Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Effort to portray that crime shows create a positive impact rather negative impact on viewers.
Since, science has developed a lot there is a “Forensic Laboratory Science” through which the
forensic team collects the blood samples, finger prints, hairs, and match it with the DNA of a
victim and can find out who has committed the crime. Crime really never pays crime shows help
to understand the motive of the person helps to fights back, helps to raise voice against the
culprit because there are certain laws for women empowerment so women should have the
courage to fight for her. Crime shows do portray real life based incident and the content are not
always fictitious. Day by day people are becoming much more aware but crime is not getting
stopped. Humans are becoming inhuman; there is no humanity left. They are murdering, raping,
kidnapping having marital affairs some of them are serial killers a psycho killing for fun. Indian
police should be more active and the laws of the court should be faster in taking the decision
should not take years to close the case. Media should always show what is authentic.
Chapter 1 Introduction
Crime based reality show also known as reality legal program is a television show. It is literary
or artistic work which focuses on reality based contents having to do with law, such as cop,
crime, judicial proceedings. It also focuses on how crimes are solved. Many crime based reality
shows have an anchor who narrates the story of the characters played so that the viewers
attention are drawn towards the show, they like watching it, they understand the nature of crime
Katz in 1959 researched on this theory and analyzed that audience are totally dependent on mass
media and mass media equally rely on audience. So whatever mass media represent to the
audience must be real life based and authentic. They in fact should not be biased should be
neutral. Mass media plays a vital role in changing the society and development they make
audience aware about all the happenings all over the world .Everything depends on media’s
presentation whatever media will show audience will believe so they should be real and
trustworthy.
What is a cultivation theory?
This theory was developed by George Gerber in 1967.It was based on the people who devoted
themselves very much on television world who thought that whatever they see on television is
actually happening around them and they were lost on their own assumptions. They also said that
media played a vital role towards changing the society, minds of the people so whatever media
publishes images, symbols, messages should be accurate not biased reality based (Agarwala &
Gupta, 2012)
Forensic Laboratory?
specialized in forensic science. These laboratories can be run by government and also by private
Forensic team collects the sample, preserve them and analyze during period of an investigation.
Some of the forensic team travel to the crime scene to collect the evidence themselves. Forensic
team witnesses in both criminal and civil cases and legal proceedings.
Myth is an unwritten stories consisting of narrations that plays a significant role in a society.
Research Scholars Elizabeth Monk Turner, Homer Martinez, Jason Holbrook and Nathan Harvey
researched on crime shows as myth. They concluded that most of the shows in the USA were not
Fear is an emotion that comes within a human by perceiving danger or threat which causes
physiological changes in the human being. Fear comes within a human in response to certain
Whereas awareness is the capability to know directly to feel and to be in a state of having
A research done by Man prêt Bhamra and Trupty Mistry tried to figure out in their research
through uses and gratification theory. In their theory they analyzed that youth not only watches
crime based reality shows for entertainment but also watches for awareness what is going on all
over the world and how to safeguards themselves. Through their research they found out that
A research done by Mudassar Abdullah and N.K Adzerieman and B.ABD Rahman in the year
2017. They concluded that crime shows are very popular all over the world there is no age bar.
They concluded that a large number of people are habituated some content have been perceived
to be good as well and some probably come out to have a negative impact on the behavioral
development of the youth. Media plays a very vital role in the development of the society
whatever content is shown in the television youth absorb it very fast. Youth are the very fast
Crime Patrol
Crime patrol is a Hindi crime series created by Subramanian S Iyer for Sony Entertainment
Television India. It was started on May 09’ 2003 and till date is running. It has been almost a
decade. People like watching Anup Sony as an anchor. He narrates the story that are being
enacted by the several characters played by Sanjeev Tyagi, Nissar Khan as senior Inspector and
Moin Azam Khan, Manish Raj, Suman Singh, Shashwita Sharma as Sub Inspectors. It is running
CID
CID is an Indian police procedural television series about Mumbai’s Crime investigative
department created by B.P Singh for Sony Entertainment Television India. The series premiere
on January 21st 1998. It is the longest running television series. It is a genre of crime fiction,
suspense and thriller. Shivaji Satam plays as ACP Pradyuman, Aditya Srivastava and Dayanand
It is the investigating agency of India. It is The Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI). The
Agency investigates several special crimes, cases of high profile people, corruption cases, cases
which remains unsolved for years which the Indian Police Team are not able to solve they are
given the case to handle. Crime Bureau of Investigation is released from the provision of the
Right to Information Act. Headquarters’ are in New Delhi, India. Rishi Kumar Shukla is the
The Aim and Intention of my research study is that I want to know what viewers feels and thinks
about after watching shows whether they watch for awareness or they watch for entertainment or
The Social Signifance and importance of my research is that as I have always been a huge fan of
crime shows. As far as now I have observed and felt that crime shows are not just for an
entertainment. It has rather motivated us not to commit crime at any cost because crime never
pays one day certainly the truth will prevail and Karma will hit back. It has always made me feel
strong after watching the crime shows as I used to feel very scared in the past. So I want to show
people how one can be strong enough to fight back if he or she is determined to get justice for
himself or herself.
