No. %age
Door to Door Campaigning with
1 70 48.27 69 47.26 139 47.77
in Village/Town
Campaigning outside the
2 8 5.52 20 13.69 28 9.62
Village/Town
3 Preparing Sticking Posters 8 5.52 10 6.85 18 6.18
4 Addressing Public Meeting 7 4.83 8 5.48 15 5.16
5 All the above 52 35.86 39 26.72 91 31.27
Total 145 100 146 100 291 100
100
Kalpana Roy, Women and their Environment, Vol.1, Delhi: Rajat Publications, 1999, pp. 241-242.
101
Praveen Rai, “Electoral Participation of Women in India: Key Determinants and Barriers”, Economic
and Political Weekly, Vol. 46, No. 3, January 2011, pp. 50-51.
251
48.27
47.26
Mandi
50
Kangra
35.86
40
26.72
Percentage (%)
30
13.69
20
6.85
5.52
5.52
5.48
4.83
10
0
Door to Door Campaigning Preparing Addressing All the above
Campaigning outside the Sticking Public
with in Village/Town Posters Meeting
Village/Town
Response
Fig.4.16: Respondents Views Regarding Participation of Women in Campaign
Activities
252
Further, there were 52 respondents who took part in all activities in campaigning,
which constitute 35.86 per cent of the sample.
The comparative analysis of the two districts reveals that majority of the
respondents take part in door to door campaigning with in village/town. Mandi district
was highly active in take part in campaigning as compared to district Kangra. It was
observed that women took part in door to door campaigning to elections. A person who
canvases for a party or a candidate or took active part in various campaign activities,
they were more involved in politically. Many younger women were becoming involved
in politics in more informal ways, such as social media campaigns.
In the present study an attempt has been made to know the opinion of the
respondents’ views regarding, won the election in first time.
Table 4.17
Respondents Views With Regard to Winning the Election
No. of Respondents
Grand Total
Sr.No Response Mandi Kangra
No. % Age No. % Age No. % Age
1 Yes 120 82.76 126 86.30 246 84.53
2 No 22 15.17 16 10.96 38 13.06
3 No Opinion 3 2.07 4 2.74 7 2.41
Total 145 100 146 100 291 100
253
86.3
82.76
90 Mandi
80
Kangra
70
Percentage (%)
60
50
40
15.17
10.96
30
2.74
2.07
20
10
0
Yes No No Opinion
Response
Fig.4.17: Respondents Views With Regard to Winning the Election
In district Mandi, out of 145 respondents 120 respondents won the election first
time, which constituted 82.76
76 per cent of the total sample, whereas 22 respondents who
did not win the election, which constitute 15.17 per cent of the sample. There were 3
respondents who gave no opinion,
opinion which constitute 2.07 per cent of the total sample.
In district Kangra, out of 146 respondents 126 respondents won the election first
time, which constituted 86.30 per cent of the total sample, whereas 16 respondents who
did not win the election, which constitute 10.96 per cent of the sample. There were 4
respondents who gave no opinion,
opinion which constitute 2.74 per cent of the total sample.
254
Institutions are the essentially institutions of concern masses for the masses and their
success depends on the people’s participation.102 The 73rd amendment act provided
reservation of seats for women and this has raised new hopes. Achieving the goal of
equal participation of women and men in decision-making will provide a balance that
more accurately reflects the composition society and is needed in order to strengthen
democracy and to promote its proper functioning. Women’s equal participation in
decision-making is not only a demand for simple justice or democracy but can also
seen as a necessary condition for women’s interests to taken into account. Without
active participation women at all levels of decision-making, the goal of equality,
development and peace cannot be achieved.103 Political participation of women is an
important determinant of their modernization. It enables women to come out of the
shackles of tradition and secluded life. It also leads to greater social and political
awareness among women. Women in politics could effectively represent opinions of
other women and also understand and deal effectively with the problems of society in
general and women in particular. Political participation of women equips them with
political competence, organizational abilities and belief in egalitarianism and
democratic planning.104 In the present study an attempt has been made to know the
opinion of the respondents by the level of their participation.
Table 4.18
Level of Political Participation of the Respondents
No. of Respondents
Grand Total
Sr.No Response Mandi Kangra
No. % Age No. % Age No. % Age
1 Village level 107 73.79 101 69.18 208 71.48
2 Block Level 20 13.79 20 13.69 40 13.74
3 District Level 18 12.42 25 17.13 43 14.78
4 State Level 00 00 00 00 00 00
5 National Level 00 00 00 00 00 00
Total 145 100 146 100 291 100
102
D. Sundar Ram, “Rural Development”, Third Concept, Vol. 14, No. 158, April 2004, p. 41.
103
S. Nagendra Ambedkar and Shilaja Nagendra (eds.), Women Empowerment and Panchayati Raj,
Jaipur: ABD Publishers, 2005, p. 200.
104
R. Indira and Deepak Kumar Behera (eds.), op.cit., 1999, p.122.
255
73.79
69.18
80
Mandi
70
Kangra
60
Percentage (%)
50
40
17.13
30
13.79
13.69
12.42
20
10
0
0
0
0
0
Village level Block Level District Level State Level National
Level
Response
256
Age at the Time of First
irst Election
Table 4.19
Respondents view
vie Regarding Age at the Time of First
irst Election
No. of Respondents
Grand Total
Sr.No Years Mandi Kangra
No. % Age No. % Age No. % Age
1 18-25 17 11.73 1 0.69 18 6.19
2 26-40 101 69.65 84 57.53 185 63.57
3 41-55 24 16.55 49 33.56 73 25.09
4 Above 55 3 2.07 12 8.22 15 5.15
Total 145 100 146 100 291 100
69.65
Mandi
70
57.53 Kangra
60
Percentage (%)
50
40 33.56
30
16.55
20 11.73
8.22
10 0.69 2.07
0
18-25 26-40 41-55 Above 55
Age in Years
105
Usha Kiran, op.cit., 2016, p.121.
257
the sample, whereas 185 respondents contested the elections for the first time at the age
of 26-40 years, which constitute 63.57 per cent. There were 73 respondents who
contested election for the first time at the age of 41-55 years and 15 respondents
contested election for the first time at the age of above 55 years. The percentage of such
respondents was 25.09 and 5.15 of the sample respectively.
The comparative analysis of two district reveals that majority of the respondents
contested election for the first time at the age of 26-40 years. In district Mandi 69.65
per cent of the respondents contested election for the first time at the age 26-40 years,
as compared to district Kangra 57.53 percent.
Motivation Factor
106
G. Palanithurai, Contemporary Issues in Development Dynamics, New Delhi: Kanishka Publishers,
1999, pp.197-200.
258
Consequently, one of the key factors that determine their high levels of
participation in casting their votes is women’s interest in politics. Women’s interest in
politics is a pre-requisite for encouraging higher participation of women in formal
politics. Individual socio-demographics including education and income, socio-cultural
norms and caste are also associated with women’s opportunities in political
participation. Women’s level of participation in electoral politics depends on their
societal background and the levels of liberty and freedom enjoyed by them. Thus
women who exercise their own discretion in deciding whom to vote for, shows a higher
level of electoral competition as voters in electoral competition than those, whose
decisions are influenced by family and friends.107
However, women in India enjoy a unique status of equality with the men as per
constitutional and legal provision. But the Indian women have come a long way to
achieve the present positions. Reservation has resulted in bringing a novel group of
women representative into Panchayati Raj Institutions. With the provision of 73rd
Amendment, women representatives have ample scope for involvement in the process
of local government.108 Women have taken initiatives to evolve an able leader, the
support of family, self-confidence and society were major factors promoting her.109
Table show the respondent’s opinion regarding motivation factor of respondents to
contest the election.
Table 4.20
Respondents Opinion With Regard Motivation Factors
No. of Respondents
Grand Total
Sr.No Response Mandi Kangra
No. % age No. % age No. % age
1 Your Own Decision 42 28.97 38 26.03 80 27.49
2 Family Members 59 40.69 62 42.47 121 41.58
3 Friends/Relatives 18 12.41 8 5.48 26 8.94
4 Political Party 14 9.66 15 10.27 29 9.96
5 Others 12 8.27 23 15.75 35 12.03
Total 145 100 146 100 291 100
107
Praveen Rai, op.cit., 2011, p. 52.
108
Dasarathi Bhuyan, “Particpation in Panchayati Raj”, Yojana, Vol. 52, October 2008, p. 36.
109
S. Waseem Ahmad, et al., op.cit., 2008, pp. 670-671.
259
42.47
40.69
Mandi
50
Kangra
28.97
26.03
40
Percentage (%)
15.75
30
12.41
10.27
9.66
8.27
20
5.48
10
0
Response
Fig.4.20: Respondents’
pondents’ Opinion With Regard Motivation Factors
260
whereas 62 respondents believed that family motivated them to contest the elections,
which constitute 42.47 per cent of the sample, while 8 respondents believed that their
friends and relatives motivated them to contest the elections, which constitute 5.48 per
cent of the respondents. There were 15 respondents which believed that political parties
motivated them to contest the elections, which constitute 10.27 per cent of the sample
and 23 respondents contested the election due to some others factors like reservation of
seats for women in Panchayati Raj Institutions and Municipalities, which constitute
15.75 per cent of the sample.
The comparative analysis of two districts reveals that the number of respondents
who believed that they were motivated by their family. Mandi district respondents were
less motivated by their family as compared to district Kangra. It was observed that
women got motivation from the family and relatives. There were some other factors i.e.
interest and political parties. These factors influence women to take part in politics.
261
They secure peoples participation in public affairs, ensure orderly transfer of power and
the authority of government with legitimacy. It provides
provide an opportunity to the people to
express their faith in the government from time to time and change it.
it When
W needed
much more significant, they highlight and dramatize a political system and open up
channels between the polity and the society, between the elite
elite and the masses and
between the individual and government. The Indian Constitution makers have given a
great importance to the electoral process. Therefore, many provisions have been made
in the constitution for a free and fair electoral process.112 The election system is a
political device through which,
which the modern state creates among its citizens a sense of
involvement and participation in public affairs.113 Table shows the categories of the
seats on which the respondents contested the election.
Table 4.21
Respondents View Regarding Elections Contested on the Seats
No. of Respondents
Grand Total
Sr.No Response Mandi Kangra
No. %Age No. %Age No. %Age
1 Reserved for Women 71 48.96 55 37.67 126 43.29
2 Reserved for SCs Women 67 46.21 39 26.71 106 36.43
3 Reserved for STs Women 2 1.38 11 7.54 13 4.47
4 Reserved for OBCs Women 5 3.45 41 28.08 46 15.81
Total 145 100 146 100 291 100
48.96
46.21
37.67
50
45
28.08
40
26.71
Percentage (%)
35
30
25
20 Mandi
7.54
15
3.45
Kangra
1.38
10
5
0
Reserved for Reserved for Reserved for Reserved for
Women SCs Women STs Women OBCs Women
Response
112
Tara, “Electoral Process in India”,
India Vidhanmala, Year 7, No.1, June 2014, p. 45.
113
Kalpana Roy, op.cit., 1999, p. 87.
262
It is clear from the above table 4.21 that out of 291 respondents, 126
respondents contested the election from the reserved seat for women, which constitute
43.29 per cent of the sample, while 106 respondents contested from the reserved for
SCs women, which constitute 36.43 per cent of the sample. There were 13 respondents
who contested elections from the reserved category for STs, which constitute 4.47 per
cent of the sample and 46 respondents contested election for OBCs women, which
constitute 15.81 per cent of the sample.
The comparative analysis of the two district reveals the categories of the seats
on, which the respondents contested the elections. Majority of the respondents in whole
sample 43.29 per cent, in Mandi district 48.46 per cent and in Kangra district 37.67 per
cent contested the elections from the reserved seats for women. This percentage further
increased in the respondents, who contested the elections from the seats reserved for
SCs women. It was observed that women generally get an opportunity to contest the
elections only on those seats, which are reserved for women.
The public rallies, protest, strikes and bandh calls are the important modes of
political participation. Participation in processions, rallies, demonstrations and
contacting party leaders and members of the bureaucracy are quite important activities
263
in the sense thatt these not only introduce a person into politics but also enable him to
influence decision-making.
making. Strikes, dharnas, riots, political assassinations, non-voting,
non
gheraos and other anomic activities,
activities which though old have been inducted into the
political process.114 Political participation through strikes/protests/ bandh call are such
activities, which include demonstration, riots and other form of civil violence through
which citizens try to pressurize or intimate the government.115 Table shows that,
that
responses of the respondents regarding their participating in public rallies.
Table 4.22
Participation in Strikes/Protest/Bandh Calls
No. of Respondents
Grand Total
Sr.No Response Mandi Kangra
No. % age No. % age No. % age
1 Yes 87 60.00 93 63.69 180 61.86
2 No 41 28.28 39 26.72 80 27.49
3 No Opinion 17 11.72 14 9.59 31 10.65
Total 145 100 146 100 291 100
70 63.69
60 Mandi
60 Kangra
50
Percentage (%)
40
28.28 26.72
30
20 11.72
9.59
10
0
Yes No No Opinion
Response
114
S. Bhatnagar, Political Theory,, New Delhi: Meenakashi Prakashan, 1984, p. 280.
115
Ali Ashraf and L. N. Sharma, Political Sociology,
Sociology Madras: Universities Press, 1983, p. 144.
264
It is evident from the table 4.22 that out of 291 respondents, 180 respondents
participated in strikes/protests/bandh calls, which constitutes 61.86 per cent. However
80 respondents were not participated in strikes/protests/bandh calls. The percentage of
such respondents was 27.49. There were 31 respondents, did not give their opinion
about participation in strikes/protests/bandh calls, which constitutes 10.65 per cent of
the sample.
The comparative analysis of the two districts reveals that majority of the
respondents participated in strike/protest/bandh calls. It was observed that these are the
important modes of political participation in political process.
Media is considered as the fourth pillar of the society and democratic medium
of information. Media has the power to pressurize and criticize the drawbacks of
democracy. The electronic media particularly television, has become the most
influential medium of mass communication in India. It is high time now that women
should get a respectable and dignified position in the Indian society. Awareness in the
women as well as society should be created and their equal rights should be effectively
implemented. In the era of globalization and with revolution in means of
communication and information technology, the media role has become more crucial
for women empowerment in India.116
116
Purnima Ojha, “Women’s Issues in India: Role and Importance of Media”, The Indian Journal of
Political Science, Vol. 72, No. 1, January-March 2011, pp. 98-101.
265
The mass media-often referred to as just, the media-are usually understood with
reference to the printed press and to radio and television broadcasters. In recent years,
the definition has perhaps become broader, encompassing internet, mobile phones,
social media, such as blogs and micro-blogs, social networking websites like facebook,
video-sharing sites, such as You Tube and others. There is no doubt that the media play
a very significant role in the life of all human societies. It provides the conduit
necessary for all kinds of communication that helps societies to exist and function.
media play the very essential role of ensuring that information vital to the existence,
and balanced manner. The media can also play a more specific part in enabling full
government. Media also provides information about the constituencies and various
human development index parameters, offering chances for people to comment on the
work done by their elected representatives and providing feedbacks to the candidate.
Emerging as a potentially powerful force, electronic media has also been playing a
similar role to that of print media in conducting free and fair elections.117 It is of course
a well known fact that better informed persons would be more aware and will
participate more in politics than the less formed ones. Information enhances the
knowledge about politics, political objects and working of the political system. While
political parties are a good source of political information, people can get information’s
through a variety of media sources. Citizens learn about politics and the government
from the news, they watch on television, read newspapers and from on social media.
117
Gurpreet Randhawa, “Role of the Media in Indian Electoral Process”, Vidhanmala, Year 7, No. 1,
June 2014, pp. 70-71.
118
Rahul Verma and Shreyas Sardeshari, “Does Media Exposure Affect Voting Behaviours
and Political Preference in India”, Economic and Politically Weekly, Vol. 49, No. 39, September
2014, p. 83.
266
Table 4.23
Source of Political Information of the Respondents
No. of Respondents
Grand Total
Sr.No Response Mandi Kangra
No. % age No. % age No. % age
1 Members of the Family 38 26.21 25 17.13 63 21.65
2 News Papers 11 7.59 13 8.91 24 8.25
3 Radio 19 13.10 20 13.69 39 13.40
4 Television 58 40.00 65 44.52 123 42.27
5 Others 19 13.10 23 15.75 42 14.43
Total 145 100 146 100 291 100
44.52
Mandi
50
40
Kangra
40
26.21
Percentage (%)
30
17.13
13.69
13.1
20
8.91
7.59
10
0
Members of the News Papers Radio Television
Family
Response
267
respondents got political information from other sources, which constitute 14.43 per
cent of the sample.
The comparative analysis of the both district reveals that the main sources of
political information were television, newspaper, radio and social media. In district
Kangra 44.52 per cent and in districts Mandi 40.00 per cent respondents seek
information from television followed by family members, reading newspaper, radio and
other sources. It was observed that in both districts majority of the respondents seek
information from television. These sources gave political information to the women
and made them aware about their rights and got information about the state, national
and international levels. It can have a huge influence on election outcomes.
Party Affiliation
A party in the most general sense of the word is a body of persons, who are
united in opinion or action, as distinguished from or opposed to the rest of a community
268
or association.119 Political parties are groups organized for the purpose of achieving and
exercising power within a political system. The roles of political parties are inevitable
in a parliamentary system. Parties are playing a key role in democracy in the world.
The 20th century saw the spread of political parties throughout the entire world. Modern
political parties are institutions that can function in widely divergent political
situations. 120 Maciver defined political party as “an association organised in support of
some principle or the policy, which by constitutional means endeavours to make the
determinant of the government”. This definition focussed attention on the associated
and the organised aspects of a political party, while bringing about the rational for its
existence in terms of some guiding principle or policy and linking the same to political
power as exercised by the government. Political parties are the closely connected with
government, and thus, in decision-making position. The parties furnish the government
with personnel. In order to socialise the masses effective, every political party must
have competent leadership. Party workers or cadres must establish contacts with the
people on a regular basis so as to aggregate and articulate their interests, educate them
politically, and thereby, secure their support for the party. The party officers and
workers aim at imbibing the ordinary members with the party spirit, imparting party
ideologies and motivating them to be active in implementation of party programmes.121
119
Edwin R.A. Seligman, “Parties, Political”, Encyclopedia of Social Science, New York: The
Macmillan Publishing Company, Vol. 11-12, 1959, p. 590.
120
New Encyclopedia Britannica, Inc. William Benton, New York: William Benton Publishers, Vol. 14,
New York, 1943, p. 677.
121
Niroj Sinha, Women in Indian Politics, New Delhi: Gyan Publishing House, 2006, p.142.
122
A.K. Majumdar and Bhanwar Singh, Panchayat Politics and Community Development, New Delhi:
Radha Publications, 1996, pp.118-134.
269
changes. Further, the working of the party system as well as the role of political leaders
significantly, influences the process of modernization so as crucial to developing
society like India. The development of Indian party system can be traced to the freedom
movement days, which resulted in the wide-ranging political recruitment, vast political
socialisation and mobilisation of the masses.123
123
Pratap Chandra Swain, “Dynamics of the Indian Party System”, The Indian Journal of Political
Science, Vol. 69, No. 1, January-March 2008, pp. 59- 60.
124
P.V. Krishna, “Participation and Awareness of Elected Women Representatives in PRIs”, Voice of
Research, Vol. 2, No.4, March 2014, p. 46.
125
Rajshree Dutta, “Measuring Party System Change in India: An Analysis at the National and at the
Level of States, 1952-2009”, The Indian Journal of Political Science, Vol.72, No.3, July-
September 2011, p. 661.
126
Kalpna Roy, op.cit., 1999, p. 150.
127
Pooja Singh, “Representation of Women in Indian Politics”, Third Concept, Vol. 28, No. 327, May
2014, pp. 48-50.
270
example, Indian National Congress, Bhartiya Janta Party, Samajwadi Party, Communist
Party, Communist Party of India (Marxist) and some other parties.128 Table deals with
party affiliation to leadership
leader at the politics.
Table 4.24
Parties Affiliation of the Respondents
60 Mandi
Kangra
50
37.67
33.79
Percentage (%)
40
30
20
7.58
6.16
3.42
10
2.07
1.38
0.69
0
Indian Bhartiya Janta CPI BSP Others
National Party
Congress Party Affiliation
128
Ramesh Kumar, “Political Parties in India and the United Sates: A Comparative Analysis”,
Analysis” The
Indian Journal of Political Science, Vol. 72, No. 2, April-June 2011, pp. 555-556.
556.
271
Table 4.24 shows that all 145 respondents were interviewed from Mandi district
and 146 respondents were interviewed in district Kangra. Out of 291 respondents, 156
respondents were affiliated with the Indian National Congress Party, which constitutes
53.61 per cent of the sample, whereas 104 respondents were affiliated with the BJP,
which constitute 35.74 per cent of the sample. There were hardly a few 3 respondents,
who were affiliated with CPI. The percentages of such respondents were 1.03 per cent
of the sample, while 8 respondents were affiliated with the BSP, which constitute 2.75
per cent of the sample. There were 20 respondents who were not active in any political
party, which constitute 6.87 per cent of the sample.
The comparative analysis of the both districts reveals that political party plays
an important role in determining women’s participation in politics. It is evident from
the table 4.24 that on an average percentage of the respondents got membership of
political parties. Majority of the respondents in both district were the members of the
Congress Party. It was observed that some respondents tried to hide their political
affiliation.
272
Type of Party Membership
129
Ibid.,
130
Gabriel A. Almond and G. Bingham Powell, Comparative Politics: A Developmental Approach,
New Dehli: Amerind Publishers, 1975, pp. 98-100.
131
Bhawana Jharta, Women and Politics in India: Impact of Family and Education on Women Political
Activists, New Delhi: Deep and Deep Publications, 1998, p. 101.
132
Lester W. Milbrath, Political Participation: How and Why do People Get Involved in Politics?, 1st
edition, Chicago: Rand McNally, 1965, p. 25.
133
Lester W. Milbrath and M.L. Goel, Political Participation How and Why do People Get Involved in
Politics, 2nd edition, Chicago: Rand McNally Publication, 1977, p. 33.
273
Table 4.25
Respondents Opinion about Type of Party Membership
No. of Respondents
Grand Total
Sr.No Response Mandi Kangra
No. % age No. % age No. % age
1 Active 80 55.17 84 57.53 164 56.36
2 Inactive 58 40.00 57 39.04 115 39.52
3 No Opinion 7 4.83 5 3.43 12 4.12
Total 145 100 146 100 291 100
57.53 Mandi
60 55.17
Kangra
50
40 39.04
Percentage (%)
40
30
20
10 4.83 3.43
0
Active Inactive No Opinion
Response
Table 4.25 shows that out of 291 respondents, 164 respondents were the active
member of political parties, which constitute 56.36 per cent of the total sample.
Whereas, 115 respondents who were inactive member of political parties,
parties which
constitute 39.52 per cent of the sample, while 12 respondents who did not give their
opinion about the membership of political
politic parties, which constitute 4.12 per cent of the
sample.
274
Whereas, 58 respondents who were inactive member of political parties, which
constitute 40.00 per cent of the sample, while 7 respondents who did not give their
opinion about the membership of political parties, which constitute 4.83 per cent of the
sample.
The comparative analysis of the both district reveals that in Kangra 57.53 per
cent of the respondents were active members of political parties as compare to Mandi
district (55.17%). It is found that in both districts women had active membership and
were office bearers of different political parties. Almost all political parties set up a
women’s cell or wing but they worked as ancillary bodies. Very few women were able
to capture seats of power. The number of women in the legislatures remained very
small. Very few women reached the position of party president or leader of legislative
party. More recently, major political parties have indeed made conscious efforts to
induct more women into the various levels of the party organisation.
Table 4.26
Views Regarding Financial Contribution to a Party/Candidate
No. of Respondents
Grand Total
Sr.No Response Mandi Kangra
275
64.83 Mandi
70
Kangra
58.91
60
50
Percentage (%)
38.35
40 33.79
30
20
10 2.74
1.38
0
Yes No No Opinion
Response
Fig.4.26: Views Regarding Financial Contribution to a Party/Candidate
It is evident of the table 4.26 that out of 291 respondents, 105 respondents who
contributed financially
ancially to a party/candidates,
party/ which constitute 36.08 per cent of the
total sample. Whereas 180 respondents did not contribute financially to any party or
candidate, which constitute 61.86 per cent of the sample. There were 6 respondents
who did not express any opinion about the financial contribution to a party
part or
candidate, which constitute 2.06 per cent of the sample.
The comparative
ve analysis of the two district reveals financial contributions
contribution to a
party or candidate. In district
strict Kangra (38.35%)
(38.35%) respondents who contributed
contribute financially
276
to a party or candidate as compared to Mandi district (33.79%). Majority of the
respondents did not contribute financially to any party/candidate. It was observed that
the majority of the respondents in the sample were not financially self-sufficient.
Voluntary Organizations are not merely the provider of social services to the
needy persons but are actively involved in accelerating the process of development. At
many places, they are an important link between the people and the administration. All
voluntary organisations are positive genuine, authentic and committed to development.
Voluntary organisations are charitable, service delivery, welfare oriented, relief and
rehabilitation type of voluntary organisation, which primarily work at the grass-roots
level to alleviate sufferings of the poor and the marginalised, to respond to failure in
government service by filling gaps in social services delivery and in the welfare of the
weaker sections.134
Table 4.27
Respondents Views Regarding Membership of Voluntary Organisations
No. of Respondents
Grand Total
Sr.No Response Mandi Kangra
No. % age No. % age No. % age
1 Yes 118 81.38 110 75.34 228 78.35
2 No 25 17.24 28 19.18 53 18.21
3 No Opinion 2 1.38 8 5.48 10 3.44
Total 145 100 146 100 291 100
134
R. Srinivsan, “Emerging Trends in NGO Sector: A Study of Tamil Nadu”, The Indian Journal of
Political Science, Vol. 66, No.2, April-June 2005, pp. 273-274.
135
Ibid., p. 276.
277
Mandi
90 81.38
Kangra
75.34
80
70
Percentage (%)
60
50
40
30
17.24 19.18
20
5.48
10 1.38
0
Yes No No Opinion
Response
Table 4.27 shows that out of 291 respondents, 228 respondents were members
of one or the other voluntary organisations,
organisation which constitute 78.35 per cent of the total
sample. Whereas, 53 respondents were not the members of voluntary organisations,
organisations
which constitute 18.21 per cent of the sample. There were 10 respondents who did not
give their opinion about the member of the voluntary organisations,
organisations which constitute
3.44 per cent of the sample.
The district Mandi was concerned, out of 145 respondents, 118 respondents
were members of one or the other voluntary
volunt organisations, which constitute 81.38 per
cent of the total sample. Whereas,
Whereas 25 respondents were not the members of voluntary
organisations, which constitute 17.24 per cent of the sample. There were 2 respondents
who did not give their opinion about the member of the voluntary organisations,
organisations which
constitute 1.38 per cent of the sample.
278
The comparative analysis of the two district reveals that majority of the
respondents were the members of one or other organisations. In district Mandi
percentage was higher with (81.38%) percent of the respondents who have the some
knowledge of the different economic and social organisations or associations working
for the welfare and uplift of women as compared to district Kangra (75.34%). It was
found that these organisation uplift women in all fields. There was a great influence of
family upon membership in voluntary organisations. Voluntary organisations attracted
rich people more than the poor. They solve their problems as well as, to serve the
weaker sections of the society.
136
S.P. Varma and Iqbal Narain, Voting Behaviour in Changing Society, Delhi: National Publishing
House, 1973, p. 276.
137
Praveen Rai, op.cit, 2011, p. 51.
279
Table 4.28
Respondents Views on Attending Party/Organisational Meetings
No. of Respondents
Grand Total
Sr.No Response Mandi Kangra
No. % age No. % age No. % age
1 Yes 103 71.03 100 68.49 203 69.75
2 No 28 19.31 37 25.34 65 22.34
3 No Opinion 14 9.66 9 6.17 23 7.91
Total 145 100 146 100 291 100
Mandi
80 71.03
68.49 Kangra
70
60
Percentage (%)
50
40
30 25.34
19.31
20
9.66
6.17
10
0
Yes No No Opinion
Response
It is evident from the table 4.28 that out of 291 respondents, 203 respondents
attended party and organizational meeting regularly,
regularly which constitute 69.75
75 per cent of
the total sample. Whereas 65 respondents did not attend the meeting regularly,
regularly which
constitute 22.34 per cent of the sample. There were 23 respondents who had no opinion
about attending the meetings, which constitute 7.91
91 per cent of the sample.
280
Similarly in district Kangra, out of 146 respondents, 100 respondents attended
party and organizational meeting regularly, which constitute 68.49 per cent of the total
sample. Whereas 37 respondents did not attend the meeting regularly, which constitute
25.34 per cent of the sample. There were 9 respondents who had no opinion about
attending the meetings, which constitute 6.17 per cent of the sample.
The comparative analysis of the two district depicts that majority of respondents
attended the party/organizational meeting regularly. In district Mandi the number of
respondents (71.03%) attending party and organizational meeting, was higher as
compared to Kangra district 68.49%). It was found that majority of the respondents had
accepted that they raised their voice on various issues in the meetings.
138
M. P. Dubbey and Munni Padalia (eds.), Democratic Decentralisation and Panchayati Raj in India,
New Delhi: Anamika Publishers, 2002, p. 96.
281
the appointment of G.V.K. Rao Committee (1985), L. M. Singhvi Committee (1986),
Chief Secretaries Conference (1988), Thungon Committee (1988) and the introduction
of constitution (Sixty-fourth) Amendment Bill, 1989. Therefore P. V. Narsimha Rao,
who became Prime Minister in 1991, was able to get the 73rd Amendment enacted in
1992 by building a consensus in its favour. The 73rd Amendment not only gave a
constitutional status to the Panchayati Raj Institutions but also provided for its uniform
structure in all the states. This amendment also made provisions for the increase in the
powers and resources of these institutions. 139 With a view to bring law relating to the
Panchayats in conformity with provisions of the 73rd Constitutional Amendment Act,
the Himachal Pradesh Panchayati Raj Act, 1968 has replaced and the Himachal Pradesh
Panchayati Raj Act, 1994 was enacted with effect from April 23, 1994.140
Any institution’s innovation, which does not reach the common man and fails to
ameliorate the conditions of the people, does not serve anything, but results in futile
experiment. The Panchayati Raj system, looked at from a historical perspective, has
had its ups and downs. Various forces have worked against the system, despite its
inbuilt strength and advantages to suit the nation. For the successful working of the
Panchayati Raj system, people’s participation is considered very important and an
effort is always made to educate the masses for their full participation and active
involvement. So, people’s perception of Panchayati Raj is an important yardstick.
Absence of awareness of the system in general and the institutions as well as their
functions in particular would result in slow progress or no progress.141 The 73rd Act is
landmark legislation, which has brought empowerment of the Panchayati Raj
Institutions and has ensured the transfer of power from the state to the Panchayati Raj
Institutions to be exercised by the people.142 Thus empowering women is one of the
major issues of Indian polity and Himachal Pradesh government today. Women can be
empowered through the knowledge and the working of Gram Sabha under the
Himachal Pradesh Panchayati Raj Act, 1994. The awareness of the new Panchayati Raj
Act is given in the table as follows:
139
Ibid., pp. 96-97.
140
Simi Agnihotri and Vijay Singh, “Women Empowerment through Reservation in Panchayati Raj
Institutions in Himachal Pradesh”, Indian Journal of Public Administration, Vol. 60, No.3, July-
September 2014, p. 418.
141
K.C Vidya, op.cit., 2007, pp.138-139.
142
Mathew C. Kunnumkal, “Grassroots Level Democracy in Indian an Assessment”, Yojana, Vol. 55,
February 2011, p. 6.
282
Table 4.29
Respondents Awareness with Regard to the Panchayati Raj Act
No. of Respondents
Grand Total
Sr.No Response Mandi Kangra
No. % age No. % age No. % age
1 Yes 57 39.31 60 41.09 117 40.21
2 No 61 42.07 64 43.84 125 42.95
3 No Opinion 27 18.62 22 15.07 49 16.84
Total 145 100 146 100 291 100
43.84
42.07
41.09
39.31
45
40
35
30
18.62
Percentage (%)
25
15.07
Mandi
20
15 Kangra
10
5
0
Yes No No Opinion
Response
Fig.4.29: Respondents
Respondents Awareness with Regard to the Panchayati Raj Act
It is evident from the table 4.29 that out 291 respondents, 117 respondents were
fully aware of the Himachal Pradesh Panchayati
Panchayat Raj Act, which constitute 40.21 of the
total sample. Whereas 125 respondents were not aware about this act,
act which constitute
42.95 per cent
ent of the sample.
sam There were 49 respondents held no opinion on either side.
The percentage
age of such respondents was 16.84 of the total sample.
283
As far as in district Kangra was concerned, out of 146 respondents, 60
respondents were fully aware of the Himachal Pradesh Panchayati Raj Act, which
constitute 41.09 of the total sample. Whereas, 64 respondents were not aware about this
act, which constitute 43.84 per cent of the sample. There were 22 respondents having
no opinion, which constitute 15.07 per cent of the sample.
The comparative analysis of the two districts reveals that in district Kangra the
elected women representatives were more aware about Panchayati Raj System in
comparison to district Mandi. It was clear from the table, women to a certain extent
were aware of the functioning of Panchayati Raj Act. But most of the women were
unaware of the functioning of Panchayati Raj System.
India is perhaps the first country to recognise the social fact underlined by
Lenin on the International Working Women’s Day in 1921. There has been taken
concrete measures to draw women into leadership positions and thereby into politics by
giving them one third reservation, in what may now be called the third tier of
governance the Panchayati Raj. The constitutional amendment providing one-third
representation to women in elected bodies as well as reserving one third of the offices
of chairpersons for them will have far-reaching consequences in Indian political and
social life.143 The 73rd Amendment to the Indian Constitution aimed at the
empowerment of women by making provision for the reservation of one-third share for
women in the Panchayati Raj Institutions.144
The 73rd Amendment has created silent revolution in the country. It has created
appropriate social, economic and political conditions that enabled women participation
in the local government institutions. Additionally, this is also of great significance as
women have a definite voice in the process of governance.145 Women reservation
(33%) has been provided by the Amendment in Panchayati Raj Act 1994, and
Himachal Pradesh Panchayati Raj Amendment Act, 2008 has provided 50 per cent
reservation of seats for women in PRIs and urban local bodies, which is a historical
step for the political empowerment of women. The experiment of 50 per cent
143
Ajit Pal Singh, “Women’s Participation at the Grassroot Level: An Analysis”, Mainstream,
Vol. 47, No.12, March 2009, p. 25.
144
S. S. Chahar (ed.), op.cit., 2005, p.76.
145
Kamini B. Dashora, “Women Empowerment and Panchayati Raj”, Third Concept, Vol. 22, No. 262,
December 2008, pp. 56-57.
284
reservation of seats for women in PRIs and urban local bodies has been successful in
the state. Before 1995, women’s representation
representatio in local self-governments
governments was up to,
to
two women in all bodies. After 1995, it has increased to minimum 33 per cent and now
50 per cent, since 2010 elections to the PRIs and urban local bodies.146 This is for the
first time in our history that an opportunity
opportunity has been provided for such substantial entry
of women in public life and large numbers have come forward to tackle the challenge
of leadership at all levels of Panchayats. In fact, right from the days of freedom struggle
the Indian women have been consistently
consis encouraged of to take part in the active
politics. 147
Table 4.30
Respondents Opinion with Regard to Women Participation in the PRIs
No. of Respondents
Grand Total
Sr.No Response Mandi Kangra
No. % age No. % age No. % age
1 Yes 112 77.24 107 73.28 219 75.25
2 No 30 20.69 28 19.18 58 19.94
3 No Opinion 3 2.07 11 7.54 14 4.81
Total 145 100 146 100 291 100
77.24 Mandi
80 73.28 Kangra
70
60
Percentage (%)
50
40
30 20.69 19.18
20
7.54
10 2.07
0
Yes No No Opinion
Response
146
Sarbjeet Singh and Pankaj Dodh (eds.), Gender Justice and Women Empowerment:
Empowerment An Integrated
Approach,, New Delhi: Regal Publications, 2013, pp. 322-323.
322
147
M.R. Biju, Panchayati Raj System in India, New Delhi: Kanishka Publishers, 2008, p.161.
285
It is evident from the table 4.30 that out of 291 respondents, 219 respondents
were satisfied with their participation in the PRIs, which constitute 75.25 of the total
sample. Whereas 58 respondents were not satisfied with the participation of women in
the PRIs, which constitute 19.94 per cent. There were 14 respondents who expressed no
opinion on either side. The percentage of such respondents was 4.81 of the total
sample.
The comparative analysis of the two districts reveals that majority of the elected
women representatives were satisfied with their participation in PRIs. The 73rd
constitutional amendment act facilitated women participation and involvement in the
PRIs.
286
than one third with the words not less than half.148 Political reservation for women in
legislative bodies has become one of the most contentious issues of political discourse
in contemporary India. This provision has opened up various avenues for women to
exercise their leadership role at the local level. Based on this provision various
women’s organizations have been fighting for 50 per cent reservation for women in the
legislative assemblies and the parliament. The Himachal Pradesh government by
introducing 50 per cent reservations has gone further and has foreground the issue of
women’s empowerment.149 In Bihar, Uttarakhand, Madhya Pradesh and Chhattisgarh,
the state governments have already reserved 50 per cent of Panchayat seats for women.
In Bihar the reservation was enhanced to one-half of the seats in 2006, in the elections
that followed 55 per cent of the elected panchayats members were women.150 This has
been the most effective formal step towards political empowerment of women.151
Empowerment is a multi-dimensional social process that helps people to gain control
over their own lives. It is a process that fosters power in people for use in their own
lives, their own communities and in their own society, by acting on issues that they
describe as important. Above all, empowerment is a result of participation in decision-
making. Therefore, women’s empowerment refers to the process by which women
acquire due recognition on par with men to participate in the development process of
the society through the political institutions as a partner with human dignity.152
Table 4.31
Respondents Opinion with Regard to Reservation for Women in PRIs
No. of Respondents
Grand Total
Sr.No Response Mandi Kangra
No. % age No. % age No. % age
1 Yes 131 90.35 135 92.46 266 91.41
2 No 10 6.89 6 4.11 16 5.50
3 No Opinion 4 2.76 5 3.43 9 3.09
Total 145 100 146 100 291 100
148
Atonu Chatterjee, “Women in Panchayats: A Review”, Yojana, Vol. 55, February 2011, p. 25.
149
Ajit Kumar Sinha, New Dimensions of Women Empowerment, New Delhi: Deep and Deep
Publications, 2008, p. 437.
150
Beyond Mere Gestures, “Enhancing Women’s Reservation in Panchayats is Good but it is not
Enough”, Economic and Political Weekly, Vol. 44, No. 40, October 2009, p. 5.
151
Nupur Tiwari, “Women and Panchayati Raj”, Yojana, Vol. 56, June 2012, pp. 36-40.
152
C.V. Ramamohan, et al., Empowerment of Women Through Leadership and Entrepreneurship,
Mumbai: Himalaya Publishing House, 2012, p. 108.
287
92.46
90.35
100
90
80
70
Percentage
60
50 Mandi
40
Kangra
30
6.89
20
4.11
3.43
2.76
10
0
Yes No No Opinion
Response
In district Mandi out of 145 respondents, 131 respondents were satisfied with
the 50 per cent reservation of seats for women in Panchayati Raj Institutions,
Institutions which
constitute 90.35
35 per cent of the total sample.
s Whereas 10 respondents were not satisfied
with 50 per cent reservation for women in Panchayati Raj Institutions,
Institutions which constitute
6.89 per cent of the sample. There were 4 respondents who did not express their
opinion, which constitute 2.76 per cent of the total sample.
288
The comparative analysis of the two district reveals that majority of women
were satisfied with the reservation of seats for women. The 73rd Act has introduced
some innovative, progressive and bold provisions in matters of enhanced statutory
representation to women, SCs and STs. It was observed that reservation has inspired
and prompted them to contest elections.
During study it was also found that the share of general category of the
respondents in district Mandi was higher (44.83%) in comparison to district Kangra
(31.51%). Therefore Scheduled Caste share is concerned district Mandi has higher
(49.66%) to district Kangra (25.34%). As far as the OBCs share was concerned district
Kangra had higher share in comparison to district Mandi. The Scheduled Tribes have
very nominal existence in both districts. It appears that the share of STs was still very
low. It may be due to less population of their groups.
It is also found that the participation of women was literate. The percentage of
illiterate women was negligible. Similarly, the women participation mainly belongs to
middle class. Very few women were from high middle class, whose annual income was
above One Lakh annum. Since, most of the respondents were from agricultural
background.
During study, it was also found that the holdings of the respondents were not
very big. Most of the respondents were having land between to 10 bighas to 20 bighas.
In Himachal Pradesh the size of holdings is small. The study also found that majority of
the people is in agricultural profession and in petty business. Very few people are in
289
horticultural profession and apart from agriculture, horticulture business and some
other professions.
In the study it was also found that in Himachal Pradesh two political parties that
is Congress and Bhartiya Janta Party are dominating the political scene of the state. The
share of other political parties is very negligible. The majority of the respondents were
either with the congress ideology or with the BJP ideology.
As far as the awareness of the respondents was concerned during the study, it
was found that majority of the women used to read newspaper daily and were aware of
day-to-day happening. Similarly, majority of the respondents used to hear news in the
radio and television which means majority of the respondents was well informed with
the happening in society and state as well as world.
It was found that these organisation uplift women in all fields. There was a great
influence of family upon membership in voluntary organisations. Voluntary
organisations attracted rich people more than the poor. They solve their problems as
well as to serve the weaker sections of the society. It was observed that women to a
certain extent were aware of the functioning of Panchayati Raj Act. But most of the
women were unaware of the functioning of Panchayati Raj System.
The study found that majority of women was satisfied with the reservation of
seats for women. The 73rd Act has introduced some innovative, progressive and bold
provisions in matters of enhanced statutory representation to women, SCs and STs. It
was observed that reservation has inspired and prompted them to contest elections.
290
CHAPTER-V
Women constitute almost half of the Indian nation and yet their representation
and participation in decision-making bodies has been, to say the least, abysmal. It was
envisioned that competitive politics and the universal adult franchise would gradually
provide the Indian womanhood an opportunity to assert their entitlements in the
emerging political system. However, more than years of competitive politics have
failed to give more than token representation to women in the highest political
decision-making bodies.1 Men and women form the wheel of the chariot on which the
human species runs. They form the very essence of our existence. If there is problem
with even one of the counterparts, the whole balance gets disturbed. So, one can very
well imagine the plight of that culture or society in which, one-half of the human
species-the womenfolk are facing diverse problems. This is especially so in the
patriarchal societies, as found in India, where women, comprising almost half of the
population, are facing multi-faceted problems.2
1
Prem R. Bhardwaj (ed.), Gender Discrimination: Politics of Women Empowerment, New Delhi:
Anamika Publishers, 2005, p. 227.
2
Ibid.,
291
The vast amount of expenditure on elections also prevents women from taking
part in politics. Thus only women with a strong financial background are able to take
an active part in politics.3 The constitution of India grants universal suffrage to both
men and women with equal rights to participate in electoral competition, but the
existing societal value system, the private-public divide in terms of domain
identification and male preponderance in political institutions restrict women from
exercising their electoral rights and a fair participation in electoral competition. These
factors also act as key barriers and obstacles in women’s active participation in the
Indian electoral system and in the larger issue of women’s advancement as a whole.
The lack of critical and quality representation of women in key decision-making
positions results in women agenda not getting reflected and addressed in public policies
and programmes. The public agenda of Indian men and women elected as people’s
representatives are quite different and their priority of public works undertaken is also
not similar. While elected women representatives addressed issues of long term
benefits such as education, health, violence against women and basic amenities that
affect community, men concentrated on issues that needed immediate attention such as
roads, community and commercial centres, tanks, bridges etc.4
To this extent, women in India seem to have failed in breaking the glass ceiling
and have been relegated to the brings in power sharing at the top level. Which in turn,
has an adverse impact on their overall political status in the country and has acted as
barriers and obstacles in higher electoral participation. The low proportion of women in
3
M.P. Dube and Neeta Bora (eds.), Social Justice and Women in India, Delhi: Swaraj Prakashan, 1999,
p.142.
4
Praveen Rai, “Women’s Participation in Electoral Politics in India: Silent Feminisation”, South Asia
Research, Vol. 37, No.1, 2017, p.73.
292
the inner political party structure of Indian further erodes women’s efforts to lobby and
garner resources and support for nurturing and building their political constituencies as
well as mobilizing financial and human resources required to meet the demands and
aspirations of their constituencies. This inevitably results in women being perceived as
weak representatives-generally unaccepted as political leaders by people in their
constituency. At times, their insignificant numbers may put them in vulnerable position
resulting in seeking alliances along caste, religion and regional identities rather than
along common gendered interests. Thus, Indian women in public life as people
representatives often become co-opted in the men-centric structure of development
agendas. At the grass-root levels of Panchayati Raj Institutions, there have been strong
roadblocks and obstacles to women’s entry into politics and a backlash of violence to
keep them away from electoral politics.5
The absence of affirmative action for 33 per cent reservation of seats for Indian
women at state legislature and parliament is having a negative impact on women’s
share in the institutions of representations. However, treating women as a blanket
category for the benefits of reservation would further complicate the issues of women’s
representation and participation in India’s electoral competition. For such benefits
would largely be appropriated by those women, who belong to the upper stratum of
society or to those already having political background. Hence, women from the lower
economic strata, backward castes and marginalized groups would get further excluded
from contesting elections and sharing political power. Thus, the disadvantage sections
among the women in India, who are already denied their political rights to participate in
elections as candidates arising out of their situational deficiencies and lack of political
connections would be further relegated.6
293
confronting them, but also bring gender issues to the forefront leading to women’s
empowerment and advancement in the society in long run. 7
Money and muscle power are used to threaten opponents and the voters; and
impose their decisions on the electorate and to raise the kinds of funds required to get
into and stay in power. Violating women’s dignity is an integral part of politics,
instilling fear in women, thereby restraining their entry into politics. In addition,
corruption is also institutionalized systematically. Criminalization and corruption are
not part of women’s value systems and therefore, they are kept away from politics in
general. Inadequate organizational support directly affects the political participation of
women. Elections in the country are fought on party lines. The poor representation of
women in political parties does not give them the strength to negotiate gender issues
and concerns that need to form a part of the party agenda. Fewer women in political
parties impedes women from seeking positions in decision-making arenas, which are
crucial in changing the profile of political parties and also effect the number of women
fielded for elections and being elected.8 Women traditionally burdened with domestic
work face difficulties in balancing the official work with their home.
Sometimes due to lack of security women members fail to visit remote areas in
odd hours or attend meetings in faraway places. Gradual, criminalization of politics is
also arresting their participation. Lack of information and knowledge about government
programmes, especially for women and child development poses problems. Again,
limited exposure to formal education breeds information gap and dependency on
second hand knowledge. Consequently, political lineage determines the distribution of
benefits of different schemes. Communication problem hinders performance as most of
the correspondences, rules and regulations are in English. Due to lack of exposure and
experience, women members face difficulty in asserting themselves. The fact, that
majority of women enters politics through reservation and kinship arrangement, only
accentuates this problem.9
7
Praveen Rai, op.cit., 2011, p. 54.
8
Rakesh K. Singh, “Elected Women Representatives in Panchayat Raj”, Social Action, Vol. 62,
January-March 2012, p. 58.
9
Atonu Chatterjee, “Women in Panchayats: A Review”, Yojana, Vol. 55, February 2011, pp. 25-26.
294
volumes about the gender bias that is practiced in the society.10 In order to view, the
problems of women in the national perspective and to develop an integral approach to
their development and progress, a national perspective plan for women was published
in 1988-2000. The plan emphasized gender equality as pre-requisite for effective
participation of women in strengthening the institutional structure of democracy.
Women have been marginalized because of several socio-economic constraints. The
plan acknowledged the fact that the number of women in leadership position at the
local, village, district and national levels is still not commensurate with their numbers
in society. 11
10
G. Palanithurai, et al. (ed), Major Issues in New Panchayati Raj System, New Delhi: Kanishka
Publishers, 1997, p. 56.
11
Yogendra Narain, et al., “Empowerment of Women”, Mainstream, Vol. 43, No.1-5, December 2004,
p. 71.
12
S. Mehartaj Begum, “Women Rights and Rural Employments”, Kurukshetra, Vol. 48, No. 7,
April
2000, pp. 60-64.
13
C. Jayanthi, “Empowering Women”, Yojana, Vol. 45, June 2001, p. 32.
295
of well-developed education and training systems for women’s leadership in general
and for orienting young women toward political life in particular is one of the obstacles
faced by women.
14
A. Thanikodi and M. Sugirtha, “Status of Women in Politics”, The Indian Journal of Political
Science, Vol. 68, No. 3, July- September 2007, pp. 591-593.
15
Sukhpal Kaur, “Women’s Rights: A Historical Perspective”, The Indian Journal of Political
Science, Vol. 70, No. 1, January-March 2009, p. 128.
16
Rakesh K. Singh, op.cit., 2012, p. 58.
17
Rashmi Shrivatava, “Minority Representation of a Political Majority Group: Women in Indian
Democratic Process”, The Indian Journal of Political Science, Vol. 72, No. 2, April-June 2011,
p. 411.
18
Satarupa Pal, “Politics of Women’s Reservation in India”, International Journal of Humanities and
Social Science Studies, Vol. 1, No. 3, November 2014, p. 118.
296
Table 5.1
Respondents Views Regarding Hurdles Come in the Way of Women’s
Participation
Non-Cooperation
Cooperation of
1 28 19.31 16 10.96 44 15.12
Husband/Family Members
Lack of Time due to Family
F
2 54 37.24 45 30.82 99 34.02
Responsibility
3 Lack of Interest in Politics 12 8.28 19 13.02 31 10.66
4 Lack of Political Awakening 34 23.45 51 34.93 85 29.21
5 Lack of Education 17 11.72 15 10.27 32 10.99
Total 145 100 146 100 291 100
37.24
40 34.93
30.82
35 Mandi
23.45
30 Kangra
19.31
Percentage
25
13.02
20
11.72
10.96
10.27
15
8.28
10
5
0
Lack of Education
Lack of Political
Lack of Time due to
of Husband/Family
Lack of Interest in
Non-Cooperation
Awakening
Responsibility
Members
Politics
Family
Response
Fig. 5.1: Respondents Views Regarding Hurdles Come in the Way of Women’s
Participation
Table 5.1 shows that out of 291 respondents, 44 respondents believed that main
hurdles comes in the way of women participation in politics were non-cooperation
non of
husband/family members,
members which constitute 15.12 per cent of the total sample, whereas
297
99 respondents perceived lack of time due to family responsibilities as the major hurdle
comes in the way of women participation in politics, which constitute 34.02 per cent of
the sample. There were 31 respondents, the main hurdles lack of interest, which
constitute 10.66 per cent of the sample, while 85 respondents who believed that the
main hurdle comes in the way of women participation i.e. the lack of political
awakening, which constitute 29.21 per cent of the sample, and 32 respondents pointed
out lack of education as the main hurdles in the way of women participation in politics,
which constitute 10.99 per cent of the sample.
The comparative analysis of two districts reveals that the women face many
problems in the society that is social, economic and political. Lack of education also
plays hurdles in the way of women participation. Due to the traditional pattern of our
298
rural society there are a number of hurdles in the way of effective participation of
women.
Caste Dominance
Caste and politics influence each other. The electoral process, administration
and politics are greatly affected by caste. M.N. Srinivas introduced the concept of
dominant caste to examine the political process in India. Caste has its hold in the Indian
politics. According to him, voting preferences are made on caste line.19 Caste is an
important factor in Indian society and politics. Over a century of social reform
movement, India could hardly make any impression on the caste system. The number
of caste, instead of diminishing has been increasing. In fact, caste organisation and
caste consciousness are increasing in modern India.20
19
Usha Kiran, Participation of Women in Indian Politics: Gender Justice and Political Challenge,
Delhi: Globus Press, 2016, p.122.
20
S.S Chahar (ed.), Governance at Grassroots Level in India, New Delhi: Kanishka Publishers, 2005, p.
408.
21
B.B. Jena and J.K. Baral, Election Politics and Voting Behaviour in India, Delhi: Discovery
Publishing House, 1989, p. 51.
22
Niroj Sinha, Women in Indian Politics: Empowerment of Women Through Political Participation,
New Delhi: Gyan Publishing House, 2006, pp. 95-96.
23
Article 332, Constitution of India.
24
Article 338, Constitution of India.
299
scheduled castes, scheduled tribes and other socially and educationally backward
classes of citizens in services.25
Keeping in view, the social hierarchical caste based structure, which exploited
the weaker sections of society, there was and is a justification for such a provision in
the constitution for a short period.26 However, while doing so, efficiency of
administration should also not be blindly ignored.27 Otherwise, their condition would
become more miserable. It should be remembered that reservation can neither be made
on communal considerations, nor more than 50 per cent seats be reserved. While, caste
has been politicised in the process, it has provided the Indian politics with processes
and symbol of political articulation. Thus, within the new context of political
democracy, caste remains a central element of Indian society even, while adapting itself
to the values and methods of democratic politics.28
25
Clause (4) to Article 15 of the Indian Constitution.
26
N.M. Tripathi, Minority and Law, Delhi: Indian Law Institute, 1972, p.10.
27
Article 335, Constitution of India.
28
Niroj Sinha, op.cit., 2006, p. 97.
300
democratic politics. The decision to implement Mandal Commission recommendation
for reservation of jobs
bs for other Backward Classes (Castes)
(Castes) and the reaction it
generated in politics testifies to the continued presence of caste as a determinant of
politics in India. However, it must be stated that the role of caste as determinant of the
voting behaviour
viour has been undergoing a change, at least in the urban areas. Issue based
political struggle is gradually taking its shape in the Indian polity. But the situation
continues to be paradoxical.29 Respondents views on caste dominance
ominance given below:
Table 5.2
Respondents Views on Caste Dominance
No. of Respondents
Grand Total
Sr.No Response Mandi Kangra
No. % age No. % age No. % age
1 Yes 99 68.27 88 60.27 187 64.26
2 No 37 25.52 47 32.19 84 28.87
3 No Opinion 9 6.21 11 7.54 20 6.87
Total 145 100 146 100 291 100
68.27
70
Mandi
60.27
60 Kangra
50
Percentage
40
32.19
30 25.52
20
6.21 7.54
10
0
Yes No No Opinion
Caste Dominance
29
Biraj Hazarika, “Voting Behaviour in India and its Determinants,” Journal of Humanities and
Social Science,, Vol. 20, No. 10, October 2015, pp. 22-25.
301
Table 5.2 indicates that out of 291 respondents, 187 respondents who were
believed caste in politics, which constitute 64.26 per cent of the total sample, whereas
84 respondents did not believe caste in politics, which constitute 28.87 per cent of the
sample. There were 20 respondents who did not give their opinion, which constitute
6.87 per cent of the sample.
The comparative analysis of two district reveals that majority of the respondents
believed that caste play an important role in politics. In district Mandi (68.27%) and
district Kangra (60.27%) of the respondents believed that caste plays important role in
politics and they affect voting behaviour. It was observed that majority of respondents,
who unite on the basis of caste and support candidate. We can see the influence of caste
in politics as voting agency.
Social System
Women were said to enjoy a high status in the society in the ancient times. They
were viewed as home makers and managers, assigned with the most important task of
bringing up a family. With the passage of time, they came to be relegated to an inferior
position considering them weak and at times incapable even of holding rights. This lead
to their exploitation at all levels and in all spheres, the woman who was the backbone
of the family enjoyed subordinate rights in family matters and at times no rights at all.30
Women constitute about 50 per cent of the total population of the nation, have
generally been considered as a weaker section. Discrimination against women has
30
Asha Bhandari and Rekha Mehta, Women, Justice and the Rule of Law, New Delhi: Serials
Publications, 2009, p. 103.
302
existed in all parts of the globe in some form or another. For all countries, the gender
Development Index (GDI) is lower than the Human Development Index indicating
gender inequality everywhere.31 The main cause for poor condition of women is rooted
in traditional structures like class, caste hierarchy and religious discriminations. The
impact of these cultural forces is that, firstly women have less direct independent
access than men to capital, property and extensive services. Secondly, women have
limited geographical mobility and economic independence or personal autonomy that
made them dependent on male kin.32 Gender inequality in our social institutions is
addressed. Many erroneously think that women are a homogenous group with identical
problems and priorities, yet Indian society is divided by caste, religion and class
differences. The majority of women live in rural areas and their problems and needs are
different from those of urban women. Access to nutritious food, clean drinking water
and primary healthcare may not be life’s priorities for an urban woman, because these
life-sustaining services are available to her. But for a rural woman who is struggling for
her livelihood, these are indeed priorities, meaningful change in their life situations can
only occur, when development efforts also address their issues.33
Therefore, 50 per cent reservation for women at all the tiers of Panchayats has
made a significant beginning in the democratic process. Over one million women have
come as decision-makers at the Panchayats levels, but experiences of women have been
disheartening. Most of the elected women had no idea, what being an elected member
meant and just did what the men (as brothers, fathers, father-in-law and husband) told
them to do. The community does not perceive the women as capable or worthy of
leadership. For a change in a mental attitude of women, their needs to be a drastic
change in social attitudes on the whole.34 In nutshell, positive social outlook towards
women would certainly help in active participation of women in the democratic
decentralization process.
31
Ajit Kumar Sinha, (ed.), New Dimensions of Women Empowerment, New Delhi: Deep and Deep
Publications, 2008, p. 25.
32
Asha Bhandari and Rekha Mehta, op.cit., 2009, p. 39.
33
Vidhyavati Chakki, “Socio-Economic Empowerment of Women in India”, Third Concept, Vol. 26,
No. 308, October 2012, p. 8.
34
Siva Subrahmanyam, “Empowerment of Women and Marginalized Groups in Panchayats”,
Kurukshetra, Vol. 50, No. 7, May 2002, p. 28.
303
Table 5.3
Respondents Opinion Regarding Social System
No. of Respondents
Grand Total
Sr.No Response Mandi Kangra
No. % Age No. % Age No. % Age
1 Yes 126 86.89 133 91.09 259 89.00
2 No 6 2.76 8 5.48 14 4.81
3 No Opinion 13 10.35 5 3.43 18 6.19
Total 145 100 146 100 291 100
91.09
86.89
100
90
Mandi
80
70 Kangra
Percentage
60
50
40
30
10.35
5.48
20
3.43
2.76
10
0
Yes No No Opinion
Response
It is clear from the table 5.3 that out of 291 respondents, 259 respondents
believe that social outlook towards women required major change,
change which constitute
89.00 per cent of the total. There were 14 respondents
respondents who disagree and 18 respondents
express no opinion. They constitute 4.81 and 6.19 per cent respectively.
304
As far as district Kangra was concerned, out of 146 respondents 133
respondents believe that the social outlook towards women required major change.
There were 8 who disagree and 5 express no opinion. They constitute 5.48 and 3.43 per
cent of the total.
The comparative analysis of the two district reveals that the number of
respondents who fully agree that social outlook towards women required major change.
It was found that the attitude of society towards women regarding their political
participation was not encouraging. It was also observed that due to the passing remarks
by the people many women candidate withdraw from the contest and sometimes from
active participation.
Family Problems
In the traditional society, women’s role was naturally limited to the family.
Since, she was bearer of children, fully occupied with her duties as a mother and home-
maker. Rural women are economically backward. Poverty, illiteracy and caste are the
factors affecting the economic development of women.35 Husbands, in-laws and close
relatives have become the main decision-makers relegating the actual women
representatives to the background. Moreover, role conflict among these representatives
has also increased while managing house responsibilities and political simultaneously.
Since, male dominating society is reluctant in accepting the women as decision-makers,
36
they are being muscle men. Hence participation of women in the field of political,
economical, social, educational, and cultural has been made to commit the issues to
recognize the equal position and status of women and men in decision making
accordance to the effective of women empowerment.37
35
M. Perumal, et al., “Empowering Rural Women Through Self- Help Groups”, in Asha Bhandari and
Rekha Mehta, Women, Justice and the Rule of Law, New Delhi: Serials Publications, 2009,
pp. 145-146.
36
Azam Khan and Tosib Alam, “Empowerment of Rural Women and Local Self-Governance”, in
Asha Bhandari and Rekha Mehta, Women, Justice and the Rule of Law, New Delhi: Serials
Publications, 2009, p.162.
37
Asha Bhandari and Rekha Mehta, op.cit., 2009, p. 2.
305
decisions of these women are largely influenced by the spouses.38 It is alleged that
husbands of the elected women representatives
represent ives interfere in their decision making. It is
also complained that often male
ale members push through their decision and do not care
about the views of their women counterparts.39
Table 5.4
Respondents Opinion
Opini Regarding Family Problems
No. of Respondents
Grand Total
Sr.No Response Mandi Kangra
No. % age No. % age No. % age
1 Yes 108 74.49 100 68.49 208 71.48
2 No 27 18.62 31 21.24 58 19.93
3 No Opinion 10 6.89 15 10.27 25 8.59
Total 145 100.00 146 100.00 291 100.00
74.49
68.49
80
70 Mandi
60 Kangra
50
Percentage
40
21.24
18.62
30
10.27
20
6.89
10
0
Yes No No Opinion
Response
38
Sakuntala Narasimhan, “Women’s Role in Gram Sabha”, Kurukshetra, Vol. 48, No.1,
1, October 1999,
p. 26.
39
S.S. Chahar (ed.), op.cit., 2005, p.78.
306
It is clear from the table 5.4 that out of total 291 respondents, 208 respondents
believed that they were facing many problems in the discharge of their duties due to
relatives and community, which constitutes 71.48 per cent of the sample. Whereas 58
respondents who believed that they faced no problems in discharge of their duties,
which constitute 19.93 per cent of the sample. There were 25 respondents who
expressed no opinion on the either side. The percentage of such respondents is 8.59 of
the sample.
In district Mandi, out of total 145 respondents, 108 respondents believed that
they were facing many problems in the discharge of their duties due to relatives and
community, which constitutes 74.49 per cent of the sample. Whereas 27 respondents
who believed that they faced no problems in discharge of their duties, which constitute
18.62 per cent of the sample. There were 10 respondents who expressed no opinion on
the either side. The percentage of such respondents, 6.89 of the sample.
In district Kangra, out of total 146 respondents, 100 respondents believed that
they were facing many problems in the discharge of their duties due to relatives and
community, which constitutes 68.49 per cent of the sample. Whereas 31 respondents
who believed that they faced no problems in discharge of their duties, which constitute
21.24 per cent of the sample. There were 15 respondents who expressed no opinion on
the either side, which constitute 10.27 per cent of the sample.
The comparative analysis of two district reveals that the male counterparts not
only in the family but in the society dominated the elected women representatives too.
Even today, women lacks of independence of thought and action. Women still crave for
social recognition for their activities.
Education
Education is the key that opens the door in life which is essentially social in
character. An illiterate woman would not be able to understand all the rules and
regulations governing the institutions. Illiteracy restricts one’s capacity to give
thoughtful judgement on issues of importance. Education facilitates the development of
a progressive attitude in individuals towards social and economic problems. In the
present society, capacity to understand the issues and problems facing the community
and the ability to communicate one’s ideas to others are important qualities for a
member. Education for women is more important political institutions, education or
307
being literate will help them to understand the rules, regulations and fulfil the
objectives of the institutions and help them in carrying out their day-to-day functions.40
Education in a society is like a mirror, which reflects the attitude of the masses.
Women which constitute almost half of the population required equal measures to
education. The hither to deprived sections of the Indian society due to orthodox
thumping of the Indian male dominate society. Education plays an important role in
determining the social and political status of a person. It is education which shapes the
pattern of leadership. An educated leader can make good law for society. It is only
through education that a leader can remain in touch with national as well as
international developments.41
Table 5.5
Respondents Opinion Regarding Educational Qualification
No. of Respondents
Grand Total
Sr.No Response Mandi Kangra
No. % age No. % age No. % age
1 Yes 130 89.66 110 75.34 240 82.47
2 No 12 8.27 24 16.44 36 12.37
3 No Opinion 3 2.07 12 8.22 15 5.16
Total 145 100 146 100 291 100
40
K.C. Vidya, Political Empowerment of Women at the Grassroots, New Delhi: Kanishka Publishers,
2007, p. 105.
41
A.K. Gupta, Emerging Pattern of Political Leadership: A Case Study of Punjab, New Delhi: Mittal
Publications, 1991, p. 35.
42
K. Thangamani, “Education for Women” , in Rameshwari Pandya, (ed.), Women Welfare and
Empowerment in India, New Delhi: New Century Publications, 2008, pp.196-197.
308
89.66
90
75.34
80
Mandi
70
Kangra
60
Percentage
50
40
30
16.44
20
8.27 8.22
10 2.07
0
Yes No No Opinion
Educational Qualification
It is evident from the table 5.5 regarding respondent’s opinion about candidate’s
qualification. Out of 291 respondents, 240 respondents favoured the minimum
educational qualification for elected candidate in politics,
politics which constitute 82.47 per
cent of the sample, whereas 36 respondents were not in favour of minimum educational
qualification for elected candidate in politics,
politics which constitute 12.37 per cent of the
sample. There were 15 respondents who expressed no opinion, which constitute 5.16
per cent the sample.
In district Mandi,
Mandi out of 145 respondents, 130 respondents favoured the
minimum educational qualification for elected candidate in politics,
politics which constitute
89.66 per cent of the sample, whereas 12 respondents were not in favour of minimum
educational qualification for elected candidate in politics which constitute 8.27 per cent
of the sample. There were 3 respondents who expressed no opinion,
opinion which constitute
2.07 per cent the sample.
In district Kangra,
Kangra out of 146 respondents, 110 respondents favoured the
minimum educational qualification for elected candidate in politics,
politics which constitute
75.34 per cent of the sample, whereas 24 respondents were not in favour of minimum
educational qualification for elected candidate in politics,
politics which constitute 16.44 per
cent of the sample. There were 12 respondents who expressed no opinion,
opinion which
constitute 8.22 per cent of the sample.
309
The comparative analysis of the two districts reveals that majority of the
respondents were in favour of minimum educational qualification for women in
politics. Therefore, illiterate women were not able to participate in politics. Without
proper education, they feel hard to understand the rules of politics. Thus, education is a
most vital channel to encourage women to participate in politics.
Economic Dependence
43
Mohd Muzaffar Banday and P. Ganesan, “Economic Empowerment of Rural Muslim Women in
Kashmir Valley”, Third Concept, Vol. 30, No. 356, October 2016, pp. 55-56.
44
D. Sundar Ram (ed.), Women Empowerment in Political Institutions: An Indian Perspective, New
Delhi: Kanishka Publishers, 2009, p.149.
310
independence.45 Empowerment is a multi-dimensional social process that helps people
gain control over their own lives communities and in their society. Empowerment
Emp
occurs within sociological,
sociological psychological, economic spheres and at various levels.
Women’s empowerment is the key to socio-economic
socio economic development of the community
that brings women into the mainstream of national development,
development has been a major
concern of government.46
Table 5.6
Respondents Opinion with Regard to Economic Dependence
ependence
No. of Respondents
Grand Total
Sr.No Response Mandi Kangra
No. % age No. % age No. % age
1 Yes 110 75.86 106 72.60 216 74.23
2 No 28 19.31 31 21.24 59 20.28
3 No Opinion 7 4.83 9 6.16 16 5.49
Total 145 100 146 100 291 100
75.86
72.6
80
Mandi
70
Kangra
60
50
Percentage
40
21.24
19.31
30
20
6.16
4.83
10
0
Yes No No Opinion
Response
45
Ritu Sapra and Divya Khatter, “Women Empowerment in India”, Third Concept, Vol. 28, No. 325
March 2014, p. 38.
46
Meenu Agrawal, (ed.), Women Empowerment and Globalization:
Globalization A Modern Perspective,
Perspective New Delhi:
Kanishka Publishers, 2009,
2009 p. 60.
311
The table 5.6 shows that out of 291 respondents, 216 respondents agreed that
economically independent women took actively participated in politics, which
constitute 74.23 per cent of total sample, whereas 59 respondents did not agree with
this view, which constitute 20.28 per cent of the sample. There were 16 respondents
who did not express opinion about this, which constitute 5.49 per cent of the sample.
India’s villages are bound by traditions. The position of women is very clear-a
traditional housewife. The upbringing of girls in the rural society is inevitably oriented
towards marriage. They could contribute an additional hand both at home and in the
fields. The rural social scene is now in the process of change. The most important
change is their entry as elected members of the PRIs.47 However, in a male dominated
Indian society women are often considered as the rubber stamp of men. It is generally
believed that women do not vote their own. Most women respect family traditions and
do not want to go against them. The decision in the family about whom to vote in an
election is generally taken by male members. When women vote, they vote in
conformity with their husband. Husband and other male family members influence
47
K. C. Vidya, op.cit., 2007, pp. 161-162.
312
their voting choice.48 Therefore, status of women differs from society to society.
According
ording to cultural milieu, family structure, class, caste, property rights and morals,
morals
their status diverge.. In the past,
past no serious attempts had been made to study the women
question. Women were neglected
neg section of the society. The process of modernization
modernizati
during the 19th century laid the greater emphasis on the political, economic and social
modernization of women. The transformation of the society as well as women took
place and the new role of women in the new emerging society replaced the status of
men in traditional society.49 Thus, the area of power politics has practically been
women
conditioned as a male domain. Table shows the influence of father/husband/other male
family members on voting choice of the respondents.
Table 5.7
Influence of the Male Family
F Members on Voting Choice of the Respondents
No. of Respondents
Grand Total
Sr.No Response Mandi Kangra
No. % Age No. % Age No. % Age
1 Yes 98 67.59 108 73.97 206 70.79
2 No 41 28.27 34 23.29 75 25.77
3 No Opinion 6 4.14 4 2.74 10 3.44
Total 145 100 146 100 291 100
73.97
67.59
80
70 Mandi
60
Percentage (%)
Kangra
50
28.27
23.29
40
30
20
4.14
2.74
10
0
Yes No No Opinion
Response
Fig. 5.7: Influence of the Male Family Members on Voting Choice of the Respondents
48
Bhawana Jharta, Women and Politics in India: Impact of Family and Education on Women Political
Activists, New Delhi: Deep and Deep Publications, 1996, p. 89.
49
Prem R. Bhardwaj (ed.), op.cit., 2005, p. 235.
313
Table 5.7 indicates that out of 291 respondents 206 respondents agreed that
women casted their vote on the advice of male counterparts, which constitute 70.79 per
cent the total sample, whereas 75 respondents disagreed to it, which constitute 25.77
per cent of the sample, while 10 respondents who gave no opinion in this aspect, which
constitute 3.44 per cent of the sample.
As far as in district Kangra, out of 146 respondents 108 respondents agreed that
women casted their vote on the advice of male counterparts, which constitute 73.97 per
cent the total sample, whereas 34 respondents disagreed to it, which constitute 23.29
per cent of the sample, while 4 respondents who gave no opinion in this aspect, which
constitute 2.74 per cent of the sample.
The comparative analysis of two district reveals that the dominance of male
over female in rural areas is still prevalent. Women at large scale agreed with the fact
that because of their lack of self confidence, they were dominated by male members
and their voting decisions were being influenced by them. It was observed that the most
of the rural women do not go for voting without prior consultation with their husband,
father, brother and any other male elite members. However, the electoral education,
awareness campaign and capacity programmes were the right steps to empower women
folk and strengthen their willingness towards, independent voting.
Bureaucracy
50
Ali Ashraf, Government and Politics of Big Citizens, New Delhi: Concept Publishing Company,
1977, p. 1.
314
plays an important role in the democratic process. It implements the policies and
programmes of elected representatives of Panchayati
Panchayati Raj Institutions. Their
involvement and commitment is necessary for the success of democratic process. In
fact, in a democratic system the elected representatives take policy decision but the
implementation exclusively depends upon the bureaucratic structure.
structure. The bureaucracy,
bureaucracy
which is attached with Panchayati Raj Institutions basically belongs to other
departments of the state governments.
Table 5.8
Respondents Opinion Regarding Bureaucratic Interference in Working of PRIs
No. of Respondents
Grand Total
Sr.No Response Mandi Kangra
65.07
80
70
Mandi
60
Percentage (%)
Kangra
30.82
50
26.21
40
30
4.11
20
1.38
10
0
Yes No No Opinion
Response
Table 5.8 depicts that out of, 291 respondents, 200 respondents believed that
bureaucracy creates problems in the functioning of PRIs,
PRIs which constitute 68.73 per
315
cent of the sample. Therefore 83 respondents did not agree with this view, which
constitute 28.52 per cent and 8 respondents did not respond on either side, which
constitute 2.75 per cent of the sample.
Corruption /Favouritism
51
G. Planithurai (ed.), New Panchayati Raj System: Status and Prospects, New Delhi: Kanishka
Publishers, 1996, p. 57.
316
phenomenon. In our own country some people in high positions have been charged for
it. A corrupt person is termed immoral, dishonest and unscrupulous in his dealings. His
disregard for honesty, righteousness and truth results in his alienation from society.
Corruption is the most virulent, when crises everywhere threaten the very existence of
the society and the faith in life is shaken.52
Corruption is a cancer, which every Indian must strives to cure. Many new
leaders, when comes into power declare their determination to eradicate corruption but
soon they themselves become corrupt and start amassing huge wealth. Many people
become materialistic and money oriented, there is no importance of ethics and morals
in business dealings. Many people thinking that money coming to their pocket is good,
same way many thinking that money, which is going out of their pocket is bad, but they
don’t consider the way money is travelling. This is because such these kinds of people
have no moral accountability to anybody, and have full trust on money. They strongly
believe that money can hold a big role in their life, they believe that money can solve
their current and future problems and give them life without problems.53 During
election time corruption is at its peak level. Big industrialists funds politicians to meet
high cost of election and ultimately to seek personal favour. Bribery to politicians buys
influence, and bribery by politicians buys votes. In order to get elected, politicians
bribe poor illiterate people, who are slogging for two times meal. Vast size of
population coupled with widespread illiteracy and the poor economic infrastructure
lead to endemic corruption in public life. 54 Therefore women have played a role that is
subordinate to men. The world of politics in India is so much surrounded by an aura of
crime and corruption, which is synonymous with politics. The fact is that if we want to
bring about a change and cleanse the political system, we will have to give reservation
to women.55 Subsequently, women must be given a chance not because they are
necessarily any better than male politician but because they cannot do any worse. Male
leaders indulge in crime and corruption and concentrate their energy in fighting for
greater power and privileges. If women are voted to power, they will fight for a cleaner
and corruption free political system. 56
52
K. Geetamma, “Corruption in India: Causes and Remedies”, Third Concept, Vol. 30, No. 360,
February 2017, pp. 42-43.
53
Ibid.,
54
Ibid., p. 41.
55
D. Sundar Ram (ed.), op.cit., 2009, p. 11.
56
Ibid., p.12.
317
Table 5.9
Respondents view Regarding Corruption and Favouritism
No. of Respondents
Grand Total
Sr.No Response Mandi Kangra
No. % Age No. % Age No. % Age
1 Yes 100 68.96 110 75.34 210 72.17
2 No 30 20.68 11 7.53 41 14.08
3 No Opinion 15 10.34 25 17.13 40 13.75
Total 145 100 146 100 291 100
75.34
68.96
80
70 Mandi
60
Percentage (%)
Kangra
50
40
20.68
17.13
30
10.34
7.53
20
10
0
Yes No No Opinion
Response
Table 5.9 shows that all 291 respondents were interviewed out of which 210
respondents admitted that there was favouritism in the identification of the beneficiaries
at the grassroots level, which constitute 72.17
72.1 per cent of the sample. Therefore, 41
respondents were not agreed with this opinion that there was no such favouritism in the
identification of beneficiaries,
beneficiaries which accounted 14.08 per cent of the sample.
However, 40 respondents did not express their opinion in either side.. The percentage of
such respondents was 13.75 per cent.
318
respondents were not agreed with this opinion that there was no such favouritism in the
identification of beneficiaries, which accounted 20.68 per cent of the sample, while 15
respondents did not express their opinion in either side. The percentage of such
respondents was 10.34 per cent.
The comparative study of both district reveals that majority of the respondents
admitted that there was favouritism in the identification of the beneficiaries at the
grassroots levels. Therefore, the corruption was a form of dishonest or unethical
conduct by a person entrusted with position of authority, often to acquire personal
benefit.
319
rotation to different constituency as was also stipulated in the earlier bill, but even in
this bill there was no reference to a possible reservation in chairpersons’ positions. The
bill was introduced in Parliament but did not come up for discussion. When the
congress party came back to power after the elections of 1991, a new Amendment bill
was introduced in the Parliament which finally became the 73rd amendment to the
constitution. This continued the provision relating to “not less than one third”
reservation in membership with the inclusion of chairperson’s posts. The Minister of
State for Rural Development, while introducing the bill for 73rd amendment in 1992
had stated that, making provision for reservation of one-third of the total seats could be
considered inadequate.57
The women’s reservation bill, which seeks to reserve one third of seats in the
Lok Sabha and the State Legislatures for women, is yet to become law despite being
passed by the Rajys Sabha in 2010 itself. Other pending reforms to the electoral system
includes the constitutional (110th Amendment) bill, for reserving half the seats in
Panchayats for women and the constitution (112th Amendment) bill, reserving one third
of elected seats in municipalities for women.58 Even in most advanced countries
women’s representation is very low in democratic bodies. But in India, women’s
reservation bill (i.e.108th Amendment of the Indian Constitution), is still pending that
proposes for thirty-three percent of seats reserved, in the parliament and the state
legislatures. The bill was first introduced in the Lok Sabha on 12th September 1996.
Though, the bill is passed in the Rajya Sabha in 2010, but is still pending in Lok Sabha.
So, it has been argued that women who constituting half of the population are lagging
behind from democratic setup in India.59 However the proper representation of women
in terms of numbers and quality is absolutely essential for their meaningful partnership
in the progress of the nation.60 There is a growing demand for the presence of women
in political decision-making, so as to facilitate their real empowerment.61 The
respondents opinion regarding reservation for women in state politics given below:
57
Nirmala Buch, “Panchayats and Women”, in George Mathew, Status of Panchayati Raj in the States
and Union Territories of India 2000, New Delhi: Concept Publishing Company, 2000, pp. 37-38.
58
Lakshmi Iyer, “The Electoral Participation of Women’’, Yojana, Vol. 58, July 2014, p. 24.
59
Satarupa Pal, op.cit., 2014, pp.119-122.
60
D. Sundar Ram (ed.), op.cit., 2009, p.13.
61
Ibid., p. 83.
320
Table 5.10
Respondents Opinion
nion Regarding Reservation for Women
omen in State Politics
No. of Respondents
Grand Total
Sr.No Response Mandi Kangra
No. % age No. % age No. % age
1 Yes 112 77.24 110 75.34 222 76.29
2 No 25 17.24 31 21.23 56 19.24
3 No Opinion 8 5.52 5 3.43 13 4.47
Total 145 100.00 146 100.00 291 100.00
77.24 75.34
80
Mandi
70
Kangra
60
Percentage (%)
50
40
30
21.23
17.24
20
5.52
10 3.43
0
Yes No No Opinion
Response
Fig. 5.10: Respondents Opinion Regarding Reservation for Women in State Politics
The table 5.10 reveals that vast majority of the respondents in the sample were
demanding the reservation for women in state politics. Out of 291 respondents, 222
respondents were demanding reservation of seats for women in state and national level,
level
which constitute 76.29 per cent of the total sample, whereas 56 respondents were not
against reservation for women in politics,
politics which constitute 19.24
24 per cent of the
sample, while13 respondents did not express their opinion,
opinion which constitute 4.47 per
cent of the sample.
321
As far as district Mandi was concerned, out of 145 respondents, 112
respondents were demanding reservation of seats for women in state and national level,
which constitute 77.24 per cent of the total sample, whereas 25 respondents were not
against reservation for women in politics, which constitute 17.24 per cent of the
sample, while 8 respondents did not express their opinion, which constitute 5.52 per
cent of the sample.
