You are on page 1of 10

Tropical Medicine and International Health doi:10.1111/j.1365-3156.2006.01809.

volume 12 no 4 pp 493–502 april 2007

Clinical features and associated morbidity of scabies in a rural


community in Alagoas, Brazil
Anne Jackson1, Jörg Heukelbach2, Arthur Ferreira da Silva Filho3, Evônio de Barros Campelo Júnior3 and
Hermann Feldmeier1

1 Institute of Microbiology and Hygiene, Charité–University Medicine Berlin, Berlin, Germany


2 Department of Community Health, School of Medicine, Federal University of Ceará and Mandacaru Foundation, Fortaleza, Brazil
3 Department of Pathology, School of Health Sciences of Alagoas, Maceió, Brazil

Summary objective To describe the clinical characteristics of scabies and the associated morbidity in an
impoverished rural community in northeast Brazil.
method A door-to-door survey was made to examine twice the population of an endemic area; first at
the end of the rainy season, and a second time in the dry season 4 months later.
results In total, 2005 individuals were examined. The overall prevalence of scabies was 9.8%
(95% CI 8.5–11.2). Predilection sites with similar relative frequencies in all age groups were the
abdomen (83.7%) and the inguinal area/inner part of the thighs (66.3%). Hands, feet, genitals and the
scalp/neck/face were significantly more often affected in children <7 years (all P < 0.03). Fifty-five per
cent of the patients showed scabies lesions simultaneously at ‡12 distinct topographic areas. Papular
lesions were most commonly found, followed by papular-crusted lesions. Vesicles were significantly
more often observed in children (P ¼ 0.04). Sixty-four per cent of the patients had three or more types of
lesions. Local lymphadenopathy was present in 53.6% and superinfection in 36.7% of the cases. The
number of topographic areas affected, as well as the proportion of superinfected lesions, was inversely
correlated with age (rho ¼ )0.22, P ¼ 0.002 and rho ¼ )0.358, P < 0.05, respectively). The quantity
of skin surface infested, the proportion of superinfected lesions and the presence of a superinfected lesion
distal to an enlarged lymphnode were predictors of lymphadenopathy. Seventy-two per cent of the
patients suffered from sleep disorders, mainly because of itching.
conclusion Scabies is associated with considerable morbidity in this endemic community. Predilection
sites, clinical presentation, quantity of skin surface affected and proportion of secondary infected lesions
show a dichotomy between children and adults.

keywords scabies, clinical features, morbidity, community-based study, Brazil

literature (Estes 1982; Gerbase et al. 1984; Kenawi et al.


Introduction
1993; Flinders & De 2004; McCarthy et al. 2004; Sarwat
Scabies is a common parasitic skin disease caused by the 1 et al. 1993; Chosidow 2006). There are hints that
infestation with the mite Sarcoptes scabiei var. hominis. predilection sites may vary between children and adults,
Clinical appearances are differentiated into primary although the existing evidence is not convincing (Hurwitz
(macules, papules, vesicles, burrows, nodules) and secon- 1973; Orkin & Maibach 1978; McCarthy et al. 2004;
dary lesions (crusts, excoriation, eczematisation, secondary Heukelbach et al. 2005; Chosidow 2006).
bacterial infection) (Estes 1982; Gerbase et al. 1984; Intense itching is invariably present and affects also areas
Sarwat et al. 1993; Kenawi et al. 1993; Chosidow 2006). other than the site of the lesion (Estes 1982; Flinders & De
At least in the tropics, burrows are only inconsistently 2004; McCarthy et al. 2004; Sarwat et al. 2004). The most
present, and the development of nodules seems to be frequent complication is secondary bacterial infection
restricted to certain topographic areas (Orkin & Maibach caused by scratching and the subsequent development of
1978; Tonkin & Wynne-Jones 1979; Gerbase et al. 1984; lymphadenopathy (Tonkin & Wynne-Jones 1979; Burgess
Chouela et al. 2002; McCarthy et al. 2004). Numerous 1994; McCarthy et al. 2004). In the developing world, post-
topographic areas are considered to be predilection sites, streptococcal glomerulonephritis is common and scabies is
but a clear ranking cannot be inferred from the existing considered as an important cause of group A streptococci

