Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ScienceDirect
Xuan Liao, MD, PhD,a,1 Jun-Xian Liang, MD,a,1 Sheng-Hong Li, MD,a
Su Huang, MD,a Jian-Xin Yan, MD,a Li-Ling Xiao, MD,a
Jian-Xing Song, MD, PhD,b and Hong-Wei Liu, MD, PhDa,*
a
Department of Plastic Surgery, The First Affiliated Hospital of Jinan University, Innovative Technology Research
Institute of Tissue Repair and Regeneration, Key Laboratory of Regenerative Medicine, Ministry of Education,
Guangzhou, Guangdong, China
b
Department of Plastic Surgery, Changhai Hospital, The Second Military Medical University, Shanghai, China
Article history: Background: Platelet-rich plasma (PRP) improves the healing of refractory wounds, and its
Received 24 March 2019 application is receiving more attention in the field of wound repair. However, when a
Received in revised form patient’s condition is very poor, it may be difficult to provide whole blood to harvest
22 July 2019 autologous PRP.
Accepted 13 September 2019 Methods: We evaluated the efficacy and safety of allogeneic PRP in the field of chronic re-
Available online xxx fractory wound repair. Sixty patients (39 males and 21 females, 57 10 y old) with chronic
wounds were enrolled in this prospective, randomized, single-center study during January
Keywords: 2014 to January 2018. Their wounds were treated by standard care. The patients with
chronic wounds chronic refractory wounds were divided into allogeneic PRP treatment and control groups
allogeneic PRP on the basis of the presence or absence of allogeneic PRP in wounds after debridement,
wound healing respectively. Allogeneic PRP was prepared by collecting whole blood from healthy in-
dividuals and two-step centrifugation. Clinical effects were evaluated by visually observing
wound conditions and objectively assessing wound surfaces.
Results: After 30 d of treatment, the allogeneic PRP-treated group showed bright red gran-
ulation that bled easily with reduced inflammatory exudation. No rejection reactions were
observed. The rate of chronic wound healing was much faster in the allogeneic PRP-treated
group than that in the control group.
Conclusions: The present study shows that combined treatment of chronic wounds by
standard care and allogeneic PRP significantly shortens healing time, suggesting that
allogeneic PRP is an effective, safe adjuvant treatment for chronic wounds.
ª 2019 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
* Corresponding author. Department of Plastic Surgery, The First Affiliated Hospital of Jinan University, Innovative Technology Research
Institute of Tissue Repair and Regeneration, Key Laboratory of Regenerative Medicine, Ministry of Education, Guangzhou, Guangdong,
510630, China. Tel.: þ86 20-386-88163; fax: þ86 20-3868-8446.
E-mail address: liuhongwei0521@hotmail.com (H.-W. Liu).
1
These authors contributed equally to this work.
0022-4804/$ e see front matter ª 2019 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jss.2019.09.019
liao et al allogeneic prp and chronic wounds 285
contains abundant growth factors5 and has a healing effect on Serum albumin 30 g/L 87 80
wounds and tissues.6 The increasing maturation of separation Etiology
and extraction technologies for PRP has led to a simple and Burns 13 23
rapid operation, which is not easily contaminated and has a Diabetic foot 23 30
reliable curative effect. Therefore, the use of PRP to promote
Venous ulcer 30 23
chronic refractory wound healing has become a research
Pressure ulcer 30 17
focus. However, patients often have severe underlying dis-
Immune diseases 3 7
eases or are elderly and their conditions do not meet the re-
quirements of extracting PRP to ensure quality and quantity.
Considering the urgent need for disease treatment, the use of
allogeneic PRP will effectively solve this limitation.
