Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Masters of Science Thesis in Geoinformatics TRITA-GIT EX 07-013 School of Architecture and the Built Environment Royal Institute of Technology (KTH) 100 44 Stockholm, Sweden October 2009
TRITA-GIT EX 07-013
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
Getting something done is an accomplishment but getting it done well is an achievement. I would like to take this opportunity to express my sincere and profound gratitude to the entire staff of the Department of Geodesy and Geoinformatics at Royal Institute of Technology for the training they have given me throughout the entire studies. Special thanks to Dr. Hans Hauska (Assoc. Prof.) and Dr. Yifang Ban (Prof.) for their able assistance, patience and constructive criticism without which the work wouldn't have been successful. I am indebted to the entire staff of Geomatic Engineering, KNUST, Kumasi, Ghana for giving me the basic training and knowledge which motivated me for further studies. I appreciate the help of Emmanuel Tetteh and Eric Kofi Forson, both at Centre for Remote Sensing and GIS, University of Ghana, Legon. I am also highly indebted to my mother for the financial, moral and spiritual support throughout my studies. I would like to express my appreciation to Alfred Awotwi, KTH for generating the regression equations (using PCI Geomatica) which were used in normalising the satellite images used in the analysis. Last but not least, I wish to express my sincere and profound gratitude to all my friends for their encouragement and support; especially Amos Atakorah Mensah, Alfred Awotwi, Daniel Dennis Konadu of
University of Oxford and Joseph Sakyiama Afari of University of Westminster, UK. Finally, my deepest appreciation goes to the Almighty God for his continuous benevolence, sustenance of life, provision of wisdom, guidelines and knowledge throughout my studies.
ABSTRACT
There has been rapid change in the land use and land-cover types in Accra, Ghana in the past decade. The major change is the conversion of agriculture and forest lands into urban areas mostly in an un-planned manner making urban sprawl characterising the urban change dynamics. Land use change has been the reason for many social, economic and environmental problems in Accra, the capital city of Ghana over the past decade. This has engaged many researchers to find out possible measures to address and monitor this phenomenon. The ultimate objective of the research is to detect the land use/land-cover change of Accra from 1990 to 2000. Satellite images of Accra at two different periods, 25/12/1990 and 04/02/2000 were analysed. Two change detection techniques namely post classification comparison (indirect method) and image-to-image comparison change detection (direct method) were employed. The different change detection techniques were also evaluated. In the indirect method, both supervised and unsupervised classifications were performed. The supervised classification proves to be better than the unsupervised classification with accuracies of 85.62% and 89.1% for 1990 and 2000 classified images are respectively. Post-classification comparison change detection was conducted to reveal the areas that have changed over the decade. In this method, the from-to-change informational classes were available. The results revealed drastic growth of urban areas and reduction of agriculture and forest lands over the decade. Overall accuracy for both change/no-change trajectories was found to be 74.63% with kappa index of 0.698. Although the classes were being detected correctly as change/nochange area, some of the change trajectories do not necessarily match the corresponding real cases. The change detection procedure, however, was able to identify the areas of significant change. In the direct change detection method (image-to-image comparison), three different techniques were used and evaluated. The three methods are: normalised difference vegetation index, principal component analysis and TassCap transformation. The accuracies for detecting the changes in the urban area for the indirect methods used are 79.51%, 82.32% and 70.13% respectively with kappa indexes are 0.715, 0.753 and 0.698. The seasonal variation of the two satellite images used in the analysis affected the spectral resolution which subsequently affected the change detection process. Because of the variation of the temporal resolution and other environmental factors, the same land cover class can have different radiance values between the images. It can be concluded from the resulting statistics that the image-to-image change detection was more accurate that the post-classification comparison. The landcover/land-use classes classified are closed vegetation, open vegetation, dense herbaceous cover, grass, urban/bare areas and water bodies. The percentage change in the land cover classes was found to be 56.4%, 64.07%, 28.7%, 25.61%, 59.34% and 3.8% respectively. ii
TABLE OF CONTENT
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT .................................................................................................. iii ABSTRACT ......................................................................................................................... ii LIST OF TABLES ................................................................................................................ v LIST OF FIGURES ............................................................................................................ vi 1 INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................................. 1 1.1 Background .................................................................................................................. 1 1.2 Problem statement ........................................................................................................ 2 1.3 Objective ...................................................................................................................... 3 1.4 Outline of sections/organisation of the thesis ................................................................ 3 2 OVERVIEW OF URBAN SPRAWL, LAND COVER/LAND ........................................ 4 USE CHANGE AND CHANGE DETECTION .................................................................. 4 2.1 Definition of urban sprawl ............................................................................................ 4 2.2 Characteristics of sprawl .............................................................................................. 5 2.2.1. Single use zoning .................................................................................................. 5 2.2.2. Low - density land use .......................................................................................... 5 2.2.3 Car dependent communities ................................................................................... 5 2.2.4 Leap frog development .......................................................................................... 6 2.3 View of Urban sprawl ................................................................................................... 6 2.4 Causes of urban sprawl ................................................................................................. 6 2.5 Effects of sprawl .......................................................................................................... 7 2.6 Difference between land use and land cover ................................................................. 7 2.7 Usefulness of remote sensing technology in land use change studies ............................ 7 2.7.1 Definition of change detection ............................................................................... 8 2.7.2 Previous works on change detection worldwide ..................................................... 8 2.7.3 Overview of Change detection techniques ........................................................... 12 2.7.4 Previous work on change detection in Ghana ....................................................... 15 3 STUDY AREA AND DATA DESCRIPTION ................................................................. 18 3.1 Description of the study area ...................................................................................... 18 3.1.1 Boundary and Administrative Area ...................................................................... 18 3.1.2 Land use and land cover types ............................................................................. 19 3.2 Potential users and stakeholders ................................................................................. 20 3.3 Data Collected ............................................................................................................ 20 4 METHODOLOGY FOR LAND USE/LAND COVER CHANGE ................................ 23 DETECTION ..................................................................................................................... 23 4.1 Flow chart for the methods employed ......................................................................... 23 4.2 Pre-processing of the multiple date remotely sensed data:........................................... 24 4.3 Image classification .................................................................................................... 24 4.3.1 Unsupervised classification.................................................................................. 26 4.3.1.1 Clustering to detect the land use classes ........................................................ 27 4.3.1.2 Aggregation of clusters ................................................................................. 27 iii
4.3.2 Supervised Classification ..................................................................................... 28 4.3.2.1 Training Sites Development .......................................................................... 28 4.3.2.2 Signature Development ................................................................................. 29 4.3.2.3 Maximum Likelihood Classifier........................................................................ 29 4.3.2.4 Classification accuracy assessment ............................................................... 30 4.3.3 Post classification comparison change detection .................................................. 31 4.3.3.1 Detecting from-to change using Cross Classification and Tabulation........... 32 4.3.3.2 Detecting and Visualization of change in urban areas by colour coding ......... 32 4.3.3.3 Change Map ................................................................................................. 32 4.3.3.4 Change detection accuracy ............................................................................ 33 4.4 Image Differencing..................................................................................................... 33 4.4.1 Radiometric normalisation ................................................................................... 34 4.4.2 Image Enhancement ............................................................................................ 35 4.4.3 Image-to-image comparison (Differencing) ......................................................... 35 4.4.3.1 Normalised Difference Vegetation Index ....................................................... 35 4.4.3.2 Principal Component Analysis ...................................................................... 36 4.4.3.3 Tasselled Cap transformations (TASSCAP) ................................................... 37 5 RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS..................................................................................... 38 5.1 Unsupervised classification ........................................................................................ 38 5.1.1 Clustering ............................................................................................................ 38 5.1.2 Aggregation of clusters ........................................................................................ 38 5.2 Supervised classification ............................................................................................ 41 5.3 Classification accuracy assessment ............................................................................. 42 5.4 Post-classification comparison using supervised classification.................................... 48 5.4.1 Detecting and Visualization of from-to changes by colour coding ...................... 51 5.4.2 Change/Non-Change map .................................................................................... 53 5.4.3 Change detection accuracy assessment ................................................................ 53 5.5 Image Differencing.........................................................................................................56 5.5.1 Radiometric Normalisation .................................................................................. 57 5.5.2 Normalised Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI) ................................................ 59 5.5.2.1 Performance and limitations of NDVI ........................................................... 60 5.5.3 Principal Component Analysis (PCA) .................................................................. 62 5.5.4 TASSCAP transformations................................................................................... 64 5.6 Change areas accuracy assessment ............................................................................. 66 5.7 General discussions .................................................................................................... 67 5.7.1 Closed vegetation cover ....................................................................................... 69 5.7.2 Open vegetation cover ......................................................................................... 69 5.7.3 Dense Herbaceous cover ...................................................................................... 69 5.7.4 Grass/herb ........................................................................................................... 69 5.7.5 Built up/bare area ................................................................................................ 70 5.7.6 Water ................................................................................................................... 70 6 CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS ............................................................ 71 6.1 Conclusion ................................................................................................................. 71 6.2 Recommendation........................................................................................................ 72 REFERENCES .................................................................................................................. 73
