You are on page 1of 12

EFFECTIVENESS OF CORE STRENGTHENING EXERCISES TO REDUCE

INCIDENCE OF SIDE STRAIN INJURY IN MEDIUM PACE BOWLERS

Omkar P.Padhye*, Subin Solomen**, Pravin Aaroon***

ABSTRACT
BACKGROUND: Sports injuries are injuries that happen when playing sports or exercising. Some are from
accidents. A side strain refers to a tear of the internal oblique the external oblique, or the Transversalis fascia
at the point where they attach to the four bottom rib. In cricket prevalence of side strain injury in bowlers is
21% in bowlers 5% and overall 9% of total injury in cricket. Management of side strain takes lengthy
procedure so players may lose game so prevention is better than cure. Study done by Tymothy et al. stated
that muscle strengthening program can reduce incidence of injury Hence in this study we have discussed
about preseason core muscle strengthening can reduce the chances of incidence of side strain injury in
medium pace bowlers. OBJECTIVES: 1) To calculate the pre-season risk of side strain injury in medium
pace bowlers.2) To measure the effectiveness of core strengthening muscles to reduce incidence of side strain
injury.3) To calculate changes in plank score measurement in medium pace bowlers before and after
intervention.4) To assess severity of side strain injury using electrotherapeutic measurements. METHODS:
Longitudinal study.30 male medium pace bowlers from Goregaon sports club, Prabodhan sports club,
Payyade sports club selected for study. Pre and post plank score taken. Follow up done by phone call.
INTERVENTION: Core muscle strengthening exercise will be given to players for 6 weeks. On first visit
core strengthening exercise will be taught to all players, they will be observed for 6 weeks and follow up
taken. RESULTS: In the study group descriptive statistical analysis is used, statistically it was found that
there were significant increase in Prone hold test score(Plank test score) (pre intervention plank score
2.00±0.00) , ( post intervention plank score 2.93±0.64), P value(< .0001). Mean incidence were calculated by
new injury per 1000 hrs. of participation time there were 3% of wrist injuries,10% ankle, 3% groin,14%

41
ISSN: 2277-1700 ● Website: http://srji.drkrishna.co.in ● URL Forwarded to: http://sites.google.com/site/scientificrji

hamstring 7% low back,3% shin splint, 13% shoulder,10% side strain and 37% no injuries.
INTERPRETATION & CONCLUSION: As compare to other common sports injuries like incidence of
Shoulder injury (33.33/1000hrs), incidence of Hamstring injury (33.33/1000hrs) incidence of side strain
injury (25.00/1000hrs) is less, so it proves that core muscle strengthening exercise is effective to reduce
incidence of side strain injury. Thus, Core muscle strengthening exercises can be given to medium pace
bowlers to reduce incidence of side strain injury.

KEYWORDS: Side strain, Prevalence of side strain injury, prone hold test, Sports injuries, Severity of side
strain.

INTRODUCTION
second highest seasonal incidence and fourth
Almost half of all injuries to adult cricketers
highest prevalence of all body areas5.
occur during formal play. One third of cricket
injuries to children occur during school hours A side strain refers to a tear of the
reflecting the popularity of cricket as a school internal oblique the external oblique,
sport, almost 20% of injuries occur during or the Transversalis fascia at the point
training or practice.1, 2 where they attach to the four bottom
rib6. All side strain injuries to bowlers
To prevent injuries in cricket, the Australian
described within the literature affect
cricket board SPOT program advocates the
the side opposite to the bowling arm,
screening of young bowlers for risk factors,
with all but one injury affecting
including postural stature, physical
internal oblique (IO) or external
preparation, avoidance of over bowling, and
oblique (EO)7. In cricket the bowlers
2
use of correct bowling techniques. There are
suffer the Side Strain7,8, on the non-
various different physical demands involved
bowling arm side as a result of a
in different types of cricket, which has meant
forcible contraction of the muscle on
the injury profile is slightly different between
that side while they are fully stretched
five day test matches, 3 day matches, one day
as the bowling arm is cocked for
matches, and twenty-20 matches. There are 5
bowling. It has been postulated that the
common cricket injuries hamstring strain, low
probable point of internal oblique
back pain, side strain, shoulder pain, and
rupture in side strain injuries in cricket
sprained ankle3. Side strain is fairly common
bowlers is the sudden vigorous motion
in cricket, where it typically occurs in
from assumed maximum eccentric
bowlers.4 Cricket injury surveillance research
contraction when the non-bowling arm
in Australian first class cricket has reported
is fully flexed and then suddenly
that side and abdominal strains account for the
extends or pulls through, allowing the

