Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Industry - Mining
Products - Copper, Aluminum, Zinc, Lead, Gold, Iron ore, Pig iron, Metallurgical Coke and Oil
and gas exploration, Power
Reasons
1. Vedanta Resources, which is listed in London, will merge all of its Indian
holdings, particularly Sterlite Industries and Sesa Goa, into a single entity.
2. Vedanta will hold 58.3 per cent in the new company.
3. The merge will entail a share swap in the 3:5 ratio, wherein five shares of
Sterlite will fetch three shares of Sesa Goa.
5. The merged company will have consolidated net profit of $2.5 billion.
10. The restructuring will come into effect only after some minority
shareholders and regulators in India and the UK give it their stamp of
approval.
Methods
FTSE-100 miner Vedanta, which has underperformed the sector by
more than 25 percent since the start of last year, has over a dozen
units, none fully owned and several separately listed, producing oil to
aluminium and copper to zinc.
The boards of the companies have approved the issue of three shares
of Sesa Goa for every five shares held in Sterlite.
Vedanta’s 38.8 percent holding in oil and gas producer Cairn India,
which it acquired last year, will be transferred to Sesa Sterlite, along
with related debt of $5.9 billion.
“On the face of it, the merger ratio is appearing to be slightly negative
to Sesa Goa shareholders and positive to Sterlite shareholders,”
Thunuguntla said. “...But on a long-term basis, this will prove to be
positive for the merged entity.”
VALUE ACCRETIVE
This is the group’s second effort to overhaul its structure. A similar
exercise in 2008 was aborted after investor opposition to the plan and
the valuations of some of Vedanta’s African assets.
The group expects cost savings of $200 million a year from the
restructuring, vice chairman Navin Agarwal told analysts in a
conference call, adding the transaction was expected to be earnings-
accretive in the first year itself.
INVESTMENT BANKERS
Vedanta Group companies Sterlite Industries and Sesa Goa have received their
shareholders’ approval for the proposed merger.
A total of 1,244 shareholders and creditors representing Sterlite Industries, Madras
Aluminium, Sterlite Energy, Vedanta Aluminium and Sesa Goa participated in the
voting procedure held at Panaji in Goa on June 19. Of them, 1,073 (representing
86.25 per cent) voted for the resolution to merge these entities and form a new
company Sesa Sterlite. Another 171 (13.75 per cent) were against the resolution,
while 13 others abstained from voting. Similarly, 861 Sterlite Industries investors
attended a meeting for getting shareholders’ approval for the merger plan. Of them,
703 (representing 81.65 per cent) investors were for the merger and 158 against it.
According to the merger proposal, Sterlite shareholders will get three shares of
Sesa Goa for every five shares held. Sesa Sterlite will become the seventh largest
diversified resources company in the world with business interests in iron ore
mining, copper, aluminium, zinc, lead, silver and oil and gas.
Earlier, the Competition Commission of India had approved the merger plan
proposed by the holding company Vedanta Resources. In February, the UK-based
Vedanta Resources had proposed to merge its Indian firms into a single entity Sesa
Sterlite and offload debt of $9 billion (Rs 45,000 crore).
Post-reorganisation, Vedanta Resources will own a 58.3 per cent in Sesa Sterlite. It
currently has 54.6 per cent in Sterlite and 55.10 per cent in Sesa Goa.
Vedanta Resources will also transfer its shareholding of 38.8 per cent in Cairn
India to the new entity along with the debt of $5.9 billion raised to acquire Cairn
India. Sesa Goa will pay a nominal consideration of $1 for buying Cairn India
stake. Post the transfer, Sesa Sterlite will have a 58.9 per cent shareholding in
Cairn India.
Valuation
Scheme
regulatory aspects
Challenges
The Centre on Monday moved the Supreme Court challenging the merger of two Vedanta
group companies iron ore mining unit Sesa Goa and copper producer Sterlite Industries
alleging that the amalgamation approved by the Bombay High Court in August last year was
aimed at avoiding taxes to the tune of Rs 847 crore.
While seeking the setting aside of the merger scheme, the ministry of corporate affairs
(MCA) said the relevant scheme of amalgamation was nothing but a colourable device
adopted by Sesa Goa, the once-flagship iron ore producer of Anil Agarwal-controlled
Vedanta Resources, to evade payment of tax, by being eligible for refund.
