Professional Documents
Culture Documents
www.ge.com/gas-power/future-of-energy
Executive Summary
The Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) countries have increased
their focus on taking actions to address climate change
concerns. However, there is an urgent need to further
accelerate decarbonizationi efforts, especially in the region’s
power sector, by leveraging its tremendous renewables
potential together with its abundant natural gas reserves,
while transitioning away from liquid fuels.
The world is in a race to reach net-zero to some of the world’s largest hydrocarbon economic development, urbanization, and
emissions to counter global warming and producers and exporters, constitutes a 2.7% industrialization, countries in the GCC
reverse climate change. 197 countries share of global GHG emissions2 but is host have committed to emissions reductions
have signed up to reduce their greenhouse to a population that is less than one third through their individual NDCs. Qatar
gas (GHG) emissions through Nationally that percentage. Average annual per capita and Saudi Arabia, together with Canada,
Determined Contributions (NDCs) under carbon dioxide (CO2) and GHG emissions Norway, and the United States—countries
the United Nations Framework Convention for the region also stand at well above the that collectively represent 40% of global
on Climate Change (UNFCCC). Countries are world average, driven by various elements, oil and gas production—are also founding
disrupting their energy mixes, attempting including the need for power for cooling members of the Net-Zero Producers Forum.
to integrate cleaner fuels, and phasing out and seawater desalination, a significant The forum aims to develop pragmatic
high-emission sources—leading to a focus proportion of liquid fuels in the energy mix, net-zero emission strategies, in line with
on the energy sector—given its 73.2% the presence of energy-intensive industries each country’s national circumstances.³
contribution to total GHG emissions.1 such as smelters, petrochemicals, and
cement, as well as other factors. Decarbonization in this paper is intended
i
The Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC)— Spurred by concerns of additional to mean the reduction of carbon emissions
on a gram per kilowatt hour basis.
Bahrain, Kuwait, Oman, Qatar, Saudi Arabia, negative emissions impact from ongoing
and the United Arab Emirates (UAE)—home
21.6 20.8
19.6 18.9
20
17.0
15.2 15.3
10
6.2
4.5
0
Bahrain Kuwait Oman Qatar Saudi Arabia United Arab World
Emirates
CO2 tons/capita CO2e tons/capita
BAHRAIN
Bahrain’s commitment to the Paris Climate Agreement involves
a combined approach comprising a renewable energy generation
target of 5% by 2025 and 10% by 20356 and reduction in energy
consumption by 6% by 2025.7
K U WA I T
Kuwait is seeking to achieve 15% of its electricity generation from
renewable sources by 2030,8 while concurrently improving the
generation efficiency of its power plants by 15% and reducing energy
consumption by 30%. 9
OMAN
As per the second NDC, Oman plans to slow GHG emission growth
and reduce emissions by 7% in 203010 compared to the Business as
Usual (BAU) scenario. Renewable energy installations coupled with
energy efficiency implementations across end users will form the
cornerstone for the country achieving its stated NDCs in 2030. While
Oman plans to increase renewable energy penetration in the energy
mix to 20% by 2030,11 this is proposed to be increased further to
35–39% by 2040.
QATA R
As per its latest communication to the UNFCCC, Qatar’s NDC12 intends to
reduce 25% of its GHG emissions by 2030 as compared to the baseline scenario
in 2019. Qatar’s NDC will focus on the energy industry including transportation
& downstream sectors, building & construction, water management,
waste and infrastructure as modalities to achieve its committed NDCs.
SAU D I A R A B I A
Saudi Arabia declared in 2015 an aim to annually abate up to 130 million
tons of carbon dioxide equivalent (MtCO2e)—approximately 20% of the
country’s current annual GHG emissions—by 2030.13 Saudi Arabia’s latest
electricity diversification plans seek a 50% or 58.7 GW contribution from
renewable energy, while the remainder is expected to be generated
through gas power projects, primarily large scale combined cycle plants.
The Saudi Energy Efficiency Programme (SEEP) is one of the key areas of
focus, through which the country seeks to reduce energy consumption
across the construction, utility, industrial, and transportation sectors by
20% by 2030.14 Saudi Aramco, the national operating company for oil and
gas, is a participant of the Oil and Gas Climate Initiative (OGCI), and has
committed15 to reduce carbon intensity across its business operations.
