Professional Documents
Culture Documents
DOI 10.1007/s12273-015-0255-2
Research Article
Mohamed Omri1 (), Jérome Barrau2, Stéphane Moreau3, Nicolas Galanis3
1. DeanShip of Scientific Research (DSR), King Abdulaziz University, Jeddah 21589, Saudi Arabia
2. University of Lleida, Edifici CREA, C/Pere de Cabrera, s/n, 25001 Lleida, Spain
3. Génie mécanique, Université de Sherbrooke Qc, J1K 2R1, Canada
Abstract Keywords
Three-dimensional mixed convection in an ice rink heated by thermostatically controlled radiant CFD,
heaters was simulated numerically using the standard k–ε model with wall functions. This large radiation,
building was modelled under transient conditions by considering the real outdoors atmospheric convection,
conditions for a typical spring day in Montréal, Canada. Results indicate the usefulness of the CFD transient simulation,
technique as a powerful tool which provides a detailed description of the flow and temperature building
fields as well as the heat fluxes into the ice. The most important results are:
– Heating is needed only during the night (from 22 h to 7 h) when the outdoors temperature is Article History
Received: 25 May 2015
relatively low.
Revised: 8 September 2015
– The On/Off switching of the radiant panels influences the temperature profiles throughout the ice
Accepted: 11 September 2015
rink; even the ice surface temperature is affected although the view factor between these two
surfaces is zero.
© Tsinghua University Press and
– The radiation heat flux towards the ice increases significantly when the radiant panels are turned
Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg
On; this can influence ice quality.
2015
– The resurfacing operation increases the ice temperature and, by convection, the temperature of
the air immediately above the stands.
– The air near the ice surface (1 meter over the ice) is essentially stagnant and significant air velocities
can only be found above the stands and near the ceiling above the ice.
– The volumetric flow rate and temperature of the air evacuated from the building vary significantly
between the different outlets.
Indoor/Outdoor Airflow
1 Introduction and heating loads as well as the air quality for such buildings.
E-mail: omrimoha2002@yahoo.fr
176 Omri et al. / Building Simulation / Vol. 9, No. 2
absolute humidity distributions in an indoor ice rink with ventilation air are constant. They indicated that in a large
heating provided by the ventilation air. Their CFD code part of the ice rink the air is essentially stagnant and significant
also calculates the heat fluxes toward the ice due to convection air velocities can only be found above the spectator stands
from the air, condensation of vapour and radiation from the and near the ceiling above the ice; turbulent kinetic energy
walls and ceiling. This 2D CFD model was later improved is also localised in the same regions. It was also found that
by Bellache et al. (2006) by including transient phenomena, the radiant heat flux into the ice is significantly higher than
heat transfer through the ground and energy gains from the convective one. When the radiant heaters are turned
lights as well as the effects of resurfacing and dissipation on the temperatures of the inside surfaces of the building
of pump work in the coolant pipes. Despite a fairly good envelope and of the air increase; this creates significant
qualitative agreement between some calculated and measured fluctuations of the radiant flux reaching the ice and can
air temperatures and heat fluxes these 2D models cannot damage its quality.
reproduce accurately the flow of the air within the ice rink In the present work, the three-dimensional flow and
which is necessarily three-dimensional since air inlets and temperature fields in the same ice rink are calculated
outlets are not continuous along the length of the building. numerically and analysed over a 24-hour period for time
Furthermore, 2D models cannot take into consideration dependent outdoors conditions with variable flow rate and
radiation exchanges between all the inside surfaces since temperature of the ventilation air. The model used to describe
they only treat a cross-section of the building. the flow and temperature fields is the same as the one used
Recently, the present authors (Omri and Galanis 2010) in our previous paper (Omri and Galanis 2010). The main
described and used a CFD model for three-dimensional objectives of the present paper are to predict the airflow
turbulent mixed convection in an ice rink heated by eight and temperature field during a typical day, to demonstrate the
radiant heaters. They used the standard k–ε model (Launder importance of surface-to-surface radiation heat exchanges,
and Spalding 1974) because of its simplicity and numerical to calculate the heat fluxes towards the ice due to radiation
robustness (Chen 1995) and wall functions in order to and to determine the effects of the radiant heaters on the
minimize the number of nodes (Omri and Galanis 2006, 2009). temperature of the ice surface.