iv
LIST OF TABLES
Table1: Number of pixel selected in each land-cover category for training ..........................29 Table 2: Correlation between the bands and principal components........................................37 Table 3: Error matrix for 1990 land use map of of Accra (Unsupervised)..43 Table 4: Error matrix for 2000 land use map of Accra (Unsupervised)......44 Table 5: Error matrix for 1990 land use map of Accra (Supervised). ....45 Table 6: Error matrix for 2000 land use map of Accra (Supervised)......46 Table 7: Producers and users accuracy in percentage for unsupervised Classification..........................................................................................................................47 Table 8: Producers and users accuracy in percentage for supervised classification................47 Table 9: Cross tabulation results for classified images, 1990 and 2000.................................49 Table 10: Percentage Change of the land-cover types from 1990 to 2000..51 Table11: Error matrix analysis of from-to-change................................................................55 Table 12: Producers and Users accuracies of the from-to change.........................................56 Table13: Change detection accuracies image-to-image comparison methods........................67
LIST OF FIGURES
Fig. 1: Map of Accra metropolis showing the surrounding districts ..................................19 Fig. 2: Satellite image of Accra, 1990.................................................................................21 Fig. 3: Satellite image of Accra, 2000.................................................................22 Fig. 4: Flow chart for the methodology..............................................................................23 Fig. 5: clustering of 1990 image .......................................................................................38 Fig. 6: clustering of 2000 image..........................................................................................38 Fig.7: Land use map of Accra, 1990 from unsupervised classification...............................39 Fig.8. Land use map of Accra, 2000 from unsupervised classification...............................40 Fig.9: Land use map of Accra, 1990 from supervised classification...................................41 Fig.10: Land use map of Accra, 2000 from supervised classification.................................42 Fig.11. Cross classification image for transition from 1990 to 2000..................................48 Fig.12. Transformation of open vegetation-cover into urban areas ....................................50 Fig.13. Change in urban areas from 1990 to 2000..............................................................52 Fig 14: Change/Non-Change map.......................................................................................53 Fig15: Scatter plot for 1990 band2(y) and 2000 band2(x)..................................................57 Fig16: Scatter plot for 1990 band3(y) and 2000 band3(x)..................................................58 Fig17: Scatter plot for 1990 band4(y) and 2000 band4(x)..................................................58 Fig18: Normalised difference vegetation difference for 1990 image..................................59 Fig19: Normalised difference vegetation Index for 2000 image.........................................60 Fig.20: Change in vegetation/Non-change area...................................................................62 Fig. 21: Principal component transformation for 1990 image.............................................63 Fig. 22: Principal component transformation for 2000 image.............................................63 Fig. 23: Difference in the second Principal components.....................................................64 Fig. 24: Differencing in the brightness value between the two images...............................64 Fig.25: Difference in greenness value between the two images..........................................65 Fig.26: Differencing moistens (Change/non-change map from differencing moistens layers....................................................................................................................................66 Fig.27. General Comparison of Area occupy by Land cover categories in Accra...............68
vi
1 INTRODUCTION
1.1 Background
In recent times, many decision makers, government bodies and agencies, urban planners, environmentalist etc., have expressed much concern about changes in land use/ land cover change dynamics. Expansion of urban areas is currently a ubiquitous phenomenon in developing countries of Africa. The region has the highest rate of urbanization in the world, though unaccompanied by economic growth (World Bank, 1995). Dramatic acceleration in urban growth and the associated ecological footprint (Rees, 1992) have serious implications for land-cover change on the one hand, and sustainability of urban and peri-urban livelihoods on the other. This phenomenon has engaged many researchers to investigate into the possible causes, its effect and pragmatic measures to alleviate its occurrence. There are many driving forces contributing to this phenomenon which could be social, economic or geographic in nature. In most cases, agriculture lands are being converted to residential, industrial and commercial lands. The major land cover change as described by many researchers is the expansion of the urban areas at the expense of vegetated areas. The expansion of the urban areas is described as a quality residential sprawl. Urban sprawl is sometimes used by some people to describe almost any growth but this is misleading cited by Ademola et.al (2003). This phenomenon is usually associated with the idea of unsuitable development. It depends on numerous simultaneous processes which make it difficult to deal with. Its modelling appears then an interesting means to understand and to run simulations according to different scenarios of urban development for making planning decisions. These changes and their repercussions require careful consideration by local and regional land managers and policy makers in order to make informed decisions that effectively balance the positive aspects of development and its negative impacts in order to preserve environmental resources and increase socioeconomic welfare. In order to understand the expansion of the urban fringe, its causes, effects and measures to alleviate this pandemic, an interdisciplinary approach is needed. There is the need to understand the possible causes, its effect on the environment, the economic and social impacts as well. In order to simulate the land cover change dynamics, the following should be considered: (i) Classification of the land-cover categories (ii) Quantification of the dynamics of the land-cover classes
1
(iii) Detection of the change These are associated to a spatio-temporal database using a grid to store the needed information within the GIS environment and the available technology. Land cover change is a dynamical temporal process which can be simulated and modelled. Some models established with remote sensing technologies have been achieved by combining time series and spatial analysis. With the advancement in technology, remote sensing and Geographic Information System (GIS) prove to be important tools in addressing land cover change dynamics phenomenon. The use of digital change detection is becoming increasingly popular as means of studying changes in the landscape.
1.3 Objective
The objective of this research is the detection of the land use/cover change in Accra. Some of the sub objectives are: Classification of the land cover categories Quantification of the dynamics of the land cover classes Detection of the change/no-change areas Evaluation of the different change detection methods and techniques
2 OVERVIEW OF URBAN SPRAWL, LAND COVER/LAND USE CHANGE AND CHANGE DETECTION
'Urban sprawl' has recently become a subject of popular debate and policy initiatives from governmental bodies and nonprofit organizations. With the advancement in technology, the phenomenon could be simulated and modelled so that policy formulation and implementation regarding urban planning could be made. This chapter will highlight on the above things discussed.
sometimes tends to be misleading. Urban sprawl could occur as a result of urban growth but the converse may not be necessarily true.
and bicycles for transportation. Most activities such as shopping, commuting to work, concerts etc. require the use of a car because of isolation of residential and commercial zones. In Accra the areas that are quite away from the city centres like Pokuase exhibit this type of sprawl character.
post classification change detection has been popular in detecting changes of urban fringe as it provides from- to information. Remote sensing application contributes a lot in studying urban sprawl phenomenon.
1 Urban change: Ramadan et al. (2005) assessed urban growth in the Shaoxing city using satellite remotely sensed data at three epoch time. The methodology used was based on post classification comparison. Results showed that the built-up area surrounding Shaoxing City has expanded at an annual average of 7 square kilometres. Analysis of the classified map showed that the physical growth of the urban area is upsetting the other land cover classes. Gupta et al. (2005) conducted a research to reveal urban/agriculture changes using multi-scale analysis in Dehradoon city in India. The authors of this paper have compared the results of five different techniques of band combination, subtraction, band division, principal component analysis and classification to find the changes in Dehradoon city, India. The research concluded that in the case of multi-resolution data, direct comparison of two multi-level image dates is restricted because various spectral and texture phenomena exist at different scales and resolutions. A method is required to allocate the unique value to each smoothed area (representing one class)
8
resulting from segmentation. Selection of the method depends on the number of classes, the spectral variability of the classes (urban has noisy appearance and complex nature), and the situation of the study area. Yuan et al. (1998) conducted a land cover change detection pilot study of the Washington D.C. area. Seventy-five change-detection techniques and variations were systematically tested and evaluated using both visual and statistical methods The initial results suggest that the automated scatter-gramcontrolled regression normalized image differencing and normalized difference vegetation index (NDVI) differencing outperform most other change-detection techniques. However, more testing of the data is needed in geographically diversified regions. Mas (1999) conducted six change detection procedures using Landsat Multi-Spectral Scanner (MSS) images for detecting areas of changes in the region of the TeA minos Lagoon, a coastal zone of the state of Campeche, Mexico. The change detection considered were image differencing, vegetative index differencing, selective principal component analysis (SPCA) direct date unsupervised classification, post classification change differencing and a combination of image enhancement and post classification. The research revealed that Post-classification comparison is the most accurate procedure for indicating the nature of the changes.
