You are on page 1of 6

Microgrid Planning and Design: Resilience to Sustainability

M. S. S. Danish1, H. Matayoshi1, H. R. Howlader1, S. Chakraborty2, P. Mandal3, T. Senjyu1


1
Department of Electrical and Electronics Engineering, University of the Ryukyus, Okinawa, Japan
2
Energy Transition Hub: Australian-German collaboration, The University of Melbourne, Melbourne, Australia
3
Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering, University of Texas, Texas, USA
(mdanish@lab.u-ryukyu.ac.jp)

Abstract - The recent global trend in automation and questions in term of decentralized microgrid at a rural
smartness has boosted the need for innovation in microgrid level electrification. This study developed a regression
that led to a renewed interest in researches and innovations model focused on accurate load forecasting scenarios and
in this context. This paper steers a plenary counseling and average ambient temperature of operation for the
discussion in the context of microgrid planning and design
for academia, industry, planners, utility operators,
Sundarbans area of West Bengal in India. Jingshuang
regulators, policymakers to disseminate the recent Shen, et al. [7] discusses a scenario-based stochastic
innovation and available barriers ahead of a microgrid in programming framework for an energy management
the 21st century. Most published researches on microgrid method. This study deals with optimization techniques for
covered specific areas. Exclusively, the thesis of this paper a microgrid financial, risk and demand-side management
addresses a pivotal question, based on a transdisciplinary that focused on profit and fuel cost of the system during a
approach including technical, managerial, economic, and period of fluctuation (12PM - 3PM).
sustainability criteria. This study addresses that how to scale Considering a microgrid main components, in
and manage a microgrid's technical and economic addition of technical, and operation segments; business
diversities, to align with local resiliency. By the help of a
semi-empirical methodology, an exhaustive roadmap is
and management are inseparable measures to ensure
proposed in form of a systemic solution that contributes to sustainability and resiliency. Recalling microgrid
ensure sustainability and resiliency in term of a microgrid evolution trend, it draws a clear picture of lacking above-
project management and operation. mentioned dimensions in the literature [8]. The main
published articles related to this study in the context of
Keywords - Microgrid planning, microgrid management, microgrid (review, research, and editorial) from 2007 to
microgrid design parameters, microgrid lifecycle analysis, 2018 explored microgrid from different approaches’
microgrid economy perspective that cross the border of hundreds of
publications [9]-[14]. In [15], authors supposed a holistic
and systematic approach that covers a microgrid from
I. INTRODUCTION business, information, application, and technical aspects.
This study mainly concentrated on lifecycle methodolo-
A microgrid is a small-scale power system with a gical approaches (definition, design, implementation,
multifarious distribution configuration (interconnected, integration and testing, operation and maintenance) rather
radial, and hybrid). It consists of a combination of than project management practices. In [16], authors
generation, load, storage facilities, monitoring, control, discussed renewable energy resources deployment and
and automation systems; to serve the utility's customers in microgrid layers in term of the computer, communication,
a reliable manner. Microgrid development trend information, application, and business. Still, need for a
enumerates the initial step toward smart-grid, which is transdisciplinary mechanism seems essential that tried to
much complicated in the form of technology and initiate in this paper. Recently, microgrid is discussed
smartness. A microgrid with prominent advantages of from different objective standpoints as well such as
dual operation modes (of grid-connected and island- scheme and configuration, resource penetration, load
mode) can be anticipated as a key player for the next management, reliability and stability analysis,
generation of the power system [1]-[3]. Therefore, sustainability analysis, economic analysis, policy and
microgrid has been central focus of the literation since standards, AC and DC analysis, and project management
1995 that shows a steep increase in the number of practices [3]. Among many other factors, balancing
publications in the last decades. Also, another reason between generation and demand in a microgrid ensures a
behind this ascending tendency to microgrid is its reliable operation. It can be achieved by distinguishing of
autonomous nature that contributes a grid to mitigate demands such as critical, adjustable, and sheddable loads
disturbances and strengthen the grid resiliency [3]. to adapt with dispatchable, predictable and a predictable
Consequently, in the recent years, microgrid has received local and grid (AC/DC) generations [17]. Seldomly, lack
sizeable attention, compared to the stand-alone power of stakeholders’ awareness from potential benefits of a
system due to its flexibility of resources integration, cost- microgrid economic lifecycle can cause uncertainty in the
effectiveness, stability and overall affordability [4]-[6]. level of service and tariff circulation [4]. The
Kobayakawa T. and T. C. Kandpal [4] offered a principle generalizability of modeling and design of a microgrid

