Marine Survey Report for MV Fortune Bay

BOYD MARINE
CONSULTANTS
Wisma PMI – 6th Floor
Jl.Wijaya I No. 63, Kebayoran Baru
Jakarta Selatan, Indonesia - 12170
Tel : +62 21 2751 3355 (Hunting)
Fax : +62 21 2751 5876
Email: surveys@bmcindonesia.co.id
Date : 3rd January 2020
To : SPICA Services (Indonesia)
Y.ref : MSI/07/20/MA
From : BOYD Marine Consultants
O.ref : 277/20/BDP/RDW
Vessel Name : “FORTUNE BAY”
Kind of Survey : Pre-loading Supervision of Steel Cargo in Bulk
Location : Jetty (wharf) 3 Bahodopi Port, Sulawesi - Indonesia
Date Inspection : 29th December 2020 & 31st December 2020
Subject : MV FORTUNE BAY - Inquiary about Pre-Loading Survey at

BAHODOPI, Indonesia
FINAL REPORT
This is to report that the undersign Marine Surveyor of Boyd Marine Consultants did, at the
request of SPICA Services Indonesia on behalf of MITSUI SUMITOMO INSURANCE
COMPANY and their Members, ASIAN SHIPPING S.A, attend on board bulk carrier MV.
“FORTUNE BAY” (the “Member’s Vessel”) at jetty# 3 IMIP of Bahodopi Port, Morowali,
Central of Sulawesi – Indonesia on 29 th December 2020 for pre-loading and loading
supervision of steel billets and coils cargo as well as conducting tally survey in order to
protect Club/Member’s interests.
We would report our final findings as follows: -

1.0 GENERAL INFORMATION AND SEQUENCE OF EVENTS
1.1 Upon receiving your email instruction on 26 th December 2020 at 2106 LT, we
subsequently liaised with Mr. Ervin as local agent at Bahodopi who informed
the Member’s Vessel will arrive at Bahodopi anchorage on 28 th December at
0100 LT.
1.2 Subsequently, on the following day we dispatched from base for proceed to
Bahodopi port by flight on 28th December at 1000 LT and safely arrived at
Kendari airport at 1130 LT then continue headed to Bahodopi by land
transportation and safely arrived at 2000 LT.
1.3 On 29th December at 1200 LT, we liaised with Mr. Purnomo as foreman that
the Member’s Vessel will alongside at the jetty No. 3 on the same day at
2000 LT.
1.4 On the same day, at 1800 LT we re-liaised with Mr. Purnomo as foreman
that the Member’s Vessel will alongside on the following day 30 th December
at 0500 LT.
1.5 Subsequently, we proceeded to Bahodopi port on 30 th December at 0500 LT

and safely embarked at the Member’s Vessel at 0600 LT with safely secured
alongside at 0448 LT.
1.6 Upon arriving on board, we introduced the purpose of our attendance on

board to Chief Officer including collected some related documents. While the
loading steel coils and slabs operation was commenced on 30 th December
2020 at 0720 LT.
1.7 The cargo loading steel coils and slabs operation had fully completed on 31st
December 2020 at 0415 LT.
1.8 On 1st January 2021 at 0908LT, we received Documents Complete from Mr.
Ervin as local agent.
Page 2 of 27
2.0 VESSEL PARTICULLAR
The Vessel is Hongkong registry. The detailed particulars are as follows: -
Name of the ship : “FORTUNE BAY”
Call Sign : 3EUZ3
Flag : Panama
IMO No. : 9561904
Official No : 43233-11
LOA : 170.70 M
LBP : 163.5 M
Breadth (Mid) : 27.0 M
Depth (Mid) : 13.80 M
Net Tonnage : 10,380 Tons
Gross Tonnage : 17,986 Tons
Owner : Asian Shipping S.A
3.0 TIME LOG
On 30th December 2020
03.42 Pilot on Board
04.24 First Line Ashore
04.48 All Line Made fast
06.00 Surveyor Embarked
07.20 Commenced loading cargo hold No.1, 2, 3, & 4 by