42
Scientific Research Journal of India ● Volume: 2, Issue: 4, Year: 2013

bowling shoulder to flex to bowl the more active rehabilitation can be


ball. started under the supervision of
physiotherapist, once the immediate
The fast bowling technique is
pain resolves. So if the strength of the
classified into four distinct styles:
muscle is less then muscle is more
(son)side-on, (sop)semi-open,
prone for strain injury10. Hence
(fo)front-on or mixed, according to
strengthening exercises can be
their relationship between the planes of
incorporated to prevent sports injuries
the hips and shoulders, and shoulder
like side strain injury. Core
counter-rotation during the bowling
strengthening exercises can be done on
action8. Investigations of side strain in
an exercise mat using swiss ball and
cricket bowlers using MRI found that
resistance band which includes core
the injury consistently occurred on the
activation exercises, mat exercises,
non-bowling side and tended to affect
simple exercise and the Pilates10.
abdominal muscles internal oblique
Compare to other sports injuries side
muscle rather than the external oblique
strain injuries are not recurrent if
muscle, this could suggest that the
treated11.
asymmetrical muscular demands of the
repetitive bowling action creates Timothy et al did study to examine
hypertrophy in the torque producing whether players classified as “at risk”
muscles of trunk rotation and side participate in an intervention program
flexion.2 could reduce the incidence of adductor
muscle strain. The author concluded
Side strain injury is very common in
that a preseason strengthening exercise
cricket players and javelin throwers8,
to adductor muscle group appears to be
in cricket prevalence of side strain
an effective method for preventing
injury in bowlers is 21% in bowlers
adductor strain in professional Ice
5% and overall 9% of total injury in
Hockey players, similarly it is not
cricket8. All side strain injuries
known that whether a preseason core
required some kind of treatment which
strengthening exercises can reduce the
is aimed at pain relief and restore
risk of incidence of side strain injury in
mobility and strength9. Management of
medium pace bowlers who are at
side strain is ice application for twenty
risk12.
minutes every two hours, application
of cohesive compression bandage to Management of side strain takes
help to limit bleeding in the tissue, lengthy procedure so players may lose

43
ISSN: 2277-1700 ● Website: http://srji.drkrishna.co.in ● URL Forwarded to: http://sites.google.com/site/scientificrji

game so prevention is better than 15 seconds. Player lifted his right leg off the
cure.9Hence, if the strength of muscle ground and holded that position for 15
is increased, it can increase seconds and take it return to ground after 15
performance of the individual.12So seconds. Player lifted his left leg off the
greater the performance more the ground and holded that position for 15
chance of winning the game and seconds. Player lifted his left leg & right arm
increase in ranking level. off the ground and holded that position for 15
seconds and take it return to the ground after
METHODOLOGY
15 seconds. Player lifted his right leg & left

Study design: Descriptive longitudinal study arm off the ground and holded that position
for 15 seconds and take it return to basic up
Setting and Participants: 30 male medium position (elbows on the ground) and hold that
pace bowlers from prabodhan sports club, position for 30 second. Grading was done
payyade sports club, cricket clubs.Medium according to scoring as mentioned in table
pace bowlers with core muscle strength below.
average (i.e. Grade 2) on plank score, Age
group of 18 to 24, with bowling action front Grades:

on were included.Previous history of lateral Time Grades Scores


trunk pain or low back pain or side trunk
injuries, previous history of chest pain due to Under 20 seconds Poor 1

cardio, respiratory disorders were excluded. 21-45 seconds Average 2

Intervention Procedure: 46-70 seconds Good 3

The plank test was described as follows. The 71+seconds Excellent 4


player lied in prone position on mat or couch.
Watch was being positioned on the ground
where the player and therapist can easily see Core muscle strengthening exercise22 was
it. Player assumed the basic press up position given to players for 6 weeks. On first visit
(elbow on the ground) and holded that core strengthening exercise was taught to all
position for 60 seconds. Player lifted his right players, they were observed for 6 weeks.
arm off the ground and holded that position During exercise sessions, coaches or
for 15 seconds and take it return to the ground physiotherapist were educated about side
after 15 seconds. Player lifted his left arm off strain injury, which includes concept of side
the ground and holded that position for 15 strain injury, its symptoms, diagnostic tests
seconds and take it return to the ground after and its management. After one season (20

