This document summarizes two studies on edible coatings for food preservation:
1. The first study examined the antimicrobial and antioxidant activities of edible coatings enriched with rosemary and olive extracts. It found that the coatings reduced bacterial growth on squash slices during refrigerated storage but did not provide additional benefits when combined with plant extracts.
2. The second study synthesized chitosan-acorn starch films with eugenol for food packaging. It tested the films' physical and antimicrobial properties and found that films containing eugenol inhibited the growth of E. coli and S. aureus, demonstrating their potential as an antimicrobial food packaging material.
This document summarizes two studies on edible coatings for food preservation:
1. The first study examined the antimicrobial and antioxidant activities of edible coatings enriched with rosemary and olive extracts. It found that the coatings reduced bacterial growth on squash slices during refrigerated storage but did not provide additional benefits when combined with plant extracts.
2. The second study synthesized chitosan-acorn starch films with eugenol for food packaging. It tested the films' physical and antimicrobial properties and found that films containing eugenol inhibited the growth of E. coli and S. aureus, demonstrating their potential as an antimicrobial food packaging material.
This document summarizes two studies on edible coatings for food preservation:
1. The first study examined the antimicrobial and antioxidant activities of edible coatings enriched with rosemary and olive extracts. It found that the coatings reduced bacterial growth on squash slices during refrigerated storage but did not provide additional benefits when combined with plant extracts.
2. The second study synthesized chitosan-acorn starch films with eugenol for food packaging. It tested the films' physical and antimicrobial properties and found that films containing eugenol inhibited the growth of E. coli and S. aureus, demonstrating their potential as an antimicrobial food packaging material.
No. Title Sample preparation Sample analysis Result
1. Antimicrobial and antioxidant Preparation of film-forming solutions Studies in vivo activities of edible coatings enriched Chitosan solution was prepared by dissolving Before film application, squash slices Changes in mesophilic bacterial counts in butternut with natural plant extracts: In vitro 20 g of chitosan in 1 kg of 1% acetic acid and were washed by immersion in tap water slices coated with edible films enriched with rosemary and in vivo studies 1% glycerol solution. To achieve complete for 60 s and then drained. Afterwards, and olive during refrigerated storage. Reductions in chitosan dispersion, the solution was stirred squash slices were immersed in the film- bacterial counts were measured as log N0 − log Nw, overnight at room temperature and centrifuged forming solutions for 180 s at 20 ◦C and where N0 represent samples with no oleoresins (in to remove impurities. It was then sterilized at then drained. Two types of controls were CFU kg−1), and Nw represent samples with oleoresins 121 ◦C for 15 min used: (1) fresh raw squash slices with no (in CFU kg−1). For dry control samples, initial treatment (fresh control samples) and reference values were 5910 ± 820; for chitosancoated (2) fresh raw squash slices immersed in samples, they were 5720 ± 980 CFU kg−1; for samples distilled water and subjected to the same coated with casein, 5930 ± 810 CFU kg−1; and for drying conditions (dry control samples). CMC-coated samples, 6170 ± 120 CFU kg−1. These After film application, squash slices were results reveal that the application of these edible films dried by exposure to flowing air at 30 ◦C would produce no significant initial bactericidal effect with 40–50% relative humidity for 50 (p < 0.05). An initial reduction in total bacterial counts min. For microbiological studies, diced was observed in all samples treated with rosemary and squash (25 g) was macerated in PO4K3 olive oleresins. No combinations of film–oleoresins buffer solution (pH 7.2) with a conferred significant advantages regarding the homogenizer (Stomacher 400 Circulator antibacterial properties observed when oleoresins were Homogenizer). The enumeration and applied to dry control samples. A possible explaination differentiation of mesophilic aerobic could be that the oleoresins antibacterial compounds bacteria were performed on PCA (plate would be dispersed in the coating and, thus, bacterial count agar) after 48 h at 35 ◦C (ICMSF, cells would be less