2. Forest or vegetation change: Allum and Dreisinger (1987) conducted a research on natural environment change detection in danube delta, based on HRV - spot images The spatio-temporal distribution of vegetation is an important component of the urban/suburban environment. Therefore correct estimation of vegetation cover in urban/suburban areas is fundamental in land use studies. Graetz et al. (1988) conducted research on a combined approach for estimating vegetation cover in urban/suburban environments from remotely sensed data in Haidian district, Beijing. In this study, the potential of extracting fractional vegetation cover (FVC) from remotely sensed data and ground measurements is explored. Based on the assumption that pixel has a mosaic structure, sub-pixel models for FVC estimation are first introduced. Then a combined approach of using different subpixel models for FVC estimation based on land cover classification is proposed. The experimental result, derived from a case study in Haidian district, Beijing, indicates that the accuracy of FVC estimation using the proposed method can be up to 80.7%. The results suggest that this method may be generally useful for FVC estimation in urban and suburban areas. Townshend and Justice (1995) conducted research on spatial variability of images and the monitoring of changes in the Normalized Difference Vegetation Index using multi spectral scanner
9
images from seven contrasting areas. The images were analysed using scale variance analysis to determine the spatial frequencies present. Specifically images of the Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI) were analysed, which is sensitive to vegetation activity. Image arithmetic Analyses were performed on images for each of the two dates and change images derived by subtracting the NDVI values of the first images from those of the second date. The change images were characterized by higher spatial frequencies than the images of individual dates, but this was only marked for four of the seven areas. Contrary to initial expectations, knowledge of the spatial frequency content of the images from the two dates could not be used to infer the spatial frequencies present in the change images and hence the spatial resolutions needed for detecting change in the NDVI.
3. Forest mortality, defoliation and damage assessment: Royle and Lathrop (1997) demonstrated the viability of using change detection technique to monitor hemlock forest health in New Jersey using Landsat TM data. A prolonged drought in the western US has resulted in alarming levels of mortality in conifer forests within 1988 and 1991. Satellite remote sensing holds the potential for mapping and monitoring the effects of such environmental changes over large geographic areas in a timely manner cited by Macomber and Woodcock (1994). Results from the application of a forest canopy reflectance model using multi-temporal Landsat TM imagery and field measurements, indicated that conifer mortality can be effectively mapped and inventoried. The test area for this project was Lake Tahoe Basin Management Unit in the Sierra Nevada of California. The Landsat TM images are from the summers of 1988 and 1991. The Li-Strahler canopy model estimates several forest stand parameters, including tree size and canopy cover for each conifer stand, from reflectance values in satellite imagery. The difference in cover estimates between the dates forms the basis for stratifying stands into mortality classes, which are used as both themes in a map and the basis of the field sampling design. The results of this project are immediately useful for fire hazard management, by providing both estimates of the degree of overall mortality and maps showing its location. They also indicated that current remote sensing technology may be useful for monitoring the changes in vegetation that are expected to result from climate change. Forest canopy and volume change can be simulated by remote sensing technology. Collins and Woodcock 1994, mapped forest vegetation of Tahoe and Stanislaus National Forests using landsat TM imagery and a canopy reflectance model. Results of timber inventories in the forests indicate the vegetation maps form a useful basis for stratification.
10
4. Deforestation, regeneration and selective logging: Change detection can be used in deforestation, regeneration and selective logging. Wilson and Sader (2002) conducted a research on Detecting of forest harvest type using multiple dates of Landsat TM imagery in northern Maine. The RGB-NDMI change detection classification applied to Landsat TM imagery collected every 2-3 years appears to be a promising technique for monitoring forest harvesting and other disturbances that do not remove the entire over storey canopy. Guatemala's Maya Biosphere Reserve (MBR) has recently experienced high rates of deforestation corresponding to human migration and expansion of the agricultural frontier. Given the importance of land-cover and land-use change data in conservation planning, accurate and efficient techniques to detect forest change from multi-temporal satellite imagery were desired for implementation by local conservation organizations cited by Hayes and Sader (2001). Normalized difference vegetation index (NDVI) image differencing, principal component analysis, and RGB-NDVI change detection techniques were employed in the analysis of three satellite images of the biosphere reserve. The changes were visualised. This is a typical application of remote sensing technology in deforestation
5. Wetland change: Wetlands could be monitored using remote sensing technology. Previous study by Munyati (2000) is an example. Remote sensing change detection approach was used to asses change on a section of the Kafue Flats floodplain wetland system in southern Zambia, which is under the pressures of reduced regional rainfall and damming and water abstraction by man. Four temporal satellite images were classified and analyzed. The results indicated spatial reduction in area of dense green vegetation in upstream sections of the wetland.
6. Forest fire: Data from the Advanced Very High Resolution Radiometer (AVHRR) have been used for the detection of fires in various ecosystems throughout the world. In this study, the most commonly used methods have been applied to a time-series of 63 AVHRR day time images for the whole of West Africa for the 1991-1992 dry seasons by Kennedy et al., 1994. The West African region includes ecosystems ranging from dry Sahara grasslands to moist tropical forests. Furthermore, these ecosystems show considerable seasonal variability. Existing methods were found to be inadequate for fire detection for the whole region because of the spatial and temporal heterogeneity of the region's environments. A number of changes were made to the established methods and the new fire detection procedure was applied to the time-series. Geographical Information System and remote sensing technology illustrates how such data can improve our knowledge of fire activity at national
11
7. Landscape change: Landscape morphology can be simulated and monitored over a period of time. Peralta and Mather (2000) conducted a research on analysis of deforestation patterns in the extractive reserves of Acre, Amazonia from satellite imagery. Three indices of landscape structure were applied to classified satellite imagery to characterize the impact of social and economic processes on the development of the forest landscape. Lacunarity Index was used to measure landscape homogeneity, the Korcak Patchiness Index to measure the distribution of patches according to their size and the AreaPerimeter Fractal Exponent to measure change in the shape of cleared forest patches. The work reveal that the changing shape, size and spatial frequency of patches in the forest landscape showed that major changes in the forest landscape occurred between 1975 and 1989. Cushman and Wallin (2000) used Landsat satellite images to quantify the changes in the rates and patterns of the landscape in a forested area of central Sikhote-alin Mountains of the Russian Far East. Wild fire and timber harvesting were identified to be the major causative factor for the changing in rates and patterns of the landscape.
9. Other applications such as crop monitoring, shifting cultivation monitoring road segments and change in glacier mass balance
(ii) Multi-date composite image change detection: This change detection technique is when multiple dates of rectified remotely sensed data are placed in a single dataset for change analysis to extract change information. Thus, selected bands of two thematic mapper scene of the same region are placed in a single dataset. A traditional classification using the associated bands is performed. Unsupervised classification technique will result in the creation of change and no change clusters. These classes are then aggregated into informational classes by the analyst after carefully studies. The advantage of this change detection technique is that only a single classification is required. However, it is sometimes difficult in labelling the change classes and from-to change class information may not be available.
(iii) Image algebra change detection (band differencing or band rationing): The same band in two different images can be used in change detection either by rationing or differencing them if the images have previously been rectified to a common base map (Green et al., 1994). The subtraction results in positive and negative values in areas of radiance change. Zero values are areas that did not change within the periods. But normally these values are transformed into positive values by adding a constant. The merit of this change detection technique is that it is an efficient method of identifying pixels that have changed in brightness value between periods but it does not provide from-to change classes. It also requires careful selection of the change and no-change threshold which sometimes make it difficult for its usage.
(iv) Post-Classification comparison change detection: This method of change detection provides quantitative information. It is the most commonly used quantitative method of change detection (Jensen et al., 1993a). It involves rectification and classification of each temporal remotely sensed image. These two classified maps are then compared on a pixel by pixel basis using a change detection matrix. It provides from-to change information and there is no need for further classification. However, the accuracy of the change detection is dependent on the classification accuracy of the two classified images.
(v) Multi- date change detection using a binary mask applied to date 2: In this method, the base image which is referred to as date 1 at a time n. The date 2 image can either be an earlier image (n-1) or later image (n+1). Traditional classification of date 1 is performed. One of the bands from both dates of imagery is placed in a new dataset. The two- band dataset is then analysed using image
13
algebra like band ratio, image differencing and principal components to produce a new image file. The analyst normally selects a threshold value to identify areas of change and no change in the new image. The change image is then recoded into a binary mask to depict areas that have change over the periods. This method minimised change error of omission and commission and provides from-to change information as well. The procedure however is more complicated and time consuming.
