Professional Documents
Culture Documents
232
The “Real” Jewish Bodies of Oligarchs
233
Chapter 10
feels free to express openly anti-Jewish feelings that appear in the form of
“biological” antisemitism.
The plot of Prohaknov’s novel is based on the notion of taking revenge
for the deeds of the oligarchs by using their own strategies and the tactics
they allegedly used against the Russian people. And as the alleged goal of the
Jewish oligarchs was the annihilation of the Russians as an ethnic collective,
Prokhanov feels free to unleash the language of racial hatred. In this novel
the Jews, represented by Zaretskii, openly speak about the annihilation of
the Russian nation. If, in Belov’s novel The Best is Yet to Come, Misha Brish
speaks sarcastically about Russian women refusing to give birth, then in
Prokhanov’s novel Zaretskii has a more open and aggressive plan for the
demographic decline of the Russian nation:
The Russian people as a nation are dead, they are no longer a nation, but a
quickly disappearing sum of species, and we supervise this population and we
regulate the numbers... We have torn out the will of the people, torn out their
tongue, cut off their testicles (78–79).
If they start procreating we will forbid their women to bear children (80).
The function of this composite type is to make acceptable the very same
features that serve as indicators of typically Jewish features, consisting
as they do of such stable clichés as sad eyes and an intelligent gaze. The
individual faces also include those features that have been marked by the
Russian culture as ugly: hooked nose and unusually shaped ears. Astros, in
his construction of the etalon, has his own “Jewish” perception of “Jewish”
features, which he perceives as pleasant and appealing, but the Russian
narrator and his Russian protagonist have a different one. The flattering
Jewish figure created by Jews turns out to be repulsive to the Russian viewer.
Certainly the main protagonist Beloseltsev (a name meaning “white village”)
experiences a physical aversion to this construct. As his surname attests,
Beloseltsev represents a warrior of the Russian people and an upholder of
Russian nativist values. For him, the Jewish faces, as well as the simulated
and artificially created ideal based on these faces, prompt a strong sense of
repulsion. Astros’s own face is presented as dominated by one aspect of his
features — the shape of his eyes. Although blue in color, they are not to be
235
Chapter 10
confused with the blue eyes of a Slav because of their “bulging shape” (114)
— the reader will recognize the stable stereotype of Jewish physiognomy in
antisemitic discourse.
Zaretskii’s Body
The idea of race and biology is further reinforced by the physical body of
the oligarchs. Zaretskii’s complexion is depicted as a sickly yellow — yellow
being a marker of race (referring to Jews’ Asiatic origins) and denoting the
diseased nature of a Jew’s body. The reader will remember that the color
of a Jew’s skin was used as a marker of both race and the physically sick
body in the medical literature at the turn of the nineteenth century.10 Because
yellow skin was considered to be a sign of jaundice, it was used to signify
the diseased nature of the Jew’s body. In Prokhanov’s novel these markers
become constant characteristics of Zaretskii’s Jewish physique:
Zarestkii put his malaria-like yellow hand on to the plump white hand of the
president’s daughter (78).
He laughed, baring his yellowish teeth (78).
His yellow hepatitis-like color was matched by his sarcasm and irony (78).
Zaretskii’s sickly yellowish face (267).
A tormenting thought wrinkled his yellow forehead (271).
The skin on his face, on his bald head and his hairy hand rapidly yellowed,
became filled with some mysterious pigment, as if he was a chameleon and
changed his coloring in line with his changing emotions (80).
236
The “Real” Jewish Bodies of Oligarchs
linked this reality with the other, outer reality, from which a mysterious
bubble flowed out, only to flow back and be sucked in again” (80).
Having paid his tribute to popular culture, Prokhanov creates a collage
made up of the stable features of the Jew’s body and new clichés concerning
the depiction of repulsive physical monsters from outer space. The body is
both super-human and non-human; it is out of bounds. Its primitive amoeba-
like structure reaffirms the notion of the rudimentary nature of a Jew’s body
with a new twist: this monster survives due to its mutability based not only
on earthly elements but also on a virtual, fantasy reality. Such physical
characteristics make the creature a difficult target to eliminate.
