Professional Documents
Culture Documents
JANE McCOMISH
Downloaded by [Fondren Library, Rice University ] at 22:56 12 November 2014
The article concerns excavations which took place in 1983 at York's medieval Jewish
cemetery at Jewbury. The article details aspects of the burial customs seen at the site
and how these differed from both contemporaneous Christian cemeteries and from
present day Jewish practices. In addition the article covers aspects of the skeletal
information recovered in terms of life expectancy, health and patterns of disease.
Considering the Christian response to the Jews in their midst, the evidence for
deliberately induced traumas present on the skeletons is also discussed.
course you count all of the Christian buildings financed by Jewish money-
lending activities. The large-scale excavation of the Jewbury cemetery in
York therefore offered a rare opportunity to provide tangible evidence of the
medieval Jewish community, its life and death. At the time of excavation
Jewbury was the only example of a medieval Jewish cemetery in England
to undergo extensive archaeological investigation (although a few graves
had been excavated at both the London and Winchester cemeteries). The
Jewbury excavations offered the chance to ask a range of questions relating
Downloaded by [Fondren Library, Rice University ] at 22:56 12 November 2014
modem Jewish practice, which stipulates that only wooden pegs should be
used. Since, however, Jewish medieval burials at Winchester, Barcelona and
Ennezat in France were also associated with iron nails, it is clear that no
tradition regarding the use of all-wooden coffins existed at that time.
Twenty burials contained iron coffin fittings in addition to, or instead of,
coffin nails. The practice is not related to the sex of the burials, but they
were largely clustered in the same area of the site as the burials with
evidence for wooden grave markers. Again this could either be a
Downloaded by [Fondren Library, Rice University ] at 22:56 12 November 2014
Jewbury as compared with the Christian sites. The Christian sites also had
a greater range of burial positions, which implies that Jews had a more
carefully controlled burial rite.
Almost half of all burials at Jewbury were disarticulated, with the degree
of disarticulation varying from a single bone being displaced to the entire
skeleton being jumbled. It is possible that since the site was close to the
River Foss, and the graves were dug into a poorly draining boulder-clay,
waterlogging had caused this movement of the bones. The processes of
decay within the coffin may also have caused some of the bone movement
seen. One of the commonest forms of disarticulation was the rotation of the
leg bones, and it is possible that the weight of the leg was sometimes
sufficient to cause it to part from the torso and then roll sideways, away
from the pelvis. In some cases this had caused the legs to face downwards.
There were six burials which lay outside the main cemetery area. The
burial positions of four of these skeletons could be determined, and in each
case they were unique in so far as this site is concerned. In addition one of
the burials was east-west, and a second was northeast-southwest with the
head at the northern end of the grave. In their unusual burial positions,
alignments and location away from other burials, these six individuals do
not conform to the site norm. There are two possible interpretations for this.
First, they could represent outliers to the medieval cemetery. Apostates were
forbidden burial within cemeteries/ so it is possible that these outlying
burials could represent people regarded as outcasts by the Jewish
community. Second, it is also possible that these burials could be Roman; a
Roman cremation burial was found during the excavations, and several
burials recovered from adjacent excavations are also of Roman date.
To summarise the information concerning medieval Jewish burial
practices, it is clear that the site was highly organised in terms both of layout
and of a carefully controlled ritual, which resulted in remarkably
standardised burials. Differences between medieval and current Jewish
practice were seen, most notably in the use of iron coffin nails and in the
south-west to north-east alignment of the burials, the modem preference
being for all-wooden coffins in an east-west orientation. Since other
medieval Jewish cemeteries also contain ironwork and varied orientations it
28 JEWISH CULTURE AND HISTORY
is clear that burial rites have changed through time. Prior to excavation two
beliefs were thought to have been fundamental to Jewish burial practices in
the medieval period; the first was that buried bodies should not suffer
disturbance, and the second was that social status and wealth held in life
should not be reflected in death. While the first of these beliefs was clearly
observed at Jewbury, it is less clear if the second belief was as strictly
adhered to. While no personal objects indicative of wealth were buried
within the graves there was considerable variation in the elaboration of the
Downloaded by [Fondren Library, Rice University ] at 22:56 12 November 2014
likely to die. The pattern of anaemia was very different at the Christian
cemetery of Fishergate, York, where 64% of children were anaemic, 36% of
females and 17% of males. It is possible that the Christian diet was less rich
in iron and that this explains the difference in the incidence of anaemia.
Another cause of iron deficiency anaemia is prolonged breast feeding, so it
could be that the Jewish custom was to wean children far more quickly on
to solid foods.
Another difference between Jewbury and the nearby Christian cemetery
of Saint Helen-on-the-Walls burials was the age at death. At Saint Helen-
on-the-Walls 16% of females and 32% of males were aged over 45 at the
time of death as compared to 30% of the Jewbury females and 28% of the
Jewbury males. So it would seem that the Jews, especially the females, lived
longer on average than their Christian counterparts. Again this may be a
reflection of different diets or even of better medical care.
Finally there was the question of the evidence for violence among the
Jewbury skeletons. There were six burials that showed deliberately induced
traumas. In one case these injuries consisted of a number of deep blade
wounds to the legs of a male aged 40+, who had clearly died as a result of
the attack. The other five cases of deliberate injury were to the skulls of the
people concerned. One female aged 50+ had a glancing blow across the top
of the skull, which had almost severed a disc of bone. This had healed,
proving that she had survived. A male aged 4{}-50 had also had a small slice
lopped off his skull, but he too had survived. An adult female exhibited a
badly cut eye orbit, but yet again had survived this injury. The remaining
two burials, which were located adjacent to one another within the
cemetery, had clearly suffered from vicious attacks. One was a female aged
15-20 years of age who had received five separate blows to the head from
a sharp, heavy-bladed weapon, that were clearly fatal. The adjacent burial
was a male aged 2{}-30 who had suffered a massive cut to the skull which
would certainly have resulted in brain damage. This individual did not die
immediately and seems to have undergone surgery; fine blade lines either
side of the cut suggest that the scalp was carefully lifted off the bone,
presumably to allow any splinters of broken bone to be carefully removed.
The fact that the bones began to heal without showing any signs of infection
30 JEWISH CULTURE AND HISTORY
suggests that the surgery was carried out cleanly and with great skill.
Unfortunately, the individual died shortly after the surgery. The fact that the
victims of the two most violent injuries were buried adjacent to one another
may suggest that they died as a result of a single attack.
However horrific these individual cases of injury were, the overall
percentage of burials with trauma was less than in Christian cemeteries in
Downloaded by [Fondren Library, Rice University ] at 22:56 12 November 2014
NOTES
1. J.M. Lilley, G. Stroud, B.R. Brothwell and M.H. Williamson, The Jewish Burial Ground at
Jewbury, The Archaeology of York, 12.3 (1994).
2. The Universal Jewish Encyclopaedia (1948), p.598.