UA E
The United Arab Emirates announced the UAE Net Zero by 2050
Strategic Initiative in October 2021. This makes the UAE the first country
in the Middle East and North Africa (MENA) region to announce the
intention to achieve net-zero emissions by 2050. The plan involves an
investment of AED 600 billion (over US$163 billion) in clean energy. The
Ministry of Climate Change and Environment (MOCCAE) will lead efforts
to execute the initiative and ensure collaboration at a national level.16
Renewables are an excellent solution to sequestration (CCS) mean that Systemic interventions will also be needed
address the climate challenge, especially gas turbines can be a long-term beyond power generation to facilitate
as technological advancements and the decarbonization of the GCC’s power
supportive policy frameworks have brought
destination technology and not sector. Grid transmission and distribution
the costs of renewable power generation just a bridging technology today. infrastructure will have to be strengthened
down. Consequently, there has been an further and digital solutions deployed, to
extraordinary 69% compound annual Nuclear energy is also beginning to enhance system visibility, responsiveness,
growth rate (CAGR) in installed renewables come online in the region, contributing reliability, and performance as more
capacity in the GCC between 2015 and to the transition to cleaner energy as a variable power sources come online.
2020, albeit from a very low starting point, dependable source of carbon-free power.
from 0.17 GW to 2.45 GW.17 Demand side management will be
another critical part of the puzzle. The
However, the rapid integration of renewable GCC countries are among the highest
power into grid infrastructure also has GE believes that the per capita consumers of electricity in
the potential to create its own set of the world, ranging from 103% to 430%
accelerated and strategic
challenges—especially around grid instability. above the global average of 3.5 megawatt
Early adopters of renewables are realizing deployment of renewables hours (MWh) per capita.22 Moreover, peak
the need to strengthen grids with additional electricity demand is expected to increase
technologies, to achieve critically required and gas power in the GCC by 7.5% CAGR, from the current 122 GW
levels of flexibility, scalability, dependability, to over 250 GW in 2030,23 creating the
can change the trajectory
and to maintain grid inertia,ii the absence of additional challenge of trying to reduce GHG
which can result in instability, power quality for climate change, emissions, while producing more electricity
issues, and blackouts. in the future. Strong actions are thus
enabling substantive needed to raise further awareness on and
Gas power has emerged as a solution in this encourage behavioral changes to reduce
reductions in emissions
environment. Offering the lowest carbon energy consumption, complementing efforts
emissions per megawatt hour of power quickly, while in parallel that governments in the GCC have already
generated among all fossil fuels, reaching started to take in this area.
as low as 310 grams of carbon dioxide per continuing to advance the
kilowatt hour (gCO2/kWh), versus about Given the anticipated increase in future
technologies for low or
547–935 gCO2/kWh or more for liquid fuel power demand, financial institutions and
plants, and 750–1,000 gCO2/kWh for coal- near-zero carbon power innovative public private partnerships will
fired power plants,18–21 gas can act as a force also have a key role to play in ensuring
multiplier for renewables, complementing generation. access to adequate resources to further
alternative energy sources that can be modernize and decarbonize the region’s
variable with reliable, on-demand electricity power sector.
that can be ramped up or down rapidly. Gas
power plants can also be deployed relatively While there is no ‘one size fits all’ Governments, the private sector, and civil
quickly, with trailer mounted TM2500* formula, and multiple technologies and fuel society across the GCC all need to work
aeroderivative gas power plants rated at 34 sources will contribute to the long-term collectively towards addressing the climate
megawatts (MW) deployable in as little as a power mix globally as well as in the GCC, challenge. However, governments will have
manner of weeks to months. The growth in to take the lead to proactively structure
the focus of this white paper
gas power generation has been enabled by policies, frameworks, and marketplaces that
the increasing availability and affordability is to elevate the emphasis on are conducive for participation by private
of natural gas. Moreover, technology renewables and gas power as investors and encourage the adoption of
urgently needed solutions to lower carbon technologies including CCS.
advancements mean that a dollar
spent on gas turbine technology change the near-term trajectory ii
I nertia in power systems refers to stored energy in
today does not necessarily on climate change. large rotating generators which becomes available
when a large power plant trips offline to temporarily
equal a dollar spent on a carbon Together, renewables and gas power
make up for the lost power from the failed generator.