ª 2007 Blackwell Publishing Ltd 493


Tropical Medicine and International Health volume 12 no 4 pp 493–502 april 2007

A. Jackson et al. Scabies in Brazil

2 (GAS)-induced renal disease (Mahe 2001; McCarthy et al. three times if a household member was absent. Each survey
2004; Feldmeier et al. 2005; Lawrence et al. 2005). was carried out within a period of 10 weeks.
In contrast to the industrialized countries, where
scabies occurs mainly sporadically or in form of epidemics
Clinical examination and case definition
in institutions, in the developing world ectoparasitosis is
endemic, and prevalence may be up to 29% in the general The household leaders were asked for a room with good
population (Gulati et al. 1977a; Sharma et al. 1984; light and in which privacy was guaranteed. In this room,
Carapetis et al. 1997; Downs et al. 1999; Hegazy et al. the whole body including the breasts and the genital area
1999; Andersen et al. 2000; Larrosa et al. 2003; Heu- was thoroughly examined for the presence of skin lesions
kelbach et al. 2005; Heukelbach & Feldmeier 2006). typical for scabies. Children <10 years were only examined
Surprisingly, the clinical features of scabies and the in the presence of a caretaker, usually the mother.
associated morbidity in these settings have only rarely The diagnosis of scabies was made clinically using a case
been described (Sharma et al. 1984; Heukelbach et al. definition. The diagnosis of scabies by means of defined
2005). Clinical characteristics are almost exclusively clinical parameters is a well-established and approved
derived from observations made in patients seen by method in the developing world (Gulati et al. 1977a,b;
general practitioners, or from patients in hospitals and Hassan et al. 1979; Gerbase et al. 1984; Sharma et al.
institutions (Gerbase et al. 1984; Kenawi et al. 1993; 1984; Landwehr et al. 1998; Heukelbach et al. 2005).
Pasternak et al. 1994; Sarwat et al. 2004). It is ques- Skin scraping cannot be considered to be of help in this
tionable whether these findings reflect the clinical features setting, as its sensitivity is low and as its application is not
and the associated morbidity of scabies present in an suitable for surveys in resource-poor settings (Parish &
endemic community. Here, we report the results of a Witkowski 1999; Flinders & De 2004; Sarwat et al. 2004;
systematic study on patients with scabies in an impover- Chosidow 2006). Scabies was suspected, if an itchy
ished rural population in northeast Brazil, based on two papular, papular-crusted or vesicular rash was present at
subsequent door-to-door surveys. the interdigital spaces, flexion sites of the wrists, extension
sites of the elbows, the axillae, mamillae, perimammilar
area, periumbicular area, penis, scrotum or the buttocks.
Materials and methods These areas are usually considered as predilection sites
(Gerbase et al. 1984; Orkin & Maibach 1985; Kenawi
Study area and design
et al. 1993; McCarthy et al. 2004; Sarwat et al. 2004). An
The study area and the design have been described individual was considered to have scabies, if two of the
previously (Jackson et al. 2006). In brief, the study was following requirements were fulfilled: pruritus which
conducted in three districts of Feliz Deserto, a traditional intensified at night, presence of the lesions for >2 weeks, at
fishing village in Alagoas state, northeast Brazil. These least one more family member with similar lesions.
areas were chosen because they had shown the highest Immediately after the diagnosis, the patient was treated
prevalences of scabies in a pilot study performed in May with 0.2% deltamethrin lotion (Deltacid; Solvay Farma,
2003. Atopic diseases were rare. Houses are constructed of São Paulo, Brazil). Superinfected lesions were treated with
brick, clay tiles or palm stems covered with a mixture of oral roxithromycin (Floxid, 150 mg b.i.d. over 5 days;
clay and straw. Eighty-eight per cent of the houses are Solvay Farma).
connected to electricity, and all have piped water. People To determine the topographic distribution of the lesions
mainly dress in shorts, summer skirts and tee-shirts or and the surface of the skin affected, the body surface was
sleeveless tops; boys usually wear only shorts. The climate divided vertically into right and left. Each side was
is tropical with most rainfall occurring from April to subdivided into 16 areas as follows: interdigital spaces,
August. The average 24-h temperature is 26.6 C in the dry hand, wrist, arm, elbow, axilla, leg (except the medial
and 25.1 C in the rainy season. area of the thigh), foot, abdomen, thorax, mamilla/
Each individual who had spent in average at least four perimammilar area, back, buttock, genitals, inguinal area/
nights per week during the last three months in a medial area of the thigh and scalp/neck/face.
household situated in the study area was eligible for the Primary lesions were differentiated into macular, papu-
study. Individuals moving into the study area after the first lar, papular-crusted (appearing as papules with a tiny
survey were registered and examined in the second survey haemorrhagic crust) and vesicular. As in scabies pruritus is
only. One door-to-door survey was carried out in June/July not limited to infested sites, excoriations on uninfested skin
2003 (rainy season), the other in October/November 2003 areas were also documented (Mellanby 1977; McCarthy
(dry season). At both surveys, households were revisited et al. 2004; Sarwat et al. 2004; Chosidow 2006). Bacterial

