Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2021
Julian Killingley
Recommended Citation
Oakes, Anne Richardson and Killingley, Julian (2021) "California's Brown Act: Clearing the Smoke-Filled
Room," California Western Law Review: Vol. 58: Iss. 1, Article 2.
Available at: https://scholarlycommons.law.cwsl.edu/cwlr/vol58/iss1/2
This Article is brought to you for free and open access by CWSL Scholarly Commons. It has been accepted for
inclusion in California Western Law Review by an authorized editor of CWSL Scholarly Commons. For more
information, please contact alm@cwsl.edu.
Oakes and Killingley: California's Brown Act: Clearing the Smoke-Filled Room
(
&!
"
03 /&"3-: 4&7&/5: :&"34 5)& "-1) 308/ $5 )"4 "4463&%
"-*'03/*"/4= 3*()5 50 3&26*3& -&(*4-"5*7& #0%*&4 50 )0-% $&35"*/
.&&5*/(401&/505)&16#-*$)*435*$-&$0/4*%&345)&&95&/5508)*$)
5)"5 -"8 )"4 #&$0.& */5&3/"-*;&% */ (07&3/.&/5 "/% /03."-*;&% */
"-*'03/*"/4=&91&$5"5*0/40'(07&3/.&/5$0/%6$5 &%*4$6441044*#-&
.&$)"/*4.4 '03 4&$63*/( $0.1-*"/$& 8*5) 5)& 308/ $5=4
3&26*3&.&/54*/$-6%*/($3*.*/"-4"/$5*0/4$*7*--*5*("5*0/(3"/%+63:
*/7&45*("5*0/4"/%4&-'10-*$*/( &&9".*/&*/%&5"*-5)&*%&/5*5*&40'
5)04& 8)0 #3*/( $*7*- $-"*.4 03 */70,& (3"/% +63: */7&45*("5*0/4 5)&
*.1-*$"5&% 46#+&$5 "3&"4 5)& /"563& 0' 5)& "--&(&% 7*0-"5*0/4 0' 5)&
308/$5"/%5)&&7&/56"-065$0.&4'5&3&7"-6"5*/(5)&&95&/550
8)*$) &"$) $0/53*#65&4 50 45"5& $0.1-*"/$& 8& $0/$-6%& 5)"5 5)&
(07&3/.&/5=408/*/5&3/"-16#-*$-"8"%7*4034)"7&-*,&-:$0/53*#65&%
.04550&/463*/(53"/41"3&/$:*/%&$*4*0/.",*/(
*
*
&
3*.*/"-304&$65*0/
*7*-$5*0/4
/7&45*("5*0/4"%&#:3"/%63*&4"/%&410/4&450
)&.
&-'0-*$*/("/%6#-*$8"3&/&44
-#(
/,?<
&-'0-*$*/(#:6#-*$0%*&4
063$&40'6#-*$8"3&/&44
-85>(5@E2<931>;9>7=1;5BC=5D9>89317?QC<13;CD?>5?D5<
?>D855F5>9>7?6!E>5
D85I3?E<4<9DD<581F5CEC@53D54D859B
45<925B1D9?>CD81D>978DG?E<425=5=?B12<5
6D5B6?EB619<5421<<?DC
51B<95BD81D41ID85I@B?355454D?C5<53D)5>1D?B-1BB5>
1B49>71C
D85 (5@E2<931> @B5C945>D91< 31>4941D5 6?B D85
@B5C945>D91<
5<53D9?>
1B49>7G5>D?>D?G9>D855<53D9?>2ED81C3?>C9CD5>D<I255>
B1>;54 1=?>7 =5B931QC C9H G?BCD @B5C945>DC
CC?391D54 'B5CC
B5@?BD5B "9B;5 #
)9=@C?> =5=?B91<9J54 D85 C5<53D9?> @B?35CC 1C
B5@?BD54D85>5HD41IN1B49>7?6&89?G1C38?C5>2I17B?E@?6=5>
9> 1 C=?;5 69<<54 B??= 51B<I D?41I 1C (5@E2<931> 31>4941D5 6?B
'B5C945>D
O *85 @8B1C5 N=5> 9> 1 C=?;5 69<<54 B??=O 9C >?G
+> ?H;9JEHE<J>; ;DJH;<EHC;H?97D' ;=7B-JK:?;I ?HC?D=>7C ?JO
/D?L;HI?JO ?HC?D=>7C /& ;C7?B7DD;E7A;I89K79KA
+HE<;IIEHE<C;H?97D+K8B?9' 7MH;J: ?HC?D=>7C ?JO/D?L;HI?JO ?H
HEEC
>?IJEHO
)KC;HEKI IKHL;OI E< FEB?J?97B I9?;DJ?IJI 7D: >?IJEH?7DI >7L; 9EDI?IJ;DJBO
H7DA;:#7H:?D=7CED=C;H?97WII?NMEHIJFH;I?:;DJI$---/ B?I>7!?;B:IJ7:J
!9-:1,-5;: #)52-, 964 '69:; ;6 -:; - )! FH
+(
>JJFIMMM98ID;MI9ECF?9JKH;IFH;I?:;DJI
H7DA;:
MEHIJ
8;IJ !9-:1,-5;1)3 1:
;691)5: $<9=-@
- >JJFIMMM9
IF7DEH=FH;I?:;DJIKHL;O
B7IJ
L?I?J;:*9J
/-);MI-J7<< #)5215/4-91+)F:'69:;!9-:1,-5;: /-
)! 1 , )EL
(
>JJFIMMMKID;MI9ECD;MIIF;9?7B
H;FEHJIJ>;
MEHIJ
FH;I?:;DJI7HJ?9B;IH7DA?D=
7C;H?97I
MEHIJ
FH;I?:;DJI
$--/-5-9)33@- W + # *N<EH:/D?L;HI?JO+H;II
=?L?D=7<KBB799EKDJE<J>;:?IFKJ;:EH?=?DIE<J>;F>H7I;7TICEA;
<?BB;:HEECU
https://scholarlycommons.law.cwsl.edu/cwlr/vol58/iss1/2 2
Oakes and Killingley: California's Brown Act: Clearing the Smoke-Filled Room
0
)
(
CI>?>I=?ECG9D81B??=?B@<135G85B5C53B5D4539C9?>C1B5=1452I
1C=1<<7B?E@?6@?G5B6E<@5?@<5
!ECD935B1>459C=5=?B12<I?2C5BF54D81DCE><978D9CND8525CD?6
49C9>653D1>DC
O&@5>=55D9>7<1GCM?BCE>C89>5<1GCM>?G=1>41D5
D81D D85 @E2<93 81F5 1335CC D? =?CD =55D9>7C ?6 6545B1< 1>4 CD1D5
7?F5B>=5>D 175>395C 1>4 B57E<1D?BI 2?495C D?75D85B G9D8 D859B
4539C9?>C1>4B53?B4C
)D1D5?@5>=55D9>7<579C<1D9?>31>25DB1354213;
1D <51CD 1C 61B 1C
?>7B5CC 5>13D54 D85 ?F5B>=5>D 9> D85
)E>C89>53D9>
1>42ID85>5F5BICD1D59>D85E>9?>814C9=9<1B
B5AE9B5=5>DC 9> @<135
)E>C89>5<1GCG9D8?@5>=55D9>7=1>41D5CC@51;D?13?==9D=5>D
D? 3?>35@DC ?6 @?@E<1B C?F5B597>DI 1>4 @E2<93 5>7175=5>D G9D8 D85
@B?35CC5C ?6 45=?3B1D93 4539C9?> =1;9>7 D81D G5 >?G B53?7>9J5 1C
$-- /-5-9)33@ $
1
( !
(
EF;D
C;;J?D=
B7MI
7D:
<H;;:EC
E<
IF;;9> B7IJ L?I?J;: *9J
$;);- 7-5
--;15/)>: >JJFI87BBEJF;:?7EH=-J7J;6EF;D6C;;J?D=I6B7MIB7IJ
L?I?J;:*9J
<EH79EDL;D?;DJ9EBB;9J?EDE<J>;I;B7MI
/-R8
,
#, , )
$ 7J 9-7915;-,15/-)
-#(
/, ?<
35>DB1<D?=5B931>@E2<93<965
?G5F5BD89C81C>?D1<G1IC255>D85
31C51C3?>CD9DED9?>1<89CD?B91>C@?9>D?ED?>5?6D8569BCD13DC?6D85
?>CD9DED9?>1<?>F5>D9?>?6
G1CD?@B?8929D3?@I9>7@B9>D9>7?B
@E2<9C89>71>I:?EB>1<5>DB95C?B1>ID89>7C@?;5>9>D85 ?EC5G9D8?ED
<51F5?6D85 ?EC5
C'B?65CC?B!?8>'
"1=9>C;9@?9>DC?EDD89C<5F5<?6C53B53IG1C
>?B=1< 5978D55>D8 35>DEBI @B13D935 9>85B9D54 6B?= D85 >7<9C8
'1B<91=5>D
*85@B5F9?EC?>D9>5>D1<1>4?>6545B1D9?>?>7B5CC5C
814 1<C? =5D 9> C53B5D 1<259D 1<<?G9>7 D859B :?EB>1<C D? 25 @E2<9C854
B57E<1B<I
*85 B51C?>C 1B5 >?D 496693E<D D? E>45BCD1>4
C , 9B79>91
45<571D5D?D85
?>F5>D9?> 5?B75$ 1C?>5H@<19>549>1<5DD5BD?
89CC?>
!1=5C$ 149C?>8141C9=9<1BF95GN/*085BE<5G1C1@BE45>D?>5
>?D?><I1C9DG9<<56653DE1<<IC53EB5D85B5AE9C9D56B554?=?649C3ECC9?>
2ED 1C 9D G9<< C1F5 2?D8 D85 ?>F5>D9?> 1>4 D85 ?==E>9DI 6B?= 1
D8?EC1>4 5BB?>5?EC 1>4 @5B81@C =9C3895F?EC B5@?BDC
O 5 6EBD85B
?@9>54 D81D N>? ?>CD9DED9?> G?E<4 5F5B 81F5 255> 14?@D54 2I D85
3?>F5>D9?>96D854521D5C814255>@E2<93
O
% + & - #
$--/-5-9)33@1,7JSDEJ?D=J>7JJ>; D=B?I>+ 7HB?7C;DJ>7:7BBEM;:<H;;
IF;;9>?D?JII;9H;J:;87J;II?D9; 8KJEDBO?D:?:J>;#EKI;E<ECCEDI
7BBEMIEC;E<?JI:;87J;IJE8;FK8B?I>;:
,7J
" ;EH=;(7IED -;;-9.964-69/-):65;6-69/-):659<5-
15 . , ! (7N!7HH7D:
;:
%7C;I (7:?IED -;;-9 .964 )4-: ),1:65 ;6 )4-: 6596- <5-
15 - ("! W . , !
%7C;I##KJIED;:
#
' 1 % -
S
https://scholarlycommons.law.cwsl.edu/cwlr/vol58/iss1/2 4
Oakes and Killingley: California's Brown Act: Clearing the Smoke-Filled Room
0
)
(
D 9C @?CC92<I 6?B D89C B51C?> D81D 1C 'B?65CC?B $ E<B?I CE775CDC
CD1D5<579C<1DEB5C@B565BD?@1CC?@5>=55D9>7<1GCD81D1@@<ID?<?31<
7?F5B>=5>D2?495C2ED>?DD?D85=C5<F5C
*89CBD93<5@B5C5>DCD85
69>49>7C ?6 1> 5=@9B931< CDE4I ?6 D85 ?@5B1D9?> ?6 ?>5 CE38 <?31<
7?F5B>=5>D?@5>=55D9>7CE>C89>5<1G14?@D542ID851<96?B>91)D1D5
#579C<1DEB59>
?B>51B<IC5F5>DII51BCD85( 1<@8$
B?G>3D
NB?G> 3DO 81C 1CCEB54 D? 1<96?B>91>C D85 B978D D? B5AE9B5 D81D
<579C<1D9F5 2?495C 8?<4 35BD19> =55D9>7C ?@5><I
*85 B?G> 3D 81C
B5359F54 3?=@1B1D9F5<I <9DD<5 1DD5>D9?> 9> D85 13145=93 <9D5B1DEB5 1>
?=9CC9?>G8938D89CBD93<5C55;CD?144B5CC
*853?>D5HD6?BD855>13D=5>D?6D85B?G>3D9>1<96?B>91G1C
1C5B95C?61BD93<5CGB9DD5>2I9>F5CD971D9F5B5@?BD5B$ 93815< 1BB9C1>4
-J;L;D%(KBHEO $<531/0;F:3)9-6> =-9*96), 7-56=-954-5;)>:
0133 9-- $7--+0 )5, )47-9 ..-+;1=- 6=-954-5; . ' ,
?9>?D=;H :<79)DEJ;
(KBHEO :<79)DEJ; 7J S
1;7H;7M7H;E<EDBOJ>;<EBBEM?D=JME7HJ?9B;IM>?9>IF;9?<?97BBO<E9KIED
J>;HEMD9J7IEFFEI;:JEC;DJ?ED?D=?J?DF7II?D=*ED7(7BB;JJ '06F:.9)1,6.
;0-1/),'63.-)33.69-/1:3);1=-#-:765:-;6;0-<,1+1)35;-979-;);165
6.;0-96>5+; (" ' ,
B;N7D:H7D:H;;D %0-
6:;6.$<5:015-%0-%09-);;6!<*31+4736@--!91=)+@!6:-,*@;0-)31.6951)
!<*31+#-+69,:+; ' ,
-#(
/, ?<
C 1BB9C >?D54 D85 B?G> 3D 494 >?D 1@@51B 9> 1 <579C<1D9F5
F13EE=
1<96?B>91 814 <1GC @B9?B D?
B5AE9B9>7 D81D =E38
7?F5B>=5>D 2EC9>5CC 25 3?>4E3D54 9> ?@5> @E2<93 =55D9>7C
(?9>7;B #7HH?I (6<9 $-+9-; 6=-954-5; ; 64-: 15 )5@ <1:-: -!
(7O 7J4>;H;?D7<J;H<1:-:5(?9>7;B#7HH?I (6<9$-+9-;6=
-954-5;5);64@6.;0-)<+<: -! (7O 7J(?9>7;B#7HH?I
(6<9$-+9-;6=-954-5;'0@)=-)36:-,-)915/ -! (7O
7J(?9>7;B#7HH?I (6<9$-+9-;6=-954-5;E?-+<;1=-$-::165:F9-6446515
65;9)6:;) -! (7O 7J(?9>7;B#7HH?I $;)90)4*-915
)23)5, -! (7O 7J(?9>7;B#7HH?I (6<9$-+9-;6=-95
4-5;.;-9))<+<:: =-9.;-9$462-):3-)9-, -! (7O
7J(?9>7;B#7HH?I 1;@);0-9:--7669: 7-5 -! %KD;
7J(?9>7;B#7HH?I 1,,-5<;;65)996>)33-! %KD;
7J(?9>7;B#7HH?I %0-=-9)/-1;1A-5'6<3,5F;)=-)0)5+- -!
%KD; 7J(?9>7;B#7HH?I )215/!<*31+<:15-::!<*31+ -!
%KD; 7J4>;H;?D7<J;H!<*31+5
<1:-: :<79)DEJ; 7J
!<*31+ :<79)DEJ; 7J
" W R
1;IJ
,R
$DJ>;EF;D?D=F7H7=H7F>IE<>?I<?HIJ7HJ?9B; #7HH?IE8I;HL;:T1>;D?JO
EKD9?BI 9EDL;D; J>; B7M ?I T(;;J?D=I I>7BB 8; FK8B?9U !EH I9>EEB 8E7H:I J>;
https://scholarlycommons.law.cwsl.edu/cwlr/vol58/iss1/2 6
Oakes and Killingley: California's Brown Act: Clearing the Smoke-Filled Room
0
)
(
%5F5BD85<5CC1C 1BB9CB5@?BD54D85C5<1GCG5B5B?ED9>5<I6<?ED542I
C9=@<I <125<<9>7 CE38 =55D9>7C G9D8 ?D85B >1=5CM31E3EC CD1B
381=25B 5H53ED9F5 C5CC9?> 3?==9DD55 ?6 D85 G8?<5 @B5 3?E>39<
=55D9>7 G?B; C5CC9?> 1>4 CDE4I =55D9>7
> D89C G1I 1I B51
3?E>39<C1>42?1B4C3?>DB9F54D?1F?94D85B5138?6D85<579C<1D9?>1>4
D? 3?>4E3D 9> @B9F1D5 2EC9>5CC D81D C8?E<4 81F5 255> 3?>4E3D54 9>
@E2<93
1BB9CQC=5CC175G1C3<51B45C@9D5D853<51BG?B4C?6D85<1G
@E2<93?669391<CG5B53?>6945>D9>D859B129<9DID?;55@D853?>4E3D?6
D859B 2EC9>5CC 89445> 6B?= @E2<93 C3BED9>I
*85 B?G> 3D G1C 1
<579C<1D9F5B5C@?>C531<3E<1D54D?3?BB53DD89CC9DE1D9?>
CG53?>3<E45
9> D89C BD93<5 G9D8 D85 25>569D ?6 89>4C978D D85 B?G> 3D =1I 25
B571B4541C1CE335CC
-5CE775CDD81DDG5>DI 69BCD35>DEBI7?F5B>=5>D
9> 1<96?B>91 9C >?G <1B75<I 3?>4E3D54 9> D85 CE>C89>5 ?6 @E2<93
C3BED9>I
-81D 9C >?D 9==5491D5<I ?2F9?EC 9C G8I D85 B?G> 3D
CE3355454G85B5@B9?B<579C<1D9?>814619<54
( 978DC 1B5 ?6 <9DD<5 F1<E5 E><5CC D85I 31> 25 5H5B39C54 2I D8?C5
5>D9D<54D?D85=
*85#1D9>=1H9=6#**64*#*3&.&%*6.B59D5B1D5CD89C
@B9>39@<51CDB1>C<1D54G85B5D85B59C1B978DD85B5=ECD251B5=54I
C 8956 !ECD935 !?8> $ 1BC81<< ?2C5BF54 1 7?F5B>=5>D 31>>?D 25
31<<541N7?F5B>=5>D?6<1GC1>4>?D?6=5>
96D85<1GC6EB>9C8>?