Women are still mostly employed in traditional and informal sectors, where
there has been a lower level of technological and information support. This further
compounds their educational handicaps. However, women with education have entered
many new areas of occupation, where their participation was virtually non-existent
before. This process of occupational diversification through education has been
accelerated during the decade in many developing countries. This enable women to
participate actively in all spheres of economic and social life, vocational and
professional training, must be further developed. In this respect, the training of trainers
is of primary importance, as is the introduction of management training for women.
Apart from the conventional types of training (seminars, workshops etc.,) the non-
conventional types are often also suitable.62
The statutory empowerment of women will become a reality and relevant only,
when they are given adequate training in performing their duties as well as in
understanding the whole system of democratic decentralization. Thus, training to
62
Usha Kiran, op.cit., 2016, p. 66.
322
leaders will make them politically conscious and expose them to constitutional and
legal rights, functions of Panchayati Raj Institutions and their role in formulating and
implementation of rural development schemes. The purpose of passing 73rd
mendment was to make PRIs more effective and representative.63 The
constitutional amendment
views of women representatives on training for effective functioning of PRIs are
summarized in the Table 5.11.
Table 5.11
No. of Respondents
Sr. Grand Total
Response Mandi Kangra
No.
No. %age No. %age No. %age
1. Yes 123 84.83 119 81.51 242 83.16
2. No 12 8.28 15 10.27 27 9.28
3. No Opinion 10 6.89 12 8.22 22 7.56
Total 145 100.00 146 100.00 291 100.00
84.83
81.51
90
80 Mandi
70 Kangra
60
Percentage
50
40
30
10.27
8.28
8.22
6.89
20
10
0
Yes No No Opinion
Response
63
G. Palanthurai (ed.), op.cit., 1996, p.151.
323
It is evident from the table 5.11 that out of, 291 respondents were interviewed
out of which respondents 242 respondents believed that the elected women
representatives should be given training in rural development programmes, which
constitute 83.16 per cent of the sample. However 27 respondents disagreed with this
view, which constitutes 9.28 per cent of the total. There were 22 respondents expressed
no opinion. The percentage of such respondents was 7.56 of the total sample.
The comparative analysis of the two district reveals that most of the elected
women representatives engaged in the implementation of policies and programmes.
They were not aware of the policies and programmes of the Panchayati Raj Institutions
leading to their improper functioning. Thus proper training of the elected women
representatives attached to the Panchayati Raj Institutions is a must.
324
various levels of political activities in India have risen considerable. However, women
are still under-represented in governance and decision-making process.64
Women members and other executive bodies must be trained and empowered to
exercise their authority. Both men and women members must be sensitive to women
issues. A massive conscientisation programmes for woman in general needs to be taken
up and modules designed for this purpose should adequately deal with social and
economic constraints, which restricts their participation, interpersonal communication
skills, amongst the trainees/ community leaders.65
64
Purnima Ojha, “Women’s Issues in India: Role and Importance of Media”, The Indian Journal of
Political Science, Vol.72, No.1, January-March 2011, pp. 94-95.
65
J.L. Singh, Women and Panchayati Raj, Delhi: Sunrise Publications, 2005, p. 356.
66
S.S.Chahar (ed.), op.cit., 2005, p. 248.
67
D.S. Chaudhary, G.K. Kar, Elections and Electoral Behaviour in India, Delhi: Kanti Publications,
1992, p.51.
68
Barsha Kalita, “Political Status of Women in Assam: An Analysis”, Golden Research Thoughts, Vol.
4, No.1, July 2014, pp. 6-7.
325
Table 5.12
Respondentss Opinion Regarding Women’s Role in Decision Making
Mak
Process
No. of Respondents
Grand Total
Sr.No Response Mandi Kangra
No. % age No. % age No. % age
1 Yes 119 82.07 114 78.09 233 80.07
2 No 24 16.55 20 13.69 44 15.12
3 No Opinion 2 1.38 12 8.22 14 4.81
Total 145 100 146 100 291 100
Mandi
90 82.07
78.09
Kangra
80
70
Percentage (%)
60
50
40
30
16.55
20 13.69
8.22
10 1.38
0
Yes No No Opinion
Response
It is evident from the table 5.12 that the total sample, 291 respondents were
interviewed, out of which 233 respondents had opinion that women took decisions on
their own in politics, which constitute 80.07 per cent of the sample, whereas 44
respondents were holding the opposite view that women were not capable of taking
decisions independently and they were being influenced by the male members in
politics, which constitute 15.12
.12 per cent of the sample, while 14 respondents had no
opinion, which constitute 4.81 per cent of the sample.
326
In district Mandi, 145 respondents 119 respondents had opinion that women
took decisions on their own in politics, which constitute 82.07 per cent of the sample,
whereas 24 respondents were holding the opposite view, that women were not capable
of taking decisions independently and they were being influenced by the male members
in politics, which constitute 16.55 per cent of the sample, while 2 respondents had no
opinion, which constitute 1.38 per cent of the sample.
In district Kangra, 146 respondents 114 respondents had opinion that women
took decisions on their own in politics, which constitute 78.09 per cent of the sample,
whereas 20 respondents were holding the opposite view that women were not capable
of taking decisions independently and they were being influenced by the male members
in politics, which constitute 13.69 per cent of the sample, while 12 respondents had no
opinion, which constitute 8.22 per cent of the sample.
The comparative analysis of the two district depicts that most of the women
take decisions independently. It was observed that some women were not able to
participate independently in the decision making process, especially in the case of
being a chairperson. They were dependent on the male counterparts. Lack of experience
was the one of the factors for male dominance over their sphere of the activities.
Democratic Process
Indian democracy is the biggest democracy in the world having large number of
electorates. Though, the constitution of India has provided right to live with respect to
all citizens of India.69 Participation is the very backbone of democracy. It is the key
concept of self-governance because in one democracy decision making process begins
and ends with the people.70 In fact, 73rd amendment has created a scope for
accomplishing development with social justice, which is mandate of the new
Panchayati Raj system. The new system brings all those, who are interested to have
voice in decision making through their participation in PRIs. The Panchayati Raj
system is basis for the “Social Justice” and “Empowerment” of weaker section on
which, the development initiative have to be built upon for achieving overall, human
welfare of the society.
69
Rajender B. Daddamani, “Indian Democracy: Reality or Myth?”, Third Concept, Vol. 22, No. 256,
June 2008, p. 11.
70
Jyoti Prakash Samantray, “Grassroots Level Democracy in India- An Overview”, Indian Journal of
Research, Vol. 4, No.7, July 2015, p. 434.
327
Therefore, democracy
emocracy is never complete without the active involvement and
participation of the people at all levels and the institutions. It has gained considerable
strength, since independence at the national
n and state levels.
evels. People’s participation has
become necessary for the success of Panchayati Raj.71 Table shows respondents
opinion regarding democratic process is the best platform for women participation.
Table 5.13
Respondentss Opinion about PRIs as the Best Platform of Democratic Process
No. of Respondents
Grand Total
Sr.No Response Mandi Kangra
No. % age No. % age No. % age
1 Yes 137 94.48 127 86.99 264 90.72
2 No 6 4.14 13 8.90 19 6.53
3 No Opinion 2 1.38 6 4.11 8 2.75
Total 145 100.00 146 100.00 291 100.00
94.48
86.99
Mandi
100
Kangra
90
80
70
Percentage (%)
60
50
40
30
8.9
4.14
4.11
20
1.38
10
0
Yes No No Opinion
Response
Fig. 5.13: Respondentss Opinion about PRIs as the Best Platform of Democratic Process
Table 5.13 shows that out of 291 respondents, 264 respondents agreed with
Panchayati Raj Institutions was the best platform
pla of the democratic process,
process which
71
S.T. Shirsath and Jitender Wasnik, “Democracy and Development
Development at Grassroots in India”,
International Journal of Research in Applied Nature and Social Sciences, Vol. 2, No.7,
No. July 2014,
p.169.
328
constitute 90.72 per cent of the total sample, whereas 19 respondents who did not agree
democratic process, which constitute 6.53 per cent of the sample, there were 8
respondents who gave no opinion about this context which constitute 2.75 per cent of
the sample.
As far as in district Kangra out of 146 respondents, 127 respondents agreed with
the Panchayati Raj Institution was the best platform of the democratic process, which
constitute 86.99 per cent of the total sample, whereas 13 respondents who did not agree
democratic process, which constitute 8.90 per cent of the sample, there were 6
respondents who gave no opinion about this context. The percentage of such was 4.11
respectively.
Comparative analysis of two district reveals that the majority of the respondents
think that the Panchayati Raj Institution was the best platform of democratic process. It
was observed that democracy is never complete without the active involvement and
participation of the people at all levels and the institutions.
329
independence are necessary to be able to play an active part in the social and political
life. It is necessary to inspire women to be financially independent.72
According to Pooja Singh found that women issues were not taken up by parties
in a serious manner nor translated into programmes, policies and legislation nor were
they mandated specifically to address issues of women. The idea of 33% reservation for
women in parliament was actively endorsed by most of the major political parties and
this had raised expectation that many more women would be nominated to contest the
elections.76
72
M. P. Dube and Neeta Bora (eds.), op.cit., 1999, pp.142-145.
73
Anuradha Chadha, “Political Participation of Women: A Case Study in India”, International Journal
of Sustainable Development, Vol. 7, No. 2, 2014, p.105.
74
Barsha Kalita, op.cit., 2014, p. 6.
75
A. Thanikodi and M. Sugirtha, op.cit., 2007, p. 594.
76
Pooja Singh, “Representation of Women in Indian Politics”, Third Concept, Vol. 28, No. 327, May
2014, pp. 48-50.
330
Further, Sukhpal Kaur revealed that, great progress has been made in the arena
of women’s rights in theory and policy formation. Women’s rights and equality must
be looked with renewed vigour and vision. It should be an integral part of the
development and welfare policies of states and international organisations. Awareness
campaigns should be organised on women’s rights by civil society and dissemination of
knowledge of the various welfare measures, implemented by the state and international
organisation. The active involvement and association of the civil society in women’s
issues can accelerate the whole process, as it works at the grass-root level. The most
important thing for upliftment of women is to change the mind set of men folk as well
as women folk.77 It is in this regard P.V Krishna suggested that, women elected
representatives needs to be politically enlightened, not only about their rights and
duties, but also the nature of our constitution, democratic process and values, working
of democratic institutions, concept and relevance of local body administration, and
various poverty alleviation programmes and policies meant for women and weaker
sections.78 The table show that respondents views regarding increase women
participation in politics.
Table 5.14
77
Sukhpal Kaur, op.cit., 2009, p.128.
78
P.V. Krishna, “ Participation and Awareness of Elected Women Representatives in PRIs”, Voice
of Research, Vol. 2, No. 4, March 2014, p. 48.
331
59.31
60
Mandi
48.63 Kangra
50
40
Percentage (%)
30 26.03
19.18
20 16.55
14.48
10 5.52
4.14 4.79
1.37
0
Self Education Awareness Economic Others
Confidence Independence
Response
Table 5.14 shows that out of 291 respondents, 157 respondents suggested
increase their self confidence,
confidence which constitute 53.95 per cent of the total sample,
whereas 62 respondents suggested to increase educational level of women and girls,
girls
which constitute 21.31 per cent of the sample, while 49 respondents suggested to
increase awareness
ness which constitute 16.83 per cent of the sample. There were 13
respondents who provided economic independence of women,
women which constitute 4.47
per cent of the sample, while 10 respondents suggested other factors to increase women
participation in politics.
s. The percentage of such respondents was 3.44 of the total
sample.
332
8 respondents suggested other factors to increase women participation in politics. The
percentage of such respondents was 5.52 of the total sample.
The comparative analysis of two districts reveals that the respondents in both
districts suggested many ways and means to enhanced women’s participation in
politics. Majority of respondents suggested to increasing self confidence of women to
participate in politics. To provide political awareness, economic independence and
trainings for elected women representatives. Education brings confidence and develops
leadership qualities apart from enhancing knowledge and skills. It was observed that
after 73rd amendment more women participated in politics at grassroots levels.
Manakshi Sethy and Prabir Sethy observed that, the growth, equality,
democracy, social justice and an enlightened public policy could only be possible in a
political system, if the issue of development and political empowerment is taken up by
the political system in a meaningful way. Women’s representation in politics is regard
as the first step towards women’s empowerment. Even after more than seventy years of
India’s independence, women are still one of the most powerless and marginalized
section of the society. Women leaders tend to pay more attention to issues of health
care, education, and other social development issues than their male counterparts.
Women legislators should work for the empowerment of other women and for giving
them an equal chance in the governance of a state and a country. Though, the
participation in politics, women are making use of power and resources to bring about
necessary changes. Empowerment of women in all spheres, particularly in the political
sphere, is crucial for their advancement and establishment of a true gender equal
society.79 It is in this context Dhruba Hazarika reveals that women are also involving in
79
Manakshi Sethy and Prabir Sethy, “Politics of Representation through Reservation-II As An
Instrument of Women’s Empowerment”, Janta, 2011, p. 13.
333
human development issues of child rearing, education, health, and gender parity. Many
of them have gone into the making and marketing of a range of cottage products-
products
pickles, tailoring, embroidery etc.80
Table 5.15
Respondents Views as Women Political Activist what would be Your Priorities
No. of Respondents
Grand Total
Sr. No Response Mandi Kangra
No. % age No. % age No. % age
38.35
45 Mandi
40 Kangra
35
27.58
Percentage (%)
30
21.92
20.55
19.31
19.18
25
20
11.04
15
10
0
Improving Gender Equality To Remove Others
Education and Corruption
Health Facilities Response
Fig. 5.15: Respondents Views ass Women Political Activist what would be Your
Priorities
80
Dhruba Hazarika, “Women
Women Empowerment in India: A Brief Discussion”,
Discussion” International Journal of
Educational Planning and Administration, Vol. 1, No. 3, 2011, p. 201.
334
Table 5.15 shows that out of 291 respondents 117 respondents indicated that
their main priorities were improving education and health facilities, which constitute
40.21 per cent of the total sample, whereas 72 respondents worked for gender equality,
which constitute 24.74 per cent of the sample. While 58 respondents whose main
priority was to remove corruption, which constitute 19.93 per cent of the sample. There
were 44 respondents women political activists indicated that their main priority was to
solve other issues, which constitute 15.12 per cent of the sample.
Thus, India which is known for the culture and traditions, has also given a place
of respect to women. In the arena of Panchayati Raj Institutions also the rural women,
who were forced to live within the four walls of the house, have come out to take part
in the political process. Though, they are not much educated and not exposed to the
political affairs. They largely depend on male members and officials for advice and
carry on the work. The study reveals that caste is still dominating the politics in both
the district. The study also reveals that, women in higher caste capture powers in
different moulds in comparison to lower caste of the society.
The current study reveals that, several factors impede the political participation
and hence discriminates women. Major among them are caste, illiteracy, family
problem, corruption, male dominance etc. It has also been observed that there is
335
favouritism and corruption both at the level of allotment of the schemes and the time of
extending the benefit to the deserving section of the society. The study also reveals
that, there is too much bureaucratic control over PRIs, so a few respondents demanded
independent bureaucratic structure for the PRIs.
It has been observed during the study that, most of the elected women
representatives engaged in the implementation of policies and programmes were not
aware of the policies and programmes of Panchayati Raj Institutions, which is
responsible for the improper functioning of this institution.
The study also reveals that, while contesting election the women face many
social, economic and political problems. Due to lack of literacy and political awareness,
it has been observed during the study, the major problems faced by women leadership
are; male dominance, caste dominance, lack of awareness and above all family and
social pressure. Majority of the respondents in both districts reveals and believe that
women participation will improve in the long run. It has been major finding of the
study, the female literacy and increased awareness would surely make an enhancement
of women participation in grassroots institutions.
It is found during the study that elected women representatives are engaged in
the implementation of policy and programmes but not aware of the policies and
programmes of PRIs. Thus training of the elected women representatives attached to
the Panchayati Raj Institutions needs proper training. NGOs are also involved in the
training and the capacity building of elected representatives.
The comparative analysis of the two district reveals that majority of the
respondents indicated that, women as a political activists, the priorities were improving
education and health facilities. It was observed that, they gave importance to other
issues like, to work on gender equality, to remove corruption and to solve the other
problems of women and weaker section of society and to make people aware of their
rights and duties and work for the development of the villages.
336
CHAPTER-VI
Women play an important role in determining the destiny of a nation and are
integral parts of society. Their greater involvement in socio-economic and political
affair have becomes more important. However, history reveals that women have not
been given their actual status in the society. Socially, women are ignored a lot in the
society. They have been and still are the victim of various social taboos in general and
particularly in developing country like India. Though, they enjoy equality but this
equality is more in legal terms rather than in reality. Later, demand for political
equality of women started in eighteenth century. In Western Europe and North
America, where the idea of equality of the sexes first took roots, a change in status
preceded legislation and with the important exception of suffrage, was often not
dependent on law. New Zealand became the first country to enfranchise women in
1893. After independence, the Constitution of India has granted women equal rights of
participation in the political process of the country along with equal opportunity and
rights in education and employment. The Indian Constitution guarantees political
equality through the adult franchise.
The first world conference on women was held in 1975 in Mexico City. The
conference along with the United Nations Decade for women (1976-1985) launched a
new era in global efforts to promote the advancement of women by opening a
worldwide dialogue on gender equality. The report of the committee on the status of
women, the observance of International Women’s Year in 1975, the formulation of a
National Plan of Action for Women, setting up of a national committee with the Prime
Minister as the head, proved the concern for women. Since then scholars and policy-
337
makers diverted their attention to the issues of women, which culminated in
establishing a National Commission for Women in 1992 and the National Perspective
Plan for Women (1988-2000).
The first chapter deals with the problems of the study. Also the objectives and
reviews literature on women have been given, which shows that there were only a few
study on the participation of women in state politics: a case study of Himachal Pradesh.
In the present study, among twelve districts, the sample has been drawn from two
districts of Himachal Pradesh i.e. Mandi and Kangra district.
In the second chapter, the historical, social economic and political profile of
Himachal Pradesh has been discussed. Himachal Pradesh came into existence on 15th
April 1948 and achieved statehood on 25th January 1971 and became eighteenth state of
the Indian Union. It is a hilly and mountainous region, which extends over an area of
55, 673 sq. Kms. with a population of 68, 64, 609 persons as per 2011 census.
Himachal is known as Dev Bhumi (The Land of God). It is situated in the heart of the
Western Himalayas. According to the Puranas, Himachal is the Jalandhara Khand of
the Himalayas. The people of the state are considered to be innocent, honest, peace
loving and hardworking. Indian National Congress (INC) and Bhartiya Janta Party
(BJP) are the major political parties, including a few regional parties like Himachal
Vikas Congress (HVC), etc. Himachal Pradesh is predominantly a rural state.
338
Agriculture is the major occupation of the people. Cash crops i.e. Apple, Potato, Peas
Tomato, Ginger, Rajmah, Kiwi Fruits, Citrus Fruits and Floriculture are becoming
popular day by day. Himachal Pradesh has made significant achievements in the field
of economy. Road transport is the main stay of economic activity of the Pradesh.
Himachal Pradesh is one of the most literate and progressive states of the country. The
state has a large potential for the generation of hydel power and tourism etc. during the
past few decades. It helped in linking the mountainous region of Himachal Pradesh to
the plains and there is an increase in the health facilities.
Attempts have been made to study the comparative profile of Mandi and
Kangra district in terms of its socio-economic and political background of women. The
comparative study could be possible only because these factors were taken into
consideration to analyze the participation of women in their respective districts. The
women’s participation could not be studied in isolation without taking into
consideration the society in which they were living, the economic status of family and
the political scenario prevailing in the state. As far as the geographical area of Mandi
district is concerned, i.e.3950 sq. kms. and Kangra district is concerned, it is 5739 sq.
kms. respectively. The population of both district was 9, 99,777 and 15,10,075 Lakhs
respectively as per the Census 2011. The sex ratio is 1007 females for 1000 males in
district Mandi and 1012 females for 1000 males in district Kangra. The literacy rate in
Mandi is 81.53 per cent, the male literacy rate is 89.56 and female literacy rate is 73.66
per cent. At the same time, literacy rate in Kangra is 85.67 per cent, male literacy rate is
91.49 per cent and female literacy rate is 80.02 per cent. As far as the economy of both
district is concerned, the majority of the populations have agrarian background.
The third chapter deals with the political participation of women in India-an
overview. In Rig Vedic, Indian women enjoyed a position of equality in the family and
society. They also participated in the political activities along with men. There was a
gradual decline in their position in the later Vedic and post-Vedic period due to certain
internal changes in the society. The position of women in the Buddhist period could not
have changed very much from that of the earlier days. Nevertheless, there was some
improvement in their condition, due to the basic principles, which Buddha laid down in
his teachings. Buddha made no distinction between a man and a woman regarding the
attainment of spiritual ends. Buddha discarded the Brahmanic rituals, in which the wife
played a secondary part and a barren women or a widow had no place. The education
339
given to female novices and nuns was not different from that imparted to their male
counterparts. The status of women was raised in the Buddhist period, it cannot but be
admitted that, in the monastic order the place accorded to the nuns was lower than that
of the monks.
During medieval period, the women were deprived of different social and
economic rights and were brought out under the overall control of their male family
members. It is witnessed by the prevalent practices of Purdh system, child marriage,
sati system, ban on widow remarriage, polygamy and devadasi etc. Therefore, there
were women rulers and many women excelled in the sphere of politics in the medieval
period e.g. Razia Sultana, Empress Noorjahan, Chand Bibi, Maharani Jija Bai, Rani
Padmini, Rani Laxmi Bai etc. At the advent of British rule in India, women’s position
was worst in the society. The British rule led to a number of socio-religious reforms in
the country. The socio-religious reforms of the nineteenth and twentieth century like
Raja Ram Mohan Roy, Keshav Chander Sen, Swami Dayanand Sarswati, Iswar
Chander Vidya Sagar, Gopal Krishna Gokhale, Pandita Ramabai etc.
340
Prime Minister, Indira Gandhi for about two decades and we have first ever women
President Pratibha Devi Singh Patil, women speaker of Lok Sabha, Meera Kumar and
Sumitra Mahajan, leader of opposition in Lok Sabha Sushma Swaraj and women
President of the largest political party Indian National Congress of the Country, Sonia
Gandhi, we also have several women occupying high positions like those of governors,
chief ministers and minister both at central and state levels but their number is dismal.
Many of them are wives, daughters, sister, and daughters in laws and relatives of
prominent political leaders. The 73rd and 74th Amendment to the Constitution was the
landmark step to empowering women to participate in grassroots democracy.
Subsequently, the study found that the most of the countries of the world have
failed to give due space and representation to women in political life. The participation
of women in the politics is not as good as provided in the constitution. The highest
representation of women in the lower house of national legislatures is found in the
countries like Rwanda, Sweden, Cuba, South Africa, Finland, Iceland, Netherland etc.
whereas in developed countries like USA, UK, Canada Australia, etc. women
representation is the national legislatures is quite low. The data reveals that the
participation of women in politics at national and state level is still marginal. No doubt,
women’s participation in parliament has increased with the passage of time which is
seen in previous Lok Sabha elections. In the first Lok Sabha election held in 1952, only
twenty two women were elected, whereas in the Lok Sabha election held in 2014 the
number of women, who got elected increased to sixty one (11.23%) which is the
highest number till date. Whereas, women’s representation in Rajya Sabha is little as
women’s representation in this house at present is 11.83 per cent. Therefore, this
number is too small in comparison to their voting strength. One of the reasons for low
representation of women in Parliament is that political parties do not give adequate
number of women candidates in the elections. In the past Lok Sabha elections, the
number of women contestants remained very less in comparison to men, despite the
fact, that their percentage of winnability is quite higher as compared to men. Women’s
representation in decision-making bodies is also marginal. Like parliament, women’s
representation at state level has also been noticed few, as the most important positions
such as governor, chief minister and Vidhan Sabha speaker is also still too marginal.
341
Women, who are taking active part in politics, they belong to the well established
political family background and relatives of prominent politicians.
Women constitute about half of the total population in Himachal Pradesh. But
their participation in state legislative Assembly, Parliament and other prominent
decision-making bodies is very low. Women participation in voting is almost equal to
their male counterparts and sometimes, it is even more than that of men. Like
parliamentary elections, in Himachal Pradesh also very few women have contested the
assembly elections. The highest number of women representatives in Himachal Pradesh
legislative Assembly was seven in the year 1998-2003. Like state assembly, women’s
representation in parliament also remained very low from Himachal Pradesh. Till date,
only three women have represented Lok Sabha and seven women remained in Rajya
Sabha from Himachal Pradesh.
Therefore, it was observed that education and governmental efforts has helped
Himachal Pradesh women to reduce infant mortality considerably and improve the
health conditions of women. Thus, compared to the status of women belonging to
India, the women of Himachal Pradesh enjoy not only better educational and health
facilities but also better indices of standard of living. Death rate connected with
delivery has also come down considerably. As far as the security of women is
concerned, transport facilities and accommodations are of paramount importance.
Agriculture is the main occupation of the people of the state. About 69 per cent of the
main workers are engaged in agricultural pursuits. Agriculture is the best with the
disadvantage of small holdings. The villages in Himachal Pradesh are inter-linked with
transport facilities.
The fourth Chapter, deals with the socio-economic and political variables of the
study area of the respondents. The analysis of the socio-economic profile of the
respondents shows that majority of the respondents in the whole sample, as well as
342
Mandi and Kangra district belong to the middle age group of 31-40 years, women take
more part in politics. During the study, it has been analysed that the younger strata of
the respondents is taking active part in the politics in both the district.
As far as the caste factor was concerned, the caste plays a very important role
in the election. The women, who belonged to higher castes, won the elections more
easily than those, who belonged to lower caste. They had to face many problems during
the elections. In district Mandi, most of the respondents belonged to SCs and general
category, whereas in district Kangra, most of the respondents belonged to OBCs and
general category taking active part in politics.
Further, the study found that the majority of the respondents were married,
which showed that younger married women took part in the politics more as compared
to the unmarried and widowed women.
The study reveals that more women belonged to joint family in both the district.
The analysis of the number of children of the respondents, who had two children
participated actively in politics.
From education point of view, the study found that mostly the women
participated in the elections were not highly educated. This indicates that women are
taking part in politics are educated but their educational level is not very high.
Therefore, comparative analysis of both the district reveals that the educational level of
respondents of Mandi was higher than that of Kangra.
Further, the occupation wise analysis reveals that majority of the respondents in
the whole sample, as well as in Mandi and Kangra district are engaged in agricultural
activities. The study reveals that income is also an important indicator of social status.
Income wise analysis shows that, the income of the respondents is comparatively better
in Mandi district than in Kangra district.
The study found that the size of the land holdings of the respondents in Kangra
district was slightly better than that of Mandi district. The landholding size of Himachal
Pradesh is very small.
The study also found that the number of respondents, who were in habit of
reading newspaper was higher in district Mandi than that of Kangra district. The study
reveals that majority of the respondents were aware in habit of hearing news in
343
television or in radio. Hence, it has been revealed that television and radio programmes
are very effective in mobilizing women to participate in politics.
The analysis of both district reveals that the vast majority of the respondents in
both district were interested in politics. The increasing interest of the respondents in
politics shows that the family responsibility. Women are also developing a positive
attitude towards politics.
The study reveals that majority of the respondent’s father and husband did not
participate in politics. It was observed that participation in voting is higher among the
respondents. Majority of the respondents in Kangra district was higher, who casted
their vote in past election as compared to Mandi district.
Regarding the factors kept in mind, while casting the votes. Majority of the
respondents give preference to the candidate’s merits, educational level of the
candidates and party affiliation, while casting their votes. On the other hand, it was
observed that respondents gave less importance to other factors like religion, and caste
etc.
The study reveals that majority of the respondents contested election from the
village level. But state and national level participation is very dismal. It was observed
that village level participation of women were increased after reservation. The study
found that the number of respondents, who believed that they were motivated by their
family members.
The study found that, majority of the respondents in whole sample contested the
elections from the reserved seats for women. It was observed that women generally get
an opportunity to contest the elections only on those seats which were reserved for
women.
344
Party, are dominating the political scene of the state. The share of other political
parties is very negligible.
As far as the awareness and knowledge of the respondents regarding the 73rd
Constitutional Amendment Act and Himachal Pradesh Panchayati Raj Act, 1994 is
concerned, it is found that only 40.21 per cent of the respondents know about these new
acts relating to PRIs. This reveals that majority of the respondents are not much aware
about these acts. However, it is found that on the whole, they are at least aware about
some of the basic provisions of these acts regarding PRIs. An analysis of the role of
PRIs in the empowerment of women reveals that, an overwhelming majority of the
respondents accepted that empowerment of women has taken place only after the
implementation of 73rd Constitutional Amendment Act that facilitated women
participation and involvement in PRIs. This act has played an important role in the
changing society. Majority of the respondents (75.25%) were the view that the
345
participation and representation of women in PRIs has empowered women to extent in
political as well as social and economic spheres.
The study also reveals that majority of the respondents have agreed that,
reservation to women in PRIs has empowered them politically, as it has enhanced their
participation in the democratic process of the grassroots level. Due to reservation, a
large number of women have entered in PRIs and their participation in decision making
process at grass-roots level has increased.
Chapter fifth deals with the hurdles in the participation of women. The women
representatives are also facing many problems, while participating in the political
process. The main problems, which women representatives generally face, while
participating effectively includes lack of knowledge, lack of time due to earning
livelihood, lack of time due to family responsibilities and caring of children and lack
of funds to under to undertake developmental activities. The other problems faced by
women representatives are non-cooperation of the family member’s, lack of political
awakening, lack of interest in politics and lack of education.
The study shows that majority of the respondent’s perceived lack of time due to
family responsibilities, as the major hurdles in political participation of women. It was
observed that the higher castes woman comes into power easily as compared to women,
who belongs to the lower strata of the society. This decreases to a certain extent the
overall participation of women in the rural areas.
The study depicts that, there is corruption in various rural development schemes
in both district, there was favouritism and corruption i.e. during allotment of the
schemes and during extending the benefits to the deserving section of the society. The
beneficiaries do not take full advantage of the scheme. There is corruption at different
levels, which are involved in the process.
It has been observed during the study that, male members played a dominant
role in decision making process and many elected representatives have no identity of
their own and act as mere mouthpieces of powerful men in politics. The study also
reveals that, while contesting elections women faced many problems from their family
members and from the society.
346
The study also finds that majority of the respondents were in favour of
minimum educational qualification for women in politics. Illiterate women were not
able to participate in politics. It is observed that without proper education, they feel
hard to understand the rules of politics.
The majority of the respondents demanded reservation for women in state and
national levels. It was observed that women participation increased at grassroots level
after reservation. But women participation in state and national level is still very low.
On the basis of the entire study following findings have been derived.
• The finding clearly shows that women have very poor knowledge about the
Panchayati Raj Institution and Constitutional provisions, development
programmes and duties of the government official in the local administration.
The main reasons for lack of knowledge are illiteracy, lack of experience and
lack of interest in politics and public life.
• Most of the respondents are of the younger age group. Women are not able to
play an effective role because of low profile, poor orientation, lack of
enthusiasm and lack of political background. Besides, these individual
approaches, social obstacles such as, conservative approach, family
responsibility, and lack of co-operation from family.
• Majority of the respondents were not aware of the provisions and main
implications of the Himachal Pradesh Panchayati Raj Act, 1994. Even after
about twenty three years of the implementation of the Act, they have no idea
about the system. Because the reasons behind it are illiteracy, lack of awareness
and lack of interest.
347
Suggestions
To make the political participation of women more visible and effective the
following suggestions are made:
• It should make an intense drive for legal and political education for women.
Legal system aiming at elimination of all forms of discrimination against
women should be strengthened. In addition to that, awareness level about laws
should be raised among women.
• Syllabi in the school and higher education should be based on the practical
utility by which, the society should be sensitized. Male folk of the society
should realise the importance of female folk.
• Our social structure should be changed, so that women do not have to face
discrimination. Even today, many people think that the political area is not a
suitable place for women. Women will have to understand that their
participation in politics and other activities of life is necessary for them, to
become a significant part of the society and only this feeling can lead to their
development.
348
• Women’s political participation will be possible by creating multi seat
constituencies with women representing a part of it.
• There has to be some electoral reforms, which would curb the role of muscle
and money power in politics.
• To ensure that women are taken seriously in their elected post by allotting
important portfolios and limiting their functions to social welfare and women
and child development.
• All the women organizations should come on a common platform with single
target of passing of Reservation Bill or face anger of women voters in the next
general elections because a critical mass of women is pre-requisite for the
effective political participation of women.
• They can motivate women to contest election and to get a sense of economic
independence and self-confidence. Their participation in these organisations
should be ensured.
349
• There is also an urgent need of the co-operative and positive attitude of
bureaucracy/government officials towards women representatives of the PRIs.
The women development programmes should be linked with more effective
participation of women and also for establishing links between women
representatives and government functionaries at the grassroots level.
• The media both print as well as electronic can play an important role in creating
awareness in the society. It can act as an agent of political socialization for
inculcating the values of gender equality and gender justice.
350
In nutshell, it may be said that the spread of education, political awareness,
competence, willingness, self-confidence, motivation, encouragement and support from
the family, society and political parties will help in bringing women in the mainstream
of political arena.
To sum up, in politics we are still struggling to find a place for women. The
under-representation and absence of women in the positions of power and decision-
making process reinforces their exploitation and deprivation. Women’s greater political
participation and representation is needed to alter the male dominated structure of
political process. Women’s equal participation in political decision-making process is a
fundamental pre-requisite not only for gender equality, gender justice and genuine
democracy but also for the reconstruction of the society. More number of women
representatives means more women will be involved in policy and decision-making
processes and will contribute to stronger attention to women’s issues and will provide
an inspiration to women to work on the vision of a better, more humane and a more
equal society, and they will make meaningful contributions towards integrated national
development. However, more efforts are still required to bring about true equality of
women in political arena in letter and spirit. Women still have a long way to go to
attain political power and gender justice. They have to assert for their de facto political
rights. There is a need for qualitative positive change in the socio-economic and
political structure of the society.
351
BIBLIOGRAPHY
..., The Changing Status of Women in India: Issues and Challenges, New Delhi:
Kanishka Publishers, 2013.
---., Social, Cultural and Economic History of Himachal Pradesh, New Delhi: Indus
Publishing Company, 1998.
Almond, Gabriel A., and Verba, Sidney, The Civic Culture: Political Attitudes and
Democracy in Five Nations, United States of America: Princeton University
Press, 1963.
Altekar, A.S., The Position of Women in Hindu Civilization, 2nd edition, Delhi: Motilal
Banarsidass, Publisher, 1959.
Angus, Campbell, et al., The American Voter, New York: John Wiley and Sons, 1964.
Agneu, Vijay, Elite Women in Indian Politics, New Delhi: Vikas Publishing House,
1986.
Arora, Ramesh K., and Hooja Meenakshi (eds.), Panchayati Raj Participation and
Decentralization, New Delhi: Rawat Publications, 2009.
Ashraf, Ali and Sharma, L.N., Political Sociology, Madras: University Press, 1983.
Ashraf, Ali, Government and Politics of Big Citizens, New Delhi: Concept Publishing
Company, 1977.
353
Attri, Rajender, Introduction to Himachal Pradesh, Shimla: Sarla Publications, 2002.
Baig, Tara Ali, Indian Women Power, 1st Edition, New Delhi: S. Chand and Company,
1976.
Biju, M. R., Dynamics of New Panchayati Raj System: Reflections and Retrospections,
New Delhi: Kanishka Publishers, 1998.
Bala, Raj, The Legal and Political Status of Women in India, New Delhi: Mohit
Publications, 1999.
---., Tribal Women Empowerment and Gender Issues, New Delhi: Kanishka Publishers,
2001.
Basu, Aparna, The Role of Women in the Indian Struggle for Freedom, New Delhi:
Allied Publishers, 1970.
Beteille, Andre, Ideology and Social Science, United Kingdom: Penguin Books 2006.
Bhagi, M. L., Medieval India: Culture and Thought, Ambala: The Indian Publications,
1965.
Bhandari, Asha and Mehta, Rekha, Women, Justice and the Rule of Law, New Delhi:
Serials Publications, 2009.
Barr, Pat and Desmond Ray, Shimla: A Hill Station in British India, Delhi: B.R.
Publishing Corporation, 1978.
Bhatt, B.D. and Sharma, S.R., Women’s Education and Social Development, Delhi:
Kanishka Publishing House, 1992.
Battu, Nagaraju, Empowerment of Women in India: New Strategies, New Delhi: Regal
Publications, 2014.
Buch, Nirmala, From Oppression to Assertion: Women and Panchayats in India, New
Delhi: Routledge, 2010.
354
Buck, Edward J., Shimla: Past and Present, Shimla: Minerva Book House, 1989.
Chahar, S.S. (ed.), Governance at Grassroots Level in India, New Delhi: Kanishka
Publishers, 2005.
Chand, Gian and Puri, Manohar, Trekking in India, New Delhi: International
Publishers India, 1983.
Chaudhary, D.S., and Kar, G.K., Elections and Electoral Behaviour in India, Delhi:
Kanti Publications, 1992.
Chakravarti, Manas and Agrawala, Vidyawati, Women and Politics in India, Ambala
Cantt: The Associated Publishers, 2006.
Chark, Sukhdev Singh, History and Culture of Himalayan States- Himachal Pradesh,
Vol. 2, New Delhi: Light and Life Publishers, 1979.
Chib, Sukhdev Singh, This Beautiful India: Himachal Pradesh, New Delhi: Light and
Life, 1977.
Das, Purdah, The Status of Indian Women, New York: Vanguard Press, 1932.
Desai, Neera, Women in Modern India, Bombay: Vora Publishing House, 1977.
Devi, Laxmi, Women and Development, New Delhi: Anmol Publications, 1998.
Dey, S.K., Panchayati Raj: A Synthesis, Bombay: Asia Publishing House, 1961.
Dowse, Robert E., Political Sociology, London: John Wiley and Sons. 1972.
355
Dube, M.P. and Bora, Neeta (eds.), Social Justice and Women in India, Delhi: Swaraj
Prakashan, 1999.
Dutta, Nandita and Jha, Sumitra, Women and Politics, Delhi: Pacific Books
International, 2014.
Everett, Jana Matson, Women and Social Change in India, New Delhi: B.R. Chawala
Heritage Publishers, 1979.
Everett, Jana Matson and Chawla, B.R., Women and Social Change in India, New
Delhi: Macmillan, 1981.
Ghosh, Ratna and Pramanik, Alok Kumar, Panchayat System in India: Historical,
Constitutional and Financial Analysis, New Delhi: Kanishka Publishers, 2007.
Goel, Madan Lal, Political Participation in Developing Nation: India Bombay, Asia
Publishing House, 1974.
Goel, Shashi, Domestic Violence against Women, Jaipur: Literary Circle, 2013.
Goyal, Omita, Interrogating Women’s Leadership and Empowerment, New Delhi: Sage
Publications, 2015.
Gupta, A.K., Emerging Pattern of Political Leadership: A Case Study of Punjab, New
Delhi: Mittal Publications, 1991.
Gupta, R., Himachal Pradesh General Knowledge, New Delhi: Ramesh Publishing
House, 2004.
2005.
356
Henry, Chafe, William, The American: Her Changing Social, Economic and Political
Roles, New York: Oxford University Press, 1972.
Hutchison, J. and Vogel J. Ph., History of the Panjab Hill States, Vol. 1, Shimla:
Director of Languages and Culture, Himachal Pradesh, 1982.
Indira, R., and Behera, Deepak Kumar, Gender and Society in India, New Delhi:
Manak Publications, 1999.
Jain, C.K., Women Parliamentarians in India, New Delhi: Surjeet Publications, 1993.
Jha, Ashok Kumar, Women and Panchayati Raj Institution, New Delhi: Anmol
Publications, 2004.
Jha, Uma Shankar and Pujari, Prem Lata, (eds.), Indian Women: Tradition, Modernity
and Challenge, Vol. 3, New Delhi: Kanishka Publishers, 1996.
Jha, Uma Shankar, et al., (eds.), Status of Indian Women Crisis and Conflict in Gender
Issues, Vol. 3, New Delhi: Kanishka Publishers, 1998.
Jharta, Bhawana, Women and Politics in India: Impact of Family and Education on
Women Political Activists, New Delhi: Deep and Deep Publications, 1998.
Jena, B.B., and Baral, J.K., Election Politics and Voting Behaviour in India, Delhi:
Discovery Publishing House, 1989.
Jones, W. H. Morris, The Government and Politics of India, New Delhi: Universal
Books, 1989.
Joshi, Savita Thakur (ed.), Women and Development: The Changing Scenario, New
Delhi: Mittal Publications, 1999.
Kaur, Inderjeet, Status of Hindu Women in India, Allahabad: Chugh Publication, 1983.
357
Kiran, Devendra, Changing Status of Women in India, 3rd edition, New Delhi: Vikas
Publishing House, 1994.
Kiran, Usha, Participation of Women in Indian Politics: Gender Justice and Political
Challenge, Delhi: Globus Press, 2016.
Kumar, A., Indian Women: A Historical Perspective, New Delhi: Anmol Publications,
2006.
Kumar, Hajira and Varghese, Jaimon, Women’s Empowerment Issues, Challenges &
Kumar, Raj (ed.), Encyclopaedia of Women and Development, Vol. 5, New Delhi:
Anmol Publications, 2000.
Lal, S., Women in Indian Politics, New Delhi: Kunal Books, 2010.
Lima, Hazel, D., Women in Rural Government: A Study of Maharashtra, New Delhi:
Concept Publishing Company, 1983.
Lipset, Seymour Martin, Political Man, New Delhi: Arnold Heineman, 1973.
McDowell, Linda and Sharp, Joanne P., (eds.), A Feminist Glossary of Human
Geography, New York: Oxford Press, 1999.
358
Maheshwari, S. R., State Government in India, New Delhi: Metropolitan, 1979.
Mathew, George, Panchayati Raj from Legislation to Movement, New Delhi: Concept
Publishing Company, 1995.
Mathur, Hari Mohan, Administering Development in the Third World: Constraints and
Choices, New Delhi: Sage Publications, 1986.
Mehta, Arati, Progressive Women and Political Identity, New Delhi: Kanishka
Publishers, 2004.
Mehta, G.S., Participation of Women in the Panchayati Raj System, New Delhi:
Kanishka Publishers, 2008.
Mehta, S.K. and Chhabra, A.R., Political Theory, Jallandhar: New Academic
Publishing Company, 2005.
Mishra, R.C., Women in India towards Gender Equality, Delhi: Authors Press, 2006.
Mishra, S.N., Politics and Society in Rural India, New Delhi: India Publications, 1980.
Mishra, S.N., Pattern of Emerging Leadership in Rural India, Patna: Associated Book
Agencies, 1977.
Mishra, R.B., and Singh, Chandrapal, Indian Women Challenges & Change, New
Delhi: Commonwealth, 2017.
Mitra, Jyoti, (ed.), Women Empowerment and Challenges of Changed, New Delhi:
Kanishka Publisher, 1997.
Misra, Preeti, Domestic Violence against Women: Legal Control and Judicial
Response, New Delhi: Deep and Deep Publications, 2007.
Mitto, Hari Krishan, India-The Land and the People-Himachal Pradesh, Delhi:
National Book Trust, 1978.
Nagendra, S., Ambedkar and Nagendra, Shilaja, Women Empowerment and Panchayati
Raj, Jaipur: ABD Publishers, 2005.
Narayan, Shriman (ed.), The Selected Works of Mahatma Gandhi, Vol. 6, Ahmadabad:
Navjivan Publishing House, 1968.
359
Negi, S.S., Himachal Pradesh: The Land and People, New Delhi: Indus Publishing
Company, 1993.
---., Discovering the Himalaya, Vol. 2, New Delhi: Indus Publishing Company, 1998.
Nehru, J. L., Glimpses of World History, New Delhi: Asia Publishing House, 1967.
Neshla, Atrocities Against Women, New Delhi: Herman Publishing House, 1997.
Palanithurai, G., et al. (eds.), Major Issues in New Panchayati Raj System, New Delhi:
Kanishka Publishers, 1997.
Palmer, Norman D., Elections and Political Development: The South Asian Experience,
New Delhi: Vikas Publication, 1976.
Pandya, Rameshwari (ed.), Women in India: Issues, Perspectives and Solutions, New
Delhi: New Century Publications, 2007.
---(ed.)., Women Welfare and Empowerment in India, New Delhi: New Century
Publications, 2008.
Pandhy, K.S., and Satapathy, Purna Chandra, Tribal India, New Delhi: Ashish
Publishing House, 1989.
Parvathamma, C., Scheduled Castes and Tribes: A Socio-Economic Survey, New Delhi:
Ashish Publishing House, 1984.
Parmar Y.S., Himachal Pradesh: Its Proper Shape and Status, Shimla: Directorate of
Public Relations Himachal Pradesh, 1965.
Prasad, R.C., Democracy and Development, New Delhi: Rachna Prakashan, 1971.
360
Raj, Maithreyi Krishna (ed.), Women’s Studies in India: Some Perspective, Bombay:
Popular Prakashan, 1986.
Rajput, Pam and Swarup, Hem Lata (eds.), Women and Globalisation: Reflections,
Options and Strategies, New Delhi: Ashish Publishing House, 1994.
Rout, Himanshu Sekher and Panda, Prasant Kumar (eds.), Gender and Development in
India: Dimensions and Strategies, New Delhi: New Century Publications,
2008.
Roy, Kalpana, Women in Indian Politics, New Delhi: Rajat Publications, 1999.
Ranganath, The Changing Pattern of Leadership in Uttar Pradesh, New Delhi: Indian
Academy of Social Sciences, 1971.
Sachchidananda, The Tribal Voter in Bihar, New Delhi: National Publishing House,
1976.
Sachidananda and Ramesh, P.S., Women Right: Myth and Reality, Jaipur: Printwell
Publishers, 1984.
Seshadri, K., Political Linkages and Rural Development, New Delhi: National
Publishing House, 1976.
Shah, Ghanshyam, Social Movement in India: A Review of Literature, New Delhi: Sage
Publications, 1990.
Sharma, K.L., Indian Social Structure and Change, Jaipur: Rawat Publications, 2007.
361
Sharda, Mridula, Evolution of Panchayati Raj in India: From Traditional to
Constitutionalize Panchayats, New Delhi: Kanishka Publishers, 2010.
Sharma, Ram Sharan, Aspects of Political Ideas and Institutions in Ancient India,
Delhi: Motilal Banarsidass, 1968.
---., Political Ideas and Institutions in Ancient India, New Delhi: Mittal Banarsi Dass,
1959.
Sharma, Ranbir, Party Politics in a Himalayan State, New Delhi: National Publishing
House, 1977.
Sharma, Shakuntla, Grassroot Politics and Panchayati Raj, New Delhi: Deep and Deep
Publication, 1994.
Sharma, Usha and Sharma, B.M., Women and Profession, New Delhi: Commonwealth
Publishers, 1995.
Shukla, A.K., Women Chief Ministers in Contemporary India, New Delhi: APH
Publishing Corporation, 2007.
Singh, Arun Kumar, Political Orientation of People in Rural India, New Delhi: Mittal
Publications, 1987.
Singh, Dharam Raj, Rural Leadership among Scheduled Castes, Allahabad: Chugh
Publications, 1985.
Singh, Har Gopal, A Period of Hot Politics in Himachal Pradesh and Other Notes,
Solan: Har Gopal Singh Publishers, 1996.
Singh, Reena, Gender Composition: Values, Preferences and Behaviour, New Delhi:
Rawat Publications, 2001.
Singh, Shiv Raj, Bureaurcacy and Rural Development: Policy Making, Planning and
Implementation, New Delhi: Mittal Publications, 1989.
Singh, Anupama, Bureaucracy at the Grassroots Level in India, New Delhi: Kanishka
Publishers, 2006.
Singh, J.L., Women and Panchayati Raj, New Delhi: Sunrise Publications, 2005.
362
Singh, Mian Goverdhan, Social Cultural and Economic Survey of Himachal Pradesh,
Simla: Minerva Book House, 1985.
---., Himachal Pradesh History, Culture & Economy, Shimla: Minerva Publishers,
2010.
Singh, Nishant, Indian Constitution and Women, New Delhi: Omega Publications,
2011.
Singh, R.S., Rural Elite Entrepreneurship and Social Change, Jaipur: Rawat
Publications, 1985.
Singh, S.K., and Singh, A.K., OBC Women Status and Educational Empowerment,
Lucknow: New Royal Book Company, 2004.
Singh, Sarita, Women in Different Ages: Traditional to Modern, New Delhi: Omega
Publications, 2015.
Singh, Sarbjeet and Dodh, Pankaj, (eds.), Gender Justice and Women Empowerment:
An Integrated Approach, New Delhi: Regal Publications, 2013.
Singh, Shiv Raj, et al.,(eds.), Public Administration in the New Millennium: Changing
and Prospects, New Delhi: Anamika Publishers, 2003.
Singh, Tejvir and Kaur Jagdish (eds.), Himalayas, Mountains and Men, Lucknow: Print
House, 1983.
Singh, V.B., Profiles of Political Elites in India, Delhi: Ritu Publications, 1984.
Sinha, A.K., Panchayati Raj and Empowerment of Women, New Delhi: Northern Book
Centre, 2004.
Sinha, Anjana Maitra, Women in a Changing Society, New Delhi: Ashish Publishing
House, 1993.
Sinha, Ajit Kumar (ed.), New Dimensions of Women Empowerment, New Delhi: Deep
and Deep Publications, 2008.
363
Srinivas, M.N., Caste in Modern India and Other Essays, Bombay: Asia Publishing
House, 1962.
Tandon, Neeru, Feminism: A Paradigm Shift, New Delhi: Atlantic publishers, 2008.
Thakur, Minni, Women Empowerment through Panchayati Raj Institutions, New Delhi:
Concept Publishing Company, 2010.
Thomas, P., Indian Women through the Ages, Bombay: Asia Publishing House, 1964.
Trivedi, B.R., Constitutional Equality and the Women’s Right, New Delhi: Cyber Tech
Publication, 2010.
Tripathi, N.M., Minority and Law, Delhi: Indian Law Institute, 1972,
Vali, Mastan, Women and Politics, New Delhi: Anmol Publications, 2002.
Verma, B.M., Rural Leadership in a Welfare Society: A Study in Social Status and Role
Performance, New Delhi: Mittal Publications, 1994.
---., Shimla Hill States in 19th Century, New Delhi: B.R. Publishing Corporation, 2008.
Varma, Sudhir, Women’s Struggle for Political Space, Jaipur: Rawat Publications,
1997.
Verba, Sidney and Nie, Norman H., Participation in America: Political Democracy
and Social Equality, New York: Harper and Row Publishers, 1972.
Verma S.P. and Narain Iqbal, Voting Behaviour in a Changing Society: A Case Study
of the Fourth General Election in Rajasthan, Delhi: National Publishing
House, 1973.
364
Vidya, K.C., Political Empowerment of Women at the Grassroots, New Delhi:
Kanishka Publishers, 1997.
Vij, Madhu, et al., Women’s Studies in India: A Journey of 25Years, Jaipur: Rawat
Publications, 2014.
Articles
Ahmed, Imtiaz, “Women in Politics”, in Jain, Devaki (ed.), Indian Women, New
Delhi: Publications Division, 1975.
Aiyar, Mani Shankar, “Towards Holistic Panchayat Raj”, Yojana, Vol. 57, August
2013.
Altekar, Anant Sadashiv, “Ideal and Position of Indian Women in Social Life”, in
Swami Madhavananda and Ramesh Chandra Majumdar (eds.), Great Women
of India, Almora: Advaita Ashrama, 1953.
Anand, Neeta, “Working Women: Issues and Problems”, Yojana, Vol.47, March 2003.
Asnal, Wan, et al., “Political Attitude and Voting Behaviour”, International Journal of
Humanities and Management Sciences, Vol. 1, No. 1, 2013.
365
Anwer, M. Tarique, “Development of Female Education”, Third Concept, Vol. 31, No.
362, April 2017.
Banday, Mohd Muzaffar and Ganesan, P., “Economic Empowerment of Rural Muslim
Women in Kashmir Valley”, Third Concept, Vol. 30, No. 356, October 2016.
Bari, Farza, “Women’s Political Participation; Issues and Challenges”, Paper Presented
in Expert Group Meeting, Division for the Advancement of Women (DAW),
Bangkok, Thailand, 8-11 November, 2005.
Bajpai, B.K., “Knowledge attitude, Behaviour and Electoral Practises of Voters in Uttar
Pradesh”, The Indian Journal of Political Science, Vol. 73, No. 4, October-
December 2012.
Begum, S. Mehartaj, “Women Rights and Rural Employment”, Kurukshetra, Vol. 48,
No. 7, April 2000.
Bhuyan, Dasarathi, “Participation in Panchayati Raj”, Yojana, Vol. 52, October 2008.
Bora, Neeta and Padalia, Munni, “Involvement of Women in India’s Political Process”,
in M.P. Dube and Neeta Bora (eds.), Social Justice and Women in India,
Delhi: Swaraj Prakashan, 1999.
Bhan, Chander and Singh Raj, “Women’s Empowerment for Gender Equality: A
Functional Analysis,” Kurukshetra, Vol. 49, No. 11, August 2001.
Bhoite, Anuradha, “Women and Democracy in India”, Kerala Sociologist, Vol. 16,
December 1988.
Bhaskar, Manu, “Women and Grass-root Politics: Theoretical Issues and Social
Concern of Kerala Women”, South Asian Journal of Socio-Political Studies,
Vol. 1, No.1, January-June 2000.
366
Buch, Nirmala, “Panchayat and Women”, Kurukshetra, Vol. 49, No.7, April 2001.
Chakra, Barti, Bidyut, “Gender Question in Freedom Struggle”, Mainstream, Vol. 43,
No. 12, March 2005.
Chakravorti, Robi, “Asia’s Women leaders and Dynastic Charisma”, Economic and
Political Weekly, Vol. 34, No. 4, October 1999.
367
Chhetri, Durga Prasad, “Women in Public Sphere: An Enquiry into Women’s
Representation and Participation in Politics”, American International Journal
of Research in Humanities, Arts and Social Sciences, Vol. 6, No.1, March-May
2014.
Chaturvedi, S.K., “Women Participation in Political Process”, in M.P. Dube and Neeta
Bora (eds.), Social Justice and Women in India, Delhi: Swaraj Prakashan,
1999.
Chattopadhyay, Swati, “Political Participation of Women”, Third Concept, Vol. 29, No.
339, May 2015.
Chhibber, Bharti, “Women and the Indian Political Process”, Mainstream, Vol. 48, No.
18, April 2010.
Daddamani, Rajender B., “Indian Democracy: Reality or Myth?”, Third Concept, Vol.
22, No. 256, June 2008.
Devi Annapurna and Pati, N. M., “Women in State Politics (Orissa),” Political Science
Review, Vol. 20, 1981.
368
Dhall Manju, “Amartya Sen and the Women’s Year of Empowerment”, Mainstream,
Vol. 40, No.19, April 2002.
Dogra, Bharat, “Women Make a Remarkable Contribution,” Mainstream, Vol. 41, No.
27, June 2003.
Dutta, Suvrokamal, “In the Name of Women Unite the Adi Shakti, Do Not Divide It”,
Mainstream, Vol. 48, No.13, March 2010.
Gaonkar, Maya S., “Political Empowerment of Women in India,” Third Concept, Vol.
24, No. 278, April 2010.
Gautam, Jyoti, “Gender Issues in Higher Education”, Third Concept, Vol. 29, No. 345,
November 2015.
Geetamma, K., “Corruption in India: Causes and Remedies”, Third Concept, Vol. 30,
No. 360, February 2017.
Ghatak, Sandip Kumar, “Political Participation of Women of West Bengal its Nature
and Extent”, The Indian Journal of Political Science, Vol. 71, No. 1, January-
March 2010.
369
Hazarika, Dhruba, “Women Empowerment in India: A Brief Discussion”, International
Journal of Educational Planning and Administration, Vol. 1, No. 3, 2011.
Hedlund, Ronald D., “The Electability of Women Candidates: The Effects of Sex Role
Stereotypes, The Journal of Politics, Vol. 41, No. 2, 1979.
Iyer, Lakshmi, “The Electoral Participation of Women’’, Yojana, Vol. 58, July 2014.
Jain, Nisha, “Women’s Reservation Bill and Gender Justice”, Mainstream, Vol. 48, No.
18, April 2010.
Kailash, K. K.,“Regional Parties in the 16th Lok Sabha Elections Who Survived and
Why?”, Economic and Political Weekly, Vol. 49, No. 39, September 2014.
Kamala, Prasad, “Lok Sabha Election 2009: Emerging Trends in National Politics”,
Mainstream, Vol. 47, No.12, March 2009.
Kathalgu, K., “Indian Women in Development Perspective”, Kurukshetra, Vol. 56, No.
11, September 2008.
370
Kaur, Sukhpal, “Women’s Rights: A Historical Perspective”, The Indian Journal of
Political Science, Vol. 70, No. 1, January-March 2009.
Khan, Azam and Alam, Tosib, “Empowerment of Rural Women and Local Self-
Governance”, in Asha Bhandari and Rekha Mehta, Women, Justice and the
Rule of Law, New Delhi: Serials Publications, 2009.
Khosla,Tamanna, “Is Democracy Bad for Women?”, Mainstream, Vol. 51, No.18,
April 2013.
Kondo, Norio, “The 15th Lok Sabha Election: Resurgance of Congress?”, Social Action
a Quarterly Review of Social Trends, Vol. 59, No. 3, July-September 2009.
Kumar, Ashutosh and Sekhon, Jagroop Singh, “Punjab: Resurgence of the Congress”,
Economic and Political Weekly, Vol. 44, No. 39, September 2009.
Kumar, Ramesh, “Political Parties in India and the United Sates: A Comparative
Analysis”, The Indian Journal of Political Science, Vol. 72, No.2, April-June
2011.
Kumar, Vijay, “Women’s Reservation Bill”, Mainstream, Vol.48, No.18, April 2010.
371
Kunnumkal, Mathew C, “Grassroots Level Democracy in Indian an Assessment”,
Yojana, Vol.55, February 2011.
Laitonjam, Muhindro Singh, “Political Morality and Ethics in Indian Polity”, The
Indian Journal of Political Science, Vol. 69, No. 2. April- June 2008.
Laitonjam, Reena, “Women Empowerment in Manipur”, Third Concept, Vol. 27, No.
314, April 2013.
Lee, Marcia Manning, “Why Few Women Hold Public Office: Democracy and Sexual
Roles”, Political Science Quarterly, Vol. 91, No. 2, 1976.
Mall, Sangeeta, “Women’s Civil and Political Rights”, Mainstream, Vol., No. ,
December 2003.
Manisha, M., “Why do We Need Parliament?” Mainstream, Vol. 51, No. 12, March
2013.
Mathew, George, “Enemies of Panchayati Raj”, Mainstream, Vol. 40, No.12, March
2002.
Mathiraj, S.P. and Nagarajan, P.S., “Empowerment of Women in India: Then and
Now”, Third Concept, Vol. 24, No. 280, June 2010.
Mirza, Amna, “Women Reservation Bill Imperfect yet Perfect”, Mainstream, Vol. 48,
No.13, March 2010.
372
Mohan, Surendra, “Struggle for Women’s Empowerment Suffers Blows as Warrior
Leaders Depart”, Mainstream, Vol. 40, No.11, March 2002.
Nair, V. Deepa, “Status of Women in Andhra Pradesh A Paradigm Shift”, Man and
Development, Vol. 32, No. I, March 2010.
Nandal, Vikas and Rajnish, “Status of Women through Ages in India”, International
Research Journal of Social Sciences, Vol. 3, No. 1, January 2014.
Narayanan, Usha, “Women in Panchayat: The Path Ahead”, Mainstream, Vol. 48,
No.13, March 2010.
---., “Women in Panchayats: The Path Ahead,” Mainstream, Vol. 34, No. 50,
November 1996.
Narasimhan, Sakuntala, “Women’s Role in Gram Sabha”, Kurukshetra, Vol. 48, No.1,
October 1999.
373
Nayyar, Benu, “Status of Women in 21st Century India”, in Meenu Agarwal (ed.),
Women Empowerment: Today’s Vision for Tomorrow’s Mission, New Delhi:
Mahamaya Publishing House, 2007.
Ojha, Purnima, “Women’s Issues in India: Role and importance of Media”, The
Indian Journal of Political Science, Vol. 72, No. 1, January-March 2011.
Ojha, Suman, “Reservation of Women in the Indian Parliament: Lessons from Other
Countries”, The Indian Journal of Political Science, Vol. 70, No. 2, April- June
2009.
Omvedt, Gail, “Women in Governance in South Asia”, Economic and Political Weekly,
Vol. 40, No. 44-45, October-November 2005.
Prema, A., “Women Status in India”, Indian Streams Research Journal, Vol. 2, No.1,
February 2012.
Perumal, M., et al., “Empowering Rural Women Through Self- Help Groups”, in Asha
Bhandari and Rekha Mehta (eds.), Women, Justice and the Rule of Law, New
Delhi: Serials Publications, 2009.
Pandit, Latha A., “Political Leadership of Women: Constraints and Challenges”, The
Indian Journal of Political Science, Vol. 71, No. 4, October-December 2010.
374
Pathak, Avijit, “Looking Beyond Reservation Need for the Feminisation of Politics”,
Mainstream, Vol. 36, No, 36, August 1998.
Puri, Bal Raj, “Permanent Resident Bill of J&K is Anti-Women”, Mainstream, Vol. 48,
No.13, March 2010.
Rath, Saswatee, “Feel Good Factor and Condition of Women in India”, Mainstream,
Vol. 42, No. 21, May 2004.
Ray, Suranjita, “Experiencing the Indian Democratic State”, Mainstream, Vol. 48,
No.18, April 2010.
Sapra, Ritu and Khatter, Divya, “Women Empowerment in India”, Third Concept, Vol.
28, No. 325, March 2014.
Satpathi, Sayantani, “The Impact of the Electronic Media on the Modern Indian Voter:
A Study of the Post Liberalization Era”, Global Media Journal, Summer Issue,
June 2011.
375
Shettar, Rajeshwari M., “A Study on Issues and Challenges of Women Empowerment
in India”, Journal of Business and Management, Vol. 17, No. 4, April 2015.
Sridharan E., “Class Voting in the 2014 Lok Sabha Elections the Growing Size and
Importance of the Middle Classes”, Economic and Political Weekly, Vol. 49,
No. 39, September 2014.
Sachar, Rajindar, “Need for a Mass Social Movement”, Mainstream, Vol. 41, No. 28,
June 2003.
Sachar, Rajindar, “Pass Immediately Women’s Reservation Bill”, Mainstream, Vol. 48,
No.13, March 2010.
Sain, Sunil Kumar and Kaware, Sudhir Sudam, “A Present Status of Women Education
in India”, Educationia Confab, Vol. 2, No. 9, September 2013.
Smith, Barbara, “Racism and Women Studies,” in Hull, G., et.al (ed.), But Some of us
Are Brave, New York: The Feminist Press, 1982.
376
Sayeed, S. M, “Women’s Participation in UP Politics: A Study of Politics Attitudes and
Performance of the Women Members of the UP Assembly”, The Indian
Journal of Political Science, Vol.32, No. 2, April-June 1971.
Sharma, Anju, “Violence and Safety Scenario of Women- A World Wide Concern”, in
Mamta Mokta (ed.), Women Saftey & Security: Issues Challenges, Chandigarh:
Mohindra Publishing House, 2015.
Sharma, Kavita, “Political Advertising and Voting Behaviour in India: The Mediating
Role of Voting Decision Involvement”, International Journal of Law and
Social Sciences, Vol.1, No.1, January 2012.
Sharma, Mamta, “NCW: Twenty Years of Empowering Women”, Yojana, Vol. 56,
June, 2012.
377
Sharma, Shailendar, “Access to Education”, Yojana, Vol. 60, January 2016.
Sharma, T.R., “Himachal Pradesh: Two Party Competition in a Small State”, Journal
of Indian School of Political Economy, Vol. 15, No. 1-2, January-June 2003.
Srinivsan, R., “Emerging Trends in NGO Sector- A Study of Tamil Nadu”, The Indian
Journal of Political Science, Vol. 66, No.2, April-June 2005.
Singh, Ajit Pal, et al., “Women’s Participation in National Politics as Seen in the Lok
Sabha Election 2009”, Mainstream, Vol. 48, No. 21, May 2010.
Singh, Inderjeet, “Globalization: Its Impact on Women Human Right in India”, The
Indian Journal of Political Science, Vol. 69, No. 2, April- June 2008.
Singh, Mohindra and Kumar Vijay, “State Control Over Panchayati Raj Institutions”,
The Indian Journal of Political Science, Vol. 66, No. 2, April- June 2005.
Singh, Prem, “World Social forum: Myth and Reality”, Mainstream, Vol. 42, No. 5,
January 2004.
Singh, Pooja, “Representation of Women in Indian Politics”, Third Concept, Vol. 28,
No. 327, May 2014.
378
Singh, Rakesh K.,“Elected Women Representatives in Panchayat Raj”, Social Action,
Vol. 62, January-March 2012.
Sinha, Chandni, “Education and Empowerment of Women”, Third Concept, Vol. 21,
No. 243, May 2007.
Srinivasan, “Women Empowerment and Parliament in India”, Third Concept, Vol. 28,
No. 331, September 2014.
Srivastva, Rashmi, “The Role of Women in Indian Politics”, Political Science Review,
Vol. 21, No.4, 1982.
Swarup, Hem Lata, et.al, “Women’s Political Engagement in India: Some Critical
Issues”, in Nelson, Barbara and Chowdhury, Najma (eds.), Women and Politics
World Wide, Delhi: Oxford University Press, 1997.
Swain, Pratap Chandra, “Dynamics of the Indian Party System”, The Indian Journal of
Political Science, Vol. 69, No. 1, January-March 2008.
379
Thangamani, K., “Education for Women”, in Rameshwari Pandya (ed.), Women
Welfare and Empowerment in India, New Delhi: New Century Publications,
2008.
Thanikodi, A. and Sugirtha, M., “Status of Women in Politics”, The Indian Journal of
Political Science, Vol. 68, No. 3, July-September 2007.
Tiwari, Nupur, “Women and Panchayati Raj”, Yojana, Vol. 56, June 2012.
Verma, Rahul and Sardeshari, Shreyas, “ Does Media Exposure Affect Voting
Behaviours and Political Preference in India”, Economic and Political Weekly,
Vol. 49, No. 39, September 2014.
Vyas, Girija, “Women Empowerment, Remedy for Social Elevation”, Yojana, Vol. 52,
September 2008.
Yadagiri, R., “Growth of Regional Political Parties in India: Influence and Impact on
Federal System”, in D. Sundar Ram (ed.), Federal System and Coalition
Government in India- Conflict and Consensus in Centre-State Relations, New
Delhi: Kanishka Publishers, 2007.
Government Reports
380
Government of Himachal Pradesh, Socio-Economic Indicators of Himachal Pradesh,
Economics and Statistics Department, Shimla: Himachal Pradesh, 2014-15.
Government of India, Women Members of Rajya Sabha, New Delhi: Rajya Sabha
Secretariat, 2009.
381
Himachal Past, Present and Future, Directorate of Correspondence Courses Himachal
Pradesh University, Shimla, 1975.
Gazetteer of the Mandi State, New Delhi: Indus Publishing Company, 1920.
Gazetteer of the Kangra District, New Delhi; Indus Publishing Company, 1883-84.
Himachal Pradesh Panchayati Raj Act, 1994 (Act No.4 of 1994) Section 8.
Convention on the Political Rights of Women, 193 U.N.T.S. 135, enforced on July 7,
1954, Article 3.
382
G. A. res. 34/80. 3U. N. GAOR. supp., (No.6) at 193 UN Doc. A/34/46, entered into
force September 3, 1981.
Thakur, Naresh K., “Women Get a Raw Deal in this Election, Again”, Hindustan
Times, Accessed on 29-10-2017.
Encyclopaedia
New Encyclopedia Britannica, Inc. William Benton Publishers, Vol. 14, New York,
1943.
International Encyclopaedia of Social Science, Vol. IX, New York: McMillan Co., The
Free Press, 1986.
The New Encyclopaedia, Britannica, Inc William Benton, Publishers, Vol. 14, 1993.
Asian Survey
383
The Indian Journal of Public Administration
Vidhanmala
Kurukshetra
Mainstream
Seminar
Third Concept
Yojana
Newspapers
Amar Ujala
Divya Himachal
Times of India
The Tribune
Hindustan times
Indian Express
Websites
www.eci.nic.in
www.ceohimachal.nic.in
www.lokniti.Org.
http:/ / inflibnet.ac.in
http:/ / Wikipedia.com
http:/ /www.epw.org.in
http: / / www.orbi.org.in.
384
PARTICIPATION OF WOMEN IN STATE
POLITICS: A CASE STUDY OF
HIMACHAL PRADESH
A THESIS
DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY
IN
POLITICAL SCIENCE
2018
CERTIFICATE
This is to certify that Ms. Jai Kiran a research scholar, Department of Political
Science, Himachal Pradesh University, Shimla-5 has completed her Ph.D. thesis
entitled, “Participation of Women in State Politics: A Case Study of Himachal
Pradesh” under my supervision and guidance. To the best of my knowledge, it is an
original piece of research work and no part of it has not been submitted elsewhere for
any degree or diploma. In my opinion the thesis is worthy of consideration for award of
the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in social sciences. The assistance and help received
during the course of this work and sources of literature have been duly acknowledged.
She has completed the following requirements as per the UGC-regulations,
2009 for the Ph. D. degree:
a) Course work as per the UGC/ University rules.
b) Residential requirements of the University.
c) Regularly submitted six-monthly progress report.
d) Presented her work in the departmental committee.
e) Published two research papers in the referred research journal and edited book.
I recommend the thesis for submission and evaluation.
The term ‘political participation’ has a very wide meaning. It is not only related
to ‘Right to Vote’, but simultaneously relates to participation in: decision making
process, political activism, political consciousness, etc. Women in India participate in
voting, run for public offices and political parties at lower levels more than men.
Political activism and voting are the strongest areas of women’s political participation.
To combat gender inequality in politics, the Indian government has instituted
reservations for seats in local governments. Women turnout during India’s 2014
parliamentary general elections was 65.7 per cent, compared to 67.1 per cent turnout
for men. Women have held the posts of president and prime minister in India, as well as
chief ministers of various states. Indian voters have elected women to numerous state
legislative assemblies and national parliament for many decades.
Women’s organizations in India first began to emerge in the early 19th century
and later in the 1970s after a period of limited activity from the 1950s to 1970s. One of
the earliest women’s organization, Bharat Stree Mahamandal, formed in 1910 and
focused on helping women escape oppression from men. Women’s associations had
traditionally began with the help of men giving few women access to work and
education, while limiting the expansion of traditional gender roles. In 1927, the All
India Women’s Conference (AIWC) was formed to advocate for women’s education
and was helpful in the passage of the Hindu Code of Bills between 1952 and 1960.
Women were also active in the freedom movement in protesting British colonial rule
over Indian holding protests and public meetings in support of independence. The new
wave of feminism in the 1970s was in response to gender inequality issues and stagnant
development in India. The Committee on the Status of Women in India released a
report in 1974, and had a significant influence in the re-emergence of activism towards
gender equality.
The present study has been divided into six chapters. The first chapter deals
with the introduction of the topic, problem formulation, objective of the study, universe
of the study, review of existing literature, research design and methodology used for the
undertaken study.
The second chapter deals with the socio-economic and political profile of
Himachal Pradesh. This study gives us little attention to the details of socio, cultural
and economic life of the people of the state.
The third chapter deals with the political participation of women-an overview.
This chapter gives us reflection on the historical background of women in India.
During ancient period women held a high place of respect in the society, as mentioned
in Rig-Veda and other scriptures. The Vedic era was the golden era so far as
equilibrium of status and freedom between men and women, with rights of knowledge
and freedom to marry is concerned. The Rig-Vedic women played significant role in
family, society and even in political life. The position of women especially registered as
gradual decline after the advent of Muslim rule in India. The study further deals with
the various initiatives undertaken after independence for bringing improvement in the
socio-economic status and empowerment of women.
The fourth chapter deals with the socio-economic and political variables in the
participation of the women. This chapter gives us the reflection on the historical
background and political participation of the women in Himachal Pradesh.
The fifth chapter deals with the hurdles in the participation of women in
politics. The lack of women’s participation in political process can be attributed to
various socio-economic constraints under our traditional social set-up.
The last chapter gives us the summary of the whole study, along with
conclusions and certain suggestions for the women participation in the political
process.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
I want to express my deep gratitude towards all those respondents who have
been a source of information and without their kind cooperation; it was not possible
to carry out my research work.
Dated:
Dated: .............
..................
............... (Jai Kiran)
Kiran)
Place: …..…
..….....….
.....….
CONTENTS
PAGE
CHAPTERS TITLE
NO.
I THE PROBLEM OF THE STUDY 1-74
• Review of Literature 22
• Hypothesis 68
• Sampling 70
• Methodology 73
• Scheme of Chapterisation 74
1
Shashi Ranjan Tewari, “People’s Participation: A Theoretical Framework”, in Ramesh K. Arora, and
Meenakshi Hooja (eds.), Panchayati Raj, Participation and Decentralization, Jaipur: Rawat
Publications, 2009, pp. 23-24.
1
There could be three modes of participation- direct at the community or project
level, indirect or mobilisation from above. In case of direct participation the main types
include turn out in elections, contesting elections and getting elected, taking part in
election campaigns, contacting or trying to influence government policies, associational
membership. The forms of participation which engage people between elections are
important. There could be two kinds of participation namely institutional and non-
institutional. The institutional participation refers to participation in the formal
structures while non-institutional participation refers to participation in meetings,
processions, rallies etc.2
2
Prabhat Dutta, Decentralisation, Participation and Governance, Delhi: Kalpaz Publications, 2006,
p.19.
3
J.L. Singh, Women and Panchayati Raj, New Delhi: Sunrise Publications, 2007, p.375.
4
Bhawana Jharta, Women and Politics in India: Impact of Family and Education on Women Political
Activists, New Delhi: Deep and Deep Publications 1998, p.10.
5
Seymour Martin Lipset, Political Man, Bombay: VFS, 1959, p. 82.
6
Hari Mohan Mathur, Administering Development in the Third World: Constraints and Choices, New
Delhi: Sage Publications, 1986, p.19.
2
political science since the days of Plato. The Aristotle defined citizen, as one who
shares in the administration of justice and in the holding of office. The declaration of
French Revolution of 1789 says that all citizens have the right to take part personally or
by their representatives in the formulation of law. The Marxists tradition also argued
about universal political participation as a means and end of the manifestation of
human freedom. The political participation generally requires two decisions. One must
decide to act or not to act, and one must also decide the direction of this action. The
participation of active citizens in the process of political decision making lies at the
core of any democratic system.7
7
Kalpana Roy, Women and their Environment, Vol. I, Delhi: Rajat Publications, 1999, pp. 289-291.
8
Herbert Mcclosky, “Political Participation”, International Encyclopaedia of the Social Science, Vol.
12, New York: Macmillan, 1968, p. 253.
9
Report: Development Cooperation, The Role of Development Cooperation in Participatory
Development, Paris: DECD Publication, 1973, pp. 45-46.
10
Canadian International Development Authority (CIDA), Mainstreaming Participatory Development:
Experiences and Lessons of the Inter Agency Group on Participation”, Draft Working Paper, CIDA,
1997, p. XIII.
11
United Nations Development Programme (UNDP), Human Development Report, New York: Oxford
University Press, 1993, p. 21.
12
D. Sundar Ram (ed.), Dynamics of Grass-roots Governance in India: Dreams and Realities, Vol.2,
New Delhi: Kanishika Publishers, 2007, p.46.
3
According to Norman D. Palmer, “Political participation as an involvement of
citizens in such political activities which directly or indirectly influence the behaviour
and actions of private citizens by which they seek to influence or to support the
government and politics.”13 Whereas, Huntington and Nelson define political
participation as, “Knowledge about politics, interest in politics, feeling of political
competence, and efficiency, perceptions of the relevance of political, all these may
often be closely related to political action, but at other times they are not. Their study
and measurement also require techniques that differ significantly from those needed to
study behaviour along.”14
Jan Leighley is of the view that “Participation in national problem- solving and
campaign activities enhances political conceptualisation (individual’s information
about politics); as individual’s are exposed to the conflict of ideas, through
participation they develop more abstract understanding of the political system.”18 Thus
13
Norman D. Palmer, Elections and Political Development: The South Asian Experience, New Delhi:
Vikas Publishing House, 1976, pp. 50-57.
14
Samuel P. Huntington and Joan M. Nelson, No Easy Choice: Political Participation in Developing
Countries, Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1976, pp. 4-5.
15
Myron Weiner, “Political Participation: Crisis of Political Process”; Quoted in Norman D. Palmer,
Elections and Political Development: The South Asian Experience, New Delhi: Vikas Publishing
House, 1976, p. 58.
16
Sandip Kumar Ghatak, “Political Participation of Women of West Bengal: Its Nature and Extent”,
The Indian Journal of Political Science, Vol. 71, No. 1, January-March 2010, p. 285.
17
Norman H. Nie, and Sidney Verba, “Political Participation”, in Fred I. Greenstein and Nelson W. Polsby
(eds.), Handbook of Political Science, Vol. 4, Massachusetts: Addison-Wesley Publishing Company,
1975, p. 1.
18
Jan Leighley, “Participation as a Stimulus of Political Conceptualization”, Journal of Politics, Vol.
53, No. 1, February 1991, p. 207.
4
political participation is the heart of democracy. Democracy is the form of government,
where majority of people possesses the right to share in the exercise of sovereign
power. In a democratic society, power is shared and the representatives of the people
make decision concerning the society.
Modes of Participation
19
Sidney Verba and Norman H. Nie, Participation in America: Political Democracy and Social
Equality, New York: Harper and Row Publishers, 1972, p. 58.
5
Participation includes (i) the activities designed to influence the decisions of
government through pressure or persuasion to attain ends such as retaining or replacing
the existing decision makers on changing some aspects of the political system as a
whole and the rules of the political game (ii) electoral activities such as voting,
campaigning, lobbying, (iii) protests strikes, demonstrations, resort to violence.20
Lester W. Milbrath has ranked these activities in a hierarchal order. At the top
he has given those activities in which an individual participates most and goes down to
lesser degrees of participation, until at the bottom where the degree of participation is
the least. Gladiatorial Activities: (i) holding public or party office, (ii) being a candidate
for the office, (iii) soliciting political funds, (iv) attending a caucus or a strategy
meeting, (v) becoming an active member in a political party, (vi) contributing time in a
political campaign. Transitional Activities: (vii) attending a political meeting or rally,
(viii) making a monetary contribution to a party or candidate, (xi) contacting a public
official or a political leader. Spectator Activities: (x) wearing a button or putting a
sticker on a car, (xi) attempting to talk to another to voting in a certain way, (xii)
initiating a political discussion, (xiii) voting, (xiii) exposing one-self to political
stimuli.21
Schonfeld has mentioned, ten types of activities, which are often cited in the
literature on political participation these include: (i) running or holding public (or
party) office, (ii) belonging to a party or other political organization, (iii) working in an
election, (iv) attending political meeting or rallies (v) making financial contribution to a
party or a candidate,(vi) contacting a public official (vii) publicly expressing a political
opinion to convince others (viii) taking part in political discussion (ix) voting and (x)
exposing one-self to political stimuli.22
Huntington and Nelson identify and define the following common variables of
political participation; Class: Individuals of similar social status, income, and
occupation; Communal group: Individuals of similar race, religion, language, or
ethnicity; Neighbourhood: Individuals residing in geographical proximity to each other;
Party: Individuals who identify with the same formal organization attempting to win or
20
Kalpana Roy, op.cit., 1999, pp. 292-293.
21
Lester W. Milbrath, Political Participation: How and Why do People Get Involved in Politics,
Chicago: Rand McNally, 1965, p.18.
22
William R. Schonfeld, “The Meaning of Democratic Participation”, World Politics, Vol. 28, No. 1,
1975, pp. 136-137.