Specific Objectives
I would research by taking in depth interviews of dedicated viewers between the age group of
General Objectives
Living in 21st Century Modern World how many people still live with fear and hesitate to
Have they learn’t how to overcome if in case gets into any kind of trouble?
Have they learn’t about the advanced scientific tests which are done nowadays to identify
the criminals?
OBJECTIVES
The Goal of my research is to find out how viewers predicts about crime shows what perceptions
do come in their mind. Do they have a positive impact or a negative impact? How often do they
watch crime shows in a week? Do they watch frequently or just the weekends. Have they ever
come across the term forensic laboratory? Do they know anything about it how does the team
work puts in effort in collecting the samples from the crime scene which becomes the lead in
solving the cases? Are they really dedicated to watch the crime shows or just for an
entertainment? Do crime shows makes them aware of all the happenings around the world and
makes them more careful, more cautious. Do crimes shows have help them to fight back if they
get into a trap? Do crime shows still create fear in them or they have become fearless as time
passed by? Do illusion still exists in them? Do they believe that whatever shown in the crime
Cultivation Theory
Gerbner and Gross predicted in their theory that giving too much of time on TV brings fear of
crime in the mind of people they also predicted that TV violence would affect perception of
crime rate. They also predicted that TV shows draws viewers into a fictitious world. Gerbner
also argued that fear in the people’s mind has not increased because they are mostly viewing
Youth watch reality based crime shows on television and what kind of emotions comes
within them
In the research of Man prêt Bhamra and Trupti they tried to figure out why youth watches reality
Since this crime reality shows are being caused as tools of information awareness, and becoming
popular day by day in recent times. Through their survey they found out that youth not only
watch crime related reality shows for entertaining but also do watches to become aware of what
They studied about the crime drama by using the uses and gratification approach that respondent
receive from using social media to understand why the youth prefer to watch reality based crime
shows. They focused on the reasons first of all why the shows are watched; second reason is to
explore the emotions and how these shows impact to the viewers.
A research done by J.V’n Swati in 2007. In her research she tried to show how the reality of
crime show and crime news impact on society how it tries to bring awareness in the society and
along with that it is also bringing fear in the people’s mind. In this situation viewers make their
own perception about the reality being worse than the show. In her research she took interviews
of Psychiatrist and concluded that reality based crime shows brings awareness but also brings
Heath and Gilbert concluded in their research that relationships are uncertain. They analyzed that
crime news and crime fear are not concerned with audience characteristics, instead of TV shows
Whichever way media uses to circulate its news whether newspaper, television or radio it
Between January and March 1994, they surveyed 2,092 adults in Tallahassee, The state capital of
Florida and their respondent were randomly chosen from adults and it found that fear is greater
“Mudassar Abdullah” and Adzrieman B.Abd Rahman researched on effects of TV crime shows
in Pakistan on the behavioral development of children. They researched in the year 2017 on how
children are affected. Crime shows are telecasted at the prime time in Pakistan and people are so
much a diehard fan of such shows, especially to the youth who are at their behavioral
development phase and are likely to follow negativity rather perceiving good things.
Crime shows are comparatively a new genre in Pakistan television Industry. Hence, they
concluded by their observation that how youth learn , what they learn have always been focused
on media contents.
Elizabeth Monk Turner, Homer Martinez, Jason Holbrook, and Nathan Harvey research on crime
myths continuation. They concluded that most of the crime shows on television in the USA were
not reality based it was fictitious and the men who were in white were police officer and the men
who were in black were the culprits. Gender and racial stereo type’s characters were portrayed in
and Andrew Leigh on the discussion paper number 8014 March 2014 concluded that there is a
direct and an indirect impact on both the victims as well as non-victims. It has a negative mental
Robbie M.Sutton and Stephen FARALL researched on 3rd September 2004 on women that are
they more anxious than men. Hence, they concluded that different levels of fear of crime
reported by men and women are realistic. After their research survey they found out that men are
more fearful than women. Men are suppressed by the perception that is not acceptable to express
one’s fear.
where crimes are conducted more in cities than small rural areas. They tried to explain by using
victimization data, evidence from the NLSY on criminal behavior and the uniform crime reports.