494 ª 2007 Blackwell Publishing Ltd


Tropical Medicine and International Health volume 12 no 4 pp 493–502 april 2007

A. Jackson et al. Scabies in Brazil

superinfection was diagnosed when pustules, abscesses or 25.7% were females. During the second survey, 261
suppuration were present. Lymphadenopathy was diag- households with a total of 1169 individuals existed in the
nosed, if swollen lymph nodes were palpated during study area. Seventeen families (159 individuals) had moved
clinical examination along the lymph vessels draining the away, whereas 13 families (73 individuals) had moved
affected topographic area. into the study area. In total, 55 persons refused to take part
Patients were asked about their complaints. Itching was in the second survey, and 27 were excluded as they spent
subjectively classified into weak, moderate and severe; less than four nights a week in the study area. Non-
sleep disturbances into sleep initiation disorders and sleep participants in the second survey had a mean age of
maintenance disorders. To reduce inter-observer bias, the 31.0 years; 74.4% were males, and 25.6% were females.
clinical examinations were carried out by the same This resulted in a target population of 1146 individuals for
investigator (Anne Jackson) on all occasions. the first and 1087 for the second survey. All households
were visited in June/July 2003 (rainy season) and a second
time in October/November 2003 (dry season). In the rainy
Data storage and analysis
season 88.6% (n ¼ 1015) of the target population was
Data were entered twice into a database using the Epi Info examined, in the dry reason 91.1% (n ¼ 990). Males aged
software package (version 6.04d; Centers for Disease 15–59 years were underrepresented in both the surveys.
Control, Atlanta, GA, USA) and checked for errors which Eighty-six per cent of the households had a monthly family
may have occurred during their entry. Ninety-five per cent income of more than or equal to one official minimum
confidence intervals were calculated using the respective wage (equivalent to US$ 86 in 2003). Of the individuals
Epi Info module. The chi-square test, the Fisher’s exact test >14 years, 34% were illiterate and 96% had not completed
and the Spearman rank correlation coefficient test were secondary school. Sixty-nine per cent of the population
applied where appropriate, using the SigmaStat software shared a bed or mattress, 15% shared their clothing and
package (version 3.1; Systat software Incorporation, 48% their towels with other household members.
Richmond, CA, USA). Odds ratios were calculated to In the rainy season, 102 of the 1015 persons examined
measure the association between the presence of lympha- were infested with scabies [10.0%; 95% confidence inter-
denopathy as the dependent and demographic and clinical val (CI) 8.3–12.1%], in the dry season 94 out of 990
characteristics as independent variables. persons (9.5%; 95% CI 7.8–11.5%), thus giving an overall
prevalence of 9.8%. The median age of the patients was
8 years (range 0–79 years).
Ethical considerations
The types of lesions observed are summarized in
The study was approved by the Ethical Committee of the Table 1. Simultaneous presence of different types of lesions
Escola de Ciências Médicas de Alagoas, the responsible was very common. Of the patients, 51.5% had signs of
ethical body in Alagoas state, as well as from an ad hoc scratching on uninfested skin. Vesicles were significantly
committee of the health department of the municipality of more often found in children £7 years than in the other age
Feliz Deserto. Prior to the study, meetings were held in the groups (35.5% vs. 17.5%; P ¼ 0.04). Children also
community with healthcare workers to explain the objec- presented a greater diversity of lesions than adults. Types
tives. All participants were informed about the study and of lesions were similar in males and females, except for
asked for written consent. In the case of minors, the excoriated lesions (28.6% vs. 50.0%; P ¼ 0.06) and did
guardian was asked for written consent. Any inhabitant of not vary between the rainy and the dry seasons.
the study area was free to refrain from participating The topographic distribution of scabies lesions is shown
without any disadvantage for himself/herself or other in Table 2. Predilection sites with similar frequencies in all
persons. age groups were the abdomen (83.7% of the patients) and
the inguinal area/inner side of the thighs (66.3%). The
hands, feet, genitals and scalp/neck/face were significantly
Results
more often infested in children £7 years (all P < 0.03).
In June 2003, the study area was inhabited by a total of Other areas with a clear preponderance in children were
1255 inhabitants living in 265 households. Household size the wrists, interdigital spaces, axillae, legs and buttocks.
varied from 1 to 13 persons, the median being 4.5. Fifty-six However, the differences between the age groups were not
individuals were excluded because they spent less than four significant. The scalp, neck and face were exclusively
nights a week in Feliz Deserto; 53 persons refused to take infested in patients £11 years (median 3 years, interquar-
part in the study. The mean age of non-participants was tile ranges 1–7 years). Sixty per cent of the patients with
28.5 years; 74.3% of non-participants were males, and infestation of the mamillae and the perimammilar area

ª 2007 Blackwell Publishing Ltd 495


Tropical Medicine and International Health volume 12 no 4 pp 493–502 april 2007

A. Jackson et al. Scabies in Brazil

Table 1 Types of lesions found in 196 patients with scabies neously found at ‡30 topographic areas; these were all
children £1 year. There was an inverse correlation between
Number of
the number of topographic areas affected and the age of the
Type of lesion* patients (%) 
patients (rho ¼ )0.221; P ¼ 0.002).
Papules 132 (67.3) In total, 36.7% of the patients presented signs of
Crusted papules 131 (66.8) superinfection; 10.4% of the topographic areas affected
Macules 84 (42.9) were superinfected (Table 3). The proportion of superin-
Vesicles 51 (26.0)
fection ranged between 0% (mamillae and perimammilar
Excoriated lesions 80 (40.8)
Excoriations at uninfested skin 101 (51.5) area) and 64% (scalp/neck/face). The proportion of
Simultaneous presence of at least 165 (84.2) superinfected lesions inversely correlated with the age of
two different types of lesions the patients (rho ¼ )0.358; P < 0.05) and positively with
Simultaneous presence of three 100 (51.0) the number of topographic areas affected (rho ¼ 0.408;
to four different types of lesions P < 0.05) (Figure 1a,b).
Simultaneous presence of more than 26 (13.3) Superinfection was further classified into suppuration,
four different types of lesions
pustules and abscesses (Table 3). Suppuration was more
Simultaneous presence of primary 80 (40.8)
lesions and excoriationsà common than pustules (52% vs. 44%), and abscesses were
rare. Abscesses were only located at the upper extremity
*Burrows, nodules and eczematization were not found in a single (two at the elbows, two at the arms and one at the hands).
case. Areas where lesions predominantly were suppurated were
 Multiple observations possible.
the buttocks and the scalp/neck/face.
àFor definition, see Materials and methods.
Fifty-four per cent of the patients presented with
lymphadenopathy proximal to the lesion (Table 4). Ingu-
were >9 years (median 11 years, interquartile ranges inal lymphadenopathy (44.4%) was more common than
4–31 years). This manifestation was seen significantly axillar (26.5%) and cervical lymphadenopathy (16.8%).
more often in females than in males (40.2% vs. 15.5%, The results of the bivariate analysis are depicted in Table 5.
P ¼ 0.008). Young age, the number of topographic areas infested, the
Fifty-five per cent of the patients showed simultaneous presence of superinfection distal to the swollen lymph
lesions at ‡12 of the 32 topographic areas assessed, and nodes and the proportion of superinfected areas were all
6.6% at ‡24 areas. In four patients, lesions were simulta- significant predictors for the presence of lymphadenopathy.

Table 2 Topographic distribution of le-


Individuals Individuals sions according to age group
infested infested
Localization of lesions* All (%) £7 years (%) >7 years (%) P-value

Abdomen 164 (83.7) 77 (82.8) 87 (84.5) 1.0


Inguinal area/medial parts of thighs 130 (66.3) 62 (66.7) 68 (66.0) 1.0
Axillas 122 (62.2) 67 (72.0) 55 (53.4) 0.25
Wrists 110 (56.1) 65 (69.9) 45 (43.7) 0.07
Interdigital spaces 105 (53.6) 60 (64.5) 45 (43.7) 0.14
Legs 100 (51.0) 56 (60.2) 44 (42.7) 0.22
Thorax 100 (51.0) 47 (50.5) 53 (51.5) 0.96
Back 99 (50.5) 51 (54.8) 48 (46.6) 0.59
Elbows 98 (50.0) 52 (55.9) 46 (44.7) 0.43
Buttocks 93 (47.4) 54 (58.1) 39 (37.7) 0.12
Arms 93 (47.4) 47 (50.5) 46 (44.7) 0.72
Hands  66 (33.7) 42 (45.2) 24 (23.3) 0.03
Mamillae/perimamillar area 58 (29.6) 21 (22.6) 37 (35.9) 0.17
Feet 45 (23.0) 34 (36.6) 11 (10.7) 0.001
Genitals 33 (16.8) 26 (28.0) 7 (6.8) 0.002
Scalp/neck/face 6 (3.1) 9 (9.7) 1 (1.0) 0.02
Total 196 93 103

*Multiple observations possible.