Radiation was calculated using a discrete ordinate method
(Michael 2003; Raithby 1999).The flow and temperature 2 Description and modelling of the problem
fields in this large building were first calculated under steady
state conditions by considering the presence of radiant heaters A schematic representation of the ice rink under consideration
and also by considering the radiation between the internal (which corresponds to an actual municipal one situated in
surfaces. After those relatively basic cases, its transient Montréal, Canada) is shown in Fig. 1. The overall dimensions
behaviour (for 400 seconds) was evaluated for constant of the building are 64 m × 9.36 m × 36.7 m and the spectator
outdoors conditions by considering that the radiant heaters zone represents almost a tenth of its volume. Thirty identical
are thermostatically controlled. All the results were obtained air inlets (0.3 m × 1.5 m) are disposed in two lines above the
by assuming that the flow rate and temperature of the stands; the first line contains sixteen equidistant inlets and
the second one contains fourteen inlets and eight identical (z = 14.95 m) walls as well as that of the ceiling exchange
radiant heaters (0.3 m × 1 m). These radiant heaters are heat by convection and radiation with the ambient air;
inclined towards the stands in order to avoid heating of the the exterior temperature profile and the corresponding
ice surface. The seven air outlets are situated behind the solar temperature are indicated in Fig. 2; these are the
stands. The xOz plane coincides with the ice surface and conditions for a typical spring day in Montréal, Canada.
the origin of the coordinate system is at its center. – The temperature under the concrete slab below the ice is
An important point that must be addressed when applying 264 K, while that of the outside surface of the walls behind
a CFD technique in large buildings is the choice of the grid the stands is 291 K since those walls are adjacent to a heated
since a large number of nodes are necessary. In order to space (there is locker rooms for players and the temperature
reduce their number we consider only half of the ice rink is maintained constant). The inside stands surface tem-
(32 m instead of 64 m) taking advantage of the inherent perature is not constant, it depends on heat exchange.
symmetry of the configuration about the plane x = 0. – At the air inlets the velocity and temperature correspond
The specific heat and the molecular transport properties to the real conditions in the considered ice rink, i.e. there is
of the air are assumed to be constant. However, its effective a permanent ventilation flow of 4.274 m3/s which increases
thermal conductivity and effective viscosity depend on the to 10.384 m3/s during the resurfacing operations. As seen
local flow conditions. The density of the air is assumed to be in Fig. 3 resurfacing takes place eight times during the day
constant except in the gravity force where the assumption and each one lasts 12 minutes.
of a linear dependence on the temperature is introduced. The ventilation air is 100% fresh air. It is treated by an
The CFD package used for this work was Ansys 12.0 HVAC system which heats it up to 288 K during cold
(Fluent) (Ansys 2011). This code solves all considered periods and cools it down to 296 K during warm periods;
equations under the form of a balance between convection, when the outdoors air temperature is between these two
diffusion and source terms: values, the temperature at the air inlets is identical to
the outdoors one. Figure 2 shows the temperature of the
(ρφ) φ ventilation air entering the ice rink for the typical day
+ (ρui φ) = Γ( + Sφ
) (1)
t x j x j φ x j under consideration.