B5=54I6?BD85F9?<1D9?>?61F5CD54<571<B978D
O$ ?CDCD1D5C@B?F945
1 F1B95DI ?6 =51>C 2I G8938 D859B 39D9J5>C 31> 1CC5BD D859B B978D D?
?2C5BF51>4C?=5D9=5CD?3?>DB92ED5D??@5>7?F5B>=5>D
1<96?B>91
9C>?5H35@D9?>
>D89CBD93<5G53?>C945B8?GD85B?G>3D9C@?<9354G9D89>
1<96?B>91
-549C3ECC@?CC92<5=5381>9C=C2IG89383?=@<91>35G9D8
D85B?G>3DQCB5AE9B5=5>DC9CC53EB549>3<E49>73B9=9>1<C1>3D9?>C
7B?<EHD?7"EL;HDC;DJ E:;H;GK?H;IT) E79J?ED7KJ>EH?P;:EHH;GK?H;:8OB7MI>7BB
8;J7A;D8OJ>;=EL;HD?D=8E7H:E<7I9>EEB:?IJH?9J;N9;FJ?D7C;;J?D=EF;DJEJ>;
FK8B?9U!EH-KF;HL?IEHIT BBC;;J?D=IE<J>; E7H:E<-KF;HL?IEHII>7BB8;FK8B?9U
.>;H;7H;I?C?B7HH;GK?H;C;DJI<EHEJ>;HFK8B?97=;D9?;IM>?9>>7L;J>;FEM;H
7CED= EJ>;H J>?D=I JE :;9?:; M>7J JOF; E< I;HL?9;I J>; -J7J;WI LEJ;HI 7D:
J7NF7O;HI M?BB H;9;?L; 7D: >EM CK9> J>;O M?BB 8; H;GK?H;: JE F7O <EH J>;C
<1:-: :<79)DEJ; 7J
,
(7H8KHOL(7:?IED /- H7D9>
!EH7=EE:EL;HL?;ME<C;9>7D?ICI<EH;D<EH9?D=IKDI>?D;B7MI I;; 7NJED
, T >?FU-J;M7HJ -;;0-$<5:015-15693:-5?)415);1656.;0-C%--;0D6.
$;);-)5,-,-9)3 7-5--;15/:)5, 7-5#-+69,:)>: W' + W#
-#(
/, ?<
*
)9>359DC
14?@D9?>D85B?G>3D81CE>45B7?>51C5B95C?6
1449D9?>C1=5>4=5>DC1>41=@<96931D9?>CCE38D81D?><IDG?@1BDC?6
D85?B979>1<CD1DED5B5=19>9>6?B35
*85?B979>1< G?B4CD1DED581C
7B?G>D??>5?6=?B5D81>
G?B4C
CD85#517E5?61<96?B>91
9D95CQ7E945D?D85B?G>3D>?D5CN*85B?G>3D3?F5BC=5=25BC
?6F9BDE1<<I5F5BIDI@5?6<?31<7?F5B>=5>D2?4I5<53D54?B1@@?9>D54
4539C9?> =1;9>7?B14F9C?BI
)?=5DI@5C?6@B9F1D5?B71>9J1D9?>C1B5
3?F5B54 1C 1B5 >5G<I 5<53D54 =5=25BC ?6 1 <579C<1D9F5 2?4I 5F5>
256?B5D85ID1;5?66935
O D9C>?DD85@EB@?C5?6D89CBD93<5D?@B?F945
.>;F7HJI?DGK;IJ?ED7H;J>;FH;7C8B;?D " W R
1;IJ
T$D;D79J?D=J>?I9>7FJ;H J>; 7B?<EHD?7-J7J;' ;=?IB7JKH;<?D:I7D::;9B7H;I
J>7JJ>;FK8B?99ECC?II?EDI 8E7H:I7D:9EKD9?BI7D:J>;EJ>;HFK8B?97=;D9?;I?DJ>?I
-J7J;;N?IJJE7?:?DJ>;9ED:K9JE<J>;F;EFB;WI8KI?D;II$J?IJ>;?DJ;DJE<J>;B7MJ>7J
J>;?H79J?EDI8;J7A;DEF;DBO7D:J>7JJ>;?H:;B?8;H7J?EDI8;9ED:K9J;:EF;DBO.>;
F;EFB;E<J>?I-J7J;:EDEJO?;B:J>;?HIEL;H;?=DJOJEJ>;7=;D9?;IM>?9>I;HL;J>;C
.>; F;EFB; ?D :;B;=7J?D= 7KJ>EH?JO :E DEJ =?L; J>;?H FK8B?9 I;HL7DJI J>; H?=>J JE
:;9?:;M>7J?I=EE:<EHJ>;F;EFB;JEADEM7D:M>7J?IDEJ=EE:<EHJ>;CJEADEM
.>; F;EFB; ?DI?IJ ED H;C7?D?D= ?D<EHC;: IE J>7J J>;O C7O H;J7?D 9EDJHEB EL;H J>;
?DIJHKC;DJIJ>;O>7L;9H;7J;:U 7D:J>;EF;DC;;J?D=H;GK?H;C;DJ?D " W
R 71;IJ
T BBC;;J?D=IE<J>;B;=?IB7J?L;8E:OE<7BE97B7=;D9O
I>7BB8;EF;D7D:FK8B?9 7D:7BBF;HIEDII>7BB8;F;HC?JJ;:JE7JJ;D:7DOC;;J?D=E<
J>;B;=?IB7J?L;8E:OE<7BE97B7=;D9O ;N9;FJ7IEJ>;HM?I;FHEL?:;:?DJ>?I9>7FJ;HU
' * +
0 " , (
!
https://scholarlycommons.law.cwsl.edu/cwlr/vol58/iss1/2 8
Oakes and Killingley: California's Brown Act: Clearing the Smoke-Filled Room
0
)
(
1; ?D?J?7BBO 9ED:K9J;: 7 I;7H9> ED K=KIJ
E<
T1;IJB7M 7I;I 7B?<EHD?7 BB 7B?<EHD?7 -J7J; 7I;IU KI?D= J>; I;7H9> F>H7I;
T, 7BF>( HEMD 9JU.>;H;IKBJFHE:K9;: H;FEHJI.>;I;M;H;;N7C?D;:7D:
H;:K9;:JE78E:OE< :;9?I?EDI :?I97H:?D=:;9?I?EDI<EH7L7H?;JOE<H;7IEDI
ECCEDH;7IEDI<EH;N9BK:?D=:;9?I?EDIM;H;J>7J HEMD 9JL?EB7J?EDIM;H;DEJ
7BB;=;: ?D J>; 9B7?C :-- -/ & ;DJ L ' 7A; ED + ;:HE ECJO -;HLI ?IJ ) E
!
1' 7J 7B J FF ;9
J>7JJ>;:;9?I?ED
EDBO?DLEA;:J>; HEMD 9J8OM7OE<7D7BE=O?DJ>; EKHJWIH;7IED?D=:-- -/
!KD;H7B-;9+ B7DI $D9L-J7J; :E<!KD;H7B ?HI 7B, FJH: S J
FF J>; HEMD 9JM7I:?IC?II;:7I?HH;B;L7DJJEJ>;7H=KC;DJ:-- -/
-JH?8B?D=L(7?BB?7H: 7B, FJH J FF
EHM>;H;7D7FF;7B
JKHD;:EDEJ>;HB;=?IB7J?EDE<J;D7DJ?
-' + + B;=?IB7J?ED 7D:M>;H;J>; HEMD 9J
M7I79EBB7J;H7B?IIK;C;DJ?ED;:8KJDEJJ>;IK8@;9JE<J>;7FF;7B:-- -/ #7HH;BBL
#7DIED ) E
1' 7J 7B J FF-;FJ
.>?I HJ?9B;EDBO9EDI?:;HIJ>;MEHA?D=IE<J>; HEMD 9J I7JJ>;:7J;E<
MH?J?D=J>?I HJ?9B; FH?B
J>;MEHA?D=IE<J>; 7=B;O
& ;;D;* F;D(;;J?D=
9J:EDEJ7FF;7HJE>7L;8;;D;NFBEH;:?D7DO:;FJ>?DB7MH;L?;M7HJ?9B;I$--
" W R
1;IJ
1,RR
S
-;; " W R
:<79)DEJ; <EH?JIJ;NJ
$-- -/ $DJWB ' ED=I>EH;C;DWI 17H;>EKI;C;DWI /D?ED L ' NF
.;HC?D7B $D9 7B, FJH:
J FF
$-- " W RR 1;IJ
-#(
/, ?<
?6D85@8B1C59CG9451>45=2B135C*/5&3"-*"D857?F5B>9>72?495C
2?1B4C 3?==9CC9?>C ?B 175>395C ?6 3?E>D95C 39D95C D?G>C C38??<
49CDB93DC=E>939@1<3?B@?B1D9?>C49CDB93DC1>4@?<9D931<CE249F9C9?>C
D9C496693E<DD?9=179>512?4IG9D89>13?E>DID81DB19C5C?BC@5>4C
@E2<93=?>95CD81D9C>?D31E78D2ID85CG55@?6D85@8B1C5
*85B?G>
3D 1@@<95C >?D ?><I D? 3EBB5>D =5=25BC ?6 D85C5 2?495C 2ED 1<C? D?
5<53D54=5=25BCG8?81F5I5DD?1CCE=5?66935
*85B?G>3D9C3?>35B>54G9D8D85@B?354EB5C?6<?31<175>3I
<579C<1D9F52?495C1D=55D9>7C6?BD1;9>713D9?>
D4569>5C2B?14<ID85
G?B4 N=55D9>7O D? 9>3<E45 >?D :ECD D85 DB149D9?>1< @8IC931< 3?=9>7
D?75D85B?6=5=25BC?6D852?4I9>?>5@<1351DD85C1=5D9=5 2ED
1<C?F9BDE1<=55D9>7C1>41CI>38B?>?EC3?==E>931D9?>CEC54D?1BB9F5
1D17B55=5>DCD?13D
*85@8B1C5N13D9?>D1;5>O9CC9=9<1B<I2B?141>4
9>3<E45C>?D:ECD@?C9D9F5?B>571D9F54539C9?>C81F9>79==5491D556653D
2ED1<C?3?==9D=5>DC?B@B?=9C5CD?13D9>1@1BD93E<1BG1I1D16EDEB5
41D5
*8535>DB1<@B?F9C9?>?6D85B?G>3D9C9DC?B979>1<B5AE9B5=5>D
D81DN/10<<=55D9>7C?6D85<579C<1D9F52?4I?61<?31<175>3IC81<<25
?@5> 1>4 @E2<93 1>4 1<< @5BC?>C C81<< 25 @5B=9DD54 D? 1DD5>4 1>I
=55D9>7?6D85<579C<1D9F52?4I?61<?31<175>3I
O )53D9?>
@B?F945C 6?B =55D9>7C D? 25 85<4 2I D5<53?>65B5>35 CE2:53D D? 79F9>7
>?D935 1>4 3?=@<I9>7 G9D8 D85 B5<5F1>D @B?F9C9?>C 6?B 1 @8IC931<
=55D9>7
)53D9?> 2 C@5396931<<I @B?F945C D81D 1 D5<5
3?>65B5>35=55D9>7=ECD253?>4E3D54N9>1=1>>5BD81D@B?D53DCD85
CD1DED?BI 1>4 3?>CD9DED9?>1< B978DC ?6 @1BD95C ?B D85 @E2<93 1@@51B9>7
256?B51<579C<1D9F52?4I?61<?31<175>3I
O>9=@?BD1>DC1657E1B4
9CD85B5AE9B5=5>DD81DN/>0?<579C<1D9F52?4IC81<<D1;513D9?>2IC53B5D
21<<?D G85D85B @B5<9=9>1BI ?B 69>1<
O #579C<1D9F5 2?495C ?6 <?31<
175>395C1B5B5AE9B54D?N@E2<93<IB5@?BD1>I13D9?>D1;5>1>4D85F?D5C
,
$--1,R
$--1,R7
$--1,R 7
$--1,R
" W R 71;IJ
$--1,R 8 :
,R 8
,R 9
https://scholarlycommons.law.cwsl.edu/cwlr/vol58/iss1/2 10
Oakes and Killingley: California's Brown Act: Clearing the Smoke-Filled Room
0
)
(
?B12CD5>D9?>C?>D81D13D9?>
O *?@B5F5>D69>1<13D9?>259>7D1;5>
?>D85B5=E>5B1D9?>?6<?31<175>3I5H53ED9F5C9>3<?C54=55D9>7CD85
<579C<1D9F52?4I=ECD?B1<<IB5@?BD1CE==1BI?69DCB53?==5>41D9?>C
@B9?BD?D1;9>7D8569>1<13D9?>4EB9>71>?@5>=55D9>7
*85B?G>3D1<C?@B?F945CC?=51>D9 5F1C9?>=51CEB5CD?45D5B
?669391<C 6B?= 49C3?EB179>7 C3BED9>I
)53D9?> ?ED<1GC F1B9?EC
3?>49D9?>C@B53545>DD?1DD5>41>351D=55D9>7C
*85C53D9?>B5AE9B5C
9D25=1453<51BD81D1<<@5BC?>C=1I1DD5>4=55D9>7CG9D8?EDC97>9>7
B579CD5B9>7?B3?=@<5D9>71>I4?3E=5>D
9>1<<ID85C53D9?>C53EB5C
1 B978D D? B53?B4 ?@5> =55D9>7C E><5CC 4?9>7 C? G?E<4 @5BC9CD5>D<I
49CBE@DD85=55D9>7 1>4@B5F5>DC<579C<1D9F52?495C?6<?31<175>395C
6B?=@B?8929D9>7?BB5CDB93D9>72B?1431CDC?6D859B@B?35549>7CG9D8?ED
7??431EC5
)E38 1 B978D G?E<4 25 ?6 <9DD<5 F1<E5 96 D85 @E2<93 3?E<4 >?D
49C3?F5BG85>?BG85B5CE38=55D9>7CG5B5D?2585<4
?BD89CB51C?>
C53D9?> B5AE9B5C D81D G9D8 C?=5 5H35@D9?>C 5138 <579C<1D9F5
2?4I ?6 1 <?31< 175>3I =ECD 79F5 >?D935 ?6 D85 D9=5 1>4 @<135 6?B
8?<49>79DCB57E<1B=55D9>7C
%?B=1<<IB57E<1B1>4C@5391<=55D9>7C
1B5 B5AE9B54 D? 25 85<4 G9D89> D85 D5BB9D?BI ?F5B G8938 D85 2?4I 81C
:EB9C493D9?>
>I @5BC?> =1I B5AE9B5 D81D 1 3?@I ?6 D85 175>41 ?B
175>41@13;5D25=19<54D?D85=1>431>69<51>1>>E1<<IB5>5G12<5
CD1>49>7 B5AE5CD 6?B CE38 9D5=C
> D85 9>D5B5CD ?6 DB1>C@1B5>3I
C53D9?>
1<C?B5AE9B5CD81D1>175>413?>D19>9>7N12B95675>5B1<
45C3B9@D9?> ?6 5138 9D5=O ?6 2EC9>5CC =ECD 25 @?CD54 1D <51CD
C5F5>DI DG? 8?EBC 256?B5 C3854E<54 =55D9>7C
*85 N2B956 75>5B1<
45C3B9@D9?>O>554>?D>?B=1<<I5H3554DG5>DIG?B4C
5>5B1<<IN>?
13D9?>?B49C3ECC9?>=1I25E>45BD1;5>?>1>I9D5=>?D1@@51B9>7?>
,R 9
,R 9
" W R 1;IJ
,R
,R
,R
,R7
,R8
" W R1;IJ
,R7
,
-#(
/, ?<
D85@?CD54175>41O
1<D8?E78D85B51B55H35@D9?>C6?B5=5B75>3I1>4
3?>D9>E54=55D9>7C
C97>96931>D CD9@E<1D9?> 9C D85 @B?F9C9?> 6?B 13D9F5 @E2<93
@1BD939@1D9?>9>=55D9>7CCE2:53DD?D85B?G>3D
)53D9?>
1
CD9@E<1D5C D81D N/50F5BI 175>41 6?B B57E<1B =55D9>7C C81<< @B?F945 1>
?@@?BDE>9DI6?B=5=25BC?6D85@E2<93D?49B53D<I144B5CCD85<579C<1D9F5
2?4I ?> 1>I 9D5= ?6 9>D5B5CD D? D85 @E2<93 256?B5 ?B 4EB9>7 D85
<579C<1D9F5 2?4IQC 3?>C945B1D9?> ?6 D85 9D5=
O *85 1<96?B>91 )D1D5
#579C<1DEB5 1>D939@1D54 D85 381?C D81D =978D 5>CE5 96 1 >E=25B ?6
=5=25BC ?6 D85 @E2<93 9>C9CD54 ?> 144B5CC9>7 D85 =55D9>7 1D <5>7D8
E>45B3?<?B?65H5B39C9>7D859BB978DCE>45BC53D9?>
1
)53D9?>
2
AE1<9695CD89CB978D2IC@5396I9>7N*85<579C<1D9F52?4I
?61<?31<175>3I=1I14?@DB51C?>12<5B57E<1D9?>CD?5>CEB5D81DD85
9>D5>D ?6 CE249F9C9?> 1 9C 31BB954 ?ED 9>3<E49>7 2ED >?D <9=9D54 D?
B57E<1D9?>C <9=9D9>7 D85 D?D1< 1=?E>D ?6 D9=5 1<<?31D54 6?B @E2<93
D5CD9=?>I?>@1BD93E<1B9CCE5C1>46?B51389>49F94E1<C@51;5B
O
*85129<9DID?9=@?C5<9=9DC?>C@51;5BCQ6B554?=D?144B5CCB?G>
3DB57E<1D54=55D9>7CG1CD5CD549>*#",0''7*5:0'0/(&"$)
( 921;?66G1C1B57E<1B1DD5>45B1D=55D9>7C?6D85#?>75138*B1>C9D
?=@1>I?1B4?69B53D?BC
*85@B13D935?6D85?1B4G1CD?B5AE9B5
@5BC?>CG9C89>7D?C@51;1DD859B=55D9>7CD?69<<?ED1@E2<93C@51;5BQC
31B4G85B5E@?>D85IG?E<4251<<?31D54D8B55=9>ED5CD?144B5CCD85
?1B4?>D85B5<5F1>D175>419D5=
( 921;?66494C?1>4144B5CC54D85
?1B4
?G5F5BG85>85DB954D?144B5CCD85?1B46?B1C53?>4D9=5
?> D85 C1=5 175>41 9D5= 85 G1C @B5F5>D54 6B?= 4?9>7 C?