44
Scientific Research Journal of India ● Volume: 2, Issue: 4, Year: 2013

matches) matches, number of incidence of OUTCOME MEASURES


side strain injury was collected from coaches
• Number and percentage of incidence
or physiotherapist then severity of side strain
of side strain injury among medium
injury was assessed by Sonography or
pace bowlers after one season.
Magnetic resonance imaging and was
• Number and percentage of players who
confirmed by Orthopaedic. Data was collected
are at risk of side strain injury
in form of number and percentage of
• Plank scores in all players before and
incidence of side strain injury after one
after one season.
season.

DATA ANALYSIS

Data analysis was performed by SPSS


(version 17). Alpha value was set as 0.05.
Effectiveness of core strengthening exercise
was assessed by number and percentage of
incidence of side strain injury. Injury
incidence was calculated by new injury per
1000 hrs. of participation time. Wilcoxon
signed rank sum test was used to find out pre
post difference within the group for plank
score (ordinal scale) for assessing core muscle
strength.

RESULTS

Study Design: A study was undertaken to


measure effectiveness of core strengthening
muscle exercise to reduce incidence of side
strain injury.

Table 1: Descriptive statistics for demographic & outcome variables

45
Variables Range Minimum Maximum Mean Std. Deviation

Age 6.00 18.0 24.00 20.73 2.04

Height 19.0 165.00 184.00 171.68 4.66

Weight 34.00 59.00 93.00 70.03 7.22

BMI 14.30 19.90 34.20 23.79 2.64

Pre Plank Score 3.00 1.00 4.00 2.70 0.74

In the study group the range of age is 6,


minimum 18.00yrs. and maximum 24.00yrs.
with mean 20.73yrs and std. deviation of 2.04.
In the study group the range of height is 19
with minimum height 165cm and maximum
height 184cm with the mean of 171.68cm and
std. deviation of 4.66. In the study group range
of weight is 34.00 with minimum weight of
59.00kg and maximum weight of 93.00kg
This graph explains about preseason risk
with mean of 70.03kg and std. deviation 7.22.
medium pace bowlers. In the study group 88%
In the study group the range of BMI is 14.30
of medium pace bowlers are considered as at
with minimum BMI 19.90 and maximum BMI
risk of injury before season and 12% were
34.20 with mean of 23.79 and std. deviation of
having no preseason risk of injury.
2.74 In the study group the range of Plank
score is 3 with minimum plank score as 1and Graph : Side strain injury in 30 medium
maximum as 4 with mean of 2.70 and std. pace bowlers
deviation 0.74.

Graph: Preseason risk of injury in


bowlers

46
Scientific Research Journal of India ● Volume: 2, Issue: 4, Year: 2013

This graph explains about presence of side


strain injury in medium pace bowlers. In the
study group 90% of medium pace bowlers
have not shown side strain injury after one
season but 10% of medium pace bowlers have
shown side strain injury after one season(one
season = 20 matches).

Graph: Percentage of injuries in medium


pace bowlers

This graph explains about percentage of total


injuries in the study group it was 1( 3%) of
wrist injuries,3 (10%) ankle,1(3)%
groin,4(14%) hamstring,2( 7%) low
back,1(3%) shin splint, 4(13%)
shoulder,3(10%) side strain and11( 37%) no
injuries.

Table 2: Pre- post data within groups

Variable Pre post þ value

Plank score 2.00±0.00 2.93±0.64 < .0001

Data are mean ± SD in study Plank score is improved from pre mean score of 2.00with Sd. of 0.00
to post mean score 2.93 with Sd.of 0.64 and which was statistically significant.( p < 0.0001 ).