Page 3 of 27
shore crane
11.10 – 11.30 Stopped CH No.1 Due to rain & Closed hatch cover
11.30 – 12.00 Break Time
12.00 Resumed loading CH. 2, 3 & 4 by shore crane and

open hatch cover No.1 for resumed loading
14.20 CH No. 1 Completed
14.50 Started loading CH No.5
18.30 – 19.00 Break time
19.00 Resumed loading
22.25 Completed Loading CH No.4
23.05 Completed Loading CH No.2
23.30 – 24.00 Break time
On 31st December 2020
00.01 Resumed loading CH No.3 & CH No.5 by shore crane
00.35 Completed loading CH No.3
04.15 Completed Loading CH 5
04.15 – 04.30 Lashing at CH No.5
04.35 CH No.5 Closed
04.40 Stevedores disembarked
05.00 Surveyor disembarked
Page 4 of 27
4.0 PRE-STOWAGE PLAN
Based on gathered information and refer to the loading plan and pre-stowage plan
available at time of our attendance, we noted as follows: -
HOLD 1 HOLD 2 HOLD 3 HOLD 4 HOLD 5 TOTAL
1,509 MT 3,160 MT 3,360 MT 3,576 MT 3,175 MT 14,780 MT
Steel Coils Steel Slabs Steel Slabs Steel Slabs Steel Coils
Total loading cargo steel coil into the holds on 31 st December 2020 at 0415 LT as
follows: -
Preload stowage plan : 14,780 MT
Total cargo load : 14,780 MT (Completed)
5.0 ATTENDING PARTIES
Capt. Paglinawan, Master of MV.” Fortune Bay” : Owners
Mr. MA Alexander, Chief Officer of MV. ”Fortune Bay” : Owners
Mr. Ridduwan, Surveyor of BOYD Marine Consultants : P&I Surveyor
Mr. Purnomo, PT. Mitra Morowali Perkasa : Foreman
Mr. Rian, PT. Mitra Morowali Perkasa : Foreman
6.0 LOADING SUPERVISION
The pre-shipment inspection at Shipper’s Warehouse had not been conducted since
not permitted by Shipper to conduct survey at their warehouse, instead of the pre-
shipment was carried out on the wharf due to the cargo only made available for
Page 5 of 27
inspection during loading and the inspection could only be conducted prior to the
cargo being transferred onto the ship’s holds and we noted as follows: -
6.1 Prior to commencement cargo loading, we had conducted inspection to the

condition of accessible area of each cargo hold nos. 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5 as well
as hatch covers as appropriate were operated hydraulic, hatch access,
ventilators, hatch coaming, ladders manhole covers and it’s closing
arrangement to ensure they are watertight for the carriage of cargo as
instructed and found to be in apparent “Fair Condition”.
6.2 The cargo loading operation was commenced on 30 th December 2020 at

0720 LT into the cargo holds using shore’s crane.
6.3 The cargo steel coils and steel slabs were transferred from warehouse by
means of truck transported to the ship side, and cargo of steel coils on the
truck was covered using tarpaulin during transferred while the cargo of steel
slabs was uncovered with tarpaulin.
6.4 The cargo of steel coils and steel slabs at ship side was lifted up from the
truck to ship holds using shore crane. And the cargo stacked in holds using
forklift and assist by labors.
6.5 The wooden boards in various size were placed between stacks of cargo and
tank top plate by dunnage, several wooden boards added as chocking which
placed vertically for protection between cargo and ship’s plate. And the
lashing / securing of cargo using steel band clamping which was carried out
by Stevedore.
Page 6 of 27
7.0 CARGO PARTICULARS
Details of cargo information which are based on our perusal of the documents
provided are as follows: -
7.1 Mate’s Receipt No : BHD201250-1
Shipper : PT. Indonesia Guang ching nickel and

Stainless Steel industry Gedung Wisma Mulia
Lt. 41 Suite 4101., Jl. Jend Gatot Subroto No.
42, Kelurahan Kuningan Barat, Kecamatan
Mampang Prapatan Kota Adm. Jakarta Selatan
12710, Indonesia.
Consignee : To the order of Akbank T.A.S Imes Ticari

Branch.
Notify Party : Saritas celik sanayi ve ticaret A.S Barbaros
Mah begonya sok No.3 Nidakule kat : 25

34746 atasehir Istanbul, Turkey.
Port of Loading : Bahodopi Port, Sulawesi - Indonesia
Port of Discharge : Evyap port, Turkey
Quantity : 24 Coils
Description of Goods : Hot Rolled Stainless coils
Weight Net/Gross : 509.220 MT / 510.525 MT

12710, Indonesia.
Consignee : To the order of Marcegaglia TR Plasnanmas

celik sanayi ve ticaret A.S
Page 7 of 27
Notify Party :Marcegaglia TR Paslanmaz celik sana velimese
Mahallesi hanedan sokak 00000 Ergenei

Tekirdag Turchia.
Port of Discharge : Ambarli Akcansa port, Turkey
Quantity : 6 Coils