5
CE2C5AE5>D<I2B?E78DCE9D1<<579>7*/5&3"-*"D81DD85?1B4QC13D9?>C
9>6B9>75489CB978DCE>45BD85B?G>3D1>4D85 9BCD=5>4=5>DD?
D85+ >9D54)D1D5C?>CD9DED9?>
*85)53?>49CDB93D?EBD?6@@51<
6?E>4D81D1D8B55 =9>ED5D9=5<9=9D?>5138C@51;5B1DD85=55D9>7494
>?D F9?<1D5 ( 921;?66QC B978D D? 6B55 C@5538 2531EC5 D85B5 G1C >?
5F945>35 D85 B5CDB93D9?> 1@@<954 21C54 ?> D85 3?>D5>D ?6 89C CD1D54 ?B
,R7
,R8
,R 7
" W R 81;IJ
7B, FJH : J FF
9-0F/,-51-,* 9J
9-=,-51-,
;9
+-9;,-51-,:<*564 - J
,7J
,
https://scholarlycommons.law.cwsl.edu/cwlr/vol58/iss1/2 12
Oakes and Killingley: California's Brown Act: Clearing the Smoke-Filled Room
0
)
(
9>D5>454B5=1B;C
*854539C9?>QCCE2C5AE5>D89CD?BI9>3<E49>7D85
45>91<?635BD9?B1B92ID85+ >9D54)D1D5C)E@B5=5?EBD81C1CCEB54
9DC@?C9D9?>1CD85<5149>71ED8?B9DI?>D9=5<9=9DCD81D=1I259=@?C54
E>45BC53D9?>
2
>I=55D9>7=1I2514:?EB>54?B3?>D9>E54D?1C@5396954D9=51>4
@<135
*85B59C1<C?1@B?F9C9?>6?B31<<9>7C@5391<=55D9>7C?>79F9>7
DG5>DI 6?EB8?EBC>?D935
%?D935=ECD25@?CD54?>D85<?31<175>3IQC
G52C9D5969D?@5B1D5C?>51>479F5>D?=5491?B71>9J1D9?>CD81D81F5
B5AE5CD54 C@5391< =55D9>7C >?D96931D9?>C
*85 >?D935 N=ECD C@5396I
D85 D9=5 1>4 @<135 ?6 D85 C@5391< =55D9>7 1>4 D85 2EC9>5CC D? 25
DB1>C13D54?B49C3ECC54
O<579C<1D9F52?4I=1I8?<41>5=5B75>3I
=55D9>7 G9D8?ED3?=@<I9>7G9D859D85BD85DG5>DI 6?EB8?EBC>?D935
?B@?CD9>7B5AE9B5=5>D
*85B51B5C@5391<@B?F9C9?>C6?B35BD19><579C<1D9F52?495CD?8?<4
3<?C54C5CC9?>CD?9>CDBE3DD859B>57?D91D?BC1CD?D5B=C6?BB51<@B?@5BDI
DB1>C13D9?>C ND?3?>C945BD85@EB381C5?BC1<5?6@1BD93E<1BC@539693
@5>C9?> 6E>4 9>F5CD=5>DCO ND? 851B 1 381B75 ?B 3?=@<19>D 6B?= /0
=5=25B/C05>B?<<549>/D859B0851<D8@<1>/C0O ?BND?3?>65BG9D8?B
B5359F514F9356B?=/D859B0<571<3?E>C5<B571B49>7@5>49>7<9D971D9?>
G85> 49C3ECC9?> 9> ?@5> C5CC9?> 3?>35B>9>7 D8?C5 =1DD5BC G?E<4
@B5:E4935/D859B@?C9D9?>09>D85<9D971D9?>
O
6B5AE5>D<I <9D971D54 @B?F9C9?> ?6 D85 B?G> 3D 9C 6?E>4 9>
C53D9?>
#9D971D9?>?6D5>9>F?<F5C31C5CG85B5<?31<175>395C1B5
1ED8?B9J54D?8?<43<?C54C5CC9?>CN4EB9>71B57E<1B?BC@5391<=55D9>7
D?3?>C945BD851@@?9>D=5>D5=@<?I=5>D5F1<E1D9?>?6@5B6?B=1>35
49C39@<9>5?B49C=9CC1<?61@E2<935=@<?I55?BD?851B3?=@<19>DC?B
,7J
S
, ?87AE<<L ?JOE<' ED= ;79> 7B - J
" W RR 1;IJ
,R7
,
,R7:;<?D?D=M>7J9EDIJ?JKJ;I7DT;C;H=;D9OI?JK7J?EDU
,R8
,R
" W R1;IJ
,R
,R
-#(
/, ?<
381B75C2B?E78D1719>CDD855=@<?I552I1>?D85B@5BC?>?B5=@<?I55
E><5CCD855=@<?I55B5AE5CDC1@E2<93C5CC9?>
O
ED8?B9DID?5>6?B35D85B?G>3DQC@B?F9C9?>CD8B?E783B9=9>1<
@B?C53ED9?>C1>439F9<13D9?>C9C<?31D549>C53D9?>C 1>4
1>4 9C 49C3ECC54 9> 45D19< 9> '1BD C53D9?>C 1>4 B5C@53D9F5<I
85B516D5B
&
3*.*/"-304&$65*0/
,R8
$--/-5-9)33@# 7HH?I :<79)DEJ;:;J7?B?D=J>;9EDJ;NJ7D:D;;:<EHJ>;
HEMD 9JWI;D79JC;DJ
$--, 7BF>( HEMD 9J 9> R -J7JI
(?9>7;B# 7HH?I ->:4-5%-33)5/-9:6.$-+9-+@ -! -;FJ
7J
https://scholarlycommons.law.cwsl.edu/cwlr/vol58/iss1/2 14
Oakes and Killingley: California's Brown Act: Clearing the Smoke-Filled Room
0
)
(
>
D85 1<96?B>91 )D1D5 #579C<1DEB5 69BCD 1DD13854 3B9=9>1<
<9129<9DI D? D85 B?G> 3D 2I 1449>7 1 >5G C53D9?> N 138
=5=25B?61<579C<1D9F52?4IG8?1DD5>4C1=55D9>7?6CE38<579C<1D9F5
2?4IG85B513D9?>9CD1;5>9>F9?<1D9?>?61>I@B?F9C9?>?6D89C381@D5B
G9D8;>?G<5475?6D85613DD81DD85=55D9>79C9>F9?<1D9?>D85B5?69C
7E9<DI?61=9C45=51>?B
O
<9DD<5?F5BD89BDII51BC<1D5B1C5B95C?6
29<<CG1C@B5C5>D54D?D851<96?B>91)D1D5#579C<1DEB5D81DC?E78D*/5&3
"-*"D?1=5>4D85=5>CB513?=@?>5>D?6D85@5>1<C53D9?>
>
)5>1D59<<
1>4CC5=2<I9<< G8938G?E<481F556653D54
=1:?B 381>75C D? D85 B?G> 3D 1>4 9DC @5>1< @B?F9C9?> @1CC54 D85
#579C<1DEB52EDG5B5F5D?542I ?F5B>?B'5D5-9<C?>
>
CC5=2<I9<<
1>4)5>1D59<<1=5>454C53D9?>
D?@B?F945N 138=5=25B?61<579C<1D9F52?4IG8?1DD5>4C1
=55D9>7?6D81D<579C<1D9F52?4IG85B513D9?>9CD1;5>9>F9?<1D9?>?6
1>I@B?F9C9?>?6D89C381@D5BG9D8GB?>76E<9>D5>DD?45@B9F5D85@E2<93
?69>6?B=1D9?>D?G89389D9C5>D9D<54E>45BD89C381@D5B9C7E9<DI?61
=9C45=51>?B
O
*85 G?B49>7 G1C 6EBD85B B5F9C54 D85 >5HD I51B 2I
)5>1D59<<D?@B?F945
*89CB5=19>CD853EBB5>DG?B49>7
*855CC5>D91<49665B5>3525DG55>D85C54569>9D9?>C?6D85?665>C59C
D85 5F?<ED9?> ?6 D85 B5AE9C9D5 C395>D5B
>
D89C B5AE9B54 13D9>7
NG9D8 ;>?G<5475 ?6 D85 613D D81D D85 =55D9>7 9C 9> F9?<1D9?> /?6 D85
B?G>3D0
O
>
9D2531=5NG9D8GB?>76E<9>D5>DD?45@B9F5D85
,7J
, 7BF>( HEMD 9J 9> R -J7JI
$--, 7BF>( HEMD 9J -J7JIS
, 7BF>( HEMD 9J 9> R -J7JIS
, 7BF>( HEMD 9J 9> R -J7JIS
$-- " W R1;IJ
R -J7JI7J
-#(
/, ?<
@E2<93?69>6?B=1D9?>D?G89389D9C5>D9D<54E>45B/D85B?G>3D0
O
*853EBB5>DB5AE9B5=5>D5>13D549>
9CD81DND85=5=25B9>D5>4C
D?45@B9F5D85@E2<93?69>6?B=1D9?>D?G8938D85=5=25B;>?GC?B81C
B51C?>D?;>?GD85@E2<939C5>D9D<54E>45B/D85B?G>3D0
O
*85
?B979>1< 4569>9D9?> B5AE9B54 =5B5<I D85 133EC54QC ;>?G<5475 ?6 D85
E><1G6E<>5CC?6D85=55D9>71DD5>454
*85
4569>9D9?>C896D54D85
B5AE9B5=5>DQC6?3ECD?N;>?G9>7<I45@B9F9>7OD85@E2<93?69>6?B=1D9?>
D?G89389D9C5>D9D<54E>45BD85B?G>3D
?G5F5BD81D4569>9D9?>
G1C 1=297E?EC 1C D? G8?= D85 B5AE9C9D5 ;>?G<5475 G1C D? 25
1DDB92ED54MD85 133EC54 ?B 1 =1:?B9DI ?6 D85 1<96?B>91 )D1D5
#579C<1DEB5
*85 3EBB5>D 4569>9D9?> 2?D8 3<1B9695C D81D D85 133EC54QC
;>?G<5475 ?6 GB?>76E<>5CC 9C 1D 9CCE5 1>4 CE38 ;>?G<5475 9>3<E45C
2?D813DE1<1>43?>CDBE3D9F5;>?G<5475
)53D9?> 4?5C>?D4569>5D85@8B1C5N;>?GC?B81CB51C?>D?
;>?G
O *85 @8B1C5 ?33EBC 619B<I 6B5AE5>D<I 9> 1<96?B>91 CD1DED5C
)?=5D9=5C9DC1@@51B1>359>1C53D9?>9C133?=@1>9542I14569>9D9?>
9>1C5@1B1D5CE2C53D9?>1>49>?D85BC9D9C<56DE>4569>54
-85B5
D85@8B1C59C>?D4569>541<96?B>913?EBDC81F53?>CDBE54D85@8B1C51C
5=2B139>72?D813DE1<1>43?>CDBE3D9F5;>?G<54751>481F585<4D81D
CE381@8B1C59C>?DE>3?>CD9DED9?>1<<IF17E5
%?DG9D8CD1>49>71<579C<1D9F59>D5B5CD9>B569>9>7D85G?B49>7?6D85
@5>1< @B?F9C9?> 9> C53D9?> 9D 1@@51BC D81D @B?C53ED9?>C 1B5
E>3?==?> 1>4 9D 9C 3<19=54 D81D D85B5 81C >?D 255> 1 C9>7<5
R -J7JI7J
R -J7JI7J " W R1;IJ
" W R1;IJ
$--1,
I;7H9>E<1;IJB7MWIT 7B?<EHD?7-J7JKJ;I7D: EKHJ, KB;IU<?B;?D(7H9>
H;JKHD;:D?D;JO
D?D;?DIJ7D9;I
$---/ " W R
81;IJ
FHE>?8?J?D=;B;9J;:
IJ7J;E<<?9?7BIKI?D=J>;?HFEI?J?EDJEC7A;EH?D<BK;D9;=EL;HDC;DJ7B:;9?I?EDI8;<EH;
J>;?H7=;D9OM>;DJ>;OADEMJ>;O>7L;7<?D7D9?7B?DJ;H;IJ
$---/ #
) R1;IJ
H;GK?H?D=EF;H7JEHI
E<L;II;BI?DLEBL;:?D799?:;DJIJ>;OADEM>7L;H;IKBJ;:?D:;7J>EH:?I7FF;7H7D9;E<
7F;HIEDJEH;FEHJJ>;?D9?:;DJJEB7M;D<EH9;C;DJ
$---/ + ;EFB;L%?C;D;P #
1'
7JS 7B J
FF!;8
9?J?D=59-%EH=;( + : 7B
$-- ' :<79) DEJ; 7J IK==;IJ?D= J>7J
FHEI;9KJ?EDIKD:;HJ>;I;9J?ED7H;KD9ECCED
https://scholarlycommons.law.cwsl.edu/cwlr/vol58/iss1/2 16
Oakes and Killingley: California's Brown Act: Clearing the Smoke-Filled Room
0
)
(
*7*-$5*0/4
9F9< 13D9?>C D? @B5F5>D F9?<1D9?>C ?6 D85 B?G> 3DQC =55D9>7
@B?F9C9?>C1B51F19<12<5
3D9?>C6?B=1>41=EC?B9>:E>3D9?>CG5B5
69BCD 14454 9>
1>4 @B?F9454 N>I 9>D5B5CD54 @5BC?> =1I
3?==5>351>13D9?>59D85B2I=1>41=EC?B9>:E>3D9?>6?BD85@EB@?C5
?6 CD?@@9>7 ?B @B5F5>D9>7 F9?<1D9?>C ?B D8B51D5>54 F9?<1D9?>C ?6 D89C
381@D5B2I=5=25BC?6D85<579C<1D9F52?4I?61<?31<175>3I
O
*85C5
G5B5 5><1B754 D? 9>3<E45 453<1B1D?BI B5<956 9>
G85> D85 C53D9?>
G1C1=5>454D?B514
&1 !&,*+ , (*+ '& %1 '%%& & ,!'& 1 %&%-+
!&"-&,!'& '* $*,'*1 *$! '* , (-*('+ ' + ,'((!& '*
(*.&,!& .!'$,!'&+ '* , *,& .!'$,!'&+ ' , !+ (,* 1
%%*+ ', $!+ $,!.'1'$'$&1'*,',*%!&,
(($!!$!,1', !+ (,*,',!'&+ '*, *,&-,-*,!'&'
, $!+ $,!.'1
*85C53D9?>G1CB5GB9DD5>9>
D?79F549CDB93D1DD?B>5ICCD1>49>7
D? 3?==5>35 39F9< @B?35549>7C
*85 1=5>454 C3?@5 ?6 453<1B1D?BI
B5<956>?G9>3<E45C45D5B=9>9>7
$-- 96>5 +; !914-9 !
>JJFI<?HIJ7C;D:C;DJ9E7B?J?EDEH=MF
9EDJ;DJKFBE7:I
! I
HEMD
9J
+ H?C;H
"EE=B;
E9IF:<IJ7J?D=J>7JJ>;H;>7IDEJ8;;D7IK99;II<KBFHEI;9KJ?ED<EH
L?EB7J?EDE<J>; HEMD 9J
$-- " W R
1;IJ
, 7BF>( HEMD 9J 9> R -J7JI
, 7BF>( HEMD 9J 9> R -J7JI
-#(
/, ?<
!+ '-* , 0(*+ + !'& ' '& '* %'* ' !,+ %%*+ '* ,'
'%($ , $!+ $,!. '1 ,' ,( *'* !,+ $'+ + + + !'&+ +
*!&,*(*'.!
%5G CE2C53D9?>C G5B5 14454 5>12<9>7 3?EBDC 9> 35BD19> 31C5C D?
?B45B<579C<1D9F52?495CD?=1;51E49?B53?B4C?6D859B3<?C54C5CC9?>C
1>4 @B5C5BF5 3?@95C @B?F945 6?B D859B <125<9>7 1>4 @B5C5BF1D9?> 1>4
C@5396I D85 39B3E=CD1>35C 1>4 @B?354EB5C 6?B 49C3?F5BI ?6 D859B
3?>D5>D
449D9?>1< =9>?B 1=5>4=5>DC G5B5 5>13D54 9>
1>4
>?2F9?EC<9=9>1<AE5CD9?>9CD81D?6CD1>49>7D?CE5
*85
1=5>4=5>DB5=?F541>IE>35BD19>DI1CD?G85D85B149CDB93D1DD?B>5I
814CD1>49>7D?2B9>71>13D9?>2EDD85AE5CD9?>?65H13D<IG8?G1C1>
N9>D5B5CD54@5BC?>OG9D89>D85=51>9>7?6D85C53D9?>B5=19>54E>3<51B
DD?B>5I >> *1I<?B )38G9>7 >?D5C D81D 7B1>DC ?6 CD1>49>7 D? N1>I
9>D5B5CD54 @5BC?>O 1B5 >?D E>ECE1< 9> 1<96?B>91QC CD1DED5C
)85
?2C5BF5C D81D 3?EBDC ECE1<<I 3?>CDBE5 D85 @8B1C5 1C B5AE9B9>7
@B?C@53D9F5<9D971>DCD?81F5149B53D>?D=5B5<I3?>C5AE5>D91<9>D5B5CD
9>D85?ED3?=5?6D8513D9?>
?EBDC81F53?>C945B54D85=51>9>7?6
D85@8B1C59>C53D9?> 9>1>E=25B?631C5C1>481F579F5>9D1
2B?149>D5B@B5D1D9?>9>;55@9>7G9D8D85CD1D5=5>D?6<579C<1D9F59>D5>D
9>C53D9?>
, 7BF>( HEMD 9J 9> R -J7JIS
,
,
,
, 7BF>( HEMD 9J 9> R -J7JI
S
, 7BF>( HEMD 9J 9> R -J7JI
S
( .# -!
