Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Manual of Policies
and Procedures
ABOUT THE AUTHORS
SIDNEY M. LEVY has 40 years of experience in commercial,
institutional, and public works construction. For the past ten
years he has been a private consultant working with owners,
general contractors, and developers assisting in contract
administration and compliance and dispute and claims
resolution. Mr. Levy is the author of 30 books relating to
project management, international construction,
construction materials and their application, and
infrastructure development, including Total Construction
Project Management, Second Edition and Project
Management in Construction, Sixth Edition.
Sidney M. Levy
Andrew M. Civitello
Fifth Edition
TERMS OF USE
This is a copyrighted work and McGraw-Hill Education and its licensors reserve all rights in and to the work. Use of this work is
subject to these terms. Except as permitted under the Copyright Act of 1976 and the right to store and retrieve one copy of the work,
you may not decompile, disassemble, reverse engineer, reproduce, modify, create derivative works based upon, transmit, distribute,
disseminate, sell, publish or sublicense the work or any part of it without McGraw-Hill Education’s prior consent. You may use the
work for your own noncommercial and personal use; any other use of the work is strictly prohibited. Your right to use the work may
be terminated if you fail to comply with these terms.
THE WORK IS PROVIDED “AS IS.” McGRAW-HILL EDUCATION AND ITS LICENSORS MAKE NO GUARANTEES
OR WARRANTIES AS TO THE ACCURACY, ADEQUACY OR COMPLETENESS OF OR RESULTS TO BE OBTAINED
FROM USING THE WORK, INCLUDING ANY INFORMATION THAT CAN BE ACCESSED THROUGH THE WORK VIA
HYPERLINK OR OTHERWISE, AND EXPRESSLY DISCLAIM ANY WARRANTY, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING
BUT NOT LIMITED TO IMPLIED WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE.
McGraw-Hill Education and its licensors do not warrant or guarantee that the functions contained in the work will meet your
requirements or that its operation will be uninterrupted or error free. Neither McGraw-Hill Education nor its licensors shall be liable
to you or anyone else for any inaccuracy, error or omission, regardless of cause, in the work or for any damages resulting therefrom.
McGraw-Hill Education has no responsibility for the content of any information accessed through the work. Under no circumstances
shall McGraw-Hill Education and/or its licensors be liable for any indirect, incidental, special, punitive, consequential or similar
damages that result from the use of or inability to use the work, even if any of them has been advised of the possibility of such
damages. This limitation of liability shall apply to any claim or cause whatsoever whether such claim or cause arises in contract, tort
or otherwise.
Contents
Preface xxi
Introduction xxiii
What This Manual Will Do for You xxv
v
vi Contents
Index I.1
This page intentionally left blank
Preface
The first edition of this book was published in 1994. Since then, the world of
design and construction has experienced a revolution in the approach to proj-
ect development, design, and execution. Design professionals using Building
Information Modeling (BIM) have either eliminated, or significantly reduced,
many of the problems that formerly plagued both their professions and the con-
tractors they work with. Coordination of the work of the various design disci-
plines, and steep declines in the number of conflicts among architectural,
structural, and mechanical components, have sharply reduced misunderstand-
ings, vagaries, change orders, and temper tantrums.
There is a new awareness that working together and sharing risks and
rewards is a better approach to achieving the goal of each member of the team.
New contract formats reflect this trend; by stressing collaboration and a desire
to work together to solve problems, the process has become memorialized.
Today, the computer is ubiquitous: in the home office, in the field office, and
in the pocket of the Project Manager and Superintendent. The speed of com-
munication among all key members of the construction process is limited only
by the time it takes to tap out a few words, snap a photograph, and press the
“Send” key. Problems encountered in the field can be easily and quickly passed
on to the appropriate parties; solutions can be discussed, agreed upon, and set
in place, in many cases within hours of the problem being brought to light.
But one thing has not changed over these past 20 years, and that is the role
of the Project Manager and the Field Superintendent in managing ever more
complex construction projects and bringing them to completion “within budget
and on time.” One can add to that duo: “while ensuring an end project of high
quality.”