Stainless-Steel industry Gedung Wisma Mulia
12710, Indonesia.

celik sanayi ve ticaret A.S.
Notify Party : Marcegaglia TR Paslanmaz celik sana

velimese

Tekirdag Turchia.
Quantity : 1 Coils
Description of Goods : ASTM 14307 No.1 Hot Rolled Stainless coils

Page 8 of 27
12710, Indonesia.
Consignee : Nikel Paslanmas selik sanayi ve ticaret

anonym sirketil emek mahallesi nato yolu CD
No: 319 sancaktepe / Istanbul - Turkey.
Notify Party : Nikel Paslanmas selik sanayi ve ticaret

Quantity : 46 Coils
Weight Net/Gross : 322.490 MT / 323.410 M

12710, Indonesia.
Consignee : Azim paslanmas celik mamullerisanayi ve

ticaret A.S.
Address : 100. Yil Bulvari1245 Sok.No.1-3-5-7

ostim/Ankara
Notify Party : Azim paslanmas celik mamullerisanayi ve

ticaret A.S
Address : 100. Yil Bulvari1245 Sok.No.1-3-5-

7 ostim/Ankara.

Page 9 of 27
Quantity : 6 Coils

12710, Indonesia.
Consignee : To the order of Yapi ve kredi Bankasi A.S.
Notify Party : Trinox Metal sanayi ve ticaret anonym sirketi,

Karamehmet MH Avrupaserbest bolgesi osman
sahin bulvari no.7 ergene tekirdag Turkey.
Port of Discharge : Ambarli port port, Turkey
Quantity : 18 Coils

12710, Indonesia.
Consignee : To the order of QNB finansbank A.S keyap

dudullu branch.

Page 10 of 27
Port of Discharge : Ambarli port, Turkey
Quantity : 49 Coils
Weight Net/Gross : 1,055.930 MT / 1,058.380 MT

12710, Indonesia.
Consignee : To the order of Akbank T.A.S Imes Ticari

Branch.

Quantity : 32 Coils

12710, Indonesia.
Consignee : To the order of Yapi ve kredi bankasi A.S.
Page 11 of 27
Quantity : 3 Coils
Shipper : PT. Indonesia Ruipu nickel and Chrome alloy

Gedung Wisma Mulia Lt. 41 Suite 4101., Jl.
Jend Gatot Subroto No. 42, Kelurahan
Kuningan Barat, Kecamatan Mampang
Prapatan Kota Adm. Jakarta Selatan 12710,
Indonesia.
Consignee :Nikel Paslanmas selik sanayi ve ticaret

Notify Party : Nikel Paslanmas selik sanayi ve ticaret

Quantity : 76 Coils
Shipper : PT. Indonesia Ruipu nickel andChrome alloy

Page 12 of 27
Indonesia.

celik sanayi ve ticaret A.S.
Notify Party : Marcegaglia TR Paslanmaz celik sana

velimese

Tekirdag Turchia.
Quantity : 23 Coils
Description of Goods : 1.4307 2B Cold Rolled Stainless coils
Shipper : PT. Indonesia Ruipu nickel andChrome alloy
Indonesia.
Consignee : To the order of Akbankk T.A.S Imes ticari

branch.
Notify Party : Saritas celik sanayi ve ticaret A.S barbarous

Mah Begonya Sok. No.3 Nidakulle Kat 25
34746 Atasehir Istanbul, Turkey.
Page 13 of 27
Quantity : 21 Coils
Description of Goods : Cold Rolled Stainless coils
Shipper : PT. Indonesia Ruipu nickel and Chrome Alloy
Indonesia.
Consignee : To the order of Yapi ve kredi bankasi A.S.

Quantity : 13 Coils
Description of Goods : Cold Rolled Stainless coils
Shipper : PT. Sulawesi Mining Investment Jalan

Bulevar gading barat, Blok LC 6/53 Kelapa
gading Jakarta, 14240, Indonesia.
Consignee : To Order.
Notify Party : Marcegaglia specialties Spa, Via Bresciani