R:;:
,9?J?D=15;-9)31) >7I' # 7HD;O $D9L EDJH79JEHIW-J7J;' ?9;DI;
: + : S 7B9EDIJHK?D=T?DJ;H;IJ;:F;HIEDU<EH:;9B7H7JEHO
H;B?;<
$-- -/ -79H7C;DJE ) ;MIF7F;H "K?B: L -79H7C;DJE DJO : E<
-KF;HL?IEHI 7B, FJH
J FFIK==;IJ?D=J>;FK8B?9WIH?=>JJE
:?I9BEIKH;I>EKB:BE=?97BBO;NJ;D:IJ7D:?D=JE7DO9EKDJO;B;9JEH, ?87AE<<L ?JO
E<' ED= ;79> 7B, FJH: J FF
DEJ?D=78HE7:7KJ>EH?P7J?ED
<EH9?J?P;DIJ7D:?D=(9& ;;L* H7D=;/D?<?;:-9> ?IJ 7B, FJH: S
J FF
9ED9BK:?D=J>7J7DT?DJ;H;IJ;:F;HIEDU?D 7B?<EHD?7"EL;HDC;DJ
E:;I;9J?EDI
7
7C;7DIT79?J?P;DE<J>;-J7J;E< 7B?<EHD?7U
https://scholarlycommons.law.cwsl.edu/cwlr/vol58/iss1/2 18
Oakes and Killingley: California's Brown Act: Clearing the Smoke-Filled Room
0
)
(
-5D??;13<?C5B<??;1D31C5C851B42I1<96?B>91QC3?EBDCG85B5
B?G>3D9CCE5CG5B5B19C549>1B7E=5>D
&EB@B565BB54B5C51B38D??<
G1CD85-5CD<1G41D121C5G89383?>D19>C1@@5<<1D531C5CB1D85BD81>
D8?C5 851B4 1D 69BCD 9>CD1>35
-5 B51C?>54 D81D D85 CE2:53D =1DD5B
E>45B<I9>7 9CCE5C 1>4 381B13D5B ?6 @1BD95C 9> 31C5C 851B4 ?> 1@@51<
C8?E<4>?D49665BCE2CD1>D91<<I6B?=31C5C851B41D69BCD9>CD1>35G9D8?ED
1> 1@@51<
C51B38 @5B6?B=54 ?> 52BE1BI
B5F51<54
B?G> 3D B5<1D54 31C5C
>C@53D9?> B5F51<54 D81D C?=5 G5B5
1@@51<C6B?=4539C9?>C?6>?> 3?E>DIC@5396932?495CC?=5B539D541
B?G>3D9CCE59>@B?35549>7C25<?GG8938G1C>?D1D9CCE59>D85
9>CD1>D1@@51<C?=5G5B56B?=6545B1<3?EBDCG85B5D85B?G>3DG1C
=5>D9?>54?29D5B1>4C?=5B19C54D85B?G>3D1C1>1>1<?7ID?194
9>D5B@B5D1D9?>?B6?BC?=5?D85B@5B9@85B1<@EB@?C5
?B?EB1>1<IC9C
G5 4539454 D? 5H3<E45 D85C5 31C5C <51F9>7 EC G9D8 1 2?4I ?6
1@@5<<1D54539C9?>C9=@<931D9>7D85B?G>3D
*85B?G>3D31=59>D?6?B359>
1>4?EB2?4I?631C5C9C
4B1G> 6B?= 1@@51<C D8B?E78?ED D85 @5B9?4
D? @B9<
D 9C
>?D12<5D81DD8569BCDB53?B4541@@51<G1C851B49>
2ED=?B5D81>
?6D85C531C5C81F5255>851B49>D85<1CDDG5>DII51BC
*89C133?B4C
G9D8 D85 CD1DED?BI 89CD?BI ?6 D85 B?G> 3D 1C D85 =?CD 5HD5>C9F5
5H@1>C9?>C 1>4 1=5>4=5>DC G5B5 5>13D54 16D5B
5DD9>7 1>
?F5B1<<655<6?BCE381<1B752?4I?6<9D971D9?>9C496693E<D
-5@5B6?B=54
1> 1>1<IC9C ?6 D85C5 31C5C 1>4 CE==1B9J5 ?EB 69>49>7C 9> D85 D12<5C
25<?G
>513831C5G52571>2I945>D96I9>7G8?2B?E78D1>1@@51<
1719>CDG8?=
*8569BCD >1=54@1BDI9>D85B5@?BD?61>1@@51<9C>?D
.>; I;7H9> M7I C7:; E< J>; <?B; T1;IJB7M 7I;I 7B?<EHD?7 BB
7B?<EHD?7-J7J; 7I;IUKI?D=J>;F>H7I;T, 7BF>( HEMD 9JU
!EH ;N7CFB;I E< J>; A?D:I E< 97I;I ;N9BK:;: I;; -7H79;D? L ?JO E<
, EI;L?BB; ) E
1' 7J 7B J FF%KD;
:?IC?II?D=7 HEMD 9J7H=KC;DJ7I?CC7J;H?7B0;HI79?L-KF;H?EH J 7B
, FJH :
J FF
7 + K8B?9 , ;9EH:I 9J 97I; M?J> HEMD 9J
7D7BE=?;I:H7MD-J HE?NL-KF;H?EH J 7B, FJH :
S
J FF
9?JO IKDI>?D; EH:?D7D9; 7D: + K8B?9 , ;9EH:I 9J 97I; H;<;HH?D= JE EH
7D7BE=?P?D=M?J>J>; HEMD 9J.H7L;HIL ?JOE<(EHHE 7O ) E
S9LS
S
!( S( ) N
1' 7J S 7B ;9
HEMD 9J
C;DJ?ED;:EDBO7IF7HJE<<79JK7B879A=HEKD:E<97I;7D:#7HH;BBL#7DIED ) EI
1' 7J 7B J FF-;FJ
7DJ?
-#(
/, ?<
>535CC1B9<ID851@@5<<1>D
$ 1>I?6D8531C5C9>F?<F54=E<D9@<5@1BD95C
1>4G5C9=@<96954?EBD1C;2I3?>35>DB1D9>7C?<5<I?>D8531C5B5@?BD
D9DE<1B1@@5<<1>DC1>4B5C@?>45>DC
-549CD9>7E9C85425DG55>39D9J5>C
13D9>79>D859B@B9F1D531@139DI1>4D8?C513D9>71C8?<45BC?61>?66935
CE38 1C 1 49CDB93D 1DD?B>5I
&EB *12<5
69>49>7C C8?G D85 B5C@53D9F5
@5B35>D175C?61<<3<1CC5C?6@1BD95C9>D851@@51<CCDE4954
'B9F1D539D9J5>C
'B9F1D539D9J5>C
1=@197>C1>4) C
1=@197>C1>4) C
4E31D9?>1<2?495C
4E31D9?>1<2?495C
'B5CC =5491
'B5CC =5491
?E>D95C 39D95C
?E>D95C 39D95C
'E2<932?495C
'E2<932?495C
&669358?<45BC &669358?<45BC
"#-&%&/5*5:"/%1301035*0/40'1"35*&4*/
308/$5"11&--"5&-*5*("5*0/<
*12<5
C8?GCD81DD85=1:?B9DI?61@@51<C
G5B52B?E78D
2I @B9F1D5 39D9J5>C 31=@197>C ?B C@5391< 9>D5B5CD 7B?E@C N) CO
1719>CD 3?E>D95C 39D95C 54E31D9?>1< 1>4 ?D85B @E2<93 2?495C CE38 1C
C@5391<49CDB93DC1>4@E2<93ED9<9D95C
-549CD9>7E9C85425DG55>
54E31D9?>1<2?495C1>4?D85B@E2<932?495C2531EC5?6D85C97>96931>D
>E=25B9>G8938CE382?495C1@@51B9>D85B5<5F1>D<9D971D9?>C
%5HD G5 <??;54 1D D85 ?ED3?=5C ?6 D85C5 1@@51<C
*12<5
CE==1B9J5C?EB69>49>7C
$:;DJ?JOE<97I;I7D:J>;?H9?J7J?EDI7H;ED<?B;M?J>J>;7KJ>EHI7D:J>;' 7M
,;L?;M* <<?9;
https://scholarlycommons.law.cwsl.edu/cwlr/vol58/iss1/2 20
Oakes and Killingley: California's Brown Act: Clearing the Smoke-Filled Room
0
)
(
!
#?G5B3?EBD4539C9?>1669B=54
#?G5B3?EBD4539C9?>1669B=549>@1BDB5F5BC549>@1BD
#?G5B3?EBD4539C9?>B5F5BC54
"#-&65$0.&4*/308/$5"11&--"5&
-*5*("5*0/<
>D85=1:?B9DI?631C5CD854539C9?>C?6<?G5B3?EBDCG5B51669B=54
?B1669B=549>@1BD1>4B5F5BC549>@1BD
>65G5BD81>?>5 D89B4?631C5C
<?G5B3?EBD4539C9?>CG5B5B5F5BC54
?=29>9>7D85*12<5
1>4*12<569>49>7CG5C55D81D=?CD1@@51<C1B52B?E78D2I@B9F1D5
39D9J5>CC9>7<I?B9>7B?E@C1>4D81D=?CD1@@51<C1B5E>CE335CC6E<
>6EBD85B1>1<IC9CG5<??;541DD85>1DEB5?6D85CE2:53D=1DD5B?6
D85 49C@ED5C 9> D85 ?B979>1< @B?35549>7C 1>4 D85 B5<956 C?E78D
*85
?B979>1<@B?35549>7C9>F?<F541G945F1B95DI?63<19=C2ED35BD19>1B51C
G5B5<9D971D54=?B56B5AE5>D<ID81>?D85BC
*12<5C8?GCD8575>5B1<
<9D971D9?>1B51C3?=@B9C9>7D85CE2C5AE5>D1@@51<C9>F?<F9>7*/5&3"-*"
1<<5754B?G>3DF9?<1D9?>C
$:;DJ?JOE<97I;I7D:J>;?H9?J7J?EDI7H;ED<?B;M?J>J>;7KJ>EHI7D:J>;'7M
,;L?;M*<<?9;
- # (
/, ?<
!
>7175=5>D1>4D5B=C?65=@<?I=5>D
=@<?I555F1<E1D9?>C49C39@<9>51>4D5B=9>1D9?>
( 51<@B?@5BDI49C@ED5C
@@?9>D=5>DCD?F131>395C9>?66935
9C@?C1<DB1>C65B1>4<51C9>7?6@E2<93@B?@5BDI
9BCD=5>4=5>DB978DC
?>DB13DE1<1>4D?BD9?EC3<19=C
'E2<937?F5B>1>35
& D85B
"#-&3&"40'03*(*/"-%*4165&*/308/
$5"11&--"5&-*5*("5*0/<
& EB 31D57?B9J1D9?>C 1B5 @19>D54 G9D8 1 2B?14 2BEC8 1C 1 69>5B
7B19>54 1>1<IC9C G?E<4 81F5 <54 D? =1>I 31D57?B95C G9D8 :ECD 1 65G
9>CD1>35C
*89C3?E<481F5?2C3EB54D855=5B75>35?613<51B5B@93DEB5
?6G85B5D851B51C?67B51D5CD3?>6<93D<95
$ ?B53<19=C1B?C59>B5<1D9?>
D? 49C@ED5C 9>F?<F9>7 @E2<93 C5BF1>DC D81> 1>I ?D85B 1B51
%51B<I
?>5 D89B4 ?6 D8?C5 49C@ED5C B5<1D54 D? 75>5B1< 89B9>7 1>4 D5B=C ?6
C5BF9359>3<E49>7B5=E>5B1D9?>1>4@5>C9?>C2ED3<?C5D?DG? D89B4C?6
D8?C549C@ED5CB5<1D54D?CD1665F1<E1D9?>C49C39@<9>51>4D5B=9>1D9?>C
*85>5HD<1B75CD1B519C<??C5<I<125<54N( 51<@B?@5BDI49C@ED5C
O
*89C <125< 5>3?=@1CC5C <1>4 EC5 J?>9>7 1>4 75>5B1< 45F5<?@=5>D
@B?@?C1<C 2ED 5H3<E45C 5H5B39C5 ?6 5=9>5>D 4?=19> @?G5BC B5>D
3?>DB?< 1>4 49C@?C1<C 1>4 <51C5C ?6 @E2<93 <1>4
*85C5 DG? 2B?14
1B51CM5=@<?I=5>D 1>4 B51< @B?@5BDIM133?E>D54 6?B =?B5 D81>
?>5 81<6?61<<?B979>1<49C@ED5CD81DB5CE<D549>1>1@@51<B19C9>7?>5?B
=?B51<<5754B?G>3DF9?<1D9?>C
*85 N 9BCD =5>4=5>D B978DCO 85149>7 2B?14<I 3?F5BC 49C@ED5C
9>F?<F9>7 6B554?=C ?6 C@5538 1>4 D85 @B5CC 1>4 D85 B978D D? @5D9D9?>
7?F5B>=5>D6?BB54B5CC?67B95F1>35C
9>1<<ID85N'E2<937?F5B>1>35O
$:;DJ?JOE<97I;I7D:J>;?H9?J7J?EDI7H;ED<?B;M?J>J>;7KJ>EHI7D:J>;'7M
,;L?;M*<<?9;
https://scholarlycommons.law.cwsl.edu/cwlr/vol58/iss1/2 22
Oakes and Killingley: California's Brown Act: Clearing the Smoke-Filled Room
0
)
(
85149>7 3?F5BC 1 G945 B1>75 ?6 2581F9?BC B5<1D9>7 D? D85 9>D5B>1<
G?B;9>7C 1>4 4539C9?> =1;9>7 @B?35CC5C ?6 <?31< 7?F5B>=5>D 2?495C
1>4D853?>4E3D?6@E2<93=55D9>7C
- 51<C?1>1<IJ54D85B5<956C?E78D9>D85?B979>1<@B?35549>7CD81D
CE2C5AE5>D<I<54D?1@@51<CD81D9>3<E4541<<5754B?G>3DF9?<1D9?>C
) ?=5 31C5C 3<19=54 D85 3<1CC93 B5=5495C ?6 GB9D ?6 =1>41D5 ?B
=1>41=EC G9D8 ?B G9D8?ED ?D85B 49C3B5D9?>1BI B5<956 G89<5 ?D85BC
C?E78D 41=175C 1>4 ?D85B B5<956
> D89C BD93<5 D85 49C3B5D9?>1BI
B5=5495C B565BB54 D? 1B5 D8?C5 ?6 453<1B1D?BI 1>4 9>:E>3D9F5 B5<956
<19=C6?B49C3B5D9?>1BI1G1B4C?61DD?B>5I655CE>45BC53D9?>
2I@B5F19<9>7<9D971>DC1B5DB51D54C5@1B1D5<I9>31C5CG85B5D85IG5B5
5H@<939D<I 3<19=54 9> D85 ?B979>1< @B?35549>7C
*12<5 B56<53DC D81D
<9D971>DCC?E78D=1>41=ECG9D8?BG9D8?ED?D85BB5<9569>=?B5D81>
C9HDI@5B35>D?631C5C
$!
$ 1>41=EC
$ 1>41=EC?D85B49C3B5D9?>1BIB5<956
9C3B5D9?>1BIB5<956
DD?B>5I655C
&D85BB5=5495C
"#-& &-*&'406()5*/308/$5
"11&--"5&-*5*("5*0/<
>1=1:?B9DI?6D85C531C5C1<<5754B?G>3DF9?<1D9?>CB19C54?>
1@@51< G5B5 >?D D85 E>45B<I9>7 31EC5 ?6 D85 ?B979>1< <9D971D9?>
*85
B?G> 3D 9CCE5C G5B5 @5B9@85B1< D? D85 =19> 3<19= 1>4 G5B5 ?><I
35>DB1<9>31C5C31D57?B9J541CN'E2<937?F5B>1>35O9>*12<5
>=?CD
31C5C D85 B?G> 3D F9?<1D9?>C C5BF54 1C 1 D??< D? 14F1>35 ?D85B
$:;DJ?JOE<97I;I7D:J>;?H9?J7J?EDI7H;ED<?B;M?J>J>;7KJ>EHI7D:J>;'7M
,;L?;M*<<?9;.>;>;7:?D=T(7D:7CKIEJ>;H:?I9H;J?ED7HOH;B?;<U?D9BK:;I9B7?CI
<EH:;9B7H7JEHOH;B?;< ?D@KD9J?L;H;B?;< EH8EJ>.>;>;7:?D=T?I9H;J?ED7HOH;B?;<U
?D9BK:;I9B7?CI<EH:;9B7H7JEHOH;B?;< ?D@KD9J?L;H;B?;< EH8EJ>.>;>;7:?D=T*J>;HU
?D9BK:;I IK9> J>?D=I 7I EH:;HI JE 9ECF;B :?I9EL;HO EH 7H8?JH7J?ED ;C?D;DJ :EC7?D
79J?EDI 7DJ?
-'++CEJ?EDI ;J9
- # (
/, ?<
9>D5B5CDC
C1>5H1=@<5D85"-#*40<9D971D9?> B19C54*/5&3"-*"1
>E=25B?61<<5754B?G>3DF9?<1D9?>C
*85C59>3<E454D85619<EB5?6
D85&B?C9'E2<93+ D9<9DI9CDB93DD?166?B4$ 1BI 1<29C?1>?@@?BDE>9DI
D?=1;51@E2<933?==5>DB571B49>79DC6?B53<?CEB513D9?>1>4D85613D
D81D9D81449C3ECC54<9D971D9?>1719>CD85B9>13<?C54@B9F1D5C5CC9?>
G9D8?ED =1;9>7 D85 B5AE9B54 @E2<93 49C3<?CEB5C
?G5F5B D85
<9D971D9?>QC@EB@?C5G1C>?DD?3?BB53DD85@B?354EB1<9>145AE1395C?6
D859CDB93DQC=55D9>7C
( 1D85B$ C
1<29C?G1C45D5B=9>54D?B5F5BC5
1>1DD5=@D54D1HC1<59>D5>454D?C1D9C6I49C@ED54C5G5B1CC5CC=5>DC?>
85B<1>4
%5HDG5<??;541DD856B5AE5>3I?61<<571D9?>C?649665B5>DB?G>
3D F9?<1D9?>C 1>4 D85 B?G> 3D C53D9?>C =?CD ?6D5> 9>F?;54 9>
1@@51<C
!