This aspect of the Project Manager or Field Superintendent’s job remains
one of control: control of each one of those previously listed objectives of budget,
time, and quality. And these objectives or goals require full-time attention and
always expecting the unexpected.
Today’s managers of construction must be technically competent and pos-
sessed of managerial skills (or the ability to learn them quickly), so that they
can direct teams of skilled tradespersons and legions of subcontractors who
xxi
xxii Preface
must interact effectively and cooperatively. But Project Managers and Field
Supervisors must also have a smattering of accounting and have both feet in cost
control. They must be aware of the legal aspects involved in nearly everything
they do, from interpreting intricate construction contracts to dealing with the
mosaic of local, state, and federal rules and regulations, and to the ongoing doc-
umentation that details the daily events taking place on a construction site.
These details can play an important role in settling the disputes that may arise
whenever a complex endeavor such as a construction project travels from start
to finish.
This fifth edition of Construction Operations Manual of Policies and
Procedures, updated to fit into today’s design and construction environment, con-
tains a series of new contract formats, checklists, forms, sample letters, and
advice and suggestions gleaned from the coauthors’ decades-long experience in
the construction industry. We hope that this fifth edition of Construction
Operations Manual of Policies and Procedures will provide you with some new
insights to assist you in managing your new construction project more effectively.
SIDNEY M. LEVY
Introduction
Throughout the decade of the 1990s, there was an increasing awareness among
construction professionals at every level of the need for efficient, coordinated
management methods, procedures, and techniques that will effectively deal
with the incredible complexity of our special brand of business. As we have pro-
gressed as an industry, the focus necessarily was forced to divide between
these proactive management ideals and that dubious category of managerial
responsibilities —“risk management.”
Simply stated, the management of risk as far as an ongoing construction or
construction management firm is concerned begins with an acknowledgment of
the complex relationships among the various parties to every construction con-
tract that must be aggressively pursued on a daily basis. We don’t have “cracks”
for things to fall through in our business— we have open crevices into which
things get sucked into a vacuum if you let them. And so the “management of risk”
begins with focusing our attention on not only the development of procedures
and methods that address all of the activities that need to be performed, but also
on those forms, procedures, follow-up, and accountability mechanisms that will
create and encourage a discipline within the organization that will encourage
all of these activities to regularly be performed — completely— every day.
From there, effective operations management combined with an appropriate
“risk management” perspective should not limit itself to the management
cliches that are offered throughout too many “authoritative” books on the sub-
ject. We need to grab the reality quickly and deal with all of the pleasant and
unpleasant realities of our work environment. In other words, it does no good
to formulate our management procedures and our daily operations with the idea
of “construction in heaven”— as it “should” be. We cannot plan and operate our
companies anticipating a work environment as we wish it to be, rather than
as we know it truly is. We need to approach our work environments with a
significant — and genuinely healthy — consideration of the realities of our busi-
ness relationships. In this way, if we actually proceed with the expectation of
routine misfires, miscommunication, and plain mistakes, our management sys-
tems will automatically be designed to include safety nets, follow-up, and
instruction or guidance that will work to close all those crevices (or at least close
them to the size of normal “cracks”).
xxiii
xxiv Introduction
This is not at all to say that we must all proceed through our work days with
cynicism and pessimism. This is only to say that if we proceed with the expecta-
tion that some number of our business associates, subordinates, and contracting
parties do deal in wishful thinking, possess wide ranges of knowledge and com-
petence, and operate with “diverse” motives, we simply will see the problems
coming and deal with them all more in stride. Just as a pilot anticipates various
potential malfunctions and each phase of flight—and gives each possibility very
specific attention as he or she prepares and executes each phase—we as man-
agers should learn to do the very same thing in the management of our con-
struction contracts. We should recognize at the onset that these types of
acknowledgments of human nature as applied to the construction industry do not
need to be just one more source of pressure, or a new layer of stress. Instead, we
must realize that the higher up the ladder of managerial responsibility that we
may aspire to, the greater percentage of our work day will be devoted to dealing
with exceptions to management routine. At the lower rungs of the project admin-
istration ladder, greater percentages of the complete work are characterized by
routine (or at least “normal”) process and procedure. Submittals are checked
against contract requirements, various log forms are produced and maintained,
and so on. As our responsibilities move up the managerial ladder, our jobs have
an increasing requirement to introduce judgment into the process. Our judgment
is presumably based upon our “experience.” It follows that the only reason why
“judgment” and “experience” are needed at higher-level positions are to allow one
to deal with the inevitable exceptions to the smooth-running processes outlined
in the procedure manual for construction in heaven.