978-1-5386-7434-5/19/$31.00 ©2019 IEEE 253


Authorized licensed use limited to: INDIAN INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY ROORKEE. Downloaded on March 24,2022 at 08:05:53 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
Proceedings of the 2019 IEEE PES GTD Asia

considering security, affordability, decarbonizability, • Considering the overall consequences of outcome and
flexibility, extensibility, optionality, financeability, alternatives
scalability, switchability, isolability, automaticity, • Evaluating the decision, and finally
dispatchability, and many more factors seems • Taking a proper action.
problematic. In overall, this study draws an in-depth For an economic-efficient microgrid planning, these
research of existing gap between management and parameters such as price elasticity and sensitivity, energy
engineering approaches to explore the emergent options options competitiveness, carbon tax and incentive,
for a smart microgrid modeling and design as a roadmap subsidies and discount rates along with stakeholders and
for scholars, researchers, managers, operators, and customers satisfactory handling are known exigence.
interested stakeholders. This study aligned with a semi-
empirical methodology, which embraced a concise late II. EVOLUTIONARILY ROADMAP FOR THE
literature review, influential factors investigation, topic FUTURE MICROGRID
prioritization, challenges and barrier identification,
solution criteria, approaches evaluation, and lastly posing Resilience to sustainability in term of a microgrid can
an applicatory roadmap of an exhaustive solution for be employed for a viable planning and design to cover
microgrid planning and design from management accessibility, affordability, disparity, safety, use
standpoint. The findings are delivered in form of a efficiency, supply and production efficiency, cost-
systemic solution that adds value for the deployment of effectiveness, and environmental impacts in the best
systematic lifecycle management and value change possible way [18]. Typically, planners tend to be more
approaches. In which, besides practicing the lifecycle concerned with the technical efficiency in the future
steps, prioritizing along with management tasks and steps operation of a microgrid. Whereas, economic efficiency
dependencies' concepts such as finish-to-start, start-to- along with sustainability factors limit planners within a
start, finish-to-start, and start-to-finish; or any other specific domain of decision that can be shown in Fig 2. It
approaches. implies policy makers, planners, designers, and operators
Economic efficiency is directly proportional with cost of a microgrid to be clear with design decisions and
down and inversely with cost up. Manifestly, the marginal statements of state to link desired future expansion and
safety circle addresses the main two concern behind the automation.
operation condition, which are the estimation of how far a However, stakeholders much involvement will
given operating point is far away from stability limit require much time and resources to achieve consensus on
(stability margin), and identification of the critical loading a detailed stakeholder process plan [24]. In the context of
condition [19]. The future projection margin utilizes for the wholesale market, influence and anticipation of
the planning of a microgrid expansion within an optimum individual will remain a decisive concern [25]. It
point of solution. At the same time, the optimal point is necessitates a seemly-fitted stakeholder management in a
concerned with supply, demand, operation and economic close adaption with local resilience.
efficiencies altogether. At the planning phase, these Alignment of technical and technological efficiencies
parameters should be analyzed to balance in accordance through innovation in technologies with an acceptance
with resiliency and sustainability pillars. The concept of rate of modernization from technical and resiliency
sustainable energy development has introduced based on standpoints are inevitable. That it concerned with
these pillars [20][21]: greenhouse gas emissions, local resiliency, resources
• Technical sustainability availability and affordability, and resources physical and
• Economic sustainability technical limitation.
• Institutional sustainability For demand side management, first and foremost,
• Environmental sustainability distinguish of types of demands (residential, commercial,
• Social sustainability transportation, agriculture or industrial sector) and
Tentatively, in the Fig 1 (phases’ information and determining of price and investment for each sector and
data are provided for a typical microgrid and for weighs to evaluate share of the sectors based on
comparison purpose only) invokes to determine supply in profitability and resiliency factors are preferred. At the
accordance to the decision-making parameters in adapt to supply side management, renewable energy (RE) has
efficiencies curves to meet a connected and anticipated- remained the first option for energy supply, technical and
future demands. A precise decision-making process technological constraints can limit this priority. Therefore,
consists these process [22][23]: RE advancement and penetration raise a vast range of
• Confirming the scenario score challenges within different circumstance from technical to
policy and management that may remain a sophisticated
• Ensuring state statements and goals
dilemma for a long-run. To step forward, the requirement
• Defining the indicators
of well-understanding the behavior of RE integration,
• Evaluating indicators interconnection and impact impact analysis, evolution options, lifecycle and risk
• Considering the hypothesis impact management, policy constraints, politics influential are
• Weighing the indicators compulsory to exert. Technically, by deployment of RE in
a microgrid the traditional concept of reactive power

254
Authorized licensed use limited to: INDIAN INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY ROORKEE. Downloaded on March 24,2022 at 08:05:53 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
Proceedings of the 2019 IEEE PES GTD Asia

Fig. 1. A microgrid planning and design main parameters.