(vi) Multi-date change detection using ancillary data source as date 1: In this method, an existing land cover data source is used to replace traditional remotely sensed imagery. This data is used as date 1 but it is recoded to be compatible with the classification scheme being used. The date 2 data is also classified and the two classified data are compared on a pixel-by-pixel basis as in post classification comparison change detection. Its advantage is the use of well-known trusted data source and possibility of minimising the error of omission and commission. Detailed information on from-to cover classes can be obtained and single classification is required. The disadvantage of this method is that it is dependent on the quality of the ancillary data.
(vii) Manual, on screen digitization of change: In this method, photographic dataset are scanned at high resolutions into digital image files. These datasets are then registered to a common base map and compared to identify change. When digitised high resolution aerial photography is displayed on a screen, it can easily be analysed using standard photo interpretation techniques such as size, shape, shadow and texture. The analyst then has to visually interpret both data using heads-up on screen digitising and compare the images to detect changes. The method however is not so accurate.
(viii) Spectral change vector analysis: In this method, two spectral variables are measured and plotted for the area both before and after change occurs. The vector describes the direction and magnitude of the change within the two periods. The total change magnitude per pixel is computed by determining the Euclidean distance between end points in an n- dimensional change space. Change vector analysis outputs two geometrically registered files, one containing the sector code and the other containing the scaled vector magnitudes. The change information is superimposed onto an image of the area with change pixels been colour coded based on their sector code. The change is detected if the threshold is exceeded.
(ix) Knowledgebased vision systems for detecting change is also becoming popular of late: Novel algorithm can be used to achieve automatic detection and positioning of changes for monitoring
14
systems in complex environments. The aim is to efficiently detect changes of unknown dimensions, shapes and velocity and to position them in a sequence of images. The practicality of the algorithm is simplified by the use of different decision rules in a multistage test for different purposes. These decision rules identify the changes and number of parts, as well as the position and its optimal pickup points for each individual part cited by Cheng et al. (2004). A lighting compensation method is embedded to maintain a constant lighting environment and therefore the error rate can be reduced. Experimental results on a variety of image sequences show that the proposed algorithm is effective and efficient, regardless of the irregularity and number of changes.
higher overall increase in woody biomass (10%), compared to an overall decrease of 9%, indicates a certain level of rainfall-induced resilience in the ecosystem. They recommends for further research into quantitatively evaluating the mechanisms enhancing vegetation recovery in dry land areas. The extent of the urbanized areas of Accra was assessed from Landsat-TM satellite images for the year 2002 and compared to similar information for the years 1985and 1991 by Yankson, Kofie and Jensen (2004). A texture-based classification method was applied. The results show that the
urbanization of the fringe areas of Accra is occurring at a pace that has increased from 10 km square per year for the period 1985-1991 to 25 km per year for the period 1991-2002. This development is subsequently discussed with focus on the unplanned and haphazard nature of the growth and the corresponding absence of inadequate infrastructure and service provision. Kizito (2007) examine the relationship between urbanization and flooding in Accra. As a result of the government of Ghanas implementation of the Structural Adjustment Program (SAP), massive expansion in the built-up area of Accra occurred. Beside the impact of the increased impervious surface due to urban growth, poor land tenure and land delivery system, poor garbage collection and disposal, as well as poor implementation of economic development programs, have been identified as contributors to flooding in Accra Richard Brand of the University of Rhode Island conducted a study of the spatial organization of residential areas in Accra in 1972. He argues that the city of Accra has expanded in a north-eastern direction due to the movement of the elites low-density housing developments. Brand sites this trend as beginning in the 1890s with Victoriaborg, and then extending north-eastward with the creation of the Ridge, then Cantonments, and then the Airport Residential Area. All of these neighbourhoods except for the Airport Residential Area were developed by the British colonial government as elite enclaves, with the Ridge and Cantonments being built to house the increased number of European residents who moved to Accra after World War II (and before Ghanaian independence). Growth in the north-eastern direction has been aided in recent years due to the main artery that runs through the area, Independence Avenue. Recent studies in Accra (Yankson 1997; Konadu-Agyemang 1998; Tipple et al. 1998 and Tipple 2000) focused on urban growth, infrastructure and housing. Konadu -Agyemang (1998) concluded that the rapid growth of Accras urban population has created a situation in which a wide gap exists between the needs for and the provision of housing and related infrastructure. Yankson (2000) assessed land cover change in Accra and tested the viability of Landsat Thematic mapper images for urban change detection. This study does not investigate and address the complexity of urban growth. Otto et al. (2006) quantifies the urban growth in the Accra metropolitan area and explores the causative mechanisms. All the previous researches contribute to understanding of the urban growth.
16
In this research, different types and techniques for land use and land-cover change detection of Accra were evaluated. In the direct change detection method, three different image-to-image change detection techniques were evaluated. The indirect change detection was conducted using both supervised and unsupervised classified maps.
17
Accra has a total land size of 200 square kilometres. Accra metropolis is bounded to west by Ga West, north by Ga East, east by Tema Municipal and to the south by the Gulf of Guinea as shown in the figure 1.
18
19
20
21
22
23
In order to detect areas that have changed as a result of the expansion of the urban fringe, the procedures as shown in the flow chart were followed. The first thing to consider is the processing of the remotely sensed data to extract change information. Basically, the main processes involve are pre-processing (geometric registration and radiometric correction), followed by image classification, change detection and finally assessing the statistical accuracies of the classification in change detection process.
be performed by application of varieties of methods which includes: (i) Algorithm based on parametric and non-parametric statistics that uses ratio and interval- scaled data and non-metric methods that can also incorporate nominal scale data (Duda et al. 2001), (ii) The use of supervised and unsupervised classification logic, (iii)The use of hard or soft set classification logic to create hard or fuzzy thematic output products, (iv) The use of object oriented logic and (v) Hybrid classification approaches which combines two or three methods In the parametric method approach of classification, such as unsupervised clustering and maximum likelihood, there is assumption that the remotely sensed data is normally distributed and knowledge about the forms of the underlying class density functions are known( Duda et al.,2001). Non parametric methods such as fuzzy classifier, neural networks and nearestneighbour classifiers are used for remotely sensed data that are not uniformly distributed and without the assumption that the underlying forms are known (Jensen ,2004; Liu et al., 2002). Non- metric methods such as ruled-based decisions tree classifiers can be used on both real value data such as reflectance values ranging from 0 to 100% and nominal scaled data (Jensen, 2004). Supervised classification requires the manual identification of known land cover/land use types within the imagery and then using statistical functions to determine the spectral signature of the identified feature. The spectral fingerprints of the identified features are then used to classify the rest of the image. In unsupervised classification, the user has to make decisions on which categories can be grouped together into a single land use category. Both supervised and unsupervised classifications were performed. The unsupervised classification has the following advantages: There is no need to have previous knowledge of the image in order to get a classified image. Hence, the classification procedure is faster as it does not utilize the training data as the basis for classification. The identification of classes of interest against reference data is often more easily carried out when the spatial distribution of spectrally similar pixels has been established in the image data. No extensive prior knowledge of the region required.
25
The opportunity for human error is minimised in this classification unlike supervised classification whereby mistakes in digitizing the training areas can affect the process. Image signatures are derived based on image statistics (Lillesand, 2004). By comparing to supervised classification, the decision functions for unsupervised classification is not biased by previous knowledge or estimates of class membership Unsupervised classification requires very few inputs into the classification processes. Unique classes are recognised as distinct units. In contrast to the a priori use of analyst-provided information in supervised classification; unsupervised classification is a segmentation of the data space in the absence of any information provided by any analyst. Analyst information is used only to attach information class (or ground cover type, or map) labels to the segments established by clustering. Clearly this is an advantage of the approach. In this classification process, natural groups of pixels based on their spectral properties are selected by the software. However, this process still requires user interaction once the classification has been performed. The advantages of the supervised classification are: It is more accurate than unsupervised because the analyst has the possibility to train the classes It provides informative classes unlike clustering Bias decision function can be created by the analyst Image signatures are derived based on the training areas which are true representative of the classes
Gonzalez., 1974; ERDAS, 1997) compares the radiometric value of each pixel with predefined number of cluster attractors, aggregat es pixels in clust ers and shift s t he cluster mean values in a way that the majority of the former aggregated pixels belongs to a cluster. The ISODATA algorithm has some further refinements by splitting and merging of clusters (Jensen, 1996). Clusters are merged if either the number of members (pixel) in a cluster is less than a certain threshold or if the centres of two clusters are closer than a certain threshold. Clusters are split into two different clusters if the cluster standard deviation exceeds a predefined value and the number of members (pixels) is twice the threshold for the minimum number of members. The ISODATA algorithm is similar to the k-means algorithm with the distinct difference that the ISODATA algorithm allows for different number of clusters while the k-means assumes that the number of clusters is known a priori. Performing an unsupervised classification is simpler than a supervised classification, because the signatures are automatically generated by the ISODATA algorithm.