 Other parts than the interdigital spaces and the wrists.

496 ª 2007 Blackwell Publishing Ltd


Tropical Medicine and International Health volume 12 no 4 pp 493–502 april 2007

A. Jackson et al. Scabies in Brazil

Table 3 Localization of lesions, superinfection and type of superinfection in 196 patients with scabies

Type of superinfection (n)


Number of topographic Number of topographic areas
Localization of lesions areas affected with superinfected lesions (%) Pustule Suppuration Abscess

Abdomen 316 10 (3.2) 4 6 0


Inguinal area/inner side of thighs 244 6 (2.5) 4 2 0
Axillas 208 6 (2.9) 2 4 0
Thorax 183 1 (0.5) 1 0 0
Interdigital spaces 181 61 (33.7) 30 31 0
Back 179 3 (1.7) 1 2 0
Buttocks 175 33 (18.9) 3 30 0
Wrists 167 38 (22.8) 24 14 0
Legs 166 22 (13.3) 9 13 0
Elbows 157 13 (8.3) 6 5 2
Arms 148 7 (4.7) 2 3 2
Hands 102 23 (22.5) 13 9 1
Mamillae/perimamillar area 86 0 (0.0) 0 0 0
Feet 71 22 (31.0) 11 11 0
Genitals 65 4 (6.2) 2 2 0
Scalp/neck/face 18 7 (63.6) 1 6 0
Total 2466 256 (10.4) 113 138 5

1.2
(a)
1

0.8

0.6

0.4
Proportion of superinfected lesions

0.2

0
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90
Age of patients
-0.2

1.2
(b)
1

0.8

0.6

0.4

Figure 1 (a) Correlation between age of 0.2


patients and proportion of superinfected
lesions; (b) Correlation between number of 0
topografic areas affected and proportion of 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35
superinfection. Number of topografic areas affected

ª 2007 Blackwell Publishing Ltd 497


Tropical Medicine and International Health volume 12 no 4 pp 493–502 april 2007

A. Jackson et al. Scabies in Brazil

Table 4 Lymphadenopathy in 196 patients with scabies Table 6 Complaints of 196 patients with scabies

Localization of lymphadenopathy* N (%) Type of complaint n (%)

Inguinal area 87 (44.4)  Itching 183 (93.4)à


Axillar area 52 (26.5) Light 57 (31.1)
Cervical area 33 (16.8)à Moderate 54 (29.5)
Total 105 (53.6%) Severe 72 (39.3)
Sleep disturbance (total) 142 (72.4)à
*Multiple observations possible. Sleep initiation disorder* 32 (16.3)à
 Thirty-five individuals had another parasitic skin disease at their Due to itching 29 (90.6)§
feet (33 tungiasis, 2 cutaneous larva migrans). Due to pain 3 (9.4)§
àEight individuals were concomitantly infested with pediculus Sleep maintenance disorder  139 (70.9)à
capitis. Due to itching 133 (95.7)–
Due to pain 6 (4.3)–
No complaints 7 (3.6)à
Table 5 Predictors of lymphadenopathy*
*Fifteen individuals were concomitantly affected by one or more
Independent 95% confidence other parasitic skin disease (nine tungiasis, six pediculosis capitis,
variable Odds ratio interval P-value two cutaneous larva migrans).
 Seventy individuals were concomitantly affected by one or more
Sex other parasitic skin disease (52 tungiasis, 29 pediculosis capitis, 8
Male Reference cutaneous larva migrans).
Female 0.66 0.4–1.2 P ¼ 0.15 àOf those with scabies.
Age §Of those with sleep initiation disorders.
>15 years Reference –Of those with sleep maintenance disorders.
6–15 years 4.4 1.9–10.2 P < 0.001
< ¼ 5 years 7.5 3.1–18.4 P < 0.001
Number of topographic areas affected
in the developing world (Gulati et al. 1977a; Sharma et al.
< ¼ 12 Reference
13–24 5.2 2.7–9.9 P < 0.001
1984; Carapetis et al. 1997; Hegazy et al. 1999; Heukel-
>24 >1000 >1000-n.d.  P < 0.0001 bach et al. 2005). Although the disease is highly prevalent
Presence of superinfected lesions distal to lymphadenopathy in these settings, the clinical features and the associated
No Reference morbidity have rarely been assessed systematically (Stanton
Yes 2.3 1.4–3.8 P ¼ 0.001 et al. 1987; Heukelbach et al. 2005). For example, it is still
Proportion of superinfected lesions a matter of debate whether the clinical appearances depend
0% Reference
on the age of the patient. There is also controversy
1–25% 2.2 1.1–4.5 P ¼ 0.04
>25% 12.9 3.7–44.8 P < 0.001 concerning the topographic localization of the lesions, and
a broad spectrum of different predilection sites is reported
*Cervical, axillar and inguinal lymphadenopathy combined. in the literature (Orkin & Maibach 1978; Estes 1982;
 Not defined. Kenawi et al. 1993; Flinders & De 2004; McCarthy et al.
2004; Orion et al. 2004; Sarwat et al. 2004; Chosidow
Only seven patients (3.6%) were without any complaints 2006). In order to obtain reliable population-based data on
(Table 6). Of the 196 patients, 183 (93.4%) complained clinical features and associated morbidity of scabies, we
about itching at the site of infestation or adjacent skin. In performed two subsequent door-to-door surveys in an
39.3% of the cases, itching was classified as severe. Sleep endemic community in rural northeast Brazil.
disturbances were common: 139 patients (70.9%) woke up Eighty per cent of the patients presented simultaneously
during the night, either because of itching (133 patients) with two ore more different types of lesions, and primary
or pain (6 patients). Thirty-two patients (16.3%) com- and secondary lesions frequently co-existed. This confirms
plained about impaired sleep initiation, and 29 (15.0%) the notion that in most patients the clinical presentation is
stated that sleep initiation and sleep maintenance was a mixture of primary lesions, intermingled with or oblit-
disturbed. erated by excoriation, crusting and secondary infection
(Orkin & Maibach 1978, 1984; Estes 1982; Hurkin 1985;
Flinders & De 2004; Orion et al. 2004; Chosidow 2006).
Discussion
The only pathognomonic sign, the presence of a burrow,
Scabies is a common, though relatively neglected, parasitic is inconsistently present, and particularly in tropical
skin disease of resource-poor rural and urban communities environments seems to be very rare (Orkin & Maibach