Fig. 2. The proposed framework for sustainable microgrid planning and design.

255
Authorized licensed use limited to: INDIAN INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY ROORKEE. Downloaded on March 24,2022 at 08:05:53 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
Proceedings of the 2019 IEEE PES GTD Asia

phenomena or one-way passive flow to end-user will be uneconomical dispatches; or unnecessarily increase in the
not applicable due to changes in load shapes, locally peak cost of system, no-load operation that can be caused a
demands and pickoff, disparity in local generation, large amount of operation and maintenance costs.
variability of demand and supply, and economic Therefore, conducting a rudimentary analysis of a
dispatches and revenue variation. sufficient load prediction through existing potential
In many cases, inconsistency at the planning and demand considering climate uncertainty, future expansion
operation levels are an increasing concern for today's and growth rate along with a community energy present
microgrid development. Chiefly, two consistency and anticipated future consumption culture is exigence
ingredients play a significant role in a microgrid policy [27].
formulation, which is bottom-up and top-down
approaches. The bottom-up approach mainly deals with C. Modernization and Integration Phase
individual customers' demand, expectation, adaption,
flexibility, optionality, control, involvement, and so on; At the modernization phase, preliminary investigation
within a reliable supply. Usually the individual customers of the existing infrastructure can be conducted to evaluate
keen to guarantee their control and participation in available options for the system expansion, operation, and
wholesale markets on an individual basis or through competitiveness improvement. While, energy efficiency
utility retailer, especially individual grid-tied generations. and reliability deal with critical states of a system, peak
At the meanwhile, the interest to control wholesale load, demand and generation diversity, and overall
markets can be varied society to society due to cultural, distributed generation and consumption secure-integrity.
economy, regulations, policies, awareness, and more Along with the microgrid technologies modernization in
importantly the local engagement. The top-down term of smartness and control, there is increasing concern
approach focuses on national and regional levels that over fundamental challenges as well [28].
address the global targets and goals within the
environment, economy, and peace measures. Alignment D. Design and Modelling Phase
between these two major factors can offer an affordable
policy for microgrid sustainable development. Design-based modelling treats (natural disasters,
unexpected accidents, and cyber or physical attack [29]) is
III. THE PROPOSED ROADMAP FORMULATION an important dimension, which in some cases these
parameters do not well-considered in a real-world
In a general term, following the globally available planning and design of a microgrid [30]. Concenter on
methodologies and successful practices in term of the how to subdue this diversity and propose a viable
project and program implementation [26], the application roadmap some factors (reliability, safety, efficiency,
of the proposed roadmap is broken down into six phases. future expansion, interconnectivity studies, topological
analysis, reserve capability) are indispensable. However,
A. Feasibility Assessment Phase planning and design of a microgrid can be vary due to
many factors, but in general can address these analysis as
This phase deals as a prerequisite for the rest phases, follows:
meanwhile it plays an important role of opener and • Load flow (multi-direction with mixed generation)
foundation of a project/program to proceed and • Adaptability and compatibility analysis
conceptualize coming phases. The main influential factors • Power and voltage stability analysis (in existing linear
of this phase for a microgrid planning and design can be and non-linear sources)
listed such as existing generation, current energy • Short circuit analysis
management system, available integrity, and • Control advancement feasibility (voltage and
expandability before an upgrade, grid structure, existing frequency with demand/generation diversity)
operation mechanism and load flow, load profile and • Automation advancement feasibility (real-time
growth rate, local resiliency (acceptability, adaptability, monitoring and control using protected cyber-
conformity, marketability and etc). security)
• Conformity with sustainability pillars
B. Planning Phase
• Characterizing generation resource (local resiliency)
• Proposing economic efficiency mechanism (power
Technically, expansion of the system through the
outage, economic dispatch and impacts)
adaption of new technologies and distributed generation
with convoluted integration and multi-direction flows can • Verification of upgrade option
encounter planners and operators in a reliable real-time • Validation of design.
operation. One of the critical decision-making at the
planning phase is identification of a microgrid sizing E. Innovation and Implementation Phase
considering investment and end-user consumption
parameters. Mismatch in sizing in any case under or over- A gradual evolution of a microgrid and adding new
sizing will lead a poor operation, customer dissatisfaction, features over a long-time considering techno-economic