The Sesa Goa-Sterlite merger conducted in an all-share transaction led to the formation of
Sesa Sterlite, Indias biggest aluminium maker. As per the merger scheme, investors got three
Sesa Goa shares for five shares of Sterlite, while London-based Vedanta transferred to the
new entity for $1 its 38.8% stake in Cairn India, including debt of $5.9 billion. The scheme,
first announced in February 2012, has since received all other regulatory clearances and the
merged entity started trading on Indian bourses on August 30 last year.
A bench headed by justice Fakkir Mohamed Ibrahim Kalifulla posted the matter for further
hearing on Thursday, the day when an earlier the income tax departments appeal in a related
matter comes up for hearing.
The department had appealed against the Bombay HCs order that dismissed its intervention
application on the ground that it had no locus standi, and the Supreme Court then said any
objection would be entertained only if the MCA filed a special leave petition.
The ministry has now said that parent company Vedanta Aluminium had huge accumulated
loss/unabsorbed depreciation of Rs 2,461 crore whereas Sesa Goa had paid total taxes of Rs
846.97 crore for the financial year ended March 31, 2012. Therefore, the entire tax liability of
Sesa Goa was wiped, causing the total taxes of Rs 846.97 crore to be refunded at the expense
of the public exchequer, it added.
Senior counsel Harish Salve and Ranjana Roy, appearing for Sesa Goa, argued that the
ministry had filed objections that were never raised by it before the high court. Under Section
72A of the Income Tax Act, if there is any merger or demerger, the company can take refund
to set off the losses, they said, adding that the SC has already upheld the merger scheme on
August 27 after dismissing an appeal filed against the merger.
To support its contentions, the government has relied upon McDowell & Co. Ltd v CTO and
SRF Ltd vs Garware Plastics & Polyesters Ltd. The Centre stated that when an amalgamation
scheme is framed with the sole objective of deriving unjustifiable benefit like obtaining
refund of taxes paid earlier at the cost of the public exchequer, then such schemes are
considered to be colourable devices with the motive of evading payment of tax.
When the HC granted approval to the merger, it had rejected a review petition filed by a
shareholder of Sesa Goa and sanctioned the scheme of amalgamation and arrangement
amongst Sterlite Industries (India) and Sesa Goa.
Recast the deal
* In February 2012, Vedanta Resources proposes consolidation of Sesa Goa, Sterlite,
Vedanta Aluminium and Madras Aluminium into a single entity Sesa Sterlite
* Argues that the single-entity structure would lead to consolidation and simplification of the
group structure
* All-share merger of Sesa Goa and Sterlite Industries became effective on August 17, 2013,
to form Sesa Sterlite
* Vedanta claims contributing R31,100 crore to govt in FY14 in taxes, duties, royalties &
profit petroleum
* Sesa Sterlites tax outgo in FY14 was negative R847 cr (credit) vs R1,024 cr (on adjusted
pro forma) basis in FY13
These three segments, which account for about 72% of earnings before
interest and tax (EBIT), also gained due to the weak rupee. Zinc
(contributed 63% to profits) saw good growth in output of zinc and silver,
while oil (22%) also saw some rise in production.
Though the September quarter results are not comparable due to the
merger of Sesa Goa and Sterlite Industries as well as goodwill
amortisation, the reported revenue of Rs 25,352 crore and net profit of Rs
2,394 crore came in higher than average estimates of Rs 16,240 crore and
Rs 1,930 crore, respectively.
Even when compared to the proforma figures, which assume the effective
merger date as April 1, 2013 against the actual (between August 17 and
26), the performance was better. Deutsche Research analysts say the EBIT
was 9% ahead of their estimates.
Post results, the Street has turned positive as the focus now shifts to
volume gains in copper, aluminium, power and iron ore businesses. While
iron ore mining in Karnataka has commenced, mining in Goa is expected
to start after the Supreme Court gives approval. In aluminium, Vedanta
Aluminium’s refinery will see capacity being ramped up whereas Balco's
coal block is expected to be operational by June 2014.
Though most analysts have cut their EPS estimates for FY14 and FY15 due
to amortisation of non-cash item, goodwill (relating to acquisition of Cairn
India) they do not perceive it in negative light.
The company has gross debt of Rs 84,000 crore (net at Rs 35,923 crore) in
the books and almost half of that is accounted by subsidiaries, while
interest costs are manageable at a fourth of Ebidta of Rs 7, 224 crore for
September quarter.
Impact
Shares of Sesa Goa fell more than 10% on Monday after parent
Vedanta Resources decided to merge the company with group firm
Sterlite Industries and set a swap ratio of three Sesa Goa shares for
every five Sterlite shares.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vedanta_Limited