27
each cover type for statistical characterization. The number of pixels selected for each landcover or land-use category in the training is shown in table 1 below.
Land Category
Closed veg. cover Open veg. cover Dense herb cover Grass/herb Urban/bare land Water bodies
The classifier assumes that the training statistics for each class have a normal or 'Gaussian' distribution. However many are not, radar statistics in particular. The classifier then uses the training statistics to compute a probability value of whether it belongs to a particular land cover category class. This allows for within-class spectral variance. Equal probabilities were assigned to each of the land-cover classes to weight the probability function. This classification technique usually provides the highest classification accuracies. Accordingly, it has a high computational requirement because of the large number of calculations needed to classify each pixel.
In confidence-building assessment accuracy assessment, visual examination of the map associated with the overall area frame is done by knowledgeable individuals to identify any gross errors. However, this method is not good for quantitative purposes. Statistical measurements however can quantify the errors using reference data. They are two sub categories: Model-based inference, and Design-based inference.
Model-based inference is concerned with estimating the error of remote sensing classification process (or model) that generated the map rather than estimating the accuracy. The designbased inference is based on statistical principles that infer the statistical characteristics of a finite population based on the sampling frame. Some common statistical measurements include producers error, consumers error, overall accuracy, and kappa coefficient of agreement (Jensen, 2004). In this research, the design based inference was used as a sample of the total population was used in determining the accuracy of the classification processes. Using the ortho-photos a reference data, sample pixels representing each of the land-cover categories were digitised and compare to the created thematic maps. The overall accuracy expresses the total accuracy of the whole classification process. It is defined as a fraction of
30
the total of the diagonal matrix and the total no of cells. However, it is express as a percentage. Pixels of known class which are incorrectly classified as other classes are known as error of omission. Pixels which are incorrectly classified as a given class when they should be some other known class are known as error of commission. When the correctly classified pixel in each class is divided by column totals, producers accuracy is obtained.
31
32
Change in grassland Change in Urban/ bare areas Change in water bodies The non-change areas are predominantly urban and water bodies respectively while the vegetations were transformed to urban areas.
1999; Song et al., 2001; Jensen, 2004). If the two images have almost identical radiometric characteristics, the subtraction results in positive and negative values in areas of radiance change and zero values are areas of no change (Jensen, 2004). The difference between two images is calculated by finding the difference between each pixel in each image, and generating an image based on the result. Radiometric normalisation is
necessary when the change detection is based on linear transformation of the data. But, if the change map is to be derived from classified images, or if the change detection is based on a multiple-date composite imagery the radiometric normalisation is unnecessary. Here the relative normalisation is used in image-to-image comparison. (Chen et al., 2005).
34
4.4.3.1 Normalised Difference Vegetation Index Assessing the type, extent, and condition of vegetation over a region is a primary goal of land use investigations. Researchers use data from Landsat and other environmental satellites to determine the number of acres of certain crop types in a region, locate vegetation that is heavily impacted by natural or man-made stresses such as pests, fire, disease, and pollution, and to delimit boundaries between such areas as wetlands or old growth forest. Such sets of
35
data, taken over time intervals and compared, can also help us understand how vegetation changes over time. Satellite data can be used to detect vegetative change from one growing season to the next, from year to year, or from decade to decade. These types of data help us better understand the ecology of our planet and will perhaps help us understand the impact of mankind on our natural biological cycles. A vegetative index is a value that is calculated (or derived) from sets of remotely-sensed data that is used to quantify the vegetative cover on the Earth's surface. Though many vegetative indices exist, the most widely used index is the Normalized Difference Vegetative Index (NDVI). The NDVI, like most other vegetative indices, is calculated as a ratio between measured reflectivity in the red and near infrared portions of the electromagnetic spectrum. These two spectral bands are chosen because they are most affected by the absorption of chlorophyll in leafy green vegetation and by the density of green vegetation on the surface. Also, in red and near-infrared bands, the contrast between vegetation and soil is at a maximum. These two spectral bands are chosen because they are most affected by the absorption of chlorophyll in leafy green vegetation and by the density of green vegetation on the surface. Also, in red and near-infrared bands, the contrast between vegetation and soil is at a maximum. The NDVI is a type of product known as a transformation, which is created by transforming raw image data into an entirely new image using mathematical formulas (or algorithms) to calculate the colour value of each pixel. This type of product is especially useful in multi-spectral remote sensing since transformations can be created that highlight relationships and differences in spectral intensity across multiple bands of the electromagnetic spectrum. In the research, NDVI were generated for the two images to compare the changes in the vegetation as a result of evolution of urban areas. The result for the NDVI analysis is discussed in the results and discussions chapter.
data. Both un-standardized and standardized principal components analysis are offered. In the standardized case, the correlation matrix is used for input rather than the usual variance/covariance matrix. Table 2: Correlation between the bands and principal components Component XS1 1 2 3 0.832 0.954 0.953 1990 XS2 -0.555 0.240 0.244 XS3 0.001 -0.181 0.180 XS1 0.869 0.981 0.932 2000 XS2 -0.493 0.112 0.342 XS3 0.049 -0.160 0.123
The first band is highly correlated to all the three components. The second component shows higher correlation to the visible spectra.
37
39
40
41
Producers Accuracy = (Number of pixels correctly classified / Reference total)* 100. It is a measure of how accurate a class can be classified in an image. Users Accuracy = (Number of pixels correctly classified / Classified total)* 100. It measures the confidence of a class in a classified image. Overall Accuracy = Total number of pixels correctly classified / (Total Reference or Total classified)* 100. It is a combination of producers and users accuracies. Tables7 and 8 represents the computed users and producers accuracies. Table 3: Error matrix for 1990 land use map of Accra (Unsupervised)
Land use Closed or cover veg. class cover Closed veg. Cover Open veg. Cover Dense herb. Cover Grass/ herb 158 Open veg. Cover 13 Dense herbaceo us cover 15 Grass/ herb 5 Urban areas 13 Water Total
204
161
21
12
205
26.67
39
253
18
331
23.56
15
120
19
165
27.27
Urban areas
35
27
386
463
16.63
Water
13
267
290
7.93
Total
177
259
337
135
461
289
1658
37.84
24.93
11.11
16.27
7.61
Columns represent the truth and rows represent mapped Kappa coefficient = 0.752
43
Table 4: Error matrix for 2000 land use map of Accra (Unsupervised) Land cover type Closed Veg. Cover Open Veg. Cover Dense herb. Cover Grass/ Herb Close veg. cover 176 Open veg. cover 12 Dense herb. Cover 13 Grass/ herb Urban/ bare areas 7 Water bodies Total Error of comm. (%)
19.89
211
220
14
15
260
18.18
24
311
35
383
23.15
67
85
26.87
10
15
21
283
11
343
21.20
280
299
6.79
Total
198
277
373
86
352
295
1581
20.58
16.62
22.09
19.60
5.08
Columns represent the truth and rows represent mapped. Kappa coefficient =0.723
44
Table 5: Error matrix for 1990 land use map of Accra (Supervised)
Land Closed use or veg. cover cover class Closed veg. cover Open veg. cover Dense herb. Cover Grass/ herb 149 Open veg. Cover Dense Grass/ herbaceo herb us cover Urban areas Water Total
13
173
185
13
218
17.84
12
255
17
11
304
19.22
96
114
18.75
Urban areas
12
15
234
11
275
17.52
Water Total
0 159
6 233
3 299
0 112
6 272
268 292
283 1367
5.60
25.95
17.25
14.29
16.24
8.96
Columns represent the truth and rows represent mapped Kappa coefficient = 0.773
45
Table 6: Error matrix for 2000 land use map of Accra (Supervised)
Land Closed use or veg. cover cover class Closed veg. Cover Open veg. Cover Dense herb. Cover Grass/ herb 73 Open veg. Cover Dense Grass/ herbaceo herb us cover Urban areas Water Total
82
189
13
217
14.81
17
203
23
246
21.18
85
102
20.00
Urban areas
13
13
268
307
14.55
Water Total
0 83
3 233
0 237
4 99
13 313
245 254
265 1219
7.55
23.28
14.35
14.14
14.38
3.54
Columns represent the truth and rows represent mapped Kappa coefficient = 0.752
46
Land Category
Use
Producer's Accuracy 1990 89.27 Producer's Accuracy 2000 88.89 User's 1990 77.6 Accuracy User's 2000 80.11 Accuracy
62.16
Overall accuracy, 1990= (81.12%) Overall accuracy, 2000= (84.57%) Table 8: Producers and users accuracy in percentage for supervised classification
Use
Producer's Accuracy 1990 93.29 74.05 82.75 85.71 83.76 91.040 Producer's Accuracy 2000 87.95 76.72 85.65 85.86 85.62 96.46 User's 1990 83.39 82.16 80.78 81.25 82.48 92.40 Accuracy User's 2000 87.67 85.19 78.82 80.00 85.45 92.45 Accuracy
It is possible to visually see the change of one cover category to the other within the two periods. In the process, it was revealed that most of the changes in the urban areas are resulted from transformation of open vegetation and dense herbaceous cover (49 %). Fig.12 demonstrates the evolution of urban areas from the above- mentioned land cover categories. The 36 classes from cross classification were re-classified into two classes by colour coding (1, 2). Class one (red), represents the transformation of open vegetation and dense herbaceous areas into urban areas (2-5 and 3-5) as shown in the legend. Class two is represented by black which is the combination of all other land cover transformations.