$ 55D9>7G1CC8?E<481F5255>?@5>3<?C54
45AE13I?6>?D935?61=55D9>7
45AE13I?6175>41@B?F94546?B=55D9>7
- 85D85B13D9?>C3?>CD9DED541P=55D9>7Q
- 85D85B@1BD939@1>D1P<579C<1D9F52?4IQ
29<9DI?6@E2<93D?@1BD939@1D59>=55D9>7
G1B4?61DD?B>5I655CD?@B5F19<9>7@1BDI
&D85B
"#-&
"563&0'7*0-"5*0/4"--&(&%*/308/
$5"11&--"5&-*5*("5*0/<
$--"7B8?IEL*HEI?+K8/J?B?IJ 7B,FJH:JFF
"7B8?IEL*HEI?+K8/J?B?IJ
7B,FJH:JFF
"7B8?IEL
*HEI?+K8/J?B?IJ )E!
1'7BJFF%KD;
$:;DJ?JOE<97I;I7D:J>;?H9?J7J?EDI7H;ED<?B;M?J>J>;7KJ>EHI7D:J>;'7M
,;L?;M*<<?9;)EJ;J>7J;79>F;H9;DJ7=;?I;NFH;II;:7IJ>7JE<7BB97I;IIJK:?;:
-EC;97I;I?DLEBL;:CEH;J>7DED;7BB;=;:L?EB7J?ED$-- -/ "7B8?IEL*HEI?+K8
/J?B?IJ 7B,FJH:JFF
:;J7?B?D=<?L;JEJ7B9B7?CIJMEE<
M>?9>M;H;KD:;HI;9J?ED
;JI;G
https://scholarlycommons.law.cwsl.edu/cwlr/vol58/iss1/2 24
Oakes and Killingley: California's Brown Act: Clearing the Smoke-Filled Room
0
)
(
)9>35D85B?G>3D9C1>N?@5>=55D9>7CO<1G9D9CE>CEB@B9C9>7
D81DD85=?CD?6D5>1<<5754F9?<1D9?>G1CG85D85B1@1BD93E<1B=55D9>7
G1C 9=@B?@5B<I ?@5> ?B 3<?C54
#5CC 6B5AE5>D<I 1<<5754 F9?<1D9?>C
31D57?B9J54E>45BD85N&D85BO85149>79>3<E45D85AE5CD9?>C?6G85D85B
1 @1BD93E<1B 2?4I 3?>CD9DED54 1 N<?31< 175>3IO G85D85B 1>
1DD?B>5I 3<95>D @B9F9<575 1DD13854 D? D85 @B?35549>7C G85D85B 35BD19>
2581F9?B3?>CD9DED54N13D9?>D1;5>O1>4G85D85B1@1BDI814CD1>49>7
5BD19> F9?<1D9?>C G5B5 3?==?><I 1CC?391D54 G9D8 C@539693 ;9>4C ?6
E>45B<I9>7CE2CD1>D9F549C@ED5C
)?1<<571D9?>C?69=@B?@5B<I8?<49>7
@E2<93=55D9>7C1>4619<9>7D?79F5=55D9>7>?D935C1>4@B?@5B175>41
45C3B9@D9?>C?6D5>697EB59>@5BC?>>5<49C@ED5C9>F?<F9>749C39@<9>1BI?B
49C=9CC1<@B?35549>7C
*12<5@B?F945C1>1>1<IC9C?6D856B5AE5>3IG9D8G8938B?G>
3DC53D9?>CG5B549C3ECC549>45D19<9>D85B1D9?453945>49?61@@5<<1D5
?@9>9?>C
-#(
/,?<
(1D85BD81>CE2:53D9>7D85C5?@9>9?>CD?69>5 7B19>54C3BED9>IG5
3?>69>54?EB1>1<IC9CD?39D9>7D85B565B5>354C53D9?>CB1D85BD81>D859B
=1>I9>49F94E1<CE249F9C9?>C
*85C53D9?>=?CD6B5AE5>D<ID85CE2:53D
?6 1B7E=5>D G1C C53D9?> G8938 7?F5B>C 9>CD1>35C G85> <?31<
175>395C=1I8?<43<?C54C5CC9?>C1>4D85@B?354EB5C6?B8?<49>7CE38
C5CC9?>C
)53D9?> G1C49C3ECC549>
?61@@51<CCDE4954
*85>5HD=?CD6B5AE5>D<I49C3ECC54@B?F9C9?>G1CC53D9?> G8938
697EB54 9>
?6 31C5C 1>4 45D5B=9>5C */5&3 "-*" 8?G >?D935 ?6
=55D9>7C9CD?2579F5>D85@B?F9C9?>?6175>41C1>4D85B978D?6D85
@E2<93 D? @1BD939@1D5 9> =55D9>7C
*89C G1C 3<?C5<I 6?<<?G54 2I
C53D9?>C 1>4 5138?6G8938G5B549C3ECC549>
?6
31C5CB5C@53D9F5<I
)53D9?> C@539695C*/5&3"-*"G81D3?>CD9DED5C
1<579C<1D9F52?4I1=55D9>71>41>13D9?>D1;5>1>4@B?8929DCC53B5D
=55D9>7C D? 3?>4E3D 2EC9>5CC
)53D9?> */5&3 "-*" 1ED8?B9J5C
1@@B?@B91D5@5BC?>CD?9>CD9DED539F9<@B?35549>7C6?BF9?<1D9?>C?6D85
B?G>3D1>4@B?F945C6?BD85B53?F5BI?63?CDC
&6D85B5=19>9>7C53D9?>C?6D85B?G>3D?><IC53D9?>C
1>4 G5B5 49C3ECC54 G9D8 1>I 6B5AE5>3I 9> ?@9>9?>C
)53D9?>
9C 1>1<IJ54 9>
?6 31C5C 1>4 @B?F945C */5&3 "-*" D81D 1<<
=55D9>7C ?6 D85 <579C<1D9F5 2?4I ?6 1 <?31< 175>3I C81<< 25 ?@5> 1>4
@E2<93 1>4 D81D 1<< @5BC?>C C81<< >?B=1<<I 25 5>D9D<54 D? 1DD5>4 D85C5
=55D9>7C
D=1I25D81DD853<1B9DI?6C53D9?> QCB5AE9B5=5>DC9C
CE38D81D45C@9D59DC35>DB1<9DI9DG1CCE2:53DD?:E49391<1>1<IC9C9>?><I
?6 31C5C
)53D9?> 451<C */5&3 "-*" G9D8 D85 39B3E=
CD1>35C9>G8938C@5391<=55D9>7C=1I2531<<541>4D85@B?354EB5C6?B
4?9>7C?
*85C53D9?>9C651DEB549>
?6?@9>9?>C
*85B5=19>9>7
C53D9?>CG5B5C97>96931>D<I<5CC6B5AE5>D<ID85CE2:53D?61B7E=5>D1>4
D?75D85B1@@51B549>>?=?B5D81>
?631C5C
-;9J?ED EHED;EHCEH;E<?JIIK8:?L?I?EDI M7I:?I9KII;:?D<EHJO
I?N97I;I ,R
-;9J?EDI7D:
EHED;EHCEH;E<J>;?HIK8:?L?I?EDI M;H;;79>
:?I9KII;:?DJ>?HJO
JME97I;I ;79>,RR
-;9J?ED EHED;EHCEH;E<?JIIK8:?L?I?EDI M7I:?I9KII;:?DJM;BL;
97I;I ,R
-;9J?ED EHED;EHCEH;E<?JIIK8:?L?I?EDI M7I:?I9KII;:?DJM;DJO
I;L;D97I;I ,R
-;9J?EDI 7D: EH ED; EH CEH; E< J>;?H IK8:?L?I?EDI M;H;
:?I9KII;:?DJ>H;;97I;I ,RR
https://scholarlycommons.law.cwsl.edu/cwlr/vol58/iss1/2 26
Oakes and Killingley: California's Brown Act: Clearing the Smoke-Filled Room
0
)
(
-51B5E>12<5D?5CD12<9C8G81D@B?@?BD9?>?639F9<CE9DC75>5B1<<I
1>4B?G>3D31C5C9>@1BD93E<1B1B5DB9541>4CE2C5AE5>D<I1@@51<54
-5@B5F9?EC<I>?D54D81DD85>E=25B?61@@51<C9>F?<F9>7B?G>3D
@B9>39@<5C81C9>3B51C54C97>96931>D<I9>B535>DI51BC
%5F5BD85<5CC?><I
1@@51<C851B4C9>35
81F59>F?<F54CE2CD1>D91<1B7E=5>D12?ED
D85B?G>3DQCB5AE9B5=5>DCM1=51>?6C<978D<I65G5BD81>69F531C5C
5138 I51B
*89C CE775CDC D81D 9> 1 CD1D5 G9D8 696DI 5978D 3?E>D95C 1
@?@E<1D9?>7B51D5BD81>D89BDI >9>5=9<<9?>@5?@<51>4D8?EC1>4C?6
<?31<175>395C39F9<<9D971D9?>1<?>59CE><9;5<ID?25D85=51>C2IG8938
B?G>3D?25495>359C3?=@5<<54
*85CE775CD9?>9CB59>6?B3542ID85
613D D81D =1>I 1@@5<<1>DC G5B5 @B9F1D5 39D9J5>C 1>4 =?CD DB91<3?EBDCQ
4539C9?>CG5B51669B=54
?G5F5B35BD19>381B13D5B9CD93C=1;59D=?B5<9;5<ID81D149C@ED5
9=@<931D9>7 B?G> 3D @B9>39@<5C G9<< 25 <9D971D54 1>4 1@@51<54
CD5B5?DI@931< 1@@51< 9>F?<F54 1> E>45B<I9>7 49C@ED5 3?>35B>9>7
5=@<?I=5>D?B<1>4EC52B?E78D2I1@B9F1D539D9J5>C55;9>7=1>41=EC
1>4 453<1B1D?BI 1>4 9>:E>3D9F5 B5<956 1719>CD 1 <?31< 1ED8?B9DI ?B
54E31D9?>1<2?4I
*851@@51<=?CD<9;5<IB19C54B?G>3DAE5CD9?>C
B571B49>7 D85 @B?@B95DI ?6 =55D9>7C 85<4 2I D85 B5C@?>45>D 1>4 D85
3?EBDCE2C5AE5>D<I1669B=54D854539C9?>?6D853?EBD25<?G
/7&45*("5*0/4"%&#:3"/%63*&4"/%&410/4&450)&.
CG5?2C5BF549>1>51B<95B1BD93<5
1<96?B>919C?>5?6?><IDG?
CD1D5C B5AE9B9>7 5138 3?E>DI D? 1@@?9>D 1 39F9< 7B1>4 :EBI G9D8 2B?14
9>F5CD971D?BI @?G5BC
1<96?B>91 <1G B5AE9B5C D81D N?>5 7B1>4 :EBI 9>
51383?E>DIC81<<25381B7541>4CG?B>D?9>F5CD971D5?B9>AE9B59>D?
3?E>DI=1DD5BC?639F9<3?>35B>
O>?D85BC53D9?>?6D85'5>1<
?45B5AE9B5C7B1>4:EB95CD?
&.+,!,&*('*,'&, '(*,!'&+'-&,+&*'*+'
, '!*+(*,%&,+'*-&,!'&+', '-&,1!&$-!&, '+
'(*,!'&+'-&,+&*'*+'&1+(!$$!+$,!.!+,*!,'*
$---J7J?IJ7,;I;7H9>;F7HJC;DJ #-:1,-5;!67<3);16515)31.6951)964
;6 - %7D
>JJFIMMMIJ7J?IJ79ECIJ7J?IJ?9I
H;I?:;DJ
FEFKB7J?ED
?D
97B?<EHD?7
$--:<79).78B;IS7D:799ECF7DO?D=J;NJ
$--)A;C :;B;O;;J7B )31.6951)F:1=139)5,<91-:)5,!91:6565,1
;165:
- ',
D
+ R1;IJ
-#(
/,?<
(5=9DC CE38 1C D85C5 @<135 7B1>4 :EB95C 9> 1 CDB?>7 @?C9D9?> D?
9>F5CD971D539D9J5>3?=@<19>DC?6B?G>3DF9?<1D9?>C?BD?C55;?ED
CE38F9?<1D9?>C4EB9>7G945BCD1DED?BI9>F5CD971D9?>C
B1>4:EB95C1B5
:E49391<2?495C1>4D859B@5B495=1<<?G1>35C1>45H@5>C5C1B5=5D
?ED?6@E2<936E>4C
&>D85?D85B81>4@B9F1D539D9J5>CQB?G>3D
CE9DC31BBID85B9C;D81DD85@<19>D966C=1I>?DB5359F5149C3B5D9?>1BI
1G1B4?6D859B<571<3?CDC1>41DG?BCD=ECD251BD859B?G>3?CDC1>4
D8?C5?6D859B@B5F19<9>7?@@?>5>DC
&EB CDE4I ?6 39F9< 1@@5<<1D5 <9D971D9?> B19C9>7 B?G> 3D 9CCE5C
3?F5B54 D85 5>D9B5 @5B9?4 D85 B?G> 3D 81C 255> 9> 6?B35
?>C945B1D9?>?67B1>4:EBI1>>E1<B5@?BDC6?BD85C1=5@5B9?4G?E<4
81F5B5AE9B54B5DB95F1<1>45H1=9>1D9?>?6@?D5>D91<<I=?B5D81>
1>>E1< B5@?BDC 6?B D85 696DI 5978D 3?E>D95C
F5> 3?>69>9>7 ?EB
5H1=9>1D9?>D?B5@?BDC6?BD85<1CDDG5>DII51BCG?E<481F59>F?<F54
?2D19>9>7 1>4 5H1=9>9>7 1C =1>I 1C
B5@?BDC
-5 D85B56?B5
3?=@B?=9C54 1>4 3?>69>54 ?EB 5H1=9>1D9?> ?6 7B1>4 :EBI
9>F5CD971D9?>C9=@<931D9>7B?G>3D9CCE5CD?D85@?D5>D91<<I1F19<12<5
1>>E1<B5@?BDC75>5B1D549>1D5> I51B69C31<@5B9?4
*85&,
@1>45=9381C81=@5B54D85G?B;?6=1>I7B1>4
:EB95C1>42ID85D9=5?6GB9D9>79>@B9<
=1>I814I5DD?@E2<9C8
D859BB5@?BDC6?BD8569C31<I51B
L
-5D85B56?B53?F5B54D85
69C31<I51BCL
D8B?E78
L
EB9>7D89C@5B9?41B?E>4
?>5 D89B4?6D851@@51<CG5CDE49549>)53D9?>G5B5851B4
-525<95F5
D89C D5> I51B C@1> ?6 7B1>4 :EBI B5@?BDC 3?BB5C@?>4C D? 1 CE669395>D<I
<1B75 @B?@?BD9?> ?6 D85 1@@51<C CDE4954 9> D89C BD93<5 6?B EC D? 4B1G
F1<943?>3<EC9?>C12?EDD85B5<1D9F59=@?BD1>35?6@B9F1D5B?G>3D
F9?<1D9?>C3?=@<19>DC1>4@E2<93:E49391<9>F5CD971D9?>C?6D85C1=5
,R
$--+ ;EFB;L-KF;H?EHJE<-7DJ7 7H87H7DJO + : 7B
T I4+ ;D7BE:;R5?D:?97J;I 7D:7IJ>;7B?<EHD?7FH;9;:;DJI>7L;BED=
H;9E=D?P;: J>;=H7D:@KHO?I7V@K:?9?7B8E:O WV7D?DIJHKC;DJ7B?JOE<J>;9EKHJIE<J>?I
IJ7J;WU9?J7J?EDIEC?JJ;:
! EH :;J7?BI E< =H7D: @KHO ;NF;D:?JKH; 7D: EJ>;H H;IEKH9;I I;; .
* " % - # $
https://scholarlycommons.law.cwsl.edu/cwlr/vol58/iss1/2 28
Oakes and Killingley: California's Brown Act: Clearing the Smoke-Filled Room
0
)
(
65F5BI3?E>DIQC7B1>4:EBI8143?=@<5D541>4@E2<9C8541>1>>E1<
B5@?BD5138I51B4EB9>7D85D5> I51B@5B9?46?BG8938G53?<<53D5441D1
D85B5G?E<4251D?D1<?6B5@?BDC
*857B1>4:EBI=1;5C9DC1>>E1<
B5@?BD D? D85 CE@5B9?B 3?EBD ?6 9DC 3?E>DI 2ED D85B5 9C >? 69B= BE<5
7?F5B>9>7D85B5D5>D9?>1>4@E2<931D9?>?6D85C5B5@?BDC?>3569<54
>
C?=531C5CD85<?31<CE@5B9?B3?EBDG9<<8?CD3?@95C?>9DCG52C9D5
$1>I3?E>D95CQ7B1>4:EB95C81F5D859B?G>G52C9D5C1>48?CD3?@95C?6
1>>E1< B5@?BDC D85B5
>?D85B C9D5 D85 +>9F5BC9DI ?6 1<96?B>91QC
979D1<(5C?EB35C6?B#1G1>4'E2<93'?<93I19=CD?81BF5CD3?@95C
*/5&3 "-*" ?6 7B1>4 :EBI B5@?BDC 1>4 8?CD 1 C51B3812<5 3?<<53D9?> ?6
D85=
> C?=5 31C5C 3?E>DI 7?F5B>=5>D ?B <?31< =5491 G52C9D5C
8?CD3?@95C?6D85C5B5@?BDC
*85B59C1<C?1B5AE9B5=5>DD81D13?@I
?6 5138 B5@?BD C8?E<4 25 C5>D D? D85 1<96?B>91 )D1D5 B389F5C
=19>D19>542ID85)53B5D1BI?6)D1D5
*85)D1D5B389F5C4?5C>?D
81F5 1 C51B3812<5 41D121C5 ?6 9DC 8?<49>7C
(1D85B C@539693 AE5B95C
12?ED4?3E=5>DC=ECD25C5>DD?D851B389F9CDC1>4963?@95C1B585<4
@1I=5>D9C>554546?BD854?3E=5>DQC@1@5B45<9F5BI
*? 3?<<53D B5@?BDC G5 C51B3854 1<< 696DI 5978D )E@5B9?B ?EBD
G52C9D5C1>44?G><?14541F19<12<5B5@?BDC
-85B5D85C5C9D5C494>?D
49C3<?C5B5@?BDCG5C51B38547B1>4:EBIG52C9D5C3?E>DI7?F5B>=5>D
C9D5C>5GC@1@5BC9>D5B>5DC51B385>79>5C1>4D85979D1<(5C?EB35C6?B
#1G1>4'E2<93'?<93IC9D59>D81D?B45B
-85>D8?C5C51B385C494>?D
$-- -/ 9)5,<9@#-769;:#-:63<;165: - +
# >JJFMMMFB79;H9EKHJI97=EL=;D;H7B
=H7D:@KHO
H;FEHJII>JCBB7IJL?I?J;:
*9J
$-- -/ 1=13 9)5, <9@ # # -!