In the cities criminals evokes poor victims by providing them money by committing criminal
Joseph P.NEWMAN Department of Psychology in his research analyzed those symptoms such
various disorders in which the contribution of some disordered psychological process is allowed
Psychopaths chronic failure of self regulation is the result that hampers them and in that state of
mind they commit crimes and they are mentally sick (Newman, 1998)
What about #US TOO? The Invisibility of Race in the #Me Too Movement.
Angela Onwuachi willing in 2018 researched in #Me Too movement which involved women.
She researched that women have highly received praised for raising their voices against
harassment in the workplace which are very common. Although this movement have received
criticism as well. Why did’nt this movement took place 10 years back. The researcher analyzed
This #Me Too movement after October 15 ‘2017 has now a society where women do not feel
hesistant in reporting FIR against harassment in the workplace. Where in the past out of fear
about society they would not be heard or believed so they did not report on any such violence.
Jeffrey L Edleson University of Minnesota researched on children who witness act of aggression,
violence in their houses are the most recent victims. They are hence named as “forgotten”,
violence is defined as being taken hostage and being forced to participate in the violence. He
hence concluded immediate measures can be taken to prevent children from witnessing such
violence. Children who are more exposed to such violence have the greater chances of
Vijay Raghavan associate professor, centre of criminology and justice researched on the city of
Mumbai and crime. As many crime takes place in the cities by lower class people who are hired
by upper class rich people. These lower class people for their need and poverty get ready for
Mumbai’s Economy is far better than other cities in the modern India Content so the number of
people who wants to earn money quickly either invests or gets involved in irrespective scams.
Money fuels the growth of an illegal economy and involving in the smuggling and underworld
Hence he concluded from his research that machinery and relationships keeps the gangs working
via small lower under privileged people in return of money and for name fame.
Chapter 3 Methodology
Social significance of the study: Since I am also a very diehard fan of crime shows I wanted to
find out that what the perceptions of the viewers on crime show are. Do they watch for
In my research study I found out that many researchers has analyses that there is both negative
and positive impact on viewers. Some of them watch for awareness, some of them who spends
most of the time on TV had negative impact. They perceive the crime show as something really
happening around them, they had an illusion of their own. Some of them watched for
entertainment many researchers called crime shows as myth, they are fictitious. Many
In America the blacks were consider as the criminals and the white were the cops. In Pakistan,
crime shows has been very popular as it runs in the prime time everybody watches but it has a
negative impact on the behavioral development of the youth if crime shows are violent, fictitious
or obscene it impacts the mind of the youth through my research analysis by taking in depth
interviews of 20 respondents I wanted to know what are the thoughts and opinions of audience
who watches crime shows dedicatedly in Kolkata. Are they still in fear or they have improvised
themselves or they think positively. Are they really getting awareness day by day? Are they
feeling secured are they able to safeguard themselves if they are in danger.
Limitation of the study: Because of the shortage of the time it could have given other
dimension. Due to lack of funds could have travelled out of Kolkata for in depth interviews.
Chapter 4 ANALYSIS
Crime based reality shows is been watched because it is entertaining, it is interesting, it makes
people aware of all the happenings around the world, it helps to safeguard oneself, it helps to
understand the motive of the people to commits crime, it helps to be prepared if one falls in any
kind of trap, it helps to learn about laws by laws and women rights.
Respondent No.7 watches crime shows because it makes her learn about the laws, by the
Respondent No.11, 14,15, watches crime show because it helps them to understand the
<Less than 1 hour, 1 hour to 2 hour, 2hour to 4 hour, More than 4 hours>
Crime shows are watched more than one hour to two hours in a week people like
Respondent No.11, 15, 17, 18 watches crime shows for more than four hours in a
week.
Respondent No.12,13 watches crime shows less than one hour in a week.
Maximum viewers have heard about the term forensic laboratory and how it works in
5) Do crime shows make you more aware regarding the types of possible crimes
happening around?
Yes it does, crime shows helps to be aware of different types of crime happening around
such as homicide, banking, call centre frauds, cyber crime, and many more. It helps to
Respondent No.1 to 20 all of them believe that crime shows makes them
6) What have you learn so far since you watch crime shows?
After watching crime shows people have learnt how to safeguard themselves, how to help
others if he or she is in trouble, no crime can be escaped from the time forensic team has
started working in the recent years, not to trust anyone blindly, they have learnt various
laws prevalent in our Indian judicial system, helps to raise voice and have faith in the
penal system to fight against in justice, to be more careful, how to take precautions, not
jump into conclusion so fast, to stay alert, one should not resort to crime in real life, one
should not get angry over any issue and commit any crime, not carrying large sums of
money around, calling police immediately if any dangers seems to be, crime never pays.