Inverter-based resources like solar PV, wind, and
footprint for the life of the asset. can help the GCC countries address battery storage do not provide this synchronous
inertia offered by steam and gas turbine driven
Developments in hydrogen- the energy trilemma of securing more generators. As penetration of renewables in the grid
based power generation reliable, affordable, and sustainable increases, due considerations will have to be made
power for present and future generations. to accommodate inertia in future power networks.
and carbon capture and
*Trademark of General Electric company
4 Pathways to faster decarbonization in the GCC’s power sector
The Power Sector: A Key Area of Focus
to Drive Decarbonization in the GCC
22% Wind
generating downstream applications. See Hydro
Figure 4 for a comparison of emissions by 150 Other
technology using traditional fossil fuels for Nuclear
power generation. Steam/Oil
Recips (large)
100 Natural Gas
Looking ahead, advancements in hydrogen- 170
159 62%
based power generation and CCS solutions 74%
also mean that a dollar spent on gas turbine
50
technology today does not equal a dollar
spent on a carbon footprint for the life of
the asset. Gas turbines can be a destination
technology as the GCC moves towards a 0
2020 2030
lower carbon energy future.
F I G U R E 6 : Evolution of renewable energy in the GCC: Installed capacity (MW), 2015 to 203031
60,000 58,700
50,000
40,000
30,000
30,000
20,000
10,000 8,000
6,050
3,100 1,885
5 7 700 3 106 2 8 4 43 24 397 135
-
Bahrain Kuwait Oman Qatar Saudi Arabia United Arab
Emirates
2015 2020 2030 estimate
0.04 0.039
project, the 50 MW Dhofar Wind
Power Project located in the Dhofar 0.029
0.03
Governorate of Oman—started to 0.023 0.024
0.016
generate power in 2019. The facility 0.02 0.017
is equipped with 13 GE wind turbines 0.013
0.01
that have been customized to desert 0.01
conditions specific to the GCC and
can power up to 16,000 homes in the 0
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021
south of Oman. As the technology
matures further, interest in wind
power is likely to keep increasing UAE Bahrain Qatar Saudi Arabia
across the region in the years ahead.
This increased adoption of renewables Conventional fossil fuel power plants can
is, however, creating certain challenges— be ramped up and down on command and
the variable nature of solar and wind are dispatchable. Renewable power on
have resulted in system instability and the other hand is not fully dispatchable
reduction in system inertia when not by the electricity grid and is often
accompanied by incremental investments accommodated in the demand-supply
in the grid and in critical enablers like curve, requiring agility. This is what South
advanced forecasting, flexible generation, Australia opted for, running gas power
fast dispatch, reserves management, plants to provide stability to the grid, even
demand response, and demand side after having capacity to achieve 99%+
flexibility. Extreme weather events and the demand fulfillment from renewables.
unavailability of solar or wind resources
require greater emphasis on developing a The GCC can draw on the experiences
resilient electricity system that can ensure of successful renewables adopters
reliable and quality supply at all times. and structure a balance in the
energy mix that incorporates various
Power generation based on solar and wind commercially viable technologies to
is dependent on the adequate availability meet its decarbonization goals.
of these natural resources—which limits
the extent to which they can be scaled
to meet variances in demand—since the
availability of these resources does not
necessarily coincide with demand.
Competitive LCOE when available, with Competitive LCOE with lowest CAPEX,
COST
no lifecycle uncertainty (mostly CAPEX) providing affordable, dependable capacity
The GCC has invested significant resources environmental impact. For example, continue to operate in simple cycle
in its existing gas power infrastructure. an organization in Qatar is using GE’s mode at efficiency percentages around
With gas power plant lifespans typically Advanced Gas Path (AGP) upgrade the mid-thirties. Modern combined
running 20–40 years, it is not economically solution on four 9F gas turbines. The cycle technologies offer efficiency levels
feasible to retire these assets. However, technology is expected to help enhance as high as 64%. Converting simple cycle
many of these facilities can be enhanced power output by up to 96.7 MW with facilities to combined cycle—something
for better performance and lower improved plant efficiency and to reduce that can be accomplished in as little
carbon emissions with solutions that carbon dioxide emissions for the same as 16 months—can enable them to
pay for themselves over time. level of power output by up to 67,000 produce up to 50% more electricity
tons annually—the equivalent of taking using the same amount of fuel with
• Upgrades: In the more immediate up to 14,000 cars off Qatar’s roads. significant CO2 emissions reductions per
to short term, upgrade solutions can megawatt hour of power generated.