256
Authorized licensed use limited to: INDIAN INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY ROORKEE. Downloaded on March 24,2022 at 08:05:53 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
Proceedings of the 2019 IEEE PES GTD Asia

efficiency and energy surety can be a subtle option. V. CONCLUSION


Economic efficiency comprises two stages: a microgrid
structure (new or upgrade), operation and generation, and A microgrid planning and design based on the
finally distribution and sales including energy resilience to sustainability approach offer a tenacity to
management, load shedding, economic dispatch, and etc. cope technical and economic efficiencies that ensure a
According to the National Renewable Energy Laboratory- viable operation for a long-run sustainability. Unlike
NREL [29], increased in economic value enhance recently, this research deals with first-ever effort to
economic dispatch and reduce lifecycle cost versus initial conceptualize a viable roadmap/framework for a
cost, which is correlative to energy security and surety. microgrid planning and design along with it
Optimization is a contentious endeavor during and after implementation systematic phases. The special measures
upgrading a microgrid that can be applied in term of are hired in this study to draw an exhaustive framework in
energy generation, consumption, efficiency, security, and
the context of a microgrid in compliance of resiliency and
overall sustainability trough reliable control and
sustainability criteria throughout its life-cycle.
automation (cybersecurity), real-time energy
The authors tried to offer solutions to merge a real-
management.
world microgrid planning and design requirements for the
F. Operation and Maintenance Phase 21st century. This study can have some significant
implications for future practice as a multilateral planning
According to [31][32], a lifecycle cost-analysis of a and design reference for students, researchers, scholars,
system includes the following segments: initial, operation, and practitioners related to a microgrid. The authors are
repair, spare, downtime, loss, maintenances (corrective, willing to put forward a series of procedures paradigm in
preventive, and predictive), and disposal costs. While, a details within management, engineering, and business
proper maintenance ensures a long-run life-spam of a domains based on the resiliency and sustainability
utility. As well as, timely maintenance definitely approach in a synergistic manner in the future.
improves energy-efficiency features, reduce risk of
various levels of damage, requiring repair or replacement
in the future [32][33]. ACKNOWLEDGMENT

IV. THE PROPOSED FRAMEWORK ECONOMIC This study is a part of the research efforts, which is
AND RESILIENCY APPRAISAL financially and technically supported by the Center for
Strategic Research Project, University of the Ryukyus
However, this is a theoretical framework, meanwhile (Senbaru 1, Nishihara, Okinawa, 903 -0213, Japan) under
with a broader merit it can ascertain technical and the research budget of JFY 2018 (98394640).
economic efficiencies for a long-run sustainable planning
and operation. Regardless multi-dimensionality aspect, REFERENCES
from market and business standpoints some factors
(consulting and planning, equipment, automation and [1] H. Y. Lai, W. Mai, and C. Y. Chung “Educational
simulation platform for micro-grid” in Power and Energy
control, analytics, service and maintenance, and Engineering Conf. APPEEC 2014, Hong Kong, China,
financing) are essential elements for stakeholders' 2014, pp. 1-7.
satisfaction to be in a tacit consensus [34]. This important [2] D. Gautam “Microgrid system advanced control in islanded
measure is addressed in this study. and grid connected mode” in Advanced Communication
Competently, a microgrid project initiation; and Control and Computing Technologies Conf. ICACCCT
following its reliable operation and management is known 2014, Ramanathapuram, India, 2014, pp. 301-305.
[3] M. S. S. Danish, T. Senjyu, T. Funabashia, M. Ahmadi, A.
engineering assets in term of economic and efficiency M. Ibrahimi, R. Ohta, H. O. R Howlader, H. Zaheb, N. R.
sustainability. The proposed scheme in term of a Sabory, and M. M Sediqi, “A sustainable microgrid: A
transdisciplinary approach can ensure a long-term life- sustainability and management-oriented approach,”
cycle cost, high reliability, and availability, at maximum unpublished paper, Applied Energy Symposium and
safety levels. That it provides a basis for making the right Forum, Renewable Energy Integration with
choice for asset investment to assess resources Mini/Microgrids, REM 2018, Rhodes, Greece, September
2018, in press.
requirement, potential acquisitions, improvement [4] T. Kobayakawa, and T. C. Kandpal. “Analysis of electricity
opportunities, and optimize operation, maintenance and consumption under a photovoltaic micro-grid system in
end-of-life costs [35]. As well as, the proposed India,” Solar Energy., vol. 116, no. 1, pp. 177-183, Jun.
systematically-integrated scheme offers resiliency that 2015.
refers to the microgrid capability to cope with risk and [5] Chaurey, and T. C. Kandpal. “A techno-economic
operate on optimum functionality. comparison of rural electrification based on solar home
systems and PV microgrids,” Energy Policy., vol. 38, no. 6,
pp. 3118-3129, Jun. 2010.