Among the staple stereotypes of the Jew’s body with which Zaretskii is
aligned is the Jew as a devil, a sadistic and bloodthirsty being:
Zaretskii rubbed his dry hands. He looked like a devil who was looking at
victims suffering in hell, throwing wood into fire (218).
You did it out of pure sadism!.. You pervert, tormentor!.. You like peoples’
sufferings!..You like Sheptun’s head which had been cut off! (217).
It is with good reason that the red-browns [fascists and communists] make
drawings which depict you with an axe covered with blood! (218).
238
The “Real” Jewish Bodies of Oligarchs
members of a Russian group participate in both the ritual slaughter and the
consumption of an animal. This ritual serves as a parallel to what antisemitic
myths attribute to Jewish rites at their core: the ritual intake of blood. It
also serves as a powerful reminder of the centrality of the mechanism of
psychological projection and the introjection of the racial Other. Christians
make Jews take blood because they themselves have made a symbol from
this act and because they have projected this belief in the mystical power of
blood onto Jews.14 In a second step, having imagined that Jews have unique
powers due to their “special attitude towards blood” (Rozanov), they then
appropriate this belief and try to become as “powerful” as Jews, hence the
“ritual” blood-taking by the Christians and Russian warriors in Prokhanov’s
novel. Central to this pattern of behavior is their fear and jealousy of what
they consider to be the special knowledge and power of Jews.15
In the novel the Russian protagonist Beloseltsev enters into an agreement
with a Chechen Muslim warrior in order to create an alliance against Jewish
domination. The Oxford-educated Chechen bases this political alliance on
racial grounds, with his hatred of Jews serving as a uniting force between his
people and the Russians. He repeats verbatim the idea of the demographic
decline of the Russian nation which becomes almost a refrain in the novel:
“Russians have astonishingly weakened as a nation. They have lost the will
to govern. Men do not want to fight, women do not want to bear children”
(183). Whereas the Chechen is slender and handsome, the Jew is described
as aesthetically ugly with a physically and psychologically sick body.
Prokhanov romanticizes the Islamic design of the interior of the Chechen’s
apartment, but he creates a Frankenstein-like experimental laboratory for
Astros and an ultra-modern, sterile and plastic environment for Zaretskii.
The Chechen powerbroker is thus clearly a friend, the Jewish powerbrokers
are enemies.
The political map in the novel is divided into two main spheres of
influence: Western civilization with America and Jews at its center, and
Russia with its Asiatic satellites. Like his alter ego Beloseltsev, Prokhanov is
by profession a specialist on Asia and Africa. He is also an important figure in
the contemporary political movement of Eurasianism, and serves as editor-in-
chief of the newspaper Zavtra, a mouthpiece for the Eurasianist movement.
Eurasianism, is a popular belief system in Russia, with a significant number
of politically influential followers.16 It advocates the division of the world
into different civilizations based on mentality and race: the Atlantic nations
are represented by America, the United Kingdom, and Israel, and so-called
Eurasia is represented by Russia and its imagined satellites from the East.
Most of these Eastern nations are Islamic and non-Christian; they are viewed
239
Chapter 10
as having a different mentality and a different set of values, as they have not
been influenced by the rationalism and materialism of Judaism. This theory
works in opposition to globalization and “melting pot” societies; it rejects
notions of “universal values” and “the new world order.”
Prokhanov’s characters base their political actions on these tenets of
Eurasianism (the alliance that his literary alter ego Beloseltsev makes
with the “good” Chechen is a micro-model of this theory), and their fight
against Jewish domination presupposes an alliance with the Islamic nations
of the Russian Federation, as well as with the new states of the former
Soviet Union and other Asian nations. At its core this political alliance is
nostalgic, structured around the desire to resurrect the spheres of the former
political influence of the Soviet Union. Israel and the United States become
the enemy of Russia, with Arab and Islamic nations once more becoming
Russia’s friends. If in the days of the Soviet Union the dominant rhetoric in
international affairs was based on the concepts of imperialist exploitation
and class differences, then in Russia today the Eurasianist rhetoric is overtly
biology-based. Supported by the terminology of Lev Gumilev’s (1912–1992)
Eurasianist theories on the “complementarity” of various ethnic identities
and the lack of compatibility among other ethnic groups, this theory isolates
Jews as the ultimate Others. Gumilev considers the ethnicity of the Turkic
and Ugro-Finnic peoples to be compatible with that of Russia, whereas
Semitic ethnicity belongs to a group outside the Slavonic and Turkic peoples.