Methods
Patients Allogenic PRP was derived from the peripheral blood of im-
mediate family members of the patient, and its serological test
Sixty patients with chronic wounds were treated at our indicators met the Chinese blood donation requirements.
department from January 2014 to January 2018. Their average Human immunodeficiency virus, HbsAg, hepatitis C virus, and
age was 57 10 y and 60% were women. The treatment was syphilis serum reaction tests were negative. Males were aged
used for chronic wounds with a mean ulcer area of 33.6 cm2, less than 55 y, and females were aged less than 50 y. The donor
which had been treated for more than 6 mo. Refractory wound record and blood acquisition registration form were obtained
occurred in various parts of the body, including five cases in at the time of blood collection, together with the donor serum
the back, five cases in the sacrococcygeal region, five cases of test results for follow-up.
the right lower limb, six cases in the lower part of the left
lower leg, five cases in the right ankle, and three cases in the
left ankle. In addition, wounds in 17 cases occurred on the PRP preparation
dorsal side of the left foot and wounds in 14 cases occurred on
the dorsal side of the right foot. The patients with chronic PRP was isolated from the blood using a previously described
refractory wounds were randomly and equally assigned to procedure.7 Briefly, we performed secondary centrifugation
two groups. Thirty patients were treated with debridement for extraction. First, 60 mL venous blood was collected in a
and allogeneic PRP in the treatment group, and the other pa- sodium citrate anticoagulated centrifuge tube. After centri-
tients were treated by conventional wound-cleaning methods fugation at 400g for 10 min, the blood was divided into three
in the control group. According to the wound condition, both layers, the uppermost layer was platelet-poor plasma (PPP),
groups underwent skin grafting to accelerate wound healing. the red blood cell layer was at the bottom, and the platelet-
The study was approved by the ethics committee of the first rich plasma was the middle layer. The uppermost superna-
affiliated hospital of Jinan university. Informed written con- tant layer which PPP was aspirated with a Pasteur pipette and
sent was obtained from all patients (Table 1). the intermediate layer to a distance of 2 mm from the bottom
286 j o u r n a l o f s u r g i c a l r e s e a r c h f e b r u a r y 2 0 2 0 ( 2 4 6 ) 2 8 4 e2 9 1
layer were pipetted out. Then, the collected layer was centri- infection, frequency of dressing replacement, immediate
fuged at 1200 g for 20 min, and the liquid was separated into adhesion of grafts, graft edema after transplantation, skin
two layers after centrifugation. The sediment was collected as graft survival, healing time, and wound healing rate.
PRP. For clinical treatment, the platelets were activated by
calcium gluconate at a ratio of 10:1, and the wound was
Statistical method
treated within 10 min to avoid gel formation. The operation
was performed with strict sterility, and PRP was used imme-
SPSS 16.0 software was used for statistical analysis. An inde-
diately after each extraction.
pendent sample t-test was used to calculate the difference
between the two groups.
Platelet count assay
Objective parameters to assess the efficacy of PRP Fig. 1 e Platelet count in PRP and whole blood assessed by
the blood cell analyzer. Values are expressed as
We selected the following parameters to evaluate the efficacy means ± SEM of three independent experiments. *P < 0.05
of PRP, such as granulation growth of wounds, presence of versus control.
liao et al allogeneic prp and chronic wounds 287
Wound area Healing rate (%) Wound area Healing rate (%)
Back On admission 49.3 4.5 - 56.5 2.1 -
After 1 wk of treatment 26.3 1.5 46.4 44.0 5.7 21.9
After 3 wk of treatment 5.7 0.6 88.5 36.5 4.9 35.2
Sacrococcygeal region On admission 59.0 0.0 - 64.8 3.8 -
After 1 wk of treatment 28.0 0.0 52.5 53.0 3.6 18.2
After 3 wk of treatment 7.0 0.0 88.1 42.2 1.7 34.6
The lower part of the lower leg On admission 95.3 12.0 - 85.8 8.6 -
After 1 wk of treatment 48.7 3.1 48.5 76.4 4.0 10.5
After 3 wk of treatment 10.2 1.5 89.2 61.8 2.6 27.5
Ankle On admission 10.8 2.2 - 11.3 1.5 -
After 1 wk of treatment 5.0 0.0 52.3 8.3 0.6 26.0
After 3 wk of treatment 0.2 0.4 98.6 5.3 1.2 53.1
Foot On admission 11.8 2.4 - 10.7 2.4 -
After 1 wk of treatment 5.4 1.6 52.8 7.3 1.4 28.3
After 3 wk of treatment 0.7 0.9 92.9 5.8 1.2 44.0
Fig. 2 e Patient 1. (A) Lower extremity arterial occlusion and diabetic foot necrosis, Wagner grade 4. (B) After vascular
treatment and debridement, the wound bed was injected with activated PRP. (C) At 1 wk after the skin graft, the skin had
survived well. (D) Durable wound coverage after 12 mo.