48
Table 9: Cross tabulation results for classified images, 1990 and 2000 (Column classification 1990 and Row classification 2000) Land class use Closed Open Dense Grass/ Urban areas Water Total
vegetation vegetation herbaceous herbs cover cover 109 (0.03%) 67806 (19.41%) 215232 (61.62%) 2083 (0.60%) 64038 (18.33%) 34 (0.01%) 349302 cover 399 (0.11%) 787 (0.21%) 262875 (70.03%) 13618 (3.63%) 97564 (25.99%) 119 (0.03%) 375362 4 (0.01%) 13 (0.03%) 133 (0.26%) 47304
40716
125510
Dense herb 3849 cover (4.12%) Grass and 1186 herbs (1.27%) Urban areas (1.47%) Water 81 (0.09%) Total 93405 1375
483108
64474
449244
(99.36%) (0.53%) 657 (0.23%) 281946 406194 (96.11%) 422647 1573992 407091
Overall kappa=0.718
49
From the cross tabulation table, it is possible to calculate the percentage of each landcover/land-use type that was transformed into the other. Each class is discussed in the general analysis. The percentage change of each land-cover/land-use category is shown in the table 10 below.
50
Table 10: Change of the land-cover/land-use types from 1990 to 2000 expressed in percentage (Area counted as number of cells)
LAND COVER CLASS Closed vegetation cover Open vegetation cover Dense herbaceous cover
AREA, 1990
AREA 2000
93405
40716
-52689
56.40
349302
125510
-223792
64.07
375362
483108
107746
28.70
Grass/herb 51330
64474
13144
25.61
449244
167298
59.34
407091
-15556
3.68
reflectance level of the same land cover category which may subsequently be mis-classified as a different land cover category.
In figure 13, the areas that did not change into any other land cover categories were colour coded to their respective cover classes with the same colours as in figures 9 and 10. As shown in the legend, the transformation from each cover class to the other is colour coded. The labels; closed vegetation cover, open vegetation, dense herbaceous cover, urban and water in the legend represent the no-change areas and the remaining labels are the transformations. By visual inspection of the colour codes, it is possible to see the change areas in any of the land
52
cover categories. The red colour was used to show the transformation of each cover class into urban areas.
classification map accuracies to have a prior knowledge of the expected change detection accuracy (Yuan et al., 1998). A more reliable and rigorous approach is to randomly sample areas classified as non-change and change and determining whether or not they were correctly classified (Fuller et al., 2003) Random areas representing change and non-change areas in the change map created were selected to perform the change detection accuracy. Randomly sample areas in the change/nonchange map were selected by making sure that they were distributed throughout the map for the change detection accuracy. Caution was taken to minimised choosing pixels on the boundaries of change area. Each sample point was compared to the reference data to confirm if the change had actually occurred. The error matrix obtained as shown in table 11 was used to compute the accuracies. The seasonal difference of the two satellite images used in the analysis influenced the change detection accuracy. This is because the seasonal variation may affect the reflectance level of the pixels which belongs to the same land cover type which may subsequently be mix-classified as a different land cover category. The error matrix for the change detection was used to compute for the overall change detection accuracy as shown in table 12.
54
No Change
Closed Veg.
Open Veg.
Dense Herb
Grass
Urban/b are
Water
Total
11422
24
557
736
13
613
26
13391
Closed Veg.
54
768
29
31
24
910
Open Veg.
320
106
1645
206
23
123
13
2436
Dense Herb.
578
89
184
2458
78
168
3555
Grass
54
21
11
43
459
31
619
Urban/b are
631
78
65
229
61
2891
16
3971
Water
42
12
26
1185
1268
13101 Total
1086
2494
3565
638
3876
1240
26150
Column represent: Test data, Row represent: Reference data The off- diagonal elements represent the pixels which were wrongly detected. The overall accuracy expresses the total accuracy of the whole change detection process. It is defined as a
55
fraction of the total of the diagonal matrix and the total no of cells. However, it is expressed as a percentage. When the correctly detected pixel in each class is divided by the column totals, producers accuracy is obtained. When the number of correctly detected pixel in each class is divided by the row total, the users accuracy is obtained. Producers Accuracy = (Number of pixels correctly detected / Reference total)* 100. It is a measure of how accurate a class can be classified in an image. Users Accuracy = (Number of pixels correctly detected / Classified total)* 100. It measures the confidence of a class in a classified image. Overall Accuracy = Total number of pixels correctly detected / (Total Reference)* 100. It is a combination of producers and users accuracies.
Producers Accuracy No Change Change Vegetation Change in Open Vegetation Change Cover Change in Grass/herb Change in Urban/bare land Change in Water 71.94 72.8 91.86 in Dense 65.96 in 78.99 Closed 70.72
67.53 69.11
herb. 68.92
56
57
58
The linear regression equations were used to normalise the dependent bands by using image calculator in idrisi32. The normalised bands were then converted to bytes before the combinations. The various image-to-image comparisons used in the research are: Normalised Difference Vegetation Index Differencing the second principal component of the separate images (PCA c2) Tasselled cap transformation differencing
59
data). Using the NDVI for quantitative assessments (as opposed to qualitative surveys as indicated above) raises a number of issues that may seriously limit the actual usefulness of this index if they are not properly addressed. Also, the NDVI has tended to be over-used (if not abused) in applications for which it was never designed. The following subsections review some of these issues as stated in Wikipedia, 2009.
Mathematically, the sum and the difference of the two spectral channels contain the same information as the original data, but the difference alone (or the normalized difference) carries only part of the initial information. Whether the missing information is relevant or valuable is for the user to judge, but it is important to understand that an NDVI product carries only a fraction of the information available in the original spectral reflectance data.
The reflectance measurements should be relative to the same area and be acquired simultaneously. This may not be easy to achieve with instruments that acquire different spectral channels through different cameras or focal planes. Mis-registration of the spectral images may lead to substantial errors and unusable results.
Also, the calculation of the NDVI value turns out to be sensitive to a number of perturbing factors including
Atmospheric effects: The actual composition of the atmosphere (in particular with respect to water vapor and aerosols) can significantly affect the measurements made in space. Hence, the latter may be misinterpreted if these effects are not properly taken into account (as is the case when the NDVI is calculated directly on the basis of raw measurements).
Soil effects: Soils tend to darken when wet, so that their reflectance is a direct function of water content. If the spectral response to moistening is not exactly the same in the two spectral bands, the NDVI of an area can appear to change as a result of soil moisture changes (precipitation or evaporation) and not because of vegetation changes.
The absolute difference of the two NDVI images represents the changes that have occurred in
61
the vegetation covers between the two periods as shown in figure 20. The higher the brightness value in the grey scale, the higher the change in the vegetation cover. The lower values are areas that did not change within the two periods. There is a clear indication that water cover and existing urban/bare areas did not change and such have zero or a very lower value. The brighter areas which represent change in vegetation are as a result of evolution of urban/bare areas. The NDVI differencing hence is vital in identifying changes in urban areas by investigating the changes in the vegetation cover.
62
Fig. 21: Principal component transformation for 1990 image The PCA transformation for the 2000 image was re-classed into urban areas and other areas using the reflectance values to show the extent of urban areas.
Finally, the two transformed images from PCA were differenced to show the changes that have occurred in the urban areas within the decade. The result is shown in the figure 23 below.
63
From the above image, the PCA has proven to be a good technique in identifying the new urban area that has evolved within the decade. The new urban area evolved is also an indication that there has been lost of vegetation within the two periods.
