Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/325205824
CITATIONS READS
0 1,750
1 author:
Kenneth E. Bruscia
Temple University
61 PUBLICATIONS 533 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Kenneth E. Bruscia on 17 May 2018.
Songs in Psychotherapy
Kenneth E. Bruscia
Rationale
The client identifies or recalls a song that has significance or special meaning in
relation to him/herself, a significant other, or any aspect of the therapy process. This
can happen in many ways. The therapist may ask the client to think of a song related to
a particular topic or theme, or the therapist may present a list of songs and ask the
client to identify one or more that are most meaningful or pertinent. Or the song may
simply come into the client’s awareness during a session. The therapist may also select
a song that he or she thinks will be helpful for the client to experience in some way.
Song selection is the first step in using many song methods, and therefore is usually
followed by another method, such as performing, listening to, discussing, or re-writing
the song. Techniques of song selection include:
Consciously induced song recall: the therapist asks the client what song comes
to mind in reference to a particular topic or issue arising in the therapeutic
process (Diaz de Chumaceiro, 1998).
Unconsciously induced song recall: a song unexpectedly comes into the client’s
(or therapist’s) awareness during a session, or in response to a particular topic or
feeling arising in the therapeutic process (Diaz de Chumaceiro, 1998).
Song communication: The client is asked to choose, identify, and then share a
song that reveals something about him or herself or a song that has special
significance or meaning for the client. The song may be concerned with the
client’s beliefs or feelings, or a song that relates to a particular period of life, a
particular person, or a relationship. The song may also depict or describe how
the client sees him or herself, thereby revealing the client’s own personal identity.
Cases 11 (Martin) 16 (Whittall) illustrate the clinical significance of the client
choosing songs to sing or play in the therapy session. The therapist may also
make a “song communication” for the client. Here the therapist composes or
chooses a song that provides some kind of therapeutic message to the client.
Case 15 (Uhlig) shows how the therapist created a special song for her client to
communicate that she had and would take “time” for him. In another case, Uhlig
asked the client to bring in songs that described the different parts of her
personality, and then they both sang them.
Song Dedication: The therapist asks the client to select a song to dedicate to a
significant other in the client’s life, and then client present it to the person. A
version of this can be found in Case 6 (Hilliard and Justice), who had the client
designate songs to give to particular friends of his as a remembrance.
Song Collage: The client selects and sequences songs or excerpts thereof in
order to produce a recording that explores autobiographical or therapeutic
issues. One example is a “song legacy,” where the client puts together a series
of songs or pieces of music as a remembrance or parting gift (Dileo & Dneaster,
2005). Case 6 gives an example of this kind of legacy. In case 16 (Whittall), the
therapist made a tape of songs selected by the client to leave as a remembrance
of her.
Song Discussion
The client(s) and therapist sing or listen to a song selected by client or therapist,
and afterward discuss any or all aspects of the song itself or the client’s reactions to or
relationship with the song. Then client and therapist try to connect the song or the
client’s reactions to the client’s life and the therapeutic issues at hand. Different
techniques include:
Song Reminiscence: The client sings or listens to a song (selected by client or
therapist) that is associated with the client’s past. While listening, the client is
asked to bring forth memories from the period; then client and therapist discuss
the memories and their therapeutic significance (Bruscia, 1998).
Song Regression: The client sings or listens to a song about childhood or youth,
and is guided by the therapist to re-experience or relive a particular period, event,
or situation in the past. Often the client is in a relaxed state (Bruscia, 1998).
Lyric Analysis: After experiencing a live or recorded song, the client and therapist
examine potential meanings of the lyrics, and then arrive at an interpretation that
best fits the song, the client, or therapeutic situation.
Song Discussion: After listening to a song, the client and therapist explore the
various thoughts, feelings, memories, or images that the client experienced
during the song, whether related to the music, the lyrics, or neither. The focus is
on whatever arises while the client listens to the song. The therapist facilitates
the discussion by asking about various layers of reactions, physical, emotional,
mental, and spiritual.
Song Improvisation
The client, therapist, or both extemporize melodies, lyrics or songs that portray
what the client and/or therapist is feeling or experiencing in the moment, or what issues
are emerging in the therapeutic process or their relationship. Therapist and client may
take any roles that they find meaningful: each may lead or follow with either the melody,
lyrics or musical accompaniment, singing or playing alone or together. The singing and
the song emerge as the therapeutic process unfolds moment to moment, and the client-
therapist relationship takes shape in sound.
This book provides several examples of how improvised singing or song
improvisations can be used in psychotherapy. Techniques of implementation include:
Extemporaneous client-therapist dialogue with therapist accompaniment: The
therapist and client sing as if they were talking to one another, while the therapist
provides an accompaniment. See cases 1 (Austin), 3 (Dvorkin), 5 (Henderson),
13 (Robarts), and 15 (Uhlig) for examples. The dialogue may be a
free-association or a more organized dialogue around a particular focus. The
focus may be here-now experiences in the therapy session or the thoughts and
feelings the client is bringing to therapy. The song improvisation can also be
evoked by presenting a song title and then asking the client to improvise a song,
or to ask the client to improvise the song around an event, image, feeling, or
significant person. This technique and the next are descendants of the recitative
and aria in an opera. The recitative moves the story along through “speech song”
or “sprechgesang” accompanied by a few intermittent chords. In speech song,
each syllable is given one tone, and the dialogue moves ahead quickly. In
contrast, the aria provides a character the opportunity to reflect upon the situation
and express his or her ideas or feelings about it. Here the syllables are given
more tones (i.e., they are melismatic), and the melody and accompaniment are
more concerned with expressing the underlying emotions.