6
maintain control of the executive and legislative branches of government, and Faction:
Individuals united by sustained or intense personal interaction with each other.23
The Centre for the Study of Developing Societies has considered the following
activities like, canvassing for candidates; getting out the voter; raising money;
organizing meeting’s and rallies; participation in procession and demonstrations;
distributing campaign literature; other types of campaign activities; involvement in
campaign through associations and groups; attending public meetings and rallies; being
member of a political party; contacting party leaders for help in solving problems;
contacting government officials for help in solving problems; and voting.24
The voting is considered as the simplest political activity which does not
require much information, initiative and motivation as do most other political activities.
Since vote determines who holds elective office, it exerts a great pressure upon the
leaders and is called the blunt instrument of control over the government. The
campaign activities require more initiative and are more difficult than the voting, but
these activities have more collective effective upon the decision-making process than
voting. The membership in political party or voluntary organisation is the co-operative
mode of political participation. However, this mode of participation requires much
initiative on the part of private citizens. Contesting election is the highest and most
serious form of political participation than the other modes of political participation.
Protest activities- marches, demonstrations and other such direct actions-which are also
called the unconventional political participation generally considered as unhealthy for
democracy.25
Variables
23
Samuel P. Huntington and Joan M. Nelson, op.cit, 1976, p.15.
24
S. Bhatnagar, Political Theory, New Delhi: Meenakshi Prakashan, 1984, p. 279.
25
Bhawana Jharta, op.cit., 1998, pp. 14-15.
26
Madan Lal Goel, Political Participation in a Developing Nation-India, Bombay: Asia Publishing
House, 1974, pp. 89-98.
7
education, occupation, income, religion, race, family background, residence, etc.,
greatly condition political participation.27 Participation tends to be higher among better
educated, members of the higher occupational and income groups, middle aged, the
dominant ethnic and religious groups, people with political family background, settled
residents, urban dwellers and members of voluntary organisations.28
The ideological, psychological, social and political factors affect the political
participation. Ideological factors as one of vital factors that patriarchy and gender
discrimination which still exists in society, shape women’s participation globally.
Patriarchy as a system of male domination shapes women’s relationship in politics. It
constructs the hierarchy of gender relations where men are privileged. Andrienne Rich
defines patriarchy, “A familial-social, ideological, political system in which men by
force, direct pressure or though ritual, tradition, law, and language, customs etiquette,
27
Ronald D. Hedlund, “The Electability of Women Candidates: The Effects of Sex Role Stereotypes”,
The Journal of Politics, Vol. 41, No. 2, 1979, pp. 515-516.
28
Bhawana Jharta, op.cit.,1998, p. 16.
29
Seymour Martin Lipset, op.cit., 1959, p. 82.
30
Hazel D. Lima, Women in Local Government: A Study of Maharashtra, New Delhi: Concept
Publishing Company, 1983, pp. 160-161.
31
Bhawana Jharta, op.cit., 1998, pp. 16-17.
8
education, and the division of labour, determine what part women shall or shall not
play in which the female is everywhere subsumed under the male.”32
The psychological factors are also responsible for women to have low
participation in politics. Generally, men are more psychologically involved in politics
because they have more ‘sense of civic duty’, ‘feelings of efficacy’ and above all they
regard politics as their respective sphere, while women are generally unfortunate in
these matters. But voting is only marginally dependent upon psychological involvement
in politics: many individuals vote because of patriotic sentiments, traditional
commitments and group or party pressures rather than personal involvement. The
psychological variables have the most complex modes of political participation.33
According to Milbrath, it is a tradition in almost all societies that politics is mainly an
affair of men and that women should fall in line with them politically. The changes
brought by modern industrial societies are eroding this sex difference but the impact of
tradition is still visible. The men tend to be more psychologically involved in politics
than women.34
The social factors are also important which effect women’s participation in
public spheres. The women find it difficult to participate in politics due to limited time
available to them because of their dual roles in the productive and reproductive spheres.
With their primary roles as mothers and wives and competing domestic responsibilities
and care work, they are left with little time to participate in politics. In some of the
countries, particularly in South Asia, women also face cultural constraints on their
mobility.35 Nie and Verba consider protest participation outside the orbit of their study
because they consider it an illegal activity. On the other hand, Ali Ashraf and L.N.
Sharma view of the political participation refers to activity that is designed to affect
governmental decision making and actions.36
32
Quoted in Farza Bari, “Women’s Political Participation; Issues and Challenges”, Paper Presented in
Expert Group Meeting, Division for the Advancement of Women (DAW), Bangkok, Thailand, 8-11
November, 2005, pp.3-4.
33
Bhawana Jharta, op.cit., 1998, pp.15-16.
34
Lester W. Milbrath and M.L. Goel, op.cit., 1977, p. 48.
35
Farza Bari, op.cit., 2005, p. 5.
36
Ali Ashraf and L.N. Sharma, Political Sociology: A New Grammar of Politics, Hyderabad:
Universities Press, 1983, pp. 140-145.
9
influence on the life of women, who are confined (mentally, if not physically) to the
home mainly. Her identity and course of life are normally considered to be determined
by her father, brother or husband. The limited political training and socialization that
takes place for her takes place within the family and home. Practices such as female
seclusion and sex segregation, the relative rigidity of the division of labour and the
notion of the ‘naturalness’ of males and females’ work and many subtle aspects of
gender relations all contribute to the shaping of and are themselves shaped by the
ideology underlying their practices and behaviour patterns.37
37
Herbert McClosky, op.cit., 1968, p. 253.
38
Neera Desai and Usha Thakkar, Women in Indian Society, New Delhi: National Book Trust, 2001,
p. 112.
39
Manuka Khanna, “Political Participation of Women in India”, The Indian Journal of Political
Science, Vol. 70, No.1, January-March 2009, p. 57.
40
Ronald D. Hedlund, op.cit., 1979, pp. 515-516.
10
Feminism
The feminist movement emerged in around the late 19th century, with the
beginning of the first wave of feminism. Feminism, as a whole, came in three ‘wave’
dealing with different aspects of the same issue; the first wave is being the feminist
movement in the 19th and 20th century, which dealt mainly with the suffrage movement.
The second wave (1960-1980s) dealt with the inequality of laws as well as unofficial
inequalities. The third wave of feminism (1900-current) arose from the perceived
failures of the second wave. The word “feminism” appeared first in France in the
1880s, Great Britain in the 1890s, and the United states in 1910. The oxford English
Dictionary lists 1894 for “feminism” and 1895 for “feminist”. Prior to that time
“Women’s Rights” was probably the term used most commonly, hence Queen
Victoria’s description of this “mad wicked folly of women’s rights” is significant. In
the 17th century John Locke and Thomas Hobbes had observed that maternal child bond
was a primary relationship, compared to the child’s relationship to the father. The
French Utopian socialists of the 1830s and 1840s challenged the “natural order’ stating
that in the Romantic tradition, the only natural order was the mother-child bond,
paternity being a legal bond defined by civil law. Women’s voices are often difficult to
discern in the ancient world, but classical Greek Philosophers such as Aristotle and
Plato sometimes claimed to be feminist (a role that is debated). The most important
feminist writer of the time was Mary Wollstonecraft, often characterized as the first
feminist philosopher. 41
Wollstonecraft believed that both sexes contributed to the inequalities and took
it for granted that women had considerable power over men, but that both would
require education to ensure that necessary changes in social attitudes. Her legacy
remains the need for women to speak out and tell their stories. Her own achievements
speak to her own determination. The French Revolution focused people’s attention
everywhere on the cry for egalite and hence by extension but in a more limited way,
inequality in the treatment of women. In 1791, the Declaration of the Rights of Man
and of the citizen elicited an immediate response from the writer Olympe de Gouges,
the amended it as the Declaration of the Rights of Woman and the female citizen,
arguing that if women were accountable to law, they must also be given equal
responsibility under the law. She also addressed marriage as a social contract between
41
Neeru Tandon, Feminism: A Paradigm Shift, New Delhi: Atlantic Publishers, 2008, pp. 1-4.
11
equals and attacked women’s reliance on beauty and charm, as a form of slavery.42
Therefore, Feminism is a social theory which is more associated these days with
political movement dealing primarily with the experience of women. There were
various feminist theories i.e. Liberal feminist theory, , Marxist school of feminism,
Radical feminist theory Psychoanalytic feminist theory, Existentialist feminist thought,
Cultural feminism, Lesbian feminism, Eco-feminism, Post-modern feminism, Post
feminism, Black feminism, French feministic theory.
The liberal feminism, also known as first wave feminism, strives to ensure a
more equitable and gender inclusive structural changes in the society. This school of
thought seeks women empowerment through various legal and administrative reforms.
Liberal feminism strives for the greater participation of women in the public realm.43
Liberal feminists, such as, Mary Wollstonecraft’s book, A Vindication of the Rights of
Women and J.S. Mill, The Subjection of Women, Harriet Taylor’s Enfranchisement of
Women44 focuses their study on the legal and political rights of women. This discipline
demonstrates the idea of equality before law and equal representation of women in
democratic institutions.
The liberal feminism has tried to explain and analyse the unjustified restrictions
imposed upon women in the male dominated socio-economic and political order the
society. The liberal feminism has inspired women to come out from private sphere to
public life, to ensure greater participation in order to secure more power in political
realm. Similarly, Margret Mend’s analysis focuses on the biological equality and
cultivated talent of each sex. Mend’s seeks an equal participation of women in the areas
of law and governance, religion, art and science. Her focus remains to ensure the
equitable and purposeful participation of women in the fields that were historically and
culturally supposed to be dominated by men. One of the important objectives of liberal
feminism remains to rescind the gender bias in the domain of art and aesthetics. A
number of liberal theorists are critical to the role of art in demonstrating and
perpetuating female inferiority. Women are generally considered an object of art rather
than a rational and creative being, to create and evaluate the aesthetical parameters.
42
Ibid.,
43
Pankaj Dodh, “Theorising Gender: A Way to Women Empowerment and Gender Justice”, in Sarbjeet
Singh and Pankaj Dodh (eds.), Gender Justice and Women Empowerment: An Integrated Approach,
New Delhi: Regal Publications, 2013, p. 23.
44
Neeru Tandon, op.cit., 2008, pp.1-4.
12
Therefore, it becomes imperative to demonstrate that the liberal feminist scholarship
dared to strike its earliest assault against the exploitation of women in both private and
public sphere. The movement initiated a very fervent criticism against the persistent
inequality and discrimination in the society. Consequently, public institutions were
reformed and made more inclusive, democratic and egalitarian in both structural as well
as functional level.
The Marxist and socialist feminism focuses primarily on the economic aspects
of women exploitation. Marx and Engels tried to understand women operation and
exploitations in terms of the nature of material production and the concept of
alienation. The Marxist thinking about women exploitation is essentially analogous to
the alienation of the working class in a capitalistic mode of production. The powerful
capitalist exploitative culture not only prevails in the economic sphere, but is equally
implied to the exploitation of women in the narrow confine of household affairs. Engels
vividly painted the picture of women subjugation in parallel to the emergence of the
private property over an extending period of history. Due to the expansion of
civilization and material possessions, male succeeded to assert greater control over the
exchange values of produced goods. This was further fortified with the emergence of
the family, a primary unit of the society. The exclusive controls of the male over the
domestic affairs as an owner of private property further worsened the condition of
women. Women were complexly marginalized in socio-economic and political life.
Therefore, Engels suggested for the complete demolition of private domestic labour
and supported the spread public industry for the liberation of women. One of the central
themes of the Marxist feminism is that, it tries to integrate women’s emancipation in
the wider context of a class struggle against the capitalistic society. 45
13
the male through patriarchal customs and the male dominated rules and regulations in
the family affairs. The theory is chiefly concerned with the issues arising out of
‘pornography, prostitution, sexual harassment, rape and woman battering. In order to
be liberated from sexual oppression, radical feminists prescribe a strategy to create an
exclusively female sexuality through celibacy, autoeroticism, or lesbianism; they are
against heterosexuality and traditional roles of women as faithful housewives and child-
bearing machines.47 It seeks to eventually deconstruct the patriarchal power prevalence
in both public and private spaces. Radical feminism makes a clear distinction between
gender and sex. The sex stands for biological difference; while, gender is a historically
and socially constructed idea. The sublime virtues of care, affection, nurture and
motherliness were deliberately overshadowed by the patriarchal rationality and power.
The artificially allotted ‘submission’ to women; and men desire to exert exclusive
control over the nature, has led to the construction of a patriarchal culture, value system
and an economic and political structure as a historical process. The radical feminist
thinkers want to destroy the socially constructed parameters of gender differences.48
To sum up with an optimism that a new era of peace, progress, equality, justice
and respect for human rights would prevail in the foreseeable future where women
would enjoy equal socio-economic and political rights as compared to men.
Women Participation
Women play an important role in determining the destiny of a nation and they
are an integral part of society. Their greater involvement in socio-economic and
political affair becomes more important. However, history reveals that women have not
been given their actual status in the society. Socially, women are an ignored a lot in the
society. They have been and still are the victim of various social taboos in general and
particularly in developing country like India. Though, they enjoy equality but this
equality is more in legal terms rather than in reality. Women are virtually excluded
from political power all over the world. There contribution to the social and economic
development of societies is also more than half as compared to that of men by virtue of
their dual roles in the productive and reproductive spheres. Yet, their participation in
formal political structures and processes, where decisions regarding the use of societal
47
Neeru Tandon, op.cit., 2008, p. 44.
48
Pankaj Dodh, op.cit., 2013, pp. 25-27.
14
resources generated by both men and women are made, remains insignificant.
Presently, women’s representation in legislatures around the world is 15 per cent.49
Political participation of women means not only using the right to vote but also
power sharing, co-decision-making and co-policy-making at all levels. The active
participation of women in political sphere is integral to empowerment of women and
helps to build a gender-equal society as well as to speed up the process of national
development. Women’s political empowerment is premised on three fundamental and
non-negotiable principles: the equality between women and men; women’s right to the
full development of their potentials; and women’s right to self-representation and self-
determination.51
49
R.Vijaya Kumari and K. Gangadhara Rao, “Women’s Political Participation in India”, Global
Journal for Research Analysis, Vol. 3, No. 8, August 2014, p. 1.
50
Molly Joseph, Women Participation and Development Strategies, New Delhi: Kanishka Publishers,
1997, pp. 53-54.
51
Meenu Agrawal (ed.), Women Empowerment and Globalization: A Modern Perspective, New Delhi:
Kanishka Publishers, 2009, p.178.
52
K. Shamatha, “Women’s Participation in Electoral Politics”, Global Journal for Research Analysis,
Vol. 3, No. 2, February 2014, p. 196.
53
K.C. Vidya, Political Empowerment of Women at the Grassroots, 2nd edition, New Delhi: Kanishka
Publishers, 2007, pp. 2-3.
15
1893.54 Subsequently, Finland became the first country to enfranchise women in 1906.
55
Australia and Canada provided the voting right to their women counterpart in 1908
and Norway in 1913. 56 After a continuous struggle for equal political rights, women
achieved voting right in 1920 in USA and 1928 in UK. In Germany, women were
enfranchised by the Weimer Constitution of 1919. Gradually, women got universal
suffrage in all the countries of Asia, Africa, Europe America, and Latin America.
However, in the Middle-East countries women are yet to gain equal suffrage.57 Japan in
1945, France in 1947, Pakistan in 1947, China in 1949, India in 1950, Argentina in
1952 and Iran in 1963.58 In Switzerland, women are provided with the full and equal
voting rights in federal and most cantonal elections by 1971 and in 1973 same rights
were granted to women in Syria in 197359 and Iraq in 1980. In most of the countries of
the world, the right to vote to women became a reality in the 20th century. The
developed nations of the world have granted right to vote to women in the first half of
the 20th century, whereas the newly independent third world countries have given the
right to vote to women after 1945 and with their freedom from the colonial rules.60
54
Anjana Maitra Sinha, Women in a Changing Society, New Delhi: Ashish Publishing House, 1993, p. 57.
55
Yogendra Narain, et al., “Empowerment of Women”, Mainstream, Vol. 43, No.1-5, December 2014,
pp. 68-69.
56
Anuradha Chadda, “Political Participation of Women: A Case Study in India”, International Journal
of Sustainable Development, Vol.7, No. 2, 2014, p. 93.
57
K.C. Vidya, op.cit., 2007, pp. 2-3.
58
Bhawana Jharta, “Marginalization of Women in Politics: Some Observations”, in Mamta Mokta (ed.),
Dimensions of Gender Inequality in Society, Chandigarh: Shree Ram Law House, 2016, p. 80.
59
Anuradha Chadda, op.cit., 2014, p. 93.
60
Bhawana Jharta, op.cit., 2016, p. 80.
61
United Nations Commission on The Status of Women, http://en.wikipedea.org/wiki/, Accessed on
09-07-2017.
62
Convention on the Political Rights of Women, 193 U.N.T.S.135, enforced on July 7, 1954, Article 3.
16
United Nations consisting of a preamble and 30 articles, aimed at to as constitute
discrimination against women and to setup an agenda to end such discrimination. It
also highlighted the participation of women in politics.63
The first world conference on women was held in 1975 in Mexico City. 64 The
conference, along with the United Nations Decade for Women (1976-1985) launched a
new era in global efforts to promote the advancement of women by opening a
worldwide dialogue on gender equality.65 The conference recommended the
governments to formulate national strategies and identify targets and priorities in their
efforts to promote the equal participation of women in political space.66 It was followed
by a second world conference on women at Copenhagen in 1980 and a third in Nairobi
in 1985. In the UN Conference on Environment and Development in Rio de Janiero
(1992), world leaders accepted women’s vital role in achieving sustainable
development. The World Conference on Human Rights in Vienna (1993), governments
acknowledged that women’s rights are human and headed the evidence of widespread
violence against women. Further, in the International Conference on Population and
Development in Cairo (1994), women’s empowerment was recognised as a cornerstone
for effective population policies. At the World Conference for Social Development in
Copenhagen (1995), gender equality was recognised as a prerequisite for the
achievement of productive employment, social integration and poverty eradication.67
The Fourth World Conference on Women held in Beijing in 1995, took actions
empowering women to take part in politics and decision making process.68 From each
of these global conference emerged, a more powerful recognition of the crucial role of
women in sustainable development and protecting the environment: of the human
rights; of violence against women as an intolerable violation of these rights; of health,
maternal care and family planning facilities, and of access to education and
information, as essential to the exercise by women of their fundamental rights. 69 These
rights were not easy to achieve because women had to fight and vociferously advocate
63
G.A.res.34/80. 3U.N.GAOR. supp.,(No.6) at 193 UN Doc. A/34/46, entered into force September 3,
1981.
64
Kuldeep Fadia, “Women’s Empowerment through Political Participation in India”, Indian
Journal of Public Administration, Vol. 60, No. 3, July-September 2014, pp. 537-539.
65
Anuradha Chadda, op.cit., 2014, pp. 95-96.
66
Farza Bari, op.cit., 2005, p.1.
67
Kuldeep Fadia, op.cit., 2014, pp. 537-539.
68
Anuradha Chadda, op.cit., 2014, p. 96.
69
Kuldeep Fadia, op.cit., 2014, pp. 537-539.
17
their rights at various forms. When the UN Charter was being discussed for adoption,
the draft neither contained the phrase “the equal rights of men and women” nor the
paragraph prohibiting discrimination on the basis of sex. Women participants fought
very hard against such discrimination and demanded that the rights for all human
beings irrespective of their gender should be included. The ardour and initiative of
women delegates to bring to light such exclusion of women and their demand that the
UN Charter reflect gender equality resulted in incorporation of the idea of equality of
men and women in the UN Charter. It is said that, the UN Charter became the first ever
international document in the history of making to have underlined the rights of all
human beings irrespective of gender. In a similar way, references such as “All men are
brothers” in the Universal Declaration of human Rights were changed to reflect the
equal rights of men and women.
70
Yogendra Narain, et al., op.cit., 2014, pp. 68-69.
71
S.P. Mathiraj and P.S. Nagarajan, “Empowerment of India: Then and Now”, Third Concept, Vol. 24,
No. 280, June 2010, p. 37.
18
earlier policy to induct women into local government bodies through reservation of a
few seats, as a form of tokenism, and recommended the establishment of statutory
women’s Panchayats at the village level to ensure greater participation in the political
process. The Report of the Committee on the Status of Women, the observance of
International Women’s Year in 1975, the formulation of a National Plan of Action for
Women, setting up of a National Committee with the Prime Minister as the head
proved the concern for women. Since then, scholars and policy-makers diverted their
attention to the issues of women, which culminated in establishing a National
Commission for Women in 1992 and the National Perspective Plan for Women (1988-
2000).72
Further, the historical 73rd and 74th Amendments to the Constitution have
enhanced women’s participation and representation in the decision-making process at
the grassroots level and also have reduced the disparity in male and female
participation in the political processes at the local levels. These amendment Acts have
provided at least 33 per cent reservation of seats for women in the Panchayati Raj
Institutions and Municipalities and have also laid down a strong foundation towards
equal access and more participation of women in the political power structure. Today,
through the Panchayati Raj Institutions, over a million women have entered political
life in India. The states like Madhya Pradesh, Bihar, Uttrakhand, Himachal Pradesh,
Andhra Pradesh, Chhattisgarh, Jharkhand, Kerala, Karnataka, Maharashtra, Orissa,
Rajasthan and Tripura have even implemented 50 per cent reservation for women in
PRIs. The majority of members/candidates in these Panchayats are women. The
currently, 100 per cent of elected members in Kodassery, Panchayat in Kerala are
women.73
72
Ratna Ghosh and Alok Kumar Pramanik, Panchayat System in India: Historical, Constitutional and
Financial Analysis, New Delhi: Kanishka Publishers, 2007, p.171.
73
Bhawana Jharta, op.cit., 2016, p. 85.
19
participation, through a wide and varied spectrum of activities, forms the central core of
the concept of political participation.74
74
S. Bhatnagar, op.cit., 1984, p. 266.
75
Meenu Agrawal (ed.), op.cit., 2009, p.163.
20
the low and inferior status of women in society in India especially in the context of the
declining sex ratio, increasing violence and crimes against women and their
marginalized status in employment education and health sectors.
21
Review of Literature
76
Madan Lal Goel, Political Participation in Developing Nation, Bombay: Asia Publishing House,
1974.
22
attitudes of the higher authorities must change in order to be viable agencies of
development. 77
A.R. Gupta (1976) in his book, “Women in Hindu Society”, the author deals
with the political status of women in a nation is reflected in extent of freedom granted
to women in regard to their participation in the political activity. With the advent of
independence, Indian women were granted the right to all political activities with men
and their participation in the political activities of the country has also increased
whereas, it has failed to make any profound impact on women’s participation in the
actual decision making process. However, the author sum up by saying that there is a
difference in the standard of values and norms of behaviour and the objective of new
social order proclaimed by the constitution of India.78
Neera Desai (1977) in her book, “Women in Modern India”, discussed the
political status of women in India. It emphasised on the study of women’s status in
different ages in history and attempted to find out the root causes affecting the status of
women. It is a comprehensive and multi-dimensional study of women dealing with the
changing status of women in the Indian society in the past. The contemporary women
are self-responsible and they can cope-up with the changing situations by leaving aside
the burden of religion, values, customs and superstitions.79
Ranbir Sharma (1977) in his study, “Party Politics in the Himalayan States”,
he studied the various political party of Himachal Pradesh to examine the potential role
of political parties in initiating, directing and managing social, economic and political
changes in Himachal Pradesh. He has observed the growth of political consciousness
amongst the hilly state of Himachal Pradesh. He analysed that the Praja Mandal
Movement in the hilly states stimulated the growth of political states, stimulated the
growth of political awakening, even though the areas are very economically backward.
During the course of struggle being launched, a simultaneous process of their
integration had also begun. This study is helpful to know that the integration of various
tribal and non-tribal communities of Himachal Pradesh has been begun from the period
of Praja Mandal Movement and national movement to achieve the common interest.80
77
S. Bhatnagar, Panchayati Raj in Kangra District of Himachal Pradesh, New Delhi: Orient
Longman,1974.
78
A.R. Gupta, Women in Hindu Society, Delhi: Songita Printers, 1976.
79
Neera Desai, Women in Modern India, Bombay: Vora Publishing House, 1977.
80
Ranbir Sharma, Party Politics in the Himalayan State, New Delhi: National Publishing House, 1977.
23
Inderjeet Kaur (1978) in this book, “Status of Hindu Women in India”, the
author discussed that a new concept of womanhood is gradually emerging in India,
which is at odds with the traditional concept of Hindu women as a devoted wife
confined to the home. The study indicated that participation of women in politics can
be seen in parliament, in the state legislative assemblies, in other policy and decision
making bodies due to higher education, self awareness and national consciousness of
women as they are now claiming equal status with men inside and outside the family.
They are passing through a transitional stage, in which they are neither wholly
traditional nor fully modern. The cultural inheritance and traditional values did not
wholly vanish from the attitude and behaviour of Hindu women. The result of study
indicated a positive change in behaviour and outlook of middle class Hindu women.81
Jana Matson Everett (1979) in her book, “Women and Social Change in
India”, the author discussed the historical development of the women’s movements in
India from the late 19th to the mid 20th century. The author examined two campaigns of
the Indian women’s movement. The campaign for political representation provoked
none of the hostility experienced by the British and American movements. However,
the Indian campaign was more complex than is usually realized. A weakness
characterising women’s movements in both India and the west was their inability to
mobilize large numbers of people. The Indian women enjoyed greater access to the
political elite relative to the American and British movements. However, in certain
circumstances, the politics of mass mobilization was crucial for success, and the
women’s movement was not able to adapt.82
Jana Matson Everett and B.R. Chawla (1981) in this book, “Women and
Social Change in India”, the authors deals with the problems of women in India and
stated that there is a great discrepancy between the idealized concept of women and the
real life situation in which women find themselves. All over the world, women are
denied equal access with men, in opportunities for personal growth and social
development in education, employment, marriage and family, professional and political
life. In India, as in other developing countries, women are less likely than men to
continue their education to higher levels and are more likely to find themselves
81
Inderjeet Kaur, Status of Hindu Women in India, Allahabad: Chugh Publication, 1983.
82
Jana Matson Everett, Women and Social Change in India, New Delhi: B.R. Chawala Heritage
Publishers, 1979.
24
constricted in female occupations like nursing, social work, typing and stenography all
of which have low status and low remuneration.83
Maithreyi Krishna Raj (1986) in his book on, “Women Studies in India: Some
Perspective”, has described about the aspects of equality and empowerment of women.
He says that the progress for women can be facilitated by government but will only
spread further, when there is change at the level of the family that inclusion of women
in development, that is not only a issue of equality, but also of necessity. The study
describes the reservation for women in legislatures as positive step for empowerment of
the women.86
Pam Rajput and Hem Lata Swarup (1994) in this book, “Women and
Globalisation: Reflections, Options and Strategies”, it is a selection of papers
presented at the Round Table forms part of this volume. It is encompassing experience
of four continents, some of the papers conceptualise the globalisation phenomenon;
83
Jana Matson Everett and B.R. Chawla, Women and Social Change in India, New Delhi: Macmillan,
1981.
84
Hazel D. Lima, Women in Local Government: A Study of Maharashtra, New Delhi: Concept
Publishing House, 1983.
85
Sachidananda and Ramesh P. Shina, Women Rights: Myth and Reality, Jaipur: Printwell Publishers,
1984.
86
Maithreyi Krishna Raj, Women’s Studies in India: Some Perspective, Bombay: Popular Prakashan,
1986.
25
ponder over the genesis of the debt-trap; the indiscriminately applied road-roller blue
print of IMF/WB conditionality’s. Other recount actual adverse impact of wiping away
of gains of more than a century of social and labour legislation; phenomenon of
‘jobless growth’ in developed countries and spectre of unemployment in the developing
countries; the mirage of promised long term gains and inevitability of short term
misery; feminisation of work force participation and its marginalisation, casualisation
and contractualisation. Some others expound the political dimensions of exaggerated
emphasis on expansion of markets and advocacy of rolling back of the nation state and
undermining its sovereignty, in a planned conspiracy of giving the cake to the elite and
crumbs to the poor and next to nothing to women and children. Almost all papers deal
with long term alternative strategies on global, national and grassroots levels for both
transformation of the systemic mal-development and disorder and redressal of
immediate miseries. However, further research has been suggested to probe and
analyse this phenomena in depth for advocacy and lobbying.87
Uma Shankar Jha and Prem Lata Pujari (1996) in this book, “Indian
Women: Tradition, Modernity and Challenge”, has done a comprehensive study of
87
Pam Rajput and Hem Lata Swarup (eds.), Women and Globalisation: Reflections, Options and
Strategies, New Delhi: Ashish Publishing House, 1994.
88
Kiran Devendra, Changing Status of Women in India, New Delhi: Vikas Publications, 1994.
26
Indian women in this volumes. The first volume contains the history of women
struggle, role of women in national movement, politics and women franchise. The
second volume deals with the evil practice of widow burning. This sacrifice was
prevalent in India since 4th century B.C., although widow burning was legally
prohibited in 1829 but was not completely abolished and this customs was again
revived in late twentieth century in Rajasthan. The third volume analyses women’s
participation in all professions dominated by men. Resurgence of feminism in India and
their organizational development encouraged women to come out their houses for equal
rights and opportunities. Women now are keen to shoulder the responsibilities as
professional in all concerned sphere.89
89
Uma Shankar Jha and Prem Lata Pujari (eds.), Indian Women: Tradition, Modernity and Challenge,
Vol. 3, New Delhi: Kanishka Publishers, 1996.
90
Molly Joseph, Women Participation and Development Strategies, New Delhi: Kanishka Publishers,
1997.
91
K.C. Vidya, Political Empowerment of Women at the Grassroots, New Delhi: Kanishka Publishers,
1997.
27
Bhawana Jharta (1998) in her book, “Women and Politics in India: Impact of
Family and Education on Women Political Activists”, has analysed the role and impact
of family and of education on women’s participation in politics. According to the
author, family and education are the two major determinants in the political
participation of women. These two variables act as both booster as well as hindrances
in their participation in politics. The author explored how and to what extent these
variables affect the nature and scope of women’s participation in politics and
determined the variation in their participatory level. She found that a political
motivation would provide an impetus to women’s initiation into politics. Women in
themselves should develop a favourable attitude towards politics. They should spare
time and should come out of their homes to take part in political activities. It is also up
to women to prepare themselves for participating in all the processes that they have
been demanding representation. Family members should also cooperate with women by
sharing their family responsibilities and encouraging them to take part in political
activities. She suggests that there is a need to replace the traditional value system,
which is based upon inequality of sexes, and in which women play a subordinate role.92
M.R. Biju (1998) in his study, “Dynamics of New Panchayati Raj System:
Reflection and Retrospection”, has tried to examine the problems of grass root
democracy in general and Panchayati Raj administration in particular. This book was
written at the time when the Kerala Panchayati Raj Act, 1994 and the launching of the
people campaign for the decentralized planning were started by the state government.
This was a unique model for the rest of the nation. The book is divided into ten
chapters, the first chapter is an introductory one. Second chapter depicts the historical
growth of Panchayati Raj Institution in India right from its inception to the present day
as briefly as possible. The third chapter intends to focus attention to the position of
Panchayati Raj in Kerala. This chapter is divided into two parts-first half is devoted to
analyze the growth of Panchayati Raj in Kerala during the pre-integration period and
the second half is for the post integration period (1956-1997). The fourth chapter is
devoted to analyze the structure powers, functions and authorities of the Panchayati Raj
Bodies in Kerala. The focus attention of Panchayati Raj system both of the revenue and
expenditure is given in the sixth chapter. The seventh chapter is devoted to analyze the
92
Bhawana Jharta, Women and Politics in India: Impact of Family and Education on Women Political
Activists, New Delhi: Deep and Deep Publications, 1998.
28
role of people and their participation in Panchayati Raj Institution in Kerala. The
chapter ninth deals with the significance of rural development and work section in
Panchayati Raj Institutions is in chapter nine. The last concluding chapter presents
briefly the major finding on the relevance of the study and also throws light on the
present problems of Panchayati Raj in Kerala with the suggestions to solve them.93
Uma Shankar Jha, Aarti Mehta and Latika Menon (1998) in this study,
“Status of Indian Women, Crisis and Conflict in Gender Issues”, analyses of the role
played by women in most of the society all over the world. In most of the society,
women role is confined to perform the household job, child bearing and care of entire
family. Due to the developments in education, communication, change in family life,
women participation in the outside job in the urban areas has gained momentum. The
study consists of volume, the first volume deals with discrimination based on gender
and with economic issues. Second volume gives an analysis of women participation in
politics and politicization of women issues. In the third volume social theories of
womanhood in India has been critically discussed.94
M.P. Dube and Neeta Bora (1999) in this book, “Social Justice and Women in
India”, have pointed out that women are always defined in relation to men who are
taken as the norm. Women are said to be naturally caring and subservient suited to their
role as home makers. They have been seen as more governed by emotions than men, a
less developed form of the species and closer to nature. After independence, many laws
have been passed to raise the status of women but despite these laws the mass of
women remain ignorant of their rights. The book is an outcome of a seminar held at
Nainital. The authors argued that there is a moreover social pressure to confirm the
traditional ways of behaving that is another factors contributes to the low progress of
women.95
Kalpana Roy (1999) in her study, “Women in Indian Politics”, deals with the
problems which women faced in their fight for representation. Firstly, no women
93
M.R. Biju, Dynamics of New Panchayati Raj System: Reflection and Retrospection, New Delhi:
Kanishka Publishers,1998.
94
Uma Shankar Jha, et al., (eds.), Status of Indian Women, Crisis and Conflict in Gender Issues, Vol. 3,
New Delhi: Kanishka Publishers, 1998.
95
M.P. Dube and Neeta Bora (eds.), Social Justice and Women in India, Delhi: Ajay Mishra Publishers,
1999.
29
organisation focus on getting women elected at the national level and most women
have not had the economic freedom to choose their life and career. The material
circumstances and the family made inhibitions in the participation of women, many
unattached young women may be politically active, but once married, they disappear
from the political scene. In spite of the progress since independence, lack of awareness
and education and absence of knowledge about the intricacies of party politics among
many non-elite women have limited their participation in the formal political arena.
The role of money, the corruption of politics and growing violence against women has
also constrained many potential activists. Above all, if women movement is to be as
violable, recognized and important political actor, it must not isolate itself either from
the diversity of, from the myriad and other social and political movements within the
country.96
Savita Thakur Joshi (1999) in her book, “Women and Development: The
Changing Scenario”, in her studies includes two areas of Himachal Pradesh in the
district of Mandi. The areas of Nagwain and Maloh in the same district have been
selected. The study determines, the status of women in both areas, the impact of
demographic and health indicators, socio-economic and political indicators that have
been empirically established. Which will provide right to the planners, policy makers
and researchers about the grass-roots realities prevailing in the rural economy of our
country, even after five decades of independence and planned development for growth
with social justice. She concluded by saying that economic development of a region
does not help in the elevation of the status of women, which is enshrined in the social
and cultural values. For the removal of inequality based on sex and discriminatory
practices against the women, we have to shift our focus on the properties of the society
and culture instead of depending upon the economic growth model. The status of
women can be elevated only, when they are made free from economic, social and
psychological dependency.97
96
Kalpana Roy, Women in Indian Politics, New Delhi: Rajat Publications, 1999.
97
Savita Thakur Joshi (ed.), Women and Development: The Changing Scenario, New Delhi: Mittal
Publications, 1999.
30
comprehensive study on Panchayati Raj. In the first phase of the book, there are three
special articles on Panchayati Raj (i) Panchayati Raj in India-a review by the editor
himself (ii) Panchayats in Scheduled Areas by S. K. Singh, and (iii) Panchayats and
Women by Nirmala Buch. Afterwards, there is a detailed discussion on the Panchayati
Raj Acts of 25 States and 7 Union Territories of India by different scholars, i.e. on
Himachal Pradesh by R. D. Sharma and on Haryana by Ranbir Singh. However, the
chapter on Himachal Pradesh is more relevant as far as our study is concerned. He has
made an attempt to review the socio-economic profile, traditional structure of the
Panchayati Raj in India, especially the post 73rd Amendment developments. The book
is an attempt to cover the status of PRIs of the states and Union Territories of India.
This study is devoted to the detailed discussion on socio-economic profile, structure of
PRIs, inclusion of maps of the concerned state. So, this is a very relevant and useful
study as far as the study of the PRIs is concerned.98
Mastan Vali (2002) in his study, “Women and Politics”, deals with women
participation in politics. In India women’s role has been marginal in the society,
although they constitute half of the country’s population. Their involvement in politics
98
George Mathew (ed.), Panchayati Raj in India: An Overview- Status of Panchayati Raj in the States
and Union Territories of India, New Delhi: Concept Publishing Company, 2001.
99
G. Palanithurai, Capacity Building for Local Body Leaders, New Delhi: Concept Publishing
Company, 2001.
31
has been negligible all along. Their number in the legislatures including parliament has
always remained at a very low, as it never exceed 10 per cent of the total membership
of these bodies at any point of time. Nevertheless, several women played an active role
in the National Movement and also in the recent past, there is wide spread realization
that they should be emancipated and all types of discrimination against them be
avoided to enable them to play a legitimate role in the society. He also emphasized that
the emancipation of women could be possible only through the social, economic and
political empowerment by taking necessary steps in this direction. The most important
among them are the 73rd and 74th constitutional amendments, which provided
reservations in the local bodies. A Women Reservation Bill was also introduced in the
parliament and state legislative assemblies. Today, women are making ways into every
sectors of society, with the gradual improvement in their position in different fields. He
makes a detailed survey of the extent of women participation in representative bodies at
various levels, at different points of time. He also highlights the role played by the
women in the nationalist movement and suggested that political training of women
should begin at the school stage and to be spread on the local, provincial, national and
international levels. Lastly, he argued by saying that women’s political participation
will be possible by creating multi-seat constituencies with women representing a part of
it.100
32
women in the economic and social development process in the country, which has
remained comparatively neglected area attracted the attention of the planners and
economists in a big way. Since, the UN declaration of women’s Decade (1974-85), the
basic aim was to end the existing discrimination towards women, practiced in varying
degrees throughout the world. The government of India has continuously been
formulating strategies and initiating processes to bring women into the mainstreams,
there have been various shifts in policy approaches during the last 50 years from the
concept of welfare. Since its inception, development of women and children has been
implementing special programmes to improve the socio-economic status of women.
The Bureau of women’s development and micro credit development in the department
play a major role in this national endeavour for the advancement and empowerment of
women.
Finally, she suggested that efforts at all levels should be made to improve health
and education status of women and work participation of women in all the spheres. To
remove the existing traditional bias that women are good only in feminine jobs and
encourage women to equip themselves with necessary professional skills and compete
with men to make an entry into new areas. Hence, a positive solution for improving
social and economic well beings of women lies in social empowerment, economic
empowerment, gender justice and legal protection. So, need of hour is to plan and
design such strategies, which may enhance the capability of women and empower them
to cope with the negative and social impacts of the globalization process. 102
102
Shakuntla Gupta, Women Development in India: A Comparative Study, New Delhi: Anmol
Publications, 2005.
33
Manas Chakravarti and Vidyawati Agrwala (2006) in their book, “Women
and Politics in India”, have stated that the women’s participation of politics has been
gradual process with great variations in time. During the period of freedom struggle,
there are numerous instances, where women not only participated but also became
conscious of their rights and opposed the dowry system, sati system, etc. A delegation
of the women under the stewardship of Smt. Sarojini Naidu demanded equal political
rights from the British parliament. In the post-independence phase women also made
their presence felt in the parliament and the legislative assemblies. The authors have
given comprehensive account of the bills introduced in the parliament from time to
time and argues that the role of the women parliamentarians are in no way less
significant than their male counterparts. The significance of the study lies in the fact
that, it provides information with regard to role of women in parliamentary laws.103
Lalit Upadhaya (2007) in his book, “Women in Indian Politics”, have stated
about the women participation in politics in India. As India is the largest democracy in
the world and is represented by women as well, though not in good numbers. In India
women have always shown their presence in all walks of life and politics is no
exception. Since the freedom struggle movement, contribution of women has been
phenomenal, not only this, they have made a good mark for themselves in politics as
well. The evolutionary women of the 21st century begin her personal campaign to
change the world by strongly infiltrating feminine heart and feminine opinion into her
daily field of endeavour.104
103
Manas Chakravarti and Vidyawati Agrwala, Women and Politics in India, Ambala Cantt: The
Associated Publishers, 2006.
104
Lalit Upadhyaya, Women in Indian Politics, Panchkula: Better Books, 2007.
34
political situation. It also investigates, whether election to Panchayat bodies has made
any significant change in the status of women in rural areas.105
In the last, she suggested that improving the economic status of poor women
working in the informal sector of the economy, we have to devise concrete strategies
which can help to enhance the ownership of and control over productive assets by these
women. Perhaps, it will be the single most important intervention towards their
empowerment and economic well-being. Some of the assets that women can be given
are plots of land, houses, tree pattas, livestock licenses, bank accounts, membership of
organizations and identity cards. By improving the social and economic conditions of
women the author calls for fundamental changes in the laws regarding the rights of
widows to property. Though belatedly, the Indian society has awakened to the need to
make women equal partners in the socio-economic development of the country by
creating protective legislations for women, however the enactments have not been easy
to implement. 106
105
Bhola Nath Ghosh, Women in Governance in Tripura, New Delhi: Concept Publishing Company,
2008.
106
Rameshwari Pandya (ed.), Women Welfare and Empowerment in India, New Delhi: New Century
Publications, 2008.
35
D. Sundar Ram (2009) in his study, “Women Empowerment in Political
Institutions: An Indian Perspective”, deals with the issue of women political
empowerment of women in India is very complex one and highly debatable, since the
introduction of the Women’s Reservation Bill in Lok Sabha. Although women
constitute half of the India’s Population, their participation in political life has been
negligible all along. It’s often noticed that the suitable representation of women in
legislatures remains a distant dream, excluding their representation in the local self-
government institutions.
107
D. Sundar Ram (ed.), Women Empowerment in Political Institutions: An Indian Perspective, New
Delhi: Kanishka Publishers, 2009.
36
The author explains that after the independence to revive the PRIs, government
made some efforts at union and state level but outcome was not effective. The author
argues by saying that till 1993, the participation at the local level was negligible in
most of the parts of the country. Finally, the 73rd Constitutional Amendment is a
landmark development in constitutional history of independent India. The Amendment
made mandatory provisions to facilitate the process at democratic decentralization. But
the implementation of the Amendment by the state governments according to their
convenience resulted into ineffective working of PRIS. The other major cause was the
social and cultural system, which is not prepared to adopt the democratic
decentralization in real manner. At the same time, the author examines the Panchayats
extension to the Schedule Area, (PSEA) Act. The author observes or analyses that in
spite of these provisions there are lack of functions, functionaries and funds. She has
suggested a concrete strategy for strengthening grassroots democracy in India. The
study is a valuable addition to the literature on grassroots democracy in India.108
S. Lal (2010) in this book, “Women in Indian Politics”, deals with the role of
women in Indian politics. This book divided into nine chapters. First chapter deals with
the introduction, in today’s era of modernization, women have made their presence felt
in almost every field and politics is no exception, although India is known for its male
chauvinist societies since ages, the ice is now gradually breaking. Indian politics is
108
Mridula Sharda, Evolution of Panchayati Raj in India: From Traditional to Constitutionalize
Panchayats, New Delhi: Kanishka Publishers, 2010.
109
Nirmala Buch, From Oppression to Assertion: Women and Panchayats in India, New Delhi:
Routledge, 2010.
37
now defined and governed by women politicians. In most parties, the women member’s
are by and large thin on the ground, if not invisible in the actual decision-making
bodies and rarely influence the more significant party policies. The majority of women
in the Indian parliament are from the elite class, while their public role challenges some
stereotypes; their class position often allows them a far greater range of options than
are available to poorer women. The author finds that caste has been an important
feature of Indian society and political life. It is important to guard against making an
easy correlation between caste and political representation. The influence of individual
national leaders is also an important factor that militates against the “male
equivalence”. The position of women has improved down the ages and there is hardly
any field without a women’s touch and politics is now exception.110
Sarbjeet Singh and Pankaj Dodh (2013) in this book, “Gender Justice and
Women Empowerment: An Integrated Approach”, provide an integrated analysis of the
dynamics of gender justice and women empowerment. The authors analyses various
dimensions of gender justice, gender equality and women empowerment by applying a
multi-disciplinary perspective. The main thrust remains on transforming the status of
women through enhancing socio-economic security supported by effective statutory
and political enforcement. The aim of the study is to ensure greater participation of
women in decision making process based on the universal values of equality, justice
and honour.111
Nandita Dutta and Sumitra Jha (2014) in this study, “Women and Politics”,
author discussed women’s participation in politics. In a major political movement of
this century, in all movements of social change, women have played an extremely
important role. But despite participation and mobilization of women in politics, in the
broad sense of the term, we have not seen a commensurate increase in the number of
women in different level of decision making. Women’s participation in mainstream
political activity has major implications for the broader arena of governance in any
country. Women’s participation in politics is very low. Finally, the authors say where
women constitute half of the population in political system, which supports equality
110
S. Lal, Women in Indian Politics, New Delhi: Kunal Books, 2010.
111
Sarbjeet Singh and Pankaj Dodh (eds.), Gender Justice and Women Empowerment: An Integrated
Approach, New Delhi: Regal Publications, 2013.
38
and where both women and men are legally eligible for political office, women’s
participation should be equal to that of men.112
112
Nandita Dutta and Sumitra Jha, Women and Politics, Delhi: Pacific Books International, 2014.
113
Omita Goyal (ed.), Interrogating Women’s Leadership and Empowerment, New Delhi: Sage
Publications, 2015.
39
gender sensitivity implies making plans which will not ignore and further marginalize
women, but will take care of women’s special needs and make efforts to involve and
empower women.
The author further points out that gender sensitization is necessary at all levels
in all organisations. Gender sensitivity also means acknowledging that all issue
economic, cultural, social or political are women’s issues because women represent
half the human race. Keeping this aspect of gender sensitivity in mind, the volume of
the study helped us to understand various dimensions of gender inequality and give
insight into various challenges relating to gender inequality.114
Articles
Annapurna Devi and N.M. Pati (1981) in this study, “Women in State Politics
(Orissa)”, deals with the women in states politics. Both the authors found that the most
114
Mamta Mokta (ed.), Dimensions of Gender Inequality in Society, Chandigarh: Shree Ram Law
House, 2016.
115
Usha Kiran, Participation of Women in Indian Politics: Gender Justice and Political Challenge,
Delhi: Globus Press, 2016.
40
of the able, educated women, especially those from the middle class background do not
wish to get themselves involved in political activities for many reasons. Lack of
training in political organizations and the poor political socialization process makes
women dependent and develop attitude of indifference towards politics. The social
traditions engulfed with various taboos continue to look down upon women as a part of
the households, not as a part of the public life. The attitude of men is the most
important factor, which retards women’s political involvement. Their political choice is
controlled, regulated and maintained by male members of the society. Finally, women
are kept out of all kinds of major decision-making processes and are therefore not given
any chance to improve the quality of leadership.116
Avijit Pathak (1998) in his article, “Looking beyond Reservation: Need for the
Feminisation of Politics”, has discussed the issue of reservation for women in
legislative bodies. According to the author, reservation has got the symbolic sense and
can inspire women to participate more actively and assertively in the process of nation
building. However, the reservation has been reported to lose its original purpose, it is
politically hijacked and used for immediate and temporal gains. Also in the name of
reservation, the collectivities are used and invented for political mobilization. He has
emphasised the need to think beyond the reservation and to feminize the culture to have
a long-term perspective. It has been advised to initiate a mass movement by women
activists.117
Neeta Bora and Munni Padalia (1999) in this article, “Involvement of women
in India’s Political Process”, deals with the brief description of the participation of
women candidates in elections. The authors observe, that a very insignificant number
of women members have been representing at the national and state levels. They
suggests to increase women’s participation, education, financial independence, role of
political parties and a liberal social view as an essential at all levels. A change in the
social outlook will not only provide a just position to women in society but would also
increase their participation in politics at all levels. Then there would be no need for
reservation to them.118
116
Annapurna Devi and N.M. Pati, “Women in State Politics (Orissa)”, Political Science Review, Vol.
20, 1981.
117
Avijit Pathak, “Looking beyond Reservation: Need for the Feminization of Politics”, Mainstream,
Vol. 36, No. 36, August 1998.
118
Neeta Bora and Munni Padalia, “Involvement of Women in India’s Political Process”, in M.P. Dube
and Neeta Bora (eds.), Social Justice and Women in India, Delhi: Swaraj Prakashan, 1999.
41
S. Shukla (1999) in this articles, “Reservation for Women and Multi-member
Constituencies”, the author discussed about male members for fearing the loss of
power on one side, do not prefer reservation for women and on the other, political
career is not based on meritocratic considerations but it is attributed by agitation,
organizational and even physical muscle capabilities. Thus, the author apprehended
capabilities and capacities of women activists in politics, in lives of their domestic and
social responsibilities and delivering goods in competition with male leaders. The
author discussed that reservation may help distribution and development of power but
the issue of giving representation to disadvantaged groups to be given a special
attention. Therefore, the author suggested multiple or double member constituencies in
order to give representation to male and females, besides on other socio-economic
variable considerations.119
119
S. Shukla, “Reservation for Women and Multi-member Constituencies”, Mainstream, Vol. 35, No.
27, June 1999.
120
S.K. Chaturvedi, “Women Participation in Political Process”, in M.P. Dube and Neeta Bora (eds.),
Social Justice and Women in India, Delhi: Swaraj Prakashan, 1999.
42
empowerment of women. However, now women are struggling for their legitimate
place in society. Political participation of the women constitutes the foremost step in
this direction. Even in the developing countries right to vote was given to women very
late. The study reveals that even today women’s political participation is less at the
world level as well as in India. She reported that we had Indira Gandhi, the longest
serving women Prime Minister of the world but there are not adequate seats for women
in parliament. It also signifies the emerging recognition of women factor in politics and
above all their role in overall development in an economy. But illiteracy, low economic
status, criminalization and violence in politics are the main hindrances. So, it is
necessary to impart education and promote women’s economic status. The author
suggested that there should be legal reform to make the lives of women safe, secure and
dignified.121
121
Usha Narayanan, “Women’s Political Empowerment: Imperatives and Challenges”, Mainstream,
Vol. 37, No.16, April 1999.
122
Manu Bhaskar, “Women and Grass-root Politics: Theoretical Issues and Social Concern of Kerala
Women”, South Asia Journal of Socio-Political Studies, Vol. 1, No.1, January-June 2000.
43
to the urban India. Thus several efforts have been made to improve the economic status
of rural women by providing them employment opportunities. The author points out
that, it is necessary to increase awareness among the women regarding available
opportunities, their rights and responsibilities through education from grass-roots level
in rural areas.123
Nirmla Buch (2001) in this article, “Panchayats and Women”, she has
discussed about the development and the status of women in Panchayati Raj
Institutions. After a great length of discussion, she observes that despite the women’s
mass participation, role of women in the mainstream activity has remained marginal.
The author took the pragmatic side after the 73rd constitutional amendment. According
to her a number of myths became current about women’s entry. In a study conducted in
the northern state led to four myths about their entry and likely performance; their
passivity and disinterest in the political institutions; only the well to do, upper strata
women will come through reservation; women’s political connectivity, only kinds of
powerful politicians will enter Panchayats to keep the seats for them and lastly and
most importantly; women’s are only proxy name sake members and they don’t
participate in the Panchayats activities. The field data collected in the study explores
these myths without discounting existence and behaviour of some women, who would
fit into this patriarchal, oriented from but the conclusion derived by the author is that it
is only transitory position of women members. Further, they would themselves learn by
their experience about the organization and working of the system.124
C. Jayanti (2001) in this article, “Empowering Women”, deals with the women
empowerment. This article is based on the speech of President K. R. Narayanan at the
Convention on Liberal Values in New Delhi on 5th January 1996. It would be seen that,
in the evolution of human civilization, economic, cultural, social, civil and political
aspects have some together to produce, what are now called human rights. The fact
that, women rights need to be safeguarded in every parts of the world cannot be
overemphasized. The government of India has made special efforts to increase its
support for social sectors and started a number of schemes aimed at the poor,
particularly weaker section among women and the informal sectors. Thus, the 73rd and
123
S. Mehartaj Begum, “Women Rights and Rural Employment”, Kurukshetra, Vol.48, No.7, April
2000.
124
Nirmala Buch, “Panchayats and Women”, Kurukshetra, Vol. 49, No. 7, April 2001.
44
74th constitutional amendment act of 1994, marks historical events in the advancement
of women, as it ensure the one third of total seats for women in all elected offices of
local bodies in rural and urban areas. Women’s empowerment in political right will be
a decisive factor that will fortify and save the democratic politics in India from the
deterioration of standards and values, as it is experiencing today.125
Rajinder Sachar (2003) in his study, “Need for a Mass Social Movement”, he
discussed that reservation of women is not a bounty but an honest recognition of their
contribution to social development. The author has advised the political parties to
involve women seriously so that the women’s Reservation Bill becomes a law. Further,
he has laid down the role that women have to play in making the bill a reality. He
suggested that women’s organizations irrespective of political affiliations should form a
common platform with single agenda. A need for the mass social movement has been
brought forward so that women representation in parliament and assemblies could be
achieved in order to achieve gender equality.126
45
election only 44 women (exactly 8 percent of the strength of Lok Sabha) have been
elected. The author argues, the pattern of voting by women in this election, clearly
establishes the fact that a large portion of women take voting decision at their own.
Women’s overwhelming supports for the issues relating to their public and political
participation can be definitely regarded as positive pointer towards strengthening of
women politics in future. The author further points out that, women acts as a single
unit in certain respects and do not act in certain others. Hence gender reality appears to
be a layered reality.128
Gail Omvedt (2005) in his article, “Women in Governance in South Asia”, the
author has discussed the women empowerment. Although, South Asia claims to be
some of the most powerful women leaders of the world, however in over all political
participation of women remain dismal. The obstacles to women’s equal participation in
governance in these countries are embedded in socio-cultural patterns of living and the
intensely competitive nature of politics. This article examines various women
empowerment initiatives, like community management, local governance and
reservation. It also analyses the representation of women in parliament of these
countries and suggests that, what is needed is not a retreat from demanding quotas but a
128
Rajeshwari Deshpende, “How Gendered was Women’s Participation in Election 2004?”, Economic
and Political Weekly, Vol. 34, No. 51, December 2004.
129
Ramesh K. Chauhan and S.N. Ghosh, “Himachal Pradesh: Bipolar Contest”, Economic and Political
Weekly, Vol. 39, No. 51, December 2004.
46
consideration of the most useful forms of such reservations. Along with this, author
sense the women’s representation in the bureaucracy and the structures of the political
parties also has to be increased.130
Girija Vyas (2008) in her study, “Women Empowerment: Remedy for Social
Elevation”, the author has discussed that empowerment is a continuous process for
realising the ideals of equality, human liberation and freedom for all. The need for
women’s empowerment was felt in India a long back. The state concern in
safeguarding the rights and privileges of women found its best expression in the
constitution. The important policies that have vital implications for women are
‘National Policy for Empowerment of Women’, 2001. The enactment of the 73rd and
the 74th amendment, is a landmark in women’s empowerment and leadership, needs to
be implemented effectively. The author puts her views forth, that a woman needs to be
oriented towards political goals. Therefore, empowerment lies in a strong willpower
and a gender just reform in the whole system, covering the major interrelated issues. It
requires involvement of every segment of society, women as well as men, government,
laws, judiciary, political parties, as well as social reformers, religious leaders, journalist
and media.132
130
Gail Omvedt, “Women in Governance in South Asia”, Economic and Political Weekly, Vol. 40, No.
44-45, October-November 2005.
131
A. Thanikodi and M. Sugirtha, “Status of Women in Politics”, The Indian Journal of Political
Science, Vol. 68, No.3, July-September 2007.
132
Girija Vyas, “Women Empowerment: Remedy for Social Elevation”, Yojana, Vol. 52, September
2008.
47
organization and social consciousness. Empowering of women pre-supposes a drastic,
dynamic and democratic change in the perception and expectation from women in our
society, to have a sustainable development. She described that the constitution of the
India, has explicitly conferred on women as well as political, social, educational and
empowerment opportunities equivalent with men. However, due to oppressive
traditions, superstitions, exploitation and corruptions, a great majority of Indian women
are not allowed to enjoy the rights and opportunities bestowed upon them. National
Policy for women empowerment 2001 has also been discussed.
The author found that women have been subjected to exploitation for ages and
cannot break the shackles of illiteracy, poverty and tradition over night. Even today
most of the women are uneducated, having little or no property and are live forced to
traditional bounds of society. So there is a little scope for them to participate in the
process of the reformation of society. Although in some cases women have initiated to
join the political power as a means of reformer, and participation in PRIs is one of
them. However, the problem with regard to women participation in the PRIs is that
many of them especially in the rural areas are not willing to come forward to contest
the elections. Even the leader of political parties and the official are opined that women
are not reluctant to participate in politics. In most cases the reservation merely
strengthened the grip of the rural elite. The funds meant for women welfare are not
used for the right purposes. They have been accepted as equals in local bodies by men.
She suggests that periodical training, orientation and sensitization make the women
leaders perform the assigned role in a better way. So, for a woman her real
empowerment begins, when she is able to raise her consciousness of herself, shape her
own worldview and form an association with other people whose consciousness is also
being awakened. 133
133
Kamini B. Dashora, “Women Empowerment and Panchayati Raj”, Third Concept, Vol. 22, No. 262,
December 2008.
48
“second class citizens”. However the 73rd constitutional amendment act, 1993 opened a
new chapter in the history of democratic decentralization in India by developing power
to the people and gives opportunities to women folk to express their voice in the
decision making process. He explained that there are so many factors upsetting the
process of participation and level of performance of women in the Panchayati Raj
Institutions. Broadly, these factors may be categorized as internal and external factor.
He point out that introduction of women’s organization and the consequent emergence
of women leadership at the grass root level have brought about social changes in the
rural women’s life, in general and village communities in particular. Reservation has
resulted in bringing a novel group of women representative in to Panchayati Raj
Institutions.
Further, the author suggested that in order to make their participation effective,
efficient and successful, there is a need of vital change in traditional, social attitude and
patriarchal values of society. There is also need for positive attitudinal change and
mental make-up of the male folk in favour of women’s participation. They should be
given appropriate training to improve their knowledge base and capacity level relating
to their rights responsibilities and duties in the functioning of Panchayats bodies. They
should be made acquainted with the procedures of Panchayati Raj rules, regulations and
financial management. There is also need for launching more and more awareness
campaigning in favour of women’s empowerment.134
Ashutosh Kumar and Jagroop Singh Sekhon (2009) in this study, “Punjab:
Resurgence of the Congress” the authors studied the electoral politics in Punjab, where
congress improved significantly on its electoral performance in Punjab as compared to
the previous Lok Sabha elections. The slender lead in terms of votes polled enabled the
congress to march ahead of Shiromani Akali Dal- Bharatiya Janta Party combine in
terms of the number of seats won. The number was much greater, if seen in terms of
assembly constituency segments, where the Congress took lead (65) as against 44
constituencies, which were being represented by the party legislators. As for the other
parties in the fray the Bahujan Samaj Party’s (BSP) poor electoral performance
continued despite a significant presence of the dalits, which constitute more than 23 per
cent of the state’s population as against the national average of 16 per cent. The article
further argues that presence of dalits is most visible in Ferozepur and Hoshiarpur
134
Dasarathi Bhuyan, “Participation in Panchayati Raj”, Yojana, Vol. 52, October 2008.
49
constituencies. The inability of the Bahujan Samaj Party to mobilise the dalit vote also
helped the Congress, which has had a relatively good support base amongst the dalits in
different religions. The Congress also benefited from the gradual slide of the left
parties, its erstwhile electoral allies.135
135
Ashutosh Kumar and Jagroop Singh Sekhon, “Punjab: Resurgence of the Congress”, Economic and
Political Weekly, Vol. 44, No. 39, September 2009.
136
Sandip Kumar Ghatak, “Political Participation of Women of West Bengal: Its Nature and Extent”,
The Indian Journal of Political Science, Vol. 71, No. 1, January-March 2010.
50
implemented several programmes to eradicate poverty and provided education to the
vulnerable sections of society. In the end, the author point out that women’s
empowerment is the hallmark of the government’s approach in its development
initiatives, especially in terms of social, political and economic.137
137
V. Deepa Nair, “Status of Women in Andhra Pradesh: A Paradigm Shift”, Man and Development,
Vol. 32, No. 1, March 2010.
138
Arpita Sharma, “Women Empowerment: Milestone and Challenges”, Kurukshetra, Vol. 59, No.11,
September 2011.
51
in all spheres of political life and electoral competition in particular, will not only
ensure political parity and equality with men, but would also serve the larger interest
that is empowerment of women.139
It was only in the aftermath of the 73rd constitutional amendment that has
created a space for women in political participation and decision-making at the
grassroots level by reserving one-third of the seats for women all over the country. The
article also expresses deep concern on the illiteracy, economic insecurity and male
interference in the functioning of women at grassroots politics. Above all, it has been
observed in the article, that the participation of women in PRIs has changed, the male
dominance at the grassroots politics. Today, women are taking interests in politics and
are becoming aware and conscious about their rights and duties. The participation of
women in panchayats is certainly one mechanism through such a change can take
place, and the strategic gender interest of women is getting advanced.141
139
Praveen Rai, “Electoral Participation of Women in India: Key Determinants and Barriers”, Economic
and Political Weekly, Vol. 46, No. 3, January 2011.
140
A. Prema, “Women Status in India”, Indian Streams Research Journal, Vol. 2, No. 1, February 2012.
141
Rakesh K. Singh, “Elected Women Representatives in Panchayat Raj,” Social Action, Vol. 62,
January-March 2012.
52
Saroj Choudhary (2012) in her article, “Political Participation and
Representation of Women in Indian Politics”, reveals that participation of women in
Indian politics is based on the principles of equality to all its citizens. The constitution
of India not only guarantees fundamental rights and freedom, but also prohibits
discrimination on the basis of religion, race, caste, sex, and place of birth. However,
these rights have remained de jure and have not been translated into de facto rights.
Lack of space for participation in political bodies has not resulted in their say in
decision making bodies but also neglected their concerned and experiences in policy
making. Women’s disproportionate absence from the political process would mean that
the concerns of the women cannot be sufficiently attended to or acted.
In the article, the author further examine that reservation would only help
women of the elitist groups to gain seats, therefore causing further discrimination and
under-representation to the poor and backward classes among women. The most of
members argue that, it is better to create reservation of women in political parties rather
than in parliament. Simultaneously, the provision of rotation of reserved seats is also
debated. It can reduce the incentive of the elected MPs to spend energy because he or
she may not be able to re-seek the mandate from the same constituency. The Bill has to
go through elaborative procedures, as it had been already passed by the Rajya Sabha
but the real impact will be only, when it passes through the Lok Sabha.142
142
Saroj Choudhary, “Political Participation and Representation of Women in Indian Politics”,
International Journal of Behavioral Social and Movement Sciences, Vol. 1, No. 4, October 2012.
53
activity at the grass-roots level at least. The present national level indicators are also
not encouraging for the future of political empowerment of women, provided that
women’s reservation bill get passed in the parliament.143
Further in this article, her study of five legislative state assemblies i.e. Goa,
Manipur, Punjab, Uttarakhand and Uttar Pradesh reveals that women have been
accepted as voters but not as policy formulators. Gender discrimination rules the scene
even in the state legislature, where women constitute a very small percentage vis-a-vis
men. The number of women candidates contesting for the state’s legislative assemblies
has been extremely discouraging. It is unfortunate that in India even after six decades
of independence, the status and position of women in political participation and their
representation, is a myth and still a distant dream. Lastly, the author argues for the
reservation of seats and due representation for women in national and state legislatures,
not only to improve the self respect of Indian women but also to ensure the political
empowerment of women in our society.144
143
Y. Sivaramaiah, “Women’s Empowerment and Indian Elections”, Indian Journal of Research, Vol.
1, No. 12, December 2012.
144
Manpreet Kaur Brar, “Political Participation and Representation of Women in State Assemblies”,
International Journal of Behavioural Social and Movement Sciences, Vol. 2, No. 4, November 2013.
54
mindsets. Finally, he suggests that women need a safe political environment, which
provides a level playing field for their participation.145
The authors further points out by examining the multi-dimensional facets of the
participation of women in politics. But conclude by saying that there is a dire need to
carry forward an extension of the reform at grass-roots democracy by reserving the
seats for women in parliament and state legislatures.146
145
Shreedhar Barki, “Issues of Women Representation and Women in Indian Parliament”, Global
Research Analysis, Vol. 2, No.10, October 2013.
146
Thapai Ananda, et al., “Political Participation of Women in India-An Overview”, International
Journal of Advanced Research, Vol.1, No.10, 2013.
147
Achla Sharma, “Status of Women: A Socio-Historical Analysis in Different Ages of Indian Society”,
Research Journal of Language, Literature and Humanities, Vol. 1, No.1, January 2014.
55
Barsha Kalita (2014) in her article, “Political Status of Women in Assam: An
Analysis”, argues that women’s participation in politics makes the democratic system
more efficient and viable. Women have been marginalised politically in our country
and have to confine within the four wall of their household. She find that, democracy
can never function in the real sense of the term, if there is no proper involvement of
women in the decision making process in the sphere of governance. The issues
concerning women always remained neglected area, without their proper representation
at all levels. However, only by enacting legislations will also not help. In this article
the author suggested an immediate change in the social attitude and mindset of people
and civil society. The proper education, economic and financial independence has been
of immense concern to bring women out of the shackles of social evils in our society.
They need to be properly represented in the decision and policy making bodies
otherwise, will always remain unrepresented and neglected. Finally not only this the
women also need to overcome from the social taboos, evil customs and traditional
myths, if proper representation is to be ensured, this will not only empowers women
but the society as a whole.148
In this article author studied, the presence of women and their participation in
public sphere and decision-making process in India has been very low both at the
national and state levels. They are not adequately represented in the parliament and in
the state legislatures. This shows that women do not enjoy the same privileges and
opportunities, as men. Although, the country has legislation that guarantees equality
before the law. For instance, while everyone has the right to seek public office, very
few women file certificates of candidacy because they lack access to the substantial
148
Barsha Kalita, “Political Status of Women in Assam: An Analysis”, Golden Research Thoughts, Vol.
4, No.1, July 2014.
56
resources needed for a political campaign. Besides, there are many barriers in public
and private space that hinder women participation in politics. Majority of women in our
country are still struggling to deal with the burden of responsibility and handle the
various obstacles that are coming their way from their traditional cultures.
Consequently, women have never been visible in great number in the political life of
the nation.
E. Sridharan (2014) in this study, “Class Voting in the 2014 Lok Sabha
Elections: The Growing Size and Importance of the Middle Classes”, analyses the
middle class and other classes voted in the 2014 elections. He focused on the voting for
the Bharatiya Janta Party and Indian National Congress, voter preferences along the
caste/community and age groups within classes, to the extent relevant, and economic
policy, particularly as concerns economic liberalization. Author found that in 2014 the
class-wise gradation of pro-BJP responses, with pro-BJP sentiment rising as we go up
the class hierarchy, as well as the caste hierarchy, indicate support for the emergence of
a loose, not compact, “new social bloc” of class and caste privilege. This supports the
Iversen Soskice (2006) finding that majoritarian electoral systems tend towards a top-
middle alliance in the absence of a corporatist economic structure. However, on
economic policy issues, particularly about liberalization and the role of the state, the
responses are much more mixed.
149
Durga Prasad Chhetri, “Women in Public Sphere: An Enquiry into Women’s Representation and
Participation in Politics”, American International Journal of Research in Humanities, Arts and Social
Sciences, Vol. 6, No.1, March-May 2014.
57
He argued earlier the Indian middle classes attitudes towards liberalization are
complex and contradictory because a large fraction of the middle class, though
declining gradually over time with the growth of the private sector and also as we go up
the class hierarchy are public employees broadly defined. Thus, an estimated 58 per
cent to 75 per cent of the broadest middle class of 26 per cent of the population as of
the turn of the century were either public employees or rich peasants and even of the
elite middle class of 6 per cent as of 2005-06 as many as 30 per cent belonged to these
segments. Even those of the middle classes who are self-employed persons or private
employees are like public employees or rich peasants, the beneficiaries of a range of
state subsidies including water, electricity fertilizer credit fuel higher education, public
transport and even food. Hence, one can accept the middle classes political alignments
to be complexly determined by competition for patronage interwoven with identity
politics, party loyalties and ideology. Besides, the poorer classes and lower castes have
also voted more for BJP than Congress or any other party in this election, a factor that
needs explanation, and one that cannot be explained in terms of redistributive
programmes or patronage politics except perhaps in the limited number of BJP-ruled
states. Class is therefore only one of several axes of polarization in India in 2014 and
class politics in the sense of developed democracies, particularly in Europe, or left-right
axis on economic policy as in the those countries, is still not the norm in India. Overall,
given the extremely regionally skewed nature of the BJP victory, with 244 seats of its
282 coming from the Hindi-belt states and western India, accounting for only 61 per
cent of the population, we need to have regionally disagreeable survey data to be able
to fully comprehend the voting trends by class, caste/community and age groups within
each region, as well as the attitudes towards minorities and majoritarianism and
towards economic policy. Author reveals that it is too early to be able to confidently
project the trends in this election into future, he suggest that we will need to observe a
couple of more elections to see whether these trends hold.150
150
E. Sridharan, “Class Voting in the 2014 Lok Sabha Elections the Growing Size and Importance of
the Middle Classes”, Economic and Political Weekly, Vol. 49, No. 39, September 2014.
58
unfortunately in this male dominating society, the education of women has been
neglected for a long time. Empowering women is an important end in itself and will
acquire the same status with men in terms of social, economic and legal sense, their
human well-being will be enhanced. The present study, explores the role of education
in women empowerment and the status of women education in India and suggested
that, education is most important part in the life of every woman.151
151
Manav Aggarwal, “A Study on Challenge for Women Empowerment”, Journal of Research in
Commerce and Management, Vol. 3, No. 5, May 2014.
152
Mamta Mokta, “Empowerment of Women in India: A Critical Analysis”, Indian Journal of Public
Administration, Vol. 60, No. 3, July-September 2014.
153
Kalidash Brahma, “Political Participation of Women in India: A Post Independence Scenario”, Asian
Journal of Multidisciplinary Studies, Vol. 2, No. 4, April 2014.
59
K. K. Kailash (2014), in his article, “Regional Parties in the 16th Lok Sabha
Elections: Who Survived and Why?”, the author attempts to explain, why some
regional parties flourished and other fizzled out in the 16th general elections to the Lok
Sabha. To explain this variation, he made a distinction between regionally-located
parties and regionalist parties. While, both are regional parties in the sense that they
have territorially limited arena of operation however, they are different in terms of their
programme and agenda. In the 2014 elections, the regionally-located parties fared
relatively poor in comparison to the regionalist parties. Further, he argues that success
and failure often depends on the efforts, strategies and tactics of competitors. The
strategy of the Bharatiya Janta Party was favourable to the electoral fortunes of
regionalist parties and disadvantageous to the regionally-located parties. This selective
emphasis and muting of issues depending on how, it fitted with its overall programme
that opened up enormous possibilities for the BJP and misfortune for the non-
regionalist party. Finally the author conclude by saying that the BJP will have to work
very hard to maintain its newly stitched social coalitions, if past experiences are
anything to go by.154
154
K.K. Kailash, “Regional Parties in the 16th Lok Sabha Elections: Who Survived and Why?”,
Economic and Political Weekly, Vol. 49, No. 39, September 2014.
155
Kuldeep Fadia, “Women’s Empowerment Through Political Participation in India”, Indian Journal of
Public Administration, Vol. 60, No. 3, July-September 2014.
60
the advancement of women throughout the globe. Participation in electoral process
involves much more than just voting. Political participation derives from the freedom to
speak out, assemble and associate; the ability to take part in the conduct of public
affairs; and the opportunity to register as a candidate to campaign, to be elected and to
hold office at all levels of government. Under international standards, men and women
have equal right to participate fully in all aspects of the political process. In this study
author finds that, in post-conflict countries there are frequently extra barriers to
women’s participation, and thereby special care is required to ensure, their rights are
protected in this regard.156
Simi Agnihotri and Vijay Singh (2014) in this study, “Women Empowerment
Through Reservation in Panchayati Raj Institutions in Himachal Pradesh”, deal with
the women empowerment through reservation in PRIs in Himachal Pradesh. In this
article author’s explained that, the situation of women representation in Panchayati Raj
Institutions (PRIs) in Himachal Pradesh through 73rd constitutional amendment act, has
changed a lot. This experiment is proving to be a big success, particularly by providing
opportunity to women to come out of their houses and participate in administrative and
political field. With the increasing violence against women in our society, it becomes
necessary to find out the problems of our society regarding women and give valuable
suggestions deals with the problem. To give the representation to the women, in a local
self-government is also a step to move forward in the direction of women
empowerment in our society.
The article further suggested that, with the establishment of PRIs in our country,
a woman got an opportunity to prove her worth as a good administrator, decision-
maker or a good leader. The government should provide extra financial, administrative
or political assistance to women for the success of the provision of the amendment. So,
it becomes necessary to encourage the women, in a largest democracy of the world. To
give a proper status to the women, government, NGOs and universities have to play a
vital role in this field.157
156
K. Shamatha, “Women’s Participation in Electoral Politics”, Global Journal for Research Analysis,
Vol. 3, No.2, February 2014.
157
Simi Agnihotri and Vijay Singh, “Women Empowerment Through Reservation in Panchayati Raj
Institutions in Himachal Pradesh”, Indian Journal of Public Administration, Vol. 60, No. 3, July-
September 2014.
61
Srinivasan (2014) in this article, “Women Empowerment and Parliament in
India”, the author emphasized on the need and urgency of empowering women,
especially in the Indian context. He takes a brief look at various initiatives, undertaken
during the past five-year plans in respect of empowering women and thereafter, he
proceeds to the political representation of women in the parliament. In final analysis,
he stresses on the need for enacting the legislation ensuring 33 percent quota for
women representation in the legislatures as an effective measure to ensure female
empowerment, keeping in view the total population of women in the country. Though,
India is already ahead of many other countries in terms of women’s participation in
politics but still the percentage of women in legislature and decision-making process
has remained low.158
Vikas Nandal and Rajnish (2014) in this article, “Status of Women Through
Ages in India” deal with the status of women in India. In ancient India status of women
to some extent was satisfactory. However, in recent years, the role of women has
undergone through drastic changes due to globalization and commercialism. It is in this
context the author in this article examined the status of women in modern Indian
society with regard to equality, education, health, employment, marriage and family life
has maintained or deteriorated. It explores that, as the society is moving toward in the
21st century, the position and respect of women is deteriorating even after so many
constitutional provisions. Both argue that, the women have equal participation in
human development but she is still lacking the honour in society women is not treated
at par with men, in comparison to ancient Indian society. Finally the article says that,
there is a lot of crime against women in modern society, even the constitutional
provisions are not sufficient to get the respectable position in society. There is a need
for change in the mind-set of both the men and women. In modern times, the
technological advancement, globalization and commercialism came in to existence but
the status and position of women has rather deteriorated.159
158
Srinivasan, “Women Empowerment and Parliament in India”, Third Concept, Vol. 28, No. 331,
September 2014.
159
Vikas Nandal and Rajnish, “Status of Women Through Ages in India”, International Research
Journal of Social Sciences, Vol. 3, No. 1, January 2014.
62
of family, religion and public life, but as centuries rolled on, the situation went on
changing adversely. He pointed out that, some of the grievances, from which women
were suffering during the last two thousand years, were either theoretical or common to
both men and women. The detailed survey of the position of women that the author has
made in this article would be of considerable use to us in understanding and solving
most of the problems that confront us today. Luckily, the need and advantage of female
education is now fully understood. When girls of 17 or 18, equipped with proper
education, enter matrimony, they cannot but be treated with instinctive respect and
consideration by all the society around. Family responsibility and not inherent
incapacity would be the normal cause of their not being earning members of their
families; they would, therefore, receive the same respect that is instinctively given to
the breadwinner. Their practical attainments would add to the beauty of their husbands,
lead to economy in its expenditure and promote sounder education of the children of
the family. This would surely ensure for them an equality of status with their husbands
in all cultured families. In the sphere of marriage and marital relations, some reforms
are necessary, very urgently. It is high time now that polygamy should be legally
prohibited. Women have already obtained political rights and privileges, more or less
coextensive with those of men. They will figure more prominently in public life when
there is a wider spread of education and a further improvement in the economic
condition of society. The few changes that are suggested above are not in any way
against the spirit of our culture.160
160
A.S. Altekar, “The Position of Women in Hindu Civilization: Retrospect and Prospect”, in
Kumkum Roy (ed.), Women in Early Indian Societies, New Delhi: Manohar Publishers, 2015.
63
needs and obsolete social customs have made women bold, outspoken and conscious of
dignity and rights.161
Nibha Rathi and M.M. Semwal (2016) in this article, “Women’s Political
Participation in Uttarakhand”, reveals that the women’s participation in the political
process in India has ensured voting rights for women, as early as in the 1st Lok Sabha
poll held in 1951-52, on the basis of gender equality. The women’s political
participation at national level is still negligible even today and the we rank amongst the
worst faring countries in the world. Author’s highlights women’s participation in the
political process, since ancient times to, with special emphasis on the state of affairs in
the hill state of Uttarakhand. Both argue that, women’s participation in the political
process in Uttarakhand is increasingly getting stronger. However, prior to 73rd and 74th
constitutional amendments, women’s presence in the politics of Uttarakhand was only
exceptional. But once these amendments became law, not only women’s participation
and representation increased in local bodies and Panchayats, but also started realizing
that, their enhanced representation in the political arena holds the key to the resolution
of many women related issues.
161
Swati Chattopadhyay, “Political Participation of Women”, Third Concept, Vol. 29, No. 339, May
2015.
162
Nibha Rathi and M.M. Semwal, “Women’s Political Participation in Uttarakhand”, Third Concept,
Vol. 29, No. 347, January 2016.
64
turnout. The difference in male and female voter turnout has slimmed down to 1.5 per
cent by 2014. This narrowing gender gap establishes beyond doubt that more women
are exercising their electoral rights. Similarly, women’s participation in election
campaigns increased significantly between 1999 and 2014. However, it is equally clear
that this feminisation of Indian politics is being resisted by the male dominated political
establishment and party personnel, apparatuses and procedures.
In the last the author says that the political parties played a destructive role in
scuttling the Women’s Reservation Bill in the last Lok Sabha have become redundant
after the general elections in 2014. The current government has given a positive signal
for women-inclusive politics, providing six cabinet ministerial positions to women,
raising hopes that it would build an all party consensus and pass the long-standing Bill
in due course.163
163
Praveen Rai, “Women’s Participation in Electoral Politics in India: Silent Feminisation”, South Asia
Research, Vol. 37, No.1, 2017.
164
Srinivasa Murthy, “Women Empowerment: Issues and Challenges”, The International Journal of
Indian Psychology, Vol. 4, No. 2, January-March 2017.
65
After reviewing the study, we are able to chart the course of our problem. The
following inferences can be drawn from the above study. These various books, journals
and articles give us a deep understanding of the concept of political participation and
empowerment of women in politics. This will not only help in data interpretation but
also gives a broader view of the concept of women empowerment. All these writers
have analysed the problem in a particular historical perspective, in a uni-dimensional or
multi-dimensional context. But we have made a humble effort to update the
participation of women in state politics, while taking a case study of Himachal Pradesh.
In the present context, when the world has focused on equality of gender the
micro study of the women as a part of political system has gained a tremendous
importance. In the national context for the last two decades, the central and the state
governments have made some efforts to improve the level of women political
participation. Women’s participation in politics goes far beyond their numbers in
elected bodies. In all major political movements of this century, in all movements of
social change, women have played an extremely important role. But despite of
participation and mobilization of women in politics, in this broad sense of the term, we
have not seen a commensurate increase in the number of women in different levels of
decision making.