– The load due to each resurfacing operation was introduced
where φ , Γ φ and Sφ are respectively the considered variable as a constant heat flux at the ice surface equal to 314 W/m2;
(velocity, temperature,…), the corresponding diffusion this value was calculated using the following equation from
coefficient and the source terms. the ASHRAE Handbook—Refrigeration (ASHRAE 2002):
For radiation calculations, the air is considered radiatively
mwater
not participating and the discrete ordinates (DO) radiation Qresurfacing = (4.18(Twater - 273.15)
model is used (all surfaces are grey and diffuse). The choice t (2)
+ 334 + 2.04(273.15 - Tice ))
of this radiation model, rather than the simpler surface-
to-surface model, is due to the fact that the latter does not where, mwater = 500 kg , Twater = 313.15 K , Tice = 267.15 K
accept the symmetry condition used in the calculations for
and t = 12 min
the reason explained earlier. To avoid numerical difficulties
due to the relatively small size of the radiant heaters their – Turbulent kinetic energy and dissipation rate at the air inlets
heat flux was redistributed over the inclined surface shown are deduced from the following equations:
in yellow in Fig. 1. The order of quadrature used in radiation
k = 1.5(Vin I )2 ε = 0.090.75 k1.5 /(0.07Dh ) (3)
calculations is 8 × 2 × 2 with increasing number of pixels
(theta pixels and phi pixels) from 1 × 1 to 3 × 3.
The computational domain includes the solid walls where
the velocity is zero and the energy conservation is expressed
by the conduction equation. The thermophysical properties
of the solids constituting the envelope (walls, ceiling and the
concrete slab under the ice) are considered to be uniform
and constant. The emissivity of the ceiling and ice surface
is 0.9 and 0.97 respectively; the emissivity of the other walls
is 0.9. The following boundary conditions are applied:
– The velocity components are zero on all inside wall surfaces
of the ice rink.
– The outside surfaces of the south (x = 32 m) and west Fig. 2 Outdoors and ventilation air temperature profiles
178 Omri et al. / Building Simulation / Vol. 9, No. 2
Fig. 5 Temperature of the radiant heaters Fig. 7 Ceiling temperature as a function of time
180 Omri et al. / Building Simulation / Vol. 9, No. 2
Figure 8(a) shows three temperature profiles for the day average temperature; this is logical since the right side
under consideration: the first (green) is the area weighted corner is far from the radiant heaters. During the peak due
average temperature of the entire ice surface, the second to resurfacing the volume weighted temperature is about 1 K
(red) is an area weighted temperature of a 2 m × 2 m surface colder than the other two temperatures while just before
situated in the corner of the ice far from the radiant heaters the resurfacing the volume weighted temperature is the
(x = 28 m and z = 12 m) and the third is the volume weighted highest. This is due to the thermal inertia of the ice.
temperature of the ice. The three profiles are not very different, Figure 9 shows the principal components of the air
which indicates a fairly homogeneous distribution of the velocity one meter above the ice at x = 0, z = 0. As seen in
temperature within the ice. This fact can be explained by the figure the x component is negligible and the dominant
the small thickness of the ice (2.5 cm). During the early one is the velocity in the z direction. However, even this
hours (before 9 h or 118 800 s) the influence of the radiant component is not significant since it doesn’t exceed 0.1 m/s
heaters is manifested by small temperature fluctuations and also changes direction; this was experimentally verified
(amplitude less than 0.25 K); they are due to radiation by Ouzzane et al. (2006) who indicated that the velocity over
exchanges from the heaters to the stands, from the stands the ice is negligible. Therefore the principal mode of heat
to the ceiling and from the ceiling to the ice. During each transfer between the ice and its surroundings is radiation as
resurfacing operation the ice surface temperature increases pointed out in our earlier article (Omri and Galanis 2010).