257
Authorized licensed use limited to: INDIAN INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY ROORKEE. Downloaded on March 24,2022 at 08:05:53 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
Proceedings of the 2019 IEEE PES GTD Asia

[6] D. p. Kaundiny, P. Balachandr, and N. H. Ravindranath. International Conference on Green Buildings and
“Grid-connected versus stand-alone energy systems for Sustainable Cities, Bologna, Italy, pp. 580-590, Sep. 2011.
decentralized power: A review of literature,” Renewable [21] Decision-making process", UMass, 2018. [Online].
and Sustainable Energy Reviews., vol. 13, no. 8, pp. 2041- Available: https://www.umassd.edu/fycm/decisionmaking/
2050, Oct. 2009. process. [Accessed: 05- Oct- 2018].
[7] J. Shen, C. Jiang, Y. Liu, and X. Wang. “A Microgrid [22] P. Juneja, "Steps in Decision Making Process",
Energy Management System and Risk Management Under Managementstudyguide.com, 2018. [Online]. Available:
an Electricity Market Environment,” IEEE Access., vol. 4, https://www.managementstudyguide.com/decision-making-
pp. 2349-2356, Apr. 2016. process.htm. [Accessed: 08- Oct- 2018].
[8] W. I. Bower, T. D. Ton, R. Guttromson, S. F. Glover, J. E. [23] M. S. S. Danish, N. R. Sabory, A. M. Ershad, S. M. S.
Stamp, D. Bhatnagar, and J. Reilly, “The advanced Danish, R. Ohta, M. Ahmadi, and T. Senjyu, “The Least
microgrid. Integration and interoperability”, Sandia Developed Countries Needs for Changing the Passive
National Lab (SNL-NM), Albuquerque, 2014. Trend of Renewable Energy Exploitation to a Proactive
[9] G. Van den Broeck, J. Stuyts, and J. Driesen. “A critical Trend,” Renewable Energy, vol. 5, no. 6, pp. 215-221, Jan.
review of power quality standards and definitions applied 2017.
to DC microgrids,” Applied Energy., vol. 229, no. 1, pp. [24] M. S. S. Danish, and T. Funabashi “Explicit recognition of
281-288, Nov. 2018. Afghanistan's power distribution networks problems and
[10] Y.Gui, B. Wei, M. Li, J. M. Guerrero, and J. C. Quintero. technical suggestions” in Proc. 2014 IEEE Region 10 Conf.
“Passivity-based coordinated control for islanded AC TENCON 2014, Bangkok, Thailand, 2014, pp. 1-6.
microgrid,” Applied Energy., vol. 229, no. 1, pp. 551-561, [25] PMI, A guide to the project management body of
Nov. 2018. knowledge-PMBOK, 6th ed. Pennsylvania, USA: Project
[11] E. Craparo, M. Karatas, and D. I. Singham. “A robust Management Institute, 2017, pp.1-126.
optimization approach to hybrid microgrid operation using [26] H. Camblong, J. Sarrb, A. T. Niang, O. Curea, J. A. Alzola,
ensemble weather forecasts,” Applied Energy., vol. 201, no. E. H. Sylla, M. Santos, “Micro-grids project, part 1:
1, pp. 135-147, Sep. 2017. Analysis of rural electrification with high content of
[12] P. Sreedharan, J. Farbes, E. Cutter, C. K. Woo, and J. renewable energy sources in Senegal,” Renewable Energy,
Wang. “Microgrid and renewable generation integration: vol. 34, no. 10, pp. 2141-2150, Oct. 2009.
University of California, San Diego,” Applied Energy., vol. [27] T. Nakata, “Energy-economic models and the
201, no. 1, pp. 709-720, May. 2016. environment,” Progress in Energy and Combustion
[13] Y. H. Chen, S. Y. Lu, Y. R. Chang, T. T. Lee, and M. C. Science, vol. 30, no. 4, pp. 417-475, Jan. 2004.