be deployed to increase the output, • Simple to combined cycle
efficiency, flexibility, lifespan, and conversion: Today, many power
availability of gas turbines, while plants in the GCC still use gas turbines
reducing fuel consumption and that were installed in the 1980s and
The development of advanced technologies Merely separating CO2 is insufficient is that it can be accomplished either as
is helping to make gas power generation to reach deep decarbonization goals, a new build or on a retrofit basis, with
cleaner than ever before and offering though. It must be either used or relatively minor changes to the gas
possible pathways to near-zero carbon stored safely and permanently. Based turbine and plant auxiliary equipment.
emissions in the years ahead. on parallels to fossil fuel extraction
technologies there is a strong technical Therefore, the decision to
• as turbines with record-setting
G basis that the Earth, and in particular, build a gas power plant
efficiency levels: Gas turbine the oil and gas-rich GCC countries, today does not necessarily
technology is becoming increasingly has the capacity to store more CO2
lock in CO2 emissions at the
efficient, which immediately translates than humans can produce, and there
into lower emissions. For example, GE’s is very strong evidence that we can original level for the entire
HA gas turbine technology, which has safely store the CO2 underground for life of the power plant.
helped to set two world records for hundreds of millions of years. All CO2
efficiency, is now available at over 64% molecules emitted began their journey Hydrogen is already being used for
combined cycle efficiency and is closing underground, so the challenge is to put power generation. GE gas turbines
in on 65%—a feat once considered to be them back when we are done. have been operating with hydrogen
almost impossible. Three GE 9HA units fuel blends in a variety of industrial
will be used at the 1.8 GW Hamriyah CCS solutions are already deployed applications, including steel mills,
Independent Power Plant in Sharjah, in the GCC and there is increasing refineries, and petrochemical plants;
UAE. The units are expected to be able interest in the technology across the we are a world leader in gas turbine
to help Sharjah Electricity, Water and region. For example, an ongoing CCS fuel flexibility, including more than
Gas Authority (SEWA) to reduce carbon project in the UAE has the capacity to 100 gas turbines that have operated
dioxide emissions by up to 4 million tons capture 800,000 tons of CO2 per year. In (or continue to operate) on fuels
per year compared to current levels— addition, we have seen commitments that contain hydrogen and have
the equivalent of taking 1 million cars by organizations in the UAE and Saudi accumulated more than 8 million
off the UAE’s roads. Arabia to produce and export large operating hours.
commercial amounts of blue hydrogen/
As the GCC continues to decarbonize ammonia, which require significant • Hybrid technologies: Hybrid solutions
the power sector, efforts should be investments in CCS. can provide vital grid stability services
made to adopt proven, robust, highest such as frequency regulation, spinning
efficiency turbines for upcoming gas • Hydrogen: The GCC is starting to look at reserve capacity, or black start capability,
power projects. hydrogen as an important fuel in a future and several hybrid systems are already
where only low-carbon fuels will be in operation today. For example, GE
•
CCS: CCS has the potential to allowed to burn. The region has many of integrated energy battery storage
significantly reduce CO2 emissions from the ingredients needed to produce both technology has been deployed to
all fossil fuel burning power generation green and blue hydrogen cost-effectively black start a 7F gas turbine at Entergy
and industrial processes. Drawbacks in the long run—enormous renewable Louisiana’s Perryville Power Station in
include a near doubling of the upfront energy potential, large reserves of the USA. The term ‘black start’ refers
CAPEX of a power plant, additional hydrocarbons, access to sea water, and to the rebooting of an idle power plant
space requirements, and a reduction depleted oil and gas reservoirs to safely without support from the grid in the
in generation efficiency of up to almost store carbon dioxide—and is investing event of a major system disruption or a
10 percentage points. Factoring in the in blue hydrogen (produced through system-wide blackout. To provide a black
additional cost and reduced efficiency steam methane reforming with CCS) and start, traditionally some power stations
results in an increase in LCOE of 30% to green hydrogen (produced through the have small diesel generators—normally
50%.46 Efforts are underway to optimize electrolysis of water using renewable called black start diesel generator
the power plant and CCS thermal needs power). In terms of power generation, (BSDG)—which can be used to start
such that the impact on efficiency is what is important to note is that the larger generators, which in turn can be
reduced, and a price on carbon could source of the hydrogen doesn’t matter— used to start the main power station
make CCS an economic option even once it is produced, any given volume can generators. Today, the Perryville Power
with the increase in LCOE. GE believes be burned in a gas turbine to generate Station is supported by GE’s 7.4 MW
in the mid-term to long-term benefits of the same amount of power, regardless of battery-based energy storage system
CCS and is planning to invest in research what means it was produced by. paired with the plant’s simple cycle gas
and development (R&D) activities turbine. The project demonstrates the
to make CCS a more affordable and complementary nature of gas-powered
A potential benefit of using hydrogen as
efficient technology to reduce over 90% energy and battery storage.
a fuel in gas turbines, either as a blend
of the carbon footprint in existing and with natural gas or at 100% hydrogen,
new combined cycle power plants.