His discourse is quasi-scientific, based as it is on concepts of biology:
The super-ethnic system... is closely connected with the nature of its region.
Each of its constituent parts and subsystems finds an ecological niche for
itself... But if a new foreign ethnic entity invaded this system and could not
find a safe ecological niche for itself, it would be forced to live at the expense
of the inhabitants of the territory, not at the expense of the territory itself... In
zoology the combination of an animal and a tapeworm in the intestines is called
a chimerical construction... Living in the host’s body the parasite takes a part in
its life cycle, dictating a heightened need for food and altering the organism’s
biochemistry by its own hormones forcibly secreted into the blood or bile of
the host (302).17
240
The “Real” Jewish Bodies of Oligarchs
body” (212) and “harmful poisons” (212) in reference to the Jewish presence
within the collective body of the German nation.18 Gumilev’s theory is a
surreptitious restatement of the Nazi theory of racial purity, updated to
include the terminology of hormones, genes, and the conflation of notions
of ethnicity and race. His main work, Ancient Russia and the Great Steppe,
was dedicated to the history of the interaction between the state of Khazaria
and Old Rus’ in the eighth and ninth centuries.19 In the works of Gumilev and
other Eurasianists, Khazaria, whose rulers and nobility accepted Judaism as
its state religion, serves as an example of a state hostile to the Russian and
Slavic people. When in Prokhanov’s novel Astros leads a project under the
name of “New Khazaria,” he evokes this link with Eurasianism as professed
by its main ideologue, Alexander Dugin.20
Prokhanov has Astros identify the aim of the “New Khazaria” project as
an attempt to move the center of Jewish civilization into Russia. According
to Eurasianist ideology, such an alliance would be destructive for Russia
because of the very antagonistic nature of the two types of civilizations.
In line with Eurasianist teachings, Prokhanov’s novel celebrates the ethnic
alliance between the Russians and the Chechens, and demarcates the place
for Jews outside this group. The Jews’ collective body is thus presented as
incompatible with the body of Russia and that of its old imperial subjects on
the oil-rich periphery of the Russian empire.
In Prokhanov’s novel’s pseudo-apocalyptic imagery, Russia’s body is
compared to that of a woman who is trying to give birth and yet cannot rid
herself of the burden of the uterus.21 As a body it is physically tortured, its
convulsions the result of unhealthy mistreatment, stimulation and sadistic
torture inflicted by Jews and other dark-colored Others. Jews encourage
traitors to use the Kremlin as a center for their conspiracy and from there,
from the office formerly occupied by Leon Trotsky, they send torturing
waves and signals:
Using the method of acupuncture, exciting and suppressing at the same time,
they held the country in total obedience, and the country, like a woman who
was left without strength and suffering from illness, lay under the light of
surgical lamps and could not give birth. People in masks injected chemicals
into her enormous stomach in which an invisible child rolled in it in painful
convulsions. (259)
241
Chapter 10
Notes
1
Lev Gumilev. Tysiacheletie: vokrug Kaspiia. Moscow. 1993. 41.
2
Kant’s explanation of the yellow skin color of Asian-Indians. See Immanuel Kant. Of the
Different Human Races. Eds. Robert Benasconi and Tommy L. Lott. The Idea of Race.
Indianapolis/Cambridge: Hackett Publishing Company. 2000. 8–23.
3
See Marshall I. Goldman. Russian Jews in Business. Eds. Zvi Gitelman, Musya Glants and
Marshall I. Goldman. Jewish Life after the USSR. Bloomington: Indiana University Press.
2003. 76–99.
4
For a good exposé on Berezovsky and Khodorkovsky see the BBC TV documentary “Russia’s
Godfathers”. 2005.