Hu. “Economic analysis and optimal energy management [28] J. E. Stamp, “Microgrid Design Tutorial Part 1-Microgrid
models for microgrid systems: A case study in Taiwan,” Design Approach,” Sandia National Lab, No. SAND2014-
Applied Energy., vol. 103, no. 1, pp. 145-154, Mar. 2013. 19832C, pp. 1-96, Nov. 2014.
[14] G. Kyriakarakos, A. I. Dounis, S. Rozakis, K. G. Arvanitis, [29] M. S. S. Danish, N. R. Sabory, S. M. S. Danish, G. A.
and G. Papadakis. “Polygeneration microgrids: a viable Ludin, A. Yona, and T. Senjyu, “An Open-door Immature
solution in remote areas for supplying power, potable water Policy for Rural Electrification: A Case Study of
and hydrogen as transportation fuel,” Applied Energy., vol. Afghanistan,” International Journal of Sustainable and
88, no. 12, pp. 4517-4526, Dec. 2011. Green Energy, vol. 6, no. 3, pp. 8-13, May. 2017.
[15] F.E. Pacheco, and J. C. Foreman. “Microgrid reference [30] J. Giraldez, “Energy Security: Microgrid Planning and
methodology for understanding utility and customer Design (Presentation),” National Renewable Energy
interactions in microgrid projects,” The Electricity Lab.(NREL), No. NREL/PR-7A30-54985, pp. 1-28, May.
Journal., vol. 30, no. 3, pp. 44-50, Apr. 2017. 2012.
[16] T. Porsinger, P. Janik, Z. Leonowicz, and R. Gono. [31] ARUP, “Five-minute guide Microgrids”, ARUP Group,
“Modelling and optimization in microgrids,” The London, pp. 1-4, 2016.
Electricity Journal., vol. 10, no. 4, pp. 1-12, Apr. 2017. [32] M. S. S. Danish, T. Senjyu, A. M. Ibrahimi, M. Ahmadi,
[17] M. S. S. Danish, T. Senjyu, N. R. Sabory, S. M. S. Danish, and A. M. Howlader, “A managed framework for energy-
G. A. Ludin, A. S. Noorzad, and A. Yona, “Afghanistan's efficient building,” Journal of Building Engineering, vol.
aspirations for energy independence: Water resources and 21, pp. 120-128, Jan. 2019.
hydropower energy,” Renewable Energy, vol. 113, no. 1, [33] M. Liua, and B. Mi, “Life-cycle cost analysis of energy-
pp. 1276-1287, Dec. 2017. efficient buildings subjected to earthquakes, Energy Build,”
[18] M. S. S. Danish, Voltage Stability in Electric Power Energy and Buildings, vol. 154, pp. 581-589, Nov. 2017.
System, 1st ed. Berlin, Germany: Logos Verlag Press, [34] K. A. Hossain, B. Gencturk B. “Life-cycle environmental
2015, pp.11-45. impact assessment of reinforced concrete buildings
[19] G. Brundtland, M. Khalid, S. Agnelli, S. Al-Athel, B. subjected to natural hazards,” Journal of Architectural
Chidzero, L. Fadika, V. Hauff, I. Lang, M. Shijun, M. M. Engineering., vol. 22, no. 4, pp. 1-12, Apr. 2014.
Botero, M. Singh. “Our common future,” The Brundtland [35] Overview: What is Life-cycle Costing?, Sustainable
report, vol. 1, no. 4, pp. 17-25, 1987. Infrastructure Management Program Learning Environ-
[20] M. Amiri, and M. S. Ghoreshi, “Green Architecture in ment, 2018. [Online]. Available: http://simple.werf.org/
clinical centers with an approach to Iranian sustainable simple/media/LCCT/index.html. [Accessed: 12- Nov-
vernacular architecture (Kashan City),” in Proc. 2011 2018].

258
Authorized licensed use limited to: INDIAN INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY ROORKEE. Downloaded on March 24,2022 at 08:05:53 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.

You might also like