Because of these forces that work every day against our carefully planned
efforts, it has become absolutely crucial that all categories of field information
be reported accurately, quickly, and completely. Administrative activities must
be orchestrated, implemented, monitored, and adjusted. Late starts, mistakes,
omissions, and inappropriate actions must be exposed and dealt with quickly and
decisively. The success or failure of this entire effort translates directly into
either containment of costs and maximization of profit, or into huge financial
losses.
Dramatic and even exponential increases in the cost of doing business com-
bined with intensifying competitive pressures dictate that managerial, admin-
istrative, and supervisory operations must be streamlined for maximum
efficiency. Despite our increasing information control and reporting require-
ments, duplication of effort must be eliminated if overhead is to be controlled.
What This Manual Will Do for You
xxv
xxvi What This Manual Will Do for You
I Risk-Management Manual
I Comprehensive Project Management System
1.1
1.1
1.2 Section One
While there may be times when for given situations these objectives may
seem to be mutually exclusive, striving for their attainment in every situation
will consistently result in efficient work, creative solutions, respect, and personal
satisfaction. When our objectives are clear, our work will be focused, our clients
will be satisfied, and our operations will be profitable.
quality and is completed in the shortest possible time. To that end, the
Superintendent must continually work to ensure adequate staffing of the
workforce, sufficient supply of materials, and complete information as neces-
sary to assemble the product, and must plan for all these things enough in
advance so as not to interfere with the progress of any one component. General
duties of the Superintendent include:
I Generating, securing, or otherwise confirming all information needed to create,
monitor, and modify the progress schedule on a continuing basis
I Developing the progress schedule with the Project Manager
I Participating in scope reviews of the various bid packages to properly coordi-
nate their respective interfaces and ensure that nothing is either left out or
bought twice
I Working with the Project Manager to develop and administer the site uti-
lization program, site services, security arrangements, and other facilities
and arrangements necessary for appropriate service to the construction effort
I Identifying field-construction and work-sequence considerations when final-
izing bid package purchases
I Monitoring actual versus required performance by all parties
I Determining whether subcontractors are providing sufficient workforce and
hours of work to achieve performance commitments
I Monitoring the performance of the company’s Purchasing and Project
Engineering functions to ensure that all subcontracts, material purchases, sub-
mittals, deliveries, clarifications, and changes are processed in time to guar-
antee jobsite arrival by, or before, the times needed
I Directing any company field staff
I Being thoroughly familiar with the requirements of the general contract, thereby
identifying changes, conflicts, etc., that are beyond the scope of responsibility
I Preparing daily reports, job diaries, narratives, and all other regular and spe-
cial documentation as determined by the company and by the project needs
1.7.3 Benchmarking
Benchmarking is a procedure where the company seeks out and studies the best
practices in the industry in order to produce superior performance at home. For
example, internal benchmarking of self-performing work can compare the com-
pany’s performance on a project where quality levels were highest and costs lowest.
Then the company can investigate and memorialize the practices that created this
quality, cost-effective job.
A—Analyze the system to identify ways to eliminate the gap between the exist-
ing performance and the desired goals.
I—Improve the system.
C—Control the new system.
Quality Control and the Specifications. Various specification sections contain references
to professional and trade organization quality standards.The more common ones are
the American Concrete Institute (ACI), American Society for Testing and Materials
(ASTM), and the American Institute of Steel Construction (AISC).