5
Rosalind Marsh. Literature, History and Identity in Post-Soviet Russia, 1991–2006. Bern:
Peter Lang. 2007.
6
On Putin’s and the Russian government’s position vis-à-vis Jewish prominence in the Russian
society today see Robert J. Brym. Russian Anisemitism, 1996–2000. Eds. Zvi Gitelman,
Musya Glants and Marshall I. Goldman. Jewish Life After the USSR. Bloomington: Indiana
University Press. 2003. 99–117.
7
On Prokhanov’s Stalinist nostalgia see his comments in Elizabeth Rich, Ed. Russian Literature
after Perestroika, South-Central Review. Special issue. Vol. 12. No. 3/4. Fall/Winter. 1995.
22–25. On Prokhanov and the right-wing writers see Rosalind Marsh. Literature, History and
Identity in Post-Soviet Russia, 1991–2006. Bern: Peter Lang. 2007.
8
See Stephen Lovell and Birgit Menzel, Eds. Reading for Entertainment in Contemporary
Russia: Post-Soviet Popular Literature in Historical Perspective. Munich: Sagner. 2005.
9
These descriptions probably refer to Zhvanetskii, Yavlinskii and Obraztsov.
10
Gilman writes about the “image of a diseased and ‘yellow’ Jew”: “One needs only to
remember The Yellow Book whose color evoked the very spirit of fin-de-siécle self-conscious
242
The “Real” Jewish Bodies of Oligarchs
degeneracy” (114). See Sander Gilman. Salome, Syphilis, Sarah Bernhardt and the Modern
Jewess. The Jew in the Text: Modernity and the Construction of Identity. Eds. Linda Nohlin
and Tamar Garb. London: Thames and Hudson. 1995. 97–121.
11
On the reception of Salome and John the Baptist story in Russian turn-of-the-century culture
see Olga Matich. Erotic Utopia: The Decadent Imagination in Russia’s Fin De Siècle. Madison:
Wisconsin University Press. 2005. In the broader European context see Sander Gilman.
Salome, Syphilis, Sarah Bernhardt and Modern Jewess. The Jew in the Text: Modernity
and the Construction of Identity. Eds. Linda Nohlin and Tamar Garb. London: Thames and
Hudson. 1995. 97–121.
12
Robert J. Brym states that in 2000 a poll run by a popular Russian television anchor asked if
the viewers believed Jews used Christian blood to make matzot during Passover—about half
the respondents said yes. Russian Anisemitism, 1996–2000. Eds. Zvi Gitelman, Musya Glants
and Marshall I. Goldman. Jewish Life After the USSR. Bloomington: Indiana University Press.
2003. 99–117.
13
Rosalind Marsh. Literature, History and Identity in Post-Soviet Russia, 1991–2006. Bern:
Peter Lang. 2007.
14
Alan Dundes. The Blood Libel Legend: A Casebook of Anti-Semitic Folklore. Madison:
University of Wisconsin Press. 1991.
15
On the psychology of fear in modern societies in application to the Vampire myth see Franco
Moretti. The Dialectic of Fear. New Left Review. Vol. 1. No. 136. 1982. 67-85.
16
For a detailed discussion of Eurasianism see Vadim Rossman. Russian Intellectual Antisemitism
in the Post-Communist Era. Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press. 2002.
17
Lev Gumilev. Etnogenez i biosfera Zemli. Leningrad. 1989. 302.
18
Adolf Hitler. Mein Kampf. Introduction by D. C. Watt. Trans. by Ralph Manheim. London:
Hutchinson of London. 1969.
19
Lev Gumilev. Drevniaia Rus’ i velikaia step’. Moscow: Tov-vo Klyshnikov. 1992.
20
On Aleksandr Dugin see Rossman. Op. cit.
21
See Marina Aptekman. Kabbalah, Judeo-Masonic Myth, and Post-Soviet Literary Discourse:
From Political Tool to Virtual Parody. The Russian Review. Vol. 64. No. 4. 2006. 657–681.
22
For a response to this stereotype see the documentary Litso Kavkazskoi Natsional’nosti
(2001). Dir. Georgii Gabelia.
243