Respondent No.2,3,4,6,9,10,11,12,13,15,16,17,19,20 said that they have learnt
Respondent No.4, 5, 8, 9,, 11,12,14, said that they have learnt to be more
Respondent No.7 said that she has learnt various laws prevalent in our Indian
Respondent No.11 said that never jump into conclusion very fast and learnt
about forensic science which plays a vital role in solving the cases.
Respondent no .12 said that she has learnt one should not resort to crime in
real life ,not to get angry over any issue and commit any crime
Respondent no.15 said that he has learnt not to carry sums of money around,
call the cop if any danger seems to be, not repeating the mistakes which the
7) What if suppose you get trapped how would you handle it?
After watching crime shows people know how to handle the situation .They would not panic,
would try to discuss it with family or friends, would call the cops if necessary, would try to prove
their innocence in the court of law, would try to find out loopholes.
Respondent No.1 ,2,3,4,6,8,9,12,13,16 said if suppose they get into a trap they would not
Respondent No.7 said that she gets into trap she would not take any hasty decision.
Respondent No.9, 20, she will stand strong and will run towards the crowd.
Respondent No.11, 14, 17, 19 would try their best to prove their innocence and help the
Respondent No.12 said that she will try to maintain her cool and not get into physical
violence.
After watching crime shows there are 60% people who feels that crime shows do not create fear
and 40% people thinks that crime shows create fear in them.
them.
Respondent No.5, 6, 17, feels that crime shows create fear in them to some extent not
always.
Respondent No.8, 9,14,18,20 feels that crime shows create fear in them.
9) Do you trust your maid or other help after watching crime shows?
After watching crime shows people have become skeptical. They do not trust their maid or other
help unless and until they know them personally and they do check their backgrounds before
Respondent No.1, 4,6,11,13,17,18, said that they trust their maid and other help.
Respondent No.3, 5,8,9,10,19 do not trust their maid and other help after watching crime
shows.
Respondent No.2, 7,9,12,14,16,20 trusts their maid or other help not blindly they keep an
eye on them and do checkout their whereabouts before hiring them for work.
10) Do you think that whatever is shown in crime shows do take place in reality?
Whatever is shown in crime shows do take place in reality but not all some are shown in an
exaggerated way.
Respondent No.4, 5, 8, 10, 11, 17, 18, and 19 said that some the crime shows are based in
Respondent No.9 said that she feels crime shows are not real life based but it brings
awareness.
11)After watching these crime shows which class of people do you think commits
them are bus conductor, drivers, middle- aged men and women, teenage boys and girls,
the upper class (Politician, Boss of Public and Private sector offices, casting couch in
cinemas), Policemen.
Respondent No.1,3,6,8,9, after watching crime shows think that lower class
people commit crime the most and amongst them are bus conductor, drivers.
Respondent No. 2,5,7,10 after watching crime shows think that all class of people
including lower ,middle and higher class people commit crimes they include the
Respondent No.4,10 after watching these crime shows think that rich people
commit crimes the most because they hire lower class people by offering them
money for murdering. The Politicians commit crimes by taking advantage of their
After watching crime shows some people get depressed because it becomes very
hard to believe that how can anyone commits crime, how their hand don’t shiver
while committing a crime why they don’t think twice or thrice that if they commit
crime they would be caught and be punished for entire life and their whole life
will be ruined. Some enjoys watching as they are entertained. Some watches to
get the knowledge of all the happening around and to be aware of.
because it becomes very hard to believe that such heinous act are
performed by the people without any fear of being punished, without any
fear of losing their career how could they dare to think even, how could
not they stop themselves from harming oneself and the other person, how
could not their inner soul stop them from committing crime.
Respondent No.2, 3,5,8,9 after watching crime shows do not get depressed
From all the research scholars who researched on crime shows conducted on their theories that
crime based reality shows have both negative impact as well as positive impact on viewers.
Some people love watching crime shows because they find it as an entertainment. Some people
watch it for awareness as they get to know what is happening all over the world and how to
safeguard themselves, how to be careful. Many research scholars also conducted on their theories
that crime shows do also have a negative impact. The more they are watching crime shows the
more they are predicting the show to be realistic they are predicting all sort of things are
happening with them. It is their illusion fear is occurring within them. As media plays a very
important role in the development of the society whatever content media represent should be real
and authentic should not contain any violence or obscene because it has a negative impact in the
minds of the people especially the youth. It is the youth who is tomorrow’s sunshine so they are
Day by day people are becoming more cautious, they are no more fearful now they are aware of
forensic science they feel that crime shows are real life based and not fictitious, how criminals
are getting caught at the end. In a simple language “crime never pays” According to my analysis
60% of dedicated viewers of Kolkata believe that crime shows are creating awareness in the
recent years.