498 ª 2007 Blackwell Publishing Ltd


Tropical Medicine and International Health volume 12 no 4 pp 493–502 april 2007

A. Jackson et al. Scabies in Brazil

1978; Taplin et al. 1983; Burgess et al. 1986; Orion et al. are short. In consequence, a mite can more easily reach
2002; Heukelbach & Feldmeier 2006). distant sites like the scalp, neck and face or the feet
In our study papules, crusted papules and excoriations irrespective where body contact with a contagious indi-
on uninfested skin were the most common types of lesions vidual had occurred. Second, infants and small children
irrespective of the age of the patients. The latter sign have a soft and thin skin free of callus at the hands and feet
occurred in 52% of the patients. Hitherto, the frequency of which facilitates the penetration of mites at these locations
excoriations on otherwise healthy skin has not been (Green 1989). Third, in the study area mothers and elder
reported. Although it is known for long that scabies causes sisters often carry small children and babies on their arms,
pruritus on healthy skin, previous studies did not differ- hips or in front of their belly and by doing so press the faces
entiate between excoriations on infested and uninfested of the children to their breasts or the naked abdomen
sites (Mellanby 1977; Gerbase et al. 1984; Kenawi et al. where scabies infestations are frequent in adults. Fourth,
1993; McCarthy et al. 2004; Sarwat et al. 2004). How- frequent and prolonged contact of children’s faces may
ever, in our opinion this sign is an important criterion for occur when playing together or sleeping in the same bed.
the diagnosis of scabies, if microscopy or videodermatos- We attempted to quantify the intensity of infestation by
copy are not at hand. dividing the body surface into 32 topographic areas and
The simultaneous presence of various lesion types was by assessing the number of areas infested in each
more frequent in young children. Supposedly, in an individual. This approach showed that in the majority of
endemic community young children experience repeated patients ‡12 areas simultaneously presented scabies
infestations within a short period of time. As treatment is lesions. It can be assumed that in these patients a
usually delayed, and reinfestation is common, this explains considerable part of the body surface was affected by
the simultaneous presence of primary and secondary scabies. It gives also credit to the notion that, at least in
lesions in the majority of the cases in this age group. The children, the whole body including the neck and the
number of topographic areas, and in consequence the scalp has to be covered with scabicides, if topical therapy
quantity of body surface affected, was inversely correlated is the preferred treatment option (Chouela et al. 2002;
with age. This indicates that young children are prone to Mengesha & Bennett 2002; McCarthy et al. 2004;
multiple infestations. Whether the higher attack rate of Heukelbach & Feldmeier 2006).
children is related to a lack of protective immune respon- The high intensity of infestation in our study population
siveness against scabies mites developing later in life presumably is related to behavioural factors. In Feliz
remains to be determined. Deserto, people mainly wear shorts, summer skirts,
Our data show that only the abdomen and the inguinal sleeveless T-shirts and tops and young children frequently
area/inner side of thighs are true predilection sites, irres- carry only underpants or slips. Thus, the greater part of the
pective of the age of the patient. Areas with a clear body surface is not covered with clothing. Socially
preponderance in children were the interdigital spaces, determined behaviour such as sharing bedsteads or
hands, wrists, axillae, legs, feet, buttocks and genitals. The carrying around babies and toddlers implicates extensive
scalp, neck and face were predominantly infested in and prolonged close physical contact which is considered
children <6 years, although elder children also showed to be the most important way of transmission (Mellanby
lesions at these topographic sites. This is in contrast to 1944; Estes 1982; Chouela et al. 2002; Orion et al. 2004;
historical data from Hurwitz (1973), who categorically Chosidow 2006).
stated that these areas are only affected in infants and small The proportion of patients with superinfected lesions
children (Hurwitz 1973). Conversely, the mamillae and the was 37% with 10% of all affected topographic areas
perimammilar area were mainly infested in females showing signs of superinfection. Again there was a clear
experiencing puberty or who have reached sexual maturity. dichotomy between age groups: young children had
This confirms suggestions from other authors who claim significantly more often their lesions superinfected than
that scabies affects the breasts only of adults and older elder age groups, and the highest proportions of super-
children, and especially of female patients (Green 1989; infection were found at sites predominantly infested in
McCarthy et al. 2004; Orion et al. 2004; Sarwat et al. children £7 years. Children can probably not refrain
2004). In general, our data clearly indicate that the from scratching when pruritus is present, whereas adults
topographic distribution of scabies lesions is age-depend- may do so, e.g. when scratching in public offends
ent. societal concepts. Similar high frequencies of superinfec-
The dichotomy in the topographic distribution of scabies tion have been observed in previous studies in resource-
lesions according to the patient’s age may be because of poor settings (Sharma et al. 1984; Kristensen 1991;
different factors. First, the bodies of babies and toddlers Heukelbach et al. 2005).

