You are on page 1of 6

One on One

The One-On-One Column provides scientifically


supported, practical information for personal trainers
who work with apparently healthy individuals or
medically-cleared special populations.

COLUMN EDITOR: Paul Sorace, MS, RCEP, CSCS*D

Health Concerns With the


Downloaded from http://journals.lww.com/nsca-scj by BhDMf5ePHKav1zEoum1tQfN4a+kJLhEZgbsIHo4XMi0hCywCX1AWnYQp/IlQrHD3i3D0OdRyi7TvSFl4Cf3VC1y0abggQZXdtwnfKZBYtws= on 04/28/2022

Fire Service and the


Benefits of a Health and
Wellness Program for
a Fire Department
John Hofman, CSCS, MS
Sacramento Fire Department, Sacremento, California

ABSTRACT flexibility, and a healthy body compo- firefighters, but many fire departments
sition are important not only for occu- are unable to afford to implement
THE ONE-ON-ONE COLUMN WILL
pational requirements but also for the them. According to the National Fire
PROVIDE EVIDENCE-BASED
safety of the firefighters, coworkers, Protection Agency (NFPA) (10), 41%
STRENGTH AND CONDITIONING and the general public. It has been of California fire departments had no
GUIDELINES TO ENHANCE PER- observed by Davis et al. that fire- program to maintain basic firefighter
FORMANCE WHILE REDUCING IN- fighters had higher levels of physical health and wellness. Despite the
JURIES ON THE FIRE GROUND, AND fitness of healthy age-matched non- increase in education regarding fire-
DISCUSS MODIFICATIONS/SAFETY firefighters. However, they observed fighter health and wellness, researchers
PRECAUTIONS SPECIFIC TO THE dramatic reduction in physical fitness at Iowa State University discovered
NEEDS OF THE FIREFIGHTER. across the career span for a firefighter that 86% of volunteer firefighters did
(3). Cardiac risk factors can increase not know their blood lipid levels and
with age and be compounded by occu- 47% did not know their blood pres-
HEALTH AND WELLNESS pational stressors. As a result, many fire sure (24).
RECOMMENDATIONS FOR
departments are seeking to incorporate
FIREFIGHTERS The International Association of Fire-
a health and wellness program to pre-
rofessional firefighters are gener- fighters and International Associations

P ally selected on the basis of their


excellent physical fitness, fire-
fighting experience, and likelihood of
vent coronary risk factors as well as
other health risks associated with
firefighting.
of Fire Chiefs-Wellness Fitness Initia-
tive (IAFF/IAFC-WFI) established
“The 10 Cities Initiative,” which uses
success with professional training. Aer- A comprehensive health and wellness some of North America’s finest fire de-
obic endurance training, fitness, mus- program is an important and proactive partments to improve the health and
cular strength, muscular endurance, strategy to protect the overall health of wellness of fire department personnel.