16,46040 Gazoldo degli Ippolitti (MN) Italy.
Page 14 of 27
Port of Discharge : Colakoglu pier, Diliskelesi, Gebzet, Turkey
Quantity : 500 Pcs
Description of Goods : Stainless steel Slab
Weight Net/Gross : 10,096.760 MT / 10,096.760 MT
8.0 CARGO DAMAGE
The above shipments were carefully inspected by us prior to and during loading
operations and following damages were found during loading cargo operation of the
cargo steel coil with green packed found damage slightly scratched, crumpled and
torn at several place of the packed cargo before shipment, as follows: -
1.0
2.0
3.0
4.0
5.0
6.0
7.0
8.0
9.0
8.1 No. 1 Hold cargo of steel Coils with the green package, the marking number
are: N2012140150, N2012140130, N2012140112, N2012140113,
N2012140234, N2012140152, N2012140135, N2012010519, N2012140161,
N2011150669, N2011150725, N2012140155, N2012080740, N2012010520,
N2012140121, N2012080741, N2012140113, N2012140212, N2012140230,
Page 15 of 27
N2012140149, N2012140206, N2012140234, N2012080743, N2012080745,
N2012140232, N2012140229, N2012140124, N2012140227, N2012140131,
N2012140142, N2012140123, N2012140148, N2012140228, N2012140134,
N2012140115, N2012140231, N2012140132, N2012140144, N2012140245,
N2012140125, N2012140111, N2012140246.
8.2 No. 2 Hold cargo of steel Slabs found scratch and slightly rusty condition
before shipment.
before shipment.
before shipment.
8.5 No. 5 Hold cargo of black steel Coils, the marking number are:
N2012070222, N2012070237, QLZ20K04329A, QLZ20K04374B,
N2012070183, QLZ20K04368A, QLZ20K04372A, N2012070184,
N2012070244, QLZ20K04369A, QLZ20K04379A, QLZ20K04361A,
QLZ20K04381A, QLZ20K04356A, QLZ20Z10837A, QLZ20Z10837B,
QLZ20K04373A, QLZ20K04352A, QLZ20K04380A, QLZ20Z10838A,
QLZ20Z10838B, QLZ20K04370B, N2012070236, N2012070234,
QLZ20Z10911A, QLZ20Z11003B, QLZ20Z10840B, QLZ20Z10839B,
QLZ20Z10841A, QLZ20Z11003A, QLZ20Z10911B, QLZ20Z10840C,
QLZ20Z10841B, QLZ20Z10837B, QLZ20Z10837A, N2012140351,
N2012140362, N2012140347, N2012140348, N2012140349, N2012010412,
N2012010413, N2012010341, N2012010420, N2012010342, N2012011413,
N2012140360, N2012140364, , N2012140349, N2012140239,
N2012140361.
The cargo steel coil with yellow packed was found packages torn and
crumpled condition prior to and during loading operation :
Marks Nos :
Page 16 of 27
N2012150120A, N2011020445B, N2012140356B, N2007180443A,
N2012140343B, N2012140355A, N2007180460B, N2012140356A,
N2012010419, N2007180461A, N2007180460C.
9.0 PHOTOGRAPHS
Page 17 of 27
MV ”Fortune Bay” was berthed at Jetty No.3 of Bahodopi port (Morowali) –
Indonesia
MV ”Fortune Bay” was berthed at Jetty No.3 of Bahodopi port (Morowali) –

Indonesia
Page 18 of 27
The examination of hatch covers found no water
The rubber joint hatch covers found in sound condition
The manhole was found in sound condition
The cargo of steel coils on truck was covered during transferred
Page 19 of 27
The cargo of steel slabs on truck was covered during transferred
The cargo on truck during transferred using shore’s crane
The cargo stacked in hold using forklift
Page 20 of 27
The wooden dunnage and chocking were placed between cargo and ship’s
plate
Page 21 of 27
The packed cargo found damage slightly scratched
The cargo found dusty and dirty stained before shipment
Page 22 of 27
The packed cargo found damage crumpled
The packed cargo found damage torn
Page 23 of 27
The packed cargo found patch tape
The cargo found rusty stained before shipment
Page 24 of 27
Silver Nitrate test found negative reaction or uncontaminated with chlorides
at Steel slabs cargo
Page 25 of 27
Process lashing cargo using steel band & clamping and chocking
The Cargo condition once completed
10.0 SURVEYOR NOTES
10.0 The cargo steel coil and steel slabs was transferred directly from shipper
warehouse using truck trailer. During transferring from warehouse to wharf
the cargo was covered with tarpaulin, while the cargo of steel slabs was
uncovered with tarpaulin.
10.1 The silver nitrate test randomly on the cargo presented onboard for loading
especially to the cargo which had found to have sign/traces of rusty
Page 26 of 27
condition on the surface, however the result of test was found negative
reaction which indicated the cargo to be unexposed or uncontaminated with
chlorides.
10.2 The wooden boards in various size were placed between stacks of cargo and
tank plating as dunnage, several wooden boards added as chocking which
placed vertically for protection between cargo and ship’s plate.
10.3 Numerous of the cargo of steel coils with package has been found slightly
scratched, dirty, dusty, torn, crumpled on several places before shipment.
10.4 The cargo stacked in holds using forklift and assist by labors. And the
lashing / securing of cargo using steel band & clamping.
10.5 Throughout loading operation, the weather sometimes found in small rain
condition.
10.6 During small rain, the CH No.1 & 5 was in closed condition while CH 2, 3,
and 4 keep continued for loading progress.
10.7 Upon completion of cargo loading, we provided to Master and C/O with
written suggestion on clausing the Mate’s Receipt and or B/L. the suggestion
and cargo damage list was acknowledged and signed by Master.
(This report reflects our findings at the time and place of inspection only. This finding is confidential
report for the information only of the Company’s Solicitors prepared for the purpose of obtaining
professional advice in proceeding pending, threatened, or anticipated.)
BOYD MARINE CONSULTANTS,
RIDDUWAN ABDULLLAH
(Attending Surveyors)
Page 27 of 27