>JJFI9?L?B=H7D:@KHOI<=ELEH=QJ;NJ.>;
?L?B
"H7D:
%KHO
?I =EL
;HDC;DJ
E<<?9;HI
:;F7HJC;DJI
EH
7=;D9?;I B7IJ L?I?J;: *9J
$-- %0- &51= 6. )3 1/1; #-: .69 )5, !<* !63F@ *). ).
>JJFI9:C9EDJ;DJ:CE9B9EH=:?=?J7B9EBB;9J?EDF
9EBBI;7H9>EH:;HJ?
JB;7:7I9B7IJL?I?J;:*9J
$-- -/ )9156<5;@1=139)5,<9@15)3#-769;: # (
>JJFIMMMC7H?D9EKDJOEH=:;FJI=@H;FEHJI
7D:
H;IFEDI;I B7IJ L?I?J;: *9J
:;J7?B?D=9EKDJO>EIJ?D="%H;FEHJI15)3#-769;:)5,#-:765:-: (
# " %# >JJF=IC7BBKI"%!?D7B,;FEHJI?D:;N>JCB B7IJ L?I?J;: *9J
:;J7?B?D=C;:?79ECF7DO>EIJ?D="%H;FEHJI
+ R 81;IJ
C7?B <HEC ,;<;H;D9; H9>?L?IJ 7B?<EHD?7 -J7J; H9>?L;I JE %KB?7D
&?BB?D=B;O + HE<;IIEH E< '7M H;JW: ?HC?D=>7C ?JO /D?L;HI?JO -;FJ
/.ED<?B;M?J>J>;7KJ>EHI7D:J>;'7M,;L?;M*<<?9;
-#(
/,?<
B5F51< B5@?BDC G5 9>AE9B54 ?6 D85 1<96?B>91 )D1D5 B389F5C ?B =145
1<96?B>91 'E2<93 (53?B4 3D B5AE5CDC
-5 B53?F5B54 1>>E1< B5
@?BDC 6?B D85 CDE4I @5B9?4
?G5F5B G5 G5B5 E>12<5 D? ?2D19> D85
B5=19>9>75978D55>B5@?BDC6B?=<@9>5?<EC15<%?BD5<?B14?
)95BB1*581=11>4*B9>9DI3?E>D95C
)?=5D9=5CD8512C5>35?6B5
@?BDC 9C E>5H@<19>54 2ED G5 C@53E<1D5 D81D 9> ?D85B 31C5C 9D =1I 25
2531EC5D853?E>D95C8141C=1<<@?@E<1D9?>1>4D859BCE@5B9?B3?EBDG1C
E>12<5D?B53BE9D1AE?B1D5:EBI9>@1BD93E<1BI51BC
>?>53?E>DIQC
31C5 D85 :E475 49C381B754 1> 9>AE?B1D5 :EBI 1>4 4539454 D85B5 G1C
9>CE669395>DD9=5D?B53BE9D1>1<D5B>1D5:EBI1>41<<?G9DD?3?=@<5D59DC
9>AE9B95C
>1>?D85B3?E>DIQC31C51B389F543?@95C?6B5@?BDCG5B5
59D85B 9>1335CC92<5 ?B 3?=@B9C54 ?><I 1 3?F5B C855D 1>4 D12<5 ?6
3?>D5>DC
<<B5@?BDCB53?F5B54G5B59>@?BD12<54?3E=5>D6?B=1DN'O
69<5C
$?CD ?6 D85 4?3E=5>DC G5B5 =1389>5 C51B3812<5 1>4 814 255>
3?>F5BD549>D?'69<5C6B?=D5HD69<5C
?G5F5B9>C5F5B1<31C5CD85
'69<5G1C3?>CDBE3D546B?=9=175C?6D85?B979>1<4?3E=5>DC1>4
G1C >?D 49B53D<I C51B3812<5 5<53DB?>931<<I
-5 EC54 %9DB? 'B?
C?6DG1B5 1C ?EB ' 69<5 B5145B G8938 B5@?BD54 G85D85B 69<5C G5B5
>?> C51B3812<59=17569<5C
%9DB?'B?
?665B54D8538?935D?3?>F5BD
D85 >?> C51B3812<5 9=175 69<5C EC9>7 ?@D931< 381B13D5B B53?7>9D9?>
N&(O1>4C1F5D85=9>D?1C51B3812<5'6?B=1D
-55H1=9>54
5138 69<5 EC9>7 D85 C51B38 CDB9>7 NB?G> 3DO D? 69>4 9>F5CD971D9?>C
=5>D9?>9>7D85B?G>3D
$1>I9>F5CD971D9?>C5>4542IB5=9>49>7
.>;C?II?D=H;FEHJIM;H; BF?D;EKDJO<EH<?I97BO;7HI;D:?D=?D
7D:
EBKI7EKDJO<EHO;7H;D:?D=
;B
)EHJ;EKDJO<EHO;7H;D:?D=
BEH7:EEKDJO<EHO;7H;D:?D=
-?;HH7
EKDJO <EH O;7H ;D:?D=
.;>7C7 EKDJO <EH O;7H ;D:?D=
7D: .H?D?JO
EKDJO<EHO;7HI;D:?D=?D
7D:
BF?D; EKDJO >7: 7 FEFKB7J?ED ;IJ?C7J;: ?D
7I F;EFB;
GKEH7J; =H7D: @KHO MEKB: >7L; 9ECFH?I;: FHE878BO CEH; J>7D E< J>; ;DJ?H;
FEFKB7J?EDE<J>;9EKDJO;B?=?8B;<EH=H7D:@KHOI;HL?9;"<1+2)+;:3715-6<5;@
)31.6951) /- >JJFIMMM9;DIKI=ELGK?9A<79JI7BF?D;9EKDJO
https://scholarlycommons.law.cwsl.edu/cwlr/vol58/iss1/2 30
Oakes and Killingley: California's Brown Act: Clearing the Smoke-Filled Room
0
)
(
@B?C@53D9F5 B5C@?>45>DC ?6 D85 >554 D? 49C3ECC D859B B5C@?>C5C 9>
=55D9>7CD81DD85=C5<F5C3?>6?B=54D?B?G>3DB5AE9B5=5>DC
-5
97>?B54B5@?BDCG85B5D89CG1CD85?><IB?G>3DB565B5>35
*85 B5=19>9>7 69<5C 3?>D19>54 C?=5 CE2CD1>D9F5 49C3ECC9?> ?6
B?G>3D@B?F9C9?>C
)?=5D9=5C17B1>4:EBIG?E<4C9=@<I>?D59>
@1CC9>71@@B?F1<D81D12?4IG1C3?>4E3D9>79DC16619BC9>133?B41>35
G9D8 B?G> 3D B5AE9B5=5>DC
-5 49C3?E>D54 D85C5 9>F5CD971D9?>C
6B?= 6EBD85B CDE4I
> C?=5 31C5C G5 5H3<E454 1 7B1>4 :EBIQC
9>F5CD971D9?>2531EC5D85C9>7<5B?G>3D=5>D9?>G1C9>D853?>D5HD
?645C3B929>713D9?>CD81D3?E<4<579D9=1D5<I254?>59>C53B5D2EDD85
B?G>3DG1C>?DB19C541C1>9>F5CD971D?BI9CCE5
-5<??;546?B
9>F5CD971D9?>C G85B5 59D85B 1> 1<<5754 B?G> 3D F9?<1D9?> G1C D85
=19> 6?3EC ?6 D85 9>F5CD971D9?> ?B G85B5 CE2CD1>D91< B?G> 3D
F9?<1D9?>C 1B?C5 1C 3?<<1D5B1< 9CCE5C 9> D85 3?EBC5 ?6 9>F5CD971D9?>C ?6
?D85B =1DD5BC ?6 3?>35B>
*89C <56D EC G9D8 1 D?D1< ?6 C9HDI 69F5
9>F5CD971D9?>C6?B1>1<IC9C1C<9CD549>@@5>49HD?D89CBD93<5
&EB69BCD9>D5B5CDG1CD85945>D9DI?6D85C?EB35C?6D857B1>4:EB95CQ
9>F5CD971D9?>C
> *12<5 G5 1>1<IJ5 D85 C?EB35C D81D 9>C@9B54 D85
9>F5CD971D9?>CCDE4954
"
9D9J5>3?=@<19>DCD?7B1>4:EBI
)E1C@?>D59>AE9B95C2I7B1>4:EBI
&D85B
"#-&&"40/4'03*/7&45*("5*0/4
6/%&35",&/%63*/(<
$-- -/ # #
. " %# #
#
!,
$-- -/ # " %#
#
"%#!,
FF;D:?N J>; ?:;DJ?JO E< ?DL;IJ?=7J?EDI ?D ;79> 97J;=EHO 7D: J>;?H
9?J7J?EDI7H;ED<?B;M?J>J>;'7M,;L?;M*<<?9;
$:;DJ?JOE<?DL;IJ?=7J?EDI?D;79>97J;=EHO7D:J>;?H9?J7J?EDI7H;ED<?B;M?J>
J>;7KJ>EHI7D:J>;'7M,;L?;M*<<?9;
-#(
/,?<
KH?D= J>; IJK:O F;H?E: ;79> =H7D: @KHO ?DL;IJ?=7J;: J>H;; 9?J?P;D
FHECFJ;:HEMD9J9ECFB7?DJI&;HDEKDJOWIM;8I?J;>7I7=H7D:@KHO9ECFB7?DJ
FHE9;IIF7=;J>7J?D9BK:;I7B?DAJE7:EMDBE7:78B;+ !<EHC7D:?DIJHK9J?EDIED>EM
JEH;JKHD?J$J7BIE>7I7J;B;F>ED;>EJB?D;<EHIK8C?II?EDE<7DEDOCEKI9ECFB7?DJI
$-- 9)5, <9@ 6473)15; !96+-:: & #
>JJFIMMMA;HD9EKDJO9EC=EL;HDC;DJEJ>;H
7=;D9?;I=H7D:
@KHO=H7D:
@KHO
https://scholarlycommons.law.cwsl.edu/cwlr/vol58/iss1/2 32
Oakes and Killingley: California's Brown Act: Clearing the Smoke-Filled Room
0
)
(
"$
)@5391<9CDB93DC%?> 4E31D9?>1<
4E31D9?>)@5391<9CDB93DC
9D95C?B*?G>C
?E>D95C
#579C<1D9F52?495C75>5B1<<I
"#-&
%&/5*5:0'#0%*&45)&46#+&$50'
*/7&45*("5*0/4%63*/(<
D C8?E<4 25 >?D54 D81D 5138 31D57?BI 4?5C >?D 3?>D19> D85 C1=5
>E=25B?63?>CD9DE5>DCC?CDB93D3?=@1B9C?>C31>>?D254B1G>1CD?D85
B5<1D9F56B5AE5>3I?69>F5CD971D9?>C
?G5F5BC9>35D85B51B5<9;5<ID?
25 =1>I =?B5 >?> 54E31D9?>1< C@5391< 49CDB93DC D81> ?D85B C@5391<
49CDB93DC 9D 9C @B?212<5 D81D 1<<571D9?>C ?6 B?G> 3D F9?<1D9?>C 9>
?1B4C?64E31D9?>)38??<C1>4?<<5759CDB93DC1B5=?B56B5AE5>D
D81> 9> ?D85B 2?495C
D 9C E>3<51B G8I D89C C8?E<4 25 C? 2ED G5
8I@?D85C9J5D81D39D9J5>C81F513<?C5B1>4=?B5@5BC?>1<9>D5B5CD9>D85
7?F5B>1>35?6<?31<54E31D9?>1<2?495C
&EB @B9>39@1< 9>D5B5CD 9> D85 1>1<IC9C <1I 9> D85 6B5AE5>395C ?6
C@539693B?G>3DF9?<1D9?>C
$?CD9>F5CD971D9?>C9>F?<F54=?B5D81>
?>5 ;9>4 ?6 1<<5754 F9?<1D9?> 1<D8?E78 35BD19> F9?<1D9?>C G5B5
6B5AE5>D<I 1CC?391D54 G9D8 ?D85B F9?<1D9?>C
?B 5H1=@<5 1<<571D9?>C
D81D1<579C<1D9F52?4I814619<54D?@B?F9451=55D9>7175>41?B814
619<54D?CE669395>D<I45C3B925175>419D5=CG5B56B5AE5>D<I1CC?391D54
G9D81<<571D9?>CD81DD85C1=52?4I814619<54D?@B?F94545D19<C?6D85
B5<5F1>D=55D9>7QC41D51>4<?31D9?>
)9=9<1B<I1<<571D9?>CD81D12?4I
814 85<4 9>1@@B?@B91D5 3<?C54 =55D9>7C G5B5 1<C? 1CC?391D54 G9D8
1<<571D9?>C D81D D85 2?4I 814 3?>4E3D54 C5B91< ?B C53B5D =55D9>7C
*12<5C5DC?ED?EB69>49>7C9>45C35>49>7?B45B?66B5AE5>3I
$:;DJ?JOE<?DL;IJ?=7J?EDI?D;79>97J;=EHO7D:J>;?H9?J7J?EDI7H;ED<?B;M?J>
J>;7KJ>EHI7D:J>;'7M,;L?;M*<<?9;
$---/ #"%#
#
"%#!, S
-#(
/,?<
https://scholarlycommons.law.cwsl.edu/cwlr/vol58/iss1/2 34
Oakes and Killingley: California's Brown Act: Clearing the Smoke-Filled Room
0
)
(
-#(
/,?<
*85CD1DED?BIB5AE9B5=5>DD?3?==5>DD?D85@B5C949>7:E475?6D85
CE@5B9?B3?EBD9C9=@?BD1>D
*85613DD81DD85B5@<I9CD?1:E475B1D85B
D81>D?D857B1>4:EBI9C<9;5<ID?=1;5B5C@?>45>DCD1;569>49>7C1>4
B53?==5>41D9?>C C5B9?EC<I 1>4 79F5 D85= 1 3?>C945B54 B5@<I
?G5F5B D85 4EDI 9C >? =?B5 D81> D? N3?==5>DO 1>4 D85B5 9C >?
B5AE9B5=5>DD?13DE@?>1>I?6D8569>49>7C?BB53?==5>41D9?>C=145
2I 1 7B1>4 :EBI
(5C@?>C5C 6B?= 175>395C 1>4 ?669391<C <9;5 D85
7B1>4:EBIQC?B979>1<B5@?BD1B5C5>DD?D85@B5C949>7:E4751>43?@95C
1B56?BG1B454D?D85)D1D5B389F9CDD?25;5@DN9>@5B@5DE9DI
O
-5 G5B5 9>D5B5CD54 D? C55 8?G <?31< 175>395C 1>4 ?669391<C
B5C@?>454 D? 69>49>7C 1>4 B53?==5>41D9?>C =145 2I 7B1>4 :EB95C
*B13;9>74?G>D85C5B5C@?>C5CG1C>?D1C9=@<5D1C;
)5F5B1<7B1>4
:EB95C 3?=@<5D54 D859B 9>F5CD971D9?>C 51B<I 9> D85 69C31< I51B
*85C5
:EB95C 6B5AE5>D<I 6?BG1B454 D85 B5CE<DC ?6 D859B 9>F5CD971D9?> D? D85
16653D54 175>395C 1>4 ?669391<C 1>4 G5B5 12<5 D? 9>3?B@?B1D5 D859B
B5C@?>C5C9>D?D8569>1<B5@?BDC
&D85B:EB95C14?@D541@B13D935?6
6?B=9>7 1 B5F95G ?B 3?>D9>E9DI 3?==9DD55 D? 71D85B 1>4 @E2<9C8
B5C@?>C5C D? D85 69>49>7C 1>4 B53?==5>41D9?>C =145 2I D859B
@B54535CC?BC 1>4 3?==5>D E@?> D859B @5B359F54 145AE13I ?B
?D85BG9C5
> C?=5 31C5C 1 B5C@?>C5 @5B359F54 D? 25 9>145AE1D5
G?E<4@B?=@D16EBD85B6?<<?G E@9>F5CD971D9?>
*85C5CE2C5AE5>D
9>AE9B95C6?B=@1BD?6D85CE1C@?>D59>F5CD971D9?>CB565BB54D?9>*12<5
12?F5
>C?=531C5CB5C@?>C5C4?>?D1@@51B9>1>>E1<B5@?BDC
2ED1B58I@5BD5HD<9>;54?>?>5?B=?B5?6D85=1>IG52C9D5CD81D8?CD
3?@95C?6D85B5@?BDC
>1>E=25B?631C5C>?B5C@?>C5C3?E<4256?E>4
5F5>D8?E781>1>>E1<B5@?BDG9D869>49>7C?BB53?==5>41D9?>CG1C
6?E>4
-5 @B5C5>D ?EB 69>49>7C 25<?G 9> *12<5C
1>4
&EB
CE==1BI 9>5F9D12<I C9=@<9695C 1 3?=@<5H @93DEB5 1>4 3<1CC96I9>7
175>3I1>4?669391<B5C@?>C5C9>F?<F5CC?=5CE2:53D9F9DI
*851>1<IC5C
,
$--1,R 8
$-- -/ . # !