74 VOLUME 37 | NUMBER 4 | AUGUST 2015 Copyright Ó National Strength and Conditioning Association
According to Kuehl et al. (9), the 10 for all members. The overall tiered aerobic training after resistance train-
departments within the WFI program medical program provides a more ing sessions.
saved $1,336,535 per year compared cost-effective strategy for depart- To determine aerobic capacity, many
with fire departments that did not ments to maintain a program and help fire departments incorporate some
implement a health and wellness pro- identify and render assistance to type of aerobic assessment. Based on
gram. The WFI is based on the premise members who need intervention. the recommendations of the IAFF/
that the program is nonpunitive and Table 1 describes the most common IAFC Wellness Fitness Initiative, a fire-
confidential. For any program to suc- health risks associated with in the fire fighter should have a peak V̇ O2 of no
ceed, it is recommended they adopt service. less than 42 mL$kg21$min21 to meet
these same conditions. the physical demands of the job. Those
A comprehensive health and wellness PHYSICAL FITNESS ASSESSMENT who have a peak V̇ O2 of 33.5
program should include the following Age and poor posture are 2 contrib- mL$kg21$min21 or less have been
components: uting factors to musculoskeletal inju- determined to be at risk because they
 Regular fitness screenings and tiered ries. One-third of all firefighter can only perform specific firefighter
medical assessments injuries occur between the age of 30 tasks for a few minutes (21).
 Aerobic output and 39 years (14). This is significant in
 Anaerobic output the prevention of injuries because ANAEROBIC OUTPUT
 Resistance training during this time period most fire- High levels of anaerobic power have
 Flexibility, mobility, and stability fighters begin to lose their flexibility, been significantly correlated to job-
 Hydration experience a reduction in aerobic specific tasks (16). Hose operation,
 Nutrition capacity, and gain weight. structure ventilation, stair climbing,
 Rehabilitation and rescue operations all require
 Data collection Identify the firefighter’s needs first by a high amount of anaerobic output.
incorporating a comprehensive assess- Assessment of anaerobic performance
ment. An older more-experienced fire- can provide exercise professionals
REGULAR WELLNESS fighter who is overweight and has with valuable information about the
SCREENINGS AND MEDICAL a bad back may not be inclined to do
ASSESSMENTS firefighter’s fitness status as well as
hard intervals. So, apply appropriate allowing them to monitor improve-
Regular wellness screenings and levels of exercise and correct progres-
medical assessments are an impor- ment throughout their training.
sions in regards to movement. Therefore, it is very important that
tant foundation for a successful com-
prehensive health and wellness both an aerobic and anaerobic train-
program. The fire service developed AEROBIC OUTPUT ing program be part of the firefighter’s
2 resources to aid in recommenda- Many recruits entering the fire acad- exercise prescription.
tions: NFPA 1583: Standard on emy do not have sufficient aerobic
RESISTANCE TRAINING
Health-Related Fitness Programs for capacity levels to fight fires. It is only
Although some fire departments have
Firefighters (12) and NFPA 1582— after they enter the academy and
implemented various forms of muscu-
Comprehensive Occupational Medi- receive the proper physical training
loskeletal conditioning activities like
cal Program for Fire Departments that they meet the necessary physical
high-intensity training, and multipla-
(13). These resources are to provide requirements (18). Generally, most
nar metabolic conditioning, one-third
the minimum requirements of the training focuses on aerobic exercise
of all injuries in the fire service were
development, implementations, and and muscular endurance, but this
a result of physical exercise activities
managements for a health-related fit- does not provide the best evaluation
(14). Firefighter’s applications of
ness program. It is not created to of the overall demands of firefight-
strength and endurance were lifting ob-
establish physical performance crite- ing (16).
jects (up to 80 pounds), pulling objects
ria and must be nonpunitive. The According to the Illinois Fire Service (up to 135 pounds), and work with
purpose of these assessments is to Institute (4), 3 hours of prolonged fire- objects at or beyond arms’ reach in
perform health screening, not pri- fighting stiffens arteries and impairs front of the body (up to 125 pounds)
mary care. heart function in young healthy male (6). It is vital for a firefighter to have
NFPA 1582 recommends an annual firefighters. One recent study per- a sufficient amount of strength
medical examination for firefighters formed at the Institute of Health Sci- throughout their career to help reduce
older than 40 years, at least every 2 ence and Applied Physiology (19) musculoskeletal injuries.
years for those aged between 30 and showed that aerobic endurance after
39 years, and at least every 3 years for weightlifting seemed to reduce the GRIP STRENGTH
those aged 29 years and younger (11). arterial stiffness. Therefore, it may Most firefighter activities require
Examinations should be standardized be recommended to incorporate a high level of grip strength. Lack of