condition. Therefore, chronic refractory wounds have become and purified platelets in PRP determines the amount of
a major problem in the clinic. various growth factors. The surfaces of platelets themselves
PRP is a concentrated platelet plasma obtained by sepa- can be used as a biological scaffold to provide attachment for
rating and concentrating venous blood, which is activated by growth factors and accumulation of chemotactic cells.11,12
calcium to release a large amount of growth factors which has The growth factors of highly concentrated platelets can
a good effect on tissue repair. Addition of calcium ions to compensate for the lack of growth factors’ quantity in chronic
activate PRP causes gradual formation of a colloidal shape, refractory wounds. The concentrations of epidermal growth
which effectively delays the loss of platelets on the wound factor, transforming growth factoreb, vascular endothelial
surface, so that the large amount of platelets contained in PRP growth factor, and platelet-derived growth factor are higher
has the ability to continuously secrete growth factors and than those of normal growth factors in vivo,13 thus promoting
synthesize functional proteins, including vascular endothelial the proliferative capacity and migration ability of wound
growth factor, platelet-derived growth factor, and epidermal repairerelated cells such as keratinocytes, fibroblasts, osteo-
growth factor, to promote wound repair. Because the con- blasts, and vascular endothelial cells.14-20 In addition, plate-
centration of platelets in the isolated and purified PRP is much lets participate in the inflammatory response and anti-
high than the conventional physiological concentration, it is inflammatory immunity of the host as a specialized “white
currently recognized that the effective therapeutic concen- blood cell” and participate in the process of tissue repair.21-23
tration of PRP is three to six times higher than the physio- Similarly, after platelets are activated, fibrinogen in plasma
logical concentration.10 There is no uniform standard for PRP is converted to fibrin that promotes activation of the coagu-
preparation, and the principle lies in the difference in the lation function of the wound, which contracts the wound
proportion of blood components. Thus, PRP containing a high surface and provides a three-dimensional support space for
concentration of platelets is desirable. Using different prepa- the proliferation of wound-related cells.
ration methods, the release of the growth factor content is not With the deepening of PRP research, PRP has been widely
the same, and the quality and quantity of PRP are affected by used in burn orthopedics, orthopedics, chronic ulcers, and
many factors such as the centrifugal force and time. Under the oral and maxillofacial surgeries.24 Moreover, it has been re-
PRP separation conditions in this study, the concentrations of ported that combination of PRP with adipose-derived stem
PRP isolated for clinical treatment were more than four times cells or stromal vascular fraction cells improved the healing of
the physiological concentration. The concentration of isolated chronic skin ulcers.25,26 It has been confirmed that PRP
liao et al allogeneic prp and chronic wounds 289
Fig. 3 e Patient 2. (A) Chronic venous lower leg ulcer for 7 y refractory to multiple conventional skin grafts. (B) After repeated
debridements, the wound bed was injected with activated PRP. (C) At 3 d after a skin graft, the thin-split-thickness skin graft
had survived. (D) Durable wound coverage after 12 mo.