! # "% #
, ) # - * )
( -
$-- -/ " # " % #
" #
"% # , S
$-- -/ $ # " % # .
$
# "% # !,
$--:<79).78B;
https://scholarlycommons.law.cwsl.edu/cwlr/vol58/iss1/2 36
Oakes and Killingley: California's Brown Act: Clearing the Smoke-Filled Room
0
)
(
B5<1D5 ?><I D? B5C@?>C5C D? :EBI B?G> 3D B5<1D54 69>49>7C 1>4
B53?==5>41D9?>C
*12<5
1>1<IJ5C @?C9D9F5 B5C@?>C5 ?33EBB5>35C
*12<5
1>1<IJ5C >571D9F5 B5C@?>C5C 1>4 *12<5
1>1<IJ5C ?D85B
B5C@?>C5C
%?D5 D81D ?EB 1>1<IC5C B5<1D5 D? ?33EBB5>35C ?6 DI@5C ?6
B5C@?>C5CD?9>F5CD971D9?>C1>4>?DD?6B5AE5>3I
138B5C@?>C5DI@59C
3?E>D54 ?>35 9> 5138 9>F5CD971D9?> B571B4<5CC ?6 D85 >E=25B ?6
9>49F94E1<B5C@?>C5C?6D81D;9>4
33?B49>7<I?EB41D131>>?D25EC54
D?45D5B=9>5D8521<1>35?6B5C@?>C55
7
?F5BG85<=9>7<I@?C9D9F5?B
>571D9F5D?1>I@1BD93E<1B9>F5CD971D9?>
DD5=@D9>7CE381>1>1<IC9C
G?E<481F59>3B51C54?EBG?B;2I?B45BC?6=17>9DE45
-5 2571> 2I <??;9>7 1D G81D G5 3<1CC96954 1C 69F5 @?C9D9F5
B5C@?>C5C
"
7B55C
(53?==5>41D9?>9=@<5=5>D54
(53?==5>41D9?>>?DI5D9=@<5=5>D542EDG9<<25
-9<<DBID?9=@<5=5>D3?>D9>E5D?3?=@<I
5>95C2B51385C2ED81CG9<<1=5>4@B13D935C
"#-&04*5*7&3&410/4&450'*/%*/(40'
308/$57*0-"5*0/4<
*12<5
9>4931D5CD81DB5C@?>45>DC17B554G9D8C?=5?6D857B1>4
:EBIQC 69>49>7C ?B B53?==5>41D9?>C 9> >51B<I ?>5 AE1BD5B ?6
9>F5CD971D9?>C
>?F5B?>5 81<6?69>F5CD971D9?>CB5C@?>45>DCB5@?BD54
D81D D85I 814 9=@<5=5>D54 ?B G?E<4 9=@<5=5>D D85 :EBIQC
B53?==5>41D9?>C
>1C=1<<5B>E=25B?631C5CB5C@?>45>DCG5B5<5CC
@?C9D9F5
)?=5 G?E<4 ?><I 7? 1C 61B 1C D? C1I D85I G?E<4 NDBIO D?
9=@<5=5>DB53?==5>41D9?>C
&D85BC45>9542B51389>7D85B?G>3D
2ED >5F5BD85<5CC CD1D54 D85I 814 ?B G?E<4 9=@<5=5>D 1
B53?==5>41D9?>
$:;DJ?JOE<?DL;IJ?=7J?EDI?D;79>97J;=EHO7D:J>;?H9?J7J?EDI7H;ED<?B;M?J>
J>;7KJ>EHI7D:J>;'7M,;L?;M*<<?9;
-#(
/,?<
%5HDG5<??;541DG81DG5@5B359F541C>571D9F5B5C@?>C5CD?1
7B1>4:EBIQC69>49>7C?BB53?==5>41D9?>C
"
9C17B55
7B559>@1BD49C17B559>@1BD
5>95C2B51389>7B?G>3D
!EBIQC69>49>7C>?> C@539693?BE>CE2CD1>D91D54
-9<<>?D9=@<5=5>DB53?==5>41D9?>C1CE>:ECD96954
"#-&&("5*7&3&410/4&450'*/%*/(40'
308/$57*0-"5*0/4<
*85=?CD5HDB5=5>571D9F5B513D9?>31=56B?=D85#1CC5>?E>DI
?1B4 ?6 )E@5BF9C?BC D? 69>49>7C 1>4 B53?==5>41D9?>C 9> 1
9>F5CD971D9?>
*85B5C@53D6E<<I3?E3854<5DD5BD?D85@B5C949>7:E475
69BCD13;>?G<54754D857B1>4:EB?BCQ3?>DB92ED9?>1>4D81>;54D85=6?B
D859B C5BF935 1>4 3?>CDBE3D9F5 3B9D939C=
?G5F5B D85 ?1B4QC
B5C@?>C5AE93;<I45C35>4549>D?1C5B95C?6?2C5BF1D9?>C?>D857B1>4
:EBIQC=?D9F5C1>4@5B6?B=1>35
*85?1B4C5DD85D?>56?BG81DG1C
D?6?<<?G
'* ' -(*.!+'*+ !+ $+' ' , (*(,!'& & / '&,
$!./*$'&, ,+'%(*+'&+/ , *, 1%!,!,'*&',
*!., !*!&,*+,!&+*.!&+*&-*'*+*+-$,'+'%
0(*!&'*'&$!,/!, $'$'.*&%&, $+'&(* (+'*
!*&,*+'&++'%', (*+'&++$,'.*, 1*+,'+*.
$:;DJ?JOE<?DL;IJ?=7J?EDI?D;79>97J;=EHO7D:J>;?H9?J7J?EDI7H;ED<?B;M?J>
J>;7KJ>EHI7D:J>;'7M,;L?;M*<<?9;
$--' # ' # "% #
,
.>;'7II;D EKDJO E7H:E<-KF;HL?IEHIWH;IFEDI;?I<EKD:7CED=79EB
15' # ' # "% #
,
https://scholarlycommons.law.cwsl.edu/cwlr/vol58/iss1/2 38
Oakes and Killingley: California's Brown Act: Clearing the Smoke-Filled Room
0
)
(
*85 ?1B4 @B561354 9DC 45D19<54 B5C@?>C5C 2I G1B>9>7 G81D D?
5H@53D
6D5B C?=5 C@9B9D54 49CC5>DC 6B?= D85 :EBIQC 69>49>7C D85 ?1B4
G5>D?>D?3?>3<E45
'* +(!!$$1 +, '-, ,' + '/ , , , *& -*1 !+ &',
$/1+*! ,&,', !&#+'!+$+'%!+,# '*'.*,
'*
,*! ,' ('!&, '-, , , (&&, '& / ' '%+ !&.'$. !& ,
*('*,!&(*'++, !&,*!,1'*('*,!,+$&$$!&,'
) -+,!'&, *1,!&, *!!$!,1', / '$
-#(
/,?<
(53?==5>41D9?>CB5AE9B56EBD85B1>1<IC9C
%?B5C@?>C5B5AE9B54
<<571D9?>C>?DE@85<4
%?B5C@?>C56?E>4?B69<54
"#-&5)&3'*/%*/(4"/%3&410/4&450
"--&("5*0/40'308/$57*0-"5*0/4<
*85=?CDCDB9;9>7697EB59>*12<5
9CD85F5BI<?G@B?@?BD9?>?6
9>F5CD971D9?>CD81DB5CE<D549>3?>3<EC9?>CD81DD85B5814>?D255>1>I
B?G>3DF9?<1D9?>C
*81DCE775CDCD8B55D89>7C
9BCD39D9J5>C1B5>?D
12EC9>7D8539D9J5> 9>9D91D543?=@<19>DC@B?354EB52I=1;9>7=1<939?EC
?B 6B9F?<?EC 3?=@<19>DC 1719>CD 175>395C ?B ?669391<C
)53?>4
9>F5CD971D9?>CCD1BD54?>17B1>4:EBIQC?G>9>9D91D9F51B5>?DECE1<<I
9<< 6?E>454
*89B4 G5 =978D 9>65B D81D D85B5 9C ECE1<<I >? C=?;5
G9D8?ED 69B5 1>4 D81D =?CD 9>F5CD971D9?>C CDE4954 E>3?F5B C?=5
5F945>35?6B?G>3D>?> 3?=@<91>35
&-'0-*$*/("/%6#-*$8"3&/&44
*85B?G>3D9>?>56?B=?B1>?D85B81C255>1B?E>46?B3<?C5
D? C5F5>DI I51BC
D G?E<4 25 CEB@B9C9>7 96 1<96?B>91QC @E2<93 2?495C
1>4 39D9J5>C 814 >?D 45F5<?@54 1> 1G1B5>5CC ?6 D85 B?G> 3DQC
@B?F9C9?>C1>49DC9=@?C54B978DC1>4?2<971D9?>C6?BCE381>5HD5>454
@5B9?4
-5 3?>C945B54 D85 5HD5>D D? G8938 DG? C5@1B1D5 =5381>9C=C
=978D3?>DB92ED5D?9>6?B=1<B59>6?B35=5>D?6B?G>3D?2C5BF1>35
C5<6 @?<939>72I@E2<932?495C1>4@E2<931G1B5>5CC
&-'0-*$*/(#:6#-*$0%*&4
&>5 ?6 D85 9>D5B5CD9>7 1C@53DC ?6 D85 7B1>4 :EBI 9>F5CD971D9?>C 9C
D859B9>C978D9>D?8?G<?31<175>395CB513DD?2581F9?B1<381<<5>75C?B
B56?B= B53?==5>41D9?>C
-85> 1 7B1>4 :EBI =1;5C 69>49>7C ?B
B53?==5>41D9?>C D85 CE2:53D 175>3I ?B ?669391<C 1B5 B5AE9B54 D?
$:;DJ?JOE<?DL;IJ?=7J?EDI?D;79>97J;=EHO7D:J>;?H9?J7J?EDI7H;ED<?B;M?J>
J>;7KJ>EHI7D:J>;'7M,;L?;M*<<?9;
https://scholarlycommons.law.cwsl.edu/cwlr/vol58/iss1/2 40
Oakes and Killingley: California's Brown Act: Clearing the Smoke-Filled Room
0
)
(
B5C@?>4D?D85<?31<CE@5B9?B3?EBDQC@B5C949>7:E475
*81DB5AE9B5
=5>D 1<?>5 ECE1<<I 5>CEB5C 1 457B55 ?6 39F9<9DI 9> D85 B5C@?>C5C
B571B4<5CC ?6 8?G G5<< 3B9D939C=C G5B5 B5359F54
> *12<5
G5
C8?G54 D81D =?CD 175>395C 1>4 ?669391<C B5C@?>454 @?C9D9F5<I D? D85
:EB95CQ69>49>7C1>4B53?==5>41D9?>C
)E38B5C@?>C5C79F59>C978D
9>D?D85457B55D?G8938D85<?31<7?F5B>=5>D9>D5B>1<9J54D85B?G>
3D@B9>39@<5C
*85?331C9?>1<8?CD9<9DID?C3BED9>I1>43B9D939C=D81DG5
3?==5>D54E@?>CE775CDCD81D:EBI69>49>7C?6B?G>3DF9?<1D9?>C
=1I>?D1<G1IC251B5<912<59>4931D?B?69=@B?@B95DIM1D<51CD9>D85
5I5C?6D8?C53B9D939J54
%5F5BD85<5CCD85B5<1D9F5<IC=1<<>E=25B?69>F5CD971D9?>C?F5B1
D5> I51B@5B9?41>4D858978457B55?61335@D1>35?6B53?==5>41D9?>C
CE775CD@E2<932?495C1B5<1B75<I?2C5BF1>D?6D85B?G>3D1>41B5
G9<<9>7 D? 1=5>4 D859B 3?>4E3D 96 6?E>4 D? 25 >?> 3?=@<91>D
-5
1DDB92ED5D89C457B55?63?=@<91>35D?D85613D?6DB19>9>7>5G<I5<53D54
=5=25BC1>4?669391<C1B5B?ED9>5<I?665B54?B79F5>B?G>3DDB19>9>7
@B9?BD?D859B1CCE=9>7?66935
$1>I1B5@B?F9454G9D8B?G>3D
7E945C<9;5D8?C5@B5@1B542ID851<96?B>91#517E5?69D95C
-5
1<C?1DDB92ED5D89C457B55?63?=@<91>35D?F979<1>35?>D85@1BD?6<?31<
7?F5B>=5>D?669391<C@1BD93E<1B<ID85<571<?66935BC1>414F9C?BCG8?
5>CEB5 D81D B?G> 3D B5AE9B5=5>DC 253?=5 9>D5B>1<9J54 9> 175>3I
9>D5B>1<@B13D935C1>4@B?354EB5C
N#?31< 175>395CO 4569>54 9> D85 B?G> 3D 5HD5>4 D? =1>I
@E2<932?495C<?31D54G9D89>1<96?B>91QC696DI 5978D3?E>D95C
$1>I?6
D85C53?E>D95C81F56E<< D9=5<1GI5BC?>CD166CE381C3?E>DI3?E>C5<
1>4 39DI 1DD?B>5IC ?B 31> 31<< E@?> D85 <?31< 49CDB93D 1DD?B>5IC ?B
C@5391<9CD <1G ?66935C 6?B <571< 14F935
'E2<93 <1G @B13D935 9C 1 <571<
C@5391<DI 1>4 @B13D9D9?>5BC 1B5 5H@53D54 D? 81F5 ;>?G<5475 ?6 <571<
1B51C ?EDC945 D85 >?B=1< 3?=@5D5>395C ?6 ?B49>1BI @B9F1D5 1>4
3?B@?B1D5 3?E>C5<
'E2<93 <1G @B13D9D9?>5BC 5>CEB5 D81D D859B <?31<
+ R 91;IJ
$--:<79)-;9J?ED$$.78B;
$---/ . ' # - :<79)DEJ;
$-- $;);- ;01+: %9)1515/ #-8<19-4-5;: .69 6+)3 ..1+1)3: 9-8<-5;3@
:2-, "<-:;165: ": $ ' " W -;FJ
>JJFIMMM97
-#(
/,?<
175>395CQ=5=25BC4?>?D13DE<DB1F9B5C1>4D89C5HD5>4CD?14F9C9>7
D85=?6D859BB?G>3DB5C@?>C929<9D95C
*85 3?E>DI 3?E>C5<QC ?66935 9C 1 CD1DED?BI @?CD 1@@?9>D54 2I 1
3?E>DIQC2?1B4?6CE@5BF9C?BC
3?E>DI3?E>C5<>?B=1<<IC5BF5C1
6?EB I51BD5B= 1>4N49C381B75/C01<<D854ED95CF5CD542I<1G9>D85
49CDB93D 1DD?B>5I ?D85B D81> D8?C5 ?6 1 @E2<93 @B?C53ED?B
O *85
1<96?B>91 )D1D5 CC?391D9?> ?6 ?E>D95C @B?F945C 1> ?F5BF95G ?6 1
3?E>DI 3?E>C5<QC B5C@?>C929<9D95C
*85 CC?391D9?> >?D5C NC D85
<571<14F9C?BD?D85?1B4?6)E@5BF9C?BC?E>DI?E>C5<1DD5>4C9DC
=55D9>7C 2?D8 @E2<93 1>4 3<?C54 C5CC9?>C
O )9=9<1B 6E>3D9?>C 1B5
B53?==5>4546?B39DI1DD?B>5IC1@@?9>D542I39DI3?E>39<C
?E>DI 3?E>C5<C 81F5 D859B ?G> @B?65CC9?>1< 1CC?391D9?> D85
?E>DI ?E>C5<CQ CC?391D9?> ?6 1<96?B>91 G8938 85<@C D85= C81B5
5H@5BD9C5 1>4 ;>?G<5475 ?6 <?31< 7?F5B>=5>D <1G
*85B5 9C >?