Strength and Conditioning Journal | www.nsca-scj.com 75


One on One

Table 1
Health risks associated within the fire service

Health concern Screening Health risk Recommendation


Obesity Body fat %/BMI Firefighters are often classified as obese or Body composition goals would be to work
overweight due to many factors with the person to affect health changes,
associated with the job (i.e., poor identify any reasons for obesity, address
nutrition, sleep disruptions, limited the underlying health issues, provide any
physical activity) (2,10). BMI was an assistance with a dietician and fitness
independent predictor of absenteeism trainer, and monitor their progress
due to injury (10,22)
Hypertension Blood pressure Hypertension is still the leading risk factor Exercise reduces the risk of having high
for heart disease and stroke (3). Elevated blood pressure by 50%, and if you already
blood pressures have both acute and have hypertension, regular physical
chronic health concerns, which usually fitness activity can take about 10 mm Hg
improve with exercise and diet (4) off your systolic and diastolic pressure (5)
Lung function FEV1/FVC% Lung function and obstructive airway Subjects’ lung disease statuses may vary.
diseases are strongly and independently Individualized assessments should
associated with increased risk of heart evaluate each firefighter’s abilities to
failure (15) perform functions safely without further
impacting on the disease. If possible,
consult with the individual’s
pulmonologist
Aerobic METS Firefighters with a low aerobic capacity Male firefighters in the lowest fitness
capacity increase their chances of having category (METS #10) had a nearly
a myocardial infarction (3) 10-fold higher prevalence of metabolic
syndrome compared with colleagues
in the highest fitness category
(METS .14) (1)
Diabetes Glycated High blood sugar or diabetes mellitus is Carbohydrate restriction improves glycemic
hemoglobin a major risk for coronary heart disease control, insulin levels, triglycerides, and
(HbA1c) and stroke HDL levels even in the absence of weight
loss (1,8,23)
Inflammation CRP The New England Journal of Medicine Low risk of developing cardiovascular
concluded that CRP outperforms LDL disease if your hs-CRP level is lower than
cholesterol as a predictor of 1.0 mg/L
cardiovascular risk and is a better
predictor of cardiovascular events (heart
attacks, strokes, bypass surgery, or
angioplasty) than other inflammatory
markers (17)
Average risk of developing cardiovascular
disease if your levels are between 1.0 and
3.0 mg/L
High risk for cardiovascular disease if your
hs-CRP level is higher than 3.0 mg/L
HbA1c is a laboratory test that shows the average level of blood sugar (glucose) over the previous 3 months. It is used in the diagnosis and
monitoring of diabetes and prediabetes (insulin resistance). Highly sensitive CRP or hs-CRP seems to be correlated to heart disease risk. The body
produces CRP during the general process of inflammation. Therefore, hs-CRP is a “marker” for inflammation, meaning its presence indicates an
increased state of inflammation in the body.

BMI 5 body mass index; CRP 5 C-reactive protein; FEV1/FVC% 5 the percentage of the vital capacity, which is expired in the first second of
maximal expiration; LDL/HDL 5 low-density lipoprotein/high-density lipoprotein; METS 5 metabolic equivalent of task.

76 VOLUME 37 | NUMBER 4 | AUGUST 2015


Table 2
Recommended physical fitness assessments associated with the fire service

Description Recommendation Assessment


Aerobic output Aerobic output will measure the degree The IAFF/IAFC Wellness Fitness Initiative Gerkin treadmill
to which a firefighter can efficiently recommend a firefighter should have protocol
move oxygen through their body and a peak V̇O2 of no less than 42
the extent to which they can mL$kg21$min21 to meet the physical
effectively use that oxygen. This will demands of the job
determine, in large part, how fast or
long they can respond to a medical
emergency or situation
It is recommended that fire recruits have FDNY stepmill test*
a peak V̇O2 max of 45 mL$kg21$min21
on entry into an academy (20)
1.5-mile run
Anaerobic output High levels of anaerobic power have High-intensity intermittent training 300-m run
been significantly correlated to job- may improve both anaerobic and
specific tasks (15). Hose operation, aerobic energy systems significantly,
structure ventilation, stair climbing, probably through imposing different
and rescue operations all require intensities (19)
a high amount of anaerobic output
20-M shuttle test
Resistance training Firefighter’s applications of strength and 85% of RM Push up with
endurance were lifting and carrying metronome
objects (up to 80 pounds), pulling (80 bpm)
objects (up to 135 pounds), and
working with objects in front of the
body (up to 125 pounds) (5)
4–6 repetitions to enhance power and Pull up
strength
Push to pull ratio 1:2 Grip strength
Unilateral movements
Core stability Job-specific tasks require balance, Lumbar and abdominal stability Front plank
strength and power, while performing
complex motor patterns. (i.e., twisting,
bending stepping, etc). A stable core,
as well as a strong foundation of
muscular balance, is essential in
preventing many of the injuries
associated with firefighting
 Stir the pot Side plank: left
 Shoulder taps Side plank: right
 Bird dogs
Ability to resist rotation
 Chops—downward diagonal plane
movements with a pillar core
 Lifts—upward diagonal plane
movements with a pillar core