DISCUSSION strain injury. Third objective was to calculate


changes in plank score measurement in
Objective of the present study was to calculate
medium pace bowlers before and after
the pre-season risk of side strain injury in
intervention. & fourth objective was to assess
medium pace bowlers. Second objective was
the severity of side strain injury using
to measure the effectiveness of core muscle
electrotherapeutic measurements.
strengthening to reduce the incidence of side

47
ISSN: 2277-1700 ● Website: http://srji.drkrishna.co.in ● URL Forwarded to: http://sites.google.com/site/scientificrji

30 male medium pace bowlers were chosen the season tending to result in an increase in
for present study. Demographic variables injuries at those times Fast bowlers are at the
included were age, weight, height, BMI. In the greatest risk of injury for a variety of reasons,
present study players with age group 18-24 including the demands that fast bowling places
who were highly susceptible for side strain on the musculoskeletal system, incorrect
injury was taken. This was in accordance with technique, poor preparation and training, and
study done by HaronObaid et al. Author did a overuse.
study on sonographic appearance of side strain
In this study there were 3 side strain injury
injury and author stated that there were nine
(10%) observed after one season( 20 matches)
men, one woman who showed side strain
out of which one was left arm medium pace
injury of mean age, 22 years; range, 16–30
bowler 33% and two were right arm medium
years it concludes that this age group is highly
pace bowlers 67%. Number of games missed
susceptible for side strain injury.
by injured bowlers is 7, 6 & 5 respectively.
In the present study 21 right arm medium pace This was in accordance with study done by
bowlers and 9 Left arm medium pace bowlers HaronObaid et al. Author stated in the study of
who fulfilled inclusion criteria and who were sonographic appearance of side strain injury
having plank score Grade-2 (poor core muscle that 8 bowlers have got side strain injury out
strength) who were at risk of side strain injury of which 7 were right arm bowlers and one
because of muscle weakness were chosen. was left arm bowler. So present study
This was in accordance with study done by concludes incidence of side strain injury were
HaronObaid et al. Author did a study on more in right arm bowlers than left am
sonographic appearance of side strain injury medium pace bowlers.
and author stated that 8 bowlers have got
In the present study, 3 (10%) out of 30
strain side injury out of which 7 were right
medium pace bowlers have got side strain
arm bowlers and one was left arm bowler, so it
injury after one season (20 matches), and 23
concludes that incidence of side strain injury
(90%) showed other injuries or no injury. As
was more to right arm bowlers than left arm.
bowlers perform high velocity combination of
In this study there were 88% out of 30 sudden eccentric contraction when they bowl,
medium pace bowlers showed risk of injury. there are high chances of getting Side stain
This was in accordance with study done by R. injury. This was in accordance with study
A. Stretch et al. Author stated that injuries done by Haronobaid et al. Author stated that
tend to occur during specific stages of the Side strain is thought to occur as a
season, with the many preseason matches and consequence of a combination of sudden
the concentration of matches toward the end of eccentric contraction of the internal oblique

48
Scientific Research Journal of India ● Volume: 2, Issue: 4, Year: 2013

muscle that results in muscle tear. Also side Mean incidence was calculated by new injury
strain injury can occur due to Side due to per 1000 hrs. of participation time.
(plank score Grade-2) poor muscle strength Calculations were given by Foundation in
which is one of the causative factor for injury. sports marketing. Out of 30 medium pace
This was in accordance with study done by bowlers there were 4 hamstring injury (33.33
Timothy et al. Author stated in preseason risk mean incidence value) 1 wrist and forearm
study that poor muscle strength may cause injury (8.33 mean incidence), 3 side strain
stain of abductor muscles. injuries (25.00 incidence), 4 shoulder injuries
(33.33 mean incidence), 3 ankle injuries
In the present study, there were 3% of wrist
(25.00 mean incidence), 1 groin injury (8.33
injuries,10% ankle, 3% groin,14% hamstring,
mean incidence), 2 low back injuries (16.66
7% low back,3% shin splint, 13%
mean incidence), and 1 shin injury (8.33
shoulder,10% side strain and 37% no injuries.
mean incidence). 11 players did not show any
This was in accordance with study published
injury after one season (20 matches).
by National Institute of Arthritis and
Musculoskeletal and Skin Diseases. NIAMS Total numbers of hours played by 30 medium
updated that there are some most common pace bowlers were 3276 hours. Total numbers
sports injuries are: Sprains and strains Knee of hours were calculated by the product of
injuries swollen muscles Achilles tendon number of matches played by individual
injuries Pain along the shin bone Fractures player and number of hours played by
Dislocations. individual. (e.g. 17 matches * 6 hours = 102
hours) and sum of all hours were calculated.
In the present study, Plank test was used to
measure strength of core muscles. This was in Total numbers of games played by 30 players
accordance with study done by Janine Gray were 546and total games missed by 30 players
and Rene Naylor. Author have used plank test were 54. In the present study it was considered
for musculoskeletal assessment for to test one season = 20 matches so total number of
strength of core muscles. The test is used to games played were calculated by product of
determine the relative strength of the global total number games played by 30 players and
stabilizers of the body namely the transverses 20 matches (one season) and total number of
abdominus, internal and external obliques, and games missed by player were calculated by
scapula stabilizers. When compared with in subtracting total number of games missed by
group it was found that there were significant 30 players from the total number of games
increase in plank score from a pre mean plank played which was considered for 20 matches
score of 2.00 to post mean plank score 2.93 i.e. one season.
which was statistically significant.