3?BB5C@?>49>7 1CC?391D9?> 6?B 39DI 1DD?B>5IC 2ED B1D85B D859B
@B?65CC9?>1<9>D5B5CDC1B5C5BF542I145@1BD=5>DG9D89>D85#517E5?6
1<96?B>919D95C
*853?=@5D5>351>4F979<1>35?63?E>DI3?E>C5<C
1>4 39DI 1DD?B>5IC D? 5>CEB5 B?G> 3D 3?=@<91>35 2I D859B <?31<
175>395C 1>4 ?669391<C 9C 1DD5CD54 D? 2I D85 3?=@1B1D9F5 C31B39DI ?6
@B?C53ED9?>C39F9<<9D971D9?>1>47B1>4:EBI9>F5CD971D9?>C49C3ECC549>
D89CBD93<5
*85C51DD?B>5IC85<@5>CEB5D81DD85B5AE9B5=5>DC?6B?G>
3D CE2:53D =55D9>7C 1B5 3?BB53D<I ?2C5BF54
*89C B19C5C @E2<93
$--1,R
$--1,R
$--1,R
$-- 6<5;@ 6<5:-3 - W # >JJFIMMM9EKD
;F7HJC;DJI?JO
JJEHD;OI'?8H7HO
DDK7B
ED<;H;D9;
?JO
JJEHD;OI
.H79A
DDK7B
%;<<
&EB?D
%ED7J>7D
'EM;BB
.>;
, EB; DEJ?D= J>7J
9?JOC7D7=;HI;NF;9JJ>;9?JO7JJEHD;OJEH;L?;M7=;D:7IE<9?JO9EKD9?BC;;J?D=I
'-3+64- ;6 ;0- 6<5;@ 6<5:-3:F ::6+1);165 6. )31.6951)
) >JJFIMMM9E9ED;JEH=B7D:?D=F>FB7IJL?I?J;:%KD;
$-- 1;@ ;;695-@: '
>JJFIMMM97B9?J?;IEH=>EC;=;J
?DLEBL;:FHE<;II?ED7B
:;F7HJC;DJI9?JO
https://scholarlycommons.law.cwsl.edu/cwlr/vol58/iss1/2 42
Oakes and Killingley: California's Brown Act: Clearing the Smoke-Filled Room
0
)
(
1G1B5>5CC?6<?31<175>3I=55D9>7C1>4166?B4C39D9J5>C?@@?BDE>9D95C
D? ?2C5BF5 1>4 @1BD939@1D5 9> D85 3?>4E3D ?6 39F93 2EC9>5CC
?E>DI
3?E>C5<C 1>4 39DI 1DD?B>5IC 1<C? @B?F945 ?B 6139<9D1D5 B?G>
3D 1G1B5>5CC DB19>9>7 6?B =5=25BC 1>4 CD166 ?6 <?31< 7?F5B>=5>DC
3?F5B54 2I D85 B?G> 3D
*B19>9>7 9C @1BD93E<1B<I 9=@?BD1>D
2531EC5D85C5B91<3?==E>931D9?>C@B?8929D9?>=51>CD81D<?31<175>3I
=5=25BC =1I ?6D5> 13D G85B5 D859B 2581F9?B 31>>?D 25 ?2C5BF54 2I
D859B<571<14F9C5BC1>4D9=5<I14F93579F5>
D 9C >?D @?CC92<5 D? 5F1<E1D5 D85 @B539C5 C97>96931>35 ?6 D85 B?<5
@<1I54 2I 3?E>DI 3?E>C5<C 1>4 39DI 1DD?B>5IC 9> 5>CEB9>7 D81D <?31<
175>395C3?>4E3DD859B16619BC9>1=1>>5BD81D133?B4CG9D8B?G>3D
B5AE9B5=5>DC
?G5F5B9DG?E<4251C5B9?EC45B5<93D9?>?6D859B<571<
4ED95C96D85I619<54D?14F9C5D859B<?31<175>395C1>4D859B=5=25BC?6
G81DG1CB5AE9B54D?3?>4E3D2EC9>5CC<1G6E<<I
*85213;7B?E>414F935
1>47E941>35D81D3?E>DI3?E>C5<C1>439DI1DD?B>5IC@B?F94581C<9;5<I
5>CEB54D81D=?CD@E2<932EC9>5CC9C@B?@5B<I>?D93541>43?>4E3D54
&F5B =1>I I51BC D89C 81C 2B?E78D 12?ED 1 C9DE1D9?> G85B52I 65G
39D9J5>C3?>C39?EC<ID89>;12?EDD85?@5>3?>4E3D?6=55D9>7C2531EC5
9D9C>?G@1BD?6D853E<DEB1<1>4@?<9D931<<1>4C31@5?6D853?>4E3D?6
1<96?B>91QC @E2<93 16619BC
&@5> =55D9>7C 1B5 E>5H35@D9?>1< 2531EC5
D85I81F5253?=5D85>?B=
)?9D9C<9;5<ID81D39D9J5>C>?D935G85>D85
B?G> 3D B5AE9B5=5>DC 1B5 /05 1485B54 D? B1D85B D81> G85> <?31<
175>395C1B59>B?G>3D3?=@<91>35
063$&40'6#-*$8"3&/&44
>DE9D9F5<I9D=978D1@@51BD81D5H5B39C9>7B978DCE>45BD85B?G>
3D 3?E<4 25 B5<1D54 D? D85 5HD5>D ?6 @?<9D931< 1>4 39F93 5>7175=5>D
G9D89> 1<96?B>91
*85 @8B1C5 N@?<9D931< 1>4 39F93 5>7175=5>DO 9C
>52E<?EC 1>4 81C 1 F1B95DI ?6 49665B5>D =51>9>7C
?B D89C BD93<5QC
@EB@?C5CG514?@DD85=51>9>779F5>2I'B?65CC?BC$1BDI>1BB5DD1>4
$-- -/ +>?B +E=B;:?9> ( 7A7OB; ';?=> 96>5 +; %9)1515/ .69
,=1:69@ 6441;;-- -4*-9: $;).. 1)1:65: 2 #
>JJFIMMMOEBE9EKDJOEH=>EC;I>EMFK8B?I>;::E9KC;DJ
B7IJL?I?J;:*9J
$-- " W R 8 1;IJ
T C7@EH?JO E< J>;
C;C8;HIE<7B;=?IB7J?L;8E:OI>7BBDEJ EKJI?:;7C;;J?D=7KJ>EH?P;:8OJ>?I9>7FJ;H
KI; 7 I;H?;I E< 9ECCKD?97J?EDI E< 7DO A?D: :?H;9JBO EH J>HEK=> ?DJ;HC;:?7H?;I JE
:?I9KII :;B?8;H7J; EHJ7A;79J?EDED7DO?J;CE<8KI?D;IIJ>7J?IM?J>?DJ>;IK8@;9J
C7JJ;H@KH?I:?9J?EDE<J>;B;=?IB7J?L;8E:OU
-#(
/,?<
BE>1.1>9
?D8@B?65CC?BCEC54D85@8B1C51C5=2B139>7DG?49CD9>3D
3?>35@DC N@?<9D931< 5>7175=5>DO 45>?D9>7 ND85 5>7175=5>D ?6 1>
9>49F94E1<G9D8@?<9D931<9>CD9DED9?>C@B?35CC5C1>44539C9?> =1;9>7O
1>4 N39F93 5>7175=5>DO 45>?D9>7 ND85 5>7175=5>D ?6 1> 9>49F94E1<
G9D8 D85 9>D5B5CDC 7?1<C 3?>35B>C 1>4 3?==?> 7??4 ?6 1
3?==E>9DI
O
-5 =978D 5H@53D D81D D85 B?G> 3DQC @B?F9C9?>C G?E<4 25
9=@?BD1>D D? @?<9D931<<I 1>4 39F931<<I 5>71754 39D9J5>C
3?>F5>95>D
9>4931D?B ?6 2B?14 @?<9D931< 5>7175=5>D 9C 39D9J5> @1BD939@1D9?> 9> D85
5<53D9?> ?6 ?669391<C
)E38 1> 9>4931D?B 9C 51C9<I =51CEB54 6B?=
5<53D9?>B5DEB>C
$51CEB12<59>4931D?BC?639F935>7175=5>D1B5C31B35B
8?G5F5B697EB5C1B51F19<12<56?BF?<E>D1BIG?B;9>3?==E>9D95C
-5 =978D 8I@?D85C9J5 D81D CDB?>7 =51CEB5C ?6 @?<9D931< 1>4 39F93
5>7175=5>D 4)06-% 25 C97>96931>D 613D?BC 9> 5>CEB9>7 B?G> 3D
3?=@<91>35
?G5F5B5F945>35CE775CDCD81D@?<9D931<1>439F935>7175=5>D9>
1<96?B>919C<?G5B =944<5B1>;9>7G85>3?=@1B54G9D85>7175=5>D9>
?D85BCD1D5C
>1CDE4ID85'E2<93'?<93I >CD9DED5?61<96?B>91
B5@?BD54D81DF?D5BN/D0EB>?ED9>=E>939@1<5<53D9?>C1B?E>4D853?E>DBI
1F5B175C81<6D81D?6>1D9?>1<5<53D9?>C
1>4<?31<F?D5BDEB>?ED?6D5>
61<<C 25<?G ?>5 AE1BD5B ?6 D85 F?D9>7 175 @?@E<1D9?>
O
>534?D1<
5F945>35CE775CD54D81DF?D5BDEB>?ED9>1<96?B>91G1C5F5><?G5BD81>
9> D85 B5CD ?6 D85 3?E>DBI
*85 B5@?BD >?D54 D85 F5BI E>5F5>
49CDB92ED9?> ?6 F?D5BC 1>4 >?> F?D5BC 13B?CC D85 @?@E<1D9?> 6?B
5H1=@<5 1<96?B>91 B5C945>DC G8? F?D54 G5B5 <9;5<I D? 25
@B54?=9>1>D<I8978<I54E31D54G51<D8I?<41>4G89D5
9665B5>35C
G5B56?E>4D?25@1BD93E<1B<I<1B7513B?CC54E31D9?>1<<5F5<C
$?B5
( 7HJOD7HH;JJHKD737D? !631;1+)3)5,1=1+5/)/-4-5;%0-69-;1+)3
&5,-9:;)5,15/: =1,-5+- )5, !631+1-: 15 +
( #+ ( 7HJOD7HH;JJHKD737D?;:I
$-- -/ , ?9>7H:+:B;H%K:O"E==?D '0);6'--)5*@C1=1+
5/)/-4-5;D %.
$-- -/ .9-5,: )5, 1/031/0;: =-9=1-> )W #
- >JJFIMMMD7J?ED7BI;HL?9;=ELL9B7IJ7J;7B?<EHD?7 B7IJ L?I?J;: -;FJ
3 ' # (
. .
9?J7J?EDEC?JJ;:
,
,7J
,
https://scholarlycommons.law.cwsl.edu/cwlr/vol58/iss1/2 44
Oakes and Killingley: California's Brown Act: Clearing the Smoke-Filled Room
0
)
(
$-- ,<+);165)3 ;;)154-5; *@ $;);-
1 + ,
>JJFIMEHB:FEFKB7J?EDH;L?;M9ECIJ7J;
H7DA?D=I;:K97J?ED7B
7JJ7?DC;DJ
8O
IJ7J;
B7IJL?I?J;:-;FJ
07-J7J;:E<+>7HC79OL07?J?P;DIEDIKC;HEKD9?B $D9 /-
9?J?D=&B;?D:?;DIJL( 7D:;B
/- S
FF;D:?N J>; ?:;DJ?JO E< ?DL;IJ?=7J?EDI ?D ;79> 97J;=EHO 7D: J>;?H
9?J7J?EDI7H;ED<?B;M?J>J>;'7M,;L?;M*<<?9;
FF;D:?N J>; ?:;DJ?JO E< ?DL;IJ?=7J?EDI ?D ;79> 97J;=EHO 7D: J>;?H
9?J7J?EDI7H;ED<?B;M?J>J>;'7M,;L?;M*<<?9;
-#(
/,?<
)30/*$-&QC ?B979>1<
1BD93<5 C5B95C G1C D85 9>C@9B1D9?> 6?B D85
B?G>3DQC@1CC175
> ?EB >DB?4E3D9?> G5 D??; 9D 1C 1H9?=1D93 D81D <?31< 1<96?B>91
7?F5B>=5>D 9C @B5C5>D<I 3?>4E3D54 ?@5><I
ED G5 >?D54 D81D 5F5>
D8?E78 ?@5> =55D9>7 <1GC G5B5 5>13D54 @B9?B D? D85 B?G> 3DQC
@1CC175DB1>C@1B5>D7?F5B>=5>D814>?D1<G1IC255>D85>?B=
-5C5D
?ED D? 9>F5CD971D5 8?G D85 B?G> 3DQC B5AE9B5=5>DC 31=5 D? 25
5=254454 9> D85 3?>4E3D ?6 <?31< 1<96?B>91 @?<9D93C 1>4 D85
=5381>9C=C2IG8938D89CG1C13895F54
*85 =?CD 49B53D G1I D? 5>6?B35 CD1DED5C 9C D? 3B9=9>1<9J5 D859B
2B5138
-5 >?D54 D81D ?F5B>=5>D ?45 C53D9?> @?D5>D91<<I
3B9=9>1<9J5C D85 2581F9?B ?6 D8?C5 G8? 45@B9F5 D85 @E2<93 ?6
9>6?B=1D9?> D? G8938 D85I ;>5G D85 @E2<93 G5B5 5>D9D<54
-5 1<C?
?2C5BF54D81DD85B581F5255>>?;>?G>3?>F93D9?>C6?BD89C?665>C5
-5 31>>?D 651C92<I 5F1<E1D5 D85 45D5BB5>D 56653D ?6 D85 C53D9?>
*85
DB19>9>7B5AE9B5=5>DC@B5F9?EC<I=5>D9?>54G9<<5>CEB51G1B5>5CCD81D
CE38 1 @5>1< @B?F9C9?> 5H9CDC
*8EC D85 DB19>9>7 B5AE9B5=5>DC =1I
?@5B1D51C1>9>CD1>35?6D855H8?BD1D9?>ND?C@51;C?6D<I1>431BBI1297
CD93;
O
-5D85>3?>C945B54D855HD5>D?639F9<5>6?B35=5>DD8B?E7813D9?>C
D81D 9>F?;54 B?G> 3D B5AE9B5=5>DC
-5 C1G D81D =1>I 3<19=C 6?B
=1>41=EC 9>:E>3D9?>C ?B 453<1B1D?BI B5<956 B5CE<D54 9> 1@@51<C
-5
31>C1I6B?=D85>E=25B?6CE381@@51<C9>CD1>3549>@@5>49H
D81D
D85C53<19=C1B5>?DE>ECE1<
?G5F5BD85>?B=1<9DI?6D85C53<19=C
9C=?B59>4931D9F5?6B?G>3D;>?G<54751=?>71<96?B>91QC<571<
@B13D9D9?>5BCD81>9>4931D9F5?6CE38;>?G<54751=?>7@?<9D9391>C1>4
D85@E2<93
F5>9>31C5CG85B5B?G>3DF9?<1D9?>C1B5@B?F5>G5
31>>?DC1IG85D85B;>?G<5475?6D81DB5CE<D5F5>DE1<<I69<D5B54213;D?
D85=5=25BC?B?669391<CG8?G5B56?E>4B5C@?>C92<56?BD85F9?<1D9?>C
-5CEC@53DD81D14F5BC54539C9?>C1719>CD1<?31<175>3I1B5=?B5<9;5<I
$--# 7HH?I :<79)DEJ;
.>; :?JEHI E< D9O9BEF;:?7 H?J7DD?97 1/ $;1+2 !631+@ #
>JJFIMMM8H?J7DD?979EC;L;DJ?=
-J?9A
FEB?9O B7IJ L?I?J;: *9J
FF;D:?N J>; ?:;DJ?JO E< ?DL;IJ?=7J?EDI ?D ;79> 97J;=EHO 7D: J>;?H
9?J7J?EDI7H;ED<?B;M?J>J>;'7M,;L?;M*<<?9;
https://scholarlycommons.law.cwsl.edu/cwlr/vol58/iss1/2 46
Oakes and Killingley: California's Brown Act: Clearing the Smoke-Filled Room
0
)
(
D?B5CE<D9>25DD5BDB19>9>71>41G1B5>5CCG9D89>D85?B71>9J1D9?>D81>
1>ICE2CD1>D91<9>3B51C59>G945B@E2<931G1B5>5CC
*859>3945>35?67B1>4:EBI9>F5CD971D9?>C9>D?1<<5754B?G>3D
F9?<1D9?>C4?5CCE775CDD81DD85B59C1D<51CD1=9>9=1<457B55?6@E2<93
1G1B5>5CC 12?ED D85 G1I <?31< 7?F5B>=5>D C8?E<4 25 3?>4E3D9>7 9DC
4539C9?>=1;9>7
$?B5?F5BG531>9>65B6B?=D85>E=25B?6CE1C@?>D5
9>F5CD971D9?>C D81D 7B1>4 :EB?BC G?E<4 3?=5 1G1I G9D8 B?G> 3D
;>?G<5475
>)53D9?> G5CE775CD54D81DD85@E2<939>1<96?B>91
=1I81F5<9=9D541G1B5>5CC?6D85B?G>3D1>49DC@B?F9C9?>C
$?CD
?6D856?B=1<@?<939>7?6D85B?G>3DQC@B?F9C9?>C9C6?E>49>:E49391<
BE<9>7C 1>4 7B1>4 :EBI B53?==5>41D9?>C ?6D5> @B?=@D54 2I @B9F1D5
7B95F1>35C?B@E2<933?=@<19>DC
*89CCE775CDCG945B1G1B5>5CC1=?>7
1DD?B>5IC1>4165G=5=25BC?6D85@E2<93
?G5F5BG525<95F5D81D
D85=5381>9C=C2IG89389=@<5=5>D1D9?>1>4?2C5BF1>35?6D85B?G>
3DQC @B9>39@<5C 81F5 255> 13895F54 1B5 9>F9C92<5 D? D85 @E2<93 71J5
'E2<931G1B5>5CC9>D856?B=?6=5491B5@?BDC1CC5BD9?>?6<571<B978DC
9><9D971D9?>1>43?=@<19>DCD?7B1>4:EB95C5H9CDCM2ED>?DD?CE381>
5HD5>D1CD?CE775CDD81DD85I1B5D85=?CDC97>96931>D=5381>9C=C2I
G8938 B?G> 3D ?2C5BF1>35 81C 255> 13895F54
-5 =ECD <??;
5<C5G85B56?BD85=5381>9C=
*85E>CE>785B?5C?6B?G>3D3?=@<91>35G5CE775CD1B5=?CD
<9;5<ID?25D85@E2<93<1G1DD?B>5ICG8?C5BF51C9> 8?EC5?B3?>CE<D1>D
3?E>C5< D? 1<96?B>91QC 3?E>DI 1>4 39DI 3?E>39<C 1>4 <?31< 175>3I
2?1B4C
+><9;53?EBDC1>47B1>4:EB95CD81D14:E4931D51>49>F5CD971D5
16D5B D85 5F5>D 1 @E2<93 <1G 1DD?B>5IQC B?<5 9C @B?@8I<13D93
D 9C D85
B?ED9>5 G?B; ?6 D85C5 1DD?B>5IC D81D 5>CEB5C D81D D859B 3<95>DCM
1<96?B>91 3?E>D95C 39D95C 1>4 <?31< 175>395CM4? >?D 2B5138 D85
B?G>3D
D9C?6D5>?><IG85>D85I1DD5>4=55D9>7C1C14F9C?BCD?
D853819BD81DD859BG?B;253?=5C@E2<93<IF9C92<5
D9CD859BF979<1>35
D81D5>CEB5CD81DD85B?G>3D31>G?B;1C9DC6B1=5BC9>D5>454
*85 613D D81D <571< 381<<5>75C 1>4 7B1>4 :EBI B5@?BDC B5F51<
?331C9?>1<<1@C5C6B?=B?G>3D9451<CCE775CDCD81DD85B5=1ICD9<<
251C<978D81J59>D8519B
?G5F5BD85B5<1D9F59>6B5AE5>3I?6D85C5
<1@C5C9>1<1B751>4@?@E<?ECCD1D5CE381C1<96?B>9149C@5<CD85=ID8
D81D D85 3?>4E3D ?6 <?31< 7?F5B>=5>D 2EC9>5CC >?G D1;5C @<135 9> 1
C=?;5 69<<54B??=