(continued)

Strength and Conditioning Journal | www.nsca-scj.com 77


One on One

Table 2
(continued )
Twists—side to side movements with
a pillar core
Flexibility, mobility, Weakness or lack of sufficient Hip and thoracic mobility Movement
and stability coordination in core musculature can assessments
lead to less efficient movements,
compensatory movement patterns,
strain, overuse, and injury
 Elbow to instep stretch  Overhead squat
 Side lying external rotation  Scapular wall slide
 Shoulder mobility
 In line lunge
 Y balance test
RM 5 repetition maximum.

*International Association of Firefighters/International Association Fire Chief—Wellness Fitness Initiative.

grip strength can make tasks like exercises (such as split squats, lunges, career firefighters. J Strength Cond Res
opening fire hydrants, pulling hoses lateral squats, lateral step-ups, and 26: 2331–2337, 2012.
of various weights and water pres- crossover step-ups) can help simulate 2. Buxton OM, Cain SW, O’Connor SP,
sures, and carrying tools during mul- some firefighting strength demands Porter JH, Duffy JF, Wang W, Czeisler CA,
tiple “call-outs” throughout a shift and potentially reduce the likelihood and Shea SA. Adverse metabolic
consequences in humans of prolonged
very difficult or impossible. Exercise of injuries. Table 2 describes the rec-
sleep restriction combined with circadian
professionals should include activities ommended physical fitness assess- disruption. Sci Transl Med 11: 129–143,
for improving grip strength within ments associated with the fire service. 2012.
resistance training workouts.
3. Davis SC, Jankovitz KZ, and Rein S.
Research has suggested grip strength Physical fitness and cardiac risk factors of
SUMMARY
could be a possible predictor of current professional firefighters across the career
Developing a comprehensive health span. Res Q Exerc Sport 73: 363–370,
health status, physical performance as
and wellness program focusing on 2002.
well as a measure of recovery from phys-
improving aerobic endurance, muscu-
ical stress. Grip strength has been shown 4. Fahs CA, Huimin Y, Ranadive S,
lar strength, muscular endurance, flex- Rossow LM, Agiovlasitis S, Echols G,
to be related to differences in endocrine
ibility, as well implementation of Smtih D, Horn GP, Rowland T, Lane A, and
function and hormone release (e.g., cor-
comprehensive health screening pro- Fernhall B. Acute effects of firefighting on
tisol, endorphins) after a night of sleep
grams can help reduce firefighter- arterial stiffness and blood flow. Vasc Med
deprivation (7). This could have impor- 16: 113–118, 2011.
related health and injury risks and
tant implications for firefighters as they
enhance their job performance. 5. Frese EM, Fick A, and Sadowsky HS.
have a high likelihood of incurring poor Blood pressure measurement guidelines
sleeping habits, thereby lacking proper Conflicts of Interest and Source of Funding:
for physical therapists. Cardiopulm Phys
recovery. The author reports no conflicts of interest Ther J 22: 5–12, 2011.
and no source of funding.
6. Gledhill N and Jamnik VK. Development
MUSCULAR STRENGTH AND and validation of a fitness screening
ENDURANCE John Hofman is the strength and con- protocol for firefighter applicants. Can J
Performing common firefighting tasks, ditioning coach for the Sacramento Fire Sport Sci 17: 199–206, 1992.
such as forced entry, throwing ladders, Department. 7. Goh VH, Tong TY, Lim CL, Low EC, and
and pulling hose, requires multiplanar Lee LK. Effects of one night of sleep
force generation and multisegmental deprivation on hormone profiles and
stability. Tasks are often on 1 leg and REFERENCES performance efficiency. Mil Med 166: 427,
in positions requiring high levels 1. Baur DM, Christophi CA, Cook EF, and
2001.
of trunk flexion, extension, and rota- Kales SN. Metabolic syndrome is inversely 8. Krauss RM, Blanche PJ, Rawlings RS,
tion. Unilateral lower-body strength related to cardiorespiratory fitness in male Fernstrom HM, and Willliams PT. Separate