exposed to them. Antimicrobial 1983; Mossel and Moreno Garcıa, ´ agents may selectively and gradually migrate from the 1985). Microbial counts were conducted film to the food surface, producing their antimicrobial in duplicate on six independent lots. effects during storage. Actually, the antimicrobial Peroxidase and polyphenoloxidase activity of the oleoresins coatings increased during the activities were determined just as first 2 d of storage in all coating/oleoresin pairings described in Section 2.5, and were except olive in CMC. After 2 d of storage, the performed in duplicate on three antimicrobial activity decreased. Chitosan and olive independent lots and rosemary oleoresins presented, by themselves, antibacterial activity in in vitro assays. Still, when the combination of chitosan and these oleoresins was employed in both in vitro and in vivo assays, the antibacterial activity did not increase, ruling out any additive or synergic effects. In fact, the antibacterial activities of olive and rosemary oleoresins were reduced when they were applied to the coating material. These results are probably due to the dispersion effect of the active compounds and the interactions among these compounds 2. Chitosan-acorn starch-eugenol edible Synthesis of edible films The antibacterial activity of the films was Antimicrobial activity film: Physico-chemical, barrier, Chitosan solution was prepared by dispersing measured using the agar diffusion The antimicrobial effects of CH/AS films incorporated antimicrobial, antioxidant and 1.5% w/v chitosan in 1% v/v acetic acid at 30 method. Spread plates of BHI agar were with Eu at different concentrations, against Escherichia structural properties oC for 4 to 6 h and 18% w/w glycerol was inoculated with 100 μL (107 -109 coli and Staphylococcus aureus were shown in Fig 5 added as the plasticizer. Acorn starch was CFU/mL) of different microorganisms and Table 2. Neat CH/AS film did not show significant stirred in distilled water at concentration of (Escherichia coli, and Staphylococcus effective against any of the two tested bacteria. This 1.5% w/v, and then heated to 95 oC for over 20 aureus). Then, samples were cut into 6 effect of CH/AS film may relate to the fact that CH min. After gelatinization, glycerol was added at mm diameter discs and laid onto the does not diffuse through the adjacent agar media in the a concentration of 18% w/w and the liquid was inoculated plate’s surface. Next, the plate agar diffusion test method; only organisms in direct subjected to further stirring for 10min. A series was incubated at 37℃ for 24 h. The contact with the active sites of chitosan were inhibited. of CH-AS film-forming solutions were diameter of the inhibitory zone There were some strong hydrogen bond interaction and prepared by mixing 100 mL of CH solution surrounding film discs was measured good compatibility between CH and starch molecules with different volumes of AS solution, and then with a vernier caliper. The whole in the films. Therefore, CH molecules were presumed allowed to cool at 45 oC before adding Eu. In inhibitory zone was calculated then to be immobilized within the film and not diffuse to order to achieve better emulsification of Eu, subtracted from the film disk area, and generate an inhibition zone. These results are in different contents Eu was firstly dissolved in 10 this difference in area was reported as the concordance with the results of other published data. mL ethyl alcohol and then 10% (g/g total Eu) zone of inhibition. No any inhibition zone was observed for the gelatin- Tween 80 was added as the emulsifier. After chitosan film against S.aureus and E. coli. However, cooling, different concentrations of Eu significant positive inhibitions were observed when emulsion was added to the CH-AS film- Eu-containing films were measured. As expected, the forming solutions. Then, the mixtures were better inhibition of the films was observed as higher Eu homogenized at 45 oC at 8000 rpm using a concentrations. It indicated that the antibacterial effect homogenizer for 4 min. After it, the mixtures of CH-AS-Eu films was attributed to Eu. It was also were filtered with cheesecloth to remove notable and interesting to fund that the inhibition zone insoluble substances and allowed to stand for of CH-AS-Eu films against E. coli (Gram-negative 1.5 h for air bubbles removal. Finally, the bacteria) were slightly larger than that of S.aureus mixtures were poured into cubic Plexiglas (Gram-positive bacteria). The result coincides with the moulds (110 mm×110 mm×8 mm) and dried at result of Hafsa et al.