Fig. 24: Differencing in the brightness value between the two images
64
From the above image, the green areas represent areas of higher reflectance values after differencing the images. This is clear indication that there has been an increase in the reflectance values between the two images. The increase in the reflectance value resulted from the evolution of urban areas. The increase in urban area is clear indication that there has been decrease in vegetation. In this sense the brightness maps generated from TassCap transformation differencing can be used in studying urban growth.
The greenness layer created from TassCap represents vegetation. Differencing the greenness images for the two periods creates a new layer that represents change in vegetation. The negative value is an indication that there has been decrease in vegetation. The decrease in vegetation is as a result of formation of new urban areas.
65
Change in moisture content (dark blue represents change in moisture content whiles pink represents no change in moisture content. This implies, the change in moisture content is as a result of changes in the vegetation. Some of the dense herbaceous cover was transformed into urban areas. Some portion of the open vegetation cover was also transformed into dense herbaceous cover and grass. Because of seasonal variation in the data-set, the moisture content for a particular land-cover class can vary significantly for the two periods. This can subsequently affect the change detection process.
66
Table13: Change detection accuracies for the three methods Change detection method NDVI PCA TASSCAP Overall accuracy % 79.51 82.32 70.13 Overall kappa 0.715 0.753 0.698 Mislabelled change % 17.513 16.537 28.643 Missed change % 21.733 18.422 26.673
To achieve this, the various land-cover/use classes should be analysed. In the cross tabulation table, the total number of cells for each land cover and land use classes that have changed from 1990 to 2000 are shown with the highest change being class 5 (urban/bare areas) with the least change occurring in class 6 (water). From the tabulation table, the columns represent the old values and the rows represent the new values. From tables 9 and 10, the total number of cells that have changed within each land cover category can be expressed as a percentage
67
with the following values: Closed vegetation cover, 56.40 % Open vegetation cover, 64.07 % Dense herbaceous cover, 28.70 % Grasslands and herbs, 25.61 % Urban area, 59.34 % Water bodies, 3.68 % These values quantify the percentage change in each land cover category. The cross tabulation gives additional information about from-to which makes post classification change detection so unique. The third task is the detection of the urban expansion as described in the post classification change detection processes. Change map in figure 14 visualised the expansion process of the urban fringe. In order to find out the location or direction of the sprawl, visual inspection of the two classified images for 1990 and 2000 respectively as shown in figures 9 and 10. The change maps in figures 13 and 14 can be used to explain the direction of the change. It is clear that the sprawl is towards east direction (Tema municipality) which is the most industrious area in Ghana and Ghanas biggest harbour city. The two cities Accra and Tema are now encroaching into each other. This implies that the harbour and the industries around Tema may be the attracting force for most people to acquire a residence closer to this vicinity as result of many socio-economic reasons. The bar chart below shows the changes within the various land-cover classes which explain the trend of the changes.
5.7.4 Grass/herb
Grass: There has been slight increase in this land-cover type. The major change was transformation into urban areas (7.54%). There were some false changes as shown in the cross-tabulation table. The false changes are closed vegetation cover (0.01%), open vegetation
cover (0.03%), dense herbaceous cover (0.26%) and water bodies (0.23). This mixclassification represents the errors that are associated with the change detection process using post-classification technique.
5.7.6 Water
Water on the average seems to have quite similar area but there are some slight variations. The slight reduction of water bodies resulted from evolution of vegetations and urban/bare areas from water. There is the possibility of wetland been classify as water and so over the two decades the wet land might have become dry land. This land may have been used for urban purposes or may be exposed as a bare-land. There could be possibilities of rivers and streams diminishing in size as a result of degradation of the forested areas. Also, the seasonal variation of the acquisition of the satellite data could represent different precipitation of the water bodies. This means, one has to be very careful in predicting changes in water bodies. The trend of water within the two periods is shown in figure 27.
70
Two change detection approaches were selected for this purpose; image-to-image comparison and post-classification comparison. These two change detection categories used can be grouped as direct and indirect change detection. Three different direct change detection methods were chosen. These are Normalised Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI), Principal Component Analysis (PCA) and TassCap transformation differencing. All the selected methods (except the TassCap) were based on the fact that the urban features have high reflection in the visible range of the electromagnetic spectrum. In general, the image-to-image change detection methods showed good results in detecting new urban features, with overall accuracies higher than that of the Post classification comparison change detection. The satellite images were also classified to six land cover classes; Closed vegetation-cover, open vegetation cover, dense herbaceous- cover, grass/herb, urban/bare area and water bodies. The classification was performed combining both supervised and unsupervised classifiers. The final urban change map, from post-classification comparison (PCC), had an accuracy of 74.63%. The PCC performed much better detecting the non-changed areas, but missed more than 26% of the changed areas. For the image-to- image change maps the corresponding value was 21% for NDVI, 18% for PCA c2 and 27% for TassCap. This indicates that the image-toimage change maps detected the changes areas better, but that they also contained more noise than the PCC change map. In conclusion, the image-to-image change detection has almost the same accuracy level that the PCC, even in large scale testing. The post-classification analysis showed that the major land cover changes were between open vegetation and dense71
herbaceous cover and urban/bare areas .The closed vegetation areas had changed, but partially the changes were due to misclassification caused by the seasonal change between the dates. The urban expansion was anyway detected and the urban growth map showed that the new built-up areas are close to the existing built-up areas. The results demonstrate that the urban area has increased by about 59% within the decade which is an indication that there has been a drastic growth within the city of Accra as a result of accelerated urbanization and industrialization. Numeric values for the area occupied by the land cover types were not sufficiently enough to the beneficiaries of this research and such statistical charts were also displayed to show the general trends of the land use/ cover dynamics. In terms of computation time and complexness, PCC took significantly more time and had to be performed in several steps. The advantage with PCC is the resulting transition matrix that cannot be received from image-toimage change detection, but if the application is targeted on limited land cover changes the image-to-image change detection is faster.
6.2 Recommendation
Land use and land cover change have both favourable and unfavourable impacts. In order to get comprehensive, pragmatic and scientific measures to monitor this phenomenon, interdisciplinary approaches should be employed. Geographic Information System and Remote sensing technologies are versatile tools which cannot be ignored in monitoring land use and land cover change. However, the availability of these technologies is not just enough but there is the need for an accurate processing of remotely sensed data as any error introduced into the image processing procedure will propagate to the final analysis. It is recommended that different image processing techniques should be employed in order to compare the results and to detect mistakes in the analysis. For urban change detection testing, different combinations of indices and sensors could also be of interest. Improving the classification process is also interesting area of further investigation. The bare open fields caused false urban changes and these could be minimized by using more frequent data covering different growth seasons. If the spatial metrics and the classification results would be reliable, the next exciting step would be simulation of the land cover changes and future growth in the region. Here automata-based modelling could be tested.
72
REFERENCES
Ademola, K. Braimoh and Paul L.G. Vlek, 2004. Land cover change analysis in the Volta Basin Ghana. AMS online Journals, Volume 8, Issue 21, Page 1. Allum, J.A.E. and Dreisinger, R., 1987. Remote sensing of vegetation change near Incos Sudbury mining complexes, International Journal of Remote Sensing, 8, 399-416. A Public-Private Partnership Programme between Min. of Local Govt., Rural Dev. & Environment & Maks Publications & Media Services, 2006. Visited on 15/11/2008 from URL: http://www.ghanadistricts.com/region/?r=1&sa=25 Australian Government, Bureau of Rural Sciences, October 2006, National Scale Land Use Mapping Technical Specifications. Visited on 10/11/2008 from URL: http://adl.brs.gov.au/mapserv/landuse/nat_scale_tec.html Brand, Richard, 1972,Growth of Accra.Visited 02/10/2007 from http://www.macalester.edu/geography/courses/geog261/eskidmore/growthpattern.htm URL:
Bruegmann, Robert, 2006. Sprawl; A Compact History, P306. Visited on 14/09/2007 from URL: http://press.uchicago.edu/cgi-bin/hfs.cgi/00/165885.ctl. Centre for Land use education. Defining and Characteristics of sprawl, The Land Use Tracker, vol.2, issue 3, winter 2003. Visited on 15/09/2007 from URL: URL:http://www.uwsp.edu/cnr/landcenter/tracker/winter2003/sprawl.html. Cheng-Huei Yang and Pau-Choo, 2000, Knowledge-based Automatic Change Detection and Positioning System for Complex Heterogeneous Environments, Springer Netherlands,Volume 33,No 1. Collins, J.B., and Woodcock, C.E., 1994. Change detection using the Gramm-Schmidt transformation applied to mapping forest mortality. Remote Sensing of Environment, 50, 267279. Congalton, R. G., & Green, K. (1993). A practical look at the sources of confusion in error matrix generation. Photogrammetric Engineering and Remote Sensing, 59(5), 641644 Duda, R.O., Hart, P.E., and Stork, D.G., 2001. Pattern Classification, New York: John Wiley and Sons, 654p. Visited on 05/12/2007 from URL: http://www.eknigu.com/get/Cs_Computer%20science/CsIp_Image%20processing/Duda%20R .O.,%20Hart%20P.E.,%20Stork%20D.G.%20Pattern%20classification%20(2ed.,%20Wiley,% 202000)(ISBN%200471056693)(738s).pdf Edwards, D. And Wassmer, R.W., 2005. Causes of Urban Sprawl (Decentralisation) in the United States: Natural Evolution, Flight from Blight, and the Fiscalisation of LandUse. Visited on 15/11/2007 from URL: www.csus.edu/indiv/w/wassmer/WassmerEdwardsCausesSprawl.pdf.