The Indian Police needs to be more dedicated more towards their work and forensic team is at
their best no doubt; there must be more strict law of punishment in the judicial system for the
criminals.
REFERENCES
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reality_legal_programming
file:///D:/c%20drive%20daa/Downloads/diss%2022.pdf
Bhamra &Mistry ,march2018, Reasons why youth watches reality based crime shows on
file:///D:/c%20drive%20daa/Downloads/Reasons%20Why%20Youth%20Watches%20Rea
lity_Based%20Crime%20Shows%20On%20Television_R.pdf
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crime_Patrol_(TV_series)
CID (Indian TV Series) Retrieved from
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CID_(Indian_TV_series)
Gerbner and Gross, 2014, Violence in popular U.S Prime Time TV Dramas and the
%20daa/Downloads/MaC%202(2)%20-
%20Violence%20in%20Popular%20U.S.%20Prime%20Time%20TV%20Dramas%2
0and%20the%20Cultivation%20of%20Fear_%20A%20Time%20Series%20Analysis.
Bhamra&Mistry, March 2018, Reasons why youth watches Reality- Based Crime
file:///D:/c%20drive%20daa/Downloads/Reasons%20Why%20Youth%20Watches%2
0Reality_Based%20Crime%20Shows%20On%20Television_R.pdf
file:///D:/c%20drive%20daa/Downloads/swati%20synopsis-1.pdf
Heath and Gilbert, 1997, Crime, News, Fear of Crime: Toward an Identification of
file:///D:/c%20drive%20daa/Downloads/hearth%20n%20gilbert.pdf
file:///D:/c%20drive%20daa/Downloads/diss%203.pdf
Turner, Martinez, Holbrook & Harway,2007, Are reality TV Crime shows continuing
file:///D:/c%20drive%20daa/Downloads/diss%2022.pdf
Cornaglia, Feldman, Leigh, march 2014, Crime and Mental Wellbeing Retrieved
from file:///D:/c%20drive%20daa/Downloads/diss.pdf
file:///C:/Users/Admin/Desktop/azh084.pdf
Glaeser and Sacerdote, January 1996, Why is there more crime in cities? Retrieved
from file:///C:/Users/Admin/Desktop/w5430.pdf
Newman J .P. (1998) Psychopathic Behaviour: An Information processing Perspective,
Springer Dordrecht.
witnessing-of-adult-domestic-violence.pdf?1364284190=&response-content-
disposition=inline%3B+filename%3DChildrens_Witnessing_of_Adult_Domestic
_V.pdf&Expires=1591527671&Signature=AY5bi0Fi5P8SuHjNYfyWeQlt2-
5Pjn97qcCGq7KMsTJ2b8fM2JIUftLZ~2Jq-
az6BrE6m8tqsQszCJvnpMdn9AnJ67pAcIEUm~sk9ZT6BtqkrSJiMmf28EcuQ7Q
ycIHZvMwbkB-
ZG1xn0EQcFsqOHiUX1MKtbuELGIOK0X4PHl6GwHNfC8mKZLVX4NdN26t
px~5ViJoArmT~uNE4eUlGYaDqQr6M0FPLsERaLELTm2yIoBgwfhqzRbZAM
HP4FFzMMLpbkfCjdnYzkUGln6G5uvzf2k9GhjEoVHN4xaqWMcalMDOpLb8t
ANfkIdlWfX0Z4gIIny0OGcNdn-Yw5~wVEw &Key-Pair-
Id=APKAJLOHF5GGSLRBV4ZA
Willing, June18, 2018, What About#US TOO? The invisible of Race in the #
fromfile:///C:/Users/Admin/Downloads/What%20About%20#UsToo %20The%
20Invisibility%20of%20Race%20in%20the%20#MeToo%20Moveme.pdf
Raghavan, 2009 Mumbai, Criminal gangs in Mumbai from Actor to orientation Retrieved from
file:///C:/Users/Admin/Downloads/v_raghavan.pdf
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Central_Bureau_of_Investigation#:~:text=The%20Central%20Bure
au%20of%20Investigation,premier%20investigating%20agency%20of%20India.&text=The%20
agency%20has%20been%20known,the%20Right%20to%20Information%20Act.