The full potential of renewable energy to • Fast dispatch and fast frequency • Two-way power flow: Distributed
decarbonize the power sector cannot be response (FFR): As penetration power generated from residential,
unlocked without the right investments in of renewable energy increases, the industrial, and commercial sources
transmission and distribution systems. Grid need to maintain a demand-supply can be connected to the grid to
operators need to ensure the availability balance on the grid at very short help balance electricity demand
of sufficient resources to account for intervals increases, too. Fast dispatch with supply and provide ancillary
the considerable variation in renewable technologies like gas generation and services such as frequency regulation,
generation, while avoiding cycling or battery storage provide access to voltage control, etc. This reduces the
curtailment strategies that can result a wider set of flexible resources to amount of large spinning reserves
in reduced efficiencies and a need for balance the system. FFR strategies that utilities need to maintain to
increased maintenance due to the thermal refer to the delivery or removal of active respond to possible fluctuations
stresses on equipment. power from the grid at very short time in renewable energy supplies.
intervals to correct any supply demand
A range of solutions are available to secure imbalance and assist in managing • Flexible market design and
and stabilize the grid. Their selection power system frequency. mechanisms: Generators can be
depends on the cost-effectiveness of the provided incentives to perform in a
method and the characteristics of the • Reserves management: Modifying flexible manner through the right market
existing grid system.47 existing reserves management design and mechanisms. Learnings
practices to reduce the overall are available from Germany, where
• Advanced forecasting: Techniques and need for balancing reserves can short-term variability in electricity
models that can help provide reliable lead to significant cost reductions. supply due to renewables resulted in
predictions of load demand and the As increasing amounts of variable costly disruptions at industrial facilities.
availability of various renewable and renewable power supplies come online, The country went on to establish
conventional energy supplies are critical one such tool is to introduce ramp a balancing market auction where
for grid management. Forecasts can rate controls that limit the extent market participants provide power or
help grid operators better accommodate to which wind or solar generation cut outputs, earning fees whether their
fluctuations in wind and solar power from a particular facility can ramp services are needed or not.
supplies and prepare for extreme down during extreme weather
events in which renewable generation events. This could be achieved, for • Cross-border grid interconnectivity:
is unusually high or low. Forecasts can example, through the integration of Cross-border grid interconnectivity,
also help to lower the operating reserves a smoothing BESS that can enable such as the GCC Interconnection Grid,
required, decreasing the overall costs of power supply to remain within the can help enable electricity exchange
balancing the system. required ramp rate limitations. and emergency support, creating more
robust and dependable power systems.