The study has immense importance today, when the women issues are
dominating the national and international scenario. Women’s participation in
mainstream political activity has major implications for the broader arena of
governance. In India, women’s role has been marginal in the society, although they
constitute half of the country’s population. Their involvement in politics has been
negligible all along. Their number in the legislatures including parliament has always
remained at the very low. Nevertheless, several women played an active role in the
national movement and also in the political process after independence. In recent past,
there is wide spread realization that they should be emancipated and all types of
discrimination against them to be avoided to enable them to play a legitimate role in the
society. It is also emphasized that the emancipation of women could be possible only
through their social, economic and political empowerment and necessary steps to be
mooted out in this direction. The present study is an attempt to know about the
awareness amongst the women. The limited nature of female participation and
66
representation in national decision making institutions has important consequences for
women and for the legitimacy of the institutions. In this study, an attempt has been
made to analyse the participation of women in state politics.
Political participation of women is still a less than men. Women for centuries
have received unequal treatment in almost all spheres of life because of patriarchal
setup of Indian society. Despite of this, women have shown their presence in many
fronts, but a lot remains to be done in order to achieve real gender equality in social,
economic and political spheres, that are interrelated and give way to one another. Since
India became independent, many policy and programmes have been adopted to
improve the condition of women but women in general have not been in a position to
avail benefits mainly due to their political backwardness. Women are considered as
dependent, poor, kitchen object, and reproductive machine and less of human being. It
has been attributed to low level of education, ignorance, poor negotiating skills,
dependency, nature and individualistic approach of women that influence their extent
of participation in politics.
67
Objectives of the Study
(ii) To study the socio-economic and political profile of the women in Himachal
Pradesh.
(iii) To know about the issues and factor affecting the level and nature of political
participation of women.
(v) To know the pattern and level of participation of the women leadership in
Himachal Pradesh.
(vi) To explore the implications of new trends that has emerged as a consequence of
73rd Amendment.
(viii) To find out the various hindrances in the participation of the women.
(ix) To evaluate the existing strategies devised by the state machinery in the form of
various interventions to include women in decision making process at different
levels.
Hypothesis
The hypothesis which proposed to be tested through the present study relates to
participation of women in state politics. Following are the main hypothesis of present
research:
(i) There are many obstacles for the women in politics, which hampers their
participation and performance.
(ii) The awareness level of women is very low, even after reservation there is no
change in the participation and effectiveness of women’s performances.
(iii) Women’s are divided among different economic class, caste, religion and the
region. They need to break barriers of inequality and powerlessness for
participatory development at grass-root levels, state and national levels.
68
Universe of the Study
The Mandi district came into existence on 15th April 1948, as one of the first
four districts at the time of the emergence of the state of Himachal Pradesh. It is one of
the fastest developing towns of Himachal Pradesh. The economy of the region is
predominately agrain, as around 79 per cent of the total population is dependent on
agriculture. Agriculture and animal husbandry are the major occupation of the people.
The production of food grains and cash crops (i.e. apple, potato, peas, etc.), are the
main source of its economy. The Mandi district is currently the second largest
economy in the state, next to the Kangra district. The district is also second largest in
population among twelve districts of Himachal Pradesh. Total Literacy rate of Mandi
district is 81.53 per cent out of which 89.56 percent of male and 73.66 per cent of
females. The district Mandi in the state is having third highest sex ratio of 1007
females per thousand males. The people of Mandi are informally called Mandyalis, the
Mandyali language Mandyalis is generally used at local level for communication. The
district has mixed population of people from different religion mainly Hindu, Muslim,
Sikh and Bodh. The Mandi district has been the second largest parliamentary
69
constituency (area-wise) in India including the area of Mandi, Kullu, Lahaul & Spiti
and Bharmour of Chamba and Rampur of Shimla districts. The district Mandi consists
of total ten Developmental Blocks viz. Chauntra, Drang, Gohar, Gopalpur, Karsog,
Mandi Sadar, Balh, Seraj, and Sunder Nagar. However, the present study has been
conducted on four blocks of Mandi district i.e Balh, Gohar, Mandi Sadar and Seraj.
These blocks were selected mainly because the Panchayat Samiti of these blocks was
headed by women as chairperson. Further, from each blocks only five Gram
Panchayats have been selected, which were headed by women as Panchayat Pradhans.
The district Kangra was a part of the state of Punjab and was merged in
Himachal Pradesh on 1st November 1966 and the newly merged areas, as called “New
Himachal”. Before the merger of these areas into Himachal as a district, it was part of
Punjab and there was an influence of Punjabi culture on the people of this area.
Therefore, the boundary of district Kangra touches to Punjab and the people of this area
speak Punjabi or mixture of Hindi and Punjabi both. The agriculture is the mainstay of
the majority of the rural population. Green and black tea is both produced in the
district. District Kangra has the distinction of having largest production of mangoes in
the state. It has no big industry worth the name. There are only small scale and cottage
industries based on local raw materials. On the basis of population Kangra is
considered the biggest district and is having second highest sex ratio of 1012 females
per thousand males. The total literacy rate of Kangra district is 85.67 per cent out of
which 91.49 percent of male and 80.02 per cent of females. The district Kangra consists
of total fifteen development blocks viz. Baijnath, Bhawarna, Lambagaon, Panchrukhi,
Kangra, Nagrota Bagwan, Rait, Dehra, Pragpur, Nagrota Surian, Nurpur, Indora,
Fatehpur, Sulah, Dharamshala. The study has been carried out in four Blocks of distrit
Kangra i.e Dharamshala, Nagrota Bagwan, Pragpur, Sulah. These blocks were selected
mainly because the Panchayat Samiti of these blocks was headed by women as
chairperson. Further, from each blocks only five Gram Panchayats have been selected,
which were headed by women as Panchayat Pradhans.
Sampling
70
Mandi and 146 from Kangra have been interviewed. In these 291 elected female
respondents from both the reserved and the open categories have been taken. To ensure
the nature of purposive representative sampling, special attention has been given to
wide representation of women with variables like age, caste, education, income, family
background and political participation etc. Thus the sample may constitute elected
female representatives from varied socio-economic and political background.
71
Himachal Pradesh
Seraj Bali Chowki Bali Chowki General Dharamshala Barwala Barwala Women
Narwana Narwana
Cheuni Cheuni SC
Khas Khas (M)
Sounkni da
Tungadhar Tungadhar General Sounkni Women
kot
Mandi
Aut Aut General Pragpur Dhounta Dhounta Women
Sadar
OBC
Takoli Takoli General Siyul Siyul
Women
Nagrota
Gohar Chhaprahan Chhaprahan General Bhuned Bhuned Women
Bagwan
72
Methodology
Primary Sources
The primary data for the present study has been collected through
questionnaires. The field study was conducted through the methods of questionnaire-
cum-interview schedule, discussions, dialogues and observations. The personal
interviews were conducted with the elected women representatives of the Panchayati
Raj Institutions and the state politics, to know about the extent of their participation in
the politics and the problems faced by them to discharge their duties in the functioning
of these institutions. An attempt has been made to observe the various problems faced
by women representatives to discharge their duties. Also efforts also have been made to
know about the role of education, age, caste, party politics, reservation, economic status
of women in political process.
Interview
73
Sometimes the respondents were reluctant to disclose their personal belongings and
secrets. In most of the cases the respondents were not aware of the exact position of the
women in politics.
Secondary Data
The secondary data was collected from published and unpublished sources. The
various published documents with regard to the women participation in politics
constitute the main sources of secondary data. It includes various books pertaining to
women participation in politics, articles, reports, seminars, etc. The various articles
related to the subject in different journals, magazines and newspaper were one of the
important sources of secondary data. The reports of different committees constituted by
the centre as well as by the state governments, also forms the main sources of
secondary data.
Tools of Data
There are many methods of analyzing the data. In the present study the
processing of data and the preparation of the tables for analysis and interpretation has
been done manually. The master charts were prepared manually and coding and
decoding was done accordingly. The percentage method was applied to analyse the
data.
Limitation of Study
The area of present study was limited to only two district out of twelve districts
of Himachal Pradesh. Out of these two district, 43 women members Zila Parishad, 40
Panchayat Samitis and 40 Gram Panchayats were selected for the purposive sampling.
But the limitation of our research was that, it was confined to only elected
representatives taken as respondents.
Scheme of Chapterisation
74
CHAPTER-II
The word Himachal derives its origin from the Hindi words, ‘Him’ and ‘Achal’
meaning ‘Snow’ and ‘Lap’ respectively. Etymologically, Himachal Pradesh stands for
the region, which lies in the slopes and foothills of snow i.e. the Himalayas.1 Himachal
was also known as Dev Bhumi to the ancients. It is situated in the heart of the Western
Himalayas. According to the Puranas, Himachal is the Jalandhara Khand of the
Himalayas.2 Himachal Pradesh is bounded on the north by the picturesque valley of
Kasmir; on the South by the fertile plains of the Punjab and Uttar Pradesh; on the west
by the districts of Ambala (Haryana) and Hoshiarpur (Punjab); and on the north-east by
Tibet.3
The Greater Himalaya and Zaskar ranges also house many glaciers. For
glaciers, the local term is Shigri, perhaps derived from a big Shigri glacier that once
created great havoc. The Diyamir is another glacier of large dimensions that descends
to the level of 9400 feet above sea level near the village Tarshing.5
1
M.S. Ahluwalia, History of Himachal Pradesh, New Delhi: Intellectual Publication, 1988, p. 2.
2
Mian Goverdhan Singh, Himachal Pradesh History, Culture & Economy, Shimla: Minerva
Publishers, 2010, p.1.
3
V. Verma, The Emergence of Himachal Pradesh: A Survey of Constitutional Developments, New
Delhi: Indus Publishing Company, 1995, p. 19.
4
Mian Goverdhan Singh, op.cit, 2010, p.1.
5
Himachal Past, Present and Future, Directorate of Correspondence Courses, Himachal Pradesh
University, Shimla, 1975, p. 3.
75
There are five rivers flowing through Himachal Pradesh. The eastern most river
is the Yamuna, which rises from Yamunotri in the Garhwal range of the Himalayas and
from the states in eastern boundary with Uttar Pradesh. Its most important tributaries
are the Tons, Giri and Pabar. The Satluj is the largest among five rivers. It enters the
eastern part of Himachal Pradesh at Shipki from the north-west. Following through
Kinnaur, Shimla Hills, Bilaspur district, it leaves Himachal Pradesh to enter the plains
of Punjab and Bhakra, where the World’s Largest Dam is constructed. The Beas which
forms the world valleys of Kullu and Kangra, rises from the 3,987 meters high Rohtang
Pass. Its tributaries are Parbati, Phojal and Sarvari streams. The Ravi river originated
from an amphitheatre like basin called Bara-Banghal, a branch of Dhauladhar. The fifth
river is Chandrabhaga or Chenab. The Chandra and Bhaga streams rise on the opposite
side of Baralacha Pass at an elevation of 4,891 meters, to stream from one river at
Tandi.6
The whole area may be classified in five zones on the basis of different soils as-
(i) low-hill soil zone (ii) mid-hill soil zone (iii) high-hill soil zone (iv) mountainous soil
zone and (v) dry-hill soil zone. The first zone covers area upto an altitude of 900
metres above sea level. The quality of the soils of this region is suitable for the
cultivation of maize, wheat, sugar-cane, ginger, paddy and citrus fruits. The second
zone covers area lying between 900 metres and 1500 metres above sea level. The soils
of this region are suitable for the cultivation of table potatoes, stone fruits, wheat and
maize. The high-hill soil zone, covering areas between 1,500 metres and 2,100 metres
above sea level, is the most suitable for the cultivation of seed potatoes and temperate
fruits. The mountainous-soil zone covering the altitudes between 2,100 metres and
3,000 metres is suitable for the cultivation of dry fruits only.7
6
Rajender Attri, Introduction to Himachal Pradesh, Shimla: Sarla Publication, 2002, p. 320.
7
Himachal Past, Present and Future, op.cit., 1975, pp. 156-157.
76
The majority of the Buddhists are concentrated in the districts of Lahaul and Spiti,
Kinnaur and Kullu, whereas the Sikhs live mostly in Kangra, Shimla and Mandi
districts. The Christians, though in a very small numbers are sprinkled over the whole
of state and so are the Jains.8 The people living in the Outer Himalaya or the Shiwaliks
have much in common with those in the plains of Punjab except that the former are
fairer in complexion because of the climatic factors. In fact, both in the medieval and
later period, there have been inter-migrations to these areas, being comparatively easily
accessible, and thus they are somewhat similar in their habits and cultural moorings to
the people of the plains.
The Brahmans and the Rajputs has migrated from the plains during the
lawlessness of Aurangzeb. The Sikhs settled in parts of Himachal, while fighting the
hilly rulers or having been driven by the Mughals. Himachal Pradesh also had its share
of displaced persons numbering about 4660 as a result of the partition. In general, the
people are honest, hospitable, peace-loving, and deeply religious and follow their
community codes very rigidly. The hilly women work harder than the men folk and are
robust. They are beautiful, modest and known for their sweet voice. Tribes or semi-
nomadic, semi-agricultural and semi-pastoral people are living in the Great Himalaya,
the Zaskar, the Pir Panjal, the Pangi, and the Dhauladhar ranges, or to be more precise,
in the Lahaul & Spiti region, Kinnaur, some part of Shimla, Kullu, Chamba districts
etc., there are an admixture of the Indo-Aryan and Mongolian races. The main tribes of
Himachal Pradesh are the Gaddis, Gujjars, Kinners of Kanaurs, Jads (Lambas,
Khampas and Bhots or Bhods), Lahaulis, Pangwalas and Swanglas.9
Due to the geographical conditions of the Pradesh, these tribes have to live a
very hard life. Most of these tribes, till recently, lived a nomadic life, wandering here
and there in search of food and grass for their animals. Also they remained practically
out of touch from the rest of the world, due to lack of modern facilities. It is believed
that most of the tribal’s in Himachal, migrated from the plains of Punjab and adjoining
areas from time to time. The early history of these tribes is shrouded in mystery.10
The cultural aspect plays an important role in shaping the progress of a region
and its society, as they are closely related to the mental attitudes of the people. As far as
8
M.S Ahluwalia, Social, Cultural and Economics History of Himachal Pradesh, New Delhi: Indus
Publishing Company, 1998, p. 66.
9
Himachal Past, Present and Future, op.cit., 1975, p. 11.
10
M.S. Ahluwalia, op.cit., 1998, p.80.
77
Himachal Pradesh is concerned, its social institutions, particularly the fairs and
festivals, have a considerable impact on its development. The fairs and festivals
represents, one of the important facets of state’s rich cultural heritage.11 Important fairs
in Himachal Pradesh are Minjar (Chamba), Dussehra (Kullu), Shivarati (Mandi), Mani
Mahesh (Chamba) and Renuka (Sirmour). Lavi fair is perhaps the only fair, which is
not connected with any legend or religion. It is an economic or trade fair, as are the
Nalwar fairs of Sundernagar (Mandi) and of Bilaspur; their origin is not as old as of the
hoary Lavi fair of Rampur Bushahr.12
Language
In Himachal Pradesh about ninety per cent people speaks western Pahari
popularly known as Pahari. The Indo-Aryan languages are spoken in the Northern
India. In Himachal Pradesh as many dialects have been counted almost at par with the
number of existing hill states. In the North of Churdhar Peak, these separates Sirmaur
district from Chopal tehsil of Shimla district. This area was known as Bishshaw in the
past. The dialect spoken there is akin to Giripari, which is named by Dr. Grierson as
Bishwai. So, the appropriate name for Giripari now is Bishwai dialect. The Brari
dialect is spoken in Pargana Brar of Jubbal Tehsil. Kirni dialect is spoken in Pargana
Kiran of Chopal Tehsil, which is influenced by Jaunsari dialect of Jaunsar-Bawar area
of Uttar Pradesh. Dami dialect is prevalent in South-East of Bilaspur. The Kinnauri
dialect called Homskad is the mother tongue of nearly 75 per cent of the population of
Kinnaur. In Lahual and Spiti, four main dialects are spoken. Bhoti is spoken in Spiti,
Chandra and Bhaga Valleys. The Gaheri is spoken around Keylong, while Manchot and
Changsa are spoken in Chenab Valley. The Lahaul in turn makes use of four dialects-
Tibetan, Boonuum, Manchat and Teenuum. In Kangra, apart Kangri, the Dogri dialect
is also spoken. Some linguists are even of the opinion that despite the fact that the
Pahari language has been surrounded by Hindi, Dogri and Punjabi Languages, but it is
more closely akin to Rajasthani. The main reason behind to be stated, is that Rajasthan
and the hilly areas of Himachal Pradesh were once inhabited by the same type of
people like Khasa, Rajput, Gujjar etc.13
11
Ibid., p. 86.
12
V. Verma, op.cit., 1995, p. 24.
13
Ramesh Chauhan, Himachal Pradesh: A Perspective, Shimla: Menerva Book House, 1998, pp. 286-
288.
78
Table 2.1
Himachal at a Glance According to 2011 Census
Description Detail
Area 55673 (Sq.Kms.)
Population 68, 64, 602
Male 3481873
Female 3382729
Rural Population 6176050
Urban Population 688552
Scheduled Castes Population 1729252
Scheduled Tribes Population 392126
Literacy Rate 82.80 (%)
Growth Rate 12.94 (%)
Density of Population 123 (Persons)
Total No. of Main Workers 20.63 (Lakh)
Birth Rate 16.4 (Per 1000)
Death Rate 6.7 (Per 1000)
Religion Hindu
Annual Rainfall 180 cm
Maximum Temperature 38.60 C
Capital Shimla
Language Hindi, English, Himachali
Per Capital Income 1, 30, 067 (Rs.)
Urbanization Ratio 90:10
Best time to Visit March to October
Total Districts 12
Divisions 3
Sub-Divisions 62
Legislative Assembly Constituencies 68
Blocks 78
Tehsils 97
Sub-Tehsils 49
Panchayats 3226
Villages 20690
Source: Census of India, 2011, and Government of Himachal Pradesh, Statistical Abstract of Himachal
Pradesh, Shimla: Department of Economics and statistics Government of Himachal Pradesh, 2015-16.
79
Area and Population
Himachal Pradesh has an area of 55,673 sq. kms. The population of Himachal
has been increasing continuously over the years. However, the growth rate of total
population shows a decreasing trend over the last three decades. In 2011, the total
population of Himachal Pradesh is 68, 64, 602 out of which 34, 81,873 were males
(51%) and 33, 82,729 (49%) were females. The composition of population shows that,
90 per cent of the total population is rural and only 10 per cent is urban. The trend
shows that, since 1981 the urban population is increasing continuously. It has been
increased from 7.61 per cent in 1981 to 8.6 per cent in 1991 and from 9.80 per cent in
2001 to 10.00 per cent in 2011.14
Table 2.2
14
Government of Himachal Pradesh, Socio-Economic Indicators of Himachal Pradesh, Shimla:
Economic and Statistics Department Himachal Pradesh, 2014-15, p. 1.
80
20
15.54
16.26
14.76
15
12.63
15.93
12.77
12.67
12.05
10.92
10.19
10
7.39
5 Growth Rate of
Population 2001-2011
-5
-5
-10
Sex Ratio
As per census 2011, there are 972 females per 1000 of male in Himachal
Pradesh as compared to 968 females as per 2001 census. This adverse trend in the sex
ratio is mainly attributed to female foeticide and infanticide. The government of
Himachal Pradesh has put a total ban on the prenatal diagnostic test by enacting the
legislation. The district wise sex ratio is given below.
Table 2.3
District Wise Sex Ratio
District Male Female Female Per 1000 Males
Bilaspur 192764 189192 981
Chamba 261320 257760 986
Hamirpur 217070 237698 1095
Kangra 750591 759484 1012
Kinnaur 46249 37872 819
Kullu 225452 212451 942
Lahaul and Spiti 16588 14976 903
Mandi 498065 501712 1007
Shimla 425039 388971 915
Sirmaur 276289 253566 918
Solan 308754 271566 880
Una 263692 257481 976
Himachal Pradesh 3481873 3382729 972
Source: Census of India 2011.
81
Female Per 1000 Males
1095
1200
1007
981
1012
942
918
976
1000
986
903
915
880
800
819
600
400
200
Participation of Women
According to census 2011, the total worker population in Himachal Pradesh was
35.59 lakh, of which 15.16 lakh were women and 20.43 lakh were men. Out of the total
women workers, 41.13 per cent were main workers, 58.87 per cent were marginal
workers. The female workforce participation rate (WPR), on an average in 2001 was
43.67 per cent, which has increased to 44.82 per cent in 2011. This has become an
evident through various census. Similarly, the male workforce participation rate
(WPR), on an average in 2001 was 56.62 per cent, which has increased to 58.69 per
cent in 2011. In respect of women employed in the government services, it was
revealed from the census of Himachal Pradesh that in 2012-13, only 21.2 per cent of
total government employees were women. However, this share of women government
employees, during in 2013 has moderately improved from 20.4 per cent in 2012.15
Historical Profile
The early history of Himachal Pradesh is not fully established. This is mainly
due to the absence of adequate archaeological and literary sources. However, some
recent explorations and research or have thrown significant light on the political and
15
Government of Himachal Pradesh, Women and Men in Himachal Pradesh, Shimla: Department of
Economics and Statistics Government of Himachal Pradesh, 2014, p.29.
82
cultural history of the state, going as far back as the pre-historic age.16 Due to difficult
terrain, cold climate and inaccessible nature of the hilly state, it was impossible for any
major empire to annex the entire area of Himachal Pradesh. The history and traditions
of Himachal Pradesh can be traced from the earliest dawn of human civilization. The
Pre-History of Himachal Pradesh is the history of migration of the people of the
affiliated races from Indian plains and Central Asia. Its history is perhaps the most
unique and remarkable as compared to any other region of the Himalayas.17 That is in a
chronological order in a periodic form- (i) Pre-Aryan and Aryan Period up to A.D. 500
(ii) Early period A.D. 500 to A.D. 1000 (iii) Medieval Period A.D.1000 to A.D. 1800
(iv) British Period A.D. 1800 to A.D. 1947 (v) Modern Period A.D. 1947 onwards.
16
M.S. Ahluwalia, op.cit., 1988, p. 38.
17
Mian Goverdhan Singh, op.cit., 1985, p. 13.
18
Ibid., p. 2.
19
M.S. Ahluwalia, op.cit., 1998, pp. 38-39.
20
Ibid., p.40.
83
The second group of people were of the Aryan origin. They were known as the
Khasas, who penetrated from the north-west and settled in the mid-mountain belt of the
Himalayas from Kashmir to Nepal. They developed a specific Indo-Aryan culture and
religion.21 According to the Mahabharata the tract, which forms the present day
Himachal Pradesh was made up of a number of small republics known as Janapadas,
each of which constituted both a state and a cultural unit. The Audumbras were the
most prominent ancient tribes of Himachal, who lived in the lower hills between the
Pathankot and the Jawlamukhi.22 The Trigrata kingdom occupied the foothill tract
drained by the Ravi, Beas and Satluj. It was an independent state which flourished
during this period. Another contemporary Kingdom was that of Kuluta, situated in the
upper Beas valley, which is also known as the Kullu Valley. Its capital was Naggar and
they issued copper coins. The Chitravaram of Kuluta, was one of the five Kings of this
region, who formed an alliance to oppose the influence of Chandragupta Maurya.23
The Kulindas was another important kingdom that covered the area lying
between the Beas-Satluj and Yamuna rivers, i.e. the Shimla and Sirmaur hills. They
issued silver coins. Their administration resembled a republic with members of central
assembly sharing the powers of the King. The Ashoka, the grandson of Chandragupta
extended his boundaries to the Himalayan region. He introduced Buddhism to this tract.
He built many stupas, one of which is in the Kullu valley. A major inscription is at
Kalsi (now in U.P.), which was once a part of Sirmaur state.24 After the collapse of the
Gupta Empire and before the rise of Harsha, this region was again ruled by small petty
chiefs known as Thakurs and Ranas, whose states were of small size with constantly
changing boundaries due to wars with neighbours. It is believed that in Chamba area
alone, there were hundred such small chiefdoms. In the early seventh century, rule of
Harsha became paramount and most of these small states acknowledged his overall
supremacy, though a number of local powers continued to be exercised by the chiefs.
During this period, the Huien Tsang, one of the greatest travellers visited many
parts of Himachal Pradesh and wrote a detailed account of the socio-political set-up of
Himachal Pradesh at that time. According to Huien Tsang, Bharmour (Brahmapura)
21
Ibid., pp.40-41.
22
S.S. Negi, Himachal Pradesh: The Land and People, New Delhi: Indus Publishing Company, 1993,
p. 124.
23
S.S. Negi, Discovering the Himalaya, Vol. 2, New Delhi: Indus Publishing Company, 1998, pp. 343-
344.
24
S.S. Negi, op.cit., 1993, pp. 124-125.
84
was the capital of Chamba state, whose boundaries touched with those of Jalandhra in
the south-east and Mandi and Suket in the east. The hill states of the interior parts of
Himachal Pradesh were outside the jurisdiction of Harsha. During this period,
Thaneshwar was a flourishing Kingdom. The Srughna was a state to the North-East of
Thaneshwar, whose frontiers flow the Yamuna River with the capital located on the
banks of the river. It is believed that Paonta or Kalsi were probably the capital of this
kingdom.25
Early Period
The outside invaders during this period exploited the internal strifes of the petty
hill chiefs and chaos prevailing in their territories. The history of this area in a way
marched ahead with these events of internal strifes and rivalries. During this period,
some foreign invaders also invaded few parts of Himachal Pradesh. It may be recalled
here that, the internal warfare of kings and chiefs did not result in any significant
political changes and administration was partly of the primitive type. The lack of
King’s personal interest in state craft could have offered opportunities to Thakurs and
Ranas, to declare themselves independent. The army had to be fed and organised by the
people. The King took the responsibility of the army only during war periods. Only the
major states like Kangra, Kullu and Chamba had organised armies.26
Medieval Period
In this period, the old and larger states of Kullu, Kangra, Mandi etc. were
broken and many new small states of Guler, Siba, Datarpur, Handur, Koti, Bhajji,
Kumarsain, Khaneti etc. came into existence. During this period, Mughals, Muslims,
Dutch, Portuguese and French invaded many parts of India. The relations between
Mughals and these hill states commenced with Akbar, who wanted to include this
valuable area in his empire and he sent Todarmal to annex Kangra. The history stands
as witness that, erstwhile ruler of Kangra, Dharm Chand readily accepted suzerainty of
Akbar. In 1620 A.D. Jahangir also got hold over Kangra. On the other hand, the hill
states of Chamba, Kullu, Lahaul and Spiti, Bushahr had strifes amongst themselves but
the Mughals never intervented in the internal matters of these hill rulers. Because of
25
S.S. Negi, op.cit., 1998, pp. 344-345.
26
Sukhdev Singh Chib, This Beautiful India: Himachal Pradesh, New Delhi: Light and Life, 1977,
pp.4-5.
85
their relations outside hills, the hill rulers also brought about changes in public
administration. In fact, the system of administration evolved during this period,
continued till the integration of these states into one unit with minor changes. However,
the general condition of the hill subjects had improved a bit as compared to the earlier
period.27
British Period
After the death of Aurangzeb, the last great Mughal, the Mughal Empire in
India stated declining. In these hilly states, Raja Sansar Chand of Kangra had earned
reputation as a warrior and ruler. In the second half of the 18th century, a new nation
known as Gurkhas in the Himalayan history rose to power. Under the leadership of
Prithvi Narain Shah, they spread like a wild fire and engulfed the whole of Western
Himalayas including Kangra. They occupied Kumaon and Garhwal in 1803 A.D. and
by 1805 A.D. they captured Kangra Fort.28 But people were tired of their harsh
tyrannical rule. They united themselves and took a stand against them. The Britishers
also came to their help and in 1815 A.D. the Gurkhas were compelled to leave the
country. The help by the Britishers turned out to be a trap for them. They compelled the
local rulers to sign certain treaties, through which the paramount power from the hands
of these rulers passed on the British government in India.29
Freedom Struggle
The people of the hills also participated in the freedom struggle from 1914-
1947. Praja Mandal launched agitations against the British yoke in areas under direct
British rule. In other princely states, agitations were launched for social and political
reforms. However, these were directed more against the princely states rather than
against the British and as such were mere extensions of the freedom movement. The
Mandi conspiracy was carried out in 1914-15 under the influence of the Gadhr Party.
The meetings were held in Mandi and Suket states in December 1914 and January
1915. It was decided to murder the superintendent and Wazir of Mandi and Suket, to
loot the Treasury, blow up the bridge over the Beas River and bring the territories of
these states under the control of the revolutionaries.
27
Ibid., pp.6-8.
28
Mian Goverdhan Singh, op.cit., 1985, p.30.
29
Shiv Raj Singh, Bureaurcacy and Rural Development: Policy Making, Planning and Implementation,
New Delhi: Mittal Publications, 1989, p. 24.
86
The Pajhota agitation in which the people of part of Sirmaur state revolted, is
regarded as an extension of the Quit India Movement in 1942.30 At last the fateful day
arrived, when the British said good-bye for ever to India and the tri-colour was unfurled
on the ramparts of the Red fort in Delhi on the midnight of the 15th August, 1947. But
that was not the end of the drama for the hill people. The National leaders invited the
prince’s to join the ocean of masses. They felt the pulse of the time and signed the
instrument of accession. In March 1948, thirty old princes of Shimla and Punjab hills
met in Delhi and inscribed their signatures on the document and surrendered their
centuries old Raj to the masses and thus Himachal Pradesh in the form of a unit came
into existence on the 15th of April 1948.31
30
S.S. Negi, op.cit, 1993, pp.130-131.
31
Mian Goverdhan Singh, op.cit., 1985, p. 20.
32
Shiv Raj Singh, op.cit., 1989, p. 26.
33
Ramesh Chauhan , op.cit., 1998, p.183.
34
Ibid, pp.183-184.
87
‘C’ state of Bilaspur was merged with Himachal Pradesh as fifth district of the state and
strength of the assembly seat was raised to 41 members.35
Himachal Pradesh maintained its status of part ‘C’ state of the Indian union till
1956, when the state reorganisation commission headed by Mr. Justice Fazil Ali and
two members i.e. H.N. Kunzru and K.M. Pannikar, submitted its recommendation to
abolish the categorization of state as part A.B.C.37 The parliament passed the territorial
council act in December 1956. According to the provision of this act, Himachal
Pradesh was made an union territory under the chairmanship of Thakur Karam Singh.
According to the government of union territory act, the territorial council re-elected in
1962 and it was turned into legislative assembly. A three member’s popular ministry
headed by Dr. Y.S. Parmar was sworn in on July 1, 1963, other two ministers were
Thakur Karam Singh and Hari Das. Another new district, the sixth one which was
carved out of the Mahasu district formed the new Kinnaur district ceded from the entire
Chini Tehsil and 14 villages from Rampur Tehsils.
35
Mian Goverdhan Singh, op.cit., 1985, pp. 85-87.
36
Himachal Past, Present and Future, op.cit. 1975, p.122.
37
M.S. Ahluwalia, op.cit., 1993, p.35.
88
Hoshiarpur district and Pathankot tehsil of Gurdaspur district with Himachal. The
integration came about on 1st November 1966.38
After granting the statehood to Himachal Pradesh, the strength of the state
legislative assembly had been fixed and increase in sixty to sixty-eight. Out of sixty
eight constituencies, nineteen seats were reserved to scheduled caste and scheduled
tribes ( i.e. Sixteen for SCs and Three for STs). Simultaneously, four seats for Lok
Sabha and three seats for Rajya Sabha were also fixed for Himachal Pradesh. At
present, all the four parliamentary constituency ( i.e. Hamirpur, Kangra, Mandi and
Shimla) consists of seventeen assembly constituencies each, will come under the sixty-
eight assembly constituencies. In 1971, mid-term election were held in centre as well as
in the state, in which congress party got majority at centre and won all four
parliamentary seats in Himachal Pradesh. In 1972, Vidhan Sabha election the Indian
National Congress got 53 seats, Bhartiya Jan Sangh 5, Independents and others 10
seats. In the 68 Vidhan Sabha the Indian National Congress got ¾ majority, as there
was hardly any opposition to the Indian National Congress at that time from any
national or regional political outfits. The Indian National Congress had projected itself
as the only party of masses in general and SC/ST’s in particular. Once again, Dr. Y. S.
38
Mian Goverdhan Singh, op.cit., 1985, p. 216.
39
Himachal Past, Present and Future, op.cit., 1975, pp. 128-129.
40
Ramesh Chauhan, op.cit., 1998, pp.187-188.
89
Parmar became the Chief Minister of Himachal Pradesh. We can see the performance
of various parties in Himachal Pradesh legislative assembly election during in 1952-
1972, in which the congress party ruled with strength in the state. It has been illustrated
in the table below:
Table 2.4
Performance of Parties in Himachal Pradesh Legislative Assembly Election from
1952-1972
Furthermore, the political scene at national level became very turmoil because
central government under Indira Gandhi suffered a setback on account of adverse
judgement of Allahabad High Court against her. In 1975, Mrs. Indira Gandhi imposed
internal emergency and put all opposition leaders in jail. The emergency continued for
nineteen months. However, the emergency proved to be a blessing in disguise, as it
brought discipline and a genuine sense of responsibility in the government
functionaries. The strikes became outdated and files started moving fast vanishing red
tapism etc. The twenty point programme for the welfare of the general masses was
taken with all earnestness. The state to some extent, witnessed virtual transformation by
90
the year 1976, when it stood in the threshold of self-sufficiency in food production, etc.
But various restrictions imposed on the fundamental rights annoyed the people at large.
However, the various welfare programmes became torturing, humiliating and fanatic in
its implementation and consequently, the farmers as well as the government employees
reacted very strongly against it. On account of the restrictions imposed on speech and
press, the government could not get realistic feed back with the result that the congress
was replaced in 1977 general elections. In February 1977, Dr. Y. S. Parmar stepped
down at the instance of the central leadership, when youth wing of the congress party
had emerged powerful and Thakur Ram Lal became the chief minister.
As a result of change in government at the centre, for seeking fresh mandate the
Himachal Pradesh government was dissolved and President’s Rule promulgated on 30th
April 1977, which remained enforced up to 21st May 1977. Subsequently, the Janta
Party was voted to thumping majority having won 54 seats out of total 68 seats in June,
1977 general elections, thus Janta Party in the state formed the government. The
Congress-I had secured only 9 seats while 5 seats were won by the independent
candidates.
Mr. Shanta Kumar became the chief minister of Himachal Pradesh on 24th June
1977. However, the Janta government made several achievements but the internal
conflicts and contradictions inherent in the party were responsible for several setbacks.
Its fall came earlier than it could be foreseen and the government collapsed under its
own weight before it could complete its full term. The careful accommodation of
interests of different groups was essential for keeping such a party intact and the
leadership then probably lacked this quality. The emergence of Janta party had raised
expectations that India was heading toward a two party system, but in vain. The Indian
social conditions and its overall structure did not conform to the conditions necessary
for such a political development. The clash of personalities and the absence of
commonly accepted ideologies were responsible for the failure of Janta government.
In 1980 Lok-Sabha elections Congress-I won all four seats and this victory of
the congress party proved last nail in the coffin of Janta party government in the state.
The politics of defection transformed the fortune of nine members congress party to
emerge as a ruling Janta under the chief-ministership of Thakur Ram Lal, Janta
government lasted for thirty months.41 In 1982, Vidhan Sabha election, Janta party has
41
Ibid., pp. 188-190.
91
virtually lost its political significance. In these elections, congress too faced a big loss.
However, BJP expanded its influence in Himachal Pradesh for the first time under the
leadership of Shanta Kumar winning 29 seats. These elections were mainly contested
between Ram Lal and Shanta Kumar, the two personalities in the state politics. At that
time, there was no political party to form the government on its own. But the congress
party once again formed the government, with the help of independent candidate
Thakur Ram Lal became the chief minister. But later on, Thakur Ram Lal was
appointed Governor of Andhra Pradesh and Virbhadra Singh became the chief minister
of Himachal Pradesh.42 Thus, in Vidhan Sabha elections of 1982 Congress-I recaptured
power in the state. As there was a short change in leadership, Ram Lal Thakur was
replaced by Virbhadra Singh. He again went to snap poll in 1985 and returned his party
with thumping majority.43
In 1985 Mid-term poll, congress party once again got thumping majority in the
state legislative assembly. The period from 1980 to 1991 was the period of great
turmoil and instability in Indian politics. The problem of terrorism was taking heavy
toll all over the country. Mrs. Indira Gandhi was assassinated by her own Sikh security
guards in New Delhi on 31st October 1984. After the gap of seven years, Mr. Rajiv
Gandhi was killed in Tamilnadu by a suicide bomber, while on his way to address an
election rally at Sriparambadur. When congress remained in power from 1985-90 in
the state, it was during this period B.J.P. strengthened its party cadre and exploited the
weakness of congress party within and outside the Vidhan Sabha. Mr. Shanta Kumar
led a Yatra from Palampur to Shimla, which received overwhelming support. In 1989
Lok Sabha election, Shanta Kumar won from Kangra seat. 44
In 1990, Himachal Pradesh Vidhan Sabha election, BJP came to power. Mr.
Shanta Kumar was sworn in as chief minister of the state for the second time on 5th
March, 1990. His council of ministers included Jagdev Chand, Radha Raman Shastri,
Nagin Chander Pal, Kishori Lal, Roop Singh Thakur, Kunj Lal Thakur, Vidya Sagar
and Dile Ram. The vital political change at the centre (Congress-I) did not bring any
change initially in Bhartiya Janta Party (BJP) government in Himachal Pradesh.
However, due to dismantling of Babri Masjid at Ram Janam Bhumi, Ayodha led to the
ouster of the three BJP ruled states including Himachal Pradesh on 15th December
42
Ibid., p.190.
43
Har Gopal Singh, A Period of Hot Politics in Himachal Pradesh and Other Notes, Solan: Har Gopal
Singh Publishers, 1996, p. 5.
44
Ibid, p.190.
92
1992, while the fourth (UP) had resigned of its own. After their dismissal the
President’s Rule was promulgated in these states. After the President’s rule of about
one year the tenth Vidhan Sabha election were held on 9th November 1993. The
congress has returned to power winning 52 of the total 68 assembly seats. Mr.
Virbhadra Singh again became the chief minister of the state for the third time on 3rd of
December 1993. On the recommendation of the council of ministers of Virbhadra
Singh the Governor Mrs V.S. Rama Devi dissolved the Vidhan Sabha under article
174-2b on the 24th December 1998 to sought simultaneously Lok Sabha and assembly
elections under the presumed favourable political scenario in the state.45 The elections
to the Lok Sabha and state assembly again were held on February 1998. The chief
minister Mr. Virbhadra Singh dissolved the legislative assembly one year earlier
schedule, to pave the way for simultaneous election for the Lok Sabha and the state
legislative assembly. But mandate of the people went against congress party. These
elections changed the whole political scenario in the state.
For the first time, the Himachal Vikas congress (HVC) emerged as “Third
Force” under the leadership of former union communication minister Pandit Sukh Ram,
who was expelled from the congress party on corruption charges. Due to Kinnaur,
Lahaul and Spiti and Bharmour, these elections were postponed in three assembly seats
and in one parliamentary constituency (Mandi). Elections in these areas were held on
3rd June 1998. There were no clear cut verdicts in favour of any political party. In three
parliamentary constituencies, BJP got two seats (Kangra and Hamirpur) while the
congress got only one seat i.e. Shimla.
As far as in sixty eight state assembly seats were concerned Indian National
Congress got 31 seats, while BJP got 29 seats. The HVC got 4 seats (Mandi Sadar,
Dharampur, Balh, Karsog), first time as a third party in Himachal Pradesh, while its
candidate contested 61 seats, one seat was rested by an independent candidate. The
HVC join hands with BJP under the leadership of Prof. Prem Kumar Dhumal as the
10th chief minister of Himachal Pradesh. It was first time in Himachal the coalition
government came into power.46 Therefore, 13th Lok Sabha elections were held on
September 25, 1999 in Himachal Pradesh BJP and HVC alliance captured all the four
seats i.e. three by BJP (Kangra, Hamirpur and Mandi) and one seat (Shimla) by HVC.
45
Ramesh Chauhan, op.cit., 1998, pp 192-193.
46
T. R. Sharma, “Himachal Pradesh: Two Party Competition in a Small State”, Journal of Indian
School of Political Economy, Vol. 15, No. 1-2, January-June 2003, pp.182-183.
93
In the by election of Solan assembly seat, Dr. Rajeev Bindal of BJP got elected in
February 2000.
In 2003 assembly election, electronic voting machines (EVMs) were used for
voting for the first time in the state and 9500 EVMs was requisitioned by Himachal
Pradesh chief election commissioner. There was a little more growth of electors than 30
per cent since 1990 election. The total electorate has increased for 3058107 in 1990 to
4088844 now. The ratio of men and women voters has remained unchanged.
Interestingly, while the number of men contestants has been constantly coming down,
that of women contestants have been on the rise. Election to the 10th Himachal Pradesh
legislative assembly except the total tribal constituencies was held on 28 February
2003. The house was constituted on 4th March 2003. The Indian National Congress
with 40 seats was swept back to power. The party raised its tally to 43 as it won all the
three tribal constituencies by election to which were held on June 8, 2003.47
In April 2004, HVC supreme Pandit Sukh Ram rejoined the congress.
Therefore, in May 2004 parliamentary election, India National Congress scored an
impressive victory wresting three of the four seats in the state. The BJP survived a
clean sweep by the congress as one of its candidate Suresh Chandel managed to scrape
through by a slender margin in Hamirpur Lok Sabha constituency.
Whereas in 2007, assembly elections, the hill state reverted to bipolar polity
with the realignment of political force during these election. The efforts to form a third
political front in the past to challenge the two main political parties, which have been
occupying the centre stage for the past three decades, have not been successful. The
emergence of the Bahujan Samaj Party (BSP) had raised the vision of a third political
force in the state, where the electoral arena has been traditionally dominated by the
Congress and BJP. Largely, it seems that the emergence of third force like the Janta
Dal, HVC and BSP during assembly elections, had dented the vote banks of main
parties to an extent but the politics in the state has largely remained bipolar. Such
emergence provided a platform to the rebels of the main parties and dependents, but
failed to create a permanent space and virtually vanished from the scene.
47
Report on General Election to Himachal Pradesh State Legislative Assembly 2003, Chief Electoral
Officer, Shimla: Himachal Pradesh.
94
seats were concerned, BJP got 41 and Congress party got 23, seats. BSP got 1 and 3
seats was rested by independent candidate. Prof. Prem Kumar Dhumal became 11th
chief minister of Himachal Pradesh.48
Table 2.5
The Position of Political Parties since (1977- 2012) in Himachal Pradesh
Sr. No. Political Parties 1977 1982 1985 1990 1993 1998 2003 2007 2012
1. Janta Party 53 02 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
2. Congress (I) 09 31 58 9 52 31 43 23 36
3. C.P.I 0 0 0 01 0 0 0 0 0
4. CPI(M) 0 0 0 0 01 0 0 0 0
5. BJP 0 29 07 46 08 31 16 41 26
6. Janta Dal (JNP) 0 0 0 11 0 0 0 0 0
7. Lok Dal 0 0 01 0 0 0 0 0 0
8. HVC 0 0 0 0 0 5 1 0 0
9. Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 1 1
10. Independents 06 06 02 01 07 01 06 3 5
Total 68 68 68 68 68 68 68 68 68
Sources: Reports on General Election to Himachal Pradesh State Legislative Assembly from
1977- 2012, Chief Electoral Officer, Shimla: Himachal Pradesh.
48
Himachal Pradesh Assembly Election Result in 2007, https://en.m.wikipedia, Accessed on 30-10-
2015.
49
Report on General Election to Himachal Pradesh State Legislative Assembly 2012, Chief Electoral
Officer, Shimla: Himachal Pradesh.
95
On 1st November 1966, the hilly area of Punjab was merged in the state and as a result
the number of Gram Panchayats were increased to 1695. In the merged areas, a three
tier Panchayati Raj System was already in existence under the provisions of Punjab
Panchayat Samiti and Zila Parishad Act, whereas two tier systems was prevalent in the
state of Himachal Pradesh. With a view to bring uniformity in the Panchayati Raj
system in the old and the newly merged areas, the Himachal Pradesh Panchayati Raj
Act, 1968 was enacted on November 15, 1970 and the two-tier Panchayati Raj system
was established throughout the state. Beside this, the Nayaya Panchayats were also in
the existence in the state for discharging judicial functions, but during the year 1977
Nayaya Panchayats were abolished and the judicial functions were transferred to Gram
Panchayats. After the enactment of the act in 1970, the existing Gram Sabha were
recognised or bifurcated from time to time and new Gram Sabha/ Gram Panchayats
were established. It was in 2005-2006 government created 206 new Gram Sabha
circles, thereby raising the number to 3243 Panchayats.50 At Present, there are 3226
Gram Panchayats 78 Panchayat Samitis and 12 Zila Parishads constituted in the state.
Table 2.6
The Number of Gram Panchayats Since 1952-2015
Sr. No. Year No. of Gram Panchayats
1 1952 280
2 1954 466
3 1962 638
4 1966 1695
5 1972 2035
6 1978 2357
7 1985 2597
8 1991 2757
9 1995 2922
10 2000 3037
11 2005 3243
12 2010 3243
13 2015 3226
Source: Government of Himachal Pradesh, Annual Administrative Report, Panchayati Raj Department,
Shimla: Himachal Pradesh, 1952 to 2015-16.
50
Government of Himachal Pradesh, Annual Administrative Report, Panchayati Raj Department,
Shimla: Himachal Pradesh, 2014-15, p. 1.
96
3243
3500
3226
3243
3000
3037
2922
2757
2597
2500
2357
2000
2035
No. of Gram Panchayats
1695
1500
1000 638
500
466
280
0
1952195419621966197219781985199119952000200520102015
With a view to bring law relating to the Panchayats in conformity with the
provisions of the 73rd Constitutional Amendment Act, the Himachal Pradesh
Panchayati Raj Act, 1968 has repealed and the Himachal Pradesh Panchayati Raj Act,
1994 was enacted with effect from April 23, 1994. This act provided for a Gram Sabha
and Gram Panchayats, Panchayat Samitis and Zila Panchayats at village, block and
district level respectively.51
Gram Sabha which forms the core of the democratic decentralization needs to
be given utmost attention. Thus the state government has already taken steps to
strengthen the institution of Gram Sabha. Gram Sabha have been empowered to form
vigilance committees from amongst its members to supervise Gram Panchayats works,
schemes and other activities, no member of the Gram Panchayat shall be eligible to
become member of the vigilance committee. It has been made mandatory for every
Gram Sabha to hold four general meetings in every year, besides special meetings.
These meetings are required to be held in January, April, July and October.52
51
Government of Himachal Pradesh, Annual Administrative Report, Panchayati Raj Department,
Shimla: Himachal Pradesh, 2010- 2011, p. 4.
52
Himachal Pradesh Panchayati Raj Act 1994, Section 7, p. 23.
97
Under section 7-A of HPPR Act (Second Amendment) Act, 2000, there shall be
a Up-Gram Sabha for each ward of a Gram Sabha. All members of the Gram Sabha
residing within the area of the ward shall be members of the Up-Gram Sabha. Every
Up-Gram Sabha shall hold two general meetings in each year, and it shall be the
responsibility of the member of the Gram Panchayat representing the ward to convene
such meetings. The meeting of the Up-Gram Sabha shall be presided over by the
member of the Gram Panchayat representing the ward, who shall also record the
proceedings. The time and place of the meetings of the Up-Gram Sabha shall be fixed
and notified by the member of the Gram Panchayat representing the ward. The Up-
Gram Sabha shall nominate its members to represent it in the general meeting of the
Gram Sabha and these members shall be nominated in such a manner, that 50 per cent
of the total families residing in the area of the ward get nominated, provided that one-
half of the nominations shall be of women. The village level functionaries of the
agriculture, animal husbandry, primary education, health and family welfare,
horticulture, irrigation and public health etc. shall attend the meetings of Gram Sabha in
the jurisdiction they are posted. The Up-Gram Sabha may deliberate on issues relating
to its area and make recommendations to the Gram Panchayat or Gram Sabha.53
Quorum
The quorum for a Gram Sabha meeting (according to HPPR Act 1994, Act
No.15 of 2010) shall be 1/3rd of the total number of its members (i.e. voters) and
decision will be taken by the majority of members present and voting. If a meeting is
adjourned for short of quorum, at least 1/5th of the total number of its members shall be
required for holding the adjourned meeting.54
Gram Panchayat
Under section 8 HPPR Act 1994, there shall be a Gram Panchayat for a Gram
Sabha and every Gram Sabha shall, in the prescribed manner, elect from amongst its
members a Pradhan and Up-Pradhan of the Sabha. Who shall also be called the Pradhan
and Up-Pradhan of the Gram Panchayat and shall also elect from amongst its members
an Executive Committee called the Gram Panchayat, consisting of such number of
persons not being less than seven and more than fifteen, including Pradhan and Up-
53
Government of Himachal Pradesh, Annual Administrative Report, Panchayati Raj Department,
Shimla: Himachal Pradesh, 2014-2015, pp. 9-10.
54
The Himachal Pradesh Panchayati Raj (Amendment) Act, 2010(Act No.15 of 2010), p. 9.
98
Pradhan. The number of members excluding Pradhan and Up-Pradhan to be assigned to
each Gram Sabha, shall be determined on the following scale:
(b) With a population exceeding 1750 but not exceeding 2750 would be seven
(c) With a population exceeding 2750 but not exceeding 3750 would be nine
(d) With a population exceeding 3750 but not exceeding 4750 would be eleven
(e) With a population exceeding 4750, the number of members would be thirteen.55
Qualification
Reservation of Seats
The act provides the reservation of seats in Gram Panchayat for SCs and STs in
proportion to their population to the total population by rotation. Not less than 1/3 of
the total number of seats shall be reserved for women belonging to SCs and STs.
Similarly, not less than one-third (including the number of the seats reserved for
women belonging to SCs and STs) of the total number of seats to be filled by direct
election in every Gram Panchayat shall be reserved for women.57 The government can
also reserve seats for backward classes in a Gram Panchaayat. According to HPPR
Adhiniyam 2001, maximum 15 per cent seats shall be reserved for backward classes in
all tiers of PRIs and one third of the total number of seats shall be reserved for
women.58
Tenure
Every Panchayat shall continue for five years from the date appointed for its
first meeting and no longer unless, sooner dissolved under this Act. An election to
constitute a Panchayat shall be completed- before the expiry of its duration specified in
sub-section. And before the expiration of a period of six months from the date of its
55
Himachal Pradesh Panchayati Raj Act, 1994 (Act No.4 of 1994) Section 8, p.7.
56
Himachal Pradesh Panchayati Raj Act 1994 (Act No. 4 of 1994) Section 8, p. 7.
57
Himachal Pradesh Panchayati Raj (Amendment Act, No. 8 of 2000), p. 1.
58
Panchayati Raj Adhiniyam or Ewam Niyam, Department of Panchayati Raj, Shimla: Himachal
Pradesh, 2001, p.6.
99
dissolution: Provided that where the remainder of the period for which the dissolved
Panchayat would have continued is less than six months, it shall not be necessary to
hold any election under this clause for constituting the Panchayat for such period. A
Panchayat constituted upon the dissolution of a Panchayat before the expiration of its
duration shall continue only for the remainder of the period, for which the dissolved
Panchayats would have continued under sub-section (1) had it not been so dissolved.
Meeting
The meeting of the Gram Panchayat have been declared a public meeting and is
to be held at least once a month. Meeting are convened by the Up- pradhan and in his
absence by the Pradhan. One half of members of the Panchayat form the quorum. All
the decisions are taken by majority votes. In case of equal voting, Pradhan or Up-
Pradhan shall have the right or casting vote.59
According to Himachal Pradesh Panchayati Raj Act 1994 under section 11, the
Gram Panchayat has been entrusted with 29 functions, which included sanitation,
constructional and maintenance of records of birth and death, plantation and
preservation of Panchayat forest, removal of social evils like dowry, providing medical
care and in general carrying out functions entrusted to be by Panchayat Samiti, Zila
Parishad of the state government.60
Panchayat Samiti
Intermediate body of the three-tier Panchayati Raj system in the state is called
Panchayat Samiti. This institution is co-terminus with the development blocks.
Members of Panchayat Samitis are elected directly, whereas the Chairperson and Vice-
Chairperson are elected indirectly by the elected members. The number of elected
members of Panchayat Samiti are determined by the government at the rate of one
member of every 3500 population or part there of subject to a minimum of 15
members. There is no separate office of Panchayat Samitis but office function as
Samitis office. Block Development Officer has been designated as Chief Executive
Officer of the Panchayat Samitis, wheras Panchayat inspector is the secretary of the
Panchayat Samiti. The member of the Zila Parishad representing the ward which
59
Himachal Pradesh Panchayati Raj Act, 1994, Section 11.
60
Himachal Pradesh Panchayati Raj Act 1994 (Act No. 4 of 1994), pp. 70-71.
100
comprises wholly or partly the Panchayat Samiti area, shall also be the member of
Panchayat Samiti. Under section 78 of the Act Panchayat Samiti Consists of :
• The members of the Lok Sabha and the MLAs of the state representing
constituencies, which comprise wholly or partly the Panchayat Samiti area;
• The members of the council of states, where they are registered as electors
within the Panchayat Samiti area;
The act provides one-half of the total number of seats reserved under sub-
section (4) shall be reserved for women belonging to the SCs or, as the case may be the
STs. One-half (including the number of seats reserved for women belonging to the SCs
and the STs) of the total number of seats to be filled by direct election in every
Panchayat Samiti shall be reserved for women. Basic qualification for a candidate, who
is seeking to contest the election of Panchayat Samiti is 25 of age. The election of first
Panchayat Samiti was held by secret ballot and direct vote.61 Before the statehood
(1971), election of first Panchayat Samiti was held in 1972 and second in 1991 after
73rd Amendment in Indian constitution, thereby more elections were held in 1995,
2000, 2005, 2010 and 2015. At present there are 78 block in Himachal Pradesh.62
Table 2.7
Panchayat Samitis in Himachal Pradesh, 1972 to 2015
Sr. No. Election Year Total Blocks
1 1972 69
2 1991 69
3 1995 72
4 2000 75
5 2005 75
6 2010 77
7 2015 78
Source: Government of Himachal Pradesh, Annual Administrative Report, Panchayati Raj Department,
Shimla: Himachal Pradesh, 2015.
61
Himachal Pradesh Panchayati Raj Act 1994 (Act No. of 1994), pp. 21-22.
62
Government of Himachal Pradesh, Annual Administrative Report, Panchayati Raj Department,
Shimla: Himachal Pradesh, 2015-16.
101
78
78 77
76 75 75
74
72
72
Total Block
70 69 69
68
66
64
1972 1991 1995 2000 2005 2010 2015
Before the statehood, the elections of all the PSs were not held regularly and
after the statehood first election of PSs was held in1972 in all the blocks and second
election was held in 1991. In December
Decem 1995 with the increase of 3 Blocks,
locks, the total
numbers of Blocks were 72. At
A present there are 78 PSs (Blocks)) in Himachal Pradesh.
After the declaration of result of election of the elected members of the Panchayat
Samiti in the prescribed manner, the Deputy Commissioner concerned or any gazetted
g
officer
fficer appointed by him in this behalf shall,
shall as soon as possible but not later than one
week of such declaration, call under his President ship a meeting of all elected
members for the purpose of oath, or the affirmation of allegiance under section 127.
Immediately after oath or affirmation of allegiance under section 127 of the Act,
the elected members of a Panchayat Samiti elect one of its members to be the Chairman
and another member to be the Vice-Chairman.
Vice If the office of the Chairman or Vice-
Vice
Chairman, as the case may be, is vacated or falls vacant during the tenure on account of
death, resignation or no-confidence
confidence motion, a fresh election within a period of two
months from the date of occurrence of vacancy
vaca shall be held and the post will be filled
up. Panchayats Samiti members will hold their officer for five years.63
63
Himachal Pradesh Panchayati Raj Act, 1994, Under Section 127, p.73.
102
Under section 81 of the Himachal Pradesh Panchayati Raj Act 1994, the
Panchayat Samiti in the state performs a variety of functions:
e) Any other function with the approval of the state government or Zila Parishad.64
Zila Parishad
This is uppermost body of the Panchayati Raj System. In our state Zila Parishad
were constituted for the first time after the enactment of new law relating to Panchayati
Raj system, consequent upon 73rd Constitutional Amendment. Presently, there are 12
Zila Parishad in our state. The members of Zila Parishad are elected directly by the
people, however the Chairperson and Vice-Chairperson are elected by the elected
members indirectly. Elected members of Zila Parishad are determined by the state
government at the rate on, one member for every 25000 populations or part there of
subject to a minimum of 10 members. The members of lok sabha, members of state
legislative assembly representing a part or whole of the district and the members of
council of states, where they are registered as voters and chairpersons of Panchayat
Samiti of the district will also be the members of Zila Parishad. Additional Disrict
Magistrate, Project Officer, ITDP in scheduled areas has been designated as Chief
Executive Officer, whereas District Panchayat Officer is the Secretary of Zila Parishad.
In addition to this district planning officer will be Planning Secretary.65 Under section
89 of the Act, every Zila Parishad shall consist of following members: The directly
64
Himachal Pradesh Panchayati Raj Act 1994, Section 81, pp. 48-49.
65
Government of Himachal Pradesh, Annual Administrative Report, op. cit., 2015-16, p. 5.
103
elected members from territorial constituencies; The Members of the House of People
and the Members of the State Legislative Assembly representing a part or whole of the
district, whose constituencies lie within the district; The members of the council of
states, where they are registered as electors within the district; The chairmen of all
Panchayat Samitis in the district.66
(c) One-half (including the number of seats reserved for women belonging to the
SCs and the STs) of the total number of seats to be filled by direct election in
every Zila Parishad shall be reserved for women of this category by rotation.
Qualification
Term: the term of the members of Zila Parishad is five years. But they continue in
office till the election of new Zila Parishad members.
a) It control, co-ordinate and guide, the Panchayat Samiti and Gram Panchayat
within the district; It co-ordinate and consolidate the Panchayat Samiti plans;
b) It co-ordinate the demands for grants for special purpose received from the
Panchayat Samiti and forward them to the state government;
c) It secure the execution of the plans, projects schemes, or other works common
to two or more Panchayat Samitis in the district;
e) Exercise and perform such other powers and functions as the state government
may, confer on or entrust to it by the government.67
66
Himachal Pradesh Panchayati Raj Act 1994 (Act No. of 1994), p. 23.
67
Himachal Pradesh Panchayati Raj Act, 1994, Section 92.
104
Economic Profile of Himachal Pradesh
The era of economic planning started in Himachal Pradesh in 1948. The first
five year plan allocated about Rs. 52.7 million to Himachal. More than 50 per cent of
the expenditure was spent on transport facilities, since then it was felt that without
proper management, the process of planning and development couldn’t be carried out.
The community development programme was launched in 1952 with in the state. In
Mandi and Kangra, package programmes were undertaken in collaboration with the
West Germany for popularising modern techniques of cultivation among the farmers.
Suitable agriculture machinery and animal husbandry were introduced in these areas.
Well equipped soil testing laboratories, dairy farms and agricultural workshops were
setup at various centres, besides an Agriculture University at Palampur.69
Himachal is one of those states in India, which was rapidly transformed from
the most backward part of country to one of the most advanced states. At present it
ranks fourth in respect of per capita income among the states of the Indian union.
Himachal education system is well established, its agriculture is enough for its self-
sufficiency, its horticulture is highly impressive in the country and even in abroad, its
68
Mian Goverdhan Singh, op.cit.1985, p. 293.
69
Economy of Himachal Pradesh, https://en.m.wikipedia.org., Accessed on 14-07-2017.
105
road connectivity system has emerged as best in the mountainous areas in India. The
infrastructure for its industrial development are well laid out, its rich forest resources
being augmented and above all, the increasing attention of the nation towards the
exploitation of its hydel resources are the signs for its bright future.70 The economy of
the state also appears to be in resilient mode in terms of growth. As per advance
estimates, the growth rate of Gross State Domestic Product during 2016-17 will be 6.8
per cent.
Gross State Domestic Product or state income is the most important indicator
for measuring the economic growth of a State. According to quick estimates, the total
State Domestic Product for the year 2015-16 is Rs. 96, 289 crore against Rs. 89, 095
core in 2014-15, thereby registering a growth of 8.1 per cent at constant prices (2011-
2012). As per the quick estimates the value of Gross State Domestic Product of the
Pradesh at current prices, which was estimated at Rs. 1, 04,177 crore for 2014-15
increased to Rs. 1, 13, 667 core during 2015-16, registering an increase of about 9.1 per
cent. This increase is attributed to the agriculture and allied activities sector besides
other sectors of the economy. The food grains production increased to 16.34 lakh MT
in 2015-16 from 16.08 lakh MT in 2014-15 and also the production of apple increased
to 7.77 lakh MT in 2015-16 from 6.25 lakh MT in 2014-15.
70
Ibid.
106
Primary sector, which includes: Agriculture, Forestry, Fishing, Mining and
Quarrying, during 2015-16, witnessed growth rate of 0.7 per cent. The Secondary
sector, which comprises Manufacturing, Construction and Electricity, Gas and Water
Supply, registered a growth of 9.3 per cent during 2015-16. Transport storage,
communications and trade, this group of sectors shows a growth of 8.6 per cent during
2015-16. The transport by other means component of this sector has shown a growth of
5.9 per cent. Finance and Real Estate, this sector comprises Banking and Insurance,
Real Estate, Ownership of dwellings and Business Services. It witnessed a growth of
7.5 per cent in 2015-16. Community and personal Services the growth in this sector
during 2015-16 was 12.3 per cent. The overall contribution of local bodies in the Gross
State Domestic Product for the year 2015-16 was 0.24 per cent.71
Agriculture
Agriculture is the main occupation of the people of Himachal Pradesh and has
an important place in the economy of the state. Agriculture has played a predominate
place in the prosperity and economic development of Himachal Pradesh.72 Himachal
Pradesh is the only state in the country whose 89.96 per cent of population (Census
2011) lives in rural areas. Therefore, dependency on Agriculture/Horticulture is
eminent, as it provides direct employment to about 62 per cent of total workers of the
state. Agriculture happens to be the premier source of State Income (GSDP). About 10
per cent of the total GSDP comes from agriculture and its allied sectors. Out of the total
geographical area of state (55.67 lakh hectare) the area of operational holdings is about
9.55 lakh hectares and is operated by 9.61 lakh farmers. The average holding size
comes to 1.00 hectare. According to 2010-11 agricultural census the distribution of
land holdings shows that 87.95 per cent of the total holdings are of small and marginal
farmers. About 11.71 per cent of holdings are owned by Semi Medium/Medium
farmers and only 0.34 per cent by large farmers. The distribution of land holdings in
Himachal Pradesh has been depicted in table below:
71
Government of Himachal Pradesh, Economic Survey, Shimla: Economics and Statistics Department
Himachal Pradesh, 2016-17, pp. 10-12.
72
Mian Goverdhan Singh, op.cit., 2010, p. 245.
107
Table 2.8
Distribution of Land Holdings
(in years)
Size of Holdings Category No. of Holdings Area (Lakh Av. Size of
(hect.) (Farmers) (Lakh) hect.) Holding (hect.)
1 2 3 4 5
Source: Government of Himachal Pradesh, Economic Survey, Shimla: Economics and Statistics
Department Himachal Pradesh, 2016-17.
Table 2.8 shows that marginal and small farmers constitute 87.95 per cent of
total land holdings. The semi-medium and medium holding together constitute 11.71
per cent and the large holdings cover only 0.34 per cent. Thus, in Himachal Pradesh
bulk of holdings constitutes small and marginal holdings.
About 80 per cent of the total cultivated area in the state is rainfed. Rice, Wheat
and Maize are important cereal crops of the state. Groundnut, Soyabeen and Sunflower
in Kharif and Rapeseed/Mustard and Toria are important oilseed crops in the Rabi
season. Urd, Bean, Moong, Rajmash in Kharif season and Gram Lentil in Rabi are the
important pulse crops of the state. Agro-climatically, the state can be divided into four
zones viz:- sub tropical, sub-mountain and low hills, sub temperate, sub humid mid
hills, wet temperate high hills and cold deserts. The agro-climatic conditions in the state
are congenial for the production of cash crops like seed potato, off-season vegetables
and ginger. There is limited scope of increasing production through expansion of
cultivable land. Like whole country, Himachal too has almost reached a plateau in so
far as cultivable land is concerned. Hence, the emphasis has to be on increasing
productivity levels besides diversification towards high value crops.
Due to an increasing shift towards commercial crops, the area under food grains
is gradually declining, as the area which in 1997-98 was 853.88 thousand hectares is
likely to be declined to 764.85 thousand hectares in 2015-16. Increase in production
thus reflects gain in productivity as is evident from the table:
108
Table 2.9
Food Grains Area and Production
(in years)
In order to increase the production of food grains, emphasis has been laid on
distribution of seeds of high yielding varieties to the farmers. The area brought under
high yielding varieties of principal crops viz. Maize, Paddy and Wheat during the last
five years and proposed for 2016-17 is given in table.
Table 2.10
Area Brought Under High Yielding Varieties
(‘000 hect.)
Source: Government of Himachal Pradesh, Economic Survey, Shimla: Economics and Statistics
Department Himachal Pradesh, 2016-17.
109
There are 20 seed multiplication farms from where foundation seed is
distributed to registered farmers. There are 3 Vegetable Development Stations, 12
Potato Development Stations and 1 Ginger Development Station in the state.
According to 2011 census, out of total population, 30.05 per cent was main
workers, 21.81 per cent marginal workers and the 48.15 per cent were non-workers. In
other words, if we combine main and marginal workers, they constitute of 51.85 per
cent of the state as a whole.
Table 2.11
The total main workers, majority of 919.8 per cent were cultivators, 68.7 per
cent agricultural labourers, 32.7 per cent engaged in household industries and 1041.4
110
per cent in other activities. The highest percentage of workers in the state is in Kinnaur
district (55.61%), and Chamba district is at the bottom (23.05%). Due to difficult
geographical terrain, small size of land holdings and inadequate irrigation facilities are
main handicaps in the way of development of the agriculture in the state.
Horticulture
Himachal has resulted in shifting of land use pattern from agriculture to fruit
crops in the past few decades. The area under fruits, which was 792 hectares in 1950-51
with total production of 1,200 tonnes increased to 2, 26,799 hectares during 2015-16.
The total fruit production in 2015-16 was 9.29 lakh tonnes, which during 2016 -17
(upto December, 2016) has been reported as 5.10 lakh tones. During 2016-17, it was
73
Rajinder Attri, op.cit., 2010, pp. 627-628.
111
envisaged to bring 3, 000 hectares of additional area under fruit plants against which 2,
816.72 hectares of area was brought under plantations and 7.53 lakh fruit plants of
different species were distributed upto 31st December 2016.
The area under temperate fruits other than apple has increased from 900
hectares in 1960-61 to 27,908 hectares in 2015-16. Nuts and dry fruits exhibit area
increase from 231 hectares in 1960-61 to 10, 491 hectares in 2015-16, Citrus and other
sub tropical fruits have increased from 1, 225 hectares and 623 hectares in 1960-61 to
24,063 hectares and 53,658 hectares in 2015-16, respectively. This development has
further jeopardized due to the erratic apple production, owing to weather vagaries and
market fluctuations. The advent of WTO, GATT and liberalisation of economy is
further imposing many challenges on the dominance of apple in fruit industry of
Himachal Pradesh.
In warmer area of the state mango has emerged as an important fruit crop.
Litchi is also gaining importance in certain regions. Mango and litchi are fetching
better market prices. In the mid hill zone, the agro-climatic conditions are highly
suitable for the successful cultivation of new fruits like kiwi, olive, pomegranate, pecan
and strawberry.
74
Government of Himachal Pradesh, Economic Survey, op.cit., 2016-17, pp. 53-54.
112
Himachal Pradesh government and the farmers have seized this opportunity and
today this Pradesh has emerged as the ‘Horticultural State of India’. Apple is the major
horticultural crop, the production of which was 777.13 lakh tonne during 2015-16. Bulk
of the apple is produced in five districts viz. Shimla, Kullu, Mandi, Kinnaur, and
Chamba. For Integrated Developjmment of Horticulture, Centrally Sponsored
Development of Horticulture, Rashtriya Krishi Vikas Yojna and Pradhan Mantri Krishi
Sinchayee Yojna are being implemented in the state. Under this scheme various
activities of development, such as production of horticulture crops, strengthening of
basic infrastructure and development of irrigation facilities are being implemented. To
promote protected cultivation in horticulture, the state government has enhanced
subsidy under Poly Houses from 50 per cent to 85 per cent and 1.10 lakh sq. metre area
is targeted under Green Houses during year 2016-17. Rashtriya Krishi Vikas Yojna, in
which old apple orchards are being rejuvenated and replaced with the new improved
and regular bearing Spur varieties. To promote micro-irrigation facilities, 659 hectare
area has been brought under Pradhan Mantri Krishi Sinchayee Yojna upto December
2016. In addition to this, for strengthening irrigation facilities in the Orchards, Water
Storage Tanks and Borewells are being established in the state.75
Animal Husbandry
Animal Husbandry plays an important role to boost the rural economy of the
state. For any rural economy, raising up of live stock is considered to be a very
significant component. The topographical relationship in Himachal Pradesh established
an unique and dynamic relationship between common property resources such as
forests, water resources, live stocks, crops and grazing land. The number of live stocks
depends upon the fodder and grass able land to the large extent. The live stocks play an
important role in the sustainable development of the economy of Himachal Pradesh.76
Thus, the livestock is not only contributing towards agricultural production, but also is
even a source of self-employment to rural artisans. According to figures of 1966
census, the livestock population in Himachal Pradesh was about 42 lakh, 47.2 lakh in
1972, 49.9 lakh in 1977, 52.3 lakh in 1992 and 62.4 lakh as per 2010-11. The total
population of live stock, according to 2011-12 censuses has reached 48, 44,431. The
Government of Himachal Pradesh has initiated various development programmes of
75
Ibid., p.55.
76
Mian Goverdhan Singh, op.,cit., 2010, p.258.
113
animal husbandry in the state, which includes Animal Health and Disease Control,
Cattle Development; Sheep Breeding and Development of Wool, Poultry Development,
Feed and Fodder Development, Veterinary Education and Livestock Census.
Himachal Pradesh is one of the state amongst a few in the union of India,
which has been gifted by mother nature with rivers emanating from glaciers that
traverse through filly terrains and finally enrich the semi-plain area of the state with
77
Government of Himachal Pradesh, Economic Survey, op.cit., 2016-17, p. 58
114
their oxygen rich water. Under fisheries about 18,641 fishermen families in the Pradesh
depend directly or indirectly on the occupation and earn their livelihood by fishing. The
reservoir of Himachal Pradesh has the distinction of highest per hectare fish production
in Govind Sagar and highest sale price value of fish catch in Pong Dam in the country.
During the year 2016, 13.06 tonne trout has been sold from the state farms and earning
revenue to the tune of Rs. 86.64 lakh.
The total livestock in Himachal Pradesh in the year 2012 was 48, 44,431 and
various steps have been taken by the state government to improve the animal
husbandry. However, dairy production also is an integral part of the Animal
Husbandry. The recent trend towards the development of a market-oriented economy
emphasized the importance of milk production, especially in areas falling in the vicinity
of urban consumption centres. This motivated farmers to replace local non-descript
breeds of cows with cross-breed cows.78
The dairy development activities continued in the state under the animal
husbandry department upto 1983. In order to boost dairy products, similar methods as
used by the Anand Dairy Co-operatives Society of Gujarat were adopted by the
Himachal Pradesh Government and then a decision was taken to form a Himachal
Pradesh State Co-operative Milk Producers Federation in 1980. The dairy development
activities in the districts of Mandi, Bilaspur, Hamirpur, Solan, Sirmaur and parts of
Shimla was transferred from Animal Husbandry Department to the Milk Federation in
1983. In the remaining part of the state, it was transferred in 1992.79
78
Livestock Census-Directorate of Land Record and Animal Husbandry, Shimla: Department of
Himachal Pradesh, 2012-17.
79
Rajender Attri, op.cit., 2010, p. 750.
115
However, three big plants with a capacity of more than 10, 000 LPD are located in
Chakkar (Mandi), Tutu (Shimla) and Dagwar (Kangra). The production of various milk
products in the organised sector (Milkfed) including milk sold in the market, paneer,
butter ghee and dahi etc.80
Irrigation
In Himachal Pradesh the fields are terraced, sloppy and small size. The water
canals called Kuhls are the main source of irrigation in all districts except Sirmour, Una
and Solan. In Kangra and Una districts wells are also found but their share to the net
irrigated area is very less. Land of Himachal Pradesh is depending on the rain water.81
Total geographical area of Himachal Pradesh is 55.67 lakh hectares. Out of this, a high
percentage of area is under perpetual snow or under forests and steep barren slopes. As
per latest available figures, only 5.83 lakh hectares is the net area sown. It is estimated
that, ultimate irrigation potential of the state is approximately 3.35 lakh hectares, out of
which 50,000 hectares can be brought under irrigation through major and medium
irrigation projects and 2.85 lakh under minor irrigation schemes. Irrigation projects are
classified into three categories major, medium and minor. Projects having Cultivable
Command Area (CCA) of more than 10,000 hectares are classified as ‘Major Irrigation
Projects’ projects, which have a CCA of more than 2,000 hectares but less than 10,000
hectares are classified as ‘Medium Irrigation Projects’ and projects with CCA of 2,000
hectares or less are classified as minor irrigation projects. Under minor irrigation
projects, both types of water development viz. surface and ground is included.82
Forest
Himachal Pradesh has extensive forests which cover almost an area of 37.033
Sq.kms. This accounts for about 65.52 per cent of the total geographical area of the
state. Most of the forest belongs to the government and private forest is very small in
extent. The strategy of Himachal Pradesh government in forestry management is
conservation along with rational utilization and side by side expanding its base. The
forest of the state can be broadly classified into coniferous forests and broad-leaved
forests. Deodar, Kail, Chil, Spruce, Silver fir and Neoza Pine are the coniferous species
80
Government of Himachal Pradesh, Economic Survey, op.cit., 2016-17, pp. 58-62.
81
M. S. Ahluwalia, op.cit, 1998, pp.114-115.
82
Government of Himachal Pradesh, Economic Survey, op.cit., 2016-17, pp. 70-71.
116
growing in Himachal Pradesh whereas, Neoza Pine which produces edible nuts, is
grown in Kinnaur district. These are the only forest of Neoza in India.83 Among the
broad-leaved species, sal, ban, oak, mohru oak, kharshu oak, walnut, maple, birdcherry,
horse-chestnut, poplar, seemal, tun, and shisham are the important species in this forest.
These forest provide a large number of medicinal herbs and aromatic plants, which are
in great demand by pharmacetutical industry and perfuneries. Medicinal herbs like
dioscorea, belladonna, banafasha, mushakbala, patish, karru are already being exploited
in large quantities from these forest. The oil of skimia laureola, valeriana wallichi, kuth
and cedar wood oil and oak moss resin are in great demand in perfume making
industry. Coniferous woods provide excellent raw material for the manufacturers of a
number of products. These are fairly extensive areas of coniferous forests in this state
and there is a great scope for the establishment of wood-based industries.
The forest of the state till now has been exploited to produce mainly timber and
railway sleepers. This type of primitive usage has resulted in a great wastage of
valuable wood, which could otherwise be utilized to feed wood-based industries like
the manufacture of newsprint pulp. The manufacture of packing cases for apples from
this wood is also becoming an established cottage and medium scale industry in the
state. Some steps have been taken to establish suitable industries based on the forest
resources. Two government owned Rosin and Turpentine factories at Nahan and
Bilaspur are capable of handling about 1,11,000 quintals of oleo-resin. More factories
are being established for the processing of oleo-resin, rosin and turpentine oil. These
industries will play a very important part in the overall economy of the state.84
Himachal Pradesh covers an area of 37,033 Sq. kms. of the total geographical
area of the state. The government of India is well aware of the importance of the forest
and a large number of schemes and projects are being implemented in the state.
Productive forestry schemes and soil conservation schemes, wild life and nature
conservation, Indo-German, Eco Development Project (ODA) UK Forestry, Research
Education and Extension Project (REEP) and Watershed Development Project for
Himalayan Hills (Kandi Projects).85
83
Mian Goverdhan Singh, op.cit., 2010, p.170.
84
Ibid., pp. 270-273.
85
Government of Himachal Pradesh, Economic Survey, op.cit., 2016-17, pp. 66-69.
117
Industries
Industrially, Himachal Pradesh has been lagging behind other states of the
Indian union despite of many efforts being made in this field. Although, there have
been a number of cottage industry units engaged in the traditional crafts, such as shawl-
making and large-scale industries have been set up in the state. The reasons for the
industrial backwardness of Himachal Pradesh in industry apparently, have been due to
its difficult terrain and lack of speedy transport.
Between 1948 and 1966 i.e., upto the integration of Punjab hill areas into
Himachal Pradesh in November 1966, the industrialization of the state progressed
steadily but at a slow pace. By 1st November 1966, the number of small scale units in
the state had risen to 750. The government on its own had setup nearly 60 training cum-
production centres to promote such crafts as shawl making, footwear, carpets, etc. The
concerted efforts being made by the state government since 1967, indeed, have yielded
fairly impressive results on the industrial front. By 1976, the number of small-scale
units multiplied to 1,663 including cottage, village and other industries.86
As on 31st January 2017, there were 43,420 units working in the state. Out of
these, 138 Industrial Units are large and 438 are Medium Scale Units. The industry
department on permanent basis having the total investment of 17, 339.89 crore is
providing employment to 2,78,528 persons. Out of these 494 industrial units are
medium and large scale units.87 After the notification of special incentives package by
government of India in January, 2003, 8,375 small scale industrial units and 298
medium and large scale units having a total investment of 13, 923.22 crore have been
actually set in the state up to October 2012 and employment opportunities were
provided to 1,15,013 persons.88 The Ministry of Commerce and Industry (DIPP),
Government of India has accorded final approval for setting up of two state of art
industrial area at Pandoga district Kangra under modified industrial infrastructure
upgradation scheme. During the financial year 2016-17, an amount of Rs. 35.51 crore
has been allocated of development of these two states of art industrial areas, which has
been booked. The Government/Forest Land measuring 515 Bighas has been identified
for development of third state of the art industrial area at Dabhota, Tehsil Nalagarh in
district Solan. The FCA case has been submitted to the forest department for forest
86
Mian Goverdhan Singh, op.cit., 2010, pp. 265-266.
87
Government of Himachal Pradesh, Economic Survey, op.cit., 2016-17, p.67.
88
Ibid., p.73.
118
clearance under FCA, 1980 and is under process. Prime Minister’s Employment
Generation Programme (PMEGP), Assistant to the States for Development of Export
Infrastructure and Allied Activities (ASIDE) has been made by the government of
India. 89
Sericulture Industry
Hydel Power
Power sector play a significant role in the economy of Himachal Pradesh. It has
registered its significance in the economy by contributing in terms of revenue
generation, providing employment opportunities and enhancing the quality of life of
general public. Himachal Pradesh has been blessed with vast hydroelectric potential in
its five river basins, namely Yamuna, Sutlej, Beas, Ravi and Chenab. It is estimated
that about 23, 000 MW of hydel potential can be exploited in the state by constructing
various major, medium, small and mini/micro hydel projects on these five river basins.
89
Ibid.,
90
Ibid., p. 73.
91
M.S. Ahluwalia, op.cit.,1998, pp. 126-127.
119
Out of this hydel potential only 8, 432.47 MW has been harnessed by various agencies,
which also include 477.50 MW by H.P.S.E.B. Ltd. uptill 31st March 2014.