78 VOLUME 37 | NUMBER 4 | AUGUST 2015


effects of reduced carbohydrate intake and 14. Poplin GS, Harris RB, Pollack KM, 20. Tabata I, Nishimura K, Kouzaki M, Hirai Y,
weight loss on atherogenic dyslipidemia. Peate WF, and Burgess JL. Beyond the Ogita F, Miyachi M, and Yamamoto K.
Am J Clin Nutr, 84: 668, 2006. fireground: Injuries in the fire service. Inj Effects of moderate-intensity endurance
9. Kuehl KS, Elliot DL, Goldburg L, and Prev 10: 1136, 2011. and high-intensity intermittent training on
Moe E. The phlame study: Short-term 15. Rattue G. Lower lung function and airflow anaerobic capacity and VO2 max. Med Sci
economic impact of health promotion. obstruction raise heart failure risk. Eur J Sports Exerc 28: 1327–1330, 1996.
J Investig Med 53: 127, 2005. Heart Fail 14: 414–422, 2012. 21. Tierney MT, Lenar D, Stanforth PR, Craig JN,
10. Kuehl KS, Kisbu-Sakarya Y, Elliot DL, 16. Rhea MR, Alvar BA, and Gray R. Physical and Farrar RP. Prediction of aerobic capacity
Moe EL, DeFrancesco CA, MacKinnon DP, fitness and job performance of firefighters. in firefighters using submaximal treadmill and
Lockhart G, Goldberg L, and Kuehl HE. J Strength Cond Res 18: 348–352, 2004. stairmill protocols. J Strength Cond Res 24:
Body mass index is a predictor of fire 757–764, 2010.
17. Ridker PM, Rifai N, Rose R, Buring JE, and
fighter injury and worker compensation Cook NR. Comparison of C-reactive 22. U.S. Fire Administration. Fire-related
claims. Int J Occup Environ Med 54: 579– protein and low-density lipoprotein Firefighter Injuries Reported to NFIRS.
582, 2012. cholesterol levels in the prediction of first Washington, DC: National Academies
11. National Fire Protection Agency. Third cardiovascular events. N Engl J Med 347: Press, 2011.
Needs Assessment of the U.S. Fire 1557–1565, 2002. 23. Volek JS and Feinman RD. Carbohydrate
Service, CA. Quincy, MA: Fire Analysis and 18. Roberts MA, O’Dea J, Boyce A, and restriction improves the features of
Research, 2011. Mannix ET. Fitness levels of firefighter metabolic syndrome. Metabolic syndrome
12. National Fire Protection Agency. 1582: recruits before and after a supervised may be defined by the response to
Standard on Comprehensive exercise training program. J Strength Cond carbohydrate restriction. J Nutr Metab
Occupational Medical Program for Fire Res 16: 271–278, 2002. (Lond) 2: 31, 2005.
Departments. NFPA, Quincy, MA, 2013. 19. Stone MH, Wilson GD, Blessing D, and 24. Yoo HL and Franke WD. Prevalence of
13. National Fire Protection Agency. 1583: Rozenek R. Cardiovascular responses to cardiovascular disease risk factors in
Standards on Health Related Programs for short-term olympic style weight-training in volunteer firefighters. Department of
Fire Department Members. NFPA, Quincy, young men. Can J Appl Sport Sci 8: 134– Kinesiology, Iowa State University. J Occup
MA, 2013. 139, 1983. Environ Med 51: 958–962, 2009.

Strength and Conditioning Journal | www.nsca-scj.com 79

You might also like