[51] about chitosan films 40 oC for 36 h at a relative humidity (RH) of 60 containing eucalyptus globules essential oil and Altiok % to obtain the films. After peeling from the et al.[52] about chitosan films incorporating with moulds, the films were stored at a temperature thyme oil. But some authors have reported that of 25 oC and 69% RH (saturated potassium essential oils were more effective against gram-positive iodide solution) for 72 h before testing. bacteria than the gram-negative bacteria tested. The Sample’s nomenclature was CH-xAS-yEu, the principal antibacterial mechanism of Eu was associated x represent the mass ratio of AS and CH in the with its increasing non-specfic permeability of film, and the y represent the concentration of cytoplasmic membrane, thus result in the disruption of Eu in the CH-AS blend film. the membrane. These results showed that Eu could be immobilized in the CH/AS film and subsequently released, thereby inhibiting target microorganisms. 3. Effect of different animal fat and Six different types of the film samples were Microorganisms used in the study Antimicrobial activity of chitosan-oil/fat blend films plant oil additives on produced as follows: Chitosan was (600 mg) The food-borne and human pathogen was investigated against food-borne and human physicochemical, mechanical, was dissolved in 60 mL of acetic acid solution microorganisms (Escherichia coli (E. pathogen bacteria antimicrobial and antioxidant (%1 v:v) under constant stirring at 100 rpm at coli) ATCC 25922, Staphylococcus Mean inhibition values for antimicrobial properties properties of chitosan films 25°C for 24 h. After filtration of each solution, aureus (S. aureus) ATCC 25923, Proteus chitosan-oil/fat blend films are presented in Fig. 8. It is 100 µL of glycerol (as a plasticizer) and 10 µL microbilis (P. microbilis) ATCC 14153, interesting that antimicrobial activity of all tested of Tween 40 (as an emulsifier agent) were Proteus vulgaris (P. vulgaris) ATCC chitosan films was greater than negative control (only added into each of chitosan solution. Chitosan 13315, Pseudomonas aeruginosa (P. solvent). Plant oils and animal fats blended chitosan solution without oil or fat content was used as a aeruginosa) ATCC 27853, Enterobacter films were strongly effective against all of the tested control. For the blend films, 0.15 mL of olive aerogenes (E. aerogenes) ATCC 13048, bacteria strains with mean inhibition zone values range oil, corn oil, sunflower oil, melted butter and Bacillus thuringiensis (B. thuringiensis), of 14.560.81 mm (P. microbilis) to 29.840.92 mm melted animal fat were put into respective Salmonella enterica serotype typhmurium (P. aeruginosa) as their inhibition zone diameter chitosan solution. The mixtures were (S typhmurium) SL 1344 and increased about 45.02.2% against tested pathogens homogenized using a homogenizer at 25.000 Streptococcus mutans (S. mutans) ATCC compared with negative control. This might be rpm for 5 min. Following the homogenization 25175) were used to evaluate the corresponded to the entrapment of oil compounds into process, all the samples were poured into the antibacterial properties of chitosan-oil/fat the chitosan film improves the stability of film plastic Petri dishes (with 15 cm diameter) and blend films. Bacteria were maintained on mechanical properties which leading to efficient dried at 25°C for 48 h. Luria Bertoni (LB) agar culture medium activity of antimicrobial compounds against pathogens. at 4°C. All bacteria strains were sub- In all test, control (only solvent) showed inhibition cultured on LB agar culture at 37°C for zone ranged with 6.320.45 mm 13.810.78 mm. 24 h Interestingly, the common antibiotic gentamicin exhibited lower values of inhibition zone (ranged from 16.560.62 to 20.730.84 mm) against almost of the tested bacteria than chitosan film blended with different oil compounds. Sunflower oil and olive oil incorporated chitosan films displayed higher antibacterial activity than other film samples (corn oil, animal fat and animal butter). These results suggest that chitosan blended with plant oils or animal fats could be used as a new generation, non-toxic and hydrophobic antimicrobial agent. In general, antimicrobial film’s functionality in food packaging can be evaluated from the extent of microorganism growth. Chitosan-oil/fat blend films produced in this study are nontoxic, biodegradable and mechanically stable. Thus, they could be used as food packaging material that can protect both the food content and the environment. 