Marine Survey Report for MV Fortune Bay

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Marine Survey Report for MV Fortune Bay

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

BOYD MARINE

Date : 3rd January 2020

To : SPICA Services (Indonesia)

From : BOYD Marine Consultants

Vessel Name : “FORTUNE BAY”

Kind of Survey : Pre-loading Supervision of Steel Cargo in Bulk

Location : Jetty (wharf) 3 Bahodopi Port, Sulawesi - Indonesia

Date Inspection : 29th December 2020 & 31st December 2020

Subject : MV FORTUNE BAY - Inquiary about Pre-Loading Survey at

We would report our final findings as follows: -

1.5 Subsequently, we proceeded to Bahodopi port on 30 th December at 0500 LT

1.6 Upon arriving on board, we introduced the purpose of our attendance on

The Vessel is Hongkong registry. The detailed particulars are as follows: -

Name of the ship : “FORTUNE BAY”

Call Sign : 3EUZ3

IMO No. : 9561904

Breadth (Mid) : 27.0 M

Depth (Mid) : 13.80 M

Net Tonnage : 10,380 Tons

Gross Tonnage : 17,986 Tons

Owner : Asian Shipping S.A

3.0 TIME LOG

On 30th December 2020

03.42 Pilot on Board

04.24 First Line Ashore

04.48 All Line Made fast

06.00 Surveyor Embarked

07.20 Commenced loading cargo hold No.1, 2, 3, & 4 by

11.30 – 12.00 Break Time

12.00 Resumed loading CH. 2, 3 & 4 by shore crane and

14.20 CH No. 1 Completed

14.50 Started loading CH No.5

18.30 – 19.00 Break time

19.00 Resumed loading

22.25 Completed Loading CH No.4

23.05 Completed Loading CH No.2

23.30 – 24.00 Break time

On 31st December 2020

00.01 Resumed loading CH No.3 & CH No.5 by shore crane

00.35 Completed loading CH No.3

04.15 Completed Loading CH 5

04.15 – 04.30 Lashing at CH No.5

04.35 CH No.5 Closed

04.40 Stevedores disembarked

05.00 Surveyor disembarked

HOLD 1 HOLD 2 HOLD 3 HOLD 4 HOLD 5 TOTAL

1,509 MT 3,160 MT 3,360 MT 3,576 MT 3,175 MT 14,780 MT

Preload stowage plan : 14,780 MT

Total cargo load : 14,780 MT (Completed)

5.0 ATTENDING PARTIES

Capt. Paglinawan, Master of MV.” Fortune Bay” : Owners

Mr. MA Alexander, Chief Officer of MV. ”Fortune Bay” : Owners

Mr. Ridduwan, Surveyor of BOYD Marine Consultants : P&I Surveyor

Mr. Purnomo, PT. Mitra Morowali Perkasa : Foreman

Mr. Rian, PT. Mitra Morowali Perkasa : Foreman

6.0 LOADING SUPERVISION

6.1 Prior to commencement cargo loading, we had conducted inspection to the

6.2 The cargo loading operation was commenced on 30 th December 2020 at

7.1 Mate’s Receipt No : BHD201250-1

Shipper : PT. Indonesia Guang ching nickel and

Consignee : To the order of Akbank T.A.S Imes Ticari

Notify Party : Saritas celik sanayi ve ticaret A.S Barbaros

Mah begonya sok No.3 Nidakule kat : 25