rapidly but does not exceed 273 K; thus melting of the ice Figure 10 shows the area weighted average net radiation
does not take place. It is interesting to note that after each heat flux towards the entire ice surface and also on one line
of the first three resurfacing operations, which take place at (x = 0, y = 0, z) during the day under consideration. The
2 h intervals, the ice temperature decreases and reaches a magnitude of these fluxes is similar to those published
fairly low value consistent with the earlier tendency and the in different sources. Their evolution with time follows
outdoor temperature. Later, when the resurfacing is done qualitatively the corresponding variations of the ceiling
every hour, there is not sufficient time to sufficiently lower temperature (see Fig. 7). During the first five hours (up to
the ice temperature. Figure 8(b) is a zoom of the same 104 400 s) these heat fluxes vary between 55 W/m2 and
figure encompassing the first two resurfacing operations 71 W/m2 reflecting the influence of the intermittent operation
which shows more clearly the differences between the three of the radiant heaters. They then increase, reach a maximum
temperature profiles. The surface temperature in the right
side corner is always slightly colder than the area weighted
Fig. 8 Ice temperature Fig. 10 Net radiation heat flux into the ice
Omri et al. / Building Simulation / Vol. 9, No. 2 181
and finally decrease due to the corresponding variation of Figure 12 shows the volumetric flow rates through the
the outdoors conditions (see Fig. 2) and their effect on the four outlets during the day. It is clear that most of the air
ceiling temperature (see Fig. 7). The effect of resurfacing leaves by the two outlets situated in the top of the stands
operations becomes less pronounced in late afternoon and where the air is warmer. Between midnight and about 9 h
early evening as the outdoors temperature and that of the (118 800 s) the four profiles are relatively constant. Between
ventilation air decrease (see Fig. 2). In late evening, the heat 9 h (118 800 s) and 20 h (158 400 s) when the exterior
fluxes vary between 44 W/m2 and 69 W/m2 due to the temperature is warm (see Fig. 2), the flow rates in the two
combined effects of the radiant heaters and the resurfacing top outlets (Outlet-t1 and Outlet-t2) behave differently from
operations. Despite these large fluctuations of the net radiation those in the two bottom outlets (Outlet-b1 and Outlet-b2):
heat fluxes, the ice temperature remains below the freezing the former increase while the latter decrease. This can be
point (see Fig. 8(a)) provided the refrigeration system can explained by the difference in temperature between the two
maintain the temperature under the concrete slab below the sets of outlets (see Fig. 11); the air in the top row is warmer
ice at the assumed value (264 K). and therefore its velocity increases. During the resurfacing
Figure 11 shows the temperature profiles of the air at the operations, all flow rates increase but the relative order of
four outlets (see Fig. 1). The letters “t” and “b” indicate outlets magnitude is maintained.
near the top and the bottom respectively; the number “1”
indicates the outlets closest to the symmetry plane (x = 0)
and the number “2” indicates the outlets furthest away.
Naturally all these profiles reflect the temperature of the
incoming ventilation air and the effects of heating and
resurfacing. During the early part of the day, each of these
temperatures fluctuates around an essentially constant
average value; the amplitude of the fluctuations is highest
for the outlets near the symmetry plane and lowest for the
outlets far from this plane. During the middle of the day
the average value of these four temperatures increase and Fig. 12 Volumetric flow rates through the four outlets
then decrease following the profile of the incoming air (see
Fig. 2); during this period, the resurfacing operations cause 5 Conclusions
fluctuations whose amplitude is highest for Outlet-b1 and
quite small for the three other outlets. Clearly, the warmest Transient turbulent mixed convection in an ice rink was
air leaves the ice rink through the two highest outlets. The analysed numerically with the standard k–ε model associated
maximum temperature corresponds to the outlet situated to wall functions. The calculations were performed with real
in the middle top of the stands (Outlet-t1). This situation exterior atmospheric conditions for a typical spring day.
leads to considerable energy waste but at the same time it is If the ice rink is used continuously during this 24-hour
necessary to preserve air quality in the ice rink. Measures to period heating must be provided during approximately
recover the energy in the outgoing air should be considered. 25% of the time; but if it is not in use during the night
Due to stratification the air leaving through the bottom
(from 22 h to 7 h) only 1 hour of heating is necessary. The
outlets is cooler.
presence of thermostatically controlled radiant heaters
influences all parameters in the building, especially the
temperature of the stands, the ceiling and most importantly
that of the ice. Furthermore, this heating method influences
the radiant heat fluxes into the ice which fluctuate with large
amplitude when the radiant heaters are switched On and
Off. The air at 1 m above the ice is essentially stagnant
indicating that radiation is the principal heat transfer mode.
The results show significant differences between the volumetric
flow rates and temperatures of the air evacuated through
the outlets of the building. The overall results illustrate the
usefulness of the CFD technique as a powerful tool which
provides a detailed description of the airflow, the temperature
Fig. 11 Air temperature at the outlets field.
182 Omri et al. / Building Simulation / Vol. 9, No. 2