The main projects which are going on in the state are Andhra (16.95 MW), Giri
(60.00 MW), Gumma (3.00 MW), Rukti (1.50 MW), Chaba (1.75 MW), Rongtong
(2.00 MW), Nogli (2.50 MW), Bhaba (120.00 MW), Ganvi (22.50 MW), Binwa (6.00
MW), Gaj (10.50 MW), Baner (12.00 MW), Uhl-11 (Bassi) (66.00 MW), Larji
(126.00 MW), Khauli (12.00 MW), Sal-II (2.00 MW), Holi (3.00 MW), Bhuri Singh
P/H (0.45MW), Killar (0.30 MW), Sissu (0.10 MW), Thirot (4.50 MW), Bhaba
Augmentation (4.50 MW) and Himurja (Under State Sector) (2.37). The main projects,
which are ongoing with the Central/Joint Sector/ HP Share are Yammuna Project
(131.57 MW), Ranjeet Sagar Dam (27.60 MW), Bhakra (1,478.73 MW), Nathpa Jhakri
(1,500.00 MW), Baira Siul (198.00 MW), Chamera-I (540.00 MW), Chamera-II
(300.00 MW), Uhl-I (Shanan) (110.00 MW), Pong Dam (396.00 MW), B.S.L. (990.00
MW) and Chamera-III (231.00 MW).
As a result the Himachal Pradesh government has given thirteen hydro electric
projects in private sector for implementation. These projects are Baspa II (3.00 MW),
Malana-I (86.00 MW), Patikari (16.00 MW), Toss (10.00 MW), Sarbari II (5.40 MW),
Allain Duhangan (192.00 MW), Karchham Wangtoo ( 1, 000 MW), Upper Joiner
(12.00 MW), Sumez (14.00 MW), Beas Kund (9.00 MW), Malana II (100.00 MW),
Budhil (70.00MW), Neogal (15.00 MW) and Mini/ Micro Hydel Projects upto 5 MW
through Himurja (220.25 MW). The increasing activities on construction of hydel
projects, there is an immediate need to lay emphasis on adequate transmission and
distribution network in order to transmit power from these projects and its distribution
for utilisation within the state.92 Electrification of rural areas has great significance for
Himachal Pradesh, where as much as 91.3 per cent of its population lives in villages.
The state has made remarkable achievements in the field of rural electrification. 93
92
Government of Himachal Pradesh, Economic Survey, op.cit., 2016-17, pp. 79-86.
93
Ibid., p. 87.
120
no exaggeration to state that the construction of roads in a mountainous region is, in
fact, the beginning of the process of development. The total length of motorable roads
in Himachal Pradesh at the time of its formation in 1948 was 290 Kilometres in
addition to about 300 Kilometres of jeep able roads. In the rest of the areas there were
either foot-path or mule tracks.94 The revenue of the corporation is expected to increase
by 58 crore during the year 2013-14. Roads are an essential ingredient of infrastructure
of economy. In the absence of any other suitable and viable modes of transportation
like railways and waterways, roads play a vital role in boosting the economy of the
hilly state like Himachal Pradesh. Starting almost from a scratch the state Government
has constructed 36, 256 Kms. of motorable roads till December, 2016. The State
Government has been assigning a very high priority to road sector. For the year 2016-
17, there was an outlay of Rs. 912.73 crore. The process of improvement of National
Highways in the state having total length of 2, 027.00 Kms., which includes urban links
and bye-passes, continued during the year also. By the end of December 2016, an
expenditure of Rs. 184.00 crore has been incurred. There are only two narrow gauge
railway lines connecting Shimla with Kalka (96 Km.) and Jogindernagar with
Pathankot (113Km.) and one 33 Km. broad gauge railway line from Nangal Dam to
Charuru in District Una.
Road transport is the main stay of economic activity in the Pradesh as other
means of transport namely Railways, Airways, Taxies, Auto Rickshaw etc. are
negligible. Therefore, the road transport corporation assumes paramount importance.
The growth of means of communication as telephone, telegraphs, newspapers, radio,
roads, post office and televisions are playing an important role in the development of
Himachal Pradesh.95 The passenger transport services to the people of Himachal
Pradesh within and outside the state are being provided by Himachal Road Transport
Corporation (HRTC), with a fleet strength of 3,012 buses as on October, 2016. HRTC
is plying bus services on 2,530 routes with coverage of 5.504 Lakh Kms. daily.96
94
Mian Goverdhan Singh, op.cit., 1988, p. 203.
95
Government of Himachal Pradesh, Economic Survey, op.cit., 2016-17, pp. 57-58.
96
Ibid., p. 94.
121
Tourism
Himachal Pradesh has mountains and hills but even more important the people
to provide both the adventure and walking tour holidays that cannot be matched
anywhere in the world. The towering middle, low series of mountains and the deepest
gorges form the picturesque scenes for tourists. The different ecological belts from sub-
tropical to perpetual snow with various climatic zones, differentiation, give pleasure for
mountain tourists throughout the year. Everywhere the mountain tourists experience
peace and happiness in the land, which is far from the madding crowd. The sparsely
populated valleys and ridges provide relief and healing touch to people of the plains,
who suffer from heat and over crowdedness and seek the desired peace and tranquillity.
Almost all the regions of Himachal Pradesh are attractive to the tourists. While trekking
in Himachal, one can see the spectacular snowy peaks, beautiful lakes and meet
interesting people living in the remote villages in the rugged mountains. Although the
trekking trails are sometimes steep and lonely, almost all the seasons are tourist’s
seasons in Himachal Pradesh. Tourists who wants to enjoy mountain life and traditions
can visit the state throughout the year.97
97
Rajender Attri, op.cit., 2010, pp.778-779.
122
The department has released advertisements in the print and electronic media to
promote the tourism from time to time during the financial year. The department has
prepared the 20 years perspective tourism master plan for the planned and sustainable
development of the tourism sector. Tourism policy, 2013 and sustainable plan for
Dharamshala, 2013 have also been formulated. The department has organized various
adventure and general training courses for the unemployed youths of the state like
trekking guide, water sports, skiing EDP, Bird watching and river rafting etc. in the
state.98
The State Government has prevention and treatment intervention are accessible
to people and are applied efficiently. In Himachal Pradesh, health and family welfare
department is providing services which include curative, preventive, promotive and
rehabilitative services through a network of 75 Civil Hospitals, 87 Community Health
Centres, 533 Primary Health Centres, 13 ESI Dispensaries and 2,078 Sub-Centres.99
A brief descriptions of various health and family welfare activities carried out in
the state during 2016-17 are as under: National Vector Borne Disease Control
Programme, National Leprosy Eradication Programme, Revised National T.B. Control
Programme, National Programme for Control of Blindness, National Family Welfare
Programme, Universal Immunization Programme, Mukhya Mantri State Health Care
Scheme, National Rural Health Mission and National AIDS Control Programme. These
all programmes are being implemented as per the guidelines of government of India.
98
Government of Himachal Pradesh, Economic Survey, op.cit., 2016-17, p.108.
99
Ibid., p.124.
123
RPGMC Tanda. Indian system of medicines and homoeopathy plays a vital role in the
health care system of the state. The separate department of Ayurveda was established in
1984 and health care services are being provided to the general public through 2
Regional Ayurvedic Hospitals, 2 Circle Hospitals, 3 Tribal Hospitals, 16 Ten/Twenty
bedded Ayurvedic Hospitals, 9 District Ayurvedic Hospitals, One Nature Care
Hospital, and 1,150 Ayurvedic Health Centres, 3 Unani Health Centres, 14
Homoeopathic Health Centres and 4 Amchiclinics. The department has inbuilt system
of production of medicines through 3 Ayurvedic Pharmacies, at Jogindernagar in
Mandi District, Majra in Sirmaur district and Paprola in Kangra district.
These pharmacy catering to the needs of the Ayurvedic health institutions of the
department and also give boost the employment to local people. The department of
Ayurveda is also associated with health programmes like malaria, family welfare and
anaemia free, AIDS, immunization and pulse polio etc. during the financial year 2016-
17, there was a budget provision of Rs. 250.00 crore. To provide better health services
to the people, the government is strengthening the existing infrastructure by providing
modern equipments, specialized services, increasing the strength of the medical and
para-medical staff in the medical institutions.100
Education
Education is the key instrument for development human capability. The state is
committed to provide education to all. Literacy is an important indicator of the socio-
economic development of any area and it is the base of socio-economic change.
Initially, Himachal was considered as a backward region of the north India. The view
came up in the report of state reorganization commission published in 1953, literacy
rate of the Himachal Pradesh was 21 per cent for female as per the 1961 census, well
below the corresponding all India literacy rate. In spite of difficult terrain and many
socio-political cultural barriers, Himachal Pradesh has been making consistent efforts
for the development of education in the Pradesh. After the independence, the overall
literacy rate has shown significant upward trend both for male and female. At present,
there are 10,738 notified primary schools out of which 10,735 are functional and 2,113
middle schools were notified out of which 2,103 are functioning in the state. To
100
Ibid.,
124
overcome the shortage of trained teachers efforts are being made to make fresh
appointments of teachers in the needy schools. An attempt has also been made to cater
the educational need of disabled children.101
There are four agricultural institutions in the state for agricultural education and
research. These institutions are, Central Potato Research Institute (Shimla); Farmers
Training Institute (Sundernagar); Himachal Agriculture College and Research Institute
(Solan-Nauni); Regional Bee Research Centre of the Central Bee Research Institute
(Kangra). These institutions are Indian Institute of Technology (IIT), Mandi at
Kamand, National Institute of Technology, Hamirpur, one National Institute of Fashion
Technology (NIFT), Kangra, Indian Institute of Management (IIM), Sirmour, Indian
Institute of Information Technology, Una, Central Institute of Plastic Engineering and
Technology (CIPET), Baddi in district Solan, Regional Vocational Training Institute
(RVTI) for Women at Jhundla, Tehsil Shimla Rural, district Shimla, Jawahar Lal Nehru
Government Engineering College, Sundernagar, Atal Bihari Vajpayee Government
Institute of Engineering and Technology, Pragatinagar, district Shimla, Rajiv Gandhi
Government Engineering College, Kangra at Nagrota Bagwan, Mahatma Gandhi
Government Engineering College, Kotla Tehsil Rampur (Jeori) district Shimla, 2
Government Pharmacy College, Rohroo District Shimla and Nagrota Bagwan District
Kangra, 13 B-Pharmacy Colleges (Private Sector), 14 Engineering Colleges (Private
Sector), 15 Polytechnics ( Government Sector), 18 Polytechnics (Private Sector), 02 D-
Pharmacy Colleges (Private Sector). There are seven, 2nd Shifts in Diploma Courses
(Private Sector), 108 Co-educational Industrial Training Institutes (Government
Sector), and nine Industrial Training Institutes (Women) (Government Sector).
However, there is one ITI for Persons with disability at Sundernagar (Government
Sector), 1 Motor Driving School at Una in Government Sector and 143 ITIs Private
Sectors.102 The literacy, rate in Himachal Pradesh which was 7.98 per cent during
1950-51, has gone upto 82.80 per cent in 2011, and the same is 89.53 per cent for males
and 75.93 per cent for females. The district wise literacy rates in Himachal Pradesh are
as under:
101
Ibid., p.101.
102
Ibid., pp.111-114.
125
Table 2.12
Bilaspur
86.53 84.59
Chamba
81.53 Sirmaur
80
Solan
76.81 79.4
Una
126
The table 2.12 shows that the highest literacy rates have been recorded in
Hamirpur district with 88.15 per cent for the total population in which 94.36 per cent
are males and 82.62 per cent are females. The lowest literacy percentage is in the
district of Chamba i.e. 72.17 per cent of the total population in which 82.59 per cent are
male and 61.67 per cent are females. Further analysis shows that apart from the
Chamba, the female literacy rates are less than the state average in other district.
Mineral Wealth
103
Ibid., p.74.
104
Mian Goverdhan Singh, op.cit., 2010, p. 272.
127
allocated amongst three banks viz. PNB, UCO Bank and State Bank of India. The UCO
Bank is the convenor Bank of State level Bankers Committee (SLBC). Up to
September, 2016 the State has a network of 2, 061 and more than 80 per cent branches
are functioning in rural areas. Banks have opened 106 new bank branches during
October, 2015 to September, 2016. At present 1, 661 branches are located in rural areas
and 308 in semi-urban areas and 92 are functioning at Shimla, the only urban centre in
the State classified by Reserve Bank of India (RBI).
Himachal Pradesh State Cooperative Bank is performing dual function viz. that
of Apex Cooperative Bank in Himachal Pradesh to play lead role in development in
Cooperative in the state and that of a Cooperative Bank in six districts viz. Bilaspur,
Chamba, Kinnaur, Mandi, Shimla and Sirmaur. The Himachal Pradesh Cooperative
Bank is serving the people of the state through a network of 198 branches and 21
extension counters, all these branches are on CBS mode. The State Co-operative Bank
is the first State Co-operative Bank on the National financial switch through which the
customers are getting ATMs facilities all over the Nation and about 71 own ATMs on
strategic locations. Bank is actively participating in government of India social security
scheme i.e. Pradhan Mantri Jeevan Jyoti Bima Yojana (PMJJBY) and Pradhan Mantri
Suraksha Bima Yojana (PMSBY).
The Kangra Central Cooperative Bank, Dharamshala had 204 branch offices
including head office as on 2016 with deposits of Rs. 8, 42,753 lakh. Similarly, the
Jogindra Central Co-operative Bank Ltd., Solan had 29 branches, including head office
with deposits of Rs. 70,784 lakh in 2016. Himachal Pradesh Gramin Bank, sponsored
by Punjab National Bank having total branch network of 244 as on September,
2016.105
Rural Development
128
Rural Livelihood Mission (NRLM); Deen Dayal Upadhaya-Gramin Kaushal Yojna;
Watershed Development Programme; Pradhan Mantri Awaas Yojana Gramin (PMAY-
G); State Rural Housing Schemes-Rajiv Awaas Yojana; Mukhaya Mantri Awaas
Yojana (MMAY); Rajiv Awaas Repair Yojana (RARY);Saansad Adrash Gram Yojana
(SAGY); Matri Shakti Bima Yojana; Swachh Bharat Mission (Gramin); Maharshi
Valmiki Sampooran Swachhata Puruskar (MVSSP); Mahila- Mandal Protsahan Yojna;
Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme (MGNREGS).106
The present District of Mandi was formed with the merger of two princely
states Mandi and Suket on 15th April, 1948, when the state of Himachal Pradesh came
into existence. Ever since the formation of the district, it has not witnessed any changes
in its jurisdiction. The state of Suket is said to have been founded by Bir Sen, an
ancestor of the Sen Dynasty of Bengal. The separation of Mandi from Suket took place
about the year 1200 AD. Upto that time, it was the single state of Suket. Mandi
emerged as a separate state in the beginning of the sixteenth century. Ajbar Sen was the
first great ruler of Mandi, who founded Mandi Town in 1927 AD. He was probably the
first to assume the designation of Raja. He built a palace here and the temple of Bhut
Nath. Down the line of descendants was Raja Sidh Sen, who succeeded Raja Gur Sen
in 1678 AD. Mandi had never been so powerful before and after his reign. Guru
Govind Singh, the tenth Guru of the Sikhs visited Mandi during his reign in the close of
the 17th century. He built the great tank before the palace. He also built the temples of
“Sidh Ganesh” and “Trilok Nath.”108
106
Ibid., pp.134-142.
107
Gazetteer of the Mandi State, New Delhi: Indus Publishing Company, 1920, p. 14.
108
Government of Himachal Pradesh, District Human Development Report Mandi, Shimla: Planning
Department Himachal Pradesh, 2001, p. 14.
129
The history of both the state of Mandi and Suket is full with wars among
themselves and other adjoining states. These two states had always been rivals and
generally enemies, but there was no great result of their warfare. On 10th November,
1921, both the states of Mandi and Suket were transferred from the political control of
Punjab Government to that of Government of India till 15th August, 1947. The only
place in the district that has an early mention in literature is Rewalsar and it is
mentioned in the Skanda Purana as a sacred place of pilgrimage. It is believed that
Karnpur, a small village, was founded by Karan, a hero of Mahabharta. According to
the Tibetan tradition, Padam Sambhab (750-800 AD), the great Buddist Patriarch, who
was summoned by King Tisong-De-Tsen of Tibet for preaching Buddhism, hailed from
Zohar, which represents the country round about Rewalsar. On the basis of this, it is
concluded that Mandi must have been a great place of Buddist learning as well about
this time.109
Geography
The district is situated between 31º-13-50” and 32º-04-30” north latitude and
76º-37-20” and 77º-23-15” east longitudes. It is bounded by Kangra on the north-west,
Hampirpur and Bilaspur in the west, Arki tehsil of Solan district in the south, Shimla
district in the south-west and Kullu district in the east. The district has two main rivers
viz; the Beas and the Satluj. The river Beas enters the district from close to Bajaura, at
the boundary of Kullu and leaves the district at Sandhol. The Mandi town is also
located on the banks of this river. For the greater part of its length, it runs between high
banks and as it is never of great width, though the current is swift, especially during the
rains. Practically, the whole of the district drains into the Beas with only the southeast
corner situated on the Satluj watershed. Within the district the principal tributaries of
the Beas on the north bank are Uhl, Luni, Rana and Binu and on the south bank are the
Hanse, Tirthan, Bakhli, Jiuni, Suketi, Ranodi, Son and Bakar. The greater part of the
district is mountainous terrain with the main ranges of mountains running from the
north to the south with the system being broken up by innumerable transverse spurs.
The most conspicuous is the Jalori range which is crossed by a high road from Kullu to
Shimla by a pass named as Jalori pass. It divides the watersheds of the Satluj and the
109
Ibid., p.15.
130
Beas and on its northern slopes is unusually well wooded with deodar (Cedrus
Deodara) and blue pine (Pinus Wallichiana) forests of great value. The highest peak in
the range is Shikari Devi (11,060 feet). Its summit being crowned by a shrine to a local
goddess. The range throws off three main spurs which extend throughout the tract
known as the Mandi Saraj. To the north of the Beas is the Nargu range, a continuation
of the Bir Bhangal, separating Mandi from Kullu proper and crossed by the Bhubu pass
(9,480 feet). The mountains here run upto 13000 feet and the slopes often being very
precipitous, while the valleys are deep. Almost parallel and running down the centre of
the district is the Ghoghar-ki-Dhar, of which the slopes are fairly gentle. It is not well
wooded, but contains large expanses of excellent grazing and the salt quarries of Drang
and Gumma. The Sikandar Range commences from the trijunction with Suket and
Bilaspur and from there runs northward for fifty miles. The range contains some good
forests of chil pine, but the greater part of it consists of rich grass slopes. Its name is
attributed to Sikander Lodhi, who, 375 years before the reign of Akbar, is supposed to
have crossed it on his way to the conquest of Kangra.110
Climate
110
Ibid., pp.15-17.
111
Mandi, Himachal Pradesh, https://en.wikipedia.org.,Accessed on 29-12-2016.
131
Area and Population
As per 2011 census, the district has a population of 9,99,777 persons with a
population density of 253 persons per sq. km. Mandi district population constituted
14.56 per cent of total Maharashtra population. Out of the total population of the
district, 293,739 persons are scheduled castes and 12,787 persons are scheduled tribes.
The male and female population in the district is 4,98,065 and 5,01,712 respectively,
with a sex ratio of 1007 females per 1000 males. The schedule caste population in the
district is 29.4 and the schedule tribe population is 1.3. As per the census of India 2011,
rural population in the district is 937,140 persons and the urban population is 62,637
persons. 112
Mandi has an average literacy rate of 81.53 per cent, higher than the national
average of 74.04 per cent and almost equal to state’s literacy rate 82.80 per cent, male
literacy is 89.56 per cent and female literacy is 73.66 per cent. Mandi has a mixed
population of Hindus, Sikhs, Buddhists and Christians with more than 90 per cent
population being Hindu. As per 2011 census, the area of Mandi district is 3,950 km2.
and covers 7.10 per cent area of the state.113
Culture
132
in the month of March every year. The celebration of Shivratri of Mandi is said to have
started in the year 1526 to commemorate the foundation of present day Mandi. Before
this, the capital of Mandi was on the right bank of the river Beas, which is now known
as Old Mandi (Purani Mandi). Mandi also hosts a half marathon every year.
Once, the tenth guru of the Sikhs was on a visit to Mandi, the king of Mandi
invited him to stay at the royal palace. The guru accepted the invitation to stay in
Mandi but not with the king. He put up outside the town in a secluded place, which had
once been the hermitage of a Rishi (Indian sage). The guru was touched by the king’s
devotion and prophesized that Mandi would ever remain safe and if any enemy tries to
harm it, bolts from heaven would crush the invader. He considered Mandi the safest
place on the planet.114
Economy
Many hectares of land in Mandi are also under apple production. Apples are
generally planted during December every year. The area under fruit cultivation in
Mandi is about 15 per cent of the total area, under fruits in Himachal Pradesh. Mandi
raw silk has acquired wide fame but the salt mines at Drang and Guma are the special
features of the economy. With abundant deposit of salt and limestone, possibilities are
114
Mandi, Himachal Pradesh, https://en.wikipedia.org.,Accessed on 29-12-2016, pp. 7-8.
133
being investigated for the existence of magnasite coal and china-clay. Mandi also has
fish markets, where brown trout is one of the most demanded fish species. In Mandi, a
farmer gets around Rs.200 per kg. for Brown Trout.115
As per the census of India 2011, out of the total population of the district,
2,84,154, persons are main workers, 2,88,517 persons are marginal workers and
4,27,106 persons are non-workers in the district. Out of the total workers, 5, 72,671 are
main workers (Main Marginal Workers), 3, 87,944 are cultivators, 15,822 are
agricultural labourers, 7,134 are engaged in household industries and 1, 61,771 are
engaged in other activities.116
Education
The city has Anganwadis, primary as well as high schools. Some of the popular
school in the city are DAV Centenary Public School, Kendriya Vidyalaya, Mandi
Public School, Indus World School, The Phoenix School of Integrated Learning, Vijay
Government Senior Secondary School, Government Senior Secondary School (Girls),
Sarswati Vidya Mandir, Sai Public School, St. Xavier Residentia School, DAV Sr.
Secondary School, Anglo Sanskrit Model School. The Medical Institutes in Mandi is
Himachal Dental College. Jawaharlal Nehru Government Engineering College, T. R.
Abhilashi Memorial Institute of Engineering and Technology, and Vallabh Bhai
Government College are also located in the city. The Indian Institute of Technology
Mandi, is an autonomous and top university of the state for Graduation in
B.Tech/M.Tech offering many courses. The Abhilashi University is also based in
Mandi, is having several branches offering engineering and technology, pharmacy,
management studies, vocal training institute. There are many other private institutes of
higher education and research located in Mandi, like M.G. Institute of Engineering and
Technology, Sirda Institute of Engineering and Emerging Technology for Women,
Noble College of Education and Centre for Computer Education and Software
Development.117
115
Ibid., pp. 5-6.
116
Government of Himachal Pradesh, Socio-Economic Indicators of Himachal Pradesh, op.cit., 2014-
15, p.19.
117
Mandi, Himachal Pradesh, https://en.wikipedia.org.,Accessed on 29-12-2016, pp. 8-10.
134
Mandi district comprises seven tehsils namely, Joginder Nagar, Sarkaghat,
Sunder Nagar, Sadar Mandi, Chachiot, Thunag, Karsog and Nine sub-tehsils, i.e.,
Ladbharol, Padher, Sandhole, Dharmpur, Baldwara, Nihri, Kotli, Aut, Bali Chowki.
For the purpose of development activities, the district has been divided into 10
Blocks. The district has six city including Pandoh as census city. These are namely
Mandi, Sunder Nagar, Joginder Nagar, Rewalsar, Sarkaghat and Pandoh. Recently,
Mandi has become Zonal Headquarter of Central Zone, which covers the districts of
Bilaspur, Hamirpur, Kullu and Mandi itself and has gained much importance from
administrative point of view. Nagar Parishad Mandi was constituted during 1950.118
Kangra district derives its name from Kangra town that was known as Nagarkot
in ancient times. Kangra proper originally was a part of the ancient Trigarta
(Jullundur), which comprises of the area lying between the river “Shatadroo” (probably
Sutlej) and Ravi. A tract of land to the east of Sutlej that probably is the area of Sirhind
in Punjab also formed a part of Trigrata. Trigrata had two provinces that is one in the
plains with headquarters at Jullundur and other in the hills with headquarters at
Nagarkot (the present Kangra).
The present Kangra district came into existence on the 1st September 1972
consequent upon the re-organisation of districts by the government of Himachal
Pradesh. It was the largest district of the composite Punjab in terms of area, till it was
transferred to Himachal Pradesh on the 1st November 1966, and had six tehsils namely
Nurpur, Kangra, Palampur, Dehragopipur, Hamirpur and Una. Kullu was also a tehsil
of Kangra district up to 1962 and Lahaul & Spiti, which also formed a part of Kangra
was carved out as a separate district in 1960. On the re-organisation of composite
Punjab on the 1st November 1966, the area constituting Kangra district were transferred
to Himachal Pradesh along with the districts of Shimla, Kullu and Lahaul & Spiti and
tehsils of Una and Nalagarh and three villages of Gurdaspur district.119
118
Ibid.,
119
Government of Himachal Pradesh, District Human Development Report Kangra, Shimla: Planning
Department Himachal Pradesh, 2009, p. 5.
135
Location
Topography
As per 2011 census, the district has a population of 15, 10,075 persons with a
population density of 263 persons per sq km. Population wise, it ranks first in the state.
Out of the total population of the district, 3, 19,385 persons are scheduled castes and
84,564 persons are scheduled tribes. The male and female population in the district is 7,
50,591 and 7, 59,484 respectively with a sex ratio of 1012 females per 1000 males. The
schedule caste population in the district is 21.2 per cent and the schedule tribe
120
Kangra, Himachal Pradesh, www.himachaltouristguide.com., Accessed on 29-12-2016.
121
Government of Himachal Pradesh, District Human Development Report Kangra, op.cit.,2009, p. 14.
136
population is 5.6 per cent. As per the census of India 2011, rural population in the
district is 14, 23,794 persons and the urban population are 86,281 persons.122
Kangra has an average literacy rate of 85.67 per cent, higher than the national
average of 74.04 per cent and almost equal to state’s literacy rate 82.80 per cent, male
literacy is 91.49 per cent and female literacy is 80.02 per cent.123
Economy
Kangra being the largest district accounting for more than one fifth of the state
population and 10.31 per cent of total geographical area plays an important role in the
economy of the state. The economy of district is primarily agrarian with two- thirds of
the population directly dependent on agriculture.124 The district is covered by fertile
valleys and agriculture is the mainstay of rural population. The agro-climatic conditions
obtaining in the district are most suitable for the growing of food crops such as wheat,
rice, maize oil seeds, sugarcane, potatoes and tea.125 Tea cultivation was introduced in
1850 into the Kangra valley. The Palampur fair, established by government with a view
to fostering commerce with central Asia, attracts a small concourse of Yarkandi
merchants. The Lahaulis, carry on an enterprising trade with Ladakh and countries
beyond the frontier, by means of pack sheep and goats. Rice, tea, potatoes, opium,
spices, wool and honey are the chief exports.126 Tourism is also an important part of the
economy, with Bir in particular becoming a strong hub for ecotourism and aero sports.
This area was significantly damaged by an earthquake on April 4, 1905.127
As per the census of India 2011, out of total population of the district, 3, 13,915
persons are main workers, 3, 61,255 persons are marginal workers and 8, 34,905
persons are non-workers in the district. Out of the total workers, 6,75,170 are the main
workers, 3, 03,007 are cultivators, 54,849 are agricultural labourers, 15,662 are
engaged in household industries and 3, 01,652 are engaged in other activities.128
122
Government of Himachal Pradesh, Statistical Abstract of Himachal Pradesh, op.cit., 2015-16, pp. 2- 15.
123
Ibid., p. 64.
124
Government of Himachal Pradesh, District Human Development Report Kangra, op.cit., 2009, p.32.
125
Jag Mohan Balokhra, The Wonderland Himachal: An Encyclopedia on a Tiny State of Western
Himalayas, New Delhi: H.G. Publications, 2007, p. 541.
126
Kangra, Himachal Pradesh, http://en.m.wikipedia.org., Accessed on 29-12-2016, p. 2.
127
Kangra District, http://en.m.wikipedia.org., Accessed on 29-12-2016.
128
Government of Himachal Pradesh, Socio-Economic Indicators of Himachal Pradesh, op.cit., 2014-
15, p.19.
137
The Beas river forms the major drainage system in the district. The river Beas
and its tributaries drain almost the entire district, except the north eastern part which is
drained by the river Ravi. There are two important lakes in the district, namely Dal
Lake and Kareri. The population of Kangra district comprises a multi religious
community of Hindus, Muslims, Buddhists, Sikhs, Christians and Jains.
Culture
The traditional dress for men was the Kurta, Pyjamas, and a woolen jacket used
in winter. Women generally wear the Salwar Kameez and with the Salwar kameez girls
and women taken Chuenni (“Chaddru” in local language).
Kangra valley is one of the most picturesque, green and luxuriant valleys of
lower Himalayas sheltered by the sublime Dhauladhar range. This is one of the most
important and famous districts of Himachal Pradesh due to its popularity. Kangra is
mainly famous for its natural beauty and tea gardens. Number of people visit here. It is
the home of Masroor Rock Cut Temple, also known as Himalayan Pyramids and
Wonder of the World, for being likely contender for the UNESCO World Heritage Site.
Many ancient temples like the Jawalaji Chamunda Devi Temple, Chintapurni Temple
Baba Baroh, Masroor Temple built by Pandvas and Baijnath Temple are found here.
One can also pay a visit to Gopalpur Nature Park in Gopalpur village and can also see
tea gardens there. The Kangra fort is also a popular tourist attraction. Mcleodganj near
Dharamshala is the home in exile to the his Holiness Dalai Lama, the Tibetan spiritual
guru and “Bhagsunag Temple” at Bhagsu. Cricket ground of Dharamshala is also a
major attraction because of its location and good quality pitch for players. Maharaja
Sansar Chandra Museum adjoins the Kangra fort. Available at the Museum are audio
guides for the Kangra fort and the museum.129
129
Kangra, Himachal Pradesh, http://en.m.wikipedia.org., Accessed on 29-12-2016, pp.2-3.
138
Kangra district consists of total fifteen Development Blocks: Baijnath,
Bhawarna, Lambagaon, Panchrukhi, Kangra, Nagrota Bagwan Rait, Dehra,
Dharmshala, Pragpur, Nagrota Suria, Nurpur, Indora, Fatehpur, Sulah.
Tehsils in Kangra : Nurpur, Nagrota, Indora, Jwali, Kangra, Palampur, Badoh, Kasba
Kotla, Jaswan, Dehra Gopipur, Khundiyan, Jaishinghpur, Baijnath, Fatehpur,
Dharamshala, and Shahpur.
130
Kangra District, http://en.m.wikipedia.org., Accessed on 29-12-2016.
139
CHAPTER-III
The statistics shows that even in the developed countries like United States of
America (19.4%), United Kingdom (32.0%), Germany (37.0%), Canada (26.3%), Italy
(31.0%), France (39.0%), Japan (9.3%), etc., the participation of women in the
Lower/Single House of National Parliaments /Legislatures is very low as compared to
men. The highest representation of women in parliaments/legislatures is found in the
countries like Rawanda (61.3%), Cuba (48.9%), Iceland (47.6%), Sweden (43.6%),
South Africa (42.0%), Finland (42.0%), Norway (39.6%), Argentina (38.9%), Denmark
(37.4%) and Netherlands (36.0%). In Scandinavian Countries, women enjoy an equal
status with men and their representation in national legislatures is found between 38.0
to 47.0 per cent, whereas the lowest representation is noted in the countries like Nauru
(10.5%), Bahrain (7.5%), Iran (5.9%), etc. There are also countries like Yemen, Qatar,
Papua New Guinea and Vanuatu, etc., where there is no representation of women in the
national legislatures/ parliaments. In the developing countries, women representations
in lower house like Nepal (29.6%), Pakistan (20.6%), China (24.2%), Bangladesh
141
(20.3%), India (11.8%), Maldives (5.9%), and Sri Lanka (5.8%), etc., the women
representation is very low.1 In 1960, Sri Lanka became the first country to have a
woman Prime Minister.2 In the 1970s, Indira Gandhi became Prime Minister of India
and in the 1980s Benajir Bhutto achieved yet another feat, when she became Prime
Minister of an Islamic country, Pakistan. However in spite of this, women constitute a
marginal proportion of representatives in the legislatures and various decision-making
bodies of these countries. It has been pointed out that, in modern South Asian countries
like India, Pakistan, Bangladesh and Sri Lanka, the largest number of women leaders
have held power (or served in the opposition) for the longest periods of time. But, all
these women leaders (Indira Gandhi, Banajir Bhutto, Hasina Wajed, Khalida Zia,
Sirimao Bandarnaike) succeeded male relatives (husbands, fathers); all of them were
propelled to their positions by party support. Therefore, none of them was a grassroots
politician, all belonged to affluent families and came from elite or ruling classes and in
all these countries weak institutionalization allowed dynastic succession to prevail even
under the democratic system of government. These women assumed leadership
generally during periods of crisis. The women leaders in modern South Asian nations
emerged as a type produced under sharply specific historical conditions. The general
women masses are however poor, illiterate, often veiled and indifferent towards
politics. Thus, the world-wide picture regarding women’s participation in politics is not
very praise-worthy. Women, who constitute half of the human population, have been
denied their due share in politics not only in India but also in the whole world.3
Ancient India
1
Women in Parliaments: World Classification-Inter-Parliamentary Union, www.ipu.org/wmn-
e/classif.htm., Accessed on 31-10-2017.
2
K.C. Vidya, Political Empowerment of Women at the Grassroots, New Delhi: Kanishka Publishers,
2007, p. 3.
3
Bhawana Jharta, “Marginalization of Women in Politics: Some Observations”, in Mamta Mokta (ed.),
Dimensions of Gender Inequality in Society, Chandigarh: Shree Ram Lal House, 2016,
pp. 81-82.
142
“Women are deities of prosperity. By cherishing women, one cherishes the
goddess of prosperity herself and by afflicting her, one is said to pain the goddess of
prosperity”.
(Anusasana Parva, Mahabharata)
Where the women are held in reverence, there do the Gods reside, is an old
Sanskrit adage. A society grows, if the women grow, if they partake of the spirit of
progress, for they are the proverbial domestic legislators, they are the matrix of social
life. In India, till the advent of the Turks Indian women enjoyed great freedom and
prestige, but due to certain social, economic and political exigencies and the unhappy
impact of alien ideologies, inhuman restrictions clamped upon them, they were
relegated to a position of servility and insignificance and they were burdened with
several taboos and restrictions. Indian society has been a tradition bound society in
which the traditionalists would present an idealised picture of women substantiating
their claims on the basis of certain references from the Vedic and classical literature.
The Indian woman is part of a culture that goes back into the past. If she has a
particular conviction of acts in a specific manner, it is due to the pattern that has been
ingrained in her by the fairly stable social structure of a thousand years.4 The highest
place has been accorded to women in Indian religious and philosophical thought. The
primordial one is conceived as a harmony of ‘Purusha’ (male) and ‘Prakrati’ (female).
The concept of ‘Ardhanarishwara’ describes god-head as half female and half male.
The ‘Shakti’ cult is centred on the superiority and destructive strength of the females.
Rivers and streams, dawn and twilight, flowers and seasons, knowledge and music are
conceived of as feminine.
The position of power, status and disabilities of the daughter, wife, and the
widow went on changing in course of time. Women enjoyed considerable freedom and
privileges in the spheres of family, religion and public life, but as centuries rolled on,
the situation went on changing adversely. The position which women occupied in
Hindu society at the dawn of civilization during the Vedic age is much better.5
4
Preeti Misra, Domestic Violence Against Women, Legal Control and Judicial Response, New Delhi:
Deep and Deep Publications, 2007, p.1-2.
5
Ibid.,
143
Vedic Period
During ancient times, women held a high place of respect in the society, as
mentioned in Rig-Veda and other scriptures.6 The Vedic era was the golden era so far
as equilibrium of status and freedom between men and women, with right of
knowledge and freedom to marry is concerned.7 The Rig-Vedic women played
significant role in family, society and even in political life.8
In the early Vedic Period, women were taking an active part in the industrial
life. They were manufacturing arrows and bows, making baskets, weaving cloth and
participating in outdoor agricultural (work) activities. These outdoor professions and
activities show early Vedic society. The girl’s were given education at par with boys
and had to pass through a period of Brahamcharya. They had equal right of Vedic
study as of men. They not only studied Vedas but also figured among the authors of
Vedic hymns.
Upanishads
6
Shiv Raj Singh, et al. (eds.), Public Administration in the New Millennium: Changing and Prospects,
New Delhi: Anamika Publishers, 2003, p. 253.
7
Mridula Bhadauria, Women in India: Some Issue, New Delhi: APH Publishing Corporation, 1997, p.1.
8
A.S. Altekar, The Position of Women in Hindu Civilization, New Delhi: Motilal Banarsidass, 1962,
p. 339.
9
Anant Sadashiv Altekar, “Ideal and Position of Indian Women in Social Life”, in Swami
Madhavananda and Ramesh Chandra Majumdar (eds.), Great Women of India, Almora: Advaita
Ashrama, 1953, pp. 26-28.
10
Kalpana Roy, Women and their Environment, Delhi: Rajat Publications, 1999, pp. 83-88.
144
Gargi even out questioned and out-wearied the Chief Philosopher of the Upanishads,
Yajnavalkya. Maitreyi was a discourser on sacred knowledge. In the Upanishads,
woman is referred to as having been created by the primeval being. Brihad-Aranyaka
says that ‘a man’s wife is his voice’.11
Manu for the first time legally assigned to woman her definite place in the scale
of society. But his laws reflect a conflict even within himself between his valuation of
woman as a spiritual entity on the one side and as a unit in society on the other. He
averred that a mother is more to be revered than a thousand fathers, yet his laws place
woman socially on a level with the lowest of all groups in Aryan society, the Sudra.12
Manu enumerates many laws directing a wife’s conduct-he says that a wife
must show to her husband such utter devotion that he must be treated like a God, even
when he is conspicuously lacking in virtue. No sacrifice, no vow, no fast must be
performed by women apart. If a wife obeys her husband, she will for that be exalted in
heaven. In childhood, a female must be subject to her father, in youth to her husband;
when her lord is dead, to her sons. A woman must never be independent. The laws of
Manu state that women were created to be mothers and that they may perform religious
rites along with their husband. The tenets of Manu have fostered a deep rooted belief in
the intellectual and otherwise inferiority of women. He says that women should never
be given independence. He equated women with slave and his laws epitomize complete
submission of women to men and there are still the sanctioned codes of conduct
ascribed for and by and large accepted by women. But Manu was not a woman hater,
for it was Manu who said in Manu Samriti that-
145
for a girl and advocated child marriage, though he warned fathers not to give away their
daughters to men devoid of good qualities. Though polygamy was practiced, he
strongly advocated monogamy and attached the greatest importance to sexual restraint
and fidelity to one’s spouse. He laid down different rules even for a man contemplating
separation. A woman deserted by her husband was given the right to marry after the
lapse of certain number of years. Thus, Manu was the principal law-maker of the
conservative Hindu period. His prime objective was to safeguard the interests of the
family and society at the expense of individual liberty. Thus, the laws of Manu, as do
all the earlier documents of Hinduism shows various attitudes, both appreciative and
depreciative, towards women.13
Epic Period
The status of women and their participation in politics during the epic period is
discussed in the context of Ramayana and Mahabharata periods. 14
The Ramayana is one of the most effective of all Hindu sacred writings. In the
laws of Manu and in the Mahabharata, it is taught that a wife should reverence her
husband, as if he were a veritable deity. This teaching is reaffirmed in the Ramayana.
Women have no individual identity; their personality is blended with men. The
Ramayana enjoys the lifelong inseparability of wives and husband.
The dependence of a woman upon her husband, son and relatives is continued
from the antecedent laws of Manu. A wife’s service to her husband is taken as the best
method of attaining heaven. The Ramayana reaffirmed the deep-seated Hindu
conception that husband is a women’s greatest deity.15
13
Preeti Misra, op.cit., 2007, pp. 13-18.
14
Roma Choudhuri, “Women’s Education in Ancient India”, in Swami Madhavananda and Ramesh
Chandra Majumdar (eds.), Great Women of India, Almora: Advaita Ashrama, 1953, pp.102-104.
15
Preeti Misra, op.cit., 2007, pp. 28-29.
146
The high standard of women’s education set up during the Vedic Age was
fortunately continued to a large extent during the Epic Age as well. Women were given
full opportunities for education of various kinds. Like men, they were entitled to
Upanayana or initiation and Brahmacharya or Vedic studentship is proved by the right
they enjoyed to take part in various Vedic rites and utter the holy Vedic Mantras.
Ascetic women engaged in the study, teaching and preaching of the highest Truth for
example, Shramani Shabari, the disciple of Matanga. With her hermitage on Lake
Pampa, is described as wearing barks and matted locks having reached the highest
point of ascetic perfection, and being honoured by great ascetics.
The social position of women was high. The wife was regarded as the very prop
of family life and the mother an object of supreme honour. In the Ayodhya-Kanda, the
mother is enjoyed to be honoured as much as the father. In the political sphere also,
women were granted equal rights. For instance, when Sita desired to accompany Rama
to the forest, the great sage Vasishtha, the spiritual preceptor of the royal family, tried
his best to dissuade her with the proposal that she should reign over the kingdom during
the absence of her husband. This instance shows the political recognition of women’s
equal rights with men. The above is sufficient to show that during the age of the
Ramayana, too, the women of India kept their colours flying in all spheres of learning
and progress, and achieved notable success in them all.16
Mahabharata, the great epic depicts the social life of India. The eminent
Professor Macdonell calls the Mahabharata “a moral encyclopaedia in Indian
Literature”. In this heroic age, the poets of Mahabharata portray, on the whole,
womanhood which was noble, intelligent and active. In this document, we see women
in the home, at court, on the battlefield, and in intellectual and spiritual capacities.
Although in some of the earlier Hindu documents, women are sometimes pictured as
helpless females. In the Mahabharata, we find many accomplished women, they are not
only beautiful in appearance, but they possess real tact and graciousness of character. 17
In the age of the Mahabharata also, women’s full rights to Naishthika Brahmacharya or
a life of celibate asceticism is recognized. The most celebrated of these is perhaps
Sulabha, who’s not finding a suitable husband, embraced a life of celibate studentship
and roamed about alone from place to place in search of the highest truth. Until, she
16
Roma Choudhuri, op.cit., 1953, pp.102-104.
17
Preeti Misra, op.cit., 2007, p. 24.
147
reached the court of king Janaka in Mithila, a great scholar versed in the highest lore
leading to salvation. Even such a celebrated scholar was compelled to recognize
Sulabha’s deep learning after a thorough examination, and was taught by her.
Shiva was another women ascetic, who studied all the Vedas and attained
spiritual perfection. The daughter of Shandilya also embraced a life of celibate
studentship and achieved the maximum perfection in asceticism. Not only the ascetic’s
women, but those women who entered the family life also versed in philosophical
knowledge. 18 In the Mahabharata period, women were versed not only in the highest
philosophy but also in other branches of knowledge. But many women of the royal
family were well grounded in politics. Gandhari, wife of the blind King Dhritarashtra
engaged in a learned political discussion with her son in the open court. Other royal
ladies, like Kunti and Draupadi are also the example of versatility and scholarship of
women of Mahabharata period. From the above brief account, it is clear that in the age
of the Mahabharata, women enjoyed equal rights with men.19
Thus, in Mahabharata, there is the highest praise for women and at the same
time the bitterest denunciation. Despite of prohibitions, the priest attempted to enforce
upon the women of the epic, on the whole, these women stand out significantly. They
are resolute and spiritual. They are not isolated but are in close contact with events of
their time. They are capable and serviceable members of society. As a matter of fact,
the epic seems to have produced outstanding portraits of women, which have helped to
stir Hindu women with hope and faith.20
Buddhism rose as a protest against the rigid rules of Brahmanism. In the Post-
Vedic period, the dominance of rituals increasingly grew, which gave indomitable
power to the Brahmanism. Buddhism opened the doors of religion to all human beings
without any distinction. Buddhism is in its essence, a religion of self-culture and self
restraint. If a woman could achieve these two qualities, she was entitled to achieve
Nirvana like men.21 The status of women in Buddhism and Jainism was assigned. Both
these were ascetic re-religions, and they have not devoted much attention to the duties
18
Roma Choudhuri, op.cit, 1953, pp. 104-105.
19
Ibid.,
20
Preeti Misra, op.cit., 2007, p. 28.
21
Ibid., p.30.
148
and ideals of lay women. The Buddha was reluctant to admit women to his Church, and
the Digambara Jains hold that women can never get salvation except by first being
reborn as men. Both Budhism and Jainism placed nuns under a more rigorous discipline
than monks. They should not stay alone without the protection of monks. They should
avoid the company of men of doubtful character; that only monks of unquestioned
purity and integrity should be allowed to preach before nuns; that they should always
live together in groups of two and three etc. Some other rules, however, betray a lack of
confidence in the character and judgement of women. Thus the admission of a new nun
was to be sanctioned by a joint meeting of the monks and nuns; new monks, however,
could be admitted without consulting the nuns at all. A nun could never preach before a
congregation of monks. The permission that was given to women to join the church by
Jainism and Buddhism raised a new and respectable career before them. 22
In Brahmanical religion, there were also some nuns like Sulabha and Gargi
Vachaknavi; their number, however, seems to have been much larger in Buddhist and
Jain circles. Buddhism declared that womanhood was no bar to salvation, and
Svetambara Jains concurred with the view. Marriage was not necessary for women;
nay, it was a fetter which women were advised to avoid. Therefore it was urged to
become nuns without entering into matrimony. Among the nuns of the Therigatha the
majority consists of women, who had renounced the world during their maidenhood.
The career of preaching was opened before women by Jainism and Buddism attracted a
large number of talented ladies, and they distinguished themselves as teachers and
preachers. Sanghamitra, the daughter of Ashoka, went to far off Ceylon to spread the
gospel of the Buddha. 23
When discipline became slack and unworthy persons began to be admitted into
monasteries and nunneries, the tone of moral life deteriorated. It hastened the process
of the downfall of Buddhism. Later, Hinduism took a lesson from it and declared
women to be ineligible for renunciation. But women have realised that improvement in
this direction in modern days depends mainly upon the spread of education and the
acquisition of economic rights and independence. They therefore naturally feel no
inclination for initiating an agitation for the restoration of their old religious rights and
22
A.S. Altekar, The Position of Women in Hindu Civilization, Delhi: Motilal Banarsidass, 1959, pp.
207-209.
23
Ibid., pp. 207-217.
149
privileges.24 Thus, the position of women in the Buddhist period could not have
changed very much from that of the earlier days. However, there was some
improvement in their condition, due to the basic principles, which Buddha laid down in
his teachings. Buddha made no distinction between a man and a woman regarding the
attainment of spiritual ends. Buddha discarded the Brahmanic rituals, in which the wife
played a secondary part and a barren women or a widow had no place. The education
given to female novices and nuns was not different from that imparted to their male
counterparts. The status of women was raised in the Buddhist period, it cannot but be
admitted that in the monastic order, the place accorded to the nuns was lower than that
of the monks.25
Medieval Period
The Indian women’s position in the society deteriorated during medieval period.
In this period the women were deprived of different social and economic rights and
26
were brought out under the overall control of their male family members. Life
became insecure. Restrictions on her rights and freedom and her resultant hardships
were aggravated. Women were forcible taken away to be slaves or to marry into
Muslim homes. The consequent insecurity and instability further narrowed down
woman’s social liberties. On the one hand, the foreign Muslim conquerors attempted to
impose their coercive norms on the conquered Hindu population. On the other hand, the
Hindu society itself became more and more rigid curtailing thereby, the rights and
freedom of the lower castes and women. Due to this two-fold reason, the post-puranic
period is one of the darkest periods for women in Indian history. The steady
deterioration of her status continued till the 19th century. Polygamy and the Purdah
were two of the most important social institutions of the Muslim conquerors of India.
Under the Purdha system, not only were women required to live in a secluded
apartment in the house, but also they had to dress in apparel which completely covered
their body excepting the eye.27
24
Ibid., pp. 207-217.
25
Nalinaksha Dutt, “Great Women in Buddhism”, in Swami Madhavananda and Ramesh Chandra
Majumdar (eds.), Great Women of India, Almora: Advaita Ashrama, 1953, pp.253-255.
26
G.S. Mehta, Participation of Women in the Panchayati Raj System, New Delhi: Kanishka Publishers,
2008, p.4.
27
Neera Desai, Women in Modern India, Bombay: Vora Publishers, 1957, p. 23.
150
Before the Muslim conquest, the Buddhism had not followed the custom of
Sati. Social sanction for the self-immolation of widows came in with Muslim invasion.
Before Muslim rule, the practice of Sati did occur off and on, but not as a regular
feature. As a result of repressive social and religious custom, a woman sometimes even
preferred Sati to widowhood.28 Instance of Brahmin women who practiced Sati are also
recorded in the 15th century and after the foreign chroniclers record, the Hindu widows
who did not observe Sati were held in great dishonor. The practice of Sati was also
extended to the southern parts of India. The widow in the case was persuaded to believe
that her act of self-immolation was even more auspicious than the nuptial ceremony,
since it guaranteed the continual association with her husband in life after death.29 Due
to lustful proposal of Alauddin Khilji, Rani Padmavati with about 700 Rajput
committed themselves to flames, which came to be known as “Jauhar Vrata”.
Gradually child marriages were preferred in the society and the death of a widow was
welcome news as she would not fall into evil hands. A woman in Hindu society has
always been considered an appendage to her husband. She has no life apart from him.
Consequently, on her husband’s death, there was no reason for her to live on. Also the
husband was her sole protector. During foreign invasions by the Turkas, Muslims and
others, when their men folk were killed, the widows were very naturally expected to
commit Sati. Hence, immolation of widows and killing of girl child infanticide started
in a large number. Even the Muslims were not spared of this fate, when they became
subjugated by the white rulers of England. They developed Purdh, illiteracy, disease,
legal discrimination and handicaps but the worst part of their fate is the male
dominance in their society.30
The Muslim conquest in the Indian subcontinent brought the Purdhah practice
in the Indian society.31 As a strict security measure, the prohibition of free movement
of woman was advocated and the Purdhah with its elaborate from was also installed.
Women participating in public discussions on vital social and philosophical problems
or in popular festivals became only a memory of the past. Along with child marriage,
marital infidelity on the part of males became more common. Polygamy was a practice
adopted frequently among upper classes and restriction on or conditions laid down as
28
Preeti Misra, op.cit., 2007, p.35.
29
Neera Desai, op.cit., 1957, p. 24.
30
Niroj Sinha, Women and Violence, New Delhi: Vikas Publishing House, 1989, pp.47-48.
31
A. Prema, “Women Status in India”, Indian Streams Research Journal, Vol. 2, No.1, February 2012,
p. 2.
151
necessary for the second marriage were also dropped. Even during this darkest period,
when the black cloud of social reaction completely submerged the freedom of woman,
a silver lining was visible. Some of the Mughal emperors through social reforms tried
to relieve the hardships of women. As regards Sati, Akbar did not permit it in cases,
where there was the slightest disinclination on the part of the widow or when a young
widow’s marriage was not consummated. During this period, two schools of law
emerged viz. Mitakshara and Dayabhaga, the exponents of these schools being
Vijnaneshwara and Jimutavahana respectively. These commentators attempted to
improve the position of women. They give a definite share of property to women.
However, in the total setting of complete subordination, these meagre rights hardly
brought any benefits to women.32 The Hindu did not assimilate the customs like
divorce, widow remarriage and a large share of property for women, which governed
the Muslim society. The Hindu society had come so static and rigidified that their
contact with the Muslims, whose social relations were relatively democratic, did not
prompt them to adopt the democratic elements of the Muslim society. 33
British Period
32
Preeti Misra, op.cit., 2007, p. 36.
33
Ibid., pp. 36-37.
34
Lalit Upadhayay, Women in Indian Politics, Panchkula: Better Books, 2007, p. 17.
35
Achla Sharma, “Status of Women: A Socio-Historical Analysis in Different Ages of Indian Society”,
Research Journal of Language, Literature and Humanities, Vol. 1 No. 1, January 2014, pp.12-13.
152
pertaining to the spirit and the practice of religion, Christianity accepts equality
between men and women. Everybody is baptised in the name of Christ. The Bible lays
great emphasis on the image of women as a strong and steady influence for the good.
Christianity also forbids polygamy and it lays emphasis on the establishment of a
mutual relationship between husband and wife and on their duty towards each other.36
The impact of British rule, English education and Christianity propagated by
missionaries resulted in a number of movements for social change and religious reform
in the nineteenth century. The first impact of western teaching on those who received, it
was to include them strongly in favour of the western way of looking at things and
under this influence they bent their energies. In the first instance, to the re-examination
of the whole of their ancient civilisation or social usages and institutions, religious
beliefs, literature, science and their art in fact their conception and realisation of life.37
There have been three distinct phases in the modern struggle for a better status, life and
opportunity for women in India. The first was in the 19th century by male reformers
aided by religious groups both Hindu and Christian. The second was participation in
the freedom movement which culminated in Independence in 1947 and the third, the
post-Independence period up to women’s International year, 1975.38
During the 19th and early 20th centuries, a number of movements (both religious
and social) were launched to reform the Indian society in general and to improve the
status of women in particular. These movements had a great impact on women’s
identity and women’s life in India. The most well-remembered social reformer of the
19th century was Raja Ram Mohan Roy, who established Brahmo Samaj in 1828 at
Calcutta, (Brahmo literally means the Supreme; Samaj means Society) which worked
for the welfare of women. Freedom and equality of women and widow remarriage were
the focus of the Samaj the cruel system of sati (sati means ‘a virtuous woman). The act
of widow immolating herself on the funeral pyre of her husband) was abolished by the
efforts of Roy. The spiritual succession of Roy was Keshav Chandra Sen, who
popularised Brahmo Samaj and fought for women’s education and established a school
for girls. Due to the struggle of Keshav Chandra Sen, Civil Marriage Act III of 1872
was brought, which included abolition of child marriage (minimum age of marriage
36
C.K. Jain, Women Parliamentarians in India, New Delhi: Surjeet Publications, 1993, p. 10.
37
Government of India, Towards Equality: Report of the Committee on the Status of Women in India,
New Delhi: Ministry of Education and Social Welfare Department of Social Welfare, 1974, p. 50.
38
Tara Ali Baig, Indian’s Woman Power, New Delhi: S. Chand and Company, 1976, pp. 24-25.
153
was fixed at 14), permission for widow remarriage and inter-caste marriage. A religious
reform movement in the form of Prarthana Samaj (worship) was started by Justice
Mahadeo Govind Ranade in Poona. Swami Dayanand Saraswati founded the Arya
Samaj, (revered) whose main objective was to give equal opportunities to all person
men and women (to acquire knowledge and to qualify themselves for whatever position
in life they would like to fill) without any discrimination.
39
K.C. Vidya, op.cit., 2007, pp.1-10.
40
Shantha Mohan, “Facilitating the fulfilment of State Obligations towards Women’s Equality”,
Baseline Report, Women and Political Participation in India, pp. 4-6.
154
was in the 1917 the women’s Indian Association was founded in Madras by Annie
Besant.41
Mahatma Gandhi’s called to women to join the freedom struggle that a new era
has dawned. He recognized the importance of women’s participation in the freedom
struggle. Gandhi appraised the women’s potential for Satyagraha and for the social
reconstruction as higher than that of men.43 Most strikingly, mass population of women
was recognized during the Civil Disobedience movement in 1930.44 In 1931, at the
Karachi session of the Indian National Congress, Nehru piloted the ‘Fundamental
Rights Resolution’, which accepted the principle of complete equality of men and
women in political life. 45 The Government of India Act 1935 invariably provided equal
right to vote to both men and women without gender bias. Consequently, in the election
of 1937, eight women were elected from general constituencies and forty-two from the
reserves constituencies. Six women were appointed as ministers.46
41
M.P. Dube and Munni, Padalia (eds.), Democratic Decentralization and Panchayati Raj in
India, New Delhi: Anamika Publishers, 2002, pp. 174-175.
42
A. Thanikodi and M. Sugirtha, “Status of Women in Politics”, The Indian Journal of Political
Science, Vol. 68, No.3, July-September 2007, p. 600.
43
Bhawana Jharta, Women and Politics in India: Impact of Family and Education on Women Political
Activists, New Delhi: Deep and Deep Publications, 1998, p. 58.
44
Rameshwari Pandya (ed.), Women Welfare and Empowerment in India, New Delhi: New Century
Publications, 2008, p. 564.
45
Bhawana Jharta, op.cit., 1998, pp. 4-5.
46
A.K. Shukla, Women Chief Ministers in Contemporary India, New Delhi: APH Publishing
Corporation, 2007, p. 58.
155
In the 1942 Quit India Movement; when all the top leaders were arrested and
the movement became practically leaderless, women joined hands with others and
carried it on by taking out processions, holding meetings, demonstrations and
organizing strikes. Aruna Asaf Ali, Kalpana Joshi, Preeti Waddadar, Kanaklata Barua,
Roopvati Jain, Durga Bai, Sushila Devi and Usha Mehta were the famous figures of
this movement. Kasturba Gandhi died in jail during the Quit India campaign. In July
1943, in response to the clarion call of Subhash Chandra Bose, a women’s regiment
named ‘The Rani of Jhansi Regiment’ was formed in Singapore with Laxmi Sehgal as
its Captain.
The Constituent Assembly was set up in October 1946, a body elected by the
existing legislatures, had among its members Sarojini Naidu, Durgabai, Renuka Roy
and Hansa Mehta, among others to frame the Constitution for India on Independence.47
In the Constituent Assembly which met in December 1946, there were 14 women
members. But there were no proportionate increase in women as representatives or in
power positions.
It has been noted that women who were active in politics or politically
successful belonged to wealthy and progressive families. They were supported by
husbands or family members who were active in congress. This is being followed even
after independence. But, there were large number of unknown women who participated
in the freedom struggle. It provided an opportunity for large number of women to enter
into active politics, which was not seen earlier. They were willing to join processions,
and to go to prisons. Women joined revolutionary groups, helped in distributing
newspapers and helped in the manufacturing bombs. Innumerable number of women
provided support to freedom fighters by looking after their families.48
During Post-Independence
47
Tara Ali Baig, op.cit., 1976, p. 218.
48
Vina Mazumdar, “Women in the Political Process”, in Maithreyi Krishnaraj (ed.), Women Studies in
India: Some Perspectives, New Delhi: Popular Prakashan, 1986, p. 97.
49
G .S. Mehta, op.cit., 2008, p.7.
156
India resolves to secure to all its citizens: Justice, social, economic and political;
Liberty of thought, expression, belief, faith and worship; Equality of status and
opportunity; and to promote among them all; Fraternity assuring the dignity of the
individual and the unity and integrity of the nation. To attain these national objectives,
the constitution guarantees certain Fundamental Rights to all the citizens. Again the
Directive Principles of State Policy enunciated in the constitution embody the major
policy goals of a welfare state. 50
The Constitution of India has granted women equal rights of participation in the
political process of the country along with equal opportunity and rights in education
and employment. The Indian Constitution guarantees political equality through the
institution adult franchise. Article 15 prohibits any kind of discrimination against any
citizen on grounds only of religion, race, caste, sex, place of birth, or any of them.
However, Article 15(3) which empower the state to make any “special provisions for
women and children” even in violation of the fundamental obligation of non-
discrimination among citizens, on the basis of sex. This provision has enabled the state
to make special provisions for women, particularly in the field of labour legislation like
the Factories Act, the Mines Act, etc. Reservation of seats for women in local or
educational institutions has been held to be valued in view of the provisions of Article
15 (3). Article 16 (1) guarantees that, “There shall be equality of opportunity for all
citizens in matters relating to employment or appointment to any office under the
state”. Again Article 16 (2) forbids discrimination in respect of any employment in
office under the state on grounds of “religion, race, caste, sex, descent, and place of
birth, residence or any one of them”. All these have assured normatively a significant
position and status to Indian women.
50
C.K. Jain, op.cit., 1993, pp.11-12.
51
K.C. Vidya, op.cit., 2007, p. 9.
157
enter occupations unsuited for their age or strength. Article 39 (d) which directs the
state to ensure that there is equal pay for equal work for both men and women. Again
Article 39 (e) which directs the state to ensure that the health and strength of workers,
men and women, and the tender age of children are not abused and that citizens are not
forced by economic necessity to enter avocations unsuited to their age or strength; and
Articles 42 which directs the state to make provision for ensuring must and humane
condition of work and maternity relief.52 However, Article 42 guarantees, just and
humane condition of work and maternity relief. This is in accordance with Article 23
and 25 of Universal Declaration of Human Rights. Article 51 (a) clause (e) says that it
shall be the duty of every citizen of India-to promote harmony and spirit of common
brotherhood amongst all the people of India, transcending religious or sectional
diversities, to renounces practice derogatory to the dignity of women.
The committee on the status of women was appointed as early as 1976. The
draft national policy on empowerment of women was envisaged equal flow of benefits
in physical and financial terms to women. A National Commission for Women was
appointed. The constitution of India guarantees certain rights and privileges to women
as fundamental rights and directive principles. It confers on man and women equal
rights and opportunities in political, economic and social spheres.
52
C.K. Jain, op.cit., 1993, p. 13.
53
Saroj Choudhary, “Political Participation and Representation of Women in Indian Politics”, International
Journal of Behavioural Social and Movement Sciences, Vol. 1, No. 4, October 2012, p. 203.
158
Acts of 1951; the Special Marriage Act of 1954 (Amended 1984). The Hindu
Succession Act of 1956 (later Amended 1976 and 1986), the Dowry Prohibition Act of
1961; the Maternity Benefit Act of 1966 (Amended 1976); Medical Termination of
Pregnancy Act of 1971; the Equal Remuneration of Act of 1976 (amended 1984); the
Indian Evidence Act, 1983; Family Court Act, 1984; Indecent Representation of
Women Prohibition Act 1987; Indian Marriage Act, 1995 (amended 1996); the New
Bill 2001 for Protecting Women against Violence, etc. were passed;54 The Protection
of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 defines the expression “domestic
violence to include actual abuse or threat of abuse-physical, sexual, verbal, emotional
or economic violence etc.55
Panchayati Raj Institutions in India have their roots since time immemorial. The
system has evolved through the ages, acquiring a definite programme or action.
Rajasthan was the first state in the country to adopt Panchayati Raj. Rajasthan
government passed the Rajasthan Panchayati and was formally inaugurated by the
Pandit Nehru at Nagour on 2nd October 1959. In this Act, three tier systems of
Panchayati Raj Institutions were created. Zila Parishad at district level, Panchayat
Samiti at block level and Gram Panchayts at village level were constituted under this
Act. Women who constitute almost half of India’s total population, have been given an
opportunity for participation in local affairs as not less than third of the posts of
Chairpersons have been reserved in their favour. This provision would bring in
qualitative change in the composition of local bodies and make women and weaker
sections equal partners in the nation’s progress and development.56 The committee on
status of woman in India (1974) not only recommended representation of women in
PRIs but also established of statutory women Panchayats at village level as a
transitional measure for managing the programmes for women and children.57
54
Nagaraju Battu, Empowerment of Women in India: New Strategies, New Delhi: Regal Publications
2014, p. 49.
55
Shashi Goel, Domestic Violence Against Women, Jaipur: Literary Circle, 2013, p. 26.
56
J.L. Singh, Women and Panchayati Raj, New Delhi: Sunrise Publications, 2007, pp. 284-285.
57
Ibid.,
159
the total number of seats to be filled by direct election in every Panchayats and urban
local body, as also designated offices in the local self-government institutions, both in
rural and urban areas. The opportunity of sharing of power on equal terms with men
and exercising an effective role in decision-making process would lead to vast
improvements in the status of women.58
The Constitution’s 110th Amendment Bill 2009, provides reservation for women
from 33 per cent to 50 per cent in PRIs. The Bill seeks to amend the Article 243D to
enhance the quantum of reservation for women from one-third to one-half of the total
seats in the Panchayats. Similar reservation shall be provided among the total number
of offices of chairpersons.59 However, Articles 325 and 326 of the Constitution of India
guarantee political equality-equal right to participation in political activities and right to
vote respectively. While the latter has been accessed, exercised and enjoyed by a large
number of women, the former i.e., right to equal political participation is still a distant
dream. Lack of space for participation in political bodies has not only resulted in their
presence in meagre numbers in these decision making bodies but also in the neglect of
their issues and experiences in policy making.60
By 1970 the political atmosphere began to change and many leading political
parties realized the importance of women. Thus the efforts of the early leaders like
Jotibha Phule, B.R.Ambedkar, E.V. Ramaswami and the leaders of the later period like
Sharat Patil, Sharat Joshi and Vandana Shiva not only fuelled the women’s movement
but also intensely motivated the Indian women by touching their inner core of
consciousness. No doubt, women of India are highly active today in this area. Sarojini
Naidu, Vijay Lakshami Pandit, Sucheta Kriplani were the torch bearer for the women
of India. Mrs. Vijay Lakshmi Pandit was the first Indian Women to hold position in the
cabinet and paved the way for other women. The most important name in the category
of women politicians is Mrs. Indira Gandhi. She was the first women Prime Minister of
independent India. Today her daughter-in-law Ms. Sonia Gandhi is following her
footsteps and leading the Indian National Congress. Other women who have played a
pivotal role in politics of India are Sheila Dixit, Uma Bharti, Jayalalitha, Vasundhra
Raje, Mamata Banerjee and Mayawati,61 Anandiben Patel, Mehbooba Mufti and
Nirmala Sitaraman.
58
V. Mohini Giri, “Women and Politics” in Yashoda Bhat and C. N. Mangala (eds.), Beyond the
Threshold: Indian Women on the Move, Delhi: B.R. Publishing Corporation, 1995, p. 24.
59
Kuldeep Fadia, “Women’s Empowerment in India”, Indian Journal of Public Administration,
Vol. 60, No. 3, July-September 2014, p. 543.
60
Baseline Report on Women and Political Participation in India Prepared by NIAS et al. and
Coordinated by IWRAW Asia Pacific Advanced Unedited Version, p.1.
61
Subrat Biswal, “Women and Political Participation”, Third Concept, Vol. 28, No. 328, June 2014, p. 12.
160
Thus, women have served in the both houses of parliament and in the state
legislatures and many women have become heads of different department in the
government. Women have also been appointed as India’s diplomats and envoys in
different countries. 62
Table 3.1
1901 972
1911 964
1921 955
1931 950
1941 945
1951 946
1961 941
1971 930
1981 934
1991 927
2001 933
2011 943
62
Bhawana Jharta, op.cit.,2016, pp. 82-83.
161
980
972
Female per 1000 Males
970
964
960
955
950
946
950
943
941
940
934
945
933
930
927
930
920
910
900
1901 1911 1921 1931 1941 1951 1961 1971 1981 1991 2001 2011
Years
Fig. 3.1: Decennial Sex Ratio in India (Females per 1000 Males)
If you educate a man you educate an individual, however, if you educate a woman you
educate a whole family. Women empowered means mother India empowered”.
Education means an all round drawing out of the best in child and man-body,
mind and spirit. Education plays a vital role in playing human beings proper equipment
to lead a gracious and harmonious life. Education is a fundamental means to bring any
desired change in society, which is an accepted fact through the world. This can be
attained only if schools become real centres of learning. Education not only helps in the
development of personality of the child but also determines his future. Education gives
solutions for any type of problems. Through education we promote values and good
habits and awareness towards corruption, terrorism and disease. Education strength to
the persons, they get knowledge and distinguish between right and wrong with the help
of education.63
Women constitute almost half of the population in the world. But the
hegemonic masculine ideology made them suffer a lot, as they were denied equal
opportunities in different parts of world. The rise of feminist idea has, however, led to
tremendous improvement of women condition throughout the world in recent times.
63
Jitendra Kumar and Sangeeta, “Status of Women Education in India”, Educationia Confab, Vol. 2,
No. 4, April 2013, p. 163.
162
Access of education has been one of the most pressing demands of these women’s
rights movements. Women education in India has also been a major preoccupation of
both the government and civil society as educated women can play a very important
role in the development of the country. India is poised to emerge as one of the most
developed nation by 2020, more literate knowledgeable and economically at the
forefront. No doubt, women will play a vital role in any country. In India, this is yet to
meet the requirements despite reforms. Little has been achieved in the area of women
empowerment but for this to happen, this sector must experience a chain of reforms.64
64
Ibid.,
65
Nagaraju Battu, op.cit., 2014, pp. 228-230.
66
Chandni Sinha, “Education and Empowerment of Women”, Third Concept, Vol. 21, No. 243,
May 2007, pp. 49-50.
67
Jitendra Kumar and Sangeeta, op.cit., 2013, pp. 172-173.
163
Table 3.2
Literacy Rate in India
80
74.04
Literacy Rate
70
65.38
60
52.1
50
40
36.2
30
29.5
16.1
24
20
7.2
5.3
16.7
5.9
10
9.5
0
1901 1911 1921 1931 1941 1951 1961 1971 1981 1991 2001 2011
164
The Table 3.2 reveals that in pre-independence period literacy rate for women
had a very poor spurt in comparison to literacy rate of man. This is witnessed from the
fact that literacy rate of women has risen from 0.7 per cent to 7.3 per cent where as the
literacy rate of men has risen from 9.8 per cent to 24.9 per cent in the first four decades.
During the post-independence period literacy rates have shown a substantial increase in
general. However the literacy rate of male has almost tripled over the period, i.e. 24.9
per cent in 1951 and 76 per cent in 2001. Surprisingly, the female literacy rate has
increased at a faster pace than the male literacy during the decade 1981-2001.
In the year 2011 the difference between the two was, the female literacy
(65.46%) and male literacy (82.14%), this rate is very small as compared to the year
1901 (0.7%) to 2011 (65.46%). From this analysis one can infer that still the female
literacy rate (only half of the female population are literates) is lacking behind male
literacy (three-fourth of the male population are literates). The higher rate of illiteracy
subordinate role. The lack of education is the root cause for women’s exploitation and
negligence. Only literacy can help women to understand the Indian’s constitutional and
empowering them to accomplish their goals at par with men in different spheres of life.
After the independence period the female literacy rate was increased. Education is a
basic requirement and fundamental right for the citizens of a free nation. It also brings a
reduction in inequalities and functions as a means of improving their status with the
family.
Education Equality
result of adult literacy programmes is the area of enrolment of boys and girls in
schools.
165
Table 3.3
State Wise Percentage of Female Literacy in India
Percentage of Female Percentage of Male
Sr.No. Name of the State
Literacy Literacy
1 Andhra Pradesh 59.74 75.56
2 Arunachal Pradesh 59.57 73.69
3 Assam 67.27 78.81
4 Bihar 53.33 73.39
5 Chattisgarh 60.59 81.45
6 Goa 81.84 92.81
7 Gujarat 70.73 87.23
8 Haryana 66.77 85.38
9 Himachal Pradesh 76.60 90.83
10 Jammu and Kashmir 58.01 78.26
11 Jharkhand 56.21 78.45
12 Karnataka 68.13 82.85
13 Kerala 91.98 96.02
14 Madhya Pradesh 60.02 80.53
15 Maharashtra 75.48 89.82
16 Manipur 73.17 86.49
17 Meghalaya 73.78 77.17
18 Mizoram 89.40 93.72
19 Nagaland 76.69 83.29
20 Orissa 64.36 82.40
21 Punjab 71.34 81.48
22 Rajasthan 52.66 80.51
23 Sikkim 76.43 87.29
24 Tamil Nadu 73.86 86.81
25 Tripura 83.15 92.18
26 Uttar Pradesh 59.26 79.24
27 Uttarakhand 70.70 88.33
28 West Bengal 71.16 82.67
29 Delhi 80.93 91.03
Union Territories
1 Andaman Nicobar Islands 81.84 90.11
2 Chandigarh 81.38 90.54
3 Dadra & Nagar Haveli 65.93 86.46
4 Daman & Diu 79.59 91.48
5 Lakshadweep 88.25 96.11
6 Pondicherry 81.22 92.12
All India 65.46 82.14
Source: Census of India, 2011.
166
The Table 3.3 depicts that the state wise female literacy rate had an average of
65.46 per cent in all India basis in 2011 census, the high literacy rate is 92.0 per cent in
Kerala and least literacy rate is 52.7 per cent in Rajasthan in 2011 census, while
comparing literacy rate of female in 2011 census, there is increase of 11 per cent from
54.16 per cent to 65.46 per cent. Women’s are growing well in the last 10 years.
Government of India has been taken various steps and plans especially for women in
every moment. The table shows that Kerala and the Mizoram shows the smallest
difference in terms of female literacy with their male counterpart. In Kerala female
literacy is (91.98%) with a difference of 4.22 per cent from the male literacy (i.e.
96.02%). Similarly, in Mizoram female literacy is (89.40%) with a difference of 4.32
per cent from the male literacy (i.e.93.72%). Thus, Kerala is having the highest female
literacy in India. Tamil Nadu state female literacy is (73.86%) with difference (12.95%)
from the male literacy (i.e. 86.81%) in India. Rajasthan (52.66 %) is having the
minimum of female literacy in India. As a result, data shows that even after seventy
years of independence, women occupy a secondary position in our social hierarchy.
Inspire of being aware of her position, women can’t transform the situation due to lack
of education. Therefore, women’s empowerment can’t be effected unless we persuade
the importance of women’s education.
167
numbers of men and women have gone to the polling booths to vote.68 The number of
women filing their nomination papers in any election, national or state is only a fraction
of the corresponding number of men. Some withdraw at the last moment and the
contesting candidates become fewer in number. Ultimately, the number of women
winning elections will be so small that their percentage in the legislative body will be
nominal.69 Women participation and representation in Lok Sabha is given below.
Table 3.4
Women Representation in Lok Sabha (1952-2014)
68
Usha Kiran, Participation of Women in Indian Politics: Gender Justice and Political Challenge,
Delhi: Globus Press, 2016, p.134.
69
Ibid.,
168
12
11.23
%age of Women
9.02
8.9
10.86
10
7.92
7.2
8
6.76
8.28
5.93
5.4
7.18
6
5.15
5.22
4
4.41
4.22
3.29
2
0
1952 1957 1962 1967 1971 1977 1980 1984 1989 1991 1996 1998 1999 2004 2009 2014
The Table 3.4 shows that the first Lok Sabha was held in 1952 where only 22
women members were elected out of total 499 members, which was just 4.4 per cent.
Though, the number of women representation were increased in second and third
election of Lok Sabha from 27 to 34 respectively, but starts declining from the fourth
election held in 1967. The number was increased only in the year 1996 (i.e. in the
eleventh election of Lok Sabha), where 39 women candidates were elected. In 1999
polls, 284 women had contested the election and 49 were elected and in 2004 election,
355 women contested the election of whom, 45 won. A record of 61 women candidates
have been elected in the sixteenth Lok Sabha election (2014), which account to 11.23
per cent of total, the highest ever since independence. Women representation in the
present 16th Lok Sabha has gone up to 61, which are the highest ever.
However as India has over half of the population of women, this number is still
too small. No doubt, the parliament had the privilege of having many prominent
women as its members, over the years who have championed the cause of women in
the house but parliament still needs more women MPs for safeguarding the women’s
rights and interests. It may be mentioned here that the women in two houses of
parliament largely belong to the privileged middle class and are educated. Many of
them are wives daughter, sister, daughter-in-law and relatives of prominent politicians.
169
The right to vote can be said to be the starting point in the struggle of women for their
political equality and participation. Therefore, the political participation of women by
way of voting has been growing but with variations. The following table reveals the
percentage of female voting in Lok Sabha election in 1952-2014.
Table 3.5
Voting Turnout Lok Sabha
Table 3.5 presents the percentage of female voting in different lok sabha
elections. In 1952 general elections, women’s voting was 37.10 per cent as compared to
170
56 per cent of men. The difference in the turnout was 15.9 per cent. Only in half
dozen out of fourteen general elections, women’s voting percentage has crossed 55 per
cent, which highlights their potential participation in the voting level. In 1967, 1977,
1989, 1998, 1999 and 2014 elections women witnessed an increase in the voting
percentage. In the table 3.5 reveals that 2014 elections have witnessed the record
increase in the voting percentage of women compared to men. According to the
Election Commission data (Statistical Report, 1952-2009), women’s voting percentage
has increased from 55.8 to 65.7 per cent in the last election. There is an increase of
nearly 10 per cent. During the same period, the voting percentages of men have also
increased but percentage of increase is lower compared to women. Therefore, there is a
common assumption that increase in men’s voting percentage, also leads to the rise in
the women’s voting percentage. However, the data clearly refutes this assumption.
Despite of decrease in the voting percentage of men, in 1999, 2004 and 2009 election,
there was an increase in women’s voting percentage.
Women as Contestants: the table depicts the total percentage of women who have
contested the Lok Sabha elections since 1952 till 2014.
171
Table 3.6
The Table 3.6 depicts that the number of women contesting election has always
been low. The highest number of women contestants has been merely 636 in 2014,
while the number of male contestants has always been in thousand, the highest being
13,353 in 1996. Yet, it is encouraging to note that the percentage of winners among
women has consistently been more than that of the men, although the fact that more
often than not, the losing seats are offered to women candidates by the respective
political parties, for instance, in 1996, only 3.8 per cent of male candidates won in
172
comparison to 6.7 per cent of female candidates. Likewise, the percentage of winners
was 11.2 per cent for men and 15.7 per cent for women in 1998, 12.3 per cent and 17.3
per cent in 1999, 6.44 per cent and 10.61 per cent in 2009 and 6.39 per cent and 9.74
per cent, respectively in 2014 (16th Lok Sabha).
Political parties during the election campaign propagate 33 per cent reservation
for the women in the national and state legislatures. But the numerical strength of
women parliamentarians indicates the difference between the perception and practices
of the political leaders. Half of the women population is represented by only 11 per
cent in the Parliament. Under representation of the women also reflects that women
issues are represented by their counterparts. Sometime they are not able to understand
these issues. Although the number of women contestants is very less in comparison to
men but their percentage of winnability is higher than to men. Thus, the winnability of
women remained higher in every Lok Sabha election than that of men.
National Parties
70
R. Yadagiri, “Growth of Regional Political Parties in India: Influence and Impact on Federal
System”, in D. Sunder Ram (ed.), Federal System and Coalition Government in India-Conflict and
Consensus in Centre-State Relations, New Delhi: Kanishka Publishers, 2007, pp. 142-143.
173
role of political parties in elections in mobilizing people opinion and also in governance
process cannot be over emphasized.71 Therefore, the backing of a political party for the
success of a candidate in election is also imperative. The following table shows the
seats allocated to women contestants in general election by the national political
parties.
Table 3.7
Seats Allotted to Women Contestants in General Elections by National Parties
Congress 45 12 43 23 57 4
BJP 30 10 44 13 37 28
Table 3.7 reveals that the number of women candidates who contested the
elections has increased and almost doubled from 355 in general elections held in 2004
to 668 in general elections of 2014. But the number of women candidates fielded by
national parties, except for the Bharatiya Janta Party, has remained almost the same
during this intervening period. Thus national parties have followed a discriminatory
and gender exclusionist policy in allotment of seats to women in elections for Lok
Sabha over the years and discouraged active participation in formal politics. The policy
of exclusion of women in granting seats at the national and state level is not only being
followed by national parties, but also by regional political parties that are in completion
in various states of the country. The political decision to not allot seats to women by
political parties at the national and state level electoral has been attributed to lack of
“winnability” of women. However, an analysis of the success rates of women
candidates in Indian general elections as compared to men reveals that it has been
higher in the last three general elections.
71
Government of India, Women Members of Rajya Sabha, New Delhi: Rajya Sabha Secretariat, 2009,
p. 9.
174
Rajya Sabha
18
%age of Women
15.5
16
14
11.83
12
11.4
10.2
11.1
10
8.3
7.6
8.97
9.8
8.6
8
8.6
7
7.6
6
7.3
4
2
0
1952 1957 1962 1967 1971 1977 1980 1985 1990 1996 1998 2004 2009 2014
175
Table 3.8 shows that the representation of women in Rajya Sabha has ranged
from 16 to 29 which are 7.3 per cent to 11.83 per cent in 2011, of the total strength of
the house. It was in 1990, there were 38 women representatives out of a total 245
members in Rajya Sabha accounting to 15.5 per cent, the hightest ever independence.