49
ISSN: 2277-1700 ● Website: http://srji.drkrishna.co.in ● URL Forwarded to: http://sites.google.com/site/scientificrji

In the present study, MRI technique is used to  Involvement of side in terms of


measure severity of side strain injury. This dominance is not considered which
was in accordance with study done by might have influenced the study.
Kathleen shorter et al. Author stated that a  Lack of control group.
high percentage of type II or fast twitch fibers
may also be a predisposing factor to tearing. RECOMMENDATIONS
MRI appears to be a sensitive test for
 Further studies can be done by
evaluating side strain injury, showing an
comparing core muscle strengthening
abnormality in all patients who had a clinical
exercise with other pre-season
suspicion of a muscular tear and also to assess
prevention protocols.
the severity of injury.
 Study can be done to see how much
It is postulated that the mechanism of injury incidence of side train injury is
for internal oblique muscle strain is sudden reduced when compared to a preseason
eccentric contracture with rupture of muscle when there is no intervention given
fibers. Movements associated with medium  Further studies can be done to find its
pace bowling, which is then subjected to effectiveness in fast bowler, batsmen
superimposed eccentric contraction, making it & other sports like javelin throw
vulnerable to rupture. Present study describes hockey, tennis, badminton etc.
an effective strategy for injury prevention, by
core muscle strengthening exercises program CONCLUSION
before season in medium pace bowlers to
reduce incidence of side strain injury. Objective of present study was to calculate the
pre-season risk of side strain injury in medium
LIMITATIONS
pace bowlers. Second objective was to
 Inability to monitor player’s measure the effectiveness of core
compliance(daily exercise strengthening muscles to reduce incidence of
performance) with the home exercise side strain injury. Third objective was to
program which might have influenced calculate changes in plank score measurement
the study. in medium pace bowlers before and after
 The study was done with small sample intervention. & fourth objective was to assess
size. severity of side strain injury using
 Long term effects of the treatment electrotherapeutic measurements. As there was
were not assessed. a significant improvement in pre and post
plank score (prone hold test) with in group.
And significant improvement in core muscle

50
Scientific Research Journal of India ● Volume: 2, Issue: 4, Year: 2013

strength. Incidence of side strain injury as reducing the incidence of side stain injury in
compare to other common cricket injuries medium pace bowlers”. Thus, Core muscle
were less. Hence null hypothesis was rejected. strengthening exercises can be given to
The study concludes as “Core muscle medium pace bowlers to reduce incidence of
strengthening exercises are effective in side strain injury.

REFERENCES

1. U.S. Department of health and human sciences public health service. Sports injuries National Institute of
Arthritis and Musculoskeletal and Skin Diseases June 2009; 1-6.