4. Improvement of the Quality and Chitosan layer was prepared by the Fruits’ Visual Contamination the Shelf Life of Figs (Ficus carica) methodology. One gram of chitosan was diluted The application of the A–Ch BE film also retarded the Using an Alginate–Chitosan Edible in 100 mL of a 1 % (v/v) lactic acid solution, fruits’ visual contamination (Fig. 5). Thus, uncoated fig Film and afterward, 0.5 g of soy lecithin, 2 g of fruits presented visual fungal infection after just 3 days glycerol, and 5 mL of olive oil were added. The of storage. On the contrary, fungal infection was only mixture was homogenized at 15,000 rpm during observable in coated figs after 15 days of storage. In 10 min using an Ultraturrax T18. Finally, the fact, at the end of storage, coated figs presented a emulsion formed was cooled to 25 °C before its visual fungal contamination on, approximately, 5 % of application. the fruits, whereas about 80–87 % of the uncoated figs were contaminated. The chitosan coatings could reduce microbial and fungal contamination in strawberries stored at 20 °C and 95–98 % RH for 4 days. The coatings of carboxymethyl cellulose, hydroxypropyl methyl cellulose, and their combination with the antifungal agent chitosan reduced fungal contamination in strawberry fruit. 5. Investigation of the physicochemical, Preparation of films Quantitative analyses Antimicrobial activity antimicrobial and antioxidant The edible films were prepared by casting The disk diffusion method was used to The results of antimicrobial activity tests for pure properties of gelatin-chitosan edible technique. The pigskin gelatin (GEL) and determine the antimicrobial activity of biopolymers films (GEL100 and CH100) and film mixed with plant ethanolic chitosan (CH) solutions were prepared the films. E. coli and S. aureus were GEL50:CH50 blend films with different extracts, extracts separately and then conveniently mixed to selected for this study. The plates against S. aureus and E. coli, are presented. As obtain the following formulations: films of pure containing Müller-Hinton agar were expected, the chloramphenicol, used as antibiotic biopolymers (GEL100 or CH100) and films inoculated after preparation of the control, presented the highest (sensitive) inhibitory based on blends of gelatin and chitosan with bacterial suspension, and then a sterile effect in comparison to all tested films. The diameter of 25% (GEL75:CH25) or 50% (GEL50:CH50) of swab was used for dipping the bacterial the inhibition zone of pure chitosan films (CH100) CH in blends. The different ethanolic extracts suspension in all the plate avoiding indicated inhibition on growth against S. aureus and E. were incorporated at 1%. Gelatin solution was leaving uncovered areas. Filter paper coli strains tested, but, contrarily, the pure gelatin films prepared, where gelatin (4g GEL/100ml of disks (18 mm diameter) were soaked with did not show any antimicrobial activity. Different distilled water) was hydrated at room 15 ml of absolute ethanol and authors have demonstrated the antimicrobial activity of temperature for 30min and solubilized later in a chloramphenicol (2.5%) used as negative chitosan and explained this behavior for its positively thermostatic bath at 55ºC (±0.5ºC). After this, and positive controls, respectively. Then charged amino group which interacts with negatively glycerol (0.2%) was added. In parallel, chitosan films samples (18 mm diameter) and charged microbial cell membranes, leading to the solution was prepared. Chitosan (1% w/w) was controls were laid onto the inoculated leakage of proteinaceous and other intracellular dispersed in an aqueous solution of glacial plate’s surface. These plates were constituents of the microorganisms. An increase of acetic acid (1.0% v/w) for 12 h using a incubated for 24 h at 37ºC. At the end, chitosan proportion and the presence of rosemary, magnetic stirrer at 40ºC. The film-forming the halos formed by inhibition zones cinnamon, boldo do-chile and guarana extracts in films solutions (FFS) were obtained by mixing GEL surrounding clear areas were considered (GEL50:CH50) allowed to observe an increased and CH solutions in different ratios using a as a measurement of the antimicrobial diameter of the inhibition zone during the period rotor–stator homogenizer at 10,000 rpm for 5 activity. All analyses were performed in analyzed. The films showed their antimicrobial activity min at room temperature. The FFS were cast in triplicate. with diameters of the inhibition zone ranging from 23 petri plates (14 cm diameter) and dried at 30ºC to 26 mm against S. aureus with rosemary and and 60% relative humidity (RH) for about 24 h, cinnamon extracts added, respectively, and from 21 to in a conventional oven. The films were peeled 24 mm against E. coli with boldo-do-chile and guarana off from the casting plates and conditioned for extracts added, respectively. Bodini et al., (2013) 7 days at 25ºC-53% RH in chambers containing studied gelatin-based films with ethanol-propolis saturated solutions of Mg (NO3)2 prior to all extract added in different concentrations (0, 5, 40 and analyses. 