A typical cast-in-place concrete specification includes references to the ACI
and ASTM, and since most general contractors do not have these extensive and
expensive manuals, they must rely on the integrity of their subcontractors and
vendors to furnish materials to meet these standards.
There are, however, several trade organizations that offer low-cost or no-cost
quality standard information for the products their organization represents:
Steel Door Institute. Provides information on hollow metal doors and frames,
including proper installation procedures, tolerances allowed, and some repair
and remedial advice.
Southern Pine Inspection Bureau. Provides specifications on various species
of southern pine framing lumber.
Western Wood Products Association. Offers specifications and mill tolerances for
fir, spruce, hemlock, hem-fir, and various other species of western softwoods.
Building a library of these types of quality standards, over time, will provide both
the Project Manager and Project Superintendent with baseline material specifi-
cations and enhance the company’s ability to provide quality service to its clients.
Experienced installers in one trade may offer suggestions to improve their per-
formance and the performance of predecessor activities or those that follow.
Issues of constructability and achievable tolerances can be raised, reviewed, and
discussed with the design consultants at these meetings.
Preconstruction conferences are particularly effective where subcontractors
involved in exterior wall and building envelope components are concerned. Curtain
wall or brick veneer construction involves a number of trades; the performance of
each one will impact the weather-tight integrity of the building’s skin. By bringing
all parties together, possibly in the presence of the architect, details are either con-
firmed or modified in order to create the most effective exterior barrier. Rather
than halt an operation in progress, problems are raised and resolved before work
commences—a clear exercise of Quality Control and Quality Assurance.
Preconstruction conferences are especially useful when working with the fol-
lowing construction operations or components:
I Sedimentation control and maintenance where subcontractors are alerted to
the provisions to be taken to preserve and avoid damage to these installations
I Cast-in-place concrete work, particularly where extreme weather conditions
can be anticipated
I Precast concrete deck, wall, architectural panels requiring embedments, and
attachment of other structural or architectural elements
I Structural steel and metal deck installation
I Waterproofing, commencing at the foundation and progressing up to and
including the roof membrane
I Exterior wall assemblies: stucco, exterior insulation finish system (EIFS),
masonry, precast concrete, metal or vinyl siding, metal panels
I Windows, louvers, ducts, and other penetrations through exterior walls
I Roofing, skylights, hatches, MEP penetrations, roof curbs, equipment platforms
I Joint sealants and compatibility to adjacent surfaces
I Interior gypsum drywall assemblies where in-wall blocking or other types of
reinforcement are required
I Kitchen and bath installations where MEP coordination is required and in-
wall blocking requirements need to be confirmed
I Finish wall items such as signage, window treatments, artwork installation
(with lighting) to confirm the location, type, and extent of in-wall reinforce-
ment, if required
acknowledged or debated prior to the actual start of work. Each participant’s input
will confirm that the design is proper or that certain changes need to be made and
approved by the design consultant in order to achieve the desired results.
These efforts taken before production begins can not only provide for a smooth
flow of work, but, again, increase or at least maintain expected quality levels.
Whenever these preconstruction conferences take place or panel mock-ups are
prepared, the event should be memorialized to document everyone’s comments,
responsibilities, and agreement on the issues presented.
I Reinspect again to ensure that these punchlist items have been corrected.
I If the work was not completed satisfactorily, send a letter to the subcontrac-
tor’s office advising the subcontractor of the need to inspect and correct any
substandard or missing work on a regular basis.
I Prior to a subcontractor demobilizing from the project, or substantially reducing
its crews toward the end of the project, the project superintendent should
“walk” the site or building with the subcontractor’s foreman to inspect, pre-
pare punchlists, and insist that the work be completed within a specified time
frame. If these requests are not met or are met with indifference, threats of
withholding payment may be the next step.
Who? Who will be responsible for QC/QA control for a specific project? The
person selected must have received ample training and be able to pass much
of his or her knowledge on to the various foremen, subcontractors, and other
supervisors he or she will oversee. It must be made clear to all concerned that
this technician has the authority of the CQCP Manager and the Project
Manager to implement company QC/QA policy on specific jobsites.