treatment significantly shortens the operation time and re- procedure. As early as 2003, Carter et al. applied homologous
duces postoperative pain and swelling. The most important PRP to a male horse refractory wound model, and found high
factor is the promoting effect on wound healing. However, the density and largely ordered collagen bundles at 79 d.27 How-
application of autologous PRP also has certain limitations. ever, there was only a small amount of disordered collagen
From the patient’s perspective, mostly middle-aged and fibers in the wounds of the control group. This study
elderly patients have chronic refractory wounds, and most of confirmed that allogeneic PRP had the same therapeutic effect
them are associated with chronic diseases such as hyperten- on chronic wounds, and no abnormal side effects were found
sion and diabetes. Their conditions are poor, and their blood during the experiment. Smrke et al. used a human thrombin-
platelet function hardly achieves the expected therapeutic activated, homologous platelet-derived platelet gel mixed
effect of PRP. Furthermore, PRP treatment requires 50-100 mL autologous bone cancellous graft to treat delayed fracture
of blood extraction per patient, which is likely to aggravate the healing of a diabetic comminuted fracture. After 6 mo, the
physical burden on patients with poor general conditions. patient’s tibia had healed, the bone defect was completely
Because of the limitations of PRP collection conditions, prep- bridged, and the load was normal. There were no abnormal
aration techniques, and environmental requirements, the side effects during the entire clinical treatment period, and no
popularization and application of autologous PRP have antiplatelet antibodies or anti-HIA-I antibodies were found.28
encountered great obstacles. A study by Han et al. showed that PRP prepared using stock
In this regard, we believe that patients cannot provide PRP platelets promotes healing of diabetic wound models.29
for wound treatment because of their own limitations, and the Compared with autologous PRP, allogeneic PRP has a wide
use of allogeneic PRP will effectively solve this limitation. PRP range of sources and is easy to collect. PRP can even be pre-
has low immunogenicity for allogeneic use. In this study, 30 pared at blood collection institutions, and high-quality plate-
patients who underwent allogeneic PRP treatment achieved lets can be screened to further ensure the efficacy and
good results, and no immune response occurred during the application of PRP technology.
290 j o u r n a l o f s u r g i c a l r e s e a r c h f e b r u a r y 2 0 2 0 ( 2 4 6 ) 2 8 4 e2 9 1
Fig. 4 e Patient 3. (A) Chronic lower leg burn ulcer for 6 mo. (B) The wound bed was injected with activated PRP immediately
after debridement. (C) At 1 wk after the skin graft, the skin survived well. (D) Durable wound coverage after 12 mo.
Clinical application of allogeneic PRP to the treatment of research fund of The First Affiliated Hospital of Jinan Univer-
chronic wounds should consider to the following aspects. sity (No. 2017306).
First, allogeneic PRP from donor blood must undergo strict The written informed consent of this study was obtained
testing to avoid the spread of blood-borne diseases. Second, from each individual.
the PRP extraction process must comply with operating rules All procedures performed in studies involving human
and adhere to the principle of sterility, while ensuring the participants were in accordance with the ethical standards of
platelet concentration in PRP. For the treatment of wounds, it the institutional and/or national research committee and with
is necessary to control the patient’s chronic diseases. When the 1964 Helsinki declaration and its later amendments or
faced with a large area refractory wound and poor blood comparable ethical standards.
supply to the wound surface, it may be better to combine Authors’ contributions: X.L. and J-X.L. contributed to
debridement, vacuum suction, and wound skin grafting. If the conception and design, collection and/or assembly of data,
wound is accompanied by a suppurative infection, PRP should data analysis and interpretation, manuscript writing, and
be applied after thorough debridement of the infection. provided study material. S-H.L. provided study material and
In summary, we studied cases of allogeneic PRP treatment contributed to collection and/or assembly of data. S.H. pro-
of chronic refractory wounds, achieved significant results, and vided study material and contributed to collection and/or as-
observed no adverse reactions. Therefore, patients with sembly of data, data analysis, and interpretation. J-X.Y.
chronic refractory wounds, who have generally poor condi- contributed to collection and/or assembly of data, data anal-
tions or other chronic underlying diseases, may choose to be ysis, and interpretation. L-L.X. provided study material and
treated with allogeneic PRP. contributed to collection and/or assembly of data. J-X.S.
contributed to conception and design, data analysis and
interpretation, and provided administrative support. H-W.L.
contributed to conception and design, data analysis and
Acknowledgment
interpretation, final approval of the manuscript and provided
financial support and administrative support.
This work was supported by the National Nature and Science
Foundation, China (81372065 and 81871563), the Major Project
of Guangzhou Municipal Science and Technology Bureau Disclosure
(201300000091 and 201508020253), the Fundamental Research
Funds for the Central Universities (21619350), and the foster No competing financial interests exist.
liao et al allogeneic prp and chronic wounds 291