73
Fuller, R. M., Smith, G. M., & Devereux, B. J. (2003). The characterisation and measurement of land cover change through remote sensing: Problems in operational applications? International Journal of Applied Earth Observation and Geoinformation, 4(3), 243253. Ghana Statistical Service (2000): Population and Housing Census: Special report on 20 largest localities/ Republic of Ghana.- Accra: Statistical Service, V 79. Graetz, R.D., Pech, R.P., and Davis, A.W., 1988. The assessment and monitoring of sparsely vegetated rangelands using calibrated Landsat data. International Journal of Remote Sensing, 8, 1201-1222. Green, K., Kempka, D., and Lackey, L., 1994. Using remote sensing to Detect and Monitor land-cover and land-use change. Photogrammetric Engineering and Remote Sensing, 60, 331 337. Grupta Anshu, 2005. Change Detection Using Various Image Processing Algorithms on Dehradoon City. Geospatial resource portal, conservation and monitoring. Visited on 01/12/2007 from URL: http://www.gisdevelopment.net/application/environment/conservation/maf06_14pf.htm. Hayes, D.J.,and Sader, S.A., 2001. Comparison of change detection techniques for monitoring tropical forest clearing and vegetation re-growth in a time series. Photogrammetric Engineering and Remote Sensing, 67, 10671075. Jensen, J. R., Cowen, D. J., Athause, J. D., Narumala, S., and Weattherbee , O.,1993. An evaluation of the Coastwatch change detection protocol in South Carolina. Photogrammetric Engineering and Remote Sensing, 59, 10391046. Johnson M.P, 2001. "Environmental impacts of urban sprawl: A survey of the literature and proposed research agenda" Environment and Planning A 33(4) 717735. Visited on 15/11/2008 from URL: http://www.envplan.com/abstract.cgi?id=a3327: Lu*D., P. Mausel, E. Brondozio and E. Moran, 2004. Change detection techniques; A comparison of change . International Journal of Remote sensing, Volume 25, Issue 12 , Pages 2365 2407. Lupo F.; Reginster I.; Lambin E. F., 2001. Monitoring land-cover changes in West Africa with SPOT Vegetation: impact of natural disasters in 1998-1999. International Journal of Remote Sensing, Volume 22, Issue 13 , September 2001 , pages 2633 2639. Mas J.F., 1999. Detection techniques, International Journal of Remote Sensing, Vol. 20, No.1, Pages 139-152. Mas, J.F., 1997. Monitoring land-cover changes in the Terminos Lagoon Region, Mexico: A comparison of change detection techniques. Proceedings of the IV International Conference on Remote Sensing for Marine and Coastal Environments, Orlando, FL, USA, Amsterdam National Aerospace Laboratory, Vol.1, Pages 159167. Macomber, S.A., and Woodcock, C.E., 1994. Mapping and monitoring conifer mortality using remote sensing in the Lake Tahoe Basin. Remote Sensing of Environment, 50, 255266.
74
Maldonado, F.D.; Dos Santos, J. R; De Carvalho V.C, 2002. Land use dynamics in the semiarid region of Brazil (Quixaba, PE): Characterization by principal component analysis (PCA). International Journal of Remote Sensing, Volume 23, Issue 23 December 2002, pages 5005 5013. Munyati, C., 2000. Wetland change detection on the Kafue Flats, Zambia, by classification of a multi-temporal remote sensing image dataset, International Journal of Remote Sensing, Volume 21, Pages 17871806. Opoku Paabi, 2007, Understanding land-use/cover change process for land and environmental resources use management policy in Ghana, Geo-Journal, Volume 68, No 4, April, 2007. Otto A. Emmanuel, Duncan J. Whyatt, and Uwem E.Ite, 2006. Quantifying Urban Growth in Accra Metropolitan Area (Ama), Ghana and Exploring Causal Mechanisms.Visited on 10/12/2007 from URL: http://www.fig.net/pub/accra/papers/ts10/ts10_03_otoo_etal.pdf Peralta, P., and Mather, P., 2000, An analysis of deforestation patterns in the extractive reserves of Acre, Amazonia from satellite imagery: A landscape ecological approach, International Journal of Remote Sensing, 21, 25552570. P.J. Kennedy, A.S. Belward, J.M. Gregoire; 1994, An improved approach to fire monitoring in West Africa using AVHRR data, International Journal of Remote Sensing, Volume 15, Issue 11 July 1994 , Pages 2235 2255. Price, K.P., Pyke, D. A., and Mendes, L., 1992. Shrub dieback in a semiarid ecosystem: The integration of remote sensing and GIS for detecting vegetation change. Photogrammetric Engineering and Remote Sensing, 58, 455463.
Ramadan et al. J.Zhejiang, 2005. Satellite remote sensing for urban growth assessment in Shaoxing City, Zhejiang Province, Journal of Zhejiang University Science ISSN 1009-3095. Visited 01/11/2007.
Rees W., 1992: Ecological footprints and appropriated carrying capacity: What urban economics leaves out. Environ. Urban., 4, (2), 121130.
Royle, D.D., and Lathrop, R.G., 1997. Monitoring hemlock forest health in New Jersey using Landsat TM data and change detection techniques. Forest Science, 42, 327335. Sam A. Cushman and David O. Wallin, 2000. Rates and patterns of landscape change in the Central Sikhote-alin Mountains, Russian Far East. Landscape Ecology, Springer Netherlands, Volume 15, No 7. Singh, A., 1989. Digital change detection techniques using remotely sensed data. International Journal of Remote Sensing, 10, 9891003. Sudhira H.S., T.V. Ramachandra and K.S. Jagadish, 2004. Urban sprawl: metrics, dynamics and modelling using GIS. International Journal of Applied Earth Observation and Geo-information, Volume 5, Issue 1, Pages 29-39. Tou, Julius T. and Rafael C. Gonzalez, 1974. Pattern Recognition Principles. Addison-Wesley Publishing Co. Visited on 08/10/2007 from URL: http://www.amazon.com/Solutions-Manual-PatternRecognition-Principles/dp/0201075881
75
Townshend, J.R.G., and Justice, C.O., 1995. Spatial variability of images and the monitoring of changes in the normalized difference vegetation index. International Journal of Remote Sensing, 16, 21872195. Wilson, E.H., and Sader, S.A., 2002, Detection of forest harvest type using multiple dates of Landsat TM imagery. Remote Sensing of Environment, 80, 385396. Wikipedia, 2007, Accra, Visited 10/08/2007 from URL:http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Accra,_Ghana. Wikipedia,2007,Accra.Visited10-08-2007 from URL:http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Urban_sprawl#Characteristics.
World Bank, 1995: World Development Report, 1995. Oxford University Press, Oxford, 251pp.
Yankson, P. (2000). Houses and Residential Neighbourhoods as Workplaces in Urban areas: The Case of Selected Low Income Residential Areas in Greater Accra Metropolitan Area (GAMA), Ghana. Singapore Journal of Tropical Geography, Vol.21 (2), pp. 200-214. Yankson W. K. Paul, Richard Y. Kofie and Lasse Moller-Jensen, 2004. Monitoring urban growth: Urbanization of the fringe areas of Accra. Visited 03-10-07 from. URL:http://www.geogr.ku.dk/lmj/rsal/docs/monitoring%20urban%20growth%201. Young, Anthony, Feb. 1994, Towards an international classification of land use, Consultancy report to UNEP/FAO, page 6. Visited on 11/11/2007 from URL:http://www.fao.org/ag/agl/agll/landuse/docs/young1994.doc Yuan, D., and Elvidge, C., 1998. NALC land cover change detection pilot study: Washington D.C. area experiments. Remote Sensing of Environment, 66,166-178.
76