What? What will the designated technician’s responsibilities be? Will the tech-
nician be required to be on site continuously, one day each week, or only on an
as-needed basis to perform in situ inspections and subsequently prepare reports
for submission to the CQCP Manager or his or her project manager? Will they
be responsible for coordinating inspections by government authorities and the
owner’s design consultants? How are they to report QC/QA violations: verbally
to the affected party followed up with a written memo to the Project Manager?
Company Organization and Quality Assurance Program 1.19
When? When will some of these QC/QA activities take place: upon delivery
of materials and equipment to the site? And what about components such as
piping, duct, and electrical conduit risers that will be enclosed in shaftwalls
and fire-rated enclosures? Since timely inspections are required, will it be the
subcontractor’s responsibility to notify when such inspections are to take
place?
Where? Will the QC/QA technician be required to visit a subcontractor’s fab-
rication plant (i.e., steel fabricator) to comment on the quality of fabrication
equipment and processes?
1.7.18
Metal Framing/Gypsum Drywall Inspection Checklist (Continued)
1.26 Section One
The quest for quality is unrelenting and requires the full backing of top man-
agement and the daily attention of both Project Manager and the Field Supervisors,
but the concept of “Do it Right the First Time” is the essence of QCQA.
1.7.20
Sample Notification to Subcontractor of Substandard Work
Contractor’s Letterhead
At our job meeting this morning (afternoon), we inspected your work in place at (indicate the area in which the inspection
took place).
We were in mutual agreement that the following items of work require rework or replacement:
(List the substandard items discussed.)
We trust that this work will be satisfactorily completed by (date) and that you will instruct your field supervisor to pay closer
attention to the performance of his or her work.
Most clients recognize that construction can be a difficult process riddled with
inevitable problems and conflicts. The way in which we all organize and execute
our work; the cooperative, optimistic attitude displayed in our approaches to prob-
lem resolution; and our effectiveness in keeping our objectives targeted at client
satisfaction while preserving the other project objectives will stand like a neon
sign confirming our professionalism.These elements must be second nature, primary
considerations in the performance of every task, every debate with Owner
representatives and design professionals, and the final position in the resolution
of every conflict.
The successful project, satisfied client, and relationships maintained with
design professionals are our best advertisements—our best sales efforts.
As our projects are completed in this manner, the primary roles of our “official”
business development effort will be the demonstration that our project personnel
are the company’s greatest advantage that any new client can secure.
1.28 Section One
1.7.21
Sample Notification to Subcontractor of Pre-Punch Out Work
Contractor’s Letterhead
Addressed to Subcontractor
We have conducted a pre-punch out list pertaining to your firm’s work that requires rework or replacement. A copy of this
list is attached. It is requested that this work be completed prior to (date).
If you take issue with any items on this list, please contact me or (name of project superintendent). If not, we will expect all
these items to be corrected.
[If this work is not done after this letter is sent, add the following here and resend the letter:
A recent inspection of your work reveals that the pre-punch list submitted to your office on (date) has not been completed.
If this work is not corrected by the time you demobilize, we may, at our option, engage another firm to complete your work
and backcharge your account for related costs.]
Please be advised that this list is not a substitute for the Owner’s formal punchlist but is an attempt to keep that formal
punchlist to a minimum.
Project Manager
Place
your business card
here
1.30 Section One
1.9.4 Contacts
Develop “secondary” personal contacts as sources of lead information on avail-
able and upcoming projects in concept, planning, design, and bid phases. Some
sources of these contacts may include:
I Architects and engineers
I Subcontractors
I Material suppliers
I Core boring and other testing companies
I Planning and zoning agencies
I Trade unions
I Government and industry sources
I Local and state development agencies
I Banks and lending institutions
I Dodge Reports and other project information services
I National publications and magazines
I Newspapers
I Trade/industry magazines and journals
I Business owners and executives
I Area considerations
I Labor market
I Project approach
I Management and labor approach
I Preconstruction plan and program
I Project schedule
I Overall plan and program
I Subcontract approach
I Subcontract listing