ª 2007 Blackwell Publishing Ltd 499


Tropical Medicine and International Health volume 12 no 4 pp 493–502 april 2007

A. Jackson et al. Scabies in Brazil

All but seven patients complained of itching, and 40% developing world (Gulati et al. 1977a,b; Hassan et al.
graded itching as severe. Without doubt, scratching is caused 1979; Gerbase et al. 1984; Sharma et al. 1984; Landwehr
by the itchiness of scabies lesions. Scratching results in et al. 1998; Heukelbach et al. 2005).
denudation of deeper layers of the epidermis and facilitates In conclusion, we convincingly demonstrated that the
the infection with pathogenic micro-organisms from adja- clinical presentation of scabies, the quantity of body
cent parts of the skin or the soil. A similar frequency of surface affected, the topographic distribution of lesions and
superinfection is known from other parasitic skin diseases the degree of superinfection depend on the age of the
such as tungiasis or cutaneous larva migrans (Lima et al. patient and that there is a clear dichotomy between young
1984; Feldmeier et al. 2002; Heukelbach et al. 2003). children and elder age groups.
More than half of the patients had enlarged cervical,
axillar or inguinal lymph nodes. Enlarged lymph nodes
Conflicts of interest
may have many reasons, particularly in the tropics, and
difficultly can be associated with a single cause. However, Anne Jackson, Jörg Heukelbach, Arthur Ferreira da Silva
in our patients there is evidence that lymphadenopathy was Filho, Evônio de Barros Campelo Júnior and Hermann
related to the presence of scabies lesions. The number of Feldmeier have no conflicts of interest to declare.
topographic areas affected, the proportion of lesions
superinfected and the presence of a superinfection distal to
Acknowledgement
enlarged lymph nodes were all significantly associated with
the presence of lymphadenopathy. This study was supported in part by a grant from the
Unexpectedly, 72% of the patients complained about Deutsche Akademie für Flug- und Reisemedizin. We thank
sleep disturbances. Although the cause of sleep disorders is Solvay Farma, São Paulo, Brazil for providing Roxythr-
difficult to disentangle, in this setting altered sleep may be a omicin (Floxid) free of charge. We are obliged to the
consequence of severe pruritus caused by the lesions. Half community healthcare workers of Feliz Deserto and to
of the patients showed signs of scratching on apparently Cláudia Maria Lins Calheiros and Valquı́ria de Lima
healthy, uninfested skin, indicating that the pruritic skin Soares for their assistance. Anne Jackson received a travel
surface was considerably greater than the surface affected grant from the DAAD-CAPES PROBRAL exchange pro-
by specific lesions. This should intensify the severity of gramme. The data are part of a medical thesis by Anne
pruritus. The assumption that scabies was responsible for Jackson.
sleep disturbances is further supported by the observation
that sleep maintenance was more often disturbed than
References
sleep initiation. Presumably, intense itching awaked
patients during the night when mite activity is higher Andersen BM, Haugen H, Rasch M, Heldal HA & Tageson A
(Orkin & Maibach 1978; Estes 1982; Green 1989; (2000) Outbreak of scabies in Norwegian nursing homes and
Chouela et al. 2002). However, as in our study several home care patients: control and prevention. Journal of Hospital
patients were simultaneously infected with other ectopar- Infection 45, 160–164.
asites that may cause pruritus, and because there was no Burgess I (1994) Sarcoptes scabiei and scabies. Advances in
Parasitology 33, 235–292.
appropriate control group living under similar conditions,
Burgess I, Robinson RJ, Robinson J, Maunder JW & Hassan Z
we cannot infer on the true proportion of sleep distur-
(1986) Aqueous malathion 0.5% as a scabicide: clinical
bances induced by scabies. trial. British Medical Journal (Clinical Research Edition) 292,
As the diagnosis of scabies was made clinically, false- 1172.
positive and false-negative diagnoses may have occurred. Carapetis JR, Connors C, Yarmirr D, Krause V & Currie BJ
We used a case definition that should have minimized false- (1997) Success of a scabies control program in an Australian
positive diagnoses. The use of a case definition seems to be aboriginal community. Pediatric Infectious Diseases Journal 16,
warranted, as other studies in similar settings are also 494–499.
based on case definitions (Gulati et al. 1977a; Stanton Chosidow O (2006) Scabies. New England Journal of Medicine
et al. 1987; Heukelbach et al. 2005). False-negative results 354, 1718–1727.
Chouela E, Abeldano A, Pellerano G & Hernandez MI (2002)
might have occured, but skin scraping is no alternative
Diagnosis and treatment of scabies: a practical guide. American
because its sensitivity is low in such settings (Parish &
Journal of Clinical Dermatology 3, 9–18.
Witkowski 1999; Sarwat et al. 2004; Flinders & De 2004; Downs AM, Harvey I & Kennedy CT (1999) The epidemiology of
Chosidow 2006). Moreover, it is not practicable in head lice and scabies in the UK. Epidemiological Infection 122,
resource-poor settings. Finally, the clinical diagnosis of 471–477.
scabies is a well-established and approved method in the