Client-improvised solos with therapist accompaniment. Cases 9 and 10 by Logis
and Turry provide an example of this technique. Maria makes up words and
melodies extemporaneously, either about her here-now experiences in the
therapy room or about thoughts and feelings about people or events in her life,
while Alan improvises a piano accompaniment to elaborate, support, and extend
Maria’s melody and lyrics.
Improvised Song Stories. The client and/or therapist improvise music that tells a
story. The story may be a well-known one, or it can be one created by the client
before or during the improvisation. In case 5 (Henderson), therapist and client
explore the client’s feelings by improvising a story created by the client while
playing with puppets. Instruments can be selected and played by the client and
therapist to symbolize a character in the story.
Improvised Play or Games. The therapist and client improvise singing while
creating a play scenario or game. Instruments are often used to stand for
elements of the scenario.
Improvised Poem Settings. In Case 2 (Boone), a forensic patient writes poems to
bring into therapy and then improvises an instrumental his own accompaniment
to them for the therapist.
Reflective Vocal Improvising. The therapist improvises a song as if talking to him
or herself about the client, reflecting what the client may be doing or feeling. This
technique is also called soliloquizing.
Song Parody
The client is asked to re-write part or all of the lyrics for an existing song. Assisted
by the therapist, the client changes words, phrases or the entire lyrics of a pre-
composed song, while maintaining its basic melodic and harmonic structure. This
technique is also called “lyric substitution.” Case 8 (Krout) gives an example of
bereaved adolescents changing the words to an existing song, entitled “Our Paths to
Peace.”
A song parody has very important clinical implications. In rewriting the lyrics of a
song, the client is literally given the chance to change “what is” or the meaning of what
is “given.” The existing lyrics usually represent the way things are, or the way someone
says they should be, whereas the rewritten lyrics express the way the client wants them
to be, or thinks they should be. The only structure that is “given” is the melody.
Contrast this metaphor with singing an existing song, where the client’s feelings
have to align with both the lyrics and the melody of the song, and with song-writing
where the client has complete freedom to create both.
Song Writing
Orientations to Songs
At least five theoretical orientations have been used by music therapists when
using songs. They are: cognitive-behavioral, psychodynamic, humanistic, and socio-
cultural. Each orientation conceives of the song and the song experience in different
ways, and offers different explanations for their therapeutic utilization and meaning.
Each orientation will be discussed briefly here.
Cognitive-Behavioral
Psychodynamic
Socio-Cultural
The first and probably most basic question is what is the meaning of the lyrics? The
answer depends on the level of interpretation. When interpreted on the individual
(psychological) level, the lyrics provide insight into the client’s personal world, and
depending on orientation, that personal world can be conceived in terms of target
outcomes, unconscious projections and symbolic representations, transitional objects
and space, personal and interpersonal contact, genuineness, and authenticity. The
lyrics may also typify a particular developmental stage which must be considered when
understanding the client’s relationship to the song in the present.
When interpreted on the socio-cultural level, the lyrics provide information on the
beliefs and values of a particular group, community, nationality, religion, organization,
society, gender, or age bracket. When interpreted on an archetypal level, the lyrics
reveal aspects of the human condition, life, the nature of the universe, etc.
The answer also depends on who is interpreting what. Are the client and therapist
interpreting what the original lyricist meant? Are the lyrics being interpreted in terms of
how the song was sung? Is the client interpreting what the therapist’s song means? Is
the therapist interpreting what the client’s song means?
Music
Several questions can be explored: What feelings or emotions are expressed in the
melody, voice, rhythm, and accompaniment? Are the various musical parts congruent
with one another? How do these musical feelings fit with the lyrics?
Personal Associations
Several questions are pertinent: Is the song associated with the client’s past or
present? Was it popular during a particular period in the past, or was it a song learned
in childhood? Is the song associated with particular events or people? Is it associated
with a particular developmental stage? Is it a song that is hated or preferred, and why?
How frequently was/is the song heard or sung?
Dynamics
Considering the lyrics, who is singing what to whom, and for what purpose? With
whom is the client identified? Considering the music, how are the various elements,
parts and musicians organized in relation to one another? Is the singer singing solo,
with one other instrument, or many? Are there back-up singers? How are the various
instruments balanced in relation to one another? Are there contrapuntal melodies or
rhythms? With which part is the client identified?
Reactions
How does the client react when singing or listening to the song? Are there visible
physical or emotional reactions? Does the client shut out the song? Are there phrases
or lines in the lyrics that are particularly moving or disturbing? Does the client identify
with the song? Are there paradoxical reactions? Do the lyrics articulate unspoken
wishes of the client?
Final Comments
Songs and song experiences are rich in therapeutic potential. They serve myriad
psychological, social, cultural, and spiritual functions. They are an integral aspect of
individual development and collective evolution. They emanate from and become
attached to important events, people, and periods in our lives, and as such become an
integral part of our life story.
Songs are also unifying. They marry music with word, and voice with instrument.
They unite sound and image in the world of symbols—personal, cultural, and
archetypal. They bring together nonverbal and verbal ways of being in the word,
musically and personally. They form a special union between singer and listener, and
they unite all members in their presence. And ultimately, songs unite the mind, body,
and spirit—which in itself is a healing experience.
References