2. McGrath A, Finch C. Bowling cricket injuries over: A review of the literature, Monash University Accident
Research Centre. Report No 105 November 1996; 9-18.
3. Laura and Stuart. Sports Injury(prevention in sports) Research Journals available from URL
http://www.physioroom.com/research/journals.php 2011;1-3
4. Shorter K, Nealon A, Smith N and Lauder M. Cricket side strain Injuries, A description of trunk muscle activity
and the potential influence of bowling technique Portuguese Journal of Sport Sciences 2011 ;11 (Suppl. 2):1-3.
5. Orchard J, James T.Cricket Australia Injury Report October 2003 – Official Report, Version 3.2:15-17.
6. David A. Connell, Jhamb A, James T.Side Strain A Tear of Internal Oblique Musculature.AJR June2003;
181:1511–1517.
7. Krishna A. Cricket injury report. Barkisland cricket club Jameka West indies 2005 available on URL
http://www.ckcricketheritage.org; 1:1-7.
8. James T, Orchard J. Summary and analysis of injuries occurring in Australian cricket board (ACB Injury
Report). Australian journal of sports medicine October 10 2002; Version 4.0:12-18.
9. Humphries M, Jamison J.Clinical and magnetic resonance imaging features of cricket bowler’s side strain.
bjsportmed 2004;38.21: 1-3.
10. Orchard, T James, Alcott E, Carter S, Farhart P. Injuries in Australian cricket at first class level1995/1996 to
2000/2001. Br J Sports Med 2002;36:270–275
11. Orchard J, James T.Cricket Australia Injury Report, Australian journal of sports medicine October 2003;
Version 3:2-7.
12. Timothy F. Tyler, Stephen J. Nicolas, Richard J.Campbel. The effectiveness of preseason exercise program to
prevent adductor muscle strain in professional ice hockey players.American journal of sports medicine 2002,
30. 5:681-83.
13. Mcdonald Da, DelgadilloJq, Fredericson M, Mcconnell J, Hodgins M, BesierTf. Reliability And Accuracy Of A
Video Analysis Protocol To Assess Core Ability. Howard Hughes Medical Institue Science Education March
2011; Volume 3, Issue 3: 204-211
14. Shorter K, Nealon A, Smith N, Lauder M. Cricket side strain Injuries, A description of trunk muscle activity and
the potential influence of bowling technique Portuguese Journal of Sport Sciences 2011 ;11 (Suppl. 2):1-3.
15. Dendas A M. The relationship between core stability and athletic performance. Humboldt State University
August 2010;1:30-56

51
ISSN: 2277-1700 ● Website: http://srji.drkrishna.co.in ● URL Forwarded to: http://sites.google.com/site/scientificrji

16. Obaid H, Nealon A, Connell D. Sonographic Appearance of Side Strain Injury.AJR December 2008; 191:264–
267.
17. Jerrold S. Petrofsky, Eric G. Johnson, Hanson A, Cuneo M, Dial R, Somers R, et al. Abdominal and Lower Back
Training for People with Disabilities Using a 6 Second Abs Machine, Effect on Core Muscle Stability.The
Journal of Applied Research 2005; 5. 2: 345-351.
18. David A. Connell, JhambA , James T. Side Strain A Tear of Internal Oblique Musculature.AJR June2003;
181:1511–1517.
19. Stretch R A. Cricket injuries: a longitudinal study of the nature of injuries to South African cricketers. British
Journal of sports medicine 2003; 37:250-253.
20. Orchard J, Marsden J, Lord S. Preseason hamstring weakness associated with hamstring muscle injury in
Australian footballers Am J Sports Med Jan1997;25:81-85
21. Hagen JS, Nemeth G, Eriksson E. Hamstring injuries in sprinters: the role of concentric and eccentric
hamstring muscle strength and flexibility. A J Sports Med. March1994;22:262-265.
22. Howell J, DC Strengthening the Core Muscles core training and athletic performances. Available from URL.
www.johnhowelldc.com;1:1-7.
23. Dr. Rebecca Denniss Evidence-based injury prevention for repetitive microtrauma injuries: The cricket
example. School of Human Movement and Sport Sciences University of Ballarat. Available from URL
www.rdemmispfarhrt.com
24. Janine Gray, Rene Naylor MUSCULOSKELETAL ASSESSMENT FORM. 2009. Available from URL.
www.booksmart.com ;1: 26
25. Anderson M.K. Foundations of Athletic Training: Prevention, Assessment, and Management. 4th Ed. Chapter 6
Foundations in sports therapy.
26. Rebecca J Dennis, Caroline F Finch, Andrew S McIntosh, Bruce C Elliott. Using field-based tests to identify
risk factors for injury to fast bowlers in cricket. Br J Sports Med2008 ;10: 3, 7, 9, 16.

CORRESPONDING AUTHOR:

• Email: padhye_omkar@rediffmail.com

52

You might also like