Thus, the low representation of women in the decision-making organizations is due to
the political parties that harbour very conservative view about women. Different parties
though champion the cause of women in their manifesto, but during election time they
give tickets mostly to men and only to few elite women.
Council of Ministers
Table 3.9
The Representation of Women in the Union Council of Ministers
In the Table 3.9 reveals that women have remained poorly represented in
council of Ministers. Since Independence, we had so far 15 women chief ministers and
176
23 women governors. Only one women so served as president of India but so far we
had no women as vice- president and chief justice of India. Only one woman has got
the opportunity to serve as chief election commissioner and one as chairperson UPSC
but none as CAG.
Women constitute about half of the total population in Himachal Pradesh. But
their participation in state legislative assembly, parliament and other prominent
decision making bodies is very low. Their participation in voting is almost equal to
their male counterparts and sometimes, it is even more than that of men. Women
participation at grassroots level to some extent is also better due to the 33 per cent
reservation for women in Panchayati Raj Institutions and municipalities. Himachal
Pradesh Government has further undertaken a historic step by raising the reservation
limit for women in PRIs and Municipalities from the existing 33 per cent of the total
number of seats. It was on 8th April 2008, Himachal Pradesh Panchayati Raj
(Amendment) Bill was presented and passed in the house, and then Himachal became
the third state after Rajasthan and Madhya Pradesh to give 50 per cent reservation to
women in Panchayati Raj Institutions. This will definitely help in empowering women
and in creating sensitivity to women related development issues.72
72
Sarbjeet Singh and Pankaj Dodh (eds.), Gender Justice and Women Empowerment: An Integrated
Approach, New Delhi: Regal Publications, 2013, p. 296.
177
most of the citizens participate in governmental affairs only through voting. Therefore,
voting is the most widespread and regularized political activity and in terms of the
overall impact of the citizenry on governmental performance, it may be the single most
important act. It is the simplest most common and least demanding but an effective
mode of political participation. It represents a mass involvement of most citizens at
scheduled times. As a part of the electoral process, it exerts great pressure upon the
leaders, hence is called a blunt but powerful instrument of control upon the government
and decision-makers. The citizens of a democratic country have the right to participate
in governing that country by means of voting.73 The table below shows the voter’s
turnout in different assembly elections in Himachal Pradesh from 1972-2012.
Table 3.10
Women Voter’s Turnout in Different Assembly Elections in Himachal Pradesh
Year Men Women Total Men %age Women %age Total %age
1972 929337 876111 1805448 508416 54.71 393335 44.90 901751 49.95
1977 1027616 969713 1997329 638849 62.16 531045 54.76 1169894 58.57
1982 1101563 1109961 2211524 807311 73.29 764263 68.85 1571574 71.06
1985 1173219 1183713 2356932 843623 71.91 814803 68.83 1658426 70.36
1990 1512419 1481280 2993699 1054484 69.72 973927 65.75 2028411 67.76
1993 1653296 1624329 3277625 1188656 71.90 1154957 71.10 2343613 71.50
1998 1827060 1801804 3628864 1283632 70.26 1301152 72.21 2584784 71.23
2003 2081015 2020078 4101093 1522140 73.14 1533570 75.92 3055710 74.51
2007 2336839 2267604 4604443 1597473 68.36 1678296 74.01 3297252 71.61
2012 2373378 2234980 4608359 1646899 69.39 1702953 76.20 3349852 72.69
Source: Reports on General Elections to Himachal Pradesh State Legislative Assembly from 1972-2012,
Chief Electoral Officer and Financial Commissioner, Shimla: Himachal Pradesh.
73
Bhawana Jharta, op.cit., 1998, p. 82.
178
Table 3.10 presents that women voter’s turnout in different assembly elections
in Himachal Pradesh over the years. The data clearly reveals that women electors have
outnumbered their male counterparts in exercising their voting rights especially in the
recent years the women voters and their turnout have increased over the years in
Himachal Pradesh. In the assembly election of 1982 and 1985, the number of women
voters increased as compared to the men voters. Further, the percentage of voting
turnout of women is more than the men in the assembly elections of 2003, 2007 and
2012. This indicates that over the years, more women have exercised their right to vote
and choose the government of their choice for the governance. It can be attributed to
the increased awareness amongst women about their voting rights and their desire to be
remained appallingly low before 1972. Women who have been the members of the
state legislative assembly, territorial council before 1972 are: Umavati, Satyavati Dang,
Devindra Kumari, Subhadra Amin Chand and Sarla Sharma. Uma Vati was elected to
Himachal Pradesh Legislative Assembly after the integration of Part ‘C’ state of
Bilaspur with Himachal Pradesh in 1954. Satyavati Dang was nominated to the
Pradesh legislative assembly after the re-organization of the state of Punjab in 1966.
There was no women member in the state legislature from 1967-1971.74 Table shows
that the participation of women in voting during the different assembly elections from
74
Himachal Pradesh Legislative Assembly, Who’s Who Members of Himachal Pradesh Legislative
Assembly 1952-1971, Shimla: Legislative Assembly Secretariat.
179
Table 3.11
Women’s Representation in Himachal Pradesh Legislative Assembly 1972-2012
Contestants Success
No. of
Rate of
Total Winning Political
Year Women
Seats Women Party
Total Men Women %age Contestants
Contestants
%age
1972 68 297 290 7 1.34 4 INC 4 57.14
1977 68 330 321 9 2.72 1 JP 1 11.11
INC 2
1982 68 441 432 9 2.04 3 33.33
JP 1
JD 1
1993 68 416 399 17 4.08 3 INC 3 17.64
INC 4
1998 68 369 344 25 6.78 6 24.00
BJP 2
2003 68 408 377 31 7.60 4 INC 4 12.90
INC 1
2007 68 336 311 25 7.44 5 20.00
BJP 4
INC 2
2012 68 459 425 34 7.40 3 8.82
BJP 1
Source: Reports on General Elections to Himachal Pradesh State Legislative Assembly from 1972-2012,
Chief Electoral Officer and Financial Commissioner, Shimla: Himachal Pradesh.
In the Table 3.10 depicts that over the year’s women’s representation in the
legislative assembly is not very satisfactory, as very less number of women contested
the elections as compared to their male counterparts. The number of winning women
contestants ever remained one to six. Till date, the highest number of winning women
contestants was six in the assembly elections held in the year of 1998 and the lowest
number of winning women contestants was only one in the year of 1977. Thus, the
number of winning women contestants never exceeded from six. But if we see the
winning rate of women contestants, it is satisfactory as the data show that in the year of
1982 and 1985, it is 33.33 per cent and 30.00 per cent respectively. But, in the year
2012, it went very low to 8.82 per cent. It is rather a disappointing and discouraging
number of women contestants in comparison to their strength. The political parties
seem very reluctant to field women candidates and a very few women are put up by
180
them as candidates in the elections. Though, some women contested elections as
independent candidates but they never won any seats. Thus, contesting election still
remains a male prerogative.
Table 3.12
Total
Women Political
Year No. of Name of Candidate Constituency
Members Party
Seats
1952 43 1 Smt. Uma Vati Geharwin Independent
1957 45 1 Smt. Satya Vati Dang Nominated Congress
1962 58 3 Sarla Sharma Barsar Congress
Subhdra Amin Chand Nominated Congress
Devindra Kumari Chamba Congress
1972 68 5 Ms. Chandresh Kumari Bamson Congress
Sarla Sharma Kutlehar Congress
Padma Bhattiyat Congress
Lata Lahaul & Spiti Congress
Theog Congress
*Vidya Stokes
1977 68 1 Shyama Sharma Nahan Janta Party
1982 68 3 Ms.Vidya Stokes Theog Congress
Shyama Sharma Nahan Janta Party
Chandresh Kumari Thural Congress
1985 68 3 Asha Kumari Banikhet Congress
Vidya Stokes Theog Congress
Viplov Thakur Jaswan Congress
1990 68 4 Ms.Vidya Stokes Theog Congress
Shyama Sharma Nahan Janta Party
Sushma Sharma Chintpurni BJP
Ms.Leela Gopalpur BJP
1993 68 4 Krishna Mohini Solan Congress
Viplov Thakur Jaswan Congress
Asha Kumari Banikhet Congress
**Anita Verma Hamirpur Congress
1998 68 7 Ms.Vidya Stokes Theog Congress
***Krishna Mohini Congress
Solan
Urmila Thakur Hamirpur Congress
Viplov Thakur Jaswan Congress
Shahpur BJP
Sarveen Choudhary
Asha Kumari Banikhet BJP
Ms.Nirmla Devi Pragpur BJP
181
2003 68 4 Vidya Stokes Kumarsain Congress
Anita Verma Hamirpur Congress
Chandresh Kumari Dharamsala Congress
Asha Kumari Banikhet Congress
Table 3.12 shows that the constituency and party wise women members of
Himachal Pradesh legislative assembly/territorial council from 1952-2012.
Subsequently, women’s representation in the Himachal Pradesh state legislative
assembly has improved to some extent. In 1998-2012, there were maximum seven
women members in the legislative assembly.
182
ministers. These were Vidya Stokes, Asha Kumari and Chandresh Kumari. But, later
on Asha Kumari had to resign due to a judicial case lying in the Hon’ble court and
Chandresh Kumari had to lose the ministry due to the downsizing of the council of
ministers to 15 per cent of the total number of members of the State Legislative
Assembly, according to the 91st Constitutional Amendment Act of 2003. In 2005, Anita
Verma was made Parliamentary Secretary and was dropped after four months. In this
way, the representation of women again got reduced to one in the eleven member’s
Council of Ministers. In the (BJP) Dhumal government of 2007, only one woman,
Sarveen Chaudhary included in the council of ministers as a cabinet minister, while
Urmila Thakur was made parliamentary secretary. After 2012 Vidhan Sabha election,
Vidya Stokes was made cabinet minister and no other women member could find place
in the state cabinet.75
Lok Sabha
Table 3.13
Women’s Representation in Lok Sabha from Himachal Pradesh
75
Himachal Pradesh Legislative Assembly, Who’s Who Members of Himachal Pradesh Lok Sabha
1952-2012, Shimla: Legislative Assembly Secretariat.
183
Table 3.13 reveals that Himachal Pradesh is far behind in women’s
representation to Lok Sabha. During 2004, only two women candidates from Himachal
Pradesh namely Smt. Pratibha Singh and Ms. Rameshwari Kanwar contested the
election for the Lower House of Union Parliament. Smt. Pratibha Singh contested from
Mandi parliamentary constituency on Indian National Congress ticket securing 3,
57,623 votes and was declared elected, whereas Ms. Rameshwari Kanwar another
women candidate contested from Hamirpur parliamentary constituency as Independent
Candidate and secured only 5,566 votes and lost the election. During 2009, only
women candidates Nirmala Sharma contested the election for Lok Sabha from Kangra
constituency and lost the election. Pritibha Singh was elected in the bye-election held
on 2013. During 2014 only two women candidates from Himachal Pradesh namely
Smt. Pratibha Singh and Ms. Urmila Sharma contested the election for the lower house
of union parliamentary and lost the election. All women’s who were elected to the Lok
Sabha from the state belong to the Congress Party. In 2014 Lok Sabha Election women
voted (65.83%) more than men (64.55%). In Hamirpur constituency their voting
percentage was highest (71.73%), while men’s share only 69.61 per cent. In Kangra,
women voted 67.32 per cent and men 62.00 in Shimla constituency women were a little
behind with 62.05 per cent than men’s 65.10 per cent. In Himachal Pradesh women are
positively expressing their political will and wisdom.
Rajya Sabha
Table 3.14
Women’s Representation in Rajya Sabha from Himachal Pradesh
S. No Period Name of MPs in Rajya Sabha
1. 1956-1962 Smt. Leela Devi
2. 1968-1974 Smt. SatyaVati Dang
3. 1978-1984 Smt. Mohinder Kaur
4. 1980-1986 Smt. Uma Malhotra
5. 1996-2002 Ms. Chandresh Kumari
6. 2006-2012 Smt.Viplove Thakur
7. 2010-2016 Smt. Bimla Kashyap
8. 2014-2020 Smt.Viplov Thakur
Source: Election Commission of India.
184
Table 3.14 presents that women participation from Himachal Pradesh in Rajya
Sabha is also very low. Only eight women of this state have represented the upper
house of the parliament. Leela Devi (1956-62) of Mandi was the first women to
represent the State in the Rajya Sabha. After that, Satyawati Dang (1968-74), a
prominent politician of State; Mohinder Kaur (1964-67 and 1978-84); Usha Malhotra
(1980-86); and Chandres Kumari (1996-2002) remained members of the Rajya Sabha.
Viplop Thakur (2006-2012); and Bimla Ksahyap (2006-2016) became member of
Rajya Sabha. Further, Viplov Thakur got an opportunity to become the member of the
Rajya Sabha in 2014-2020. Chandresh Kumari is the only woman in Himachal who
has got an opportunity to be a member of both the House of Parliament i.e., Lok sabha
as well as the state legislative assembly. She also remained a cabinet and deputy
minister in the state cabinet. At the national level party politics, she also remained the
president of all India Mahila Congress. This shows that women’s representation from
Himachal Pradesh has remained comparatively better in the Rajya Sabha than in the
Lok Sabha. However, the overall, representation of women in parliament from
Himachal Pradesh is very marginal and unsatisfactory.
The 73rd and 74th Constitutional Amendment Acts (1993) are a very
revolutionary landmark in the history of women’s participation in politics in India.
These amendment acts have provided 33 per cent reservation of seats for women in the
Panchayati Raj Institutions (PRIs) and Municipalities. This has laid down a strong
foundation for women’s participation in decision making at the grass-roots level. These
amendments have worked as a break-through towards ensuring equal access and more
participation of women in the political power structure. The Panchayati Raj Institutions
and Municipalities are playing a very significant role in the process of enhancing
women’s participation in public life at the local levels. In consonance of the 73rd and
74th Constitutional Amendment Act, Himachal Pradesh Government has also passed its
Panchayati Raj and Municipalities Act in 1994 and first elections to the Panchayati Raj
and Municipalities, according to this new Act were held in December 1995. Till date,
five general elections have held to the Panchayat, at village level and urban bodies in
the state in the years 1995, 2000, 2005, 2010 and 2015.76
76
Bhawana Jharta, “Women in the Politics of Himachal Pradesh: An Analysis”, Himachal Pradesh
University Journal, July 2011, pp. 9-10.
185
The latest Amendment to Panchayati Raj Act (2008) provided 50 per cent
reservation of seats for women in Panchayats at village level and urban local bodies,
which is a historical step for the political empowerment of women in this hill state. In
2010, the elections to Panchayats at village level and urban local bodies were held as
per the provisions laid down in the Himachal Pradesh Panchayati Raj Amendment Act,
2008, vide which 50 per cent seats were reserved for women in Panchayats at village
level and urban local bodies.77 The experiment of 50 per cent reservation of seats for
women in Panchayat at village level and urban local bodies has been successful in the
state. Before 1995, women’s representation in Panchayats at village level and
Municipalities was maximum upto two women in all the bodies. After 1995, it has
increased to minimum 33 percent and now 50 per cent, since 2010 elections to the
panchayats at village level and urban local bodies. The representation of women in
these institutions has shown an increasing trend. In the last five elections to the
Panchayats at village level and urban local bodies, women have been more than the
fixed quota allotted to them.
77
Ibid.,
78
Ibid.,
186
Table 3.15
Panchayat
12252 6013 18265 32.92 11727 6822 18549 36.78
Members
Panchayat
1952 970 2922 33.19 2011 1026 3037 33.78
Pradhan
BDC
1103 558 1661 33.59 1090 562 1658 33.89
Members
BDC
49 23 72 31.91 48 27 75 36.00
Chairpersons
ZP
8 4 12 33.33 8 4 12 33.33
Chairperson
Table 3.16
Women’s Representation in PRIs in Himachal Pradesh Year: 2005-2010 to 2010-2015
2005-2010 2010-2015
BDC Members 1097 579 1676 34.54 819 863 1682 51.30
187
Table 3.17
Table 3.15, 3.16 and 3.17 shows women’s representation in Panchayati Raj
Institutions in Himachal Pradesh since 1995-2015. The data in the table reveals that the
percentage share of women for the post of Panchayat members was 32.92 per cent in
the year 1995, which increased to 36.78 per cent in 2000 and further increased to 38.43
per cent in 2005. The percentage of women who were elected for the post of Pradhan
was 33.19 per cent in the elections of 1995, 33.78 per cent in the elections of 2000 and
34.28 per cent in the elections held in the year 2005. Thus, the recent elections indicate
more representation of women than the reservation provision of 33 percentages. For the
post of BDC member, the percentage share of women has been found almost same in
all the three elections. However, the percentage share of women who were elected for
the post of Chairperson of BDC has increased from 31.94 per cent in1995 to 45.33 per
cent in the year 2005. The data also reveals for the post of Zila Parishad member has
been almost as per the provision of reservation of 33 per cent except in 2000, when
34.66 per cent women were elected to this post in the state. The percentage share of
women who were elected for the post of chairperson-Zila Parishad increased from
33.33 per cent in the years of 1995 and 2000 to 58.33 per cent in the year 2005. Before
1995, women’s representation in local self-governments was up to two women in all
the bodies. After 1995, it has increased to minimum 33 per cent and 50 per cent, since
2010 elections to the PRIs and urban local bodies.
In 2010-11 election in PRIs it has been proved that the participation of women
has increased considerably. At all the three tiers in Himachal Pradesh, women
participated. At the Gram Panchayat level total women contestants were 11317
188
(58.30%), Panchayat Samiti contested 863 (51.31%) and Zila Praishad level contestants
were 128 (51%). The Pradhan of Gram Panchayat were between 1639 (50.54%), at
Panchayat Samiti Level 42 (54.54%) and Zila Parishad the total chairpersons were 6
(50%).
Similarly in 2015 election in PRIs, it has been proved that the participation of
women has considerable increase due to fifty per cent of reservation. Therefore, at the
Gram Panchayat level total women contestants were 11778 (57.88%), Panchayat Samiti
contested 862 (51.52%) and Zila Praishad level contestants were 127 (50.08%). The
chairpersons of Gram Panchayat were between 1631 (50.55%), at Panchayat Samiti
Level 42 (53.84%) and Zila Parishad the total chairpersons were 6 (50%).
79
Nagaraju Battu, op.cit., 2014, p. 51.
80
Sarbjeet Singh and Pankaj Dodh (eds.), op.cit., 2013, p. 309.
189
services in the remotest rural areas of the Pradesh. Disease control and eradication
programmes have given rich dividends. Total number of medical institutions in
government sector stood at 3, 911 on March 2016.81
Table 3.18
Life Expectancy at Birth, Himachal Pradesh and India
(per thousand)
The table 3.18 shows that life expectancy for men and women in Himachal
Pradesh has been higher than that of all India Level. Himachal Pradesh women’s life
expecting marked 62.9 years during 1981-1985 as against the 55.9 years of the all India
level. The life expectancy of Himachal Pradesh women reached 72.4 years during
2006-2010, while the national average came only up to 67.7 years. The table also
81
Government of Himachal Pradesh, Statistical Abstract of Himachal Pradesh, Shimla: Department of
Economics and Statistics Government of Himachal Pradesh, 2015-2016.
190
indicates that in Himachal Pradesh itself the rise in the life expecting of women has
surpassed that of men during the period of 1981-2010.
Birth Rate
The birth rate in Himachal Pradesh was also much lower than that of the all
India average. The following table provides the data regarding the birth rates in
Himachal Pradesh and India.
Table 3.19
Birth Rate in Himachal Pradesh and India
Year Himachal Pradesh India
1971 37.3 36.9
1981 31.5 33.9
1991 28.5 29.5
2000 21.1 25.8
2001 20.7 25.4
2002 20.7 25.0
2003 20.6 24.8
2004 19.2 24.1
2005 20.0 23.8
2006 18.8 23.5
2007 17.4 23.1
2008 17.7 22.8
2009 17.2 22.5
2010 16.9 22.1
2011 16.5 21.8
2012 16.2 21.6
2013 16.0 21.4
2014 16.4 21.0
Source: Sample Registration System, Bulletin Registrar General, India or Himachal Pradesh
82
Sarbjeet Singh and Pankaj Dodh (eds.), op.cit., 2013, p. 309.
191
Table 3.19 depicts that Himachal Pradesh birth rate during 1971 period marked
37.3, whereas the same in the all India Level was 36.9 per thousand. During the 2004
period the birth rate of Himachal Pradesh was 19.2 per thousand against the all India
rate of 24.1. During the 2014 period the birth rate in Himachal Pradesh is 16.4 per
thousand, while the same with regard to India was 21 per thousand. It is found that the
birth rate of Himachal Pradesh came down to 16.4 per thousand, whereas the same in
India stood at 21 per thousand.
Death Rate
The following table provides the data regarding the death rates in Himachal
Pradesh and India.
Table 3.20
Death Rates, Himachal Pradesh and India
(Per thousand)
192
The Table 3.20, shows that during 1971 period the death rate of Himachal
Pradesh stands at 15.6 per thousand, whereas the same in India was 14.9. During the
2004 period the death rate in Himachal Pradesh registered 6.8 per thousand as against
the national rate of 7.5. In the 2014 period, the rate in Himachal Pradesh comes down
to 6.7, whereas the all India rate moved to 6.7 per thousand.
Infant Mortality
Table 3.21
Infant Mortality Rates, Himachal Pradesh and India
(Per thousand)
The above Table 3.21, reveals the fact that infant mortality rate in Himachal
Pradesh came down 32 per thousand in 2014 from 118 per thousand in 1951.
Therefore, it can be compared to the all India rate of 129 per thousand in 1971 and 37
83
Nagaraju Battu, op.cit., 2014, p.52.
193
per 1000 in 2014. While Himachal succeeded in bringing down infant mortality rate
from 118 per thousand to 32, the all India rate comes down only to 37 from 129 over a
period. It is definitely a notable achievement not only for the entire society but more
particularly for the womenfolk in Himachal Pradesh.
Women in India a better half of Indian society, today are becoming the most
vulnerable section, as far as their safety and security is concerned. Violence against
women in India is an issue rooted in societal norms and economic dependence.
Discriminatory practices are underlined by laws favouring men. Inadequate policing
and judicial practices deny female victims proper protection and justice, it is pertinent
to note that a crime against women is committed every three minutes in India.84 The
table clearly shows that the crime against women has increasing trend in Himachal
Pradesh and India.
Table 3.22
Violence against Women in Himachal Pradesh and India
Table 3.22 shows that in Himachal Pradesh crime against women has
increasedover the years, as total numbers of crime against women reported has gone
from 1106 in 2008 to 1576 in 2014. According to the National Crime Records Bureau
of India, reported incidents of crime against women were a total of 3 37 922 in 2014. It
has increased in Himachal Pradesh and India.
84
Anju Sharma, “ Violence and Safety Scenario of Women- A World Wide Concern”, in Mamta
Mokta (ed.), Women Safety & Security: Issues Challenges, Chandigarh: Mohindra Publishing House,
2015, p. 200.
194
Therefore, it was noted that education has helped Himachal Pradesh women to
reduce infant mortality considerably and improve the health conditions of women.
Thus compared to the status of women belonging to India, the women of Himachal
Pradesh enjoy not only better educational and health facilities but also better indices of
standard of living. Death rate connected with delivery has also come down
considerably. As far as the security of women is concerned, transport facilities and
accommodations are of paramount importance. Agriculture is the main occupation of
the people of the state. About 69 per cent of the main workers are engaged in
agricultural pursuits. Agriculture is the best with the disadvantage of small holdings.
The villages in Himachal Pradesh are inter-linked with transport facilities.
The Government of India has been trying to empower the women through
various schemes some of schemes related to women empowerment in India are:
The Rashtriya Mahila Kosh (RMK) 1993: National Credit Fund for Women
was set up in 1993 to make credit available for lower income women in India.
85
Welfare Schemes for Women in India, https://en.m.Wikipedia.org., Accessed on 01-10- 2015.
195
The National Plan of Action for the Girl Child (1991-2000): The plan of
action is to ensure survival, protection and development of the girl child with the
ultimate objective of building up a better future for the girl child.
86
Mamta Mokta (ed.), Dimensions of Gender Inequality in Society, Chandigarh: Shree Ram Lal House,
2016, p. 259.
87
Welfare Schemes for Women in India, https://en.m.Wikipedia.org., Accessed on 01-10-2015.
88
Mamta Mokta, op.cit., 2016, p. 259.
196
acquiring the skills necessary for improving the economic status and well-being of
women, imbibing the value of women’s equality empowerment.89
Swayam Siddha (2001): This scheme organizing women into self-help group.
Empowerment of women through SHGs is the needs of the hours. It is basically
concerned with equality, participation, influencing decision and access to opportunity.
It has been realized that organizing of women group is one of the most effective tools
for involving women in the development process and this task can be fully performed
by the involvement of self-help groups in women’s empowerment.90
National Rural Health Mission (NRHM) (2005): The National Rural Health
Mission (NRHM) was launched by the Government of India in April 2005, with a view
to bringing about dramatic improvement in the health system and the health status of
the people, especially those who live in the rural areas of the country. The mission
seeks to provide universal access to equitable, affordable and quality health care, which
is accountable at the same time responsive to the needs of the people. The NRHM also
aims to achieve the goals set out under the National Health Policy and the Millennium
Development Goals during the mission period.91
The Mother and Child Tracking System (MCTS) (2009): This program
helps to monitor the health care department to ensure that all mothers and children have
access all the required services and medical care, during pregnancy and delivery. Also
the system maintains a database of all pregnancies registered and all births from 2009,
December.
89
Ajit Kumar Sinha (ed.), New Dimensions of Women Empowerment, New Delhi: Deep and Deep
Publications, 2008, p.142.
90
Ibid., p. 87.
91
Shahin Razi, “Rural Infrastructure-A Gateway to Rural Prosperity”, Kurukshetra, Vol. 61, No.12,
2013, p. 31.
197
money to help better health and nutrition of the pregnant women/- in 3 instalments.
Any government employee doesn’t come under this scheme.
Women State Homes: Women and wayward girls Women State Home is
being run at Mashobra (Shimla) by the department. The main purpose of this scheme is
to provide shelter, food, clothing, education and vocational training to the young girls,
widows, deserted, destitute and women, who are in moral danger. For rehabilitation of
such women, after leaving State Home, Financial Assistance of Rs.20,000 per women
is provided. In case of marriage, assistance of Rs. 51,000 also provided to women.
Mukhya Mantri Kanyadaan Yojna: Under this scheme, marriage grant of Rs.
40,000 is given to the parents/ guardians of the girls to solemnize her marriage
provided their annual income does not exceed Rs. 35,000. During 2015-16 a budget
92
Welfare Schemes for Women in India, https://en.m.Wikipedia.org., Accessed on 01-10-2015.
93
Pradhan Mantri Ujjwala Yojana, https:// en.m. Wikipedia.org., Accessed on 04-08-2017.
198
provision of 566.25 lakh has been kept for this purpose, out of which an amount of
378.98 lakh has been spent and 1516 beneficiaries were covered up to December 2015.
Mother Teressa Asahay Matri Sambal Yojna: Under this scheme Rs.3000
per child per annum given is to the destitute women belonging to the BPL families or
having income less than Rs. 35,000 for the maintenance of their children, till they attain
the age of 18 years. The assistance will be provided only for two children.
Indira Gandhi Matritva Sahyog Yojna : Under this scheme free institutional
deliveries of expectant mothers, irrespective of their income are being done in all
government hospitals in the state.
Vishesh Mahila Utthan Yojna: State government has started “Vishesh Mahila
Utthan Yojna” as 100 per cent State Plan Scheme for training and rehabilitation of
women in mortal danger in the state. There is a provision to provide stipend Rs.3,000
per month per trainee through the department of women and child development.
199
upon the needs of rape victims. An affected woman shall be entitled to financial
assistance and restorative support/ services adding up to a maximum amount of Rs.
75,000 additional assistance of Rs. 25,000 can also be given in a special cases. During
the current financial year 2015-16, there is a budget provision of 66.00 lakh and upto
December 2015, 30 women have been benefited.
Beti Bachao Beti Padhao Scheme: This scheme has been launched on 21st
January 2015 in 100 districts of India with the objective of preventing gender biased
sex selective elimination ensuring survival, protection and education of the girl child.
The scheme is an initiative to arrest and reverse (improve) the decline in child sex ratio.
In the state, this scheme is implemented in Una district, were the child sex ratio was
reported lowest. Through this process, efforts are made to create awareness among
masses about the adverse effects of declining sex ratio.
Beti Hai Anmol Yojna: With a view to change negative family and community
attitude towards the girl child at birth and to improve enrolment and retention of girl
children in schools, Beti Hai Anmol Scheme is being implemented in the state on 5th
July 2010. Under this scheme Post Birth Grant of Rs. 10,000 is provided to two girls
only belonging to BPL families and scholarships are provided from 1st Class to 10+2
Classes for their education. The State Government has made 50 per cent increase in
scholarship rates on 23rd July 2015, with a new rates of scholarships ranging from Rs.
450 to Rs.2, 250 per annum. For the year 2015-16, there is a budget provision of 946.65
lakh and an amount of 518.70 lakh has been spent upto December 2015 and 16, 111
girls have been benefited.
200
Rajiv Gandhi Scheme for Empowerment of Adolescent Girls: Rajeev
Gandhi Scheme for empowerment of Adolescent Girls (RGSEAG)–SABLA is a central
sponsored scheme for empowerment of the adolescent girls (AGs from the age 11-18).
The main objectives of the scheme is to improve their nutrition and health status,
spread awareness among them about health, hygiene, nutrition, Adolescent
Reproductive and Sexual Health (ARSH), and family and child care, upgrades their
home-based skills, life skills and vocational skills. The cost sharing ratio of nutrition
component of the scheme was 50:50 and non-nutrition component was 100 percent
central share upto financial year 2014-15, which has been revised to 90:10 between the
centre and state from current financial year 2015-16. This scheme has been started in
four districts viz. Solan, Kullu, Chamba and Kangra. Nutrition and non-nutrition are
two major components of the scheme.94
State Commission for Women: State women commission has been set up in
the state for redressal of grievance of women and to make them aware about their legal
rights. This commission is providing counselling services and legal aid to women. The
commission also looks into the complaint of violence and atrocities against women.
State Level Council for Empowerment of Women: State level council for
empowerment has been set up in the state for effective implementation and monitoring
of national policy for empowerment of women.95
First Five Year Plan (1951-56): First five year plan set up the central social
welfare board in 1953 to promote welfare work through voluntary organizations,
charitable trusts etc.
Second Five Year Plan (1956-61): Second five year plan supported the
development of Mahila Mandals to work at the grassroots.
94
Government of Himachal Pradesh, Economic Survey, Shimla: Economic and Statistics Department
Himachal Pradesh, 2016-17, pp.131-134.
95
Government of Himachal Pradesh, Women and Men in Himachal Pradesh, Shimla: Department of
Economics and Statistics Government of Himachal Pradesh, 2014, pp. 12-15.
201
Third Five Year Plan (1961-1966): Women education was recognized as most
important and main welfare indicator in third five year plan. More thrust was given for
the programmes relating to their health, mother and child welfare, health education,
nutrition and family planning.96
Fourth Five Year Plan (1969-1974): In the fourth five year plan, special focus
was made towards women education and family welfare.
Fifth Five Year Plan (1974-78): There was a major shift in the approach
towards women, from welfare to development.
Sixth Five Year Plan (1980-1985): Sixth five year plan accepted women’s
development as a separate economic agenda took a multi-disciplinary approach with a
three-pronged thrust on health, education and employment.
Seventh Five Year Plan (1985-1990): It had the objective of bringing women
into the mainstream of national development.
Eighth Five Year Plan (1992-97): It saw a paradigm shift from development to
empowerment and benefits to women in the core sectors of education, health and
employment. Outlay for women rose from Rs. 4 crore in the first five year plan to Rs.
2000 crore in the eighth.97
Ninth Five Year Plan (1997-2002): In the 9th five year plan the effective steps
were taken by central government for social economic and educational development of
women. In this five year plan, thirty per cent funds were kept reserved for the
development of women through self help groups. Adequate attention was given
towards women health. Many programmes were stated for improvement of women
nutrition such as mid-day meal.
Tenth Five Year Plan (2002-2007): Tenth five year plan suggests specific
strategies, policies and programmes for the empowerment of women.98
96
Anju Pal, “Women Empowerment in India: Globalization and Opportunities”, in Meenu Agrawal
(ed.), Women Empowerment and Globalization: A Modern Perspective, New Delhi: Kanishka
Publishers, 2009, p.344.
97
Ibid.,
98
Ibid, p.344.
202
Eleventh Five Year Plan (2007-2012): In the eleventh five year plan 2007-
2012 twenty five main sectors have been identified, wherein women development has
been given the place in two sectors viz., social justice and women empowerment,
women and child development, forty one members working committee has been
constituted for women empowerment.99
Twelfth Five Year Plan 2012-2017: The twelfth five year plan entitled as
faster, sustainable and more inclusive growth. Twelfth five year plan has emphasized
on single women by providing ‘quota’ in jobs. Moreover, women’s inclusion in
inclusive growth is only possible, when inclusive democracy turned to be reality not the
myth.100
99
Public Welfare Plan of Government of India, Directorate of Ministry of Information and
Broadcasting, Advertisement, New Delhi, p. 24.
100
Satarupa Pal, “Women in Twelfth Five Year Plan in India: An Analysis”, A Journal of Humanities,
Vol. 2, No.I, 2013, pp.121-124.
203
CHAPTER-IV
1
M.P. Dube and Neeta Bora (eds.), Social Justice and Women in India, Delhi: Swaraj Prakashan,
1999, p.137.
2
Savita Thakur Joshi (ed.), Women and Development: The Changing Scenario, New Delhi: Mittal
Publications, 1999, p. 32.
3
S.S.Chahar (ed.), Governance at Grassroots Level in India, New Delhi: Kanishka Publishers, 2005,
p. 399.
205
Social background is still more significant in the context of leadership, because
it does not only decide the descriptive status style of life and class position, values and
aspirations but also the capacity of leaders of sustain struggle for power and authority.
In an ascription-oriented society as Indian, the social existence of an individual
becomes all the more significant in nature and structure of leadership.4 Democracy is
never complete unless active involvement and participation of people at all levels is
assured.5 Panchayati Raj is regarded as the heart and soul of Indian democracy. The
health and strength of Indian democracy depends on its sound functioning. It is an
agency of social progress, economic prosperity and political development.
4
Ibid., pp. 399-400.
5
Ibid., p. 351.
6
M. R. Biju, Dynamics of New Panchayati Raj System: Reflections and Retrospections, New Delhi:
Kanishka Publishers, 1998, p. 203.
7
Thapai Ananda, et al., “Political Participation of Women in India- An Overview”, International
Journal of Advanced Research, Vol.1, No. 10, 2013, p. 632.
8
Rameshwari Pandya (ed.), Women Welfare and Empowerment in India, New Delhi: New Century
Publications, 2008, p. 571.
206
empowerment as well as participation in the decision-making process lead to
empowerment in the true sense.9 The collected information and data were classified on
the basis of age, caste, religion, marital status, education, occupation, landholding and
family size and political involvement of women.
Age
9
Meenu Agrawal (ed.), Women Empowerment and Globalization: A Modern Perspective, New Delhi:
Kanishka Publishers, 2009, p. 163.
10
Manjunath S. Hosagur, “Role of Panchayats in Rural Development: A Political Study”, Third
Concept, Vol. 26, No. 300-301, February-March 2012, p. 41.
11
Anupama Singh, Bureaucracy at the Grassroots Level in India, New Delhi: Kanishka Publishers,
2006, p. 26.
12
Arun Kumar Singh, Political Orientation of People in Rural India, New Delhi: Mittal Publications,
1987, p. 42.
13
B.S. Bhargava, Grassroots Leadership, New Delhi: Ashish Publishing House, 1978, p.18.
207
influences one’s ideas and views. As one grows up, one gets exposed to the prevailing
social and cultural patterns and develops a particular kind of attitude.14
Rural society is predominantly traditional and conservative, but the need of the
hour is an orientation towards the progress and change. Such changes can be initiated
and promoted only by the young leaders.19 In the tradition-bound and patriarchal Indian
society, social mobility of women usually occurs very marginally and therefore, entry
of the young unmarried women in politics was restrictive. But the situation has been
changed after the new dispensation, which inducts younger women in rural politics.20
The age wise composition of the respondents has been given below.
14
Reena Singh, Gender Composition Values, Preference and Behaviour, New Delhi: Rawat
Publications, 2001, p. 46.
15
S.S Chahar (ed.), op.cit., 2005, p. 400.
16
S.K. Singh and A.K. Singh, OBC Women: Status and Educational Empowerment, Lucknow: New
Royal Book Company, 2004, p.143.
17
B.S. Bhargava, op.cit., 1978, p.18.
18
K.C.Vidya, Political Empowerment of Women at the Grassroots, New Delhi: Kanishka Publishers,
2007, p. 103
19
Ibid.,p. 20.
20
D. Sundar Ram (ed.), Women Empowerment in Political Institutions: An Indian Perspective, New
Delhi: Kanishka Publishers, 2009, p.115.
208
Table: 4.1
Age Wise Classification of the Respondents
No. of Respondents
Age in Grand Total
Sr.No Mandi Kangra
Years
No. % age No. % age No. % age
1 18-30 46 31.73 9 6.16 55 18.90
2 31-40 72 49.66 74 50.69 146 50.17
3 41-50 23 15.86 41 28.09 64 22.00
4 Above 50 4 2.75 22 15.06 26 8.93
Total 145 100
50.69 146 100 291 100
60
49.66
50
31.73
40
Percentage (%)
28.09
30 Mandi
15.86
15.06
Kangra
20
6.16
2.75
10
0
18-30 31-40 41-50 Above 50
Age in Years
Table 4.1 shows that out of the total, 291 respondents were interviewed, out of
which 55 respondents were from the age group of 18 to 30 years,
years which constitute
18.90 per cent of the total sample, while 146 respondents were from the age group of
31 to 40 years, which constitute 50.17 per cent of the total sample. There were 64
respondents who were from the age group of 41 to 50 years, which constitute 22.00 per
cent of the total sample. Similarly, from the age group of above 50 years,
years the number of
respondents was 26 which constitute 8.93 per cent of the sample.
209
In district Mandi out of the total 145 respondents were interviewed, out of
which 46 respondents were from the age group of 18 to 30 years which constitute 31.73
per cent of the total sample, while 72 respondents were from the age group of 31 to 40
years which constitute 49.66 per cent of the total sample. There were 23 respondents
who were from the age group of 41 to 50 years, which constitute 15.86 per cent of the
total sample. Similarly, from the age group of above 50 years the number of
respondents was 4 which constitute 2.75 per cent of the sample.
Similarly, in district Kangra out of the total 146 respondents were interviewed,
out of which 9 respondents were from the age group of 18 to 30 years, which constitute
6.16 per cent of the total sample, while 74 respondents were from the age group of 31
to 40 years which constitute 50.69 per cent of the total sample. There were 41
respondents, who were from the age group of 41 to 50 years, which constitute 28.09 per
cent of the total sample. Similarly, from the age group of above 50 years the number of
respondents was 22 which constitute 15.06 per cent of the sample.
The comparative analysis of two districts reveals that as far as the age factor
was concerned there was little variation in the age group of women respondents in two
districts. The old women had very little share in the participation of politics. The study
reveals that the younger generation takes more interest in the politics.
Caste
210
pursuit by tradition of a particular occupation and was usually associated with a more
or less distinct ritual status in a hierarchical status. The Indian society was highly
stratified into the age-old division of castes and sub-castes. The Indian caste system
manifests itself as a vertical structure, in which individual castes were hierarchically
graded and kept permanently apart, and at the same time, were linked by well-defined
expectation and obligations which integrate them into the village social system.22
Historically, according to the verna scheme of cast grouping, there were four
varnas; the Brahmins (Priests), the Kshatriyas (Warriors), the Vaishyas (Business and
Trade) and the Shudras (Craftsman) ranking of this classification was generally agreed
upon and by custom and consensus. Brahmins had been placed above all, followed by
Kshatriyas, Vaishayas and Shudras in that order. The caste structure in Indian context
cannot be completely overruled, since it has deep roots in our history. The Indian
society was greatly divided into various castes and sub-castes. The main purpose of this
query was to see, whether all castes were well represented in the bureaucracy or not. 23
Caste has played an instrumental role in raising issues related to the more
marginalised among women. In a highly hierarchical society, women belonging to the
lower castes have lesser access to public fora, which is compounded by their gender.
22
Anupama Singh, op.cit., 2006, p.28.
23
Ibid.,
24
Rajni Kothari, Caste in Indian Politics, Bombay: Orient Longman, 1973, p.8.
25
Andre Beteille, Ideology and Social Science, United Kingdom: Penguin Books 2006, p. 43.
26
Savita Thakur Joshi (ed.), op.cit., 1999, pp. 39-40.
211
This exclusion makes it difficult for these women to represent and articulate the voices
of their constituency and their demands are often overlooked or subsumed by the
dominant sections of the society. Social divisions on the basis of caste often limit the
potential for gender solidarity between women, thereby thwarting attempts at
developing a common political agenda. Caste is a significant variable in the functioning
of the Indian political system. In ancient India, the caste Panchayats used to deal with
the matters pertaining to their castes only and also to the matter of wider importance
affecting the whole village that was dealt by the village council. This was the manner in
which the British transferred the political functions. In the independent India, the
provisions of constitutional safeguard to the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes
have given a new lease of life to the caste.27
Caste has been the most powerful institution in rural power structure in India.28
On attribute of caste, the leader should belong to the dominant caste, which is usually
the most numerous and economically dominant caste group.29 According to A. R.
Desai, “Caste largely determines the function, the status, available opportunities as well
as handicaps for individuals.30 The influence of caste is marked more in rural society.
Caste plays a significant role in moulding the emergence of leadership at the village
level. It has been observed that the people belonging to the ‘dominant castes’ have
usually been found elected to these grassroots level institutions. 31
27
K.C. Vidya, op.cit., 2007, p. 103.
28
R.S. Singh, Rural Elite Entrepreneurship and Social Change, Jaipur: Rawat Publications, 1985, p. 60.
29
Dharam Raj Singh, Rural Leadership Among Scheduled Castes, Allahabad: Chugh Publications, 1985, p. 28.
30
A.R. Desai, Rural Sociology in India, Bombay: Oxford University Press, 1969, p. 39.
31
K.C. Vidya, op.cit., 2007, p. 103.
32
K.L. Sharma, op.cit., 2007, p.8.
212
decision making process. Caste system is a hereditary classification of people in a
society. The status of a person gets pre-determined
pre in a caste system. The social
stratification that categories people into different groups called caste,
caste is usually based
on your family tree. The caste wise composition of the respondents has been given
below.
Table 4.2
Classification of the Respondents on the Basis of Caste
No. of Respondents
Grand Total
Sr.No Caste Mandi Kangra
No. % age No. % age No. % age
1 General 65 44.83 46 31.51 111 38.15
2 SCs 72 49.66 37 25.34 109 37.46
3 STs 3 2.06 13 8.90 16 5.49
4 OBCs 5 3.45 50 34.25 55 18.90
Total 145 100 146 100 291 100
49.66
44.83
50 Mandi
45
34.25
Kangra
31.51
40
25.34
Percentage (%)
35
30
25
20
8.9
15
3.45
2.06
10
5
0
General SCs STs OBCs
Caste
The table 4.2 indicate that in all 291 respondents were interviewed through a
questionnaire in which the information regarding caste factor in the society has been
presented. Out of the total 291,
291 respondents 111 respondents were from the general
category, which constitutes 38.15 per cent of the total sample. Whereas,
Whereas there were 109
213
respondents from Scheduled Caste which constitute 37.46 per cent of the sample, while
there were 16 respondents from Schedule Tribe, which constitute 5.49 per cent of the
sample and there were 55 respondents from OBCs which constitute 18.90 per cent of
the total sample.
In district Mandi out of 145 respondents 65 respondents were from the general
category, which constitutes 44.83 per cent of the total sample. Whereas, there were 72
respondents from Scheduled Caste, which constitute 49.66 per cent of the sample,
while there were 3 respondents from Schedule Tribe, which constitute 2.06 per cent of
the sample and there were 5 respondents from OBCs, which constitute 3.45 per cent of
the total sample.
In district Kangra out of 146 respondents 46 respondents were from the general
category, which constitutes 31.51 per cent of the total sample. Whereas, there were 37
respondents from scheduled caste, which constitute 25.34 per cent of the sample, while
there were 13 respondents from schedule tribe, which constitute 8.90 per cent of the
sample and there were 50 respondents from OBCs which constitute 34.25 per cent of
the total sample.
From the above analysis it appears that the share of general category of the
respondents in district Mandi was higher (44.83%) in comparison to district Kangra
(31.51%). And Scheduled Caste share is concerned, district Mandi has higher (49.66%)
to district Kangra (25.34%). As far as the OBCs share was concerned district Kangra
had higher share in comparison to district Mandi. The Scheduled Tribes have very
nominal existence in both districts. It appears that the share of STs was still very low. It
may be due to less population of their groups. It was observed during the field study,
that there were mainly two dominant castes in the districts i.e. Brahmin and Rajput in
the general category. People were still graded on their caste position and this was truer
of hilly areas of Himachal Pradesh.
Education
33
Anupama Singh, Contemporary Discourses on Gender Justice, New Delhi: SSDN Publishers, 2016,
p. 53.
214
ready for social life. Its objective was to awaken and develop in the child those
physical, intellectual and moral states, which were required to him both by his society
as a whole and by the milieu for which he was specially destined. Education, in fact,
helps in social and occupational mobility for the members in social hierarchy.
Educational attainments, to a large extent determine the nature and type of job
opportunities. Johnson rightly argues that there was a broad tendency for people with
higher education to have higher-ranking occupations.34
Education in a broad sense, from infancy to adulthood, was thus a vital means
of social control, and its significance has been greatly enhanced in the last two decades
by the rapid expansion of education at all levels in the developing countries. Through
education, new generations learn the social norms and the penalties for infringing them;
they were instructed also in their station and its duties within the system of social
differentiation and stratification.35 Women constitute almost half of the population of
the world. Education for women is the best way to improve the health, nutrition and
economic status of a household that constitute a micro unit of a nation’s economy.36
Education has far reaching input on the march of women towards empowerment.
Education is the key to all ways and means of women’s empowerment. Virtually, it
opens new vistas to overall achievement of women and consequently leads to their
empowerment.37
34
Anupama Singh, op.cit., 2006, p. 30.
35
Ibid., p. 42.
36
M. Tarique Anwer, “Development of Female Education”, Third Concept, Vol. 31, No. 362, April
2017, p. 25.
37
Chandni Sinha, “Education and Empowerment of Women”, Third Concept, Vol. 21, No. 243, May
2007, p. 51.
215
During the first half of the 19th century, education for women was limited only
to a small number of aristocratic families, who imparted education to their women, so
that they could help them the management of their huge estates. The charter Act of
1813 passed by the East India Company provided them with more opportunities to send
their children to schools and colleges. Missionaries and a few philanthropic
Englishmen entered this field and began rendering support to the establishment of
special schools for girls. Among the Indians, who took a keen interest in women’s
education were Ram Mohan Roy, and Iswar Chandra Vidya Sagar (1813-1854).
However the education was confined to a few privileged women. At the time of
Indian’s independence in 1947, not only was a large percentage of its population
illiterate, but there was a marked discrimination so far as imparting education to the
men and women were concerned.38 In this context, it can be argued that lack of women
education can be an impediment to the country’s economic development. In India
women achieved for less education that of men. The growth of women’s education in
rural areas is very slow. This obviously means that still large womenfolk of our country
are illiterate, the weak, backward and exploited.
Higher Education in India is provided by both the public and private sector.
India has the largest number of higher educational institutions. According to the data
published by the Ministry of Human Resource Development, Government of India, the
38
Savita Thakur Joshi (ed.), op.cit., 1999, pp. 80-81.
39
M. Tarique Anwer, op.cit., 2017, p. 25.
40
Sunil Kumar Sain and Sudhir Sudam Kaware, “A Present Status of Women Education in India”,
Educationia Confab, Vol. 2, No. 9, September 2013, p. 50.
41
Shailendar Sharma, “Access to Education”, Yojana, Vol. 60, January 2016, p. 49.
216
number of Universities/University-level institutions has increased 18 times from 27 in
1950 to 504 in 2009. The sector boasts of 42 Central Universities, 243 State
Universities, 53 State Private Universities, 130 Deemed Universities, 33 Institutions of
National importance (established under Acts of Parliament) and five Institutions
(Established under various State legislations). The number of colleges has also
registered a manifold increase with just 578 in 1950 growing to be more than 30,000 in
2011.42
Education is the process that liberates mind. It is liberation from all forms of
darkness and ignorance. Women’s literacy is essential for economic viability and
independence. Acquisition of knowledge is one of the prerequisites of human
development. Today all development agencies agree on the importance of educating
women in order to promote and maintain family education, health, nutrition and general
well-being. The aim of education should be to train women in such a way that they
apply their acquired knowledge to the pursuits of daily life and fit them for the position
they have to fill. Education for women should always be directed towards their holistic
development. Education enhances a women’s sense of her own health needs and
perspectives, and her power to make any health and family planning decisions.43 It is
considered an important variable not only for widening mental horizon of the
individual but also it helps a person to make use of rational and scientific approach to
different problems.44 Therefore, according to census report 2011, in Himachal Pradesh
the literacy rate of women is 75.93 per cent and that of men is 89.53 per cent. As per
the census report 2011, in India the literacy rate of women is 65.46 per cent and that of
men is 82.14 per cent. There has been a sincere effort to improve the education
attainment of women by both government and voluntary organizations. The changes in
the policies and in-frastructural supports on primary, secondary and higher education
reflect the initiatives of the government of India towards women education.45 Higher
educational level of citizen is an important prerequisite for greater role in political
process. Education enables one to act rationally. Some previsions study shows that
higher education leads to greater commitment. In the opinion of Jorgan, education is
not to be regarded as an important factor for political participation. Duverger is
42
Jyoti Gautam, “Gender Issues in Higher Education”, Third Concept, Vol. 29, No. 345, November
2015, pp. 20-21.
43
Rameshwari Pandya (ed.), op.cit., 2008, p. 165.
44
Savita Thakur Joshi (ed.), op.cit., 1999, pp. 35-36.
45
M. Tarique Anwer, op.cit., 2017, p. 25.
217
convinced that education is the most decisive
decisive factor for women’s political
participation.46 Table shows the educational levels of the respondents.
Table 4.3
Educational Levels of the Respondents
No. of Respondents
Educational Grand Total
Sr.No Mandi Kangra
Qualification
No. % age No. % age No. % age
1 Illiterate 00 00 4 2.74 4 1.37
2 Primary 14 9.65 17 11.64 31 10.66
3 Middle 16 11.04 28 19.18 44 15.12
4 Matric 52 35.86 44 30.14 96 32.99
5 Plus Two 45 31.03 33 22.60 78 26.81
6 Graduation 8 5.52 13 8.90 21 7.22
Post
7 8 5.52 4 2.74 12 4.12
Graduation
8 Others 2 1.38 3 2.06 5 1.71
Total 145 100 146 100 291 100
35.86
31.03
30.14
40
Mandi
22.6
Percentage (%)
19.18
30 Kangra
11.64
11.04
20
9.65
8.9
5.52
5.52
2.74
2.74
2.06
1.38
10
0
Educational Qualification
Table 4.3 depicts that out of 291 respondents there were 4 respondents who
were illiterate, which constitute 1.37 per cent of the total sample,
sample while 31 respondents
46
Usha Kiran, Participation of Women in Indian Politics:
Politics Gender Justice and Political Challenge,
Delhi: Globus Press, 2016, p.122.
122.
218
were having educational qualification level up to primary which constitute 10.66 per
cent of the sample, 44 respondents were with middle standard which constitute 15.12
per cent of the total sample. Whereas 96 respondents were matriculates which
constitute 32.99 per cent of the sample, 78 respondents were upto ten plus two which
constitute 26.81 per cent of the sample and 21 respondents were graduates which
constitute 7.22 per cent of the sample. There were 12 respondents were post graduates
which constitute 4.12 per cent of the sample. There were only 5 respondents having
some other type of educational qualification, which constitute 1.71 per cent of the
sample.
The comparative analysis of both districts reveals that the education level of
respondents of Mandi was higher than that of Kangra. Majority of the respondents were
educated up to matriculation level. The analysis of education standard also proves that
the majority of the leadership in state politics is in the hands of educated elected
219
women. In rural area educational system is not well developed. Hence educational level
and their understanding of the current issues were very poor.
Marital Status
47
Savita Thakur Joshi (ed.), op.cit., 1999, p. 34.
48
Priyanka Tomer, Indian Women, New Delhi: Shree Publishers, 2006, p. 52.
49
M.R. Biju (ed.), Dynamics of Modern Democracy: The Indian Experience, Vol. 2, New Delhi:
Kanishka Publishing House, 2009, p. 353.
50
K.L. Sharma, op.cit., 2007, p. 144.
220
case of late marriages, when the man and women will have developed set attitudes. But
from the physiological point of view, Velde (1976) maintains that marriage is the
permanent form of monogamous erotic relationship. Sexual urges cannot be ignored
from marriage. It is one of the marital right and duties.51 Johnson (1970) argues that
wherever we look in history or in the contemporary world, whether at civilized people
or the most primitive, we find that social life is molded to a great extent by social
institutions like marriage. There is no society on record, which is without this
institution, whatever the cultural pattern may be. The idea of marriage, however, differs
from society to society and conditioned always by time and place. As a culturally and
socially recognized institution, people almost believe that family and sexual relation
should be within legal marriage. Marriage brings love, affection, happiness, etc. It is
absolutely a sacred bond of individuals and there is need to remark the marriage intact,
marriage has to be made a permanent bond between two individuals.52
Table 4.4
Classification of the Respondents on the Basis of their Marital Status
No. of Respondents
Grand Total
Marital
Sr.No Mandi Kangra
Status
No. % age No. % age No. % age
51
M.R. Biju, op.cit., 2009, p. 353.
52
Ibid.,
53
S.S Chahar (ed.), op.cit., 2005, pp. 405-406.
54
A.R. Desai, Rural Sociology in India, Bombay: Popular Parkashan, 1992, p. 21.
221
98.62
93.84
100 Mandi
Kangra
80
Percentage (%)
60
40
6.16
20
0.69
0.69
0
0
Married Unmarried Widow
Marital Status
Fig. 4.4: Classification of the Respondents on the Basis of their Marital Status
The table 4.4 indicate that out of 291 respondents 280 respondents were
married, which constitute 96.22 per cent of the total sample, whereas 1 respondent was
unmarried which constitute 0.34 per cent of the sample. There were 10 respondents
were widow, which constitutes 3.44 per cent of the sample.
As far as inn district Kangra out of 146 respondents, 137 respondents were
married, which constitute 93.84 per cent of the total sample
sampl and there were 9
respondents was widow, which constitutes 6.16 per cent of the sample.
Thus, the comparative analysis of table indicate that the majority of the
respondents in the whole sample in both districts were married which indicated that
more married women was getting family support to join politics. Marital status of the
women enjoys more freedom as compared to the unmarried women. Due to patriarchal
character, familyy members and society does not permit girl to actively involved in the
public issues. The findings of the study indicated
indicate that married women have more
acceptability as women leaders in the society as compared to unmarried women
leaders.
222
Type of Family
Family holds a central position in social life. It is the family which lays the
foundations of the child’s personality and his emotional stability. The quality of the
generation is determined more especially by the family. India is one such nation where
agriculture is the main occupation for its population, and size of a family has a role to
fulfil in order of birth. Large families are one of the characteristics of the third world
nations. Family size tends to be particularly large in the communities, whose
subsistence economy is agriculture, where kinship ties are strong and large families are
taken as symbols of social prestige. The size of the family and number of children
count a lot in every one’s life. The limited size family can help to create conditions in
which happier families can grow and parents can be able to give their children the due
care. The large size of the family entails heavier responsibilities and burdens in meeting
the obligations of the family towards feeding, clothing, education, housing
accommodation, entertainments etc. In the Indian society two types of families are
identified viz., the Joint family and the nuclear family. 55 The type of family also affects
the political behaviour and participation of women in politics. In the family structure
generally distinction is made between joint family and nuclear family. The joint family
is associated with a traditional, agricultural society, where conservatism and family
status tend to dominate over individual interest. On the other hand, the nuclear family is
more a development of a mobile, industrialised society permit of a greater degree of
flexibility and self- expression among its members.56
223
community. The basic unit of our democracy will be the individual family.58 Data in
this regard are presented in Table 4.5
4.
Table 4.5
Family Structure of the Respondents
No. of Respondents
Family Grand Total
Sr.No Mandi Kangra
Structure
No. % age No. % age No. % age
56.85
52.41
Mandi
47.59
43.15
60 Kangra
50
Percentage (%)
40
30
20
10
0
Nuclear Joint
Family Structure
Table 4.55 shows that all 291 respondents were interviewed, out of 132
respondents were living in nuclear family system,
system which constitutes 45.36 per cent of
the total sample, whereas, 159 respondents were living in the joint family. The
percentages of such respondents were 54.64 of the total sample.
58
S. K. Dey, Panchayati Raj: A Synthesis,
Synthesis, Bombay: Asia Publishing House, 1961, pp. 102-103.
102
224
As far as district Kangra was concerned, out of 146 respondents 63 respondents
were living in nuclear family system, which constitutes 43.15 per cent of the total
sample, whereas 83 respondents were living in the joint family. The percentages of
such respondents were 56.85 of the total sample.
From the comparative analysis of the two districts reveals that joint family
system is still prevailing in the rural and urban areas of Mandi and Kangra districts. It is
not possible for a woman to choose joint family or nuclear family especially in the rural
areas, where the system of joint family is still common. It was observed that in a
sample where all the respondents come from agricultural households, the greater
number would live in joint families. There seems no big difference between styles of
family life in terms of percentage in both districts.
Number of Children
59
Rameshwari Pandya (ed.), op.cit., 2008, p. 171.
60
Marcia Manning Lee, “Why Few Women Hold Public Office: Democracy and Sexual Roles”,
Political Science Quarterly, Vol. 91, No. 2, 1976, pp. 304-10.
225
potential to participate in political activities. The number of children that a citizen
c has
can impede his/her participation in elections.61
Table 4.6
Classification of Respondents for the Basis of Number of Children
No. of Respondents
Number of Grand Total
Sr.No Mandi Kangra
Children
No. % age No. % age No. % age
1 None 6 4.14 1 0.69 7 2.41
2 One 14 9.66 20 13.69 34 11.68
3 Two 103 71.03 89 60.96 192 65.98
4 Three 16 11.03 29 19.87 45 15.46
5 Above Three 6 4.14 7 4.79 13 4.47
Total 145 100 146 100 291 100
71.03
80 Mandi
60.96
70 Kangra
60
Percentage (%)
50
40
19.87
13.69
30
11.03
9.66
20
4.79
4.14
4.14
0.69
10
0
None One Two Three Above Three
Number of Children
Table 4.6 reveals that out of 291 respondents, 7 respondents were having no
child, which constitute 2.41 per cent of the total sample, 34 respondents were having
single child which constitute 11.68 per cent of the sample, whereas 192 and 45
respondents were having two and three children respectively. The percentage of such
respondents was 65.98 and 15.46 of the sample. And 13 respondents were having more
than three children they constituted about 4.47
4.47 per cent of the total sample.
61
S. Lal, Women in Indian Politics, New Delhi: Kunal Books, 2010, p.110.
226
In district Mandi out of 145 respondents 6 respondents were having no child,
which constitute 4.14 per cent of the total sample, 14 respondents were having single
child which constitute 9.66 per cent of the sample, whereas 103 and 16 respondents
were having two and three children respectively. The percentage of such respondents
was 71.03 and 11.03 of the sample. And 6 respondents were having more than three
children, they constituted about 4.14 per cent of the total sample.
Occupation
62
Savita Thakur Joshi (ed.), op.cit., 1999, p. 42.
227
occupational change and mobility among these communities and caste was accelerated
only after the state enacted the policy of safeguards and reservations.63
63
Dharam Raj Singh, op.cit., 1985, pp. 41-42.
64
Usha Sharma and B. M. Sharma, Women and Profession, New Delhi: Commonwealth Publishers,
1995, p. 68.
65
S.S Chahar (ed.), op.cit., 2005, pp. 401-402.
66
S.N. Mishra, Pattern of Emerging Leadership in Rural India, Patna: Associated Book Agencies,
1977, pp. 62-63.
67
Reena Singh, op.cit., 2001, p.58.
68
Madan Lal Goel, Political Participation in a Developing Nation: India, Bombay: Asia Publishing
House, 1974, p.116.
228
study attempts has been made to know about the occupation
occupation of the respondents in the
Table 4.7.
Table 4.7
Occupational Patterns of the Respondents
No. of Respondents
Occupational Grand Total
Sr.No Mandi Kangra
Pattern
No. % age No. % age No. % age
1 Agriculture 113 77.93 100 68.49 213 73.19
2 Horticulture 6 4.14 00 00 6 2.06
3 Business 15 10.34 22 15.07 37 12.72
4 Others 11 7.59 24 16.44 35 12.03
Total 145 100 146 100 291 100
77.93
68.49
80
Mandi
70
Kangra
60
Percentage (%)
50
40
30
16.44
15.07
10.34
20
7.59
4.14
10
0
0
Agriculture Horticulture Business Others
Occupational Patterns
Table 4.7 shows that the occupation distribution of the respondents. It is clear
from the table that out of 291 respondents, 213 respondents were engaged in agriculture
which constitutes 73.19 per cent of the total sample, whereas 6 respondents engaged in
horticulture which constitutes 2.06 per cent of the total sample. There were 37
respondents were from the business,
busine which constitute 12.72 per cent of the sample and
229
35 respondents were having occupation other than above, which constitute 12.03 per
cent of the sample.
The comparative analysis of Mandi and Kangra districts reveals that the number
of respondents on agriculture based profession was higher in district Mandi than that of
district Kangra. Whereas, people engaged in business activities and small scale
industries were higher in district Kangra than that of district Mandi. But overall,
majority of the respondents were in agriculture. It is clear from this table that leadership
in India as well as in Himachal Pradesh is dominated by the agricultural class and
particularly by the women leadership. This is the fact that the economy of Himachal
Pradesh is dependent upon agriculture.
Income
69
K.C. Vidya., op.cit., 2007, p.109
70
D. Sundar Ram (ed.), op.cit., 2009, p. 121
230
important indicator to judge the status and influence of the respondents on the society.
People who had good financial position in the rural areas wield good influence in the
village. Lack of financial institutions in the past had made the people dependent on the
money lenders in the villages. After the independence, banking facilities were available
to the rural people. Now, the exploitation by the money lenders has been reduced to a
greater extent. With the upcoming of co-operative credit institutions poor people got
their financial needs fulfilled through these institutions.71 Agriculture plays a vital role
in India’s economy, as 54.6 per cent of the population is engaged in agriculture and
allied activities and it contributes 17.4 per cent of the country’s Gross Value Added.72
In Himachal Pradesh, the economy of state is highly dependent on three sources:
agriculture, hydro-electric powers and tourism. Agriculture is the main source of
income and employment in Himachal Pradesh. Agriculture in Himachal Pradesh
provides direct employment to about 62 per cent of its people. Hydro power and
tourism is also one of the major sources of income generation for the state. The
economy of the state also appears to be in a resilient mode in terms of growth. As per
advance estimates the Growth Rate of Gross State Domestic Product (GSDP) during of
2016-17 will be 6.8 per cent against 7.9 per cent at the national level. GSDP or state
income is the most important indicator for measuring the economic growth of a state.
According to the quick estimates based on the new series, Per Capita Income of the
Himachal Pradesh at current prices in 2015-16 stood at Rs. 94,178.73 Income of family
is an important determinant in the election of the state. It is generally said that, money
plays an important role in electoral process of the state politics. The criterion adopted
here for determining the economic status of respondents was to enquire about their
annual income from all sources. The amount of income largely determines the status of
the family in the society and also affects their participation and involvement in politics.
The table shows that distribution of the respondents by their annual income.
71
O.C. Sud, Administration Problems of Rural Development, Delhi: Kanishka Publishing House,
1992, p.102.
72
Government of India, Annual Report, Department of Agriculture, Cooperation and Farmers, New
Delhi: Welfare Ministry of Agriculture and Farmers Welfare Government of India, 2015-16, p.1.
73
Government of Himachal Pradesh, Economic Survey, Shimla: Economics and Statistics Department
Himachal Pradesh, 2016-17, pp.1-13.
231
Table 4.8
Distribution of the Respondents of the Basis of Annual Income
No. of Respondents
Grand Total
Sr.No Annual Income Mandi Kangra
No. % age No. % age No. % age
1 5000-15000 20 13.79 32 21.92 52 17.87
2 15000-25000 31 21.38 44 30.14 75 25.77
3 25000-50000 48 33.10 21 14.39 69 23.71
4 50000-75000 15 10.35 7 4.79 22 7.56
5 75000-one Lac 14 9.66 7 4.79 21 7.22
6 Above one Lac 17 11.72 35 23.97 52 17.87
Total 145 100 146 100 291 100
33.1
30.14
35 Mandi
Kangra
23.97
30
21.92
21.38
25
Percentag (%)
14.39
13.79
20 11.72
10.35
9.66
15
4.79
4.79
10
0
75000-one
Above one
15000
15000-
25000-
50000-
5000-
25000
50000
75000
Lac
Lac
Annual Income
Table 4.8 depicts that out of 291 respondents, 52 respondents were having
annual income Rs. 5000-15000
15000, which constitute 17.87 per cent of the total sample,
while 75 respondents were having income Rs.15000-25000, which constitutes 25.77
per cent of the sample, whereas 69 respondents were having income Rs. 25000-50000,
25000
which constitute 23.71 per cent of the sample,
sample while 22 respondents were having
havin
annual income Rs. 50000-75000
75000, which constitute 7.56 per cent of the sample. There
were 21 respondents were having Rs.75000-One
Rs.75000 Lac, which constitute 7.22 per cent of
232
the sample and 52 respondents were having income above One Lac, which constitute
17.87 per cent of total sample.
The comparative analysis of Mandi and Kangra districts reveals that the power
of politics was in the hand of middle class society in both districts. The study reveals
that most of the respondents came under the low income group. Due to uneconomic
size of holding most of the poor people cultivate only field crops like maize, wheat etc.
They were not able to produce cash crops at large like vegetables such as cabbage,
cauliflower, potato, peas and tomato etc. Due to non-fertile and small land holding, lack
of irrigation facilities and their poor economic standards.
Land Holdings
233
power in the Indian rural society.74 In India, for a long time land ownership played a
very significant role as an element of influence in community power structure, land
ownership is crucial factor in establishing dominance ownership of land not only
insured a stable and secure income but also symbolized high social and economic
status. Generally the pattern of land is concentrated in the hands of a relatively small
number of big owners (Landlord) as against a large number, who either owns very little
land or no land at all.
The power and prestige which land owning castes command, affect their social
and economic relations in the society.75 If land ownership is not always an
indispensable passport to high rank, it certainly facilities upward mobility.76 Land
constitutes the basic foundation of agrarian social structure in India. Whereas, it
determines the nature of occupational and economic activities and the rewards flowing
from them, it also serves as a pointer towards status and prestige in society.77 Land
ownership was a crucial factor in establishing dominance in the village. The pattern of
land ownership in rural India was such that bulk of the arable land was concentrated in
the hands of a relatively small number of big owners, as against a large number, who
either owned very little land or no land at all.78
74
R. Indira and Deepak Kumar Behera (eds.), Gender and Society in India: Rural and Tribal Studies,
Vol. 2, New Delhi: Manak Publications, 1999, p.112.
75
S.S. Chahar (ed.), op.cit., 2005, pp. 406.
76
M.N. Srinivas, Social Change in Modern India, New Delhi: Orient Longman, 1982, pp. 12-13.
77
Dharam Raj Singh, op.cit., 1985, p. 38
78
K.C. Vidya, op.cit., 2007, p.110.
79
D.S. Chaudhary, Emerging Rural Leadership in an Indian State: A Case Study of Rajasthan, Rohtak:
Manthan Publications, 1981, pp. 55-56.
234
operated by 9.61 lac farmers. The average holding size is about 1.00 hectare. About 10
per cent of the total GSDP comes from agriculture
agriculture and its allied sectors.
Table 4.9
Size of Land Holding of the Respondents
No. of Respondents
Land Grand Total
Sr.No Holding Mandi Kangra
(Bighas)
No. % age No. % age No. % age
1 0-10 111 76.55 112 76.71 223 76.63
2 11-20 24 16.55 18 12.33 42 14.43
3 21-30 6 4.14 6 4.11 12 4.13
4 31-40 3 2.07 2 1.37 5 1.72
5 Above 40 1 0.69 8 5.48 9 3.09
Total 145 100 146 100 291 100
76.55
76.71
80
Mandi
70
Kangra
60
Percentage (%)
50
40
16.55
30
12.33
20
5.48
4.14
4.11
2.07
1.37
0.69
10
0
0-10 11-20 21-30 31-40 Above 40
Size of Land Holding
The table 4.9 indicate that out of 291 respondents, 223 respondents whose total
size of land holding was 0-10
0 bighas, which constitute 76.63 per cent of the total
sample, whereas 42 respondents whose size of land holding was 11-20
11 bighas, which
constitute 14.43 per cent of the sample,
sample while 12 respondents whose size of land
holding was 21-30
30 bighas,
bighas which constitute 4.13 per cent of the sample. There were 5
respondents who were having land 31-40
31 bighas, which constitute 1.72 per cent of the
235
sample and 9 respondents who were having land above 40 bighas, which constitute
3.09 per cent of the sample.
In district Mandi out of 145 respondents, 111 respondents whose total size of
land holding was 0-10 bighas, which constitute 76.55 per cent of the total sample,
whereas 24 respondents whose size of land holding was 11-20 bighas, which constitute
16.55 per cent of the sample, while 6 respondents whose size of land holding 21-30
bighas, which constitute 4.14 per cent of the sample. There were 3 respondents who
were having land 31-40 bighas, which constitute 2.07 per cent of the sample and 1
respondent who was having land above 40 bighas, which constitute 0.69 per cent of the
sample.
The comparative study of two district reveals that the size of land holding in the
study areas was very small. Majority of the respondents at all levels were found holding
land below 10 bighas. However, the size of the land holding of the respondents in
Kangra district was slightly better than that of the district Mandi. This shows that
majority of women political activists in Mandi and Kangra districts have their own
land. But the size of land holding is not very large. It was observed that due to the
growth of population, the size of land holding was going down day by day at village
level and poor people compel to sell their land for the requirement of some domestic
social needs. It is evident that the high land holding farmers are minority in comparison
with the large number of small farmers and agricultural labourers, who constitute the
back-bone of the rural population.
Role of Newspaper
Newspaper is a collection of news from all over the world which keeps us up-
to-date about everything going outside. Now-a-days the newspaper has been a necessity
236
of the life. It gives us all about what is happening in our own country as well as whole
world. It is essential to be aware of with day to day happening in the society as well as
at the governmental level. Attempt was made to analyse the awareness of the
respondents in the day to day life. Table shows that the respondents take interest in
reading newspapers daily.
Table 4.10
Respondents
spondents Awareness Role of Newspapers
No. of Respondents
Regarding Grand Total
Sr.No Mandi Kangra
Newspapers
No. % Age No. % Age No. % Age
1 Yes 115 79.31 104 71.24 219 75.26
2 No 26 17.93 35 23.97 61 20.96
3 No Opinion 4 2.76 7 4.79 11 3.78
Total 145 100 146 100 291 100
79.31
71.24
80 Mandi
70
Kangra
60
Percentage (%)
50
23.97
40
17.93
30
20
4.79
2.76
10
0
Yes No No Opinion
Response
Fig.4.10
10: Respondents Awareness Role of Newspapers
Table 4.10 shows that 291 respondents were interviewed regarding their habits
of reading newspapers. Out of which 219 respondents responded positively,
positively which
constitute
te 75.26 per cent of the sample and there were 61 respondents replied
negatively.
y. The percentage of such was 20.96 of the total sample. While 11 respondents
who gave no opinion, which constitute 3.78 per cent of the sample.
237
As far as in district Mandi was concerned, out of 145 respondent’s 115
respondents who responds positively, constitute 79.31 per cent of the sample, which
whereas 26 respondents did not show any interest in the reading of newspapers. The
percentage of such respondents was 17.93 of the sample respectively. There were 4
respondents who gave no opinion, which constitute 2.76 per cent of the sample.
The comparative analysis of the two district shows that the number of
respondents, who were in habit of reading newspaper was higher in district Mandi in
comparisons to district Kangra. Majority of the respondents take interest in the reading
of newspapers.
Media has been the source of shared images and messages relating to political
and social context. India is a multilingual, multiethnic and multi-religious country. In
India, internet and cable television have about meaningful change to public and private
spheres of life more quickly than education, industrialization or any other socio-
economic factor. Electronic media had no role to play for a decade after independence.
Print media and radio served as the primary means of political information and
mobilization. Mass media received a boost in September 1959, as a result of the
introduction of television to urban India. The emergence of television to post-colonial
India was characterized by competing visions, its deeply segmented political sphere
witnessed several rounds of intense debating between politicians and bureaucrats, who
were concerned with the efficacy of investing in television, considering only a few
could manage access to the medium.80
80
Sayantani Satpathi and Oindrila Roy, “The Impact of the Electronic Media on the Modern Indian Voter: A
Study of the Post Liberalization Era”, Global Media Journal, Summer Issue, June 2011, pp. 1-3.
238
restricted to educational and entertainment based programs. In 1991, the Indian
television network was deregulated and cable-satellite network emerged for the first
time from its modest beginning with two channels by June 2010. Moreover, there were
thirty three for hour news channels that would constantly engage in political and
economic debates and conduct opinion/exit polls in election years.81
Radio is a vehicle for projecting personality through which it attracts and hold
an audience. Radio is an efficiency instrument for getting a message to a large number
of people at the same time. Radio is a powerful instrument in the area of public
enlightenment. Not been constrained by the barriers of time space, illiteracy, and
electricity supply, radio is one of the ideal means of mass communication in both
developed and developing societies because it is easy to establish, own operate and
maintain, and does not demand much intellectual exertion from listeners. It is capable
of offering tutorial support and resources to stimulate discussions, reflections and
practical learning on the socio-economic, socio-political and cultural activities of a
society or a nation. The radio has different roles some of which are: Informing Role:
the radio performs the role of keeping women informed. It has an important job in
providing political information to women and the general public. Influencing role: the
media may not always be successful in telling people what to think, but are usually
successful in telling them, what to think about. Mobilising people: through
commentaries and programmes, the radio acts as secondary agents of mobilization. The
radio facilitates and enhances the process by which, individuals partake in collective
decision making. This role is one, the radio adapts through political programmes in
mobilizing women for participation.82
Thus, radio and television play a vital role in the life style of the people. At the
basic level, they inform people about the various things in various ways and through a
variety of programmes. Radio and the television are the most effective media to
achieve the much desired rural development. Radio and television constitute the
effective media for national awareness and the mood of advancement of the society, the
need of the society and the objective of the government as laid down in the national
interest of the country. In the present time television and radio have become an integral
81
Ibid.,
82
Adekoya, Helen Odunola, et al., “The Role of Radio in the Mobilization of Women towards Political
Participation: A Study of Ogun State Nigeria”, Research on Humanities and Social Sciences, Vol. 5,
No. 24, 2015, p.13.
239
part of our life. The people who are sitting in the rural areas are the well aware of day
to day happenings in the state. In the present study, an attempt has been made to know
the opinion of the respondents,
respondents whether they see and hear news in television or in radio.
Table 4.11
Respondents Awareness Role of Radio and Television
No. of Respondents
Regarding Radio Grand Total
Sr.No Mandi Kangra
and Television
No. % Age No. % Age No. % Age
1 Yes 124 85.52 119 81.51 243 83.51
2 No 16 11.03 23 15.75 39 13.40
3 No Opinion 5 3.45 4 2.74 9 3.09
Total 145 100 146 100 291 100
85.52
Mandi
81.51
100
Kangra
80
Percentage (%)
60
15.75
40
11.03
3.45
2.74
20
0
Yes No No Opinion
Response
Table 4.11 reveals that 291 respondents were interviewed, out of which 243
respondents replied positively they were in habit of hearing news in the radio or in the
television, whereas only 39 respondents expressed their ignorance regarding news in
television or in radio
adio and while 9 respondents did not express their opinion. The
percentage of all the three types of respondents was 83.51, 13.40 and 3.09 respectively.
240
the sample, whereas 16 respondents were not in habit of hearing news. The percentage
of such was 11.03 respectively. There were only 5 respondents who gave no opinion
which constitute 3.45 per cent of the sample.
The comparative analysis of two districts Mandi and Kangra depicts that in
district Mandi the respondents were slightly higher in habit of hearing news in
television or in the radio in compared to district Kangra. Hence, it has been revealed
that television and radio programmes are very effective in mobilizing women to
participate in politics. It was observed that there was a tendency among the rural
leaders to hear news in television and radio. These sources gave information about the
state, national and international level. Thus television and radio become an integral part
of our daily life.
Political Interest
83
Jan Leighley, “Participation as a Stimulus of Political Conceptualization”, Journal of Politics, Vol.
53, No. 1, February 1991, p. 190.
84
Joel. D. Schwartz, “Participation and Multisubjective Understanding: An Interpretivist Approach to
the Study of Political Participation”, The Journal of Politics, Vol. 46, 1984, pp. 1128-1129.
241
Political interest is the first
first and psychological component of political
participation. The interest of a person in political institutions, elections, the processes of
struggle for power, political events and national and local issues are important indices
of his psychological participation
ipation in political structure and process. The political
interest of a person does not only reflect his commitment and attachment to state and
polity but also expresses his will to participate and understand their complexities.85
Though, the power struggle is an incessant fact of democratic political life, life no all
members of political community are always and alike involved in it. People are
interested and involved in the country’s politics at all time.86 Mumtaz Soysal defines,defines
“Participation
Participation as all forms of action by which citizens ‘take part’ in the operation of
administration. The taking part refers to any level from macro to micro region or it may
be of any type e.g. advisory in nature or in participate through public or private bodies
or other organizations”.87
Table 4.12
Respondent’s Opinion Regarding Interest in Politics
No. of Respondents
Grand Total
Sr.No Response Mandi Kangra
No. % Age No. % Age No. % Age
1 Yes 85 58.62 94 64.38 179 61.51
2 No 42 28.96 32 21.92 74 25.43
3 No Opinion 18 12.42 20 13.70 38 13.06
Total 145 100 146 100 291 100
64.38
70 58.62
60
Percentage (%)
50
40 28.96
30 21.92 Mandi
20 12.42 13.7 Kangra
10
0
Yes No No Opinion
Response
242
Table 4.12 depicts that out of 291 respondents, 179 respondents were interested
in politics, which constitute 61.51 per cent of the total sample, whereas 74 respondents
were not interested in politics, which constitute 25.43 per cent of the sample, while 38
respondents did not give their opinion, which constitute 13.06 per cent of the sample.
The comparative analysis of both the districts reveals that vast majority of the
respondents in the whole sample 61.51 per cent, as well as individually in Mandi (58.62
%) and Kangra (64.38%) districts were interested in politics. However, the respondents
in Kangra district were found to be slightly more interested in politics, as compared to
Mandi district.
88
S. Waseem Ahmad, et al., “Women’s Political Participation and Changing Pattern of Leadership in
Rural Areas of U.P”, The Indian Journal of Political Science, Vol. 69, No.3, July- September 2008,
p. 664.
89
Vijay Agneu, Elite Women in Indian Politics, New Delhi: Vikas Publishing House, 1986, p. 133.