200 g of extract/100 g of gelatin) and concluded that only the films with concentrations of 40 and 200 g of extract inhibited the growth of S. aureus, possibly associated with the increase in polyphenol concentrations. 6. The antimicrobial, mechanical, Film-making materials Antimicrobial activity Antimicrobial properties physical and structural properties of Chitosan (95-98% deacetylated, MV ¼ 8.0 - Antimicrobial properties of the crafted To examine the antimicrobial properties of the studied chitosan gallic acid films 105 Da) (Moreira et al., 2011) and glacial acetic films were determined by the log edible films, E. coli, S. typhimurium, B. subtilis, and L. acid (99%, analytical reagent grade) were reduction method with a slight inoculate, which are very significant pathogens in the obtained as a plasticizing agent, and gallic acid, modification. Briefly, culture medium food industry, were tested. The results are shown in as an antimicrobial agent, were purchased from broth was inoculated with certain amount Fig. 1. The edible films incorporated with different Fisher Scientific Inc. (Pittsburgh, PA, USA). of suspension of bacteria. The bacterial concentrations of gallic acid significantly improved the 2.2. Film preparation. The edible films were concentration in the seeding culture was antimicrobial activities of the chitosan film against all prepared by dissolving 1 g of chitosan in 100 g approximately 6 - 108 CFU/mL. Serial the tested bacteria (p < 0.05). The log reduction of 1% acetic acid solution and stirred, at room dilutions of the suspension were increases with the increase of gallic acid concentration, temperature, until chitosan was completely performed, and the optical density values which illustrates the antimicrobial activity of gallic dissolved. Glycerol at 0.3 g/100 g was added as were tested to achieve a standard curve. acid. The results show that the log reductions of B. a plasticizer. Film without gallic acid was Square film pieces (20 20 mm) were subtilis, ranged from 1.24 to 5.75, are demonstrated to designated as film 0 (F0) which was used as a sterilized and introduced into a test tube be higher than other bacteria. The minimum inhibitory control. Gallic acid was added at varying containing 5 mL fresh suspension of concentration (MIC) of chitosan against B. subtilis is concentrations: 0.5 g/100 g in film 1 (F1), 1.0 bacteria and incubated at 37 C for 24 h. 0.10 g/L. The log reductions of E. coli ranges from g/100 g in film 2 (F2) and 1.5 g/100 g in film 3 Optical density of culture media was 0.57 to 2.31. The MIC of chitosan against E. coli is (F3), respectively. Equal volumes (150 mL) of measured at 620 nm using a Perkine 0.75 mg/mL and gallic acid demonstrated significant the film solutions were spread on glass plates Elmer HTS 7000 Bioassay reader, and antimicrobial activity against E. coli (MIC ¼ 1 g/L). (200 - 200 mm) and dried for 12 h at 35 - 2 C in cell concentrations were determined. All Combining gallic acid with chitosan shows a potent an incubator (New Brunswick Scientific samples/standards were run in triplicates. antimicrobial effect according to our results. The log Excella* E24 , Fisher Scientific Inc. PA, reductions of S. typhimurium ranged from 1.07 to 1.75. USA). The films were removed from the glass Furthermore, the combination of gallic acid in chitosan plate with a thin spatula and conditioned at 23 films exhibited obvious reduction in the growth of L. 2 C and 50 2% relative humidity (RH) before inoculate, resulting in an approximate 2.5-log running further test reduction. Listeria growth inhibition was recorded for gallic acid at 0.45 g/L (A. The diameters of the zone of inhibition (mm) of chitosan against E. coli and B. subtilis were 18 mm and 40 mm respectively, which verified that B. subtilis is more sensitive than E. coli to chitosan. Furthermore, the film showed a higher effectiveness against B. subtilis, and L. inoculate compared to E. coli and S. typhimurium which may be rationalized by the characteristic difference of the outer membrane between Gram-positive bacteria and Gram- negative bacteria.