500 ª 2007 Blackwell Publishing Ltd


Tropical Medicine and International Health volume 12 no 4 pp 493–502 april 2007

A. Jackson et al. Scabies in Brazil

Estes SA (1982) Diagnosis and management of scabies. Medical Landwehr D, Keita SM, Ponnighaus JM & Tounkara C (1998)
Clinics of North America 66, 955–963. Epidemiologic aspects of scabies in Mali, Malawi, and
Feldmeier H, Chhatwal GS & Guerra H (2005) Pyoderma, group Cambodia. International Journal of Dermatology 37, 588–
A streptococci and parasitic skin diseases - a dangerous 590.
relationship. Tropical Medicine and International Health 10, Larrosa A, Cortes-Blanco M, Martinez S et al. (2003) Nosocomial
713–716. outbreak of scabies in a hospital in Spain. European Surveillance
Feldmeier H, Heukelbach J, Eisele M et al. (2002) Bacterial 8, 199–203.
superinfection in human tungiasis. Tropical Medicine and Lawrence G, Leafasia J, Sheridan J et al. (2005) Control of scabies,
International Health 7, 559–564. skin sores and haematuria in children in the Solomon Islands:
Flinders DC & De SP (2004) Pediculosis and scabies. American another role for ivermectin. Bulletin of World Health Organ-
Family Physician 69, 341–348. ization 83, 34–42.
Gerbase AC, Schwartz J, Gorelik M & Gutierrez M (1984) Lima W, de Camargo MC & Guimaraes MP (1984) [Outbreak of
[Clinical review of scabies: comparison of the clinical descrip- cutaneous larva migrans in a nursery school in Belo Horizonte,
tion found in literature with 179 patients examined]. Medicine Minas Gerais (Brazil)]. Revista do Instituto de Medicina Tro-
of Cutaneous Ibero in Latin America 12, 513–518. 4 pical de São Paulo 26, 122–124.
Green MS (1989) Epidemiology of scabies. Epidemiologial Review Mahe A (2001) Bacterial skin infections in a tropical environment.
11, 126–150. Current Opinion on Infectious Diseases 14, 123–126.
Gulati PV, Braganza C, Singh KP & Borker V (1977a) Scabies in a McCarthy JS, Kemp DJ, Walton SF & Currie BJ (2004) Scabies:
semiurban area of India: an epidemiologic study. International more than just an irritation. Postgraduate Medical Journal 80,
Journal of Dermatology 16, 594–598. 382–387.
Gulati PV, Singh KP & Braganza C (1977b) Role of sociocultural Mellanby K (1944) The development of symptoms, parasitic
and environmental factors in the cause of scabies. International infection and immunity in human scabies. Parasitology 35,
Journal of Dermatology 16, 281–283. 197–206.
Hassan HA, Ezzat W & Lebshtein A (1979) Scabies as a health Mellanby K (1977) Scabies in 1976. Royal Society of Health
problem among primary school children in Cairo. Journal of Journal 97, 32–6,
Egyptian Public Health Association 54, 65–75. Mengesha YM & Bennett ML (2002) Pustular skin disorders:
Hegazy AA, Darwish NM, bdel-Hamid IA & Hammad SM diagnosis and treatment. American Journal of Clinical Derma-
(1999) Epidemiology and control of scabies in an Egyptian tology 3, 389–400.
village. International Journal of Dermatology 38, 291– Orion E, Matz H & Wolf R (2004) Ectoparasitic sexually trans-
295. mitted diseases: scabies and pediculosis. Clinical Dermatology
Heukelbach J & Feldmeier H (2006) Scabies. The Lancet 367, 22, 513–519.
1767–1774. Orion E, Matz H, Ruocco V & Wolf R (2002) Parasitic skin
Heukelbach J, Wilcke T, Winter B & Feldmeier H (2005) Epide- infestations II, scabies, pediculosis, spider bites: unapproved
miology and morbidity of scabies and pediculosis capitis in re- treatments. Clinical Dermatology 20, 618–625.
source-poor communities in Brazil. British Journal of Orkin M & Maibach HI (1978) Scabies in children. Pediatric
Dermatology 153, 150–156. Clinics of North America 25, 371–386.
Heukelbach J, Wilcke T, Meier A, Saboia Moura RC & Feldmeier Orkin M & Maibach HI (1984) Current views of scabies and
H (2003) A longitudinal study on cutaneous larva migrans in an pediculosis pubis. Cutis 33, 85–86.
impoverished Brazilian township. Travel Medicine and In- Orkin M & Maibach HI (1985) Modern aspects of scabies.
fectious Diseases 1, 213–218. Current Problems in Dermatology 13, 109–127.
Hurkin S (1985) Scabies in infants and children. In: Cutaneous Parish LC & Witkowski JA (1999) The saga of ectoparasitoses:
Infestations and Insect Bites (eds M Orkin & HI Maibach) scabies and pediculosis. International Journal of Dermatology
Marcel Dekker Inc., New York, pp. 31–48. 38, 432–433.
Hurwitz S (1973) Scabies in babies. American Journal of Child Pasternak J, Richtmann R, Ganme AP et al. (1994) Scabies epi-
Diseases 126, 226–228. demic: price and prejudice. Infection Control and Hospital
Jackson A, Heukelbach J, Calheiros CML, Soares VL, Harms G & Epidemiology 15, 540–542.
Feldmeier H (2006) Clinical features and morbidity of hook- Sarwat MA, el Okbi LM, el Sayed MM, el Okbi SM & el Deeb HK
worm-related cutaneous larva migrans: a study in an endemic (1993) Parasitological and clinical studies on human scabies in
3 commuity in Brazil. Clinical Infectious Diseases 43, 13–18. Cairo. Journal of Egyptian Society and Parasitology 23, 809–
Kenawi MZ, Morsy TA, Abdalla KF, Nasr ME & Awadalla RA 819.
(1993) Clinical and parasitological aspects on human scabies in Sharma RS, Mishra RS, Pal D et al. (1984) An epidemiological
Qualyobia Governorate, Egypt. Journal of Egyptian Society and study of scabies in a rural community in India. Annals of
Parasitology 23, 247–253. Tropical Medicine and Parasitology 78, 157–164.
Kristensen JK (1991) Scabies and Pyoderma in Lilongwe, Malawi. Stanton B, Khanam S, Nazrul H, Nurani S & Khair T (1987)
Prevalence and seasonal fluctuation. International Journal of Scabies in urban Bangladesh. Journal of Tropical Medicine and
Dermatology 30, 699–702. Hygiene 90, 219–226.