243
Table 4.13
Politicall Participation of Respondents Father/Husband
F
No. of Respondents
Grand Total
Sr.No Response Mandi Kangra
No. % age No. % age No. % age
1 Yes 57 39.31 53 36.30 110 37.80
2 No 67 46.21 69 47.26 136 46.74
3 No Opinion 21 14.48 24 16.44 45 15.46
Total 145 100 146 100 291 100
47.26
46.21
50 Mandi
39.31
45 Kangra
36.3
40
Percentage (%)
35
30
16.44
25
14.48
20
15
10
5
0
Yes No No Opinion
Response
Table 4.13 shows that out of 291 respondents 110 respondents father/husband
participate in politics, which constitute 37.80 per cent of the total sample, whereas 136
respondents, the father/ husband had no participation in politics, which constitute 46.74
per cent of the sample, while 45 respondents gave no opinion on the question,
question which
constitute 15.46 per cent of the total sample.
244
In district Kangra out of 146 respondents, 53 respondents father/husband
participates in politics, which constitute 36.30 per cent of the total sample, whereas 69
respondents had no participation in politics, which constitute 47.26 per cent of the
sample, while 24 respondents gave no opinion on either side question, which constitute
16.44 per cent of the total sample.
The comparative analysis of the two districts reveals that majority of the
respondent’s father and husband did not participate in politics. However, a few
respondents’ father and husband did participate in political activities. On the other
hand, a very lesser number of the respondents were completely active in politics.
Voting
Voting has a tremendous strength and weakness and has impact for equalizing
and mobilizing women. Yet, it has to be noted that voting requires the least initiative
and interval motivation. Many times women treats the day of voting as a welcome
break from her dull and tiring routine and does not appear to have a notion of, why she
should vote for a particular candidate.
90
Wan Asnal, et al., “Political Attitude and Voting Behaviour”, International Journal of Humanities
and Management Sciences, Vol. 1, No. 1, 2013, p. 126.
91
Sidney Verba, et al., Participation and Political Equality: A Seven-Nation Comparison, New York:
Cambridge University Press, 1978, p. 313.
92
Rashmi Shrivastava, “Minority Representation of a Political Majority Group: Women in Indian
Democratic Process”, The Indian Journal of Political Science, Vol. 66, No.2, April-June 2005, pp.
234-235.
93
Savita Thakur Joshi (ed.), op. cit., 1999, p.148.
245
Though, women’s participation in the political process has increased both in the
elections and their readiness to express their view on issues directly concerning their
life. But their ability to produce an impact on the political process has been negligible
because of the inadequate attention paid to their political education and mobilization by
both political parties and women’s organizations, as political parties see women voters
as appendages of the males. Political parties seem uniformly reluctant to field women
candidates. The high cost of electioneering is another deterrent to most women
candidates. Because of these factors there is an increasing tendency among women to
contest election as independent candidates.94 Political participation denotes such
activities by which the citizens share in choosing the government and directly or
indirectly in the formation of public policy. These activities are voting, seeking
information about the policy of political parties and of the government, attending
election meetings, contributing money to the party or election funds of its candidate,
enrolment in a party, canvassing for a party and working in campaigns. Among these,
making contributions to the party fund, enrolment in a party, canvassing and working in
campaigns are considered to be more active forms of participation. In a democracy, the
citizens’ participation in election is a basic norm. It is the right by which, they grant or
withdraw consent in a democracy.95 Table shows the participation in voting in different
past election.
Table 4.14
No. of Respondents
Grand Total
Sr.No Response Mandi Kangra
No. % Age No. % Age No. % Age
1 Yes 134 92.41 137 93.84 271 93.13
2 No 8 5.52 7 4.79 15 5.15
3 No opinion 3 2.07 2 1.37 5 1.72
Total 145 100 146 100 291 100
94
Rameshwari Pandya (ed.), op.cit., 2008, pp.570-571.
95
Sachchidananda, The Tribal Voter in Bihar, New Delhi: National Publishing House, 1976, p. 36.
246
93.84
92.41
100
Percentage (%) 80
60
Mandi
40
Kangra
5.52
4.79
2.07
1.37
20
0
Yes No No opinion
Response
In district Mandi out of 145 respondents, 134 respondents casted their vote in
last election, which constitute 92.41 per cent of the total sample, whereas 8 respondents
did not cast their vote in the last election,
election which constitute 5.52 per cent of the sample.
There were 3 respondents,
respondents who did not give their opinion about the cast of vote in
election, which constitute 2.07 per cent of the sample.
In district Kangra out of 146 respondents, 137 respondents casted their vote in
last election, which constitute 93.84 per cent of the total sample, whereas 7 respondents
did not cast their vote in the last election,
election which constitute 4.79 per cent of the sample.
There were 2 respondents,
respondents who did not give their opinion about the cast of vote in
election, which constitute 1.37 per cent of the sample.
247
Factors Influence on the Voting
The interest of the voters and accordingly their behaviour at the time of voting
is also influenced by the nature or purpose of the elections or the extent of the suffrage.
The force of charisma has its own part to play, whereby the voters are influenced by a
slogan like “Garibi Hatao”, or “A vote for a pair of bullocks is vote for Panditji and
progress”, or “Indira means India, India means Indira”, or “Indira means Dictatorship,
“My heart beats for India” versus “Rajiv means Bofors” and the like. The role of all
these factors can be examined in the study of Indian electoral behaviour. There are
several factors responsible for voting behaviour in India. In India following are main
political and socio-economic factors, which act as determinants of voting behaviours in
our democratic system. 96 In elections there are so many factors which affect the voting
behaviour, such as candidate, religion, caste, education and political party etc. Table
shows the responses of the respondents regarding the factors, which they keep in mind
while casting their votes.
Table 4.15
Respondents Views Regarding Influence on the Voting
No. of Respondents
Grand Total
Sr.No Response Mandi Kangra
No. % age No. % age No. % age
1 Candidate 60 41.38 64 43.83 124 42.61
2 Religion 00 00 00 00 00 00
3 Caste 18 12.42 11 7.54 29 9.97
4 Education 21 14.48 29 19.86 50 17.18
5 Party 46 31.72 42 28.77 88 30.24
Total 145 100 146 100 291 100
96
Biraj Hazarika, “Voting Behaviour in India and its Determinants”, Journal of Humanities and Social
Science, Vol. 20, No.10, October 2015, pp.22-25.
248
43.83
41.38
Mandi
45
Kangra
40
31.72
28.77
35
Percentage (%)
30
19.86
25
14.48
20
12.42
15
7.54
10
5
0
0
0
Candidate Religion Caste Education Party
Response
Fig.4.15: Respondents
Respond Views Regarding Influence on the Voting
249
while 42 respondents gave importance to political party affiliation of the candidate,
which constitute 28.77 per cent of the sample.
The comparative analysis of the two districts reveals that in majority the
respondents casted their votes in elections, keeping in mind the merits of the candidate.
There were so many factors, which affected the voting behaviour such as caste, religion
political party and education of the candidate. It was observed that the respondents
gave less importance to other factors, while casting their votes.
The election campaign provides another sphere for women to participate in the
political process. The campaign strategy plays an important part in the electoral
process. The partied have organised regular forums, cell to mobilise and campaign
among women. The handbills, posters and public meetings etc. emphasise specific
promises for women. Recognising the significance of women voters, many political
parties of late, are deploying their women workers as campaigners to deal with women
voters. Women campaigners are sent for house to house visits. They usually enjoy the
advantage of mixing freely with all the members of the family during such visits.
However, it is obvious that the numbers of women are engaged in this sort of activity.
They attend a meeting only for a short time. It appears that, broadcasts through radio
and television also have been effective among women to an extent. Propaganda,
97
Sidney Verba and Norman H. Nie, Participation in America: Political Democracy and Social
Equality, New York: Harper and Row, 1972, p. 52.
98
B. B. Jena and J. K. Baral, Election Politics and Voting Behaviour in India, Delhi: Discovery
Publishing House, 1989, p.140.
99
K.S. Pandhy and Purna Chandra Satapathy, Tribal India, New Delhi: Ashish Publishing House, 1989, p. 103.
250
publicity slogans and symbols generally kindle the interest of the illiterate women
voters.100
Table 4.16
Respondents Views Regarding Participation of Women in Campaign Activities
No. of Respondents Grand
Sr.No Campaign Activities Mandi Kangra Total
No. % age No. % age No. %age
Door to Door Campaigning with
1 70 48.27 69 47.26 139 47.77
in Village/Town
Campaigning outside the
2 8 5.52 20 13.69 28 9.62
Village/Town
3 Preparing Sticking Posters 8 5.52 10 6.85 18 6.18
4 Addressing Public Meeting 7 4.83 8 5.48 15 5.16
5 All the above 52 35.86 39 26.72 91 31.27
Total 145 100 146 100 291 100
100
Kalpana Roy, Women and their Environment, Vol.1, Delhi: Rajat Publications, 1999, pp. 241-242.
101
Praveen Rai, “Electoral Participation of Women in India: Key Determinants and Barriers”, Economic
and Political Weekly, Vol. 46, No. 3, January 2011, pp. 50-51.
251
48.27
47.26
Mandi
50
Kangra
35.86
40
26.72
Percentage (%)
30
13.69
20
6.85
5.52
5.52
5.48
4.83
10
0
Door to Door Campaigning Preparing Addressing All the above
Campaigning outside the Sticking Public
with in Village/Town Posters Meeting
Village/Town
Response
Fig.4.16: Respondents Views Regarding Participation of Women in Campaign
Activities
252
Further, there were 52 respondents who took part in all activities in campaigning,
which constitute 35.86 per cent of the sample.
The comparative analysis of the two districts reveals that majority of the
respondents take part in door to door campaigning with in village/town. Mandi district
was highly active in take part in campaigning as compared to district Kangra. It was
observed that women took part in door to door campaigning to elections. A person who
canvases for a party or a candidate or took active part in various campaign activities,
they were more involved in politically. Many younger women were becoming involved
in politics in more informal ways, such as social media campaigns.
In the present study an attempt has been made to know the opinion of the
respondents’ views regarding, won the election in first time.
Table 4.17
Respondents Views With Regard to Winning the Election
No. of Respondents
Grand Total
Sr.No Response Mandi Kangra
No. % Age No. % Age No. % Age
1 Yes 120 82.76 126 86.30 246 84.53
2 No 22 15.17 16 10.96 38 13.06
3 No Opinion 3 2.07 4 2.74 7 2.41
Total 145 100 146 100 291 100
253
86.3
82.76
90 Mandi
80
Kangra
70
Percentage (%)
60
50
40
15.17
10.96
30
2.74
2.07
20
10
0
Yes No No Opinion
Response
Fig.4.17: Respondents Views With Regard to Winning the Election
In district Mandi, out of 145 respondents 120 respondents won the election first
time, which constituted 82.76
76 per cent of the total sample, whereas 22 respondents who
did not win the election, which constitute 15.17 per cent of the sample. There were 3
respondents who gave no opinion,
opinion which constitute 2.07 per cent of the total sample.
In district Kangra, out of 146 respondents 126 respondents won the election first
time, which constituted 86.30 per cent of the total sample, whereas 16 respondents who
did not win the election, which constitute 10.96 per cent of the sample. There were 4
respondents who gave no opinion,
opinion which constitute 2.74 per cent of the total sample.
254
Institutions are the essentially institutions of concern masses for the masses and their
success depends on the people’s participation.102 The 73rd amendment act provided
reservation of seats for women and this has raised new hopes. Achieving the goal of
equal participation of women and men in decision-making will provide a balance that
more accurately reflects the composition society and is needed in order to strengthen
democracy and to promote its proper functioning. Women’s equal participation in
decision-making is not only a demand for simple justice or democracy but can also
seen as a necessary condition for women’s interests to taken into account. Without
active participation women at all levels of decision-making, the goal of equality,
development and peace cannot be achieved.103 Political participation of women is an
important determinant of their modernization. It enables women to come out of the
shackles of tradition and secluded life. It also leads to greater social and political
awareness among women. Women in politics could effectively represent opinions of
other women and also understand and deal effectively with the problems of society in
general and women in particular. Political participation of women equips them with
political competence, organizational abilities and belief in egalitarianism and
democratic planning.104 In the present study an attempt has been made to know the
opinion of the respondents by the level of their participation.
Table 4.18
Level of Political Participation of the Respondents
No. of Respondents
Grand Total
Sr.No Response Mandi Kangra
No. % Age No. % Age No. % Age
1 Village level 107 73.79 101 69.18 208 71.48
2 Block Level 20 13.79 20 13.69 40 13.74
3 District Level 18 12.42 25 17.13 43 14.78
4 State Level 00 00 00 00 00 00
5 National Level 00 00 00 00 00 00
Total 145 100 146 100 291 100
102
D. Sundar Ram, “Rural Development”, Third Concept, Vol. 14, No. 158, April 2004, p. 41.
103
S. Nagendra Ambedkar and Shilaja Nagendra (eds.), Women Empowerment and Panchayati Raj,
Jaipur: ABD Publishers, 2005, p. 200.
104
R. Indira and Deepak Kumar Behera (eds.), op.cit., 1999, p.122.
255
73.79
69.18
80
Mandi
70
Kangra
60
Percentage (%)
50
40
17.13
30
13.79
13.69
12.42
20
10
0
0
0
0
0
Village level Block Level District Level State Level National
Level
Response
256
Age at the Time of First
irst Election
Table 4.19
Respondents view
vie Regarding Age at the Time of First
irst Election
No. of Respondents
Grand Total
Sr.No Years Mandi Kangra
No. % Age No. % Age No. % Age
1 18-25 17 11.73 1 0.69 18 6.19
2 26-40 101 69.65 84 57.53 185 63.57
3 41-55 24 16.55 49 33.56 73 25.09
4 Above 55 3 2.07 12 8.22 15 5.15
Total 145 100 146 100 291 100
69.65
Mandi
70
57.53 Kangra
60
Percentage (%)
50
40 33.56
30
16.55
20 11.73
8.22
10 0.69 2.07
0
18-25 26-40 41-55 Above 55
Age in Years
105
Usha Kiran, op.cit., 2016, p.121.
257
the sample, whereas 185 respondents contested the elections for the first time at the age
of 26-40 years, which constitute 63.57 per cent. There were 73 respondents who
contested election for the first time at the age of 41-55 years and 15 respondents
contested election for the first time at the age of above 55 years. The percentage of such
respondents was 25.09 and 5.15 of the sample respectively.
The comparative analysis of two district reveals that majority of the respondents
contested election for the first time at the age of 26-40 years. In district Mandi 69.65
per cent of the respondents contested election for the first time at the age 26-40 years,
as compared to district Kangra 57.53 percent.
Motivation Factor
106
G. Palanithurai, Contemporary Issues in Development Dynamics, New Delhi: Kanishka Publishers,
1999, pp.197-200.
258
Consequently, one of the key factors that determine their high levels of
participation in casting their votes is women’s interest in politics. Women’s interest in
politics is a pre-requisite for encouraging higher participation of women in formal
politics. Individual socio-demographics including education and income, socio-cultural
norms and caste are also associated with women’s opportunities in political
participation. Women’s level of participation in electoral politics depends on their
societal background and the levels of liberty and freedom enjoyed by them. Thus
women who exercise their own discretion in deciding whom to vote for, shows a higher
level of electoral competition as voters in electoral competition than those, whose
decisions are influenced by family and friends.107
However, women in India enjoy a unique status of equality with the men as per
constitutional and legal provision. But the Indian women have come a long way to
achieve the present positions. Reservation has resulted in bringing a novel group of
women representative into Panchayati Raj Institutions. With the provision of 73rd
Amendment, women representatives have ample scope for involvement in the process
of local government.108 Women have taken initiatives to evolve an able leader, the
support of family, self-confidence and society were major factors promoting her.109
Table show the respondent’s opinion regarding motivation factor of respondents to
contest the election.
Table 4.20
Respondents Opinion With Regard Motivation Factors
No. of Respondents
Grand Total
Sr.No Response Mandi Kangra
No. % age No. % age No. % age
1 Your Own Decision 42 28.97 38 26.03 80 27.49
2 Family Members 59 40.69 62 42.47 121 41.58
3 Friends/Relatives 18 12.41 8 5.48 26 8.94
4 Political Party 14 9.66 15 10.27 29 9.96
5 Others 12 8.27 23 15.75 35 12.03
Total 145 100 146 100 291 100
107
Praveen Rai, op.cit., 2011, p. 52.
108
Dasarathi Bhuyan, “Particpation in Panchayati Raj”, Yojana, Vol. 52, October 2008, p. 36.
109
S. Waseem Ahmad, et al., op.cit., 2008, pp. 670-671.
259
42.47
40.69
Mandi
50
Kangra
28.97
26.03
40
Percentage (%)
15.75
30
12.41
10.27
9.66
8.27
20
5.48
10
0
Response
Fig.4.20: Respondents’
pondents’ Opinion With Regard Motivation Factors
260
whereas 62 respondents believed that family motivated them to contest the elections,
which constitute 42.47 per cent of the sample, while 8 respondents believed that their
friends and relatives motivated them to contest the elections, which constitute 5.48 per
cent of the respondents. There were 15 respondents which believed that political parties
motivated them to contest the elections, which constitute 10.27 per cent of the sample
and 23 respondents contested the election due to some others factors like reservation of
seats for women in Panchayati Raj Institutions and Municipalities, which constitute
15.75 per cent of the sample.
The comparative analysis of two districts reveals that the number of respondents
who believed that they were motivated by their family. Mandi district respondents were
less motivated by their family as compared to district Kangra. It was observed that
women got motivation from the family and relatives. There were some other factors i.e.
interest and political parties. These factors influence women to take part in politics.
261
They secure peoples participation in public affairs, ensure orderly transfer of power and
the authority of government with legitimacy. It provides
provide an opportunity to the people to
express their faith in the government from time to time and change it.
it When
W needed
much more significant, they highlight and dramatize a political system and open up
channels between the polity and the society, between the elite
elite and the masses and
between the individual and government. The Indian Constitution makers have given a
great importance to the electoral process. Therefore, many provisions have been made
in the constitution for a free and fair electoral process.112 The election system is a
political device through which,
which the modern state creates among its citizens a sense of
involvement and participation in public affairs.113 Table shows the categories of the
seats on which the respondents contested the election.
Table 4.21
Respondents View Regarding Elections Contested on the Seats
No. of Respondents
Grand Total
Sr.No Response Mandi Kangra
No. %Age No. %Age No. %Age
1 Reserved for Women 71 48.96 55 37.67 126 43.29
2 Reserved for SCs Women 67 46.21 39 26.71 106 36.43
3 Reserved for STs Women 2 1.38 11 7.54 13 4.47
4 Reserved for OBCs Women 5 3.45 41 28.08 46 15.81
Total 145 100 146 100 291 100
48.96
46.21
37.67
50
45
28.08
40
26.71
Percentage (%)
35
30
25
20 Mandi
7.54
15
3.45
Kangra
1.38
10
5
0
Reserved for Reserved for Reserved for Reserved for
Women SCs Women STs Women OBCs Women
Response
112
Tara, “Electoral Process in India”,
India Vidhanmala, Year 7, No.1, June 2014, p. 45.
113
Kalpana Roy, op.cit., 1999, p. 87.
262
It is clear from the above table 4.21 that out of 291 respondents, 126
respondents contested the election from the reserved seat for women, which constitute
43.29 per cent of the sample, while 106 respondents contested from the reserved for
SCs women, which constitute 36.43 per cent of the sample. There were 13 respondents
who contested elections from the reserved category for STs, which constitute 4.47 per
cent of the sample and 46 respondents contested election for OBCs women, which
constitute 15.81 per cent of the sample.
The comparative analysis of the two district reveals the categories of the seats
on, which the respondents contested the elections. Majority of the respondents in whole
sample 43.29 per cent, in Mandi district 48.46 per cent and in Kangra district 37.67 per
cent contested the elections from the reserved seats for women. This percentage further
increased in the respondents, who contested the elections from the seats reserved for
SCs women. It was observed that women generally get an opportunity to contest the
elections only on those seats, which are reserved for women.
The public rallies, protest, strikes and bandh calls are the important modes of
political participation. Participation in processions, rallies, demonstrations and
contacting party leaders and members of the bureaucracy are quite important activities
263
in the sense thatt these not only introduce a person into politics but also enable him to
influence decision-making.
making. Strikes, dharnas, riots, political assassinations, non-voting,
non
gheraos and other anomic activities,
activities which though old have been inducted into the
political process.114 Political participation through strikes/protests/ bandh call are such
activities, which include demonstration, riots and other form of civil violence through
which citizens try to pressurize or intimate the government.115 Table shows that,
that
responses of the respondents regarding their participating in public rallies.
Table 4.22
Participation in Strikes/Protest/Bandh Calls
No. of Respondents
Grand Total
Sr.No Response Mandi Kangra
No. % age No. % age No. % age
1 Yes 87 60.00 93 63.69 180 61.86
2 No 41 28.28 39 26.72 80 27.49
3 No Opinion 17 11.72 14 9.59 31 10.65
Total 145 100 146 100 291 100
70 63.69
60 Mandi
60 Kangra
50
Percentage (%)
40
28.28 26.72
30
20 11.72
9.59
10
0
Yes No No Opinion
Response
114
S. Bhatnagar, Political Theory,, New Delhi: Meenakashi Prakashan, 1984, p. 280.
115
Ali Ashraf and L. N. Sharma, Political Sociology,
Sociology Madras: Universities Press, 1983, p. 144.
264
It is evident from the table 4.22 that out of 291 respondents, 180 respondents
participated in strikes/protests/bandh calls, which constitutes 61.86 per cent. However
80 respondents were not participated in strikes/protests/bandh calls. The percentage of
such respondents was 27.49. There were 31 respondents, did not give their opinion
about participation in strikes/protests/bandh calls, which constitutes 10.65 per cent of
the sample.
The comparative analysis of the two districts reveals that majority of the
respondents participated in strike/protest/bandh calls. It was observed that these are the
important modes of political participation in political process.
Media is considered as the fourth pillar of the society and democratic medium
of information. Media has the power to pressurize and criticize the drawbacks of
democracy. The electronic media particularly television, has become the most
influential medium of mass communication in India. It is high time now that women
should get a respectable and dignified position in the Indian society. Awareness in the
women as well as society should be created and their equal rights should be effectively
implemented. In the era of globalization and with revolution in means of
communication and information technology, the media role has become more crucial
for women empowerment in India.116
116
Purnima Ojha, “Women’s Issues in India: Role and Importance of Media”, The Indian Journal of
Political Science, Vol. 72, No. 1, January-March 2011, pp. 98-101.
265
The mass media-often referred to as just, the media-are usually understood with
reference to the printed press and to radio and television broadcasters. In recent years,
the definition has perhaps become broader, encompassing internet, mobile phones,
social media, such as blogs and micro-blogs, social networking websites like facebook,
video-sharing sites, such as You Tube and others. There is no doubt that the media play
a very significant role in the life of all human societies. It provides the conduit
necessary for all kinds of communication that helps societies to exist and function.
media play the very essential role of ensuring that information vital to the existence,
and balanced manner. The media can also play a more specific part in enabling full
government. Media also provides information about the constituencies and various
human development index parameters, offering chances for people to comment on the
work done by their elected representatives and providing feedbacks to the candidate.
Emerging as a potentially powerful force, electronic media has also been playing a
similar role to that of print media in conducting free and fair elections.117 It is of course
a well known fact that better informed persons would be more aware and will
participate more in politics than the less formed ones. Information enhances the
knowledge about politics, political objects and working of the political system. While
political parties are a good source of political information, people can get information’s
through a variety of media sources. Citizens learn about politics and the government
from the news, they watch on television, read newspapers and from on social media.
117
Gurpreet Randhawa, “Role of the Media in Indian Electoral Process”, Vidhanmala, Year 7, No. 1,
June 2014, pp. 70-71.
118
Rahul Verma and Shreyas Sardeshari, “Does Media Exposure Affect Voting Behaviours
and Political Preference in India”, Economic and Politically Weekly, Vol. 49, No. 39, September
2014, p. 83.
266
Table 4.23
Source of Political Information of the Respondents
No. of Respondents
Grand Total
Sr.No Response Mandi Kangra
No. % age No. % age No. % age
1 Members of the Family 38 26.21 25 17.13 63 21.65
2 News Papers 11 7.59 13 8.91 24 8.25
3 Radio 19 13.10 20 13.69 39 13.40
4 Television 58 40.00 65 44.52 123 42.27
5 Others 19 13.10 23 15.75 42 14.43
Total 145 100 146 100 291 100
44.52
Mandi
50
40
Kangra
40
26.21
Percentage (%)
30
17.13
13.69
13.1
20
8.91
7.59
10
0
Members of the News Papers Radio Television
Family
Response
267
respondents got political information from other sources, which constitute 14.43 per
cent of the sample.
The comparative analysis of the both district reveals that the main sources of
political information were television, newspaper, radio and social media. In district
Kangra 44.52 per cent and in districts Mandi 40.00 per cent respondents seek
information from television followed by family members, reading newspaper, radio and
other sources. It was observed that in both districts majority of the respondents seek
information from television. These sources gave political information to the women
and made them aware about their rights and got information about the state, national
and international levels. It can have a huge influence on election outcomes.
Party Affiliation
A party in the most general sense of the word is a body of persons, who are
united in opinion or action, as distinguished from or opposed to the rest of a community
268
or association.119 Political parties are groups organized for the purpose of achieving and
exercising power within a political system. The roles of political parties are inevitable
in a parliamentary system. Parties are playing a key role in democracy in the world.
The 20th century saw the spread of political parties throughout the entire world. Modern
political parties are institutions that can function in widely divergent political
situations. 120 Maciver defined political party as “an association organised in support of
some principle or the policy, which by constitutional means endeavours to make the
determinant of the government”. This definition focussed attention on the associated
and the organised aspects of a political party, while bringing about the rational for its
existence in terms of some guiding principle or policy and linking the same to political
power as exercised by the government. Political parties are the closely connected with
government, and thus, in decision-making position. The parties furnish the government
with personnel. In order to socialise the masses effective, every political party must
have competent leadership. Party workers or cadres must establish contacts with the
people on a regular basis so as to aggregate and articulate their interests, educate them
politically, and thereby, secure their support for the party. The party officers and
workers aim at imbibing the ordinary members with the party spirit, imparting party
ideologies and motivating them to be active in implementation of party programmes.121
119
Edwin R.A. Seligman, “Parties, Political”, Encyclopedia of Social Science, New York: The
Macmillan Publishing Company, Vol. 11-12, 1959, p. 590.
120
New Encyclopedia Britannica, Inc. William Benton, New York: William Benton Publishers, Vol. 14,
New York, 1943, p. 677.
121
Niroj Sinha, Women in Indian Politics, New Delhi: Gyan Publishing House, 2006, p.142.
122
A.K. Majumdar and Bhanwar Singh, Panchayat Politics and Community Development, New Delhi:
Radha Publications, 1996, pp.118-134.
269
changes. Further, the working of the party system as well as the role of political leaders
significantly, influences the process of modernization so as crucial to developing
society like India. The development of Indian party system can be traced to the freedom
movement days, which resulted in the wide-ranging political recruitment, vast political
socialisation and mobilisation of the masses.123
123
Pratap Chandra Swain, “Dynamics of the Indian Party System”, The Indian Journal of Political
Science, Vol. 69, No. 1, January-March 2008, pp. 59- 60.
124
P.V. Krishna, “Participation and Awareness of Elected Women Representatives in PRIs”, Voice of
Research, Vol. 2, No.4, March 2014, p. 46.
125
Rajshree Dutta, “Measuring Party System Change in India: An Analysis at the National and at the
Level of States, 1952-2009”, The Indian Journal of Political Science, Vol.72, No.3, July-
September 2011, p. 661.
126
Kalpna Roy, op.cit., 1999, p. 150.
127
Pooja Singh, “Representation of Women in Indian Politics”, Third Concept, Vol. 28, No. 327, May
2014, pp. 48-50.
270
example, Indian National Congress, Bhartiya Janta Party, Samajwadi Party, Communist
Party, Communist Party of India (Marxist) and some other parties.128 Table deals with
party affiliation to leadership
leader at the politics.
Table 4.24
Parties Affiliation of the Respondents
60 Mandi
Kangra
50
37.67
33.79
Percentage (%)
40
30
20
7.58
6.16
3.42
10
2.07
1.38
0.69
0
Indian Bhartiya Janta CPI BSP Others
National Party
Congress Party Affiliation
128
Ramesh Kumar, “Political Parties in India and the United Sates: A Comparative Analysis”,
Analysis” The
Indian Journal of Political Science, Vol. 72, No. 2, April-June 2011, pp. 555-556.
556.
271
Table 4.24 shows that all 145 respondents were interviewed from Mandi district
and 146 respondents were interviewed in district Kangra. Out of 291 respondents, 156
respondents were affiliated with the Indian National Congress Party, which constitutes
53.61 per cent of the sample, whereas 104 respondents were affiliated with the BJP,
which constitute 35.74 per cent of the sample. There were hardly a few 3 respondents,
who were affiliated with CPI. The percentages of such respondents were 1.03 per cent
of the sample, while 8 respondents were affiliated with the BSP, which constitute 2.75
per cent of the sample. There were 20 respondents who were not active in any political
party, which constitute 6.87 per cent of the sample.
The comparative analysis of the both districts reveals that political party plays
an important role in determining women’s participation in politics. It is evident from
the table 4.24 that on an average percentage of the respondents got membership of
political parties. Majority of the respondents in both district were the members of the
Congress Party. It was observed that some respondents tried to hide their political
affiliation.
272
Type of Party Membership
129
Ibid.,
130
Gabriel A. Almond and G. Bingham Powell, Comparative Politics: A Developmental Approach,
New Dehli: Amerind Publishers, 1975, pp. 98-100.
131
Bhawana Jharta, Women and Politics in India: Impact of Family and Education on Women Political
Activists, New Delhi: Deep and Deep Publications, 1998, p. 101.
132
Lester W. Milbrath, Political Participation: How and Why do People Get Involved in Politics?, 1st
edition, Chicago: Rand McNally, 1965, p. 25.
133
Lester W. Milbrath and M.L. Goel, Political Participation How and Why do People Get Involved in
Politics, 2nd edition, Chicago: Rand McNally Publication, 1977, p. 33.
273
Table 4.25
Respondents Opinion about Type of Party Membership
No. of Respondents
Grand Total
Sr.No Response Mandi Kangra
No. % age No. % age No. % age
1 Active 80 55.17 84 57.53 164 56.36
2 Inactive 58 40.00 57 39.04 115 39.52
3 No Opinion 7 4.83 5 3.43 12 4.12
Total 145 100 146 100 291 100
57.53 Mandi
60 55.17
Kangra
50
40 39.04
Percentage (%)
40
30
20
10 4.83 3.43
0
Active Inactive No Opinion
Response
Table 4.25 shows that out of 291 respondents, 164 respondents were the active
member of political parties, which constitute 56.36 per cent of the total sample.
Whereas, 115 respondents who were inactive member of political parties,
parties which
constitute 39.52 per cent of the sample, while 12 respondents who did not give their
opinion about the membership of political
politic parties, which constitute 4.12 per cent of the
sample.
274
Whereas, 58 respondents who were inactive member of political parties, which
constitute 40.00 per cent of the sample, while 7 respondents who did not give their
opinion about the membership of political parties, which constitute 4.83 per cent of the
sample.
The comparative analysis of the both district reveals that in Kangra 57.53 per
cent of the respondents were active members of political parties as compare to Mandi
district (55.17%). It is found that in both districts women had active membership and
were office bearers of different political parties. Almost all political parties set up a
women’s cell or wing but they worked as ancillary bodies. Very few women were able
to capture seats of power. The number of women in the legislatures remained very
small. Very few women reached the position of party president or leader of legislative
party. More recently, major political parties have indeed made conscious efforts to
induct more women into the various levels of the party organisation.
Table 4.26
Views Regarding Financial Contribution to a Party/Candidate
No. of Respondents
Grand Total
Sr.No Response Mandi Kangra
275
64.83 Mandi
70
Kangra
58.91
60
50
Percentage (%)
38.35
40 33.79
30
20
10 2.74
1.38
0
Yes No No Opinion
Response
Fig.4.26: Views Regarding Financial Contribution to a Party/Candidate
It is evident of the table 4.26 that out of 291 respondents, 105 respondents who
contributed financially
ancially to a party/candidates,
party/ which constitute 36.08 per cent of the
total sample. Whereas 180 respondents did not contribute financially to any party or
candidate, which constitute 61.86 per cent of the sample. There were 6 respondents
who did not express any opinion about the financial contribution to a party
part or
candidate, which constitute 2.06 per cent of the sample.
The comparative
ve analysis of the two district reveals financial contributions
contribution to a
party or candidate. In district
strict Kangra (38.35%)
(38.35%) respondents who contributed
contribute financially
276
to a party or candidate as compared to Mandi district (33.79%). Majority of the
respondents did not contribute financially to any party/candidate. It was observed that
the majority of the respondents in the sample were not financially self-sufficient.
Voluntary Organizations are not merely the provider of social services to the
needy persons but are actively involved in accelerating the process of development. At
many places, they are an important link between the people and the administration. All
voluntary organisations are positive genuine, authentic and committed to development.
Voluntary organisations are charitable, service delivery, welfare oriented, relief and
rehabilitation type of voluntary organisation, which primarily work at the grass-roots
level to alleviate sufferings of the poor and the marginalised, to respond to failure in
government service by filling gaps in social services delivery and in the welfare of the
weaker sections.134
Table 4.27
Respondents Views Regarding Membership of Voluntary Organisations
No. of Respondents
Grand Total
Sr.No Response Mandi Kangra
No. % age No. % age No. % age
1 Yes 118 81.38 110 75.34 228 78.35
2 No 25 17.24 28 19.18 53 18.21
3 No Opinion 2 1.38 8 5.48 10 3.44
Total 145 100 146 100 291 100
134
R. Srinivsan, “Emerging Trends in NGO Sector: A Study of Tamil Nadu”, The Indian Journal of
Political Science, Vol. 66, No.2, April-June 2005, pp. 273-274.
135
Ibid., p. 276.
277
Mandi
90 81.38
Kangra
75.34
80
70
Percentage (%)
60
50
40
30
17.24 19.18
20
5.48
10 1.38
0
Yes No No Opinion
Response
Table 4.27 shows that out of 291 respondents, 228 respondents were members
of one or the other voluntary organisations,
organisation which constitute 78.35 per cent of the total
sample. Whereas, 53 respondents were not the members of voluntary organisations,
organisations
which constitute 18.21 per cent of the sample. There were 10 respondents who did not
give their opinion about the member of the voluntary organisations,
organisations which constitute
3.44 per cent of the sample.
The district Mandi was concerned, out of 145 respondents, 118 respondents
were members of one or the other voluntary
volunt organisations, which constitute 81.38 per
cent of the total sample. Whereas,
Whereas 25 respondents were not the members of voluntary
organisations, which constitute 17.24 per cent of the sample. There were 2 respondents
who did not give their opinion about the member of the voluntary organisations,
organisations which
constitute 1.38 per cent of the sample.
278
The comparative analysis of the two district reveals that majority of the
respondents were the members of one or other organisations. In district Mandi
percentage was higher with (81.38%) percent of the respondents who have the some
knowledge of the different economic and social organisations or associations working
for the welfare and uplift of women as compared to district Kangra (75.34%). It was
found that these organisation uplift women in all fields. There was a great influence of
family upon membership in voluntary organisations. Voluntary organisations attracted
rich people more than the poor. They solve their problems as well as, to serve the
weaker sections of the society.
136
S.P. Varma and Iqbal Narain, Voting Behaviour in Changing Society, Delhi: National Publishing
House, 1973, p. 276.
137
Praveen Rai, op.cit, 2011, p. 51.
279
Table 4.28
Respondents Views on Attending Party/Organisational Meetings
No. of Respondents
Grand Total
Sr.No Response Mandi Kangra
No. % age No. % age No. % age
1 Yes 103 71.03 100 68.49 203 69.75
2 No 28 19.31 37 25.34 65 22.34
3 No Opinion 14 9.66 9 6.17 23 7.91
Total 145 100 146 100 291 100
Mandi
80 71.03
68.49 Kangra
70
60
Percentage (%)
50
40
30 25.34
19.31
20
9.66
6.17
10
0
Yes No No Opinion
Response
It is evident from the table 4.28 that out of 291 respondents, 203 respondents
attended party and organizational meeting regularly,
regularly which constitute 69.75
75 per cent of
the total sample. Whereas 65 respondents did not attend the meeting regularly,
regularly which
constitute 22.34 per cent of the sample. There were 23 respondents who had no opinion
about attending the meetings, which constitute 7.91
91 per cent of the sample.
280
Similarly in district Kangra, out of 146 respondents, 100 respondents attended
party and organizational meeting regularly, which constitute 68.49 per cent of the total
sample. Whereas 37 respondents did not attend the meeting regularly, which constitute
25.34 per cent of the sample. There were 9 respondents who had no opinion about
attending the meetings, which constitute 6.17 per cent of the sample.
The comparative analysis of the two district depicts that majority of respondents
attended the party/organizational meeting regularly. In district Mandi the number of
respondents (71.03%) attending party and organizational meeting, was higher as
compared to Kangra district 68.49%). It was found that majority of the respondents had
accepted that they raised their voice on various issues in the meetings.
138
M. P. Dubbey and Munni Padalia (eds.), Democratic Decentralisation and Panchayati Raj in India,
New Delhi: Anamika Publishers, 2002, p. 96.
281
the appointment of G.V.K. Rao Committee (1985), L. M. Singhvi Committee (1986),
Chief Secretaries Conference (1988), Thungon Committee (1988) and the introduction
of constitution (Sixty-fourth) Amendment Bill, 1989. Therefore P. V. Narsimha Rao,
who became Prime Minister in 1991, was able to get the 73rd Amendment enacted in
1992 by building a consensus in its favour. The 73rd Amendment not only gave a
constitutional status to the Panchayati Raj Institutions but also provided for its uniform
structure in all the states. This amendment also made provisions for the increase in the
powers and resources of these institutions. 139 With a view to bring law relating to the
Panchayats in conformity with provisions of the 73rd Constitutional Amendment Act,
the Himachal Pradesh Panchayati Raj Act, 1968 has replaced and the Himachal Pradesh
Panchayati Raj Act, 1994 was enacted with effect from April 23, 1994.140
Any institution’s innovation, which does not reach the common man and fails to
ameliorate the conditions of the people, does not serve anything, but results in futile
experiment. The Panchayati Raj system, looked at from a historical perspective, has
had its ups and downs. Various forces have worked against the system, despite its
inbuilt strength and advantages to suit the nation. For the successful working of the
Panchayati Raj system, people’s participation is considered very important and an
effort is always made to educate the masses for their full participation and active
involvement. So, people’s perception of Panchayati Raj is an important yardstick.
Absence of awareness of the system in general and the institutions as well as their
functions in particular would result in slow progress or no progress.141 The 73rd Act is
landmark legislation, which has brought empowerment of the Panchayati Raj
Institutions and has ensured the transfer of power from the state to the Panchayati Raj
Institutions to be exercised by the people.142 Thus empowering women is one of the
major issues of Indian polity and Himachal Pradesh government today. Women can be
empowered through the knowledge and the working of Gram Sabha under the
Himachal Pradesh Panchayati Raj Act, 1994. The awareness of the new Panchayati Raj
Act is given in the table as follows:
139
Ibid., pp. 96-97.
140
Simi Agnihotri and Vijay Singh, “Women Empowerment through Reservation in Panchayati Raj
Institutions in Himachal Pradesh”, Indian Journal of Public Administration, Vol. 60, No.3, July-
September 2014, p. 418.
141
K.C Vidya, op.cit., 2007, pp.138-139.
142
Mathew C. Kunnumkal, “Grassroots Level Democracy in Indian an Assessment”, Yojana, Vol. 55,
February 2011, p. 6.
282
Table 4.29
Respondents Awareness with Regard to the Panchayati Raj Act
No. of Respondents
Grand Total
Sr.No Response Mandi Kangra
No. % age No. % age No. % age
1 Yes 57 39.31 60 41.09 117 40.21
2 No 61 42.07 64 43.84 125 42.95
3 No Opinion 27 18.62 22 15.07 49 16.84
Total 145 100 146 100 291 100
43.84
42.07
41.09
39.31
45
40
35
30
18.62
Percentage (%)
25
15.07
Mandi
20
15 Kangra
10
5
0
Yes No No Opinion
Response
Fig.4.29: Respondents
Respondents Awareness with Regard to the Panchayati Raj Act
It is evident from the table 4.29 that out 291 respondents, 117 respondents were
fully aware of the Himachal Pradesh Panchayati
Panchayat Raj Act, which constitute 40.21 of the
total sample. Whereas 125 respondents were not aware about this act,
act which constitute
42.95 per cent
ent of the sample.
sam There were 49 respondents held no opinion on either side.
The percentage
age of such respondents was 16.84 of the total sample.
283
As far as in district Kangra was concerned, out of 146 respondents, 60
respondents were fully aware of the Himachal Pradesh Panchayati Raj Act, which
constitute 41.09 of the total sample. Whereas, 64 respondents were not aware about this
act, which constitute 43.84 per cent of the sample. There were 22 respondents having
no opinion, which constitute 15.07 per cent of the sample.
The comparative analysis of the two districts reveals that in district Kangra the
elected women representatives were more aware about Panchayati Raj System in
comparison to district Mandi. It was clear from the table, women to a certain extent
were aware of the functioning of Panchayati Raj Act. But most of the women were
unaware of the functioning of Panchayati Raj System.
India is perhaps the first country to recognise the social fact underlined by
Lenin on the International Working Women’s Day in 1921. There has been taken
concrete measures to draw women into leadership positions and thereby into politics by
giving them one third reservation, in what may now be called the third tier of
governance the Panchayati Raj. The constitutional amendment providing one-third
representation to women in elected bodies as well as reserving one third of the offices
of chairpersons for them will have far-reaching consequences in Indian political and
social life.143 The 73rd Amendment to the Indian Constitution aimed at the
empowerment of women by making provision for the reservation of one-third share for
women in the Panchayati Raj Institutions.144
The 73rd Amendment has created silent revolution in the country. It has created
appropriate social, economic and political conditions that enabled women participation
in the local government institutions. Additionally, this is also of great significance as
women have a definite voice in the process of governance.145 Women reservation
(33%) has been provided by the Amendment in Panchayati Raj Act 1994, and
Himachal Pradesh Panchayati Raj Amendment Act, 2008 has provided 50 per cent
reservation of seats for women in PRIs and urban local bodies, which is a historical
step for the political empowerment of women. The experiment of 50 per cent
143
Ajit Pal Singh, “Women’s Participation at the Grassroot Level: An Analysis”, Mainstream,
Vol. 47, No.12, March 2009, p. 25.
144
S. S. Chahar (ed.), op.cit., 2005, p.76.
145
Kamini B. Dashora, “Women Empowerment and Panchayati Raj”, Third Concept, Vol. 22, No. 262,
December 2008, pp. 56-57.
284
reservation of seats for women in PRIs and urban local bodies has been successful in
the state. Before 1995, women’s representation
representatio in local self-governments
governments was up to,
to
two women in all bodies. After 1995, it has increased to minimum 33 per cent and now
50 per cent, since 2010 elections to the PRIs and urban local bodies.146 This is for the
first time in our history that an opportunity
opportunity has been provided for such substantial entry
of women in public life and large numbers have come forward to tackle the challenge
of leadership at all levels of Panchayats. In fact, right from the days of freedom struggle
the Indian women have been consistently
consis encouraged of to take part in the active
politics. 147
Table 4.30
Respondents Opinion with Regard to Women Participation in the PRIs
No. of Respondents
Grand Total
Sr.No Response Mandi Kangra
No. % age No. % age No. % age
1 Yes 112 77.24 107 73.28 219 75.25
2 No 30 20.69 28 19.18 58 19.94
3 No Opinion 3 2.07 11 7.54 14 4.81
Total 145 100 146 100 291 100
77.24 Mandi
80 73.28 Kangra
70
60
Percentage (%)
50
40
30 20.69 19.18
20
7.54
10 2.07
0
Yes No No Opinion
Response
146
Sarbjeet Singh and Pankaj Dodh (eds.), Gender Justice and Women Empowerment:
Empowerment An Integrated
Approach,, New Delhi: Regal Publications, 2013, pp. 322-323.
322
147
M.R. Biju, Panchayati Raj System in India, New Delhi: Kanishka Publishers, 2008, p.161.
285
It is evident from the table 4.30 that out of 291 respondents, 219 respondents
were satisfied with their participation in the PRIs, which constitute 75.25 of the total
sample. Whereas 58 respondents were not satisfied with the participation of women in
the PRIs, which constitute 19.94 per cent. There were 14 respondents who expressed no
opinion on either side. The percentage of such respondents was 4.81 of the total
sample.
The comparative analysis of the two districts reveals that majority of the elected
women representatives were satisfied with their participation in PRIs. The 73rd
constitutional amendment act facilitated women participation and involvement in the
PRIs.
286
than one third with the words not less than half.148 Political reservation for women in
legislative bodies has become one of the most contentious issues of political discourse
in contemporary India. This provision has opened up various avenues for women to
exercise their leadership role at the local level. Based on this provision various
women’s organizations have been fighting for 50 per cent reservation for women in the
legislative assemblies and the parliament. The Himachal Pradesh government by
introducing 50 per cent reservations has gone further and has foreground the issue of
women’s empowerment.149 In Bihar, Uttarakhand, Madhya Pradesh and Chhattisgarh,
the state governments have already reserved 50 per cent of Panchayat seats for women.
In Bihar the reservation was enhanced to one-half of the seats in 2006, in the elections
that followed 55 per cent of the elected panchayats members were women.150 This has
been the most effective formal step towards political empowerment of women.151
Empowerment is a multi-dimensional social process that helps people to gain control
over their own lives. It is a process that fosters power in people for use in their own
lives, their own communities and in their own society, by acting on issues that they
describe as important. Above all, empowerment is a result of participation in decision-
making. Therefore, women’s empowerment refers to the process by which women
acquire due recognition on par with men to participate in the development process of
the society through the political institutions as a partner with human dignity.152
Table 4.31
Respondents Opinion with Regard to Reservation for Women in PRIs
No. of Respondents
Grand Total
Sr.No Response Mandi Kangra
No. % age No. % age No. % age
1 Yes 131 90.35 135 92.46 266 91.41
2 No 10 6.89 6 4.11 16 5.50
3 No Opinion 4 2.76 5 3.43 9 3.09
Total 145 100 146 100 291 100
148
Atonu Chatterjee, “Women in Panchayats: A Review”, Yojana, Vol. 55, February 2011, p. 25.
149
Ajit Kumar Sinha, New Dimensions of Women Empowerment, New Delhi: Deep and Deep
Publications, 2008, p. 437.
150
Beyond Mere Gestures, “Enhancing Women’s Reservation in Panchayats is Good but it is not
Enough”, Economic and Political Weekly, Vol. 44, No. 40, October 2009, p. 5.
151
Nupur Tiwari, “Women and Panchayati Raj”, Yojana, Vol. 56, June 2012, pp. 36-40.
152
C.V. Ramamohan, et al., Empowerment of Women Through Leadership and Entrepreneurship,
Mumbai: Himalaya Publishing House, 2012, p. 108.
287
92.46
90.35
100
90
80
70
Percentage
60
50 Mandi
40
Kangra
30
6.89
20
4.11
3.43
2.76
10
0
Yes No No Opinion
Response
In district Mandi out of 145 respondents, 131 respondents were satisfied with
the 50 per cent reservation of seats for women in Panchayati Raj Institutions,
Institutions which
constitute 90.35
35 per cent of the total sample.
s Whereas 10 respondents were not satisfied
with 50 per cent reservation for women in Panchayati Raj Institutions,
Institutions which constitute
6.89 per cent of the sample. There were 4 respondents who did not express their
opinion, which constitute 2.76 per cent of the total sample.
288
The comparative analysis of the two district reveals that majority of women
were satisfied with the reservation of seats for women. The 73rd Act has introduced
some innovative, progressive and bold provisions in matters of enhanced statutory
representation to women, SCs and STs. It was observed that reservation has inspired
and prompted them to contest elections.
During study it was also found that the share of general category of the
respondents in district Mandi was higher (44.83%) in comparison to district Kangra
(31.51%). Therefore Scheduled Caste share is concerned district Mandi has higher
(49.66%) to district Kangra (25.34%). As far as the OBCs share was concerned district
Kangra had higher share in comparison to district Mandi. The Scheduled Tribes have
very nominal existence in both districts. It appears that the share of STs was still very
low. It may be due to less population of their groups.
It is also found that the participation of women was literate. The percentage of
illiterate women was negligible. Similarly, the women participation mainly belongs to
middle class. Very few women were from high middle class, whose annual income was
above One Lakh annum. Since, most of the respondents were from agricultural
background.
During study, it was also found that the holdings of the respondents were not
very big. Most of the respondents were having land between to 10 bighas to 20 bighas.
In Himachal Pradesh the size of holdings is small. The study also found that majority of
the people is in agricultural profession and in petty business. Very few people are in
289
horticultural profession and apart from agriculture, horticulture business and some
other professions.
In the study it was also found that in Himachal Pradesh two political parties that
is Congress and Bhartiya Janta Party are dominating the political scene of the state. The
share of other political parties is very negligible. The majority of the respondents were
either with the congress ideology or with the BJP ideology.
As far as the awareness of the respondents was concerned during the study, it
was found that majority of the women used to read newspaper daily and were aware of
day-to-day happening. Similarly, majority of the respondents used to hear news in the
radio and television which means majority of the respondents was well informed with
the happening in society and state as well as world.
It was found that these organisation uplift women in all fields. There was a great
influence of family upon membership in voluntary organisations. Voluntary
organisations attracted rich people more than the poor. They solve their problems as
well as to serve the weaker sections of the society. It was observed that women to a
certain extent were aware of the functioning of Panchayati Raj Act. But most of the
women were unaware of the functioning of Panchayati Raj System.
The study found that majority of women was satisfied with the reservation of
seats for women. The 73rd Act has introduced some innovative, progressive and bold
provisions in matters of enhanced statutory representation to women, SCs and STs. It
was observed that reservation has inspired and prompted them to contest elections.
290
CHAPTER-V
Women constitute almost half of the Indian nation and yet their representation
and participation in decision-making bodies has been, to say the least, abysmal. It was
envisioned that competitive politics and the universal adult franchise would gradually
provide the Indian womanhood an opportunity to assert their entitlements in the
emerging political system. However, more than years of competitive politics have
failed to give more than token representation to women in the highest political
decision-making bodies.1 Men and women form the wheel of the chariot on which the
human species runs. They form the very essence of our existence. If there is problem
with even one of the counterparts, the whole balance gets disturbed. So, one can very
well imagine the plight of that culture or society in which, one-half of the human
species-the womenfolk are facing diverse problems. This is especially so in the
patriarchal societies, as found in India, where women, comprising almost half of the
population, are facing multi-faceted problems.2
1
Prem R. Bhardwaj (ed.), Gender Discrimination: Politics of Women Empowerment, New Delhi:
Anamika Publishers, 2005, p. 227.
2
Ibid.,
291
The vast amount of expenditure on elections also prevents women from taking
part in politics. Thus only women with a strong financial background are able to take
an active part in politics.3 The constitution of India grants universal suffrage to both
men and women with equal rights to participate in electoral competition, but the
existing societal value system, the private-public divide in terms of domain
identification and male preponderance in political institutions restrict women from
exercising their electoral rights and a fair participation in electoral competition. These
factors also act as key barriers and obstacles in women’s active participation in the
Indian electoral system and in the larger issue of women’s advancement as a whole.
The lack of critical and quality representation of women in key decision-making
positions results in women agenda not getting reflected and addressed in public policies
and programmes. The public agenda of Indian men and women elected as people’s
representatives are quite different and their priority of public works undertaken is also
not similar. While elected women representatives addressed issues of long term
benefits such as education, health, violence against women and basic amenities that
affect community, men concentrated on issues that needed immediate attention such as
roads, community and commercial centres, tanks, bridges etc.4
To this extent, women in India seem to have failed in breaking the glass ceiling
and have been relegated to the brings in power sharing at the top level. Which in turn,
has an adverse impact on their overall political status in the country and has acted as
barriers and obstacles in higher electoral participation. The low proportion of women in
3
M.P. Dube and Neeta Bora (eds.), Social Justice and Women in India, Delhi: Swaraj Prakashan, 1999,
p.142.
4
Praveen Rai, “Women’s Participation in Electoral Politics in India: Silent Feminisation”, South Asia
Research, Vol. 37, No.1, 2017, p.73.
292
the inner political party structure of Indian further erodes women’s efforts to lobby and
garner resources and support for nurturing and building their political constituencies as
well as mobilizing financial and human resources required to meet the demands and
aspirations of their constituencies. This inevitably results in women being perceived as
weak representatives-generally unaccepted as political leaders by people in their
constituency. At times, their insignificant numbers may put them in vulnerable position
resulting in seeking alliances along caste, religion and regional identities rather than
along common gendered interests. Thus, Indian women in public life as people
representatives often become co-opted in the men-centric structure of development
agendas. At the grass-root levels of Panchayati Raj Institutions, there have been strong
roadblocks and obstacles to women’s entry into politics and a backlash of violence to
keep them away from electoral politics.5
The absence of affirmative action for 33 per cent reservation of seats for Indian
women at state legislature and parliament is having a negative impact on women’s
share in the institutions of representations. However, treating women as a blanket
category for the benefits of reservation would further complicate the issues of women’s
representation and participation in India’s electoral competition. For such benefits
would largely be appropriated by those women, who belong to the upper stratum of
society or to those already having political background. Hence, women from the lower
economic strata, backward castes and marginalized groups would get further excluded
from contesting elections and sharing political power. Thus, the disadvantage sections
among the women in India, who are already denied their political rights to participate in
elections as candidates arising out of their situational deficiencies and lack of political
connections would be further relegated.6
293
confronting them, but also bring gender issues to the forefront leading to women’s
empowerment and advancement in the society in long run. 7
Money and muscle power are used to threaten opponents and the voters; and
impose their decisions on the electorate and to raise the kinds of funds required to get
into and stay in power. Violating women’s dignity is an integral part of politics,
instilling fear in women, thereby restraining their entry into politics. In addition,
corruption is also institutionalized systematically. Criminalization and corruption are
not part of women’s value systems and therefore, they are kept away from politics in
general. Inadequate organizational support directly affects the political participation of
women. Elections in the country are fought on party lines. The poor representation of
women in political parties does not give them the strength to negotiate gender issues
and concerns that need to form a part of the party agenda. Fewer women in political
parties impedes women from seeking positions in decision-making arenas, which are
crucial in changing the profile of political parties and also effect the number of women
fielded for elections and being elected.8 Women traditionally burdened with domestic
work face difficulties in balancing the official work with their home.
Sometimes due to lack of security women members fail to visit remote areas in
odd hours or attend meetings in faraway places. Gradual, criminalization of politics is
also arresting their participation. Lack of information and knowledge about government
programmes, especially for women and child development poses problems. Again,
limited exposure to formal education breeds information gap and dependency on
second hand knowledge. Consequently, political lineage determines the distribution of
benefits of different schemes. Communication problem hinders performance as most of
the correspondences, rules and regulations are in English. Due to lack of exposure and
experience, women members face difficulty in asserting themselves. The fact, that
majority of women enters politics through reservation and kinship arrangement, only
accentuates this problem.9
7
Praveen Rai, op.cit., 2011, p. 54.
8
Rakesh K. Singh, “Elected Women Representatives in Panchayat Raj”, Social Action, Vol. 62,
January-March 2012, p. 58.
9
Atonu Chatterjee, “Women in Panchayats: A Review”, Yojana, Vol. 55, February 2011, pp. 25-26.
294
volumes about the gender bias that is practiced in the society.10 In order to view, the
problems of women in the national perspective and to develop an integral approach to
their development and progress, a national perspective plan for women was published
in 1988-2000. The plan emphasized gender equality as pre-requisite for effective
participation of women in strengthening the institutional structure of democracy.
Women have been marginalized because of several socio-economic constraints. The
plan acknowledged the fact that the number of women in leadership position at the
local, village, district and national levels is still not commensurate with their numbers
in society. 11
10
G. Palanithurai, et al. (ed), Major Issues in New Panchayati Raj System, New Delhi: Kanishka
Publishers, 1997, p. 56.
11
Yogendra Narain, et al., “Empowerment of Women”, Mainstream, Vol. 43, No.1-5, December 2004,
p. 71.
12
S. Mehartaj Begum, “Women Rights and Rural Employments”, Kurukshetra, Vol. 48, No. 7,
April
2000, pp. 60-64.
13
C. Jayanthi, “Empowering Women”, Yojana, Vol. 45, June 2001, p. 32.
295
of well-developed education and training systems for women’s leadership in general
and for orienting young women toward political life in particular is one of the obstacles
faced by women.
14
A. Thanikodi and M. Sugirtha, “Status of Women in Politics”, The Indian Journal of Political
Science, Vol. 68, No. 3, July- September 2007, pp. 591-593.
15
Sukhpal Kaur, “Women’s Rights: A Historical Perspective”, The Indian Journal of Political
Science, Vol. 70, No. 1, January-March 2009, p. 128.
16
Rakesh K. Singh, op.cit., 2012, p. 58.
17
Rashmi Shrivatava, “Minority Representation of a Political Majority Group: Women in Indian
Democratic Process”, The Indian Journal of Political Science, Vol. 72, No. 2, April-June 2011,
p. 411.
18
Satarupa Pal, “Politics of Women’s Reservation in India”, International Journal of Humanities and
Social Science Studies, Vol. 1, No. 3, November 2014, p. 118.
296
Table 5.1
Respondents Views Regarding Hurdles Come in the Way of Women’s
Participation
Non-Cooperation
Cooperation of
1 28 19.31 16 10.96 44 15.12
Husband/Family Members
Lack of Time due to Family
F
2 54 37.24 45 30.82 99 34.02
Responsibility
3 Lack of Interest in Politics 12 8.28 19 13.02 31 10.66
4 Lack of Political Awakening 34 23.45 51 34.93 85 29.21
5 Lack of Education 17 11.72 15 10.27 32 10.99
Total 145 100 146 100 291 100
37.24
40 34.93
30.82
35 Mandi
23.45
30 Kangra
19.31
Percentage
25
13.02
20
11.72
10.96
10.27
15
8.28
10
5
0
Lack of Education
Lack of Political
Lack of Time due to
of Husband/Family
Lack of Interest in
Non-Cooperation
Awakening
Responsibility
Members
Politics
Family
Response
Fig. 5.1: Respondents Views Regarding Hurdles Come in the Way of Women’s
Participation
Table 5.1 shows that out of 291 respondents, 44 respondents believed that main
hurdles comes in the way of women participation in politics were non-cooperation
non of
husband/family members,
members which constitute 15.12 per cent of the total sample, whereas
297
99 respondents perceived lack of time due to family responsibilities as the major hurdle
comes in the way of women participation in politics, which constitute 34.02 per cent of
the sample. There were 31 respondents, the main hurdles lack of interest, which
constitute 10.66 per cent of the sample, while 85 respondents who believed that the
main hurdle comes in the way of women participation i.e. the lack of political
awakening, which constitute 29.21 per cent of the sample, and 32 respondents pointed
out lack of education as the main hurdles in the way of women participation in politics,
which constitute 10.99 per cent of the sample.
The comparative analysis of two districts reveals that the women face many
problems in the society that is social, economic and political. Lack of education also
plays hurdles in the way of women participation. Due to the traditional pattern of our
298
rural society there are a number of hurdles in the way of effective participation of
women.
Caste Dominance
Caste and politics influence each other. The electoral process, administration
and politics are greatly affected by caste. M.N. Srinivas introduced the concept of
dominant caste to examine the political process in India. Caste has its hold in the Indian
politics. According to him, voting preferences are made on caste line.19 Caste is an
important factor in Indian society and politics. Over a century of social reform
movement, India could hardly make any impression on the caste system. The number
of caste, instead of diminishing has been increasing. In fact, caste organisation and
caste consciousness are increasing in modern India.20
19
Usha Kiran, Participation of Women in Indian Politics: Gender Justice and Political Challenge,
Delhi: Globus Press, 2016, p.122.
20
S.S Chahar (ed.), Governance at Grassroots Level in India, New Delhi: Kanishka Publishers, 2005, p.
408.
21
B.B. Jena and J.K. Baral, Election Politics and Voting Behaviour in India, Delhi: Discovery
Publishing House, 1989, p. 51.
22
Niroj Sinha, Women in Indian Politics: Empowerment of Women Through Political Participation,
New Delhi: Gyan Publishing House, 2006, pp. 95-96.
23
Article 332, Constitution of India.
24
Article 338, Constitution of India.
299
scheduled castes, scheduled tribes and other socially and educationally backward
classes of citizens in services.25
Keeping in view, the social hierarchical caste based structure, which exploited
the weaker sections of society, there was and is a justification for such a provision in
the constitution for a short period.26 However, while doing so, efficiency of
administration should also not be blindly ignored.27 Otherwise, their condition would
become more miserable. It should be remembered that reservation can neither be made
on communal considerations, nor more than 50 per cent seats be reserved. While, caste
has been politicised in the process, it has provided the Indian politics with processes
and symbol of political articulation. Thus, within the new context of political
democracy, caste remains a central element of Indian society even, while adapting itself
to the values and methods of democratic politics.28
25
Clause (4) to Article 15 of the Indian Constitution.
26
N.M. Tripathi, Minority and Law, Delhi: Indian Law Institute, 1972, p.10.
27
Article 335, Constitution of India.
28
Niroj Sinha, op.cit., 2006, p. 97.
300
democratic politics. The decision to implement Mandal Commission recommendation
for reservation of jobs
bs for other Backward Classes (Castes)
(Castes) and the reaction it
generated in politics testifies to the continued presence of caste as a determinant of
politics in India. However, it must be stated that the role of caste as determinant of the
voting behaviour
viour has been undergoing a change, at least in the urban areas. Issue based
political struggle is gradually taking its shape in the Indian polity. But the situation
continues to be paradoxical.29 Respondents views on caste dominance
ominance given below:
Table 5.2
Respondents Views on Caste Dominance
No. of Respondents
Grand Total
Sr.No Response Mandi Kangra
No. % age No. % age No. % age
1 Yes 99 68.27 88 60.27 187 64.26
2 No 37 25.52 47 32.19 84 28.87
3 No Opinion 9 6.21 11 7.54 20 6.87
Total 145 100 146 100 291 100
68.27
70
Mandi
60.27
60 Kangra
50
Percentage
40
32.19
30 25.52
20
6.21 7.54
10
0
Yes No No Opinion
Caste Dominance
29
Biraj Hazarika, “Voting Behaviour in India and its Determinants,” Journal of Humanities and
Social Science,, Vol. 20, No. 10, October 2015, pp. 22-25.
301
Table 5.2 indicates that out of 291 respondents, 187 respondents who were
believed caste in politics, which constitute 64.26 per cent of the total sample, whereas
84 respondents did not believe caste in politics, which constitute 28.87 per cent of the
sample. There were 20 respondents who did not give their opinion, which constitute
6.87 per cent of the sample.
The comparative analysis of two district reveals that majority of the respondents
believed that caste play an important role in politics. In district Mandi (68.27%) and
district Kangra (60.27%) of the respondents believed that caste plays important role in
politics and they affect voting behaviour. It was observed that majority of respondents,
who unite on the basis of caste and support candidate. We can see the influence of caste
in politics as voting agency.
Social System
Women were said to enjoy a high status in the society in the ancient times. They
were viewed as home makers and managers, assigned with the most important task of
bringing up a family. With the passage of time, they came to be relegated to an inferior
position considering them weak and at times incapable even of holding rights. This lead
to their exploitation at all levels and in all spheres, the woman who was the backbone
of the family enjoyed subordinate rights in family matters and at times no rights at all.30
Women constitute about 50 per cent of the total population of the nation, have
generally been considered as a weaker section. Discrimination against women has
30
Asha Bhandari and Rekha Mehta, Women, Justice and the Rule of Law, New Delhi: Serials
Publications, 2009, p. 103.
302
existed in all parts of the globe in some form or another. For all countries, the gender
Development Index (GDI) is lower than the Human Development Index indicating
gender inequality everywhere.31 The main cause for poor condition of women is rooted
in traditional structures like class, caste hierarchy and religious discriminations. The
impact of these cultural forces is that, firstly women have less direct independent
access than men to capital, property and extensive services. Secondly, women have
limited geographical mobility and economic independence or personal autonomy that
made them dependent on male kin.32 Gender inequality in our social institutions is
addressed. Many erroneously think that women are a homogenous group with identical
problems and priorities, yet Indian society is divided by caste, religion and class
differences. The majority of women live in rural areas and their problems and needs are
different from those of urban women. Access to nutritious food, clean drinking water
and primary healthcare may not be life’s priorities for an urban woman, because these
life-sustaining services are available to her. But for a rural woman who is struggling for
her livelihood, these are indeed priorities, meaningful change in their life situations can
only occur, when development efforts also address their issues.33
Therefore, 50 per cent reservation for women at all the tiers of Panchayats has
made a significant beginning in the democratic process. Over one million women have
come as decision-makers at the Panchayats levels, but experiences of women have been
disheartening. Most of the elected women had no idea, what being an elected member
meant and just did what the men (as brothers, fathers, father-in-law and husband) told
them to do. The community does not perceive the women as capable or worthy of
leadership. For a change in a mental attitude of women, their needs to be a drastic
change in social attitudes on the whole.34 In nutshell, positive social outlook towards
women would certainly help in active participation of women in the democratic
decentralization process.
31
Ajit Kumar Sinha, (ed.), New Dimensions of Women Empowerment, New Delhi: Deep and Deep
Publications, 2008, p. 25.
32
Asha Bhandari and Rekha Mehta, op.cit., 2009, p. 39.
33
Vidhyavati Chakki, “Socio-Economic Empowerment of Women in India”, Third Concept, Vol. 26,
No. 308, October 2012, p. 8.
34
Siva Subrahmanyam, “Empowerment of Women and Marginalized Groups in Panchayats”,
Kurukshetra, Vol. 50, No. 7, May 2002, p. 28.
303
Table 5.3
Respondents Opinion Regarding Social System
No. of Respondents
Grand Total
Sr.No Response Mandi Kangra
No. % Age No. % Age No. % Age
1 Yes 126 86.89 133 91.09 259 89.00
2 No 6 2.76 8 5.48 14 4.81
3 No Opinion 13 10.35 5 3.43 18 6.19
Total 145 100 146 100 291 100
91.09
86.89
100
90
Mandi
80
70 Kangra
Percentage
60
50
40
30
10.35
5.48
20
3.43
2.76
10
0
Yes No No Opinion
Response
It is clear from the table 5.3 that out of 291 respondents, 259 respondents
believe that social outlook towards women required major change,
change which constitute
89.00 per cent of the total. There were 14 respondents
respondents who disagree and 18 respondents
express no opinion. They constitute 4.81 and 6.19 per cent respectively.
304
As far as district Kangra was concerned, out of 146 respondents 133
respondents believe that the social outlook towards women required major change.
There were 8 who disagree and 5 express no opinion. They constitute 5.48 and 3.43 per
cent of the total.
The comparative analysis of the two district reveals that the number of
respondents who fully agree that social outlook towards women required major change.
It was found that the attitude of society towards women regarding their political
participation was not encouraging. It was also observed that due to the passing remarks
by the people many women candidate withdraw from the contest and sometimes from
active participation.
Family Problems
In the traditional society, women’s role was naturally limited to the family.
Since, she was bearer of children, fully occupied with her duties as a mother and home-
maker. Rural women are economically backward. Poverty, illiteracy and caste are the
factors affecting the economic development of women.35 Husbands, in-laws and close
relatives have become the main decision-makers relegating the actual women
representatives to the background. Moreover, role conflict among these representatives
has also increased while managing house responsibilities and political simultaneously.
Since, male dominating society is reluctant in accepting the women as decision-makers,
36
they are being muscle men. Hence participation of women in the field of political,
economical, social, educational, and cultural has been made to commit the issues to
recognize the equal position and status of women and men in decision making
accordance to the effective of women empowerment.37
35
M. Perumal, et al., “Empowering Rural Women Through Self- Help Groups”, in Asha Bhandari and
Rekha Mehta, Women, Justice and the Rule of Law, New Delhi: Serials Publications, 2009,
pp. 145-146.
36
Azam Khan and Tosib Alam, “Empowerment of Rural Women and Local Self-Governance”, in
Asha Bhandari and Rekha Mehta, Women, Justice and the Rule of Law, New Delhi: Serials
Publications, 2009, p.162.
37
Asha Bhandari and Rekha Mehta, op.cit., 2009, p. 2.
305
decisions of these women are largely influenced by the spouses.38 It is alleged that
husbands of the elected women representatives
represent ives interfere in their decision making. It is
also complained that often male
ale members push through their decision and do not care
about the views of their women counterparts.39
Table 5.4
Respondents Opinion
Opini Regarding Family Problems
No. of Respondents
Grand Total
Sr.No Response Mandi Kangra
No. % age No. % age No. % age
1 Yes 108 74.49 100 68.49 208 71.48
2 No 27 18.62 31 21.24 58 19.93
3 No Opinion 10 6.89 15 10.27 25 8.59
Total 145 100.00 146 100.00 291 100.00
74.49
68.49
80
70 Mandi
60 Kangra
50
Percentage
40
21.24
18.62
30
10.27
20
6.89
10
0
Yes No No Opinion
Response
38
Sakuntala Narasimhan, “Women’s Role in Gram Sabha”, Kurukshetra, Vol. 48, No.1,
1, October 1999,
p. 26.
39
S.S. Chahar (ed.), op.cit., 2005, p.78.
306
It is clear from the table 5.4 that out of total 291 respondents, 208 respondents
believed that they were facing many problems in the discharge of their duties due to
relatives and community, which constitutes 71.48 per cent of the sample. Whereas 58
respondents who believed that they faced no problems in discharge of their duties,
which constitute 19.93 per cent of the sample. There were 25 respondents who
expressed no opinion on the either side. The percentage of such respondents is 8.59 of
the sample.
In district Mandi, out of total 145 respondents, 108 respondents believed that
they were facing many problems in the discharge of their duties due to relatives and
community, which constitutes 74.49 per cent of the sample. Whereas 27 respondents
who believed that they faced no problems in discharge of their duties, which constitute
18.62 per cent of the sample. There were 10 respondents who expressed no opinion on
the either side. The percentage of such respondents, 6.89 of the sample.
In district Kangra, out of total 146 respondents, 100 respondents believed that
they were facing many problems in the discharge of their duties due to relatives and
community, which constitutes 68.49 per cent of the sample. Whereas 31 respondents
who believed that they faced no problems in discharge of their duties, which constitute
21.24 per cent of the sample. There were 15 respondents who expressed no opinion on
the either side, which constitute 10.27 per cent of the sample.
The comparative analysis of two district reveals that the male counterparts not
only in the family but in the society dominated the elected women representatives too.
Even today, women lacks of independence of thought and action. Women still crave for
social recognition for their activities.
Education
Education is the key that opens the door in life which is essentially social in
character. An illiterate woman would not be able to understand all the rules and
regulations governing the institutions. Illiteracy restricts one’s capacity to give
thoughtful judgement on issues of importance. Education facilitates the development of
a progressive attitude in individuals towards social and economic problems. In the
present society, capacity to understand the issues and problems facing the community
and the ability to communicate one’s ideas to others are important qualities for a
member. Education for women is more important political institutions, education or
307
being literate will help them to understand the rules, regulations and fulfil the
objectives of the institutions and help them in carrying out their day-to-day functions.40
Education in a society is like a mirror, which reflects the attitude of the masses.
Women which constitute almost half of the population required equal measures to
education. The hither to deprived sections of the Indian society due to orthodox
thumping of the Indian male dominate society. Education plays an important role in
determining the social and political status of a person. It is education which shapes the
pattern of leadership. An educated leader can make good law for society. It is only
through education that a leader can remain in touch with national as well as
international developments.41
Table 5.5
Respondents Opinion Regarding Educational Qualification
No. of Respondents
Grand Total
Sr.No Response Mandi Kangra
No. % age No. % age No. % age
1 Yes 130 89.66 110 75.34 240 82.47
2 No 12 8.27 24 16.44 36 12.37
3 No Opinion 3 2.07 12 8.22 15 5.16
Total 145 100 146 100 291 100
40
K.C. Vidya, Political Empowerment of Women at the Grassroots, New Delhi: Kanishka Publishers,
2007, p. 105.
41
A.K. Gupta, Emerging Pattern of Political Leadership: A Case Study of Punjab, New Delhi: Mittal
Publications, 1991, p. 35.
42
K. Thangamani, “Education for Women” , in Rameshwari Pandya, (ed.), Women Welfare and
Empowerment in India, New Delhi: New Century Publications, 2008, pp.196-197.
308
89.66
90
75.34
80
Mandi
70
Kangra
60
Percentage
50
40
30
16.44
20
8.27 8.22
10 2.07
0
Yes No No Opinion
Educational Qualification
It is evident from the table 5.5 regarding respondent’s opinion about candidate’s
qualification. Out of 291 respondents, 240 respondents favoured the minimum
educational qualification for elected candidate in politics,
politics which constitute 82.47 per
cent of the sample, whereas 36 respondents were not in favour of minimum educational
qualification for elected candidate in politics,
politics which constitute 12.37 per cent of the
sample. There were 15 respondents who expressed no opinion, which constitute 5.16
per cent the sample.
In district Mandi,
Mandi out of 145 respondents, 130 respondents favoured the
minimum educational qualification for elected candidate in politics,
politics which constitute
89.66 per cent of the sample, whereas 12 respondents were not in favour of minimum
educational qualification for elected candidate in politics which constitute 8.27 per cent
of the sample. There were 3 respondents who expressed no opinion,
opinion which constitute
2.07 per cent the sample.
In district Kangra,
Kangra out of 146 respondents, 110 respondents favoured the
minimum educational qualification for elected candidate in politics,
politics which constitute
75.34 per cent of the sample, whereas 24 respondents were not in favour of minimum
educational qualification for elected candidate in politics,
politics which constitute 16.44 per
cent of the sample. There were 12 respondents who expressed no opinion,
opinion which
constitute 8.22 per cent of the sample.
309
The comparative analysis of the two districts reveals that majority of the
respondents were in favour of minimum educational qualification for women in
politics. Therefore, illiterate women were not able to participate in politics. Without
proper education, they feel hard to understand the rules of politics. Thus, education is a
most vital channel to encourage women to participate in politics.
Economic Dependence
43
Mohd Muzaffar Banday and P. Ganesan, “Economic Empowerment of Rural Muslim Women in
Kashmir Valley”, Third Concept, Vol. 30, No. 356, October 2016, pp. 55-56.
44
D. Sundar Ram (ed.), Women Empowerment in Political Institutions: An Indian Perspective, New
Delhi: Kanishka Publishers, 2009, p.149.
310
independence.45 Empowerment is a multi-dimensional social process that helps people
gain control over their own lives communities and in their society. Empowerment
Emp
occurs within sociological,
sociological psychological, economic spheres and at various levels.
Women’s empowerment is the key to socio-economic
socio economic development of the community
that brings women into the mainstream of national development,
development has been a major
concern of government.46
Table 5.6
Respondents Opinion with Regard to Economic Dependence
ependence
No. of Respondents
Grand Total
Sr.No Response Mandi Kangra
No. % age No. % age No. % age
1 Yes 110 75.86 106 72.60 216 74.23
2 No 28 19.31 31 21.24 59 20.28
3 No Opinion 7 4.83 9 6.16 16 5.49
Total 145 100 146 100 291 100
75.86
72.6
80
Mandi
70
Kangra
60
50
Percentage
40
21.24
19.31
30
20
6.16
4.83
10
0
Yes No No Opinion
Response
45
Ritu Sapra and Divya Khatter, “Women Empowerment in India”, Third Concept, Vol. 28, No. 325
March 2014, p. 38.
46
Meenu Agrawal, (ed.), Women Empowerment and Globalization:
Globalization A Modern Perspective,
Perspective New Delhi:
Kanishka Publishers, 2009,
2009 p. 60.
311
The table 5.6 shows that out of 291 respondents, 216 respondents agreed that
economically independent women took actively participated in politics, which
constitute 74.23 per cent of total sample, whereas 59 respondents did not agree with
this view, which constitute 20.28 per cent of the sample. There were 16 respondents
who did not express opinion about this, which constitute 5.49 per cent of the sample.
India’s villages are bound by traditions. The position of women is very clear-a
traditional housewife. The upbringing of girls in the rural society is inevitably oriented
towards marriage. They could contribute an additional hand both at home and in the
fields. The rural social scene is now in the process of change. The most important
change is their entry as elected members of the PRIs.47 However, in a male dominated
Indian society women are often considered as the rubber stamp of men. It is generally
believed that women do not vote their own. Most women respect family traditions and
do not want to go against them. The decision in the family about whom to vote in an
election is generally taken by male members. When women vote, they vote in
conformity with their husband. Husband and other male family members influence
47
K. C. Vidya, op.cit., 2007, pp. 161-162.
312
their voting choice.48 Therefore, status of women differs from society to society.
According
ording to cultural milieu, family structure, class, caste, property rights and morals,
morals
their status diverge.. In the past,
past no serious attempts had been made to study the women
question. Women were neglected
neg section of the society. The process of modernization
modernizati
during the 19th century laid the greater emphasis on the political, economic and social
modernization of women. The transformation of the society as well as women took
place and the new role of women in the new emerging society replaced the status of
men in traditional society.49 Thus, the area of power politics has practically been
women
conditioned as a male domain. Table shows the influence of father/husband/other male
family members on voting choice of the respondents.
Table 5.7
Influence of the Male Family
F Members on Voting Choice of the Respondents
No. of Respondents
Grand Total
Sr.No Response Mandi Kangra
No. % Age No. % Age No. % Age
1 Yes 98 67.59 108 73.97 206 70.79
2 No 41 28.27 34 23.29 75 25.77
3 No Opinion 6 4.14 4 2.74 10 3.44
Total 145 100 146 100 291 100
73.97
67.59
80
70 Mandi
60
Percentage (%)
Kangra
50
28.27
23.29
40
30
20
4.14
2.74
10
0
Yes No No Opinion
Response
Fig. 5.7: Influence of the Male Family Members on Voting Choice of the Respondents
48
Bhawana Jharta, Women and Politics in India: Impact of Family and Education on Women Political
Activists, New Delhi: Deep and Deep Publications, 1996, p. 89.
49
Prem R. Bhardwaj (ed.), op.cit., 2005, p. 235.
313
Table 5.7 indicates that out of 291 respondents 206 respondents agreed that
women casted their vote on the advice of male counterparts, which constitute 70.79 per
cent the total sample, whereas 75 respondents disagreed to it, which constitute 25.77
per cent of the sample, while 10 respondents who gave no opinion in this aspect, which
constitute 3.44 per cent of the sample.
As far as in district Kangra, out of 146 respondents 108 respondents agreed that
women casted their vote on the advice of male counterparts, which constitute 73.97 per
cent the total sample, whereas 34 respondents disagreed to it, which constitute 23.29
per cent of the sample, while 4 respondents who gave no opinion in this aspect, which
constitute 2.74 per cent of the sample.
The comparative analysis of two district reveals that the dominance of male
over female in rural areas is still prevalent. Women at large scale agreed with the fact
that because of their lack of self confidence, they were dominated by male members
and their voting decisions were being influenced by them. It was observed that the most
of the rural women do not go for voting without prior consultation with their husband,
father, brother and any other male elite members. However, the electoral education,
awareness campaign and capacity programmes were the right steps to empower women
folk and strengthen their willingness towards, independent voting.
Bureaucracy
50
Ali Ashraf, Government and Politics of Big Citizens, New Delhi: Concept Publishing Company,
1977, p. 1.
314
plays an important role in the democratic process. It implements the policies and
programmes of elected representatives of Panchayati
Panchayati Raj Institutions. Their
involvement and commitment is necessary for the success of democratic process. In
fact, in a democratic system the elected representatives take policy decision but the
implementation exclusively depends upon the bureaucratic structure.
structure. The bureaucracy,
bureaucracy
which is attached with Panchayati Raj Institutions basically belongs to other
departments of the state governments.