DIGITAL SOLUTIONS
Integration of assets is a critical enabler assets after considering availability of and lower carbon emissions through the
for decarbonizing the power sector—to resources, while factoring in the actual implementation of digital solutions that
optimize the system, by pulling together cost associated with the operation of each enable real time asset and system visibility,
generating assets, the electricity grid, and generation technology. Utilities across predictive diagnostics, troubleshooting, and
loads. As the region adds more renewable developed and developing economies have more. It is anticipated that by 2025, digitized
capacity, system operators will need to witnessed improved production efficiency plants will result in up to 4.7% reduction in
integrate and optimize the dispatch of and reliability, reduced generation costs, emissions from power stations.53
1
Our World in Data, September 2020 (https://ourworldindata.org/ghg-emissions-by-sector)
2
World Resources Institute, December 2020 (https://www.wri.org/blog/2020/12/interactive-chart-top-emitters)
3
United States Department of Energy, April 2021 (https://www.energy.gov/articles/joint-statement-establishing-net-zero-producers-forum-between-energy-ministries-canada)
4
World Resources Institute, December 2020 (https://www.wri.org/insights/interactive-chart-shows-changes-worlds-top-10-emitters)
5
Per Capita CO2 Emissions, World Bank Database 2021 (https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/EN.ATM.CO2E.PC?most_recent_value_desc=true)
6
National Renewable Energy Action Plan (NREAP), Sustainable Energy Unit (Kingdom of Bahrain), January 2017
7
National Energy Efficiency Action Plan (NEEAP), Sustainable Energy Unit (Kingdom of Bahrain), January 2017
8
Kuwait Annual National Energy Outlook (KNEO), United Nations Development Program (UNDP), August 2017
9
Renewable Energy Market Analysis: GCC, International Renewable Energy Agency, January 2019 (https://www.irena.org/publications/2019/Jan/Renewable-Energy-Market-
Analysis-GCC-2019)
10
Second Nationally Determined Contribution, Sultanate of Oman, July 2021 (https://www4.unfccc.int/sites/ndcstaging/PublishedDocuments/Oman%20Second/Second%20
NDC%20Report%20Oman.pdf)
11
Oman 2040 Vision Document, November 2020 (https://www.national-day-of-oman.info/wp-content/uploads/2020/11/OmanVision2040-Preliminary-Vision-Document.pdf)
12
State of Qatar Ministry of Municipality and Environment, Nationally Determined Contribution (NDC), August 2021, (https://www4.unfccc.int/sites/ndcstaging/
PublishedDocuments/Qatar%20First/Qatar%20NDC.pdf)
13
The Intended Nationally Determined Contribution of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia Under the UNFCCC, United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change
(UNFCCC), November 2015 (https://www4.unfccc.int/sites/ndcstaging/PublishedDocuments/Saudi%20Arabia%20First/KSA-INDCs%20English.pdf)
14
Saudi Energy Efficiency Centre (SEEC)
15
Oil and Gas Climate Initiative Sets Sights on Carbon Capture, October 2, 2019, (https://www.aramco.com/en/news-media/news/2019/ocgi-new-measures-climate-challenges)
16
UAE Announces Net Zero by 2050 Strategic Initiative, October 2021 (https://www.wam.ae/en/details/1395302978138)
17
Renewable Energy Statistics 2020, International Renewable Energy Agency (IRENA), July 2020 (https://www.irena.org/publications/2020/Jul/Renewable-energy-statistics-2020)
18
Specific Carbon Dioxide Emissions of Various Fuels, May 2021 (https://www.volker-quaschning.de/datserv/CO2-spez/index_e.php)
19
Carbon Dioxide Production per Kilowatt Hour of US Electricity Generation, 2019 (https://www.eia.gov/tools/faqs/faq.php?id=74&t=11)
20
Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), Energy Systems, February 2018 (https://www.ipcc.ch/site/assets/uploads/2018/02/ipcc_wg3_ar5_chapter7.pdf)
21
Comparison of Lifecycle Greenhouse Gas Emissions of Various Electricity Generation Sources, World Nuclear Association (WNA), 2011
(http://www.world-nuclear.org/uploadedFiles/org/WNA/Publications/Working_Group_Reports/comparison_of_lifecycle.pdf)
22
Atlas of Energy, International Energy Agency (IEA), 2018 and 2019 (http://energyatlas.iea.org/#!/tellmap/-1118783123/1)
23
Frost and Sullivan Analysis of Electricity Statistics Data Published by Government Ministries, Electricity Regulatory Authorities, and Electricity Utilities
24
GHG Emissions by Country and Sector, World Resources Institute (WRI), December 2020 (https://www.wri.org/blog/2020/12/interactive-chart-top-emitters)
25
Frost and Sullivan Analysis of Electricity Statistics Data Published by Government Ministries, Electricity Regulatory Authorities, and Electricity Utilities
26
Specific Carbon Dioxide Emissions of Various Fuels, May 2021 (https://www.volker-quaschning.de/datserv/CO2-spez/index_e.php)
27
Carbon Dioxide Production per Kilowatt Hour of US Electricity Generation, 2019 (https://www.eia.gov/tools/faqs/faq.php?id=74&t=11)
28
Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), Energy Systems, February 2018 (https://www.ipcc.ch/site/assets/uploads/2018/02/ipcc_wg3_ar5_chapter7.pdf)
29
Comparison of Lifecycle Greenhouse Gas Emissions of Various Electricity Generation Sources, World Nuclear Association (WNA), 2011
(http://www.world-nuclear.org/uploadedFiles/org/WNA/Publications/Working_Group_Reports/comparison_of_lifecycle.pdf)