ª 2007 Blackwell Publishing Ltd 501


Tropical Medicine and International Health volume 12 no 4 pp 493–502 april 2007

A. Jackson et al. Scabies in Brazil

Taplin D, Arrue C, Walker JG, Roth WI & Rivera A (1983) Tonkin SL & Wynne-Jones N (1979) Tokelau Islands Children’s
Eradication of scabies with a single treatment schedule. Journal Study: scabies infestation in children. New Zealand Medical
of the American Academy of Dermatology 9, 546–550. Journal 90, 8–11.

Corresponding Author Prof. Hermann Feldmeier, Institute of Microbiology and Hygiene, Charité–University Medicine, Campus
Benjamin Franklin, Hindenburgdamm 27, 12203 Berlin, Germany. Tel.: +49 4181 281628; Fax: +49 4181 36943;
E-mail: hermann.feldmeier@charite.de

Présentations cliniques et morbidité associée à la gale dans une communauté rurale à Alagoas au Brésil

objectif Décrire les caractéristiques cliniques de la gale et la morbidité associée dans une communauté rurale appauvrie dans le nord-est du Brésil.
méthode Une surveillance de porte-à-porte a été utilisée pour examiner deux fois de suite la population d’une zone endémique; d’abord à la fin de la
saison des pluies et durant la saison sèche 4 mois plus tard.
résultats Au total, 2005 individus ont été examinés. La prévalence totale de la gale était de 9,8% (IC95%: 8,5–11,2). Les zones corporelles de
prédilection, avec des fréquences relatives semblables, dans tous les groupes d’âge étaient l’abdomen (83,7%) et la région inguinale (partie intérieure des
cuisses) (66,3%). Les mains, les pieds, les parties génitales et le cuir chevelu/cou/visage étaient significativement plus souvent affectés chez les enfants < 7
ans (p < 0,03 pour toutes ces zones). 55% des patients présentaient des lésions de gale simultanément dans ‡ 12 zones topographiques distinctes. Des
lésions papuleuses étaient plus communément observées, suivi par des lésions papuleuses en croûte. Des vésicules étaient significativement plus souvent
d’observées chez les enfants (p ¼ 0,04). 64% des patients avaient trois types de lésions ou plus. Des lymphadénopathies locales étaient présentes chez
53,6% et des lésions surinfectées chez 36,7% des cas. Le nombre de zones topographiques affectées ainsi que la proportion de lésions surinfectées étaient
inversement associés avec l’âge (rho ¼ )0,2; p ¼ 0,002 et rho ¼ )0,358; p < 0,05 respectivement). L’étendue de surface de peau infestée, la proportion
de lésions surinfectées et la présence d’une lésion surinfectée distale à un ganglion élargie étaient des facteurs prédictifs de lymphadénopathie. 72% des
patients souffraient de troubles de sommeil, principalement dus aux démangeaisons.
conclusion La gale est associée à une morbidité considérable dans cette communauté endémique. Les zones corporelles de prédilection, la présen-
tation clinique, l’étendue de surface de peau affectée et la proportion de lésions secondaires infectées montrent une dichotomie entre les enfants et les
adultes.

mots clés la gale, présentions cliniques, morbidité, étude basée sur la communauté, Brésil

Caracterı́sticas clı́nicas y asociadas con la morbilidad de la sarna, en una comunidad rural en Alagoas, Brasil.

objetivo Describir las caracterı́sticas clı́nicas de la sarna y la morbilidad asociada, en una comunidad rural empobrecida al noreste del Brasil.
método Se realizó un estudio puerta a puerta con el fin de examinar dos veces a la población de un área endémica; la primera vez al final de la estación
de lluvias, y la segunda durante la estación seca, cuatro meses después.
resultados Se examinaron 2005 individuos en total. La prevalencia total de sarna fue de 9.8% (95% IC 8.5–11.2). Los lugares de predilección, con
frecuencias relativas similares en todos los grupos de edad, fueron el abdomen (83.7%) y el área inguinal/parte interna de los muslos (66.3%). Las
manos, pies, genitales y el cuero cabelludo/cuello/cara estaban significativamente más afectados en niños <7 años (todos p < 0.03). Un 55% de los
pacientes tenı́an lesiones de sarna simultáneas en ‡12 áreas topográficas distintivas. Las lesiones papulares eran las más comúnmente encontradas,
seguidas por las lesiones papulares crostosas. Las vesı́culas eran significativamente más observadas en niños (p ¼ 0.04). Un 64% de los pacientes tenı́an
tres o más tipos de lesiones. La linfoadenopatı́a local estaba presente en un 53.6% y la sobreinfección en un 36.7% de los casos. El número de áreas
topográficas afectadas, ası́ como la proporción de lesiones sobreinfectadas, estaban inversamente correlacionadas con la edad (rho ¼ )0.22, p ¼
0.002 y rho ¼ )0.358, p < 0.05, respectivamente). El área de superficie de piel infestada, la proporción de lesiones sobreinfectadas y la presencia de una
lesión sobre infectada, distal a un nodo linfático engrandecido, eran predictores de una linfoadenopatı́a. Un 72% de los pacientes sufrı́an de desórdenes
de sueño, principalmente debido a los picores.
conclusión La sarna está asociada con una morbilidad considerable en esta comunidad endémica. Los lugares predilectos, la presentación clı́nica y la
cantidad de superficie de piel afectada ası́ como la proporción de lesiones secundarias infectadas muestran una dicotomı́a entre niños y adultos.

palabras clave sarna, caracterı́sticas clı́nicas, morbilidad, estudio basado en la comunidad, Brasil

502 ª 2007 Blackwell Publishing Ltd

You might also like