Table 5.8
Respondents Opinion Regarding Bureaucratic Interference in Working of PRIs
No. of Respondents
Grand Total
Sr.No Response Mandi Kangra
65.07
80
70
Mandi
60
Percentage (%)
Kangra
30.82
50
26.21
40
30
4.11
20
1.38
10
0
Yes No No Opinion
Response
Table 5.8 depicts that out of, 291 respondents, 200 respondents believed that
bureaucracy creates problems in the functioning of PRIs,
PRIs which constitute 68.73 per
315
cent of the sample. Therefore 83 respondents did not agree with this view, which
constitute 28.52 per cent and 8 respondents did not respond on either side, which
constitute 2.75 per cent of the sample.
Corruption /Favouritism
51
G. Planithurai (ed.), New Panchayati Raj System: Status and Prospects, New Delhi: Kanishka
Publishers, 1996, p. 57.
316
phenomenon. In our own country some people in high positions have been charged for
it. A corrupt person is termed immoral, dishonest and unscrupulous in his dealings. His
disregard for honesty, righteousness and truth results in his alienation from society.
Corruption is the most virulent, when crises everywhere threaten the very existence of
the society and the faith in life is shaken.52
Corruption is a cancer, which every Indian must strives to cure. Many new
leaders, when comes into power declare their determination to eradicate corruption but
soon they themselves become corrupt and start amassing huge wealth. Many people
become materialistic and money oriented, there is no importance of ethics and morals
in business dealings. Many people thinking that money coming to their pocket is good,
same way many thinking that money, which is going out of their pocket is bad, but they
don’t consider the way money is travelling. This is because such these kinds of people
have no moral accountability to anybody, and have full trust on money. They strongly
believe that money can hold a big role in their life, they believe that money can solve
their current and future problems and give them life without problems.53 During
election time corruption is at its peak level. Big industrialists funds politicians to meet
high cost of election and ultimately to seek personal favour. Bribery to politicians buys
influence, and bribery by politicians buys votes. In order to get elected, politicians
bribe poor illiterate people, who are slogging for two times meal. Vast size of
population coupled with widespread illiteracy and the poor economic infrastructure
lead to endemic corruption in public life. 54 Therefore women have played a role that is
subordinate to men. The world of politics in India is so much surrounded by an aura of
crime and corruption, which is synonymous with politics. The fact is that if we want to
bring about a change and cleanse the political system, we will have to give reservation
to women.55 Subsequently, women must be given a chance not because they are
necessarily any better than male politician but because they cannot do any worse. Male
leaders indulge in crime and corruption and concentrate their energy in fighting for
greater power and privileges. If women are voted to power, they will fight for a cleaner
and corruption free political system. 56
52
K. Geetamma, “Corruption in India: Causes and Remedies”, Third Concept, Vol. 30, No. 360,
February 2017, pp. 42-43.
53
Ibid.,
54
Ibid., p. 41.
55
D. Sundar Ram (ed.), op.cit., 2009, p. 11.
56
Ibid., p.12.
317
Table 5.9
Respondents view Regarding Corruption and Favouritism
No. of Respondents
Grand Total
Sr.No Response Mandi Kangra
No. % Age No. % Age No. % Age
1 Yes 100 68.96 110 75.34 210 72.17
2 No 30 20.68 11 7.53 41 14.08
3 No Opinion 15 10.34 25 17.13 40 13.75
Total 145 100 146 100 291 100
75.34
68.96
80
70 Mandi
60
Percentage (%)
Kangra
50
40
20.68
17.13
30
10.34
7.53
20
10
0
Yes No No Opinion
Response
Table 5.9 shows that all 291 respondents were interviewed out of which 210
respondents admitted that there was favouritism in the identification of the beneficiaries
at the grassroots level, which constitute 72.17
72.1 per cent of the sample. Therefore, 41
respondents were not agreed with this opinion that there was no such favouritism in the
identification of beneficiaries,
beneficiaries which accounted 14.08 per cent of the sample.
However, 40 respondents did not express their opinion in either side.. The percentage of
such respondents was 13.75 per cent.
318
respondents were not agreed with this opinion that there was no such favouritism in the
identification of beneficiaries, which accounted 20.68 per cent of the sample, while 15
respondents did not express their opinion in either side. The percentage of such
respondents was 10.34 per cent.
The comparative study of both district reveals that majority of the respondents
admitted that there was favouritism in the identification of the beneficiaries at the
grassroots levels. Therefore, the corruption was a form of dishonest or unethical
conduct by a person entrusted with position of authority, often to acquire personal
benefit.
319
rotation to different constituency as was also stipulated in the earlier bill, but even in
this bill there was no reference to a possible reservation in chairpersons’ positions. The
bill was introduced in Parliament but did not come up for discussion. When the
congress party came back to power after the elections of 1991, a new Amendment bill
was introduced in the Parliament which finally became the 73rd amendment to the
constitution. This continued the provision relating to “not less than one third”
reservation in membership with the inclusion of chairperson’s posts. The Minister of
State for Rural Development, while introducing the bill for 73rd amendment in 1992
had stated that, making provision for reservation of one-third of the total seats could be
considered inadequate.57
The women’s reservation bill, which seeks to reserve one third of seats in the
Lok Sabha and the State Legislatures for women, is yet to become law despite being
passed by the Rajys Sabha in 2010 itself. Other pending reforms to the electoral system
includes the constitutional (110th Amendment) bill, for reserving half the seats in
Panchayats for women and the constitution (112th Amendment) bill, reserving one third
of elected seats in municipalities for women.58 Even in most advanced countries
women’s representation is very low in democratic bodies. But in India, women’s
reservation bill (i.e.108th Amendment of the Indian Constitution), is still pending that
proposes for thirty-three percent of seats reserved, in the parliament and the state
legislatures. The bill was first introduced in the Lok Sabha on 12th September 1996.
Though, the bill is passed in the Rajya Sabha in 2010, but is still pending in Lok Sabha.
So, it has been argued that women who constituting half of the population are lagging
behind from democratic setup in India.59 However the proper representation of women
in terms of numbers and quality is absolutely essential for their meaningful partnership
in the progress of the nation.60 There is a growing demand for the presence of women
in political decision-making, so as to facilitate their real empowerment.61 The
respondents opinion regarding reservation for women in state politics given below:
57
Nirmala Buch, “Panchayats and Women”, in George Mathew, Status of Panchayati Raj in the States
and Union Territories of India 2000, New Delhi: Concept Publishing Company, 2000, pp. 37-38.
58
Lakshmi Iyer, “The Electoral Participation of Women’’, Yojana, Vol. 58, July 2014, p. 24.
59
Satarupa Pal, op.cit., 2014, pp.119-122.
60
D. Sundar Ram (ed.), op.cit., 2009, p.13.
61
Ibid., p. 83.
320
Table 5.10
Respondents Opinion
nion Regarding Reservation for Women
omen in State Politics
No. of Respondents
Grand Total
Sr.No Response Mandi Kangra
No. % age No. % age No. % age
1 Yes 112 77.24 110 75.34 222 76.29
2 No 25 17.24 31 21.23 56 19.24
3 No Opinion 8 5.52 5 3.43 13 4.47
Total 145 100.00 146 100.00 291 100.00
77.24 75.34
80
Mandi
70
Kangra
60
Percentage (%)
50
40
30
21.23
17.24
20
5.52
10 3.43
0
Yes No No Opinion
Response
Fig. 5.10: Respondents Opinion Regarding Reservation for Women in State Politics
The table 5.10 reveals that vast majority of the respondents in the sample were
demanding the reservation for women in state politics. Out of 291 respondents, 222
respondents were demanding reservation of seats for women in state and national level,
level
which constitute 76.29 per cent of the total sample, whereas 56 respondents were not
against reservation for women in politics,
politics which constitute 19.24
24 per cent of the
sample, while13 respondents did not express their opinion,
opinion which constitute 4.47 per
cent of the sample.
321
As far as district Mandi was concerned, out of 145 respondents, 112
respondents were demanding reservation of seats for women in state and national level,
which constitute 77.24 per cent of the total sample, whereas 25 respondents were not
against reservation for women in politics, which constitute 17.24 per cent of the
sample, while 8 respondents did not express their opinion, which constitute 5.52 per
cent of the sample.
Women are still mostly employed in traditional and informal sectors, where
there has been a lower level of technological and information support. This further
compounds their educational handicaps. However, women with education have entered
many new areas of occupation, where their participation was virtually non-existent
before. This process of occupational diversification through education has been
accelerated during the decade in many developing countries. This enable women to
participate actively in all spheres of economic and social life, vocational and
professional training, must be further developed. In this respect, the training of trainers
is of primary importance, as is the introduction of management training for women.
Apart from the conventional types of training (seminars, workshops etc.,) the non-
conventional types are often also suitable.62
The statutory empowerment of women will become a reality and relevant only,
when they are given adequate training in performing their duties as well as in
understanding the whole system of democratic decentralization. Thus, training to
62
Usha Kiran, op.cit., 2016, p. 66.
322
leaders will make them politically conscious and expose them to constitutional and
legal rights, functions of Panchayati Raj Institutions and their role in formulating and
implementation of rural development schemes. The purpose of passing 73rd
mendment was to make PRIs more effective and representative.63 The
constitutional amendment
views of women representatives on training for effective functioning of PRIs are
summarized in the Table 5.11.
Table 5.11
No. of Respondents
Sr. Grand Total
Response Mandi Kangra
No.
No. %age No. %age No. %age
1. Yes 123 84.83 119 81.51 242 83.16
2. No 12 8.28 15 10.27 27 9.28
3. No Opinion 10 6.89 12 8.22 22 7.56
Total 145 100.00 146 100.00 291 100.00
84.83
81.51
90
80 Mandi
70 Kangra
60
Percentage
50
40
30
10.27
8.28
8.22
6.89
20
10
0
Yes No No Opinion
Response
63
G. Palanthurai (ed.), op.cit., 1996, p.151.
323
It is evident from the table 5.11 that out of, 291 respondents were interviewed
out of which respondents 242 respondents believed that the elected women
representatives should be given training in rural development programmes, which
constitute 83.16 per cent of the sample. However 27 respondents disagreed with this
view, which constitutes 9.28 per cent of the total. There were 22 respondents expressed
no opinion. The percentage of such respondents was 7.56 of the total sample.
The comparative analysis of the two district reveals that most of the elected
women representatives engaged in the implementation of policies and programmes.
They were not aware of the policies and programmes of the Panchayati Raj Institutions
leading to their improper functioning. Thus proper training of the elected women
representatives attached to the Panchayati Raj Institutions is a must.
324
various levels of political activities in India have risen considerable. However, women
are still under-represented in governance and decision-making process.64
Women members and other executive bodies must be trained and empowered to
exercise their authority. Both men and women members must be sensitive to women
issues. A massive conscientisation programmes for woman in general needs to be taken
up and modules designed for this purpose should adequately deal with social and
economic constraints, which restricts their participation, interpersonal communication
skills, amongst the trainees/ community leaders.65
64
Purnima Ojha, “Women’s Issues in India: Role and Importance of Media”, The Indian Journal of
Political Science, Vol.72, No.1, January-March 2011, pp. 94-95.
65
J.L. Singh, Women and Panchayati Raj, Delhi: Sunrise Publications, 2005, p. 356.
66
S.S.Chahar (ed.), op.cit., 2005, p. 248.
67
D.S. Chaudhary, G.K. Kar, Elections and Electoral Behaviour in India, Delhi: Kanti Publications,
1992, p.51.
68
Barsha Kalita, “Political Status of Women in Assam: An Analysis”, Golden Research Thoughts, Vol.
4, No.1, July 2014, pp. 6-7.
325
Table 5.12
Respondentss Opinion Regarding Women’s Role in Decision Making
Mak
Process
No. of Respondents
Grand Total
Sr.No Response Mandi Kangra
No. % age No. % age No. % age
1 Yes 119 82.07 114 78.09 233 80.07
2 No 24 16.55 20 13.69 44 15.12
3 No Opinion 2 1.38 12 8.22 14 4.81
Total 145 100 146 100 291 100
Mandi
90 82.07
78.09
Kangra
80
70
Percentage (%)
60
50
40
30
16.55
20 13.69
8.22
10 1.38
0
Yes No No Opinion
Response
It is evident from the table 5.12 that the total sample, 291 respondents were
interviewed, out of which 233 respondents had opinion that women took decisions on
their own in politics, which constitute 80.07 per cent of the sample, whereas 44
respondents were holding the opposite view that women were not capable of taking
decisions independently and they were being influenced by the male members in
politics, which constitute 15.12
.12 per cent of the sample, while 14 respondents had no
opinion, which constitute 4.81 per cent of the sample.
326
In district Mandi, 145 respondents 119 respondents had opinion that women
took decisions on their own in politics, which constitute 82.07 per cent of the sample,
whereas 24 respondents were holding the opposite view, that women were not capable
of taking decisions independently and they were being influenced by the male members
in politics, which constitute 16.55 per cent of the sample, while 2 respondents had no
opinion, which constitute 1.38 per cent of the sample.
In district Kangra, 146 respondents 114 respondents had opinion that women
took decisions on their own in politics, which constitute 78.09 per cent of the sample,
whereas 20 respondents were holding the opposite view that women were not capable
of taking decisions independently and they were being influenced by the male members
in politics, which constitute 13.69 per cent of the sample, while 12 respondents had no
opinion, which constitute 8.22 per cent of the sample.
The comparative analysis of the two district depicts that most of the women
take decisions independently. It was observed that some women were not able to
participate independently in the decision making process, especially in the case of
being a chairperson. They were dependent on the male counterparts. Lack of experience
was the one of the factors for male dominance over their sphere of the activities.
Democratic Process
Indian democracy is the biggest democracy in the world having large number of
electorates. Though, the constitution of India has provided right to live with respect to
all citizens of India.69 Participation is the very backbone of democracy. It is the key
concept of self-governance because in one democracy decision making process begins
and ends with the people.70 In fact, 73rd amendment has created a scope for
accomplishing development with social justice, which is mandate of the new
Panchayati Raj system. The new system brings all those, who are interested to have
voice in decision making through their participation in PRIs. The Panchayati Raj
system is basis for the “Social Justice” and “Empowerment” of weaker section on
which, the development initiative have to be built upon for achieving overall, human
welfare of the society.
69
Rajender B. Daddamani, “Indian Democracy: Reality or Myth?”, Third Concept, Vol. 22, No. 256,
June 2008, p. 11.
70
Jyoti Prakash Samantray, “Grassroots Level Democracy in India- An Overview”, Indian Journal of
Research, Vol. 4, No.7, July 2015, p. 434.
327
Therefore, democracy
emocracy is never complete without the active involvement and
participation of the people at all levels and the institutions. It has gained considerable
strength, since independence at the national
n and state levels.
evels. People’s participation has
become necessary for the success of Panchayati Raj.71 Table shows respondents
opinion regarding democratic process is the best platform for women participation.
Table 5.13
Respondentss Opinion about PRIs as the Best Platform of Democratic Process
No. of Respondents
Grand Total
Sr.No Response Mandi Kangra
No. % age No. % age No. % age
1 Yes 137 94.48 127 86.99 264 90.72
2 No 6 4.14 13 8.90 19 6.53
3 No Opinion 2 1.38 6 4.11 8 2.75
Total 145 100.00 146 100.00 291 100.00
94.48
86.99
Mandi
100
Kangra
90
80
70
Percentage (%)
60
50
40
30
8.9
4.14
4.11
20
1.38
10
0
Yes No No Opinion
Response
Fig. 5.13: Respondentss Opinion about PRIs as the Best Platform of Democratic Process
Table 5.13 shows that out of 291 respondents, 264 respondents agreed with
Panchayati Raj Institutions was the best platform
pla of the democratic process,
process which
71
S.T. Shirsath and Jitender Wasnik, “Democracy and Development
Development at Grassroots in India”,
International Journal of Research in Applied Nature and Social Sciences, Vol. 2, No.7,
No. July 2014,
p.169.
328
constitute 90.72 per cent of the total sample, whereas 19 respondents who did not agree
democratic process, which constitute 6.53 per cent of the sample, there were 8
respondents who gave no opinion about this context which constitute 2.75 per cent of
the sample.
As far as in district Kangra out of 146 respondents, 127 respondents agreed with
the Panchayati Raj Institution was the best platform of the democratic process, which
constitute 86.99 per cent of the total sample, whereas 13 respondents who did not agree
democratic process, which constitute 8.90 per cent of the sample, there were 6
respondents who gave no opinion about this context. The percentage of such was 4.11
respectively.
Comparative analysis of two district reveals that the majority of the respondents
think that the Panchayati Raj Institution was the best platform of democratic process. It
was observed that democracy is never complete without the active involvement and
participation of the people at all levels and the institutions.
329
independence are necessary to be able to play an active part in the social and political
life. It is necessary to inspire women to be financially independent.72
According to Pooja Singh found that women issues were not taken up by parties
in a serious manner nor translated into programmes, policies and legislation nor were
they mandated specifically to address issues of women. The idea of 33% reservation for
women in parliament was actively endorsed by most of the major political parties and
this had raised expectation that many more women would be nominated to contest the
elections.76
72
M. P. Dube and Neeta Bora (eds.), op.cit., 1999, pp.142-145.
73
Anuradha Chadha, “Political Participation of Women: A Case Study in India”, International Journal
of Sustainable Development, Vol. 7, No. 2, 2014, p.105.
74
Barsha Kalita, op.cit., 2014, p. 6.
75
A. Thanikodi and M. Sugirtha, op.cit., 2007, p. 594.
76
Pooja Singh, “Representation of Women in Indian Politics”, Third Concept, Vol. 28, No. 327, May
2014, pp. 48-50.
330
Further, Sukhpal Kaur revealed that, great progress has been made in the arena
of women’s rights in theory and policy formation. Women’s rights and equality must
be looked with renewed vigour and vision. It should be an integral part of the
development and welfare policies of states and international organisations. Awareness
campaigns should be organised on women’s rights by civil society and dissemination of
knowledge of the various welfare measures, implemented by the state and international
organisation. The active involvement and association of the civil society in women’s
issues can accelerate the whole process, as it works at the grass-root level. The most
important thing for upliftment of women is to change the mind set of men folk as well
as women folk.77 It is in this regard P.V Krishna suggested that, women elected
representatives needs to be politically enlightened, not only about their rights and
duties, but also the nature of our constitution, democratic process and values, working
of democratic institutions, concept and relevance of local body administration, and
various poverty alleviation programmes and policies meant for women and weaker
sections.78 The table show that respondents views regarding increase women
participation in politics.
Table 5.14
77
Sukhpal Kaur, op.cit., 2009, p.128.
78
P.V. Krishna, “ Participation and Awareness of Elected Women Representatives in PRIs”, Voice
of Research, Vol. 2, No. 4, March 2014, p. 48.
331
59.31
60
Mandi
48.63 Kangra
50
40
Percentage (%)
30 26.03
19.18
20 16.55
14.48
10 5.52
4.14 4.79
1.37
0
Self Education Awareness Economic Others
Confidence Independence
Response
Table 5.14 shows that out of 291 respondents, 157 respondents suggested
increase their self confidence,
confidence which constitute 53.95 per cent of the total sample,
whereas 62 respondents suggested to increase educational level of women and girls,
girls
which constitute 21.31 per cent of the sample, while 49 respondents suggested to
increase awareness
ness which constitute 16.83 per cent of the sample. There were 13
respondents who provided economic independence of women,
women which constitute 4.47
per cent of the sample, while 10 respondents suggested other factors to increase women
participation in politics.
s. The percentage of such respondents was 3.44 of the total
sample.
332
8 respondents suggested other factors to increase women participation in politics. The
percentage of such respondents was 5.52 of the total sample.
The comparative analysis of two districts reveals that the respondents in both
districts suggested many ways and means to enhanced women’s participation in
politics. Majority of respondents suggested to increasing self confidence of women to
participate in politics. To provide political awareness, economic independence and
trainings for elected women representatives. Education brings confidence and develops
leadership qualities apart from enhancing knowledge and skills. It was observed that
after 73rd amendment more women participated in politics at grassroots levels.
Manakshi Sethy and Prabir Sethy observed that, the growth, equality,
democracy, social justice and an enlightened public policy could only be possible in a
political system, if the issue of development and political empowerment is taken up by
the political system in a meaningful way. Women’s representation in politics is regard
as the first step towards women’s empowerment. Even after more than seventy years of
India’s independence, women are still one of the most powerless and marginalized
section of the society. Women leaders tend to pay more attention to issues of health
care, education, and other social development issues than their male counterparts.
Women legislators should work for the empowerment of other women and for giving
them an equal chance in the governance of a state and a country. Though, the
participation in politics, women are making use of power and resources to bring about
necessary changes. Empowerment of women in all spheres, particularly in the political
sphere, is crucial for their advancement and establishment of a true gender equal
society.79 It is in this context Dhruba Hazarika reveals that women are also involving in
79
Manakshi Sethy and Prabir Sethy, “Politics of Representation through Reservation-II As An
Instrument of Women’s Empowerment”, Janta, 2011, p. 13.
333
human development issues of child rearing, education, health, and gender parity. Many
of them have gone into the making and marketing of a range of cottage products-
products
pickles, tailoring, embroidery etc.80
Table 5.15
Respondents Views as Women Political Activist what would be Your Priorities
No. of Respondents
Grand Total
Sr. No Response Mandi Kangra
No. % age No. % age No. % age
38.35
45 Mandi
40 Kangra
35
27.58
Percentage (%)
30
21.92
20.55
19.31
19.18
25
20
11.04
15
10
0
Improving Gender Equality To Remove Others
Education and Corruption
Health Facilities Response
Fig. 5.15: Respondents Views ass Women Political Activist what would be Your
Priorities
80
Dhruba Hazarika, “Women
Women Empowerment in India: A Brief Discussion”,
Discussion” International Journal of
Educational Planning and Administration, Vol. 1, No. 3, 2011, p. 201.
334
Table 5.15 shows that out of 291 respondents 117 respondents indicated that
their main priorities were improving education and health facilities, which constitute
40.21 per cent of the total sample, whereas 72 respondents worked for gender equality,
which constitute 24.74 per cent of the sample. While 58 respondents whose main
priority was to remove corruption, which constitute 19.93 per cent of the sample. There
were 44 respondents women political activists indicated that their main priority was to
solve other issues, which constitute 15.12 per cent of the sample.
Thus, India which is known for the culture and traditions, has also given a place
of respect to women. In the arena of Panchayati Raj Institutions also the rural women,
who were forced to live within the four walls of the house, have come out to take part
in the political process. Though, they are not much educated and not exposed to the
political affairs. They largely depend on male members and officials for advice and
carry on the work. The study reveals that caste is still dominating the politics in both
the district. The study also reveals that, women in higher caste capture powers in
different moulds in comparison to lower caste of the society.
The current study reveals that, several factors impede the political participation
and hence discriminates women. Major among them are caste, illiteracy, family
problem, corruption, male dominance etc. It has also been observed that there is
335
favouritism and corruption both at the level of allotment of the schemes and the time of
extending the benefit to the deserving section of the society. The study also reveals
that, there is too much bureaucratic control over PRIs, so a few respondents demanded
independent bureaucratic structure for the PRIs.
It has been observed during the study that, most of the elected women
representatives engaged in the implementation of policies and programmes were not
aware of the policies and programmes of Panchayati Raj Institutions, which is
responsible for the improper functioning of this institution.
The study also reveals that, while contesting election the women face many
social, economic and political problems. Due to lack of literacy and political awareness,
it has been observed during the study, the major problems faced by women leadership
are; male dominance, caste dominance, lack of awareness and above all family and
social pressure. Majority of the respondents in both districts reveals and believe that
women participation will improve in the long run. It has been major finding of the
study, the female literacy and increased awareness would surely make an enhancement
of women participation in grassroots institutions.
It is found during the study that elected women representatives are engaged in
the implementation of policy and programmes but not aware of the policies and
programmes of PRIs. Thus training of the elected women representatives attached to
the Panchayati Raj Institutions needs proper training. NGOs are also involved in the
training and the capacity building of elected representatives.
The comparative analysis of the two district reveals that majority of the
respondents indicated that, women as a political activists, the priorities were improving
education and health facilities. It was observed that, they gave importance to other
issues like, to work on gender equality, to remove corruption and to solve the other
problems of women and weaker section of society and to make people aware of their
rights and duties and work for the development of the villages.
336
CHAPTER-VI
Women play an important role in determining the destiny of a nation and are
integral parts of society. Their greater involvement in socio-economic and political
affair have becomes more important. However, history reveals that women have not
been given their actual status in the society. Socially, women are ignored a lot in the
society. They have been and still are the victim of various social taboos in general and
particularly in developing country like India. Though, they enjoy equality but this
equality is more in legal terms rather than in reality. Later, demand for political
equality of women started in eighteenth century. In Western Europe and North
America, where the idea of equality of the sexes first took roots, a change in status
preceded legislation and with the important exception of suffrage, was often not
dependent on law. New Zealand became the first country to enfranchise women in
1893. After independence, the Constitution of India has granted women equal rights of
participation in the political process of the country along with equal opportunity and
rights in education and employment. The Indian Constitution guarantees political
equality through the adult franchise.
The first world conference on women was held in 1975 in Mexico City. The
conference along with the United Nations Decade for women (1976-1985) launched a
new era in global efforts to promote the advancement of women by opening a
worldwide dialogue on gender equality. The report of the committee on the status of
women, the observance of International Women’s Year in 1975, the formulation of a
National Plan of Action for Women, setting up of a national committee with the Prime
Minister as the head, proved the concern for women. Since then scholars and policy-
337
makers diverted their attention to the issues of women, which culminated in
establishing a National Commission for Women in 1992 and the National Perspective
Plan for Women (1988-2000).
The first chapter deals with the problems of the study. Also the objectives and
reviews literature on women have been given, which shows that there were only a few
study on the participation of women in state politics: a case study of Himachal Pradesh.
In the present study, among twelve districts, the sample has been drawn from two
districts of Himachal Pradesh i.e. Mandi and Kangra district.
In the second chapter, the historical, social economic and political profile of
Himachal Pradesh has been discussed. Himachal Pradesh came into existence on 15th
April 1948 and achieved statehood on 25th January 1971 and became eighteenth state of
the Indian Union. It is a hilly and mountainous region, which extends over an area of
55, 673 sq. Kms. with a population of 68, 64, 609 persons as per 2011 census.
Himachal is known as Dev Bhumi (The Land of God). It is situated in the heart of the
Western Himalayas. According to the Puranas, Himachal is the Jalandhara Khand of
the Himalayas. The people of the state are considered to be innocent, honest, peace
loving and hardworking. Indian National Congress (INC) and Bhartiya Janta Party
(BJP) are the major political parties, including a few regional parties like Himachal
Vikas Congress (HVC), etc. Himachal Pradesh is predominantly a rural state.
338
Agriculture is the major occupation of the people. Cash crops i.e. Apple, Potato, Peas
Tomato, Ginger, Rajmah, Kiwi Fruits, Citrus Fruits and Floriculture are becoming
popular day by day. Himachal Pradesh has made significant achievements in the field
of economy. Road transport is the main stay of economic activity of the Pradesh.
Himachal Pradesh is one of the most literate and progressive states of the country. The
state has a large potential for the generation of hydel power and tourism etc. during the
past few decades. It helped in linking the mountainous region of Himachal Pradesh to
the plains and there is an increase in the health facilities.
Attempts have been made to study the comparative profile of Mandi and
Kangra district in terms of its socio-economic and political background of women. The
comparative study could be possible only because these factors were taken into
consideration to analyze the participation of women in their respective districts. The
women’s participation could not be studied in isolation without taking into
consideration the society in which they were living, the economic status of family and
the political scenario prevailing in the state. As far as the geographical area of Mandi
district is concerned, i.e.3950 sq. kms. and Kangra district is concerned, it is 5739 sq.
kms. respectively. The population of both district was 9, 99,777 and 15,10,075 Lakhs
respectively as per the Census 2011. The sex ratio is 1007 females for 1000 males in
district Mandi and 1012 females for 1000 males in district Kangra. The literacy rate in
Mandi is 81.53 per cent, the male literacy rate is 89.56 and female literacy rate is 73.66
per cent. At the same time, literacy rate in Kangra is 85.67 per cent, male literacy rate is
91.49 per cent and female literacy rate is 80.02 per cent. As far as the economy of both
district is concerned, the majority of the populations have agrarian background.
The third chapter deals with the political participation of women in India-an
overview. In Rig Vedic, Indian women enjoyed a position of equality in the family and
society. They also participated in the political activities along with men. There was a
gradual decline in their position in the later Vedic and post-Vedic period due to certain
internal changes in the society. The position of women in the Buddhist period could not
have changed very much from that of the earlier days. Nevertheless, there was some
improvement in their condition, due to the basic principles, which Buddha laid down in
his teachings. Buddha made no distinction between a man and a woman regarding the
attainment of spiritual ends. Buddha discarded the Brahmanic rituals, in which the wife
played a secondary part and a barren women or a widow had no place. The education
339
given to female novices and nuns was not different from that imparted to their male
counterparts. The status of women was raised in the Buddhist period, it cannot but be
admitted that, in the monastic order the place accorded to the nuns was lower than that
of the monks.
During medieval period, the women were deprived of different social and
economic rights and were brought out under the overall control of their male family
members. It is witnessed by the prevalent practices of Purdh system, child marriage,
sati system, ban on widow remarriage, polygamy and devadasi etc. Therefore, there
were women rulers and many women excelled in the sphere of politics in the medieval
period e.g. Razia Sultana, Empress Noorjahan, Chand Bibi, Maharani Jija Bai, Rani
Padmini, Rani Laxmi Bai etc. At the advent of British rule in India, women’s position
was worst in the society. The British rule led to a number of socio-religious reforms in
the country. The socio-religious reforms of the nineteenth and twentieth century like
Raja Ram Mohan Roy, Keshav Chander Sen, Swami Dayanand Sarswati, Iswar
Chander Vidya Sagar, Gopal Krishna Gokhale, Pandita Ramabai etc.
340
Prime Minister, Indira Gandhi for about two decades and we have first ever women
President Pratibha Devi Singh Patil, women speaker of Lok Sabha, Meera Kumar and
Sumitra Mahajan, leader of opposition in Lok Sabha Sushma Swaraj and women
President of the largest political party Indian National Congress of the Country, Sonia
Gandhi, we also have several women occupying high positions like those of governors,
chief ministers and minister both at central and state levels but their number is dismal.
Many of them are wives, daughters, sister, and daughters in laws and relatives of
prominent political leaders. The 73rd and 74th Amendment to the Constitution was the
landmark step to empowering women to participate in grassroots democracy.
Subsequently, the study found that the most of the countries of the world have
failed to give due space and representation to women in political life. The participation
of women in the politics is not as good as provided in the constitution. The highest
representation of women in the lower house of national legislatures is found in the
countries like Rwanda, Sweden, Cuba, South Africa, Finland, Iceland, Netherland etc.
whereas in developed countries like USA, UK, Canada Australia, etc. women
representation is the national legislatures is quite low. The data reveals that the
participation of women in politics at national and state level is still marginal. No doubt,
women’s participation in parliament has increased with the passage of time which is
seen in previous Lok Sabha elections. In the first Lok Sabha election held in 1952, only
twenty two women were elected, whereas in the Lok Sabha election held in 2014 the
number of women, who got elected increased to sixty one (11.23%) which is the
highest number till date. Whereas, women’s representation in Rajya Sabha is little as
women’s representation in this house at present is 11.83 per cent. Therefore, this
number is too small in comparison to their voting strength. One of the reasons for low
representation of women in Parliament is that political parties do not give adequate
number of women candidates in the elections. In the past Lok Sabha elections, the
number of women contestants remained very less in comparison to men, despite the
fact, that their percentage of winnability is quite higher as compared to men. Women’s
representation in decision-making bodies is also marginal. Like parliament, women’s
representation at state level has also been noticed few, as the most important positions
such as governor, chief minister and Vidhan Sabha speaker is also still too marginal.
341
Women, who are taking active part in politics, they belong to the well established
political family background and relatives of prominent politicians.
Women constitute about half of the total population in Himachal Pradesh. But
their participation in state legislative Assembly, Parliament and other prominent
decision-making bodies is very low. Women participation in voting is almost equal to
their male counterparts and sometimes, it is even more than that of men. Like
parliamentary elections, in Himachal Pradesh also very few women have contested the
assembly elections. The highest number of women representatives in Himachal Pradesh
legislative Assembly was seven in the year 1998-2003. Like state assembly, women’s
representation in parliament also remained very low from Himachal Pradesh. Till date,
only three women have represented Lok Sabha and seven women remained in Rajya
Sabha from Himachal Pradesh.
Therefore, it was observed that education and governmental efforts has helped
Himachal Pradesh women to reduce infant mortality considerably and improve the
health conditions of women. Thus, compared to the status of women belonging to
India, the women of Himachal Pradesh enjoy not only better educational and health
facilities but also better indices of standard of living. Death rate connected with
delivery has also come down considerably. As far as the security of women is
concerned, transport facilities and accommodations are of paramount importance.
Agriculture is the main occupation of the people of the state. About 69 per cent of the
main workers are engaged in agricultural pursuits. Agriculture is the best with the
disadvantage of small holdings. The villages in Himachal Pradesh are inter-linked with
transport facilities.
The fourth Chapter, deals with the socio-economic and political variables of the
study area of the respondents. The analysis of the socio-economic profile of the
respondents shows that majority of the respondents in the whole sample, as well as
342
Mandi and Kangra district belong to the middle age group of 31-40 years, women take
more part in politics. During the study, it has been analysed that the younger strata of
the respondents is taking active part in the politics in both the district.
As far as the caste factor was concerned, the caste plays a very important role
in the election. The women, who belonged to higher castes, won the elections more
easily than those, who belonged to lower caste. They had to face many problems during
the elections. In district Mandi, most of the respondents belonged to SCs and general
category, whereas in district Kangra, most of the respondents belonged to OBCs and
general category taking active part in politics.
Further, the study found that the majority of the respondents were married,
which showed that younger married women took part in the politics more as compared
to the unmarried and widowed women.
The study reveals that more women belonged to joint family in both the district.
The analysis of the number of children of the respondents, who had two children
participated actively in politics.
From education point of view, the study found that mostly the women
participated in the elections were not highly educated. This indicates that women are
taking part in politics are educated but their educational level is not very high.
Therefore, comparative analysis of both the district reveals that the educational level of
respondents of Mandi was higher than that of Kangra.
Further, the occupation wise analysis reveals that majority of the respondents in
the whole sample, as well as in Mandi and Kangra district are engaged in agricultural
activities. The study reveals that income is also an important indicator of social status.
Income wise analysis shows that, the income of the respondents is comparatively better
in Mandi district than in Kangra district.
The study found that the size of the land holdings of the respondents in Kangra
district was slightly better than that of Mandi district. The landholding size of Himachal
Pradesh is very small.
The study also found that the number of respondents, who were in habit of
reading newspaper was higher in district Mandi than that of Kangra district. The study
reveals that majority of the respondents were aware in habit of hearing news in
343
television or in radio. Hence, it has been revealed that television and radio programmes
are very effective in mobilizing women to participate in politics.
The analysis of both district reveals that the vast majority of the respondents in
both district were interested in politics. The increasing interest of the respondents in
politics shows that the family responsibility. Women are also developing a positive
attitude towards politics.
The study reveals that majority of the respondent’s father and husband did not
participate in politics. It was observed that participation in voting is higher among the
respondents. Majority of the respondents in Kangra district was higher, who casted
their vote in past election as compared to Mandi district.
Regarding the factors kept in mind, while casting the votes. Majority of the
respondents give preference to the candidate’s merits, educational level of the
candidates and party affiliation, while casting their votes. On the other hand, it was
observed that respondents gave less importance to other factors like religion, and caste
etc.
The study reveals that majority of the respondents contested election from the
village level. But state and national level participation is very dismal. It was observed
that village level participation of women were increased after reservation. The study
found that the number of respondents, who believed that they were motivated by their
family members.
The study found that, majority of the respondents in whole sample contested the
elections from the reserved seats for women. It was observed that women generally get
an opportunity to contest the elections only on those seats which were reserved for
women.
344
Party, are dominating the political scene of the state. The share of other political
parties is very negligible.
As far as the awareness and knowledge of the respondents regarding the 73rd
Constitutional Amendment Act and Himachal Pradesh Panchayati Raj Act, 1994 is
concerned, it is found that only 40.21 per cent of the respondents know about these new
acts relating to PRIs. This reveals that majority of the respondents are not much aware
about these acts. However, it is found that on the whole, they are at least aware about
some of the basic provisions of these acts regarding PRIs. An analysis of the role of
PRIs in the empowerment of women reveals that, an overwhelming majority of the
respondents accepted that empowerment of women has taken place only after the
implementation of 73rd Constitutional Amendment Act that facilitated women
participation and involvement in PRIs. This act has played an important role in the
changing society. Majority of the respondents (75.25%) were the view that the
345
participation and representation of women in PRIs has empowered women to extent in
political as well as social and economic spheres.
The study also reveals that majority of the respondents have agreed that,
reservation to women in PRIs has empowered them politically, as it has enhanced their
participation in the democratic process of the grassroots level. Due to reservation, a
large number of women have entered in PRIs and their participation in decision making
process at grass-roots level has increased.
Chapter fifth deals with the hurdles in the participation of women. The women
representatives are also facing many problems, while participating in the political
process. The main problems, which women representatives generally face, while
participating effectively includes lack of knowledge, lack of time due to earning
livelihood, lack of time due to family responsibilities and caring of children and lack
of funds to under to undertake developmental activities. The other problems faced by
women representatives are non-cooperation of the family member’s, lack of political
awakening, lack of interest in politics and lack of education.
The study shows that majority of the respondent’s perceived lack of time due to
family responsibilities, as the major hurdles in political participation of women. It was
observed that the higher castes woman comes into power easily as compared to women,
who belongs to the lower strata of the society. This decreases to a certain extent the
overall participation of women in the rural areas.
The study depicts that, there is corruption in various rural development schemes
in both district, there was favouritism and corruption i.e. during allotment of the
schemes and during extending the benefits to the deserving section of the society. The
beneficiaries do not take full advantage of the scheme. There is corruption at different
levels, which are involved in the process.
It has been observed during the study that, male members played a dominant
role in decision making process and many elected representatives have no identity of
their own and act as mere mouthpieces of powerful men in politics. The study also
reveals that, while contesting elections women faced many problems from their family
members and from the society.
346
The study also finds that majority of the respondents were in favour of
minimum educational qualification for women in politics. Illiterate women were not
able to participate in politics. It is observed that without proper education, they feel
hard to understand the rules of politics.
The majority of the respondents demanded reservation for women in state and
national levels. It was observed that women participation increased at grassroots level
after reservation. But women participation in state and national level is still very low.
On the basis of the entire study following findings have been derived.
• The finding clearly shows that women have very poor knowledge about the
Panchayati Raj Institution and Constitutional provisions, development
programmes and duties of the government official in the local administration.
The main reasons for lack of knowledge are illiteracy, lack of experience and
lack of interest in politics and public life.
• Most of the respondents are of the younger age group. Women are not able to
play an effective role because of low profile, poor orientation, lack of
enthusiasm and lack of political background. Besides, these individual
approaches, social obstacles such as, conservative approach, family
responsibility, and lack of co-operation from family.
• Majority of the respondents were not aware of the provisions and main
implications of the Himachal Pradesh Panchayati Raj Act, 1994. Even after
about twenty three years of the implementation of the Act, they have no idea
about the system. Because the reasons behind it are illiteracy, lack of awareness
and lack of interest.
347
Suggestions
To make the political participation of women more visible and effective the
following suggestions are made:
• It should make an intense drive for legal and political education for women.
Legal system aiming at elimination of all forms of discrimination against
women should be strengthened. In addition to that, awareness level about laws
should be raised among women.
• Syllabi in the school and higher education should be based on the practical
utility by which, the society should be sensitized. Male folk of the society
should realise the importance of female folk.
• Our social structure should be changed, so that women do not have to face
discrimination. Even today, many people think that the political area is not a
suitable place for women. Women will have to understand that their
participation in politics and other activities of life is necessary for them, to
become a significant part of the society and only this feeling can lead to their
development.
348
• Women’s political participation will be possible by creating multi seat
constituencies with women representing a part of it.
• There has to be some electoral reforms, which would curb the role of muscle
and money power in politics.
• To ensure that women are taken seriously in their elected post by allotting
important portfolios and limiting their functions to social welfare and women
and child development.
• All the women organizations should come on a common platform with single
target of passing of Reservation Bill or face anger of women voters in the next
general elections because a critical mass of women is pre-requisite for the
effective political participation of women.
• They can motivate women to contest election and to get a sense of economic
independence and self-confidence. Their participation in these organisations
should be ensured.
349
• There is also an urgent need of the co-operative and positive attitude of
bureaucracy/government officials towards women representatives of the PRIs.
The women development programmes should be linked with more effective
participation of women and also for establishing links between women
representatives and government functionaries at the grassroots level.
• The media both print as well as electronic can play an important role in creating
awareness in the society. It can act as an agent of political socialization for
inculcating the values of gender equality and gender justice.
350
In nutshell, it may be said that the spread of education, political awareness,
competence, willingness, self-confidence, motivation, encouragement and support from
the family, society and political parties will help in bringing women in the mainstream
of political arena.
To sum up, in politics we are still struggling to find a place for women. The
under-representation and absence of women in the positions of power and decision-
making process reinforces their exploitation and deprivation. Women’s greater political
participation and representation is needed to alter the male dominated structure of
political process. Women’s equal participation in political decision-making process is a
fundamental pre-requisite not only for gender equality, gender justice and genuine
democracy but also for the reconstruction of the society. More number of women
representatives means more women will be involved in policy and decision-making
processes and will contribute to stronger attention to women’s issues and will provide
an inspiration to women to work on the vision of a better, more humane and a more
equal society, and they will make meaningful contributions towards integrated national
development. However, more efforts are still required to bring about true equality of
women in political arena in letter and spirit. Women still have a long way to go to
attain political power and gender justice. They have to assert for their de facto political
rights. There is a need for qualitative positive change in the socio-economic and
political structure of the society.
351
BIBLIOGRAPHY
..., The Changing Status of Women in India: Issues and Challenges, New Delhi:
Kanishka Publishers, 2013.
---., Social, Cultural and Economic History of Himachal Pradesh, New Delhi: Indus
Publishing Company, 1998.
Almond, Gabriel A., and Verba, Sidney, The Civic Culture: Political Attitudes and
Democracy in Five Nations, United States of America: Princeton University
Press, 1963.
Altekar, A.S., The Position of Women in Hindu Civilization, 2nd edition, Delhi: Motilal
Banarsidass, Publisher, 1959.
Angus, Campbell, et al., The American Voter, New York: John Wiley and Sons, 1964.
Agneu, Vijay, Elite Women in Indian Politics, New Delhi: Vikas Publishing House,
1986.
Arora, Ramesh K., and Hooja Meenakshi (eds.), Panchayati Raj Participation and
Decentralization, New Delhi: Rawat Publications, 2009.
Ashraf, Ali and Sharma, L.N., Political Sociology, Madras: University Press, 1983.
Ashraf, Ali, Government and Politics of Big Citizens, New Delhi: Concept Publishing
Company, 1977.
353
Attri, Rajender, Introduction to Himachal Pradesh, Shimla: Sarla Publications, 2002.
Baig, Tara Ali, Indian Women Power, 1st Edition, New Delhi: S. Chand and Company,
1976.
Biju, M. R., Dynamics of New Panchayati Raj System: Reflections and Retrospections,
New Delhi: Kanishka Publishers, 1998.
Bala, Raj, The Legal and Political Status of Women in India, New Delhi: Mohit
Publications, 1999.
---., Tribal Women Empowerment and Gender Issues, New Delhi: Kanishka Publishers,
2001.
Basu, Aparna, The Role of Women in the Indian Struggle for Freedom, New Delhi:
Allied Publishers, 1970.
Beteille, Andre, Ideology and Social Science, United Kingdom: Penguin Books 2006.
Bhagi, M. L., Medieval India: Culture and Thought, Ambala: The Indian Publications,
1965.
Bhandari, Asha and Mehta, Rekha, Women, Justice and the Rule of Law, New Delhi:
Serials Publications, 2009.
Barr, Pat and Desmond Ray, Shimla: A Hill Station in British India, Delhi: B.R.
Publishing Corporation, 1978.
Bhatt, B.D. and Sharma, S.R., Women’s Education and Social Development, Delhi:
Kanishka Publishing House, 1992.
Battu, Nagaraju, Empowerment of Women in India: New Strategies, New Delhi: Regal
Publications, 2014.
Buch, Nirmala, From Oppression to Assertion: Women and Panchayats in India, New
Delhi: Routledge, 2010.
354
Buck, Edward J., Shimla: Past and Present, Shimla: Minerva Book House, 1989.
Chahar, S.S. (ed.), Governance at Grassroots Level in India, New Delhi: Kanishka
Publishers, 2005.
Chand, Gian and Puri, Manohar, Trekking in India, New Delhi: International
Publishers India, 1983.
Chaudhary, D.S., and Kar, G.K., Elections and Electoral Behaviour in India, Delhi:
Kanti Publications, 1992.
Chakravarti, Manas and Agrawala, Vidyawati, Women and Politics in India, Ambala
Cantt: The Associated Publishers, 2006.
Chark, Sukhdev Singh, History and Culture of Himalayan States- Himachal Pradesh,
Vol. 2, New Delhi: Light and Life Publishers, 1979.
Chib, Sukhdev Singh, This Beautiful India: Himachal Pradesh, New Delhi: Light and
Life, 1977.
Das, Purdah, The Status of Indian Women, New York: Vanguard Press, 1932.
Desai, Neera, Women in Modern India, Bombay: Vora Publishing House, 1977.
Devi, Laxmi, Women and Development, New Delhi: Anmol Publications, 1998.
Dey, S.K., Panchayati Raj: A Synthesis, Bombay: Asia Publishing House, 1961.
Dowse, Robert E., Political Sociology, London: John Wiley and Sons. 1972.
355
Dube, M.P. and Bora, Neeta (eds.), Social Justice and Women in India, Delhi: Swaraj
Prakashan, 1999.
Dutta, Nandita and Jha, Sumitra, Women and Politics, Delhi: Pacific Books
International, 2014.
Everett, Jana Matson, Women and Social Change in India, New Delhi: B.R. Chawala
Heritage Publishers, 1979.
Everett, Jana Matson and Chawla, B.R., Women and Social Change in India, New
Delhi: Macmillan, 1981.
Ghosh, Ratna and Pramanik, Alok Kumar, Panchayat System in India: Historical,
Constitutional and Financial Analysis, New Delhi: Kanishka Publishers, 2007.
Goel, Madan Lal, Political Participation in Developing Nation: India Bombay, Asia
Publishing House, 1974.
Goel, Shashi, Domestic Violence against Women, Jaipur: Literary Circle, 2013.
Goyal, Omita, Interrogating Women’s Leadership and Empowerment, New Delhi: Sage
Publications, 2015.
Gupta, A.K., Emerging Pattern of Political Leadership: A Case Study of Punjab, New
Delhi: Mittal Publications, 1991.
Gupta, R., Himachal Pradesh General Knowledge, New Delhi: Ramesh Publishing
House, 2004.
2005.
356
Henry, Chafe, William, The American: Her Changing Social, Economic and Political
Roles, New York: Oxford University Press, 1972.
Hutchison, J. and Vogel J. Ph., History of the Panjab Hill States, Vol. 1, Shimla:
Director of Languages and Culture, Himachal Pradesh, 1982.
Indira, R., and Behera, Deepak Kumar, Gender and Society in India, New Delhi:
Manak Publications, 1999.
Jain, C.K., Women Parliamentarians in India, New Delhi: Surjeet Publications, 1993.
Jha, Ashok Kumar, Women and Panchayati Raj Institution, New Delhi: Anmol
Publications, 2004.
Jha, Uma Shankar and Pujari, Prem Lata, (eds.), Indian Women: Tradition, Modernity
and Challenge, Vol. 3, New Delhi: Kanishka Publishers, 1996.
Jha, Uma Shankar, et al., (eds.), Status of Indian Women Crisis and Conflict in Gender
Issues, Vol. 3, New Delhi: Kanishka Publishers, 1998.
Jharta, Bhawana, Women and Politics in India: Impact of Family and Education on
Women Political Activists, New Delhi: Deep and Deep Publications, 1998.
Jena, B.B., and Baral, J.K., Election Politics and Voting Behaviour in India, Delhi:
Discovery Publishing House, 1989.
Jones, W. H. Morris, The Government and Politics of India, New Delhi: Universal
Books, 1989.
Joshi, Savita Thakur (ed.), Women and Development: The Changing Scenario, New
Delhi: Mittal Publications, 1999.
Kaur, Inderjeet, Status of Hindu Women in India, Allahabad: Chugh Publication, 1983.
357
Kiran, Devendra, Changing Status of Women in India, 3rd edition, New Delhi: Vikas
Publishing House, 1994.
Kiran, Usha, Participation of Women in Indian Politics: Gender Justice and Political
Challenge, Delhi: Globus Press, 2016.
Kumar, A., Indian Women: A Historical Perspective, New Delhi: Anmol Publications,
2006.
Kumar, Hajira and Varghese, Jaimon, Women’s Empowerment Issues, Challenges &
Kumar, Raj (ed.), Encyclopaedia of Women and Development, Vol. 5, New Delhi:
Anmol Publications, 2000.
Lal, S., Women in Indian Politics, New Delhi: Kunal Books, 2010.
Lima, Hazel, D., Women in Rural Government: A Study of Maharashtra, New Delhi:
Concept Publishing Company, 1983.
Lipset, Seymour Martin, Political Man, New Delhi: Arnold Heineman, 1973.
McDowell, Linda and Sharp, Joanne P., (eds.), A Feminist Glossary of Human
Geography, New York: Oxford Press, 1999.
358
Maheshwari, S. R., State Government in India, New Delhi: Metropolitan, 1979.
Mathew, George, Panchayati Raj from Legislation to Movement, New Delhi: Concept
Publishing Company, 1995.
Mathur, Hari Mohan, Administering Development in the Third World: Constraints and
Choices, New Delhi: Sage Publications, 1986.
Mehta, Arati, Progressive Women and Political Identity, New Delhi: Kanishka
Publishers, 2004.
Mehta, G.S., Participation of Women in the Panchayati Raj System, New Delhi:
Kanishka Publishers, 2008.
Mehta, S.K. and Chhabra, A.R., Political Theory, Jallandhar: New Academic
Publishing Company, 2005.
Mishra, R.C., Women in India towards Gender Equality, Delhi: Authors Press, 2006.
Mishra, S.N., Politics and Society in Rural India, New Delhi: India Publications, 1980.
Mishra, S.N., Pattern of Emerging Leadership in Rural India, Patna: Associated Book
Agencies, 1977.
Mishra, R.B., and Singh, Chandrapal, Indian Women Challenges & Change, New
Delhi: Commonwealth, 2017.
Mitra, Jyoti, (ed.), Women Empowerment and Challenges of Changed, New Delhi:
Kanishka Publisher, 1997.
Misra, Preeti, Domestic Violence against Women: Legal Control and Judicial
Response, New Delhi: Deep and Deep Publications, 2007.
Mitto, Hari Krishan, India-The Land and the People-Himachal Pradesh, Delhi:
National Book Trust, 1978.
Nagendra, S., Ambedkar and Nagendra, Shilaja, Women Empowerment and Panchayati
Raj, Jaipur: ABD Publishers, 2005.
Narayan, Shriman (ed.), The Selected Works of Mahatma Gandhi, Vol. 6, Ahmadabad:
Navjivan Publishing House, 1968.
359
Negi, S.S., Himachal Pradesh: The Land and People, New Delhi: Indus Publishing
Company, 1993.
---., Discovering the Himalaya, Vol. 2, New Delhi: Indus Publishing Company, 1998.
Nehru, J. L., Glimpses of World History, New Delhi: Asia Publishing House, 1967.
Neshla, Atrocities Against Women, New Delhi: Herman Publishing House, 1997.
Palanithurai, G., et al. (eds.), Major Issues in New Panchayati Raj System, New Delhi:
Kanishka Publishers, 1997.
Palmer, Norman D., Elections and Political Development: The South Asian Experience,
New Delhi: Vikas Publication, 1976.
Pandya, Rameshwari (ed.), Women in India: Issues, Perspectives and Solutions, New
Delhi: New Century Publications, 2007.
---(ed.)., Women Welfare and Empowerment in India, New Delhi: New Century
Publications, 2008.
Pandhy, K.S., and Satapathy, Purna Chandra, Tribal India, New Delhi: Ashish
Publishing House, 1989.
Parvathamma, C., Scheduled Castes and Tribes: A Socio-Economic Survey, New Delhi:
Ashish Publishing House, 1984.
Parmar Y.S., Himachal Pradesh: Its Proper Shape and Status, Shimla: Directorate of
Public Relations Himachal Pradesh, 1965.
Prasad, R.C., Democracy and Development, New Delhi: Rachna Prakashan, 1971.
360
Raj, Maithreyi Krishna (ed.), Women’s Studies in India: Some Perspective, Bombay:
Popular Prakashan, 1986.
Rajput, Pam and Swarup, Hem Lata (eds.), Women and Globalisation: Reflections,
Options and Strategies, New Delhi: Ashish Publishing House, 1994.
Rout, Himanshu Sekher and Panda, Prasant Kumar (eds.), Gender and Development in
India: Dimensions and Strategies, New Delhi: New Century Publications,
2008.
Roy, Kalpana, Women in Indian Politics, New Delhi: Rajat Publications, 1999.
Ranganath, The Changing Pattern of Leadership in Uttar Pradesh, New Delhi: Indian
Academy of Social Sciences, 1971.
Sachchidananda, The Tribal Voter in Bihar, New Delhi: National Publishing House,
1976.
Sachidananda and Ramesh, P.S., Women Right: Myth and Reality, Jaipur: Printwell
Publishers, 1984.
Seshadri, K., Political Linkages and Rural Development, New Delhi: National
Publishing House, 1976.
Shah, Ghanshyam, Social Movement in India: A Review of Literature, New Delhi: Sage
Publications, 1990.
Sharma, K.L., Indian Social Structure and Change, Jaipur: Rawat Publications, 2007.
361
Sharda, Mridula, Evolution of Panchayati Raj in India: From Traditional to
Constitutionalize Panchayats, New Delhi: Kanishka Publishers, 2010.
Sharma, Ram Sharan, Aspects of Political Ideas and Institutions in Ancient India,
Delhi: Motilal Banarsidass, 1968.
---., Political Ideas and Institutions in Ancient India, New Delhi: Mittal Banarsi Dass,
1959.
Sharma, Ranbir, Party Politics in a Himalayan State, New Delhi: National Publishing
House, 1977.
Sharma, Shakuntla, Grassroot Politics and Panchayati Raj, New Delhi: Deep and Deep
Publication, 1994.
Sharma, Usha and Sharma, B.M., Women and Profession, New Delhi: Commonwealth
Publishers, 1995.
Shukla, A.K., Women Chief Ministers in Contemporary India, New Delhi: APH
Publishing Corporation, 2007.
Singh, Arun Kumar, Political Orientation of People in Rural India, New Delhi: Mittal
Publications, 1987.
Singh, Dharam Raj, Rural Leadership among Scheduled Castes, Allahabad: Chugh
Publications, 1985.
Singh, Har Gopal, A Period of Hot Politics in Himachal Pradesh and Other Notes,
Solan: Har Gopal Singh Publishers, 1996.
Singh, Reena, Gender Composition: Values, Preferences and Behaviour, New Delhi:
Rawat Publications, 2001.
Singh, Shiv Raj, Bureaurcacy and Rural Development: Policy Making, Planning and
Implementation, New Delhi: Mittal Publications, 1989.
Singh, Anupama, Bureaucracy at the Grassroots Level in India, New Delhi: Kanishka
Publishers, 2006.
Singh, J.L., Women and Panchayati Raj, New Delhi: Sunrise Publications, 2005.
362
Singh, Mian Goverdhan, Social Cultural and Economic Survey of Himachal Pradesh,
Simla: Minerva Book House, 1985.
---., Himachal Pradesh History, Culture & Economy, Shimla: Minerva Publishers,
2010.
Singh, Nishant, Indian Constitution and Women, New Delhi: Omega Publications,
2011.
Singh, R.S., Rural Elite Entrepreneurship and Social Change, Jaipur: Rawat
Publications, 1985.
Singh, S.K., and Singh, A.K., OBC Women Status and Educational Empowerment,
Lucknow: New Royal Book Company, 2004.
Singh, Sarita, Women in Different Ages: Traditional to Modern, New Delhi: Omega
Publications, 2015.
Singh, Sarbjeet and Dodh, Pankaj, (eds.), Gender Justice and Women Empowerment:
An Integrated Approach, New Delhi: Regal Publications, 2013.
Singh, Shiv Raj, et al.,(eds.), Public Administration in the New Millennium: Changing
and Prospects, New Delhi: Anamika Publishers, 2003.
Singh, Tejvir and Kaur Jagdish (eds.), Himalayas, Mountains and Men, Lucknow: Print
House, 1983.
Singh, V.B., Profiles of Political Elites in India, Delhi: Ritu Publications, 1984.
Sinha, A.K., Panchayati Raj and Empowerment of Women, New Delhi: Northern Book
Centre, 2004.
Sinha, Anjana Maitra, Women in a Changing Society, New Delhi: Ashish Publishing
House, 1993.
Sinha, Ajit Kumar (ed.), New Dimensions of Women Empowerment, New Delhi: Deep
and Deep Publications, 2008.
363
Srinivas, M.N., Caste in Modern India and Other Essays, Bombay: Asia Publishing
House, 1962.
Tandon, Neeru, Feminism: A Paradigm Shift, New Delhi: Atlantic publishers, 2008.
Thakur, Minni, Women Empowerment through Panchayati Raj Institutions, New Delhi:
Concept Publishing Company, 2010.
Thomas, P., Indian Women through the Ages, Bombay: Asia Publishing House, 1964.
Trivedi, B.R., Constitutional Equality and the Women’s Right, New Delhi: Cyber Tech
Publication, 2010.
Tripathi, N.M., Minority and Law, Delhi: Indian Law Institute, 1972,
Vali, Mastan, Women and Politics, New Delhi: Anmol Publications, 2002.
Verma, B.M., Rural Leadership in a Welfare Society: A Study in Social Status and Role
Performance, New Delhi: Mittal Publications, 1994.
---., Shimla Hill States in 19th Century, New Delhi: B.R. Publishing Corporation, 2008.
Varma, Sudhir, Women’s Struggle for Political Space, Jaipur: Rawat Publications,
1997.
Verba, Sidney and Nie, Norman H., Participation in America: Political Democracy
and Social Equality, New York: Harper and Row Publishers, 1972.
Verma S.P. and Narain Iqbal, Voting Behaviour in a Changing Society: A Case Study
of the Fourth General Election in Rajasthan, Delhi: National Publishing
House, 1973.
364
Vidya, K.C., Political Empowerment of Women at the Grassroots, New Delhi:
Kanishka Publishers, 1997.
Vij, Madhu, et al., Women’s Studies in India: A Journey of 25Years, Jaipur: Rawat
Publications, 2014.
Articles
Ahmed, Imtiaz, “Women in Politics”, in Jain, Devaki (ed.), Indian Women, New
Delhi: Publications Division, 1975.
Aiyar, Mani Shankar, “Towards Holistic Panchayat Raj”, Yojana, Vol. 57, August
2013.
Altekar, Anant Sadashiv, “Ideal and Position of Indian Women in Social Life”, in
Swami Madhavananda and Ramesh Chandra Majumdar (eds.), Great Women
of India, Almora: Advaita Ashrama, 1953.
Anand, Neeta, “Working Women: Issues and Problems”, Yojana, Vol.47, March 2003.
Asnal, Wan, et al., “Political Attitude and Voting Behaviour”, International Journal of
Humanities and Management Sciences, Vol. 1, No. 1, 2013.
365
Anwer, M. Tarique, “Development of Female Education”, Third Concept, Vol. 31, No.
362, April 2017.
Banday, Mohd Muzaffar and Ganesan, P., “Economic Empowerment of Rural Muslim
Women in Kashmir Valley”, Third Concept, Vol. 30, No. 356, October 2016.
Bari, Farza, “Women’s Political Participation; Issues and Challenges”, Paper Presented
in Expert Group Meeting, Division for the Advancement of Women (DAW),
Bangkok, Thailand, 8-11 November, 2005.
Bajpai, B.K., “Knowledge attitude, Behaviour and Electoral Practises of Voters in Uttar
Pradesh”, The Indian Journal of Political Science, Vol. 73, No. 4, October-
December 2012.
Begum, S. Mehartaj, “Women Rights and Rural Employment”, Kurukshetra, Vol. 48,
No. 7, April 2000.
Bhuyan, Dasarathi, “Participation in Panchayati Raj”, Yojana, Vol. 52, October 2008.
Bora, Neeta and Padalia, Munni, “Involvement of Women in India’s Political Process”,
in M.P. Dube and Neeta Bora (eds.), Social Justice and Women in India,
Delhi: Swaraj Prakashan, 1999.
Bhan, Chander and Singh Raj, “Women’s Empowerment for Gender Equality: A
Functional Analysis,” Kurukshetra, Vol. 49, No. 11, August 2001.
Bhoite, Anuradha, “Women and Democracy in India”, Kerala Sociologist, Vol. 16,
December 1988.
Bhaskar, Manu, “Women and Grass-root Politics: Theoretical Issues and Social
Concern of Kerala Women”, South Asian Journal of Socio-Political Studies,
Vol. 1, No.1, January-June 2000.
366
Buch, Nirmala, “Panchayat and Women”, Kurukshetra, Vol. 49, No.7, April 2001.
Chakra, Barti, Bidyut, “Gender Question in Freedom Struggle”, Mainstream, Vol. 43,
No. 12, March 2005.
Chakravorti, Robi, “Asia’s Women leaders and Dynastic Charisma”, Economic and
Political Weekly, Vol. 34, No. 4, October 1999.
367
Chhetri, Durga Prasad, “Women in Public Sphere: An Enquiry into Women’s
Representation and Participation in Politics”, American International Journal
of Research in Humanities, Arts and Social Sciences, Vol. 6, No.1, March-May
2014.
Chaturvedi, S.K., “Women Participation in Political Process”, in M.P. Dube and Neeta
Bora (eds.), Social Justice and Women in India, Delhi: Swaraj Prakashan,
1999.
Chattopadhyay, Swati, “Political Participation of Women”, Third Concept, Vol. 29, No.
339, May 2015.
Chhibber, Bharti, “Women and the Indian Political Process”, Mainstream, Vol. 48, No.
18, April 2010.
Daddamani, Rajender B., “Indian Democracy: Reality or Myth?”, Third Concept, Vol.
22, No. 256, June 2008.
Devi Annapurna and Pati, N. M., “Women in State Politics (Orissa),” Political Science
Review, Vol. 20, 1981.
368
Dhall Manju, “Amartya Sen and the Women’s Year of Empowerment”, Mainstream,
Vol. 40, No.19, April 2002.
Dogra, Bharat, “Women Make a Remarkable Contribution,” Mainstream, Vol. 41, No.
27, June 2003.
Dutta, Suvrokamal, “In the Name of Women Unite the Adi Shakti, Do Not Divide It”,
Mainstream, Vol. 48, No.13, March 2010.
Gaonkar, Maya S., “Political Empowerment of Women in India,” Third Concept, Vol.
24, No. 278, April 2010.
Gautam, Jyoti, “Gender Issues in Higher Education”, Third Concept, Vol. 29, No. 345,
November 2015.
Geetamma, K., “Corruption in India: Causes and Remedies”, Third Concept, Vol. 30,
No. 360, February 2017.
Ghatak, Sandip Kumar, “Political Participation of Women of West Bengal its Nature
and Extent”, The Indian Journal of Political Science, Vol. 71, No. 1, January-
March 2010.
369
Hazarika, Dhruba, “Women Empowerment in India: A Brief Discussion”, International
Journal of Educational Planning and Administration, Vol. 1, No. 3, 2011.
Hedlund, Ronald D., “The Electability of Women Candidates: The Effects of Sex Role
Stereotypes, The Journal of Politics, Vol. 41, No. 2, 1979.
Iyer, Lakshmi, “The Electoral Participation of Women’’, Yojana, Vol. 58, July 2014.
Jain, Nisha, “Women’s Reservation Bill and Gender Justice”, Mainstream, Vol. 48, No.
18, April 2010.
Kailash, K. K.,“Regional Parties in the 16th Lok Sabha Elections Who Survived and
Why?”, Economic and Political Weekly, Vol. 49, No. 39, September 2014.
Kamala, Prasad, “Lok Sabha Election 2009: Emerging Trends in National Politics”,
Mainstream, Vol. 47, No.12, March 2009.
Kathalgu, K., “Indian Women in Development Perspective”, Kurukshetra, Vol. 56, No.
11, September 2008.
370
Kaur, Sukhpal, “Women’s Rights: A Historical Perspective”, The Indian Journal of
Political Science, Vol. 70, No. 1, January-March 2009.
Khan, Azam and Alam, Tosib, “Empowerment of Rural Women and Local Self-
Governance”, in Asha Bhandari and Rekha Mehta, Women, Justice and the
Rule of Law, New Delhi: Serials Publications, 2009.
Khosla,Tamanna, “Is Democracy Bad for Women?”, Mainstream, Vol. 51, No.18,
April 2013.
Kondo, Norio, “The 15th Lok Sabha Election: Resurgance of Congress?”, Social Action
a Quarterly Review of Social Trends, Vol. 59, No. 3, July-September 2009.
Kumar, Ashutosh and Sekhon, Jagroop Singh, “Punjab: Resurgence of the Congress”,
Economic and Political Weekly, Vol. 44, No. 39, September 2009.
Kumar, Ramesh, “Political Parties in India and the United Sates: A Comparative
Analysis”, The Indian Journal of Political Science, Vol. 72, No.2, April-June
2011.
Kumar, Vijay, “Women’s Reservation Bill”, Mainstream, Vol.48, No.18, April 2010.
371
Kunnumkal, Mathew C, “Grassroots Level Democracy in Indian an Assessment”,
Yojana, Vol.55, February 2011.
Laitonjam, Muhindro Singh, “Political Morality and Ethics in Indian Polity”, The
Indian Journal of Political Science, Vol. 69, No. 2. April- June 2008.
Laitonjam, Reena, “Women Empowerment in Manipur”, Third Concept, Vol. 27, No.
314, April 2013.
Lee, Marcia Manning, “Why Few Women Hold Public Office: Democracy and Sexual
Roles”, Political Science Quarterly, Vol. 91, No. 2, 1976.
Mall, Sangeeta, “Women’s Civil and Political Rights”, Mainstream, Vol., No. ,
December 2003.
Manisha, M., “Why do We Need Parliament?” Mainstream, Vol. 51, No. 12, March
2013.
Mathew, George, “Enemies of Panchayati Raj”, Mainstream, Vol. 40, No.12, March
2002.
Mathiraj, S.P. and Nagarajan, P.S., “Empowerment of Women in India: Then and
Now”, Third Concept, Vol. 24, No. 280, June 2010.
Mirza, Amna, “Women Reservation Bill Imperfect yet Perfect”, Mainstream, Vol. 48,
No.13, March 2010.
372
Mohan, Surendra, “Struggle for Women’s Empowerment Suffers Blows as Warrior
Leaders Depart”, Mainstream, Vol. 40, No.11, March 2002.
Nair, V. Deepa, “Status of Women in Andhra Pradesh A Paradigm Shift”, Man and
Development, Vol. 32, No. I, March 2010.
Nandal, Vikas and Rajnish, “Status of Women through Ages in India”, International
Research Journal of Social Sciences, Vol. 3, No. 1, January 2014.
Narayanan, Usha, “Women in Panchayat: The Path Ahead”, Mainstream, Vol. 48,
No.13, March 2010.
---., “Women in Panchayats: The Path Ahead,” Mainstream, Vol. 34, No. 50,
November 1996.
Narasimhan, Sakuntala, “Women’s Role in Gram Sabha”, Kurukshetra, Vol. 48, No.1,
October 1999.
373
Nayyar, Benu, “Status of Women in 21st Century India”, in Meenu Agarwal (ed.),
Women Empowerment: Today’s Vision for Tomorrow’s Mission, New Delhi:
Mahamaya Publishing House, 2007.
Ojha, Purnima, “Women’s Issues in India: Role and importance of Media”, The
Indian Journal of Political Science, Vol. 72, No. 1, January-March 2011.
Ojha, Suman, “Reservation of Women in the Indian Parliament: Lessons from Other
Countries”, The Indian Journal of Political Science, Vol. 70, No. 2, April- June
2009.
Omvedt, Gail, “Women in Governance in South Asia”, Economic and Political Weekly,
Vol. 40, No. 44-45, October-November 2005.
Prema, A., “Women Status in India”, Indian Streams Research Journal, Vol. 2, No.1,
February 2012.
Perumal, M., et al., “Empowering Rural Women Through Self- Help Groups”, in Asha
Bhandari and Rekha Mehta (eds.), Women, Justice and the Rule of Law, New
Delhi: Serials Publications, 2009.
Pandit, Latha A., “Political Leadership of Women: Constraints and Challenges”, The
Indian Journal of Political Science, Vol. 71, No. 4, October-December 2010.
374
Pathak, Avijit, “Looking Beyond Reservation Need for the Feminisation of Politics”,
Mainstream, Vol. 36, No, 36, August 1998.
Puri, Bal Raj, “Permanent Resident Bill of J&K is Anti-Women”, Mainstream, Vol. 48,
No.13, March 2010.
Rath, Saswatee, “Feel Good Factor and Condition of Women in India”, Mainstream,
Vol. 42, No. 21, May 2004.
Ray, Suranjita, “Experiencing the Indian Democratic State”, Mainstream, Vol. 48,
No.18, April 2010.
Sapra, Ritu and Khatter, Divya, “Women Empowerment in India”, Third Concept, Vol.
28, No. 325, March 2014.
Satpathi, Sayantani, “The Impact of the Electronic Media on the Modern Indian Voter:
A Study of the Post Liberalization Era”, Global Media Journal, Summer Issue,
June 2011.
375
Shettar, Rajeshwari M., “A Study on Issues and Challenges of Women Empowerment
in India”, Journal of Business and Management, Vol. 17, No. 4, April 2015.
Sridharan E., “Class Voting in the 2014 Lok Sabha Elections the Growing Size and
Importance of the Middle Classes”, Economic and Political Weekly, Vol. 49,
No. 39, September 2014.
Sachar, Rajindar, “Need for a Mass Social Movement”, Mainstream, Vol. 41, No. 28,
June 2003.
Sachar, Rajindar, “Pass Immediately Women’s Reservation Bill”, Mainstream, Vol. 48,
No.13, March 2010.
Sain, Sunil Kumar and Kaware, Sudhir Sudam, “A Present Status of Women Education
in India”, Educationia Confab, Vol. 2, No. 9, September 2013.
Smith, Barbara, “Racism and Women Studies,” in Hull, G., et.al (ed.), But Some of us
Are Brave, New York: The Feminist Press, 1982.
376
Sayeed, S. M, “Women’s Participation in UP Politics: A Study of Politics Attitudes and
Performance of the Women Members of the UP Assembly”, The Indian
Journal of Political Science, Vol.32, No. 2, April-June 1971.
Sharma, Anju, “Violence and Safety Scenario of Women- A World Wide Concern”, in
Mamta Mokta (ed.), Women Saftey & Security: Issues Challenges, Chandigarh:
Mohindra Publishing House, 2015.
Sharma, Kavita, “Political Advertising and Voting Behaviour in India: The Mediating
Role of Voting Decision Involvement”, International Journal of Law and
Social Sciences, Vol.1, No.1, January 2012.
Sharma, Mamta, “NCW: Twenty Years of Empowering Women”, Yojana, Vol. 56,
June, 2012.
377
Sharma, Shailendar, “Access to Education”, Yojana, Vol. 60, January 2016.
Sharma, T.R., “Himachal Pradesh: Two Party Competition in a Small State”, Journal
of Indian School of Political Economy, Vol. 15, No. 1-2, January-June 2003.
Srinivsan, R., “Emerging Trends in NGO Sector- A Study of Tamil Nadu”, The Indian
Journal of Political Science, Vol. 66, No.2, April-June 2005.
Singh, Ajit Pal, et al., “Women’s Participation in National Politics as Seen in the Lok
Sabha Election 2009”, Mainstream, Vol. 48, No. 21, May 2010.
Singh, Inderjeet, “Globalization: Its Impact on Women Human Right in India”, The
Indian Journal of Political Science, Vol. 69, No. 2, April- June 2008.
Singh, Mohindra and Kumar Vijay, “State Control Over Panchayati Raj Institutions”,
The Indian Journal of Political Science, Vol. 66, No. 2, April- June 2005.
Singh, Prem, “World Social forum: Myth and Reality”, Mainstream, Vol. 42, No. 5,
January 2004.
Singh, Pooja, “Representation of Women in Indian Politics”, Third Concept, Vol. 28,
No. 327, May 2014.
378
Singh, Rakesh K.,“Elected Women Representatives in Panchayat Raj”, Social Action,
Vol. 62, January-March 2012.
Sinha, Chandni, “Education and Empowerment of Women”, Third Concept, Vol. 21,
No. 243, May 2007.
Srinivasan, “Women Empowerment and Parliament in India”, Third Concept, Vol. 28,
No. 331, September 2014.
Srivastva, Rashmi, “The Role of Women in Indian Politics”, Political Science Review,
Vol. 21, No.4, 1982.
Swarup, Hem Lata, et.al, “Women’s Political Engagement in India: Some Critical
Issues”, in Nelson, Barbara and Chowdhury, Najma (eds.), Women and Politics
World Wide, Delhi: Oxford University Press, 1997.
Swain, Pratap Chandra, “Dynamics of the Indian Party System”, The Indian Journal of
Political Science, Vol. 69, No. 1, January-March 2008.
379
Thangamani, K., “Education for Women”, in Rameshwari Pandya (ed.), Women
Welfare and Empowerment in India, New Delhi: New Century Publications,
2008.
Thanikodi, A. and Sugirtha, M., “Status of Women in Politics”, The Indian Journal of
Political Science, Vol. 68, No. 3, July-September 2007.
Tiwari, Nupur, “Women and Panchayati Raj”, Yojana, Vol. 56, June 2012.
Verma, Rahul and Sardeshari, Shreyas, “ Does Media Exposure Affect Voting
Behaviours and Political Preference in India”, Economic and Political Weekly,
Vol. 49, No. 39, September 2014.
Vyas, Girija, “Women Empowerment, Remedy for Social Elevation”, Yojana, Vol. 52,
September 2008.
Yadagiri, R., “Growth of Regional Political Parties in India: Influence and Impact on
Federal System”, in D. Sundar Ram (ed.), Federal System and Coalition
Government in India- Conflict and Consensus in Centre-State Relations, New
Delhi: Kanishka Publishers, 2007.
Government Reports
380
Government of Himachal Pradesh, Socio-Economic Indicators of Himachal Pradesh,
Economics and Statistics Department, Shimla: Himachal Pradesh, 2014-15.
Government of India, Women Members of Rajya Sabha, New Delhi: Rajya Sabha
Secretariat, 2009.
381
Himachal Past, Present and Future, Directorate of Correspondence Courses Himachal
Pradesh University, Shimla, 1975.
Gazetteer of the Mandi State, New Delhi: Indus Publishing Company, 1920.
Gazetteer of the Kangra District, New Delhi; Indus Publishing Company, 1883-84.
Himachal Pradesh Panchayati Raj Act, 1994 (Act No.4 of 1994) Section 8.
Convention on the Political Rights of Women, 193 U.N.T.S. 135, enforced on July 7,
1954, Article 3.
382
G. A. res. 34/80. 3U. N. GAOR. supp., (No.6) at 193 UN Doc. A/34/46, entered into
force September 3, 1981.
Thakur, Naresh K., “Women Get a Raw Deal in this Election, Again”, Hindustan
Times, Accessed on 29-10-2017.
Encyclopaedia
New Encyclopedia Britannica, Inc. William Benton Publishers, Vol. 14, New York,
1943.
International Encyclopaedia of Social Science, Vol. IX, New York: McMillan Co., The
Free Press, 1986.
The New Encyclopaedia, Britannica, Inc William Benton, Publishers, Vol. 14, 1993.
Asian Survey
383
The Indian Journal of Public Administration
Vidhanmala
Kurukshetra
Mainstream
Seminar
Third Concept
Yojana
Newspapers
Amar Ujala
Divya Himachal
Times of India
The Tribune
Hindustan times
Indian Express
Websites
www.eci.nic.in
www.ceohimachal.nic.in
www.lokniti.Org.
http:/ / inflibnet.ac.in
http:/ / Wikipedia.com
http:/ /www.epw.org.in
http: / / www.orbi.org.in.
384
Questionnaire-cum-Interview Schedule
Note: The researcher is a Ph. D students and doing the survey for the research
purpose only. The information submitted by you will be kept confidential and
will only be used for the academic purpose only.
District .............................................................................................................................
Dated ..................................................................................................................................
Background Information
1) Age:
2) Post:
a) President b) Vice President c) Pradhan
d) Up-Pradhan e) Member f) Others
3) Sex:
a) Male b) Female
4) Marital Status:
a) Married b) Unmarried c) Widowed
5) Type of Family:
a) Nuclear b) Joint
6) Place of Residence:
a) Rural b) Urban
7) Caste:
a) General b) Schedule Caste c) Schedule Tribe
d) Other Backward Classes
i
8) Religion:
a) Hindu b) Muslim c) Sikh d) Others
9) Occupation Status:
a) Agriculture b) Horticulture c) Business d) Others
Yes/No/ No Opinion
Yes/No/ No Opinion
Yes/No/No opinion
Yes/No/ No opinion
ii
Participation of Women in Politics
7) At what age did you contested the election for the first time? (years of age)
8) From which seat did you contested the election? (Please tick)
a) Reserve for women b) Reserve for SCs women
c) Reserve for STs women d) Reserved for OBCs women
iii
12) Who motivated you to contest the election? (Please tick)
a) Your own decision b) Family members
c) Friends and relatives d) Political parties
e) Others ........................................................................
15) What post you are holding in the party? (Please specify)
Yes/No/No Opinion
18) Do you attend party/ organisations meetings?
Yes/ No /No Opinion
20) Do you take part in Strikes/ Protests/ Bandh/ Calls, etc.? Yes/No/No Opinion
21) Are you aware about the 73rd Constitutional Amendment Act regarding the
Panchayati Raj System and Himachal Pradesh Panchayati Raj Act, 1994?
Yes/No/ No Opinion
22) Are you satisfied with the 50 per cent reservation for women in Panchayati Raj
Institutions?
Yes/ No/ No Opinion
23) Should women have 33 per cent reservation in Parliament and State Legislative
Assembly?
Yes/No/No Opinion......
24) Are you satisfied with the present level of participation of women in politics?
Yes/ No
iv
25) In your opinion which factor is more important for women to enter into politics?
a) Family b) Education c) Both are equally important
d) Other factors ...........
26) Do you think the male members dominate the women in decision making process?
Yes/No/ No opinion
28) Do you think that education is essential to encourage women participation and
involvement in the politics?
Yes/ No/ No Opinion
Yes/No/ No opinion
Yes/No/ No opinion
31) Do you think that women's participation has increased considerably after the 73rd
Amendment?
Yes/No/ No opinion
32) Do you think women play important role in decision making process?
Yes/No/ No opinion
d) Any others.............
v
35) In your opinion, what hurdles come in the way of women’s participation in the
politics?
a) Non-cooperation of husband/ family members
b) Lack of time due to family responsibilities
c) Lack of interest in the politics d) Lack of political awakening
e) Lack of education
36) Do you face any problem from your family members in the discharge of your
duties?
Yes/ No/ No Opinion
37) Do you think the higher caste has monopoly in the rural power structure?
38) Do you think women participation can increase by their social outlook?
Yes/No/ No opinion
40) Do you think there is a corruption and favouritism in the implementation of various
rural development programmes?
Yes/ No/ No Opinion
41) Do you think that training should be imparted in relation to rural development
programmes and participation?
Yes/ No/ No Opinion
42) Do you think that participation of women can improve in the long run?
Yes/No/ No opinion
43) Do you think that Panchayati Raj Institutions are the best platform of democratic
process?
Yes/No/ No Opinion
Any suggestion
................................................................................................................................
................................................................................................................................
vi